Embryo development in plants initiates following the transverse division of a zygote into an apical, proembryo cell and a basal cell that gives rise to the suspensor. Although mutants affected in embryo development through changes in cell division have been described, little is known about the control of the first zygotic division that gives rise to the proembryo. Ascorbic acid (Asc) promotes cell division by inducing G1 to S progression but its role in embryo development has not been examined. In this study, we show that the level of dehydroascorbate reductase (DHAR) expression, which recycles Asc and regulates Asc pool size, affects the rate of monozygotic twinning and polycotyly. DHAR-induced twinning resulted from altered cell polarity and longitudinal instead of transverse cell division that generated embryos of equal size. Direct injection of Asc into ovaries phenocopied DHAR-induced twinning. Twinning induced by Asc was developmentally limited to the first two days after pollination whereas polycotyly was induced when the level of Asc was elevated just prior to cotyledon initiation. This work describes the first example of gene-directed monozygotic twinning and shows that Asc regulates cell polarity during embryo development.
Citation: Chen Z, Gallie DR (2012) Induction of Monozygotic Twinning by Ascorbic Acid in Tobacco. PLoS ONE 7(6): e39147. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0039147
Editor: Michal Shapira, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel
Received: February 24, 2012; Accepted: May 20, 2012; Published: June 18, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Chen, Gallie. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The research was supported by the University of California Agricultural Experiment Station. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Embryo development initiates following the transverse division of a zygote into an apical, proembryo cell and a basal cell that gives rise to the suspensor, to generate one embryo per seed. The presence of more than one embryo per seed can result from apomixis, which occurs in a wide range of flowering plant taxa, or by twinning –, . Apomixis is the asexual formation of a seed from maternal ovule tissues not involving meiosis and fertilization which results in monoembryony or polyembryony. In apomicts, embryos can arise spontaneously from ovule cells (i.e., sporophytic apomixis) or from cells of an unreduced embryo sac (i.e., gametophytic apomixis) depending on the species . In either case, embryos resulting from apomixis are genetically maternally-derived. Twinning commonly refers to the generation of more than one zygotically-derived embryo following fertilization. Identical twins arise from the same zygote, either following the first zygotic division (i.e., monozygotic twinning) or ectopically from other embryonic tissues such as the suspensor –.
In Arabidopsis, embryos of the twn2 mutant exhibit reduced valyl-tRNA synthetase expression resulting in growth arrest of the embryo proper and embryogenetic transformation of suspensor cells . Embryogenetic development of suspensor cells also occurs in the twn1 and amp1 mutants in the absence of embryo proper arrest, suggesting loss of embryo proper-suspensor communication –. In these examples, twinning resulted from embryo development from suspensor cells once suppression of the embryogenetic potential of the suspensor was released. In such mutants, the development of ectopic embryos requires changes in the plane of cell division within the suspensor (e.g., longitudinal instead of transverse) that enable the growth of embryos or embryoid tissue. These mutants also exhibited cotyledon fusion or polycotyly independent of suspensor transformation, suggesting that these genes can affect cotyledon development as well as embryo development. Despite the isolation of several mutants affecting embryo development, no mutant affecting the first zygotic division in a way that results in monozygotic twinning has been reported and therefore those factors controlling the correct formation of the apical, proembryo cell and basal cell are unknown.
Ascorbic acid (Asc) is a major antioxidant that serves several functions in plants. Asc is involved in the detoxification of reactive oxygen species, e.g., superoxide, singlet oxygen, ozone, and H2O2, which are produced during aerobic metabolic processes such as photosynthesis or respiration). Asc is required for the re  generation of α-tocopherol (vitamin E) from the tocopheroxyl radical . Asc serves as a co-factor for enzymes such as violaxanthin de-epoxidase (VDE) in the xanthophyll cycle, ACC oxidase which generates ethylene, and prolyl and lysyl hydrolases – as well as for 2-oxoacid-dependent dioxygenases required for the synthesis of abscisic acid and gibberellic acid –.
Asc may also be involved in regulating cell growth where it promotes the G1 to S phase progression of cells within the quiescent center (QC) of onion roots –. Asc is present in low amounts in the QC of maize roots and increases considerably during logarithmic growth of tobacco cell culture , . Asc also reversed the inhibition of cell division caused by lycorine treatment which reduces Asc content .
Once used, Asc is oxidized to the monodehydroascorbate radical (MDHA) that can be reduced to Asc in the chloroplast stroma by either monodehydroascorbate reductase (MDHAR) or ferredoxin or in the cytosol by MDHAR , . MDHA can also rapidly disproportionate to Asc and dehydroascorbate (DHA) . DHA is then reduced to Asc by dehydroascorbate reductase (DHAR) in a reaction requiring glutathione. In the absence of sufficient DHAR, however, DHA undergoes irreversible hydrolysis to 2,3-diketogulonic acid. Because the apoplast contains little glutathione or DHAR, DHA, which predominates in the apoplast, is actively transported into the cell for reduction to Asc to avoid its hydrolysis.
Despite the several pathways in which Asc can be regenerated, the level of DHAR expression in leaves is rate-limiting for Asc recycling and therefore, DHAR significantly contributes to the control of the Asc pool size and redox state –. Increased DHAR expression improved the efficiency of Asc recycling resulting in a larger cytosolic and apoplastic Asc pool size and higher redox state (i.e., was more reduced) –. Conversely, suppression of DHAR expression reduced the efficiency of Asc recycling which resulted in a lower cytosolic and apoplastic Asc redox state (i.e., was more oxidized) –.
Because Asc has been reported to promote cell division, we examined whether Asc regulates cell division during embryo development. We observed that a high level of DHAR expression induced monozygotic twinning and polycotyly. Twinning induced by DHAR resulted from altered cell polarity and longitudinal instead of transverse cell division of the zygote, generating embryos of equal size. Direct injection of Asc into ovaries phenocopied the DHAR-induced twinning demonstrating that it was the product of DHAR activity that was responsible for altered embryo development. Monozygotic twinning induced by Asc was developmentally limited to the first two days after pollination, consistent with its role in altering zygotic division. Similarly, polycotyly was induced when Asc levels were elevated just prior to cotyledon initiation. Our results demonstrate that the level of DHAR expression, and therefore, the level of Asc regulates cell polarity during embryo development.
DHAR expression regulates polyembryony
In previous work, we reported the generation of tobacco (i.e., Nicotiana tabacum) in which DHAR was overexpressed or suppressed –. To overexpress DHAR, tobacco was transformed with a wheat (i.e., Triticum aestivum) DHAR cDNA (DTa) under the control of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter . As DTa has diverged sufficiently from the tobacco DHAR ortholog at the nucleotide level, this approach avoided RNA silencing of DHAR expression. To suppress DHAR, tobacco was transformed with a tobacco DHAR cDNA (DNt) under the control of the 35S promoter, resulting in the generation of lines in which DHAR expression was suppressed . An increase in DHAR expression results in a larger Asc pool size . Polyembryony (i.e., 2–3 embryos per seed)(Fig. 1A–H) and either polycotyly (3–4 cotyledons per seedling, Fig. 1K–P) or monocotyly (Fig. 1Q–S) were observed in DTa progeny at a higher frequency (9/4081 and 117/4081 seeds, respectively) than in vector-only lines (0/1774 and 9/1774 seeds, respectively) or lines expressing inactive, C-terminally-truncated, inactive DTa  (0/1496 and 3/1496 seeds, respectively). Removal of chlorophyll from seedlings exhibiting monocotyly revealed two main veins and a fusion plane that extended to the base (Fig. 1T) indicating fusion of two cotyledons that was also observed in tricot seedlings (Fig. 1M–N). The simple venation of the cotyledons in single and polycot seedlings and the observation that they arose from the first node (Fig. 1Q–T) indicated that they were true cotyledons. Cotyledon defects were as likely to result from monoembryonic DTa seed as from polyembryonic DTa seed, suggesting that polycotyly was not a consequence of polyembryony. Seed from DHAR-overexpressing tobacco were viable and twin seedlings grew normally with no vegetative defects, demonstrating that this aspect of DHAR overexpression was embryo-specific.
