Tundra swans (Cygnus columbianus) are broadly distributed in North America, use a wide variety of habitats, and exhibit diverse migration strategies. We investigated patterns of hematozoa infection in three populations of tundra swans that breed in Alaska using satellite tracking to infer host movement and molecular techniques to assess the prevalence and genetic diversity of parasites. We evaluated whether migratory patterns and environmental conditions at breeding areas explain the prevalence of blood parasites in migratory birds by contrasting the fit of competing models formulated in an occupancy modeling framework and calculating the detection probability of the top model using Akaike Information Criterion (AIC). We described genetic diversity of blood parasites in each population of swans by calculating the number of unique parasite haplotypes observed. Blood parasite infection was significantly different between populations of Alaska tundra swans, with the highest estimated prevalence occurring among birds occupying breeding areas with lower mean daily wind speeds and higher daily summer temperatures. Models including covariates of wind speed and temperature during summer months at breeding grounds better predicted hematozoa prevalence than those that included annual migration distance or duration. Genetic diversity of blood parasites in populations of tundra swans appeared to be relative to hematozoa prevalence. Our results suggest ecological conditions at breeding grounds may explain differences of hematozoa infection among populations of tundra swans that breed in Alaska.
Citation: Ramey AM, Ely CR, Schmutz JA, Pearce JM, Heard DJ (2012) Molecular Detection of Hematozoa Infections in Tundra Swans Relative to Migration Patterns and Ecological Conditions at Breeding Grounds. PLoS ONE 7(9): e45789. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045789
Editor: Reiner Albert Veitia, Institut Jacques Monod, France
Received: May 21, 2012; Accepted: August 23, 2012; Published: September 25, 2012
This is an open-access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Funding: This work was funded by the U.S. Geological Survey through the Alaska Science Center’s Changing Arctic Ecosystems Initiative and Avian Disease Research Program, and by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service through the Avian Influenza Surveillance Program. The funders had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of this manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
In North America, hematozoa infection in wild birds varies across the landscape and among taxa . Past studies have generally found low prevalence of blood parasites in taxa sampled at northern arctic and sub-arctic tundra landscapes – in contrast to higher rates of infection detected in birds sampled throughout forested habitats of Alaska and northern Canada , –. Low apparent prevalence of hematozoa in wild birds using tundra habitats may be due to lack of tree cover and concomitant high wind speeds that limit the availability of hosts to suitable vectors , or lower daily temperatures that inhibit hematozoa development –. Exposure of birds to blood parasites at wintering areas and/or en route to and from breeding grounds could be another important factor. Indeed, prevalence and diversity of hematozoa infections have been correlated with annual migration distance in waterfowl  and other avian taxa . Therefore, ecological conditions at breeding grounds and migration patterns of birds may explain disparate rates of hematozoa infection, even within host species .
North American tundra swans (Cygnus columbianus) are divided into populations based on seasonal distribution and migratory patterns. In Alaska, birds that breed along the Arctic Coastal Plain migrate eastward during autumn and winter in the Atlantic Flyway –, whereas birds that breed in western Alaska migrate down the Pacific Flyway –. A small and mostly non-migratory population resides on the Lower Alaska Peninsula . Therefore, differences in breeding habitats and migratory patterns of North American tundra swans could contribute to variation in prevalence and genetic diversity of blood parasites.
In this study, we evaluated the relationships between migratory patterns, environmental conditions at breeding areas, and hematozoa prevalence in three populations of tundra swans. We also describe genetic diversity of hematozoa infecting swans from these three populations. We predicted tundra swans that breed and molt at high latitude tundra landscapes, where environmental conditions are likely less favorable for hematozoa development and transmission, would have a lower incidence of hematozoa infection than those using habitats adjacent to or within forest during summer –. Additionally, we predicted populations of tundra swans that migrate long distances to lower latitude wintering areas would have higher rates of infection and greater genetic diversity of blood parasites than those that are less migratory and remain in Alaska throughout the year . We evaluated predictions about hematozoa prevalence by contrasting the fit of competing models formulated in an occupancy modeling framework , which allows estimation of prevalence while accounting for imperfect detection. Occasional failure of molecular techniques to detect hematozoa infections is a limitation of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based diagnostic tests – which may occur for a variety of reasons (see Materials and methods). We assessed genetic diversity of blood parasites among populations by calculating the number of unique parasite haplotypes observed. Results of this study provide an assessment of evidence for differential parasite infection among three populations of tundra swans sampled in Alaska. Furthermore, results provide an empirical evaluation of conclusions from previous investigations pertaining to possible relationships between hematozoa prevalence and migration distance  and habitat characteristics – while controlling for potential species effects.
Materials and Methods
All procedures involving animals were approved by the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service Region 7 and U. S. Geological Survey Alaska Science Center Animal Care and Use Committees. Animals were instrumented with satellite transmitters under the Department of Interior, U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service permit MB789758-5 (2008) and the State of Alaska, Department of Fish and Game scientific permit 2008-029. Blood samples were collected from tundra swans under the Department of the Interior, U. S Geological Survey Federal Bird Banding Permit #20022.
