DNA barcoding will revolutionize our understanding of fern ecology, most especially because the accurate identification of the independent but cryptic gametophyte phase of the fern's life history—an endeavor previously impossible—will finally be feasible. In this study, we assess the discriminatory power of the core plant DNA barcode (rbcL and matK), as well as alternatively proposed fern barcodes (trnH-psbA and trnL-F), across all major fern lineages. We also present plastid barcode data for two genera in the hyperdiverse polypod clade—Deparia (Woodsiaceae) and the Cheilanthes marginata group (currently being segregated as a new genus of Pteridaceae)—to further evaluate the resolving power of these loci.
Our results clearly demonstrate the value of matK data, previously unavailable in ferns because of difficulties in amplification due to a major rearrangement of the plastid genome. With its high sequence variation, matK complements rbcL to provide a two-locus barcode with strong resolving power. With sequence variation comparable to matK, trnL-F appears to be a suitable alternative barcode region in ferns, and perhaps should be added to the core barcode region if universal primer development for matK fails. In contrast, trnH-psbA shows dramatically reduced sequence variation for the majority of ferns. This is likely due to the translocation of this segment of the plastid genome into the inverted repeat regions, which are known to have a highly constrained substitution rate.
Citation: Li F-W, Kuo L-Y, Rothfels CJ, Ebihara A, Chiou W-L, Windham MD, et al. (2011) rbcL and matK Earn Two Thumbs Up as the Core DNA Barcode for Ferns. PLoS ONE 6(10): e26597. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0026597
Editor: Sergios-Orestis Kolokotronis, Barnard College, Columbia University, United States of America
Received: June 3, 2011; Accepted: September 29, 2011; Published: October 20, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Li et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: A National Science Foundation (www.nsf.gov) grant #DEB-0717398 to KMP and MDW (co-authors). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
In all land plants—from bryophytes to angiosperms—the typical sexual life cycle involves the alternation of a diploid sporophyte phase with a haploid gametophyte phase. Ferns and lycophytes are unique among land plants in that both sporophyte and gametophyte are not only visible to the unaided eye, but they are completely independent from one another . Although diminutive and inconspicuous, fern gametophytes are key players in fern ecology and biogeography: many are thought to have wider geographic distributions than their sporophytic counterparts –, some can exist indefinitely without producing sporophytes , , and others may be involved in hybridization events far outside the range of the parental sporophyte . However, because the morphology of fern gametophytes is so reduced, it has been very difficult to confidently assign gametophytes to species, or, frequently, even to particular genera. As a result, ecological studies of gametophytes have largely been restricted to temperate regions where relatively few species exist , or to well-studied biological field stations in the tropics .
DNA barcoding offers a possible solution to this problem and could greatly improve our understanding of fern gametophytes and their biology. Recently, unknown fern gametophytes were shown to be identifiable, often to species level, by using plastid DNA sequences , , , suggesting that this DNA-based identification tool has the potential to be applied to large-scale ecological surveys . The DNA barcoding approach has also been useful in distinguishing among fern species in the horticultural trade  and in Chinese herbal medicine , , two areas where species names are frequently confused. Despite these promising applications, ferns, with their critical phylogenetic position as sister to seed plants, have largely been neglected in choosing the standardized barcode for all land plants , .
Recently, the Consortium for the Barcode of Life (CBOL) approved two plastid loci, rbcL and matK, as the official DNA barcode for all land plants , , while urging further data collection on trnH-psbA to assess its potential to be added to the land plant barcode. CBOL's pronouncement posed a serious challenge for fern systematists and ecologists because matK had been recovered from only one fern species in the previous loci evaluation studies –. Because of the difficulties involved in obtaining matK data for ferns, Ebihara et al.  and de Groot et al.  proposed trnH-psbA and trnL-F, respectively, as possible substitutes.
In most plants, matK is nested within a trnK intron in the large single copy region of the plastid genome and can be amplified using primers targeting the flanking trnK exons , ; as these full-length matK sequences accumulate, further primer development for matK coding region should be relatively easy. In most ferns, however, the flanking trnK exons are absent –, and the amplification of full-length matK is very difficult, thereby hindering primer development. Only recently has novel primer design helped to overcome this obstacle, with matK sequences now available for representatives from all fern families (sensu ) . The primary aim of our study is to provide a broad overview of sequence variation across fern lineages for the core DNA barcode (rbcL and matK), as well as for the two alternatively proposed barcode regions (trnH-psbA and trnL-F). We then focus particular attention on two genera within the hyperdiverse polypod clade—Deparia (Woodsiaceae) and the Cheilanthes marginata group (a group of 17 species currently being segregated as a new genus of Pteridaceae; F.W. Li et al., unpublished). These case studies provide more detailed information regarding the resolving power of all four loci for species level identifications.
Of the four plastid loci examined in the large-scale comparisons, trnL-F is the most variable across ferns, followed by matK, trnH-psbA, and then rbcL (Fig. 1; p<0.0001 for each comparison in Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed-rank tests, after Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons). In contrast to its high levels of variation in most other plant lineages, trnH-psbA shows a markedly reduced variability in ferns (Table 1), such that 99.1% of the species pairs tested show lower divergence at trnH-psbA compared to matK (Fig. 1B), and only 5.6% are more than twice as variable as rbcL (Fig. 1C). This reduced variation in trnH-psbA is most pronounced in the recent-diverging fern lineages Cyatheales and Polypodiales (Fig. 1B–C, 1F), which together account for almost 90% of fern diversity .