A–F, Twin progeny emerging from DHAR-overexpressing tobacco seed. G–H, Triplet progeny emerging from DHAR-overexpressing tobacco seed. I–J, Twin progeny emerging from WT seed that developed from ovaries injected with 10 mM Asc on the day of pollination. K–N, Tricotyledon progeny from DHAR-overexpressing tobacco seed in various states of fusion. O–P, Tetracotyledon progeny from DHAR-overexpressing tobacco seed. Q–T, Monocotyledon progeny from DHAR-overexpressing tobacco seed where (T) the fused cotyledon was cleared of chlorophyll to reveal two main veins and plane of fusion. U, Wild-type seedling cleared of chlorophyll.
To determine whether twinning results from inheritance of the DHARTa transgene through the female or male germline, reciprocal crosses between wild-type (WT) and DTa plants were performed. An increase in twinning following DHARTa transgene inheritance through male gametes would demonstrate that expression of DHAR in maternal tissues is not essential. Conversely, twinning resulting only from DHARTa transgene inheritance through the female germline would suggest that transmission through male gametes is insufficient to cause twinning. An equal increase in twinning regardless of which parent transmits the DHARTa transgene would suggest that twinning is dependent on inheritance of the DHARTa transgene alone and that maternal effects are not involved. Progeny from a cross between a WT male (WT-m) and a DTa female (DTa-f) exhibited a 50-fold increase in polyembryony (1.70%) relative to WT plants (0.034%)(Fig. 2), demonstrating that inheritance of the DHARTa transgene through the female germline is sufficient to cause twinning. Progeny from a cross between a DTa male (DTa-m) and a WT-female (WT-f) exhibited a 7-fold increase in polyembryony (0.24%) compared to WT plants (Fig. 2), demonstrating that inheritance of the DHARTa transgene through the male germline is also sufficient to cause twinning but to a lower extent than in the reciprocal cross. These results demonstrate that maternal expression of DHAR, which results in an increase in the Asc pool size throughout the plant , induces a higher level of polyembryony than does paternal expression of DHAR. The polyembryony resulting from transmission of the DTa transgene through male gametes, however, demonstrates that DHAR-mediated polyembryony occurs after fertilization.
Frequency of twinning and polycotyly resulting from crosses between WT and DHAR-overexpressing tobacco. Crosses between wild-type (WT) and tobacco transformed with wheat DHAR (DTa) or tobacco DHAR (DNt) were performed. The histograms represent the frequency of twinning (black bars, left scale) and cotyledon abnormalities (i.e., polycotyly or single fused cotyledon)(white bars, right scale) measured in the resulting seed.
Overexpression of the DTa transgene results in an increase in DHAR expression throughout the plant (Fig. 3) whereas expression of the DNt transgene results in silencing of DHAR expression in leaves but not in ovules and results in a lower foliar Asc pool size and redox state during plant growth . Measurements of Asc revealed that its level in DHARNt ovules was lower (i.e., 0.861 µg/g FW) than in WT ovules (i.e., 1.25 µg/g FW) whereas the level of Asc in DHARTa ovules was higher (i.e., 1.48 µg/g FW). Because of this, it was possible to separate maternal effects of Asc from Asc produced in the zygote specifically. The frequency of polyembryony was lower in a cross between a WT-m and a DNt female (DNt-f) (0.28%) than between a WT-m and a DTa-f (1.70%), demonstrating that increasing DHAR expression throughout the plant increases polyembryony. As Asc can be transported to sink tissues including floral organs , these results indicate that the frequency of polyembryony is likely determined by contributions made by maternal tissues in addition to embryo-derived Asc. The frequency of polyembryony in the cross between a WT-m and a DNt-f was also lower than it was in a cross between a DNt male (DNt-m) and a WT-f (0.68%), the reverse of the parental influence observed in reciprocal crosses between WT and DTa plants (Fig. 2). Therefore, the frequency of polyembryony was highest in crosses using a DTa female, followed by crosses using a WT female (when the DHAR transgene was provided by the male), which in turn was higher than in crosses using a DNt female. Because the Asc pool size is higher in DTa plants than it is in WT plants which in turn is higher in than it is in DNt plants (Chen and Gallie, 2006), these data support the conclusion that the maternal contribution of Asc influences the frequency of polyembryony. The frequency of polyembryony in the cross between a WT-m and a DNt female (DNt-f), however, was higher (0.28%) than in WT plants (0.034%) despite the fact that the level of Asc is higher in WT plants than in DNt plants. As it is the level of Asc in the fertilized egg specifically that should determine the level of twinning, this observation suggests that the DNt transgene in the embryo is sufficient to modestly increase polyembryony even when the level of Asc in surrounding maternal tissues is low.
DHAR activity was measured in leaves or the indicated floral organs in DHAR-overexpressing (DTa), DHAR-overexpressing (DNt), and wild-type (WT) plants.
In reciprocal crosses between DTa and DNt plants, progeny from a cross between a DNt-m and a DTa-f exhibited a higher level of polyembryony (3.36%) than progeny resulting from a cross between a DTa-m and a DNt-f (0.43%)(Fig. 2), consistent with the previous conclusion that increasing the maternal Asc pool size substantially increases polyembryony. Interestingly, transmission of the DNt transgene through male gametes in the cross between a DNt-m and a DTa-f increased polyembryony approximately 2-fold more (3.36%) relative to a cross between a WT-m and a DTa-f (1.70%), suggesting that the DNt and DTa transgenes each contribute to polyembryony and that the DNt transgene does so following its transmission by the male gametes. Compared to the level of polyembryony observed in the cross between a DNt-m and a DTa-f, the level of polyembryony was reduced almost 2-fold in a cross between a hemizygous DNt-m (WT/DNt-m) and a DTa-f (1.9%)(Fig. 2), supporting the notion that transmission of the DNt transgene through male gametes contributes to polyembryony and reducing its presence in half of the male gametes results in a corresponding reduction in polyembryony. An increase in polyembryony was also observed in a cross between a DTa-m and a DNt-f (0.43%) relative to a cross between a WT-m and a DNt-f (0.28%), supporting the conclusion that both transgenes contribute to polyembryony regardless of their transmission through male or female gametes. A reduction in polyembryony was observed in a cross between a DTa-m and a hemizygous DNt-f (WT/DNt-f) (0.25%) relative to the cross between a DTa-m and a homozygous DNt-f (0.43%), additional evidence indicating that reducing the presence of the DNt transgene in half of the ovules results in a corresponding reduction in polyembryony.
Although the level of polycotyly also increased, this was largely limited to those crosses in which the DTa transgene was expressed in the female (Fig. 2). For example, relative to the level of polycotyly in wild-type plants (0.41%), a nearly 6-fold increase in polycotyly was observed in progeny from a cross between a WT-m and a DTa-f (2.4%) but only a slight increase was observed in progeny from the reciprocal cross (0.5%)(Fig. 2). No increase in polycotyly was observed in progeny from a cross between a WT-m and a DNt-f (0.41%)(where the female has a reduced Asc pool size in vegetative tissues) and only a slight increase in the reciprocal cross (0.68)(Fig. 2). A substantial increase in polycotyly was observed in progeny from a cross between a DNt-m and a DTa-f (4.73%) but no increase in progeny from the reciprocal cross (0.32%)(Fig. 2). These results suggest that it is not so much the presence of the DHAR transgene in the developing embryo but rather the maternal Asc pool size that most influences the frequency of polycotyly. However, transmission of a DHAR transgene through male gametes can contribute moderately to polycotyly especially in females expressing the DTa transgene.
