Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) in immune-mediated diseases have identified over 150 associated genomic loci. Many of these loci play a role in T cell responses, and regulation of T cell differentiation plays a critical role in immune-mediated diseases; however, the relationship between implicated disease loci and T cell differentiation is incompletely understood. To further address this relationship, we examined differential gene expression in naïve human CD4+ T cells, as well as in in vitro differentiated Th1, memory Th17-negative and Th17-enriched CD4+ T cells subsets using microarray and RNASeq. We observed a marked enrichment for increased expression in memory CD4+ compared to naïve CD4+ T cells of genes contained among immune–mediated disease loci. Within memory T cells, expression of disease-associated genes was typically increased in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative cells. Utilizing RNASeq and promoter methylation studies, we identified a differential regulation pattern for genes solely expressed in Th17 cells (IL17A and CCL20) compared to genes expressed in both Th17 and Th1 cells (IL23R and IL12RB2), where high levels of promoter methylation are correlated to near zero RNASeq levels for IL17A and CCL20. These findings have implications for human Th17 celI plasticity and for the regulation of Th17-Th1 expression signatures. Importantly, utilizing RNASeq we found an abundant isoform of IL23R terminating before the transmembrane domain that was enriched in Th17 cells. In addition to molecular resolution, we find that RNASeq provides significantly improved power to define differential gene expression and identify alternative gene variants relative to microarray analysis. The comprehensive integration of differential gene expression between cell subsets with disease-association signals, and functional pathways provides insight into disease pathogenesis.
Citation: Zhang W, Ferguson J, Ng SM, Hui K, Goh G, et al. (2012) Effector CD4+ T Cell Expression Signatures and Immune-Mediated Disease Associated Genes. PLoS ONE 7(6): e38510. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0038510
Editor: R. Lee Mosley, University of Nebraska Medical center, United States of America
Received: October 10, 2011; Accepted: May 7, 2012; Published: June 8, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Zhang et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by National Institutes of Health U01DK062422. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Genome-wide association studies in immune-mediated diseases have implicated a variety of inflammatory pathways, with a striking overlap of major association signals across disease subtypes . One of the most significant is the interleukin 23 (IL-23) pathway, highlighted by associations within the IL23R (interleukin 23 receptor, alpha chain) gene region to inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) , psoriasis , and ankylosing spondylitis . Interleukin 23 (IL-23) is required for the optimal expansion and maintenance of Th17 lymphocytes, a key pro-inflammatory cell subset . Within IBD, a striking number of the top association signals include genes along the IL-23 signaling pathway, including STAT3, IL12B (p40, a component of the heterodimeric IL-23 cytokine; also part of IL-12), JAK2 and TYK2 , , , although these genes are not specific to IL-23 signaling. In addition, genes enriched in Th17 cells, such as CCR6, have also been associated with IBD .
Human Th17 cells are characterized by the selective expression of CD161, CCR6 (chemokine C-C motif receptor 6), IL23R and the master transcription factor, RORC . Th17 cells arise from a CD161+CD4+ T cell precursor , ,  and CCR6 plays a key role in Th17 cell trafficking to the intestine , . Importantly, Th17 cells also expressing IFNγ are abundant in the gut of patients with Crohn’s disease, a subtype of IBD . The traditional view of an initiating role of IFNγ, IL-12 and Th1 cells in immune-mediated human and disease models of autoimmunity has been revised both by human genetic association studies implicating the IL-23 pathway, as well as the requirement for IL-23, and not the IL-12 pathway, in mouse models of intestinal, dermatologic and central nervous system inflammation , , , .
Given the preponderance of IL-23 pathway and Th17 enriched genes associated with immune-mediated diseases, we sought to more precisely define the spectrum and molecular basis of differential gene expression in naïve, in vitro differentiated Th1, Th17-negative and Th17-enriched CD4+ memory T cell subsets. We observed an enrichment of immune-mediated disease genes among upregulated genes in CD4+ memory compared to naïve T cells and also among upregulated genes in Th17-enriched CD4+ T cells compared to Th17-negative expanded memory CD4+ T cells. We demonstrate evidence for an abundant, novel isoform in IL23R predicted to terminate prior to the transmembrane domain. The differential mechanisms of gene regulation observed between initial Th17-lineage defining genes such as IL17A, IL17F and CCL20, compared to genes induced in both Th17 and Th1 cells, such as IL23R and IL12RB2, provide insight into the sequential and versatile roles that Th17 cells play in immune health and disease.
The Surface Markers CD161 and CCR6 Distinguish Th17-negative from Th17-enriched CD4+ Memory Cell Subsets
To explicitly compare Th17-enriched with Th17-negative cells, we sorted freshly isolated human CD4+ memory T cells into CD161+CCR6+ and CD161-CCR6- subsets (Figure 1A), and expanded these cells for seven days with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 mAb in the presence of IL-23 and IL-1β. Intracellular staining of IL-17 and IFN demonstrates that expanded CD161-CCR6- cells express minimal IL-17 (Figure 1B); in contrast, a significant fraction of expanded CD161+CCR6+ cells produces IL-17 (25–52%, Th17-enriched). Comparable fractions of expanded CD161-CCR6- and CD161+CCR6+ cells express IFNγ; as expected, these fractions are lower than those attained by expansion of naïve CD4+ T cells under Th1-skewing conditions (range, 72–80%) (Figure 1B). Within the expanded memory CD161+CCR6+ subset, 10–15% of cells express IL-17 but not IFNγ, whereas 15–40% of cells express both IL-17 and IFNγ, reflecting heterogeneity of gene expression within Th17-cell subsets (Figure 1B).
