Bacteriocytes set the stage for some of the most intimate interactions between animal and bacterial cells. In all bacteriocyte possessing systems studied so far, de novo formation of bacteriocytes occurs only once in the host development, at the time of symbiosis establishment. Here, we present the free-living symbiotic flatworm Paracatenula galateia and its intracellular, sulfur-oxidizing bacteria as a system with previously undescribed strategies of bacteriocyte formation and bacterial symbiont transmission. Using thymidine analogue S-phase labeling and immunohistochemistry, we show that all somatic cells in adult worms – including bacteriocytes – originate exclusively from aposymbiotic stem cells (neoblasts). The continued bacteriocyte formation from aposymbiotic stem cells in adult animals represents a previously undescribed strategy of symbiosis maintenance and makes P. galateia a unique system to study bacteriocyte differentiation and development. We also provide morphological and immunohistochemical evidence that P. galateia reproduces by asexual fragmentation and regeneration (paratomy) and, thereby, vertically transmits numerous symbiont-containing bacteriocytes to its asexual progeny. Our data support the earlier reported hypothesis that the symbiont population is subjected to reduced bottleneck effects. This would justify both the codiversification between Paracatenula hosts and their Candidatus Riegeria symbionts, and the slow evolutionary rates observed for several symbiont genes.
Citation: Dirks U, Gruber-Vodicka HR, Leisch N, Bulgheresi S, Egger B, Ladurner P, et al. (2012) Bacterial Symbiosis Maintenance in the Asexually Reproducing and Regenerating Flatworm Paracatenula galateia. PLoS ONE 7(4): e34709. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0034709
Editor: Jr-Kai Sky Yu, Academia Sinica, Taiwan
Received: November 9, 2011; Accepted: March 5, 2012; Published: April 3, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Dirks et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) project P20394 (HGV, UD, JO), the Sparkling Science grant SPA/02 - 81/Plattwürmer (BE), the Leverhulme grant F/07 134/DA (BE) and is contribution 921 from the Carrie Bow Cay Laboratory, Caribbean Coral Reef Ecosystem Program, NMNH, Washington, D.C. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
A major challenge in symbiosis research is to identify the mechanisms that allow symbiotic partners to selectively establish and maintain symbiotic associations. In the particular case of bacteria residing inside animal host cells – commonly called bacteriocytes , ,  – this involves differentiation and maintenance of bacteriocytes during the symbiotic part of the life cycle (intragenerational transmission) as well as symbiont transmission between host generations. In the latter case the symbionts can either be acquired from an environmental symbiont population (horizontal transmission) or passed on from the parental generation (vertical transmission) (reviewed in ). The vertical transmission of symbionts can occur both during sexual  and asexual reproduction , . If symbionts can be acquired both from the environment and the parental generation, the transmission is called ‘mixed’. Strict vertical transmission typically results in tight codiversification of the partners . Moreover, it requires a high degree of integration of the symbiotic life style into the host developmental program. Intracellular symbionts are typically restricted to specialized tissues or organs such as for example the bacteriome in various insects, the trophosome of deep-sea tubeworms (Siboglinidae) or the gill filaments of lucinid bivalves , , , , . Bacteriome, trophosome and gill filaments are functionally analogous tissues that mainly consist of symbiont-housing bacteriocytes. In these three systems, bacteriocyte de novo formation (differentiation of aposymbiotic cells and acquisition of symbionts; often called “infection”) happens during the embryonic/larval development of the animals , , , , . Once established in the insects and tubeworms, the bacteriocytes themselves proliferate, whereas in the case of lucinids, mitotic bacteriocytes have not been detected , , , . All these hosts have in common that neither symbiont acquisition nor de novo differentiation of bacteriocytes happens in the adults. This restriction of de novo bacteriocyte determination and formation to a given life cycle stage complicates the investigation of these essential processes. Only for some eukaryote/eukaryote intracellular symbioses, such as those between cnidarians and intracellular algae, life-long uptake and release of symbionts has been reported , , .
The flatworm class Catenulida (phylum Platyhelminthes) are bilaterians with a simple bauplan . Mouth- and gutless catenulids of the genus Paracatenula are members of the meiofauna in marine shallow-water sediments. They harbor intracellular chemosynthetic alphaproteobacterial symbionts, “Candidatus Riegeria”, which can equal the hosts' biomass , , . The most intensively studied species of the genus, Paracatenula galateia Dirks et al., 2011, is dorso-ventrally flattened, about 300 µm wide and extremely variable in length (1–6 mm) (Figure 1A). The body consists of two parts: (1) the narrow and symbiont-free rostrum anterior to the brain and (2) the posterior “trophosome region”, which mainly consists of the symbiont-housing bacteriocytes (Figure 1A, 1D). Collectively, all bacteriocytes constitute a tissue termed “trophosome” in functional analogy to the trophosome of siboglinid tubeworms . A recent study by Gruber-Vodicka, et al.  reports a tight codiversification between species of the genus Paracatenula and their specific symbionts possibly dating back up to 500 million years. This points to a strict vertical symbiont transmission in the genus, although the reproduction strategies were unknown at the time we started this study. Most catenulids, however, predominantly reproduce by a type of asexual fission termed paratomy, during which new clonal worms grow from the posterior end of the animal, thus generating a chain of zooids (the Latin word “catenula” means “small chain”). The zooids subsequently develop into separate individuals and detach from the mother zooid. Sexual reproduction is rarely observed in catenulids  and has never been observed in Paracatenula , .
(A) Squeeze preparation of a live P. galateia specimen under incident light showing the smooth, silky appearance of the trophosome and the transparent rostrum. (B) TEM trophosome region cross section. One bacteriocyte (surrounded by a dashed line), the thin epidermis, neoblasts stem cells and dorso-ventral muscles are labeled. (C) TEM section of a neoblast (nb) proximal to the epidermis (ep); the cell contains highly active chromatin in the nucleus, chromatoid bodies (cb, arrowheads) and a high nucleo-cytoplasmatic ratio. (D) TEM section of a bacteriocyte with the delicate bacteriocyte membrane (bm, arrowhead); it contains the eukaryotic nucleus (nu, arrowhead) and numerous symbiotic bacteria (ba), which in turn contain bright refractive granules. (E) Schematic drawing of the trophosome region cross section reduced to the three types of cells and tissues most important for this study. Scale bars in (A) and (B) 50 µm, in (C) and (D) 5 µm.
Platyhelminthes possess pluripotent (maybe totipotent) stem cells – the so-called neoblasts – during their whole lifespan , , . Neoblasts are self-renewing and the sole source of all differentiated cell types including the germ cells (reviewed in ). Morphologically, they are characterized by chromatoid bodies, a small size, a very high nucleo-cytoplasmatic ratio and a characteristic heterochromatin pattern , , , . In addition to their function in cell renewal, neoblasts provide exceptional regenerative powers to many flatworm taxa (reviewed in , ).
In this study, we used pulse and pulse-chase incubations with thymidine analogues to label and trace S-phase cells in P. galateia. We show that bacteriocytes, along with all other somatic cell types, derive from aposymbiotic neoblast stem cells. Their continuous production allows bacterial symbiosis maintenance in an animal, which reproduces by asexual fragmentation.
