Tuberculosis (TB) and HIV comorbidity is a major challenge in TB prevention and control but difficult to assess in Germany as in other countries, where data confidentiality precludes notifying the HIV status of TB patients. We aimed to estimate the HIV-prevalence in TB patients in Germany, 2002–2009, and to characterize the HIV/TB patients demographically. Data from the long-term observational open multicentre cohort ClinSurv HIV were used to identify incident TB in HIV-positive individuals. We assessed the cohort’s coverage for the nationwide HIV-positive population by contrasting ClinSurv HIV patients under antiretroviral therapy (ART) with national HIV patient numbers derived from ART prescriptions (data by Insight Health; available for 2006–2009). The HIV-prevalence in TB patients was calculated as the number of HIV/TB cases projected for Germany over all culture-positive TB notifications. From 2002 to 2009, 298 of 15,531 HIV-positive patients enrolled in the ClinSurv HIV cohort were diagnosed with TB. A 21% cohort coverage was determined. The annual estimates of the HIV-prevalence in TB patients were on average 4.5% and ranged from 3.5% (95%CI 2.3–5.1%) in 2007 to 6.6% (95%CI 5.0–8.5%) in 2005. The most recent estimate for 2009 was 4.0% (95%CI 2.6–5.9%). The 298 HIV/TB patients were characterized by a male-to-female ratio of 2.1, by a median age of 38 years at TB diagnosis, and by 59% of the patients having a foreign origin, mainly from Subsahara Africa. We provide, to our knowledge, the first estimate of the HIV-prevalence in TB patients for Germany by joint evaluation of anonymous HIV and TB surveillance data sources. The identified level of HIV in TB patients approximates available surveillance data from neighbouring countries and indicates a non-negligible HIV/TB burden in Germany. Our estimation approach is valuable for epidemiological monitoring of HIV/TB within the current legal frameworks.
Citation: Fiebig L, Kollan C, Hauer B, Gunsenheimer-Bartmeyer B, an der Heiden M, Hamouda O, et al. (2012) HIV-Prevalence in Tuberculosis Patients in Germany, 2002–2009: An Estimation Based on HIV and Tuberculosis Surveillance Data. PLoS ONE 7(11): e49111. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049111
Editor: Madhukar Pai, McGill University, Canada
Received: September 4, 2012; Accepted: October 8, 2012; Published: November 7, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Fiebig et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The German Federal Ministry of Health is acknowledged for funding this study (grant number: IIA5-2011-2511AUK385). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Tuberculosis (TB) and HIV comorbidity is a relevant public health issue worldwide and does not spare the European region –. HIV/TB is considered a leading cause, together with multi- and extensively drug resistant tuberculosis (M/XDR-TB), impairing success in TB control , . Both HIV and TB adversely interact when affecting the same patient: TB as an AIDS-defining disease is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in people living with HIV (PLWH) , . HIV-positive individuals infected with Mycobacterium (M.) tuberculosis complex bacteria are placed at a 20 to 30 times greater risk of developing active TB –; moreover, they are more prone to endogenous reactivation or exogenous reinfection than HIV-negative individuals , , , . Diagnosis of latent infection and active TB is more challenging in immunocompromised individuals including PLWH . They may present with atypical clinical manifestations of TB or have masked disease with implications on adequate clinical case management , .
The need for systematic HIV/TB surveillance including the monitoring of the level of routine testing has been internationally recognized. The strategic environment was decisively shaped by the “Interim policy on collaborative TB/HIV activities” launched in 2004 by the WHO  (latest update in 2012 ) advocating three main areas of activities: A. establishing the mechanisms for collaboration between TB and HIV programmes; B. decrease the burden of TB in PLWH; and C. decrease the burden of HIV in TB patients.
The European region was specifically addressed with the “Berlin Declaration on Tuberculosis” of the WHO European Ministerial Forum , the “European Framework to decrease the burden of TB/HIV” , and the “Framework Action Plan to fight tuberculosis in the European Union” , adding authority on collaboration between TB and HIV/AIDS national programmes and joint surveillance. Through the “Global Plan to Stop TB” all WHO member states were requested to provide information on HIV-prevalence among new TB notifications by the year 2010 . However, levels of implementing routine HIV/TB surveillance have remained heterogeneous in European Union/European Economic Area (EU/EEA) member states. For 2010, only 18/30 EU/EEA member states, excluding Germany, provided data on HIV among TB patients to the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) .
