The probiotic effects of Lactobacillus reuteri have been speculated to partly depend on its capacity to produce the antimicrobial substance reuterin during the reduction of glycerol in the gut. In this study, the potential of this process to protect human intestinal epithelial cells against infection with Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium was investigated. We used a three-dimensional (3-D) organotypic model of human colonic epithelium that was previously validated and applied to study interactions between S. Typhimurium and the intestinal epithelium that lead to enteric salmonellosis. Using this model system, we show that L. reuteri protects the intestinal cells against the early stages of Salmonella infection and that this effect is significantly increased when L. reuteri is stimulated to produce reuterin from glycerol. More specifically, the reuterin-containing ferment of L. reuteri caused a reduction in Salmonella adherence and invasion (1 log unit), and intracellular survival (2 log units). In contrast, the L. reuteri ferment without reuterin stimulated growth of the intracellular Salmonella population with 1 log unit. The short-term exposure to reuterin or the reuterin-containing ferment had no observed negative impact on intestinal epithelial cell health. However, long-term exposure (24 h) induced a complete loss of cell-cell contact within the epithelial aggregates and compromised cell viability. Collectively, these results shed light on a potential role for reuterin in inhibiting Salmonella-induced intestinal infections and may support the combined application of glycerol and L. reuteri. While future in vitro and in vivo studies of reuterin on intestinal health should fine-tune our understanding of the mechanistic effects, in particular in the presence of a complex gut microbiota, this the first report of a reuterin effect on the enteric infection process in any mammalian cell type.
Citation: De Weirdt R, Crabbé A, Roos S, Vollenweider S, Lacroix C, van Pijkeren JP, et al. (2012) Glycerol Supplementation Enhances L. reuteri’s Protective Effect against S. Typhimurium Colonization in a 3-D Model of Colonic Epithelium. PLoS ONE 7(5): e37116. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0037116
Editor: Dipshikha Chakravortty, Indian Institute of Science, India
Received: January 25, 2012; Accepted: April 15, 2012; Published: May 31, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 De Weirdt et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was supported by an FWO-Vlaanderen travel grant (www.fwo.be), an FWO-Vlaanderen research grant 1526012N and a GOA Project (BOF12/GOA/008) (www.ugent.be). RDW was funded by the Special Research Fund of Ghent University (www.ugent.be). CAN was supported by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration Grant NCC2-1362 (www.nasa.gov). TVDW benefits from an FWO-Vlaanderen postdoctoral grant. RB and JPVP were supported by a Strategic Partnership Grant by Michigan State University (http://msufoundation.msu.edu/index.html). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Intestinal infection by non-typhoidal Salmonella strains (NTS) leads to gastroenteritis and diarrheal disease, and is a major source of foodborne illness worldwide . Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. Typhimurium) causes a self-limiting gastroenteritis and diarrheal disease in healthy individuals, but can cause life threatening systemic illness in immuno-compromised individuals. Usually, treatment relies on water and electrolyte supplementation, but when the associated dehydration becomes severe or when Salmonella reaches the bloodstream, antimicrobial treatment becomes essential. However, since the 1990s multi-drug resistant strains have emerged and are compounding the problems associated with severe enteric salmonellosis , . Therefore, the development of novel therapeutic treatments and vaccines is ongoing. An alternative approach is to prevent or reduce Salmonella infection, using benign microorganisms that are naturally occurring in the gastrointestinal tract. The gut symbiont Lactobacillus reuteri has previously been shown to protect against gastrointestinal infections and even to reduce diarrhea in children , . However, it remains unclear how these effects are mediated. In this study, we explored the possibility for L. reuteri to decrease S. Typhimurium infection of the intestinal epithelium by producing and excreting the antimicrobial metabolite reuterin during the infection process.
Reuterin or the hydroxypropionaldehyde (HPA)-system is an antimicrobial mixture of 3-HPA mono-, di- and polymers, and HPA-hydrate. It is produced as an intermediate during the reduction of glycerol to 1,3-propanediol (1,3-PDO) . Several gut bacterial species are described to produce reuterin in a specialized bacterial compartment or metabolosome . Among these species, L. reuteri is the one reported to most efficiently produce reuterin and excrete relatively high amounts –. Only recently, two studies demonstrated that reuterin’s mode of action involves the modification of thiol groups in proteins and small molecules, which results in oxidative stress and ultimately leads to bacterial cell death , . Moreover, the latter studies indicated that the aldehyde group in 3-HPA is the bioactive agent in reuterin.
Several studies have investigated the antimicrobial activity of reuterin by determining its minimal inhibitory and bactericidal concentration (MIC and MBC) on pathogens and commensal gut bacteria both in the absence and presence of L. reuteri –. Recent reports indicated that reuterin production also occurs in mixed microbial communities found in human feces , , whereas Morita et al.  found in vivo reuterin production in the caecum of gnotobiotic mice inoculated with L. reuteri. Furthermore, there is increasing evidence that reuterin production is crucial for the ecological behavior and probiotic properties of L. reuteri isolates from the human gastrointestinal tract , . While mechanistic in vitro studies demonstrated that L. reuteri may protect intestinal cells against enteric infection by regulating immune responses – or by competition for host binding sites , the effect of reuterin production on modulating host-pathogen interactions with eukaryotic cells has not yet been investigated. Hence, in this study we assessed the capacity of reuterin to target the early stages of S. Typhimurium interaction with human colonic epithelium that lead to enteric salmonellosis, specifically adherence and invasion, intracellular survival and intracellular growth (i.e. colonization).
For these studies, we utilized a previously characterized rotating wall vessel (RWV)-derived 3-D HT-29 organotypic model of human intestinal epithelium. The application of a 3-D HT-29 model for this investigation is logical, since the former better approximates the parental tissue and has been shown to be more predictive of key in vivo responses to infection by S. Typhimurium as compared to monolayers , . This is evidenced by 3-D HT-29 cells exhibiting a) distinct apical and basolateral polarity, b) enhanced expression and organization of tight junctions, extracellular matrix, and brush border proteins, c) highly localized mucus production, and d) differentiation into multiple epithelial cell types relevant to those found in the intestine, including enterocytes, goblet cells, Paneth cells and M-like cells –. These in vivo-like expression levels and distribution patterns of key biological surface markers in 3-D cells are critical for differentiated form and function. These traits of the 3-D models could contribute to their ability to support pathogen infection in a manner more akin to that in the infected host as compared to monolayers . For example, the enhanced formation, integrity, and physiological distribution of tight junctions in 3-D HT-29 epithelial cells could serve as a protective barrier against pathogen invasion, thereby reducing infection and maintaining structural integrity. In addition, differences in mucus localization could alter bacterial adherence and invasion into the underlying epithelium. Moreover, the differentiation status of the intestinal epithelium drives important differences in cytokine production in polarized cells following bacterial infection as compared to their non-polarized counterparts, which is also an important determinant of infection outcome , . Likewise, the use of human surrogate infection models that possess multiple epithelial cell types normally found in the intestine is essential to better predict in vivo-like responses to infection with enteric pathogens. When applied to study the early stages of human enteric salmonellosis, the highly differentiated 3-D HT-29 intestinal model responded in ways that were similar to an in vivo infection, including differences in tissue morphology, adherence, invasion, apoptosis and cytokine expression , . To our knowledge, 3-D HT-29 cells were the first in vitro model of human intestinal epithelium to suggest that the Salmonella Pathogenicity Island 1 Type Three Secretion System (SPI-1 T3SS) may not be the main determinant for invasion of Salmonella into in vitro models of human intestinal epithelium . Subsequent work demonstrated that all characterized S. Typhimurium T3SSs (SPI-1, SPI-2, and the flagellar pore) are dispensable for Salmonella invasion into highly differentiated 3-D HT-29 cells, but are required for intracellular bacterial growth, paralleling in vivo infection observations and demonstrating the utility of these models in predicting in vivo-like pathogenic mechanisms and for studying host-microbe interactions . Using this organotypic model, we show that glycerol conversion to reuterin by L. reuteri reduces S. Typhimurium colonization of human intestinal epithelium and might be a useful therapeutic approach to consider for treatment and prevention of enteric salmonellosis.