Materials and Methods
All animal work has been conducted according to relevant national and international guidelines. All necessary permits were obtained for the described field studies. Permission for the export of invertebrate animals from Belize (Central America) was issued by the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries of Belize. The permission holder for the collection of invertebrates in Egypt is the Dahab Marine Research Center (DMRC), which hosted us during our fieldwork. No animals were exported from Egypt.
Since none of the Paracatenula species can be grown in culture, all experiments requiring live animals were performed immediately after sampling in the field laboratories of Carrie Bow Cay, Belize (16°48′11″N, 88°04′55″W) and Dahab, Egypt (28°28′13.83″N, 34°30′32.51″E). Sediments were collected in shallow water near Carrie Bow Cay (March 2009 and October 2010) or in the “Napoleon Reef” in Dahab (June 2010). The worms were extracted by gently shaking the sand with ample amounts of filtered sea water (FSW) (0.45 µm filter) followed by pouring the supernatant through a 63 µm pore-size mesh that retains the animals. Animals were then immediately and very carefully washed from the mesh into petri dishes and picked by hand with Pasteur pipettes under a dissecting microscope. Then they were either fixed immediately (see below) or kept alive for different experiments for up to 16 days in 2 ml glass vials containing FSW and a small amount of sediment from the sampling area.
Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM)
Freshly collected animals were immediately relaxed in a MgCl2 solution isotonic to SW for 5 min and fixed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde in a 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer, post fixed for 2 h with 1% osmium tetroxide in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer (pH 7.3) and, after dehydration, embedded in Low Viscosity Resin (Agar Scientific, England). Complete ultra-thin cross-sections mounted on formvar-coated slot grids were post stained with 0.5% uranyl acetate for 20 min and lead citrate for 6 min. Sections were viewed on a Zeiss EM-902 (Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany) and images were recorded with an Olympus (Tokyo, Japan) SharpEye camera system using the AnalySIS 5.0 software (Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany). Single images were merged and further processed with the Adobe Photoshop CS5 software (Adobe Systems complex, San Jose, California, U.S.A.).
Thymidine Analogue and Nocodazole Incubations
For labeling of S-phase cells the thymidine analogues EdU (5-ethynyl-2′-deoxyuridine, Click-it EdU Kit) (Invitrogen Life Technologies, Carlsbad, California, U.S.A.) or BrdU (5′-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine, Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A.) were dissolved in FSW to a concentration of 2.5 mM. Animals were incubated for the length of the labeling pulse (always 30 min) in one of these solutions. Each pulse was followed by five washes in FSW and eventually a chase in FSW (ranging from 12 h up to 148 h, n≥5 for each chase). Incubations (including chase incubations) in FSW, containing 1 µg/ml nocodazole (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A.) for 12 h, were used to arrest cells in mitosis. Afterwards the animals were immediately relaxed in MgCl2 solution isotonic to SW for 5 min followed by fixation in 4% formaldehyde in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) for 12 h at 4°C. Fixed animals were stored in PBS for up to three weeks at 4°C or in pure methanol at −20°C for longer periods.
Click Chemistry and Immunocytochemistry
Alexa fluor 488-azide fluorescent dye (Invitrogen Life Technologies, Carlsbad, California, U.S.A.) was covalently connected to the EdU-label in fixed specimens of P. galateia, performing the “click reaction” following the protocol of the EdU click-iT Kit. Stainings with antibodies against BrdU (Becton & Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, New Jersey, U.S.A.), serotonin (staining serotonergic nerves) (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A.) and phosphorylated histone 3 (staining mitotic cells) (Millipore, Billerica, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) were performed according to the immunostaining protocols established by Ladurner et al. , , except for the protease treatment. We used Proteinase K (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A.) at a final concentration of 0.1 mg/ml for up to 10 min at room temperature. Fluorescently stained whole animals were mounted on slides and scanned with a confocal laser-scanning microscope Zeiss LSM 510 (Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany).
For permanent non-fluorescent labeling, we used a horseradish peroxidase (HRP) catalyzed deposition staining approach (see ) except that we used secondary antibodies directly conjugated to HRP (GE Healthcare, Fairfield, Connecticut, U.S.). Pre-stained whole animals were embedded in LR-white resin (London Resin Company, London, England), and 2-µm-thin cross sections of the trophosome region were produced and counterstained with 1% methylene blue. The sections were examined under the bright field microscope Zeiss Axio Imager.
Images were further analyzed and processed with the Zeiss LSM Image Browser and the Adobe Photoshop CS5 software. Illustrations were produced with Adobe Illustrator CS5 software (Adobe Systems complex, San Jose, California, U.S.A.).
For both EdU-click-iT and antibody stainings, negative controls were conducted.
Freshly collected P. galateia and P. cf. polyhymnia were reversibly anesthetized with MgCl2 solution isotonic to FSW (see above). Using a clean razor blade the worms (n = 50 for each species) were cut transversally posterior to the brain region or further posterior in the trophosome region. Fragments were kept in glass vials as described above and regeneration was observed and photographically documented in 12 h intervals using a dissecting microscope with a camera.
Tissue Composition of the Trophosome Region
We analyzed the tissue composition of the trophosome region using TEM cross sections of P. galateia. Three prominent cell and tissue types were identified: (1) a thin epidermis (Figure 1B), (2) neoblast stem cells (Figure 1B, 1C) and (3) the trophosome consisting of large bacteriocytes (Figure 1B, 1D and S1 showing a dividing symbiont). Rarely, other differentiated cell types such as dorso-ventral muscles permeated the trophosome between the bacteriocytes (Figure 1B). The neoblasts were identified based on their characteristic pattern of heterochromatin, the high nucleo-cytoplasmatic ratio and the presence of chromatoid bodies in the cytoplasm (Figure 1C). They were mostly found proximal and adjacent to the epidermis of the dorsal and ventral side. A schematic trophosome cross section is shown in Figure 1E.
Neoblasts Are Restricted to the Trophosome Region
We determined which cell types are proliferating in P. galateia by using thymidine analogue pulse-labeling. In whole-mounts of specimens pulse-labeled with EdU (or BrdU) (30 min pulse length) we detected S-phase cells exclusively in the posterior body region (trophosome region) (n = 10). In EdU-labeled specimens in which serotonergic nerves were also stained, the S-phase cells were evenly distributed posterior to the brain (Figure 2A). On semithin sections of the trophosome region of pulse-labeled specimens, we found the labeled cells proximal to the epidermis on both the dorsal and ventral side (n = 30 from three specimens) (Figure 3A, B). This neoblast distribution is consistent with that described on TEM sections (above). No label was observed in already differentiated cells types such as epidermal or muscle cells, in nuclei of bacteriocytes or in the bacterial symbionts themselves.
(A) Confocal fluorescence projections of 30 min EdU pulse-labeled S-phase cells (green) and serotonergic nerves (red) superimposed with interference-contrast images of P. galateia whole-mounts. S-phase cells are restricted to the body region posterior to the brain. Longitudinal dorsal nerves extend from the brain to the posterior end of the body. (B) Superimposition of interference-contrast and confocal fluorescence projections of mitotic cells (red) in the anterior body region of a 12 h nocodazole-treated P. galateia. Mitotic cells are restricted to the body region posterior to the brain. Scale bars in (A) and (B) 100 µm.