In Germany, both HIV infections and active TB are of recognized public health relevance . Mandatory notification according to the German Protection against Infection Act  resulted in 3.5 new HIV cases and 5.3 active TB cases per 100,000 population in 2011 . However, their reporting channels are separate: TB cases are notified by name to local public health offices and anonymously transmitted via State health departments to the national level, the Robert Koch Institute (RKI). HIV diagnoses are anonymously notifiable directly to the RKI. Data confidentiality legislation precludes recording the HIV status of TB patients in national TB notification data. HIV surveillance instruments may however include information on TB as AIDS-defining disease.
With this study, we aimed to estimate the HIV-prevalence in TB patients in Germany from 2002 to 2009 by jointly evaluating available anonymous HIV and TB surveillance data sources, as well as to characterize HIV/TB patients demographically.
Materials and Methods
The rationale of our estimation of the HIV-prevalence in TB patients was to use an HIV surveillance instrument to identify HIV/TB case numbers and relate them to TB notification data as subsequently described.
HIV/TB Case Definition
We defined eligible HIV/TB patients as HIV-diagnosed individuals living in Germany, irrespective of antiretroviral treatment (ART) status, who presented with active culture-positive TB (all forms) from 2002 to 2009. Individuals with history of previous TB only were not eligible.
The investigated data sources comprised (i) the ClinSurv HIV cohort; (ii) ART prescription data; and (iii) national TB notification data of Germany (Figure 1):
- The ClinSurv HIV cohort is a prospective open multicentre observational cohort study for the clinical surveillance of HIV , . The cohort has been established in 1999 and is maintained by collaborating HIV clinical centres in Germany, mainly located in urban areas, and the RKI as coordinating centre. All HIV-positive individuals presenting in one of these clinical centres are by default enrolled in the cohort. The data set comprises anonymous demographic patient information (age, sex, geographic origin) and time-related variables on clinical events, such as diagnoses of AIDS-defining diseases including TB , as well as the administered ART regimen. TB is defined by a positive culture of M. tuberculosis complex and includes both pulmonary and extra-pulmonary forms. The patients’ origin was assessed as foreign, when their predominant place of residence had been abroad (supported by information on a foreign country of birth or foreign citizenship), and was classified as in the European HIV Infection Data Set (EHIDS) .
- ART prescription data comprise prescribed daily drug doses recorded by quarter and by Federal State of Germany. The data set was made available by the service provider Insight Health for 2006 to 2009.
- National TB notification data result from mandatory notification of active TB (all forms) with indication of antituberculotic therapy, irrespective of laboratory confirmation . For agreement with the ClinSurv HIV cohort, the TB notification data set was restricted to culture-positive cases.
All data sources were anonymous and independent from each other; case-based record-linkage was not performed.
Subpopulations of interest (in italic) include PLWH, mostly placed under ART after HIV diagnosis, as well as TB and HIV/TB patients. Data sources (coloured boxes) include national TB notification data restricted to culture-positive cases, ART prescription data by Insight Health, and the ClinSurv HIV cohort. TB notification and ART prescription data capture patients irrespective of their comorbidity status. ClinSurv HIV is the only source systematically capturing both HIV and TB. This schematic is not to scale.
Our estimation consisted of three major steps: step 1 was to extract TB cases among patients enrolled in ClinSurv HIV; step 2 was to assess the nationwide coverage of the ClinSurv HIV cohort; and step 3 to determine the HIV-prevalence in TB patients in Germany based on results from steps 1 and 2.
In step 1, the ClinSurv HIV cohort database was searched for all patients newly diagnosed with TB from 2002 to 2009. These annual HIV/TB case numbers were provided with a 95% binomial exact confidence interval (CI) using the number of all HIV-diagnosed patients presenting at the clinical centres in the respective years as a base.
