The development and progression of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is significantly correlated to the accumulation of genomic alterations. Array-based comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) has been applied to a wide range of tumors including HCCs for the genome-wide high resolution screening of DNA copy number changes. However, the relevant chromosomal variations that play a central role in the development of HCC still are not fully elucidated.
In present study, in order to further characterize the copy number alterations (CNAs) important to HCC development, we conducted a meta-analysis of four published independent array-CGH datasets including total 159 samples.
Eighty five significant gains (frequency ≥25%) were mostly mapped to five broad chromosomal regions including 1q, 6p, 8q, 17q and 20p, as well as two narrow regions 5p15.33 and 9q34.2-34.3. Eighty eight significant losses (frequency ≥25%) were most frequently present in 4q, 6q, 8p, 9p, 13q, 14q, 16q, and 17p. Significant correlations existed between chromosomal aberrations either located on the same chromosome or the different chromosomes. HCCs with different etiologies largely exhibited surprisingly similar profiles of chromosomal aberrations with only a few exceptions. Furthermore, the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) pathway analysis indicated that the genes affected by these chromosomal aberrations were significantly enriched in 31 canonical pathways with the highest enrichment observed for antiviral immunity pathways.
Citation: Guo X, Yanna, Ma X, An J, Shang Y, Huang Q, et al. (2011) A Meta-Analysis of Array-CGH Studies Implicates Antiviral Immunity Pathways in the Development of Hepatocellular Carcinoma. PLoS ONE6(12): e28404. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028404
Editor: Shree Ram Singh, National Cancer Institute, United States of America
Received: October 19, 2011; Accepted: November 7, 2011; Published: December 12, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Guo et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by grant 30872927 from the National Natural Science Foundation of China and grant 2009CB521704 from the National Basic Research Program. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The development and progression of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is significantly correlated to the accumulation of genomic alterations . Therefore, it is important to have a clear landscape of the genomic aberrations that occur during the multistep process of hepatocarcinogenesis. Previous studies have used high-resolution molecular karyotyping analyses to provide a comprehensive catalog of structural aberrations of the whole chromosomes in HCC . However, this method is highly specialized and time-consuming. As a consequence, only a very limited number of HCC cases have been evaluated in these studies. Moreover, the modest resolution of the karyotyping analysis made it difficult to fully define the overall genomic profiles of HCC in a more accurate manner. Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) has been developed in recent years to monitor the DNA copy number changes at a global level . However, traditional CGH techniques still have the limitation of modest resolution (approximately 2 Mb for amplifications and 10–20 Mb for deletions) and thus could not detect changes in smaller chromosomal regions . In comparison, array-based CGH (array CGH) is a newly developed technology that allows for high-throughput and high-resolution (at 1 Mb) screening of genome-wide DNA copy number changes (either amplifications or deletions) at the gene level . Array CGH combines fluorescence techniques with the microarray platform that allows for the comparison of DNA content in two differentially labeled genomes: a test genome (patient) and a reference genome (control). The microarray platform also allows for the simultaneous scanning of thousands of individual DNA sequences from the whole genome, and provides high-resolution data on the locations of identified aberrations in a single experiment. To date, array-CGH has been applied to a wide range of solid tumors, including liver, breast, gastric, kidney and bladder cancers , , , , . Recently, another technology platform based on single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) array has been developed to determine the copy number abnormalities of genomic DNA at sub-kilobase resolution , . Except for an advantage of high resolution, this platform also has a limitation of high signal-to-noise ratio which is hard to improve.
Many investigators have made varying attempts to search for genes implicated in hepatocarcinogenesis. Screening for chromosomal regions with frequent gains and losses is one of the first steps toward the identification of genes. Using the traditional and array-CGH, frequent DNA copy number gains at chromosomes 1q, 8q and 20q, and frequent DNA copy number losses at 1p, 4q, 8p, 13q, 16q and 17p have been identified in HCC samples , , , , , , . Some of these regions contain known candidate oncogenes or tumor suppressor genes, such as ZNF217 (20q13) , TP53 (17p13), RB1 (13q14) and cyclin D1 (11q13) . However, it is believed that the currently identified genes represented only a small percentage of causal elements in hepatocarcinogenesis and the vast majority of genes with chromosomal aberrations that may play a central role in HCC development are still unknown.
Meta-analysis is a systematic and quantitative synthesis of prior evidence . It offers the opportunity to critically evaluate and statistically combine the results of comparable studies or trials in order to achieve more robust and reliable results as well as identify novel findings that are not apparent in individual studies. In previous reports, a meta-analysis of CGH data comprising of 785 HCCs has been carried out and identified significant correlations of chromosomal deletions on 4q, 13q, and 16q with hepatitis B virus (HBV) etiology . Recently, using the array-CGH technology, several different studies have generated a wealth of data on more than 100 analyzed HCC samples that await a more comprehensive interpretation , , , . The aim of this study was to identify potential genes and pathways important to HCC by utilizing the available data from published array CGH studies of human HCC.
Materials and Methods
Data collection of array CGH studies in HCC
Datasets for HCC array CGH studies were identified from public resources including the supplementary files of published papers, NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo), ArrayExpress (http://www.ebi.ac.uk) database using hepatocellular carcinoma and array-based comparative genomic hybridization as keywords. Datasets from studies using HCC cell lines were excluded. We identified four datasets with complete original data that are publicly available, including two from the supplementary files of published HCC array CGH studies and two from the GEO database (GSE8351 and GSE22635) , , , . The detailed information was listed in Table 1. Three of the four studies used BAC clone as the hybridization probe while one used synthetic oligonucleotides as the hybridization probe. A total of 159 HCC tissue samples in these four datasets were collected, including 54 samples with HBV infection, 57 with hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection, 6 with the infections of both HBV and HCV, 3 with positive hepatitis B virus X protein (HBx), and 39 samples without viral infection.
