The main goal of the present study was to analyse the genetic architecture of mRNA expression in muscle, a tissue with an outmost economic importance for pig breeders. Previous studies have used F2 crosses to detect porcine expression QTL (eQTL), so they contributed with data that mostly represents the between-breed component of eQTL variation. Herewith, we have analysed eQTL segregation in an outbred Duroc population using two groups of animals with divergent fatness profiles. This approach is particularly suitable to analyse the within-breed component of eQTL variation, with a special emphasis on loci involved in lipid metabolism.
GeneChip Porcine Genome arrays (Affymetrix) were used to determine the mRNA expression levels of gluteus medius samples from 105 Duroc barrows. A whole-genome eQTL scan was carried out with a panel of 116 microsatellites. Results allowed us to detect 613 genome-wide significant eQTL unevenly distributed across the pig genome. A clear predominance of trans- over cis-eQTL, was observed. Moreover, 11 trans-regulatory hotspots affecting the expression levels of four to 16 genes were identified. A Gene Ontology study showed that regulatory polymorphisms affected the expression of muscle development and lipid metabolism genes. A number of positional concordances between eQTL and lipid trait QTL were also found, whereas limited evidence of a linear relationship between muscle fat deposition and mRNA levels of eQTL regulated genes was obtained.
Our data provide substantial evidence that there is a remarkable amount of within-breed genetic variation affecting muscle mRNA expression. Most of this variation acts in trans and influences biological processes related with muscle development, lipid deposition and energy balance. The identification of the underlying causal mutations and the ascertainment of their effects on phenotypes would allow gaining a fundamental perspective about how complex traits are built at the molecular level.
Citation: Cánovas A, Pena RN, Gallardo D, Ramírez O, Amills M, Quintanilla R (2012) Segregation of Regulatory Polymorphisms with Effects on the Gluteus Medius Transcriptome in a Purebred Pig Population. PLoS ONE 7(4): e35583. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0035583
Editor: Stephen Moore, University of Queensland, Australia
Received: January 3, 2012; Accepted: March 19, 2012; Published: April 24, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Cánovas et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This project has been funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science (projects GEN2003-20658-C05-05, AGL2007-66707-C02-01 and AGL2010-22208-C02-01). AC received a predoctoral scholarship from INIA (Instituto Nacional de Investigación y Tecnología Agraria y Alimentaria). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) mapping represents a valuable approach towards identifying regulatory regions and DNA sequence variants affecting the expression levels of genes. Genetical genomics studies performed in human have indicated that: (i) eQTL maps obtained in different cell types are partially concordant , , i.e. often regulatory polymorphisms exert their effects on multiple tissues, and (ii) these maps might differ amongst populations with different genetic backgrounds , , mainly because of differences in the frequency of regulatory alleles rather than in the specific set of mechanisms involved in the fine-tuning of mRNA levels . More controversy exists about the abundance of regulatory hotspots in the human genome, which have been identified in certain studies but not in others, and the relative impact of cis-eQTL vs trans-eQTL on transcriptome variation . In general, studies performed in model organisms have been more successful at identifying regulatory hotspots and trans-eQTL than those performed in human, probably because of experimental rather than biological reasons , .
So far, the few eQTL studies performed in pigs , , ,  are based on the analysis of samples obtained from crossbred individuals (e.g. Duroc x Pietrain and Large White x Landrace). This experimental design is particularly suited to capture the between-breed component of genetic variation. Although useful, eQTL maps obtained in crossbreds do not provide an accurate account of the regulatory DNA variation segregating in purebred swine populations, where intensive selection, inbreeding, founder effects and genetic drift have strongly modified genetic diversity.
In the current work, we have analysed the segregation of muscle eQTL in two groups of Duroc pigs with divergent phenotypes for fat deposition traits. Important differences in the expression of cell differentiation, energy balance and fat metabolism genes between these groups had been detected in a previous study . Our main goal was to dissect the within-breed component of eQTL variation in a purebred population with a special focus on the regulation of lipid metabolism- and fatness-related genes.
Results and Discussion
Segregation of expression Quantitative Trait Loci regulating gluteus medius mRNA levels in a commercial Duroc pig population
In the whole-genome scan carried out for 6,139 transcripts, a total of 613 genome-wide significant eQTL (P-value cut off P<0.0009) affecting the mRNA expression of 569 probes were identified (Table 1). There was an uneven distribution of these eQTL across the 18 autosomes (Figure 1), with Sus Scrofa Chromosomes (SSC) 3 and 5 harbouring the highest number of eQTL (74 and 107 respectively). In contrast, only three and seven eQTL were observed on SSC11 and SSC14, respectively. Out of the 569 total eQTL-targeted probes, 490 were successfully mapped to the pig genome (Table 1), although a small fraction (12) corresponded to non-specifically mapped probes. The high number of unmapped probes (123 probes; 20%) is due to the incomplete annotation of the porcine genome sequence currently available.
(A) Total number of eQTL and (B) cis-acting (▪) and trans-acting (▴) eQTL.
The relative position of the eQTL and the target genes was studied in order to classify them into cis-acting and trans-acting eQTL. From the 478 mapped eQTL, only 63 were catalogued as cis-acting eQTL on the basis of their close physical distance to the target gene, whereas the remaining 415 eQTL were considered to regulate gene expression in trans (Table 1). Finally, only eQTL whose target probes showed high quality binding of the probe-sets (i.e. six or more out of 11 probes specifically assembled to a unique region) were retained for further analysis (59 cis- and 396 trans-eQTL; Table 1). Whole data regarding these 455 eQTL (eQTL peaks, target gene locations, flanking markers, confidence intervals, distances from the closest marker and classification as cis-/trans- eQTL) is provided in Table S1.
