Human PITX2 mutations are associated with Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome, an autosomal-dominant developmental disorder that involves ocular anterior segment defects, dental hypoplasia, craniofacial dysmorphism and umbilical abnormalities. Characterization of the PITX2 pathway and identification of the mechanisms underlying the anomalies associated with PITX2 deficiency is important for better understanding of normal development and disease; studies of pitx2 function in animal models can facilitate these analyses. A knockdown of pitx2 in zebrafish was generated using a morpholino that targeted all known alternative transcripts of the pitx2 gene; morphant embryos generated with the pitx2ex4/5 splicing-blocking oligomer produced abnormal transcripts predicted to encode truncated pitx2 proteins lacking the third (recognition) helix of the DNA-binding homeodomain. The morphological phenotype of pitx2ex4/5 morphants included small head and eyes, jaw abnormalities and pericardial edema; lethality was observed at ∼6–8-dpf. Cartilage staining revealed a reduction in size and an abnormal shape/position of the elements of the mandibular and hyoid pharyngeal arches; the ceratobranchial arches were also decreased in size. Histological and marker analyses of the misshapen eyes of the pitx2ex4/5 morphants identified anterior segment dysgenesis and disordered hyaloid vasculature. In summary, we demonstrate that pitx2 is essential for proper eye and craniofacial development in zebrafish and, therefore, that PITX2/pitx2 function is conserved in vertebrates.
Citation: Liu Y, Semina EV (2012) pitx2 Deficiency Results in Abnormal Ocular and Craniofacial Development in Zebrafish. PLoS ONE 7(1): e30896. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0030896
Editor: Domingos Henrique, Instituto de Medicina Molecular, Portugal
Received: August 22, 2011; Accepted: December 23, 2011; Published: January 27, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Liu, Semina. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health award EY015518 (EVS). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
PITX2 is a member of the bicoid-like homeodomain transcription factor family which, when mutated, is responsible for Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome (MIM ID #180500), an autosomal-dominant developmental disorder characterized by ocular anterior chamber anomalies, increased risk for glaucoma, dental hypoplasia, craniofacial dysmorphism and umbilical region abnormalities .
The majority of PITX2 mutations are located in the homeobox region encoding the homeodomain and affect all known PITX2 isoforms (see below). These mutations typically generate a null-allele, which supports PITX2 haploinsufficiency as a mechanism for Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome, consistent with reports of gene deletion in some patients; PITX2 mutations that appear to retain limited wild-type activities are usually associated with milder phenotypes . Identification of increased transactivation activity of two mutant PITX2 proteins associated with human disease suggests that elevated PITX2 activity may also be disruptive , . Expression studies demonstrate that Pitx2 is expressed in neural-crest derived cells that contribute to the ocular and craniofacial tissues affected in Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome , as well as during brain, heart, lung, stomach, gut and gonad development –.
Several PITX2 isoforms have been reported with four transcripts, PITX2A-D, identified in humans , three, Pitx2a–c, in mice and frogs  and two, pitx2a and pitx2c, described in chickens , zebrafish  and even ascidians ; the isoforms have different N-terminal sequences but share exons encoding for the homeodomain and C-terminal region. Although some variations were observed, the Pitx2 isoforms demonstrate largely overlapping expression patterns –, ; similarly, functional assays demonstrate comparable DNA-binding and transactivation activities for the main isoforms with minor differences revealed under certain conditions , .
In the mouse, complete knockout of Pitx2 results in embryonic lethality and ocular, craniofacial, dental, brain, heart, lung, body wall and other systemic defects; various conditional Pitx2-deficient animals were generated to study specific aspects of its function , , , , –. Ocular anomalies are observed in the Pitx2−/− homozygous but not in Pitx2+/− heterozygous animals and include arrest in anterior segment development, thickening of the mesothelial layer of the cornea resulting in enophthalmos, dysgenesis of the extraocular muscle and other defects. In terms of craniofacial anomalies, Pitx2−/− animals display arrested tooth development at the placode (for maxillary teeth) or bud (for mandibular teeth) stage. The combination of ocular and craniofacial defects observed in Pitx2-deficient mice shows similarity to Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome in humans, suggesting conservation of function for this gene during embryonic development.
Zebrafish offer several advantages compared to mammalian models including rapid early development, optical clarity, availability of gene manipulation techniques (including the recently developed gene knockout technnology via zinc-finger nucleases), and large number of progeny, therefore providing powerful genetic screening opportunities , . Zebrafish have been utilized to demonstrate the effects of pitx2 misexpression on heart development ,  but the overall effects of pitx2-deficiency in zebrafish have not yet been fully investigated. In this manuscript, we demonstrate that the function of pitx2 is conserved in vertebrates and that zebrafish pitx2 is essential for proper eye and craniofacial development.
Materials and Methods
Zebrafish (Danio rerio) adult fish were maintained on a 14-hour light/ 10-hour dark cycle in system water; the embryos were acquired by natural spawning and kept at 28.5°C. The developmental stage was determined by time (hours post fertilization (hpf) or days post fertilization (dpf)) as well as by morphological criteria . The Tg (fli1:gfp), Tg (gsnl1:gfp) and p53−/− zebrafish lines used in this study have been previously described –.
The study was carried out in accordance with the recommendations in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the National Institutes of Health. The protocol was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the Medical College of Wisconsin (protocol number AUA00000352).
In situ hybridization
Plasmids for dlx2a, dlx4a, foxd3 and lmx1b were obtained from Open Biosystems (Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc, Huntsville, AL ); pax6a was kindly shared by Dr. Link (Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI); pitx3 probe have been previously described ; pitx2-exon 5, foxc1a and dkk2 plasmids were constructed by PCR amplification and cloned into pCRII-TOPO vector (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) using with the following primers: zf-pitx2ac-1345f, 5′-CGAAGATTCGAACGATGACC-3′ and zf-pitx2ac-1345r, 5′-TGGGATGTTGAAAAACGAAA-3′ (to produce a 1345-bp probe that detects both pitx2 isoforms); zf-foxc1a-273F and 5′-GAAACCCCCGTACAGCTACA-3′, zf-foxc1a-273R, 5′-AAAAAGCTGCCGTTCTCAAA-3′ (to produce a 273-bp probe); zf_dkk2_ex1f503, 5′- CACACTGGCAGAGGAGATCA and zf-dkk2_ex3r503: TCTGCTGTGGTTTTGACAGG (to produce a 503-bp probe). Digoxigenin-labeled RNA probes were synthesized by in vitro transcription and in situ hybridization was performed as previously described .
Morpholino oligonucleotides were synthesized by Gene Tools (Gene Tools, Philomath, OR). Antisense morpholino oligonucleotides were designed to target translation initiation sites of the pitx2a, 5′-CAAGTTTGCGGCAGTGGGAGTCCAT-3′ (pitx2aATG), and pitx2c, CCTTCATAGAGGTCATGGATAAGAC (pitx2cATG), isoforms as well as the pitx2 exon 4 donor site, 5′-TTTATCAAACTTACTCGGACTCTGG-3′ (pitx2ex4/5), and a standard control morpholino, 5′-CCTCTTACCTCAgTTACAATTTATA-3′ (control-MO), was used. The morpholinos were solubilized in water and diluted to 300–500 µM with 0.1% phenol red for microinjections into embryos. The morpholino oligomers (4–14 ng) were injected into 1–4 cell-stage embryos as previously described . The efficacy of morpholino injections was evaluated by semi-quantitative RT-PCR using RNA extracted from injected embryos.
Nucleic acid extractions and amplification
RNA was extracted using zebrafish embryos harvested in Trizol reagent (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) and standard procedures. cDNA was synthesized from 1 µg of total RNA with SuperScript III (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) and random hexamers. Semi-quantitative PCR was performed using cDNA prepared from whole embryos, uninjected wild-type, pitx2ex4/5 and control-MO injected embryos, and using two sets of pitx2 primers (a combination of pitx2 primers 1 and 3 (499-bp product) and a combination of primers 2 and 3 (637-bp product to amplify isoforms pitx2a and pitx2c, respectively) and a control set of primers for β-actin (329-bp product). Oligonucleotide sequences are as follows: pitx2 forward primer 1 (zpitx2aF): 5′-AAGACTGGCACGGCTGCAAA-3′, pitx2 forward primer 2 (zpitx2cF): 5′-CGTCGGTAAATCGCTTGTCT-3′ and pitx2 reverse primer 3 (zpitx2-R): 5′-AACTTGATCCTGGTACACCG-3′, and control forward and reverse primers: β-actin-F, 5′-GAGAAGATCTGGCATCACAC-3′, β-actin-R, 5′- ATCAGGTAGTCTGTCAGGTC-3′. The DNA sequence of PCR products was determined by direct automated DNA sequencing. DNA sequencing was performed to confirm the identity of PCR products by comparison with database records; no novel sequences are reported.
Histological analysis, alcian blue and alkaline phosphatase staining
Histological analysis was performed using standard protocols. Briefly, embryos were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde at 4°C, washed three times in PBS (pH 7.4), dehydrated in ascending grades of ethyl alcohol (25%, 50%, 75%, 100%) and infiltrated overnight in the dark at 4°C. The embryos were placed in a molding cup tray capped by an EBH-2 Block Holder (Electron Microscopy Sciences, West Chester, PA), embedded in a fresh mixture of embedding solution and polymerized at 4°C overnight according to the manufacturer's directions. Polymerized blocks were cut at 1–2 mm using a Leica RM2255 microtome (Leica Microsystems, Vienna, Austria) with glass knives made from 7.0 mm glass strips on a Leica EMKMR2 Knifemaker (LeicaMicrosystems, Vienna, Austria); sections were collected onto charged glass slides and dried on the heater at 150°C. Hematoxylin and eosin staining was performed using standard protocols. Alcian blue staining was performed according to Barrallo-Gimeno et al. ; cartilage elements were identified as previously described . The alkaline phosphatase staining of hyaloid vessels was performed according to Alvarez et al. . Images were obtained using an AxioImager Zeiss microscope (Zeiss, Thornwood, NY).
Immunohistochemistry was performed with the following primary serum: mouse anti-Keratin Sulfate Proteoglycan antibody (Chemicon International, Temecula, CA), mouse anti-Keratan sulfate monoclonal antibody (Millipore, Billerica, MA), rabbit anti-crystallin αA and βB1 antibodies (a generous gift from Dr. Thomas C. Vihtelic); and the following secondary antibodies, Alexa Fluor 568 donkey anti-mouse IgG (H+L) (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA), Alexa Fluor 488 donkey anti-rabbit IgG (H+L) (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) and FITC conjugated Affinipure donkey anti-mouse IgG (H+L) (Jackson Immuno Research Laboratories Inc, West Grove, PA). Embryos were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde/PBS and infiltrated with 30% sucrose and then OCT, embedded in cryomolds and frozen. 7-µm sections were prepared, mounted on charged glass slides and dehydrated for 30 min at 37°C. Sections were incubated in blocking solution (1× PBS/10% normal donkey serum /0.1% Tween 20) for 1 hour at room temperature and then overnight at 4°C in primary antibody/blocking solution. The sections were washed in 1× PBS/0.1% Tween 20 and incubated for 1 hour at room temperature in blocking solution and then exposed to secondary antibody. Immunoreactivity was captured with a AxioImager Zeiss microscope (Zeiss, Thornwood, NY).
Generation of a complete knockdown of pitx2 in zebrafish by blocking translation or mRNA splicing
The zebrafish pitx2 gene generates two transcripts, pitx2a and pitx2c, produced by alternative promoter usage similar to the human PITX2 gene ,  (Figure 1A). Both pitx2 transcripts are expressed embryonically at various sites including the developing pharyngeal arches, tissues surrounding the oral cavity and anterior segment of the eye , .
A. Schematic drawing of pitx2 genomic structure. Exons are shown as numbered boxes, sizes are indicated at the top (for exons) or at the bottom (for introns). The positions of primers to amplify pitx2 transcripts are shown and numbered 1–3; primers 1 and 3 are used for pitx2a and 2 and 3 for pitx2c. The position of antisense morpholino oligonucleotides, pitx2aATG, pitx2cATG and pitx2ex4/5sp, are shown with red lines. B. RT-PCR of pitx2 expression in pitx2ex4/5 morphants. Please note a complete absence of normal pitx2 transcripts (indicated with black arrows) and the presence of an abnormal large PCR product (indicated with red arrowheads) in mRNA extracted from pitx2ex4/5 embryos at 24–48-hpf, the presence of both normal (diminished) and abnormal products at 72–96-hpf pitx2ex4/5, and normal levels of pitx2 by 120-hpf due to weakening of morpholino effects. C. DNA sequencing of the abnormal PCR product observed in pitx2ex4/5 morphant embryos identified the presence of the 902-bp intron 4 in the pitx2ex4/5 transcript consistent with aberrant splicing (forward sequence is shown and the beginning of the intron is indicated with a red arrow; exon 4 sequence is shown in upper case while intron 4 is in lower case letters; the exon-intron junction sequence corresponding to the pitx2ex4/5 antisense oligomer is indicated in red). Therefore, the pitx2ex4/5 protein is predicted to contain partial pitx2 sequence (lacking amino acids encoded by exon 5) followed by 10 erroneous amino acids (pitx2ex4/5 stop codon is indicated with red box). D. Representative images of pitx2ex4/5 morphants, control morpholino-injected embryos and larvae developed from uninjected eggs at 48-hpf, 96-hpf and 7-dpf. E. Bar graph showing the distribution of observed embryonic phenotypes following pitx2ex4/5 morpholino injections into p53−/− and wild-type zebrafish eggs. e- eye, j- jaw, pe- pericardial edema.
To achieve a complete knockdown of pitx2, the following antisense morpholino oligomers were designed: pitx2aATG and pitx2cATG (targeting the translation initiation sites of the pitx2a and pitx2c isoforms, respectively) and pitx2ex4/5 (targeting the donor site of exon 4 and predicted to affect normal splicing of exons 4 and 5 that are common to both pitx2a and pitx2c transcripts and, therefore, to simultaneously knockdown both pitx2 isoforms) (Figure 1A). Injection of either a combination of pitx2aATG/pitx2cATG oligomers or the single pitx2ex4/5 morpholino resulted in an abnormal phenotype, described below. RT-PCR analysis of mRNA extracted from pitx2ex4/5 morphants identified an acute reduction (in embryos injected with 4.7 ng of pitx2ex4/5 morpholino) or a complete absence (in larvae injected with 7 ng of morpholino) of normal pitx2 transcripts along with the presence of an aberrant PCR product at 24–48-hpf (Figure 1B); the quantity of normal transcript continued to be significantly diminished in 72–96-hpf pitx2ex4/5 morphants and reached normal levels in 120-hpf embryos (Figure 1B). Sequence analysis of the aberrant RT-PCR product revealed the presence of a 902-bp fragment corresponding to intron 4 (Figure 1C). The abnormal transcript was predicted to encode truncated pitx2a and pitx2c proteins lacking the third (recognition) helix of the DNA-binding homeodomain with pitx2a sequence truncated at 92 amino acids (34% of normal length) and pitx2c at 137 amino acids (44% of normal length).
Knockdown of pitx2 disrupts embryonic development
Embryos injected with either a combination of pitx2aATG and pitx2cATG oligomers or a single pitx2ex4/5 morpholino demonstrated similar abnormal phenotypes, indicating an essential role for pitx2 in normal zebrafish development; pitx2ex4/5 morpholino was selected for further studies as it provided the ability to easily verify/quantify injection outcomes by RT-PCR (please see above; Figure 1B) and injection of this single oligomer was associated with higher efficiency and lower mortality rates.
Gross morphological comparison of pitx2ex4/5 morphant and control embryos was performed using 150–300 embryos in each experiment: at 24-hpf, the first embryos displaying smaller head, eyes and body length were detected with the number of abnormal embryos increasing sharply by 48-hpf; most of these embryos survived until 6–8-dpf and, in addition to the small eye, head, and trunk, displayed pericardial edema (starting at ∼60-hpf) and jaw abnormalities (from ∼72-hpf) (Figure 1D). Other phenotypic classes included severely malformed fish (displaying twisted shortened trunk, small malformed head, massive heart edema, and associated with lethality at ∼72-hpf in most fish), “curved body” fish, and embryos with normal appearance. The proportions of phenotypes were as follows: specific head and trunk and severe phenotypes were observed in 70–82% of pitx2ex4/5 morphants and not observed in embryos injected with control morpholino or uninjected larvae; the non-specific “curved body” phenotype was detected in ∼12% of pitx2ex4/5, 14–16% of control morpholino-injected larvae, and not observed in uninjected embryos; normal phenotype was seen in 6–16% of pitx2ex4/5 morphants, 84–86% of control morpholino-injected fish and ∼100% of uninjected embryos. Since the “curved body” fish were present at a similar rate in pitx2ex4/5 morphants and control embryos, this phenotype was classified as non-specific and further studies focused on morphants with specific head/trunk or severely malformed phenotypes.
To further investigate the specificity of the observed pitx2ex4/5 phenotypes, injections into p53-deficient zebrafish embryos were performed to identify features possibly associated with off-target effects which may accompany morpholino injections due to activation of p53-mediated apoptosis . The distribution of observed phenotypes following pitx2ex4/5 injections was similar at the 96-hpf stage while at 48-hpf a lower percentage of “curved body” (4% versus 12%) and severe phenotypes (4.3% versus 38.4%) was detected in p53−/− versus wild-type backgrounds (Figure 1E). These data suggest that both the “curved body” and severe phenotypes detected at earlier stages may be related to off-target effects of morpholino injections while the specific head and trunk phenotype observed at both earlier and later stages is caused by pitx2 deficiency. Further analyses of morphology, histology and alcian blue staining were performed using zebrafish that displayed the specific phenotype in wild-type and p53−/− backgrounds with no apparent difference in features observed in these two backgrounds.
pitx2 ex4/5sp morphants demonstrate craniofacial and ocular defects
To investigate the craniofacial and ocular anomalies associated with pitx2 deficiency, pitx2ex4/5 morphant and control embryos were assayed by alcian blue staining and histological analysis.
The cartilage elements of the pitx2ex4/5 pharyngeal arches were reduced in size, malformed and displaced (Figure 2A–H). This phenotype was clearly visible starting at 72-hpf; no noticeable abnormalities were detected in morphant embryos at earlier stages of development using morphological and histological analyses. The position of the palatoquadrate of the mandibular arch (or the first pharyngeal arch) appeared to be normal while the Meckel's cartilage component of the mandibular arch was positioned perpendicular to the palatoquadrate and pointing towards the upper jaw in 72-hpf embryos (Figure 2A–D). The ceratohyal cartilage of the hyoid arch (or the second pharyngeal arch) was positioned perpendicular to the upper jaw and pointing ventrally. The ceratobranchial arches 1 through 5 (pharyngeal arches 3–7) as well as the basihyal and basibranchial components of the pharyngeal arches appeared to be underdeveloped. At 120-hpf (Figure 2E–H), the mandibular and the hyoid pharyngeal arches were pointed ventrally, giving the appearance of an “open mouth”. In addition to this, a visible reduction in size and irregular shape of the elements of the mandibular arch (Meckel's and palatoquadrate cartilages) was noted. The ceratobranchial arches could be observed at this stage but were reduced in size. At the same time, the ethmoid plate cartilage of the upper jaw appeared to be largely unaffected. The described anomalies were observed in 100% of 72–120-hpf pitx2ex4/5 morphants (n = 35 (72–96-hpf), n = 20 (120-hpf) embryos).
A–H. pitx2 knockdown disrupts development of the pharyngeal arches. Lateral (A, B, E, F) and ventral (C, D, G, H) views of 72-hpf (A–D) and 120-hpf (E–H) larvae stained with Alcian blue. Numerous defects in the development of the lower jaw (anterior arches) and ceratobranchial (posterior) arches can be observed. I–T. pitx2 knockdown disrupts eye development. Representative images of histological sections of 72-hpf (I,J,O,P), 120-hpf (K,L,Q,R) and 8-dpf (M,N,S,T) control and pitx2ex4/5 morphants; head sections at the optic nerve level are shown (I–N) as well as high magnification images for the eye (O–T). Please note the accumulation of cells in the anterior segment in 72-hpf pitx2ex4/5 morphant embryos (arrowhead in P) and abnormal eye size/shape in 120-hpf and 8-dpf morphants (arrowheads in R, T). Abbreviations: A–H- bb,basibranchial; bh, basihyal; cb, ceratobranchial (P3–P7); ch, ceratohyal (P2); ep, ethmoid plate; hs, hyosympletic (P2); m, Meckel's cartilage (P1); pq, palatoquadrate (P1); I–T- ase, anterior segment of the eye; le, lens; on, optic nerve; re- retina.
Analysis of histological sections at the eye level revealed defects in ocular development in pitx2ex4/5 morphants (Figure 2I–T). At 72-hpf, the developing eye appeared to be largely unaffected with the exception of an increased number of cells observed in the anterior segment in some embryos (40%, n = 30; Figure 2I, J, O, P). At 120-hpf and 8-dpf, the pitx2ex4/5 eyes seemed small/misshapen and appeared to lack developed anterior segment region structures (93%, n = 30 (120-hpf) and 100%, n = 10 (8-dpf); Figure 2K–N and Q–T).
Since pitx2ex4/5 morphant embryos express abnormally spliced pitx2 transcript that includes exon 5, we were able to use the pitx2-exon 5 antisense riboprobe to detect cells with active pitx2 expression in morphant and control embryos and to compare these patterns: in early stage (24–48-hpf) pitx2ex4/5 embryos, we expected to primarily observe abnormal transcript while at later stages (72–120-hpf) we were likely to detect a mixture of abnormal and normal pitx2 transcripts due to weakening of the effects of morpholino in the maturing pitx2ex4/5 embryos. At 24-hpf, pitx2-positive cells were detected in morphants in a pattern similar to normal pitx2 expression in control embryos in the brain, developing pharyngeal arches and around the eye (Figure 3A–D). At 48-hpf, the overall pattern continued to be similar but increased pitx2 staining was observed in the anterior segment of the eye on sections (80% of morphants, n = 10; Figure 3E–I) and by 72-hpf, an abnormal accumulation/pattern of pitx2 positive cells was detected by both whole mount and section in situ hybridization (100% of morphants, n = 17; Figure 3J–P). Clusters of pitx2 positive cells in the anterior segment of the eye were seen as late as 120-hpf (100% of pitx2 ex4/5 embryos, n = 10; Figure 3Q–W); an increased staining behind the lens, in the developing hyaloid vasculature was also observed (Figure 3W). Similarly, robust expression of pitx2 in the craniofacial region of morphant embryos was observed at 72-hpf and 120-hpf in contrast to downregulation of normal pitx2 expression in control embryos (100% of morphants, n = 17 (72-hpf), n = 10 (120-hpf); Figure 3J–W).
The pitx2 antisense riboprobe comprising exon 5 sequence detects wild-type and abnormally spliced pitx2ex4/5 transcripts. Images of whole mount embryos (A–F, J–M and Q–U) and sections (G–I, N–P and V, W) are shown for embryonic stages of 24-hpf (A–D), 48-hpf (E–I), 72-hpf (J–P) and 120-hpf (Q–W). Please note abnormal pitx2 transcripts around the developing eye (arrowheads in B, D) and pharyngeal arches (arrows in B) in morphants at 24-hpf, which is similar to pitx2 expression in control embryos (A, C). Staining for pitx2 positive cells in morphant embryos at 48-, 72- and 120-hpf identifies abnormal patterns during ocular and craniofacial development in comparison to pitx2 expression in control embryos (E–W). In terms of ocular patterns, some 48- and 72-hpf morphants demonstrate an accumulation of pitx2 transcriptionally active cells in the anterior segment of the eye (arrowheads; images for whole mount and sections from two different pitx2ex4/5 morphant embryos at 48-hpf (F, H, I) and 72-hpf (K, M, O, P) in comparison to control 48-hpf (E,G) and 72-hpf (J, L, N) are shown). In 120-hpf eyes, a disorganized pattern of pitx2 positive cells continues to be observed in pitx2ex4/5 morphant embryos (arrowheads in T, U, two different morphant embryos are shown, and W) in comparison to pitx2 expression in control embryos (S, V); in addition to the abnormal pattern in the anterior structures, an increased signal behind the lens corresponding to the hyaloid vasculature is also observed (asterisks in W). With regards to craniofacial development, in 72-hpf morphant embryos, strong staining is observed around the malformed oral cavity and arches with the level of expression similar to control pitx2 expression (arrows in J–M); at 120-hpf, pitx2 transcripts continue to be strongly expressed in the malformed pharyngeal arches (arrows in R and W) while expression of wild-type pitx2 is downregulated in control 120-hpf embryos (arrows in Q and V).
Patterns of craniofacial and ocular gene expression are affected in pitx2ex4/5 morphants
In vertebrate embryos, the pharyngeal arches receive a significant contribution from the cranial neural crest cells that migrate into the craniofacial region. Forkhead transcription factor foxd3 is required for maintenance of neural crest population , , fli1 is expressed in neural crest derived lineages  and the distal-less homeobox gene family plays an important role in early as well as late stages of craniofacial development , . We analyzed expression of foxd3, dlx2a and dlx4a, and Tg(fli1:gfp) in pitx2ex4/5 morphants and control embryos and observed a number of differences.
Expression of foxd3 in 24-hpf pitx2ex4/5 embryos appeared to be mostly unaffected with similar levels of transcripts seen in the migrating neural crest cells marked with foxd3 (Figure 4A/A′ and B/B′); expression of dlx2a was similar in regions of the anterior (mandibular and hyoid) arches while slightly reduced levels were seen in the posterior (ceratobranchial) arches (n = 10; Figure 4C and C′). At 32-hpf, a decrease in signal associated with the posterior arches was clearly observed in ∼80% of morphant embryos based on expression of dlx2a, dlx4a and Tg(fli1:gfp) (n = 5–8; Figure 4D–G and D′–G′). By 48-hpf, an increased dlx2a staining in the dorsal domain of the anterior arches and reduction of staining in the posterior arches was observed in 92.5% of morphant embryos (n = 25; Figure 4H and H′). Expression of dlx4a in the developing pharyngeal arches and in the epithelia around the oral cavity at 48-hpf was also affected: expression in the posterior arches or anterior domain of the oral cavity was decreased while broader expression was detected in the anterior arches (65% of morphants, n = 17; Figure 4I–K and I′–K′). In 72-hpf control embryos, dlx4a expression was detected in the anterior arches that extend frontward as well as in the posterior arches, while lack of the anterior extension is observed in pitx2ex4/5 morphants with broad strong dlx4a expression continuing in this region in 83% of morphants (n = 23; Figure 4L–P and L′–P′).
Developmental patterns of foxd3, dlx2a and dlx4a, and Tg(fli1:gfp) expression in pitx2 ex4/5 embryos. In situ hybridization was performed with foxd3, dlx2a, dlx4a or gfp-specific antisense riboprobe in control (A–P) or morphant (A′–P′) zebrafish embryos. Please note similar expression patterns in migrating neural crest cells (foxd3) and pharyngeal arch primordial regions (dlx2a) at 24-hpf (arrows in control (A–C) and morphant (A′–C′) embryos). Starting at 32-hpf, expression of dlx2a, dlx4a and Tg(fli1:gfp) in the posterior arches appears to be reduced in pitx2ex4/5 fish (arrowheads in control (D–G) and morphant (D′–G′) embryos) while expression in the anterior arches (arrows in control (D–G) and morphant (D′–G′) embryos) is not significantly affected. In 48–72-hpf embryos, an increased expression of dlx4a in the anterior arches is detected (arrows in control (H–N) and morphant (H′–N′) embryos) while expression in the posterior arches remains reduced (arrowheads in control (H–N) and morphant (H′–N′) embryos); dlx4a expression around the oral cavity in 48-hpf embryos (arrow with asterisk in K and K′) as well as a frontward extension of the anterior arches at 72-hpf (arrows in L–N for controls and L′–N′ for morphants) are not observed in pitx2ex4/5 fish. Analysis of sections at 72-hpf also shows broadened expression of dlx4a in the craniofacial region of morphant embryos (O′, P′) in comparison to controls (O, P).
Expression of several ocular factors was also examined in pitx2ex4/5 morphants. This analysis included pax6a, a paired-box homeodomain transcription factor ; pitx3, another member of the pitx family that plays an active role in early lens development , ; dkk2, a zebrafish ortholog of mammalian Dkk2 that encodes an extracellular antagonist of canonical Wnt/ß-catenin signaling and is downstream of Pitx2 in the developing eye in mice ; corneal keratan sulfate proteoglycan that is highly expressed in the corneal stroma and represents an excellent cornea-specific differentiation marker , crystallins αA and βB1 that are expressed in the developing lens fibers ,  and Tg (gsnl1:gfp) that marks the developing annular ligament (analog of trabecular meshwork) in the iridocorneal angle of zebrafish eyes .
Expression of pax6a was detected in the retinal ganglion cells and inner nuclear layer neurons in pitx2ex4/5 morphant and control 100–120-hpf eyes (Figure 5A–D). Expression of pitx3 in the developing lens also seemed to be mostly unaffected, although morphant lenses appeared to be smaller than control lenses (n = 6; Figure 5E–H); in addition to the lens, pitx3 is expressed in the developing pharyngeal arches in a pattern similar to pitx2 and this expression continued to be observed in the abnormally developing craniofacial structures (Figure 5F and H).
In situ hybridization (A–L), double immunohistochemistry (M–P), live gfp fluorescence images (Q–V) and alkaline phosphatase staining (W, X) for control and morphant embryos are shown and are labeled with corresponding developmental stages in the lower right corner; dorsal (A, B, I, J) and ventral (E–H) views of a zebrafish larval head as well as transverse sections at the eye level (C, D, M–P), all positioned anterior to the top, and lateral views of an embryonic eye (K, L) or head (Q–V), positioned anterior to the left, are shown. Please note expression of pax6a in the developing retina of the control and morphant embryos (arrowheads in A–D); similar pitx3 expression in the developing lens in 48–72-hpf control and morphant embryos (arrowheads in E–H; abnormally developing pharyngeal arches and oral cavity in 48–72-hpf embryos are marked with arrows); reduced expression of dkk2 in the anterior segment of the pitx2 morphants (arrowheads in I–L); decreased/absent expression of corneal keratan sulfate proteoglycan (CKS) in the developing morphant corneas (red fluorescence, arrowheads in M–P) but similar expression of crystallins αA (green fluorescence, arrows in M, N) and βB1 (green fluorescence, arrows in O, P) in control and morphant lenses; and a decreased/absent expression of the Tg(gsnl1:gfp) transgene in the developing iridocorneal structures of pitx2ex4/5 morphants (arrowheads in R, T) in comparison to control embryos (Q, S). In addition to this, fluorescence (Tg(fli1:gfp) transgene) images (U, V) as well as alkaline phosphatase staining (W, X) demonstrate abnormal development of the hyaloid vasculature in pitx2ex4/5 morphants (arrowhead in V) in comparison to control embryos (U); increased number and disorganized appearance of pitx2ex4/5 hyaloid vessels (X) in comparison to controls (W) is revealed by alkaline phosphatase staining.
The most significant changes were detected in the expression of genes associated with the developing anterior segment structures. Analysis of dkk2 expression in pitx2ex4/5 morphants revealed a sharp reduction in the amount of dkk2 transcript in the anterior segment region at 72-hpf (67% of pitx2ex4/5 embryos; n = 12) (Figure 5I–L). Dual immunohistochemistry of keratan sulfate proteoglycan and crystallin (αA and βB1) in control and pitx2ex4/5 embryos at 96-hpf demonstrated normal expression for both crystallins in 100% of the pitx2ex4/5 lenses (n = 16) while highly reduced/absent staining for keratan sulfate proteoglycan was observed in 75% of pitx2ex4/5 corneal stroma (n = 16; Figure 5M–P). Examination of GFP expression in Tg (gsnl1:gfp) zebrafish embryos injected with control or pitx2ex4/5 morpholino identified clearly detectable patches of GFP positive cells in the iridocorneal angle and the developing annular ligament in 72–96-hpf eyes followed by strong expression in all 120-hpf control embryos (n = 10 for every stage) while a significant reduction (80%) or a complete absence (20%) of ocular GFP expression was observed in pitx2ex4/5 72–120-hpf morphants (n = 10) (Figure 5Q–T).
Finally, the development of the ocular vasculature in pitx2ex4/5 morphants was evaluated using the Tg(fli1:gfp) transgenic line ; in this line, the fli1 promoter drives the expression of green fluorescent protein (gfp) in all blood vessels throughout embryogenesis. In 100% of 72–120-hpf pitx2ex4/5 morphants, the ocular blood vessels appeared to be disorganized and misdirected based on fluorescence detection (n = 15; Figure 5U, V) and in situ analysis with the gfp probe (data not shown). To further investigate the hyaloid vasculature patterning in control and pitx2ex4/5 morphants, alkaline phosphatase staining was performed as described . Consistent with the Tg(fli1;gfp) data, pitx2ex4/5 hyaloid vessels demonstrated abnormal branching with extra interconnections, appeared to be thinner, were increased in number and attached loosely to the smaller lens in comparison to control lenses (Figure 5W, X). The size of the pitx2ex4/5 lens was measured and found to be significantly smaller than the control lens (p = 0.034 for 72-hpf and p = 0.007 for 120-hpf).
In this manuscript we describe the effects of pitx2 knockdown in zebrafish. The functional disruption generated with pitx2ex4/5 splice-blocking morpholino is highly similar to the effects of human PITX2 mutations, which are clustered in the homeodomain region of the protein with many of them resulting in truncation of normal PITX2 sequence and lack of the recognition helix of the homeodomain –. Deficiency of pitx2 led to a number of abnormalities in zebrafish including craniofacial and ocular defects consistent with the classic features of Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome. These data, together with the previously reported preservation of PITX2/pitx2 expression pattern and transcriptional regulation  suggests a high level of conservation of PITX2/pitx2 function in vertebrates.
The craniofacial abnormalities observed in pitx2ex4/5 morphants appear to be similar to what was reported in foxd3 and dlx mutants and morphants , . We observed no significant differences in the expression pattern of foxd3 in pitx2ex4/5 morphants; in general, expression of foxd3 appears to precede pitx2 expression in the pharyngeal arches' primordial region and, therefore, foxd3 may be acting upstream of pitx2 in the developmental pathway. PITX2 and DLX2 have been previously reported to be acting in the same pathway during tooth development in mammals; PITX2 was shown to bind to bicoid-like sites in the DLX2 promoter resulting in a 30-fold activation of reporter expression in transfected cells .
Ocular developmental phenotypes observed in pitx2ex4/5 zebrafish such as accumulation of pitx2-transcriptionally active cells in the front of the developing eye followed by lack of differentiation of anterior segment structures are highly similar to the features previously reported in Pitx2 knockout mice ,  and point to possible defects in migration patterns and differentiation of neural-crest derived periocular mesenchymal cells. The expression pattern of several ocular markers was found to be affected in pitx2ex4/5 morphants consistent with the abnormal development of anterior segment structures and overall ocular dysgenesis. In addition to anterior segment dysgenesis and vasculature defects in pitx2 deficient zebrafish, a misshapen and small retina and lens were observed. A small and misshapen eye/retina has been previously reported in Pitx2−/− deficient mice . At this point it is unclear whether pitx2 plays a direct role in the development of posterior ocular structures or if maldevelopment of the anterior segment and/or hyaloid vasculature affects the formation of other parts of the eye including the retina; the second possibility seems to be more likely since pitx2 is not expressed in the developing retina.
Zebrafish pitx2 deficiency was also found to result in an abnormal patterning of the hyaloid vasculature with an increased number of thin and disorganized vessels observed in the pitx2 ex4/5 morphant eyes. Recently, Rutland et al demonstrated that defects in the development of the hyaloid vasculature can lead to microphthalmia and lens anomalies in mice . A similar mechanism may be implicated in the small eye/lens phenotype observed in pitx2 deficient zebrafish reported here; the role of the hyaloid vasculature in normal development of various ocular structures needs to be investigated further. Previously, Evans and Gage  observed hypomorphic hyaloid vasculature in neural-crest-specific Pitx2 knockout mice: a reduced number of hyaloid vessels was observed in the developing mutant eye that was apparently associated with an inability of the Pitx2-negative pericytes to differentiate and stabilize the developing vessels. Abnormalities in human ocular vasculature development such as persistent fetal vasculature are often associated with anterior segment defects, cataracts, glaucoma, retinal detachment, nystagmus, microphthalmia, and other ocular anomalies –. Recently, a persistent hyaloid artery extending towards the fibrovascular tissue behind the lens was identified in a patient affected with Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome caused by a PITX2 mutation , further suggesting that human PITX2 may be involved in normal ocular vasculogenesis, similar to its vertebrate orthologs.
The hyaloid vasculature represents a transient intraocular system which is gradually lost during the late embryonic period with a complete regression in adults; the embryonic eye relies on the hyaloid vasculature to provide nourishment to its various developing structures , , . The mechanisms of hyaloid vasculogenesis and its subsequent regression are not yet well understood. Disorganized/ persistent hyaloid vasculature defects have also been previously reported in Bmp4 , plexin D1 , Cited2 , Lama1/lama1 , , norrie disease protein (Ndp) , Wnt7b  and Frizzled-5 ,  zebrafish or mouse mutants as well as in association with mutations in the human LAMB2 , NDP  and FRIZZLED-4  genes. Interestingly, Cited2 has been previously reported to directly control Pitx2c expression during cardiovascular development . Pitx2c expression in the left lateral plate mesoderm was absent in the Cited2(−/−) mice; Cited2 and Tfap2 were found to be bound to the Pitx2c promoter in embryonic heart tissues and to activate Pitx2c transcription in transient transfection assays. Therefore, it is possible that a similar pathway is acting during ocular vasculature development.
The Axenfeld-Rieger malformation spectrum represents a complex group of conditions showing significant intrafamilial and interfamilial variability , . Ocular abnormalities appear to be the most penetrant feature of PITX2-deficient phenotypes as even partial loss-of-function mutations can result in ocular manifestations , . The mechanisms of these ocular defects and, in particular, the developmental glaucoma seen in ∼50% of affected patients, are still unclear. Our manuscript introduces a zebrafish model of pitx2 deficiency and presents data that support conservation of pitx2 function in vertebrates. While our results are consistent with pitx2 playing an essential role in anterior segment development, other ocular anomalies observed in zebrafish suggest a broader role for pitx2/PITX2 in the developing eye, with potential implications to human disease, that needs to be investigated further. At the same time, the phenotype reported here is associated with a complete loss of normal pitx2 at early developmental stages while the human phenotype, Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome, is caused by PITX2 haploinsufficiency; it is still unclear whether permanent inactivation of one allele of pitx2 can lead to a zebrafish phenotype with relevance to human disease. Since morpholino technology offers a temporary and imprecise disruption of gene function, the development/identification of a permanent zebrafish line carrying a pitx2-inactivating mutation is needed to fully investigate this question. Zebrafish are increasingly being utilized for studies of disease mechanisms due to a number of advantages in comparison to mammalian systems , ; studies of pitx2-deficient zebrafish are likely to facilitate examination of the developmental roles of this important factor.
The authors would like to thank Nevin Mlodik and Rebecca C. Tyler for their help with manipulations involving zebrafish embryos and DNA sequencing, Sanaa Muheisen for assistance with immunohistochemistry and histology and Linda M. Reis for critical reading of the manuscript.
Conceived and designed the experiments: EVS. Performed the experiments: YL. Analyzed the data: YL EVS. Wrote the paper: YL EVS.
- 1. Semina EV, Reiter R, Leysens NJ, Alward WL, Small KW, et al. (1996) Cloning and characterization of a novel bicoid-related homeobox transcription factor gene, RIEG, involved in Rieger syndrome. Nat Genet 14(4): 392–399.
- 2. Tümer Z, Bach-Holm D (2009) Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome and spectrum of PITX2 and FOXC1 mutations. Eur J Hum Genet 17: 1527–1539.
- 3. Hjalt TA, Semina EV (2005) Current molecular understanding of Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome. Expert Rev Mol Med 7(25): 1–17.
- 4. Ryan AK, Blumberg B, Rodriguez-Esteban C, Yonei-Tamura S, Tamura K, et al. (1998) Pitx2 determines left-right asymmetry of internal organs in vertebrates. Nature 394(6693): 545–551.
- 5. Campione M, Steinbeisser H, Schweickert A, Deissler K, van Bebber F, et al. (1999) The homeobox gene Pitx2: mediator of asymmetric left-right signaling in vertebrate heart and gut looping. Development 126(6): 1225–1234.
- 6. Campione M, Ros MA, Icardo JM, Piedra E, Christoffels VM, et al. (2001) Pitx2 expression defines a left cardiac lineage of cells: evidence for atrial and ventricular molecular isomerism in the iv/iv mice. Dev Biol 231(1): 252–264.
- 7. Lin CR, Kioussi C, O'Connell S, Briata P, Szeto D, et al. (1999) Pitx2 regulates lung asymmetry, cardiac positioning and pituitary and tooth morphogenesis. Nature 401(6750): 279–282.
- 8. Kitamura K, Miura H, Miyagawa-Tomita S, Yanazawa M, Katoh-Fukui Y, et al. (1999) Mouse Pitx2 deficiency leads to anomalies of the ventral body wall, heart, exta- and periocular mesoderm and right pulmonary isomerism. Development 126(24): 5749–5758.
- 9. Bisgrove BW, Essner JJ, Yost HJ (2000) Multiple pathways in the midline regulate concordant brain, heart and gut left-right asymmetry. Development 127(16): 3567–3579.
- 10. Martin DM, Skidmore JM, Philips ST, Vieira C, Gage PJ, et al. (2004) PITX2 is required for normal development of neurons in the mouse subthalamic nucleus and midbrain. Dev Biol 267(1): 93–108.
- 11. Ishimaru Y, Komatsu T, Kasahara M, Katoh-Fukui Y, Ogawa H, et al. (2008) Mechanism of asymmetric ovarian development in chick embryos. Development 135(4): 677–685.
- 12. Cox CJ, Espinoza HM, McWilliams B, Chappell K, Morton L, et al. (2002) Differential regulation of gene expression by PITX2 isoforms. J Biol Chem 277(28): 25001–25010.
- 13. Schweickert A, Campione M, Steinbeisser H, Blum M (2000) Pitx2 isoforms: involvement of Pitx2c but not Pitx2a or Pitx2b in vertebrate left-right asymmetry. Mech Dev 90(1): 41–51.
- 14. Yu X, St Amand TR, Wang S, Li G, Zhang Y, et al. (2001) Differential expression and functional analysis of Pitx2 isoforms in regulation of heart looping in the chick. Development 128(6): 1005–1013.
- 15. Essner JJ, Branford WW, Zhang J, Yost HJ (2000) Mesendoderm and left-right brain, heart and gut development are differentially regulated by pitx2 isoforms. Development 127: 1081–1093.
- 16. Christiaen L, Bourrat F, Joly JS (2005) A modular cis-regulatory system controls isoform-specific pitx expression in ascidian stomodaeum. Dev Biol 277(2): 557–566.
- 17. Liu W, Selever J, Lu MF, Martin JF (2003) Genetic dissection of Pitx2 in craniofacial development uncovers new functions in branchial arch morphogenesis, late aspects of tooth morphogenesis and cell migration. Development 130: 6375–6385.
- 18. Toro R, Saadi I, Kuburas A, Nemer M, Russo AF (2004) Cell-specific activation of the atrial natriuretic factor promoter by PITX2 and MEF2A. J Biol Chem 279(50): 52087–52094.
- 19. Lu MF, Pressman C, Dyer R, Johnson RL, Martin JF (1999) Function of Rieger syndrome gene in left-right asymmetry and craniofacial development. Nature 401(6750): 276–278.
- 20. Gage PJ, Suh H, Camper SA (1999) Dosage requirement of Pitx2 for development of multiple organs. Development 126: 4643–4651.
- 21. Evans AL, Gage PJ (2005) Expression of the homeobox gene Pitx2 in neural crest is required for optic stalk and ocular anterior segment development. Hum Mol Genet 14(22): 3347–3359.
- 22. Ekker SC (2008) Zinc finger-based knockout punches for zebrafish genes. Zebrafish 5(2): 121–123.
- 23. Lieschke GJ, Currie PD (2007) Animal models of human disease: zebrafish swim into view. Nat Rev Genet 8(5): 353–367.
- 24. Kimmel CB, Ballard WW, Kimmel SR, Ullmann B, Schilling TF (1995) Stages of embryonic development of the zebrafish. Dev Dyn 203: 253–310.
- 25. Lawson ND, Weinstein BM (2002) In vivo imaging of embryonic vascular development using transgenic zebrafish. Dev Bio 248: 307–318.
- 26. Yoshikawa S, Norcom E, Nakamura H, Yee RW, Zhao XC (2007) Transgenic analysis of the anterior eye-specific enhancers of the zebrafish gelsonlin-like 1 (gsnl1) gene. Dev Dyn 236: 1929–1938.
- 27. Robu ME, Larson JD, Nasevicius A, Beiraghi S, Brenner C, et al. (2007) p53 activation by knockdown technologies. PLOS Genetics 3: e78.
- 28. Shi X, Bosenko DV, Zinkevich NS, Foley S, Hyde DR, et al. (2005) Zebrafish pitx3 is necessary for normal lens and retinal development. Mech Dev 122(4): 513–27.
- 29. Barrallo-Gimeno A, Holzschuh J, Driever W, Knapik EW (2004) Neural crest survival and differentiation in zebrafish depends on mont blanc/tfap2a gene function. Development 131: 1463–1477.
- 30. Piotrowski T, Schilling TF, Brand M, Jiang YJ, Heisenberg CP, et al. (1996) Jaw and branchial arch mutants in zebrafish II: anterior arches and cartilage differentiation. Development 123: 345–356.
- 31. Alvarez Y, Cederlund ML, Cottell DC, Bill BR, Ekker SC, et al. (2007) Genetic determinants of hyaloid and retinal vasculature in zebrafish. BMC Dev Biol 7: 114.
- 32. Volkmann BA, Zinkevich NS, Mustonen A, Schilter KF, Bosenko DV, et al. (2011) Potential novel mechanism for Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome: deletion of a distant region containing regulatory elements of PITX2. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 52(3): 1450–1459.
- 33. Nelms BL, Labosky PA (2010) Transcriptional Control of Neural Crest Development. 227 p. Morgan and Claypool Life Sciences.
- 34. Lister JA, Cooper C, Nguyen K, Modrell M, Grant K, et al. (2006) Zebrafish Foxd3 is required for development of a subset of neural crest derivatives. Dev Biol 290(1): 92–104.
- 35. Kraus P, Lufkin T (2006) Dlx homeobox gene control of mammalian limb and craniofacial development. Am J Med Genet A 140(13): 1366–1374.
- 36. Sperber SM, Saxena V, Hatch G, Ekker M (2008) Zebrafish dlx2a contributes to hindbrain neural crest survival, is necessary for differentiation of sensory ganglia and functions with dlx1a in maturation of the arch cartilage elements. Dev Biol 314(1): 59–70.
- 37. Kleinjan DA, Bancewicz RM, Gautier P, Dahm R, Schonthaler HB, et al. (2008) Subfunctionalization of duplicated zebrafish pax6 genes by cis-regulatory divergence. PLoS Genet 4(2): e29.
- 38. Zilinski CA, Shah R, Lane ME, Jamrich M (2005) Modulation of zebrafish pitx3 expression in the primordia of the pituitary, lens, olfactory epithelium and cranial ganglia by hedgehog and nodal signaling. Genesis 41(1): 33–40.
- 39. Gage PJ, Qian M, Wu D, Rosenberg KI (2008) The canonical Wnt signaling antagonist DKK2 is an essential effector of PITX2 function during normal eye development. Dev Biol 317(1): 310–324.
- 40. Zhao XC, Yee RW, Norcom E, Burgess H, Avanesov AS, et al. (2006) The zebrafish cornea: structure and development. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 47(10): 4341–4348.
- 41. Chen JY, Chang BE, Chen YH, Lin CJ, Wu JL, et al. (2001) Molecular cloning, developmental expression, and hormonal regulation of zebrafish (Danio rerio) beta crystallin B1, a member of the superfamily of beta crystallin proteins. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 285(1): 105–110.
- 42. Dahlman JM, Margot KL, Ding L, Horwitz J, Posner M (2005) Zebrafish alpha-crystallins: protein structure and chaperone-like activity compared to their mammalian orthologs. Mol Vis 11: 88–96.
- 43. Espinoza HM, Cox CJ, Semina EV, Amendt BA (2002) A molecular basis for differential developmental anomalies in Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome. Hum Mol Genet 11(7): 743–753.
- 44. Rutland CS, Mitchell CA, Nasir M, Konerding MA, Drexler HC (2007) Microphthalmia, persistent hyperplastic hyaloid vasculature and lens anomalies following overexpression of VEGF-A188 from the alphaA-crystallin promoter. Mol Vis 13: 47–56.
- 45. Haddad R, Font R L, Reeser F (1978) Persistent hyperplastic primary vitreous. A clinicopathologic study of 62 cases and review of the literature. Surv Ophthalmol 23: 123–124.
- 46. Silbert M, Gurwood AS (2000) Persistent hyperplastic primary vitreous. Clin Eye Vis Care 12(3–4): 131–137.
- 47. Goldberg MF (1997) Persistent fetal vasculature (PFV): an integrated interpretation of signs and symptoms associated with persistent hyperplastic primary vitreous (PHPV). LIV Edward Jackson Memorial Lecture. Am J Ophthalmol 124(5): 587–626.
- 48. Arikawa A, Yoshida S, Yoshikawa H, Ishikawa K, Yamaji Y, et al. (2010) Case of novel PITX2 gene mutation associated with Peters' anomaly and persistent hyperplastic primary vitreous. Eye (Lond) 24(2): 391–393.
- 49. Zhu M, Madigan MC, van Driel D, Maslim J, Billson FA, et al. (2000) The human hyaloid system: cell death and vascular regression. Exp Eye Res 70(6): 767–776.
- 50. Ito M, Yoshioka M (1999) Regression of the hyaloid vessels and pupillary membrane of the mouse. Anat Embryol (Berl) 200(4): 403–411.
- 51. Chang B, Smith RS, Peters M, Savinova OV, Hawes NL, et al. (2001) Haploinsufficient Bmp4 ocular phenotypes include anterior segment dysgenesis with elevated intraocular pressure. BMC Genet 2: 18.
- 52. Chen Y, Doughman YQ, Gu S, Jarrell A, Aota S, et al. (2008) Cited2 is required for the proper formation of the hyaloid vasculature and for lens morphogenesis. Development 135(17): 2939–2948.
- 53. Semina EV, Bosenko DV, Zinkevich NC, Soules KA, Hyde DR, et al. (2006) Mutations in laminin alpha 1 result in complex, lens-independent ocular phenotypes in zebrafish. Dev Biol 299(1): 63–77.
- 54. Edwards MM, Mammadova-Bach E, Alpy F, Klein A, Hicks WL, et al. (2010) Mutations in Lama1 disrupt retinal vascular development and inner limiting membrane formation. J Biol Chem 285(10): 7697–7711.
- 55. Richter M, Gottanka J, May CA, Welge-Lüssen U, Berger W, et al. (1998) Retinal vasculature changes in Norrie disease mice. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 39(12): 2450–7.
- 56. Lobov IB, Rao S, Carroll TJ, Vallance JE, Ito M, et al. (2005) WNT7b mediates macrophage-induced programmed cell death in patterning of the vasculature. Nature 437(7057): 417–421.
- 57. Liu C, Nathans J (2008) An essential role for frizzled 5 in mammalian ocular development. Development 135(21): 3567–3576.
- 58. Zhang J, Fuhrmann S, Vetter ML (2008) A nonautonomous role for retinal frizzled-5 in regulating hyaloid vitreous vasculature development. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 49(12): 5561–5567.
- 59. Bredrup C, Matejas V, Barrow M, Bláhová K, Bockenhauer D, et al. (2008) Ophthalmological aspects of Pierson syndrome. Am J Ophthalmol 146(4): 602–611.
- 60. Dhingra S, Shears DJ, Blake V, Stewart H, Patel CK (2006) Advanced bilateral persistent fetal vasculature associated with a novel mutation in the Norrie gene. Br J Ophthalmol 90(10): 1324–5.
- 61. Robitaille JM, Wallace K, Zheng B, Beis MJ, Samuels M, et al. (2009) Phenotypic overlap of familial exudative vitreoretinopathy (FEVR) with persistent fetal vasculature (PFV) caused by FZD4 mutations in two distinct pedigrees. Ophthalmic Genet 30(1): 23–30.
- 62. Bamforth SD, Bragança J, Farthing CR, Schneider JE, Broadbent C, et al. (2004) Cited2 controls left-right patterning and heart development through a Nodal-Pitx2c pathway. Nat Genet 36(11): 1189–1196.