To assess the nationwide coverage of the ClinSurv HIV cohort in step 2, we focussed on patients under ART. To quantify this subpopulation, ART prescription data, a data source independent from HIV notification data and thus not subject to physicians’ reporting behaviour , were used. The approach to derive patient numbers from ART prescription data was established by Kollan et al. . An underlying assumption was that ART regimen and treatment interruptions as recorded in ClinSurv HIV apply likewise to patients outside of the cohort. To account for patients without statutory health insurance (private, uninsured and free medical care), whose prescriptions are not covered by Insight Health, 15% were added to the patient numbers derived from ART prescription data. The determined patient numbers were contrasted with numbers of patients under ART in ClinSurv HIV for each of the years 2006 to 2009. The resulting ratio ( = coefficient) was assessed for its robustness over time. The average value was applied to the years 2002 to 2005, for which ART prescription data were unavailable. We assumed that this coefficient, determined for the subpopulation under ART, would also approximate the share of ART naïve individuals enrolled in ClinSurv HIV of all ART naïve HIV-diagnosed individuals living in Germany.
Step 3 was to determine the HIV-prevalence in TB patients. For each of the years 2002 to 2009, HIV/TB case numbers and their confidence limits (step 1) were multiplied with the coefficient determined in step 2 to project the number of HIV/TB cases for entire Germany. These products were divided by the number of notified culture-positive TB patients of the respective years.
To assess the 2002 to 2009 trend in the estimated HIV-prevalence in TB patients, negative binomial regression was used and incidence rate ratios (IRR) including 95%CIs and p-values (5% significance level) were specified.
Analysis of HIV/TB Patient Characteristics
The HIV/TB patients enrolled in ClinSurv HIV were described as to age, sex, and their geographical region of origin. For continuous variables median and inter-quartile range (IQR), for categorical variables numbers and proportions were specified.
Following a case-cohort approach, characteristics of HIV/TB patients were contrasted with those of the entire ClinSurv HIV cohort enrolled until the end of 2009, as well as with all culture-positive TB patients notified from 2002 to 2009 (pooled).
All analyses were performed using Excel (version 11, Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, Washington, USA) and Stata (version 12.1, StataCorp LP, Texas, USA).
The ClinSurv HIV study has been approved by the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information in Germany. The need for written consent was waived given the anonymous reporting of data to the RKI, the Federal Public Health Institute of Germany. German TB notification data are collected within the legal framework of the Protection against Infection Act .
From 1999 to 2009, a total of 15,531 HIV-positive individuals were enrolled in the ClinSurv HIV cohort (recorded as of June 30, 2010). The proportion of patients under ART was 81% to 87% from 2002 to 2009, respectively.
Patient numbers derived from ART prescription data were in average by factor 4.8 higher than numbers of ClinSurv HIV participants under ART. Accordingly, the ClinSurv HIV cohort was assessed to enrol 21% of all HIV-diagnosed individuals living in Germany.
The cohort comprised 298 HIV-positive individuals diagnosed with culture-positive TB from 2002 to 2009 and thus classified as HIV/TB patients. Annual HIV/TB case numbers ranged from 25 (95%CI 16–37) in 2009 to 56 (95%CI 42–73) cases in 2005. Extrapolated to Germany overall this corresponds to 126 (95%CI 81–185) HIV/TB cases in 2009 and 270 (95%CI 204–350) cases in 2005 (Table 1).
The estimated HIV-prevalence in notified culture-positive TB patients was on average 4.5% in the study period. The annual level ranged from 3.5% (95%CI 2.3–5.1%) in 2007 to 6.6% (95%CI 5.0–8.5%) in 2005, and was 4.0% (95%CI 2.6–5.9%) in 2009 (Table 1).
Negative binomial regression revealed that the estimated HIV-prevalence in TB patients was overall stable over time (IRR 0.99; 95%CI 0.93–1.04; p = 0.659; Figure 2); year-wise regression analysis revealed that the 2005 estimate was an upwards outlier (IRR 1.54; 95%CI 1.28–1.84; p<0.001) using year 2002 as reference.
Point estimates are presented with 95% binomial exact confidence intervals (CI). The estimated trend of the HIV-prevalence in culture-positive TB patients with 95%CI was determined by negative binomial regression. Underlying data sources include national TB notification data, ART prescription data by Insight Health and the ClinSurv HIV cohort.
The 298 HIV/TB patients identified in the ClinSurv HIV cohort were characterized by a male-to-female ratio of 2.1. Their median age was 36 (IQR 30–44) years at enrolment, and 38 (IQR 31–45) years at TB diagnosis; female patients were about eight years younger than males. The HIV/TB patients’ geographic origin was in 41% (117/286 with available information) German and in 59% (169/286) foreign. A foreign origin was markedly more frequent in women than in men (88% (80/91) versus 46% (89/195), respectively; Table 2).
