Two decades ago, we developed a congenic strain of Mus musculus, called b-congenic, by replacing the androgen-binding protein Abpa27a allele in the C3H/HeJ genome with the Abpa27b allele from DBA/2J. We and other researchers used this b-congenic strain and its C3H counterpart, the a-congenic strain, to test the hypothesis that, given the choice between signals from two strains with different a27 alleles on the same genetic background, test subjects would prefer the homosubspecific one. It was our purpose in undertaking this study to characterize the segment transferred from DBA to the C3H background in producing the b-congenic strain on which a role for ABPA27 in behavior has been predicated. We determined the size of the chromosome 7 segment transferred from DBA and the genes it contains that might influence preference. We found that the “functional" DBA segment is about 1% the size of the mouse haploid genome and contains at least 29 genes expressed in salivary glands, however, only three of these encode proteins identified in the mouse salivary proteome. At least two of the three genes Abpa27, Abpbg26 and Abpbg27 encoding the subunits of androgen-binding protein ABP dimers evolved under positive selection and the third one may have also. In the sense that they are subunits of the same two functional entities, the ABP dimers, we propose that their evolutionary histories might not be independent of each other.
Citation: Laukaitis CM, Mauss C, Karn RC (2012) Congenic Strain Analysis Reveals Genes That Are Rapidly Evolving Components of a Prezygotic Isolation Mechanism Mediating Incipient Reinforcement. PLoS ONE 7(4): e35898. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0035898
Editor: Norman Johnson, University of Massachusetts, United States of America
Received: January 18, 2012; Accepted: March 23, 2012; Published: April 25, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Laukaitis et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: ML received salary support from the University of Arizona SPORE in GI Cancer (P50 CA95060). Laboratory space was supported by Cancer Center Support Grant (CA023074). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Strains of mice that differ in only one gene on an otherwise identical genetic background provide a powerful tool for investigating the function of the isolated gene. Twenty years ago, our laboratory developed a mouse strain congenic for a salivary Androgen-binding protein (Abp) gene in order to test the hypothesis that mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) is a signal for mouse mate recognition. ABP is a dimeric protein, composed of two subunits originally described as an alpha subunit, encoded by Abpa, connected by disulfide bridging to either a beta or a gamma subunit, encoded by Abpb and Abpg, respectively (these are now a large gene family with a new nomenclature described below). The dimer is capable of binding male sex steroid hormones and progesterone with a relatively high specificity and affinity (, reviewed in ). Thought at the time to be the only alpha subunit gene in the mouse genome, Abpa had been shown to have three different alleles, each fixed in one of the three subspecies of Mus musculus (Abpaa in M. m. domesticus (western Europe and the Mediterranean basin), Abpab in M. m. musculus (eastern Europe to northern China) and Abpac in M. m.castaneus (Southeast Asia and Malaysia) , ). This unusual Abpa monomorphism, resulting from a different allele having been fixed in each of three different subspecies, suggested that ABP might have a role in mediating subspecies recognition and that idea stimulated our interest in producing strains congenic for different alleles of Abpa. The existence of a relatively narrow house mouse hybrid zone between M. m. domesticus and M. m. musculus in Europe influenced us to choose the alleles from those two subspecies to produce congenic strains.
We crossed DBA/2J (the strain donating the Abpab allele) to C3H (the recipient strain; originally C3H/Strong and later C3H/HeJ) which possesses the Abpaa allele and then backcrossed the F1 to the C3H parent strain, selecting the Abpaa/Abpab heterozygote for subsequent backcrosses to C3H. Backcrossing was continued for 16 generations before an intercross was made. The resulting congenic strain was named “b-congenic" and was used in conjunction with the C3H strain (by default “a-congenic") to provide sources of signals in various types of behavioural tests. A locus such as Abpa, which has been selected for 16 generations, is expected to retain flanking heterozygosity for an average combined distance of 12 cM (i.e. 12 map units), with a standard deviation of 8 cM . In the mouse genome, a cM is ∼2 Mb of DNA, so the region transferred from DBA to the C3H background to make the b-congenic strain may be as small as 8 Mb or as large as 40 Mb.
Numerous preference tests in Y-mazes conducted in laboratories in the U.S. and Europe, using salivas of C3H and b-congenic strains as sources of signals and either inbred strains and wild-derived, mildly inbred strains  or wild-caught individuals ,  as subjects, have confirmed a consistent homosubspecific preference, evidently based on Abpa genotype. The most recent of these studies has produced evidence that ABP constitutes an incipient system of reinforcement on the verges of the European house mouse hybrid zone (; this and the foregoing studies are reviewed in ).
One important observation from early studies was that subjects do not show a preference for urine from the congenic strains , consistent with previous studies showing that ABP is not secreted into urine . Thus the segment transferred from DBA to produce the b-congenic strain apparently does not contain genes for urinary proteins that can influence mate choice. Indeed, the major urinary protein (MUP) genes, which encode the vast majority of proteins secreted into urine, are on chromosome 4 while the Abp genes are on chromosome 7. Because salivas were the sources of the signals used in these tests, we conclude that the product of the gene of interest must be secreted into saliva. This has been previously shown for the three ABP subunits: alpha, beta and gamma .
While these behavioral studies were in progress, genomic studies were underway that ultimately revealed that the Abp gene region in the mouse is comprised of 3 Mb of DNA on the proximal (with respect to the centromere) end of mouse chromosome 7 and contains 30 alpha (Abpa) paralogs, as well as 34 beta-gamma (Abpbg) paralogs for a total of 64 Abp genes , . The chosen Abpab allele, now called Abpa27b , has its nearest proximal neighbour (Abpbg27, originally Abpb) ∼7.6 kb away, while its nearest distal neighbour, Abpa30 is 76.8 kb away. And what of other genes in the Abp cluster? Even though the entire family (3 Mb) comprises 0.1% of the mouse genome, it could nonetheless easily fit into the smallest estimate for the region transferred from DBA. When one considers the larger estimate of the segment transferred (40 Mb), the possibility that other genes on the transferred chromosomal segment might have some effect on the mate choice seen in the behavioral experiments has to be considered.
