To establish the reliability and validity of a shortened (10-item) depression scale used among HIV-positive patients enrolled in the Drug Treatment Program in British Columbia, Canada.
The 10-item CES-D (Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale) was examined among 563 participants who initiated antiretroviral therapy (ART) between August 1, 1996 and June 30, 2002. Internal consistency of the scale was measured by Cronbach’s alpha. Using the original CES-D 20 as primary criteria, comparisons were made using the Kappa statistic. Predictive accuracy of CES-D 10 was assessed by calculating sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive values and negative predictive values. Factor analysis was also performed to determine if the CES-D 10 contained the same factors of positive and negative affect found in the original development of the CES-D.
The correlation between the original and the shortened scale is very high (Spearman correlation coefficient = 0.97 (P<0.001). Internal consistency reliability coefficients of the CES-D 10 were satisfactory (Cronbach α = 0.88). The CES-D 10 showed comparable accuracy to the original CES-D 20 in classifying participants with depressive symptoms (Kappa = 0.82, P<0.001). Sensitivity of CES-D 10 was 91%; specificity was 92%; and positive predictive value was 92%. Factor analysis demonstrates that CES-D 10 contains the same underlying factors of positive and negative affect found in the original development of the CES-D 20.
Citation: Zhang W, O’Brien N, Forrest JI, Salters KA, Patterson TL, Montaner JSG, et al. (2012) Validating a Shortened Depression Scale (10 Item CES-D) among HIV-Positive People in British Columbia, Canada. PLoS ONE 7(7): e40793. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0040793
Editor: Shilpa J. Buch, University of Nebraska Medical Center, United States of America
Received: March 16, 2012; Accepted: June 13, 2012; Published: July 19, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Zhang et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the Michael Smith Foundation for Health Research through Fellowship Awards to Dr. Lima. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have read the journal's policy and have the following conflicts to report: Dr. Robert Hogg has held grant funding from the National Institutes of Health, Canadian Institutes of Health Research National Health Research Development Program, Health Canada, GlaxoSmithKline and Merck Frosst Laboratories. Dr. Julio S.G. Montaner has received grants from Abbott, Biolytical, Boehringer Ingelheim, Bristol-Myers Squibb, Gilead Sciences, Janssen, Merck and ViiV Healthcare. He is also supported by the Ministry of Health Services and the Ministry of Healthy Living and Sport, from the Province of British Columbia; through a Knowledge Translation Award from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR); and through an Avant-Garde Award (No. 1DP1DA026182-01) from the National Institute of Drug Abuse, at the U.S. National Institutes of Health. He has also received support from the International AIDS Society, United Nations AIDS Program, World Health Organization, National Institute on Drug Abuse, National Institutes of Health Research-Office of AIDS Research, National Institute of Allergy & Infectious Diseases, The United States President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPfAR), Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, French National Agency for Research on AIDS & Viral Hepatitis (ANRS), Public Health Agency of Canada. He has academic partnerships with the University of British Columbia, Simon Fraser University, Providence Health Care and Vancouver Coastal Health. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLoS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Depression is a major problem among people living with HIV/AIDS , . The Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) is one of the most common screening tests for identifying depressive symptoms in the general population . The 20-item scale is a self-reported measure of an individual’s depressive feelings and behaviors in the past week. It is designed for studies ascertaining the relationship between depression and other variables. Major components of depressive symptomology are incorporated into the scale including, depressed mood, feelings of guilt and worthlessness, feelings of helplessness and hopelessness, psychomotor retardation, loss of appetite, and sleep disturbance . The scale’s validity and reliability to detect both clinical and non-clinical depressive symptoms have been well established . Moreover, the scale has been widely used in different cohort studies suggesting its suitability for a variety of sample populations and diverse contexts.
Despite the CES-D scale’s established reliability among general populations, when embedded in large-scale surveys, the 20-item measurement tool is lengthy and onerous. A few studies have shown that the CES-D could be reduced to 10-items with comparable reliability and validity to the original scale, though none with entire cohorts of HIV-positive individuals –. Previous studies have used various depression scales, such as the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) , the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI)  and the Hamilton Rating Scale  to assess HIV-positive persons. While the BDI has been validated as a shortened scale to increase utilization, research has found that the questions in the BDI are depressing and too focused on the body , . HIV is a condition that spans physical, mental, emotional, social and environmental spheres of health, thus the CES-D scale was selected for use in our research study. The validation of the 10-item CES-D scale may aid survey administration and reduce interviewee burden, especially for HIV patients, many of who are marginalized and face literacy limitations and have competing life demands.