Identifying Migratory Patterns of Alaska Tundra Swans
Tundra swans were captured and marked with satellite transmitters (PTTs – Platform Transmitting Terminals) from mid-July through mid-August of 2008 at three molting locations in Alaska: the Arctic Coastal Plain (n = 10), the Bristol Bay Lowlands (n = 10) and the Lower Alaska Peninsula (n = 10; Figure 1). It should be noted that birds that use the Arctic Coastal Plain are considered to belong to the Eastern population and that those occurring at the Bristol Bay Lowlands and the Lower Alaska Peninsula are generally considered to be part of the Western population; however, swans are referenced by breeding/molting location in Alaska throughout this manuscript. The age of each bird (second-year or after-second-year) was assessed by plumage and sex was determined through cloacal examination. PTTs manufactured by Microwave Telemetry (Columbia, MD) were surgically implanted in second-year (12–14 months) or after-second-year (≥24 months) tundra swans. A single instrumented swan from each of the Arctic Coastal Plain and Bristol Bay Lowland populations was identified as male. All other individuals carrying transmitters were female. PTTs were programmed to transmit for 5 hours every 18 to 80 hours, depending upon season. The Argos Data Collection and Location System  was used to obtain information on latitude and longitude, date, time, and quality of locations of swans instrumented with PTTs. Unlikely locations were filtered based on rate and angle of movement , and the highest quality location was used to represent the daily position of swans.
Detecting Hematozoa Infection
Whole blood samples were collected from molting second-year and after-second-year tundra swans at locations along the Arctic Coastal Plain (n = 100), the Bristol Bay Lowlands (n = 104), and the Lower Alaska Peninsula (n = 104) in July and August of 2010. Blood samples were collected from the jugular vein of each bird and preserved in Longmire buffer solution. DNA was extracted from all samples using the DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. Extracted DNA was screened for presence of hematozoa using a nested PCR as described by Hellgren et al. . A minimum of one negative control every 24 wells was incorporated into each PCR reaction. Reactions were conducted in eight well strip tubes with individual caps which remained closed except while loading template and reagents to prevent cross contamination. Products were run out on 0.8% agarose gels. All samples were screened for hematozoa by nested PCR twice or until samples were identified as positive for both Leucocytozoon and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium parasites. Infections identified as Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium were assessed through a single test and therefore were only distinguished by parasite genera through subsequent genetic sequencing and phylogenetic analysis.
The target fragment of 479 base pairs (bp) of parasite cytchrome b (cyt b) mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) was sequenced for all samples detected as positive for hematozoa infection to provide information on haplotype diversity and to prevent misidentification resulting from co-amplification . PCR products were treated with ExoSap-IT (USB Inc., Cleveland, OH) without additional purification prior to sequencing. Cycle sequencing was performed with identical primers used for PCR along with BigDye Terminator version 3.1 mix (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) and analyzed on an Applied Biosystems 3730xl automated DNA sequencer (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). Sequence data from Leucocytozoon, Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus and Plasmodium parasites was cleaned and edited using Sequencher version 4.7 (Gene Codes Corp., Ann Arbor, MI).
Additionally, a positive control PCR was performed that targeted a 470 bp fragment of the mtDNA cytochrome oxidase I gene of each sample to confirm competency of extractions. Reactions were conducted using 2 µl of template DNA, primers specifically designed for this study (TUSW COI F: GAT CGG GGG ATT TGG TAA CT and TUSW COI R: ACA GGA TTG GGT CTC CTC CT), and the same proportion of reagents as previously reported for the nested PCR . Thermalcycling conditions followed Kerr et al. .
Estimating Prevalence Using Model Selection and Occupancy Modeling
Samples were considered positive for hematozoa infection in analyses only if the 479 bp mtDNA cyt b product was visualized on a 0.8% agarose gel and confirmed by ≥90% max identity score of the double stranded target sequence as Leucocytozoon, Haemoproteus, Parahaemoproteus, or Plasmodium parasites using the nucleotide BLAST function available through the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI). However, molecular techniques described above may have failed to detect hematozoa that were present in any given blood sample for a variety of reasons including: strong infection by one parasite masking weak infection by another , PCR inhibition, or degraded/low quantity template mtDNA. Thus, imperfect detection was accounted for and prevalence more accurately estimated using an occupancy modeling approach .
A central assumption of occupancy modeling is ‘demographic closure’ among two or more independent assessments of presence (e.g., if hematozoa are present in a blood sample, then they remain throughout all detection attempts). The basic premise of occupancy modeling in the context of this study is that, if hematozoa are detected in a sample in one assessment but not in a subsequent or previous assessment, then that constitutes a detection failure. Thus, occupancy modeling allows for estimation of the detection rate across the population of samples.
For this particular application, we did not expect there to be variation in the probability of detection among attempts to detect hematozoa within a given blood sample nor among samples because of controlled and consistent laboratory methods. However, we did expect there to be variation among groups of swans in the prevalence of hematozoa because of ecological differences among populations. Thus, we explicitly evaluated whether population affiliation, mean daily temperature at breeding areas, mean daily wind speed at breeding areas, annual migration duration by population, and annual migration distance by population affected estimated prevalence rates by contrasting the fit of competing models that differed in which covariates were included in the model structure. Mean daily temperature and wind speed were estimated for habitats used during summer for each swan population using weather data  for the breeding season (June through August) from 2000 through 2010 from the reporting station nearest to PTT deployment/blood sample collection locations (Table 1, Figure 1). Duration of autumn and spring migration was defined as the number of days between the time a bird initiated migration (date of first location away from a breeding area or wintering area) and the time it arrived (was first detected) at a wintering site or breeding area. There was rarely substantial distal (>50 km) movement prior to actual departure for migration, so timing of initiation of migration was rarely equivocal. The distance birds moved during migration was calculated by summing the total distances moved between sequential locations during that entire migratory period, including local movement at staging areas . Therefore, mean annual migration distance was calculated by summing the mean annual distance of autumn and spring migrations by population.