This project was motivated by two goals: 1) to complement our studies with congenic strains by identifying the genes transferred onto the C3H background that might contribute to the preference seen in mouse behavioural tests; and 2) to investigate the possibility that the signal that stimulates mate choice might be complex, with ABPA27 interacting with another protein(s). We used the mouse genome and genomic sequences of individual strains to determine the size and gene content of the chromosome 7 segment donated by DBA to the b-congenic strain. We combined this information with studies of mouse salivary gland ESTs  and proteomes  to identify the genes in the transferred chromosome 7 segment that are transcribed by mouse salivary glands and translated into protein secreted into saliva. We examined the genes corresponding to the secreted salivary proteins in the transferred region and found evidence of rapid evolution and positive selection in three of them: Abpa27, Abpbg26, and Abpbg27. This alters our notion of how mouse salivary androgen-binding proteins interact to influence mouse mate preference with at least two, and perhaps three, subunits of ABP dimers comprising the salivary signal.
The size of the DBA chromosome 7 segment transferred onto the C3H background in the b-congenic line
The Perlegen Mouse Ancestry Browser (MAB) and the Mouse Phylogeny Viewer (MPV) suggest that essentially the entire 3 Mb Abp gene region spanning coordinates (cds) ∼32 to ∼35 Mb of DBA chromosome 7 came from M. m. musculus, with a small contribution from M. m. castaneus (Fig. 1A; mm9/build 37 cds are used here and for other map locations in this paper). Hereinafter Abpa and Abpbg genes will simply be “a" and “bg", respectively, each followed by a number in italics. To estimate the size of the DBA chromosome segment transferred onto the C3H background, we first sequenced the genes on the proximal and distal ends of the Abp region in the C3H, DBA and b-congenic strains, including a2, a21p, a24, bg26, bg27, a27 and a30p (see Table S1 for gene information on these and the genes that follow). All these Abp genes in the b-congenic strain have the DBA sequence (Fig. 1B).
Panel A: The center of the figure shows the genetic make-up of the chromosome 7 region of interest in the two parent strains, DBA (donor) and C3H (recipient) in terms of the Mus musculus subspecies of origin, Mus musculus domesticus (yellow in the Perlegen Mouse Ancestry Browser [MAB] and blue in the Mouse Phylogeny Viewer [MPV]); M. m. musculus (red in both) and M. m. castaneus (green in both). The various regions are shifted slightly in the two because they are based on different builds: mm7 for MAB and mm9 for MPV. The histogram of UCSC genes and the bar representing identity-by-descent (IBD) was obtained from the MPV based on the mm9 genome build. At the top of this panel are the results of typing six genes flanking the Abp gene region in the two parent strains and the b-congenic strain. The reduced data sets show only the SNP haplotypes for the two parent strains and their genotypes in the b-congenic strain. Below the MAB and the MPV representations are bars representing the maximum size of the transferred segment calculated from the derived plots of expected combined lengths and standard deviation of heterozygous chromosome segments flanking a selected locus  with the maximum size represented as an open bar and the minimum size as a green bar and both centered on the selected locus, Abpa27. The proximal end of the transferred segment extends to the left of Fkrp, into the shared region that continues nearly to the centromere. The distal end extends no farther than a crossover identified at Siglece but might have terminated somewhere in the large gap to the right of Ccne1. Panel B: The results of typing three Abp genes near the left and right ends of the 3 Mb Abp gene region. The reduced data sets show only the SNP haplotypes for the two parent strains and their genotypes in the b-congenic strain. The entire Abp gene region appears to have been transferred in the segment donated by DBA to the b-congenic strain.
Three genes on the proximal side of the Abp region, Fkrp, Plaur and Aplp1 were sequenced in the b-congenic strain and found to have DBA SNPs (Fig. 1A). The >10 Mb region from the left of Fkrp extending leftward nearly to the centromere appears to be derived from M. m. domesticus and is identical by descent (IBD) in the two strains. Thus it is not possible to determine exactly the left boundary of the transferred portion. Two genes on the distal side of the Abp region, Lrp3 and Ccne1 have the DBA SNPs in b-congenic, while the more distal gene Siglece has C3H SNPs in b-congenic. This suggests that a crossover occurred between cds ∼38.8 and ∼50.9 during backcrossing. There is a large gap between cds ∼39.5 and ∼46 Mb that begins almost immediately to the right of Ccne1 (see Table S2 for cds of gaps in this region of chromosome 7). This gap limits the possibility for making a better estimate of where the transferred chromosomal segment ended distal to the Abp region. Nonetheless, the cross-over proximal to Siglece defines the furthest possible distal reach of the chromosome segment transferred from DBA.
Regardless of its actual size, the “functional" size of the segment transferred from DBA to the b-congenic strain, i.e., the region where the two parent strains differ in the subspecies source of their segments, is ∼34 Mb. This is calculated as the distance from the first point beyond the chromosome 7 centromere (cd ∼17.3), where the two parental strains differ in their subspecies genetic contribution, to the crossover somewhere proximal to Siglece at cd ∼50.9. While it is not possible to determine the exact left terminus of the transferred segment, this is irrelevant for our study because it was derived from M. m. domesticus in both C3H and DBA and thus their genes will have the same subspecies origin in the region IBD. These considerations lead to the interesting conclusion that the segment is nearly as large as the 40 Mb maximal theoretical estimate (Fig. 1). Gene(s) encoding the signal recognized by female mouse subjects must lie in this 34 Mb region.
We used two different analyses to search for candidate genes: 1. Searching ESTs expressed in mouse salivary glands  for those encoded by genes located on the portion of chromosome 7 that might have been transferred onto the C3H background. 2. Searching recently published mouse saliva proteomes  for evidence of proteins expressed by genes in the chromosome 7 region of interest and secreted into saliva. This analysis allows us to determine which of the apparent expressions from analysis 1 actually produce proteins identified in mouse saliva.
