In 2007, part of a drinking water distribution system was accidentally contaminated with waste water effluent causing a gastroenteritis outbreak in a Finnish town.
We examined the acute and cumulative effects of this incidence on sick leaves among public sector employees residing in the clean and contaminated areas, and the additional costs of lost workdays due to the incidence.
Daily information on sick leaves of 1789 Finnish Public Sector Study participants was obtained from employers' registers. Global Positioning System-coordinates were used for linking participants to the clean and contaminated areas. Prevalence ratios (PR) for weekly sickness absences were calculated using binomial regression analysis. Calculations for the costs were based on prior studies.
Among those living in the contaminated areas, the prevalence of participants on sick leave was 3.54 (95% confidence interval (CI) 2.97–4.22) times higher on the week following the incidence compared to the reference period. Those living and working in the clean area were basically not affected, the corresponding PR for sick leaves was 1.12, 95% CI 0.73–1.73. No cumulative effects on sick leaves were observed among the exposed. The estimated additional costs of lost workdays due to the incidence were 1.8–2.1 million euros.
The prevalence of sickness absences among public sector employees residing in affected areas increased shortly after drinking water distribution system was contaminated, but no long-term effects were observed. The estimated costs of lost workdays were remarkable, thus, the cost-benefits of better monitoring systems for the water distribution systems should be evaluated.
Citation: Halonen JI, Kivimäki M, Oksanen T, Virtanen P, Virtanen MJ, Pentti J, et al. (2012) Waterborne Outbreak of Gastroenteritis: Effects on Sick Leaves and Cost of Lost Workdays. PLoS ONE 7(3): e33307. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0033307
Editor: Qamaruddin Nizami, Aga Khan University, Pakistan
Received: November 21, 2011; Accepted: February 6, 2012; Published: March 19, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Halonen et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was funded by the Academy of Finland (projects 124271, 124322, 129262, and 132944). Mika Kivimäki is supported by the BUPA Foundation, UK; and the New OSH ERA research programme. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Regardless of the developed systems for drinking water purification and distribution, and the active legislation towards safe water , microbial contamination of drinking water and waterborne infections keep occurring also in developed societies , , , , , , . Large populations may become affected if public water systems are contaminated. These incidences may be due to system deficiencies, improper water treatment or contamination of one part of, or the whole, water supply , , . In most developed countries with public water distribution systems, however, rapid actions for managing the incidences can be taken to limit the harms; clean water can often be provided by temporary arrangements and the distribution systems can be disinfected. Severities of the waterborne outbreaks are often evaluated by calculating excess cases or risk rates for morbidity among the exposed , , . However, the effects of the waterborne infections on acute and cumulative sickness absences (Campylobacter, Salmonella and Giardia infections may also have long-term health effects , , , ) and the related costs of lost workdays have rarely been determined .
In late November 2007 part of the municipal drinking water system in a Finnish town Nokia, a municipality participating in the Finnish Public Sector Study, was contaminated with wastewater effluent (including Campylobacter sp., Norovirus, Giardia, and Salmonella sp.) causing an outbreak of gastroenteritis . In this study, we determined how this epidemic affected the sick leaves immediately and in the following year among employees of the Public Sector Study cohort who resided in Nokia. We hypothesized that employees living in the contaminated areas would be more affected than those living in the non-contaminated “clean” areas. We also estimated the additional costs of lost workdays for all branches of industry during the acute phase of the epidemic.
All the register data obtained from the national registers were based on the legal permissions granted by institutes maintaining these registers, and data were analyzed anonymously. According to Finnish Personal Data Act (523/1999, Chapter 4, Section 14) , written consent was not needed for research that uses register data. The Coordinating Ethics Committee of Helsinki and Uusimaa Hospital District has approved the study.