A. CD4+CD25- T cells were sorted by flow cytometry into CD45RO- and CD45RO+ subsets. Memory CD4+CD25-CD45RO+ cells were sorted into CD161+ CCR6+ and CD161-CCR6- subsets for subsequent activation and expansion. B. Th1 cells were generated from naïve CD4+CD62L+CD25-CD45RO- T cells by activating and expanding with anti-CD3, anti-CD28 in the presence of IL-12 and anti-IL4 for seven days. CD161+CCR6+ and CD161-CCR6- memory CD4+ T cells were activated and expanded with anti-CD3, anti-CD28, IL-1β and IL-23 for seven days. The distinct T cell subsets were assessed for differentiation by intracellular cytokine staining for IL-17A and IFNγ expression. Representative flow cytometry plots are shown in the figure.
Improved Power to Identify Differential Gene Expression with RNASeq Compared to Expression Microarrays
To accurately evaluate differential gene expression in naïve, in vitro differentiated Th1, Th17-negative and Th17-enriched CD4+ T cell subsets from healthy individuals, we utilized both microarray and transcriptome sequencing (RNASeq)  and compared the results. Gene expression was measured by the estimated number of fragments of RNA per kilobase of exon per million fragments mapped (FPKM) for RNASeq and by log2 normalized intensity for microarray analysis (Figure S1). The gene expression estimates generated by the two approaches were strongly correlated (r = 0.83 - 0.85) for all four cell subsets (Figure S1). Of note, the correlation between the two expression estimates was much smaller when restricting to transcripts with lower FPKMs because of the high level of background noise inherent in the microarray platform (r = 0.38 - 0.45 for transcripts with RNASeq FPKM less than the median).
We next tested for differential gene expression between Th1 vs. naïve and Th17-enriched vs. Th17-negative cells, comparing RNASeq with expression microarrays. The distribution of the P-values obtained from the RNASeq and microarray experiments using Q-Q plots (Figure 2A and 2C) and bar plots (Figure 2B and 2D) demonstrated a marked increase in the number of highly significant differentially expressed genes when expression was measured by RNASeq. Since a comparable number of samples were used for the two approaches (n = 5 for expression microarrays, n = 4 for RNASeq), this indicates that there is markedly greater power to identify differential gene expression using RNASeq compared to expression microarrays. The improved power of RNASeq reflects the numerous sequence reads obtained from analysis of a single sample, compared to the single intensity measurement obtained from microarray expression measurements, thereby allowing the more precise measurement of low transcript abundance compared to microarray-based measurements of gene expression.
A. Q-Q plot for observed and expected P-Values for differential gene expression comparing in vitro differentiated Th1 and Naïve CD4+ T cells (N = 4). B. Observed statistical significance for differential gene expression between in vitro differentiated Th1 and Naïve CD4+ T cells (N = 4). C. Q-Q plot for observed and expected P-values for differential gene expression comparing Th17-enriched and Th17-negative CD4+ memory T cells. D. Observed statistical significance for differential gene expression between Th17-enriched and Th17-negative CD4+ T cells.
Significant Enrichment for Increased Expression of Genes within Immune-mediated Genetic Loci in CD4+ Memory Compared to Naïve CD4+ T Cells and in Th17-enriched Compared to Th17-negative Expanded Memory CD4+ T Cells
The Immunochip was designed to densely map loci demonstrating genome-wide significant evidence for association to one of nine immune-mediated diseases using 0.1 cM (centimorgan) flanking boundaries from the peak association signal . Loci related to 12 immune-mediated diseases were included on this custom chip. We extracted 1387 genes related to the loci from the Ensembl gene reference set, which we refer to as immune-mediated disease transcript subset. We hypothesized that such genes would demonstrate differential gene expression in CD4+ T cell subsets, since they surround or flank immune-mediated disease loci. Using RNASeq and microarray-based expression in CD4+ T cell subsets, we evaluated differential gene expression for all combinations of CD4+ T cells. We then tested for enrichment of the 1387 Immune-Mediated Disease Transcripts among upregulated genes (defined as those genes having P-values for upregulation amongst the 5% most significant P-values) using Fisher’s exact test for each comparison.
Table 1 reports the enrichment P-values obtained for relative gene expression for each possible pair of cell subsets using both the RNASeq and microarray datasets. First, we observed significant enrichment of immune-mediated disease transcripts among transcripts up-regulated in CD4+ memory T cells compared CD4+ naïve T cells. Specifically, in the RNASeq analysis, significant enrichment of disease-associated transcripts were observed comparing Th17-enriched memory to naïve CD4+ T cells (P-value = 7.63×10−04), with similar, more modest enrichment of Th17-negative memory compared to naïve CD4+ T cells (P-value = 0.019). Similar, less significant trends are observed in the microarray data; enrichment P-values comparing Th17-enriched memory cells to naïve CD4+ T cells and Th17-negative cells vs. naïve CD4+ T cells 0.025 and 0.091, respectively. Secondly, within memory CD4+ T cells, significant enrichment of immune-mediated disease transcripts was detected in genes upregulated in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative CD4+ memory T cells with the RNASeq analysis (P-value = 2.46×10−03). This enrichment was consistently, but less significantly detected in the microarray dataset (P-value = 0.043). Finally, comparing CD4+ memory T cells and in vitro differentiated Th1 cells, we observed a significant enrichment for upregulated in Th17-negative compared to Th1 (P = 1.13×10−03) and Th17-enriched compared to Th1 (P = 7.24×10−03) with RNASeq analyses; the P values of the same comparisons in microarray data were rather modest, 0.09 and 0.11 respectively, likely reflecting the lower power of microarray data to identify differential gene expression. Taken together, these data highlight the central role of genes demonstrating enriched expression in CD4+ memory cells generally, and memory Th17 CD4+ T cells specifically, in immune-mediated disease pathogenesis.
As an additional analysis of the enrichment of “Th17” genes (genes upregulated in Th17-enriched memory comparing to Th17-negative memory CD4+ T cells) among autoimmune-disease associated genes, we have identified the known disease associations for each pertinent transcript using the GWAS catalog , (Table S1 for RNASeq; Table S2 for microarray data). Genes were selected for this annotation based on satisfying all of the following three criteria: 1) having a P-value less than 0.05 for differential expression between Th17-enriched and Th17-negative memory CD4+ T cells, (2) being upregulated in Th17-enriched cells and (3) appearing in both the microarray and RNASeq datasets. The genes are ordered by P-value for upregulation in Th17-enriched compared to Th-17 memory CD4+ T cells.