These two analyses are complementary and allowed us to make the most thorough search possible with the data currently available. For the first analysis, we downloaded the ESTs reported from a study of gene expressions in all three major salivary glands, parotid, sublingual and submandibular, evaluated in both sexes in the BALB/c strain . We sorted the BALB/c data subsets on chromosome 7 to retain those with genes located between cd ∼17.3 Mb and 50.9 Mb where C3H and DBA differ in the subspecies origins of their genomes (Fig. 2; Table S3). Other studies have reported ESTs from only one gland and just one sex in other inbred strains, however, mouse submandibular glands show sex-limited developmental differences at puberty. Male mice elaborate granulated convoluted tubular tissue  causing submandibular gland enlargement and expression of salivary proteins not found in female salivas, including 12 members of the mouse-specific subfamily b kallikreins .
For reference, the subspecies origin of both parent strains as determined from the Mouse Phylogeny Viewer (MPV) is shown on the top bars (Mus musculus domesticus in blue; M. m. musculus in red and M. m. castaneus in green) with the density of SNPs above them. The UCSC gene histogram and bar representing identity-by-descent (IBD) is shown below the bars and the salivary gland ESTs from two different studies are arrayed in the bottom two tiers of the figure. The salivary gland EST data of  was sorted to obtain only the ESTs encoded on the chromosome 7 region of interest. Abp cDNAs amplified by PCR using paralog-specific primers  are arrayed at the bottom of the figure.
There were 26 genes within the segment described above (Fig. 2). Ten of these (38%) were expressed in all three salivary glands of the mouse, while seven (27%) were restricted to expression in the parotid, one to the sublingual (4%) and none were found only in the submandibular. These 26 genes were examined to determine which ones encode proteins with strictly intracellular (e.g. ribosomal proteins) and/or membrane-bound (e.g. Rab acceptor 1) localization, and which ones encode exocrine proteins potentially secreted into saliva (File S1). The sequences of some coding regions which might produce secreted proteins were compared between C3H and DBA in the Sanger Mouse Genomes Project data (File S2). Genes were eliminated if they had either no nonysynonymous substitutions or only one or two that made conservative amino acid substitutions (File S1).
Data from male and female mouse saliva proteomes  were compared with EST data to determine which genes in this region of chromosome 7 were candidates for the signal influencing female choice in preference tests (Fig. 2; Table S4). Reducing identification stringency  increased the number of salivary protein identifications from 81 to 730. In spite of that, we did not find evidence that any of the 26 ESTs gleaned from our analysis correspond to proteins identified in the mouse saliva proteomes. For most of the ESTs, this result is not surprising because they have been identified as intracellular and/or membrane-bound in their localizations and do not have characteristics of exocrine proteins (File S1). By contrast, the bg26, bg27 and a27 Abp paralogs that had salivary gland cDNAs identified by  were some of the most highly represented proteins in the Scaffold array under the most stringent criteria . The only other genes encoded on chromosome 7 expressed in the mouse saliva proteome were the genes for nucleobindin and the salivary kallikreins (Klk1 and Klk1b5 in both sexes, and 12 other Klk1b family genes in males only). All these genes map distally to Siglece and thus outside the region transferred from DBA to the b-congenic strain.
Evolution of candidate signal genes
The three closely linked Abp genes, a27, bg27 and bg26 map in the chromosome segment transferred from DBA and encode proteins found in saliva. C3H and DBA cDNA and protein sequences of these genes were published previously , . bg26 has the most nonsynonymous substitutions (40 causing 32 amino acid substitutions; ), a27 has five, causing four amino acid substitutions  and bg27 has the least (three, each causing an amino acid substitution; ). We obtained the sequences of the a27, bg27 and bg26 genes in five taxa (File S3), including the three subspecies of Mus musculus, as well as Mus spicilegus and Mus spretus and constructed gene phylogenies. The bg27 gene phylogeny was congruent with the species tree but the gene phylogenies for a27 and bg26 were not (Fig. 3; File S4).
Taxa used in this study include the three subspecies of Mus musculus (M. m. domesticus, M. m. musculus and M. m. castaneus), M. spicilegus and M. spretus. The species tree is modified from  with the three subspecies of Mus musculus represented as an unresolved polytomy. The gene trees for Abpa27, Abpbg26 and Abpbg27 were made by aligning the sequences of each of the five taxa in Clustal X and using the alignments to make neighbor-joining trees in PAUP* (see methods for details). Each of the four trees was rooted on the M. spretus sequence. Only the gene tree for Abpbg27 is congruent with the species tree. The gene trees for Abpa27 and Abpbg26 both show the M. m. domesticus sequence out of place relative to those of the other taxa.
The phylogeny of  was used for the rodent species guide tree for the CODEML tests and the three subspecies of M. musculus were treated as an unresolved polytomy (Fig. 3; , ). Two of the three genes, a27 and bg26 showed significant signs of positive selection within these five murid rodents when the species phylogeny was used as the CODEML guide tree (Table 1). On the other hand, gene phylogenies for a27 and bg26 suggest that the evolution of these two genes may not be accurately represented by the species tree, but are better supported by an alternate tree (Fig. 3, File S1). While this had been observed previously for a27 , , this is the first report of gene and species trees for the two bg subunits. Differences in gene and species trees may be explained by phenomena including one or more introgression events, incomplete lineage sorting, and/or homoplasies (recurrent mutations). Such introgression or homoplastic mutations might even have been fixed due to positive selection, and the gene trees for a27 and bg26 are curiously similar insofar as it is the M. m. domesticus branch that is out of place in both. While some investigators feel that the evolutionary relationships among the three full Palearctic species of Mus may be tenuous (e.g. –), PAML's author has suggested that the gene tree should be used when it differs substantially from the species tree (http://www.ucl.ac.uk/discussions/viewtopic.php?t = 7850). Thus the gene tree was the appropriate choice regardless of the status of the species tree.
