Phycomyces carRA gene encodes a protein with two domains. Domain R is characterized by red carR mutants that accumulate lycopene. Domain A is characterized by white carA mutants that do not accumulate significant amounts of carotenoids. The carRA-encoded protein was identified as the lycopene cyclase and phytoene synthase enzyme by sequence homology with other proteins. However, no direct data showing the function of this protein have been reported so far. Different Mucor circinelloides mutants altered at the phytoene synthase, the lycopene cyclase or both activities were transformed with the Phycomyces carRA gene. Fully transcribed carRA mRNA molecules were detected by Northern assays in the transformants and the correct processing of the carRA messenger was verified by RT-PCR. These results showed that Phycomyces carRA gene was correctly expressed in Mucor. Carotenoids analysis in these transformants showed the presence of ß-carotene, absent in the untransformed strains, providing functional evidence that the Phycomyces carRA gene complements the M. circinelloides mutations. Co-transformation of the carRA cDNA in E. coli with different combinations of the carotenoid structural genes from Erwinia uredovora was also performed. Newly formed carotenoids were accumulated showing that the Phycomyces CarRA protein does contain lycopene cyclase and phytoene synthase activities. The heterologous expression of the carRA gene and the functional complementation of the mentioned activities are not very efficient in E. coli. However, the simultaneous presence of both carRA and carB gene products from Phycomyces increases the efficiency of these enzymes, presumably due to an interaction mechanism.
Citation: Sanz C, Velayos A, Álvarez MI, Benito EP, Eslava AP (2011) Functional Analysis of the Phycomyces carRA Gene Encoding the Enzymes Phytoene Synthase and Lycopene Cyclase. PLoS ONE 6(8): e23102. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0023102
Editor: Michael Freitag, Oregon State University, United States of America
Received: March 11, 2011; Accepted: July 6, 2011; Published: August 9, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Sanz et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by Grant WAS GR64 (Junta de Castilla y León, Spain). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Carotenoids are natural pigments widely distributed that contribute to the color of many plants and animals and play a major role in photoprotection. Carotenoid derivatives are of great importance in different processes such as vision, nutrition, cellular growth and development. Biosynthesis of carotenoids occurs in all photosynthetic organisms as well as in many nonphotosynthetic bacteria and fungi –. Phycomyces blakesleeanus accumulates ß-carotene, a C40 carotenoid which gives this fungus its typical yellow color . The biosynthetic pathway of all C40 carotenoids starts with the condensation of two geranylgeranyl pyrophosphate (GGPP) molecules to form the colorless compound phytoene, a step catalyzed by the enzyme phytoene synthase. From this point, the pathway can take different directions depending on the organism . In Phycomyces, phytoene is converted into lycopene by four consecutive dehydrogenation reactions carried out by the enzyme phytoene dehydrogenase. Finally two cyclizations at both ends of the lycopene molecule catalyzed by the enzyme lycopene cyclase give rise to ß-carotene, the end-product of the pathway (Figures 1 and 2). These enzymes are thought to be organized in an aggregate, formed by four and two units of phytoene dehydrogenase and lycopene cyclase, respectively, that works as an assembly line –.
The organization of the structural genes involved in the carotenoid biosynthesis pathway in P. blakesleeanus, M. circinelloides and E. uredovora is shown. The function of these genes is described in the main text.
Enzymatic steps and structural genes involved in the biosynthesis of β-carotene from GGPP in P. blakesleeanus, M. circinelloides and E. uredovora. PS, phytoene synthase; PD, phytoene dehydrogenase; LC, lycopene cyclase.
The study of carotenogenesis in Phycomyces is facilitated by the large number of mutants available, both in structural and regulatory carotenogenic genes, and the easiness in obtaining them. The use of classical genetics techniques such as complementation, including quantitative complementation , –, and genetic sexual analysis –, as well as the existence of a general model for carotene biosynthesis and its regulation ,  that allows testing hypotheses, constitute important tools in this field. The main downside of this system comes from the failure to obtain stable transformants with exogenous DNA in Phycomyces . This problem is compensated in part by using the related fungus Mucor circinelloides, which can be easily transformed and is more amenable to molecular techniques  and where Phycomyces genes can be expressed , . Moreover, both fungi seem to have a very similar carotenogenic pathway (Figures 1 and 2) although with clear differences in its regulation . In Phycomyces this pathway is feed-back regulated by the end-product, while in Mucor and Blakeslea such a regulation is absent or clearly different , .