We used an information-theoretic approach to distinguish among competing models of estimated prevalence rate, wherein those with the lowest Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) score were the most likely within our model set . Models were constructed and evaluated in program MARK . The population affiliation covariate used in models subsumed both environmental and migratory variables that could explain differences in hematozoa infection rates. Therefore we used the coefficient of determination (R2) to assess the amount of variation in infection rates among populations that could be explained by temperature, wind speed, migration duration, and migration distance. More explicitly, these R2 values were calculated using deviance values , which represent fit of the model to the data, as follows: (deviance[model with no differences among populations] - deviance[model incorporating an ecological covariate, such as migration distance or wind speed])/(deviance[model with no population differences in prevalence] - deviance[model wherein all 3 populations differ in prevalence]). For some samples, sequencing efforts resulted in poor quality, single stranded, and/or short fragments (≤380 bp) of parasite mtDNA. Results for these samples were considered to be unresolved, as products could have resulted from poor amplification due to co-infection , degraded or low concentrations of template parasite mtDNA, secondary structures in template mtDNA, or as the result of laboratory techniques (e.g., reading errors encountered during automated sequencing or undetected contamination). Therefore, to assess the sensitivity of our results to the presence of these unresolved samples, we conducted two sets of analyses – one where we treated unresolved samples as detections of hematozoa (positives) and another where we treated unresolved samples as cases where blood parasites were not detected (negatives).
Additionally, we conducted separate analyses of Leucocytozoon prevalence and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium prevalence. New models that account for detection rates (i.e., occupancy models) have been developed to explicitly evaluate whether prevalence rates in two species, or species groups, are related at the individual level . However, these models could not be successfully applied here as our data set is not large enough to support the significant increase in numbers of parameters that would need to be estimated. If we ignored detection rates (i.e., assumed they are perfect), then we could evaluate whether the frequency of joint occurrence of Leucocytozoon and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium in individuals is greater than expected, given the individual occurrence of these taxonomic groups. Variances and confidence intervals (c.i.) for these occurrence rates were computed based on a binomial distribution .
Phylogenetic Assignment of Hematozoa
Phylogenetic analyses were used to taxonomically assign sequence data for hematozoa mtDNA to three broad taxonomic groups: (1) Leucocytozoon (2) Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus and (3) Plasmodium. Only sequences resulting from positive samples as previously defined and containing two or fewer ambiguous bases were included in phylogenetic analyses. Samples with two or fewer ambiguous bases could either be simultaneously infected with closely related parasites or may be the product of variation within a single parasite mtDNA genome . Sequences containing three or more ambiguous nucleotide sites were presumed to be probable co-infections and therefore excluded from phylogenetic assignment. Phylogenies were constructed by comparing hematozoa mtDNA cyt b sequence data to reference sample sequences (Table S1) obtained from NCBI. Ten reference mtDNA cyt b sequences from each of four genera of hematozoa originating from samples of wild migratory birds were selected to represent Leucocytozoon, Haemoproteus, Parahaemoproteus, and Plasmodium lineages. Sequences were aligned using Sequencher version 4.7 and edited to a final contig of 423 nucleotides.
Phylogenies were created using MEGA version 4.0.2  and MrBayes version 3.1.2 . The maximum composite likelihood model for nucleotide sequences was used in MEGA with 10,000 bootstrap replicates to generate neighbor-joining trees. In MrBayes, each analysis was run for at least 1 · 106 generations (or until the standard deviation of split frequencies was <0.01) using four heated chains following a burn-in of 5000 generations. Average posterior probabilities of the 50% majority rule consensus tree topologies were estimated using a sampling of likelihood parameters every 100 generations. Trees were visualized using FigTree .
Assessing Haplotype Diversity
Haplotype diversity of hematozoa mtDNA cyt b sequences was assessed for Alaska tundra swan populations by summarizing the frequency of unique haplotypes and creating a median-joining minimum spanning network  using Network version 4.6 (available at www.fluxus-engineering.com). Only those haplotypes without ambiguous nucleotide positions were used to generate the network of observed mtDNA diversity. Parasite haplotypes detected in tundra swans sampled in Alaska were compared to 990 lineages available on the MalAvi public database  as of 9 July 2012 to identify sequences identical to those previously reported for hematozoa infecting wild birds.
Migratory Patterns of Alaska Tundra Swans
PTT marked swans from each of three sample populations followed migration patterns between summer and wintering areas as previously documented , , . Generally, Arctic Coastal Plain tundra swans departed molting areas in autumn and migrated southeast across the Northwest Territories and Prairie Pothole regions of Canada, continued east-southeast across the eastern Great Plains and Great Lakes regions of the United States, and arrived at wintering areas at Chesapeake Bay and eastern North Carolina (Figure 2). Spring migratory movements generally followed the same pathway taken southward the previous autumn (Figure 2). Tundra swans from the Arctic Coastal Plain migrated a mean annual distance of 11,932 km and spent a mean of 153.0 days in transit.
Locations representing the endpoint of migratory movements are indicated by circles.
Tundra swans marked at the Bristol Bay Lowlands generally migrated southeast in autumn along the coast of Alaska before either continuing along the west coast of North America to the Pacific Northwest, or migrating inland across British Columbia, down the east side of the northern Rocky Mountains, to wintering areas in the Pacific Northwest and northern California (Figure 2). In spring movements were generally north, along coastal or interior British Columbia or northeast to western Alberta and then northwest to southern Alaska (Figure 2). Swans then generally flew west along the southern Alaska coast to summer sites at the Bristol Bay Lowlands (Figure 2). Birds from this population migrated a mean annual distance of 7347 km and spent a mean of 101.2 days in transit.
