Astroviruses are a known cause of human diarrhea. Recently the highly divergent astrovirus MLB1 (MLB1) was identified in a stool sample from a patient with diarrhea. It has subsequently been detected in stool from individuals with and without diarrhea. To determine whether MLB1 is associated with diarrhea, we conducted a case control study of MLB1. In parallel, the prevalence of the classic human astroviruses (HAstVs) was also determined in the same case control cohort. 400 cases and 400 paired controls from a longitudinal birth cohort in Vellore, India were analyzed by RT-PCR. While HAstVs were associated with diarrhea (p = 0.029) in this cohort, MLB1 was not; 14 of the controls and 4 cases were positive for MLB1. Furthermore, MLB1 viral load did not differ significantly between the cases and controls. The role of MLB1 in human health still remains unknown and future studies are needed.
Citation: Holtz LR, Bauer IK, Rajendran P, Kang G, Wang D (2011) Astrovirus MLB1 Is Not Associated with Diarrhea in a Cohort of Indian Children. PLoS ONE 6(12): e28647. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028647
Editor: Leo L. M. Poon, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Received: October 25, 2011; Accepted: November 11, 2011; Published: December 9, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Holtz et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported in part by National Institutes of Health (NIH)/National Center for Research Resources Washington University-ICTS grant number KL2 RR024994 and by NIH grant R21 AI090199. DW holds an Investigators in the Pathogenesis of Infectious Disease Award from the Burroughs Wellcome Fund. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The first astrovirus infecting humans was described in 1975 . Since then, a total of 8 serotypes closely related to this original astrovirus (“classic human astroviruses” (HAstVs)) have been identified, all of which are believed to cause diarrhea. Diarrhea symptoms typically last 2–4 days following a 3–4 day incubation period . These infections most commonly affect children, the elderly, and the immunocompromised . HAstVs account for up to ∼10% of sporadic cases of non-bacterial diarrhea in children , , , . Since 2008, five highly divergent astroviruses have been discovered in human diarrhea specimens: MLB1 , astrovirus MLB2 (MLB2) , astrovirus VA1 (VA1) , astrovirus VA2 (VA2) , and astrovirus VA3 (VA3) . Of these viruses, MLB1 has been detected at the highest frequency. MLB1 was first identified in the stool of child with unexplained diarrhea. Subsequently, it has been found in stools collected from around the world , , , , ,  from patients with and without diarrhea.
The finding of the novel astrovirus MLB1 in stool specimens from patients with diarrhea raises the question of whether or not, like all other human astroviruses, it also causes diarrhea. Historically, proof of causality for diarrheagenic viruses relied upon ingestion of fecal filtrates by human volunteers , , , . Such studies are, however, no longer feasible for novel viruses of unknown pathogenicity. Thus, assigning pathogenicity to a newly identified virus requires indirect approaches such as infection of surrogate animal models or epidemiologic analyses of human populations. Here we describe a case control study aimed at determining whether or not MLB1 is associated with diarrhea.
Materials and Methods
Description of Samples
The institutional review boards of Christian Medical College, Vellore, India and Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, USA approved this study. 400 case and 400 control stool samples were selected from a previously described longitudinal birth cohort in Vellore, India , , . Children were followed for 3 years with twice-weekly home visits and collection of stool every two weeks and during every diarrheal episode. 373 children completed the three year study. A total of 1955 diarrhea and ∼27,000 control stools were collected from 2002–2006. The severity of each diarrheal episode was recorded using the 20 point Vesikari scale developed for rotaviral gastroenteritis, which includes number and duration of diarrhea and vomiting episodes, presence of fever and dehydration and classifies gastroenteritis as mild, moderate, severe and very severe . 400 stool samples from acute diarrhea episodes that were negative for rotavirus by enzyme immunoassay and PCR, for norovirus by PCR, for bacterial pathogens (Vibrio cholerae, enteropathogenic Escherichia coli, Salmonella, Shigella, Aeromonas and Plesiomonas) by culture, biochemical reactions and serogrouping where appropriate and for parasites by routine saline and iodine preparations and modified acid fast stain were chosen as cases . To obtain paired control samples, an asymptomatic surveillance stool sample collected at least 6 weeks prior to the acute diarrhea sample was selected from the same child. The 400 paired samples were collected from 249 children.