When a27 and bg26 were analyzed with CODEML using their gene phylogenies as the guide trees, we again obtained significant signs of positive selection within these five murid rodents (a27 P = 0.01 with an estimated 14.6% of codons showing a dN/dS ratio of 11.9; bg26 P = 0.007 with an estimated 4.6% of codons showing a dN/dS ratio of 12; Table 1). It seems likely that the proteins encoded by both a27 and bg26 evolved under positive selection but, by contrast, the gene tree for bg27 was congruent with the species tree (Fig. 3) and the CODEML result was non-significant (P = 0.14 with an estimated 37% of codons showing a dN/dS ratio of 6.1).
Because of the evidence for positive selection on ABPA27 and ABPBG26, we predicted positively selected amino acid sites using a Bayes empirical Bayes (BEB) method (; Table 1). While selected sites identified by analysis of paralogs as a group have been reported , this is the first time that Abp orthologs from various taxa have been analyzed to identify specific sites under selection in each. Four amino acid sites in ABPA27 were identified as positively selected at a BEB posterior probability threshold of 90%, regardless of which tree was used. In the case of ABPBG26, however, eleven sites were identified as positively selected at a BEB posterior probability threshold of 90% when the species tree was used as the guide tree but only two when the gene tree was used. Thus, the gene tree produced a more conservative result. In spite of the non-significant CODEML result for ABPBG27, three amino acid sites were identified as positively selected at a BEB posterior probability threshold of 95%. Whether or not to report positively selected amino acid sites obtained with the BEB method when the CODEML result is non-significant is controversial (W. Swanson, personal communication). While the outcome (M8 - M8a) was not statistically significant, the current test is underpowered . However, the BEB sites indicated with a high posterior probability of being under positive selection are still of interest and represent interesting targets for future functional analysis and so we report both results here with that caveat.
It is possible that adding taxa to the CODEML analysis would have tipped the scales from nonsignificant to significant for the bg27 gene. We attempted to amplify segments from Mus caroli (an Asian species; the others are Palearctic species) genomic DNA using the bg26 and bg27 primer sets, and sequenced a candidate from the bg26 amplification. Attempts to verify orthology of the bg26 candidate using BLAT suggested that it was more closely related to bg27. While that seemed to qualify this as a sixth sequence for the purpose of re-running the bg27 CODEML analysis, the M. caroli sequence is radically different from any of the original five. More problematic is the observation in M. caroli of two, closely related a27 paralogs in the clade containing a26p, a27 and a30p . Thus the orthology of the four genes in the <bg26-a26p> and <bg27-a27> modules in M. caroli with their counterparts in the other species and subspecies of Mus is obscured by the possibility that their evolutionary history is different in the M. caroli genome than in those of Palearctic species used in this study.
Using the Phyre2 threading program, we predicted three-dimensional structures for the ABPA27, ABPBG26 and ABPBG27 monomers, as well as the A27-BG26 and A27-BG27 dimers they form (Table 2). We plotted the sites selected at a BEB posterior probability threshold of 90% on all three models with Pymol (Fig. 4), using the sites from the more conservative gene tree analyses for a27 and bg26, and the species tree analysis for bg27 (Table 1). All the selected sites in the three monomers fall on their exteriors. The solid-filled models of the two dimers show that all six selected sites fall on one face of the A27-BG26 dimer, while six of the seven selected sites fall on the same face of the A27-BG27 dimer.
Panels A–E are cartoon-format models with spiral ribbons representing alpha helices and thinner connecting lines representing loops. Gene trees were used for the CODEML analyses of the coding regions of bg26 and a27, the species tree for bg27. Panels F and G are illustration of the dimers composed of the two subunits with amino acid residues as filled spheres. Panels A–C show inside views of the three ABP subunits: ABPA27 (white), ABPBG26 (tan) and ABPBG27 (light green), respectively. The conserved residues that line the ligand-binding pocket are represented in purple for the ABPA27 model and blue for the ABPBG26 and ABPBG27 models, with the conserved Phe that coordinates the orientation of the monomers shown in green with stick side chain. The Cys residues that form disulfide bridges uniting the monomers in antiparallel orientation are shown in yellow with stick side chains. The residue in bright blue is selected with a BEB posterior probability of 99%; those in red with BEB posterior probabilities of 95%; and the one in orange with a BEB posterior probability of 90%. Panel D: the ABPA27-ABPBG26 dimer in cartoon format. Panel E: the ABPA27-ABPBG27 dimer in cartoon format. Panel F: a solid model of the ABPA27-ABPBG26 dimer showing all six selected residues on one face. Panel G: a solid model of the ABPA27-ABPBG27 dimer showing six of the seven selected residues on one face (one of the ABPBG27 selected residues is out of sight on the left side).
The b-congenic strain and its counterpart, the C3H parent strain (a-congenic) served as the foundation of a number of studies aimed at testing the hypothesis that, given the choice between signals from two strains with different a27 alleles on the same genetic background, test subject mice would show a preference for the homosubspecific one . The most commonly used study design involved two-way choice testing in a Y-maze and has confirmed the original hypothesis in laboratory mice  and wild mice . Most recently provided evidence that ABP forms the basis of incipient reinforcement on the hybrid zone where two subspecies of M. musculus made secondary contact .
Why analyze a congenic strain?
We undertook the project reported here to determine the physical and genetic nature of the chromosome 7 segment transferred from DBA onto the C3H genome to produce the b-congenic strain. We employed the information in the mouse genome , an EST database  and mouse saliva proteomes  We wished to learn whether the results of the many behavioral tests that relied on the b-congenic strain were the direct affect of the a27b allele, as originally intended. The alternative hypothesis is that they are attributable to the affect of another, closely linked gene that is also expressed in saliva and that differs significantly in the two parental strains. Another possibility that must be considered is that one or more Abp genes (a27 and/or another Abp gene) is responsible for the preference test results but those results were also influenced by the expression of an additional, non-Abp gene that also encodes a protein secreted into saliva and that differed significantly in the parental strains.