HIV/TB patient characteristics differed from those of the entire ClinSurv HIV cohort, and from those of notified culture-positive TB patients: The entire ClinSurv HIV cohort was characterized by a male-to-female ratio of 4.0, a median age at enrolment of 38 (IQR 32–45) years, and by 24% (3,659/15,240) individuals of foreign origin. Culture-positive TB patients had a male-to-female ratio of 1.6, a median age of 48 (IQR 32–68) years at TB diagnosis, and were in 45% born abroad (Table 2).
The age distribution of HIV/TB patients, both at enrolment and TB diagnosis, contrasted with the age distributions of the entire ClinSurv HIV cohort at enrolment and of the notified culture-positive TB patients is shown in Figure 3.
The HIV and HIV/TB groups refer to individuals enrolled in ClinSurv HIV since 1999; and HIV/TB patients diagnosed with TB from 2002 to 2009. The TB group refers to notified culture-positive TB patients in Germany, 2002 to 2009 (pooled data).
The proportional distribution of regions of foreign origin differed by sex and across HIV/TB patients, the entire ClinSurv HIV cohort, and culture-positive TB patients as shown in Figure 4. PLWH including HIV/TB patients of foreign origin, especially women, were most frequently from Subsahara Africa. Foreign-born TB patients in contrast originated more often from the Western and Central Europe, as well as the Eastern Europe and Central Asia regions; without marked differences between male and female patients.
The HIV and HIV/TB groups refer to individuals enrolled in ClinSurv HIV since 1999, and HIV/TB patients diagnosed with TB from 2002 to 2009 with specified foreign origin in terms of predominant stay. The TB group refers to notified culture-positive TB patients in Germany with specified foreign country of birth, 2002 to 2009 (pooled data).
With this study, we provide, to our knowledge, the first nationwide estimate of the HIV-prevalence in TB patients for Germany, as well as a demographic description of HIV/TB patients.
Core of our estimation was a clinical HIV surveillance instrument, the ClinSurv HIV cohort. ClinSurv HIV was the only identified large-scale data source systematically enrolling HIV-diagnosed individuals and capturing TB as AIDS-defining disease including its date of diagnosis. The cohort was assessed to enrol 21% of all HIV-diagnosed individuals living in Germany.
The estimated level of HIV in TB patients was largely stable level around 4.5% from 2002 to 2009.
For cross-validation of our estimates we identified two epidemiological studies providing quantitative data on HIV in TB patients in Germany. From 2002 to 2004, a multicentre study had been carried out by the German Central Committee against Tuberculosis. Here, 4.3% (101/2.364) of the voluntarily interviewed TB patients (unknown level of HIV testing) were reportedly HIV-positive . This was in agreement with our nationwide 2002 to 2004 estimates of 4.3% (95%CI 3.1–5.7%), 4.3% (95%CI 3.1–5.8%), and 4.5% (95%CI 3.2–6.1%), respectively. From 2007 to 2010, a smaller retrospective case series of TB patients in Berlin prisons revealed a HIV-prevalence of 3.3% (2/60; all tested for HIV) [unpublished data]. This was lower than our respective 2007 to 2009 estimates of 3.5% (95%CI 2.3–5.1%), 4.8% (95%CI 3.3–6.8%), and 4.0% (95%CI 2.6–5.9%) but within the confidence intervals.
Outside of Germany, 15 EU/EEA member states provided 2009 data on the HIV-prevalence among TB patients with known HIV tests status to the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC). Their HIV-prevalence was 7.3% (1,334/18,181) in average, and 4.6% (43/930) in Belgium, 4.3% (9/207) in Denmark, and 3.8% (6/160) the Czech Republic (all neighbouring countries of Germany) . Our estimate for Germany is within the range of these levels. However, assuming the level of HIV testing was unknown (as it is the case in Germany) and thus all TB notifications being used as the denominator would result in a HIV-prevalence of 3.2% (1,334/42,335) in average for these 15 EU/EEA member states, and of 4.6% (43/944) in Belgium, 2.7% (9/337) in Denmark, and 0.9% (6/695) in the Czech Republic. A low proportion of HIV testing, as found for several EU/EEA member states, influences the ascertainable proportion of HIV among TB patients  and leads to an underestimation of the comorbidity when the denominator comprises all TB notifications.