Strong evidences of muscle eQTL segregation had been previously reported by Steibel et al.  in a population of 176 F2 Duroc x Pietrain and by Liaubet et al.  in 57 F2 Pietrain x composite line (Hampshire, Duroc and Large White) pigs, but no studies on the segregation of eQTL in porcine purebred population have been carried out so far. As a whole, the number and magnitude of muscle eQTL detected in the present study were comparable to those reported by Steibel et al. , who described 397 putative eQTL peaks using a first P-value cut off (P<0.0001), which is slightly more conservative than ours (P<0.0009). Similarly, Liaubet et al.  described 335 eQTL significant at a chromosome-wide empirical threshold of 1%. Given the high cut-off values applied to correct for multiple testing, the hundreds of eQTL identified in our and other studies is expected to be the tip of the iceberg (i.e. many small-effect alleles are missed because of a lack of statistical power to detect them). This is particularly meaningful in a purebred population such as the one described in the current work, where allelic frequencies could have been substantially modified by selection, inbreeding and genetic drift.
Although genetic variability of our Duroc population should be much lower than that detected in F2 crosses, it is relevant to highlight that in previous studies we detected moderate to high heritability estimates  and a wide number of QTL for several lipid metabolism and fat deposition traits , , . Probably, both the inbreeding control programme and the simultaneous selection for multiple breeding objectives diminished the impact of selection, in terms of reducing variability. Moreover, the half-sibs family design employed in the current work (five boars mated to minimally related females) allowed us minimizing inbreeding in the analysed population (F = 0.006; computed from a pedigree of 1630 ancestors). These circumstances have facilitated the identification of a remarkable level of regulatory allelic variation at the within-breed level, even comparable with that detected in F2 divergent crosses , . The current findings imply that selecting beneficial gene expression profiles, in terms of carcass or meat quality, would be feasible from a theoretical point of view.
A majority of trans-acting eQTL modulate gene expression in the gluteus medius muscle of Duroc pigs
We have detected a much higher percentage of trans-acting than cis-acting eQTL (396 vs 59 respectively) in the pig muscle. Following Ponsuksili et al. , we considered eQTL as cis-acting when both the eQTL peak and the target gene fell within the interval delimited by the two flanking markers of the eQTL (Table S1). It is worth noting that our map resulted in relatively large confidence intervals for eQTL positions (average 31.40 cM), while the average distance from the closest marker was 7.39 cM. These relatively large confidence intervals lead to classify as cis-acting most eQTL that happen to be located in the same chromosome that the corresponding target gene. Thus, it must be taken into account that some trans-eQTL could have been misclassified as cis-eQTL.
The relative importance of cis-eQTL vs trans-eQTL is still under debate, with the former predominating in certain studies ,  and the latter in other ones , , . Since basic regulatory mechanisms amongst mammals are not expected to differ substantially, either technical or experimental factors might probably be the main source of these discrepancies. There are several reasons by which cis-eQTL should be more frequently identified in whole-genome scans than trans-eQTL. First of all, and according to Cheung et al. , trans-eQTL might have smaller effects on individual genes than cis-eQTL (i.e. genes are regulated by many trans-acting factors but by a few cis-acting factors), so they would be more difficult to detect. Moreover, multiple-testing thresholds are stricter for trans-eQTL than for cis-eQTL . In the line of these arguments, Steibel et al.  highlighted that local (cis-acting) eQTL were in general much more significant (smaller P-values) than trans-acting eQTL. In summary, given the conservative thresholds applied to correct for multiple testing and the smaller effects expected for the trans-eQTL, a high number of trans-regulatory polymorphisms might be undetected in studies burdened by low sample size and/or less powerful designs. However, and in strong contrast with this theoretical expectation, our study and others , ,  have highlighted a higher abundance of trans- vs cis-eQTL. Importantly, this predominance of trans-eQTL decreases substantially when more stringent P-value cutoffs are employed to assess the significance of the data. For instance, when Steibel et al.  applied a multiple-testing correction with a P-value of 3.5×10−6 (corresponding to a FDR of 10%), 40 out of 62 significant eQTL had linkage peaks on the same chromosome where the regulated probe was physically located. Results obtained in the current study were also consistent with this statement: the predominance of trans- over cis-eQTL decreased dramatically as the significance threshold increased (Figure 2), although in our case trans-acting eQTL were more frequent than the cis-ones even with the most conservative P-value cut-off (P<10−6). Another plausible hypothesis that would be worth to investigate is whether a relatively lower genetic variation, as expected in our outbred population subjected to selection, could result in gene regulatory networks (trans-eQTL) standing out when compared to gene regulatory elements (cis-eQTL). In any case, the higher frequency of trans-eQTL probably reflects a biological reality since, as discussed above, experimental factors usually lead to underestimate the number of trans-eQTL. In this sense, Cheung et al.  demonstrated that when large datasets are used, trans-eQTL are also more abundant than the cis-ones in human.
The pig genome contains regulatory hotspots with effects on the muscle transcriptome
In principle, trans-eQTL are expected to affect the expression of many genes while cis-eQTL must (necessarily) have a more restricted effect. A detailed analysis of eQTL affecting the expression level of several genes led us to define 11 eQTL hotspots (Figure 3), mapping to SSC1, SSC2, SSC3, SSC5, SSC6, SSC7, SSC12 and SSC18, and regulating the expression levels of four to 16 genes (Table 2). In close resemblance with our results, Liaubet et al.  found that 50% of muscle eQTL clustered to six pig chromosomes. For instance, they detected a SSC1 region influencing the expression of 31 genes, 26 of which displayed a pattern that was consistent with co-regulation by a common genetic determinant. Also Steibel et al.  reported 16 peaks on pig genome regions trans-regulating more than four genes, despite posterior multiple-testing correction led to discard an important number of trans-eQTL and to conclude that trans-regulation hotspots are, in general, scarce.