To further explore the Th17 cell expression signature, we performed cluster analysis focusing on the transcripts demonstrating increased expression in Th17-enriched cells relative to Th17-negative cells by using Partek Genomics Suites (Partek, MO). 195 transcripts with P-values less than 10−09 were used for the cluster analysis of the RNASeq dataset (Figure 3), and 147 transcripts with at least a 1.5 fold change and P-values less than 0.05 were used for the clustering analysis of the Microarray dataset (Figure S2). We compared the patterns of expression in Th17-enriched, Th17-negative, CD4+ naïve and in vitro differentiated Th1 cells. As expected, the samples from each of the four cell types clustered together. Because the selection criteria for transcript inclusion was based on increased expression in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative cells, increased expression (red-colored predominance) is observed in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative cells (blue-colored predominance). Asterisks (*) designate the transcripts within immune-mediated disease regions; there were a total of 32 such transcripts in the whole cluster (Figure 3, indicating that these immune-mediated disease transcripts are highly expressed in Th17-enriched CD4+ T cells. In addition, these immune-mediated disease transcripts are not exclusively expressed in Th17-enriched memory T cells. Nearly half are highly expressed in both Th17-enriched memory and in vitro differentiated Th1 cells, for instance, IL23R, IL12RB2, IL18RAP, and CTSH. Similarly, in the microarray cluster (Figure S2), there were a total of 25 immune-mediated disease transcripts in the total 147 transcripts. These clustering analyses demonstrate the consistency between RNASeq and microarray gene expression (as can also be seen in Figure S1). Taken together, these data support the conclusion from the enrichment analysis that immune-mediated disease transcripts are enriched among transcripts upregulated in Th17-enriched CD4+ memory T cells.
Hierarchical clustering was performed on 195 transcripts with increased expression in Th17-enriched (red, increased expression relative to other cell types) compared to Th17-negative (blue, decreased expression) and differential expression P-values less than 1×10−09. Asterisks (*) designate the transcripts within immune-mediated disease loci. There are total 32 immune-mediated disease associated genes with names marked in the figure.
Promoter Methylation Patterns Contribute to Differential Gene Expression in CD4+ T Cell Subsets
Gene expression is regulated at multiple levels, including promoter methylation, covalent modification of histones, interactions with non-coding RNAs, and post-translational modifications. We investigated the promoter DNA methylation patterns of illustrative genes in CD4+ T cell subsets, selecting two transcripts demonstrating increased expression in both Th17-enriched and Th1 cells (IL23R and IL12RB2), as well as two transcripts demonstrating increased expression solely in Th17-enriched cells (IL17A, CCL2)), compared with two transcripts demonstrating increased expression (Figure 4, Figure S3). High levels of methylation at conserved CpG sites result in gene silencing ; however, additional levels of gene regulation contribute, as gene expression is imperfectly correlated with promoter methylation levels alone . For example, IL23R and IL12RB2 are adjacent on chromosome 1p31; despite similar patterns of gene expression of these two genes across CD4+ T cell subsets (Figure 3), very different patterns of promoter methylation are observed comparing IL23R and IL12RB2 (Figure 4A–B). In the IL23R promoter, high levels of CpG methylation and gene silencing are observed in naïve CD4+ T cells (Figure 4A), with significantly lower levels observed in CD4+ memory subsets, including Th17-negative cells that express low levels of IL23R. In contrast, IL12RB2 promoter methylation levels are low in all CD4+ subsets (Figure 4B), even in naïve CD4+ T cells, reflecting a fundamental difference in regulation of gene expression between IL23R and IL12RB2.
Shown are the fractions of methylation at conserved CpG promoter sites estimated by mass spectrometry (N = 5) for A. IL23R, B. IL12RB2, C. IL17A and D. CCL20 promoters. Paired t-tests were used to test for differential methylation fractions between naïve vs. Th1 and Th17-negative vs. Th17-enriched were estimated by paired t-test; *P<0.05, **P<0.01, ***P<0.001. E. Average expression estimates from four individulas in both RNASeq and microarray show that Th17-specific transcripts IL17A and CCL20 have nearly zero expression in Th17-negative cells, corresponding to high promoter methylation levels (C–D). Gene expression was measured by FPKM (fragments of RNA per Kilobase of exon per Million fragments mapped) for RNASeq and log2 RMA normalized intensity for microarray.
Using RNASeq, differential gene expression between cell subsets associated with the complete absence of mRNA expression can be defined, such as the absence of IL17A sequences in Th17-negative subsets; the distinction between the complete absence of gene expression and present, but relatively decreased, gene expression levels, suggests distinct mechanisms of gene regulation. For example, while marked induction of gene expression in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative cells is observed for IL23R, IL12RB2, IL17A and CCL20, the latter two Th17 signature genes have RNASeq counts in Th17-negative cells near zero (Figure 4E). Consistent with this, high methylation levels (fraction methylated greater than 0.7) are observed at conserved CpG sites within the IL17A (Figure 4C), IL17F (Figure S3B) and CCL20 (Figure 4D) promoters in all CD4+ T cell subsets examined except for Th17-enriched cell subsets. Therefore, with IL17A, IL17F and CCL20, promoter methylation levels account for much of the variable gene expression observed between CD4+ T cell subsets. However, with IL23R and IL12RB2, promoter methylation levels are less well correlated; for example, modest trends toward decreased CpG methylation (and therefore increased gene expression) in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative cells is observed. While CpG promoter methylation levels are comparable between Th1 and Th17-negative cells, IL23R gene expression levels are much higher in Th1 cells (Figure 4E).