In Phycomyces the biosynthesis of β-carotene is influenced by external agents such as culture conditions, chemicals, blue light and sexual interactions . The activation of the β-carotene biosynthesis by light requires the products of genes madA and madB, which are components of a photoreceptor and transcription factor complex ,  that is homologous to the White Collar complex in Neurospora crassa , . Protein binding complexes are suggested to be involved in the down-regulation of photocarotenogenesis in Phycomyces . Despite the differences in the pathway regulation, the similarities between the structural genes of both organisms make Mucor a system suitable to test the function of the Phycomyces genes involved in the synthesis of carotenoids .
Among the many carotenoid mutants isolated in Phycomyces, those from a particular class, obtained after a single mutagenic treatment, seemed to lack two functions controlled by a single gene, denoted as carRA, because they did not complement mutants belonging to two different complementation groups (carR and carA) . carR mutants are red because they accumulate lycopene, and are supposed to be altered at the lycopene cyclase, while carA mutants are white, accumulate only traces of β-carotene, and were supposed to be altered in substrate transfer in and between the carotenogenic enzyme complexes , . Similar mutants were also described in M. circinelloides and the gene was termed carRP . Biochemical analysis of a particular Mucor strain later shown to be a carRP mutant suggested an alteration in the synthesis of phytoene . Isolation and characterization of the Mucor carRP gene (AJ250827) confirmed this hypothesis, showing that both lycopene cyclase and phytoene synthase activities are encoded by this gene . The same situation had previously been reported by Verdoes et al.  for gene crtYB (AJ133646) in the basidiomycetous yeast X. dendrorhous. Another previously isolated fungal gene, al-2 (L27652) from the ascomycete Neurospora crassa, initially reported as the phytoene synthase gene , was then also proved to encode the lycopene cyclase activity , . The enzymatic activities encoded by these genes (crtYB, carRP, and al-2) have been proven by complementation assays in E. coli containing plasmids carrying different carotenogenic genes from Erwinia uredovora .
The isolation of the Phycomyces carRA gene (AJ276965), the detection of changes in its sequence in several mutants, and the correlation with homologous sequences from the above mentioned fungi has led to identify it as the gene encoding not only the lycopene cyclase activity but also the phytoene synthase  (Figures 1 and 2). Unlike for its homologous genes listed above, however, no functional data have been reported so far. In this work we undertook detailed functional analyses of the Phycomyces carRA gene in the heterologous systems M. circinelloides and E. coli to confirm the molecular nature of the activities codified by this gene as was previously done for the other structural gene of this pathway in Phycomyces, the carB gene (X78434) , .
Materials and Methods
Plasmids, strains and growth conditions
The plasmids used in this work and their main properties are listed in Table 1. Vector NTI Suite software package (InforMax, North Bethesda, Md., USA) was used for managing and analysis of plasmids and other DNA sequences. E. coli strain DH5α was used for all cloning experiments and plasmid amplifications, and was grown at 37°C in Luria broth (LB) medium appropriately supplemented . P. blakesleeanus wild type (NRRL1555) was grown at 22°C on minimal medium (SIV) . M. circinelloides wild-type (CBS277.49) and mutant strains MS7 (leuA1, carP4), MS8 (leuA1, carRP5) and MS21 (leuA1, carR9)  were grown at 22°C on minimal (YNB) and complete (YPG) media, with the pH adjusted to 4.5 for normal or 3.0 for colonial growth, and supplemented with leucine (200 µg/mL) when needed .
Preparation and transformation of M. circinelloides protoplasts
Protoplasts of leucine auxotrophic M. circinelloides strains MS7, MS8 and MS21 were prepared by treatment of washed germlings with 1.5 mg/ml Novozyme234 (Novo Industries, Denmark) and 4–12 U/ml of Streptozyme in the presence of 0.5 M sorbitol and 10 mM sodium phosphate buffer, pH 6.5 . Transformation of protoplasts was polyethyleneglycol (PEG)-mediated . Transformations were performed with plasmid pCS5.1(3) (Figure 3) containing the genomic copies of the P. blakesleeanus carRA and the M. circinelloides leuA genes, and prototrophic transformants were selected on minimal medium. Several transformants from each mutant strain were transferred individually to fresh minimal medium plates and incubated under continuous light for four days.