The x and y axes depict the p-distances calculated for each species pair within each fern order (Psilotales and Ophioglossales are combined here into class Psilotopsida). All loci comparisons are presented as y-axis vs x-axis: (A) matK vs rbcL, (B) matK vs trnH-psbA, (C) rbcL vs trnH-psbA, (D) matK vs trnL-F, (E) rbcL vs trnL-F, (F) trnL-F vs trnH-psbA. The lines in each panel (labeled with the ratios 1∶1, 1∶2, 1∶4, 4∶1 or 2∶1) are not regression lines, but are drawn to guide the eye in interpreting the results. (G) Phylogenetic relationships among fern orders, taxonomic symbols, and number of species compared per order for each locus (matK, rbcL, trnH-psbA, trnL-F, respectively). The arrow on the phylogenetic topology points to the branch where the trnH-psbA region of the plastid genome is predicted to have been translocated to the inverted repeat region . The arrowheads point to the locations of trnH-psbA in the plastid genome.
Pairwise sequence divergence within the focal polypod genus Deparia is mostly comparable to the large-scale trends observed across all ferns (cf. Fig. 1A–B with Fig. 2A–B, and Fig. 1D–F with Fig. 2D–F), although trnH-psbA is even more conservative (cf. Fig. 1C, 1F with Fig. 2C, 2F) (Table 1). Although we do not have trnL-F data for the Cheilanthes marginata group, it shows the same general trends observed in Deparia for matK, rbcL and trnH-psbA (Fig. 2A–C). The average sequence divergence for trnH-psbA is lower than for all other loci tested (Table 1), and 83.2% and 58.5% of the species pairs in the C. marginata group and Deparia, respectively, exhibit a trnH-psbA divergence that is lower than for rbcL (Fig. 2C).
The x and y axes depict the interspecific pairwise p-distances; the C. marginata group data points are represented by blue circles and Deparia by red diamonds. Note that trnL-F data were not available for the C. marginata group, hence they are not shown in panels D, E, F. All loci comparisons are presented as y-axis vs x-axis: (A) matK vs rbcL, (B) matK vs trnH-psbA, (C) rbcL vs trnH-psbA, (D) matK vs trnL-F, (E) rbcL vs trnL-F, (F) trnL-F vs trnH-psbA. The lines in each panel (labeled with the ratios 1∶1, 1∶4, 4∶1 or 2∶1) are not regression lines, but are drawn to guide the eye in interpreting the results.
Finally, we examined the discriminating power for each locus and locus combination within the C. marginata group and within Deparia. Table 2 shows that among the single-locus barcodes, matK has the highest success rate in species discrimination and trnH-psbA the lowest. More importantly, when considering each locus and all combinations of loci, the highest success rate is provided by matK+rbcL, the official core DNA barcode , , , while including additional trnH-psbA did not increase the rate (Table 2).
Toward A Consensus Barcode For Ferns
Two proposals regarding a global DNA barcode for all land plants were recently formulated and presented to CBOL , . One consisted of rbcL and matK while the other included rbcL, matK and trnH-psbA. CBOL officially approved the rbcL+matK combination, and encouraged more data collection on trnH-psbA to assess its potential as a backup barcoding locus . Because matK had been previously thought to be unattainable in ferns, two non-coding loci, trnH-psbA and trnL-F, were independently proposed as alternative barcoding loci , .
In this study, we provide the first thorough evaluation of the official CBOL land plant barcode (matK and rbcL) and the two alternative (trnH-psbA and trnL-F) loci for ferns. Our results build on the recent demonstration that matK is attainable in ferns , and shows that its variability is consistently high across fern lineages. Even within the species complexes represented by our two focal polypod genera, matK and rbcL together provide the highest discriminating power, supporting their use as the official core DNA barcode. It should be noted that our matK and rbcL sequences are longer than the barcode regions specified by CBOL ; however, we do not believe this affects our conclusions. Although universal matK primers remain elusive in ferns, we believe primer development will be considerably improved as more sequences become available. Therefore, it would be biased at this stage to examine and compare PCR amplification rate and sequence quality against other loci. However, if attempts to design universal matK primers eventually fail, our results suggest that trnL-F would be a good alternative locus since variation within trnL-F across ferns is comparable to that observed in matK.
On the other hand, we find trnH-psbA to be an unsuitable barcode for the majority of ferns, despite its obvious utility in seed plants , –, mosses , and the early-diverging fern order, Hymenophyllales  (Table 1). Our results indicate that the nucleotide substitution rate for trnH-psbA is greatly reduced, especially in two recent-diverging lineages (Cyatheales and Polypodiales) that together comprise nearly 90% of fern diversity. This reduced variation in the recent-diverging ferns was also reported by Ebihara et al. , but it was not considered likely to be a major drawback for barcoding. However, data from our two focal polypod genera reveal that the ability of trnH-psbA to discriminate species is the lowest among the loci we tested. Considering the limited usefulness of trnH-psbA in ferns, we recommend adoption of the official CBOL land plant barcode (rbcL+matK) for future fern studies.