Data pre-processing for the integration across different platforms
Because the four array CGH datasets in this study were generated using different types of technical platforms that contain different numbers of probes at varied spacing and resolution, they cannot be directly compared and combined. To transform the datasets from different platforms into a common format for the purpose of meta-analysis, we pre-processed the original dataset of each study based on a procedure previously described with minor modification , . The detailed procedure used in this study is described below:
First step: reconciliation of genome mapping data generated from BAC clones and oligonucleotide probes.
In the original datasets, chromosomal positions of BAC and oligo probes were assigned based on the different versions of human genome assembly, such as hg15, hg17 and hg18. Therefore, we used the annotation database of UCSC human genome (hg19/GRCh37) to re-assign the start and end chromosomal positions for all BAC and oligo probes from the four datasets. The unmappable probes were excluded from further analysis.
Second step: assignment of chromosomal positioning anchors.
Because the copy number alterations (CNAs) of chromosomal segments were detected on different scales by different probes in the four datasets, it was difficult to directly compare and integrate these datasets. To resolve this issue, we assigned a set of chromosomal positioning anchors that were composed of the start and end chromosomal positions of all the probes used in the four datasets. The log2-transformed DNA copy number ratio for each anchor was then determined for all the samples from different datasets based on the following principles. For any dataset, when anchors lied in the probes of the dataset, the log2-transformed ratio for probe was assigned to corresponding anchors. When an anchor lied outside of any detected probes of the dataset, a missing value was created and set to the anchor. Using this approach, we were able to delineate the same chromosomal positions to the different probes used in the different datasets of the four studies.
Third step: scaling and segmentation across multiple platforms.
To integrate data across multiple sources for meta-analysis, multi-platform segmentation with proper scaling was performed by using a multi-platform circular binary segmentation (MPCBS) algorithm recently reported by Zhang et al , which was implemented into an R package which can be accessed on R-Forge under a project name MPCBS (http:// r-forge.r-project.org/). This algorithm, which is based on a simple multi-platform change-point model, relies on a weighted sum of t-statistics to scan for copy number changes and does not require a pre-standardization of different data sources. To minimize the computational complexity and maximize the generality, chromosomes were segmented individually and sex chromosomes were not included.
Fourth step: determination of gain and loss events.
After segmentation, the CNAs of chromosomal segments were determined using a nonhierarchical k-means clustering (k = 3) algorithm . All log2-transformed ratio values of the segments generated in the third step were clustered and classified into three subgroups by two threshold values (0.141 and −0.136), representing copy number gain (>0.141), copy number loss (<−0.136), and no copy number change (between −0.136 and 0.141).
Fifth step: evaluation of pre-processing performance.
Pearson Correlation Coefficient (PCC) analysis was used to evaluate the performance of pre-processing. We first calculated the PCC value of log2-transformed ratio between any two samples from the same datasets. Then we estimated the correlation among samples of different platforms before and after pre-processing. The PCC values of any two samples should not show the dependencies on the platform after high-quality preprocessing.
Profiling of chromosomal aberrations and pathway analysis
Based on the definition of gain and loss events, we conducted genome-wide profiling of CNAs for all the HCC samples included in the four datasets and calculated the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations for each sample. We then, using a Chi-square test, compared the frequencies of copy number gains and losses separately between HBV-HCC and HCV-HCC, or between HCC with and without viral infection. In further analyses, we only focused on those highly prevalent events of copy number gains and losses (frequency >25%). We first evaluated the correlation between any two CNAs by calculating the PCC value. Then, the genes in these segments with frequent gains/losses were mapped into the pathways derived from the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) database . The pathways that were significantly affected by the identified CNAs were determined by Fisher' exact test.
Profile of chromosomal alterations in all HCC samples
We profiled the CNAs (gains or losses) of chromosomal segments in human HCC through a meta-analysis of four available independent array CGH datasets including total 159 samples. To integrate all datasets from different platforms, the raw data were pre-processed and the pre-processing performance was evaluated using the PCC analysis. Our results indicated that the PCC values of individual samples within a platform were significantly higher than those between two different platforms before data pre-processing. After pre-processing, the correlation obtained for samples between different platforms after pre-processing was significantly improved with an increase of average correlation coefficient from 0.198 to 0.349 (Fig. 1). These data showed that the four independent datasets have been successfully transformed into a comparable form. Next, chromosomal gain and loss events were determined using log2-transformed ratio thresholds of 0.141 and -0.136 derived from the k-means clustering analysis and the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations were calculated for all HCC samples. Our results indicated that 85 chromosomal segments exhibited a frequent copy number gain (≥25%) and 88 exhibited a frequent copy number loss (≥25%). Detailed data was not presented here because of the space limitation. They are available when required. As shown in Fig. 2, the significant gains were mostly mapped to several broad chromosomal regions including 1q, 6p, 8q, 17q and 20q, as well as four narrow regions including 5p15.33- 5p14.2, 9q34.2-34.3, 20p13 and 20p11.21. Significant losses were frequently observed in 4q, 6q, 8p, 9p, 13q, 14q, 16q, and 17p. Among these regions, chromosome 1q was most significantly affected by copy number gain and chromosome 8p was most significantly affected by copy number loss. In particular, gains in 1q32.1, 1q24.1, and 1q21.3-23.3 were detected in >70% of all HCC samples, and losses in 8p23.3-21.3 were detected in >55% of the samples.
In triangle (a) and (b), color points dotted in rectangles represent PCC values of log2-transformed ratio between any two samples from different datasets, while color points dotted in small triangles represent those from same dataset. The brightness of color blue is directly proportional to the value (0 – 1) of Pearson correlation coefficient.
(a), heatmap of CNAs across all chromosomes. (b), the frequencies of CNAs across all chromosomes. Copy number gain and loss events of chromosomal segments were determined using log2-transformed ratio thresholds of 0.141 and −0.136 derived from the k-means clustering analysis. The color brightness is directly proportional to the frequency of CNA. Color red represents copy number gain and color blue represents copy number loss. CNA: copy number alteration.
Correlations between significant chromosomal aberrations
Spearman's rank correlation coefficient was calculated to assess the correlations between different chromosomal copy number gains and losses described above at the significant level of p<0.001. Our results indicated that significant correlations existed between specific chromosomal aberrations either located on the same or different chromosomes and the significances from the same chromosome were usually higher than those from different chromosomes. As shown in Fig. 3(a), significant finding from the same chromosome were mainly identified for chromosomes 1q, 4q, 5p, 6p, 6q, 8p, 8q, 9p, 13q, 14q, 16q, 17p, 17q, 20p, 20q and between 6p and 6q, 8p and 8q, 17p and 17q, 20p and 20q. As indicated in Fig. 3(b), significant correlations mainly existed between 1q gains and 5p gains, and 6p gains or 4q losses, with a positive correlation coefficient of at least 0.25, 20q gains and 9p losses or 14q losses with a negative correlation coefficient of over −0.3. In addition, losses of 4q, 9p, 13q, 16q and 17p frequently co-occurred with a correlation coefficient ranging from 0.26 to 0.46. Significant correlations were also observed between 6p gains and 8p losses, 8p losses and 9p losses, and 14q losses and 16q losses.
Chromosomal segments with significant gain were highlighted in red and those with significant loss in blue. Spearman's rank correlation coefficient was calculated to assess the correlations between different chromosomal copy number gains and losses at the significant level of p<0.001.
Canonical pathways significantly linked with chromosomal aberrations
To explore the potential effects of chromosomal aberrations implicated in the molecular mechanism of HCC development, we further analyzed the functional KEGG pathways enriched with genes located on the chromosomal segments with significant copy number alterations. Our results indicated that the genes affected by chromosomal aberrations were significantly enriched in 31 canonical pathways. The list of pathways together with the related gene information was summarized in Table 2. According to the biological function, these pathways were divided into three major categories: 18 immune-related pathways, 3 cancer-related pathways and 10 metabolism-related pathways. Among these pathways, antiviral immunity pathways were most significantly affected, such as the antigen processing and presentation pathway (hsa04612), RIG I like receptor signaling pathway (hsa04622), natural killer cell mediated cytotoxicity pathway (hsa04650), cytosolic DNA sensing pathway (hsa04623), toll like receptor signaling pathway (hsa04620), and cytokine and cytokine receptor interaction pathway (hsa04060). Moreover, we found many pathways were interrelated and driven by the presence of same or similar sets of genes. For example, seven immune-related pathways (hsa05320, hsa04612, hsa04622, hsa04650, hsa04623, hsa04620 and hsa04140) were driven by signals in the same core set of the interferon-alpha family genes (IFNA1, IFNA10, IFNA13, IFNA14, IFNA16, IFNA17, IFNA2, IFNA21, IFNA4, IFNA5, IFNA6, IFNA7, IFNA8) that are contiguously located within a 0.3 Mb region on chromosome 9p21.3. These genes play a vital role in the non-specific antiviral immunity that occurs at the early phase of viral infections. We also found that 10 immune-related pathways harbored another core set of genes, the human leukocyte antigen gene family . In addition, six metabolism-related pathway (hsa00982, hsa00140, hsa00053, hsa00983, hsa00980, hsa00040) had the same core set of genes, the uridine diphosphate glycosyltransferase 2 family (UGT2A1, UGT2A3, UGT2B4, UGT2B7, UGT2B10, UGT2B11, UGT2B15, UGT2B17, UGT2B28), that are contiguously located within a 2 Mb region on chromosome 4q13.2. Only a few cancer-related pathways were found to be significantly affected by the chromosomal aberrations identified in this study with a common gene set. However, several oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes are mapped to these pathways, such as TP53, RB1, and MYC, which have been shown to play an important role in hepatocarcinogenesis , .
Etiology-related chromosomal aberrations
We investigated the profiles of etiology-related chromosomal aberrations in HCCs. As indicated in Fig. 4, HCC samples with different etiologies exhibited very similar profiles of chromosomal aberrations with only a few exceptions. When we compared the profiles of 48 HBV-related and 23 HCV-related HCCs, 14 copy number gains and 59 losses had significantly different frequencies. Almost all of these segmental gains and losses were harbored in HBV-related HCCs, except for gains of 12p13.1-12p12.3 and losses of 3q26.1-3q26.2 and 3q26.2-3q26.33 that appeared in HCV-related HCCs with significantly higher frequencies. The significant copy number gains and losses in HBV-related HCCs were most commonly located on chromosomal region 10p, and 14q and 4q, respectively. We also performed the comparison of chromosomal aberration profiles between virus-related HCCs and non-virus-related HCCs, and identified 27 gains and 17 losses showing a significant difference in frequencies. All significant losses were present in virus-related HCCs and most were located on chromosomal region 16q. In comparison, significant gains were mostly located on chromosomal regions 2p and 4p in virus-related HCCs, whereas chromosomal regions 8p and 10p in non-virus-related HCCs.
(a). the comparison of chromosomal aberration profiles between HBV-related HCCs and HCV-related HCCs. (b), the comparison of chromosomal aberration profiles between virus-related HCCs and non-virus-related HCCs. Copy number gains and losses with a significant difference in frequencies were highlighted in red and blue, respectively.
Meta-analysis of array CGH is valued as an integrated approach to simultaneously analyze information from different studies for the detection of chromosome aberrations with enhanced resolution and accuracy. A recent study has successfully performed a meta-analysis of array CGH data derived from a series of primary cancers to cluster tumor type by CNAs . In this study, we, for the first time, conducted a cross-platform meta-analysis of HCC array CGH data obtained from different studies. We developed a preprocessing methodology to normalize the original data based on the MPCBS statistical algorithm and demonstrated that this data pre-processing exhibited an optimum performance on multi-platform integration.
In the present study, our meta-analysis identified 85 significant chromosomal gains and 88 losses. The majority of these significant aberrations were consistent with previous reports using conventional CGH approaches or including smaller sample size. In addition, our study identified several aberrations located in very narrow chromosomal regions, such as copy number gains on 5p15.33-5p14.2, 9q34.2-9q34.3 or 20p13-20p11.21 and copy number loss on 9p24.3-9p21.1 or 14q. The 5p15.33 regions contains hTERT gene, which encodes the catalytic subunit of telomerase, a critical component in telomere regulation. In an array CGH study, Yasuyo et al.  have reported that the gain of 5p15.33 was detected in 50% of HCC samples. Gain of this region has also been reported to be associated with progression of bladder cancer . The 5p15.2 region hosts the potential target gene, delta catenin (CTNND2), over-expressed in prostate cancer . The chromosomal region 9p24.3 harbors three putative tumor suppressor genes, DMRT1, DMRT3 and DOCK8. A recent study has reported the frequent deletion of this region in squamous cell carcinoma of the lung . Furthermore, our results indicated that significant correlations existed between chromosomal aberrations either located on the same chromosome or the different chromosomes, suggesting that these aberrations might appear non-randomly. It remains to be further elucidated whether there are sequential correlations among the occurrence of these genomic aberrations in the development and progression of HCC.
We also compared genomic aberrations between HCCs with different etiologies and observed two noteworthy findings. First, our study found that HCCs with different etiologies exhibited very similar profiles of chromosomal aberrations. Second, we found that chromosomal aberrations appeared more frequently in HBV-HCCs than in HCV-HCCs, and in virus-related HCCs than in non-virus-related HCCs. These findings suggest that virus infection, especially HBV infection, may play a major role in hepatocarcinogenesis by causing chromosomal aberrations. In our analyses, we observed that the significant copy number gains were most commonly located on chromosomal region 10p and significant losses on 14q and 4q in HBV-related HCCs. Yeh et al. have reported that allelic loss at chromosome 4q21-23 occurs frequently in human hepatocellular carcinoma . Fas-associated phosphatase-1 (FAP-1) gene, a potential candidate TSG, is located in this region. Another study has demonstrated that three regions at 14q exhibit the frequent loss of heterozygosity in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Several candidate TSGs such as CHES1, BMP4, SAV, and PNN exist in these region . These TSGs may play critical roles in hepatocarcinogenesis. Previous CGH studies have also analyzed the CNA profiles of HCCs with HBV or HCV infection. One study has reported that the amplification of 11q13, which corresponds to the chromosomal region harboring the genes for cyclin D1 and hst-1, is frequently observed in HBV-positive HCCs. In contrast, loss of 10q has been detected exclusively in HCV-positive HCCs . Another study has demonstrated that a single high level amplification is only seen on 5q21 in HBV-related HCCs . In addition, Christof Schlaeger et al compared HBV- and HCV-associated HCCs by array CGH, and observed that major differences in the frequencies of gains were at 1q32.1, 7q22.1, 10q26.3-qter in HCV- positive tumors, and losses at 4q34.3-qter, 9p24.3, and 14q21.2-32.33 were more significant in HBV–positive tumors . The inconsistency among these results is possibly due to the different technology platforms and sample selection. Further validation using large sample size is warranted.
The tumorigenesis of HCC is a multi-step and multi-factorial process. Many attempts have been made to identify the abnormal pathways underlying hepatocarcinogenesis. Epidermal growth factor (EGF) signaling pathway is one of the most thoroughly evaluated signaling cascades in human HCC . Genetic evidence has been also provided by a recent study showing gains of chromosome 7 in human HCC, where EGFR is located. A series of studies have also found the dysregulation of pathways involved in cellular differentiation and proliferation in HCC, such as the WNT canonical pathway and the Hedgehog signaling pathway (HH) , , , . Interestingly, the most noteworthy finding of this study is that the genes affected by chromosomal aberrations in HCC were most significantly enriched in antiviral immunity pathways, followed by the cancer-related pathways and metabolism-related pathways. This is highly biologically plausible, given the important functions of immunity pathways in the response to viral infection and chronic inflammation . Previous studies have provided various lines of experimental evidence in accordance with our findings. For example, Kirsten et al. have reported a significant amplification of 6p21.3 that corresponds to the HLA-region in ovarian cancer . In addition, somatic deletions in chromosomes 9 and 22 have been studied in 21 paired HCC and adjacent tumor-free liver tissue samples . Among informative HCC cases, the highest rates of loss of heterozygosis (LOH) were observed for 9p21 (40% or 4/10 at IFNA) and 9q23 (23% or 3/13 at D9S318). Clinical data indicate that chromosome 9p21 deletions occurred preferentially in larger tumors (>5 cm diameter). Another study has also reported that LOH on IFN-alpha locus at 9p21 is a prognostic indicator of bacillus Calmette-Guerin response for non-muscle invasive bladder cancer . Similarly, Roman et al.  has investigated the chromosomal aberrations in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas by array CGH and found that the genes involved in cytokine-cytokine receptor interaction pathway were the largest group of genes (23/149) showing chromosomal gains. The copy number of several interleukin genes (IL10, IL19, IL20 and IL24) mapped to1q32 have been significantly increased and all these genes were previously found to be associated with the development of HNSCCs. In addition to the interleukins at 1q32, there were amplified genes from other regions of the genome, such as CCL26, EGFR, IL17R, IL28A, IL29, IL2RB, IL12RB1, VEGF, XCL2, TNFSF9 and CD40. Taken together, these lines of evidence strongly suggest that the functional aberration of antiviral immunity pathways may be significantly involved in the development and progression of HCC.
In summary, we conducted a cross-platform meta-analysis of HCC array CGH data. We identified multiple chromosome regions with significant aberrations in genes enriched in antiviral immunity pathways. Our results provide a sketchy description of the genomic alterations in HCCs and generate further testable hypotheses that the deficiency of antiviral immunity pathways may play key roles in hepatocarcinogenesis.
Conceived and designed the experiments: JLX XM ZNC. Performed the experiments: XG YKS YNB. Analyzed the data: YKS XM YNB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: QCH JZA YNB. Wrote the paper: XG HSY.
- 1. Coleman WB (2003) Mechanisms of human hepatocarcinogenesis. Curr Mol Med 3: 573–588.WB Coleman2003Mechanisms of human hepatocarcinogenesis.Curr Mol Med3573588
- 2. Wong N, Lai P, Pang E, Leung TW, Lau JW, et al. (2000) A comprehensive karyotypic study on human hepatocellular carcinoma by spectral karyotyping. Hepatology 32: 1060–1068.N. WongP. LaiE. PangTW LeungJW Lau2000A comprehensive karyotypic study on human hepatocellular carcinoma by spectral karyotyping.Hepatology3210601068
- 3. Kallioniemi A, Kallioniemi OP, Sudar D, Rutovitz D, Gray JW, et al. (1992) Comparative genomic hybridization for molecular cytogenetic analysis of solid tumors. Science 258: 818–821.A. KallioniemiOP KallioniemiD. SudarD. RutovitzJW Gray1992Comparative genomic hybridization for molecular cytogenetic analysis of solid tumors.Science258818821
- 4. Hermsen MA, Meijer GA, Baak JP, Joenje H, Walboomers JJ (1996) Comparative genomic hybridization: a new tool in cancer pathology. Hum Pathol 27: 342–349.MA HermsenGA MeijerJP BaakH. JoenjeJJ Walboomers1996Comparative genomic hybridization: a new tool in cancer pathology.Hum Pathol27342349
- 5. Pollack JR, Perou CM, Alizadeh AA, Eisen MB, Pergamenschikov A, et al. (1999) Genome-wide analysis of DNA copy-number changes using cDNA microarrays. Nat Genet 23: 41–46.JR PollackCM PerouAA AlizadehMB EisenA. Pergamenschikov1999Genome-wide analysis of DNA copy-number changes using cDNA microarrays.Nat Genet234146
- 6. Hashimoto K, Mori N, Tamesa T, Okada T, Kawauchi S, et al. (2004) Analysis of DNA copy number aberrations in hepatitis C virus-associated hepatocellular carcinomas by conventional CGH and array CGH. Mod Pathol 17: 617–622.K. HashimotoN. MoriT. TamesaT. OkadaS. Kawauchi2004Analysis of DNA copy number aberrations in hepatitis C virus-associated hepatocellular carcinomas by conventional CGH and array CGH.Mod Pathol17617622