Bacterial Strains, Media and Growth Conditions
The strains used in this study are provided in Table 1. L. reuteri ATCC PTA 6475 belongs to lineage II of the L. reuteri species . The genome of lineage II L. reuteri contains the pdu-cbi-cob-hem gene cluster, which encodes reuterin production . A knock-out mutant of pduC was generated using RecT-mediated oligonucleotide recombineering, as described by van Pijkeren and Britton . L. reuteri expressing RecT (strain RPRB0000) was used to target the pduC gene (Genbank locus ZP_08162814; glycerol dehydratase, large subunit) to yield strain RPRB1321, further indicated as ATCC PTA 6475 ΔpduC. Mutations were verified by PCR, and the integrity was confirmed by sequence analysis. Oligonucleotides for recombineering and screening purposes are available upon request.
S. Typhimurium and E. coli were grown on Lennox (L) agar (Fisher, New Jersey, USA) and L. reuteri was grown on de Man-Rogosa-Sharpe (MRS) agar (Difco, Maryland, USA) for 24 h at 37°C. Then, a colony of S. Typhimurium and E. coli was picked up and grown overnight (for approximately 15 h) in 5 mL L broth at 37°C with shaking at 180 rpm. Prior to use in experiments, overnight cultures were back-diluted 1∶100 in L broth and grown at 37°C with aeration until reaching mid-log phase of growth (OD595 ≈ 0.6). All infection studies were performed at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of approximately 1 bacterium per host cell. Similarly, a colony of L. reuteri ATCC PTA and ATCC PTA 6475 ΔpduC was picked and grown overnight (16–18 h) in 5 mL MRS broth either without or with 20 mM glycerol (99.9%, Sigma, Missouri, USA) at 37°C with shaking at 180 rpm. Ferments of ATCC PTA 6475 were prepared by harvesting (1500 rcf for 10 min) and washing the pellets with 5 mL Dulbecco’s Phosphate Buffered Saline (DPBS) with ions, and incubating them in 5 mL of the mammalian cell culture medium GTSF-2 without or with 100 mM glycerol during 2 h at 37°C with shaking at 180 rpm. The supernatant of these ferments was recovered after centrifugation at 8000 rcf for 10 min and filter-sterilized over a 0.45 µM PVDF filter (Whatman, Maine, USA). Prior to use in approach 1 experiments (Fig. 1), the supernatant obtained by fermentation without glycerol was diluted 10-fold in GTSF-2 medium (SN- 1∶10) and the supernatant of the ferment with glycerol was diluted 10-, 100- and 1000-fold, further indicated as SN+1∶10, SN+1∶100 and SN+1∶1000. For use in approach 2 infection experiments (Fig. 1), ATCC PTA 6475 was grown either in the absence or presence of 20 mM glycerol, while ATCC PTA 6475 ΔpduC was grown in the absence of glycerol. Consecutively, the pellets were suspended in 5 mL GTSF-2 without (PTA 6475 -) or with 40 mM glycerol (PTA 6475+ and PTA 6475 ΔpduC +). The L. reuteri cultures were diluted twice prior to use in infection studies, resulting in a population of (1.8±0.1)×109 CFU.mL−1.
Approach 1 infection experiments were done in the presence of supernatants of the L. reuteri ferment with or without reuterin (green star), while approach 2 infections were done in the presence of an established L. reuteri population (blue line) producing reuterin in situ.
To our knowledge, there are no data available on actual glycerol and reuterin concentrations in the human gut in vivo. However, Morita et al.  were the first to demonstrate that reuterin can be produced in vivo in the intestine of mice and that feces of untreated mice contain glycerol concentrations of 7–10 mM, suggesting the presence of glycerol in the intestine. Moreover, glycerol may rapidly be consumed by the colon microbiota , , which indicates that actual glycerol concentrations in the intestine might be higher than those found in the feces.
Reuterin Production and Quantification of Glycerol Metabolites
Reuterin was produced by L. reuteri ATCC 53608 in a two-step glycerol fermentation process and purified to a stock of 330 mM 3-HPA as described previously . Glycerol, acetic acid, lactic acid and 1,3-PDO were quantified by means of HPLC-UV/RI. Detailed information on sample preparation and analytical parameters can be found in . The concentration of 3-HPA was determined in the fresh samples by means of a colorimetric assay previously described by Vollenweider et al.  and modified to a 96-well plate format by Spinler et al. . In brief, 50 µL of a (10-fold diluted) sample was mixed with 37.5 µL tryptophan solution (0.01 M in 0.05 M HCl, stabilized with a few drops of toluene per 250 mL) and 150 µL 12 M HCl, and incubated during 20 min at 37°C. Then, reuterin was quantified as 3-HPA based on the optical density measured at 550 nm and a standard curve made with acrolein (Fluka, St. Louis, MO, USA).
Growth Inhibition of S. Typhimurium by 3-HPA and Supernatants from the L. Reuteri Ferment
To assess the effects of the supernatants from the ATCC PTA 6475 ferment (SN- and SN+) and 3 mM 3-HPA on survival and growth of S. Typhimurium, parallel experiments were performed according to the approach 1 infection studies described below and depicted in Fig. 1. The experiments were set-up in 24-well plates (500 µL/well) in the absence of host cells and with a single addition of the supernatants from the ATCC PTA 6475 ferment in GTSF-2. Mid-log phase grown S. Typhimurium was added to the wells at a concentration of 2×106 cells.mL−1 and incubated statically at 37°C in a 5% CO2 environment. A 20-µL sample was taken to plate 10-fold dilution series on L agar plates after 1, 4 and 24 h. The experiment was repeated three times and each time performed in duplicate, resulting in two technical and three biological replicates.
The minimal inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of 3-HPA and the reuterin-containing supernatants of the ATCC PTA 6475 ferment were determined for S. Typhimurium χ3339 using a standard serial dilution overnight growth assay downscaled to a 96-well plate. In brief, 2-fold dilution series were made in GTSF-2 starting either from 33 mM 3-HPA (20 µL 3-HPA stock of 330 mM in milliQ +180 µL GTSF-2) or undiluted supernatant of the ATCC PTA 6475 ferment. The final volume in each well was 100 µL. Then, a mid-log phase grown S. Typhimurium culture was added to the wells in a maximum volume of 3.8 µL per well and a final concentration of 2×106 bacterial cells.mL−1. The MIC was determined to be an intermediate concentration lying between that of the wells with and without visible growth (turbidity) after 24 h of static incubation at 37°C. The assay was repeated two times from independent S. Typhimurium cultures, each including 3 replicates.
3-D Model of Colonic Epithelium
Three-dimensional intestinal models were derived from the human colonic epithelial cell line HT-29 (American Type Culture Collection ATCC # HTB-38), using the RWV bioreactor from Synthecon as previously described , . For all studies, HT-29 cells were cultured in GTSF-2 medium (Hyclone) supplemented with heat-inactivated fetal bovine serum (Invitrogen, California, USA), ITS (insulin-transferrin-sodium selenite; Sigma, Missouri, USA), sodium bicarbonate, penicillin/streptomycin (Sigma, Missouri, USA) and fungizone (Invitrogen, California, USA) as described by Bentrup et al. . Fresh medium was replenished after 5 days and then every 24 h until harvest of the cultures after 15–18 days.