At the time that we began breeding the b-congenic strain, only three Abp genes had been predicted from biochemical and genetic studies . This affected the initial behavioral studies that used the b-congenic strain in the mid-1990s because the assumption behind the experimental design  was that the gene, then called Abpa, that encoded the alpha subunit of ABP was the only one encoding that subunit common to two dimeric forms found in mouse salivas: alpha-beta and alpha-gamma (beta encoded by Abpb and gamma by Abpg; ). The original three-gene hypothesis was eventually confirmed , however, as that study was in progress in 2002, the draft mouse genome sequence was being completed  and it became apparent that there were many more Abp genes than just those three. A collaboration between the laboratories of Karn in the U.S. and Ponting in the U.K. produced a number of papers (e.g., , ) culminating in the description of 64 Abp paralogs covering a span of 3 Mb in the completed Abp region on chromosome 7 . Although this region encompasses ∼0.1% of the mouse genome, it is still small enough to have been included in the lower estimate (24 Mb) of the region transferred from DBA onto the C3H genome in producing the b-congenic strain. Thus it is possible that one or more of the other Abp genes lying close to the selected gene, a27, contribute to the preference of subjects in the Y-maze tests. This increased the complexity of the question regarding just what genes are congenic in the b-congenic strain we produced.
The size and gene content of the segment contributed by DBA to the b-congenic line
In spite of a large region of M. m. domesticus contribution to both strains' chromosome 7 and a number of gaps, we were able to narrow down the “functional" size of the segment to ∼34 Mb. This is not appreciably smaller than the upper value of 40 Mb estimated from the exact derivation of . The mm9 cds of our estimate extend from ∼17.3 Mb to ∼50.9 Mb, delineated by the common region in the parental strains proximal to 17.3 Mb and by the region on the right, distal to the large gap (cds ∼39 to ∼46 Mb) where there is a crossover in the Siglece gene. This determination of the size of the segment is important because it delimits its gene content. For example, it excludes the vomeronasal receptor genes proximal to cds 17.3 Mb and the kallikrein genes distal to cds 50.9 Mb. More importantly, it allows us to look for genes included within its span that are transcribed in one or more of the three salivary glands and secreted into saliva. This region of chromosome 7 contains many genes, most of which are not transcribed in any of the three salivary glands. We searched the results of a study that identified salivary gland ESTs  and found 26 that map to the segment transferred from DBA chromosome 7. The one characteristic that all of the 26 proteins in this group shared was that we could find no evidence in the data from a recent mouse proteome for any of their peptides in either male or female mouse saliva, even when the criteria in the Scaffold software analysis were relaxed substantially . This is not entirely unexpected given that the segment in question is little more than ∼1% of the mouse genome. Moreover, we could expect that many of the ESTs in the three salivary glands will represent the expression of genes encoding proteins such as those required for cell function and those produced by other types of cells that do not secrete exocrine proteins.
One protein, Abph (aka Abpa2) was listed as showing a medium level of expression in microarray analysis of the sublingual and submandibular glands, however, there was no evidence of a transcript for this Abp gene in: 1) extensive testing of parotid gland, sublingual gland and submaxillary gland , 2) cDNA libraries from C3H and DBA strains , 3) saliva from androgen-binding and immunostaining studies , or 4) a recent saliva proteomics analysis . We conclude that the Abph (Abpa2) expression in sublingual and submandibular glands  was probably a misidentification caused by the binding of transcripts from other, highly expressed Abp genes (see below) to the probes produced from the Abph transcript for the study. Of the 64 Abp paralogs in the mouse genome there is only evidence that three of them, bg26, bg27 and a27, are transcribed in the three salivary glands  and their gene products are ecreted into saliva in significant amounts , . There is no evidence for the expression of any of the 61 other Abp paralogs.
The genes encoding the preference signal and their evolutionary characteristics
It appears, in light of the proteome data , that a27, bg26 and bg27 are the only genes identified on the segment of chromosome 7 transferred to the b-congenic strain that could have influenced the results of the Y-maze preference tests –. While this study makes it unlikely that other genes may have been involved, we cannot absolutely rule that out. Each of these three genes has a substantial number of nonsynonymous substitutions in its coding region. We investigated the evolutionary history of both of these Abpbg genes by comparing their gene phylogenies and by using the CODEML program to look for the footprints of adaptive evolution.
Our CODEML analysis supports the notion that both subunits, A27 and BG26, have a history of adaptive evolution driven by positive selection on a few sites at the surface of one face of the dimer they form. We suggest that these two genes evolved rapidly as subunits that form one of the dimers secreted in relatively large quantity into the salivas of mice and that their evolutionary histories may not be independent. This is not unexpected given that at least A27 appears to be involved in incipient reinforcement on the hybrid zone where M. m. domesticus and M. m. musculus made secondary contact  but it must do so in conjunction with at least one BG monomer because all ABP subunits described to date are paired in an alpha-beta/gamma dimer.
Four amino acid sites of A27 apparently evolved under positive selection as have at least two of BG26. Whether the rapid evolution of A27 and BG26 has been shared by the BG27 subunit is less clear. The CODEML result for bg27 was non-significant, however, there were three sites in the sequence of BG27 identified as positively selected at a BEB posterior probability threshold of >95%. As noted above, whether to accept such sites as selected, given the non-significant CODEML result, is controversial but it is nonetheless interesting that two of the three sites are at the surface of one face of the dimer formed with the A27 subunit resulting in a model that looks very similar to that of the A27-BG26 dimer (Fig. 4).