An Unexpected Substitution Rate Reduction in trnH-psbA in Ferns
Our data provide evidence of an abrupt reduction in trnH-psbA sequence variation within ferns (Figure 1B–C, 1F, 2B–C, 2F; Table 1). This apparent deceleration in substitution rate seems to occur on the same branch of the fern phylogeny where the translocation of trnH-psbA into the inverted repeat (IR) region of the plastid genome is predicted to have occurred : on the branch leading to Schizaeales, Salviniales, Cyatheales and Polypodiales (Fig. 1G, arrow). The IR region comprises two identical copies of the plastid genome that are separated by the large- and small-single copy regions (the LSR and SSR, respectively), and nucleotide substitution rates in the IR region have been shown to be dramatically slower than in either the LSR or SSR –.
Lower substitution rates in the IR region (relative to the rest of the plastid genome) were originally attributed to the predominance of conservative rRNA genes in this region ; however, it has since been shown that rates are ubiquitously slow in the IR region regardless of rRNA content . Two additional hypotheses have been put forth to address this rate disparity—a reduced mutation rate in the IR region, or biased gene conversion between the repeats that tend to correct mutations back to the wild-type states . Invoking a reduced mutation rate may be unnecessary since it can be caused by biased gene conversion and it has been theoretically determined that a slight conversion bias could explain a reduced substitution rate . An empirical study on legumes demonstrated support for this idea, showing that genes that were typically located in the IR region showed an accelerated substitution rate when the IR structure disappeared . Our results from fern trnH-psbA provide further evidence, but from the opposite perspective—there is an apparent deceleration in substitution rate when genes are translocated into the IR region. Future statistical analyses, as well as an investigation of ycf2, another gene that was co-translocated with trnH-psbA into the IR region , should better characterize the dynamics of plastid genome evolution in ferns. It is nevertheless evident that because of its low substitution rate in the majority of ferns, trnH-psbA is not a suitable DNA barcode region for the fern lineage as a whole.
Low Discriminating Power Within Species Complexes
Because the current DNA barcoding approach in plants relies solely on plastid loci that are mostly uniparentally inherited, it is expected that barcoding will not work well within species complexes where hybridization and polyploidy are frequent , , , . Of our two genus case studies, the Cheilanthes marginata group provides a clear illustration of the problem. In addition to a series of diploid species that are easily distinguished by the official rbcL+matK barcode, the C. marginata group includes two species complexes, each composed of four morphological species that are polyploids of unknown origin (F.W. Li et al., unpublished) . DNA barcoding only discriminates one species in the C. angustifolia complex, and none in the C. marginata complex (Supporting Information Table S1), thus recognizing less than half of the species-level biodiversity predicted on the basis of morphology. A comparable lack of discriminating power was also reported within species complexes in barcoding studies of Japanese  and northwestern European ferns .
One might argue that incorporating a nuclear locus (e.g., the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region) could better solve the species complex problem. However, we are hesitant to recommend the use of nuclear loci in ferns (where polyploidy is frequent), because cloning is usually required, not only to obtain clear sequencing results but also to acquire all possible copies. In addition, although ITS has been shown to have high discriminating power in certain plants and animals , , these results needs to be interpreted with caution in ferns, where most of the ITS sequences reported for ferns to date – are nearly identical to ITS sequences reported for angiosperms (e.g., Asteraceae, Apiaceae or Fabaceae based on BLAST searches in April 2011). It should be noted that disentangling species complexes, which requires extensive genetic and chromosomal analyses, is beyond the expected goals of DNA barcoding. As shown here, the official CBOL land plant barcode allows the identification of most species derived through divergent evolution (as opposed to recent reticulate evolution), and such resolution should be sufficient for most applications .
By incorporating both large-scale analyses and genus-level case studies, our study represents the first thorough evaluation of the official CBOL land plant barcode (matK and rbcL), as well as of two alternative barcode loci (trnH-psbA and trnL-F), for ferns. Our results provide a strong endorsement of the two-locus barcode (rbcL+matK) in ferns, and favor trnL-F over trnH-psbA as a potential back-up locus. The dramatically reduced variation observed in trnH-psbA is likely due to its translocation into the IR region of the plastid genome. Future work should focus on gathering more matK sequences for improved primer development, as well as examining PCR amplification and sequencing quality.
Materials and Methods
To assess the discriminatory power of potential DNA barcoding loci at a broad scale, we assembled sequences of rbcL, matK and trnH-psbA from 74 fern species, including representatives from each of the 37 families (sensu ), and trnL-F sequences from 32 species representing 19 families (Supporting Information Table S2 and Table S4). More intensive inter- and intra-specific sampling was done within two focal polypod genera: Deparia and the Cheilanthes marginata group. In a recent phylogenetic analysis of the cheilanthoid ferns (M.D. Windham et al., unpublished), the C. marginata group was shown to be strongly monophyletic and only distantly related to the type species of Cheilanthes (C. micropteris Swartz). Taxonomic treatment of this group as a new genus is forthcoming (F.W. Li et al., unpublished). This new genus comprises 17 species, all of which were included in this study. Fifteen of the 17 species were represented by multiple individuals, giving a total sample size of 58 for the C. marginata group (Supporting Information Table S2). The two species that lack intra-specific sampling are known only from the type specimen or a single non-type collection (see Supporting Information Table S2) . All members of the C. marginata group were sequenced for matK, rbcL and trnH-psbA. The genus Deparia comprises approximately 50 species currently assigned to the Woodsiaceae in the eupolypod II lineage , , , and 28 of these were sampled for this study. Three Deparia species included intra-specific sampling (42 individuals in total; Supporting Information Table S2 and Table S4), and two varieties were treated as distinct species for the species discrimination tests (Table 2). Four loci, matK, rbcL, trnH-psbA, and trnL-F were sequenced in Deparia. Voucher information for all taxa included in this study are provided in the Supporting Information Table S2 and Table S4, along with their GenBank sequence accessions.