Adherence and Invasion, Intracellular Survival and Intracellular Growth Assays
A gentamicin exclusion assay was performed to assess S. Typhimurium adhesion and invasion (1 h), intracellular survival (4 h) and intracellular growth (24 h). The experimental flow was modified from previous publications , ,  and is depicted in Fig. 1. Two days prior to the infection experiments, 3-D HT-29 cells were grown in antibiotic free GTSF-2, and streak incubations of the bacterial cultures were started on agar and further prepared as described above. On the day of infection (day 15–18), the 3-D aggregates were removed from the RWV bioreactor and seeded evenly into 48-well plates with 2×106 cells.mL−1 and 250 µL GTSF-2 per well. The number of cells associated with 3-D aggregates was determined by dissociation into individual cells with 0.25% trypsin-EDTA. The cell number and viability were determined by 0.4% trypan blue (1∶1) (Sigma, Missouri, USA) dye exclusion and counting in a hemocytometer. S. Typhimurium or non-invasive E. coli were added to the 3-D HT-29 cells at an MOI of approximately 1-to-1 (bacteria-to-host cell). In approach 1 infection experiments, 3-D aggregates were exposed to S. Typhimurium or E. coli together with (a) 3-HPA (3 mM) or (b) dilutions of the supernatants from the L. reuteri ferment as described above. Infections according to approach 2 were done in the presence of an established (reuterin-producing) L. reuteri population. Non-exposed controls (with and without bacteria) were included. Both approach 1 and 2 cultures were incubated for 1 h in a 5% CO2 environment at 37°C, yielding adhered and invaded S. Typhimurium. Medium was subsequently changed to GTSF-2 containing gentamicin to eliminate extracellular bacteria, and cells were incubated for an additional 3 h. Then, the intracellular bacteria were determined (survival) and again fresh medium with gentamicin was added for a final incubation until 24 h after the start of infection to determine intracellular growth. At each time point, adherent and/or intracellular bacteria were quantified after lysing the host cells with 0.1% sodium deoxycholate (approach 1) or 1% triton (approach 2) and plating serial dilutions of the lysates on L agar plates overnight. Additionally, host cell viability was assessed following trypsinization of the 3-D aggregates, staining with 0.4% trypan blue (1∶1) (Sigma, Missouri, USA) and counting in a hemocytometer. All infection experiments were performed at least twice, in duplicates, resulting in a minimum of two technical and two biological replicates.
Significant differences between treatments were detected with SPSS Statistics 19. Normality was tested with the Kolmogorov-Smirnoff test. Normal distributed data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA, testing for equality of the variances with the Modified Levene test and determining the p-value according to Bonferroni or Dunnett T3. Significant differences within non-normal distributions were detected using the Mann-Whitney U test. The significance level was set at 0.05.
Characterization of the Supernatants from the L. Reuteri Ferment
A fully-grown culture of L. reuteri ATCC PTA 6475 was incubated in GTSF-2 without (SN-) and with 100 mM glycerol (SN+) for 2 h. The supernatant of these ferments was characterized for its glycerol, 3-HPA, 1,3-PDO, acetic acid and lactic acid content (Table 2). Prior to application in growth and infection experiments the SN- supernatant was diluted 10-fold and the SN+ supernatant 10-, 100- or 1000-fold. In the SN+ supernatant, 67±4 mol % of the supplemented glycerol had been converted to 3-HPA (62±7% of converted glycerol) and 1,3-PDO (42±6% of converted glycerol). Acetic acid and lactic acid were formed in both the SN- and the SN+ supernatant, but in different amounts. The lactic acid concentration was significantly higher in the SN- supernatants (p<0.001), while the acetic acid concentration was more than 3-fold higher in the SN+ supernatants (p<0.001). The pH of all dilutions was very similar with an average value of 7.49±0.02.
Growth Effects of Supernatants from the L. Reuteri Ferment and Pure 3-HPA on a S. Typhimurium Population
The growth effects of the supernatant from the L. reuteri ferments on the S. Typhimurium population were assessed after 1, 4 and 24 h of exposure to dilutions of the ferment, parallel to the approach 1 infection assay. Fig. 2 shows the reduction of the χ3339 population after exposure to the 10-fold diluted reuterin-containing supernatant (SN+1∶10, 2.5±0.4 mM 3-HPA) with 0.2±0.1 (1 h), 1.8±0.1 (4 h) and 6.5±0.7 (24 h) log units, respectively. Addition of 3 mM 3-HPA resulted in a similar reduction of the χ3339 population (0.1±0.1, 1.7±0.1 and 7.0±0.6 for 1, 4 and 24 h, respectively). No significant growth effects were observed for higher dilutions of the same supernatant (SN+1∶100 and SN+1∶1000) or the supernatant without reuterin (SN- 1∶10).
Log difference in χ3339 counts (CFU.mL−1) of the untreated χ3339 control minus the treatments with 3 mM 3-HPA, the 10-, 100- or 1000-fold diluted supernatants containing reuterin (respectively SN+1∶10 with 2.5 mM 3-HPA, SN+1∶100; 0.25 mM 3-HPA and SN+1∶1000; 0.025 mM 3-HPA) and the 10-fold diluted supernatant without reuterin (SN- 1∶10) after 1, 4 and 24 h of exposure. Significant differences between the treatments are indicated with different letters (a or b; p<0.05).
The MIC-value of the supernatants from the reuterin-containing ferment of L. reuteri corresponded to a 3-HPA concentration between 0.9 and 1.4 mM, as calculated from the MIC-values obtained for two biological replicates. The MIC-value of pure 3-HPA was found to lie between 1.0 and 2.1 mM.
Infection of 3-D Intestinal Cells with S. Typhimurium in the Presence of Supernatants from the L. Reuteri Ferment or Pure 3-HPA (Approach 1)
After assessment of the growth effects of the L. reuteri supernatant and pure 3-HPA on S. Typhimurium χ3339, their capacity to generate similar effects in the presence of eukaryotic cells and to protect the intestinal epithelium against S. Typhimurium infection was tested. This approach allowed us to more closely assess the effect of reuterin on the in vivo infection process of S. Typhimurium. Therefore, 3-D HT-29 cells infected with S. Typhimurium were exposed to L. reuteri supernatant and pure 3-HPA under the same conditions of incubation (medium, temperature, CFU.mL−1, 3-HPA concentration) as for the experiments with S. Typhimurium in the absence of host cells.
The 10-fold diluted reuterin-containing supernatant (2.5±0.4 mM 3-HPA) from the L. reuteri ferment was able to significantly reduce χ3339 adhesion and invasion, and intracellular survival with 0.7±0.2 and 1.6±0.3 log units, respectively, when compared to the untreated S. Typhimurium control (Fig. 3). Moreover, after 24 h no χ3339 survival was detected (detection limit = 102 CFU.mL−1). Higher dilutions of the reuterin-containing supernatants did not result in any statistically significant differences compared to the control (Fig. 3). Addition of 3 mM 3-HPA resulted in a 0.8±0.1 log unit reduction of the χ3339 intracellular survival (Fig. 3). However, it did not affect χ3339 adhesion and invasion. Interestingly, the 10-fold diluted L. reuteri supernatant without reuterin was found to stimulate χ3339 adhesion and invasion, and intracellular survival, with a 0.7±0.2 log unit increase in intracellular growth after 24 h (Fig. 3).
Log difference in χ3339 counts (CFU.mL−1) of the untreated χ3339 control minus the treatments with 3 mM 3-HPA, the 10-, 100- and 1000-fold diluted supernatants containing reuterin (respectively SN+1∶10 with 2.5 mM 3-HPA, SN+1∶100; 0.25 mM 3-HPA and SN+1∶1000; 0.025 mM 3-HPA) and the 10-fold diluted supernatant without reuterin (SN- 1∶10) after 1 h (adhesion & invasion), 4 h (intracellular survival) and 24 h (intracellular growth) of exposure. The non-invasive E. coli HB101 control strain did not show countable colonies at the lowest dilution (detection limit = 102 CFU.mL−1). Significant differences between the treatments are indicated with different letters (a, b, c or d; p<0.05). bdl = below detection limit.
In Fig. 4, the effects of 3 mM 3-HPA and the supernatants of the L. reuteri ferments on χ3339 adhesion and invasion, intracellular survival and growth are compared with those found when no HT-29 aggregates were added (Fig. 2). In the presence of the HT-29 aggregates, both supernatants seemed to affect the χ3339 population stronger. For the reuterin-containing supernatant (SN+1∶10; 2.5 mM 3-HPA) and 3 mM pure 3-HPA, a bacteriostatic effect was observed up to 4 h of exposure in the absence of the HT-29 aggregates, while in the presence of these aggregates, the reuterin-containing supernatant – but not pure 3-HPA – immediately affected the χ3339 population viability after 1 h. In addition, the supernatants without reuterin (SN- 1∶10) significantly stimulated χ3339 intracellular growth in the presence of HT-29 aggregates, while no such effect was observed for the SN- 1∶10 supernatant in the absence of the aggregates.