Bright field micrographs of immuno-stained trophosome region sections. All sections were counterstained with methylene blue (blue). (A) 30 min BrdU pulse-labeled S-phase cells (brown) in subepidermal positions on the dorsal and ventral side of the trophosome region (arrows). (B) Detailed micrograph of BrdU-labeled cells in sub-epidermal positions. (C) Detailed micrograph of mitotic cells (brown) in sub-epidermal positions of trophosome region cross sections. Mitotic cells were accumulated by 12 h nocodazole treatment. One bacteriocyte is indicated with an asterisk and surrounded by a dashed line. A nucleus presumably belonging to a muscle cell is labeled by an arrowhead. Scale bars in (A) 50 µm, (B) and (C) 10 µm.
The number of mitotic cells, which were detected with an antibody against phosphorylated histone 3, was always low and highly variable between different individuals. We used nocodazole (an inhibitor of microtubule polymerization) to arrest and accumulate cells in mitosis. In whole-mounts of nocodazole-treated worms, mitotic cells were evenly distributed in the trophosome region but absent in the rostrum (n = 10) (Figure 2B). This mirrors the distribution of the S-phase neoblasts (Figure 2A). On stained sections we always found mitotic cells proximal to the epidermal cells, the same position described for S-phase neoblasts (n = 30 from three specimens). We did not find any mitotic cells in the epidermis or inside the trophosome. In whole-mounts of EdU-pulse-labeled worms subjected to a 12 h nocodazole chase, most of the mitosis label overlapped with the EdU signals (Figure S2). This indicates that mitotic cells are derived from previously labeled S-phase cells.
Neoblasts Are the Source of Bacteriocytes and All Other Somatic Cell Types
To study cell migration and differentiation into bacteriocytes and other cells types, we performed EdU and BrdU pulse-chase incubations. Pulse-labeled worms were subjected to increasing chase length to determine when cell migration and differentiation starts. The first cell migrations were detected after 72 h chase, when three out of five specimens showed clusters of EdU-labeled cells entering the rostrum (arrowhead in Figure 4A). After 96 h chase, all specimens showed labeled cells distributed over the whole length of the rostrum (n = 5); this indicates ongoing migration and differentiation. In these whole-mounts, we identified labeled cells in the epidermis (arrowhead in Figure 4B) and in the brain (double arrowhead in Figure 4B). In semithin sections of specimens with BrdU pulse and 120 h chase (n = 60 from three specimens) and 148 h chase (n = 40 from two specimens), we observed labeled cells in the epidermis, in subepidermal positions and in the trophosome (Figure 5A and B). In the trophosome, nuclei of bacteriocytes were labeled (dotted line in Figure 5B), as were those of cells between bacteriocytes which probably belong to dorsoventral muscles, nerves or mesenchymal cells (Figure 5C). No label was detected in the symbionts.
Confocal projections of EdU pulse-chase labeled cells (green) and serotonergic nerves (red) superimposed with interference-contrast images of P. galateia whole-mounts. Only the anterior parts of the worms are shown. (A) Worms with EdU-pulse and 72 h-chase showing labeled cells in the moment of entering the rostrum (arrowhead). (B) After 96 h, chase-labeled cells are distributed over the whole length of the rostrum. Label is visible in the epidermis and in nerve cells of the brain (yellow double label, arrows). Scale bars in (A) and (B) 100 µm.
Bright field micrographs of 30 min BrdU pulse and 120 h chase immuno-labeled P. galateia trophosome region cross sections. All sections were counterstained with methylene blue (blue). (A) BrdU-labeled cells (brown) were distributed in all regions of the section including the trophosome (arrowhead). (B) Detailed micrograph of BrdU-labeled bacteriocyte (asterisk, surrounded by a dashed line) and labeled epidermal cells (arrowhead). (C) Other BrdU-labeled cell types between the bacteriocytes. Scale bars in (A) 50 µm, (B) and (C) 10 µm.
P. galateia Can Reproduce by Paratomy and Can Regenerate From Small Fragments
Fission planes (FPs) are constrictions perpendicular to the anterior-posterior axis correlated with asexual fission in flatworms. FPs were abundant in freshly collected P. galateia and other species of the genus (arrowheads in Figure 6A and S3). They were most common in long specimens (≥3 mm) and were confined to the trophosome region. The main longitudinal serotonergic nerves in specimens with FPs and stained with anti-serotonin antiserum were interrupted and well separated into nerve fractions anterior and posterior to the FP (Figure 6B). A prominent commissure in the posterior nerve section shows the reorganization of the central nervous system before fragment separation (arrowhead in Figure 6B). This indicates that the FPs are not due to mechanical stress but are signs of paratomy (transverse fission during which differentiation of new organs occurs prior to separation from the parental animal; see introduction). Under culture conditions, however, FPs did not progress and no detachment of fragments could be observed within the limited observation period of 16 days.
(A) In vivo squeeze preparation of P. galateia under incident light. The animal exhibits a fission plane (arrowhead) in the trophosome region. (B) Confocal fluorescent projection of a serotonin staining (red) superimposed with an interference-contrast image of a fission plane area. The longitudinal nerves (red) are separated into an anterior and posterior fraction. A commissure (arrowhead) in the posterior fraction indicates the reorganization of the nerves. Scale bars in (A) and (B) 100 µm.
To investigate the fate of headless P. galateia trophosome region fragments, which are probably produced in the natural environment, we tested their ability to regenerate a rostrum. Intact worms were decapitated posterior to the brain (dashed line in Figure 7A). Subsequently, four stages of the rostrum regeneration process were observed. Decapitation resulted in a trophosome region fragment of varying length (≥1 mm) with a wound at its anterior end (stage 0) (Figure 7B). Within the following two days the wound surface was minimized and closed before a symbiont-free anterior region appeared (stage 1) (Figure 7C). This was followed by the outgrowth of the rostrum tip (stage 2) (Figure 7D), leading to the formation of the typical shoulder-shaped transition between rostrum and trophosome region (stage 3) (Figure 7E). The time to complete rostrum regeneration varied between 12 and 16 days (n = 10 for each stage). In addition, rostrum regeneration after decapitation was studied in another species, P. cf. polyhymnia, with comparable results (Figure S4) except that rostrum regeneration was completed within only 48–72 h. We also cut P. galateia with long trophosome regions twice or three times. These fragments (length ≥0.5 mm) were also capable of rostrum regeneration, regardless whether they were cut on only one or both sides (n = 20) (Figure S5).
Squeeze preparations of live P. galateia under incident light. (A) Intact P. galateia prior to rostrum amputation. The dashed line indicates the level of cutting. (B) P. galateia directly after rostrum amputation (stage 0). Small shreds of injured bacteriocytes leak out the wound. (C) Regeneration stage 1: the wound is closed and a symbiont-free area on the anterior tip indicates ongoing rostrum regeneration. (D) Regeneration stage 2: a small outgrowing rostrum is visible on the anterior tip. (E) Regeneration stage 3: the new rostrum has its final characteristic shape and has grown almost to its full size. Scale bars in (A–E) 100 µm.
In the rostrum fragments resulting from the decapitation, the wound also closed within the first days. Although all of these fragments retained a small piece of trophosome after cutting (Figure 7A, dashed line indicates the cutting plane) no regrowth occurred (n≥40), probably due to the small number of neoblasts remaining in such pieces (compare Figure 2A). All rostrum fragments died within the 16 days of observation.
To determine how many symbionts can be transmitted to the asexual offspring during paratomy or inside accidently produced fragments, we estimated the number of bacterial cells in a 1 mm long (A–P axis) slice of the trophosome region based on the mean dimensions of their cells and their number on cross sections (15 sections from 3 specimens). Our estimates suggest that 36,000–42,000 symbiont cells are transmitted per millimeter trophosome region upon each fragmentation event.