Tundra swans from the Lower Alaska Peninsula generally moved between locations along the peninsula throughout autumn and winter months and made few long distance movements with the exception of two individuals that migrated across the Gulf of Alaska to Puget Sound during the autumns of 2008 and 2010, returning via a similar, but more near-shore, route in the spring of 2009 and 2011, respectively (Figure 2). Tundra swans from the Lower Alaska Peninsula migrated a mean distance of 393 km throughout autumn and spring months and spent a mean of 1.2 days in transit as calculated using data for all birds for which transmitters were active throughout the migration period. However, the mean annual migration distance was 5503 km and mean annual time in transit was 17.0 days when considering only the two swans from the Lower Alaska Peninsula that made movements away from breeding and molting areas.
A 470 bp fragment from the mtDNA cytochrome oxidase I gene was successfully amplified from all but a single sample from the Bristol Bay Lowland tundra swan population confirming the competency of 307 of 308 DNA extractions. Results for the one sample that failed to yield a PCR product at the mtDNA cytochrome oxidase I gene were therefore dropped from subsequent analyses. Of the remaining 307 samples, 135 tested positive on one or more attempts to detect hematozoa infection (44.0%). A total of 108 samples tested positive for Leucocytozoon parasites (35.2%; Table S2) and 71 samples tested positive for Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium infection (23.1%; Table S2). If infection with Leucocytozoon parasites is independent of infection by Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium species, then we would expect approximately 8.1% to be positive for infection for both nested PCR detection tests (the product of 35.2% and 23.1%). The observed rate of co-infection (14.3%, 95% c.i. 10.4% –18.2%, n = 44 samples) was slightly higher than expected. The proportion of samples from which Leucocytozoon infection was detected among the Arctic Coastal Plain, Bristol Bay Lowland, and Lower Alaska Peninsula populations of Alaska tundra swans was 0.33, 0.68, and 0.05, respectively as determined by nested PCR (Table S2). The proportion of samples from which Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium parasites were detected was 0.03, 0.62, and 0.04, respectively from the same populations (Table S2).
Estimating Prevalence Rates and Effects of Covariates
Estimates of hematozoa prevalence and effects of covariates were assessed for three populations of tundra swans under two conditions: (1) treating unresolved samples as either positive or (2) negative for infection. Estimates for prevalence rates, detection probabilities, and model selection criteria varied slightly between these two sets of analyses; however, statistical relationships and model support were unchanged. Therefore, we present only results of analyses where unresolved samples were treated as negative for hematozoa infection unless identified otherwise. Estimates of hematozoa prevalence rates, detection probabilities, and model selection criteria for analyses treating unresolved samples as positive for infection have been included as supplemental material (Tables S3, S4, Figure S1).
Estimated prevalence rates of blood parasites differed among populations, as based on the model with the lowest AIC value (Table 2). Statistical evaluation of the simultaneous influence of multiple covariates on prevalence rates among populations was precluded by too few degrees of freedom in our analyses. Therefore R2 values were used to gain insight as to whether the four ecological covariates we considered may contribute to population differences in hematozoa prevalence. Mean daily wind speed had high R2 values for both Leucocytozoon and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium analyses, suggesting some influence of wind or a correlated factor on parasite prevalence. Temperature also had a high R2 value, but only in relation to Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium prevalence (Table 2).
The detection probabilities for Leucocytozoon and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium infection were relatively high (≥0.86) based on the top model in each analysis (Table 3). Leucocytozoon infection was significantly different across all populations of Alaska tundra swans examined with the highest estimated prevalence occurring in Bristol Bay Lowland birds (0.69, 95% c.i. 0.59–0.77) followed by Arctic Coastal Plain (0.33, 95% c.i. 0.25–0.43) and Lower Alaska Peninsula swans (0.05, 95% c.i. 0.02–0.11; Figure 3). Similarly, Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium infection was estimated to be highest in the Bristol Bay Lowland tundra swan population (0.63, 95% c.i. 0.53–0.72; Figure 3). Lower, statistically equivalent prevalence of Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium infection was estimated for the Arctic Coastal Plain (0.03, 95% c.i. 0.01–0.09) and Lower Alaska Peninsula (0.04, 95% c.i. 0.01–0.10) populations (Figure 3).
Phylogenetic Assignment of Hematozoa
Phylogenetic assignment was successfully used to differentiate 156 double-stranded hematozoa mtDNA sequences into three broad taxonomic groups: (1) Leucocytozoon spp. (2) Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus spp. and (3) Plasmodium spp. as confirmed by relatively high bootstrap support (≥77%) and posterior probability (≥0.94) values (Figure 4). Sequence totals of 100, 55, and 1 were phylogenetically assigned as being Leucocytozoon spp., Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus spp., and Plasmodium spp., respectively. The proportion of tundra swans samples from which Leucocytozoon spp. were detected from the Bristol Bay Lowland population was 0.61 as compared to 0.32 for the Arctic Coastal Plain population and 0.05 for the Lower Alaska Peninsula population based on phylogenetic assignment of haplotypes (Table 4). Similarly, the proportion of swan samples from the Bristol Bay population from which Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus spp. was detected was 0.47 as compared to 0.03 and 0.04 from the Arctic Coastal Plain and Lower Alaska Peninsula populations, respectively (Table 4). Plasmodium parasites were only detected in a single sample from the Bristol Bay Lowland population (Table 4).