This plasmid includes the M. circinelloides leuA and the P. blakesleeanus carRA genes. It was employed in the transformation of the M. circinelloides strains MS7, MS8 and MS21. Digestion with SacI results in plasmid linearization (12-kb single band). Digestion with SalI gives rise to two fragments of 7.3 kb (including the leuA gene) and 4.7 kb (including the carRA gene).
Purification of nucleic acids
The isolation of genomic DNA from P. blakesleeanus and M. circinelloides was performed as previously described , . Total RNA was isolated by the guanidine isothiocyanate method , except that the mycelium was ground with pestle and mortar while frozen. Mucor and Phycomyces strains were cultured in minimal medium plates supplemented as required and grown for 4 days at 22°C and under continuous broad-band blue light irradiation at a fluence of 40 J/m2 (4 W/m2 for 10 s).
Standard molecular procedures
Commonly used protocols for plasmid DNA purification, cloning, transformation of E. coli, and electrophoresis and transfer of DNA onto nylon filters were followed . DNA fragments for subcloning or labeling were recovered from agarose gels and purified using the Geneclean kit (BIO 101, Ohio, USA). Total RNA was electrophoresed in MOPS/formaldehyde buffer and transferred to a nylon membrane. Labeling, hybridization and immunological detections were carried out using the “non-radioactive labeling and immunological detection kit” and the “polymerase chain reaction (PCR) digoxigenin labeling mix” (Roche, Indianapolis, USA) following the supplier's recommendations. For Southern analyses, a carRA gene derived probe was labeled by PCR using oligonucleotides PSP8 (5′-CAAAGGAGAACACGGAAG-3′) and PSP10 (5′-TGCAAAGGCCTGGGTATG-3′). A leuA probe was generated by random primed labeling. For Northern analyses, a carRA probe was obtained by PCR using total cDNA and oligonucleotides PSP12 (5′-ATCTTACTCGAGGATGCTGACTTATATG- 3′) and PSP13 (5′-TTTTGAGCTCTTAAATGACAGTAAAGGC - 3′). PCR amplification conditions were performed as previously described . After autoradiography, the films were analyzed with an Image Acquisition Console and the Whole Band Analyzer software (Bio Image; MilliGen/Biosearch, Ann Arbor, Mich., USA).
For RT-PCR analysis, synthesis of total cDNA and amplification reactions were carried out in a Thermal Cycler 480 (Applied Biosystems, N.J., USA). For each cDNA synthesis reaction, 1 µg of total RNA was mixed with 1 µl of oligonucleotide d(T)16 (50 µM), incubated at 70°C for 10 min and cooled on ice before adding 4 µl of 5× PCR buffer, 2 µl of DTT 0.1 M and 8 µl of 2.5 mM of each dNTP. The mix was incubated at 42°C for 2 min before addition of 1 µl of SUPERSCRIPT™ II RNAse H Reverse Transcriptase at 200 U/µl (LIFE TECHNOLOGIES, California, USA). Reactions were incubated at 42°C for 50 min, and then inactivated at 70°C for 15 min. For the amplification of the P. blakesleeanus carRA cDNA, oligonucleotides PSP8 (5′-CAAAGGAGAACACGGAAG-3′) and PSP14 (5′-AAGGCCTGGGCCAGCAG- 3′) were used. The sequence of PSP14 comprises 9 nucleotides of the first exon 3′ end followed by 8 nt of the second exon 5′ end, so the amplification with PSP8 and PSP14 gives rise to a 510 bp fragment of the cDNA obtained after the splicing of the carRA intron. In addition, to confirm the quality of the cDNA synthesis reactions, a control PCR was performed to amplify the pyrG gene cDNA using oligonucleotides pyrG3 (5′-ATGATGCTGAACACATACAAG-3′) and pyrG4 (5′-TTATGCTTTATGCATGCTTAC-3′). The amplifications were performed in 100 µl reactions containing 2 µl of the cDNA synthesis reaction, 0.15 µM of each primer, 2 mM MgCl2, 200 µM of each dNTP, 1× PCR buffer II and 2.5 U of AmpliTaq DNA polymerase (Applied Biosystems, California, USA) with the following PCR profile: 95°C for 2 min; 40 cycles of 95°C for 30 s, 55°C for 1 min and 72°C for 90 s; 72°C for 5 min.