Activity from the CaMV 35S promoter in developing embryos is not detected until the early heart stage –. Significantly higher expression of DHAR was observed in the reproductive organs of DTa and DNt plants, including in pollen, ovules, and style (Fig. 3). If twinning results from an increase in Asc, the observed twinning in DTa plants can be understood by the increase of DHAR expression in maternal tissues and transport of Asc to developing embryos . Maternally-generated Asc can not explain, however, the twinning observed following fertilization of WT ovules by DNt pollen (Fig. 2). Although some studies have reported that the CaMV 35S promoter is silent in pollen, others have observed substantial activity, e.g., in strawberry, cotton, and pine –. Differences in the regulatory elements included in the CaMV 35S promoter used as well as the species examined may account for differences in the level of activity observed –. In tobacco, expression in pollen from the CaMV 35S promoter has been reported, albeit at a lower level than other promoters, e.g., from the nos or lat52 genes , . The higher level of DHAR activity in pollen of DTa and DNt plants indicates that the CaMV 35S promoter used is active during pollen development. To follow the fate of expression from the CaMV 35S promoter in pollen during its subsequent growth through the style and in ovules following fertilization, luciferase expression from tobacco plants containing a 35S::Luc transgene was used as a proxy for DHAR expression. Significant luciferase expression was detected in mature pollen of DTa plants whereas wild-type pollen, style, or ovules had no detectable luciferase expression (Table 1). Two days following pollination, luciferase expression was also detected in the style (excluding the stigma where the pollen grains were present) and in ovules as well (Table 1). Similar results were obtained when pollen from 35S::Luc tobacco was used in crosses with DTa or DNt plants (Table 1). These results indicate that the CaMV 35S promoter used is active during pollen development in tobacco. These results also indicate that, like luciferase, DHAR accompanies growth of the pollen tube through the style and is likely delivered to the egg following fertilization. Any pollen-mediated increase in Asc levels in the fertilized egg would be expected to be greatest at the earliest stage of embryogenesis. As discussed below, increasing Asc in the ovules was effective in inducing twinning only during early embryo development.
Polyembryony induced by DHAR results from monozygotic twinning
Polyembryony can arise through apomixis, i.e., the generation of embryos from maternal cells alone (e.g., parthenogenesis, apogamy, or apospory) or through twinning, i.e., the generation of multiple embryos from the fertilized egg or embryonic cells. Paternal inheritance is absent in apomitic embryos but present in true twins. To determine whether the observed polyembryony was a consequence of apomixis or represented twinning, genetic analysis of the progeny from polyembryonic seeds was performed to determine paternal inheritance. All progeny of polyembryonic seeds resulting from a DNt-m×DTa-f cross or a DNt-m×WT-f cross inherited the pollen-transmitted DNt transgene (Fig. 4A). These results exclude the possibility of apomixis and suggest that the observed polyembryony results from twinning. These results are also consistent with the observation that the polyembryony from a DNt-m×WT-f cross or DTa-m×WT-f cross occurred following fertilization since WT ovules would not be expected to produce twins until after fertilization by DNt pollen. In some cases, fertilization is required to induce apomixis. To rule out that apomixis was induced when the DTa transgene was pollen-transmitted, the presence of the DTa transgene in polyembryonic progeny resulting from a DTa-m×DNt-f cross or a DTa-m×WT-f cross was determined. All polyembryonic progeny inherited the DTa transgene as transmitted through the male gametes (Fig. 4A), ruling out the generation of adventitious, non-zygotic embryos that might have been induced following fertilization by DTa-pollen.
(A) Inheritance of the DTa or DNt transgenes when transmitted through pollen (m) or egg (f) homozygous for the transgene. Inheritance of the DNt transgene in twin (Tw) and triplet (Trp) progeny from DNt pollen (DNt-m) when used to fertilize (1) DTa or (2) WT flowers (WT-f). Inheritance of the DTa transgene in twin and triplet progeny from DTa pollen (DTa-m) when used to fertilize (3) DNt or (4) WT flowers. (B) Inheritance of the DTa or DNt transgenes when transmitted through pollen (m) or egg (f) hemizygous for each transgene. (1) Inheritance of the DNt and DTa transgenes in twin and triplet progeny from eggs hemizygous for the DTa and DNt transgenes (DTa/DNt-f) when fertilized by WT pollen (WT-m). (2) Inheritance of the DNt and DTa transgenes in twin and triplet progeny from pollen hemizygous for the DTa and DNt transgenes (DTa/DNt-m) when used to fertilize WT flowers. (3) Inheritance of the DNt transgene in twin and triplet progeny from pollen hemizygous for DNt transgene present in 2 copies in the genome (DNt(2 copies)-m) when used to fertilize DTa flowers (DTa-f). p: PCR of tobacco containing the appropriate DHAR transgene to serve as a positive control. n: PCR of wild type tobacco to serve as a negative control.
It was possible that the DHAR-induced polyembryonic seed resulted from fusion of independently fertilized ovules as observed in maize  or dizygotic twinning, i.e., the independent fertilization of multiple eggs within a single ovule by multiple male gametes , . To examine this possibility, the transgene inheritance in polyembryonic progeny from a cross between a WT-m and a hemizygous DTa/DNt-f or between a hemizygous DTa/DNt-m and a WT-f was determined. The uniform inheritance of either the DNt transgene or the DTa transgene from a hemizygous DTa/DNt-f parent in the polyembryonic progeny of a seed would rule out fusion of independently fertilized ovules. Similarly, the uniform inheritance of either the DNt transgene or the DTa transgene from a hemizygous DTa/DNt-m parent in the polyembryonic progeny of a seed would rule out dizygotic twinning. Progeny from a cross between a WT-m and a hemizygous DTa/DNt-f were identical in their transgene inheritance as were progeny from a cross between a hemizygous DTa/DNt-m and a WT-f (Fig. 4B), i.e., the inheritance or lack of inheritance of either the DTa or DNt transgene was uniform for all progeny within a given polyembryonic seed. Progeny were also identical in their inheritance of the DNt transgene from male gametes hemizygous for this transgene in a cross with a DTa female (Fig. 4B). These results ruled out the possibility of fusion of independently fertilized ovules or dizygotic twinning, supporting the notion that the progeny arose from a single zygote.
Monozygotic twinning, i.e., twinning that occurs during the first zygotic division, delays embryo development by the time required for the first zygotic division. However, as the twin embryos would be delayed equally, they would exhibit a similar rate of development. To examine whether this may account for the DHAR-induced polyembryony, the development of twin embryos was compared to that of WT embryos. Two or more zygotes were observed in developing seed from DHAR-overexpressing plants (Fig. 5F–H) compared to only one zygote in WT seed (Fig. 5A–D). At 5 days after pollination (DAP), two proembryos were observed in DHAR-overexpressing seed (Fig. 5J). Each proembryo was composed of an apical to two-celled proembryo and a basal cell, indicating that twinning occurred prior to the transverse division of the zygote. Both proembryos were at a similar developmental stage, arguing against the possibility that the twin arose from the embryo-proper or suspensor of the primary embryo. Both embryos were developmentally delayed relative to WT embryos which were at quadrant to octant (Fig. 5I). Similarly, when WT embryos were at mid-globular (Fig. 5K) or transition (Fig. 5M) stages, twin DHAR-overexpressing embryos, each with a distinct suspensor, were at early-globular (Fig. 5L) or mid-globular (Fig. 5N) stages, respectively, supporting the conclusion that embryo development was delayed as a consequence of the twinning event during the first zygotic division. Analysis at subsequent stages revealed the continued development of double and triple progeny within a seed (Fig. 5P–Q, S–T) relative to a single embryo in WT seed (Fig. 5R). Seedlings from polyembryonic seeds were of similar size (Fig. 1A–H), supporting the notion that their development had initiated simultaneously.
A–D, Developing WT zygotes showing growth prior to the first zygotic division. E–H, Developing zygotes in DTa ovules showing (E) horizontal position of nucleoli prior to the first zygotic division, (F) presence of twin zygotes in adjacent proximity with vertical position of nucleoli in one of the zygotes, (G) presence of twin zygotes in adjacent proximity with vertical position of nucleoli in both zygotes, (H) presence of triplet zygotes. I–J, Developing embryos at 5 DAP from (I) WT and (J) DTa plants showing twin proembryos at the same developmental stage. K–L, Developing embryos at 6 DAP from (K) WT and (L) DTa plants. Cells of the protoderm are evident in the embryo proper of the WT embryo not present in the twin DTa embryos as the latter are delayed in their development. M–N, Developing embryos at 8 DAP from (M) WT and (N) DTa plants. O–Q, 10 DAP developing embryos from (O) WT and (P) DTa-double and (Q) DTa-triple embryo seed. R–T, 12 DAP developing embryos from (R) WT and (S) DTa-double and (T) DTa-triple embryo seed. ac, apical cell; b, basal cell; e, embryo; ep, embryo proper; p, protoderm; s, suspensor; zy, zygote. Scale bars represent 50 µm.