Log counts (CFU.mL−1) of the χ3339 population (initial inoculum 2×106 cells.mL−1) exposed to the 10-fold diluted supernatant without (SN- 1∶10) and with reuterin (SN+1∶10, 2.5 mM 3-HPA) both in the absence (left) and presence (right) of 3-D HT-29 aggregates. Detection limit = 102 CFU.mL−1.
The negative control strain, Escherichia coli HB101, did not exhibit invasion into the colon cells, as no bacterial colony forming units were detected after addition of gentamicin to the medium (4 h) (detection limit = 102 CFU.mL−1).
Infection of 3-D Intestinal Cells with S. Typhimurium in the Presence of an Established L. Reuteri Population (Approach 2)
The importance of glycerol reduction and reuterin production for L. reuteri to protect against χ3339 infection was tested in an approach 2 gentamicin exclusion assay (Fig. 1). An overnight culture of wild-type L. reuteri ATCC PTA 6475 was suspended in fresh GTSF-2 medium supplemented with 40 mM glycerol and incubated in the presence of 3-D HT-29 cells to allow for in situ reuterin production. The average reuterin production was 2.8±1.0 mM (after 30 min) and 3.8±1.3 mM (after 1 h30). Negative controls were provided by incubating (1) a pduC knockout of ATCC PTA 6475 in GTSF-2 with 40 mM glycerol and (2) ATCC PTA 6475 in GTSF-2 without glycerol. Reuterin production by both negative controls was always below detection limit (0.8 mM for 3-HPA). Fig. 5A shows that the presence of both wild type and pduC knockout strains of L. reuteri ATCC PTA 6475 significantly reduced χ3339 adhesion and invasion, but that this reduction was significantly higher when reuterin was produced in situ. Interestingly, the presence of all L. reuteri strains during the first 1 h30 of the assay further reduced the relative survival of the invaded χ3339 population after 4 h (Fig. 5B), but stimulated χ3339 intracellular growth after 24 h (Fig. 5C) when compared to the Salmonella control. For these time points, no significant differences were observed between reuterin-producing L. reuteri populations and the negative L. reuteri controls.
Log differences in χ3339 counts (CFU.mL−1) of (A) adhered and invaded minus initial inoculum, (B) intracellular surviving minus adhered and invaded, and (C) intracellular growth minus survival upon exposure to an established population of L. reuteri ATCC PTA 6475 producing reuterin (PTA 6475+40 mM gly) or unable to produce reuterin (ΔpduC +40 mM gly and PTA 6475 no gly). Significant differences between the treatments are indicated with different letters (a, b or c; p<0.05).
3-D HT-29 Aggregate Morphology and Cell Viability
For every time point of the infection assays, separate wells were used to assess morphology of the 3-D HT-29 aggregates under a light microscope and to quantify cell viability after trypsinization and trypan blue staining. For both approaches 1 and 2 infection assays, a maximum of 10% dead cells was found for the aggregates exposed to all conditions after 1 and 4 h, both in the presence and absence of S. Typhimurium. An example for the morphology of these healthy aggregates is depicted in Fig. 6A. However, after 24 h a remarkable difference was observed in the morphology of aggregates exposed to 3 mM 3-HPA and the reuterin-containing L. reuteri supernatant (SN+1∶10, 2.5±0.4 mM 3-HPA), when compared to the other treatments and controls. Fig. 6B depicts the complete destruction of the 3-D structure of the aggregates into that of a single cell suspension. Moreover, 55±20% of these single cells were dead, as indicated by their absorption of trypan blue (Fig. 6C). Exposure to all other treatments of both approaches 1 and 2, and the untreated S. Typhimurium controls did not lead to any significant effect on cell viability at the 24 h exposure time point and resulted in 3-D morphology comparable to that shown in Fig. 6A.
(A) Aggregates of HT-29 colon cancer cells grown in three dimensions on porous collagen-coated microcarrier beads. The picture represents the situation for all treatments after 0, 1 and 4 h and the treatments with the L. reuteri supernatants without reuterin (SN- 1∶10) or containing low concentrations of reuterin (SN+1∶100 with 0.25 mM 3-HPA and SN+1∶1000 with 0.025 mM 3-HPA) after 24 h. (B) Example of a single cell suspension and naked porous collagen-coated microcarrier beads after 24 h of exposure to 3 mM 3-HPA or the 10-fold diluted reuterin-containing L. reuteri supernatant (SN+1∶10, 2.5 mM 3-HPA). (C) Example of live/dead counts of trypan blue treated single cell suspensions depicted in B with a hemocytometer. Dead cells are colored blue.
Due to the increasing incidence of multidrug-resistant and highly invasive Salmonella strains, the development of new therapeutic treatments against human enteric salmonellosis becomes critical. In this study, we demonstrated the capacity of the reuterin-containing glycerol ferment of the probiotic and commensal species L. reuteri to significantly decrease adhesion and invasion, and intracellular survival of S. Typhimurium in a 3-D organotypic model of colonic epithelium. Moreover, it was found that an established L. reuteri population had an additional protective effect against χ3339 adhesion and invasion when it was able to convert glycerol to reuterin in situ. In contrast to conventional 2-D monolayers, our 3-D colon model was previously shown to respond to S. Typhimurium infection in key ways that reflect the infection process in vivo, including adherence, invasion, structural damage, cytokine production, and the lack of dependence on the SPI-1, SPI-2 and flagellar T3SS for Salmonella invasion , . These findings highlight the relevance of our organotypic models for use as novel platforms to provide unique insight for development and screening of new therapies against Salmonella infection.
In approach 1 infection experiments, we compared the potential of the ferment of L. reuteri without and with glycerol to decrease colonization of the 3-D model colon epithelium by an actively growing χ3339 population (Fig. 3). Only the glycerol-supplemented ferment that contained reuterin at concentrations of 2.5±0.4 mM 3-HPA was found to significantly decrease colonization by χ3339. Higher dilutions of the reuterin-containing glycerol ferment (containing 0.25±0.04 mM 3-HPA and 0.025±0.004 mM 3-HPA) did not change the χ3339 infection process. However, the ferment without glycerol actually stimulated χ3339 intracellular survival and growth significantly. In this respect, the low concentrations of 3-HPA in the diluted reuterin-containing ferments (0.25±0.04 mM and 0.025±0.004 mM) could have counteracted the stimulatory effect on χ3339 intracellular survival and growth, as was observed for the ferment without glycerol or reuterin. This stimulatory effect might have been caused by the presence of low concentrations of acetic acid. This bacterial product was previously shown to stimulate the expression of SPI-1 T3SS genes at pH 6.7 but not at pH 8.0 , . Since, the pH in our study was approximately 7.5, other unknown mechanisms were possibly involved in this stimulatory effect. Overall, these data illustrate the importance of glycerol and its conversion to reuterin for the inhibitory effects of the L. reuteri ferment towards χ3339 colonization.
Interestingly, the effects of pure 3-HPA and the L. reuteri ferment (both with and without glycerol) on the χ3339 population infecting host cells were found to be more profound than those in the absence of host cells (Fig. 4). Moreover, in the presence of the 3-D HT-29 cultures, pure 3-HPA exhibited a reduced ability to affect adherence and invasion, and intracellular survival of χ3339 populations as compared to the L. reuteri supernatant containing a similar amount of 3-HPA (2.5±0.4 mM 3-HPA). Interestingly, in the absence of host cells, both treatments resulted in an equal decrease of the χ3339 population. This suggests that the (combined) effect of L. reuteri metabolites on the ability of S. Typhimurium to colonize our well-differentiated models of intestinal epithelium may be enhanced due to (1) an increased sensitivity of χ3339 to these compounds in the context of an epithelial infection and/or (2) a host response to the bacterial metabolites of L. reuteri that affects the χ3339 infection process. The first mechanism could involve a direct or indirect effect of reuterin (alone or together with other metabolites) on Salmonella genes or their products that mediate colonization of the intestinal epithelium. While extremely limited information is available regarding the effect of reuterin on the mechanisms of Salmonella enteric pathogenesis, Kim et al.  found that a low concentration of reuterin (0.26 mM) is able to effectuate a moderate and short-term down-regulation of the SPI-1 T3SS genes invA and hilA without affecting the survival or growth of the S. Typhimurium culture after 8 h of exposure. The SPI-1 T3SS has been shown to be essential for Salmonella invasion into a variety of model host systems , –. However, the choice of host species alters Salmonella infection strategies, and it was previously shown that the SPI-1 T3SS is not required for S. Typhimurium invasion into our highly differentiated 3-D HT-29 colon models , , which is in agreement with studies reporting that SPI-1 is not required to cause enteropathogenesis in vivo –. Given the growing interest in the use of probiotics to maintain intestinal homeostasis and their potential to protect against enteric infection, identification of the mechanism(s) by which reuterin impacts intestinal colonization by Salmonella will likely become an area of expanding investigation. Central to the successful identification of these mechanisms will be the use of advanced intestinal models like those used in this study that exhibit key similarities to the responses of their in vivo parental tissues during a Salmonella infection.