Identification of a Major, Novel IL23R Truncated Isoform
Inspection of the mapped sequence reads in the IL23R gene region on chromosome 1p31 in Th17-negative and positive cells revealed a striking increase of expressed sequences in the intronic region immediately centromeric to exon 6, particularly in Th17-enriched cells and in vitro differentiated Th1 cells (Figure 5A). The y-axis scale represents RNASeq coverage, and indicates that IL23R was highly expressed on both Th17-enriched and in vitro differentiated Th1 cells. Also, IL23R expression is higher in in vitro differentiated Th1 cells compared to Th17-enriched CD4+ memory T cells. Examination of paired sequence reads (Figure 5B) confirmed numerous examples where the sense sequence originated in the coding portion of exon 6, and its antisense partner mapped to a region centromeric to the exon 6 consensus sequence. Continuation of transcripts into the consensus intron 6 region would result in a stop signal 9 codons downstream of the consensus exon 6 sequence. The transmembrane domain of IL23R is contained within exon 9, with the extracellular domain encoded by exons 2 through 8. We performed 3′ RACE priming from the coding region of exon 6 followed by sequence analysis, and confirmed the presence of a major transcript continuing into the region adjacent to the consensus exon 6 region resulting in an extended form of exon 6 (~700 base pair amplicon, Figure 5C), as well as amplicons containing the full-length transcript (~2000 base pair fragment, Figure 5C). The presence of PCR amplicons priming between the non-coding region of the extended exon 6 to sense primers in each of exons 2–5 was also confirmed (Figure S4). In the 3′ RACE analysis priming from the coding region of exon 6, the early truncating transcript extends 672 base pairs into the consensus intron 6 region (67,672,739 to 67,673,410 base pairs). In four donors, using Cufflinks applied to a custom annotation file for the IL23R region, we observed a high fraction of this IL23R transcript with an extended form of exon 6, (32.78% ±4.70% for Th17-enriched and 42.80% ±0.28% for in vitro differentiated Th1 cells). The sequences mapping immediately centromeric to this are largely self-contained, with sequence pairs mapping between 67,673,962 to 67,675,317 base pairs, forming an independent transcript (Figure 5B, zoom-in picture of intron 6). This independent RNA is expressed in both Th17-enriched and in vitro differentiated Th1 cells (Figure 5A), highlighting both the abundance and regulated nature of such novel transcripts.
A. Sequence reads were mapped to the IL23R gene region in Th17-enriched and in vitro differentiated Th1 cells using Tophat v1.3.3. The intron 6 region was highly covered in both the Th17-enriched and Th1 cell subsets. The scale on the y-axis represents coverage (average number of reads that cover a particular base). B. Zoom in picture of extended coverage on exon 6 and intron 6. Blue and red bars correspond to sense- and anti-sense reads, respectively. The expanded inset demonstrates sequence reads mapping to an extended exon 6 resulting in a stop signal 9 codons downstream with contiguous 3′UTR sequence; in addition an independent transcript maps immediately centromeric to this. C. 3′ RACE (rapid amplification of cDNA ends) was performed, and 2000 and 700 base pair fragments were sequenced, confirming the exon contents designated. The 700 base pair transcript terminating in the intron 6 region would encode for a transcript terminating prior to the transmembrane domain in exon 9.
Enrichment of CD4+ T Cell Gene Signatures in Immune-mediated Disease Loci
The overlap of associated genetic loci identified by GWAS across immune-mediated diseases suggests a shared pathogenesis. Commonly, the precise risk alleles are also the same, suggesting that the overlap results not merely from the identification of key immune-mediated genes with functional polymorphisms, but that the directionality of effects is also shared. In this study, we observe that genes contained within immune-mediated disease genetic loci demonstrate a striking enrichment of increased gene expression in Th17-enriched, Th17-negative CD4+ memory compared to naïve CD4+ cells (Table 1). Within memory CD4+ T cells, we observe increased gene expression in Th17-enriched compared to Th17-negative cells. Importantly, enrichment of increased gene expression in the converse direction is not observed; for example, genes demonstrating increased gene expression in naïve CD4+ T cells compared to memory T cells are not enriched among disease-associated genes. These findings provide a basis for an increasingly refined and systematic, directional molecular mapping between disease associations and altered function of CD4+ T cell subsets.
It might be anticipated that a Th17 or Th1 enrichment signature would be obscured by the broad inclusion of all transcripts within association signals, as clearly not all genes in associated regions contribute to disease pathogenesis. The presence of a clear Th17 and Th1 expression signature highlights the precise and significant enrichment provided by the composite information gleaned from GWAS across immune-mediated diseases. Furthermore, the commonly observed concordance of expression for genes closely linked in the genome also contributes to the enrichment signature observed. The close clustering of IL23R and IL12RB2 (chr1p31) is consistent with this. This concordance of expression for closely linked genes also suggests, in some cases, a limitation in defining a single gene driving what are often complex, extended and multiple disease associations within a particular locus.
Association, Expression and Functional Overlap between IL-23 and IL-12 Pathways
Within the IL23R-IL12RB2 locus, several independent SNPs have been associated with multiple immune-mediated diseases. A protective missense mutation in IL23R, Arg381Gln, has been reported to be a loss-of-function allele , , indicating that increased IL-23 signaling increases immune-mediated disease risk. Multiple independent association signals are observed within the IL23R gene region and the intergenic region between IL23R and IL12RB2. While cis-acting eQTLs are present within IL12RB2 , these eSNPs are not correlated with disease association signals. No eQTLs and allelic imbalance have been reported for IL23R. The absence of correlations between mRNA levels and single SNPs associated with disease could reflect more complex mappings between disease-associated polymorphisms and gene expression. One possibility is that haplotypes in the IL23R-IL12RB2 gene region confer greater disease risk; consistent with this, GWAS-derived haplotypes provide superior predictive capacity for disease risk in Crohn’s disease compared to single-marker models  suggesting improved biologic modeling with haplotypes. Additional possibilities are that disease-associated polymorphisms may modulate gene expression only in specific biologic contexts (e.g. cellular activation), that the key alteration in gene expression may be post-transcriptional, or that disease-associated polymorphisms may modulate relative expression of alternative isoforms.