200 µL of a ∼20% fecal suspension were extracted using the Boom method  and the extracted total nucleic acid was eluted into 40 µL of water. As previously described, a two stage screening strategy was used to detect astroviruses . In brief, astrovirus consensus primers SF0073 (5′-GATTGGACTCGATTTGATGG-3′) and SF0076 (5′-CTGGCTTAACCCACATTCC-3′), designed to the RNA polymerase (ORF 1b) were used to screen all samples in the first stage. Samples that were positive in the first phase of screening were then subjected to additional RT-PCR screenings with primers specific for classic human astroviruses [Mon269 (5′-CAACTCAGGAAACAGGGTGT-3′) and Mon270 (5′-TCAGATGCATTGTCATTGGT-3′)]  and primers specific for MLB1 [SF0053 (5′-CTGTAGCTCGTGTTAGTCTTAACA-3′) and SF0061 (5′-GTTCATTGGCACCATCAGAAC-3′)], both of which target the capsid region (ORF 2). PCR amplicons were cloned into pCR4 (Invitrogen) and sequenced using standard Sanger sequencing technology.
Sequences of the capsid region amplicons from HAstV and MLB1 positive samples were aligned using ClustalX1.83. PAUP was then used to generate maximum parsimony trees with 1,000 bootstrap replicates.
MLB1 consensus primers ( LG0189 5′- AAGTGTGCATATGTTGGGACC -3′ and LG0190 5′- CTACACCTCTCCAATTCATG -′3) targeting a 131 nt segment of the ORF1a region of the MLB1 genome were designed by alignment of the 4 MLB1 sequences present in GenBank (NC_011400.1, FJ402983.1, HM450380.1, and HM989952.1) containing the region of interest as of 12/23/2010; these primers were used in a SYBR green qRT-PCR assay. QRT-PCR was performed using qScript One-Step kit (Quanta) as follows: 50°C for 10 min, 95°C for 5 min, 45 cycles of 95°C for 10 sec and 60°C for 30 sec followed by a melt curve. To establish a standard curve for this assay, in-vitro transcribed RNA was generated from a plasmid containing nt 1 to 846 of MLB1 (GenBank NC_011400.1) using MAXIscript (Ambion) per manufacturer's protocol. Serial dilutions of this in-vitro transcribed RNA from 5×106 copies to 5 copies were used for the standard curve.
RT-PCR case control study
For HAstVs, 14 of the 400 cases were positive and 4 of the 400 controls were positive. By contrast, for MLB1 only four of the cases were positive while 14 of the controls were positive. To take into account the fact that some participants were sampled more than once, logistic regression models were fit using generalized estimating equations. HAstVs were more likely to be present in the diarrheal samples than in the asymptomatic samples (OR 3.59, 95% CI 1.14–11.31, p = 0.029), consistent with results of previous studies . By contrast MLB1 was less likely to be present in the diarrheal samples than in the asymptomatic samples (OR 0.28, 95% CI 0.09–0.89, p = 0.033).
All RT-PCR positive samples were cloned and sequenced (GenBank JN871233–JN871268). Amplicons from the capsid region were chosen for sequencing, as this is the least conserved region of the genome and might reveal the most divergence. The MLB1 capsid amplicons shared 96–99% nucleotide identity to each other while the HAstV capsid amplicons shared 77–100% nucleotide identity to each other. Phylogenetic analysis of the HAstV and MLB1 amplicons obtained in the capsid regions showed no clustering of the cases vs controls (data not shown). Five samples (4 controls and 1 case) were positive for both HAstV and MLB1.