The second mechanism would require the direct interaction of reuterin with the host cells, as 3-HPA was previously shown to bind to thiol groups and glutathione , . In addition, reuterin can be spontaneously dehydrated to acrolein, which is a highly reactive toxin with a mutagenic potency comparable to that of formaldehyde , . A possible reuterin interaction with host cells was furthermore supported in our study by the destruction of the 3-D aggregate structure and loss of cell viability within 24 h of exposure to both 3 mM pure 3-HPA and the reuterin-containing L. reuteri ferment (2.5±0.4 mM 3-HPA) (Fig. 6). This is the first study showing a reuterin effect on a model of intestinal epithelium. However, many in vivo trials support the safe administration of high doses of L. reuteri strains to full-term healthy infants younger than 4 months, healthy and even HIV-infected adults –. Given the reactive nature of reuterin with microbes and proteins, it could therefore be proposed that, in vivo, colonic reuterin interacts first with the luminal bacteria and bacteria colonizing the outer layer of the mucosal interface of the intestinal epithelium , , before it would affect the host. Further in vitro studies should carefully determine whether our observed reuterin effects are relevant in the presence of a complex gut microbiota and to what extent glycerol can be safely supplemented as a nutrient for the basal or enriched L. reuteri population in the human gut.
To further validate the safety and importance of the glycerol metabolism for L. reuteri to protect against intestinal S. Typhimurium infection, a second series of experiments was performed in which the model colon epithelium was infected with χ3339 in the presence of an established L. reuteri population that was either unable or stimulated to produce reuterin from glycerol (Fig. 5). In either case, L. reuteri was able to significantly reduce S. Typhimurium adhesion and invasion. This result was expected, as several research groups have demonstrated the capacity of L. reuteri to protect intestinal epithelial cells against inflammation and enteric infection by regulating the expression of pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines – or to decrease S. Typhimurium adherence to Caco-2 cells . However, we found that L. reuteri populations that were stimulated to convert glycerol to reuterin caused a significantly higher reduction of χ3339 adhesion and invasion as compared to populations that were not able to produce reuterin. Hence, in addition to L. reuteri’s protective effects via immunoregulatory modulation or competition for binding places –, our results indicate that protection against S. Typhimurium could also occur via its capacity to produce reuterin from glycerol. This process was recently found to be important for the success and ecological behavior of L. reuteri strains isolated from the human gastrointestinal tract (GIT), poultry and to a lesser extent from pigs . Moreover, glycerol is a potential nutrient source for Salmonella  and the latter was suggested to have acquired part of the genomic island for reuterin production via horizontal gene transfer, indicating that L. reuteri and Salmonella are potential competitors for the glycerol niche , . Increasingly, metabolic pathways of the host and its associated microbiome are indicated to support growth of S. Typhimurium . However, in this study we found an inhibitory microbial pathway that requires the presence of glycerol and L. reuteri. Previous studies indicated that the production of propionate and butyrate by the colon microbiota, but not acetate, reduces Salmonella invasion in the large intestine of mice , . Together, these data suggest that management of the gut microbial metabolism towards such inhibitory pathways may be a new tool to protect against or treat Salmonella infections .
In conclusion, our results suggest that glycerol conversion to reuterin by L. reuteri might be an effective therapeutic approach to consider for protection against and treatment of intestinal Salmonella infections. However, prior to investigating its use as a potential antimicrobial agent in humans, both in vitro colonic fermentation studies  and in vivo model studies with reuterin would need to be performed to determine the effects and mechanisms of this compound on gastrointestinal health.
The authors like to thank Tim Lacoere for designing the overview figure of the experimental set-up (Fig.1).
Conceived and designed the experiments: RDW AC CAN TVdW. Performed the experiments: RDW AC SS. Analyzed the data: RDW AC CAN. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SR SV CL JPvP RB. Wrote the paper: RDW AC CAN SR CL TVdW.
- 1. WHO (2005) Drug-resistant Salmonella. Department FS, editor. Fact sheet N° 139: WHO2005Drug-resistant Salmonella. Department FS, editor.Fact sheet N°139
- 2. Chiu LH, Chiu CH, Horn YM, Chiou CS, Lee CY, et al. (2010) Characterization of 13 multi-drug resistant Salmonella serovars from different broiler chickens associated with those of human isolates. BMC Microbiology 10: 10.LH ChiuCH ChiuYM HornCS ChiouCY Lee2010Characterization of 13 multi-drug resistant Salmonella serovars from different broiler chickens associated with those of human isolates.BMC Microbiology1010
- 3. Wiesner M, Calva E, Fernandez-Mora M, Cevallos MA, Campos F, et al. (2011) Salmonella Typhimurium ST213 is associated with two types of IncA/C plasmids carrying multiple resistance determinants. BMC Microbiology 11: 11.M. WiesnerE. CalvaM. Fernandez-MoraMA CevallosF. Campos2011Salmonella Typhimurium ST213 is associated with two types of IncA/C plasmids carrying multiple resistance determinants.BMC Microbiology1111
- 4. Casas IA, Dobrogosz WJ (2000) Validation of the probiotic concept: Lactobacillus reuteri confers broad-spectrum protection against disease in humans and animals. Microbial Ecology in Health and Disease 12: 247–285.IA CasasWJ Dobrogosz2000Validation of the probiotic concept: Lactobacillus reuteri confers broad-spectrum protection against disease in humans and animals.Microbial Ecology in Health and Disease12247285
- 5. Weizman Z, Asli G, Alsheikh A (2005) Effect of a probiotic infant formula on infections in child care centers: Comparison of two probiotic agents. Pediatrics 115: 5–9.Z. WeizmanG. AsliA. Alsheikh2005Effect of a probiotic infant formula on infections in child care centers: Comparison of two probiotic agents.Pediatrics11559
- 6. Vollenweider S, Lacroix C (2004) 3-Hydroxypropionaldehyde: applications and perspectives of biotechnological production. Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology 64: 16–27.S. VollenweiderC. Lacroix20043-Hydroxypropionaldehyde: applications and perspectives of biotechnological production.Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology641627
- 7. Sriramulu DD, Liang M, Hernandez-Romero D, Raux-Deery E, Lunsdorf H, et al. (2008) Lactobacillus reuteri DSM 20016 produces cobalamin-dependent diol dehydratase in metabolosomes and metabolizes 1,2-propanediol by disproportionation. Journal of Bacteriology 190: 4559–4567.DD SriramuluM. LiangD. Hernandez-RomeroE. Raux-DeeryH. Lunsdorf2008Lactobacillus reuteri DSM 20016 produces cobalamin-dependent diol dehydratase in metabolosomes and metabolizes 1,2-propanediol by disproportionation.Journal of Bacteriology19045594567
- 8. Talarico TL, Casas IA, Chung TC, Dobrogosz WJ (1988) Production and isolation of reuterin, a growth inhibitor produced by Lactobacillus reuteri. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 32: 1854–1858.TL TalaricoIA CasasTC ChungWJ Dobrogosz1988Production and isolation of reuterin, a growth inhibitor produced by Lactobacillus reuteri.Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy3218541858