Depression in HIV patients is often under-identified and under-treated which may become very harmful to HIV patients. A meta-analysis of ten studies investigating the relationship between HIV infection and depressive disorders found the frequency of events was nearly two times higher in people living with HIV compared to HIV-negative individuals . Furthermore, studies have demonstrated that the presence of depressive symptoms in HIV-positive individuals is associated with earlier mortality and increased HIV-specific morbidity, despite access to HAART , –. Specifically, depressive symptoms have been found to be associated with key clinical markers of disease progression such as reduced CD4 counts , increased activated CD8 lymphocyte counts  and reduced virologic suppression for people accessing therapy .
The purpose of this study is to validate the shortened 10-item CES-D scale among a cohort of HIV-positive individuals.
Ethical approval was granted by the Providence Health Care Research Ethics Board to use the data for research purposes. Written consent via a standardized consent form approved by the Research Ethics Board verified participant consent prior to any data collection or engagement in the study. Participants who declined to participate, before, during or after data collection or otherwise did not participate remained eligible for treatment and were not disadvantaged in any other way by not participating in the study.
HIV/AIDS Drug Treatment Program
This study was conducted at the Drug Treatment Program (DTP), at the BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS, which is mandated by the provincial government to distribute antiretroviral medications free of charge to all eligible HIV-positive individuals. The DTP distributes medications in accordance with the BC Therapeutic Guideline Committee, which have remained consistent with those from the International AIDS Society-USA between 1996 and the most recent revision in 2010 . Details regarding the distribution of antiretroviral medications though the DTP have been previously described in depth . In brief, physicians enter individuals into the DTP when they are first prescribed ART. The enrolling physician must complete a drug request form, which acts as a legal prescription and is used to compile baseline information including past HIV-specific drug history, CD4 cell counts, plasma HIV RNA levels, current drug requests, and enrolling-physician data.
Study Subjects and Data Collection
Between August 1, 1996 and June 30, 2002, a total of 1,011 participants completed enrollment surveys, which elicited socio-demographic, clinical and behavioral data including the 20-item CES-D scale. Four hundred and forty-eight (44%) were excluded because they did not complete all 20 questions on the CES-D scale, thus 563 were included in this analysis. A comparison of the included and excluded participants showed that, while there is no significant age difference, the excluded group had more females, higher median CD4 cell counts, lower viral load baseline measurements, and fewer individuals that had completed high school. Participants were ≥18 years of age and naïve to antiretroviral therapy when they started HAART.
CES-D 20 and CES-D 10
The CES-D 20 component of the survey  was administered and completed by HIV-positive participants at their enrollment in the provincial Drug Treatment Program. In brief, subjects responded to each item of the scale by rating the frequency of each mood or symptom “during the past week” on a four-point scale. A score is assigned by totaling all items (after reversing the positive mood items]. The possible range for the 20-item scale is 0 to 60, and a cut off score of 16 or higher indicates the presence of significant depressive symptoms.
Our shortened scale was selected from a previously validated ten items in an older adult population . A list of all CES-D 20 items is presented in Table 1, with an asterisk identifying the ten items of our proposed shortened scale. In accordance with Andresen, the possible range of the 10-item scale is 0 to 30, and a cut off score of ten or higher indicates the presence of significant depressive symptoms.
For each individual we compared their responses to the 20-item scale to our proposed 10-items. The agreement between the CES-D 20 and CES-D 10 was measured using the spearman correlation coefficient and the kappa statistic with two-tailed probability for statistical significance. Cronbach’s alpha  was used to estimate the internal consistency of the items within the scale. A reliability coefficient exceeding 0.70 was considered acceptable. Sensitivity and specificity were calculated for the proposed CES-D 10, with sensitivity being the probability of identifying correctly those participants with significant depressive symptoms, while specificity measured the probability of identifying correctly those participants without significant depressive symptoms. Factor analysis with varimax rotation was conducted to examine the latent structure of the new scale. All analyses were conducted using SAS version 9.1.3 (SAS, Cary, North Carolina, United States) with a level of significance set at 0.05.