DNA Extraction, Amplification and Sequencing
For the Cheilanthes marginata group, genomic DNA was extracted using QIAGEN DNeasy Plant Mini Kits following published protocols . DNA extractions in Deparia were done using a modified CTAB procedure . All primers and PCR conditions used in this study are reported in Supporting Information Table S3. For the large-scale locus comparisons, 17 taxa were newly sequenced for trnH-psbA using “trnH2” and “psbAF” primers  or specially designed universal primers. In the C. marginata group, trnH-psbA amplification and sequencing were mostly done using “trnH2” and “psbAF” ; in Deparia newly designed universal primers were used. For matK, specific primers were designed separately for the two focal genera. Amplification and sequencing of rbcL for the C. marginata group used published primers , and for Deparia used “F1F”  and “1379R” . trnL-F was amplified and sequenced using “f”  and “FernLr1”. For some of the older herbarium-derived samples in the C. marginata group, smaller overlapping fragments of matK and rbcL were amplified and sequenced using newly designed primers, and the final sequences assembled from contigs.
Sequence Alignment And Barcoding Utility Assessment
For the large-scale comparison, we calculated species pairwise sequence divergence values within each fern order  to minimize alignment ambiguities: Equisetales, Marattiales, Ophioglossales+Psilotales, Osmundales, Hymenophyllales, Gleicheniales, Schizaeales, Salviniales, Cyatheales, and Polypodiales. Psilotum nudum was our sole representative of Psilotales, and hence was compared with Ophioglossales, which belongs to the same class (Psilotopsida). Sequences in each order were separately aligned, manually for rbcL and matK and using SATé 1.2  or ClustalW  (followed by manual adjustments) for trnH-psbA and trnL-F. In SATé, MAFFT  was used as the “Aligner”, OPAL  as the “Merger”, and RAxML  with GTRGAMMAI as the tree estimator, and other parameters followed the default settings. When there were less than four sequences to be aligned, SATé was not applicable, and ClustalW was used instead (with the default settings). Alignments within the two focal genera were straightforward and done manually.
PAUP* v4.0a114  was used to calculate pairwise sequence divergence (uncorrected p-distance). Substitutions in sites with gaps and/or missing data were distributed proportionally to unambiguous changes in PAUP*. For comparing sequence variation of different loci, Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed-rank tests were carried out using an online calculator (http://www.fon.hum.uva.nl/Service/Statistics/Signed_Rank_Test.html). To assess the discrimination power of each DNA region, we examined the ability of each locus and locus combination to uniquely discriminate a species from all others. The success rate of species discrimination is the percentage of species that could be distinguished among all possible species pairs. A pair of species was scored as successfully distinguished if the interspecific distance was always greater than zero and greater than the intraspecific distance. A Perl script was written to calculate the discrimination success rate from the PAUP* output (available upon request).
List of species in the Cheilanthes marginata group that cannot be uniquely discriminated by the core DNA barcode.
List of the taxa, samples, and GenBank accession used in this study, with separate sub-tables for the large-scale, Cheilanthes marginata group, and Deparia datasets.
List of the primers and PCR conditions used in this study.
We thank Dr. Chun-Neng Wang for his initial support on the fern matK project. We are grateful for the kind help and permission to sample herbarium specimens from the curators and staff of NY, TEX/LL, CAS and MO; for valuable comments from Dr. Layne Huiet, Erin Sigel, Amanda Grusz, and two anonymous reviewers; to Joel Nitta for sharing some unpublished information; and to Dr. George Yatskievych for supporting FWL's presentation of these results at the International Botanical Congress 2011.
Conceived and designed the experiments: FWL LYK MDW KMP. Performed the experiments: FWL LYK. Analyzed the data: FWL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: FWL LYK CJR AE WLC MDW KMP. Wrote the paper: FWL MDW KMP.