Of the 249 children studied 107 were sampled at multiple time points. One subject had two diarrhea samples positive for HAstVs separated by 14 months. The intervening control stool, collected 12 months after the 1st diarrhea sample and 7 weeks before the 2nd diarrhea sample, from this subject was negative for HAstVs. The capsid-derived amplicons from these two diarrhea samples shared 78% identity, suggesting that this subject was infected by two different HAstV serotypes at the two time points. Two subjects had two asymptomatic stools positive for MLB1 with an intervening diarrhea sample that was negative for MLB1. For one subject these asymptomatic samples were separated by 18 months. The capsid-derived amplicons from these two samples shared 98% identity. For the other subject, these asymptomatic samples were separated by 8 months and shared 99% identity. One interpretation of this observation is that reinfection by MLB1 is possible.
qRT-PCR of positive samples
Samples positive for MLB1 by RT-PCR were then subjected to qRT-PCR to establish if viral load differed between cases and controls as has been described for norovirus . There was no significant difference in the RNA copy number/ml of fecal suspension between cases and controls. Specifically, for the 4 cases the average RNA copy number/ml fecal suspension was 7×103 and for the 14 positive control samples the average copy number/ml of fecal suspension was 4×104. Using the Mann-Whitney test, there was not a significant difference between cases and controls (p = 0.51).
In this study, we performed a case control study of MLB1 and HAstVs. We demonstrated in this cohort that HAstVs are associated with diarrhea. By contrast, MLB1 was not associated with diarrhea. These results suggest that MLB1 may not play an etiologic role in human diarrhea. However, a single case control study is not sufficient to definitively answer this question as evidenced by the fact that there are examples from the literature of bona fide diarrhea pathogens for which case control studies did not yield positive associations. For example, a case control study of Campylobacter found that it was present in 22% of cases vs. 25% of controls . Furthermore, Giardia lamblia was found more commonly in controls than in cases in two studies , . A case control study from Vietnam found diarrheagenic E.coli in 23% of cases and 23% of controls . These studies highlight the challenges of determining association of a microbe with a given disease strictly by a case control study. The role of MLB1 in human health remains uncertain. It remains possible that MLB1 is an agent of diarrhea. One formal possibility is that it is present in stool simply as a result of dietary ingestion and it has no pathogenic role. Another possibility is that MLB1's pathogenic effects are outside of the enteric system and that its detection in stool simply reflects its mode of transmission, much like poliovirus. In support of this possibility, we have recently described a febrile child with MLB2 viremia, demonstrating that astroviruses can access the circulatory system and thus could have broader tropism outside the GI tract . In addition, another astrovirus was recently found in the brain tissue of an immunocompromised patient with encephalitis . Further studies are still needed to establish the role of MLB1 in human health and disease.
Conceived and designed the experiments: DW GK LRH. Performed the experiments: LRH IKB PR. Analyzed the data: LRH IKB DW. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: GK. Wrote the paper: LRH DW.
- 1. Madeley CR, Cosgrove BP (1975) Letter: 28 nm particles in faeces in infantile gastroenteritis. Lancet 2: 451–452.CR MadeleyBP Cosgrove1975Letter: 28 nm particles in faeces in infantile gastroenteritis.Lancet2451452
