Most epidemiological studies exploring the association between smokeless tobacco (SLT) use and coronary heart disease (CHD) have been in Western populations, and have focused on SLT products used in those countries. Few studies come from South Asian countries. Our objective was to determine the association between SLT use and CHD among non-smoking adults in Bangladesh.
A matched case-control study of non-smoking Bangladeshi adults aged 40–75 years was conducted in 2010. Incident cases of CHD were selected from two cardiac hospitals. Community controls, matched to CHD cases, were selected from neighbourhoods, and hospital controls were selected from outpatient departments of the same hospitals. The Rose Angina Questionnaire (RAQ) was also used to re-classify cases and controls.
The study enrolled 302 cases, 1,208 community controls and 302 hospital controls. Current use was higher among community controls (38%) compared to cases (33%) and hospital controls (32%). Current use of SLT was not significantly associated with an increased risk of CHD when community controls were used (adjusted OR 0.87, 95% CI 0.63–1.19), or when hospital controls were used (adjusted OR 1.00, 95% CI 0.63–1.60), or when both control groups were combined (adjusted OR 1.00, 95% CI 0.74–1.34). Risk of CHD did not increase with use of individual types except gul, frequency, duration, past use of SLT products, or using the RAQ to re-classify cases and controls. There was a significant association between gul use and CHD when both controls were combined (adjusted OR 2.93, 95% CI 1.28–6.70).
There was no statistically significant association between SLT use in general and CHD among non-smoking adults in Bangladesh. Further research on the association between gul use and CHD in Bangladesh along with SLT use and CHD in other parts of the subcontinent will guide public health policy and interventions that focus on SLT-related diseases.
Citation: Rahman MA, Spurrier N, Mahmood MA, Rahman M, Choudhury SR, Leeder S (2012) Is There Any Association between Use of Smokeless Tobacco Products and Coronary Heart Disease in Bangladesh? PLoS ONE 7(1): e30584. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0030584
Editor: German Malaga, Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia, Peru
Received: October 2, 2011; Accepted: December 19, 2011; Published: January 20, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Rahman et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Funding for this study was provided by the Discipline of Public Health, The University of Adelaide. Additionally, human resource and in-kind support for the research was also provided by the Institute of Epidemiology, Disease Control and Research (IEDCR), Dhaka, Bangladesh and the National Heart Foundation Hospital & Research Institute (NHFH&RI), Dhaka, Bangladesh. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Smokeless tobacco (SLT), commonly used in many countries , is associated with various health effects. Epidemiological studies have consistently reported a significant positive association between SLT use and cancers of various organs such as oropharynx, oesophagus, stomach, pancreas, and lungs amongst others . Studies also report a positive association between SLT use and oral diseases, dental diseases, hypertension, diabetes, poor reproductive outcomes, addiction, and all-cause mortality .
A number of studies have also reported a significant positive association between SLT use and risk factors for cardiovascular diseases (CVD) such as raised blood pressure and a less healthy lipid profile , . However, the results of epidemiological studies assessing the association between SLT use and CHD, stroke or CVD in general are inconsistent , . While several cohort , ,  and case-control studies ,  have reported a significant positive association, other sufficiently powered cohort , ,  and case-control studies , ,  have not reported such an association. Some studies undertaken in Western countries (Sweden and USA) have found an association , ,  whereas others have not , , . South Asian SLT products differ from Western products in terms of constituents, nicotine concentration, manufacturing, and storage methods . Usage patterns are also likely to be different and may explain the different results from studies conducted across various settings , .
There are a limited number of studies from South Asian countries focusing on the association between SLT use and CHD. One Indian cohort study  and another multinational case-control study (INTERHEART) involving 52 countries  reported a significant positive association and did include South Asian SLT products. However, betel-quid and areca-nut were included as SLT products although these products do not contain tobacco. In addition, the INTERHEART study did not report results separately for any South Asian country . A small number of Taiwanese studies , ,  found a significant positive association between betel-quid chewing and CHD, but not with SLT use. The only study which has included SLT products available in Bangladesh , all of which contain tobacco, showed a significant positive association between SLT use and CHD (adjusted odds ratio 2.2, 95% confidence interval 1.1–4.5) and was conducted by the first author.
As a developing country in South-East Asia, Bangladesh has high rates of smoking and SLT usage. Half of those aged ≥15 years (43%≈41 million) use tobacco in some form . The prevalence of SLT use has been estimated as 27% with similar rates in men (26%) and women (28%), but more prevalent in rural areas (29%) compared to urban areas (23%) . Whilst a number of studies in Bangladesh have examined tobacco use , , , the only study focusing on the SLT-CHD association  had a small sample size (n = 207), included smokers, and recruited cases and controls from a hospital setting.
Betel-leaf (paan) chewing is a cultural tradition of Bangladeshi people extending back many centuries . In Bangladesh, as in other countries of the subcontinent, people chew betel-leaf with/without SLT products routinely at various cultural and social events . As there has been no large systematic study conducted in the Subcontinent, and the results of studies conducted in Western settings are inconsistent , we conducted the current study to determine whether there was any association between SLT use and CHD among non-smoking adults in Bangladesh.
Informed written consent was requested from each participant in the prescribed consent form. Privacy and confidentiality were maintained regarding the collected data. The protocol including the information sheet and consent forms for this project was approved by The University of Adelaide Human Research Ethics Committee, Australia (H-117-2009) and the local ethics committee of Bangladesh Medical Research Council, Bangladesh (BMRC/NREC/2007–2010/125).