The Finnish Public Sector Study cohort consists of employees working for 10 municipalities (including Nokia and neighbouring town Tampere) and 21 hospitals (including Tampere University Hospital). All men and women employed by these organizations for more than six months in any year between 1991 and 2005 were eligible for the cohort (n = 151 618). Of this cohort, 1789 members were employed and resided in Nokia during the outbreak (weeks 48/2007–8/2008 referred to as week of outbreak = 0, and weeks after +1, +2, etc. up to week +12) and formed the analytic sample of this study. Because in Finland female-dominated occupations are common in the public sector (nurses, kindergarten teachers, cleaners etc.) a majority of the study population were women. All information about cohort members' job contracts, age, sex and sick leaves was obtained from the employers' registers. For each day we obtained data on all sick leaves (due to own illness), and sick-child leaves (due to illness of a child <10 years), however, diagnoses for the illnesses were not available as they are not recorded by the employers. Sick days (up to 60 days) and sick-child days (allowed absence up to four days at one time) are paid by the employer and, thus, carefully recorded. Residential addresses of the cohort members and Global Positioning System (GPS)-coordinates of these addresses were obtained from Population Register Center. Coordinates of the buildings alongside the contaminated water line were in the National Institute for Health and Welfare. Using these coordinates the cohort members' residences we linked to the buildings to which contaminated drinking water was distributed. The locations of cohort participants' residences in relation to areas where contaminated and clean drinking water were supplied are shown in Figure 1.
Dots in the inner pattern represent cohort participants' residences receiving contaminated water.
The incidence has been described in detail previously . In short, during maintenance work at the Nokia wastewater plant on November 28th 2007 (week 0) a valve connecting wastewater effluent line and drinking water line was accidentally opened, and in some areas inhabitants started to receive contaminated municipal drinking water (referred to as contaminated areas: inner pattern in Figure 1). This area was approximately 18 km2 in size (whole town 347 km2), and defined based on the addresses and GPS-coordinates of the buildings along the branch of the contaminated distribution system. Two days later, an increase in the number of patients with symptoms of gastroenteritis was observed at the local health care center. An estimated 450 m3 of wastewater effluent had been mixed to the drinking water and distributed to the customers, until the water contamination was realized. Recommendation for boiling tap water was issued the same day, clean water distribution organized by municipal officials, the military, and volunteers was started, as well as increased chlorination of the distribution system. After the incident schools and day care centres were closed due to Christmas holiday on weeks +4 and +5. The last restrictions in water use were canceled on February 18th 2008 (week +12).
We calculated the weekly prevalence of study population taking at least one sick day or sick-child day during each week for seven weeks before, during, and 12 weeks after the incidence, separately for those living in the contaminated and clean areas. For contaminated and clean areas cumulative sick days per person year were also calculated for the 52 weeks following the incidence. This was because there is evidence of long-term health effects of Campylobacter infections (rheumatological complaints, symptoms of arthritis, inflammatory bowel disease) , , , Giardia infections (functional gastrointestinal diseases) , and Salmonella infections (inflammatory bowel disease) .
We calculated the prevalence ratios (PR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) for weekly sickness absences using log-binomial regression analyses with GENMOD procedure of SAS , adjusting for age and sex. The reference period used in the analyses was the mean weekly prevalence of participants taking at least one sick day during the seven weeks prior to the incidence (weeks −7 to −1). The same method was used for the subgroup analyses of the cohort members consisting of those employed by schools and day care centers (n = 361). For them, the data included the location of their residence and workplace, and information of whether these were in the contaminated or clean area. Thus, we could estimate more explicitly the role of clean and contaminated areas in the sickness absences.
The additional cost of lost workdays on weeks 0 to +3 was estimated for the total number of employees residing in Nokia based on the number of additional (compared to reference period) personal and sick-child days per person among the cohort participants. The costs were estimated at 280 and 330 euros per day; the mean estimated costs of sickness absence for the service sector (200–250 €/day), industry (300–350 €/day)  and government employees (340–380 €/day)  in Finland. Of the total workforce in Nokia in 2007 (n = 10,719), 30% was employed by the government and 32% by industry. These estimations considered the contamination status of the residential area, and were calculated by sex (n of employed women in town = 5020, n of employed men in town = 5699) because the sex distribution of the analytic sample was skewed and women generally have higher rates of sick leaves than men .
The total population in Nokia was 30 016 of which 9538 (32%) lived in the area of contaminated water distribution system. Correspondingly, of the 1789 cohort members 586 (33%) lived in the contaminated area. Of the study population 1419 (79.5%) were women, and the mean age was 45.9 years (standard deviation 9.4). The number of cohort members who worked at schools and day care centers in Nokia was 361, of which 174 lived and worked in the clean area, and 187 lived or worked, or both, in the contaminated area.