The Bacterial Symbionts Are Integrated into the Ancient Cell-Renewal Machinery of the Flatworm Host
Platyhelminthes are exceptional model systems in stem cell and regenerative biology . Their simple neoblast stem cell system, in which all differentiated cells constantly derive from undetermined stem cells, provides a unique opportunity to investigate the development of specific cell types . In this study we identified neoblast stem cells as the source of bacteriocytes and other somatic cell types in Paracatenula. With a combined approach using ultrastructure, incubations with thymidine analogues and immunostaining, we provide several lines of evidence for this: (1) the detection of cells with typical flatworm-neoblast features (see introduction) in P. galateia; (2) the restriction of neoblasts (S-phase and mitotic cells) to the posterior body region, which is comparable with that found in many other flatworm species , , ; (3) migration of pulse-chase labeled S-phase cells and their differentiation into various cell types known from many other flatworm models , , . All these results show that aposymbiotic neoblasts of adult P. galateia continuously generate bacteriocytes and all other somatic cell types.
Although various cnidarians including hard corals are known to be capable to exchange their intracellular algae with the environment throughout their life cycle, in all reported intracellular animal/bacteria associations de novo bacteriocyte formation and symbiont acquisition happens only once , , , . Adult siboglinid tubeworms (Lamellibrachia luymesi and Riftia pachyptila) possess unipotent bacteriocyte stem cells that proliferate and produce new bacteriocytes. During their division the symbionts are transferred to both daughter cells. One daughter retains the status of an unipotent stem cell, the other terminally differentiates and loses the capability to divide . This is in agreement with the general mode of tissue renewal in annelids, whose needs are met by proliferating multi- and unipotent tissue-specific stem cells , . In the aphids Acyrthosiphon pisum and Megoura viciae as well as in the cockroach Periplaneta americana de novo bacteriocyte formation from aposymbiotic cells is restricted to early developmental stages. During postembryonic development the bacteriocytes themselves proliferate , , , , . In adult aphids, however, they stop dividing and the stock of symbionts is progressively reduced due to repeated vertical symbiont transfer to the offspring. The post-reproductive aphids are free of symbionts . All the presented modes of bacteriocyte production obey the central cell renewal strategy of insect development: totipotency is restricted to germ cells, and all other stem cell types become progressively restricted from pluripotent (during embryonic development) to tissue-specific multipotent or unipotent stem cells (adults) (reviewed in ). The larvae of lucinid bivalves get infected by specific environmental bacteria. This infection can artificially be delayed or prevented when keeping the animals in aseptic sediment. Postembryonic aposymbiotic lucinids, however, remain receptive for symbionts and become infected as soon they get in contact . After the initial infection, source and fate of bacteriocytes in adults are not known. Mitotic bacteriocytes have not been detected yet , , . We have shown here that the remarkable neoblast stem cell system enables adult P. galateia to produce bacteriocytes de novo at any time of the life span. Therefore P. galateia is a promising system to study bacteriocyte determination and differentiation.
All the animal hosts discussed above have integrated bacteriocyte production into their conventional cell renewal systems. In general, cell renewal strategies of an animal taxon should be indicative for bacteriocyte formation and maintenance in their respective symbiotic tissues. Also acoelomorph flatworms, whose phylogenetic placement is highly disputed , , , , have a totipotent stem cell system with comparable features , , . It would therefore be interesting to study the formation process of the symbiont-housing cells in the acoels Symsagittifera roscoffensis (formerly Convoluta roscoffensis) Graff 1891 ,  or Convolutriloba longifissura Bartolomaeus & Balzer 1997 , .
We could not clarify how symbionts enter newly formed P. galateia pre-bacteriocytes (cells determined to become bacteriocytes). There are several possibilities: (1) bacteriocytes release symbionts to the extracellular space; these are then phagocytized by pre-bacteriocytes, (2) bacteriocytes transiently fuse with the pre-bacteriocytes, forming a syncytium, and transfer symbionts, or (3) bacteriocytes pinch off symbiont-containing vesicles which subsequently fuse with pre-bacteriocytes. Inside the bacteriocytes each symbiont is encapsulated by a host-derived membrane . This should simplify symbiont transfer across the hosts' cell membranes. An uptake of new bacteria from the environment is highly unlikely since the worm has no mouth and gut and we never found any indication for phagocytosis of particles via the skin.
We never detected BrdU or EdU incorporation into the DNA of the symbionts, although they apparently proliferate in the bacteriocytes (Figure S1). This is consistent with other studies , . Fuhrman & Azam  found evidence that some autotrophic bacteria do not incorporate thymidine analogues. Since the alphaproteobacterial Paracatenula-symbionts are chemoautotrophic, this might be a possible explanation .
P. galateia Reproduces Asexually and Regenerates
Many catenulids, such as members of the genera Catenula and Stenostomum, reproduce predominantly by paratomy , , . The same genera also exhibit high regenerative powers. Our results indicate that P. galateia, P. cf. polyhymnia and probably all other species of the genus (own unpublished observation) are capable of paratomy and can regenerate the rostrum. Regeneration of the trophosome from rostrum fragments was, however, not observed. Possible explanations may be the low number of neoblasts in the rostrum piece and/or insufficient nutrition due to the few bacteriocytes in the rostrum fragment when cut right posterior to the brain.
Natural disturbances such as wave action and bioturbation by macrofauna may cause accidental fragmentation in these fragile animals . The frequent finding of fragments or battered and partly regenerated individuals in our field collections suggests the importance of regeneration in Paracatenula's natural environment. Amputation experiments demonstrated the potential of different Paracatenula species to regrow the rostrum even in small body fragments. Under good growth conditions, repeated paratomy and fragmentation/regeneration can lead to an exponential growth of the population, helping to explain the extremely patchy distribution of the worms (own unpublished observation). Figure 8 schematically outlines the hypothetical reproduction of Paracatenula by paratomy. Since sexual reproduction has never been observed in Paracatenula species, asexual fragmentation is probably the predominant mode of reproduction , .
Drawing of P. galateia reproducing by paratomy (grey = trophosome). Paratomy starts when the trophosome extends to a certain length (1). Progressively, constrictions appear perpendicular to the anterior-posterior axis and zooids develop (2) which finally detach from the mother zooid (3). Then, each of the zooids grows to a complete worm (4), whereas the trophosome region continuously grows until it extends to a certain size and the process of paratomy starts again.