The abundance of an IL23R isoform terminating at exon 6, which would not encode the transmembrane domain, suggests that IL23R isoforms play a significant role in gene regulation. The abundance of sequence reads in consensus intron 6 indicates that transcripts terminating in an extended exon 6 are highly prevalent. A recent study reported an isoform lacking the exon 9, transmembrane domain (Δ9) . This alternative isoform would encode for a soluble form of IL23R, and comprised approximately 10% of IL23R isoforms. However, this study performed mass spectrometry on amplified cDNA using primers from exons 2 and 11, and could therefore not identify the major isoform terminating in an extended exon 6. Whether the non-coding disease-associated polymorphisms in the IL23R gene region modulate the relative fraction of exon 6 terminating compared to full-length IL23R will be the subject of future studies; ongoing, large scale, fine-mapping association studies performed using Immunochip may provide important insight.
IL-12 and IL-23 play central, proliferative roles in Th1 (IFNγ-expressing) and Th17 (IL-17 expressing) cells, respectively. Expression patterns of IL23R and IL12RB2 are similar across CD4+ T cell subsets, with both induced in Th17-enriched and Th1 subsets, relative to Th17-negative and CD4+ naïve cells, respectively. In fact, expression of IL23R is relatively higher in vitro differentiated Th1 compared to Th17-enriched subsets. In CD4+CD45RbHI IL23R−/− T cell transfer models, IL23R−/− T cells demonstrated normal Th1 differentiation. However, in the intestine CD4+CD45RbHI IL23R−/− T cells showed impaired proliferation, decreased accumulation, and reduced expression of IL-17+IFNγ+ cells . Therefore, multiple factors regulate the downstream consequences to T cell subset outcomes in addition to the regulated expression of select proteins.
Importantly, Th17 cells demonstrate substantial plasticity after their initial commitment to the Th17 program , ; IL-12 can extinguish RORγt and IL17 expression in Th17 cells  through covalent histone modifications resulting in epigenetic silencing of the IL17A-IL17F and RORC genes and enhancement of IFNγ expression. In fact, using cell fate mapping in the experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) model, proinflammatory cytokines in the spinal cord were produced almost exclusively by “ex-Th17 cells” . The specialized, sequential functions of the Th17 and Th1 pathways  in jointly mediating mucosal inflammation have yet to be fully defined. It is possible that the Th17 pathway plays an essential initiating and amplifying role in mucosal inflammation through its joint expression of the chemokine receptor, CCR6 , and its ligand, CCL20, which results in efficient transport of effector Th17 cells to mucosal sites. Consistent with this, demethylation of IL17A and CCL20 promoter CpG sites plays a key role in initial Th17 program commitment (Figure 4C–D). The presence of repressive H3K27me3 epigenetic marks throughout the CCR6 gene region in murine-derived Th1 cells  further supports the concept that a key feature of Th17 cells involves its efficient transport to mucosal sites. Teleologically, it has been proposed that the versatility of Th17 cells to adjust its effector program as needed allow them to respond most efficiently to early and late immune clearance requirements, as well as to a broad range of mucosal pathogens which ultimately might confer significant evolutionary benefit .
Toward a Comprehensive Molecular Integration of Disease Association Signals and Differential Gene Expression
The enrichment of Th17-Th1 expression signatures for genes contained within immune-mediated genetic loci implies, but does not establish, a directionality of disease-associated polymorphisms on gene expression and function. A key next step in this regard is the performance of fine-mapping studies using large case-control cohorts to refine independent and dependent SNPs and haplotypes that account for observed association signals. RNASeq data provides a useful adjunct to eQTL mapping  by providing molecular mapping to variable gene expression. Alternative isoforms, post-transcriptional regulation and regulation in select biologic conditions likely also contribute to disease-associated regulation of gene expression. Integration of allele and haplotype-based variable gene expression with disease association results from large fine-mapping studies will provide an important foundation toward developing increasingly refined models of gene expression and disease networks.
Materials and Methods
This study has been approved by Yale University Institutional Review Boards. A written informed consent has been obtained from each individual healthy donor, and the consent procedure has also been approved by Yale University Institutional Boards. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were isolated from 5 individual healthy donors with Ficoll separation. CD4+ T cells were enriched by negative selection (Miltenyi Biotech) and CD4+CD25-CD45RO+CCR6+CD161+, CD4+CD25-CD45RO+CCR6-CD161- and CD4+CD25-CD45RO-CD62L+ naïve T cells were sorted by FACS Aria (BD Bioscience). For Th1 differentiation, naive T cells were activated with plate-bound anti-CD3 mAb (10µg/ml) and soluble anti-CD28 mAb (1.0 µg/ml) in serum-free media supplemented with recombinant IL-12 (5 ng/ml) and anti-IL-4 (10 µg/ml) for 7 days. Sorted CD4+ memory T cell subsets were activated with plate-bound anti-CD3 mAb and soluble anti-CD28 mAb, and supplemented with IL-23 (20 ng/ml) and IL-1β (10 ng/ml) for 7 days. Intracellular staining was performed by using the Cytofix/Cytoperm buffer set (BD Biosciences) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Briefly, cells were incubated for 5 hours with PMA (50 ng/ml), ionomycin (500 ng/ml) and GolgiPlug (BD Biosciences, CA), then permeabilized with Cytofix/Cytoperm buffer and stained with FITC-conjugated anti-IFNγ (BD Biosciences) and APC-conjugated anti-IL-17 (eBioscience, CA).