- 1. Pryer KM, Schuettpelz E, Wolf PG, Schneider H, Smith AR, et al. (2004) Phylogeny and evolution of ferns (monilophytes) with a focus on the early leptosporangiate divergences. Am J Bot 91: 1582–1598.KM PryerE. SchuettpelzPG WolfH. SchneiderAR Smith2004Phylogeny and evolution of ferns (monilophytes) with a focus on the early leptosporangiate divergences.Am J Bot9115821598
- 2. Ebihara A, Farrar DR, Ito M (2008) The sporophyte-less filmy fern of Eastern North America Trichomanes Intricatum (Hymenophyllaceae) has the chloroplast genome of an Asian species. Am J Bot 95: 1645–1651.A. EbiharaDR FarrarM. Ito2008The sporophyte-less filmy fern of Eastern North America Trichomanes Intricatum (Hymenophyllaceae) has the chloroplast genome of an Asian species.Am J Bot9516451651
- 3. Dassler CL, Farrar DR (2001) Significance of gametophyte form in long-distance colonization by tropical, epiphytic ferns. Brittonia 53: 352–369.CL DasslerDR Farrar2001Significance of gametophyte form in long-distance colonization by tropical, epiphytic ferns.Brittonia53352369
- 4. Rumsey FJ, Jermy AC, Sheffield E (1998) The independent gametophytic stage of Trichomanes speciosum Willd. (Hymenophyllaceae), the Killarney Fern and its distribution in the British Isles. Watsonia 22: 1–19.FJ RumseyAC JermyE. Sheffield1998The independent gametophytic stage of Trichomanes speciosum Willd. (Hymenophyllaceae), the Killarney Fern and its distribution in the British Isles.Watsonia22119
- 5. Li FW, Tan BC, Buchbender V, Moran RC, Rouhan G, et al. (2009) Identifying a mysterious aquatic fern gametophyte. Pl Syst Evol 281: 77–86.FW LiBC TanV. BuchbenderRC MoranG. Rouhan2009Identifying a mysterious aquatic fern gametophyte.Pl Syst Evol2817786
- 6. Farrar DR (1967) Gametophytes of four tropical fern genera reproducing independently of their sporophytes in the southern appalachians. Science 155: 1266–1267.DR Farrar1967Gametophytes of four tropical fern genera reproducing independently of their sporophytes in the southern appalachians.Science15512661267
- 7. Ebihara A, Matsumoto S, Ito M (2009) Hybridization involving independent gametophytes in the Vandenboschia radicans complex (Hymenophyllaceae): a new perspective on the distribution of fern hybrids. Mol Ecol 18: 4904–4911.A. EbiharaS. MatsumotoM. Ito2009Hybridization involving independent gametophytes in the Vandenboschia radicans complex (Hymenophyllaceae): a new perspective on the distribution of fern hybrids.Mol Ecol1849044911
- 8. Gureyeva II (2003) Demographic studies of homosporous fern populations in south Siberia. In: Chandra S, Srivastava M, editors. Pteridology in the new millennium. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers. pp. 341–364.II Gureyeva2003Demographic studies of homosporous fern populations in south Siberia.S. ChandraM. SrivastavaPteridology in the new millenniumDordrechtKluwer Academic Publishers341364
- 9. Watkins JE, Mack MK, Mulkey SS (2007) Gametophyte ecology and demography of epiphytic and terrestrial tropical ferns. Am J Bot 94: 701–708.JE WatkinsMK MackSS Mulkey2007Gametophyte ecology and demography of epiphytic and terrestrial tropical ferns.Am J Bot94701708
- 10. Schneider H, Schuettpelz E (2006) Identifying fern gametophytes using DNA sequences. Mol Ecol Notes 6: 989–991.H. SchneiderE. Schuettpelz2006Identifying fern gametophytes using DNA sequences.Mol Ecol Notes6989991
- 11. de Groot GA, During HJ, Maas JW, Schneider H, Vogel JC, et al. (2011) Use of rbcL and trnL-F as a two-locus DNA barcode for identification of NW-European ferns: an ecological perspective. PLoS ONE 6: e16371.GA de GrootHJ DuringJW MaasH. SchneiderJC Vogel2011Use of rbcL and trnL-F as a two-locus DNA barcode for identification of NW-European ferns: an ecological perspective.PLoS ONE6e16371
- 12. Li FW, Kuo LY, Huang YM, Chiou WL, Wang CN (2010) Tissue-direct PCR, a rapid and extraction-free method for barcoding of ferns. Mol Ecol Resour 10: 92–95.FW LiLY KuoYM HuangWL ChiouCN Wang2010Tissue-direct PCR, a rapid and extraction-free method for barcoding of ferns.Mol Ecol Resour109295
- 13. Pryer KM, Schuettpelz E, Huiet L, Grusz AL, Rothfels CJ, et al. (2010) DNA barcoding exposes a case of mistaken identity in the fern horticultural trade. Mol Ecol Resour 10: 979–985.KM PryerE. SchuettpelzL. HuietAL GruszCJ Rothfels2010DNA barcoding exposes a case of mistaken identity in the fern horticultural trade.Mol Ecol Resour10979985
- 14. Zhao ZL, Leng CH, Wang ZT (2007) Identification of Dryopteris crassirhizoma and the adulterant species based on cpDNA rbcL and translated amino acid sequences. Planta Med 73: 1230–1233.ZL ZhaoCH LengZT Wang2007Identification of Dryopteris crassirhizoma and the adulterant species based on cpDNA rbcL and translated amino acid sequences.Planta Med7312301233
- 15. Ma XY, Xie CX, Liu C, Song JY, Yao H, et al. (2010) Species identification of medicinal pteridophytes by a DNA barcode marker, the chloroplast psbA-trnH intergenic region. Biol Pharm Bull 33: 1919–1924.XY MaCX XieC. LiuJY SongH. Yao2010Species identification of medicinal pteridophytes by a DNA barcode marker, the chloroplast psbA-trnH intergenic region.Biol Pharm Bull3319191924
- 16. Lahaye R, van der Bank M, Bogarin D, Warner J, Pupulin F, et al. (2008) DNA barcoding the floras of biodiversity hotspots. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 105: 2923–2928.R. LahayeM. van der BankD. BogarinJ. WarnerF. Pupulin2008DNA barcoding the floras of biodiversity hotspots.Proc Nat Acad Sci USA10529232928
- 17. Hollingsworth ML, Andra Clark A, Forrest LL, Richardson J, Pennington RT, et al. (2009) Selecting barcoding loci for plants: evaluation of seven candidate loci with species-level sampling in three divergent groups of land plants. Mol Ecol Resour 9: 439–457.ML HollingsworthA. Andra ClarkLL ForrestJ. RichardsonRT Pennington2009Selecting barcoding loci for plants: evaluation of seven candidate loci with species-level sampling in three divergent groups of land plants.Mol Ecol Resour9439457
- 18. CBOL Plant Working Group website. 30: CBOL Plant Working Group website.30Available: http://www.barcoding.si.edu/plant_working_group.html. Accessed 2011 September. Available: http://www.barcoding.si.edu/plant_working_group.html. Accessed 2011 September.