Asexual Transmission of Intracellular Symbionts
The diversity of symbiont transmission strategies between host generations were recently reviewed , . Horizontal and vertical transmission are the two fundamentally different modes described (see introduction). Trophosome region fragments of P. galateia always contain many hundreds to thousands of bacteriocytes. As a consequence the worm vertically transmits high numbers of symbionts (36,000–42,000 per mm trophosome region) to the asexual offspring. This vertical “bacteriocyte transmission” results in a permanent host-symbiont liaison during asexual reproduction. We have no evidence for sexual reproduction in the genus Paracatenula , , but even if this would occur, horizontal transmission is unlikely given the tight codiversification reported for hosts and symbionts . In most other systems, intracellular symbionts have to undergo a complex journey during vertical transmission. They must translocate from the parental symbiont-housing tissue into either germ cells or the developing progeny. In both cases the symbionts experience environmental changes, especially if they have to pass an extracellular space and risk losing contact with the host (reviewed in ). Asexual reproduction by fragmentation or budding is common in other symbiotic metazoans such as corals. These may asexually transmit their intracellular algae, however, the newly formed polyps are not released into the sea, but usually stay in contact with the colony that generated them , . The transmission of whole symbiont-housing cells to separate new individuals has been described for Hydra viridis and Convolutriloba longifissura. During budding of H. viridis the algal and bacterial symbionts are transmitted directly through dividing gastrodermal cells to the developing bud. Sexually produced offspring, however, have to take up both kinds of symbionts from the environment, showing that this intracellular association is not uninterrupted in time . Accordingly, no codiversification can be observed between this group of hydroids and their symbionts. C. longifissura and Waminoa brickneri also transmit their intracellular algal symbionts during asexual fission, but a detailed investigation is pending , .
The strict vertical transmission of a limited number of symbionts to the offspring – the transmission bottleneck – bears the risk of accumulating slightly deleterious mutations in the symbiont pool through genetic drift , , , . Buchner observed that fewer than 200 bacteria are transmitted to each offspring of the louse Pediculus . In various aphid-species the number of symbiont cells transmitted ranged from 800–8000 . In contrast, when P. galateia reproduces by paratomy or accidental fragmentation, the high number of transmitted symbionts minimizes bottlenecking.
In conclusion, the capacity of the P. galateia's cell renewal machinery to produce bacteriocytes at any time of the life cycle will promote the understanding of a dark side of symbiosis research: bacteriocyte determination and differentiation. Moreover, this ancient two partner association is a promising system to study an undescribed symbiont transmission strategy which enabled a tight codiversification between Paracatenula-species and their Candidatus Riegeria symbionts.
The Symbionts Proliferate Inside the Bacteriocytes. Detailed TEM-micrograph of a dividing bacterial symbiont. Sulfur storage granules (white inclusions) visible in bacterial cells.
The Pulse-labeled Cells Enter Mitosis After a Certain Chase Time. Confocal fluorescence projections of EdU-labeled S-phase cells (green) and mitotic cells (red) in the P. galateia trophosome region. The worm was subjected to a 30 min EdU pulse followed by a 12 h nocodazole chase. (A) Double label of EdU and mitosis. All mitotic cells also show EdU S-phase label (yellow). (B) Same image section showing only the red mitosis label. Scale bar in (A) and (B) 10 µm.
Fission Plane in the Trophosome Region of P. cf polyhymnia. In vivo squeeze preparation of P. cf polyhymnia under incident light. (A) The animal exhibits a fission plane (arrowhead) in the trophosome region. The inset shows a higher magnification of the fission plane. Scale bar in the main figure 100 µm and in the inset 50 µm.
Regeneration After Rostrum Amputation of P. cf polyhymnia. Micrographs of regenerating P. cf polyhymnia. Live worms before (A) and directly after rostrum amputation (B). Rostrum regeneration 24 h (C) and 48 h (D) after amputation. Scale bar in (A–D) 50 µm.
Regeneration of Tiny Trophosome Region Fragments of P. galateia. Micrograph of a 0.5-mm-long regenerating trophosome region fragment 14 days after rostrum amputation. A small rostrum is visible on one side (arrowhead). Scale bar 100 µm.
We gratefully acknowledge Wolfgang Sterrer and Renate Ott for supporting the fieldwork, Monika Bright for many suggestions that improved the manuscript and Michael Stachowitsch for language editing. We thank the Core Facility for Cell Imaging and Ultrastructural Research and the Department of Microbial Ecology at the University of Vienna for providing facilities.
Conceived and designed the experiments: UD HGV JO. Performed the experiments: UD NL BE. Analyzed the data: UD HGV NL SB BE PL JO. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SB BE PL. Wrote the paper: UD.
- 1. Hand SC (1987) Trophosome ultrastructure and the characterization of isolated bacteriocytes from invertebrate-sulfur bacteria symbioses. The Biological Bulletin 173: 260–276.SC Hand1987Trophosome ultrastructure and the characterization of isolated bacteriocytes from invertebrate-sulfur bacteria symbioses.The Biological Bulletin173260276
- 2. Gros O, Darrasse A, Durand P, Frenkiel L, Mouëza M (1996) Environmental transmission of a sulfur-oxidizing bacterial gill endosymbiont in the tropical lucinid bivalve Codakia orbicularis. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 62: 2324–2330.O. GrosA. DarrasseP. DurandL. FrenkielM. Mouëza1996Environmental transmission of a sulfur-oxidizing bacterial gill endosymbiont in the tropical lucinid bivalve Codakia orbicularis.Applied and Environmental Microbiology6223242330
- 3. Braendle C, Miura T, Bickel R, Shingleton AW, Kambhampati S, et al. (2003) Developmental origin and evolution of bacteriocytes in the aphid-Buchnera symbiosis. PLoS Biol 1: 70–76.C. BraendleT. MiuraR. BickelAW ShingletonS. Kambhampati2003Developmental origin and evolution of bacteriocytes in the aphid-Buchnera symbiosis.PLoS Biol17076
- 4. Bright M, Bulgheresi S (2010) A complex journey: transmission of microbial symbionts. Nat Rev Micro 8: 218–230.M. BrightS. Bulgheresi2010A complex journey: transmission of microbial symbionts.Nat Rev Micro8218230
- 5. Maldonado M, Cortadellas N, Trillas MI, Ruetzler K (2005) Endosymbiotic Yeast Maternally Transmitted in a Marine Sponge. Biol Bull 209: 94–106.M. MaldonadoN. CortadellasMI TrillasK. Ruetzler2005Endosymbiotic Yeast Maternally Transmitted in a Marine Sponge.Biol Bull20994106
- 6. Morris DJ, Adams A (2006) Transmission of freshwater myxozoans during the asexual propagation of invertebrate hosts. International Journal for Parasitology 36: 371–377.DJ MorrisA. Adams2006Transmission of freshwater myxozoans during the asexual propagation of invertebrate hosts.International Journal for Parasitology36371377