The CODEML results for a27, bg26, and bg27 suggest that at least A27 and BG26 may have coevolved. These are the subunits of the same functional entity, the A27-BG26 dimer found in mouse saliva. BG27 may have also coevolved with A27 because these two subunits form a dimer found in mouse saliva at a level nearly equal-molar with the A27-BG26 dimer . Both of the residues under selection in BG26, and two of the three residues under selection in BG27, share the same exterior face of the dimer with the four residues under selection in A27. This location of all but one of these selected residues suggests that these ABP dimers interact with another molecule(s). It is interesting to compare the results we report here with those of  who showed that the two different dimers, A27-BG26 and A27-BG27 bind dihydrotestosterone (DHT) and testosterone (T), respectively, with different affinities. Although it is not clear how amino acid variation at sites on an exterior face of the molecule might make this possible, it is likely that the different binding affinities result from a synergistic affect caused by the interaction of A27 with the BG monomer in each of the two dimers. One possibility is that conformation of the binding pocket depends on which BG subunit is involved, since this pocket is created by the formation of the dimer . Indeed BG26 and BG27 differ at more amino acid sites than the ones shown here to be evolving under positive selection . Thus, while coevolution of A27 with one or both BG26 and BG27 can affect a surface interaction with another molecule, changes at other amino acid sites independently, or in conjunction with the positively selected site, can affect ligand binding.
We produced the b-congenic strain to test the hypothesis that, given the choice between signals from two strains with different a27 alleles on the same genetic background, the test subject mice would show a preference for the homosubspecific one . At the time that project was undertaken, it was clear that whatever affect A27 has on behavior, it does so as a subunit of a dimer with either BG26 or BG27, since no free monomers have been observed in mouse salivas . Thus it is not surprising that these genes, closely linked to a27 and sharing its evolutionary history , should both also have a role in mediating mate preference behavior. It seems evident that we can conclude this about the A27-BG26 dimer at the very least and perhaps about the A27-BG27 dimer as well.
Our analysis of the segment transferred from DBA in the process of breeding the b-congenic strain reinforces and extends the role of ABP in the many studies done with saliva from the congenic strains. The most exciting finding, however, is that the gene used for selection in the congenic breeding, Abpa27, encodes only one component of the salivary proteins that influence assortative mate choice. We have presented evidence here that at least one, and perhaps both of the genes, Abpbg26 and Abpbg27, encoding the other members of the two salivary ABP dimers shows the characteristics of adaptive evolution. We suggest that the two different ABP dimers in saliva exist to modulate the stimulus, especially if their different affinities for the steroid ligands T and DHT also influence mate choice.
Materials and Methods
All animal manipulation was performed humanely and under appropriate Animal Welfare Guidelines under University of Arizona IACUC protocol 08-138. Methods are summarized here; details appear in File S5.
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was run as previously described  using genomic DNAs either purchased (Jackson Laboratory) or purified from tail tips and the products sequenced either by the UAGC facility at the University of Arizona or by MCLAB (http://www.mclab.com/). DNA sequence traces were edited with Chromas 2.3 (http://www.technelysium.com.au). DNA sequence alignment, coding region assembly, and in silico translation were done using the DNAsis Max program 2.0 (Hitachi).
Salivary gland protein expression data sets were obtained by searching “mouse salivary gland" on the NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus website (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/). Data was downloaded and cross-referenced with Amersham Codelink UniSet Mouse 1 Bioarray, and protein information for each probe target was gathered by searching probe accession numbers on MGI (http://www.informatics.jax.org/), the international database resource for the laboratory mouse. The data in the region of interest was also sorted on the sample signal intensity from the array, which ranged from 0 to 250–400 in the six data sets, and only those with values of 10 or above were retained for this study.
Positive selection was assessed in the program CODEML in the PAML package –. The three-dimensional structures of mouse a27, bg26 and bg27 were modeled using the PHYRE2 (version 2.0) threading program (http://www.sbg.bio.ic.ac.uk/phyre2/html/page.cgi?id=index; ), and the resulting models were visualized using PYMOL (open-source 1.2.8; http://www.pymol.org/). Sites under positive selection were mapped onto the structural models using PYMOL and incorporated into a figure.
Sequence gaps (regions with low/no SNP density in the Mouse Diversity array and lacking UCSC genes).
ESTs found in one or more of three glands of the two sexes of BALB/c mice  .
Chromosome 7 encoded proteins found in mouse saliva proteomes  .
Retained and eliminated proteins (represented by ESTs and cDNAs).
Protein sequences from Sanger Data and from sequencing.
Sequences of Abp coding regions used in CODEML analysis.
Unrooted trees for Abpa27, Abpbg26 and Abpbg27. Trees were made as in Fig. 3 but were not rooted. Rather, the suggested root is shown by a black dot on the branch to the Mus spretus ortholog.
The authors wish to thank Willie Swanson and Gary Churchill for helpful discussions.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CML RCK. Performed the experiments: CM RCK. Analyzed the data: CML CM RCK. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: RCK. Wrote the paper: CML CM RCK.
- 1. Karn RC (1998) Steroid binding by mouse salivary proteins. Biochem Genet 36: 105–117.RC Karn1998Steroid binding by mouse salivary proteins.Biochem Genet36105117
- 2. Laukaitis C, Karn RC (2012) Recognition of subspecies status mediated by androgen-binding protein (ABP) in the evolution of incipient reinforcement on the European house mouse hybrid zone. In: Macholan M, Munclinger P, Baird SJ, Pialek J, editors. Evolution of the House Mouse. C. LaukaitisRC Karn2012Recognition of subspecies status mediated by androgen-binding protein (ABP) in the evolution of incipient reinforcement on the European house mouse hybrid zone.M. MacholanP. MunclingerSJ BairdJ. PialekEvolution of the House Mousepp. In Press. pp. In Press.