Determination of carotenoids accumulated in both M. circinelloides and E. coli was performed by HPLC analysis as previously described .
The Phycomyces carRA gene complements mutations in Mucor carRP
In order to confirm that the carRA gene codes for an enzyme with lycopene cyclase and phytoene synthase activities, as the M. circinelloides carRP gene does, functional complementation in M. circinelloides was attempted. Plasmid pCS5.1(3) (Figure 3) carrying genomic DNA copies of the P. blakesleeanus carRA and the M. circinelloides leuA genes was employed to transform the M. circinelloides strains MS7 (leuA1, carP4), MS8 (leuA1, carRP5) and MS21 (leuA1, carR9). MS7 and MS8 strains are white because they do not accumulate any carotenoid; MS21 strain shows a pink phenotype due to accumulation of lycopene. Approximately 20 transformants per experiment were obtained for each of the three mutant strains. Several leu+ transformants derived from each mutant strain were transferred individually to fresh minimal medium plates and incubated under continuous light conditions for four days. No clear differences among the transformants for each strain could be detected by visual inspection suggesting a similar degree of complementation. For further analysis we selected three transformants of each type. Visual inspection of mycelia color indicated that MS7 and MS8 transformants showed a light-creamy color, slightly darker than the clean white color characteristic of the untransformed MS7 and MS8 strains. The MS21-derived transformants showed a slightly orange color somewhat distinguishable from the typical pink color of the original MS21 strain. Transformants were grown for 3 vegetative cycles on selective and non selective media (YNB or YNB/leucine, respectively). It was observed that in the medium supplemented with leucine, where there was no selective pressure, the transforming phenotype was lost rapidly, whereas in the selective medium the transforming phenotype remained. This mitotic instability of the leu+ phenotype indicates that pCS5.1(3) is maintained extrachromosomally in the Mucor transformants. One pCS5.1(3)-transformant of each strain (MS7, MS8 and MS21) was selected for further analyses, and will be referred to as T7, T8 and T21, respectively.
The presence of pCS5.1(3) in T7, T8 and T21 was analyzed by Southern blot hybridization. Genomic DNA was extracted, digested with SacI or SalI and prepared for hybridization with probes for the carRA and leuA genes (see Materials and Methods section). pCS5.1(3) plasmid DNA and genomic DNA from untransformed strain MS7 were employed as positive and negative controls, respectively. Figure 4 shows the results of this analysis. In the hybridization with the carRA probe (Figure 4A), a single band was detected in all the transformants and in the positive control (pCS5.1(3) lane) corresponding to the 12-kb linearized plasmid in the SacI digestions and to the 4.7-kb SalI-SalI fragment of pCS5.1(3) that includes the carRA gene in the SalI digestions. In the negative control (lane MS7) no signal was detected. In the hybridization with the leuA probe (Figure 4B), both in the SacI and in the SalI panels, a single band of different size was detected in the negative control MS7 lanes and in the positive control pCS5.1(3) lanes corresponding, respectively, to the endogenous and the plasmid-derived copies of the M. circinelloides leuA gene. Both bands were detected in the T7, T8 and T21 lanes. These results confirm that plasmid pCS5.1(3), and so the P. blakesleeanus carRA gene, is present in these transformants. In addition, it is shown that the plasmid is maintained extrachromosomally and does not seem to have suffered any major modification in the transformants.
Genomic DNA from M. circinelloides untransformed MS7 strain was employed as negative control and plasmid DNA from pCS5.1(3) (P5 lane) was employed as positive control. DNA samples were digested with SacI or SalI enzymes. Hybridizations were performed with a P. blakesleeanus carRA probe (A) and a M. circinelloides leuA probe (B).