The baseline characteristics of the 563 participants have been previously reported . Within the sample, the median age was 38 years (IQR: 34–46 years) and 14% reported aboriginal ancestry, as noted in table 2. In addition, 35% of participants had an average annual income of less than $10,000, 29% did not complete high school, 28% had a history of injection drug use, 20% had an AIDS diagnosis at baseline and 23% reported suboptimal adherence (≥95%) in the first year of follow-up (table 2). Clinical characteristics included a median CD4 cell count of 230 cells/µL (IQR: 80-390 cells/ul), and median HIV RNA plasma viral load (pVL) of 120,000 copies/ml (IQR: 43800-280000 copies/ml) at their initiation of antiretroviral therapy.
We initially compared participants categorized as significant vs non-significant depressive scores on the two scales (table 2). The Kappa statistic for the two methods was 0.82 (table 3). In detail, 289 individuals (51%) were classified as having significant depressive symptoms (CES-D-20≥16) and 284 individuals (50%) were classified as having significant depressive symptoms (CES-D-10≥10) (see table 3). These data suggest that the brief scale is able to identify individuals with significant depression with good precision.
A factor analysis was conducted to reveal the internal structure of the two scales (as seen in Table 4). Factor 1 was made up of eight items that are all negative statements on patient’s daily life and feeling (all with correlation >0.5) and the remaining two items that are both positive statements were loaded heavily on factor 2 (both with correlation >0.7). The structure clearly revealed two independent factors of the CES-D 10, which were similar to the “negative (depressed) affect” and “positive” affect of the original version of the CES-D. The two factors together explained nearly 60% of the variation of the data.
In our analysis, the CES-D-10 scale accurately predicts significant depressive symptoms with good precision in comparison to the 20-item scale. While the reliability of the shortened scale in screening for depressive symptoms in healthy older adults has been demonstrated , our findings extend previous reports of the reliability of shortened scales to HIV+ populations who are treatment-naïve at time of enrollment. The factor analysis concluded that the factors most associated with predicating outcomes in the 20-item scale were paralleled in the 10-item scale. The current study provides evidence that the 10-items selected here from the original CES-D scale can be a reliable and a valid measure of significant depressive symptoms among HIV-positive participants.
Given the length of comprehensive questionnaires used to survey the well-being and health of HIV-positive research participants, a shortened scale is needed to allow for a more rapid assessment of significant depressive symptomology, while still maintaining a high degree of sensitivity. This shortened tool will prove to be especially relevant when surveying populations faced with chaotic and un-structured daily lives that may find a 20-item scale too onerous. A number of studies demonstrate a high prevalence of depression among HIV-positive populations and the negative health outcomes of this co-morbidity, which again underlines the importance of this shortened scale . This tool will improve the ability of clinical and public health researchers to assess depressive symptoms among HIV-positive individuals.
There are several limitations of this study. Future studies should examine the test-retest reliability of the CES-D-10 item scale. While we have shown the reliability of this scale using internal consistency, measured by Cronbach’s alpha , unfortunately, unlike previous studies , , where these authors assessed the test-retest reliability, we were unable to assess the test-retest reliability because these participants were not followed up with the same instrument items. However, previous research has used the same ten items to demonstrate that the test-retest reliability of the scale has been satisfied .
Our study did not compare the CES-D 10 with clinical diagnoses of depression made by licensed psychiatrists, as the BC-CfE does not collect or link to this data. Although the original CES-D was not designed as a clinical diagnostic tool, the shorter instrument may still benefit from comparisons with clinical criteria of depression, such as the Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC) or the Diagnostic Interview Survey (DIS).
With a potential sample size of 1,011 for this analysis, nearly half (44%) were excluded because they failed to complete the entire 20-question CES-D scale. Participants that did not complete the entire scale were more likely to be female, have a higher median CD4 cell count, lower viral load baseline measurements and to have not completed high school. Factors such as gender, viral load and education are also found to differ significantly between those characterized by depressive symptoms in our study. The authors hypothesize that individuals may have felt these questions were irrelevant as their physical health is considered to be satisfactory. Another reasoning for this trend is that these are populations that are socially marginalized and have competing priorities that don’t allow for mental health to be a concern, suggesting that a large proportion of the population is being overlooked in terms of their potential depressive symptoms.