- 2. Midthun K, Greenberg HB, Kurtz JB, Gary GW, Lin FY, et al. (1993) Characterization and seroepidemiology of a type 5 astrovirus associated with an outbreak of gastroenteritis in Marin County, California. Journal of clinical microbiology 31: 955–962.K. MidthunHB GreenbergJB KurtzGW GaryFY Lin1993Characterization and seroepidemiology of a type 5 astrovirus associated with an outbreak of gastroenteritis in Marin County, California.Journal of clinical microbiology31955962
- 3. Mendez E, Arias CF (2007) Astroviruses. In: Knipe D, Howley PM, editors. Fields Virology. 5th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams &Wilkins. pp. 981–1000.E. MendezCF Arias2007Astroviruses.D. KnipePM HowleyFields Virology. 5th edPhiladelphiaLippincott Williams &Wilkins9811000
- 4. Glass RI, Noel J, Mitchell D, Herrmann JE, Blacklow NR, et al. (1996) The changing epidemiology of astrovirus-associated gastroenteritis: a review. Archives of virology Supplementum 12: 287–300.RI GlassJ. NoelD. MitchellJE HerrmannNR Blacklow1996The changing epidemiology of astrovirus-associated gastroenteritis: a review.Archives of virology Supplementum12287300
- 5. Klein EJ, Boster DR, Stapp JR, Wells JG, Qin X, et al. (2006) Diarrhea etiology in a Children's Hospital Emergency Department: a prospective cohort study. Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America 43: 807–813.EJ KleinDR BosterJR StappJG WellsX. Qin2006Diarrhea etiology in a Children's Hospital Emergency Department: a prospective cohort study.Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America43807813
- 6. Nguyen TA, Hoang L, Pham le D, Hoang KT, Mizuguchi M, et al. (2008) Identification of human astrovirus infections among children with acute gastroenteritis in the Southern Part of Vietnam during 2005–2006. Journal of medical virology 80: 298–305.TA NguyenL. HoangD. Pham leKT HoangM. Mizuguchi2008Identification of human astrovirus infections among children with acute gastroenteritis in the Southern Part of Vietnam during 2005–2006.Journal of medical virology80298305
- 7. Soares CC, Maciel de Albuquerque MC, Maranhao AG, Rocha LN, Ramirez ML, et al. (2008) Astrovirus detection in sporadic cases of diarrhea among hospitalized and non-hospitalized children in Rio De Janeiro, Brazil, from 1998 to 2004. Journal of medical virology 80: 113–117.CC SoaresMC Maciel de AlbuquerqueAG MaranhaoLN RochaML Ramirez2008Astrovirus detection in sporadic cases of diarrhea among hospitalized and non-hospitalized children in Rio De Janeiro, Brazil, from 1998 to 2004.Journal of medical virology80113117
- 8. Finkbeiner SR, Allred AF, Tarr PI, Klein EJ, Kirkwood CD, et al. (2008) Metagenomic analysis of human diarrhea: viral detection and discovery. PLoS pathogens 4: e1000011.SR FinkbeinerAF AllredPI TarrEJ KleinCD Kirkwood2008Metagenomic analysis of human diarrhea: viral detection and discovery.PLoS pathogens4e1000011
- 9. Finkbeiner SR, Holtz LR, Jiang Y, Rajendran P, Franz CJ, et al. (2009) Human stool contains a previously unrecognized diversity of novel astroviruses. Virology journal 6: 161.SR FinkbeinerLR HoltzY. JiangP. RajendranCJ Franz2009Human stool contains a previously unrecognized diversity of novel astroviruses.Virology journal6161
- 10. Finkbeiner SR, Li Y, Ruone S, Conrardy C, Gregoricus N, et al. (2009) Identification of a novel astrovirus (astrovirus VA1) associated with an outbreak of acute gastroenteritis. Journal of virology 83: 10836–10839.SR FinkbeinerY. LiS. RuoneC. ConrardyN. Gregoricus2009Identification of a novel astrovirus (astrovirus VA1) associated with an outbreak of acute gastroenteritis.Journal of virology831083610839
- 11. Ahmed S, Sebeny PJ, Klena JD, Pimentel G, Mansour A, et al. S. AhmedPJ SebenyJD KlenaG. PimentelA. MansourNovel Astroviruses in Children, Egypt. In press. Novel Astroviruses in Children, Egypt. In press.