Determination of the embryo cell number (estimated from the number of cells in median, longitudinal sections) demonstrated that WT embryos contained an average of 75 cells (representing 6.2 cell divisions) at 6.5 DAP (Table 2) whereas twin DHAR-overexpressing embryos contained an average of 26.5 cells (4.7 cell divisions), a delay of 1.5 cell divisions. At 8 DAP, WT embryos contained 212 cells (7.7 cell divisions) whereas twin embryos contained 73 cells (6.2 cell divisions). These data suggest that twin embryos had undergone 1.5 fewer cell divisions than WT embryos, consistent with the delayed development associated with monozygotic twinning.
Ascorbic acid phenocopies DHAR-induced twinning
Overexpression of DHAR results in an increase in the Asc pool size . To test directly whether an increase in Asc was responsible for the DHAR-induced twinning, Asc, at concentrations similar to those present in plants , was injected into WT ovaries on the day of pollination. The frequency of twinning in progeny of WT plants increased substantially following the injection of Asc (Figs. 1I–J and 6) or its immediate precursor, L-galactono-1,4-lactone (GL) (Fig. 6) which is known to increase the Asc pool size , . Injection of Asc or GL also further increased the frequency of twinning following injection into ovaries of DTa plants (Fig. 6). Injection of dehydroascorbate (DHA), which increases the Asc pool size  following its reduction to Asc by DHAR in a glutathione-requiring reaction, induced twinning as did injection with glutathione (Fig. 6). Injection of 5 mM Asc resulted in more polyembryony than did higher levels of Asc, perhaps due to a threshold effect beyond which further increases in Asc have no additional effect. It is also possible that injecting high concentrations of Asc limits its ability to promote polyembryony through its effect on the Asc redox state of the apoplast. Asc is normally present in the apoplast at only very low concentrations as DHA is the dominant form . Injection of Asc would transiently increase the Asc redox state of the apoplast in addition to increasing the intracellular Asc concentration. Injection of Asc at higher concentrations than 50 mM caused death of the ovaries indicating that it has toxic effects not seen with GL or DHA at similar concentrations. Injection of Asc on the day of pollination induced only a slight increase in cotyledon defects (Fig. 6), demonstrating that the effect of Asc on twinning can be temporally separated from its effect on polycotyly. Injection of Asc later in embryo development, however, did increase polycotyly substantially (see below). No increase in the frequency of twinning was observed in ovaries injected with water, H2O2, organic acids such as malate (Fig. 6) or citric acid, or α-tocopherol (data not shown). These data support the conclusion that twinning is induced by Asc or compounds known to increase intracellular Asc levels –.
Frequency of twinning and polycotyly in progeny of WT ovaries injected with (A) Asc, GL, dehydroascorbate (DHA), glutathione (GSH), H2O2, or malate at the concentrations indicated on the day of pollination. The histograms represent the frequency of twinning (black bars, left scale) and cotyledon abnormalities (i.e., polycotyly or single fused cotyledon)(white bars, right scale) observed following germination.
Auxin and cytokinin play important roles in regulating cell division and changes to the auxin gradient in the female gametophyte can alter the number of egg cells per embryo sac . The involvement of Asc in the synthesis of some hormones raised the possibility that perturbation in hormone levels in the zygote may be involved in the Asc-induced twinning. To examine whether altered levels of hormones might influence twinning, gibberellic acid (GA3), auxin (IAA), cytokinin (BA), the ethylene-releasing compound 2-chloroethylphosphonic acid (2-CEPA), or aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG), an inhibitor of ethylene biosynthesis was injected into WT ovaries. Only BA resulted in a consistent increase in the frequency of polyembryony and polycotyly (Fig. 7). Injection of a combination of BA and Asc did not increase polyembryony above that observed for BA (data not shown), suggesting that Asc and cytokinin may affect the same developmental step leading to twinning.
Frequency of twinning and polycotyly in progeny of WT ovaries injected with gibberellic acid (GA3), indole acetic acid (IAA), aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG), 2-chloroethylphosphonic acid (CEPA) that produces ethylene, or the cytokinin, benzyladenine (BA) at the concentrations indicated on the day of pollination. The histograms represent the frequency of twinning (black bars, left scale) and cotyledon abnormalities (i.e., polycotyly or single fused cotyledon)(white bars, right scale) observed following germination.
Ascorbic acid-induced twinning is developmentally limited to the first two days after pollination
A study of the timing of fertilization in tobacco reported no evidence of fertilization by 48 hours after pollination (HAP) and only 50% egg cells showing various stages of fusion of the egg and sperm nuclei at 54 HAP . Zygotic division did not occur prior to 84 HAP . If Asc induces twinning, its effect should be limited to the period prior to the first zygotic division following fertilization. Twinning was induced substantially when GL or Asc was injected within 0–2 DAP but lower rates were observed when either was injected after 2 DAP (Fig. 8A), consistent with its role in regulating the first zygotic division but not subsequent cell divisions until cotyledon development. GL or Asc injected on the day of pollination did lead to a small increase in cotyledon defects (Fig. 8B) as was also observed in Fig. 6 but the highest frequency of polycotyly was observed when GL or Asc was injected at 7 DAP (Fig. 8B), the developmental stage representing the transition from globular to heart stage during which cotyledon formation initiates (Fig. 5K and M, respectively). These data demonstrate that early embryo development is sensitive to Asc-induced twinning and polycotyly, consistent with the notion that Asc alters zygotic division and apical patterning during cotyledon initiation, respectively. In contrast to the sus or rsp mutants of Arabidopsis in which the suspensor undergoes inappropriate cell divisions and takes on some characteristics of embryo-proper cells , , suspensor development was unaffected by Asc (Fig. 5J, L, N), indicating that the signaling between the embryo-proper and suspensor cells was maintained.
5 mM Asc (white bars) or GL (black bars) was injected into WT ovaries the day of pollination or on days after pollination as indicated. A, The frequency of twinning and (B) polycotyly observed in the resulting progeny. The horizontal line represents the spontaneous frequency of polyembryony or cotyledon abnormalities.
Cytoskeleton altering agents phenocopy ascorbic acid-induced polyembryony
The changes in cell polarity, and thus cell division, caused by Asc during embryo development suggested possible alterations to the elements of the cytoskeleton, i.e., microtubules or microfilaments, which determine the orientation or perhaps rate of cell division. Pharmacologically perturbing the cytoskeleton during zygotic cell division might also be expected result in polyembryony. To investigate this, WT ovaries were injected at 48 hours after pollination (HAP) with taxol, which stabilizes microtubules and thus perturbs the bundling of microtubules involved in formation of the spindle poles and the preprophase band (PPB) that marks the division site  Progeny from taxol-treated ovaries exhibited a 15-fold increase in polyembryony (0.74%; 13/1747) relative to that observed in untreated ovaries (0.05%; 1/1846). Taxol injected at 54 HAP, i.e., following fertilization but prior to the first zygotic division , resulted in an 11-fold increase in polyembryony (0.56%; 7/1255). Cytochalasin B, which inhibits actin polymerization resulting in misorientation of new cell walls , increased polyembryony nearly 5-fold over the basal frequency (0.24%; 3/1248) when injected at 48 HAP or 3-fold (0.14%; 2/1461) when injected at 54 HAP.
Consistent with notion that Asc may affect aspects of cytokinesis was the central position of the nucleus (with transverse nucleoli) surrounded by vacuoles in a non-elongated, DHAR-overexpressing zygote (Fig. 5E). An increase from one nucleolus in the egg cell to two vertically positioned nucleoli in the fertilized zygote has been described and has been suggested to represent karyogamy . Such a position of the nucleus is in contrast to WT zygotes in which the nucleus (with vertically positioned nucleoli) is typically present in the apical region of an elongated cell above a vacuolated basal region (Fig. 5A–D). Subsequent divisions of horizontally-positioned, twin zygotes show a wild-type asymmetric position of the nucleus (with vertically positioned nucleoli) above a vacuolated basal region in elongated cells (Fig. 5F–G).
We have shown that ascorbic acid promotes polyembryony and polycotyly when its level is elevated either by the activity of DHAR, which increases the Asc pool size as a consequence of its recycling function –, or through direct application to ovules. Apomixis was ruled out as the basis for the polyembryony because progeny of polyembryonic seed inherited pollen-transmitted genes which does not occur in apomictic progeny. We conclude that Asc-induced polyembryony is a result of monozygotic twinning because 1) polyembryony was induced only when Asc was injected prior to the first zygotic division; 2) two or more zygotes were observed in polyembryonic seed; 3) twin embryos with normal suspensors developed at the same rate and were developmentally delayed with respect to WT embryos; and 4) twin progeny in DHAR-induced polyembryonic seed were genetically identical. These observations suggest that Asc affects the first zygotic division and, in the case of triplet progeny, the subsequent round of division as well.