- 7. Darby AC, Douglas AE (2003) Elucidation of the transmission patterns of an insect-borne bacterium. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 69: 4403–4407.AC DarbyAE Douglas2003Elucidation of the transmission patterns of an insect-borne bacterium.Applied and Environmental Microbiology6944034407
- 8. Sachs JL, Essenberg CJ, Turcotte MM (2011) New paradigms for the evolution of beneficial infections. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 26: 202–209.JL SachsCJ EssenbergMM Turcotte2011New paradigms for the evolution of beneficial infections.Trends in Ecology & Evolution26202209
- 9. Gros OG, Liberge ML, Felbeck HF (2003) Interspecific infection of aposymbiotic juveniles of Codakia orbicularis by various tropical lucinid gill-endosymbionts. Marine Biology 142: 57–66.OG GrosML LibergeHF Felbeck2003Interspecific infection of aposymbiotic juveniles of Codakia orbicularis by various tropical lucinid gill-endosymbionts.Marine Biology1425766
- 10. van der Land J, Norrevang A (1975) The systematic position of Larnellibrachia (Annelida, Vestimentifera). Zool Syst Evolutionsforsch Sonderheft 1: 86–101.J. van der LandA. Norrevang1975The systematic position of Larnellibrachia (Annelida, Vestimentifera).Zool Syst Evolutionsforsch Sonderheft186101
- 11. Denlinger DL, Ma W-C (1975) Maternal nutritive secretions as possible channels for vertical transmission of microorganisms in insects: The Tsetse fly example. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 266: 162–165.DL DenlingerW-C Ma1975Maternal nutritive secretions as possible channels for vertical transmission of microorganisms in insects: The Tsetse fly example.Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences266162165
- 12. Douglas AE, Dixon AFG (1987) The mycetocyte symbiosis of aphids: Variation with age and morph in virginoparae of Megoura viciae and Acyrthosiphon pisum. Journal of Insect Physiology 33: 109–113.AE DouglasAFG Dixon1987The mycetocyte symbiosis of aphids: Variation with age and morph in virginoparae of Megoura viciae and Acyrthosiphon pisum.Journal of Insect Physiology33109113
- 13. Gros O, Frenkiel L, Felbeck H (2000) Sulfur-oxidizing endosymbiosis in Divaricella quadrisulcata (Bivalvia: Lucinidae): morphological, ultrastructural, and phylogenetic analysis. Symbiosis 29: 293–317.O. GrosL. FrenkielH. Felbeck2000Sulfur-oxidizing endosymbiosis in Divaricella quadrisulcata (Bivalvia: Lucinidae): morphological, ultrastructural, and phylogenetic analysis.Symbiosis29293317
- 14. Miura T, Braendle C, Shingleton A, Sisk G, Kambhampati S, et al. (2003) A comparison of parthenogenetic and sexual embryogenesis of the pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum (Hemiptera: Aphidoidea). J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol 295: 59–81.T. MiuraC. BraendleA. ShingletonG. SiskS. Kambhampati2003A comparison of parthenogenetic and sexual embryogenesis of the pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum (Hemiptera: Aphidoidea).J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol2955981
- 15. Nussbaumer AD, Fisher CR, Bright M (2006) Horizontal endosymbiont transmission in hydrothermal vent tubeworms. Nature 441: 345–348.AD NussbaumerCR FisherM. Bright2006Horizontal endosymbiont transmission in hydrothermal vent tubeworms.Nature441345348
- 16. Harmer TL, Rotjan RD, Nussbaumer AD, Bright M, Ng AW, et al. (2008) Free-living tube worm endosymbionts found at deep-sea vents. Appl Environ Microbiol 74: 3895–3898.TL HarmerRD RotjanAD NussbaumerM. BrightAW Ng2008Free-living tube worm endosymbionts found at deep-sea vents.Appl Environ Microbiol7438953898
- 17. Pflugfelder B, Cary SC, Bright M (2009) Dynamics of cell proliferation and apoptosis reflect different life strategies in hydrothermal vent and cold seep vestimentiferan tubeworms. Cell Tissue Res 337: 149–165.B. PflugfelderSC CaryM. Bright2009Dynamics of cell proliferation and apoptosis reflect different life strategies in hydrothermal vent and cold seep vestimentiferan tubeworms.Cell Tissue Res337149165
- 18. Lambiase S, Grigolo A, Laudani U, Sacchi L, Baccetti B (1997) Pattern of bacteriocyte formation in Periplaneta americana (L.) (Blattaria: Blattidae). International Journal of Insect Morphology and Embryology 26: 9–19.S. LambiaseA. GrigoloU. LaudaniL. SacchiB. Baccetti1997Pattern of bacteriocyte formation in Periplaneta americana (L.) (Blattaria: Blattidae).International Journal of Insect Morphology and Embryology26919
- 19. Gros O, Frenkiel L, Moueza M (1998) Gill filament differentiation and experimental colonization by symbiotic bacteria in aposymbiotic juveniles of Codakia orbicularis (Bivalvia: Lucinidae). Invertebrate Reproduction & Development 34: 219–231.O. GrosL. FrenkielM. Moueza1998Gill filament differentiation and experimental colonization by symbiotic bacteria in aposymbiotic juveniles of Codakia orbicularis (Bivalvia: Lucinidae).Invertebrate Reproduction & Development34219231
- 20. Koren O, Rosenberg E (2006) Bacteria associated with mucus and tissues of the coral Oculina patagonica in summer and winter. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 72: 5254–5259.O. KorenE. Rosenberg2006Bacteria associated with mucus and tissues of the coral Oculina patagonica in summer and winter.Applied and Environmental Microbiology7252545259
- 21. Rosenberg E, Koren O, Reshef L, Efrony R, Zilber-Rosenberg I (2007) The role of microorganisms in coral health, disease and evolution. Nat Rev Micro 5: 355–362.E. RosenbergO. KorenL. ReshefR. EfronyI. Zilber-Rosenberg2007The role of microorganisms in coral health, disease and evolution.Nat Rev Micro5355362
- 22. Thorington G, Margulis L (1979) Transmission of symbionts through the sexual cycle of Hydra viridis. I. Observations on living organisms. Transactions of the American Microscopical Society 98: 401–413.G. ThoringtonL. Margulis1979Transmission of symbionts through the sexual cycle of Hydra viridis. I. Observations on living organisms.Transactions of the American Microscopical Society98401413
- 23. Rieger RM (1981) Morphology of the Turbellaria at the ultrastructural level. Hydrobiologia 81: 213–229.RM Rieger1981Morphology of the Turbellaria at the ultrastructural level.Hydrobiologia81213229
- 24. Ott JA, Rieger G, Rieger R, Enderes F (1982) New mouthless interstitial worms from the sulfide system: Symbiosis with Prokaryotes. PSZN I: Marine Ecology 3: 313–333.JA OttG. RiegerR. RiegerF. Enderes1982New mouthless interstitial worms from the sulfide system: Symbiosis with Prokaryotes.PSZN I: Marine Ecology3313333
- 25. Sterrer W, Rieger R (1974) Retronectidae - a new cosmopolitan marine family of Catenulida (Turbellaria). In: Riser N, Morse M, editors. Biology of the Turbellaria. New York: McGraw-Hill. pp. 63–92.W. SterrerR. Rieger1974Retronectidae - a new cosmopolitan marine family of Catenulida (Turbellaria).N. RiserM. MorseBiology of the TurbellariaNew YorkMcGraw-Hill6392
- 26. Gruber-Vodicka HR, Dirks U, Leisch N, Baranyi C, Stoecker K, et al. (2011) Paracatenula, an ancient symbiosis between thiotrophic Alphaproteobacteria and catenulid flatworms. PNAS. HR Gruber-VodickaU. DirksN. LeischC. BaranyiK. Stoecker2011Paracatenula, an ancient symbiosis between thiotrophic Alphaproteobacteria and catenulid flatworms.PNAS
- 27. Ehlers U (1985) “Das Phylogenetische System der Plathelminthes.”. Stuttgart: Gustav Fisher. U. Ehlers1985“Das Phylogenetische System der Plathelminthes.”StuttgartGustav Fisher
- 28. Dirks U, Gruber-Vodicka HR, Leisch N, Sterrer W, Ott JA (2011) A new species of symbiotic flatworms, Paracatenula galateia sp. nov. (Platyhelminthes: Catenulida: Retronectidae) from Belize (Central America). Marine Biology Research 7: 769–777.U. DirksHR Gruber-VodickaN. LeischW. SterrerJA Ott2011A new species of symbiotic flatworms, Paracatenula galateia sp. nov. (Platyhelminthes: Catenulida: Retronectidae) from Belize (Central America).Marine Biology Research7769777
- 29. Newmark PA, Sanchez Alvarado A (2000) Bromodeoxyuridine specifically labels the regenerative stem cells of planarians. Dev Biol 220: 142–153.PA NewmarkA. Sanchez Alvarado2000Bromodeoxyuridine specifically labels the regenerative stem cells of planarians.Dev Biol220142153
- 30. Baguna J, Salo E, Auladell C (1989) Regeneration and pattern formation in planarians. III. Evidence that neoblasts are totipotent stem cells and the source of blastema cells. Development 107: 77–86.J. BagunaE. SaloC. Auladell1989Regeneration and pattern formation in planarians. III. Evidence that neoblasts are totipotent stem cells and the source of blastema cells.Development1077786
- 31. Ladurner P, Rieger R, Baguna J (2000) Spatial distribution and differentiation potential of stem cells in hatchlings and adults in the marine platyhelminth Macrostomum sp.: a bromodeoxyuridine analysis. Dev Biol 226: 231–241.P. LadurnerR. RiegerJ. Baguna2000Spatial distribution and differentiation potential of stem cells in hatchlings and adults in the marine platyhelminth Macrostomum sp.: a bromodeoxyuridine analysis.Dev Biol226231241
- 32. Peter R, Gschwentner R, Schürmann W, Rieger R, Ladurner P (2004) The significance of stem cells in free-living flatworms: one common source for all cells in the adult. Journal of Applied Biomedicine 2: 21–35.R. PeterR. GschwentnerW. SchürmannR. RiegerP. Ladurner2004The significance of stem cells in free-living flatworms: one common source for all cells in the adult.Journal of Applied Biomedicine22135
- 33. Hori I (1982) An ultrastructural study of the chromatoid body in planarian regenerative cells. Journal of Electron Microscopy 31: 63–72.I. Hori1982An ultrastructural study of the chromatoid body in planarian regenerative cells.Journal of Electron Microscopy316372
- 34. Fernandéz-Taboada E, Moritz S, Zeuschner D, Stehling M, Schöler HR, et al. (2010) Smed-SmB, a member of the LSm protein superfamily, is essential for chromatoid body organization and planarian stem cell proliferation. Development 137: 1055–1065.E. Fernandéz-TaboadaS. MoritzD. ZeuschnerM. StehlingHR Schöler2010Smed-SmB, a member of the LSm protein superfamily, is essential for chromatoid body organization and planarian stem cell proliferation.Development13710551065
- 35. Auladell C, Garcia-Valero J, Baguñà J (1993) Ultrastructural localization of RNA in the chromatoid bodies of undifferentiated cells (neoblasts) in planarians by the RNase–gold complex technique. Journal of Morphology 216: 319–326.C. AuladellJ. Garcia-ValeroJ. Baguñà1993Ultrastructural localization of RNA in the chromatoid bodies of undifferentiated cells (neoblasts) in planarians by the RNase–gold complex technique.Journal of Morphology216319326
- 36. Kotaja N, Sassone-Corsi P (2007) The chromatoid body: a germ-cell-specific RNA-processing centre. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 8: 85–90.N. KotajaP. Sassone-Corsi2007The chromatoid body: a germ-cell-specific RNA-processing centre.Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol88590
- 37. Reddien PW, Sanchez Alvarado A (2004) Fundamentals of planarian regeneration. Annu Rev Cell Dev Biol 20: 725–757.PW ReddienA. Sanchez Alvarado2004Fundamentals of planarian regeneration.Annu Rev Cell Dev Biol20725757
- 38. Egger B, Gschwentner R, Rieger R (2007) Free-living flatworms under the knife: past and present. Dev Genes Evol 217: 89–104.B. EggerR. GschwentnerR. Rieger2007Free-living flatworms under the knife: past and present.Dev Genes Evol21789104
- 39. Ladurner P, Mair GR, Reiter D, Salvenmoser W, Rieger RM (1997) Serotonergic nervous system of two macrostomid species: recent or ancient divergence? Invertebrate Biology 116: 178–191.P. LadurnerGR MairD. ReiterW. SalvenmoserRM Rieger1997Serotonergic nervous system of two macrostomid species: recent or ancient divergence?Invertebrate Biology116178191
- 40. Egger B, Gschwentner R, Hess M, Nimeth K, Adamski Z, et al. (2009) The caudal regeneration blastema is an accumulation of rapidly proliferating stem cells in the flatworm Macrostomum lignano. BMC Developmental Biology 9: 41.B. EggerR. GschwentnerM. HessK. NimethZ. Adamski2009The caudal regeneration blastema is an accumulation of rapidly proliferating stem cells in the flatworm Macrostomum lignano.BMC Developmental Biology941
- 41. Wagner DE, Wang IE, Reddien PW (2011) Clonogenic neoblasts are pluripotent adult stem cells that underlie planarian regeneration. Science 332: 811–816.DE WagnerIE WangPW Reddien2011Clonogenic neoblasts are pluripotent adult stem cells that underlie planarian regeneration.Science332811816
- 42. Palmberg I (1990) Stem cells in microturbellarians - an autoradiographic and immunocytochemical study. Protoplasma 158: 109–120.I. Palmberg1990Stem cells in microturbellarians - an autoradiographic and immunocytochemical study.Protoplasma158109120
- 43. Myohara M, Yoshida-Noro C, Kobari F, Tochinai S (1999) Fragmenting oligochaete Enchytraeus japonensis: A new material for regeneration study. Development, Growth & Differentiation 41: 549–555.M. MyoharaC. Yoshida-NoroF. KobariS. Tochinai1999Fragmenting oligochaete Enchytraeus japonensis: A new material for regeneration study.Development, Growth & Differentiation41549555
- 44. Yoshida-Noro C, Tochinai S (2010) Stem cell system in asexual and sexual reproduction of Enchytraeus japonensis (Oligochaeta, Annelida). Development, Growth & Differentiation 52: 43–55.C. Yoshida-NoroS. Tochinai2010Stem cell system in asexual and sexual reproduction of Enchytraeus japonensis (Oligochaeta, Annelida).Development, Growth & Differentiation524355
- 45. Brooks MA, Richards AG (1955) Intracellular symbiosis in cockroaches: II. Mitotic division of mycetocytes. Science 122: 242.MA BrooksAG Richards1955Intracellular symbiosis in cockroaches: II. Mitotic division of mycetocytes.Science122242
- 46. Corley LS, Lavine MD (2006) A review of insect stem cell types. Seminars in Cell & Developmental Biology 17: 510–517.LS CorleyMD Lavine2006A review of insect stem cell types.Seminars in Cell & Developmental Biology17510517
- 47. Philippe H, Brinkmann H, Copley RR, Moroz LL, Nakano H, et al. (2011) Acoelomorph flatworms are deuterostomes related to Xenoturbella. Nature 470: 255–258.H. PhilippeH. BrinkmannRR CopleyLL MorozH. Nakano2011Acoelomorph flatworms are deuterostomes related to Xenoturbella.Nature470255258
- 48. Hejnol A, Martindale MQ (2008) Acoel development indicates the independent evolution of the bilaterian mouth and anus. Nature 456: 382–386.A. HejnolMQ Martindale2008Acoel development indicates the independent evolution of the bilaterian mouth and anus.Nature456382386
- 49. Egger B, Steinke D, Tarui H, De Mulder K, Arendt D, et al. (2009) To be or not to be a flatworm: the acoel controversy. PLoS One 4: e5502.B. EggerD. SteinkeH. TaruiK. De MulderD. Arendt2009To be or not to be a flatworm: the acoel controversy.PLoS One4e5502
- 50. Philippe H, Brinkmann H, Martinez P, Riutort M, Baguñà J (2007) Acoel Flatworms Are Not Platyhelminthes: Evidence from Phylogenomics. PLoS One 2: e717.H. PhilippeH. BrinkmannP. MartinezM. RiutortJ. Baguñà2007Acoel Flatworms Are Not Platyhelminthes: Evidence from Phylogenomics.PLoS One2e717
- 51. Gschwentner R, Ladurner P, Nimeth K, Rieger R (2001) Stem cells in a basal bilaterian: S-phase and mitotic cells in Convolutriloba longifissura (Acoela, Platyhelminthes). Cell and Tissue Research 304: 401–408.R. GschwentnerP. LadurnerK. NimethR. Rieger2001Stem cells in a basal bilaterian: S-phase and mitotic cells in Convolutriloba longifissura (Acoela, Platyhelminthes).Cell and Tissue Research304401408
- 52. De Mulder K, Kuales G, Pfister D, Willems M, Egger B, et al. (2009) Characterization of the stem cell system of the acoel Isodiametra pulchra. BMC Developmental Biology 9: 69.K. De MulderG. KualesD. PfisterM. WillemsB. Egger2009Characterization of the stem cell system of the acoel Isodiametra pulchra.BMC Developmental Biology969
- 53. Doonan SA, Dooday GW (1982) Ecological studies of symbiosis in Convoluta roscoffensis. Marine Ecology - Progress Series 8: 69–73.SA DoonanGW Dooday1982Ecological studies of symbiosis in Convoluta roscoffensis.Marine Ecology - Progress Series86973
- 54. Douglas AE (1985) Growth and reproduction of Convoluta roscoffensis containing different naturally occurring algal symbionts. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 65: 871–879.AE Douglas1985Growth and reproduction of Convoluta roscoffensis containing different naturally occurring algal symbionts.Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom65871879
- 55. Akesson B, Gschwentner R, Hendelberg J, Ladurner P, Muller J, et al. (2001) Fission in Convolutriloba longifissura: asexual reproduction in acoelous turbellarians revisited. Acta Zoologica 82: 231–239.B. AkessonR. GschwentnerJ. HendelbergP. LadurnerJ. Muller2001Fission in Convolutriloba longifissura: asexual reproduction in acoelous turbellarians revisited.Acta Zoologica82231239
- 56. Hirose E, Hirose M (2007) Body colors and algal distribution in the acoel flatworm Convolutriloba longifissura: histology and ultrastructure. Zoological Science 24: 1241–1246.E. HiroseM. Hirose2007Body colors and algal distribution in the acoel flatworm Convolutriloba longifissura: histology and ultrastructure.Zoological Science2412411246
- 57. Kloiber U, Pflugfelder B, Rinke C, Bright M (2009) Cell proliferation and growth in Zoothamnium niveum (Oligohymenophora, Peritrichida) - thiotrophic bacteria symbiosis. Symbiosis 47: 43–50.U. KloiberB. PflugfelderC. RinkeM. Bright2009Cell proliferation and growth in Zoothamnium niveum (Oligohymenophora, Peritrichida) - thiotrophic bacteria symbiosis.Symbiosis474350
- 58. Fuhrman JA, Azam F (1982) Thymidine incorporation as a measure of heterotrophic bacterioplankton production in marine surface waters: Evaluation and field results. Marine Biology 66: 109–120.JA FuhrmanF. Azam1982Thymidine incorporation as a measure of heterotrophic bacterioplankton production in marine surface waters: Evaluation and field results.Marine Biology66109120
- 59. Moraczewski J (1977) Asexual reproduction and regeneration of Catenula (Turbellaria, Archoophora). Zoomorphologie 88: 65–80.J. Moraczewski1977Asexual reproduction and regeneration of Catenula (Turbellaria, Archoophora).Zoomorphologie886580
- 60. Bulgheresi S (2011) Microbial symbiont transmission: basic principles and dark sides beneficial microorganisms in multicellular life forms. In: Rosenberg E, Gophna U, editors. pp. 299–311.S. Bulgheresi2011Microbial symbiont transmission: basic principles and dark sides beneficial microorganisms in multicellular life forms.E. RosenbergU. Gophna299311Springer Berlin Heidelberg. Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
- 61. LaJeunesse TC, Lee S, Bush S, Bruno JF (2005) Persistence of non-caribbean algal symbionts in Indo-Pacific mushroom corals released to Jamaica 35 years ago. Coral Reefs 24: 157–159.TC LaJeunesseS. LeeS. BushJF Bruno2005Persistence of non-caribbean algal symbionts in Indo-Pacific mushroom corals released to Jamaica 35 years ago.Coral Reefs24157159
- 62. Sachs JL, Wilcox TP (2006) A shift to parasitism in the jellyfish symbiont Symbiodinium microadriaticum. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 273: 425–429.JL SachsTP Wilcox2006A shift to parasitism in the jellyfish symbiont Symbiodinium microadriaticum.Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences273425429
- 63. Barneah O, Brickner I, Hooge M, Weis VM, Benayahu Y (2007) First evidence of maternal transmission of algal endosymbionts at an oocyte stage in a triploblastic host, with observations on reproduction in Waminoa brickneri (Acoelomorpha). Invertebrate Biology 126: 113–119.O. BarneahI. BricknerM. HoogeVM WeisY. Benayahu2007First evidence of maternal transmission of algal endosymbionts at an oocyte stage in a triploblastic host, with observations on reproduction in Waminoa brickneri (Acoelomorpha).Invertebrate Biology126113119
- 64. Mira A, Moran NA (2002) Estimating population size and transmission bottlenecks in maternally transmitted endosymbiotic bacteria. Microbial Ecology 44: 137–143.A. MiraNA Moran2002Estimating population size and transmission bottlenecks in maternally transmitted endosymbiotic bacteria.Microbial Ecology44137143
- 65. Rispe C, Moran NA (2000) Accumulation of deleterious mutations in endosymbionts: Muller's ratchet with two levels of selection. The American Naturalist 156: 425–441.C. RispeNA Moran2000Accumulation of deleterious mutations in endosymbionts: Muller's ratchet with two levels of selection.The American Naturalist156425441
- 66. Moran NA (1996) Accelerated evolution and Muller's rachet in endosymbiotic bacteria. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 93: 2873–2878.NA Moran1996Accelerated evolution and Muller's rachet in endosymbiotic bacteria.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences9328732878
- 67. Peek AS, Vrijenhoek RC, Gaut BS (1998) Accelerated evolutionary rate in sulfur-oxidizing endosymbiotic bacteria associated with the mode of symbiont transmission. Molecular Biology and Evolution 15: 1514–1523.AS PeekRC VrijenhoekBS Gaut1998Accelerated evolutionary rate in sulfur-oxidizing endosymbiotic bacteria associated with the mode of symbiont transmission.Molecular Biology and Evolution1515141523
- 68. Buchner P (1965) Endosymbiosis of animals with plant microorganisms. New York: Interscience Publishers. 909 p.P. Buchner1965Endosymbiosis of animals with plant microorganismsNew YorkInterscience Publishers909