- 9. Luthi-Peng Q, Scharer S, Puhan Z (2002) Production and stability of 3-hydroxypropionaldehyde in Lactobacillus reuteri. Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology 60: 73–80.Q. Luthi-PengS. ScharerZ. Puhan2002Production and stability of 3-hydroxypropionaldehyde in Lactobacillus reuteri.Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology607380
- 10. Vollenweider S, Grassi G, Konig I, Puhan Z (2003) Purification and structural characterization of 3-hydroxypropionaldehyde and its derivatives. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 51: 3287–3293.S. VollenweiderG. GrassiI. KonigZ. Puhan2003Purification and structural characterization of 3-hydroxypropionaldehyde and its derivatives.Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry5132873293
- 11. Schaefer L, Auchtung TA, Hermans KE, Whitehead D, Borhan B, et al. (2010) The antimicrobial compound reuterin (3-hydroxypropionaldehyde) induces oxidative stress via interaction with thiol groups. Microbiology-SGM 156: 1589–1599.L. SchaeferTA AuchtungKE HermansD. WhiteheadB. Borhan2010The antimicrobial compound reuterin (3-hydroxypropionaldehyde) induces oxidative stress via interaction with thiol groups.Microbiology-SGM15615891599
- 12. Vollenweider S, Evers S, Zurbriggen K, Lacroix C (2010) Unraveling the hydroxypropionaldehyde (HPA) system: an active antimicrobial agent against human pathogens. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 58: 10315–10322.S. VollenweiderS. EversK. ZurbriggenC. Lacroix2010Unraveling the hydroxypropionaldehyde (HPA) system: an active antimicrobial agent against human pathogens.Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry581031510322
- 13. Axelsson LT, Chung TC, Dobrogosz WJ, Lindgren SE (1989) Production of a broad-spectrum antimicrobial substance by Lactobacillus reuteri. Microbial Ecology in Health and Disease 2: 131–136.LT AxelssonTC ChungWJ DobrogoszSE Lindgren1989Production of a broad-spectrum antimicrobial substance by Lactobacillus reuteri.Microbial Ecology in Health and Disease2131136
- 14. Arques JL, Fernandez J, Gaya P, Nunez M, Rodriguez E, et al. (2004) Antimicrobial activity of reuterin in combination with nisin against food-borne pathogens. International Journal of Food Microbiology 95: 225–229.JL ArquesJ. FernandezP. GayaM. NunezE. Rodriguez2004Antimicrobial activity of reuterin in combination with nisin against food-borne pathogens.International Journal of Food Microbiology95225229
- 15. Cleusix V, Lacroix C, Vollenweider S, Duboux M, Le Blay G (2007) Inhibitory activity spectrum of reuterin produced by Lactobacillus reuteri against intestinal bacteria. BMC Microbiology 7: 9.V. CleusixC. LacroixS. VollenweiderM. DubouxG. Le Blay2007Inhibitory activity spectrum of reuterin produced by Lactobacillus reuteri against intestinal bacteria.BMC Microbiology79
- 16. Spinler JK, Taweechotipatr M, Rognerud CL, Ou CN, Tumwasorn S, et al. (2008) Human-derived probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri demonstrate antimicrobial activities targeting diverse enteric bacterial pathogens. Anaerobe 14: 166–171.JK SpinlerM. TaweechotipatrCL RognerudCN OuS. Tumwasorn2008Human-derived probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri demonstrate antimicrobial activities targeting diverse enteric bacterial pathogens.Anaerobe14166171
- 17. Bian L, Molan AL, Maddox I, Shu QA (2010) Antimicrobial activity of Lactobacillus reuteri DPC16 supernatants against selected food borne pathogens. World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology 27: 991–998.L. BianAL MolanI. MaddoxQA Shu2010Antimicrobial activity of Lactobacillus reuteri DPC16 supernatants against selected food borne pathogens.World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology27991998
- 18. Cleusix V, Lacroix C, Vollenweider S, Le Blay G (2008) Glycerol induces reuterin production and decreases Escherichia coli population in an in vitro model of colonic fermentation with immobilized human feces. FEMS Microbiology Ecology 63: 56–64.V. CleusixC. LacroixS. VollenweiderG. Le Blay2008Glycerol induces reuterin production and decreases Escherichia coli population in an in vitro model of colonic fermentation with immobilized human feces.FEMS Microbiology Ecology635664
- 19. De Weirdt R, Possemiers S, Vermeulen G, Moerdijk-Poortvliet TCW, Boschker HTS, et al. (2010) Human faecal microbiota display variable patterns of glycerol metabolism. FEMS Microbiology Ecology 74: 601–611.R. De WeirdtS. PossemiersG. VermeulenTCW Moerdijk-PoortvlietHTS Boschker2010Human faecal microbiota display variable patterns of glycerol metabolism.FEMS Microbiology Ecology74601611
- 20. Morita H, Toh H, Fukuda S, Horikawa H, Oshima K, et al. (2008) Comparative genome analysis of Lactobacillus reuteri and Lactobacillus fermentum reveal a genomic island for reuterin and cobalamin production. DNA Research 15: 151–161.H. MoritaH. TohS. FukudaH. HorikawaK. Oshima2008Comparative genome analysis of Lactobacillus reuteri and Lactobacillus fermentum reveal a genomic island for reuterin and cobalamin production.DNA Research15151161
- 21. Walter J, Britton RA, Roos S (2011) Host-microbial symbiosis in the vertebrate gastrointestinal tract and the Lactobacillus reuteri paradigm. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 108: 4645–4652.J. WalterRA BrittonS. Roos2011Host-microbial symbiosis in the vertebrate gastrointestinal tract and the Lactobacillus reuteri paradigm.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America10846454652
- 22. Frese SA, Benson AK, Tannock GW, Loach DM, Kim J, et al. (2011) The evolution of host specialization in the vertebrate gut symbiont Lactobacillus reuteri. PLoS Genetics 7: 16.SA FreseAK BensonGW TannockDM LoachJ. Kim2011The evolution of host specialization in the vertebrate gut symbiont Lactobacillus reuteri.PLoS Genetics716
- 23. Maassen CBM, van Holten-Neelen C, Balk F, den Bak-Glashouwer JH, Leer RJ, et al. (2000) Strain-dependent induction of cytokine profiles in the gut by orally administered Lactobacillus strains. Vaccine 18: 2613–2623.CBM MaassenC. van Holten-NeelenF. BalkJH den Bak-GlashouwerRJ Leer2000Strain-dependent induction of cytokine profiles in the gut by orally administered Lactobacillus strains.Vaccine1826132623
- 24. Peran L, Sierra S, Comalada M, Lara-Villoslada F, Bailon E, et al. (2007) A comparative study of the preventative effects exerted by two probiotics, Lactobacillus reuteri and Lactobacillus fermentum, in the trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid model of rat colitis. British Journal of Nutrition 97: 96–103.L. PeranS. SierraM. ComaladaF. Lara-VillosladaE. Bailon2007A comparative study of the preventative effects exerted by two probiotics, Lactobacillus reuteri and Lactobacillus fermentum, in the trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid model of rat colitis.British Journal of Nutrition9796103
- 25. Lin YP, Thibodeaux CH, Pena JA, Ferry GD, Versalovic J (2008) Probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri suppress proinflammatory cytokines via c-Jun. Inflammatory Bowel Diseases 14: 1068–1083.YP LinCH ThibodeauxJA PenaGD FerryJ. Versalovic2008Probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri suppress proinflammatory cytokines via c-Jun.Inflammatory Bowel Diseases1410681083
- 26. Liu YY, Fatheree NY, Mangalat N, Rhoads JM (2010) Human-derived probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri strains differentially reduce intestinal inflammation. American Journal of Physiology-Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology 299: G1087–G1096.YY LiuNY FathereeN. MangalatJM Rhoads2010Human-derived probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri strains differentially reduce intestinal inflammation.American Journal of Physiology-Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology299G1087G1096