In addition to DHAR or ascorbic acid, itself, compounds that affect the pool size of ascorbic acid also induced polyembryony. For example, feeding experiments with the immediate precursor of ascorbic acid, L-galactono-1,4-lactone (GL), increased the Asc pool size ,  and induced polyembryony to a high level. Similar observations were made with dehydroascorbate (DHA), the substrate for DHAR, which also increases the Asc pool size  and to lesser extent with glutathione which is used by DHAR to reduce DHA to Asc. Organic acids unrelated to ascorbic acid or its biosynthesis had no effect on polyembryony. The specificity of DHAR and the effect that ascorbic acid or compounds that affect its pool size had on polyembryony strongly implicate ascorbic acid as responsible for the twinning.
Changes to the auxin gradient within the female gametophyte can alter the number of egg cells per embryo sac and consequently, the number of fertilization events by independent pollen tubes entering the ovule . However, as the auxin gradient functions by regulating cell fate specification within the embryo sac at cellularization , the polyembryony resulting from transmission of a DHAR transgene by male gametes or following delivery of ascorbic acid to an ovary the same day as fertilization is inconsistent with an ascorbic acid-mediated change in the auxin gradient generating multiple egg cells as is the observation that twin progeny in DHAR-induced polyembryonic seed were genetically identical.
Although increasing the expression of DHAR in the male or female parent revealed that polyembryony was induced by paternal or maternal inheritance of a DHAR transgene, increasing DHAR expression throughout the female parent resulted in a greater induction of polyembryony than did inheritance of the same transgene through male gametes. Suppression of DHAR expression in tissues other than the style and ovules also resulted in a substantially lower level of polyembryony than when its expression was elevated throughout the plant. These observations suggest that the elevated expression of DHAR in maternal tissues likely contributes to the increase in the Asc pool size in the ovule. Nevertheless, the observation that inheritance of a DHAR transgene through male gametes can increase polyembryony demonstrates that confining expression of the transgene to embryonic tissues is sufficient to influence the rate of twinning.
Embryogenesis begins with an asymmetric transverse division of the zygote, resulting in an elongated basal cell that initiates acquisition of suspensor identity and a smaller nonvacuolated apical cell that specifies into the embryo proper. The asymmetric division resulting in daughter cells of different sizes or cytoplasmic determinants may be required for the subsequent specification of the apical and basal cells , . Cell specification may also require positional information, e.g., contact of the basal cell with the maternal tissue , , . Asc-induced twinning suggests that the plane of cytokinesis during early embryo development is altered resulting in symmetric division, a loss of positional information following the first zygotic division, and a lack of cell specification of the daughter cells that then develop into genetically identical twins. This possibility is supported by the ability of cytoskeleton-perturbing agents to phenocopy Asc-induced polyembryony. Treatment with taxol is known to perturb formation of the preprophase band that marks the division site and treatment with cytochalasin B results in misorientation of new cell walls , consistent with the notion that the control of the plane or rate of cell division during the first zygotic division may be important to avoid twinning. Of the phytohormones tested, only cytokinin was able to induce polyembryony, suggesting that this hormone may influence the positioning of the plane or rate of cell division during the first zygotic division, consistent with its role in regulating cell division , . Kinetin has been shown to cause the longitudinal orientation of cortical microtubules resulting in the deposition of cellulose microfibrils in the same orientation ,  and demonstrating a potential role for this hormone in the orientation of cell division during embryogenesis.
Asc has been implicated in promoting G1 to S phase progression as was shown in cells within the QC of roots where cells remain in G1 longer than cells surrounding the QC –, , . The observation that the development of twin embryos is temporally delayed relative to WT embryos suggests that Asc does not induce a premature initiation of the first zygotic division prior to the correct positioning of the plane of cell division. Our observations do suggest, however, that one or more steps involved in cytokinesis or the rate of cell division are affected by Asc which are revealed during critical developmental stages including the first zygotic division and specification of cotyledon-forming fields. Although these two stages during embryo development may be particularly sensitive to Asc, it is equally plausible that they simply represent developmental stages in which perturbations in cell division are most easily observed. The maximum rate of twinning resulting from increased DHAR expression was just over 3% and most stages of embryo development may be able to tolerate this level of alterations to cell division without resulting in a readily apparent phenotype. The identification of the step(s) during cell division affected by Asc will be necessary in future work in order to understand fully the role that Asc plays in cell division.
Materials and Methods
Plant growth conditions
Full-length wheat DHAR (DTa) cDNA (Accession number: AY074784) and tobacco DHAR (DNt) cDNA (Accession number: AY074787) under the control of the CaMV 35S promoter in the binary vector, pBI101, were used to generate DTa-overexpressing and DNt-silenced tobacco (N. tabacum, cv. Xanthi), respectively, using Agrobacterium tumefaciens as described previously , . pBI101 containing the firefly luciferase (Luc) was also used to generate tobacco expressing luciferase. Transgenic tobacco plants were grown in a greenhouse supplied with charcoal-filtered air. Compounds were injected into ovaries in a 50 µl volume on the day of pollination or on subsequent days as indicated. Taxol and cytochalasin B were used at a concentration of 25 µM. Clearing intact cotyledons of chlorophyll was performed using 95% ethanol for 2 hr with one change of solution.
Seeds were germinated on 0.8% agar containing one-half strength MS salts containing 1% sucrose. Images were collected using a dissecting microscope. Ovaries containing developing seeds were fixed in FAA (50% ethanol, 5% acetic acid, 3.7% formaldehyde) at 4°C and dehydrated through a graded ethanol series to 100%. The samples were embedded in Paraplast or in resin. Sections were stained with Toluidine Blue O and images were collected using a compound microscope. Images of ovules were collected using a dissecting microscope.
DHAR enzyme assay
DHAR activity was assayed essentially as described . Soluble protein was extracted from tobacco ground in liquid nitrogen before grinding in extraction buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.4, 100 mM NaCl, 2 mM EDTA, 1 mM MgCl2) and centrifuging twice at 13,000 rpm for 5 min to remove cell debris. Protein concentration was determined as described . DHAR activity was assayed from an equal amount of protein in 50 mM K2HPO4/KH2PO4 pH 6.5, 0.5 mM DHA, and 1 mM GSH and activity was followed by an increase in absorbance at 265 nm.
Leaf tissue was ground in liquid nitrogen to fine powder, then, mixed with extraction buffer (containing 100 mM Tris-HCl pH 9.0, 200 mM NaCl, 1% sarcosyl, 20 mM EDTA, and 10 µl/ml β–mercaptoethanol). After extracted with equal volume of phenol/chloroform, RNA was removed from the supernatant by precipitating with 2 M LiCl. Equal volume of isopropanol was added to the RNA-depleted supernatant to pellet the DNA.
Polymerase chain reaction
Amplification of transgenes was performed in 25 µl reactions containing 1× PCR buffer, 1 u HotStarTaq DNA polymerase (Qiagen Inc, Valencia CA, U.S.A.), 250 µM dNTP, 10 µM forward and reverse primers, and 50 ng genomic DNA. Reactions were carried out using the following conditions: 95°C/15 min (1 cycle); 95°C/30 sec, 56°C/30 sec for the tobacco DHAR gene (62°C/30 sec for the wheat DHAR gene), 72°C/1.5 min (35 cycles); and extension at 72°C for 1.5 min; and a final extension at 72°C/5 min (1 cycle). The upstream primer is 5′-ACTGACGTAAGGGATGACGCA-3′, which anneals within the CaMV 35S promoter region. The downstream primers are 5′-GCGAAACAACGGGATTATAATTATG-3′ (tobacco DHAR gene) and 5′GGATCCAGGGGCTTACGGGTTCACTTTC-3′ (wheat DHAR gene), respectively.