Study design and study sites
A matched case-control study was conducted in 2010. Data were collected through structured interviews. CHD cases were recruited from inpatient facilities of the National Institute of Cardiovascular Diseases (NICVD) and the National Heart Foundation Hospital and Research Institute (NHFH&RI), Dhaka, Bangladesh. Both hospitals are accessible to people from all socio-economic groups as minimal costs are associated with cardiac care. During the recruitment period, approximately 550 patients per day were admitted to the six cardiovascular units of NICVD and 110 patients per day were admitted to the seven cardiovascular units of NHFH&RI. Four hundred patients per day and 75 patients per day attended the outpatient facilities of the NICVD and the NHFH&RI respectively. Both hospital controls and community controls were selected in this study in order to assess whether results differed according to the use of different control groups. Hospital controls were recruited amongst individuals attending cardiac outpatient facilities of the NICVD and the NHFH&RI, while community controls were recruited from the neighbourhood households of CHD cases within Dhaka City Corporation (DCC) areas.
Inclusion criteria were: age 40–75 years, non-smoker, residence within DCC areas, and well enough to undertake a 20 minute interview. Non-smokers were defined as either (i) never smokers or (ii) ex-smokers who had not smoked a single puff in the past 10 years. This was because most studies suggest that the maximum reduction in CHD risk occurs within 4–14 years following smoking cessation , , ; and from a practical perspective, only including never smokers would have been difficult.
CHD patients admitted to the two hospitals and diagnosed as incident cases of CHD (diagnosis for the first time within the preceding twelve months) by hospital cardiologists, were selected as cases. Cardiologists diagnosed CHD cases based on clinical judgment (a combination of classical symptoms with positive results from electrocardiogram, cardiac enzymes, exercise tolerance test, or coronary artery angiogram). Either angina and/or myocardial infarction were included in the definition of CHD for the purpose of this study.
Neighbourhood residents of the CHD cases, who had no self-reported cardiac disease, were selected as community controls. Control subjects were matched by age (±5 years), sex and socio-economic status (SES) to the corresponding case. If a suitable control subject could not be located in a suburb of the CHD case, the next adjacent suburb was used (this happened in 28% of cases).
Hospital controls were also used in this study. This was to determine whether any systematic bias existed in the use of hospital controls as is often postulated in the literature , . These additional analyses are not the focus of this particular article and will be presented elsewhere. Patients, who attended cardiac outpatient facilities of the same hospitals and were diagnosed as not suffering from CHD by hospital cardiologists, were selected as hospital controls. It should be noted that unlike a developed country, many individuals with symptoms of chest pain or breathlessness attend outpatient facilities of cardiac hospitals for screening of cardiac disease; either self-referred or referred by a general practitioner in Bangladesh. About two-thirds (64%) of the hospital controls were selected from the hypertension clinic of NHFH&RI, which was the only available source of recruiting controls in that study setting. This poses a risk of potential bias because SLT use is known to be associated with hypertension . Diagnoses for these patients included hypertension (62%), non-specific chest pain (48%), and gastric hyper-acidity (13%). Some patients were not assigned a diagnosis, and symptoms of palpitation (10%) or breathlessness (8%) were given in the case-notes. Each hospital control was matched with a corresponding case by age (±5 years) and sex.
Cases and controls re-classified by the Rose Angina Questionnaire (RAQ)
In addition to our study definition of cases and controls, we also used the RAQ  to re-classify study participants into RAQ cases and RAQ controls. Individuals responding affirmatively to the RAQ were re-classified as RAQ cases and the negative responders were re-classified as RAQ controls as shown in Figure 1. It is to be noted that the RAQ cases and the RAQ controls were not matched.
Sample size was calculated using Epi-info version 3.5.1. With 95% confidence intervals, 80% power, a control: case ratio of 4∶1, a correlation for matched design of 0.1, an expected frequency of SLT use among controls of 25% , and a clinically significant odds ratio considered to be 1.5 , , 302 cases and 1,208 controls were required for this study. Additionally, one hospital control was selected for each case (302 additional controls).
A structured interview was conducted to measure exposure and confounding variables. Initially, a screening questionnaire was used to select eligible cases and controls. This included information on age, residence, smoking and heart disease status. Once informed consent was obtained, participants were asked a range of questions covering socio-demographic information, a detailed history of SLT use, and other known risk factors for CHD. Socio-demographic information included age, gender, marital status, highest level of education achieved, primary occupation and monthly house-rent as a proxy to socio-economic status.
Betel-leaf or areca-nut alone was not included as a SLT product, as they do not contain tobacco. If a respondent used any SLT product with/without betel-leaf or areca-nut in the last twelve months, he/she was categorized as a current SLT user. If a respondent ceased using SLT products for at least last twelve months, he/she was categorized as a past SLT user. If a respondent was not using any SLT product currently or in the past, he/she was categorized as never a tobacco user (as they were also non-smokers according to the participant selection criteria). Using frequency and duration of SLT use, we categorized frequency into light use (less than once a day) and heavy use (at least once a day), duration into short duration (<10 years) and long duration (>10 years), and quit duration into short-term quit (2–10 years) and long-term quit (>10 years).
Information on known risk factors for CHD included self-reported history of hypertension, diabetes, family history of heart disease, level of physical activity, use of hormonal contraceptives for women, exposure to indoor passive smoking, and occurrence of acute psycho-social events within last one year.
Reasons for non-participation were documented. If participants asked whether SLT could cause any health effect, interviewers only provided this information at the completion of the interview. Categorization of CHD cases according to the case definition and the RAQ was undertaken by the first author and selection of the majority of controls was undertaken in his presence. The first author trained the interviewers and undertook regular supervision of all data collection activities. In addition, the first author re-interviewed 4 cases (1%), 24 community controls (2%) and 6 hospital controls (2%) as a means of quality control of data collection.
To enhance interpretation of the study results, samples of SLT products most commonly used within the DCC areas, were tested for nicotine. Purchased samples of paan-masala (3 samples), jarda (1 sample), and gul (1 sample) were analysed following extraction, steam distillation and silicotungstic acid gravimetric method  at the Institute of Food Science and Technology (IFST), Bangladesh Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (BCSIR). Nicotine concentration was reported in percentage by weight (% by wt.). Sada-pata, which is the natural tobacco leaf in dried form, was also used by study participants but was not tested for nicotine because of the natural variation of this product. A recent surveillance study reported nicotine concentrations in Bangladeshi sada-pata as 1.97% .