Studies in other organisms have identified hotspots containing genetic variants that influence multiple gene expression phenotypes , . Expression QTL hotspots have also been reported in the human genome , . As pointed out by Morley et al. , mRNAs regulated by a common genetic hotspot often share similar functions and are co-expressed. For instance, we identified a trans-regulatory hotspot at SSC7 that agreed well with this principle, as it regulated genes with crucial roles on lipid metabolism (e.g.ACACA, ACLY or FABP5).
Functional annotation of genes regulated by eQTL
GO term annotations were used in order to perform a functional categorization of genes regulated by genome-wide significant eQTL (Figure 4). As a predictable consequence of our experimental design, which analysed two groups of pigs with divergent phenotypes for lipid traits, GO terms related with lipid metabolism were particularly abundant. In this context, the biological process GO category (Figure 4A) included regulation of fatty acid oxidation, fatty acid biosynthetic process, regulation of fatty acid metabolic process, regulation of lipid metabolic process, and lipid biosynthetic process among GO terms significantly enriched by our list of eQTL-regulated genes. Additionally, a variety of developmental and morphological processes related to muscle development and function (e.g. actin filament-based process, cytoskeleton organization, and muscle organ development) were also spread over the list of most significantly enriched GO terms. Other metabolic processes such as regulation of glucose metabolic process and regulation of insulin-like growth factor receptor signalling appeared in the middle of the list. Concerning the molecular function GO category (Figure 4B), carboxylic acid binding, acetyl-CoA carboxylase activity and lipid metabolism were among the most significantly enriched GO terms. The cellular component GO classification (data not shown) only indicated that most genes encoded intracellular components. Our findings partially agree with those obtained by Liaubet et al. , where most eQTL were engaged in functions related to muscle development and physiology, cell metabolism, cellular movement, cell-to-cell signalling and interaction and protein synthesis and posttranslational modification. Steibel et al.  also found that lipid metabolism, cell cycle, apoptosis and DNA replication, recombination and repair networks were particularly enriched in eQTL-regulated genes.
(A) List of most significant GO terms represented in the biological process category (P<0.01). (B) List of most significant GO terms represented in the molecular function category (P<0.01).
Within the general goal of investigating the segregation of muscle eQTL at the within-breed level, we were particularly interested on the genetic regulation of lipid metabolism and fatness traits. On the basis of results previously presented, eQTL-regulated genes potentially associated with muscle fat deposition and meat quality traits were further investigated. First of all, we performed a more refined analysis of the genes enriching the five lipid metabolism-related GO terms (Tables 3 and 4). These included eight cis- (ABAT, ACER3, ANXA8L1, APOBEC1, EHD1, FIG4, PAFAH1B3 and SNX14) and 16 trans-regulated (ACLY, ACACA, ACOT6, ARNTL, CAST, CS, CYP24A1, EHD1, FABP5, HRC, IGFBP5, IGF1, LRP6, PRKAA1, PRKAA and RRMB2) loci. In general, cis-regulated genes were involved in either (i) modulation of intracellular levels of bioactive lipids that function as second messengers to cell and differentiation events, or (ii) lipid transport by lipoproteins. The list of 16 trans-regulated loci included well-studied genes related with fat deposition (e.g. ACACA, FABP5, IGF1, ACLY and CS) and meat tenderisation (CAST).
As a complementary approach, we performed a pathway analysis of the eQTL regulated genes. In clear consistency with the GO analysis, pathways involved in lipid metabolism and/or adipose/muscle tissue differentiation were amongst the most significant ones (Table 5). These included the hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and the adipocytokine signalling pathway on the top of the list. The insulin signalling pathway, associated with energy balance, was enriched by genes related to insulin resistance (e.g. IRS1) as well as by several genes involved in lipogenesis and cholesterogenesis (e.g. ACACA, PRKAA1 and PRKAA2). Besides, the PPAR signalling pathway appeared in the middle of the list, gathering several genes with roles in lipid biosynthesis and fatty acid uptake, transport, and metabolism (e.g. ACSL1, ACSL5 and FABP5). Finally, the TGF-beta signalling pathway, which regulates the switch of myocyte/adipocyte differentiation, was also present in this list.
Taken as a whole, these findings suggest that genetic factors modulating muscle lipid metabolism exert their effects at multiple levels including lipid biosynthesis, absorption, transport and degradation. However, the specific polymorphisms involved in the genetic control of these processes may vary from population to population. In their experiment, closely paralleling ours, Steibel et al.  reported loin muscle eQTL in a divergent cross population that were mainly regulating three gene networks associated with lipid metabolism, DNA replication, and cell cycle regulation. The high consistency between these two experiments suggests that, in spite of the fact that gene pools are different, the regulatory mechanisms that modify the porcine skeletal muscle transcriptome are very similar across pig breeds.
Finally, it is worth mentioning that 306 (41 cis- and 267 trans-eQTL) out of 455 eQTL-regulated loci matched to genes that happened to be differentially expressed between pigs displaying divergent fatness profiles . Amongst these genes, we identified loci related with fat deposition (e.g. ACACA, ACSL1, ACSL5, ACLY, FABP5, CEBPD, IGFBP5 and SCD) that showed at least one trans-regulatory polymorphism. This result suggests that the divergent fatness phenotypes characterized in our purebred Duroc population by Canovas et al.  might have, in part, a genetic origin i.e. they might be due to the differential segregation (in the High and Low groups) of regulatory polymorphisms with effects on lipid metabolism-related genes. Further research dealing with differential allelic segregation analyses at a whole-genome level would shed light on this topic.