- 7. Yeh IT, Martin MA, Robetorye RS, Bolla AR, McCaskill C, et al. (2009) Clinical validation of an array CGH test for HER2 status in breast cancer reveals that polysomy 17 is a rare event. Mod Pathol 22: 1169–1175.IT YehMA MartinRS RobetoryeAR BollaC. McCaskill2009Clinical validation of an array CGH test for HER2 status in breast cancer reveals that polysomy 17 is a rare event.Mod Pathol2211691175
- 8. Tomioka N, Morita K, Kobayashi N, Tada M, Itoh T, et al. (2010) Array comparative genomic hybridization analysis revealed four genomic prognostic biomarkers for primary gastric cancers. Cancer Genet Cytogenet 201: 6–14.N. TomiokaK. MoritaN. KobayashiM. TadaT. Itoh2010Array comparative genomic hybridization analysis revealed four genomic prognostic biomarkers for primary gastric cancers.Cancer Genet Cytogenet201614
- 9. Wilhelm M, Veltman JA, Olshen AB, Jain AN, Moore DH, et al. (2002) Array-based comparative genomic hybridization for the differential diagnosis of renal cell cancer. Cancer Res 62: 957–960.M. WilhelmJA VeltmanAB OlshenAN JainDH Moore2002Array-based comparative genomic hybridization for the differential diagnosis of renal cell cancer.Cancer Res62957960
- 10. Veltman JA, Fridlyand J, Pejavar S, Olshen AB, Korkola JE, et al. (2003) Array-based comparative genomic hybridization for genome-wide screening of DNA copy number in bladder tumors. Cancer Res 63: 2872–2880.JA VeltmanJ. FridlyandS. PejavarAB OlshenJE Korkola2003Array-based comparative genomic hybridization for genome-wide screening of DNA copy number in bladder tumors.Cancer Res6328722880
- 11. Lamb JR, Zhang C, Xie T, Wang K, Zhang B, et al. (2011) Predictive genes in adjacent normal tissue are preferentially altered by sCNV during tumorigenesis in liver cancer and may rate limiting. PLoS One 6: e20090.JR LambC. ZhangT. XieK. WangB. Zhang2011Predictive genes in adjacent normal tissue are preferentially altered by sCNV during tumorigenesis in liver cancer and may rate limiting.PLoS One6e20090
- 12. Okamura Y, Nomoto S, Hayashi M, Hishida M, Nishikawa Y, et al. (2011) Identification of the bleomycin hydrolase gene as a methylated tumor suppressor gene in hepatocellular carcinoma using a novel triple-combination array method. Cancer Lett 312: 150–157.Y. OkamuraS. NomotoM. HayashiM. HishidaY. Nishikawa2011Identification of the bleomycin hydrolase gene as a methylated tumor suppressor gene in hepatocellular carcinoma using a novel triple-combination array method.Cancer Lett312150157
- 13. Carter NP (2007) Methods and strategies for analyzing copy number variation using DNA microarrays. Nat Genet 39: S16–21.NP Carter2007Methods and strategies for analyzing copy number variation using DNA microarrays.Nat Genet39S1621
- 14. Kusano N, Shiraishi K, Kubo K, Oga A, Okita K, et al. (1999) Genetic aberrations detected by comparative genomic hybridization in hepatocellular carcinomas: their relationship to clinicopathological features. Hepatology 29: 1858–1862.N. KusanoK. ShiraishiK. KuboA. OgaK. Okita1999Genetic aberrations detected by comparative genomic hybridization in hepatocellular carcinomas: their relationship to clinicopathological features.Hepatology2918581862
- 15. Katoh H, Ojima H, Kokubu A, Saito S, Kondo T, et al. (2007) Genetically distinct and clinically relevant classification of hepatocellular carcinoma: putative therapeutic targets. Gastroenterology 133: 1475–1486.H. KatohH. OjimaA. KokubuS. SaitoT. Kondo2007Genetically distinct and clinically relevant classification of hepatocellular carcinoma: putative therapeutic targets.Gastroenterology13314751486
- 16. Chochi Y, Kawauchi S, Nakao M, Furuya T, Hashimoto K, et al. (2009) A copy number gain of the 6p arm is linked with advanced hepatocellular carcinoma: an array-based comparative genomic hybridization study. J Pathol 217: 677–684.Y. ChochiS. KawauchiM. NakaoT. FuruyaK. Hashimoto2009A copy number gain of the 6p arm is linked with advanced hepatocellular carcinoma: an array-based comparative genomic hybridization study.J Pathol217677684
- 17. Kim TM, Yim SH, Shin SH, Xu HD, Jung YC, et al. (2008) Clinical implication of recurrent copy number alterations in hepatocellular carcinoma and putative oncogenes in recurrent gains on 1q. Int J Cancer 123: 2808–2815.TM KimSH YimSH ShinHD XuYC Jung2008Clinical implication of recurrent copy number alterations in hepatocellular carcinoma and putative oncogenes in recurrent gains on 1q.Int J Cancer12328082815
- 18. Wu JC, Sun BS, Ren N, Ye QH, Qin LX (2010) Genomic aberrations in hepatocellular carcinoma related to osteopontin expression detected by array-CGH. J Cancer Res Clin Oncol 136: 595–601.JC WuBS SunN. RenQH YeLX Qin2010Genomic aberrations in hepatocellular carcinoma related to osteopontin expression detected by array-CGH.J Cancer Res Clin Oncol136595601
- 19. Katoh H, Shibata T, Kokubu A, Ojima H, Loukopoulos P, et al. (2005) Genetic profile of hepatocellular carcinoma revealed by array-based comparative genomic hybridization: identification of genetic indicators to predict patient outcome. J Hepatol 43: 863–874.H. KatohT. ShibataA. KokubuH. OjimaP. Loukopoulos2005Genetic profile of hepatocellular carcinoma revealed by array-based comparative genomic hybridization: identification of genetic indicators to predict patient outcome.J Hepatol43863874
- 20. Guan XY, Fang Y, Sham JS, Kwong DL, Zhang Y, et al. (2000) Recurrent chromosome alterations in hepatocellular carcinoma detected by comparative genomic hybridization. Genes Chromosomes Cancer 29: 110–116.XY GuanY. FangJS ShamDL KwongY. Zhang2000Recurrent chromosome alterations in hepatocellular carcinoma detected by comparative genomic hybridization.Genes Chromosomes Cancer29110116
- 21. Edamoto Y, Hara A, Biernat W, Terracciano L, Cathomas G, et al. (2003) Alterations of RB1, p53 and Wnt pathways in hepatocellular carcinomas associated with hepatitis C, hepatitis B and alcoholic liver cirrhosis. Int J Cancer 106: 334–341.Y. EdamotoA. HaraW. BiernatL. TerraccianoG. Cathomas2003Alterations of RB1, p53 and Wnt pathways in hepatocellular carcinomas associated with hepatitis C, hepatitis B and alcoholic liver cirrhosis.Int J Cancer106334341
- 22. Nishida N, Fukuda Y, Komeda T, Kita R, Sando T, et al. (1994) Amplification and overexpression of the cyclin D1 gene in aggressive human hepatocellular carcinoma. Cancer Res 54: 3107–3110.N. NishidaY. FukudaT. KomedaR. KitaT. Sando1994Amplification and overexpression of the cyclin D1 gene in aggressive human hepatocellular carcinoma.Cancer Res5431073110
- 23. Ioannidis JP, Lau J (1999) Pooling research results: benefits and limitations of meta-analysis. Jt Comm J Qual Improv 25: 462–469.JP IoannidisJ. Lau1999Pooling research results: benefits and limitations of meta-analysis.Jt Comm J Qual Improv25462469
- 24. Jong K, Marchiori E, van der Vaart A, Chin SF, Carvalho B, et al. (2007) Cross-platform array comparative genomic hybridization meta-analysis separates hematopoietic and mesenchymal from epithelial tumors. Oncogene 26: 1499–1506.K. JongE. MarchioriA. van der VaartSF ChinB. Carvalho2007Cross-platform array comparative genomic hybridization meta-analysis separates hematopoietic and mesenchymal from epithelial tumors.Oncogene2614991506
- 25. Patil MA, Gutgemann I, Zhang J, Ho C, Cheung ST, et al. (2005) Array-based comparative genomic hybridization reveals recurrent chromosomal aberrations and Jab1 as a potential target for 8q gain in hepatocellular carcinoma. Carcinogenesis 26: 2050–2057.MA PatilI. GutgemannJ. ZhangC. HoST Cheung2005Array-based comparative genomic hybridization reveals recurrent chromosomal aberrations and Jab1 as a potential target for 8q gain in hepatocellular carcinoma.Carcinogenesis2620502057
- 26. Kakar S, Chen X, Ho C, Burgart LJ, Adeyi O, et al. (2009) Chromosomal abnormalities determined by comparative genomic hybridization are helpful in the diagnosis of atypical hepatocellular neoplasms. Histopathology 55: 197–205.S. KakarX. ChenC. HoLJ BurgartO. Adeyi2009Chromosomal abnormalities determined by comparative genomic hybridization are helpful in the diagnosis of atypical hepatocellular neoplasms.Histopathology55197205
- 27. Schlaeger C, Longerich T, Schiller C, Bewerunge P, Mehrabi A, et al. (2008) Etiology-dependent molecular mechanisms in human hepatocarcinogenesis. Hepatology 47: 511–520.C. SchlaegerT. LongerichC. SchillerP. BewerungeA. Mehrabi2008Etiology-dependent molecular mechanisms in human hepatocarcinogenesis.Hepatology47511520
- 28. Zhang NR, Senbabaoglu Y, Li JZ (2010) Joint estimation of DNA copy number from multiple platforms. Bioinformatics 26: 153–160.NR ZhangY. SenbabaogluJZ Li2010Joint estimation of DNA copy number from multiple platforms.Bioinformatics26153160
- 29. Chari R, Lockwood WW, Lam WL (2006) Computational methods for the analysis of array comparative genomic hybridization. Cancer Inform 2: 48–58.R. ChariWW LockwoodWL Lam2006Computational methods for the analysis of array comparative genomic hybridization.Cancer Inform24858
- 30. Kanehisa M, Goto S (2000) KEGG: kyoto encyclopedia of genes and genomes. Nucleic Acids Res 28: 27–30.M. KanehisaS. Goto2000KEGG: kyoto encyclopedia of genes and genomes.Nucleic Acids Res282730
- 31. Kaposi-Novak P, Libbrecht L, Woo HG, Lee YH, Sears NC, et al. (2009) Central role of c-Myc during malignant conversion in human hepatocarcinogenesis. Cancer Res 69: 2775–2782.P. Kaposi-NovakL. LibbrechtHG WooYH LeeNC Sears2009Central role of c-Myc during malignant conversion in human hepatocarcinogenesis.Cancer Res6927752782
- 32. Yamamoto Y, Chochi Y, Matsuyama H, Eguchi S, Kawauchi S, et al. (2007) Gain of 5p15.33 is associated with progression of bladder cancer. Oncology 72: 132–138.Y. YamamotoY. ChochiH. MatsuyamaS. EguchiS. Kawauchi2007Gain of 5p15.33 is associated with progression of bladder cancer.Oncology72132138
- 33. Wang T, Chen YH, Hong H, Zeng Y, Zhang J, et al. (2009) Increased nucleotide polymorphic changes in the 5′-untranslated region of delta-catenin (CTNND2) gene in prostate cancer. Oncogene 28: 555–564.T. WangYH ChenH. HongY. ZengJ. Zhang2009Increased nucleotide polymorphic changes in the 5′-untranslated region of delta-catenin (CTNND2) gene in prostate cancer.Oncogene28555564
- 34. Kang JU, Koo SH, Kwon KC, Park JW (2010) Frequent silence of chromosome 9p, homozygous DOCK8, DMRT1 and DMRT3 deletion at 9p24.3 in squamous cell carcinoma of the lung. Int J Oncol 37: 327–335.JU KangSH KooKC KwonJW Park2010Frequent silence of chromosome 9p, homozygous DOCK8, DMRT1 and DMRT3 deletion at 9p24.3 in squamous cell carcinoma of the lung.Int J Oncol37327335
- 35. Yeh SH, Wu DC, Tsai CY, Kuo TJ, Yu WC, et al. (2006) Genetic characterization of fas-associated phosphatase-1 as a putative tumor suppressor gene on chromosome 4q21.3 in hepatocellular carcinoma. Clin Cancer Res 12: 1097–1108.SH YehDC WuCY TsaiTJ KuoWC Yu2006Genetic characterization of fas-associated phosphatase-1 as a putative tumor suppressor gene on chromosome 4q21.3 in hepatocellular carcinoma.Clin Cancer Res1210971108
- 36. Pehlivan D, Gunduz E, Gunduz M, Nagatsuka H, Beder LB, et al. (2008) Loss of heterozygosity at chromosome 14q is associated with poor prognosis in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas. J Cancer Res Clin Oncol 134: 1267–1276.D. PehlivanE. GunduzM. GunduzH. NagatsukaLB Beder2008Loss of heterozygosity at chromosome 14q is associated with poor prognosis in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas.J Cancer Res Clin Oncol13412671276
- 37. Zondervan PE, Wink J, Alers JC, JN IJ, Schalm SW, et al. (2000) Molecular cytogenetic evaluation of virus-associated and non-viral hepatocellular carcinoma: analysis of 26 carcinomas and 12 concurrent dysplasias. J Pathol 192: 207–215.PE ZondervanJ. WinkJC AlersIJ JNSW Schalm2000Molecular cytogenetic evaluation of virus-associated and non-viral hepatocellular carcinoma: analysis of 26 carcinomas and 12 concurrent dysplasias.J Pathol192207215
- 38. Villanueva A, Chiang DY, Newell P, Peix J, Thung S, et al. (2008) Pivotal role of mTOR signaling in hepatocellular carcinoma. Gastroenterology 135: 1972–1983, 1983 e1971-1911.A. VillanuevaDY ChiangP. NewellJ. PeixS. Thung2008Pivotal role of mTOR signaling in hepatocellular carcinoma.Gastroenterology13519721983, 1983 e1971-1911
- 39. Zaret KS, Grompe M (2008) Generation and regeneration of cells of the liver and pancreas. Science 322: 1490–1494.KS ZaretM. Grompe2008Generation and regeneration of cells of the liver and pancreas.Science32214901494
- 40. Thompson MD, Monga SP (2007) WNT/beta-catenin signaling in liver health and disease. Hepatology 45: 1298–1305.MD ThompsonSP Monga2007WNT/beta-catenin signaling in liver health and disease.Hepatology4512981305
- 41. Sicklick JK, Li YX, Jayaraman A, Kannangai R, Qi Y, et al. (2006) Dysregulation of the Hedgehog pathway in human hepatocarcinogenesis. Carcinogenesis 27: 748–757.JK SicklickYX LiA. JayaramanR. KannangaiY. Qi2006Dysregulation of the Hedgehog pathway in human hepatocarcinogenesis.Carcinogenesis27748757
- 42. Tada M, Kanai F, Tanaka Y, Tateishi K, Ohta M, et al. (2008) Down-regulation of hedgehog-interacting protein through genetic and epigenetic alterations in human hepatocellular carcinoma. Clin Cancer Res 14: 3768–3776.M. TadaF. KanaiY. TanakaK. TateishiM. Ohta2008Down-regulation of hedgehog-interacting protein through genetic and epigenetic alterations in human hepatocellular carcinoma.Clin Cancer Res1437683776
- 43. Guidotti LG, Chisari FV (2001) Noncytolytic control of viral infections by the innate and adaptive immune response. Annu Rev Immunol 19: 65–91.LG GuidottiFV Chisari2001Noncytolytic control of viral infections by the innate and adaptive immune response.Annu Rev Immunol196591
- 44. Kubler K, Arndt PF, Wardelmann E, Landwehr C, Krebs D, et al. (2008) Genetic alterations of HLA-class II in ovarian cancer. Int J Cancer 123: 1350–1356.K. KublerPF ArndtE. WardelmannC. LandwehrD. Krebs2008Genetic alterations of HLA-class II in ovarian cancer.Int J Cancer12313501356
- 45. Chung MY, Wu JC, Chau GY, Lui WY, Tsay SH, et al. (2000) Preferentially deleted chromosome region 9p21 in large hepatocellular carcinomas. Int J Mol Med 5: 521–524.MY ChungJC WuGY ChauWY LuiSH Tsay2000Preferentially deleted chromosome region 9p21 in large hepatocellular carcinomas.Int J Mol Med5521524
- 46. Cai T, Nesi G, Dal Canto M, Tinacci G, Mondaini N, et al. (2010) Loss of heterozygosis on IFN-alpha locus is a prognostic indicator of bacillus Calmette-Guerin response for nonmuscle invasive bladder cancer. J Urol 183: 1738–1743.T. CaiG. NesiM. Dal CantoG. TinacciN. Mondaini2010Loss of heterozygosis on IFN-alpha locus is a prognostic indicator of bacillus Calmette-Guerin response for nonmuscle invasive bladder cancer.J Urol18317381743
- 47. Roman E, Meza-Zepeda LA, Kresse SH, Myklebost O, Vasstrand EN, et al. (2008) Chromosomal aberrations in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas in Norwegian and Sudanese populations by array comparative genomic hybridization. Oncol Rep 20: 825–843.E. RomanLA Meza-ZepedaSH KresseO. MyklebostEN Vasstrand2008Chromosomal aberrations in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas in Norwegian and Sudanese populations by array comparative genomic hybridization.Oncol Rep20825843