Statistical analysis of PCR results
Paternal or maternal inheritance using PCR was performed on multiple twin/triplet embryos. All progeny within a seed exhibited similar paternal inheritance, ruling out apomixis. The possibility of multiple fertilization events of a polyembyro-containing ovule or the post-fertilization fusion of ovules was considered highly unlikely as Mendelian inheritance of paternal genes would be expected. The probability that twin progeny resulting from independent fertilization events exhibit similar paternal inheritance (i.e., either both inherit or both fail to inherit) of a pollen-transmitted transgene from a hemizygous parent is one out of two, i.e., a 50% chance that the twin seedlings are genetically identical. For triplet embryos, there is a 25% chance that they are genetically identical if from independent fertilization events. The probability that independent fertilization was responsible for twin embryos in 4 seed and triplet embryos in 3 seed and resulted in uniform inheritance of a pollen-transmitted transgene from a hemizygous parent is (1/2)4×(1/4)3 = 1/1024. Therefore, there is a 99.9% probability that the uniform inheritance resulted from twinning from a single zygote and not from multiple fertilization event.
Tobacco tissue was frozen in liquid nitrogen and ground in luciferase assay buffer (25 mM Tricine pH 8, 5 mM MgCl2, 0.1 mM EDTA supplemented with 33.3 mM DTT, 270 µM coenzyme A, 500 µM ATP). Following centrifugation, the extract was assayed for luciferase activity following injection of 0.5 mM luciferin using a Monolight 2010 Luminometer (Analytical Luminescence Laboratory). Triplicate samples were assayed and the average value is reported.
Conceived and designed the experiments: DRG ZC. Performed the experiments: DRG ZC. Analyzed the data: DRG ZC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DRG ZC. Wrote the paper: DRG ZC.
- 1. Coulter JM, Chamberlain CJ (1903) In Morphology of Angiosperms. D. Appleton and Company, New York, New York. pp. pp. 212–226.JM CoulterCJ Chamberlain1903In Morphology of Angiosperms. D. Appleton and Company, New York, New York.pp212226
- 2. Tisserat B, Esan BR, Murashige T (1979) Somatic embryogenesis in angiosperms. Hort Rev 1: 1B78.B. TisseratBR EsanT. Murashige1979Somatic embryogenesis in angiosperms.Hort Rev11B78
- 3. Carman JG (1997) Asynchronous expression of duplicate genes in angiosperms may cause apomixis, bispory, tetraspory, and polyembryony. Biol J Linn Soc 61: 51–94.JG Carman1997Asynchronous expression of duplicate genes in angiosperms may cause apomixis, bispory, tetraspory, and polyembryony.Biol J Linn Soc615194
- 4. Bicknell RA, Koltunow AM (2004) Understanding apomixis: recent advances and remaining conundrums. Plant Cell 16: S228–245.RA BicknellAM Koltunow2004Understanding apomixis: recent advances and remaining conundrums.Plant Cell16S228245
- 5. Vernon DM, Meinke DW (1994) Embryogenic transformation of the suspensor in twin, a polyembryonic mutant of Arabidopsis. Dev Biol 165: 566–573.DM VernonDW Meinke1994Embryogenic transformation of the suspensor in twin, a polyembryonic mutant of Arabidopsis.Dev Biol165566573
- 6. Zhang JZ, Somerville CR (1997) Suspensor-derived polyembryony caused by altered expression of valyl-tRNA synthetase in the twn2 mutant of Arabidopsis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 94: 7349–7355.JZ ZhangCR Somerville1997Suspensor-derived polyembryony caused by altered expression of valyl-tRNA synthetase in the twn2 mutant of Arabidopsis.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A9473497355
- 7. Vernon DM, Hannon MJ, Le M, Forsthoefel NR (2001) An expanded role for the TWN1 gene in embryogenesis: defects in cotyledon pattern and morphology in the twn1 mutant of Arabidopsis (Brassicaceae). Am J Bot 88: 570–582.DM VernonMJ HannonM. LeNR Forsthoefel2001An expanded role for the TWN1 gene in embryogenesis: defects in cotyledon pattern and morphology in the twn1 mutant of Arabidopsis (Brassicaceae).Am J Bot88570582
- 8. Asada K, Takahashi M (1987) Production and scavenging of active oxygen in photosynthesis. In Kyle DJ, Osmond CB, Arntzen CJ, editors. Photoinbihition, Elsevier, Amsterdam. pp. pp. 227–287.K. AsadaM. Takahashi1987Production and scavenging of active oxygen in photosynthesis. In Kyle DJ, Osmond CB, Arntzen CJ, editors. Photoinbihition, Elsevier, Amsterdam.pp227287
- 9. Asada K (1994) Mechanisms for scavenging reactive molecules generated in chloroplasts under light stress. In: Baker NR, Bowyer JR, editors. pp. 129–142.K. Asada1994Mechanisms for scavenging reactive molecules generated in chloroplasts under light stress.NR BakerJR Bowyer129142editors.Photoinhibition of photosynthesis.From molecular mechanisms to the field.Oxford: Bios Scientific Publishers.pp. pp.
- 10. Davies MB, Austin J, Partridge DA (1991) In Vitamin C: Its chemistry and biochemistry. Cambridge: Royal Society of Chemistry. MB DaviesJ. AustinDA Partridge1991In Vitamin C: Its chemistry and biochemistry.Cambridge: Royal Society of Chemistry
- 11. Smith JJ, Ververidis P, John P (1992) Characterization of the ethylene-forming enzyme partially purified from melon. Phytochemistry 31: 1485–1494.JJ SmithP. VerveridisP. John1992Characterization of the ethylene-forming enzyme partially purified from melon.Phytochemistry3114851494
- 12. Eskling M, Arvidsson P, Akerlund HE (1997) The xanthophyll cycle, its regulation and components. Physiol Plant 100: 806–816.M. EsklingP. ArvidssonHE Akerlund1997The xanthophyll cycle, its regulation and components.Physiol Plant100806816
- 13. Smirnoff N (2000) Ascorbic acid: metabolism and functions of a multi-facetted molecule. Curr Opin Plant Biol 3: 229–235.N. Smirnoff2000Ascorbic acid: metabolism and functions of a multi-facetted molecule.Curr Opin Plant Biol3229235
- 14. Arrigoni O, De Tullio MC (2000) The role of ascorbic acid in cell metabolism: between gene-directed functions and unpredictable chemical reactions. J Plant Physiol 157: 481–488.O. ArrigoniMC De Tullio2000The role of ascorbic acid in cell metabolism: between gene-directed functions and unpredictable chemical reactions.J Plant Physiol157481488
- 15. Arrigoni O, De Tullio MC (2002) Ascorbic acid: much more than just an antioxidant. Biochim Biophys Acta 1569: 1–9.O. ArrigoniMC De Tullio2002Ascorbic acid: much more than just an antioxidant.Biochim Biophys Acta156919
- 16. Liso R, Calabrese G, Bitonti MB, Arrigoni O (1984) Relationship between ascorbic acid and cell division. Exp Cell Res 150: 314–320.R. LisoG. CalabreseMB BitontiO. Arrigoni1984Relationship between ascorbic acid and cell division.Exp Cell Res150314320
- 17. Arrigoni O, Bitonti MB, Cozza R, Innocenti AM, Liso R, Veltri R (1989) Ascorbic acid effect on pericycle cell line in Allium cepa root. Caryologia 42: 213–216.O. ArrigoniMB BitontiR. CozzaAM InnocentiR. LisoR. Veltri1989Ascorbic acid effect on pericycle cell line in Allium cepa root.Caryologia42213216
- 18. Innocenti AM, Bitonti MB, Arrigoni O, Liso R (1990) The size of the quiescent center in roots of Allium cepa L. grown with ascorbic acid. New Phytologist 114: 507–509.AM InnocentiMB BitontiO. ArrigoniR. Liso1990The size of the quiescent center in roots of Allium cepa L. grown with ascorbic acid.New Phytologist114507509
- 19. Arrigoni O (1994) Ascorbate system in plant development. J Bioenerg Biomembr 26: 407–419.O. Arrigoni1994Ascorbate system in plant development.J Bioenerg Biomembr26407419