Closely related haplotypes are represented by a single asterisk. Reference sequences for Leucocytozoon (white circles), Plasmodium (black circles), Haemoproteus (grey circles), and Parahaemoproteus (grey squares) parasites were obtained from the National Center for Biotechnology Information. Bootstrap support values and posterior probabilities for differentiation of broad taxonomic groups are indicated.
A total of nine unique haplotypes were observed among the 124 mtDNA cyt b hematozoa sequences analyzed from all populations of tundra swans sampled in Alaska (Table 5). Genbank accession numbers for these nine haplotypes are: JQ314220– JQ314228. Haplotypes were identified as Leucocytozoon spp. (n = 5) Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus spp. (n = 3) and Plasmodium sp. (n = 1) as inferred from phylogenetic assignment (Table 5). The greatest number of haplotypes was detected in the Bristol Bay Lowland population (n = 9) followed by the Arctic Coastal Plain (n = 5) and the Lower Alaska Peninsula populations (n = 3; Table 5, Figure 5). All haplotypes for Leucocytozoon, Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus, and Plasmodium species were detected in samples from the Bristol Bay Lowland population (Table 5, Figure 5). Four Leucocytozoon haplotypes and a single Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus sequence were detected in samples from the Arctic Coastal Plain tundra swan population (Table 5, Figure 5). Two Leucocytozoon haploypes and a single Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus haplotype were detected in samples from swans sampled at the lower Alaska Peninsula (Table 5, Figure 5).
Circles are drawn proportional to the frequency at which haplotypes were observed. Shading represents the population from which haplotypes originated: gray (Arctic Coastal Plain), white (Bristol Bay Lowland), and black (Lower Alaska Peninsula). A single mutation separates nodes unless explicitly indicated by number. Lines separating nodes are drawn to scale unless indicated by a break. Parasite taxa have been abbreviated in haplotype names (Leu = Leucocytozoon, Hae/Par = Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus and Pla = Plasmodium).
Three haplotypes detected in tundra swans sampled in Alaska were identical to lineages reported on the MalAvi database. Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus mtDNA cytochrome b haplotype 1 was identical to lineage ANACRE01 previously identified from a sample collected from a green-winged teal (Anas crecca). Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus mtDNA cytochrome b haplotype 2 was identical to lineage CYGNUS01 which has been detected in samples originating from a tundra swan and a mallard (Anas platyrhynchos) sampled in Minnesota. Plasmodium mtDNA cytochrome b haplotype 1 was identical lineage BT7 which has been identified in samples collected from numerous avian taxa throughout the Holarctic including a pectoral sandpiper (Caldris melanotos) sampled in Alaska.
We observed differences in seasonal distribution and migration patterns between tundra swans marked in Alaska along the Arctic Coastal Plain, the Bristol Bay Lowlands, and the Lower Alaska Peninsula (Figure 2), corroborating earlier designation of discrete populations . We also detected differences in the prevalence and genetic diversity of blood parasites among these populations (Table 5, Figures 3 and 5). Although no single environmental covariate could explain population differences in hematozoa prevalence, ecological characteristics of summer use areas (wind and temperature) were the best fitting of those considered and consistent with predictions of how habitats may influence patterns of hematozoa infection in wild bird populations –. Our results do not support migration distance or duration as a predictive covariate of hematozoa infection in tundra swans .
In this study, the Bristol Bay Lowland tundra swan population was found to have the highest prevalence and diversity of hematozoa (Table 5, Figures 3, 5, and S5), most likely a function of ecological characteristics of summer habitats and exposure of swans to insect vectors. The Bristol Bay Lowlands are located at the limit of the North American boreal forest and are characterized by discontinuous woodlands adjacent to wet meadow habitats (Figure 6) . Forested habitats in this region likely support ornithophilic mosquitoes, blackflies, and biting midges capable of accessing nearby swans during active feeding flights for blood meals. Furthermore, daily mean wind speeds are lower at this location than at other areas investigated in this study (Table 1) which may facilitate flight of biting insect vectors. Additionally, mean summer temperatures, which may limit some stages of hematozoa development , are higher at this site than at other sampling locations in Alaska examined in this study (Table 1). Therefore, hematozoa may have a longer period during which to develop at the Bristol Bay Lowlands than at other locations from which swans were sampled in this study. The relatively high prevalence rate of hematozoa in tundra swans at this location (Figure 3) is consistent with rates of hematozoa detection (≥57%) in avian taxa sampled near the boreal forest edge in Canada near Ungava Bay, Quebec  and Churchill, Manitoba .
(A) the Arctic Coastal Plain, (B) the Bristol Bay Lowlands, and (C) the Lower Alaska Peninsula.
Although our data do not support migration distance or duration as being predictive of hematozoa infection, tundra swans from the Bristol Bay Lowland population did undertake long annual migrations between the northeastern Alaska Peninsula and wintering areas in British Columbia, Washington, Oregon, and California (Figure 2). The acquisition of hematozoa infections has been demonstrated at wintering areas of migratory birds including California . Furthermore, stop-over and staging areas used by swans throughout migration are additional areas of potential parasite exposure, including locations in Alberta where active transmission of Leucocytozoon, Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus, and Plasmodium parasites has been demonstrated in trumpeter swans (Cygnus buccinator) . Therefore, although our data suggest that ecological conditions at the Bristol Bay Lowlands may explain the prevalence of hematozoa in this population, swans could be exposed to blood parasites at different points in time and space throughout the year.