- 12. Banyai K, Meleg E, Moschidou P, Martella V (2010) Detection of newly described astrovirus MLB1 in stool samples from children. Emerging infectious diseases 16: 169; author reply 169–170.K. BanyaiE. MelegP. MoschidouV. Martella2010Detection of newly described astrovirus MLB1 in stool samples from children.Emerging infectious diseases16169; author reply 169–170
- 13. Chu DK, Chin AW, Smith GJ, Chan KH, Guan Y, et al. (2010) Detection of novel astroviruses in urban brown rats and previously known astroviruses in humans. The Journal of general virology 91: 2457–2462.DK ChuAW ChinGJ SmithKH ChanY. Guan2010Detection of novel astroviruses in urban brown rats and previously known astroviruses in humans.The Journal of general virology9124572462
- 14. Finkbeiner SR, Le BM, Holtz LR, Storch GA, Wang D (2009) Detection of newly described astrovirus MLB1 in stool samples from children. Emerging infectious diseases 15: 441–444.SR FinkbeinerBM LeLR HoltzGA StorchD. Wang2009Detection of newly described astrovirus MLB1 in stool samples from children.Emerging infectious diseases15441444
- 15. Kapoor A, Li L, Victoria J, Oderinde B, Mason C, et al. (2009) Multiple novel astrovirus species in human stool. The Journal of general virology 90: 2965–2972.A. KapoorL. LiJ. VictoriaB. OderindeC. Mason2009Multiple novel astrovirus species in human stool.The Journal of general virology9029652972
- 16. Kapikian AZ, Wyatt RG, Levine MM, Yolken RH, VanKirk DH, et al. (1983) Oral administration of human rotavirus to volunteers: induction of illness and correlates of resistance. J Infect Dis 147: 95–106.AZ KapikianRG WyattMM LevineRH YolkenDH VanKirk1983Oral administration of human rotavirus to volunteers: induction of illness and correlates of resistance.J Infect Dis14795106
- 17. Thornhill TS, Kalica AR, Wyatt RG, Kapikian AZ, Chanock RM (1975) Pattern of shedding of the Norwalk particle in stools during experimentally induced gastroenteritis in volunteers as determined by immune electron microscopy. J Infect Dis 132: 28–34.TS ThornhillAR KalicaRG WyattAZ KapikianRM Chanock1975Pattern of shedding of the Norwalk particle in stools during experimentally induced gastroenteritis in volunteers as determined by immune electron microscopy.J Infect Dis1322834
- 18. Atmar RL, Opekun AR, Gilger MA, Estes MK, Crawford SE, et al. (2008) Norwalk virus shedding after experimental human infection. Emerging infectious diseases 14: 1553–1557.RL AtmarAR OpekunMA GilgerMK EstesSE Crawford2008Norwalk virus shedding after experimental human infection.Emerging infectious diseases1415531557
- 19. Gladstone BP, Das AR, Rehman AM, Jaffar S, Estes MK, et al. (2010) Burden of illness in the first 3 years of life in an Indian slum. Journal of tropical pediatrics 56: 221–226.BP GladstoneAR DasAM RehmanS. JaffarMK Estes2010Burden of illness in the first 3 years of life in an Indian slum.Journal of tropical pediatrics56221226
- 20. Gladstone BP, Muliyil JP, Jaffar S, Wheeler JG, Le Fevre A, et al. (2008) Infant morbidity in an Indian slum birth cohort. Archives of disease in childhood 93: 479–484.BP GladstoneJP MuliyilS. JaffarJG WheelerA. Le Fevre2008Infant morbidity in an Indian slum birth cohort.Archives of disease in childhood93479484
- 21. Gladstone BP, Ramani S, Mukhopadhya I, Muliyil J, Sarkar R, et al. (2011) Protective effect of natural rotavirus infection in an Indian birth cohort. The New England journal of medicine 365: 337–346.BP GladstoneS. RamaniI. MukhopadhyaJ. MuliyilR. Sarkar2011Protective effect of natural rotavirus infection in an Indian birth cohort.The New England journal of medicine365337346
- 22. Ruuska T, Vesikari T (1990) Rotavirus disease in Finnish children: use of numerical scores for clinical severity of diarrhoeal episodes. Scandinavian journal of infectious diseases 22: 259–267.T. RuuskaT. Vesikari1990Rotavirus disease in Finnish children: use of numerical scores for clinical severity of diarrhoeal episodes.Scandinavian journal of infectious diseases22259267