Positional concordance between eQTL and QTL for lipid metabolism and fat deposition traits
Combining eQTL and QTL linkage maps represents an interesting approach to identifying polymorphisms regulating phenotypic variation through changes in gene expression. We have carried out a positional concordance study between 455 eQTL (with a high quality mapped target probes) and a dataset of QTL for IMF, muscle cholesterol content and fatty acid profile segregating in the same Duroc population  (Tables 3 and 4). In this way, we identified 80 positional concordances, which corresponded to 14 cis-acting and 66 trans-acting eQTL. We were particularly interested in those eQTL-QTL pairs involving genes functionally related with lipid metabolism and meat quality. In this regard, as much as five IMF QTL showed positional concordance with eQTL regulating lipid metabolism- and adipose function-related genes. It is particularly remarkable the co-localisation of a highly significant IMF QTL at SSC7 and a trans-acting regulatory hotspot influencing, among others, the expression levels of ACACA, ACLY and FABP5 mRNA. These three genes have a well-known role in fat metabolism and showed a differential mRNA expression pattern in pigs with divergent phenotypes for fatness traits . All these evidences point out this SSC7 region (Figure 3) as a major genetic factor modifying lipid traits, as previously demonstrated in several QTL studies , , , . Similarly, we have identified a SSC3 region harbouring a highly significant IMF QTL , ,  and an eQTL hotspot (Figure 3). This trans-regulatory hotspot is associated with at least seven genes (Table S1) including RRM2B, which plays a relevant role in the processes of fatty acid β-oxidation and lipid synthesis  (Table 4).
QTL affecting muscle fatty acid composition (such as vaccenic, myristic and palmitic fatty acids percentage) at SSC3, SSC6, SSC8, SSC14 and SSC18 also co-localised with several cis-and trans-acting eQTL (Table 3 and 4). Amongst the genes regulated by these eQTL it is worth mentioning LRP6, which encodes a co-receptor for Wnt factors and LDL lipoproteins. This molecule is involved in lipid uptake by adipocytes through regulation of early adipogenesis events  and receptor-mediated endocytosis of LDL lipoproteins . Besides, it is worth to mention a QTL for muscle cholesterol content at SSC11 that co-localised with an eQTL affecting the expression of ARNTL (Table 4). ARNTL is a clock gene involved in the circadian rhythm of cholesterol (and other lipids) accumulation, having been linked to susceptibility to the metabolic syndrome in humans .
The existence of eQTL-QTL positional concordance may be interpreted as evidence that a number of regulatory polymorphism, and more particularly those located at eQTL-hotspot regions on SSC3 and SSC7, display relevant associations with phenotypes of economic interest (i.e. IMF content and composition traits), probably through the regulation of a number of genes related with lipid metabolism and other biological functions (Table 3 and 4). Conceivably, polymorphisms with quantitative effects on the transcriptome might be also partially responsible for phenotypic variability of IMF content and composition. Under this assumption, studies combining eQTL-QTL scans, optimally in combination with gene network/biological systems approaches, should be considered as the most powerful strategy to identify causal genes and mutations. It is fundamental to stress, however, that finding overlaps between eQTL and QTL, although suggestive from a biological point of view, does not allow establishing a causal connection . In fact, correlations due to linkage disequilibrium and/or fortuitous overlaps are expected to occur because of the low resolution of microsatellite QTL mapping (QTL intervals are large) and the high density of eQTL maps (they cover a substantial part of the genome).
Correlation analysis between target gene expression and muscle lipid phenotypes
A correlation study was performed in order to confirm the relationship between mRNA expression of certain genes and phenotypic variation. A total of 16 (ACACA, ACLY, ARNTL, CAST, CS, CYP24A1, DNAJB6, FABP5, HOXA10, IL12RB2, LRP6, NEDD4L, NUDT6, PPP1CB, RRM2B and YWHAZ) out of 80 genes that were regulated by eQTL mapping to the confidence interval of QTL were selected for the correlation study, on the basis of their functional relationship with muscle fat deposition. We computed the correlation coefficients between their mRNA expression levels and muscle fat deposition traits, including IMF, muscle cholesterol content and fatty acid composition. Correlation coefficients that were significant in at least one of the three calculations (whole dataset or within High or Low fatness groups) are shown in Table 6. As a whole, correlation coefficients between gene expression levels and IMF content and composition phenotypes were moderate (positive and negative), displaying absolute values that ranged from 0.25 to 0.44 (Table 6). A few robust and positive correlations were observed between NEDD4L mRNA levels and myristic fatty acid content, and between CYP24A1 expression levels and palmitic fatty acid content. However, consistency between correlation coefficients obtained within the two groups of pigs with divergent profiles for lipid traits was, in general, quite low. For instance, the mRNA levels of the ACACA and ACLY genes showed positive correlation coefficients with IMF content, but this relationship did not reach statistical significance in the High group. Similarly, muscle gene expression of IL12RB2 was positively correlated with IMF content but only in the High group (Table 6). Even more, opposite relationships (negative correlation in one group, positive in the other one) were observed when comparing the High and Low groups (e.g. correlation of CS, CAST, LRP6 and RRM2B mRNA levels with linoleic fatty acid content in muscle). Opposite correlation relationship in extreme groups had been reported before between SCD protein expression levels and oleic acid muscle composition , probably as an effect of selection for favourable alleles.
Taken as a whole, this correlation study provided limited evidences of a linear relationship between muscle fat deposition and mRNA levels of genes functionally related with lipid metabolism. Discrepancies between correlations estimated in the two groups might be explained by experimental (i.e. limited sample size) and biological (i.e. gene expression might be modulated to some extent by the metabolic profile of individuals) factors. In this sense, it is well known that obesity and leanness, as “metabolic states”, can influence the expression of many genes, including those that are completely unrelated with lipid metabolism , . For instance, the increased expression of proinflammatory cytokines by the adipose tissue of obese individuals is explained by its substantial infiltration by macrophages . In this same line, Cánovas et al.  also showed important differences in the expression of cell differentiation, energy balance and fat metabolism genes between pigs with divergent lipid metabolic profiles. Finally, the possibility of epistatic interactions, jointly with the differential segregation of regulatory polymorphisms, would be also worth to be explored as a potential cause of divergent expression-phenotype relationships between High and Low groups. In any case, it is necessary to emphasize that correlations should not be interpreted in terms of causality, but as a measure of the association between two variables. In other words, the existence of a correlation between gene expression and phenotypic variation of complex traits is suggestive from a biological point of view, but it does not formally proof the existence of a functional link between both datasets.