- 27. Jones SE, Versalovic J (2009) Probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri biofilms produce antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory factors. BMC Microbiology 9: 9.SE JonesJ. Versalovic2009Probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri biofilms produce antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory factors.BMC Microbiology99
- 28. Todoriki K, Mukai T, Sato S, Toba T (2001) Inhibition of adhesion of food-borne pathogens to Caco-2 cells by Lactobacillus strains. Journal of Applied Microbiology 91: 154–159.K. TodorikiT. MukaiS. SatoT. Toba2001Inhibition of adhesion of food-borne pathogens to Caco-2 cells by Lactobacillus strains.Journal of Applied Microbiology91154159
- 29. Bentrup KHZ, Ramamurthy R, Ott CM, Emami K, Nelman-Gonzalez M, et al. (2006) Three-dimensional organotypic models of human colonic epithelium to study the early stages of enteric salmonellosis. Microbes and Infection 8: 1813–1825.KHZ BentrupR. RamamurthyCM OttK. EmamiM. Nelman-Gonzalez2006Three-dimensional organotypic models of human colonic epithelium to study the early stages of enteric salmonellosis.Microbes and Infection818131825
- 30. Radtke AL, Wilson JW, Sarker S, Nickerson CA (2010) Analysis of interactions of Salmonella Type Three Secretion mutants with 3-D intestinal epithelial cells. PLoS One 5: 12.AL RadtkeJW WilsonS. SarkerCA Nickerson2010Analysis of interactions of Salmonella Type Three Secretion mutants with 3-D intestinal epithelial cells.PLoS One512
- 31. Barrila J, Radtke AL, Crabbe A, Sarker SF, Herbst-Kralovetz MM, et al. (2010) Organotypic 3-D cell culture models: using the rotating wall vessel to study host-pathogen interactions. Nature Reviews Microbiology 8: 791–801.J. BarrilaAL RadtkeA. CrabbeSF SarkerMM Herbst-Kralovetz2010Organotypic 3-D cell culture models: using the rotating wall vessel to study host-pathogen interactions.Nature Reviews Microbiology8791801
- 32. Hobert ME, Sands KA, Mrsny RJ, Madara JL (2002) Cdc42 and Rac1 regulate late events in Salmonella Typhimurium-induced interleukin-8 secretion from polarized epithelial cells. Journal of Biological Chemistry 277: 51025–51032.ME HobertKA SandsRJ MrsnyJL Madara2002Cdc42 and Rac1 regulate late events in Salmonella Typhimurium-induced interleukin-8 secretion from polarized epithelial cells.Journal of Biological Chemistry2775102551032
- 33. Hurley BP, McCormick BA (2003) Translating tissue culture results into animal models: the case of Salmonella Typhimurium. Trends in Microbiology 11: 562–569.BP HurleyBA McCormick2003Translating tissue culture results into animal models: the case of Salmonella Typhimurium.Trends in Microbiology11562569
- 34. Oh PL, Benson AK, Peterson DA, Patil PB, Moriyama EN, et al. (2010) Diversification of the gut symbiont Lactobacillus reuteri as a result of host-driven evolution. ISME Journal 4: 377–387.PL OhAK BensonDA PetersonPB PatilEN Moriyama2010Diversification of the gut symbiont Lactobacillus reuteri as a result of host-driven evolution.ISME Journal4377387
- 35. van Pijkeren J, Britton R (2012) High-efficiency recombineering in lactic acid bacteria. Nucleic Acids Research. In press. J. van PijkerenR. Britton2012High-efficiency recombineering in lactic acid bacteria.Nucleic Acids Research. In pressDOI:10.1093/nar/GKS147. DOI:10.1093/nar/GKS147.
- 36. Nickerson CA, Goodwin TJ, Terlonge J, Ott CM, Buchanan KL, et al. (2001) Three-dimensional tissue assemblies: Novel models for the study of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium pathogenesis. Infection and Immunity 69: 7106–7120.CA NickersonTJ GoodwinJ. TerlongeCM OttKL Buchanan2001Three-dimensional tissue assemblies: Novel models for the study of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium pathogenesis.Infection and Immunity6971067120
- 37. Lawhon SD, Maurer R, Suyemoto M, Altier C (2002) Intestinal short-chain fatty acids alter Salmonella Typhimurium invasion gene expression and virulence through BarA/SirA. Molecular Microbiology 46: 1451–1464.SD LawhonR. MaurerM. SuyemotoC. Altier2002Intestinal short-chain fatty acids alter Salmonella Typhimurium invasion gene expression and virulence through BarA/SirA.Molecular Microbiology4614511464
- 38. Van Immerseel F, Russell JB, Flythe MD, Gantois I, Timbermont L, et al. (2006) The use of organic acids to combat Salmonella in poultry: a mechanistic explanation of the efficacy. Avian Pathology 35: 182–188.F. Van ImmerseelJB RussellMD FlytheI. GantoisL. Timbermont2006The use of organic acids to combat Salmonella in poultry: a mechanistic explanation of the efficacy.Avian Pathology35182188
- 39. Kim JY, Ryu S, Ji GE (2007) Effects of sulforaphane, grapefruit seed extracts, and reuterin on virulence gene expression using hilA and invF fusion strains of Salmonella Typhimurium. Food Science and Biotechnology 16: 778–782.JY KimS. RyuGE Ji2007Effects of sulforaphane, grapefruit seed extracts, and reuterin on virulence gene expression using hilA and invF fusion strains of Salmonella Typhimurium.Food Science and Biotechnology16778782
- 40. Pullinger GD, Paulin SM, Charleston B, Watson PR, Bowen AJ, et al. (2007) Systemic translocation of Salmonella enterica serovar Dublin in cattle occurs predominantly via efferent lymphatics in a cell-free niche and requires type III secretion system I (T3SS-1) but not T3SS-2. Infection and Immunity 75: 5191–5199.GD PullingerSM PaulinB. CharlestonPR WatsonAJ Bowen2007Systemic translocation of Salmonella enterica serovar Dublin in cattle occurs predominantly via efferent lymphatics in a cell-free niche and requires type III secretion system I (T3SS-1) but not T3SS-2.Infection and Immunity7551915199
- 41. Raffatellu M, Wilson RP, Chessa D, Andrews-Polymenis H, Tran QT, et al. (2005) SipA, SopA, SopB, SopD, and SopE2 contribute to Salmonella enterica serotype Typhimurium invasion of epithelial cells. Infection and Immunity 73: 146–154.M. RaffatelluRP WilsonD. ChessaH. Andrews-PolymenisQT Tran2005SipA, SopA, SopB, SopD, and SopE2 contribute to Salmonella enterica serotype Typhimurium invasion of epithelial cells.Infection and Immunity73146154
- 42. Baumler AJ, Tsolis RM, Valentine PJ, Ficht TA, Heffron F (1997) Synergistic effect of mutations in invA and lpfC on the ability of Salmonella Typhimurium to cause murine typhoid. Infection and Immunity 65: 2254–2259.AJ BaumlerRM TsolisPJ ValentineTA FichtF. Heffron1997Synergistic effect of mutations in invA and lpfC on the ability of Salmonella Typhimurium to cause murine typhoid.Infection and Immunity6522542259
- 43. Morgan E, Campbell JD, Rowe SC, Bispham J, Stevens MP, et al. (2004) Identification of host-specific colonization factors of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. Molecular Microbiology 54: 994–1010.E. MorganJD CampbellSC RoweJ. BisphamMP Stevens2004Identification of host-specific colonization factors of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium.Molecular Microbiology549941010
- 44. Watson PR, Paulin SM, Bland AP, Jones PW, Wallis TS (1995) Characterization of intestinal invasion by Salmonella Typhimurium and Salmonella Dublin and effect of a mutation in the InvH gene. Infection and Immunity 63: 2743–2754.PR WatsonSM PaulinAP BlandPW JonesTS Wallis1995Characterization of intestinal invasion by Salmonella Typhimurium and Salmonella Dublin and effect of a mutation in the InvH gene.Infection and Immunity6327432754
- 45. Wallis TS, Galyov EE (2000) Molecular basis of Salmonella-induced enteritis. Molecular Microbiology 36: 997–1005.TS WallisEE Galyov2000Molecular basis of Salmonella-induced enteritis.Molecular Microbiology369971005
- 46. Tenor JL, McCormick BA, Ausubel FM, Aballay A (2004) Caenorhabditis elegans-based screen identifies Salmonella virulence factors required for conserved host-pathogen interactions. Current Biology 14: 1018–1024.JL TenorBA McCormickFM AusubelA. Aballay2004Caenorhabditis elegans-based screen identifies Salmonella virulence factors required for conserved host-pathogen interactions.Current Biology1410181024
- 47. Murray RA, Lee CA (2000) Invasion genes are not required for Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium to breach the intestinal epithelium: Evidence that Salmonella Pathogenicity Island 1 has alternative functions during infection. Infection and Immunity 68: 5050–5055.RA MurrayCA Lee2000Invasion genes are not required for Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium to breach the intestinal epithelium: Evidence that Salmonella Pathogenicity Island 1 has alternative functions during infection.Infection and Immunity6850505055
- 48. Coombes BK, Coburn BA, Potter AA, Gomis S, Mirakhur K, et al. (2005) Analysis of the contribution of Salmonella Pathogenicity Islands 1 and 2 to enteric disease progression using a novel bovine heal loop model and a murine model of infectious enterocolitis. Infection and Immunity 73: 7161–7169.BK CoombesBA CoburnAA PotterS. GomisK. Mirakhur2005Analysis of the contribution of Salmonella Pathogenicity Islands 1 and 2 to enteric disease progression using a novel bovine heal loop model and a murine model of infectious enterocolitis.Infection and Immunity7371617169
- 49. Hu QH, Coburn B, Deng WY, Li YL, Shi XL, et al. (2008) Salmonella enterica serovar Senftenberg human clinical isolates lacking SPI-1. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 46: 1330–1336.QH HuB. CoburnWY DengYL LiXL Shi2008Salmonella enterica serovar Senftenberg human clinical isolates lacking SPI-1.Journal of Clinical Microbiology4613301336
- 50. Desin TS, Lam PKS, Koch B, Mickael C, Berberov E, et al. (2009) Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis Pathogenicity Island 1 is not essential for but facilitates rapid systemic spread in chickens. Infection and Immunity 77: 2866–2875.TS DesinPKS LamB. KochC. MickaelE. Berberov2009Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis Pathogenicity Island 1 is not essential for but facilitates rapid systemic spread in chickens.Infection and Immunity7728662875
- 51. Jeong JH, Song M, Park SI, Cho KO, Rhee JH, et al. (2008) Salmonella enterica serovar Gallinarum requires ppGpp for internalization and survival in animal cells. Journal of Bacteriology 190: 6340–6350.JH JeongM. SongSI ParkKO ChoJH Rhee2008Salmonella enterica serovar Gallinarum requires ppGpp for internalization and survival in animal cells.Journal of Bacteriology19063406350
- 52. Martinez-Argudo I, Jepson MA (2008) Salmonella translocates across an in vitro M cell model independently of SPI-1 and SPI-2. Microbiology-SGM 154: 3887–3894.I. Martinez-ArgudoMA Jepson2008Salmonella translocates across an in vitro M cell model independently of SPI-1 and SPI-2.Microbiology-SGM15438873894
- 53. Kehrer JP, Biswal SS (2000) The molecular effects of acrolein. Toxicological Sciences 57: 6–15.JP KehrerSS Biswal2000The molecular effects of acrolein.Toxicological Sciences57615
- 54. O’Brien PJ, Siraki AG, Shangari N (2005) Aldehyde sources, metabolism, molecular toxicity mechanisms, and possible effects on human health. Critical Reviews in Toxicology 35: 609–662.PJ O’BrienAG SirakiN. Shangari2005Aldehyde sources, metabolism, molecular toxicity mechanisms, and possible effects on human health.Critical Reviews in Toxicology35609662
- 55. Weizman Z, Alsheikh A (2006) Safety and tolerance of a probiotic formula in early infancy comparing two probiotic agents: A pilot study. Journal of the American College of Nutrition 25: 415–419.Z. WeizmanA. Alsheikh2006Safety and tolerance of a probiotic formula in early infancy comparing two probiotic agents: A pilot study.Journal of the American College of Nutrition25415419
- 56. Wolf BW, Garleb KA, Ataya DG, Casas IA (1995) Safety and tolerance of Lactobacillus reuteri in healthy adult male subjects. Microbial Ecology in Health and Disease 8: 41–50.BW WolfKA GarlebDG AtayaIA Casas1995Safety and tolerance of Lactobacillus reuteri in healthy adult male subjects.Microbial Ecology in Health and Disease84150
- 57. Rosander A, Connolly E, Roos S (2008) Removal of antibiotic resistance gene-carrying plasmids from Lactobacillus reuteri ATCC 55730 and characterization of the resulting daughter strain, L. reuteri DSM 17938. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 74: 6032–6040.A. RosanderE. ConnollyS. Roos2008Removal of antibiotic resistance gene-carrying plasmids from Lactobacillus reuteri ATCC 55730 and characterization of the resulting daughter strain, L. reuteri DSM 17938.Applied and Environmental Microbiology7460326040
- 58. Wolf BW, Wheeler KB, Ataya DG, Garleb KA (1998) Safety and tolerance of Lactobacillus reuteri supplementation to a population infected with the Human Immunodeficiency Virus. Food and Chemical Toxicology 36: 1085–1094.BW WolfKB WheelerDG AtayaKA Garleb1998Safety and tolerance of Lactobacillus reuteri supplementation to a population infected with the Human Immunodeficiency Virus.Food and Chemical Toxicology3610851094
- 59. Johansson MEV, Phillipson M, Petersson J, Velcich A, Holm L, et al. (2008) The inner of the two Muc2 mucin-dependent mucus layers in colon is devoid of bacteria. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 105: 15064–15069.MEV JohanssonM. PhillipsonJ. PeterssonA. VelcichL. Holm2008The inner of the two Muc2 mucin-dependent mucus layers in colon is devoid of bacteria.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America1051506415069
- 60. Johansson MEV, Larsson JMH, Hansson GC (2011) The two mucus layers of colon are organized by the MUC2 mucin, whereas the outer layer is a legislator of host-microbial interactions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 108: 4659–4665.MEV JohanssonJMH LarssonGC Hansson2011The two mucus layers of colon are organized by the MUC2 mucin, whereas the outer layer is a legislator of host-microbial interactions.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America10846594665
- 61. Becker D, Selbach M, Rollenhagen C, Ballmaier M, Meyer TF, et al. (2006) Robust Salmonella metabolism limits possibilities for new antimicrobials. Nature 440: 303–307.D. BeckerM. SelbachC. RollenhagenM. BallmaierTF Meyer2006Robust Salmonella metabolism limits possibilities for new antimicrobials.Nature440303307
- 62. Bobik TA, Xu YP, Jeter RM, Otto KE, Roth JR (1997) Propanediol utilization genes (pdu) of Salmonella Typhimurium: Three genes for the propanediol dehydratase. Journal of Bacteriology 179: 6633–6639.TA BobikYP XuRM JeterKE OttoJR Roth1997Propanediol utilization genes (pdu) of Salmonella Typhimurium: Three genes for the propanediol dehydratase.Journal of Bacteriology17966336639
- 63. Thiennimitr P, Winter SE, Bäumler AJ (2011) Salmonella, the host and its microbiota. Current Opinion in Microbiology 15: 108–114.P. ThiennimitrSE WinterAJ Bäumler2011Salmonella, the host and its microbiota.Current Opinion in Microbiology15108114
- 64. Payne AN, Zihler A, Chassard C, Lacroix C (2012) Advances and perspectives in in vitro human gut fermentation modeling. Trends in Biotechnology 30: 17–25.AN PayneA. ZihlerC. ChassardC. Lacroix2012Advances and perspectives in in vitro human gut fermentation modeling.Trends in Biotechnology301725
- 65. Gulig PA, Curtiss R (1987) Plasmid-associated virulence of Salmonella Typhimurium Infection and Immunity 55: 2891–2901.PA GuligR. Curtiss1987Plasmid-associated virulence of Salmonella Typhimurium Infection and Immunity5528912901
- 66. Boyer HW, Roulland-Dussoix D (1969) A complementation analysis of the restriction and modification of DNA in Escherichia coli. Journal of Molecular Biology 41: 459–472.HW BoyerD. Roulland-Dussoix1969A complementation analysis of the restriction and modification of DNA in Escherichia coli.Journal of Molecular Biology41459472