Analyses were performed using STATA version 10 statistical software. Initially, categorical variables were described as proportions for socio-demographic variables, SLT use, and risk factors for CHD. To determine the association between SLT use and CHD, cases and controls were compared using cross-tabulations at first. To statistically compare cases and controls, we used McNemar's chi-squared (χ2) tests when the frequency in all of the cells of the cross-tabulation was ≥5 and Fisher's exact test otherwise. Univariate conditional logistic regression models  were fitted to determine the strength of the association between SLT use and CHD, with the effect of SLT use expressed as a matched odds ratios (ORs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Then multivariate conditional logistic regression models were fitted to adjust for potential confounding variables. The most important confounder is the presence of hypertension; this is particular so with analysis using only hospital controls. Confounding variables were identified initially using a χ2 test relating the variables to CHD. If the p-value from the χ2 test was less than 0.20 and there was no missing data for the confounder, that variable was included into the final multivariate analysis. The adjusted ORs with 95% CIs finally determined the association between SLT use and CHD in this study. To determine whether the inclusion of ex-smokers could have biased the results, analyses were conducted separately for never-smokers, ex-smokers, and combining both groups. Data were analysed separately using community controls, hospital controls, and combining both control groups. We also analysed data with all groups of re-classified cases and controls done by the RAQ to further explore the association between SLT use and CHD (Figure 1). As the RAQ cases and the RAQ controls were not matched, we used univariate and multivariate logistic regression models for these analyses.
Eligible participants included 311 hospital cases, 1293 community controls and 316 hospital controls. Nine potential hospital cases (3%), 85 potential community controls (7%), and 14 potential hospital controls (4%) did not consent to participate. Thus, the overall response rate was 94%. Results for the remaining 302 CHD cases from two cardiac hospitals, 1208 community controls and 302 hospital controls are presented in this paper.
Mean age of participants was 53 years (standard deviation ±8.5 years), 49.7% were men. Table 1 shows the distribution of different socio-demographic variables among cases and controls, and there were no significant differences in socio-demographic variables comparing cases and controls. Amongst the 1812 participants, 1292 (71%) were never-smokers. Never-smoking status was similar between cases (203 out of 302, 67%) and either community controls (864 out of 1208, 72%) or hospital controls (225 out of 302, 75%).
Risk factors for CHD
Table 1 shows the distribution of risk factors for CHD among cases and controls. More than two-thirds of hospital controls (67%) were hypertensive compared to half of cases (60%) and one-third of community controls (34%).The majority of these hospital controls were selected from the hypertension clinic of one study hospital which explains this difference.
Nicotine content of the SLT products
Nicotine was absent in all three commercial samples of paan-masala products tested. The selected samples of jarda and gul contained 0.96% and 5.48% nicotine respectively. Therefore, our data analysis included only three types of SLT products containing nicotine: jarda, sada-pata (1.97% nicotine) and gul.
Use of SLT products
Amongst the 1812 participants, 648 (36%) were current SLT users. Current use was higher among community controls (38%) compared to that of cases (33%) and hospital controls (32%). Quitting was more common among cases compared to either group of controls. Amongst the never-smoker participants, current use of SLT was more common among community controls (35%) than that of cases (25%) and hospital controls (30%). Amongst the ex-smoker participants, ever use, current use and quitting of SLT products were more common among cases compared to either group of controls. Table 2 shows the status of SLT use among the study participants.
Amongst the individual types of SLT products, use of jarda was more common compared to sada-pata and gul. Current use of jarda was slightly higher among community controls (26%) compared to either cases (21%) or hospital controls (24%). There was no difference between cases and controls for current use of sada-pata. Current use of gul was slightly more common among cases (5%) compared to either group of controls (2%). The majority of exclusive jarda, sada-pata or gul consumers were heavy users and long duration users. Mean duration of jarda use was 16 years (0.1–55 years), sada-pata 28 years (3–60 years), and gul 17 years (0.5–45 years). There was no difference between cases and controls for heavy use or long duration use of each SLT product.
Association between SLT use and CHD
Table 2, 3, 4 show the results of univariate and multivariate analyses. Among the socio-demographic variables and risk factor variables for CHD, age, hypertension, diabetes, and acute psycho-social stress were significantly associated with CHD when data were analysed using community controls, hospital controls or both controls. In addition, marital status and indoor passive smoking were significantly associated with CHD when data were analysed with hospital controls. There was no statistically significant association between current SLT use and CHD when community controls were used (adjusted OR 0.87, 95% CI 0.63–1.19), or hospital controls were used (adjusted OR 1.00, 95% CI 0.63–1.60), or when both controls were combined (adjusted OR 1.00, 95% CI 0.74–1.34). There was no association between ever use or cessation of SLT usage and CHD. Similar results were found when data were analysed separately for never-smokers and ex-smokers. Similarly, Table 3 shows that there was no statistically significant association between SLT use and CHD, when data were analysed using the RAQ classified cases and RAQ classified controls.
When we stratified our analyses according to younger (40–57 years) and older (58–75 years) age groups, there was no statistically significant association between current SLT use and CHD among younger and older participants, when community controls were used (younger: adjusted OR 1.08, 95% CI 0.73–1.60, older: adjusted OR 0.54, 95% CI 0.27–1.07), or hospital controls were used (younger: adjusted OR 1.14, 95% CI 0.59–2.19, older: adjusted OR 0.89, 95% CI 0.32–2.47), or when both controls were combined (younger: adjusted OR 1.19, 95% CI 0.82–1.72, older: adjusted OR 0.75, 95% CI 0.42–1.32). Results did not change when data were analysed separately for never-smokers and ex-smokers.