Materials and Methods
Animal material and microsatellite genotyping
An experimental pig population (350 castrated males) distributed in five half-sib families and four contemporary batches was generated from a commercial Duroc line mainly devoted to the production of fine quality dry-cured products. This commercial line was selected to increase intramuscular fat (IMF) content, jointly with prolificacy and growth traits, while maintaining carcass fatness. Inbreeding was controlled by an appropriate mating design and the sporadic introgression of genetic material. Pigs were castrated and controlled at IRTA-Pig Control Centre facilities. A number of phenotypes related with fatness, serum lipid levels, and IMF content and composition were recorded and measured as previously described by Gallardo et al. , . So far, several investigations including QTL mapping for lipid metabolism and fat deposition traits , ,  and a differential mRNA expression study  have been conducted in this commercial population. The experimental procedures, phenotype recording and blood sampling were approved by the Ethical Committee of the Institution (IRTA- Institut de Recerca i Tecnologia Agroalimentàries).
The Duroc commercial population was genotyped for 116 informative microsatellites covering the 18 autosomes with an average interval space between markers of 19.2 cM. All the information related to microsatellite genotyping and the description of the linkage map can be found in Quintanilla et al. .
Expression data and normalization
We have analysed the global mRNA expression profile of gluteus medius muscle samples obtained from 105 Duroc pigs distributed in two groups with divergent phenotypes for fatness traits (53 and 52 individuals in the High and Low groups, respectively). Groups were established on the basis of multivariant analyses for several lipid deposition traits, as described in Cánovas et al. . RNA isolation and hybridization in GeneChip Porcine Genome® arrays (Affymetrix, Inc., Santa Clara, CA) procedures are also reported in Cánovas et al. . Microarray data normalisation was assessed through the gcRMA algorithm, which corrects the intensity of each probe by its GC content , using the BRB-ArrayTools software version 3.7.1 , which is available online at http://linus.nci.nih.gov/BRB-ArrayTools.html. Microarray data obtained in the current study have been deposited in the Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) public repository with GSE19275 and GSE26091 GEO accession numbers.
Before performing the eQTL scan, the “minimum fold-change” filter implemented in the BRB-ArrayTools was applied in order to filter out those probes displaying low expression variability across the 105 muscle samples. The criterion consisted on selecting those probes with more than 20% of its expression values (from the 105 arrays) meeting at least ±1.5 times the median expression of the probe.
Expression quantitative trait loci analyses
A genome-wide eQTL scan was carried out for 6,139 Affymetrix probes which had passed the “minimum fold-change” filter described above. These eQTL analyses were performed for each probe, using the aforementioned panel of 116 microsatellites, by means of the GridQTL software , available at http://www.gridqtl.org.uk/. The common model used for eQTL scanning was:where: yijk is the expression data of individual k; bi is the effect of ith contemporary batch of fattening (four levels); lj is the laboratory j effect (two levels); α is the regression coefficient (mean allele substitution effect); pk is the probability of individual k inheriting a given allele from its common parent; eijk is the residual effect. Genome-wide significance thresholds for the F-values (eQTL model vs no eQTL model) were approximated with the Bonferroni correction as described in Gallardo et al. . Genome-wide significance levels of 95% and 99% corresponded to P-values of 0.0009 and 0.0002 respectively.
Reference assembly and mapping analyses
For those target probes regulated by significant eQTL, we analysed the Affymetrix porcine probe-sets (11 probes per probe-set). These probes were assembled to the pig genome sequence with the Ensembl annotation tool (http://www.ensembl.org/info/data/ftp/index.html) using CLCBio workbench software (CLC Bio, Aarhus, Denmark), and quality of all significant probes was thoroughly examined. In the mapping analysis, we took into account the proportion of mismatches with the reference sequence. In this way, probes were classified into uniquely mapped probes and non-specifically mapped probes.
The GBrowse tool, available at the pig QTL database (http://www.animalgenome.org/cgi-bin/gbrowse/pig/), was used to locate all probes affected by significant eQTL as well as to align these eQTL to the pig genome. The alignment of eQTL genomic locations against target transcripts or genes was accomplished by converting the linkage eQTL map (cM) to genome sequence assembly locations (bp) as described in Hu et al. . This was achieved by taking as a reference anchoring markers that are mapped on both (linkage and genome) maps. Whenever eQTL boundaries did not coincide with anchoring marker locations, relative genome locations were calculated with an algorithm that takes into account the chromosomal length, the cM vs bp ratio, and the offset of the eQTL location to that of anchoring marker . The comparison between eQTL and their corresponding target gene locations allowed us to classify eQTL in cis-acting eQTL (close to the target gene) and trans-acting eQTL (in different chromosome or far away from the target gene). As in Ponsuksili et al. , cis-acting eQTL were defined as those in which the target gene position falls within the interval delimited by the two flanking markers of the eQTL peak.
Functional annotation: Gene Ontology and Pathway analyses
Gene Ontology (GO) describes the basic hierarchies and relationships between terms within the context of biology. The three GO categories (biological process, molecular function and cellular component) were analysed in order to achieve a full coverage of the GO spectrum. The GO term enrichment analyses for overrepresentation of specific GO terms were carried out with the Database for Annotation, Visualization and Integrated Discovery (DAVID) bioinformatic package, available at http://david.abcc.ncifcrf.gov. Significance levels were computed following a modification of Fisher's exact test. Multiple testing-corrected P-values were also obtained using the Benjamini and Hochberg algorithm, and only GO terms with Benjamini-corrected P-values <0.01 were considered. DAVID was additionally used to explore the biological pathways enriched in the resulting eQTL-regulated gene list, computing a total overrepresentation value for each pathway represented in the Kyoto Encyclopaedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG, http://www.genome.jp/kegg).
Correlation analyses between gene expression levels and muscle lipid phenotypes
Correlation analyses between expression levels and several phenotypes related to lipid metabolism and fat deposition were additionally carried out for a number of eQTL-regulated genes selected on the basis of the former analyses. The correlation study was performed using the CORR procedure of SAS (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC) after adjusting phenotypes and expression levels for the environmental significant effects considered in previous analyses (residual correlations). Two correlations analyses were carried out: 1) correlation analyses considering the whole dataset (n = 105 for each correlation); and 2) within-group correlation analyses, considering separately the two groups of individuals with divergent lipid metabolism profiles (n = 53 and 52 for the High and Low groups, respectively).
We are in debt to Dr. J.M. Reecy (Iowa State University), Dr. J.F. Medrano and Dr. G. Rincón (University of California-Davis) for their help in statistical analyses. We are also grateful to Selección Batallé S.A. for providing the animal material, and very particularly to J. Reixach for helping in the experimental protocol. Thanks also to J.L. Noguera, D. Almuzara and I. Díaz (IRTA, Spain) for their cooperation in the experimental procedure and the laboratory analyses.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RQ RP MA. Performed the experiments: AC RP DG OR. Analyzed the data: AC RQ. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: AC RQ. Wrote the paper: AC RQ MA RP.
- 1. Emilsson V, Thorleifsson G, Zhang B, Leonardson AS, Zink F, et al. (2008) Genetics of gene expression and its effect on disease. Nature 452(7186): 423–31.V. EmilssonG. ThorleifssonB. ZhangAS LeonardsonF. Zink2008Genetics of gene expression and its effect on disease.Nature452718642331
- 2. Schadt EE, Molony C, Chudin E, Hao K, Yang X, et al. (2008) Mapping the genetic architecture of gene expression in human liver. PLoSBiol 6: e107.EE SchadtC. MolonyE. ChudinK. HaoX. Yang2008Mapping the genetic architecture of gene expression in human liver.PLoSBiol6e107
- 3. Zhang W, Duan S, Kistner EO, Bleibel WK, Huang RS, et al. (2008) Evaluation of genetic variation contributing to differences in gene expression between populations. Am J Hum Genet 82: 631–640.W. ZhangS. DuanEO KistnerWK BleibelRS Huang2008Evaluation of genetic variation contributing to differences in gene expression between populations.Am J Hum Genet82631640
- 4. Duan S, Huang RS, Zhang W, Bleibel WK, Roe CA, et al. (2008) Genetic architecture of transcript-level variation in humans. Am J Hum Genet 82(5): 1101–1113.S. DuanRS HuangW. ZhangWK BleibelCA Roe2008Genetic architecture of transcript-level variation in humans.Am J Hum Genet82511011113
- 5. Cheung VG, Spielman , RS (2009) Genetics of human gene expression: mapping DNA variants that influence gene expression. Nature Reviews Genetics 10(9): 595–604.VG CheungSpielmanRS2009Genetics of human gene expression: mapping DNA variants that influence gene expression.Nature Reviews Genetics109595604
- 6. Gilad Y, Rifkin SA, Pritchard JK (2008) Revealing the architecture of gene regulation: the promise of eQTL studies. Trends Genet 24(8): 408–423.Y. GiladSA RifkinJK Pritchard2008Revealing the architecture of gene regulation: the promise of eQTL studies.Trends Genet248408423
- 7. Wimmers K, Murani E, Ponsuksili S (2010) Functional genomics and genetical genomics approaches towards elucidating networks of genes affecting meat performance in pigs. Brief Funct Genomics 9: 251–258.K. WimmersE. MuraniS. Ponsuksili2010Functional genomics and genetical genomics approaches towards elucidating networks of genes affecting meat performance in pigs.Brief Funct Genomics9251258
- 8. Ponsuksili S, Murani E, Brand B, Schwerin M, Wimmers K (2011) Integrating expression profiling and whole-genome association for dissection of fat traits in a porcine model. J Lipid Res 52(4): 668–678.S. PonsuksiliE. MuraniB. BrandM. SchwerinK. Wimmers2011Integrating expression profiling and whole-genome association for dissection of fat traits in a porcine model.J Lipid Res524668678
- 9. Steibel JP, Bates RO, Rosa GJ, Tempelman RJ, Rilington VD, et al. (2011) Genome-wide linkage analysis of global gene expression in loin muscle tissue identifies candidate genes in pigs. PLoS One 6(2): e16766.JP SteibelRO BatesGJ RosaRJ TempelmanVD Rilington2011Genome-wide linkage analysis of global gene expression in loin muscle tissue identifies candidate genes in pigs.PLoS One62e16766
- 10. Liaubet L, Lobjois V, Faraut T, Tircazes A, Benne F, et al. (2011) Genetic variability of transcript abundance in pig peri-mortem skeletal muscle: eQTL localized genes involved in stress response, cell death, muscle disorders and metabolism. BMC Genomics 12: 548.L. LiaubetV. LobjoisT. FarautA. TircazesF. Benne2011Genetic variability of transcript abundance in pig peri-mortem skeletal muscle: eQTL localized genes involved in stress response, cell death, muscle disorders and metabolism.BMC Genomics12548
- 11. Cánovas A, Quintanilla R, Amills M, Pena RN (2010) Muscle transcriptomic profiles in pigs with divergent phenotypes for fatness traits. BMC Genomics 11: 372.A. CánovasR. QuintanillaM. AmillsRN Pena2010Muscle transcriptomic profiles in pigs with divergent phenotypes for fatness traits.BMC Genomics11372
- 12. Casellas J, Noguera JL, Reixach J, Díaz I, Amills M, Quintanilla R (2010) Bayes factor analyses of heritability for serum and muscle lipid traits in Duroc pigs. J Anim Sci 88: 2246–2254.J. CasellasJL NogueraJ. ReixachI. DíazM. AmillsR. Quintanilla2010Bayes factor analyses of heritability for serum and muscle lipid traits in Duroc pigs.J Anim Sci8822462254
- 13. Gallardo D, Pena RN, Amills M, Varona L, Ramírez O, et al. (2008) Mapping of quantitative trait loci for cholesterol, LDL, HDL and triglyceride serum concentrations in pigs. Physiol Genomics 35: 199–209.D. GallardoRN PenaM. AmillsL. VaronaO. Ramírez2008Mapping of quantitative trait loci for cholesterol, LDL, HDL and triglyceride serum concentrations in pigs.Physiol Genomics35199209
- 14. Quintanilla R, Pena RN, Gallardo D, Cánovas A, Ramírez O, et al. (2011) Porcine intramuscular fat content and composition are regulated by quantitative trait loci with muscle-specific effects. J Anim Sci 89: 2963–2971.R. QuintanillaRN PenaD. GallardoA. CánovasO. Ramírez2011Porcine intramuscular fat content and composition are regulated by quantitative trait loci with muscle-specific effects.J Anim Sci8929632971
- 15. Gallardo D, Pena RN, Quintanilla R, Ramírez O, Almuzara D, et al. (2012) Quantitative trait loci analysis of a Duroc commercial population highlights differences in the genetic determination of meat quality traits at two different muscles. Anim Genet.. D. GallardoRN PenaR. QuintanillaO. RamírezD. Almuzara2012Quantitative trait loci analysis of a Duroc commercial population highlights differences in the genetic determination of meat quality traits at two different muscles.Anim Genet.In press. In press.
- 16. Ponsuksili S, Jonas E, Murani E, Phatsara C, Srikanchai T, et al. (2008) Trait correlated expression combined with expression QTL analysis reveals biological pathways and candidate genes affecting water holding capacity of muscle. BMC Genomics 9: 367.S. PonsuksiliE. JonasE. MuraniC. PhatsaraT. Srikanchai2008Trait correlated expression combined with expression QTL analysis reveals biological pathways and candidate genes affecting water holding capacity of muscle.BMC Genomics9367
- 17. Göring HH, Curran CJ, Johnson MP, Dyer TD, Charlesworth J, et al. (2007) Discovery of expression QTLs using large-scale transcriptional profiling in human lymphocytes. Nat Genet 39: 1208–1216.HH GöringCJ CurranMP JohnsonTD DyerJ. Charlesworth2007Discovery of expression QTLs using large-scale transcriptional profiling in human lymphocytes.Nat Genet3912081216
- 18. Morley M, Molony CM, Weber TM, Devlin JL, Ewens KG, et al. (2004) Genetic analysis of genome-wide variation in human gene expression. Nature 430: 743–747.M. MorleyCM MolonyTM WeberJL DevlinKG Ewens2004Genetic analysis of genome-wide variation in human gene expression.Nature430743747
- 19. Myers AJ, Gibbs GJ, Webster JA, Rohrer K, Zhao A, et al. (2007) A survey of genetic human cortical gene expression. Nature Genet 39: 1494–1499.AJ MyersGJ GibbsJA WebsterK. RohrerA. Zhao2007A survey of genetic human cortical gene expression.Nature Genet3914941499
- 20. Cheung VG, Nayak RR, Wang IX, Elwyn S, Cousins SM, et al. (2010) Polymorphic cis- and trans-regulation of human gene expression. PLoS Biol 8(9): e1000480.VG CheungRR NayakIX WangS. ElwynSM Cousins2010Polymorphic cis- and trans-regulation of human gene expression.PLoS Biol89e1000480
- 21. Yvert G, Brem RB, Whittle J, Akey JM, Foss E, et al. (2003) Trans-acting regulatory variation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the role of transcription factors. Nat Genet 35(1): 57–64.G. YvertRB BremJ. WhittleJM AkeyE. Foss2003Trans-acting regulatory variation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the role of transcription factors.Nat Genet3515764
- 22. Hubner N, Wallace CA, Zimdahl H, Petretto E, Schulz H, et al. (2005) Integrated transcriptional profiling and linkage analysis for identification of genes underlying disease. Nat Genet 37(3): 243–253.N. HubnerCA WallaceH. ZimdahlE. PetrettoH. Schulz2005Integrated transcriptional profiling and linkage analysis for identification of genes underlying disease.Nat Genet373243253
- 23. de Koning DJ, Janss LL, Rattink AP, van Oers PA, de Vries BJ, et al. (1999) Detection of quantitative trait loci for backfat thickness and intramuscular fat content in pigs (Sus scrofa). Genetics 152(4): 1679–1690.DJ de KoningLL JanssAP RattinkPA van OersBJ de Vries1999Detection of quantitative trait loci for backfat thickness and intramuscular fat content in pigs (Sus scrofa).Genetics152416791690
- 24. Nagamine Y, Haley CS, Sewalem A, Visscher PM (2003) Quantitative trait loci variation for growth and obesity between and within lines of pigs (Sus scrofa). Genetics 164: 629–635.Y. NagamineCS HaleyA. SewalemPM Visscher2003Quantitative trait loci variation for growth and obesity between and within lines of pigs (Sus scrofa).Genetics164629635
- 25. Sato S, Hasebe H, Sato S, Asahi Y, Hayashi T, et al. (2006) High-resolution physical mapping and construction of a porcine contig spanning the intramuscular fat content QTL. Anim Genet 37: 113–120.S. SatoH. HasebeS. SatoY. AsahiT. Hayashi2006High-resolution physical mapping and construction of a porcine contig spanning the intramuscular fat content QTL.Anim Genet37113120
- 26. de Koning DJ, Pong-Wong R, Varona L, Evans GJ, Giuffra E, et al. (2003) Full pedigree quantitative trait locus analysis in commercial pigs using variance components. J Anim Sci 81: 2155–2163.DJ de KoningR. Pong-WongL. VaronaGJ EvansE. Giuffra2003Full pedigree quantitative trait locus analysis in commercial pigs using variance components.J Anim Sci8121552163
- 27. Huang CC, Hsu CH (2009) Mitochondrial disease and mitochondrial DNA depletion syndromes. Acta Neurol Taiwan 18: 287–295.CC HuangCH Hsu2009Mitochondrial disease and mitochondrial DNA depletion syndromes.Acta Neurol Taiwan18287295
- 28. Christdoulides C, Laudes M, Cawthorn WP, Schinner S, Soos M, et al. (2006) The Wnt antagonist Dickkopf-1 and its receptors are coordinately regulated during early human adipogenesis. J Cell Sci 119(Pt 12): 2613–2620.C. ChristdoulidesM. LaudesWP CawthornS. SchinnerM. Soos2006The Wnt antagonist Dickkopf-1 and its receptors are coordinately regulated during early human adipogenesis.J Cell Sci119Pt 1226132620
- 29. Tomaszewski M, Charchar FJ, Barnes T, Gawron-Kiszka M, Sedkowska A, et al. (2009) A common variant in low-density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 6 gene (LRP6) is associated with LDL-cholesterol. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 29: 1316–1321.M. TomaszewskiFJ CharcharT. BarnesM. Gawron-KiszkaA. Sedkowska2009A common variant in low-density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 6 gene (LRP6) is associated with LDL-cholesterol.Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol2913161321
- 30. Gómez-Abellán P, Hernández-Morante JJ, Luján JA, Madrid JA, Garaulet M (2008) Clock genes are implicated in the human metabolic syndrome. Int J Obes 32(1): 121–128.P. Gómez-AbellánJJ Hernández-MoranteJA LujánJA MadridM. Garaulet2008Clock genes are implicated in the human metabolic syndrome.Int J Obes321121128
- 31. George M (2007) Mapping, Fine Mapping, and Molecular Dissection of Quantitative Trait Loci in Domestic Animals. Ann Rev Genomics & Human Genetics 8: 131–162.M. George2007Mapping, Fine Mapping, and Molecular Dissection of Quantitative Trait Loci in Domestic Animals.Ann Rev Genomics & Human Genetics8131162
- 32. Canovas A, Estany J, Tor M, Pena RN, Doran O (2009) Acetyl-CoA carboxylase and stearoyl-CoA desaturase protein expression in subcutaneous adipose tissue is reduced in pigs selected for decreased backfat thickness at constant intramuscular fat content. J Anim Sci 87: 3905–3914.A. CanovasJ. EstanyM. TorRN PenaO. Doran2009Acetyl-CoA carboxylase and stearoyl-CoA desaturase protein expression in subcutaneous adipose tissue is reduced in pigs selected for decreased backfat thickness at constant intramuscular fat content.J Anim Sci8739053914
- 33. Balistreri CR, Caruso C, Candore G (2010) The role of adipose tissue and adipokines in obesity-related inflammatory diseases. Mediators Inflamm 2010: 802078.CR BalistreriC. CarusoG. Candore2010The role of adipose tissue and adipokines in obesity-related inflammatory diseases.Mediators Inflamm2010802078
- 34. Morris DL, Singer K, Lumeng CN (2011) Adipose tissue macrophages: phenotypic plasticity and diversity in lean and obese states. Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care 14(4): 341–346.DL MorrisK. SingerCN Lumeng2011Adipose tissue macrophages: phenotypic plasticity and diversity in lean and obese states.Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care144341346
- 35. Gallardo D, Quintanilla R, Varona L, Diaz I, Ramirez O, et al. (2009) Polymorphism of the pig acetyl-coenzyme A carboxylase alpha gene is associated with fatty acid composition in a Duroc commercial line. Anim Genet 40: 410–417.D. GallardoR. QuintanillaL. VaronaI. DiazO. Ramirez2009Polymorphism of the pig acetyl-coenzyme A carboxylase alpha gene is associated with fatty acid composition in a Duroc commercial line.Anim Genet40410417
- 36. Wu Z, Airizarry R, Gentleman R, Martinez-Murillo F, Spencer F (2004) A Model-Based Background Adjustment for Oligonucleotide Expression Arrays. J Amer Statist Asso 99: 909–917.Z. WuR. AirizarryR. GentlemanF. Martinez-MurilloF. Spencer2004A Model-Based Background Adjustment for Oligonucleotide Expression Arrays.J Amer Statist Asso99909917
- 37. Xu X, Zhao Y, Simon R (2008) Gene Set Expression Comparison kit for BRB-ArrayTools. Bioinformatics 24: 137–139.X. XuY. ZhaoR. Simon2008Gene Set Expression Comparison kit for BRB-ArrayTools.Bioinformatics24137139
- 38. Seaton G, Hernandez J, Grunchec JA, White I, Allen J, et al. (2006) GridQTL: A grid portal for QTL mapping of compute intensive datasets. In Proc 8th WCGALP 27: 633–634.G. SeatonJ. HernandezJA GrunchecI. WhiteJ. Allen2006GridQTL: A grid portal for QTL mapping of compute intensive datasets.In Proc 8th WCGALP27633634
- 39. Hu ZL, Fritz ER, Reecy JM (2007) Animal QTLdb: a livestock QTL database tool set for positional QTL information mining and beyond. Nuc Acid Res 35: 604–609.ZL HuER FritzJM Reecy2007Animal QTLdb: a livestock QTL database tool set for positional QTL information mining and beyond.Nuc Acid Res35604609
- 40. Hu ZL, Reecy JM (2007) Animal QTLdb: beyond a repository. A public platform for QTL comparisons and integration with diverse types of structural genomic information. Mamm Genome 18: 1–4.ZL HuJM Reecy2007Animal QTLdb: beyond a repository. A public platform for QTL comparisons and integration with diverse types of structural genomic information.Mamm Genome1814