- 19. Hollingsworth PM, Graham SW, Little DP (2011) Choosing and using a plant DNA barcode. PLoS ONE 6: e19254.PM HollingsworthSW GrahamDP Little2011Choosing and using a plant DNA barcode.PLoS ONE6e19254
- 20. Kress WJ, Erickson DL (2007) A two-locus global DNA barcode for land plants: the coding rbcL gene complements the non-coding trnH-psbA spacer region. PLoS ONE 2: e508.WJ KressDL Erickson2007A two-locus global DNA barcode for land plants: the coding rbcL gene complements the non-coding trnH-psbA spacer region.PLoS ONE2e508
- 21. Fazekas AJ, Burgess KS, Kesanakurti PR, Graham SW, Newmaster SG, et al. (2008) Multiple multilocus DNA barcodes from the plastid genome discriminate plant species equally well. PLoS ONE 3: e2802.AJ FazekasKS BurgessPR KesanakurtiSW GrahamSG Newmaster2008Multiple multilocus DNA barcodes from the plastid genome discriminate plant species equally well.PLoS ONE3e2802
- 22. CBOL Plant Working Group (2009) A DNA barcode for land plants. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 106: 12794–12797.CBOL Plant Working Group2009A DNA barcode for land plants.Proc Nat Acad Sci USA1061279412797
- 23. Ebihara A, Nitta JH, Ito M (2010) Molecular species identification with rich floristic sampling: DNA barcoding the pteridophyte flora of Japan. PLoS ONE 5: e15136.A. EbiharaJH NittaM. Ito2010Molecular species identification with rich floristic sampling: DNA barcoding the pteridophyte flora of Japan.PLoS ONE5e15136
- 24. Johnson LA, Soltis DE (1995) Phylogenetic inference in Saxifragaceae sensu stricto and Gilia (Polemoniaceae) using matK sequences. Ann Mo Bot Gard 82: 149–175.LA JohnsonDE Soltis1995Phylogenetic inference in Saxifragaceae sensu stricto and Gilia (Polemoniaceae) using matK sequences.Ann Mo Bot Gard82149175
- 25. Hilu KW, Borsch T, Muller K, Soltis DE, Soltis PS, et al. (2003) Angiosperm phylogeny based on matK sequence information. Am J Bot 90: 1758–1776.KW HiluT. BorschK. MullerDE SoltisPS Soltis2003Angiosperm phylogeny based on matK sequence information.Am J Bot9017581776
- 26. Duffy AM, Kelchner SA, Wolf PG (2009) Conservation of selection on matK following an ancient loss of its flanking intron. Gene 438: 17–25.AM DuffySA KelchnerPG Wolf2009Conservation of selection on matK following an ancient loss of its flanking intron.Gene4381725
- 27. Wolf PG, Rowe CA, Sinclair RB, Hasebe M (2003) Complete nucleotide sequence of the chloroplast genome from a leptosporangiate fern, Adiantum capillus-veneris L. DNA Res 10: 59–65.PG WolfCA RoweRB SinclairM. Hasebe2003Complete nucleotide sequence of the chloroplast genome from a leptosporangiate fern, Adiantum capillus-veneris L. DNA Res105965
- 28. Kuo LY, Li FW, Chiou WL, Wang CN (2011) First insights into fern matK phylogeny. Mol Phylogenet Evol 59: 556–566.LY KuoFW LiWL ChiouCN Wang2011First insights into fern matK phylogeny.Mol Phylogenet Evol59556566
- 29. Smith AR, Pryer KM, Schuettpelz E, Korall P, Schneider H, et al. (2006) A classification for extant ferns. Taxon 55: 705–731.AR SmithKM PryerE. SchuettpelzP. KorallH. Schneider2006A classification for extant ferns.Taxon55705731
- 30. Kress W, Wurdack K, Zimmer E, Weigt L (2005) Use of DNA barcodes to identify flowering plants. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 102: 8369–8374.W. KressK. WurdackE. ZimmerL. Weigt2005Use of DNA barcodes to identify flowering plants.Proc Nat Acad Sci USA10283698374
- 31. Roy S, Tyagi A, Shukla V, Kumar A, Singh UM, et al. (2010) Universal plant DNA barcode loci may not work in complex groups: a case study with Indian berberis species. PLoS ONE 5: e13674.S. RoyA. TyagiV. ShuklaA. KumarUM Singh2010Universal plant DNA barcode loci may not work in complex groups: a case study with Indian berberis species.PLoS ONE5e13674
- 32. Ren B-Q, Xiang X-G, Chen Z-D (2009) Species identification of Alnus (Betulaceae) using nrDNA and cpDNA genetic markers. Mol Ecol Resour 10: 594–605.B-Q RenX-G XiangZ-D Chen2009Species identification of Alnus (Betulaceae) using nrDNA and cpDNA genetic markers.Mol Ecol Resour10594605
- 33. Newmaster SG, Ragupathy S (2009) Testing plant barcoding in a sister species complex of pantropical Acacia (Mimosoideae, Fabaceae). Mol Ecol Resour 9: 172–180.SG NewmasterS. Ragupathy2009Testing plant barcoding in a sister species complex of pantropical Acacia (Mimosoideae, Fabaceae).Mol Ecol Resour9172180
