To determine potential links between the clinical isolate to animal products and their geographic origin, we genotyped (MLVA-8, MVLA-15, and canSNP analysis) 80 environmental and 12 clinical isolates and 2 clinical specimens from five cases of anthrax (California in 1976 [n = 1], New York in 2006 [n = 1], Connecticut in 2007 [n = 2], and New Hampshire in 2009[n = 1]) resulting from recreational handling of animal products. For the California case, four clinical isolates were identified as MLVA-8 genotype (GT) 76 and in the canSNP A.Br.Vollum lineage, which is consistent with the Pakistani origin of the yarn. Twenty eight of the California isolates were in the A.Br.Vollum canSNP lineage and one isolate was in the A.Br. 003/004 canSNP sub-group. All 52 isolates and both clinical specimens related to the New York and Connecticut cases were MLVA-8 GT 1. The animal products associated with the NY and CT cases were believed to originate from West Africa, but no isolates from this region are available to be genotyped for comparison. All isolates associated with the New Hampshire case were identical and had a new genotype (GT 149). Isolates from the NY, CT and NH cases diverge from the established canSNP phylogeny near the base of the A.Br.011/009. This report illustrates the power of the current genotyping methods and the dramatically different epidemiological conditions that can lead to infections (i.e., contamination by a single genotype versus widespread contamination of numerous genotypes). These cases illustrate the need to acquire and genotype global isolates so that accurate assignments can be made about isolate origins.
Citation: Marston CK, Allen CA, Beaudry J, Price EP, Wolken SR, et al. (2011) Molecular Epidemiology of Anthrax Cases Associated with Recreational Use of Animal Hides and Yarn in the United States. PLoS ONE 6(12): e28274. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0028274
Editor: Tara C. Smith, University of Iowa, United States of America
Received: May 17, 2011; Accepted: November 4, 2011; Published: December 9, 2011
This is an open-access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Funding: Portions of this work were supported by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security S&T CB Division Bioforensics R&D Program. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. No additional external funding was received for this report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Bacillus anthracis is the etiologic agent of anthrax, a zoonotic disease which historically affected people in the United States who worked at textile mills or had other contact with contaminated animal products. In the USA, industrial processing of animal products accounted for the majority of human anthrax cases (n = 153) from 1955–1999 . However, with improvements in industrial hygiene and the implementation of other practices (such as improved ventilation, vaccination of at-risk employees, decreased use of imported animal products), industrial cases of anthrax began to decline.
Reports of anthrax cases related to handling of animal products in a non-industrial setting are rare in the USA. In 1974, a cutaneous anthrax case was reported in a woman who bought drums made from goat hides in Haiti . Prior to the 2001 bioterrorism-associated anthrax outbreak, the last fatal case of inhalation anthrax in the USA occurred in a self-employed, 32-year-old male home weaver in California in 1976 . In follow-up investigations, the source of B. anthracis was determined to be contaminated hand-spun yarn consisting of various types of animal fibers (camel, goat, and sheep) imported from Pakistan , .
Recently, two inhalation and two cutaneous cases of anthrax were related to drum-making using imported goat hides. In 2006, two unrelated inhalation anthrax cases were reported in New York City and Scotland , . In the New York City case, the patient, who recovered, made traditional African drums from processed hard-dried goat hides imported from West Africa. The case from Scotland also involved a drum-maker and was fatal. Additionally, in 2007, two cases of cutaneous anthrax were reported in a Connecticut drum-maker and his son . This drum-maker also made West African drums using unprocessed hides. Lastly, in 2009, a gastrointestinal anthrax case was reported in a female drummer from New Hampshire . In this case, the drummer did not make drums but attended a drumming event held in a community building where drums of various animal hides were played.
While B. anthracis has very little genetic variation, successful molecular subtyping methods have been developed within the last decade to examine phylogenetic relationships among isolates and as a molecular epidemiology tool to investigate anthrax cases. The original multiple-locus variable-number tandem repeats analysis system (MLVA) targeted eight loci (six chromosomally-located loci and one on each of the two virulence plasmids, pXO1 and pXO2) . This method has been used to identify 89 B. anthracis genotypes (GTs), to study anthrax ecology, and to genotype isolates during the 2001 bioterrorism-associated anthrax outbreak. The MLVA-15 scheme includes seven additional loci and allows for increased differentiation of isolates . Canonical single nucleotide polymorphism (canSNPs) analysis has been used to identify major clonal lineages within B. anthracis . CanSNP analysis, in concert with MLVA-15, was used to subtype over 1000 isolates from 42 countries and subdivided the three major B. anthracis lineages into 12 clonal sub-lineages or sub-groups and 221 MLVA-15 genotypes .
In this report, we describe the molecular epidemiology of the anthrax cases linked to the recreational use of animal products occurring in the USA which includes the California and New York City inhalation anthrax cases, the two cutaneous cases from Connecticut, and the gastrointestinal case in New Hampshire. In all five cases, epidemiologic and environmental investigations were carried out to determine the source of exposure. For the 2006 and 2007 cases, law enforcement authorities were also involved to rule out any potential criminal activity. Numerous samples were collected from each patient's home, work space, or other associated facilities as part of the respective investigations. Culturing of the samples resulted in the recovery of many B. anthracis isolates. We utilized both MLVA-8 and MLVA-15, in addition to SNP analysis, to subtype both clinical and environmental isolates to determine 1) the genotype and canSNP lineage of the infectious isolate, 2) the genotypes of strains contaminating the patient's residence or work space, 3) the potential link between the source of the infectious isolate to animal products (goat hide, yarn, etc.) and 4) if the origin of the isolates as predicted by genotype is consistent with what is known about the origin of the animal products.
In this report, we analyzed 94 isolates and specimens by MLVA-8, MLVA-15 and canSNP analysis from five inhalation and cutaneous anthrax cases from a weaver (1976), three individuals associated with drum-making (2006, 2007), and a drummer (2009).
1976 California inhalation case
The six chromosomal loci of the MLVA-8 scheme were detected in all 29 isolates (Table 1). However, amplification of the pXO1 and/or the pXO2 loci failed for 19 (5 clinical, 14 environmental) of the isolates suggesting they lacked one or both virulence plasmids. This was further supported by additional plasmid specific PCR assays performed which also yielded negative results (data not shown). Seven isolates were missing one plasmid (three isolates cured of pXO1 and four isolates cured of pXO2) while the remaining 12 lacked both plasmids. Consequently, identification and assignment of a complete MLVA genotype (GT) was not possible for these isolates.
Among the nine clinical isolates, all four isolates containing both plasmids were identified as GT 76. An additional four isolates were cured of both plasmids but had identical allele sizes for all six chromosomal loci as the GT 76 isolates. However, one isolate, 4274, differed in allele size at the vrrA loci (313 vs. 325 bp) and also had an unusual pXO1 allele size (155 bp) which has not been previously documented. This isolate was in the A.Br.Vollum lineage by canSNP analysis.
Of the environmental isolates containing both plasmids (n = 6), five isolates had MLVA-8 genotypes which had been previously described: two yarn isolates were GT 71 and one isolate from the loom and an additional yarn isolate were GT 72. In addition, one isolate (from yarn) was GT 92. One camel/goat hair isolate was GT 105 which has not been previously observed (Table 1, Figure 1).
All other genotypes are reference genotypes from Keim et al. . For the California case, the clinical isolates were GT 76 (n = 4), while environmental isolates were GT 71 (n = 2), GT 72 (n = 2), GT 92 (n = 1), and GT 105 (n = 1). All clinical and environmental isolates from the New York (one clinical, 35 environmental) and Connecticut cases (one clinical specimen, 15 environmental isolates) were GT 1. All clinical (n = 2) and environmental (n = 9) isolates from the NH case were GT 149. Scale bar indicates amount of evolutionary change .
The new branch, “A.Br.011,” is flanked by branches A.Br.008 and A.Br.009. Thus, the group A.Br.008/009 is now subdivided into two groups: A.Br.008/011 and A.Br.011/009. The canSNP signature and assay that defines this new branch is provided in Table 3.
2006 New York inhalation case
The clinical isolate from the patient was identified as MLVA-8 GT 1 (Table 2). Thirty-one environmental isolates collected from the patient's vehicle and work space were also identified as MLVA-8 GT 1. In addition, all 37 isolates were identical by MLVA-15. All isolates associated with this case were in the A.Br.011/009 sub-group (Table 2, Figure 2) by canSNP analysis.
2007 Connecticut cutaneous cases
While the biopsy specimen from the drum-maker did not amplify any of the MLVA loci, all MLVA-8 loci were amplified from the biopsy specimen from the drum-maker's son and identified as MLVA-8 GT 1. All environmental isolates from the drum-maker's home and shed where he processed the goat hides were also MLVA-8 GT 1 (Table 2). The clinical sample and the environmental isolates were identical by MLVA-15. All isolates associated with these two cases were in the A.Br.011/009 sub-group by canSNP analysis (Table 2).
2009 New Hampshire gastrointestinal case
The two clinical isolates from the patient and the nine environmental isolates recovered from the drums and the community building were identified as a new MLVA-8 genotype, designated GT 149 (Table 1). As in the CT and NY cases, the eleven isolates associated with this case were in the A.Br.011/009 sub-group by canSNP analysis (Table 2, Figure 2). Although the New Hampshire case isolate had a different MLVA-8 genotype than the New York and Connecticut cases, all isolates from these four cases were within the same canSNP lineage and clustered together by MLVA-8 (A1.a, Figure 1).
Among the five cases reported in this study, we were able to match clinical isolates or samples with environmental isolates in four of the cases (NY case, 2 CT cases, and NH case). Conversely, we were not able to match the clinical and environmental isolates associated with the California case. At the time of the California case (1976), molecular subtyping systems were not available to allow for more precise characterization of the clinical isolates and their possible linkage to environmental contamination. In this report, MLVA was used successfully to detect numerous genotypes in the environment of the California weaver's residence. Although none of the environmental isolate genotypes matched the clinical isolate genotypes, the clinical and environmental isolates that were completely genotyped appear to be closely related within the A4 MLVA cluster (Vollum cluster) as described by Keim et al. (Figure 1) . Among the clinical isolates, all isolates were in the A.Br.Vollum canSNP lineage, and four out of nine clinical isolates were GT 76 and an additional four isolates had chromosomal allele sizes that were consistent with this genotype which has been described from Pakistan . Thus, the MLVA-8 and canSNP analysis was consistent with the geographic origin of the yarn used by the weaver.
Based on the number of genotypes found in the environment of the California weaver's home, a co-infection of the patient might be expected. While all the clinical isolates were in the same canSNP lineage, we identified two MLVA-8 genotypes. Four of the isolates were GT 76, and one of the isolates, 4274, differed from the other clinical isolates at two loci demonstrating this isolate differs genotypically from GT 76. In addition, in the original investigation, two different biotypes of B. anthracis were observed . One of the clinical isolates was poorly encapsulated and had low virulence for guinea pigs. This strain appeared to be non-encapsulated in colonial form on bicarbonate agar, but capsules were observed by immunofluorescence microscopy using anti-B. anthracis anti-serum . Suffin et al. also report that these two same biotypes were seen in the yarn obtained in the weaver's home . Unfortunately, we were not able to correlate these two biotypes with the MLVA genotypes identified in the clinical isolates due to plasmid loss. The presence of multiple genotypes may have resulted from the weaver's use of animal products originating from multiple sources (camel, goat, and sheep). In addition, the number of contamination events that occurred prior to the weaver's illness remains unknown.
None of the environmental isolates from the California case were an exact match to either clinical isolate genotype. However, several of the environmental isolates (GT 71 and 72) differed from the clinical isolates only at the pXO1 loci. Thus, the matching genotype among the environmental isolates may not have been identified due to the high rate of pXO1 loss in our archived isolates associated with this case. The isolates included in this report from the California case were stored for over 25 years at room temperature on agar slants with mineral oil overlay. We have previously documented that the storage conditions used for these isolates may have had an adverse effect on their plasmid stability and, thus, caused the loss of plasmids over the course of their long-term storage . The loss of plasmids prevented assignment of complete MLVA-8 genotypes in some cases.
In contrast to the California case where multiple MLVA genotypes were found, the isolates collected in the NY, CT and NH cases were MLVA-8 GT 1 (NY and CT) and MLVA-8 GT 149 (NH), and all isolates from these three cases belong in the A.Br.011/009 lineage. The animal products associated with the NY and CT cases were believed to originate from West Africa, but only isolates from other African regions were available to be genotyped for comparison. The link between the canSNP lineage and the West African origin of the hides is surprising as only one isolate originating from Africa (isolated in Ethiopia) has been discovered to belong in this canSNP A.Br.011/009 lineage but possesses a different MLVA genotype. While molecular subtyping data exists for isolates from the southern parts of Africa, very little information is known regarding the molecular subtypes of isolates in the western region of Africa. Molecular subtyping of additional B. anthracis isolates from this region in Africa is necessary in order to gain a better understanding of the diversity of isolates in this area of the world.
While little is known regarding the diversity of B. anthracis strains in West Africa, outbreaks of anthrax continue to occur there . Thus, animal products obtained from this region could be contaminated with B. anthracis spores. Public health agencies continue to recommend using only animal products which are free of B. anthracis spores (i.e., not using hides of unknown origin or from regions with epizootic anthrax such as West Africa) in order to reduce the potential for an anthrax infection . In addition to the hides being contaminated with B. anthracis spores, the practice of drum-making, which creates aerosols, also contributed to the infections of both drum-makers and the CT drum-maker's child. The drum-making process involves scraping, stretching, and sanding the goat hides which likely produced aerosols contributing to the infections of the NY and CT cases.
Similar to the NY and CT cases, all of the isolates associated with the NH case were identical and MLVA-8 was used to successfully match the clinical and environmental isolates from this case. However, the NH isolates were a new genotype, GT 149. While this genotype differed from GT 1 at three loci (vrrB2, vrrC1, pXO1), it was within the same cluster (A1.a) as GT 1 (Figure 1) . Indeed, canSNP analyses confirmed that these isolates are from the same lineage and the different MLVA genotypes suggest that further SNP analyses would provide additional resolution. All CT, NY, and NH isolates showed the ancestral state for canSNP3692595 (discovered by comparing the A0343 genome to other existing genomes), suggesting that the bifurcation point leading to these isolates lies near the base of the A.Br.011/009 lineage terminating in A0343 (Figure 2). While the origins of the drums used at the drumming event are not definitively known and, thus, a geographic link cannot be made, the isolates in the NH case are closely related to the isolates from the NY and CT cases.
In the current report, we used MLVA and canSNP analysis of B. anthracis to attempt to link clinical isolates with environmental isolates recovered from various locations associated with animal products used by the patients. MLVA and canSNP analysis successfully linked clinical and environmental isolates recovered in the NY, CT, and NH cases. Although none of the environmental isolate genotypes matched the clinical isolate genotypes in the CA case, the clinical and environmental isolates that were completely genotyped appear to be closely related (within the same MLVA-8 cluster) and genotypes identified from the yarn used by weaver were consistent with the yarn's geographic origin. These examples illustrate the power of the currently available genotyping methods and the dramatically different conditions that can be identified (i.e., contamination by a single event or genotype versus widespread contamination of numerous genotypes). In addition, the NY, CT, and NH cases illustrate the continued need to acquire and molecularly subtype isolates from around the world so that accurate predictions can be made about isolate origins.
This report does not meet the definition of research under 45 CFR 46.102(d), the U. S. Code of Federal Regulations regarding the protection of human subjects. Thus, review from our institutional review board was not required, and a waiver was obtained. Specimens were initially obtained during the course of outbreak investigations and submitted for diagnostic testing; specific informed consent was not obtained, although individuals were free to decline. Activities that do not meet the definition of research are not subject to informed consent requirements under 45 CFR 46.
Twenty nine isolates related to the California inhalation case were included in this report (Table 1). Nine clinical isolates from the patient and 20 additional isolates from samples labeled as yarn, wool, camel/goat hair, human hair, or the loom used by the patient were assayed.
The clinical isolate from the patient and 36 environmental isolates were included from the 2006 New York City case. The environmental isolates were recovered from samples collected in the drum-maker's warehouse and home, from goat hides in the drum-maker's possession, and in the vehicle that was used to transport the goat hides.
No clinical isolates were recovered from the 2007 cutaneous anthrax cases from Connecticut. However, biopsy specimens from both patients were tested. In addition, 15 environmental isolates recovered from samples taken in the drum-maker's residence and work shed, previously made drums, vehicle and goat hides found in the work shed were included in this report.
Eleven isolates associated with the 2009 New Hampshire case were included in the report. Two clinical isolates from the patient and nine environmental isolates that were recovered from drums and the community building where the patient attended the drumming event were assayed.
Isolates were stored in 25% glycerol with water and held at −70°C until needed. The clinical specimens were stored at −20°C until processed. Prior to their inclusion in this study, the California isolates were stored at ambient temperature on tryptic soy agar slants overlayed with mineral oil in various physical locations for over 25 years until they were recovered from the slants in 2002 .
DNA template from all recovered isolates was obtained by heat-lysis of a single colony after overnight growth on SBA. Using a 1 µl loop, one colony was suspended in 200 µl of 10 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.0 in a 1.5-ml tube containing a 0.22 µM filter unit (Millipore, Billerica, MA). The suspension was heated at 95°C for 20 min and centrifuged in a microfuge at 6000× g for 2 min. The filter unit was discarded, and the cell lysate was held at −20°C until testing. One µl of lysate was used in each reaction.
DNA from clinical specimens was extracted using the QIAamp DNA Mini kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA) according to manufacturer's instructions.
MLVA-8 and the expanded MLVA-15 were performed as previously described by Keim et al. and Van Ert et al., respectively , . Briefly, six chromosomal (vrrA, vrrB1, vrrB2, vrrC1, vrrC2, CG3) and 2 plasmid (pXO1-aat, pXO2-at) loci were amplified for the MLVA-8 scheme. Seven additional loci (VNTR 12, VNTR16, VNTR17, VNTR 19, VNTR 23, VNTR 32, and VNTR 35) were amplified for the MLVA-15 scheme. Each amplicon was labeled with one of three dyes (FAM, HEX, or NED) and analyzed on an ABI 377 and/or ABI 3130 automated DNA sequencers (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). ABI Genescan (ABI 377) and Genemapper v3.7 (ABI 3130) software (Applied Biosystems) were used to analyze gel images and fragment sizes, respectively.
CanSNP analysis was performed as previously described . This technique categorizes isolates into one of 12 sub-lineages (C.Br.A1055, B.Br.CNEVA, B.Br.KrugerB, A.Br.Vollum, A.Br.Aust94, A.Br.Ames, A.Br.WNA,B.Br.001/002, A.Br.005/006, A.Br.003/004, A.Br.001/002, A.Br.008/009). During the course of this work, we identified an additional canSNP that provides resolution within the A.Br.008/009 group (Table 3). In keeping with the nomenclature system previously reported , this canSNP is called A.Br.011 and the two flanking sub-groups are A.Br.008/011 and A.Br.011/009. We also tested a canSNP (3692595; Table 3) located near the base of A.Br.011/009 to gain further resolution of our ABr011/009 isolates.
We would like to acknowledge Richard Okinaka, Dawn Birdsell, Molly Matthews and James Schupp, who assisted with assay design and genotyping of some of the samples used in this report.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CKM ARH TP PK. Performed the experiments: CKM CAA JB EPP SRW. Analyzed the data: CKM CAA JB EPP SRW TP PK ARH. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: CKM CAA JB EPP SRW TP PK ARH. Wrote the paper: CKM CAA JB EPP SRW TP PK ARH.
- 1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2006) Inhalation anthrax associated with dried animal hides-Pennsylvania and New York City, 2006. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 55: 280–82.
- 2. Center for Disease Control (1974) Cutaneous anthrax acquired from imported Haitian drums-Florida. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 23: 142–47.
- 3. Center for Disease Control (1976) Anthrax-California. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 25: 33–34.
- 4. Suffin SC, Carnes WH, Kaufmann AF (1978) Inhalation anthrax in a home craftsman. Human Pathol 9: 594–97.
- 5. Editorial team (2006) Probable human anthrax death in Scotland. Euro Surveill 11(33): pii = 3025. Available: http://www.eurosurveillance.org/ViewArticle.aspx?ArticleId=3025. Accessed 2010 Dec 20.
- 6. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2007) Cutaneous anthrax associated with drum making using goat hides from West Africa-Connecticut, 2007. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 57: 628–31.
- 7. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2010) Gastrointestinal Anthrax after an Animal-Hide Drumming Event — New Hampshire and Massachusetts, 2009. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 59: 872–77.
- 8. Keim P, Price LB, Klevytska AM, Smith KL, Schupp JM, et al. (2000) Multiple-locus variable-number tandem repeat analysis reveals genetic relationships with Bacillus anthracis. J Bacteriol 182: 2928–36.
- 9. Van Ert MN, Esterday WR, Huynh LY, Okinaka RT, Hugh-Jones ME, et al. (2007) Global genetic population structure of Bacillus anthracis. Plos One 2: 461.
- 10. Marston CK, Hoffmaster AR, Wilson KE, Bragg SL, Plikaytis B, et al. (2006) Effects of long-term storage on viability and plasmid stability of Bacillus anthracis. Appl Environ Micro 71: 7778–80.
- 11. Opare C, Nsiire A, Awumbilla B, Akanmoir BD (2000) Human behavioral factors implicated in outbreaks of human anthrax in the Tamale municipality of northern Ghana. Acta Trop 76: 49–52.
- 12. McDonald D (2004) Available: http://www.uwyo.edu/dbmcd/molmark/practica/trees.html. Accessed 2011 Oct 3.
- 13. Germer S, Higuchi R (1999) Single-tube genotyping without oligonucleotide probes. Genome Res 9: 72–78.
- 14. Germer S, Holland MJ, Higuchi R (2000) High-throughput SNP allele-frequency determination in pooled DNA samples by kinetic PCR. Genome Res 10: 258–66.