Simultaneous limitation of plant growth by two or more nutrients is increasingly acknowledged as a common phenomenon in nature, but its cellular mechanisms are far from understood. We investigated the uptake kinetics of CO2 and phosphorus of the algae Chlamydomonas acidophila in response to growth at limiting conditions of CO2 and phosphorus. In addition, we fitted the data to four different Monod-type models: one assuming Liebigs Law of the minimum, one assuming that the affinity for the uptake of one nutrient is not influenced by the supply of the other (independent colimitation) and two where the uptake affinity for one nutrient depends on the supply of the other (dependent colimitation). In addition we asked whether the physiological response under colimitation differs from that under single nutrient limitation.
We found no negative correlation between the affinities for uptake of the two nutrients, thereby rejecting a dependent colimitation. Kinetic data were supported by a better model fit assuming independent uptake of colimiting nutrients than when assuming Liebigs Law of the minimum or a dependent colimitation. Results show that cell nutrient homeostasis regulated nutrient acquisition which resulted in a trade-off in the maximum uptake rates of CO2 and phosphorus, possibly driven by space limitation on the cell membrane for porters for the different nutrients. Hence, the response to colimitation deviated from that to a single nutrient limitation. In conclusion, responses to single nutrient limitation cannot be extrapolated to situations where multiple nutrients are limiting, which calls for colimitation experiments and models to properly predict growth responses to a changing natural environment. These deviations from single nutrient limitation response under colimiting conditions and independent colimitation may also hold for other nutrients in algae and in higher plants.
Citation: Spijkerman E, de Castro F, Gaedke U (2011) Independent Colimitation for Carbon Dioxide and Inorganic Phosphorus. PLoS ONE 6(12): e28219. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028219
Editor: Zoe Finkel, Mt. Alison University, Canada
Received: August 19, 2011; Accepted: November 3, 2011; Published: December 1, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Spijkerman et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by the German research foundation (DFG, SP695/2 & GA401/12-1). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Plant biomass forms the basis of food webs and its primary production promotes global economic and ecosystem services such as crop harvest, fish yield and carbon sequestration. Because plant photosynthesis and growth is often nutrient limited, knowledge on how nutrients limit plant growth is both, ecologically and economically important. On the other hand, massive plant growth such as large scale algal blooms, arising from an excess of nutrients, negatively affect biodiversity and are a nuisance to human activity. This excessive plant growth often results from plants acclimated to scavenge the limiting nutrient but which are suddenly faced with saturating conditions often due to antropogenic impacts. Thus, knowledge on plant nutrient uptake kinetics and response to changes of the limiting nutrient provides important insights to predict plant growth response.
Most previous studies have focused on the effect of a single limiting nutrient, such as inorganic phosphate (P) which often limits algal growth in freshwater (e.g. ). In many cases, however, this approach was unsatisfactory, which has recently been explained by the occurrence of colimitation by two or more nutrients under natural conditions , . For example, a colimitation by nitrogen, P and iron was shown in the phytoplankton communities of Lake Kasumigaura  and Lake Erie . As illustrated in these two studies, nutrient supplementation alleviates each incremental limitation and produces a synergistic effect when all limiting nutrients are added together (see  for a nice illustration). In the case of entire plankton communities a stepwise increase in growth and biomass after addition of all limiting nutrients, possibly results from the independent response of different species. In addition, a single species can also show the effects of colimitation , .
In general, algal cells respond to nutrient limiting conditions by increasing their ability for nutrient uptake. This can be achieved in two ways which are not mutually exclusive (Fig. 1); either increasing the maximum uptake rate (Vmax) and/or increasing the affinity for uptake. The latter is typically reflected in a decrease of the half saturation constant (Km), and an increase of the initial slope of the curve (affinity characterized by Vmax:Km). Vmax is positively related to the number of porters in the cytoplasmic membrane  whereas changes in Km reflect different types of porters. The affinity thus reflects the physiological combination of the two strategies of acclimation.
A) Data from  on the high (Km 0.7 µM P) and low (Km 9.2 µM P) affinity P transporter in Escherichia coli that have similar Vmax, B) Data from  on P-limited (high Vmax) and P-saturated (low Vmax) Chlamydomonas acidophila with the same Km (0.1–0.5 µM P).
In response to a P-limitation most algae increased Vmax as found in the green alga Scenedesmus sp. , the diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana  and the cyanobacterium Anabaena flos-aquae , while the Km often remained relatively constant. In contrast, in response to low CO2 many algae decrease their Km –. Both responses often result in an enhanced affinity for nutrient uptake; likely driven by the need to maintain a balanced cell nutrient content. Cell homeostasis is of great importance for a proper functioning of enzymes and proteins, and consequently nutrient uptake and excretion rates are regulated to balance nutrient ratios within a certain range , .
Even if colimitation is a rather common phenomenon in phytoplankton and plant growth in general , , the cellular response mechanisms in a single algal species are far from understood. They may involve interactions between two or more nutrients in short supply which questions the common practice to infer the consequences of nutrient limitation by considering only a single nutrient at a time. Consequently, we ask whether a colimitation by two macronutrients alters their respective uptake kinetics, compared to situations where a single nutrient is limiting, to better understand the mechanism(s) of algal growth acclimation and cellular response to colimiting conditions.
Here, we study the uptake and growth of the single-celled flagellated green alga Chlamydomonas acidophila to limiting conditions of CO2 and P, two important macro-nutrients for phytoplankton which are prone to change in the future and often limit phytoplankton blooms in very acidic and neutral fresh waters, as well as in marine systems –. Inorganic carbon occurs in three forms in aquatic systems: CO2, HCO3− and CO32−, but here we consider only the dissolved gas, CO2, which is the only inorganic C source present in the low pH environment (pH 2.7) of our model organism . In C. acidophila, CO2 uptake is considered an active process supported by a high affinity uptake mechanism at least under low CO2 conditions , thus allowing us to consider CO2 as a ‘normal’ macro-nutrient.
Recent theoretical studies suggest two types of colimitation for macro-nutrients: 1) independent and 2) dependent colimitation , , . An independent colimitation arises when the concentration of more than one nutrient is below the optimal concentration for uptake (a multi-nutrient colimitation sensu ). Under these conditions, the cell will increase Vmax and/or decrease the Km for the uptake of both limiting nutrients, i.e. exhibit a multiplicative response to the two concurrent limitations. The response to an independent colimitation might be restricted according to theoretical considerations showing that Vmax is positively related to the number of nutrient transporter proteins  and as space on the cell surface for these proteins may be limited , , the total number of nutrient transporters is thus restricted. Hence, theory predicts a trade-off between the Vmax of both limiting nutrients on a cellular level depending on the limiting nutrient in highest demand . However, as far as we know, this hypothesis has never been tested with empirical data.
Alternatively, a dependent colimitation for nutrients exists if the uptake of one nutrient is enhanced by the availability of another one (a biochemical colimitation sensu ). In our situation, a P-limitation may inhibit the high affinity uptake of inorganic carbon (i.e. prevent a low affinity constant for CO2 uptake (Km,C)) and of a CO2 concentrating mechanism (CCM, –) which are both active processes ,  that depend, directly or indirectly, on ATP. Under P-saturated and low CO2 conditions, C. acidophila had a low Km,C and a CCM, both of which were absent under high CO2 conditions ,  indicating some costs which promote their down regulation at sufficient C-supply. If CO2 uptake depends on P-supply, the Km for CO2 uptake should increase with increasing P-limitation (as shown in the green alga Chlorella emersonii ). The dependent colimitation hypothesis implies that a minimum P concentration is required to acclimate to low CO2. If that minimum is not satisfied it results in a high Km,C when both P and CO2 are low. The alternative, that P uptake ability depends on CO2-concentration, is also possible. Recent studies on C. acidophila  support this option: at high CO2 concentrations, cells could deplete the P concentration in the medium more strongly than at low CO2 concentrations. Also, the minimum cellular P quota was lower in high than in low CO2 cells , suggesting that cellular P requirements for growth are lower at high CO2. Following this hypothesis, the P uptake ability (enhanced maximum P uptake rate (Vmax,P) and/or decreased affinity constant for P uptake (Km,P)) should increase with increasing CO2-concentration.
We analyzed the response of C. acidophila to a combination of CO2 and P limitations. Our objectives are first, to test the hypothesis that responses to two limiting factors cannot be inferred from single-nutrient studies; second to decide which of the above-described mechanisms of colimitation is more plausible. For this, four different models, two of independent colimitation and two of dependent colimitation (CO2 limiting P uptake and vice versa), were fitted to the data by maximum likelihood. We also provide empirical evidence for the theoretically expected trade-off between the Vmax for both nutrients.
Cultures and analyses
Triplicate semi-continuous cultures of C. acidophila Negoro (CCAP 11/137) were grown at 20±1°C in Woods Hole medium  with 1.6 µM P and a pH adjusted to 2.7 with HCl. Daily diluted cultures at growth rates of 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4 and 0.6 d−1 in low CO2 and 0.1, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6 and 0.8 d−1 in high CO2 treatments resulted in a decrease of P-limitation with increasing growth rate. Cell densities ranged between 1.1 105 cells ml−1 in the highest growth rates to 1.5 106 cells ml−1 in the lowest growth rates. Cell densities were on average 1.6-fold higher in the high CO2 cultures than in the low CO2. Incident light was approximately 200 µmol photons m−2 s−1 in all cultures with a light/dark period of 16/8 h. Daily dilution and harvesting were done 4–5 hours after the onset of light. High CO2 cultures were mildly aerated with a mixture of 4.5% CO2 in air, resulting in an average CO2 concentration in the medium of 0.33 (±0.05, n = 20) mM C, whereas low CO2 cultures were non-aerated to realise CO2 limiting conditions and contained approximately 0.02 mM CO2 (HighToc, Elementar, Hanau, Germany). These concentrations were measured in the medium, but do not reflect concentrations nearby the cell (see discussion for further details). Inorganic iron buffered the pH of the medium, thus resulting in a constant pH independent of CO2 concentration. At balanced growth (remaining at constant cell density 4–5 hours after the onset of light after an exchange of three to five times the culture volume), samples were taken for measurements of algal density, chemical analyses and CO2- and P-uptake kinetics.
Cellular phosphorus quota (Qp), cellular C and P content were determined by measuring the particulate P and C in the cultures. The particulate P concentration was determined on filtered culture suspension (0.2 µm Whatman nucleopore) extracted at 100°C for 1 h with K2S2O8 and 0.5 M H2SO4 and measured spectrophotometrically using molybdate and ascorbic acid . Particulate C was analysed on culture suspension filtered on pre-combusted GF/F filters (Whatman), dried for one week at 50°C, and combusted in a carbon analyser (HighTOC+N, Elementar or EuroVector CHNS-O Elementaranalysator, Wegberg, Germany). Cell numbers were determined using an automatic cell counter (CASY 1, Model TT, Schärfe, Reutlingen, Germany).
The CO2-uptake kinetics was obtained in a temperature regulated light dispensation system (Topgallant LLC, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA) providing 500 µmol photons m−2 s−1 and measuring oxygen evolution in a Clark type electrode (Micro-electrode Inc., Bedford, Ohio, USA) as described for P-replete C. acidophila in , . Cells were centrifuged (1500g, 5 min) and resuspended in C-free medium to an optical density of 0.2 at 750 nm in a 1 cm cuvette. After O2 evolution ceased, one of six different concentrations of HCO3− was added and the response recorded on a computer. Each concentration was measured in three-fold, resulting in 18 data points for establishing one kinetic curve. At pH 2.65, 95% of the added HCO3− was assumed to be dehydrated to CO2 within 60 s and no delay in response in O2 evolution was observed. There was no significant effect of the addition of HCO3− on the pH: on average pH decreased by 0.001 units over the total run of 6 additions. Part of the algal suspension was fixed with iodine and cell densities were determined as described above. Oxygen evolution rates were related to cell densities and fitted to the Michaelis Menten model using the non-linear regression module in SPSS software (using the Levenberg Marquardt estimation, version 12.01) to obtain the Km,C and the maximum CO2 uptake rate by photosynthesis (Vmax,C).
For P-uptake kinetics, cells were centrifuged (1500g, 5 min) and the pellet resuspended in medium without P and iron-EDTA at a pH of 2.7. Final densities were adjusted to an optical density of 0.02 at 750 nm in a 1 cm cuvette. After an acclimation of 15 to 30 min at 90 µmol photons m−2 s−1, P-uptake was determined over a period of one minute after the addition of different concentrations of H333PO4 (111 TBq mmol−1 specific activity, Amersham biosciences, Freiburg, Germany) diluted in stock solutions of 50 or 500 µM K2HPO4 at pH 2.7 as described in . Uptake was terminated by filtration on 1.2 µm cellulose acetate filters and subsequently rinsed with 0.2 M LiCl. P-uptake kinetics from two out of three replicate P-limited cultures and data of P-replete cells were published before . Similar as for CO2-uptake kinetics, cell specific data were fitted to the Michaelis-Menten model to estimate the Km,P and Vmax,P.
Modelling and statistics
We fitted four models describing colimitation to our data, following terminology and equations from  and . This was done by calculating the external P and CO2 (C) concentrations from individual uptake kinetics and cellular quota for each balanced growth rate following principle characteristics of the (semi-) continuous culture as explained by several authors , –. Direct measurements of the limiting nutrient concentrations in the medium were not possible as they were too low to be measured directly, but the calculation of external concentration is a reasonable procedure despite the inevitable uncertainty involved . Prior to this, we tested single nutrient models with the standard Monod function for P and C. In both cases the fit was poorer than in two-nutrient (colimitation) models, so we do not show detailed results here (Fig. S1). We used the following models describing colimitation:
1a. Independent co-limitation, multiplicative form:1b. Independent co-limitation, minimum form (Liebig's Law):2a. Dependent co-limitation with C acquisition depending on P-limitation:where the first term of the denominator comes from:
and since: it follows that:
The symbols used in the equations are μ, growth rate (in h−1); μmax, maximum growth rate (in h−1); αC, αP, affinity for growth at C or P-limiting conditions; αCmax, αPmax, maximum affinity for growth at C or P-limiting conditions; KC, half saturation constant for growth in relation to external CO2 concentration and KP, half saturation constant for growth in relation to external P concentration (for details see , ). We used maximum likelihood to fit the models to the data, assuming a normal distribution for the stochastic component of the models.
In addition to the Monod curves we established contour plots to distinguish between the effects of the cellular C and P contents on the uptake kinetics using Matlab 7.8 and interpolation based on Sandwell .
Statistical tests were performed with SPSS (version 12.01). Homogeneity of variances was checked with a Levene test.
We tested the nutrient uptake response in the green alga Chlamydomonas acidophila to different CO2 and P colimiting conditions. By using semi-continuous cultures the extent of limitation decreases with increasing dilution rate and, thus, with increasing balanced growth rate.
CO2 and P uptake kinetics differed in the high and low CO2 acclimated algae (Fig. 2), e.g. Vmax,C was higher in the low CO2 acclimated cultures than in the high CO2 ones, when the effect of growth rate was accounted for (Fig. 2A; ANCOVA, F1,27 = 27.0, p<0.001). Possibly, this kinetic difference resulted from the lower cellular C content (Fig. S2A) in the low CO2 than in the high CO2 cells at a given steady state growth rate. The higher Vmax,C in cells with low C content supports the nutrient kinetic response theory (Fig. 1B) that at a cellular level, a C-deficiency results in a higher CO2 demand and thus a higher Vmax,C. The potential growth rate (growth capacity) calculated from Vmax,C and the cellular carbon content supports the idea that conditions were limiting for CO2, as the growth capacity was between 1.7 and 4.4-fold higher than balanced growth rates in the low but not in the high CO2 cultures (Table S1). The ratio between growth capacity and balanced growth rate increased with decreasing growth rate, i.e. with increasing CO2 limitation (see also ). In high CO2 cells the growth capacity equaled the balanced growth rate, but enrichment experiments showed that these cells were nevertheless colimited for P and CO2  meaning that results from C-uptake kinetics alone were not conclusive.
A) Maximum CO2 uptake rate by photosynthesis (Vmax,C, mmol O2 10−12 cells h−1), B) affinity constant for CO2 uptake by photosynthesis (Km,C, µM CO2), C) maximum P uptake rate (Vmax,P, mmol P 10−12 cells h−1) and, D) affinity constant for P uptake (Km,P, µM P). Mean ± SE of 3 replicates.
In low CO2, Vmax,C was the same in P-limited cells (data from the three highest growth rates in Fig. 2) and P-replete (data from ), whereas in high CO2 it was lower in P-limited than in P-replete cells (Table 1). These results illustrate that the kinetic response to a colimitation differs from that to a single nutrient limitation. In contrast, the Km,C was the same in P-limited and P-replete cultures (Table 1), but depended on the CO2 concentration: Km,C was higher in the high CO2 than in the low CO2 cultures (ANCOVA, F1, 27 = 10.5, p<0.01).
Contrary to expectations, Km,C did not increase with decreasing growth rate in the low CO2 cultures (Fig. 2B; Pearson r15 = 0.40, p = 0.14), which should happen if CO2 uptake depended on P-limitation (model 2a). Moreover, Km,C decreased with decreasing growth rate in the high CO2 cultures (Fig. 2B; Pearson r15 = 0.55, p<0.05), thus suggesting that the high CO2 cells became more severely CO2-limited with lower growth rates (see discussion for a possible mechanism). Although at such low growth rates high CO2 cells were severely P-limited, a high affinity CO2 uptake kinetics was established also suggesting that a P-limitation did not influence CO2-acquisition.
Under low CO2 conditions Vmax,P did not vary over growth rate (Fig. 2C), suggesting that all cultures were severely P-limited. This Vmax,P was 20-fold higher in P-limited than in P-replete cells (data from ; Table 1). In the colimited cultures Vmax,P was on average higher in high CO2 than in the low CO2 cultures (ANCOVA, F1, 24 = 12.4, p<0.01) and coincides with a lower cellular P content in the high CO2 cells (Fig. S2B). Thus, high CO2 cells could exploit the external P concentration more and were possibly more severely P-limited than low CO2 cells resulting in a higher calculated growth capacity (Table S1). Growth P capacities (i.e. the hypothetical growth rate at Vmax) greatly exceeded the balanced growth rate in all cultures. The higher Vmax,P in the high CO2 cultures suggests that P-uptake depended on CO2 during growth (possibly supporting model 2b).
Km,P did not vary over growth rate in either high or low CO2 treatments, but was higher in the high CO2 than in the low CO2 cultures (Fig. 2D; T-test, t27 = 3.1, p<0.005), suggesting that low CO2 cells had a higher affinity P-uptake system. Possibly, Vmax,P influenced the estimation of this parameter as C. acidophila had a high affinity P-uptake system under all conditions, including P-replete conditions (Table 1). Because the cellular C and P content of the high and low CO2-acclimated cells differed at a given balanced growth rate (Fig. S2) and we expected cell homeostasis to play a role, we will now relate the uptake kinetics to the cellular P to C quota which is independent of cell size.
Independent of CO2 conditions the Qp determined Vmax of both nutrients. Vmax,C increased (Pearson r30 = 0.83, p<0.001) and Vmax,P decreased with increasing Qp (r22 = −0.69, p<0.001; Fig. 3A, C). Consequently, there was a clear trade-off in the Vmax for both nutrients (Pearson r 22 = −0.59, p<0.005; Fig. 4). The variation in Vmax,C was much larger than that in Vmax,P hence, a small increase of Vmax,P can only be obtained by a substantial lowering of Vmax,C, implying high costs involved in this adaptation (P-starvation). Cells relatively rich in P (high Qp) had a lower Vmax,P, and cells relatively rich in C (low Qp) had a much lower Vmax,C. Contour plots which display the cellular C and P content on 2 separate axes, reveal that a low cellular C content resulted in the highest Vmax,C and a low cellular P content in the highest Vmax,P (Fig. 5A, B). In addition, there is a tendency for an even higher Vmax,C at higher cellular P and maximum values of Vmax,P at higher cellular C contents.
A) Maximum CO2 uptake rate (Vmax,C, mmol O2 10−12 cells h−1), B) affinity constant for CO2 uptake by photosynthesis (Km,C, µM CO2), C) maximum P uptake rate (Vmax,P, mmol P 10−12 cells h−1) and, D) affinity constant for P uptake (Km,P, µM P).
A) maximum CO2 uptake rate (Vmax,C, mmol O2 10−12 cells h−1), B) maximum P uptake rate (Vmax,P, mmol P 10−12 cells h−1), C) affinity constant for CO2 uptake by photosynthesis (Km,C, µM CO2), D) affinity constant for P uptake (Km,P, µM P), E) affinity for C uptake (Vmax,C:Km,C); and F) affinity for P uptake (Vmax,P:Km,P). In some parts of the graph, the absence of measured data leads the interpolation algorithm to produce negative values. These values are not plotted.
In both high and low CO2 conditions, Km,C increased with increasing Qp when data from high and low CO2 cultures were analyzed separately (Fig. 3B; Pearson r15 = 0.53, p<0.05 for high CO2 and Pearson r15 = 0.67, p<0.01 for low CO2). In addition, Km,C was higher in high than in low CO2 cells (Qp as a co-variate; ANCOVA, F1, 29 = 25.3, p<0.001). In contrast, no changes in Km,P were observed over Qp (Fig. 3D). The contour plots that separate the cellular C and P content on 2 axes, reveal rather complex patterns of Km in relation to the cellular C and P content (Fig. 5C, D). Against theory (Fig. 1A), cells with a low nutrient content often had a high Km for that nutrient. Observed changes in Km were however small compared to the changes in Vmax, suggesting that overall Vmax dominated responses in uptake kinetics. As a result, the affinity for C or P uptake was highest at the lowest cellular C and P content, respectively (Fig. 5E, F), although the pattern is less clear than with Vmax (Fig. 5A, B). That is, the highest affinity for C uptake was realized at the lowest cellular C content with a tendency that the maximum affinity was present in cells with a higher P content (Fig. 5E). The highest affinity for P uptake was realized at the lowest cellular P content but values varied little over cellular C and P content (Fig. 5F).
To test for an independent or dependent colimitation, the external P and CO2 concentrations were calculated from the kinetic data (concentrations were too low to be measured), thus combining the kinetic characteristics of uptake with the cellular C and P content into a external nutrient concentration present in the medium. Growth rates in relation to these external nutrient concentrations were first fitted to single-nutrient Monod models and revealed that external P concentration could satisfactionally explain growth rate, whereas CO2 concentration could not (Fig. S1). Then, we fitted the data to 4 models, reflecting 4 types of colimitation. The best fit of the data was obtained when assuming the multiplicative form of independent colimitation (model 1a; Fig. 6, Table 2) suggesting no interaction between the uptake kinetics of the two limiting nutrients. The fit was better than the single Monod model (Fig. S1), supporting the presence of a colimitation. Figure 6A reveals a strong effect of the external P concentrations on the growth rate, while the effect of the CO2 concentration is much weaker. This agrees with the response in the enrichment experiments, where growth was enhanced by P-addition, and CO2 addition only stimulated growth when provided in concert with P . Fitting model 1b to the growth rates, which also assumes independent nutrient uptake kinetics but that only the most limiting nutrient (either C or P) is affecting the growth rate (ultimately, Liebig's law) resulted in a more angular shape given the sudden changes in nutrient limitation (Fig. 6B; Table 2). The fit of this model to the data was also good, but significantly less than that of model 1A, according to the difference of ∼5 in the Akaike Information Criterion (AICc) between both fits .
A) model 1a: Independent co-limitation, multiplicative form, B) model 1b: Independent co-limitation, minimum form (Liebig's Law), C) model 2a: Dependent co-limitation (C-uptake depends on P-lim) and, D) model 2b: Dependent co-limitation (P-uptake depends on C-lim). See Table 2 for estimated values of parameters and goodness-of-fit. Please notice the difference in axis between the external CO2 (in µM) and P concentration (in nM).
The models 2a, and 2b (Fig. 6C,D; Table 2) assume a dependent colimitation. In the model 2a, CO2 uptake depends on the P-limitation, resulting in an angular shape of the surface that shows an even stronger effect of P concentration on the growth rate (lowest Kp, Table 2) and a weaker effect of CO2 concentration. Especially the data points at high CO2 concentration were badly fitted by the model. Given that the fitting was highly sensitive to starting values and that we found a difference in AICc compared to the fit of model 1a of ∼50, we conclude that model 2a does not reflect the underlying mechanisms of colimitation. In contrast, if we assume that P uptake depends on CO2-limitation (model 2b) we get a fit to the data similar to that obtained with the model 1b (Fig. 6D). There are no strong differences between the goodness of fit of model 1b and 2b as the AICc is similar (Table 2). The independent, multiplicative colimitation of model 1a resulted in the best fit, but the difference in AICc between model 1a and 2b is only ∼4.5. The residuals (observed-predicted) for the four models shown in Fig. 6 are visualised in Fig. S3.
When facing nutrient limiting conditions plants respond by increasing their ability for nutrient uptake. This can be established by increasing their maximum uptake rate (Vmax) and/or increasing their affinity for uptake (lower affinity constant, Km). Vmax is positively related to the number of porters on the cytoplasmic membrane  whereas a change in Km reflects the presence of a different porter type . Because the response to single-nutrient or colimitation may differ, we analyzed the uptake kinetics of the green alga Chlamydomonas acidophila to different CO2 and P colimiting conditions and fitted the data to 4 different models describing colimitation.
We used semi-continuous cultures which implies that the strength of limitation decreases with increasing balanced growth rate. Moreover, uptake kinetics and cellular quota were directly converted into external nutrient concentrations that could then be related to balanced growth rate  and used to test different colimitation models. Because growth rates were used to calculate the external nutrient concentrations, the modeling results were considered carefully and conclusions were based in concert with the contour plots that show only measured kinetic characteristics. Enrichment experiments had revealed that growth in all cultures was colimited by CO2 and P, since the growth rates of both high and low CO2 acclimated cells were enhanced by increased P concentration (3.8–fold) but even more when both CO2 and P were supplemented (4.8–fold; .
Single vs. multiple nutrient limitation
Cell homeostasis of balanced nutrient content is of the greatest importance for a proper functioning of enzymes and proteins, and consequently nutrient uptake and excretion rates are regulated to balance nutrient ratios within a certain range , . Thus, survival and growth critically depend on an increase of the uptake capacity of all nutrients available in sub-optimal concentrations. This was reflected in the uptake response of colimited C. acidophila that had a high Vmax,C when the cellular C content was low, and a high Vmax,P when the cellular P content was low (Fig. 5). Vmax was strongly related to Qp (Fig. 3). Cell homeostasis therefore determined the limitation status of the cell, and consequently its nutrient uptake kinetics. The relationships of Vmax,P and Vmax,C versus Qp for both high and low CO2 cells support previous observations that all cells were colimited for CO2 and P  and that acclimation to nutrient limiting conditions resulted mainly in changes in Vmax (as exemplified in Fig. 1B; ). High CO2 cells had a lower cellular P content and were more severely P-limited whereas low CO2 cells had the lower cellular C content and were thus more severely CO2-limited. In addition, high CO2 cells possibly contained more C as a result of luxury accumulation caused by high CO2 concentrations, or their C content was increased by cellular accumulation of photosynthate products resulting from P-limitation (mainly lipids; ). The fact that Vmax,P increases with increasing P-limitation has been amply demonstrated by a large number of observations in single nutrient, P-limited algal species –, however, our colimitation results contrast with many single-nutrient studies in which Vmax,C decreased with increasing CO2-limitation (e.g. , ). Thus, under colimiting conditions, CO2 and P uptake interact and single nutrient limitation studies cannot predict the cell response adequately. A similar conclusion was recently obtained in a cyanobacterium grown under N, Fe and N/Fe colimited conditions .
In P-replete cells of C. acidophila Vmax,C was higher in high CO2 than in low CO2 conditions . The same pattern was observed in many other P-replete algal species, which is explained by enhanced growth rates at high CO2 , . If growth is not limited by either nutrient supply or light, high CO2 concentrations stimulate photosynthesis and consequently growth. In our experiments uptake and growth response to changing CO2 conditions was uncoupled in P-limited cells, revealed by the lower Vmax,C in high CO2 P-limited cells that still have a higher maximum growth rate  than the low CO2 P-limited cells.
One intriguing result of our study is the colimitation for CO2 and P in cells growing at high CO2. The CO2 concentration measured in the CO2 aerated, algae-containing vessels was 330 µM independent of whether cultures contained 7.8 105 or 1.5 106 cells ml−1, nonetheless, calculations of external CO2 concentrations in the medium were a 100-fold lower (i.e 3 µM). A possible explanation is the presence of a diffusion barrier around the cells  despite the fact that C. acidophila is an active swimming flagellate with a strong chemotactic response to CO2 (pers. obs. and see  for Chlamydomonas moewussii).
The presence of such diffusion barrier can be inferred more clearly by looking closer at the difference between Vmax,C and Vmax,P and also at the definition of Vmax. Vmax is a function of two parameters : The number of porters divided by the handling time for nutrient uptake. High CO2 acclimated cells had the highest Vmax,P showing they were under stringent P-limitation. Under P-limitation, cells excrete superfluously produced sugars from photosynthesis and cells producing a polysaccharide mucous layer will extend such layer under severe P-depletion , thus surrounding the cell with a diffusion barrier for nutrient uptake that increases handling time. Indeed, high CO2, P-limited cultures of C. acidophila had higher concentrations of dissolved organic substances than low CO2 cultures suggesting more (poly)saccharide excretion . Presumably, this affects P uptake much less than C-uptake as Vmax,P did not decline in the presence of a thick mucous layer in two other green algal species (mucilage twice cell radius; ), whereas CO2-uptake is considered seriously hampered by such diffusion barrier , . This implies that high CO2, P-limited cells had to cope with increased handling time for CO2 uptake, which dampened the increase in Vmax,C and the measured values of Vmax,C underestimate the number of CO2-uptake porters actually present. Because low CO2 cells were also P-limited, a (lesser) diffusion barrier for CO2 uptake may likewise be present in these cells.
The low Km,C in the high CO2, P-limited cells at low growth rate (Fig. 2b) also indicates that the CO2 concentration in direct vicinity of the cell was limiting and supports the presence of a diffusion barrier around the cells. This layer presumably increased in size with decreasing growth rate. The impact of a mucilage layer possibly explains the difference in response between a single nutrient limitation and colimitation in CO2-uptake kinetics, because P-replete cells will have a small or no diffusion barrier around the cells.
The fact that model 1a delivered the best fit suggests that an independent, multiplicative colimitation for CO2 and P in C. acidophila is the best explanation. Liebig's Law of the minimum (model 1b), another form of independent colimitation, showed a worse fit, as did the two dependent colimitation models. But, beyond differences in goodness of fit, there are other arguments that support an independent colimitation. For instance, a basic assumption of Liebig's Law (model 1b) does not really apply, because the instantaneous maximum growth in a nutrient enrichment experiment was obtained when both CO2 and P were added . The model 1b nevertheless fits reasonably well because one limitation (P) is considerably stronger than the other (CO2), which was confirmed by single-nutrient models (Fig. S1).
Regarding the dependent colimitation models (2a,b), their basic assumption does not agree with the results. The models assume changes in Km over the range of nutrient limitation that did not occur in the experiments (see below for further discussion). The data show that, irrespective of the other nutrient limitation, the cells responded to a low nutrient content by increasing their Vmax for that nutrient. On a cellular level this presumably resulted in a trade-off in space for porters of either nutrient on the cytoplasm membrane (see below). The contour plots support the conclusions from the model fittings as they reveal a trade-off in Vmax for both limiting nutrients (Fig. 5A,B).
We expected to find that CO2-acquisition depends on P-limitation , , , since the realization of a low Km,C and a CCM  are both active processes hampered by insufficient ATP during P-limitation . Under P-replete, low CO2 conditions, C. acidophila had both a low Km,C and a CCM , . However, the Km,C was also unexpectedly low in stringent P-limited cells (Figs. 2B, 3B). Thus, our results support those of Kozlowska et al. , who showed a lower Km,C in P-limited than in P-replete cells of Chlorella vulgaris. Possibly, Chlorella vulgaris was also colimited by P and CO2 in their study as cell densities were high, whereas in the study of Beardall et al. (Km,C higher in P-limited than P-replete low CO2 cells) the cell density of Chlorella emersonii was low . Of course other explanations such as the presence of entirely different adaptation mechanisms in the different species of Chlorella are also possible. Nonetheless, the poor fit of our data to model 2a (which reflects these assumptions) clearly results in a rejection of a dependent colimitation in which CO2 acquisition depends on P-limitation in C. acidophila.
Model 2b (P-uptake depended on CO2 limitation) provided a reasonable fit to the data and it supports our earlier finding that high CO2, P-depleted cells of C. acidophila had a higher P uptake ability (i.e. realized a lower external P concentration) than low CO2 cultures . However, we think that the model fits for the wrong reason, as the presence of a dependent colimitation would imply that the Km,P is higher in the low CO2 cells (i.e. more stringent CO2-limited), whereas we find the direct opposite (related to growth rate) or no difference (related to Qp). The relative good fit of model 2b must therefore be a result of the enhanced growth capacity for P in the high CO2 cells (Table S1) compared to low CO2 cells. Again, the contour plots support the conclusions from the model fittings, as changes in Km and affinity for both limiting nutrients did not follow the expected changes based on dependent colimitation models (Fig. 5).
Our data show a trade-off between Vmax,P and Vmax,C (Fig. 4): when P uptake ability (Vmax,P) was high, that for CO2 (Vmax,C) was low and vice versa. Nutrient uptake modeling revealed that Vmax is directly and positively related to the number of porters, although increased handling time can dampen this relation . Also experimentally, in higher plant cell cultures (guard cells of Solanum tuberosum, Nicotiana tabacum and Vicia faba) a positive relation was found between the K+-uptake porter density and K+ transport capacity . Therefore, Vmax can be used as an indicator for the number of active porters. Accordingly, we conclude that the number of porters was related to the cellular content of the limiting nutrient, but also to its external concentration. This relation not only holds for micro-organisms or plant cell cultures but also for higher plants as, for example, the density of stomata (porter for gas) declined linearly with air CO2 concentration , although there is much debate at this point .
An algal cell requires many different nutrients for growth, and all need transportation through the cytoplasm membrane by (often) nutrient-specific porters. Calculations on the number of nitrate porters in a hypothetical algal cell revealed that 8.5% of the cell surface may be covered by just one type of porter , . Within the constraint of an overall fixed number of porters, a cell can only increase the density of porters for a specific limiting nutrient at the expense of others . Under colimiting conditions, it seems plausible that a space limitation for porters on the membrane results in a trade-off in the investment for porters for those limiting nutrients , for which we provide the first empirical evidence.
At the cellular level, the trade-off in Vmax can be interpreted as a kind of dependent colimitation: The space freed by a decrease in number of porters for one nutrient is used for an increase of porters of another one. In contrast, current dependent colimitation models assume that the concentration of one limiting nutrient has an effect on the Km for the acquisition of another one and not on Vmax. This requires a different set of models where adaptation in Vmax is considered (possibly starting from ).
Increasing evidence reveals that phytoplankton in marine and freshwater ecosystems and plants in general are colimited in their growth, and our study enhances the understanding of phytoplankton growth response and physiological adaptation under a colimitation for CO2 and P. In conclusion, cell nutrient homeostasis regulated nutrient acquisition in C. acidophila, and the most plausible mechanism was a multiplicative, independent colimitation. Given the space constraints on the cytoplasm membrane a trade-off in the number of porters for the uptake of different nutrients seems plausible under colimiting conditions. Responses to colimitation cannot be predicted from those to single nutrient limitation and therefore experiments on colimited plants are required to properly predict growth responses to a complex and changing natural environment. Our conclusions may also apply for other nutrients such as K and P , Si and P , N and CO2 , – in algae and in higher plants , , .
Balanced growth rates (h−1) fitted to external CO2 concentration (A: Sc, in µM) and P concentration (B: Sp, in nM) using a single nutrient Monod model. Prior to testing colimitation models, we fitted single-nutrient models to check if one nutrient alone can satisfactorily explain the growth response of C. acidophila. For this, we used a standard Monod function with the external concentration of either carbon or phosphorous as predictors, as:where S represents either carbon or phosphorous concentrations in the medium. The ability of carbon concentration to explain growth response was quite low, compared with other models, which is coherent with the high dispersion evident in the data (Fig. S1a). Additionally, the maximum growth rate predicted by this model was much lower than all the others. On the other hand, phosphorous had a much better predictive ability (Fig. S1b), which is also consistent with the stronger effect of phosphorous detected in the colimitation models. Still, the model with phosphorous alone had a worse fit than most of the colimitation models, suggesting again that growth is better described based on a multiple-nutrient colimitation. The modelling of μ to CO2 resulted in an estimation and 95% confidence interval of μmax of 0.036 [0.029 0.043], KC of 0.97 [0.42 1.74], Log-likelihood of 75.5, and corrected Akaike Information Criterion (AICC) of −148.3. The modelling of μ to P resulted in an estimation and 95% confidence interval of μmax of 0.059 [0.054 0.065], KP of 1.08 [0.9 1.38], Log-likelihood of 105.8, and AICC of −208.9.
Cellular carbon (A, in pmol C cell−1) and cellular phosphorus (B, in fmol P cell−1) content of Chlamydomonas acidophila in relation to balanced growth rate (d−1) of high CO2 (+CO2) and low CO2 (−CO2) P-limited cultures. Mean ± SE of 3 measurements. CO2 concentration had a significant effect on the cellular C content (ANCOVA, df = 1,27, F = 5.9, p<0.05) and cellular P content (ANCOVA, df = 1,27, F = 12.5, p<0.01) when the effect of growth rate is accounted for.
Residuals (observed-predicted) for the four models shown in Fig. 6 in the main text. A) model 1a; B) model 1b; C) model 2a; and D) model 2b.
Calculated growth capacity, i.e. Vmax/cellular nutrient content (d−1), of Chlamydomonas acidophila in relation to balanced growth rate (d−1) of high CO2 (+CO2) and low CO2 (−CO2) P-limited cultures at pH 2.7. The following assumptions were made: 1) The maximum uptake rate is for 100% converted into growth during the 16 h light period per day, and 2) 1 mol O2 is released when 1 mol CO2 is fixed (required to calculate Vmax,C). Calculated growth capacity based on maximum CO2 uptake rates revealed a higher capacity in the low CO2 cells than needed to maintain balanced growth rate, whereas capacity equaled balanced growth rate in high CO2 cells. Calculated growth capacity based on maximum P uptake rate were >100-fold higher than balanced growth rates. Such overcapacity has been found more often in P-limited algal cultures , . In addition, growth capacity was higher in the high CO2 than in the low CO2 cells.
Conceived and designed the experiments: ES. Performed the experiments: ES. Analyzed the data: ES FdC UG. Wrote the paper: ES FdC UG.
- 1. Schindler DW (1977) Evolution of phosphorus limitation in lakes. Science 195: 260–262.DW Schindler1977Evolution of phosphorus limitation in lakes.Science195260262
- 2. North RL, Guildford SJ, Smith REH, Havens SM, Twiss MR (2007) Evidence for phosphorus, nitrogen, and iron colimitation of phytoplankton communities in Lake Erie. Limnol Oceanogr 52: 315–328.RL NorthSJ GuildfordREH SmithSM HavensMR Twiss2007Evidence for phosphorus, nitrogen, and iron colimitation of phytoplankton communities in Lake Erie.Limnol Oceanogr52315328
- 3. Elser JJ, Bracken MES, Cleland EE, Gruner DS, Harpole WS, et al. (2007) Global analysis of nitrogen and phosphorus limitation of primary producers in freshwater, marine and terrestrial ecosystems. Ecology Lett 10: 1135–1142.JJ ElserMES BrackenEE ClelandDS GrunerWS Harpole2007Global analysis of nitrogen and phosphorus limitation of primary producers in freshwater, marine and terrestrial ecosystems.Ecology Lett1011351142
- 4. Nagai T, Imai A, Matsushige K, Fukushima T (2006) Effect of iron complexation with dissolved organic matter on the growth of cyanobacteria in a eutrophic lake. Aquat Microb Ecol 44: 231–239.T. NagaiA. ImaiK. MatsushigeT. Fukushima2006Effect of iron complexation with dissolved organic matter on the growth of cyanobacteria in a eutrophic lake.Aquat Microb Ecol44231239
- 5. Davidson EA, Howarth RW (2007) Environmental science - Nutrients in synergy. Nature 449: 1000–1001.EA DavidsonRW Howarth2007Environmental science - Nutrients in synergy.Nature44910001001
- 6. Arrigo KR (2005) Marine microorganisms and global nutrient cycles. Nature 437: 349–355.KR Arrigo2005Marine microorganisms and global nutrient cycles.Nature437349355
- 7. Saito MA, Goepfert TJ, Ritt JT (2008) Some thoughts on the concept of colimitation: Three definitions and the importance of bioavailability. Limnol Oceanogr 53: 276–290.MA SaitoTJ GoepfertJT Ritt2008Some thoughts on the concept of colimitation: Three definitions and the importance of bioavailability.Limnol Oceanogr53276290
- 8. Aksnes DL, Egge JK (1991) A theoretical model for nutrient uptake in phytoplankton. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 70: 65–72.DL AksnesJK Egge1991A theoretical model for nutrient uptake in phytoplankton.Mar Ecol Prog Ser706572
- 9. Rhee G-Y (1973) A continous culture study of phosphate uptake, growth rate and polyphosphate in Scenedesmus sp. J Phycol 9: 495–506.G-Y Rhee1973A continous culture study of phosphate uptake, growth rate and polyphosphate in Scenedesmus sp.J Phycol9495506
- 10. Perry MJ (1976) Phosphate ultilization by an oceanic diatom in phosphorus-limited chemostat culture and in the oligotrophic waters of the central North Pacific. Limnol Oceanogr 21: 88–107.MJ Perry1976Phosphate ultilization by an oceanic diatom in phosphorus-limited chemostat culture and in the oligotrophic waters of the central North Pacific.Limnol Oceanogr2188107
- 11. Nalewajko C, Lean DRS (1980) Phosphorus. In: Morris I, editor. The physiological ecology of phytoplankton. pp. 235–258.C. NalewajkoDRS Lean1980Phosphorus.I. MorrisThe physiological ecology of phytoplankton235258
- 12. Spijkerman E (2008) What physiological acclimation supports increased growth at high CO2 conditions? Physiol Plant 133: 41–48.E. Spijkerman2008What physiological acclimation supports increased growth at high CO2 conditions?Physiol Plant1334148
- 13. van Hunnik E, Amoroso G, Sultemeyer D (2002) Uptake of CO2 and bicarbonate by intact cells and chloroplasts of Tetraedron minimum and Chlamydomonas noctigama. Planta 215: 763–769.E. van HunnikG. AmorosoD. Sultemeyer2002Uptake of CO2 and bicarbonate by intact cells and chloroplasts of Tetraedron minimum and Chlamydomonas noctigama.Planta215763769
- 14. Rost B, Riebesell U, Burkhardt S, Sultemeyer D (2003) Carbon acquisition of bloom-forming marine phytoplankton. Limnol Oceanogr 48: 55–67.B. RostU. RiebesellS. BurkhardtD. Sultemeyer2003Carbon acquisition of bloom-forming marine phytoplankton.Limnol Oceanogr485567
- 15. Beardall J, Giordano M (2002) Ecological implications of microalgal and cyanobacterial CO2 concentrating mechanisms, and their regulation. Funct Plant Biol 29: 335–347.J. BeardallM. Giordano2002Ecological implications of microalgal and cyanobacterial CO2 concentrating mechanisms, and their regulation.Funct Plant Biol29335347
- 16. Klausmeier CA, Litchman E, Daufresne T, Levin SA (2004) Optimal nitrogen-to-phosphorus stoichiometry of phytoplankton. Nature 429: 171–174.CA KlausmeierE. LitchmanT. DaufresneSA Levin2004Optimal nitrogen-to-phosphorus stoichiometry of phytoplankton.Nature429171174
- 17. Tittel J, Bissinger V, Gaedke U, Kamjunke N (2005) Inorganic carbon limitation and mixotrophic growth in Chlamydomonas from an acidic mining lake. Protist 156: 63–75.J. TittelV. BissingerU. GaedkeN. Kamjunke2005Inorganic carbon limitation and mixotrophic growth in Chlamydomonas from an acidic mining lake.Protist1566375
- 18. Spijkerman E (2008) Phosphorus limitation of algae living in iron-rich, acidic lakes. Aquat Microb Ecol 53: 201–210.E. Spijkerman2008Phosphorus limitation of algae living in iron-rich, acidic lakes.Aquat Microb Ecol53201210
- 19. Ibelings BW, Maberly SC (1998) Photoinhibition and the availability of inorganic carbon restrict photosynthesis by surface blooms of cyanobacteria. Limnol Oceanogr 43: 408–419.BW IbelingsSC Maberly1998Photoinhibition and the availability of inorganic carbon restrict photosynthesis by surface blooms of cyanobacteria.Limnol Oceanogr43408419
- 20. Riebesell U, Wolf-Gladrow DA, Smetacek V (1993) Carbon dioxide limitation of marine phytoplankton growth rates. Nature 361: 249–251.U. RiebesellDA Wolf-GladrowV. Smetacek1993Carbon dioxide limitation of marine phytoplankton growth rates.Nature361249251
- 21. Stumm W, Morgan JJ (1970) Aquatic chemistry: chemical equilibria and rates in natural waters. New York: Wiley-Interscience. 583 p.W. StummJJ Morgan1970Aquatic chemistry: chemical equilibria and rates in natural watersNew YorkWiley-Interscience583
- 22. Buitenhuis ET, Timmermans KR, de Baar HJW (2003) Zinc-bicarbonate colimitation of Emiliania huxleyi. Limnol Oceanogr 48: 1575–1582.ET BuitenhuisKR TimmermansHJW de Baar2003Zinc-bicarbonate colimitation of Emiliania huxleyi.Limnol Oceanogr4815751582
- 23. Raven JA (1980) Nutrient transport in microalgae. Advances in Microbial Physiology 21: 47–226.JA Raven1980Nutrient transport in microalgae.Advances in Microbial Physiology2147226
- 24. Klausmeier CA, Litchman E, Levin SA (2007) A model of flexible uptake of two essential resources. J theor Biol 246: 278–289.CA KlausmeierE. LitchmanSA Levin2007A model of flexible uptake of two essential resources.J theor Biol246278289
- 25. Beardall J, Roberts S, Raven JA (2005) Regulation of inorganic carbon acquisition by phosphorus limitation in the green alga Chlorella emersonii. Can J Bot 83: 859–864.J. BeardallS. RobertsJA Raven2005Regulation of inorganic carbon acquisition by phosphorus limitation in the green alga Chlorella emersonii.Can J Bot83859864
- 26. Raven JA, Giordano M, Beardall J (2008) Insights into the evolution of CCMs from comparisons with other resource acquisition and assimilation processes. Physiol Plant 133: 4–14.JA RavenM. GiordanoJ. Beardall2008Insights into the evolution of CCMs from comparisons with other resource acquisition and assimilation processes.Physiol Plant133414
- 27. Giordano M, Beardall J, Raven JA (2005) CO2 concentrating mechanisms in algae: Mechanisms, environmental modulation, and evolution. Annu Rev Plant Biol 56: 99–131.M. GiordanoJ. BeardallJA Raven2005CO2 concentrating mechanisms in algae: Mechanisms, environmental modulation, and evolution.Annu Rev Plant Biol5699131
- 28. Raven JA (1982) The energetics of freshwater algae: Energy requirements for biosynthesis and volume regulation. New Phytol 92: 1–20.JA Raven1982The energetics of freshwater algae: Energy requirements for biosynthesis and volume regulation.New Phytol92120
- 29. Spijkerman E (2005) Inorganic carbon acquisition by Chlamydomonas acidophila across a pH range. Can J Bot 83: 872–878.E. Spijkerman2005Inorganic carbon acquisition by Chlamydomonas acidophila across a pH range.Can J Bot83872878
- 30. Spijkerman E, Bissinger V, Meister A, Gaedke U (2007) Low potassium and inorganic carbon concentrations influence a possible phosphorus limitation in Chlamydomonas acidophila (Chlorophyceae). Eur J Phycol 42: 327–339.E. SpijkermanV. BissingerA. MeisterU. Gaedke2007Low potassium and inorganic carbon concentrations influence a possible phosphorus limitation in Chlamydomonas acidophila (Chlorophyceae).Eur J Phycol42327339
- 31. Spijkerman E (2007) Phosphorus acquisition by Chlamydomonas acidophila under autotrophic and osmo-mixotrophic growth conditions. J Exp Bot 58: 4195–4202.E. Spijkerman2007Phosphorus acquisition by Chlamydomonas acidophila under autotrophic and osmo-mixotrophic growth conditions.J Exp Bot5841954202
- 32. Nichols HW (1973) Growth media-freshwater. In: Stein JR, editor. Handbook of Phycological Methods: Culture Methods and Growth Measurements. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 7–24.HW Nichols1973Growth media-freshwater.JR SteinHandbook of Phycological Methods: Culture Methods and Growth MeasurementsCambridgeCambridge University Press724
- 33. Murphy J, Riley JP (1962) A modified single solution method for determination of phosphate in natural waters. Anal Chim Acta 26: 31–36.J. MurphyJP Riley1962A modified single solution method for determination of phosphate in natural waters.Anal Chim Acta263136
- 34. Tilman D (1981) Tests of resource competition theory using four species of Lake Michigan algae. Ecology 62: 802–815.D. Tilman1981Tests of resource competition theory using four species of Lake Michigan algae.Ecology62802815
- 35. Grover JP (1989) Phosphorus-dependent growth kinetics of 11 species of freshwater algae. Limnol Oceanogr 34: 341–348.JP Grover1989Phosphorus-dependent growth kinetics of 11 species of freshwater algae.Limnol Oceanogr34341348
- 36. Wilson JB, Spijkerman E, Huisman J (2007) Is there really insufficient support for Tilman's R Concept? A comment on Miller et al. Am Nat 169: 700–706.JB WilsonE. SpijkermanJ. Huisman2007Is there really insufficient support for Tilman's R Concept? A comment on Miller et al.Am Nat169700706
- 37. Rhee G-Y (1980) Continuous culture in phytoplankton ecology. In: Droop MR, Jannasch HW, editors. Advances in aquatic microbiology. London: Academic Press. pp. 151–203.G-Y Rhee1980Continuous culture in phytoplankton ecology.MR DroopHW JannaschAdvances in aquatic microbiologyLondonAcademic Press151203
- 38. Sandwell DT (1987) Biharmonic Spline Interpolation of GEOS-3 and SEASAT Altimeter Data. Geophys Res Letters 14: 139–142.DT Sandwell1987Biharmonic Spline Interpolation of GEOS-3 and SEASAT Altimeter Data.Geophys Res Letters14139142
- 39. Spijkerman E (2010) High photosynthetic rates under a colimitation for inorganic phosphorus and carbon dioxide. J Phycol 46: 658–664.E. Spijkerman2010High photosynthetic rates under a colimitation for inorganic phosphorus and carbon dioxide.J Phycol46658664
- 40. Bolker , M B (2008) Ecological Models and Data in R. Princeton University Press. BolkerB. M2008Ecological Models and Data in RPrinceton University Press
- 41. Turpin DH (1988) Physiological mechanisms in phytoplankton resource competition. In: Sandgren CD, editor. Growth and Reproductive Strategies of Freshwater Phytoplankton. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 316–368.DH Turpin1988Physiological mechanisms in phytoplankton resource competition.CD SandgrenGrowth and Reproductive Strategies of Freshwater PhytoplanktonCambridgeCambridge University Press316368
- 42. Spijkerman E, Wacker A (2011) Interactions between P-limitation and different C conditions on the fatty acid composition of an extremophile microalga. Extremophiles 15: 597–609.E. SpijkermanA. Wacker2011Interactions between P-limitation and different C conditions on the fatty acid composition of an extremophile microalga.Extremophiles15597609
- 43. Vance P, Spalding MH (2005) Growth, photosynthesis, and gene expression in Chlamydomonas over a range of CO2 concentrations and CO2/O2 ratios: CO2 regulates multiple acclimation states. Can J Bot 83: 796–809.P. VanceMH Spalding2005Growth, photosynthesis, and gene expression in Chlamydomonas over a range of CO2 concentrations and CO2/O2 ratios: CO2 regulates multiple acclimation states.Can J Bot83796809
- 44. Schrader PS, Milligan AJ, Behrenfeld MJ (2011) Surplus photosynthetic antennae complexes underlie diagnostics of iron limitation in a cyanobacterium. Plos One 6: e18753.PS SchraderAJ MilliganMJ Behrenfeld2011Surplus photosynthetic antennae complexes underlie diagnostics of iron limitation in a cyanobacterium.Plos One6e18753
- 45. Wolf-Gladrow D, Riebesell U (1997) Diffusion and reactions in the vicinity of plankton: A refined model for inorganic carbon transport. Mar Chem 59: 17–34.D. Wolf-GladrowU. Riebesell1997Diffusion and reactions in the vicinity of plankton: A refined model for inorganic carbon transport.Mar Chem591734
- 46. Clegg MR, Maberly SC, Jones RI (2004) Chemosensory behavioural response of freshwater phytoplanktonic flagellates. Plant Cell Environ 27: 123–135.MR CleggSC MaberlyRI Jones2004Chemosensory behavioural response of freshwater phytoplanktonic flagellates.Plant Cell Environ27123135
- 47. Spijkerman E, Coesel PFM (1997) Growth kinetic parameters of two planktonic desmid species under fluctuating phosphorus conditions in continuous-flow culture. J Plankton Res 19: 1899–1912.E. SpijkermanPFM Coesel1997Growth kinetic parameters of two planktonic desmid species under fluctuating phosphorus conditions in continuous-flow culture.J Plankton Res1918991912
- 48. Spijkerman E, Coesel PFM (1998) Alkaline phosphatase activity in two planktonic desmid species and the possible role of an extracellular envelope. Freshwater Biol 39: 503–513.E. SpijkermanPFM Coesel1998Alkaline phosphatase activity in two planktonic desmid species and the possible role of an extracellular envelope.Freshwater Biol39503513
- 49. Raven JA, Cockell CS, La Rocha CL (2008) The evolution of inorganic carbon concentrating mechanisms in photosynthesis. Philos Trans R Soc B 363: 2641–2650.JA RavenCS CockellCL La Rocha2008The evolution of inorganic carbon concentrating mechanisms in photosynthesis.Philos Trans R Soc B36326412650
- 50. Spijkerman E (2011) The expression of a carbon concentrating mechanism in Chlamydomonas acidophila under variable phosphorus, iron, and CO2 concentrations. Photosynth Res 109: 179–189.E. Spijkerman2011The expression of a carbon concentrating mechanism in Chlamydomonas acidophila under variable phosphorus, iron, and CO2 concentrations.Photosynth Res109179189
- 51. Kozlowska-Szerenos B, Bialuk I, Maleszewski S (2004) Enhancement of photosynthetic O2 evolution in Chlorella vulgaris under high light and increased CO2 concentration as a sign of acclimation to phosphate deficiency. Plant Physiol Bioch 42: 403–409.B. Kozlowska-SzerenosI. BialukS. Maleszewski2004Enhancement of photosynthetic O2 evolution in Chlorella vulgaris under high light and increased CO2 concentration as a sign of acclimation to phosphate deficiency.Plant Physiol Bioch42403409
- 52. Dietrich P, Dreyer I, Wiesner P, Hedrich R (1998) Cation sensitivity and kinetics of guard-cell potassium channels differ among species. Planta 205: 277–287.P. DietrichI. DreyerP. WiesnerR. Hedrich1998Cation sensitivity and kinetics of guard-cell potassium channels differ among species.Planta205277287
- 53. Franks PJ, Beerling DJ (2009) Maximum leaf conductance driven by CO2 effects on stomatal size and density over geologic time. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106: 10343–10347.PJ FranksDJ Beerling2009Maximum leaf conductance driven by CO2 effects on stomatal size and density over geologic time.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA1061034310347
- 54. Gerhart LM, Ward JK (2010) Plant responses to low [CO2] of the past. New Phytol 188: 674–695.LM GerhartJK Ward2010Plant responses to low [CO2] of the past.New Phytol188674695
- 55. Kooijman SALM (1998) The Synthesizing Unit as model for the stoichiometric fusion and branching of metabolic fluxes. Biophys Chem 73: 179–188.SALM Kooijman1998The Synthesizing Unit as model for the stoichiometric fusion and branching of metabolic fluxes.Biophys Chem73179188
- 56. Kilham SS, Kott CL, Tilman D (1977) Phosphate and silicate kinetics for the Lake Michigan diatom Diatoma elongatum. J Great Lakes Res 31: 93–99.SS KilhamCL KottD. Tilman1977Phosphate and silicate kinetics for the Lake Michigan diatom Diatoma elongatum.J Great Lakes Res319399
- 57. Clark DR, Flynn KJ (2000) The relationship between the dissolved inorganic carbon concentration and growth rate in marine phytoplankton. Proc R Soc B-Biol Sci 267: 953–959.DR ClarkKJ Flynn2000The relationship between the dissolved inorganic carbon concentration and growth rate in marine phytoplankton.Proc R Soc B-Biol Sci267953959
- 58. Beardall J, Roberts S, Millhouse J (1991) Effects of nitrogen limitation on uptake of inorganic carbon and specific activity of Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase in green microalgae. Can J Bot 69: 1146–1150.J. BeardallS. RobertsJ. Millhouse1991Effects of nitrogen limitation on uptake of inorganic carbon and specific activity of Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase in green microalgae.Can J Bot6911461150
- 59. Giordano M (2001) Interactions between C and N metabolism in Dunaliella salina cells cultured at elevated CO2 and high N concentrations. J Plant Physiol 158: 577–581.M. Giordano2001Interactions between C and N metabolism in Dunaliella salina cells cultured at elevated CO2 and high N concentrations.J Plant Physiol158577581
- 60. O'Neill RV, DeAngelis DL, Pastor JJ, Jackson BJ, Post WM (1989) Multiple nutrient limitations in ecological models. Ecol Modelling 46: 147–163.RV O'NeillDL DeAngelisJJ PastorBJ JacksonWM Post1989Multiple nutrient limitations in ecological models.Ecol Modelling46147163
- 61. Medveczky N, Rosenberg H (1971) Phosphate transport in Escherichia coli. Biochim Biophys Acta 241: 494–506.N. MedveczkyH. Rosenberg1971Phosphate transport in Escherichia coli.Biochim Biophys Acta241494506
- 62. Spijkerman E, Coesel PFM (1996) Phosphorus uptake and growth kinetics of two planktonic desmid species. Eur J Phycol 31: 53–60.E. SpijkermanPFM Coesel1996Phosphorus uptake and growth kinetics of two planktonic desmid species.Eur J Phycol315360