- 20. Citterio S, Sgorbati S, Scippa S, Sparvoli E (1994) Ascorbic acid effect on the onset of cell proliferation in pea root. Physiol. Plant 92: 601–607.S. CitterioS. SgorbatiS. ScippaE. Sparvoli1994Ascorbic acid effect on the onset of cell proliferation in pea root.Physiol. Plant92601607
- 21. Kerk NM, Feldman LJ (1995) A biochemical model for the initiation and maintenance of the quiescent center: implications for organization of root meristems. Development 121: 2825–2833.NM KerkLJ Feldman1995A biochemical model for the initiation and maintenance of the quiescent center: implications for organization of root meristems.Development12128252833
- 22. Kato N, Esaka M (1999) Changes in ascorbate oxidase gene expression and ascorbate levels in cell division and cell elongation in tobacco cells. Physiol Plant 105: 321–329.N. KatoM. Esaka1999Changes in ascorbate oxidase gene expression and ascorbate levels in cell division and cell elongation in tobacco cells.Physiol Plant105321329
- 23. Miyake C, Asada K (1994) Ferredoxin-dependent photoreduction of the monodehydroascorbate radical in spinach thylakoids. Plant Cell Physiol 35: 539–549.C. MiyakeK. Asada1994Ferredoxin-dependent photoreduction of the monodehydroascorbate radical in spinach thylakoids.Plant Cell Physiol35539549
- 24. Asada K (1999) The water-water cycle in chloroplasts: Scavenging of active oxygens and dissipation of excess photons. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 50: 601–639.K. Asada1999The water-water cycle in chloroplasts: Scavenging of active oxygens and dissipation of excess photons.Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol50601639
- 25. Chen Z, Young TE, Ling J, Chang SC, Gallie DR (2003) Increasing vitamin C content of plants through enhanced ascorbate recycling. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 100: 3525–3530.Z. ChenTE YoungJ. LingSC ChangDR Gallie2003Increasing vitamin C content of plants through enhanced ascorbate recycling. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A.10035253530
- 26. Chen Z, Gallie DR (2004) The ascorbic acid redox state controls guard cell signaling and stomatal movement. Plant Cell 16: 1143–1162.Z. ChenDR Gallie2004The ascorbic acid redox state controls guard cell signaling and stomatal movement.Plant Cell1611431162
- 27. Chen Z, Gallie DR (2005) Increasing tolerance to ozone by elevating foliar ascorbic acid confers greater protection against ozone than increasing avoidance. Plant Physiol 138: 1673–1689.Z. ChenDR Gallie2005Increasing tolerance to ozone by elevating foliar ascorbic acid confers greater protection against ozone than increasing avoidance.Plant Physiol13816731689
- 28. Chen Z, Gallie DR (2006) Dehydroascorbate reductase affects leaf growth, development, and function. Plant Physiol 142: 775–787.Z. ChenDR Gallie2006Dehydroascorbate reductase affects leaf growth, development, and function.Plant Physiol142775787
- 29. Franceschi VR, Tarlyn NM (2002) L-Ascorbic acid is accumulated in source leaf phloem and transported to sink tissues in plants. Plant Physiol 130: 649–656.VR FranceschiNM Tarlyn2002L-Ascorbic acid is accumulated in source leaf phloem and transported to sink tissues in plants.Plant Physiol130649656
- 30. Odell JT, Hoopes JL, Vermerris W (1994) Seed-specific gene activation mediated by the Cre/lox site-specific recombination system. Plant Physiol 106: 447–458.JT OdellJL HoopesW. Vermerris1994Seed-specific gene activation mediated by the Cre/lox site-specific recombination system.Plant Physiol106447458
- 31. Uwer U, Wilmitzer L, Altmann T (1998) Inactivation of a glycyltRNA synthetase leads to an arrest in plant embryo development. Plant Cell 10: 1277–1294.U. UwerL. WilmitzerT. Altmann1998Inactivation of a glycyltRNA synthetase leads to an arrest in plant embryo development.Plant Cell1012771294
- 32. Sunilkumar G, Mohr L, Lopata-Finch E, Emani C, Rathore KS (2002) Developmental and tissue-specific expression of CaMV 35S promoter in cotton as revealed by GFP. Plant Mol Biol. 50: 463–474.G. SunilkumarL. MohrE. Lopata-FinchC. EmaniKS Rathore2002Developmental and tissue-specific expression of CaMV 35S promoter in cotton as revealed by GFP. Plant Mol Biol.50463474
- 33. Fernando DD, Owens JN, Misra S (2000) Transient gene expression in pine pollen tubes following particle bombardment. Plant Cell Rep 19: 224–228.DD FernandoJN OwensS. Misra2000Transient gene expression in pine pollen tubes following particle bombardment.Plant Cell Rep19224228
- 34. de Mesa MC, Santiago-Doménech N, Pliego-Alfaro F, Quesada MA, Mercado JA (2004) The CaMV 35S promoter is highly active on floral organs and pollen of transgenic strawberry plants. Plant Cell Rep 23: 32–38.MC de MesaN. Santiago-DoménechF. Pliego-AlfaroMA QuesadaJA Mercado2004The CaMV 35S promoter is highly active on floral organs and pollen of transgenic strawberry plants.Plant Cell Rep233238
- 35. Benfey PN, Chua NH (1989) The cauliflower mosaic virus 35SCaMV promoter: combinatorial regulation of transcription in plants. Science 250: 959–966.PN BenfeyNH Chua1989The cauliflower mosaic virus 35SCaMV promoter: combinatorial regulation of transcription in plants.Science250959966
- 36. Wilkinson JE, Twell D, Lindsey K (1997) Activities of CaMV 35S and nos promoters in pollen: implications for field release of transgenic plants. J Exp Bot 48: 265–275.JE WilkinsonD. TwellK. Lindsey1997Activities of CaMV 35S and nos promoters in pollen: implications for field release of transgenic plants.J Exp Bot48265275
- 37. Conner AJ, Mlynarova L, Stiekema WJ, Nap J-P (1999) Gametophytic expression of GUS activity controlled by the potato Lhca3.St.1 promoter in tobacco pollen. J Exp Bot 50: 1471–1479.AJ ConnerL. MlynarovaWJ StiekemaJ-P Nap1999Gametophytic expression of GUS activity controlled by the potato Lhca3.St.1 promoter in tobacco pollen.J Exp Bot5014711479
- 38. Twell D, Klein TM, Fromm ME, McCormick S (1989) Transient expression of chimeric genes delivered into pollen by microprojectile bombardment. Plant Physiol 91: 1270–1274.D. TwellTM KleinME FrommS. McCormick1989Transient expression of chimeric genes delivered into pollen by microprojectile bombardment.Plant Physiol9112701274
- 39. Young TE, Giesler-Lee J, Gallie DR (2004) Senescence-induced expression of cytokinin reverses pistil abortion during maize flower development. Plant J. 38: 910–922.TE YoungJ. Giesler-LeeDR Gallie2004Senescence-induced expression of cytokinin reverses pistil abortion during maize flower development. Plant J.38910922
- 40. Pagnussat GC, Yu HJ, Sundaresan V (2007) Cell-fate switch of synergid to egg cell in Arabidopsis eostre mutant embryo sacs arises from misexpression of the BEL1-like homeodomain gene BLH1. Plant Cell 19: 3578–3592.GC PagnussatHJ YuV. Sundaresan2007Cell-fate switch of synergid to egg cell in Arabidopsis eostre mutant embryo sacs arises from misexpression of the BEL1-like homeodomain gene BLH1.Plant Cell1935783592
- 41. Pagnussat GC, Alandete-Saez M, Bowman JL, Sundaresan V (2009) Auxin-dependent patterning and gamete specification in the Arabidopsis female gametophyte. Science 324: 1684–1689.GC PagnussatM. Alandete-SaezJL BowmanV. Sundaresan2009Auxin-dependent patterning and gamete specification in the Arabidopsis female gametophyte.Science32416841689
- 42. Smirnoff N (2000) Ascorbate biosynthesis and function in photoprotection. Philos Trans R Soc Lond BBiol Sci 355: 1455–1464.N. Smirnoff2000Ascorbate biosynthesis and function in photoprotection.Philos Trans R Soc Lond BBiol Sci35514551464
- 43. Wheeler GL, Jones MA, Smirnoff N, et al. (1998) The biosynthetic pathway of vitamin C in higher plants. Nature 393: 365–369.GL WheelerMA JonesN. Smirnoff1998The biosynthetic pathway of vitamin C in higher plants.Nature393365369