Sick leaves increased sharply after the contamination among those who lived in the contaminated area, but not among those living in the clean area for whom the prevalence returned back to the pre-incident level in three weeks (Figure 2). The prevalence of cohort members taking at least one sick day during the week immediately after the contamination (week +1) was 35%, whereas in the week before the contamination the corresponding figure was 10% (week −1). The prevalence of participants at sick-child leave also peaked in the contaminated area on week +1, being 4.3%, whereas the week before (week −1) the level was 1.3% (data not shown). The cumulative number of sick days grew at a faster rate during the first post-incident weeks among those who lived in the contaminated compared to clean area (Figure 3). However, later the curves for cumulative sick days developed similarly for the exposed and non-exposed and by the end of the year the difference had disappeared.
Percentages are given by the contamination status of the participants' residence.
Compared to the reference period, the proportion of participants at sick leave in the contaminated area was the highest on the week following the incidence after which the prevalence ratio decreased gradually (Table 1). A slight increase in the sick leaves was observed also among those living in the clean area with the highest prevalence ratio for week +1. In the subgroup of personnel of schools and day care centers, we found that for those living and working in clean areas, the prevalence ratios for sick leaves remained at the same level after, compared to prior, the contamination (Table 2).
For the cost estimations we calculated weekly additional sick days (compared to the reference period) in this study population. For the clean and contaminated areas, the sum of additional sick days per person on weeks 0 to +3 was 0.71 for women and 0.42 for men. Thus, the estimated auxiliary cost of lost workdays due to sick leaves among all employees residing in Nokia were 1.00–1.18 and 0.67–0.80 million euros for women and men, respectively. Similarly, the sum of additional sick-child days per person were 0.07 and 0.02, and the estimated cost of lost workdays 0.11–0.13 and 0.03–0.04 million euros for women and men, respectively. These resulted in a total of 1.8–2.1 million euros from lost workdays due to own illness and illness of one's child(ren).
We studied the effect of microbial contamination of drinking water distribution system on sick leaves among public sector employees. Sick- and sick-child leaves were found to increase sharply after the contamination, and this increase was restricted to people either residing or working in the contaminated areas. However, 1-year accumulation of sick days was similar for exposed and unexposed suggesting the effects of the incidence were short-term. The estimated additional costs of lost workdays due to the incidence were 1.8–2.1 million euros.
Contaminations of water distribution systems in the scale of this study are rare, although some have been reported , , . As far as we are aware, the effects of these incidences on sick leaves have scarcely been studied. We found that those residing in the contaminated area were heavily affected, while those residing and working in the clean areas were unaffected. The peak in the proportion of participants at sick leave was observed during the week after the contamination, which is in agreement with the peak in the detected cases of gastroenteritis related to this incidence . This delay is also in line with other studies on waterborne outbreaks , .
For the following year, we found no difference in the sick leave accruals between those living in the contaminated and clean areas during the incidence. This suggests the acute epidemic had no residual effects at a population level. Supporting evidence has been reported in regard of occurrence of reactive arthritis in this study area half a year after the incidence . However, prior studies have shown that the effects of gastroenteritis from drinking water contaminated with Campylobacter may materialize later -with a delay of up to fifteen years- as increase in arthritis symptoms or inflammatory bowel disease , , , or in case of Giardia infection as functional gastrointestinal diseases . Thus, we cannot exclude the possibility that the exposed may still be at increased risk of developing chronic conditions.