The prevalence and diversity of hematozoa detected in the Arctic Coastal Plain population of tundra swans was found to be intermediary for Lecocytozoon spp. and relatively low for Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus spp. (Table 5, Figures 3, 5, and S5). Infection of tundra swans by Plasmodium spp. was not detected in this population (Table 4). Nesting habitats used by the Arctic Coastal Plain population during summer are well beyond the northern extent of the North American boreal forest, providing little or no tall vegetative cover for biting insects (Figure 6) –. Furthermore, the mean daily wind speed at the Arctic Coastal Plain throughout summer months was higher than at the Bristol Bay Lowlands (Table 1) and appreciably greater than necessary to inhibit active flight of biting insects –. These ecological variables may reduce the exposure of swans to suitable vectors of hematozoa. Furthermore, low mean summer temperatures along the Arctic Coastal Plain (Table 1) may inhibit the development of certain life stages of hematozoa, particularly Plasmodium and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus parasites –. Indeed, previous studies found no evidence for active transmission of hematozoa beyond the Arctic Circle in resident Nearctic avian species , . However, active transmission of Leucocytozoon simondi has been demonstrated beyond the Arctic Circle in the Palearctic , likely as the result of sporogony adapting to develop at low temperatures in high latitudes . Similar adaptation of Nearctic Leucocytozoon spp. could explain the intermediary prevalence of these parasites in the Arctic Coastal Plain population of swans.
The long annual migration distance of tundra swans marked at the Arctic Coastal Plain (Figure 2) could also contribute towards the intermediary prevalence of Leucocytozoon infections in this population, even if unsupported as a predictive covariate. Low rates of parasite transmission at breeding and molting areas due to environmental conditions could be supplemented by exposure to parasites during migration and at wintering areas. Swans from the Arctic Coastal Plain population traversed large expanses of the northern boreal forest during both autumn and spring migrations in each year and passed through the ranges of numerous species of blackflies, biting midges, and mosquitoes known to be the vectors of Leucocytozoon, Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus, and Plasmodium parasites, respectively , , . However, it remains unclear if insect vectors were active and carrying infectious life stages of hematozoa during times when tundra swans were using stop-over and staging areas throughout migration. Seasonal transmission of Haemoproteus columbae by hippoboscid flies was found to be highest among feral pigeons (Columba livia) in autumn and winter in Michigan ; and, Leucocytozoon smithi was actively transmitted among domestic turkeys (Meleagris gallopavo) by simuliid flies in South Carolina throughout the year . This suggests that vectors may spread hematozoa among birds at mid-latitude locations of North America temporally and spatially proximate to those used by Arctic Coastal Plain tundra swans outside of the summer breeding season.
The Lower Alaska Peninsula tundra swan population had the lowest prevalence and diversity of avian hematozoa (Table 5, Figures 3, 5, and S5). Habitats along the Lower Alaska Peninsula are characterized by large expanses of lowland coastal tundra with relatively little or no tree cover (Figure 6), low mean monthly temperatures throughout the year, and persistent high winds (Table 1) . The low temperatures and high winds that occur at this location throughout the breeding season (Table 1) could both limit the exposure of breeding tundra swans to biting insect vectors and inhibit the development of blood parasites. Similar to our findings at the Lower Alaska Peninsula, a low incidence (2.9%) of hematozoa infection has been documented in tundra nesting geese in sub-arctic Canada near Hudson Bay .
Lower Alaska Peninsula tundra swans made infrequent migratory movements in autumn to mid-latitude wintering locations (Figure 2), which likely minimized exposure to vectors outside of the breeding season and may have further contributed to the low rates of infection detected in this study. However, it remains unclear if the low prevalence of blood parasites estimated for this population (Figure 3) is representative of infrequent transmission of hematozoa at the Lower Alaska Peninsula during summer or the result of migratory movements of a proportion of individuals from this population to mid-latitude wintering areas where infections are acquired.
In this study, we explored patterns of hematozoa infection in discrete populations of tundra swans that breed in Alaska using empirical data for host migration, ecological conditions at breeding areas, and parasite prevalence/genetics while controlling for potential host species effects. However, we recognize that several important assumptions were made which should be considered when interpreting our results. A central assumption of this study is that migratory movements of instrumented birds are representative of those which were screened for hematzooa infection and vice versa. Similarly, weather data for microhabitats used by individual swans were not obtained and therefore mean daily values for the nearest reporting station throughout the annual breeding season were assumed to be representative of conditions encountered by birds during summer. As migration parameters and ecological conditions at breeding areas were calculated with one sample population per region, the power of our current model selection approach is limited. Future sampling across broader areas of each habitat region will allow better assessments of within as well as among region variation in environmental factors that may contribute to hemosporidian infection rates. Additionally, it was assumed that ecological conditions at breeding areas in Alaska were important in explaining patterns of hematozoa infection in tundra swans. However, as infections by Leucocytozoon, Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus, and Plasmodium parasites have all been demonstrated to persist across years with annual relapses most commonly occurring during the breeding season , it cannot be conclusively determined if initial infections occurred at or away from breeding areas. This consideration is particularly relevant to this study as tundra swans are long-lived  and most blood samples were collected from after-second-year birds. Finally, as all blood samples analyzed in this study were collected during the breeding season in Alaska when temperatures are generally highest (July and August), it was assumed that our sampling approach minimized temporal variation in levels of infection among populations.
Future examination of hematozoa in Alaska breeding tundra swans could build upon results of this study by sampling cygnets, making peripheral blood smears, sampling across broader regions within each habitat type, and conducting vector screening. Samples collected from hatch-year birds at or near breeding grounds would more clearly demonstrate transmission at summer habitats. Peripheral blood smears could be used to better assess co-infection rates, to identify parasite morpho-species, and to assess levels of parasitemia. Vector screening to assess the relative abundance of biting insects and to determine if they are carrying infectious life stages of hemosporidians could be useful for identifying whether blood parasite transmission is limited by the absence of suitable vectors or the effects of ecological variables such as temperature and wind. Additionally, a comparative study of hematozoa infection in tundra swans and trumpeter swans sampled in Alaska would be of interest, as trumpeter swans nest almost exclusively in boreal forest habitats and migrate shorter distances compared to tundra swans. The addition of these components to future studies would provide further insight into patterns of hematozoa infection in migratory birds breeding in Alaska and provide additional baseline data to assess potential changes through time.
Estimated prevalence of Leucocytozoon (white bars) and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium (gray bars) infection in populations of Alaska tundra swans with unresolved samples considered as positive for infection. Associated 95% confidence intervals for estimates are indicated with error bars.
Reference sequences used to create hematozoa phylogenies.
The number and proportion (in parentheses) of samples testing positive for Leucocytozoon and Haemoproteus/Parahaemoproteus/Plasmodium infection from populations of Alaska tundra swans as determined by nested PCR. The number and proportion of unresolved samples is also reported.
Model selection results using the information theoretic approach with unresolved samples considered as positive for infection.
Estimated detection probabilities for Leucocytozoon and Haemoproteus / Parahaemoproteus / Plasmodium infections in Alaska tundra swans from the highest ranking model using AIC where unresolved samples were considered positive for infection.
We are grateful to A. Ahonen, B. Casler, C. Petersen, S. Savage, J. Shook, J. Terenzi, and D. Watts for field assistance. We thank D. Deaton for her assistance with laboratory analyses. We appreciate reference material provided by D. Mulcahy and analytical advice provided by S. Sonsthagen. We thank J. Terenzi and M. Whalen for assistance with figures. D. Derksen and two anonymous reviewers provided comments on an earlier version of this manuscript. Any use of trade names is for descriptive purposes only and does not imply endorsement by the U.S. Government.
Conceived and designed the experiments: AMR CRE JAS JMP. Performed the experiments: CRE DJH. Analyzed the data: AMR CRE JAS. Wrote the paper: AMR CRE JAS JMP DJH.
- 1. Greiner EC, Bennett GF, White EM, Coombs RF (1975) Distribution of avian hematozoa of North America. Can J Zool 53: 1762–1787.
- 2. Bennett GF, Montgomerie R, Seutin G (1992) Scarcity of hematozoa in birds breeding on the arctic tundra of North America. Condor 94: 289–292.
- 3. Hollmén TE, Franson JC, Creekmore LH, Schmutz JA, Fowler AC (1998) Leucocytozoon simondi in emperor geese from the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta in Alaska. Condor 100: 402–404.
- 4. Engström H, Dufva R, Olsson G (2000) Absence of haematozoa and ectoparasites in a highly sexually ornamented species, the Crested Auklet. Waterbirds 23: 486–488.
- 5. Deviche P, Greiner EC, Manteca X (2001) Interspecific variability of prevalence in blood parasites of adult passerine birds during the breeding season in Alaska. J Wildl Dis 37: 28–35.
- 6. Barnard WH, Mettke-Hofmann C, Matsuoka SM (2011) Prevalence of hematozoa infections among breeding and wintering rusty blackbirds. Condor 112: 849–853.
- 7. Valkiūnas G, Iezhova TA (2001) A comparison of blood parasites in three subspecies of the yellow wagtail Motacilla flava. J Parasitol 87: 930–934.
- 8. Valkiūnas G (2005) Avian malaria parasites and other haemosporidia. Boca Raton: CRC Press. 946 p.
- 9. Figuerola J, Green AJ (2000) Haematozoan parasites and migratory behaviour in waterfowl. Evol Ecol 14: 143–153.
- 10. Jenkins T, Thomas GH, Hellgren O, Owens IPF (2011) Migratory behavior of birds affects their coevolutionary relationship with blood parasites. Evolution 66: 740–751.
- 11. Sladen WJL (1973) A continental study of Whistling Swans using neck collars. Wildfowl 24: 8–14.
- 12. Limpert RJ, Sladen WJ, Allen Jr HA (1991) Winter distribution of tundra swans Cygnus columbianus columbianus breeding in Alaska and western Canadian arctic. Wildfowl Suppl. No.1: 78–83.
- 13. Petrie SA, Wilcox KL (2003) Migration chronology of eastern-population tundra swans. Can J Zool 81: 861–870.
- 14. Wilkins KA, Malecki RA, Sullivan PJ, Fuller JC, Dunn JP, et al. (2010) Migration routes and bird conservation regions used by eastern population tundra swans Cygnus columbianus columbianus in North America. Wildfowl 60: 20–37.
- 15. Moermond JA, Spindler MA (1997) Migration route and wintering area of tundra swans (Cygnus columbianus) nesting in the Kobuk-Selawik lowlands of northwest Alaska. Wildfowl 48: 16–25.
- 16. Ely CR, Douglas DC, Fowler AC, Babcock CA, Derksen DV, et al. (1997) Migration behavior of tundra swans from the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta, Alaska. Wilson Bull 109: 679–692.
- 17. Dau CP, Sarvis JE (2002) Tundra swans of the lower Alaska Peninsula: differences in migratory behavior and productivity. Waterbirds 25: 241–249.
- 18. MacKenzie DI, Nichols JD, Royle JA, Pollock KH, Bailey LL, et al.. (2006) Occupancy estimation and modeling: Inferring patterns and dynamics of species occurrence. Burlington: Academic Press. 324 p.