When we stratified our analyses further according to gender, there was no statistically significant association between current SLT use and CHD among men and women, when community controls were used (men: adjusted OR 1.30, 95% CI 0.81–2.10, women: adjusted OR 0.62, 95% CI 0.38–0.99), or hospital controls were used (men: adjusted OR 1.08, 95% CI 0.46–2.55, women: adjusted OR 0.84, 95% CI 0.42–1.68), or when both controls were combined (men: adjusted OR 1.36, 95% CI 0.88–2.09, women: adjusted OR 0.73, 95% CI 0.47–1.14). Results did not change when data were analysed separately for never-smokers and ex-smokers.
Table 4 shows that there was no statistically significant association between use of jarda or sada-pata and CHD for current use, quitting or ever use during analyses by different control groups or by different smoking status. However, the product containing highest amount of nicotine (5.48%) in this study, gul, showed a significant positive association with CHD (adjusted OR 2.93, 95% CI 1.28–6.70), when data were analysed using both groups of controls.
There was no statistically significant association between frequency or duration of each SLT product use and CHD, except use of gul. There was a significant positive association between heavy use of gul and CHD (adjusted OR 2.78, 95% CI 1.17–6.57), and long duration use of gul and CHD (adjusted OR 3.57, 95% CI 1.26–10.1) when both controls were used. There may have been a problem with lack of power to make stratified analyses with each SLT product to identify the association with CHD, as there were very few users of each SLT product in this study (Table 4).
In this study, there was no statistically significant association between SLT use in general and CHD among non-smoking adults in Bangladesh. However, there was a significant association between use of gul and CHD. This is very important because whilst in general our study did not find an association between SLT use and CHD, if nicotine content is higher in SLT (as it is in some other countries), it is likely to pose a significant risk for the development of CHD. No significant association was found for frequency or duration of each SLT product except gul. Heavy use and long duration of gul use was significantly associated with CHD. Results did not change when community controls, hospital controls, or both control groups were used during analyses, and when never-smoker, ex-smoker, or both groups were used. The results were the same for current users, quitters or ever users of SLT products. In addition, re-classification of cases and controls utilizing the RAQ did not change the findings of association between SLT use and CHD. Separate analyses with different age groups and gender did not change the results as well.
Findings of this study are supported by earlier case-control , , , , cross-sectional  as well as cohort studies , , , , . None of these case-control studies conducted in Sweden reported a statistically significant positive association between use of snuff and CHD, although the findings were for men only. Similar to case-control studies, none of these cohort studies have reported a significant association between SLT use and CHD. All of these cohort studies except the US study  included men only. The US study , which considered only fatal CHD, showed the same results when analysed separately for men (adjusted hazard ratio 0.6, 95% CI 0.3–1.2) and women (adjusted OR 1.4, 95% CI 0.8–2.2).
On the other hand, findings of this study are not supported by other cohort , , ,  and case-control studies , . The Swedish Construction Worker study  and the US Cancer Prevention Study  involving a larger cohort reported a significant positive association between SLT use and CHD. However, it is to be noted that both of these studies included men and fatal CHD only. Another US cohort study , which included both sexes as well as fatal and non-fatal CHD, reported a significant positive association between SLT use and CVD, but no separate results were reported for fatal and non-fatal CVD, or for CHD and stroke. All of these cohort studies included Western SLT products and populations. The only South Asian cohort study, conducted in India , showed a significant positive association between use of Indian SLT products and CHD among women (adjusted risk ratio 1.25, 95% CI 1.05–1.49), but not among men (adjusted risk ratio 0.89, 95% CI 0.75–1.05). This is also in contrast to what we have found in this study. The constituents of Indian SLT products are likely to be different from Bangladeshi SLT products, which could have resulted in the significant positive association in the Indian study. The INTERHEART  and the Bangladeshi case-control study  showed a significant positive association between SLT use and non-fatal CHD. All of these studies were limited by various methodological issues as described in the introduction to this paper and elsewhere .
The literature suggests inconsistent evidence regarding the association between SLT use and CHD among different age-groups. We did not find any difference in results by age, which is supported by another study that did not find any significant association among younger (35–54 years) and older (55–64 years) people . On the other hand, whilst a cross-sectional study of Swedish construction workers did not find a significant association among younger workers (46–55 years) , the subsequent cohort study reported a significant association among young (35–54 years) as well as older workers (55–65 years) .
There was a significant association between use of gul and CHD in this study, although the numbers were not large enough to confirm this association from this study as mentioned before. Gul is the mixture of tobacco powder, molasses, alkaline modifiers and other ingredients prepared commercially, and used in other parts of South Asia including Bangladesh , . This product is kept between cheek and gum, used alone unlike other SLT products which are usually used with betel leaf in Bangladesh. This product was reported as having the highest nicotine concentration in this study. A recent survey of SLT products from different countries also reported higher nicotine concentration in Bangladeshi gul compared to other SLT products . Frequency and duration of gul use was also significantly associated with CHD in the present study. Further well-powered study need to explore the association between this specific SLT product and CHD in a more detailed way.