- 34. Newmaster SG, Fazekas AJ, Steeves RAD, Janovec J (2008) Testing candidate plant barcode regions in the Myristicaceae. Mol Ecol Resour 8: 480–490.SG NewmasterAJ FazekasRAD SteevesJ. Janovec2008Testing candidate plant barcode regions in the Myristicaceae.Mol Ecol Resour8480490
- 35. Piredda R, Simeone MC, Attimonelli M, Bellarosa R, Schirone B (2010) Prospects of barcoding the Italian wild dendroflora: oaks reveal severe limitations to tracking species identity. Mol Ecol Resour 11: 72–83.R. PireddaMC SimeoneM. AttimonelliR. BellarosaB. Schirone2010Prospects of barcoding the Italian wild dendroflora: oaks reveal severe limitations to tracking species identity.Mol Ecol Resour117283
- 36. Liu Y, Yan HF, Cao T, Ge XJ (2010) Evaluation of 10 plant barcodes in Bryophyta (Mosses). J Syst Evol 48: 36–46.Y. LiuHF YanT. CaoXJ Ge2010Evaluation of 10 plant barcodes in Bryophyta (Mosses).J Syst Evol483646
- 37. Nitta JH (2008) Exploring the utility of three plastid loci for biocoding the filmy ferns (Hymenophyllaceae) of Moorea. Taxon 57: 725–736.JH Nitta2008Exploring the utility of three plastid loci for biocoding the filmy ferns (Hymenophyllaceae) of Moorea.Taxon57725736
- 38. Wolf PG, Roper JM, Duffy AM (2010) The evolution of chloroplast genome structure in ferns. Genome 53: 731–738.PG WolfJM RoperAM Duffy2010The evolution of chloroplast genome structure in ferns.Genome53731738
- 39. Curtis SE, Clegg MT (1984) Molecular evolution of chloroplast DNA sequences. Mol Biol Evol 1: 291–301.SE CurtisMT Clegg1984Molecular evolution of chloroplast DNA sequences.Mol Biol Evol1291301
- 40. Bowman CM, Bonnard G, Dyer TA (1983) Chloroplast DNA variation between species of Triticum and Aegilops — location of the variation on the chloroplast genome and its relevance to the inheritance and classification of the cytoplasm. Theor Appl Genet 65: 247–262.CM BowmanG. BonnardTA Dyer1983Chloroplast DNA variation between species of Triticum and Aegilops — location of the variation on the chloroplast genome and its relevance to the inheritance and classification of the cytoplasm.Theor Appl Genet65247262
- 41. Palmer JD, Singh GP, Pillay DTN (1983) Structure and sequence evolution of three legume chloroplast DNAs. Mol Gen Genet 190: 13–19.JD PalmerGP SinghDTN Pillay1983Structure and sequence evolution of three legume chloroplast DNAs.Mol Gen Genet1901319
- 42. Wolfe KH, Li WH, Sharp PM (1987) Rates of nucleotide substitution vary greatly among plant mitochondrial, chloroplast, and nuclear DNAs. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 84: 9054–9058.KH WolfeWH LiPM Sharp1987Rates of nucleotide substitution vary greatly among plant mitochondrial, chloroplast, and nuclear DNAs.Proc Nat Acad Sci USA8490549058
- 43. Birky CW, Walsh JB (1992) Biased gene conversion, copy number, and apparent mutation rate differences within chloroplast and bacterial genomes. Genetics 130: 677–683.CW BirkyJB Walsh1992Biased gene conversion, copy number, and apparent mutation rate differences within chloroplast and bacterial genomes.Genetics130677683
- 44. Perry AS, Wolfe KH (2002) Nucleotide substitution rates in legume chloroplast DNA depend on the presence of the inverted repeat. J Mol Evol 55: 501–508.AS PerryKH Wolfe2002Nucleotide substitution rates in legume chloroplast DNA depend on the presence of the inverted repeat.J Mol Evol55501508
- 45. Spooner DM (2009) DNA barcoding will frequently fail in complicated groups: an example in wild potatoes. Am J Bot 96: 1177–1189.DM Spooner2009DNA barcoding will frequently fail in complicated groups: an example in wild potatoes.Am J Bot9611771189
- 46. Fazekas AJ, Kesanakurti PR, Burgess KS, Percy DM, Graham SW, et al. (2009) Are plant species inherently harder to discriminate than animal species using DNA barcoding markers? Mol Ecol Resour 9: Suppl. 1130–139.AJ FazekasPR KesanakurtiKS BurgessDM PercySW Graham2009Are plant species inherently harder to discriminate than animal species using DNA barcoding markers? Mol Ecol Resour 9Suppl. 1130139
- 47. Mickel JT, Smith AR (2004) The pteridophytes of Mexico. Memoir New York Bot Gard 88: 176–213.JT MickelAR Smith2004The pteridophytes of Mexico.Memoir New York Bot Gard88176213
- 48. Yao H, Song JY, Liu C, Luo K, Han JP, et al. (2010) Use of ITS2 region as the universal DNA barcode for plants and animals. PLoS ONE 5: e13102.H. YaoJY SongC. LiuK. LuoJP Han2010Use of ITS2 region as the universal DNA barcode for plants and animals.PLoS ONE5e13102