Our analysis of the shortened 10-item CES-D scale attained satisfactory prediction accuracy and reliability in assessing significant depressive symptoms among HIV-positive patients. The validation of this shortened scale provides a useful tool for researching depressive symptomology among HIV-positive populations. We further recommend that our 10-item scale be validated among other populations.
We would like to thank the LISA participants for their willingness to contribute to this study. We would also like to thank the additional LISA study team members at the British Columbia Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS who helped contribute to this project.
Conceived and designed the experiments: VDL WZ RSH TLP JSGM. Performed the experiments: VDL RSH. Analyzed the data: WZ VDL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: NO WZ JIF VDL RSH. Wrote the paper: WZ NO JIF KAS. Statistical analysis: WZ VDL.
- 1. Lima VD, Geller J, Bangsberg DR, Patterson TL, Daniel M, et al. (2007) The effect of adherence on the association between significant depressive symptoms and mortality among HIV-infected individuals first initiating HAART. AIDS 21: 1175.VD LimaJ. GellerDR BangsbergTL PattersonM. Daniel2007The effect of adherence on the association between significant depressive symptoms and mortality among HIV-infected individuals first initiating HAART.AIDS211175
- 2. Penzak S, Reddy S, Grimsley S (2000) Depression in patients with HIV infection. Am J Health 2000 57: 376.S. PenzakS. ReddyS. Grimsley2000Depression in patients with HIV infection.Am J Health 200057376
- 3. Radloff LS (1977) The CES-D Scale: A Self Report Depression Scale for Research in the General. Applied psychological measurement 1(3): 385–401.LS Radloff1977The CES-D Scale: A Self Report Depression Scale for Research in the General.Applied psychological measurement1(3)385401
- 4. Boey KW (1999) Cross-validation of a short form of the CES-D in Chinese elderly. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 14(8): 608–617.KW Boey1999Cross-validation of a short form of the CES-D in Chinese elderly.Int J GeriatrPsychiatry 14(8)608617
- 5. Irwin M, Artin KH, Oxman MN (1999) Screening for depression in the older adult: criterion validity of the 10-item Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D). Arch Intern Med 159(15): 1701.M. IrwinKH ArtinMN Oxman1999Screening for depression in the older adult: criterion validity of the 10-item Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D).Arch Intern Med159(15)1701
- 6. Andresen EM (1994) Screening for depression in well older adults: Evaluation of a short form of the CES-D. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 10(2): 77.EM Andresen1994Screening for depression in well older adults: Evaluation of a short form of the CES-D.American Journal of Preventive Medicine10(2)77
- 7. Reda A (2011) Reliability and validity of the Ethiopian Version of the hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS) in HIV infected patients. PloS ONE 6(1): el60409.A. Reda2011Reliability and validity of the Ethiopian Version of the hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS) in HIV infected patients.PloS ONE6(1)el60409
- 8. Beck AT, Ward CH, Mendelson M, Mock J, Erbaugh J (1961) An Inventory for Measuring Depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 4(6): 561.AT BeckCH WardM. MendelsonJ. MockJ. Erbaugh1961An Inventory for Measuring Depression.Arch Gen Psychiatry4(6)561
- 9. Hamilton M (1960) A rating scale for depression. Journal of neurology, neurosurgery and psychiatry 21(1): 56.M. Hamilton1960A rating scale for depression.Journal of neurology, neurosurgery and psychiatry21(1)56
- 10. Golub E, Latka M, Hagan H, Havens J, Hudson S, et al. (2004) Screening for depressive symptoms among HCV-infected injection drug users: Examination of the utility of the CES-D and the beck depression inventory. Journal of Urban Health 81(2): 278.E. GolubM. LatkaH. HaganJ. HavensS. Hudson2004Screening for depressive symptoms among HCV-infected injection drug users: Examination of the utility of the CES-D and the beck depression inventory.Journal of Urban Health81(2)278
- 11. Wilcox H, Field T, Prodromidis M, Scafidi F (1998) Correlations between the Bdi and Ces-D in a Sample of Adolescent Mothers. Adolescence 33: 565.H. WilcoxT. FieldM. ProdromidisF. Scafidi1998Correlations between the Bdi and Ces-D in a Sample of Adolescent Mothers.Adolescence33565
- 12. Ciesla JA, Roberts JE (2001) Meta-Analysis of the relationship between HIV infection and risk for depressive disorders. Am J Psychiatry 158: 725.JA CieslaJE Roberts2001Meta-Analysis of the relationship between HIV infection and risk for depressive disorders.Am J Psychiatry158725
- 13. Burack JH, Barrett DC, Stall RD, Chesney MA, Ekstrand ML, et al. (1993) Significant depressive symptoms and CD4 lymphocyte decline among HIV-infected men. JAMA 270: 2568.JH BurackDC BarrettRD StallMA ChesneyML Ekstrand1993Significant depressive symptoms and CD4 lymphocyte decline among HIV-infected men.JAMA2702568
- 14. Ickovics JR, Hamburger ME, Vlahov D, Schoenbaum E, Schuman P, et al. (2001) Mortality, CD4 cell count decline, and depression symptoms among HIV-seropositive Women: Longitudinal Analysis from the HIV epidemiology research study. JAMA 285: 1466.JR IckovicsME HamburgerD. VlahovE. SchoenbaumP. Schuman2001Mortality, CD4 cell count decline, and depression symptoms among HIV-seropositive Women: Longitudinal Analysis from the HIV epidemiology research study.JAMA2851466
- 15. Mayne TJ, Vittinghoff E, Chesney MA, Barrett DC, Coates TJ (1996) Depressive affect and survival among gay and bisexual men infected with HIV. Arch intern Med 156: 2233.TJ MayneE. VittinghoffMA ChesneyDC BarrettTJ Coates1996Depressive affect and survival among gay and bisexual men infected with HIV.Arch intern Med1562233
- 16. Hartzell JD, Spooner K, Howard R, Wegner S, Wortmann G (2007) Race and mental health diagnosis are risk factors for highly active antiretroviral therapy failure in a military cohort despite equal access to care. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 44: 411.JD HartzellK. SpoonerR. HowardS. WegnerG. Wortmann2007Race and mental health diagnosis are risk factors for highly active antiretroviral therapy failure in a military cohort despite equal access to care.J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr44411
- 17. Evans DL, Ten Have TR, Douglas SD, Gettes DR, Morrison M, et al. (2002) Association of depression with viral load, CD8 T lymphocytes, and natural killer cells in women with HIV infection. Am J Psychiatry 159: 1752.DL EvansTR Ten HaveSD DouglasDR GettesM. Morrison2002Association of depression with viral load, CD8 T lymphocytes, and natural killer cells in women with HIV infection.Am J Psychiatry1591752
- 18. Pence BW, Miller WC, Gaynes BN, Eron JJ (2007) Psychiatric illness and virologic response in patients initiating highly active antiretroviral therapy. J Acquire Immune Defic Syndr 44: 159.BW PenceWC MillerBN GaynesJJ Eron2007Psychiatric illness and virologic response in patients initiating highly active antiretroviral therapy.J Acquire Immune Defic Syndr44159
- 19. Thompson M, Aberg J, Cahn P, Montaner J, Rizzardini G, et al. (2010) International AIDS Society-USA. Antiretroviral treatment of adult HIV infection: 2010 recommendations of the International AIDS Society-USA panel. JAMA 304(3): 321–333.M. ThompsonJ. AbergP. CahnJ. MontanerG. Rizzardini2010International AIDS Society-USA. Antiretroviral treatment of adult HIV infection: 2010 recommendations of the International AIDS Society-USA panel.JAMA304(3)321333
- 20. Hogg RS, Yip B, Chan KJ, Wood E, Craib KJ, et al. (2001) Rates of disease progression by baseline CD4 cell count and viral load after initiating triple-drug therapy. JAMA 286(20): 2568–2577.RS HoggB. YipKJ ChanE. WoodKJ Craib2001Rates of disease progression by baseline CD4 cell count and viral load after initiating triple-drug therapy.JAMA286(20)25682577
- 21. Cronbach L (1951) Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests. Psycheometrika 16(3): 297.L. Cronbach1951Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests.Psycheometrika16(3)297