Results from the existing research in Western countries are inconclusive; studies from South Asia are very limited and have some methodological constraints . The current study addressed some of these methodological issues. Strengths of this study comprise including only non-smoking participants, a wider age range, both men and women, both community controls and hospital controls, and including exclusive SLT products from Bangladesh. Inclusion of non-smokers controlled for the potential strong confounding effects of smoking on CHD at the design stage. In addition, potential confounders were measured and adjusted for. This was particularly important for hypertension, which had the potential of introducing bias when data were analysed using hospital controls. Increasing the age limit of the participants in contrast to the earlier Bangladeshi case-control study helped assess the association between SLT use and CHD among a broader and more representative sample of Bangladeshi population. The consistent findings regardless of using either hospital controls or community controls support the accuracy of the study results. For the exposure variable, betel-quid or areca-nut was not included as a SLT product unlike other prior studies; rather selection of SLT products was supported by direct analysis of nicotine content. Selecting subjects from the two tertiary care cardiac hospitals and the catchment areas within the DCC, which include people from all socio-economic strata, suggest our results are representative for urban dwellers in Bangladesh. However, the issue of different health care seeking behaviours should be kept in mind. Re-interviewing a percentage of both cases and controls ensured the quality of the collected data. Re-analysing data using the RAQ classification strengthened the study findings because milder or as yet undiagnosed CHD were identified from both hospitals and communities in this study.
The lack of an association between SLT use in general and CHD in this study can be explained in several ways. Nicotine concentration of some Bangladeshi SLT products, specifically gul is higher compared to commercial cigarettes (1.63%) or bidi smoking (2.12%) . But more gradual and least peaked dosing of nicotine occurs for SLT use, although the blood concentration of nicotine remains similar for a daily SLT user and a smoker . On the other hand, rapid dosing of nicotine occurs with smoking and this has the potential to result in much more intense cardiovascular stimulation . Finally, SLT products do not contain carbon monoxide and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, which are known to contribute to the cardiovascular effects of smoking , . A significant association between gul use and CHD may be due to the higher nicotine concentration in the product itself along with the rapid absorption from buccal cavity to cause cardiovascular effects. It may also be due to other additives in gul having cardiovascular effects. Further studies need to confirm these hypotheses.
It was beyond the scope of this study to verify the self-reported diagnosis of non-CHD among the community controls by a qualified physician. Fatal CHD cases were not included in this study, because hospital death registers in Bangladesh are not well developed. In addition, collection of SLT exposure data from family members of deceased individuals would be less reliable compared to data collected from the users themselves. Reporting of the stratified analyses with each SLT product in this study has the potential to be biased as we had relatively small number of specific SLT users. We could not measure the amount of different SLT use from the study participants, as there are no standard pack sizes unlike snus or snuff. This limited us from including the amount during calculation of dose-response relationship between SLT use and CHD. However, as there was no association between SLT use and CHD, this missing information did not affect the result of this study. There is a chance of having interviewer-bias in this study, which can happen to any epidemiological study. But we had a structured questionnaire and the interviewers were trained to ask the exact question only, not try and interpret the questions for the respondents. However, as the interviewers could not be blinded, it is difficult to completely overcome this. Since our subjects were recruited from within Dhaka, our results may not be generalizable to the rural areas of Bangladesh. We attempted to measure and adjust for as many possible confounding variables as possible. Importantly, this included hypertension as previously discussed. However, it was not possible to measure body mass index (BMI) because we felt that urban dwellers in Bangladesh would be unlikely to invite interviewers into their homes to undertake height and weight measurements. Also, Bangladeshis do not tend to measure their own weight on a regular basis and so self-report data was also not considered feasible.
This study has implications for tobacco control policy. There is an ongoing debate regarding the use of SLT products as a safer alternative to active smoking and as a possible mechanism to encourage smoking cessation . On the other hand, there is a concern that SLT use may potentiate tobacco smoking . As tobacco control policies vary strikingly between countries , there is the potential of introducing Western SLT products as a harm-reduction agent into developing countries of South Asia . Such products may contain ingredients, which could have unknown deleterious effects on CHD and other health conditions. In addition, SLT products and nicotine concentration also differ in other South Asian countries such as in India or Pakistan , .
This study did not find an association between SLT use in general and CHD among non-smoking Bangladeshi adults. This is the first large scale case-control study assessing the association between SLT use and CHD from a South Asian perspective. Despite the fact that the current study did not find an association between different Bangladeshi SLT products and CHD except gul, SLT use has an established risk for development of cancers and of dental diseases. Tobacco control campaigns should focus on these SLT-related diseases. Given the fact that the burden of tobacco-related illnesses are more among people of lower socio-economic status , as well as limited resources for health promotion activities in developing countries, policies supporting non-use of any form of tobacco are justified. Further research on the association between gul use and CHD in Bangladesh, along with SLT use and CHD in other parts of the subcontinent where SLT products may differ will guide public health policy and interventions to prevent SLT-related diseases. Because SLT use is not harmless, the strategic focus should be upon controlling both smoking and SLT use in Bangladesh.
We would like to remember with sincere gratitude the late Professor Konrad Jamrozik from the University of Adelaide, Australia for his contribution in developing the concept of this research area. We would like to thank the Director of NICVD and the Chairman of NHFH&RI for providing their official support in collecting data from the hospital patients. Also we are very grateful to the physicians and nurses of NICVD and NHFH&RI for their cooperation in collecting data; specifically, Dr. Monwarul Islam, Registrar of NICVD and Dr. Ziauddin Ahmad from Bangladesh. We appreciate the support from the fellow colleagues of IEDCR (Institute of Epidemiology, Disease Control and Research), Bangladesh during training and selection of data collectors for this study. Special thanks to Mrs. Habibun Nahar Lotus, Ms. Shafia Zerin, Ms. Afroza Begum Nilu, Mr. Sheikh Mohd. Shafiqul Bari and Ms. Bilkis Sultana for their sincere and conscientious efforts in collecting data for this study. Above all, we would like to express our sincere gratitude to each of the study participant from both hospitals and communities within Dhaka City Corporation, Bangladesh for their valuable time in participating in this study.
Conceived and designed the experiments: MAR NS MAM MR SRC SL. Performed the experiments: MAR MR SRC. Analyzed the data: MAR NS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: NS MAM MR. Wrote the paper: MAR NS MAM SL.
- 1. International Agency for Research on Cancer (2007) Smokeless tobacco and some tobacco-specific N-Nitrosamines. IARC Monographs on the evaluation of carcinogenic risks to humans Lyon, France: International Agency for Research on Cancer. pp. 1–641.International Agency for Research on Cancer2007Smokeless tobacco and some tobacco-specific N-Nitrosamines.IARC Monographs on the evaluation of carcinogenic risks to humans Lyon, FranceInternational Agency for Research on Cancer1641
- 2. Lee PN (2011) Summary of the epidemiological evidence relating snus to health. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 59: 197–214.PN Lee2011Summary of the epidemiological evidence relating snus to health.Regul Toxicol Pharmacol59197214
- 3. Hergens MP, Lambe M, Pershagen G, Ye W (2008) Risk of hypertension amongst Swedish male snuff users: a prospective study. J Intern Med 264: 187–194.MP HergensM. LambeG. PershagenW. Ye2008Risk of hypertension amongst Swedish male snuff users: a prospective study.J Intern Med264187194
- 4. Gupta BK, Kaushik A, Panwar RB, Chaddha VS, Nayak KC, et al. (2007) Cardiovascular risk factors in tobacco-chewers: a controlled study. J Assoc Physicians India 55: 27–31.BK GuptaA. KaushikRB PanwarVS ChaddhaKC Nayak2007Cardiovascular risk factors in tobacco-chewers: a controlled study.J Assoc Physicians India552731
- 5. Boffetta P, Straif K (2009) Use of smokeless tobacco and risk of myocardial infarction and stroke: systematic review with meta-analysis. BMJ 339: b3060.P. BoffettaK. Straif2009Use of smokeless tobacco and risk of myocardial infarction and stroke: systematic review with meta-analysis.BMJ339b3060
- 6. Rahman MA, Mahmood MA, Spurrier N, Rahman M, Leeder S (2011) A systematic review of epidemiological studies on the association between smokeless tobacco use and coronary heart disease. J Public Health Epidemiol 3: 593–603.MA RahmanMA MahmoodN. SpurrierM. RahmanS. Leeder2011A systematic review of epidemiological studies on the association between smokeless tobacco use and coronary heart disease.J Public Health Epidemiol3593603
- 7. Bolinder G, Alfredsson L, Englund A, de Faire U (1994) Smokeless tobacco use and increased cardiovascular mortality among Swedish construction workers. Am J Public Health 84: 399–404.G. BolinderL. AlfredssonA. EnglundU. de Faire1994Smokeless tobacco use and increased cardiovascular mortality among Swedish construction workers.Am J Public Health84399404
- 8. Henley SJ, Thun MJ, Connell C, Calle EE (2005) Two large prospective studies of mortality among men who use snuff or chewing tobacco (United States). Cancer Cause Control 16: 347–358.SJ HenleyMJ ThunC. ConnellEE Calle2005Two large prospective studies of mortality among men who use snuff or chewing tobacco (United States).Cancer Cause Control16347358
- 9. Yatsuya H, Folsom AR (2010) Risk of incident cardiovascular disease among users of smokeless tobacco in the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) study. Am J Epidemiol 172: 600–605.H. YatsuyaAR Folsom2010Risk of incident cardiovascular disease among users of smokeless tobacco in the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) study.Am J Epidemiol172600605
- 10. Teo KK, Ounpuu S, Hawken S, Pandey MR, Valentin V, et al. (2006) Tobacco use and risk of myocardial infarction in 52 countries in the INTERHEART study: a case-control study. Lancet 368: 647–658.KK TeoS. OunpuuS. HawkenMR PandeyV. Valentin2006Tobacco use and risk of myocardial infarction in 52 countries in the INTERHEART study: a case-control study.Lancet368647658
- 11. Rahman MA, Zaman MM (2008) Smoking and smokeless tobacco consumption: possible risk factors for coronary heart disease among young patients attending a tertiary care cardiac hospital in Bangladesh. Public Health 122: 1331–1338.MA RahmanMM Zaman2008Smoking and smokeless tobacco consumption: possible risk factors for coronary heart disease among young patients attending a tertiary care cardiac hospital in Bangladesh.Public Health12213311338
- 12. Accortt NA, Waterbor JW, Beall C, Howard G (2002) Chronic disease mortality in a cohort of smokeless tobacco users. Am J Epidemiol 156: 730–737.NA AccorttJW WaterborC. BeallG. Howard2002Chronic disease mortality in a cohort of smokeless tobacco users.Am J Epidemiol156730737
- 13. Hansson J, Pedersen NL, Galanti MR, Andersson T, Ahlbom A, et al. (2009) Use of snus and risk for cardiovascular disease: results from the Swedish Twin Registry. J Intern Med 265: 717–724.J. HanssonNL PedersenMR GalantiT. AnderssonA. Ahlbom2009Use of snus and risk for cardiovascular disease: results from the Swedish Twin Registry.J Intern Med265717724
- 14. Janzon E, Hedblad B (2009) Swedish snuff and incidence of cardiovascular disease. A population-based cohort study. BMC Cardiovasc Disord 9: 21.E. JanzonB. Hedblad2009Swedish snuff and incidence of cardiovascular disease. A population-based cohort study.BMC Cardiovasc Disord921
- 15. Huhtasaari F, Asplund K, Lundberg V, Stegmayr B, Wester PO (1992) Tobacco and myocardial infarction: is snuff less dangerous than cigarettes? BMJ 305: 1252–1256.F. HuhtasaariK. AsplundV. LundbergB. StegmayrPO Wester1992Tobacco and myocardial infarction: is snuff less dangerous than cigarettes?BMJ30512521256
- 16. Huhtasaari F, Lundberg V, Eliasson M, Janlert U, Asplund K (1999) Smokeless tobacco as a possible risk factor for myocardial infarction: a population-based study in middle-aged men. J Am Coll Cardiol 34: 1784–1790.F. HuhtasaariV. LundbergM. EliassonU. JanlertK. Asplund1999Smokeless tobacco as a possible risk factor for myocardial infarction: a population-based study in middle-aged men.J Am Coll Cardiol3417841790
- 17. Hergens MP, Ahlbom A, Andersson T, Pershagen G (2005) Swedish moist snuff and myocardial infarction among men. Epidemiology 16: 12–16.MP HergensA. AhlbomT. AnderssonG. Pershagen2005Swedish moist snuff and myocardial infarction among men.Epidemiology161216
- 18. McKee M, Gilmore A (2007) Commentary: Smokeless tobacco: seeing the whole picture. Int J Epidemiol 36: 805–808.M. McKeeA. Gilmore2007Commentary: Smokeless tobacco: seeing the whole picture.Int J Epidemiol36805808
- 19. Asplund K (2003) Smokeless tobacco and cardiovascular disease. Prog Cardiovasc Dis 45: 383–394.K. Asplund2003Smokeless tobacco and cardiovascular disease.Prog Cardiovasc Dis45383394
- 20. Gupta PC, Pednekar MS, Parkin DM, Sankaranarayanan R (2005) Tobacco associated mortality in Mumbai (Bombay) India. Results of the Bombay Cohort Study. Int J Epidemiol 34: 1395–1402.PC GuptaMS PednekarDM ParkinR. Sankaranarayanan2005Tobacco associated mortality in Mumbai (Bombay) India. Results of the Bombay Cohort Study.Int J Epidemiol3413951402
- 21. Yen AM-F, Chen L-S, Chiu Y-H, Boucher BJ, Chen TH-H (2008) A prospective community-population-registry–based cohort study of the association between betel-quid chewing and cardiovascular disease in men in Taiwan (KCIS no. 19). Am J Clin Nutr 87: 70–78.AM-F YenL-S ChenY-H ChiuBJ BoucherTH-H Chen2008A prospective community-population-registry–based cohort study of the association between betel-quid chewing and cardiovascular disease in men in Taiwan (KCIS no. 19).Am J Clin Nutr877078
- 22. Lin W-Y, Chiu T-Y, Lee L-T, Lin C-C, Huang C-Y, et al. (2008) Betel nut chewing is associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease and all-cause mortality in Taiwanese men. Am J Clin Nutr 87: 1204–1211.W-Y LinT-Y ChiuL-T LeeC-C LinC-Y Huang2008Betel nut chewing is associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease and all-cause mortality in Taiwanese men.Am J Clin Nutr8712041211
- 23. Guh JY, Chen HC, Tsai JF, Chuang LY (2007) Betel-quid use is associated with heart disease in women. Am J Clin Nutr 85: 1229–1235.JY GuhHC ChenJF TsaiLY Chuang2007Betel-quid use is associated with heart disease in women.Am J Clin Nutr8512291235
- 24. World Health Organization-Bangladesh (2009) Global adult tobacco survey: Bangladesh report 2009. Dhaka, Bangladesh: World Health Organization-Bangladesh. World Health Organization-Bangladesh2009Global adult tobacco survey: Bangladesh report 2009.Dhaka, BangladeshWorld Health Organization-Bangladesh
- 25. World Health Organization-Bangladesh (2006) Impact of tobacco related illnesses in Bangladesh. Dhaka, Bangladesh: WHO-Bangladesh. World Health Organization-Bangladesh2006Impact of tobacco related illnesses in Bangladesh.Dhaka, BangladeshWHO-Bangladesh
- 26. Flora MS, Mascie-Taylor CG, Rahman M (2009) Gender and locality differences in tobacco prevalence among adult Bangladeshis. Tob Control 18: 445–450.MS FloraCG Mascie-TaylorM. Rahman2009Gender and locality differences in tobacco prevalence among adult Bangladeshis.Tob Control18445450
- 27. Efroymson D, Ahmed S, Townsend J, Alam SM, Dey AR, et al. (2001) Hungry for tobacco: an analysis of the economic impact of tobacco consumption on the poor in Bangladesh. Tob Control 10: 212–217.D. EfroymsonS. AhmedJ. TownsendSM AlamAR Dey2001Hungry for tobacco: an analysis of the economic impact of tobacco consumption on the poor in Bangladesh.Tob Control10212217
- 28. Choudhury K, Hanifi SMA, Mahmood SS, Bhuiya A (2007) Sociodemographic characteristics of tobacco consumers in a rural area of Bangladesh. J Health Popul Nutr 25: 456–464.K. ChoudhurySMA HanifiSS MahmoodA. Bhuiya2007Sociodemographic characteristics of tobacco consumers in a rural area of Bangladesh.J Health Popul Nutr25456464
- 29. Gupta PC, Ray CS (2003) Smokeless tobacco and health in India and South Asia. Respirology 8: 419–431.PC GuptaCS Ray2003Smokeless tobacco and health in India and South Asia.Respirology8419431
- 30. Critchley JA, Capewell S (2003) Mortality risk reduction associated with smoking cessation in patients with coronary heart disease: a systematic review. Journal of the American Medical Association 290: 86–97.JA CritchleyS. Capewell2003Mortality risk reduction associated with smoking cessation in patients with coronary heart disease: a systematic review.Journal of the American Medical Association2908697
- 31. Kawachi I, Colditz GA, Stampfer MJ, Willett WC, Manson JAE, et al. (1993) Smoking cessation in relation to total mortality rates in women: a prospective cohort study. Ann Intern Med 119: 992–1000.I. KawachiGA ColditzMJ StampferWC WillettJAE Manson1993Smoking cessation in relation to total mortality rates in women: a prospective cohort study.Ann Intern Med1199921000
- 32. McElduff P, Dobson A, Beaglehole R, Jackson R (1998) Rapid reduction in coronary risk for those who quit cigarette smoking. Aust N Z J Public Health 22: 787–791.P. McElduffA. DobsonR. BeagleholeR. Jackson1998Rapid reduction in coronary risk for those who quit cigarette smoking.Aust N Z J Public Health22787791
- 33. Infante-Rivard C (2003) Hospital or population controls for case-control studies of severe childhood diseases? Am J Epidemiol 157: 176–182.C. Infante-Rivard2003Hospital or population controls for case-control studies of severe childhood diseases?Am J Epidemiol157176182
- 34. West DW, Schuman KL, Lyon JL, Robison lM, Allred R (1984) Differences in risk estimations from a hospital and a population-based case-control study. Int J Epidemiol 13: 235–239.DW WestKL SchumanJL LyonlM RobisonR. Allred1984Differences in risk estimations from a hospital and a population-based case-control study.Int J Epidemiol13235239
- 35. Rose GA (1962) The diagnosis of ischaemic heart pain and intermittent claudication in field surveys. Bull World Health Organ 27: 645–658.GA Rose1962The diagnosis of ischaemic heart pain and intermittent claudication in field surveys.Bull World Health Organ27645658
- 36. AOAC International (2004) Official methods of analysis: Nicotine in tobacco prodcuts. AOAC International2004Official methods of analysis: Nicotine in tobacco prodcuts
- 37. Stanfill SB, Connolly GN, Zhang L, Jia LT, Henningfield JE, et al. (2011) Global surveillance of oral tobacco products: total nicotine, unionised nicotine and tobacco-specific N-nitrosamines. Tob Control 20: e2.SB StanfillGN ConnollyL. ZhangLT JiaJE Henningfield2011Global surveillance of oral tobacco products: total nicotine, unionised nicotine and tobacco-specific N-nitrosamines.Tob Control20e2
- 38. Rahman M, Sakamoto J, Fukui T (2003) Conditional versus unconditional logistic regression in the medical literature. J Clin Epidemiol 56: 101–102.M. RahmanJ. SakamotoT. Fukui2003Conditional versus unconditional logistic regression in the medical literature.J Clin Epidemiol56101102
- 39. Wennberg P, Eliasson M, Hallmans G, Johansson L, Boman K, et al. (2007) The risk of myocardial infarction and sudden cardiac death amongst snuff users with or without a previous history of smoking. J Intern Med 262: 360–367.P. WennbergM. EliassonG. HallmansL. JohanssonK. Boman2007The risk of myocardial infarction and sudden cardiac death amongst snuff users with or without a previous history of smoking.J Intern Med262360367
- 40. Bolinder GM, Ahlborg BO, Lindell JH (1992) Use of smokeless tobacco: blood pressure elevation and other health hazards found in a large-scale population survey. J Intern Med 232: 327–334.GM BolinderBO AhlborgJH Lindell1992Use of smokeless tobacco: blood pressure elevation and other health hazards found in a large-scale population survey.J Intern Med232327334
- 41. Johansson S-Ea, Sundquist Ka, Qvist Jb, Sundquist Ja (2005) Smokeless tobacco and coronary heart disease: a 12-year follow-up study. Eur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil 12: 387–392.S-Ea JohanssonKa SundquistJb QvistJa Sundquist2005Smokeless tobacco and coronary heart disease: a 12-year follow-up study.Eur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil12387392
- 42. Haglund B, Eliasson M, Stenbeck M, Rosen M (2007) Is moist snuff use associated with excess risk of IHD or stroke? A longitudinal follow-up of snuff users in Sweden. Scand J Public Health 35: 618–622.B. HaglundM. EliassonM. StenbeckM. Rosen2007Is moist snuff use associated with excess risk of IHD or stroke? A longitudinal follow-up of snuff users in Sweden.Scand J Public Health35618622
- 43. Malson JL, Sims K, Murty R, Pickworth WB (2001) Comparison of the nicotine content of tobacco used in bidis and conventional cigarettes. Tob Control 10: 181–183.JL MalsonK. SimsR. MurtyWB Pickworth2001Comparison of the nicotine content of tobacco used in bidis and conventional cigarettes.Tob Control10181183
- 44. Benowitz NL (1997) Systemic absorption and effects of nicotine from smokeless tobacco. Adv Dent Res 11: 336–341.NL Benowitz1997Systemic absorption and effects of nicotine from smokeless tobacco.Adv Dent Res11336341
- 45. Benowitz NL (1991) Nicotine and coronary heart disease. Trends Cardiovasc Med 1: 315–321.NL Benowitz1991Nicotine and coronary heart disease.Trends Cardiovasc Med1315321
- 46. Melikian AA, Hoffmann D (2009) Smokeless tobacco: a gateway to smoking or a way away from smoking. Biomarkers 14: Suppl 185–89.AA MelikianD. Hoffmann2009Smokeless tobacco: a gateway to smoking or a way away from smoking.Biomarkers14Suppl 18589
- 47. Henningfield JE, Fagerstrom KO (2001) Swedish Match Company, Swedish snus and public health: a harm reduction experiment in progress? Tob Control 10: 253–257.JE HenningfieldKO Fagerstrom2001Swedish Match Company, Swedish snus and public health: a harm reduction experiment in progress?Tob Control10253257
- 48. Foulds J, Ramstrom L, Burke M, Fagerström K (2003) Effect of smokeless tobacco (snus) on smoking and public health in Sweden. Tob Control 12: 349–359.J. FouldsL. RamstromM. BurkeK. Fagerström2003Effect of smokeless tobacco (snus) on smoking and public health in Sweden.Tob Control12349359
- 49. Stepanov I, Hecht SS, Ramakrishnan S, Gupta PC (2005) Tobacco-specific nitrosamines in smokeless tobacco products marketed in India. Int J Cancer 116: 16–19.I. StepanovSS HechtS. RamakrishnanPC Gupta2005Tobacco-specific nitrosamines in smokeless tobacco products marketed in India.Int J Cancer1161619