- 3. Karn RC, Dlouhy SR (1991) Salivary androgen-binding protein variation in Mus and other rodents. J Hered 82: 453–458.RC KarnSR Dlouhy1991Salivary androgen-binding protein variation in Mus and other rodents.J Hered82453458
- 4. Karn RC, Orth A, Bonhomme F, Boursot P (2002) The complex history of a gene proposed to participate in a sexual isolation mechanism in house mice. Mol Biol Evol 19: 462–471.RC KarnA. OrthF. BonhommeP. Boursot2002The complex history of a gene proposed to participate in a sexual isolation mechanism in house mice.Mol Biol Evol19462471
- 5. Naveira H, Barbadilla A (1992) The theoretical distribution of lengths of intact chromosome segments around a locus held heterozygous with backcrossing in a diploid species. Genetics 130: 205–209.H. NaveiraA. Barbadilla1992The theoretical distribution of lengths of intact chromosome segments around a locus held heterozygous with backcrossing in a diploid species.Genetics130205209
- 6. Talley HM, Laukaitis CM, Karn RC (2001) Female preference for male saliva: implications for sexual isolation of Mus musculus subspecies. Evolution 55: 631–634.HM TalleyCM LaukaitisRC Karn2001Female preference for male saliva: implications for sexual isolation of Mus musculus subspecies.Evolution55631634
- 7. Bímová B, Karn RC, Pialek J (2005) The role of salivary androgen-binding protein in reproductive isolation between two subspecies of house mouse: Mus musculus musculus and Mus musculus domesticus. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 84: 349–361.B. BímováRC KarnJ. Pialek2005The role of salivary androgen-binding protein in reproductive isolation between two subspecies of house mouse: Mus musculus musculus and Mus musculus domesticus.Biological Journal of the Linnean Society84349361
- 8. Vošlajerová Bímová B, Macholán M, Baird SEB, Munclinger P, Laukaitis CM, et al. (2011) Reinforcement selection acting on the European house mouse hybrid zone. Mol Ecol 20: 2403–2424.B. Vošlajerová BímováM. MacholánSEB BairdP. MunclingerCM Laukaitis2011Reinforcement selection acting on the European house mouse hybrid zone.Mol Ecol2024032424
- 9. Dlouhy SR, Nichols WC, Karn RC (1986) Production of an antibody to mouse salivary androgen binding protein (ABP) and its use in identifying a prostate protein produced by a gene distinct from Abp. Biochem Genet 24: 743–763.SR DlouhyWC NicholsRC Karn1986Production of an antibody to mouse salivary androgen binding protein (ABP) and its use in identifying a prostate protein produced by a gene distinct from Abp.Biochem Genet24743763
- 10. Dlouhy SR, Taylor BA, Karn RC (1987) The genes for mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) subunits alpha and gamma are located on chromosome 7. Genetics 115: 535–543.SR DlouhyBA TaylorRC Karn1987The genes for mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) subunits alpha and gamma are located on chromosome 7.Genetics115535543
- 11. Laukaitis CM, Heger A, Blakley TD, Munclinger P, Ponting CP, et al. (2008) Rapid bursts of androgen-binding protein (Abp) gene duplication occurred independently in diverse mammals. BMC Evol Biol 8: 46.CM LaukaitisA. HegerTD BlakleyP. MunclingerCP Ponting2008Rapid bursts of androgen-binding protein (Abp) gene duplication occurred independently in diverse mammals.BMC Evol Biol846
- 12. Treister NS, Richards SM, Lombardi MJ, Rowley P, Jensen RV, et al. (2005) Sex-related differences in gene expression in salivary glands of BALB/c mice. Journal of Dental Research 84: 160–165.NS TreisterSM RichardsMJ LombardiP. RowleyRV Jensen2005Sex-related differences in gene expression in salivary glands of BALB/c mice.Journal of Dental Research84160165
- 13. Karn RC, Laukaitis CM (2011) Positive selection shaped the convergent evolution of independently expanded kallikrein subfamilies expressed in mouse and rat saliva proteomes. PLoS ONE 6: e20979.RC KarnCM Laukaitis2011Positive selection shaped the convergent evolution of independently expanded kallikrein subfamilies expressed in mouse and rat saliva proteomes.PLoS ONE6e20979
- 14. Laukaitis CM, Dlouhy SR, Emes RD, Ponting CP, Karn RC (2005) Diverse spatial, temporal, and sexual expression of recently duplicated androgen-binding protein genes in Mus musculus. BMC Evol Biol 5: 40.CM LaukaitisSR DlouhyRD EmesCP PontingRC Karn2005Diverse spatial, temporal, and sexual expression of recently duplicated androgen-binding protein genes in Mus musculus.BMC Evol Biol540
- 15. Hwang JM, Hofstetter JR, Bonhomme F, Karn RC (1997) The microevolution of mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) paralleled subspeciation of Mus musculus. J Hered 88: 93–97.JM HwangJR HofstetterF. BonhommeRC Karn1997The microevolution of mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) paralleled subspeciation of Mus musculus.J Hered889397
- 16. Karn RC, Laukaitis CM (2003) Characterization of two forms of mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP): implications for evolutionary relationships and ligand-binding function. Biochemistry 42: 7162–7170.RC KarnCM Laukaitis2003Characterization of two forms of mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP): implications for evolutionary relationships and ligand-binding function.Biochemistry4271627170
- 17. Chevret P, Veyrunes F, Britton-Davidian J (2005) Molecular phylogeny of the genus Mus (Rodentia:Murinae) based on mitochondrial and nuclear data. Biol J Linn Soc 84: 417–427.P. ChevretF. VeyrunesJ. Britton-Davidian2005Molecular phylogeny of the genus Mus (Rodentia:Murinae) based on mitochondrial and nuclear data.Biol J Linn Soc84417427
- 18. Karn RC, Clark NL, Nguyen ED, Swanson WJ (2008) Adaptive evolution in rodent seminal vesicle secretion proteins. Mol Biol Evol 25: 2301–2310.RC KarnNL ClarkED NguyenWJ Swanson2008Adaptive evolution in rodent seminal vesicle secretion proteins.Mol Biol Evol2523012310
- 19. Karn RC, Young JM, Laukaitis CM (2010) A candidate subspecies discrimination system involving a vomeronasal receptor gene with different alleles fixed in M. m. domesticus and M. m. musculus. PLoS ONE 5: e12638.RC KarnJM YoungCM Laukaitis2010A candidate subspecies discrimination system involving a vomeronasal receptor gene with different alleles fixed in M. m. domesticus and M. m. musculus.PLoS ONE5e12638
- 20. She JX, Bonhomme F, Boursot P, Thaler L, Catzeflis F (1990) Molecular Phylogenies in the Genus Mus - Comparative-Analysis of Electrophoretic, Scndna Hybridization, and Mtdna Rflp Data. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 41: 83–103.JX SheF. BonhommeP. BoursotL. ThalerF. Catzeflis1990Molecular Phylogenies in the Genus Mus - Comparative-Analysis of Electrophoretic, Scndna Hybridization, and Mtdna Rflp Data.Biological Journal of the Linnean Society4183103
- 21. Suzuki H, Shimada T, Terashima M, Tsuchiya K, Aplin K (2004) Temporal, spatial, and ecological modes of evolution of Eurasian Mus based on mitochondrial and nuclear gene sequences. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 33: 626–646.H. SuzukiT. ShimadaM. TerashimaK. TsuchiyaK. Aplin2004Temporal, spatial, and ecological modes of evolution of Eurasian Mus based on mitochondrial and nuclear gene sequences.Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution33626646
- 22. Tucker PK, Sandstedt SA, Lundrigan BL (2005) Phylogenetic relationships in the subgenus Mus (genus Mus, family Muridae, subfamily Murinae): examining gene trees and species trees. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 84: 653–662.PK TuckerSA SandstedtBL Lundrigan2005Phylogenetic relationships in the subgenus Mus (genus Mus, family Muridae, subfamily Murinae): examining gene trees and species trees.Biological Journal of the Linnean Society84653662
- 23. Yang Z, Wong WS, Nielsen R (2005) Bayes empirical bayes inference of amino acid sites under positive selection. Mol Biol Evol 22: 1107–1118.Z. YangWS WongR. Nielsen2005Bayes empirical bayes inference of amino acid sites under positive selection.Mol Biol Evol2211071118
- 24. Emes RD, Riley MC, Laukaitis CM, Goodstadt L, Karn RC, et al. (2004) Comparative evolutionary genomics of androgen-binding protein genes. Genome Res 14: 1516–1529.RD EmesMC RileyCM LaukaitisL. GoodstadtRC Karn2004Comparative evolutionary genomics of androgen-binding protein genes.Genome Res1415161529
- 25. Anisimova M, Bielawski JP, Yang Z (2002) Accuracy and power of bayes prediction of amino acid sites under positive selection. Mol Biol Evol 19: 950–958.M. AnisimovaJP BielawskiZ. Yang2002Accuracy and power of bayes prediction of amino acid sites under positive selection.Mol Biol Evol19950958
- 26. Laukaitis CM, Critser ES, Karn RC (1997) Salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) mediates sexual isolation in Mus musculus. Evolution 51: 2000–2005.CM LaukaitisES CritserRC Karn1997Salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) mediates sexual isolation in Mus musculus.Evolution5120002005
- 27. Waterston RH, Lindblad-Toh K, Birney E, Rogers J, Abril JF, et al. (2002) Initial sequencing and comparative analysis of the mouse genome. Nature 420: 520–562.RH WaterstonK. Lindblad-TohE. BirneyJ. RogersJF Abril2002Initial sequencing and comparative analysis of the mouse genome.Nature420520562
- 28. Laukaitis CM, Dlouhy SR, Karn RC (2003) The mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) gene cluster on Chromosomes 7: characterization and evolutionary relationships. Mamm Genome 14: 679–691.CM LaukaitisSR DlouhyRC Karn2003The mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) gene cluster on Chromosomes 7: characterization and evolutionary relationships.Mamm Genome14679691
- 29. Karn RC, Clements MA (1999) A comparison of the structures of the alpha:beta and alpha:gamma dimers of mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) and their differential steroid binding. Biochem Genet 37: 187–199.RC KarnMA Clements1999A comparison of the structures of the alpha:beta and alpha:gamma dimers of mouse salivary androgen-binding protein (ABP) and their differential steroid binding.Biochem Genet37187199
- 30. Callebaut I, Poupon A, Bally R, Demaret JP, Housset D, et al. (2000) The uteroglobin fold. Ann N Y Acad Sci 923: 90–112.I. CallebautA. PouponR. BallyJP DemaretD. Housset2000The uteroglobin fold.Ann N Y Acad Sci92390112
- 31. Nielsen R, Yang Z (1998) Likelihood models for detecting positively selected amino acid sites and applications to the HIV-1 envelope gene. Genetics 148: 929–936.R. NielsenZ. Yang1998Likelihood models for detecting positively selected amino acid sites and applications to the HIV-1 envelope gene.Genetics148929936
- 32. Yang Z (1997) PAML: a program package for phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood. Comput Appl Biosci 13: 555–556.Z. Yang1997PAML: a program package for phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood.Comput Appl Biosci13555556
- 33. Yang Z, Swanson WJ, Vacquier VD (2000) Maximum-likelihood analysis of molecular adaptation in abalone sperm lysin reveals variable selective pressures among lineages and sites. Mol Biol Evol 17: 1446–1455.Z. YangWJ SwansonVD Vacquier2000Maximum-likelihood analysis of molecular adaptation in abalone sperm lysin reveals variable selective pressures among lineages and sites.Mol Biol Evol1714461455
- 34. Kelley LA, Sternberg MJ (2009) Protein structure prediction on the Web: a case study using the Phyre server. Nat Protoc 4: 363–371.LA KelleyMJ Sternberg2009Protein structure prediction on the Web: a case study using the Phyre server.Nat Protoc4363371