- 44. Paciolla C, De Tullio MC, Chiappetta A, Innocenti AM, Bitonti MB (2001) Short- and long-term effects of dehydroascorbate in Lupinus albus and Allium cepa roots. Plant Cell Physiol 42: 857–863.C. PaciollaMC De TullioA. ChiappettaAM InnocentiMB Bitonti2001Short- and long-term effects of dehydroascorbate in Lupinus albus and Allium cepa roots.Plant Cell Physiol42857863
- 45. Rautenkranz A, Li L, Machler F, Martinoia E, Oertli JJ (1994) Transport of ascorbic and dehydroascorbic acids across protoplast and vacuole membranes isolated from barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv Gerbel) leaves. Plant Physiol 106: 187–193.A. RautenkranzL. LiF. MachlerE. MartinoiaJJ Oertli1994Transport of ascorbic and dehydroascorbic acids across protoplast and vacuole membranes isolated from barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv Gerbel) leaves.Plant Physiol106187193
- 46. Horemans N, Asard H, Caubergs RJ (1997) The ascorbate carrier of higher plant plasma membranes preferentially translocates the fully oxidized (dehydroascorbate) molecule. Plant Physiol 114: 1247–1253.N. HoremansH. AsardRJ Caubergs1997The ascorbate carrier of higher plant plasma membranes preferentially translocates the fully oxidized (dehydroascorbate) molecule.Plant Physiol11412471253
- 47. Horemans N, Foyer CH, Asard H (2000) Transport and action of ascorbate at the plant plasma membrane. Trends Plant Sci 5: 263–267.N. HoremansCH FoyerH. Asard2000Transport and action of ascorbate at the plant plasma membrane.Trends Plant Sci5263267
- 48. Potters G, Horemans N, Caubergs RJ, Asard H (2000) Ascorbate and dehydroascorbate influence cell cycle progression in a tobacco cell suspension. Plant Physiol 124: 17–20.G. PottersN. HoremansRJ CaubergsH. Asard2000Ascorbate and dehydroascorbate influence cell cycle progression in a tobacco cell suspension.Plant Physiol1241720
- 49. Tabata K, Oba K, Suzuki K, Esaka M (2001) Generation and properties of ascorbic acid-deficient transgenic tobacco cells expressing antisense RNA for L-galactono-1,4-lactone dehydrogenase. Plant J 27: 139–148.K. TabataK. ObaK. SuzukiM. Esaka2001Generation and properties of ascorbic acid-deficient transgenic tobacco cells expressing antisense RNA for L-galactono-1,4-lactone dehydrogenase.Plant J27139148
- 50. Tian HQ, Tong T, Russell SD (2005) Relationship between double fertilization and the cell cycle in male and female gametes of tobacco. Sex Plant Reprod 17: 243–252.HQ TianT. TongSD Russell2005Relationship between double fertilization and the cell cycle in male and female gametes of tobacco.Sex Plant Reprod17243252
- 51. Schwartz BW, Yeung EC, Meinke DW (1994) Disruption of morphogenesis and transformation of the suspensor in abnormal suspensor mutants of Arabidopsis. Development 120: 3235–3245.BW SchwartzEC YeungDW Meinke1994Disruption of morphogenesis and transformation of the suspensor in abnormal suspensor mutants of Arabidopsis.Development12032353245
- 52. Yadegari R, Paiva G, Laux T, Koltunow AM, Apuya N, et al. (1994) Cell differentiation and morphogenesis are uncoupled in Arabidopsis raspberry embryos. Plant Cell 6: 1713–1729.R. YadegariG. PaivaT. LauxAM KoltunowN. Apuya1994Cell differentiation and morphogenesis are uncoupled in Arabidopsis raspberry embryos.Plant Cell617131729
- 53. Weerdenburg C, Falconer MM, Setterfield G, Seagull RW (1986) Effects of taxol on microtubule arrays in cultured higher plant cells. Cell Mot Cytoskel 6: 469–478.C. WeerdenburgMM FalconerG. SetterfieldRW Seagull1986Effects of taxol on microtubule arrays in cultured higher plant cells.Cell Mot Cytoskel6469478
- 54. Wick SM (1991) Spatial aspects of cytokinesis in plant cells. Curr Opin Cell Biol 3: 253–260.SM Wick1991Spatial aspects of cytokinesis in plant cells.Curr Opin Cell Biol3253260
- 55. Faure JE, Rotman N, Fortuné P, Dumas C (2002) Fertilization in Arabidopsis thaliana wild type: developmental stages and time course. Plant J 30: 481–488.JE FaureN. RotmanP. FortunéC. Dumas2002Fertilization in Arabidopsis thaliana wild type: developmental stages and time course.Plant J30481488
- 56. Kirk MM, Ransick A, McRae SE, Kirk DL (1993) The relationship between cell size and cell fate in Volvox carteri. J Cell Biol 123: 191–208.MM KirkA. RansickSE McRaeDL Kirk1993The relationship between cell size and cell fate in Volvox carteri.J Cell Biol123191208
- 57. Gurdon JB (1992) The generation of diversity and pattern in animal development. Cell 68: 185–199.JB Gurdon1992The generation of diversity and pattern in animal development.Cell68185199
- 58. Liu C, Xu Z, Chua NH (1993) Auxin polar transport is essential for the establishment of bilateral symmetry during early plant embryogenesis. Plant Cell 5: 621–630.C. LiuZ. XuNH Chua1993Auxin polar transport is essential for the establishment of bilateral symmetry during early plant embryogenesis.Plant Cell5621630
- 59. Liu C, Xu Z, Chua NH (1993) Proembryo culture: in vitro development of early globular-staged zygotic embryos of Brassica juncea. Plant J 3: 291–300.C. LiuZ. XuNH Chua1993Proembryo culture: in vitro development of early globular-staged zygotic embryos of Brassica juncea.Plant J3291300
- 60. Haberlandt G (1913) Zur physiologie der zellteilung. Sitzber K. Preuss. Akad Wiss 318–345. G. Haberlandt1913Zur physiologie der zellteilung. Sitzber K. Preuss.Akad Wiss 318–345
- 61. van Overbeek J, Conklin ME, Blakeslee AF (1941) Factors in coconut milk essential for growth and development of very young Datura embryos. Science 94: 350.J. van OverbeekME ConklinAF Blakeslee1941Factors in coconut milk essential for growth and development of very young Datura embryos.Science94350
- 62. Shibaoka H (1974) Involvement of wall microtubles in gibberellin promotion and kinetin inhibition of stem elongation. Plant Cell Physiol 15: 255–263.H. Shibaoka1974Involvement of wall microtubles in gibberellin promotion and kinetin inhibition of stem elongation.Plant Cell Physiol15255263
- 63. Shibaoka H, Hogetsu T (1977) Effects of ethyl N-phenylcarbamate on wall microtubules and on gibberellin- and kinetin-controlled cell expansion. Bot Mag Tokyo 90: 317–321.H. ShibaokaT. Hogetsu1977Effects of ethyl N-phenylcarbamate on wall microtubules and on gibberellin- and kinetin-controlled cell expansion.Bot Mag Tokyo90317321
- 64. Liso R, Innocenti AM, Bitonti MB, Arrigoni O (1988) Ascorbic acid-induced progression of quiescent centre cells from G1 to S phase. New Phytol 110: 469–471.R. LisoAM InnocentiMB BitontiO. Arrigoni1988Ascorbic acid-induced progression of quiescent centre cells from G1 to S phase.New Phytol110469471
- 65. Clowes FAL (1975) The quiescent centre. In Torrey JG, Clarkson DT, editors. The Development and Function of Roots. New York: Academic Press. pp. pp. 3–19.FAL Clowes1975The quiescent centre. In Torrey JG, Clarkson DT, editors. The Development and Function of Roots. New York: Academic Press.pp319
- 66. Hossain MA, Asada K (1984) Purification of dehydroascorbate reductase from spinach and its characterization as a thiol enzyme. Plant Cell Physiol 25: 85–92.MA HossainK. Asada1984Purification of dehydroascorbate reductase from spinach and its characterization as a thiol enzyme.Plant Cell Physiol258592
- 67. Bradford MM (1976) A rapid and sensitive method for the quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the principle of protein-dye binding. Anal Biochem 72: 248–254.MM Bradford1976A rapid and sensitive method for the quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the principle of protein-dye binding.Anal Biochem72248254