- 19. Hellgren O, Waldenström J, Bensch S (2004) A new PCR assay for simultaneous studies of Leucocytozoon, Plasmodium, and Haemoproteus from avian blood. J Parasitol 90: 797–802.
- 20. Cosgrove CL, Day KP, Sheldon BC (2006) Coamplification of Leucocytozoon by PCR diagnostic tests for avian malaria: a cautionary note. J Parasitol 92: 1362–1365.
- 21. CLS America (2007) Argos user’s manual. Available: http://www.argos-system.org/manual/. Accessed 2012.
- 22. Douglas D (2006) The Douglas Argos-filter Program. Available: http://alaska.usgs.gov/science/biology/spatial/douglas.html. Accessed 2012.
- 23. Kerr KCR, Stoeckle MY, Dove CJ, Weigt LA, Francis CM, Hebert PDN (2007) Comprehensive DNA barcode coverage of North American birds. Mol Ecol 7: 535–543.
- 24. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, NNDC Climate Data Online, Available: http://www7.ncdc.noaa.gov/CDO/cdo.Accessed 2012 January 13.
- 25. Burnham KP, Anderson DR (2002) Model selection and multi-model inference: a practical information-theoretic approach. New York: Springer-Verlag. 514 p.
- 26. White GC, Burnham KP (1999) Program MARK: survival estimation from populations of marked animals. Bird Study 46S: 120–138.
- 27. Agresti A (1990) Categorical Data Analysis. New York: John Wiley and Sons. 576 p.
- 28. Richmond OM, Hines JE, Beissinger SR (2010) Two-species occupancy models: a new parameterization applied to co-occurrence of secretive rails. Ecology 20: 2036–2046.
- 29. Sokal RR, Rohlf FJ (1981) Biometry: The principles and practices of statistics in biological research. New York: Freeman and Company. 880 p.
- 30. Szymanski MM, Lovette IJ (2005) High lineage diversity and host sharing of malarial parasites in a local avian assemblage. J Parasitol 91: 768–774.
- 31. Tamura K, Dudley J, Nei M, Kumar S (2007) MEGA4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 4.0. Mol Biol Evol 24: 1596–1599.
- 32. Ronquist F, Huelsenbeck JP (2003) MRBAYES 3: Bayesian phylogenetic inference under mixed models. Bioinformatics 19: 1572–1574.
- 33. Rambaut A, Drummond A (2007) FigTree v1.0, Available: http://beast.bio.ed.ac.uk/FigTree.Accessed 2009 August 15.
- 34. Bandelt H-J, Forster P, Röhl A (1999) Median-joining networks for inferring intraspecific phylogenies. Mol Biol Evol 16: 37–48.
- 35. Bensch S, Hellgren O, Pérez-Tris J (2009) MalAvi: A public database of malaria parasites and related haemosporidians in avian hosts based on mitochondrial cytochrome b lineages. Mol Ecol Res 9: 1353–1358.
- 36. Bellrose FC (1980) Ducks, geese, and swans of North America. Harrisburg: Stackpole Books. 568 p.
- 37. Wilk RJ (1988) Distribution, abundance, population structure and productivity of tundra swans in Bristol Bay, Alaska. Arctic 41: 288–292.
- 38. Laird M (1961) A lack of avian and mammalian haematozoa in the Antarctic and Canadian arctic. Can J Zool 39: 209–213.
- 39. Super PE, van Riper C (1995) A comparison of avian hematozoan epizootiology in two California coastal scrub communities. J Wildl Dis 31: 447–461.
- 40. Bennett GF, Turner B, Holton G (1981) Blood parasites of trumpeter swans, Olor buccinator (Richardson), from Alberta. J Wildl Dis 17: 213–215.
- 41. Monda MJ, Ratti JT, McCabe TR (1994) Reproductive ecology of tundra swans on the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, Alaska. J Wildl Manag 58: 757–773.
- 42. Stickney AA, Anderson BA, Ritchie RJ, King JG (2002) Spatial distribution, habitat characteristics and nest-site selection by tundra swans on the central arctic coastal plain, northern Alaska. Waterbirds 25: 227–235.
- 43. Gjullin CM, Sailer RI, Stone A, Travis BV (1961) The mosquitoes of Alaska. U.S. Department of Agriculture Handbook 182. 98 p.
- 44. Service MW (1980) Effects of wind on the behaviour and distribution of mosquitoes and blackflies. International J of Biometeorol 24: 347–353.
- 45. Eide A, Fallis AM (1972) Experimental studies of the life cycle of Leucocytozoon simondi in ducks in Norway. J Eukaryotic Microbiol 19: 414–416.
- 46. Bennett GF, Nieman DJ, Turner B, Kuyt E, Whiteway M, et al. (1982) Blood parasites of prairie Anatids and their implication in waterfowl management in Alberta and Saskatchewan. J Wildl Dis 18: 287–296.
- 47. Klei TR, DeGiusti DL (1975) Seasonal occurrence of Haemoproteus columbae Kruse and its vector Pseudolynchia canariensis Bequaert. J Wildl Dis 11: 130–135.
- 48. Noblet R, Kissam JB, Adkins TR (1975) Leucocytozoon smithi: incidence of transmission by black flies in South Carolina (Diptera: Simuliidae). J Medical Entomol 12: 111–114.
- 49. Bennett GF, MacInnes CD (1972) Blood parasites of geese of the McConnell River, N. W. T. Can J Zool. 50: 1–4.
- 50. Nichols JD, Bart J, Limpert RJ, Sladen WJL, Hines JE (1992) Annual survival rates of adult and immature eastern population tundra swans. J Wildl Manag 56: 485–494.