Our estimation approach is subject to several limitations. First, ClinSurv HIV centres are mainly based in urban areas . City States and Federal States with big cities are known to have above-average HIV and TB notification rates in Germany . Moreover, the proportion of HIV-positives among TB patients may be increased in big cities, as known from several EU/EEA member states , involving potential geographical bias. Secondly, a possible overrepresentation of individuals with AIDS in the ClinSurv HIV cohort, related to the particular expertise of the cohort’s clinical centres, as well as an underrepresentation of individuals originating from HIV high-prevalence countries were suggested by Bätzing-Feigenbaum and colleagues  with unknown effect on the cohort’s representativeness for HIV/TB among PLWH. Thirdly, diagnostic bias cannot entirely be ruled out, e.g., a HIV testing shifted towards TB patients at (supposedly) increased HIV risk as observed in a study in the United Kingdom . Though, universal HIV counselling and testing in TB patients is recommended in Germany  and awareness is raised on TB among PLWH . Fourthly, the ClinSurv HIV cohort focusses by definition on culture-positive TB, which may not represent the entire TB burden among PLWH and does not correspond to definition used in national TB notification data . If all ClinSurv HIV centres had departed from their TB case definition and considered also clinically diagnosed TB eligible, this would result in a HIV-prevalence in TB patients of around 3.1% for 2002 to 2009 corresponding to an overestimation of about 47% (ranging from 41% to 54%) by restricting the denominator to culture-positive cases.
To account for the uncertainty of our estimates we provided them with 95% confidence intervals. No separate range of uncertainty was, however, determined when assessing the nationwide coverage of ClinSurv HIV.
Beyond validity, the question arises of how important a level of about 4.5% HIV in TB patients is for individual and public health. In different settings, individual disease burden of HIV/TB was assessed to be particularly high involving dual stigma , , more complex clinical manifestations , , and complications resulting from simultaneous antituberculous treatment and ART , , such as immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome (IRIS) – and high risk of severe liver toxicity . These aspects entail time- and resource-intensive patient care. From this view point, the determined number of about 126 (95%CI 81–185) HIV/TB patients in 2009 represents a non-negligible burden of comorbidity.
Knowledge of the HIV-prevalence in TB patients is not only important in absolute terms but to evaluate trends and epidemiological patterns. We found no significant decline in the estimated HIV-prevalence in a context of decreasing HIV/TB and TB case numbers, but a presumably increasing HIV-prevalence in Germany from 2002 to 2009 .
Our general estimate of HIV in TB patients may serve as starting point for group-specific investigations. Evaluating demographic characteristics of HIV/TB patients indicated a shift towards individuals of foreign origin among HIV/TB patients, which supports earlier findings , and might reflect the high HIV/TB burden in the regions of origin, mainly in Subsahara African countries .
HIV/TB patients were found to have a male-to-female ratio of 2.1, which approximates the ratio of 2.7 found for 16 WHO European region countries (pooled) in 2005 and reflects that both infectious diseases are more prevalent in the male population in the European region . A systematic review of HIV/TB comorbidity in the EU/EEA identified an increased risk of HIV/TB in male TB patients . This is also supported by our identified male-to-female ratio of 1.6 among TB patients being lower than among HIV/TB patients (ratio 2.1). More pronounced, however, was the overrepresentation of women among HIV/TB patients in relation to all PLWH enrolled in ClinSurv HIV (ratio 4.0). TB as AIDS-defining disease was only slightly more frequent in women according to HIV/AIDS notification data of EU/EEA member states . Sex ratios, however, might be influenced by the patients’ geographic origins and their respective epidemiological patterns suggesting the need for multivariable approaches for correct interpretation.
Our study, estimating the HIV-prevalence in TB patients by joint evaluation of available anonymous HIV and TB surveillance data sources, enhances rather than suspends the need for an integrated HIV/TB notification within the national TB surveillance system in Germany. Only this would allow group-specific analyses and the assessment of for instance treatment outcomes and drug-resistance in both HIV-positive and HIV-negative TB patients. Such quantitative evidence is needed to monitor progress in TB control , to further define risk-groups for HIV/TB and target interventions accordingly, as well as to design further operational research .
Yet, already today, our developed approach for estimating the HIV-prevalence in TB patients is valuable for epidemiological monitoring of HIV/TB and applicable within the current legal frameworks.
Insight Health is thanked for providing the ART prescription data. The authors would like to further thank all notifying physicians, laboratories, local and state health departments in Germany, as well as the ClinSurv study Group (Berlin: Robert Koch Institute: A. Kühne (Cohort manager); Vivantes Auguste-Viktoria-Hospital: K. Arastéh; Charité University Medicine: F. Bergmann, M. Warncke; Bochum: St.-Josef-Hospital/Ruhr University: N. Brockmeyer, N. Mühlbächer; Bonn: University Hospital: J. Rockstroh, J. Wasmuth, S. Hass; Düsseldorf: University Hospital Düsseldorf: B. Jensen, L. Rollmann; Essen: University Hospital Essen: S. Esser, P. Schenk-Westkamp; Hamburg: ifi-Institute for Interdisciplinary Medicine; A. Plettenberg, F. Kuhlendahl; ICH Studycenter: A. Adam, L. Weitner, K. Schewe, H. Goey, S. Fenske, T. Buhk, H.-J. Stellbrink, C. Hoffmann; University Hospital Eppendorf: J. van Lunzen, K. Wassmus; Hanover: Medical University Hanover: M. Stoll, S. Gerschmann, K. Hoeper; Kiel: University Schleswig-Holstein, Campus Kiel: H.A. Horst, S. Trautmann; Cologne: University Hospital Cologne: G. Fätkenheuer, D. Gillor, P. Schommers; Munich: University Hospital, Ludwig-Maximilian University: J. Bogner, B. Sonntag; Regensburg: University Hospital Regensburg: B. Salzberger; Rostock: University Hospital Rostock: C. Fritzsche).
Conceived and designed the experiments: LF OH WH. Performed the experiments: LF CK. Analyzed the data: LF CK MA. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: LF CK BH BGB MA OH WH. Wrote the paper: LF.
- 1. Corbett EL, Watt CJ, Walker N, Maher D, Williams BG, et al. (2003) The growing burden of tuberculosis: global trends and interactions with the HIV epidemic. Arch Intern Med 163: 1009–1021.
- 2. Lazarus JV, Olsen M, Ditiu L, Matic S (2008) Tuberculosis-HIV co-infection: policy and epidemiology in 25 countries in the WHO European region. HIV Med 9: 406–414.
- 3. Pontali E, Pasticci MB, Matteelli A, Baldelli F, Migliori GB (2011) Tuberculosis and HIV co-infection: do we have a surveillance system in Europe? Eur Respir J 38: 1258–1260.
- 4. Migliori GB, Centis R (2002) Problems to control TB in Eastern Europe and consequences in low incidence countries. Monaldi Arch Chest Dis 57: 285–290.
- 5. World Health Organization European Ministerial Forum (2007) The Berlin Declaration on Tuberculosis. Berlin, Germany: EUR/07/5061622/5.
- 6. Day JH, Grant AD, Fielding KL, Morris L, Moloi V, et al. (2004) Does tuberculosis increase HIV load? J Infect Dis 190: 1677–1684.
- 7. Selwyn PA, Hartel D, Lewis VA, Schoenbaum EE, Vermund SH, et al. (1989) A prospective study of the risk of tuberculosis among intravenous drug users with human immunodeficiency virus infection. N Engl J Med 320: 545–550.
- 8. Bucher HC, Griffith LE, Guyatt GH, Sudre P, Naef M, et al. (1999) Isoniazid prophylaxis for tuberculosis in HIV infection: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. AIDS 13: 501–507.
- 9. Girardi E, Antonucci G, Vanacore P, Libanore M, Errante I, et al. (2000) Impact of combination antiretroviral therapy on the risk of tuberculosis among persons with HIV infection. AIDS 14: 1985–1991.
- 10. Aaron L, Saadoun D, Calatroni I, Launay O, Memain N, et al. (2004) Tuberculosis in HIV-infected patients: a comprehensive review. Clin Microbiol Infect 10: 388–398.
- 11. Small PM, Shafer RW, Hopewell PC, Singh SP, Murphy MJ, et al. (1993) Exogenous reinfection with multidrug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis in patients with advanced HIV infection. N Engl J Med 328: 1137–44.