Total RNA Isolation, Microarray, Definition of Immune-mediated Gene Loci, Enrichment and Cluster Analysis
Total RNA was isolated from naïve CD4+ T cells, Th1, Th17-enriched and Th17-negative memory CD4+ T cells using the RNeasy Mini Kit (Qiagen) with DNase treatment. Naïve and Th1 cells were from 4 individuals. Th17-enriched and Th17-negative memory CD4+ T cells were from 5 individuals, and 4 of them are the same individuals as the Naïve and Th1 group. High quality (RIN >8.5) RNA was hybridized to the Affymetrix GeneChipR Human Gene 1.0 ST expression arrays for gene expression profiling. RMA normalization  of the intensity data was performed using the Partek Genomics Suite. All microarray data is MIAME compliant and the raw data has been deposited in GEO database. The GEO accession number is GSE 32901.
Immune-mediated disease loci were defined by the inclusion as a fine-mapping disease locus on the custom-designed Immunochip. Loci were included if genome-wide significant evidence for disease association was observed in at least one immune-mediated disease (Crohn1s disease, ulcerative colitis, celiac disease, psoriasis, type 1 diabetes mellitus, rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis, ankylosing spondylitis, systemic lupus erythematosus). All European ancestry 1000 Genomes SNPs within 0.1 cM of the peak association signals were included in the fine-mapping loci, and 1387 transcripts within the fine-mapping boundaries were included in the enrichment analyses. For each possible ordered pair of 2 cell types, (cell type 1, cell type 2), where cell type belongs to the set (naive, in vitro differentiated Th1, Th17-enriched and Th17-negative), we measure the degree of enrichment between a set of 1387 transcripts, chosen for to their proximity to immune-mediated disease associated loci, and the set of up-regulated transcripts in cell type 1 relative to cell type 2. Fisher’s exact test was used to estimate enrichment P-values using the following steps:
- Calculate the P-values for upregulation of cell type 1 relative to cell type 2 for 18,524 transcripts (that are common to both RNASeq and microarray).
- From this set of 18,524 transcripts, find a subset of transcripts, S, which are not related to autoimmune disease loci, with the property that the median gene expression of cell type 1 and cell type 2 for transcripts within this set, S, equals the median gene expression within the 1387 immune mediated disease transcripts. Next merge this set with the 1387 immune mediated disease transcripts to create a ‘background’ set of transcripts appropriate for the enrichment test.
- Construct a 2 x 2 table of counts which assigns each of the background transcripts to one of 4 cells depending on whether it is among the 5% most differentially expressed transcripts (according to P-value), and whether the transcript is within the 1387 autoimmune transcripts or not.
- Calculate the Fisher’s exact test P-value associated with the table constructed in (iii).
RNA libraries were prepared according to the manufacturer’s recommended protocol (Illumina, CA). Total RNA samples of Naïve, in vitro differentiatedTh1, Th17-enriched and Th17-negative CD4+ T cells from 4 individual healthy controls were transcribed to cDNA. cDNA samples were then sheared by nebulization (35 psi, 6 min). Duplexes were blunt ended (large Klenow fragment, T4 polynucleotide kinase and T4 polymerase) and a single 3′adenosine moiety was added using Klenow exo− and dATP. Illumina adapters, containing primer sites for flow cell surface annealing, amplification and sequencing, were ligated onto the repaired ends of the cDNA. Gel electrophoresis was used to select for DNA constructs 200–250 base pairs in size, which were subsequently amplified by 18 cycles of PCR with Phusion polymerase. These libraries were denatured with sodium hydroxide and diluted to 3.5 pM in hybridization buffer for loading onto a single lane of an Illumina GA flow cell. Cluster formation, primer hybridization and sequencing reactions were according to the manufacturer’s protocol. High throughput sequencing was performed using paired end, 75 base pair reads. Two flow lanes were used for each cDNA sample, yielding an average of 103.3 million reads per sample.
RNASeq Mapping, Estimates of Differential Expression and Isoform Abundance
Tophat v1.3.3  was used to align the RNAseq reads to the hg19 genome. RNASeq gene expression was measured for each gene from version 59 of the Ensembl database by Mapped Fragments per Kilobase of Exon model per Million mapped reads (FPKM) calculated via Cufflinks v1.2.1. The Affymetrix annotation for the Human HuGene 1.0 array was downloaded and used to annotate the microarray probes. Subsequently, microarray intensity was calculated as the RMA-normalized log intensity for a single chosen probe in a given gene region. Microarray intensity and FPKM were matched on common gene name for 18,524 genes, and plotted against each other (Figure S1).
We used the program Cuffdiff to test for differential transcript expression in each pair of cell lines. When samples were paired, it was necessary to analyze each sample individually in Cufflinks before combining the resulting P-values using the Fisher method to get a single P-value for differential expression for each gene. We made an exception to this rule for genes where the estimated log fold changes for the 4 samples did not all have the same sign. These genes were assigned a P-value of 1. P-values for differential expression from the microarray data were calculated via paired t-tests. The QQ plot (Figure 2) was created by plotting the observed ordered negative log10 P-values for the RNASeq (or microarray) data against the ordered negative log10 P-values that would be expected if no genes were differentially expressed.
Quantitative Methylation Studies
Quantitative DNA methylation analysis was performed at the Keck Core Facility at Yale University using the MassARRAY EpiTYPER system (Sequenom, CA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Genomic DNA samples were bisulfite treated to convert non-methylated cytosine into uracil using the EZ DNA methylation kit (Zymo Research, CA), followed by PCR amplification using T7-promotor tagged reverse primers. After shrimp alkaline phosphatase treatment, in vitro transcription was performed, and the generated transcript was subjected to an enzymatic base specific cleavage. The resulting fragments differ in size and mass depending on the sequence changes generated through bisulfite treatment. The fragment masses were determined by MALDI-TOF MS and the EpiTYPER software used to estimate percentages of methylation at CpG sites for each analyzed fragment.
3′ Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends (3′ RACE)
3′ Race was performed with FirstChoice RLM-RACE Kit (Ambio by Applied Biosystem, CA) according to manufacturer’s protocol. 3′ Race outer and inner primers were designed from Exon 6 with Primer3 Plus, the first and nested PCR were done using an annealing temperature of 60°C. The highly expressed fragments after nested PCR were purified with QIAquick Gel Extraction Kit (Qiagen, CA), and then Sanger sequenced by using ABI 3730XL DNA Analyzer and sequence scanner v1.0 from ABI.