- 49. Chen S, Yao H, Han J, Liu C, Song J, et al. (2010) Validation of the ITS2 region as a novel DNA barcode for identifying medicinal plant species. PLoS ONE 5: e8613.S. ChenH. YaoJ. HanC. LiuJ. Song2010Validation of the ITS2 region as a novel DNA barcode for identifying medicinal plant species.PLoS ONE5e8613
- 50. Van den Heede CJ, Viane RLL, Chase MW (2003) Phylogenetic analysis of Asplenium subgenus Ceterach (Pteridophyta: Aspleniaceae) based on plastid and nuclear ribosomal ITS DNA sequences. Am J Bot 90: 481–495.CJ Van den HeedeRLL VianeMW Chase2003Phylogenetic analysis of Asplenium subgenus Ceterach (Pteridophyta: Aspleniaceae) based on plastid and nuclear ribosomal ITS DNA sequences.Am J Bot90481495
- 51. Schuettpelz E, Pryer KM (2007) Fern phylogeny inferred from 400 leptosporangiate species and three plastid genes. Taxon 56: 1037–1050.E. SchuettpelzKM Pryer2007Fern phylogeny inferred from 400 leptosporangiate species and three plastid genes.Taxon5610371050
- 52. Rothfels CJ, Larsson A, Kuo LY, Korall P, Chiou WL, et al. CJ RothfelsA. LarssonLY KuoP. KorallWL ChiouIn press. In press.
- 53. Wang CN, Moller M, Cronk QC (2004) Phylogenetic position of Titanotrichum oldhamii (Gesneriaceae) inferred from four different gene regions. Syst Bot 29: 407–418.CN WangM. MollerQC Cronk2004Phylogenetic position of Titanotrichum oldhamii (Gesneriaceae) inferred from four different gene regions.Syst Bot29407418
- 54. Tate JA, Simpson BB (2003) Paraphyly of Tarasa (Malvaceae) and diverse origins of the polyploid species. Syst Bot 28: 723–737.JA TateBB Simpson2003Paraphyly of Tarasa (Malvaceae) and diverse origins of the polyploid species.Syst Bot28723737
- 55. Wolf PG, Soltis PS, Soltis DE (1994) Phylogenetic relationships of dennstaedtioid ferns: evidence from rbcL sequences. Mol Phylogenet Evol 3: 383–392.PG WolfPS SoltisDE Soltis1994Phylogenetic relationships of dennstaedtioid ferns: evidence from rbcL sequences.Mol Phylogenet Evol3383392
- 56. Pryer KM, Smith AR, Hunt JS, Dubuisson JY (2001) rbcL data reveal two monophyletic groups of filmy ferns (Filicopsida: Hymenophyllaceae). Am J Bot 88: 1118–1130.KM PryerAR SmithJS HuntJY Dubuisson2001rbcL data reveal two monophyletic groups of filmy ferns (Filicopsida: Hymenophyllaceae).Am J Bot8811181130
- 57. Taberlet P, Gielly L, Pautou G, Bouvet J (1991) Universal primers for amplification of three noncoding regions of chloroplast DNA. Plant Mol Biol 17: 1105–1109.P. TaberletL. GiellyG. PautouJ. Bouvet1991Universal primers for amplification of three noncoding regions of chloroplast DNA.Plant Mol Biol1711051109
- 58. Liu K, Raghavan S, Nelesen S, Linder CR, Warnow T (2009) Rapid and accurate large-scale coestimation of sequence alignments and phylogenetic trees. Science 324: 1561–1564.K. LiuS. RaghavanS. NelesenCR LinderT. Warnow2009Rapid and accurate large-scale coestimation of sequence alignments and phylogenetic trees.Science32415611564
- 59. Thompson JD, Higgins DG, Gibson TJ (1994) CLUSTAL W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence weighting, position-specific gap penalties and weight matrix choice. Nucleic Acids Res 22: 4673–4680.JD ThompsonDG HigginsTJ Gibson1994CLUSTAL W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence weighting, position-specific gap penalties and weight matrix choice.Nucleic Acids Res2246734680
- 60. Katoh K, Toh H (2008) Recent developments in the MAFFT multiple sequence alignment program. Brief Bioinform 9: 286–298.K. KatohH. Toh2008Recent developments in the MAFFT multiple sequence alignment program.Brief Bioinform9286298
- 61. Wheeler TJ, Kececioglu JD (2007) Multiple alignment by aligning alignments. Bioinformatics 23: i559–568.TJ WheelerJD Kececioglu2007Multiple alignment by aligning alignments.Bioinformatics23i559568
- 62. Stamatakis A (2006) RAxML-VI-HPC: maximum likelihood-based phylogenetic analyses with thousands of taxa and mixed models. Bioinformatics 22: 2688–2690.A. Stamatakis2006RAxML-VI-HPC: maximum likelihood-based phylogenetic analyses with thousands of taxa and mixed models.Bioinformatics2226882690
- 63. Swofford DL (2002) PAUP*. Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and Other Methods). Version 4. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts. DL Swofford2002PAUP*.Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and Other Methods). Version 4. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts