Routine computed tomography (CT) examinations contain an abundance of findings unrelated to the diagnostic question. Those with prognostic significance may contribute to early detection and treatment of disease, irrelevant findings can be ignored. We aimed to assess the association between unrequested chest CT findings in lungs, mediastinum and pleura and future cardiovascular events.
Multi-center case-cohort study in 5 tertiary and 3 secondary care hospitals involving 10410 subjects who underwent routine chest CT for non-cardiovascular reasons. 493 cardiovascular hospitalizations or deaths were recorded during an average follow-up time of 17.8 months. 1191 patients were randomly sampled to serve as a control subcohort. Hazard ratios and annualized event rates were calculated.
Abnormalities in the lung (26–44%), pleura (14–15%) and mediastinum (20%) were common. Hazard ratios after adjustment for age and sex were for airway wall thickening 2.26 (1.59–3.22), ground glass opacities 2.50 (1.72–3.62), consolidations 1.97 (1.12–3.47), pleural effusions 2.77 (1.81–4.25) and lymph-nodes 2.04 (1.40–2.96). Corresponding annual event rates were 5.5%, 6.0%, 3.8%, 10.2% and 4.4%.
We have identified several common chest CT findings that are predictive for future risk of cardiovascular events and found that other findings have little utility for this. The added value of the non-vascular predictors to established vascular calcifications on CT remains to be determined.
Citation: de Jong PA, Gondrie MJA, Buckens CFM, Jacobs PC, Mali WPThM, van der Graaf Y, et al. (2011) Prediction of Cardiovascular Events by Using Non-Vascular Findings on Routine Chest CT. PLoS ONE 6(10): e26036. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0026036
Editor: Ewout W. Steyerberg, University Medical Center Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Received: May 27, 2011; Accepted: September 16, 2011; Published: October 12, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 de Jong et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was funded by a program grant from the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research-Medical Sciences (NWO-MW, www.nwo.nl) grant 40-00812-98-07-005. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The use of diagnostic imaging is increasing rapidly: in the United States of America approximately 62 million computed tomography (CT) examinations  are obtained annually in a population of some 300 million. Chest CT images exhibit an abundance of findings unrelated to the clinical problem which challenge physicians as they often lead to further testing, patient anxiety and unnecessary procedures for findings without relevance. On the other hand unrequested findings also provide an opportunity for early disease detection and prevention of symptoms and mortality , . Therefore, reliable, reproducible and meaningful prognostic models need to be developed for treatable diseases and the impact of such models on patient outcome needs to be evaluated .
We hypothesized that certain findings in the lung, pleura and mediastinum on routine chest CT examinations might contain prognostic information for cardiovascular events. The hypothesis is based on the fact that airway obstruction is consistently found to be independently associated with cardiovascular mortality  and lung diseases are now coming to be seen as a risk factor for cardiovascular mortality , . Several mechanisms including ongoing pulmonary inflammation , , repair mechanisms , misbalances between proteases and anti-proteases  and auto-immune phenomena  that damage the lung also appear to adversely affect the cardiovascular system. The advances and increased use of chest CT make the pulmonary manifestations of these processes increasingly accessible by direct in vivo visualization of the morphological signs  of obstructive pulmonary disease , – and chest inflammation , –.
We believe that for an important subgroup of patients who undergo chest CT the cardiovascular risk is unknown and therefore that a cardiovascular risk calculation based on unrequested chest CT findings may reveal hidden cardiovascular disease. Cardiovascular diseases, despite their high prevalence  and high awareness of risk reduction measures, often manifest suddenly and unexpectedly in a large portion of patients with no prior cardiovascular disease history . Identification of at-risk patients using unrequested findings on otherwise routine chest CT leading to timely diagnosis and concomitant treatment may be relevant as early treatment has potential to reduce risk of future cardiovascular events , .
The aim of this study was to assess the association between unrequested chest CT findings in lungs, mediastinum and pleura and future cardiovascular events in a cohort of routine diagnostic chest CTs performed on adults in the Netherlands.
This study was approved by the ethical review board of the University Medical Center Utrecht (number 06/193), data were analyzed anonymously, informed consent was waived.
The rationale and design of the PROVIDI (PROgnostic Value of unrequested Information in Diagnostic Imaging) study has been described in detail and is presented in Figure 1 . Briefly, we identified 23443 subjects 40 years of age and older who underwent chest CT in eight hospitals. Subjects who had lung cancer or metastasis were excluded (N = 9077) because of the poor prognosis. Patients who were suspected of or whom were known to have the outcome of interest (cardiovascular disease) on the pre-CT referral forms were excluded (N = 2303). Finally, for future external validation studies, 1653 subjects from one centre were excluded. For the present study the cohort consisted therefore of chest CT examinations from 10410 individuals. Cases consisted of those subjects who experienced a cardiovascular event hospitalization or died from cardiovascular disease during follow-up. Cardiovascular diseases included cerebrovascular disease, coronary heart disease, peripheral artery disease, heart failure, aortic aneurysm and non-rheumatic heart disease.
A case-cohort design (Figure 1)  was used to limit the number of CT examinations that had to be scored by the observers, while still enabling absolute risk estimations. The random sample of the cohort (subcohort) included 1285 individuals and 94 (7.3%) of these were excluded because the CT examination could not be retrieved, leaving a subcohort of 1191. The cardiovascular endpoints were recorded during an average follow-up time of 17.8 months. The endpoints were obtained through linkage with the National Death Registry and the National Registry of Hospital Discharge Diagnoses –. In cases with multiple valid endpoints, cause of death prevailed over hospital admissions; otherwise the first hospital discharge diagnosis to occur was used.
Chest CT scoring
All chest CT examinations were obtained using multi-detector CT (2–64 detector rows) of different vendors according to the prevailing routine clinical protocols of the participating hospitals. All CT examinations (all images from all CT data acquisitions) were scored by one of two observers for abnormalities in the mediastinum, lungs and pleura (Table 1) that were considered to be potentially related to inflammation and/or obstructive pulmonary function. For emphysema the scoring system from the National Emphysema Treatment Trial  was used, other pulmonary abnormalities were scored as absent or present in 5 lobes. Abnormalities were defined according to the Fleischner Society criteria . A random set of 150 examinations were scored by both observers independently to evaluate the inter-observer agreement. For bronchiectasis, airway wall thickening, ground glass and pleural effusion score 1 was defined as mild, score 2 as moderate and score 3 and higher as severe disease. For emphysema score 1–3 was defined as mild, score 3–6 as moderate and score 7 and higher as severe disease. For lymph-adenopathy a short axis diameter between 6 and 10-mm was defined as mild and greater than 10-mm as moderate disease. In routine clinical practice lymph nodes <10-mm are seen as normal, but we argued that these small lymph nodes may still be predictive for cardiovascular disease.
Observer agreement was calculated using a weighted Kappa statistic or an intra-class correlation coefficient (icc). Crude and age and sex adjusted hazard ratios for cardiovascular events were estimated by using Cox proportional-hazards regression. Interaction with CT indication and slice thickness was tested for CT findings that were significantly associated with any cardiovascular event. Annualized event rates were calculated for each CT abnormality . Missing values for CT scores (all <4%) were imputed using regression methods in SPSS (SPSS 14.0, Chicago, Illinois).
During follow-up we recorded 559 cases of incident cardiovascular disease, 66 (11.8 %) of these were excluded because the CT examination could not be retrieved. Further details of the subcohort and cases are presented in Table 2.
Lung abnormalities were found to be common with an overall prevalence between 26% and 30% for the various abnormalities in the subcohort. Lymph-nodes >10-mm were seen in 20% whilst pleural abnormalities were less common (14 and 15% for effusion and plaques respectively). There was minimal overlap between these CT findings; it was more common to have either airway wall thickening (42%) or ground glass (36%) than having both (21%). This pattern was similar for the subcohort and the cases and for the other CT findings. Observer agreement was good for pleural effusion (kappa 0.89) and emphysema (icc 0.80), moderate for consolidations (kappa 0.45), lymphadenopathy (kappa 0.54) and plaques (kappa 0.42) and fair for airway wall thickening (kappa 0.33), bronchiectasis (kappa 0.31) and ground glass (kappa 0.38).
Prediction of cardiovascular events
Several CT findings predicted cardiovascular events. Compared to subjects without the given CT abnormality the hazard for any cardiovascular event was significantly increased in patients with airway wall thickening in more than 1 lobe, ground glass in more than 2 lobes, any consolidation, more than a small unilateral pleural effusion and mediastinal lymphadenopathy >10-mm, even when age and sex were taken into account. The strongest adjusted hazard ratio was for moderate pleural effusion (adjusted hazard ratio 2.77). This corresponds to an annual event rate of 10%, while the annual event rate was 2.3% for the group with no effusion.
On the other hand several other CT items were not predictive for cardiovascular events. The hazard ratio's confidence interval for emphysema, bronchiectasis and pleural plaques covered the value of 1.0 corresponding to no increase in hazard compared to the group without the abnormality.
No significant interaction was found between slice thickness and CT indication and the hazards ratios for airway wall thickening, ground glass, consolidation, pleural effusion and lymph-adenopathy. Such interaction was tested in the age and sex adjusted models. The hazard ratios are presented in Table 3 and annualized mortality and age and sex adjusted Kaplan Meier curves are presented in Table 4 and Figure 2.
Group 1 represents abnormality absent, group 2, 3 and 4 represent mild, moderate and severe abnormalities, respectively. These are simulated Kaplan Meier curves for (age and sex adjusted) 60 year old women.
In a cohort of patients who underwent routine chest CT examinations we showed that unrequested findings in the lungs, mediastinum and pleura are common and that airway wall thickening, ground glass opacities, areas of consolidation, pleural effusion and mediastinal lymph nodes predict cardiovascular events. On the other hand emphysema, bronchiectasis and pleural plaques did not predict cardiovascular events.
In the present study we propose a novel strategy which is the reason why it is not possible to calculate incremental value over known cardiovascular risk factors. We will now illustrate our design to explain why calculating incremental value is not possible and conform clinical practice from the perspective of a radiologist. We see the clinical scenario as follows: A patient is submitted for a chest CT. The radiologist, parallel to the diagnostic procedure, calculates the cardiovascular risk based on CT findings, age and sex. In clinical routine the radiologist does not have access to cardiovascular risk factors and these are even unknown for a large proportion of patients referred for chest CT. If based on the CT findings the cardiovascular risk reaches a certain level this is reported to the referring physician, who can next evaluate conventional risk factors (as long as there is no evidence that CT findings can be treated). The patient is subsequently managed and treated based on current guidelines. The patient may benefit from this CT based strategy as cardiovascular death often occur sudden in patients unknown with cardiovascular disease and even patients known with cardiovascular disease can be undertreated.
This type of prediction research based on routine CT imaging findings has gained interest recently –,  and opens a wide field of imaging research with new hypotheses to be tested . The ultimate goal is to determine whether routine CT findings can detect and successfully treat patients at high risk for treatable disease . Currently imaging findings are often summarized in detail in the radiologists' written report while the meaning to referring physicians can be unknown. This potentially leads to unneeded further work-up while on the other hand potentially useful findings are ignored. It would be more meaningful to report only relevant unrequested findings for which the prognostic value is known and incorporate absolute risk estimates in the report, especially for outcomes of which the prognosis can be altered. Pragmatically, these risk estimation should be based on information that is readily available to radiologists such as age, sex, probably some medical information (previous malignancy) and imaging findings. The referring physician can then assess, based on the by the radiologist reported risk, whether this reveals hidden disease or whether the patient was already known with increased cardiovascular risk. Our hypothesis that unrequested findings in the lung, pleura and mediastinum might harbor possible prognostic factors was borne out by the observation that several chest diseases are associated with cardiovascular events. Our study may serve as a starting point for including findings in the lungs, mediastinum and pleura in a comprehensive prognostic model that includes known prognostic cardiovascular disease factors such as coronary calcifications. Although our hypothesis was based on potentially causal associations between abnormalities in the lungs , , –, , –, mediastinum and pleura –, our study cannot establish causality between the morphological findings and future cardiovascular events. Possibly, the significant findings in our study are simply a consequence of (subclinical) heart failure , . Nevertheless we would like to stress that for the predictive purposes of this study, merely the strength of the predictor and the absolute risk that is associated with that predictor are of interest while the underlying mechanisms are of secondary interest.
Our study has limitations. First, we cannot be certain that there was no history of cardiovascular disease or known cardiovascular risk profile amongst our patients, although we minimized this limitation by excluding all CT examinations obtained for a cardiovascular indication. Also cardiovascular events still occur often sudden and unexpected . Because of these 2 arguments, we believe that although misclassification is an issue this does not invalidate the study. Second, the events are registered on a national basis and there may be errors leading to misclassification on the outcome. Given the strength of the CT predictors in our study, some misclassification would not have seriously altered our conclusion. Third, we cannot be certain that our CT findings were truly incidental or unrequested in all subjects.
In conclusion, unrequested imaging findings in the lungs, mediastinum and pleura are common on diagnostic chest CT. Some CT examinations exhibit prognostic information while others do not. Improving understanding of this information can lead to more intelligent imaging, chest CT reporting, prevention of unnecessary further testing and costs for those findings without prognostic relevance and efficient use of prognostic findings to prevent diseases. CT findings in lungs, mediastinum and pleura may facilitate the detection of subjects at risk for cardiovascular events, especially the detection of airway wall thickening in more than 1 lobe, ground glass in more than 2 lobes, any area of consolidation, more than a small unilateral pleural effusion and mediastinal lymphadenopathy >10-mm. Logical further studies would be the development of a prognostic model that includes vascular calcifications and the evaluation of such models regarding impact on patient management and outcome is needed before widespread application.
We acknowledge the help with data collection and administrative support by Cees Haaring (UMCU, Utrecht, The Netherlands), Karin Flobbe (AZM, Maastricht, The Netherlands), Mirjam Borg (VUMC, Amsterdam, The Netherlands), Pascal Verzijl (St Antonius Hospital, Nieuwegein, The Netherlands), Jan Wolfers (AMC, Amsterdam, The Netherlands), Peter van Ooijen (UMCG, Groningen, The Netherlands), Willie Donkers (Elkerliek Hospital, Helmond, The Netherlands), and Robert Dragt (Gelre Hospital, Apeldoorn, The Netherlands).
Members of the PROVIDI study group: Johan Laméris (Dept. of Radiology, Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands), Cees van Kuijk (Dept. of Radiology, VU Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands), Willem ten Hove (Dept. of Radiology, Gelre Hospital, Apeldoorn, The Netherlands), Matthijs Oudkerk (Dept. of Radiology, University Medical Center Groningen, The Netherlands), Ayke L. Oen (Dept. of Radiology, Elkerliek Hospital, Helmond, The Netherlands), Joachim Wildberger (Dept. of Radiology, Academic Hospital Maastricht, Maastricht, The Netherlands), Johannes van Heesewijk (Dept. of Radiology, St Antonius Hospital, Nieuwegein, The Netherlands), Mathias Prokop (Dept. of Radiology, University Medical Center Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands).
Conceived and designed the experiments: PAdJ MJAG CFMB PCJ WPThMM YG PROVIDI Study Group. Performed the experiments: PAdJ MJAG. Analyzed the data: PAdJ MJAG CFMB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MJAG PCJ WPThMM YG PROVIDI Study Group. Wrote the paper: PAdJ MJAG CFMB PCJ WPThMM YG. Approved the final version of the manuscript: PAdJ MJAG CFMB PCJ WPThMM YG PROVIDI Study Group.
- 1. Brenner DJ, Hall EJ (2007) Computed tomography--an increasing source of radiation exposure. N Engl J Med 357(22): 2277–84.
- 2. Lee CI, Forman HP (2010) What we can and cannot see coming. Radiology Nov 257(2): 313–4.
- 3. Gondrie MJ, Mali WP, Jacobs PC, Oen AL, van der Graaf Y, et al. (2010) Cardiovascular disease: prediction with ancillary aortic findings on chest CT scans in routine practice. Radiology Nov 257(2): 549–59.
- 4. Gondrie MJ, Mali WP, Buckens CF, Jacobs PC, Grobbee DE, et al. (2010) The PROgnostic Value of unrequested Information in Diagnostic Imaging (PROVIDI) Study: rationale and design. Eur J Epidemiol Oct; 25(10): 751–8.
- 5. van Eeden SF, Sin DD (2008) Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a chronic systemic inflammatory disease. Respiration 75(2): 224–38.
- 6. McAllister DA, Maclay JD, Mills NL, Mair G, Miller J, et al. (2007) Arterial stiffness is independently associated with emphysema severity in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 176(12): 1208–14.
- 7. Sin DD (2209) Is COPD really a cardiovascular disease? Chest Aug; 136(2): 329–30.
- 8. Macnee W, Maclay J, McAllister D (2008) Cardiovascular injury and repair in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Proc Am Thorac Soc Dec 1; 5(8): 824–33.
- 9. Man SF, Xing L, Connett JE, Anthonisen NR, Wise RA, et al. (2008) Circulating fibronectin to C-reactive protein ratio and mortality: a biomarker in COPD? Eur Respir J Dec; 32(6): 1451–7.
- 10. Lee SH, Goswami S, Grudo A, Song LZ, Bandi V, et al. (2007) Antielastin autoimmunity in tobacco smoking-induced emphysema. Nat Med 13(5): 567–9.
- 11. Jacobs PC, Prokop M, Oen AL, van der Graaf Y, Grobbee DE, et al. (2008) Prevalence of incidental findings in computed tomographic screening of the chest: a systematic review. J Comput Assist Tomogr. 32. (2): pp. p. 214–21.
- 12. Williams FL, Lloyd OL (1989) Cerebrovascular disease in Scotland during 1959 to 1983: its geographical distribution and associations. Community Med Nov; 11(4): 306–15.
- 13. Keistinen T, Säynäjäkangas O, Tuuponen T, Kivelä SL (1997) Bronchiectasis: an orphan disease with a poorly-understood prognosis. Eur Resp J 10: 2784–2787.
- 14. Akalin F, Köroglŭ TF, Bakaç S, Dagli E (2003) Effects of childhood bronchiectasis on cardiac functions. Pediatrics International 45: 169–174.
- 15. Liu SF, Liu JW, Lin MC (2005) Characteristics of patients suffering from tuberculous pleuritis with pleural effusion culture positive and negative for Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and risk factors for fatality. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis Jan; 9(1): 111–5.
- 16. Wells DK, Ward MM (2010) Nephritis and the risk of acute myocardial infarction in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. Clin Exp Rheumatol May-Jun; 28(2): 223–9.
- 17. Badui E, Garcia-Rubi D, Robles E, Jimenez J, Juan L, et al. (1985) Cardiovascular manifestations in systemic lupus erythematosus. Prospective study of 100 patients. Angiology Jul; 36(7): 431–41.
- 18. Vehmas T, Hiltunen A, Kivisaari L, Leino-Arjas P (2008) Atherosclerotic and pleural calcifications are related among asbestos-exposed workers. Eur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil Oct; 15(5): 599–601.
- 19. Mathers CD, Loncar D (2006) Projections of global mortality and burden of disease from 2002 to 2030. PLoS Med 3(11): e442.
- 20. Fox CS, Evans JC, Larson MG, Kannel WB, Levy D (2004) Temporal trends in coronary heart disease mortality and sudden cardiac death from 1950 to 1999: the Framingham Heart Study. Circulation 110(5): 522–7.
- 21. Critchley JA, Capewell S (2003) Mortality risk reduction associated with smoking cessation in patients with coronary heart disease: a systematic review. JAMA 290(1): 86–97.
- 22. LaRosa JC, Grundy SM, Waters DD, Shear C, Barter P, Fruchart JC, et al. (2005) Intensive lipid lowering with atorvastatin in patients with stable coronary disease. N Engl J Med 352(14): 1425–35.
- 23. Pentice RL (1986) A case-cohort design for epidemiologic cohort studies and disease precention trials. Biometrika. 73: 1–11.
- 24. De Bruin A, Kardaun JW, Gast A, Bruin E, van Sijl M, Verweij G (2004) Record linkage of hospital discharge register with population register: experiences at Statistics Netherlands. Stat J UN Econ Comm Eur; 23-32:
- 25. Paas GR, Veenhuizen KC (2002) Research on the validity of the LMR. Utrecht: Prismant.
- 26. ICD9 website. Available: http://icd9cm.chrisendres.com/index.php?action=contents. 2009. Accessed 2011 Sept 21.
- 27. ICD10 website. Available: http://apps.who.int/classifications/apps/icd/icd10online/. 2009. Accessed 2011 Sept 21.
- 28. National Emphysema Treatment Trial (NETT) Research Group (2001) Patients at high risk of death after lung-volume-reduction surgery. N Engl J Med 345: 1075–83.
- 29. Hansell DM, Bankier AA, MacMahon H, McLoud TC, Müller NL, Remy J (2008) Fleischner Society: glossary of terms for thoracic imaging. Radiology 246(3): 697–722.
- 30. Mayne T, Whalen E, Vu A (2006) Annualized was found better than absolute risk reduction in the calculation of number needed to treat in chronic conditions. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 59(3); 217-223:
- 31. Gondrie MJ, van der Graaf Y, Jacobs PC, Oen AL, Mali WP; On behalf of the PROVIDI Study Group (2010) The association of incidentally detected heart valve calcification with future cardiovascular events. Eur Radiol May; 21(5): 963–73.
- 32. Tiddens H, Silverman M, Bush A (200) The role of inflammation in airway disease: remodeling. Am J Respir Crit Care Med Aug 162: 2 Pt 2S7–S10.
- 33. Patel BD, Coxson HO, Pillai SG, Agustí AG, Calverley PM, Donner CF, et al. (2008) Airway wall thickening and emphysema show independent familial aggregation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Am J Respir Crit Care Med Sep 1 178(5): 500–5.
- 34. Nakano Y, Müller NL, King GG, Niimi A, Kalloger SE, Mishima M, et al. (2002) Quantitative assessment of airway remodeling using high-resolution CT. Chest Dec 122: 6 Suppl271S–275S.
- 35. Ahmad K, Gandhi MS, Smith WC, Weber KT (2008) Bilateral pleural effusions in congestive heart failure. Am J Med Sci 335(6): 484–8.
- 36. Ngom A, Dumont P, Diot P, Lemarié E (2001) Benign mediastinal lymphadenopathy in congestive heart failure. Chest 119(2): 653–6.