RNASeq gene expression, measure by log2 FPKM, is highly correlated with microarray gene expression measured by log2 normalized intensity. (Pearson correlation ranging from 0.83 to 0.85 in naïve, in vitro differentiated Th1, Th17-negative, and Th17-enriched CD4+ T cell subsets.
A. Hierarchical clustering, based on normalized microarray intensity, was performed for a set of 147 transcripts. The transcripts were selected to show at least a 1.5 fold up-regulation, and a P-value for differential expression less than 0.05 in the Th17-enriched cell subset compared to the Th17-negative cell subset. A total of 25 transcripts, associated with various autoimmune diseases, are designated with asterisks (*) on the right hand side of the heatmap. B. Disease-associated transcripts demonstrating increased expression in both Th17-enriched and Th1 cells: IL1R2, interleukin 1 receptor 2; PFKFB3, 6-phophofructo-2-kinase/fructose-2,6-biphosphatase3; IL18RAP, interleukin 18 receptor accessory protein; IL18R1, interleukin 18 receptor 1; IL12RB2, interleukin 12 receptor, beta2; IL23R, interleukin 23 receptor; ITGAX, integrin, alpha X (complement 3 receptor 4 subunit); VDR, vitamin D (1, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D3) receptor; SMOX, spermine oxidase; ATP6V0A1, ATPase, H+ transporting, lysosomal V0 subunit. C. Disease-associated transcripts demonstrating increased expression solely in Th17-enriched cells: KLRB1, killer cell lectin-like receptor subfamily B, member 1; IL17F, interleukin 17, F isoform; CCR6, chemokine (C-C motif) receptor 6; CAMTA1, calmodulin binding transcription activator 1; IL1R1, interleukin 1 receptor 1.
A. Vista genome browser view showing conservation scores near the IL23R promoter. In the IL23R promoter sequences, italicized red CpGs were included in the methylation analysis and SNPs are shown in blue. B. Fractions of methylation at conserved CpG promoter sites estimated by mass spectrometry (N = 5) for IL22, RORC, IL7R, IL18RAP and IL17F promoters. A paired t-test were used to test for differential methylation for the comparisons: naïve vs. Th1 and Th17-negative vs. Th17-enriched; *P<0.05, **P<0.01, ***P<0.001.
Confirmation of sequence contiguity for IL23R isoforms terminating in the extended exon 6 region. The reverse primer (5′ GGGTTGAAAAGCAAATTATTGGTAACTA - 3′) was designed from the extended exon 6 region, with forward primers designed from exons 1 through 6. The forward primers were: Exon 1, 5′ - GGTCAAGCGATCACTGAACTTAGA -3′; Exon 2, 5′ - CCTTTACATACTCTTCAGCTGGTGTC -3′; Exon 3, 5′ - TATTGCCAAGCAGCAATTAAGAAC -3′; Exon 4, 5′ - AGAAGAGCAACATGATCTCACCTCAA -3′; Exon 5, 5′ - CAAGGCTACAACAAACCAAACTT -3′; Exon 6, 5′ - CAAGGCTACAACAAACCAAACTT - 3″.
Known GWAS disease associations within upregulated transcripts in Th17-enriched cells compared to Th17-negative CD4+ T cells according to RNASeq.
Known GWAS disease associations within upregulated transcripts in Th17-enriched cells compared to Th17-negative CD4+ T cells according to Microarray.
Conceived and designed the experiments: WZ JF EE RAF CA HZ JHC. Performed the experiments: WZ SN. Analyzed the data: WZ JF AL KH GG JHC. Wrote the paper: WZ JF JHC.
- 1. Zenewicz LA, Abraham C, Flavell RA, Cho JH (2010) Unraveling the genetics of autoimmunity. Cell 140: 791.797
- 2. Duerr RH, Taylor KD, Brant SR, Rioux JD, Silverberg MS (2006) A genome-wide association study identifies IL23R as an inflammatory bowel disease gene. Science 314: 1461.1463
- 3. Cargill M, Schrodi SJ, Chang M, Garcia VE, Brandon R (2007) A large-scale genetic association study confirms IL12B and leads to the identification of IL23R as psoriasis-risk genes. Am J Hum Genet 80: 273.290
- 4. Burton PR, Clayton DG, Cardon LR, Craddock N, Deloukas P (2007) Association scan of 14,500 nonsynonymous SNPs in four diseases identifies autoimmunity variants. Nat Genet 39: 1329.1337
- 5. Ghoreschi K, Laurence A, Yang XP, Tato CM, McGeachy MJ (2010) Generation of pathogenic T(H)17 cells in the absence of TGF-beta signalling. Nature 467: 967.971
- 6. Parham C, Chirica M, Timans J, Vaisberg E, Travis M (2002) A receptor for the heterodimeric cytokine IL-23 is composed of IL-12Rbeta1 and a novel cytokine receptor subunit, IL-23R. J Immunol 168: 5699.5708
- 7. Anderson CA, Boucher G, Lees CW, Franke A, D’Amato M (2011) Meta-analysis identifies 29 additional ulcerative colitis risk loci, increasing the number of confirmed associations to 47. Nat Genet 43: 246.252
- 8. Franke A, McGovern DP, Barrett JC, Wang K, Radford-Smith GL (2010) Genome-wide meta-analysis increases to 71 the number of confirmed Crohn’s disease susceptibility loci. Nat Genet 42: 1118.1125
- 9. Ivanov , McKenzie BS, Zhou L, Tadokoro CE, Lepelley A (2006) The orphan nuclear receptor RORgammat directs the differentiation program of proinflammatory IL-17+ T helper cells. Cell 126: 1121.1133
- 10. Cosmi L, De Palma R, Santarlasci V, Maggi L, Capone M (2008) Human interleukin 17-producing cells originate from a CD161+CD4+ T cell precursor. J Exp Med 205: 1903.1916
