The objectives of this study were to evaluate the best position and best exploration probe for determining liver stiffness (LS) in dogs using transient liver elastography (TE). Thirteen dogs were used in the study.
Morphometric measurements taken were thoracic circumference, weight and height. Elastographic measurements were taken in 4 anatomical positions using two different probes: medium (M) and small (S). The exploration was considered correct when the success rate was above 60% and the interquartile range of the measurements did not exceed 30%. The best measurements were obtained in the middle of the 6th–9th intercostal spaces, with the dog in the left lateral position and using probe M for preference in adults and probe S mandatory for animals <2 years. The correlation between probes was 99%. Intra-observer variability showed an intra-class correlation of 97.6%.
Citation: Rivero-Juárez A, Morgaz J, Camacho A, Muñoz-Rascón P, Dominguez JM, Sánchez-Céspedes R, et al. (2012) Liver Stiffness Using Transient Elastography is Applicable to Canines for Hepatic Disease Models. PLoS ONE7(7): e41557. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0041557
Editor: Hans Tillmann, Duke University, United States of America
Received: March 21, 2012; Accepted: June 22, 2012; Published: July 20, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Rivero-Juarez et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study received no external funding.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Chronic hepatitis C infection is a very common liver disease . The outcome and prognosis of the disease are changing due to an improved knowledge of the pathogenesis of the infection, the discovery of new treatment targets and the optimization of patients monitored –. Animal models have played an important role in these challenges –. The main animal models designed for the study of HCV infection have been mouse-based . These models however have several limitations, associated with immunological host factors and the fact that the mouse is not a natural host for HCV –. In this respect, a canine homolog of the human hepatitis C virus has recently been characterized . This is the first step towards an HCV animal model not based on rodents for probing the pathogenesis, prevention and treatment of diseases caused by hepacivirus infection [a canine equivalent of the hepatitis C virus infection].
One of the most important parameters for optimization is the evaluation of liver damage and fibrosis stage. In this respect, transient liver elastography (TE) is a novel diagnostic method that enables the liver stiffness (LS) which is associated with liver fibrosis to be tested quickly and non-invasively. LS is directly related to tissue elasticity and its opposite, fibrosis. TE has a high sensitivity and specificity for diagnosing the presence or absence of significant fibrosis – and there is greater interobserver and intraobserver concordance . Futhermore, TE explores a portion of liver tissue 100 times larger than that studied by liver biopsy –. In fact, TE is used quite extensively in clinical practice for patients affected with HCV, providing clinicians with a good deal of information about disease progression.
It may therefore be speculated that TE could be a way of monitoring experimental dogs chronically infected with hepacivirus, with considerable repercussions on future study models involving this canine equivalent of the hepatitis C virus. To date, however, the procedure has not been employed using dogs (bibliographic search). The objective of this study was to assess the reproducibility of the TE technique in dogs.
Materials and Methods
This study was carried out in strict accordance with the recommendations in the Regulation for the Management of Laboratory of the Animals Federation of European Laboratory Animal Science (FELASA).
Thirteen healthy dogs belonging to the Veterinary Teaching Hospital of the University of Cordoba were used in the study. The animals included in the study were beagles or greyhounds of between 1 and 7 years old, which showed no evidence of liver disease (defined as normal liver enzyme and bilirubin levels at the time of the study and 6 months previously), had not been included in other studies and had no concomitant diseases at the time of the study. The experimental protocol was approved by the Bioethics Committee of the University of Córdoba.
The thoracic circumference, weight and height of all animals were measured. We defined “overweight” as a body condition score of more than 6 .
LS measurements were taken using FibroScan (Echosens, Paris, France), an ultrasound transducer system, coupled to the axis of a vibrator that generates a vibration of low frequency and amplitude (50 Hz, 2 mm throw), causing elastic shear wave propagation through the tissue. The results of the measurements were expressed as kPa. Two probes were used to measure LS: a medium probe (M) used for adult humans, and a paediatric probe (S) with two modes: an S2 mode for dogs with a thoracic circumference wider than 45 cm, and S1 for dogs with a thoracic circumference not exceeding 45 cm.
A single observer trained in conducting transient elastography made the determinations (more than 200). The observer's general procedure in every instance was to carry out a sonographic examination using the same TE probe, in order to determine the best liver-tissue window in the various positions evaluated. When the best one was found, the elastography measure continued.
Four determinations were made of every animal in different anatomical positions in order to find the best one for carrying out an exploration. The anatomical positions studied were: position 1: lateral projection. On the right side, between the 6th and 9th intercostal spaces, with the animal in standing position; position 2: ventral projection exploration on the right side, just below the 8th rib, with the animal in standing position; position 3: lateral projection exploration in the 6th and 9th intercostal spaces on the right side, with the animal in left lateral position; position 4: ventral projection, between the xiphoid process and the 8th rib, with the animal in left lateral position. The LS of every animal was measured twice in each anatomical position, using the M or S probe according to circumference of the thorax, and with an interval of no less than 30 min between determinations in order to erase the skin impression made by the probe during the previous exploration. Determinations were made without sedation or anesthesia being used. Animals were shaved in the area of the anatomy being measured.
During each TE investigation, a minimum of 10 measurements were taken, with the mean of all of them established as the final value. An examination was considered suitable for analysis when 10 valid measurements had been taken, with a success rate (SR) of above 60% (SR60) for measurements, and when the interquartile range (IQR) between the 10 measurements was less than 30% (IQR30) –.
An anatomical position was considered unsuitable for exploration by TLE if it did not meet the minimum quality criterion set (IQR30 and SR60) in more than 80% of animals explored. The position obtaining the highest SR and lowest IQR among the measurements was considered the best, and was selected as the reference position for determining LS in future studies.
The SPSS statistical package, 18th version (SPSS software, Chicago, Illinois, USA), was used to carry out statistical analyses. Categorical variables were evaluated using the Chi-square test. The intraclass correlation coefficient was used to evaluate concordance between the TE values taken with the two study probes and reproducibility.
The baseline characteristics of the population are shown in Table 1. The SR for determinations in position 1 was 53.8% (beagle SR 25%, greyhound SR 100%), while the SR in position 3 was 100% (100% for both breeds). At positions 2 and 4, and using both probes, no window was found in any dog of either breed that gave a successful determination of LS. Analysis of positions 1 and 3 by SR, IQR and LS values is shown in Table 2. Position 3 was considered the best one for determining LS in dogs.
Using the M probe, there were no valid measurements for any dog under two years old, although probe S gave a valid measurement for all of them (p<0.001). The mean value of measurements was 5.2 kPa using the M probe, and 5.7 kPa with the S probe (P = 0.476). The mean value of results for beagles was 3.2 kPa using both probes (P = 0.999); for greyhounds, mean values were 6.5 kPa using the M probe and 7.5 kPa using the S probe (P = 0.704). The intraclass correlation coefficient between the probes was 98.7% for all determinations. Intra-observer reproducibility was 97.6%. Univariate analysis of possible success rate characteristics for determining liver stiffness is shows in Table 3.
TE is a new technique which is useful in human clinical practice for evaluating liver fibrosis sequentially and non-invasively –, , . In dogs, however, the technique is not standardized, and so has not so far been used with them. Our study is the first to evaluate the feasibility of this technique and shows that the tool may be applied to study models involving the canine equivalent of the hepatitis C virus.
Determining the proper position for scanning is the first step towards standardizing TE in dogs. To determine the best position and the best probe for exploration in each situation, we ranked the quality of the results obtained for each position, including the number and percentage of valid determinations and the IQR between determinations –. We used the same quality criteria in our study as those used in human studies, which show a good correlation between LS values and degree of liver fibrosis , , , . According to the results of our study, the best position for TE in dogs is between the 6th and 9th intercostal spaces, with the animal in the left lateral position (position 3), since there was a 100% SR in our study population for explorations in this position. Our study found that TE applied between the 6th and 9th intercostal spaces on the right side, and with the animal in a standing position (position 1), yielded a lower SR. This position could be considered an alternative only in situations where it is not possible to use the reference position for some reason. The other positions tested (positions 2 and 4) did not give the minimum percentage of quality scans and should not therefore be considered for TE in dogs.
In our study, we used two probes to make determinations. We compared the determination values of the two probes in order to establish the correct probe for use, depending on the situation, with the aim of being able to explore a high proportion of patients in routine clinical practice. In our study, there was a 0% SR using probe M for dogs of less than two years old, although a determination could be made in every case using probe S. We found no relationship, in our study, between the morphometric parameters studied and the SR percentage, irrespective of the probe, although probe S was less useful than probe M for adults in terms of the group SR,. Therefore, our results suggest that, as with humans , the probe used to evaluate LS in dogs using TE should be adjusted to cater for the age of the animal.
On the other hand, there was very little variability obtained using the two probes. This phenomenon, as far as we know, has not yet been evaluated in humans. In our study there was a high correlation between the M and S exploratory probes and intra-observer reproducibility.
However, our study has several limitations. Firstly, the number of animals tested was low and studies using bigger populations are required. Secondly, LS was not compared with liver biopsy, and we could not therefore consider determination values or the presence or absence of liver disease. Studies testing this point in sick dogs are required are necessary and it should be addressed in further studies before TE enters canine clinical practice. Thirdly, our study only included two dog breeds and our results cannot therefore be extrapolated to other breeds. However, differences in TE technique are not expected in other breeds of similar morphometric characteristics. Fourthly, in our study, the LS values of the greyhounds were higher than those of the beagles. The reason for the different LS values between the two breeds is not known, although it could be due to different physiological and morphometric characteristics. For this reason, it might be hypothesized that normal LS values and cut-off levels for advanced fibrosis could vary depending on the breed. Studies evaluating the influence of breed on LS values are needed.
In conclusion, our study shows that TE is a reproducible technique in dogs, with the best results being obtained by exploring the animal between the 6th–9th intercostal spaces in the left lateral position. It seems that, as in human medicine, probe M should be used for adults and probe S for puppies. Therefore, the great utility of TE in the clinical practice of HCV infected patients could be extrapolated to models involving the canine equivalent of the hepatitis C virus.
Conceived and designed the experiments: ARJ JM AR. Performed the experiments: ARJ PMR RSC AC. Analyzed the data: ARJ JM AC AR. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: JMD JTC AC JM AR. Wrote the paper: ARJ JM AR. Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: AR ARJ JM AC PMR JMD RSC JTC.
- 1. Lauer GM, Walker BD (2011) Hepatitis C virus infection. N Engl J Med 345: 41–52.GM LauerBD Walker2011Hepatitis C virus infection.N Engl J Med3454152
- 2. WHO Consultation organized in collaboration with the viral hepatitis prevention board (1999) Global surveillance and control of hepatitis C. Antwerp, Belgium. J Viral Hepat 6: 35–47.WHO Consultation organized in collaboration with the viral hepatitis prevention board1999Global surveillance and control of hepatitis C. Antwerp, Belgium.J Viral Hepat63547
- 3. Ghany MG, Strader DB, Thomas DL, Seeff LB (2009) Diagnosis, Management and Treatment of hepatitis C: An update. AASLD Practice Guidelines. Hepatology 49: 1335–1374.MG GhanyDB StraderDL ThomasLB Seeff2009Diagnosis, Management and Treatment of hepatitis C: An update. AASLD Practice Guidelines.Hepatology4913351374
- 4. Hofmann WP, Zeuzem S (2011) A new standard of care for treatment of chronic HCV infection. Nature Review/Gastroenterology & Hepatology 8: 257–64.WP HofmannS. Zeuzem2011A new standard of care for treatment of chronic HCV infection.Nature Review/Gastroenterology & Hepatology825764
- 5. Pietschmann T (2009) Virology: Final entry key for hepatitis C. Nature 457: 797–8.T. Pietschmann2009Virology: Final entry key for hepatitis C.Nature4577978
- 6. Ding CB, Zhang JP, Zhao Y, Peng ZG, Song DQ, Jiang JD (2011) Zebrafish as a potential model organism for drug test against hepatitis C virus. Plos One 6: e22921.CB DingJP ZhangY. ZhaoZG PengDQ SongJD Jiang2011Zebrafish as a potential model organism for drug test against hepatitis C virus.Plos One6e22921
- 7. Verstrepen BE, Depla E, Rollier CS, Mares G, Drexhage JA, et al. (2011) Clearance of genotype 1b hepatitis C virus in chimpanzees in the presence of vaccine-induced E1-neutralizing antibodies. J Infect Dis 204: 837–44.BE VerstrepenE. DeplaCS RollierG. MaresJA Drexhage2011Clearance of genotype 1b hepatitis C virus in chimpanzees in the presence of vaccine-induced E1-neutralizing antibodies.J Infect Dis20483744
- 8. Dorner M, Horwitz JA, Robbins JB, Barry WT, Feng Q, et al. (2011) A genetically humanized mouse model for hepatitis C virus infection. Nature 474: 208–11.M. DornerJA HorwitzJB RobbinsWT BarryQ. Feng2011A genetically humanized mouse model for hepatitis C virus infection.Nature47420811
- 9. Ploss A, Rice CM (2009) Towards a small animal model for hepatitis C. EMBO 10: 1220–7.A. PlossCM Rice2009Towards a small animal model for hepatitis C.EMBO1012207
- 10. Ploss A, Evans MJ, Gaysinskaya VA, Panis M, You H, et al. (2009) Human occluding is a hepatitis C virus entry factor required for infection of mouse cells. Nature 457: 882–6.A. PlossMJ EvansVA GaysinskayaM. PanisH. You2009Human occluding is a hepatitis C virus entry factor required for infection of mouse cells.Nature4578826
- 11. McGivern DR, Lemon SM (2011) Model Systems for hepatitis C Research: the Cup half empty? Gastroenterology 141: 806–9.DR McGivernSM Lemon2011Model Systems for hepatitis C Research: the Cup half empty?Gastroenterology1418069
- 12. Kapoor A, Simmonds P, Gerold G, Qaisar N, Jain K, et al. (2011) Characterization of a canine homolog of hepatitis C virus. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108: 11608–13.A. KapoorP. SimmondsG. GeroldN. QaisarK. Jain2011Characterization of a canine homolog of hepatitis C virus.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA1081160813
- 13. Abenavoli L, Addolorato G, Riccardi L, Gasbarrini A, et al. (2008) Elastography assessment in patients with chronic HCV infection. Int J Clin Pract 62: 1108–1112.L. AbenavoliG. AddoloratoL. RiccardiA. Gasbarrini2008Elastography assessment in patients with chronic HCV infection.Int J Clin Pract6211081112
- 14. Castera L, Forns X, Alberti A (2008) Non-invasive evaluation of liver fibrosis using transient elastography. J Hepatol 48: 835–847.L. CasteraX. FornsA. Alberti2008Non-invasive evaluation of liver fibrosis using transient elastography.J Hepatol48835847
- 15. Fraquelli M, Rigamonti C, Casazza G, Conte D, Donato MF, et al. (2007) Reproducibility of transient elastography in the evaluation of liver fibrosis in patients with chronic liver disease. Gut 56: 968–973.M. FraquelliC. RigamontiG. CasazzaD. ConteMF Donato2007Reproducibility of transient elastography in the evaluation of liver fibrosis in patients with chronic liver disease.Gut56968973
- 16. Takeda T, Yasuda T, Nakayama Y, Nakaya M, Kimura M, et al. (2006) Usefulness of noninvasive transient elastography for assessment of liver fibrosis stage in chronic hepatitis C. World J Gastroenterol 12: 7768–7773.T. TakedaT. YasudaY. NakayamaM. NakayaM. Kimura2006Usefulness of noninvasive transient elastography for assessment of liver fibrosis stage in chronic hepatitis C.World J Gastroenterol1277687773
- 17. Vergara S, Macías J, Rivero A, Gutiérrez-Valencia A, González-Serrano M, et al. (2007) The Use of Transient Elastometry in Assessing Liver Fibrosis in Patients with HIV/HCV Coinfection. Clinical Infectious Diseases 45: 969–74.S. VergaraJ. MacíasA. RiveroA. Gutiérrez-ValenciaM. González-Serrano2007The Use of Transient Elastometry in Assessing Liver Fibrosis in Patients with HIV/HCV Coinfection.Clinical Infectious Diseases4596974
- 18. Ingiliz P, Chhay KP, Munteanu M, Lebray P, Ngo Y, et al. (2009) Applicability and variability of liver stiffness measurements according to probe position. World Journal of Gastroenterology 15: 3398–3404.P. IngilizKP ChhayM. MunteanuP. LebrayY. Ngo2009Applicability and variability of liver stiffness measurements according to probe position.World Journal of Gastroenterology1533983404
- 19. Neukam K, Recio E, Camacho A, Macias J, Rivero A, et al. (2010) Interobserver concordance in the assessment of liver fibrosis in HIV/HCV-coinfected patients using transient elastometry. European Journal of Gastroenterology&Hepatology 15: 93–6.K. NeukamE. RecioA. CamachoJ. MaciasA. Rivero2010Interobserver concordance in the assessment of liver fibrosis in HIV/HCV-coinfected patients using transient elastometry.European Journal of Gastroenterology&Hepatology15936
- 20. Sandrin L, Fourquet B, Hasquenoph JM, Yon S, Fournier C, et al. (2003) Transient elastography: a new noninvasive method for assessment of hepatic fibrosis. Ultrasound in Medicine&Biology 29: 1705–1713.L. SandrinB. FourquetJM HasquenophS. YonC. Fournier2003Transient elastography: a new noninvasive method for assessment of hepatic fibrosis.Ultrasound in Medicine&Biology2917051713
- 21. Kim KM, Choi WB, Park SH, Yu E, Lee SG, et al. (2007) Diagnosis of hepatic steatosis and fibrosis by transient elastography in asymptomatic healthy individuals: a prospective study of related living potential liver donors. Journal of Gastroenterology 42: 382–388.KM KimWB ChoiSH ParkE. YuSG Lee2007Diagnosis of hepatic steatosis and fibrosis by transient elastography in asymptomatic healthy individuals: a prospective study of related living potential liver donors.Journal of Gastroenterology42382388
- 22. Laflamme DP (1997) Development and Validation of a Body Condition Score System for Dogs. Canine Practice 22: 10–15.DP Laflamme1997Development and Validation of a Body Condition Score System for Dogs.Canine Practice221015
- 23. Friedrich-Rust M, Ong MF, Martens S, Sarrazin C, Bojunga , et al. (2008) Performance of transient elastography for the staging of liver fibrosis: a metaanalysis. Gastroenterology Journal 134: 960–974.M. Friedrich-RustMF OngS. MartensC. SarrazinBojunga2008Performance of transient elastography for the staging of liver fibrosis: a metaanalysis.Gastroenterology Journal134960974
- 24. Roulot D, Czernichow S, Le Clesiau H, Costes JL, Vergnaud AC, et al. (2008) Liver stiffness values in apparently healthy subjects: influence of gender and metabolic syndrome. Journal of Hepatology 48: 606–613.D. RoulotS. CzernichowH. Le ClesiauJL CostesAC Vergnaud2008Liver stiffness values in apparently healthy subjects: influence of gender and metabolic syndrome.Journal of Hepatology48606613
- 25. Pineda JA, Recio E, Camacho A, Macías J, Almodóvar C, et al. (2009) Liver stiffness as a predictor of esophageal varices requiring therapy in HIV/hepatitis C virus-coinfected patients with cirrhosis. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 51: 445–9.JA PinedaE. RecioA. CamachoJ. MacíasC. Almodóvar2009Liver stiffness as a predictor of esophageal varices requiring therapy in HIV/hepatitis C virus-coinfected patients with cirrhosis.Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes514459
- 26. Lucidarme D, Foucher J, Le Bail B, Castera L, Villars S, et al. (2007) Ratio interquartile range/median value of liver stiffness measurement is a key factor of accuracy of transient elastography (FIBROSCAN®) for the diagnosis of liver fibrosis. Journal of Hepatology 46: A318.D. LucidarmeJ. FoucherB. Le BailL. CasteraS. Villars2007Ratio interquartile range/median value of liver stiffness measurement is a key factor of accuracy of transient elastography (FIBROSCAN®) for the diagnosis of liver fibrosis.Journal of Hepatology46A318