We estimated that the excess costs due to sick leaves related to this incidence was 1.8–2.1 million euros, a remarkable part of the total expenditure of the whole incidence that reaches possibly five to six million euros. The other expenses include e.g. the distribution of clean water for the inhabitants, cleaning of the water distribution system, and overtime work of the town and water works employees. As in occupational health in general , cost-benefit analyses are needed to estimate whether actions such as online monitoring systems of the water distribution networks would be beneficial in preventing and limiting the magnitude of waterborne outbreaks and all harms related to them. We found that only one study, almost two decades ago, has estimated costs of a waterborne gastroenteritis outbreak. The authors concluded the outbreak affecting 2000–3000 people caused costs of 1.6 million Danish krones (∼215 000 euros in current exchange rate) . However, the algorithm of this estimate was not reported, and because of the long delay between studies the comparison of the costs is difficult. We also found that sick leaves and sick-child leaves were more common among women than men, a finding in line with prior research . Indeed, only a fourth of the costs of sick-child leaves were observed among men, which suggests that female-dominated sectors suffer considerably more from the illnesses of children than male-dominated sectors.
Major strengths of this study are the reliable and comprehensive records on the cohort members' sickness absences and information whether contaminated water was distributed to their residences. Additional information on the locations of workplaces for a sub-population of the cohort enabled us a more detailed examination of the differences in sick leaves between the exposed and non-exposed. One limitation of this study is that we could not determine the portion of the sick leaves that was actually related to the increase in infections of the digestive system because data on diagnoses were not available; however, it is unlikely that the observed short-term increase in the sick leaves is due to illnesses not related to the incidence. Because e.g. salaries and insurance costs vary by industry, we also emphasize that the calculations for the costs of sick leaves depend on the country and employer in question. Finally, due to differences in infrastructure and public services, the generalizability of these findings in less developed regions may be limited.
In summary, we have shown that the prevalence of sickness absences among public sector employees residing in affected areas increased considerably after drinking water distribution system was contaminated. The estimated costs of lost workdays were remarkable, thus, the cost-benefits of better monitoring systems for the water distribution systems should be evaluated.
The authors thank town of Nokia for providing the map of contaminated and clean areas to be used in this article.
Conceived and designed the experiments: JIH MK TO JP JV. Analyzed the data: JIH JP MJV. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MK JP MJV JV PV. Wrote the paper: JIH TO JV. Critically reviewed the article: MV MJV JP PV.
- 1. Zacheus O, Miettinen IT (2011) Increased information on waterborne outbreaks through efficient notification system enforces actions towards safe drinking water. J Water Health 9: 763–772.O. ZacheusIT Miettinen2011Increased information on waterborne outbreaks through efficient notification system enforces actions towards safe drinking water.J Water Health9763772
- 2. Yang Z, Wu X, Li T, Li M, Zhong Y, et al. (2011) Epidemiological survey and analysis on an outbreak of gastroenteritis due to water contamination. Biomed Environ Sci 24: 275–283.Z. YangX. WuT. LiM. LiY. Zhong2011Epidemiological survey and analysis on an outbreak of gastroenteritis due to water contamination.Biomed Environ Sci24275283
- 3. Craun GF, Brunkard JM, Yoder JS, Roberts VA, Carpenter J, et al. (2010) Causes of outbreaks associated with drinking water in the United States from 1971 to 2006. Clin Microbiol Rev 23: 507–528.GF CraunJM BrunkardJS YoderVA RobertsJ. Carpenter2010Causes of outbreaks associated with drinking water in the United States from 1971 to 2006.Clin Microbiol Rev23507528
- 4. Riera-Montes M, Brus Sjolander K, Allestam G, Hallin E, Hedlund KO, et al. (2011) Waterborne norovirus outbreak in a municipal drinking-water supply in Sweden. Epidemiol Infect 20: 1–8.M. Riera-MontesK. Brus SjolanderG. AllestamE. HallinKO Hedlund2011Waterborne norovirus outbreak in a municipal drinking-water supply in Sweden.Epidemiol Infect2018
- 5. Daly ER, Roy SJ, Blaney DD, Manning JS, Hill VR, et al. (2009) Outbreak of giardiasis associated with a community drinking-water source. Epidemiol Infect 138: 491–500.ER DalySJ RoyDD BlaneyJS ManningVR Hill2009Outbreak of giardiasis associated with a community drinking-water source.Epidemiol Infect138491500
- 6. Laine J, Huovinen E, Virtanen MJ, Snellman M, Lumio J, et al. (2010) An extensive gastroenteritis outbreak after drinking-water contamination by sewage effluent, Finland. Epidemiol Infect 15: 1–9.J. LaineE. HuovinenMJ VirtanenM. SnellmanJ. Lumio2010An extensive gastroenteritis outbreak after drinking-water contamination by sewage effluent, Finland.Epidemiol Infect1519
- 7. Brunkard JM, Ailes E, Roberts VA, Hill V, Hilborn ED, et al. (2011) Surveillance for waterborne disease outbreaks associated with drinking water—United States, 2007–2008. MMWR Surveill Summ 60: 38–68.JM BrunkardE. AilesVA RobertsV. HillED Hilborn2011Surveillance for waterborne disease outbreaks associated with drinking water—United States, 2007–2008.MMWR Surveill Summ603868
- 8. Breitenmoser A, Fretz R, Schmid J, Besl A, Etter R (2011) Outbreak of acute gastroenteritis due to a washwater-contaminated water supply, Switzerland, 2008. J Water Health 9: 569–576.A. BreitenmoserR. FretzJ. SchmidA. BeslR. Etter2011Outbreak of acute gastroenteritis due to a washwater-contaminated water supply, Switzerland, 2008.J Water Health9569576
- 9. Locht H, Krogfelt KA (2002) Comparison of rheumatological and gastrointestinal symptoms after infection with Campylobacter jejuni/coli and enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli. Ann Rheum Dis 61: 448–452.H. LochtKA Krogfelt2002Comparison of rheumatological and gastrointestinal symptoms after infection with Campylobacter jejuni/coli and enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli.Ann Rheum Dis61448452
- 10. Garg AX, Pope JE, Thiessen-Philbrook H, Clark WF, Ouimet J (2008) Arthritis risk after acute bacterial gastroenteritis. Rheumatology (Oxford) 47: 200–204.AX GargJE PopeH. Thiessen-PhilbrookWF ClarkJ. Ouimet2008Arthritis risk after acute bacterial gastroenteritis.Rheumatology (Oxford)47200204
- 11. Mann EA, Saeed SA (2012) Gastrointestinal infection as a trigger for inflammatory bowel disease. Curr Opin Gastroenterol 28: 24–29.EA MannSA Saeed2012Gastrointestinal infection as a trigger for inflammatory bowel disease.Curr Opin Gastroenterol282429
- 12. Hanevik K, Dizdar V, Langeland N, Hausken T (2009) Development of functional gastrointestinal disorders after Giardia lamblia infection. BMC Gastroenterol 9: 27.K. HanevikV. DizdarN. LangelandT. Hausken2009Development of functional gastrointestinal disorders after Giardia lamblia infection.BMC Gastroenterol927
- 13. Laursen E, Mygind O, Rasmussen B, Ronne T (1994) Gastroenteritis: a waterborne outbreak affecting 1600 people in a small Danish town. J Epidemiol Community Health 48: 453–458.E. LaursenO. MygindB. RasmussenT. Ronne1994Gastroenteritis: a waterborne outbreak affecting 1600 people in a small Danish town.J Epidemiol Community Health48453458
- 14. Finnish Ministry of Justice (1999) Personal Data Act (523/1999). Finnish Ministry of Justice1999Personal Data Act (523/1999).Available: http://www.finlex.fi/en/laki/kaannokset/1999/en19990523.pdf. Accessed 2012 15 Feb. Available: http://www.finlex.fi/en/laki/kaannokset/1999/en19990523.pdf. Accessed 2012 15 Feb.
- 15. Gradel KO, Nielsen HL, Schonheyder HC, Ejlertsen T, Kristensen B, et al. (2009) Increased short- and long-term risk of inflammatory bowel disease after salmonella or campylobacter gastroenteritis. Gastroenterology 137: 495–501.KO GradelHL NielsenHC SchonheyderT. EjlertsenB. Kristensen2009Increased short- and long-term risk of inflammatory bowel disease after salmonella or campylobacter gastroenteritis.Gastroenterology137495501
- 16. Spiegelman D, Hertzmark E (2005) Easy SAS calculations for risk or prevalence ratios and differences. Am J Epidemiol 162: 199–200.D. SpiegelmanE. Hertzmark2005Easy SAS calculations for risk or prevalence ratios and differences.Am J Epidemiol162199200
- 17. Pohjola Pankki Oyj, (Company offering bank and insurance services) Sairauspoissaolokustannus [Sick leave costs]. Pohjola Pankki Oyj, (Company offering bank and insurance services) Sairauspoissaolokustannus [Sick leave costs].Available: https://www.pohjola.fi/pohjola/yritys-ja-yhteisoasiakkaat/vakuutukset/vakuutustuotteet/henkilovakuutukset/sairauspoissaolokustannukset?id=321811&srcpl=4. Accessed 2012 16 Jan. Available: https://www.pohjola.fi/pohjola/yritys-ja-yhteisoasiakkaat/vakuutukset/vakuutustuotteet/henkilovakuutukset/sairauspoissaolokustannukset?id=321811&srcpl=4. Accessed 2012 16 Jan.
- 18. Lehtonen V Miten hallita sairauspoissaoloja? [in Finnish]. Lehtonen V Miten hallita sairauspoissaoloja? [in Finnish].Available: http://www.vm.fi/vm/fi/04_julkaisut_ja_asiakirjat/01_julkaisut/06_valtion_tyomarkkinalaitos/miten_hallita_sairauspoissaoloja.pdf. Accessed 2011 15 Nov. Helsinki: Valtiovarainministeriö [Ministry of finance]. Available: http://www.vm.fi/vm/fi/04_julkaisut_ja_asiakirjat/01_julkaisut/06_valtion_tyomarkkinalaitos/miten_hallita_sairauspoissaoloja.pdf. Accessed 2011 15 Nov. Helsinki: Valtiovarainministeriö [Ministry of finance].
- 19. Bekker MH, Rutte CG, van Rijswijk K (2009) Sickness absence: A gender-focused review. Psychol Health Med 14: 405–418.MH BekkerCG RutteK. van Rijswijk2009Sickness absence: A gender-focused review.Psychol Health Med14405418
- 20. Koroglu M, Yakupogullari Y, Otlu B, Ozturk S, Ozden M, et al. (2011) A waterborne outbreak of epidemic diarrhea due to group A rotavirus in Malatya, Turkey. New Microbiol 34: 17–24.M. KorogluY. YakupogullariB. OtluS. OzturkM. Ozden2011A waterborne outbreak of epidemic diarrhea due to group A rotavirus in Malatya, Turkey.New Microbiol341724
- 21. Auld H, MacIver D, Klaassen J (2004) Heavy rainfall and waterborne disease outbreaks: the Walkerton example. J Toxicol Environ Health A 67: 1879–1887.H. AuldD. MacIverJ. Klaassen2004Heavy rainfall and waterborne disease outbreaks: the Walkerton example.J Toxicol Environ Health A6718791887
- 22. Public Health Agency of Canada (2000) Waterborne outbreak of gastroenteritis associated with a contaminated municipal water supply, Walkerton, Ontario, May–June 2000. Can Commun Dis Rep 26: 170–173.Public Health Agency of Canada2000Waterborne outbreak of gastroenteritis associated with a contaminated municipal water supply, Walkerton, Ontario, May–June 2000.Can Commun Dis Rep26170173
- 23. Uotila T, Antonen J, Laine J, Kujansuu E, Haapala AM, et al. (2011) Reactive arthritis in a population exposed to an extensive waterborne gastroenteritis outbreak after sewage contamination in Pirkanmaa, Finland. Scand J Rheumatol 40: 358–362.T. UotilaJ. AntonenJ. LaineE. KujansuuAM Haapala2011Reactive arthritis in a population exposed to an extensive waterborne gastroenteritis outbreak after sewage contamination in Pirkanmaa, Finland.Scand J Rheumatol40358362
- 24. Bremell T, Bjelle A, Svedhem A (1991) Rheumatic symptoms following an outbreak of campylobacter enteritis: a five year follow up. Ann Rheum Dis 50: 934–938.T. BremellA. BjelleA. Svedhem1991Rheumatic symptoms following an outbreak of campylobacter enteritis: a five year follow up.Ann Rheum Dis50934938
- 25. Burdorf A (2011) Do costs matter in occupational health? Occup Environ Med 68: 707–708.A. Burdorf2011Do costs matter in occupational health?Occup Environ Med68707708