- 11. Kleinschek MA, Boniface K, Sadekova S, Grein J, Murphy EE (2009) Circulating and gut-resident human Th17 cells express CD161 and promote intestinal inflammation. J Exp Med 206: 525.534
- 12. Maggi L, Santarlasci V, Capone M, Peired A, Frosali F (2010) CD161 is a marker of all human IL-17-producing T-cell subsets and is induced by RORC. Eur J Immunol 40: 2174.2181
- 13. Izadpanah A, Dwinell MB, Eckmann L, Varki NM, Kagnoff MF (2001) Regulated MIP-3alpha/CCL20 production by human intestinal epithelium: mechanism for modulating mucosal immunity. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol 280: G710.719
- 14. Varona R, Villares R, Carramolino L, Goya I, Zaballos A (2001) CCR6-deficient mice have impaired leukocyte homeostasis and altered contact hypersensitivity and delayed-type hypersensitivity responses. J Clin Invest 107: R37.45
- 15. Annunziato F, Cosmi L, Santarlasci V, Maggi L, Liotta F (2007) Phenotypic and functional features of human Th17 cells. J Exp Med 204: 1849.1861
- 16. Izcue A, Hue S, Buonocore S, Arancibia-Carcamo CV, Ahern PP (2008) Interleukin-23 restrains regulatory T cell activity to drive T cell-dependent colitis. Immunity 28: 559.570
- 17. Cua DJ, Sherlock J, Chen Y, Murphy CA, Joyce B (2003) Interleukin-23 rather than interleukin-12 is the critical cytokine for autoimmune inflammation of the brain. Nature 421: 744.748
- 18. Chan JR, Blumenschein W, Murphy E, Diveu C, Wiekowski M (2006) IL-23 stimulates epidermal hyperplasia via TNF and IL-20R2-dependent mechanisms with implications for psoriasis pathogenesis. J Exp Med 203: 2577.2587
- 19. Ahern PP, Schiering C, Buonocore S, McGeachy MJ, Cua DJ (2010) Interleukin-23 drives intestinal inflammation through direct activity on T cells. Immunity 33: 279.288
- 20. Wang Z, Gerstein M, Snyder M (2009) RNA-Seq: a revolutionary tool for transcriptomics. Nat Rev Genet 10: 57.63
- 21. Trynka G, Hunt KA, Bockett NA, Romanos J, Mistry V (2011) Dense genotyping identifies and localizes multiple common and rare variant association signals in celiac disease. Nat Genet 43: 1193.1201
- 22. Hindorff LA, Sethupathy P, Junkins HA, Ramos EM, Mehta JP (2009) Potential etiologic and functional implications of genome-wide association loci for human diseases and traits. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106: 9362.9367
- 23. Bird A (2002) DNA methylation patterns and epigenetic memory. Genes Dev 16: 6.21
- 24. Meissner A, Mikkelsen TS, Gu H, Wernig M, Hanna J (2008) Genome-scale DNA methylation maps of pluripotent and differentiated cells. Nature 454: 766.770
- 25. Sarin R, Wu X, Abraham C (2011) Inflammatory disease protective R381Q IL23 receptor polymorphism results in decreased primary CD4+ and CD8+ human T-cell functional responses. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 108: 9560.9565
- 26. Di Meglio P, Di Cesare A, Laggner U, Chu CC, Napolitano L (2011) The IL23R R381Q gene variant protects against immune-mediated diseases by impairing IL-23-induced Th17 effector response in humans. PLoS One 6: e17160.
- 27. Dixon AL, Liang L, Moffatt MF, Chen W, Heath S (2007) A genome-wide association study of global gene expression. Nat Genet 39: 1202.1207
- 28. Kang J, Cho J, Zhao H (2010) Practical issues in building risk-predicting models for complex diseases. J Biopharm Stat 20: 415.440
- 29. Yu RY, Gallagher G (2010) A naturally occurring, soluble antagonist of human IL-23 inhibits the development and in vitro function of human Th17 cells. J Immunol 185: 7302.7308
- 30. Lee YK, Turner H, Maynard CL, Oliver JR, Chen D (2009) Late developmental plasticity in the T helper 17 lineage. Immunity 30: 92.107
- 31. Bending D, De la Pena H, Veldhoen M, Phillips JM, Uyttenhove C (2009) Highly purified Th17 cells from BDC2.5NOD mice convert into Th1-like cells in NOD/SCID recipient mice. J Clin Invest 119: 565.572
- 32. Hirota K, Duarte JH, Veldhoen M, Hornsby E, Li Y (2011) Fate mapping of IL-17-producing T cells in inflammatory responses. Nat Immunol 12: 255.263
- 33. Uhlig HH, McKenzie BS, Hue S, Thompson C, Joyce-Shaikh B (2006) Differential activity of IL-12 and IL-23 in mucosal and systemic innate immune pathology. Immunity 25: 309.318
- 34. Hedrick MN, Lonsdorf AS, Shirakawa AK, Richard Lee CC, Liao F (2009) CCR6 is required for IL-23-induced psoriasis-like inflammation in mice. J Clin Invest 119: 2317.2329
- 35. Wei G, Wei L, Zhu J, Zang C, Hu-Li J (2009) Global mapping of H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 reveals specificity and plasticity in lineage fate determination of differentiating CD4+ T cells. Immunity 30: 155.167
- 36. Cheung VG, Spielman RS, Ewens KG, Weber TM, Morley M (2005) Mapping determinants of human gene expression by regional and genome-wide association. Nature 437: 1365.1369
- 37. Irizarry RA, Hobbs B, Collin F, Beazer-Barclay YD, Antonellis KJ (2003) Exploration, normalization, and summaries of high density oligonucleotide array probe level data. Biostatistics 4: 249.264
- 38. Trapnell C, Pachter L, Salzberg SL (2009) TopHat: discovering splice junctions with RNA-Seq. Bioinformatics 25: 1105.1111