- 12. Sharma SK, Mohan A, Kadhiravan T (2005) HIV-TB co-infection: epidemiology, diagnosis & management. Indian J Med Res 121: 550–567.
- 13. De Jong BC, Israelski DM, Corbett EL, Small PM (2004) Clinical management of tuberculosis in the context of HIV infection. Annu Rev Med 55: 283–301.
- 14. World Health Organisation (2004) Interim policy on collaborative TB/HIV activities. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO/HTM/TB/2004.330.
- 15. World Health Organisation (2012) WHO policy on collaborative TB/HIV activities: guidelines for national programmes and other stakeholders. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO/HTM/TB/2012.1.
- 16. De Colombani P, Banatvala N, Zaleskis R, Maher D (2004) WHO regional office for Europe (2004) European Framework to decrease the burden of TB/HIV. Eur Respir J 24: 493–501.
- 17. European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (2008) A Framework Action Plan to fight tuberculosis in the European Union. Stockholm, Sweden: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.
- 18. Stop TB Partnership and World Health Organization (2006) The Global Plan to Stop TB. Part III - Partnership Action to Achieve Goals: TB/HIV. Geneva, Switzerland: Available: http://www.stoptb.org/global/plan/main/part3.asp. Accessed: 2012 October 10.
- 19. European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (2012) Tuberculosis surveillance and monitoring in Europe 2012. Stockholm, Sweden: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.
- 20. Balabanova Y, Gilsdorf A, Buda S, Burger R, Eckmanns T, et al. (2011) Communicable diseases prioritized for surveillance and epidemiological research: results of a standardized prioritization procedure in Germany, 2011. PLoS One 6: e25691.
- 21. Gesetz zur Verhütung und Bekämpfung von Infektionskrankheiten beim Menschen (Infektionsschutzgesetz – IfSG) (2000) Bundesgesetz vom 20. Juli 2000. Bundesgesetzblatt 2000; 33(Teil I-G5702): 1045–77. [In German].
- 22. Robert Koch Institute (2012) Infektionsepidemiologisches Jahrbuch meldepflichtiger Krankheiten für 2011. Berlin, Germany: Robert Koch Institute. Available: http://edoc.rki.de/series/infektionsepidemiologische-jahrbuecher/2011/PDF/2011.pdf. Accessed: 2012 July 9. [In German].
- 23. Bätzing-Feigenbaum J, Kollan C, Kuhne A, Matysiak-Klose D, Gunsenheimer-Bartmeyer B, et al. (2011) Cohort profile: the German ClinSurv HIV project – a multicentre open clinical cohort study supplementing national HIV surveillance. HIV Med 12: 269–278.
- 24. Stoll M, Kollan C, Bergmann F, Bogner J, Faetkenheuer G, et al. (2011) Calculation of direct antiretroviral treatment costs and potential cost savings by using generics in the German HIV ClinSurv cohort. PLoS One 6: e23946.
- 25. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (1992) 1993 revised classification system for HIV infection and expanded surveillance case definition for AIDS among adolescents and adults. MMWR Recomm Rep. December 18, 1992 ed. 1–19.
- 26. European Commission – DG Sanco (2002) EuroHIV: HIV/AIDS surveillance in Europe. Data File Specification for the European HIV Infection Data Set (EHIDS) and European AIDS Case Reporting (ENAADS) agreed at the meeting on HIV/AIDS Surveillance in Europe Paris, November 2001. Paris, France. Available: http://ec.europa.eu/health/ph_projects/2001/com_diseases/fp_commdis_2001_frep_16_en.pdf. Accessed: 2012 July 9.
- 27. Robert Koch Institute (2007) M.-tuberculosis-Komplex außer BCG (Tuberkulose) Falldefinitionen des Robert Koch-Instituts zur Übermittlung von Erkrankungs- oder Todesfällen und Nachweisen von Krankheitserregern. Berlin, Germany: Robert Koch Institute. [In German].
- 28. Robert Koch Institute (2011) Zum Welt-AIDS-Tag. Epid Bulletin 46: 415–425. Available: http://www.rki.de/DE/Content/Infekt/EpidBull/Archiv/2011/Ausgaben/46_11.pdf?__blob=publicationFile. Accessed: 2012 July 9. [In German].