- 23. Ajjampur SS, Rajendran P, Ramani S, Banerjee I, Monica B, et al. (2008) Closing the diarrhoea diagnostic gap in Indian children by the application of molecular techniques. Journal of medical microbiology 57: 1364–1368.SS AjjampurP. RajendranS. RamaniI. BanerjeeB. Monica2008Closing the diarrhoea diagnostic gap in Indian children by the application of molecular techniques.Journal of medical microbiology5713641368
- 24. Boom R, Sol CJ, Salimans MM, Jansen CL, Wertheim-van Dillen PM, et al. (1990) Rapid and simple method for purification of nucleic acids. Journal of clinical microbiology 28: 495–503.R. BoomCJ SolMM SalimansCL JansenPM Wertheim-van Dillen1990Rapid and simple method for purification of nucleic acids.Journal of clinical microbiology28495503
- 25. Noel JS, Lee TW, Kurtz JB, Glass RI, Monroe SS (1995) Typing of human astroviruses from clinical isolates by enzyme immunoassay and nucleotide sequencing. Journal of clinical microbiology 33: 797–801.JS NoelTW LeeJB KurtzRI GlassSS Monroe1995Typing of human astroviruses from clinical isolates by enzyme immunoassay and nucleotide sequencing.Journal of clinical microbiology33797801
- 26. Dennehy PH, Nelson SM, Spangenberger S, Noel JS, Monroe SS, et al. (2001) A prospective case-control study of the role of astrovirus in acute diarrhea among hospitalized young children. The Journal of infectious diseases 184: 10–15.PH DennehySM NelsonS. SpangenbergerJS NoelSS Monroe2001A prospective case-control study of the role of astrovirus in acute diarrhea among hospitalized young children.The Journal of infectious diseases1841015
- 27. Phillips G, Lopman B, Tam CC, Iturriza-Gomara M, Brown D, et al. (2009) Diagnosing norovirus-associated infectious intestinal disease using viral load. BMC infectious diseases 9: 63.G. PhillipsB. LopmanCC TamM. Iturriza-GomaraD. Brown2009Diagnosing norovirus-associated infectious intestinal disease using viral load.BMC infectious diseases963
- 28. Bodhidatta L, McDaniel P, Sornsakrin S, Srijan A, Serichantalergs O, et al. (2010) Case-control study of diarrheal disease etiology in a remote rural area in Western Thailand. The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene 83: 1106–1109.L. BodhidattaP. McDanielS. SornsakrinA. SrijanO. Serichantalergs2010Case-control study of diarrheal disease etiology in a remote rural area in Western Thailand.The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene8311061109
- 29. Albert MJ, Faruque AS, Faruque SM, Sack RB, Mahalanabis D (1999) Case-control study of enteropathogens associated with childhood diarrhea in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Journal of clinical microbiology 37: 3458–3464.MJ AlbertAS FaruqueSM FaruqueRB SackD. Mahalanabis1999Case-control study of enteropathogens associated with childhood diarrhea in Dhaka, Bangladesh.Journal of clinical microbiology3734583464
- 30. Hien BT, Trang do T, Scheutz F, Cam PD, Molbak K, et al. (2007) Diarrhoeagenic Escherichia coli and other causes of childhood diarrhoea: a case-control study in children living in a wastewater-use area in Hanoi, Vietnam. Journal of medical microbiology 56: 1086–1096.BT HienT. Trang doF. ScheutzPD CamK. Molbak2007Diarrhoeagenic Escherichia coli and other causes of childhood diarrhoea: a case-control study in children living in a wastewater-use area in Hanoi, Vietnam.Journal of medical microbiology5610861096
- 31. Holtz LR, Wylie KM, Sodergren E, Jiang Y, Franz CJ, et al. (2011) Astrovirus MLB2 Viremia in a Febrile Child. LR HoltzKM WylieE. SodergrenY. JiangCJ Franz2011Astrovirus MLB2 Viremia in a Febrile Child.Emerging infectious diseases. Emerging infectious diseases.
- 32. Quan PL, Wagner TA, Briese T, Torgerson TR, Hornig M, et al. (2010) Astrovirus encephalitis in boy with X-linked agammaglobulinemia. Emerging infectious diseases 16: 918–925.PL QuanTA WagnerT. BrieseTR TorgersonM. Hornig2010Astrovirus encephalitis in boy with X-linked agammaglobulinemia.Emerging infectious diseases16918925