- 29. Kollan C, Bartmeyer B, Bergmann F, Bogner J, Fritzsche C, et al.. (2011) The total number of persons infected with HIV initiating and receiving antiretroviral therapy (ART) in Germany (2006–2009). An estimate based on antiretroviral treatment data of the ClinSurv Cohort and national antiretroviral prescription data (APD). 5 Deutsch-Österreichischer AIDS-Kongress Hannover, Germany. Available: http://www.rki.de/DE/Content/InfAZ/H/HIVAIDS/Epidemiologie/Surveillance/ClinSurv/ClinSurv-DOEAK-2011-Poster-Infected.pdf?__blob=publicationFile. Accessed: 2012 July 9. [In German].
- 30. Hauer B, Kunitz F, Sagebiel D, Niemann S, Diel R, et al.. (2006) Untersuchungen zur Tuberkulose in Deutschland: Molekulare Epidemiologie, Resistenzsituation und Behandlung – Abschlussbericht erweiterte Fassung. Berlin, Germany: Deutsches Zentralkommitee zur Bekämpfung der Tuberkulose. [In German].
- 31. Kruijshaar ME, Pimpin L, Abubakar I, Rice B, Delpech V, et al. (2011) The burden of TB-HIV in the EU: how much do we know? A survey of surveillance practices and results. Eur Respir J 38: 1374–1381.
- 32. Pimpin L, Drumright LN, Kruijshaar ME, Abubakar I, Rice B, et al. (2011) Tuberculosis and HIV co-infection in European Union and European Economic Area countries. Eur Respir J 38: 1382–1392.
- 33. Rodger AJ, Story A, Fox Z, Hayward A, London Tuberculosis Nurses Network (2010) HIV prevalence and testing practices among tuberculosis cases in London: a missed opportunity for HIV diagnosis? Thorax 65: 63–69.
- 34. Schaberg T, Bauer T, Castell S, Dalhoff K, Detjen A, et al.. (2012) Recommendations for therapy, chemoprevention and chemoprophylaxis of tuberculosis in adults and children. German Central Committee against Tuberculosis (DZK), German Respiratory Society (DGP). Pneumologie 66: 133–171. [In German].
- 35. Robert Koch Institute (2011) HIV/AIDS. Ratgeber für Ärzte. Berlin, Germany: Robert Koch Institute. Available: http://edoc.rki.de/series/rki-ratgeber-fuer-arzte/2011/PDF/hiv/aids.pdf. Accessed: 2012 July 9. [In German].
- 36. Kipp AM, Pungrassami P, Stewart PW, Chongsuvivatwong V, Strauss RP, et al.. (2011) Study of tuberculosis and AIDS stigma as barriers to tuberculosis treatment adherence using validated stigma scales. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 15: 1540–1545, i.
- 37. Neves LA, Canini SR, Reis RK, Santos CB, Gir E (2012) Aids and tuberculosis: coinfection from the perspective of the quality of life of patients. Rev Esc Enferm USP 46: 704–710.
- 38. Lawn SD, Bekker LG, Miller RF (2005) Immune reconstitution disease associated with mycobacterial infections in HIV-infected individuals receiving antiretrovirals. Lancet Infect Dis 5: 361–373.
- 39. Muller M, Wandel S, Colebunders R, Attia S, Furrer H, et al. (2010) Immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome in patients starting antiretroviral therapy for HIV infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet Infect Dis 10: 251–261.
- 40. Pawlowski A, Jansson M, Skold M, Rottenberg ME, Kallenius G (2012) Tuberculosis and HIV co-infection. PLoS Pathog 8: e1002464.
- 41. Pukenyte E, Lescure FX, Rey D, Rabaud C, Hoen B, et al. (2007) Incidence of and risk factors for severe liver toxicity in HIV-infected patients on anti-tuberculosis treatment. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 11: 78–84.
- 42. World Health Organization (2011) Global tuberculosis control 2011. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO/HTM/TB/2011.16.
- 43. European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (2011) HIV/AIDS surveillance in Europe 2010. Stockholm, Sweden: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.
- 44. European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (2010) Progressing towards TB elimination – a follow-up to the framework action plan to fight tuberculosis in the European Union. Stockholm, Sweden: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.