Transcription of the P. blakesleeanus carRA gene in the T7, T8 and T21 transformants was checked by Northern hybridization of total RNA using P. blakesleeanus wild-type strain and M. circinelloides untransformed strain MS7 as positive and negative controls, respectively (Figure 5A and B). While no hybridization signal was observed in the untransformed MS7 strain, a single hybridization band was detected in samples derived from transformants T7, T8 and T21. The size of this band corresponds to that of the band detected in the P. blakesleeanus wild-type lane. These results confirm that the carRA gene is expressed in these transformants. A clear mRNA smear is observed after hybridization with the carRA probe. This degradation tail has been previously observed in the analysis of the light-mediated expression of the carB and carRA/P genes of Phycomyces and Mucor, but not for other genes such as actA, pyrF and pyrG which expression is not light-regulated , , .
A: Northern blot hybridization of total RNA from M. circinelloides transformants T7, T8 and T21 with a carRA cDNA probe. The untransformed Mucor MS7 strain and the P. blakesleeanus wild-type (Pwt) strain were used as negative and positive controls, respectively. B: Ethidium bromide staining after gel electrophoresis of RNA samples. C: Detection by RT-PCR of the P. blakesleeanus carRA cDNA in the same RNA samples. D: Quality control of the same RNA samples by RT-PCR detection of the M. circinelloides pyrG cDNA. M: 100 bp marker.
Furthermore, in order to confirm the correct expression and splicing of the carRA gene in the analyzed M. circinelloides transformants, a RT-PCR analysis was performed (Figure 5C and D). The same total RNA samples employed in the Northern blot assay were subjected to reverse transcription and the resulting total cDNA amplified with oligonucleotides PSP8 and PSP14, which had been designed to test the correct splicing of the carRA mRNA (see Materials and Methods section). A single amplification product of 510 bp was detected in T7, T8 and T21 transformants and the P. blakesleeanus wild-type samples, while no band was amplified from the untransformed MS7 strain (Figure 5C). These results further confirm that the carRA gene from P. blakesleeanus was expressed in these transformants and show that the intron in the carRA gene has been correctly processed in M. circinelloides. The quality of all the Mucor cDNA samples was checked by the positive control amplification of the M. circinelloides pyrG cDNA in the untransformed MS7 strain as well as in T7, T8 and T21 transformants, but not in the wild-type P. blakesleeanus strain (Figure 5D).
Finally, to study the functionality of the Phycomyces carRA gene product in the M. circinelloides T7, T8 and T21 transformants, an analysis of their carotenoid content was performed. Carotenoids were extracted from mycelia collected from the three transformants as well as from the untransformed strains MS7, MS8 and MS21 and analyzed by HPLC. Representative chromatograms of the obtained results are shown in Figure 6. As previously reported , , no β-carotene was detected in MS7, MS8 and MS21. However, small quantities of β-carotene were detected in the T7 (520±36 ng/gdw (g dry weight)), T8 (380±22 ng/gdw) and T21 (3252±19 ng/gdw) transformants (data are averages plus/minus standard errors of three independent experiments). Although these amounts are clearly lower than those observed in M. circinelloides wild-type (322 µg/gdw), the detection of β-carotene in the transformants indicates that the carRA gene can indeed complement, at least partially, the M. circinelloides carR, carP and carRP mutations.
Carotenoids were detected at 450 nm. Profiles obtained from M. circinelloides wild-type, MS7 (leuA1, carP4) and MS21 (leuA1, carR9) strains, as well as T7 and T21 transformants (MS7 and MS21, respectively, transformed with the P. blakesleeanus carRA gene) are shown. β: β-carotene, L: Lycopene. Y-axis not scaled.
Complementation analysis in E. coli
Transformation of E. coli with plasmids carrying crt genes from E. uredovora leads to the synthesis and accumulation of different carotenoids in the bacteria . In this system, a DNA fragment of 6.9 kb from the bacteria E. uredovora contains six open reading frames (crt genes) responsible for the transformation of GGPP into zeaxanthin-β-diglucoside. These genes are denoted as crtE, crtX, crtY, crtI, crtB and crtZ, and encode the enzymatic activities GGPP synthase, zeaxanthin glucosyl transferase, lycopene cyclase, phytoene dehydrogenase, phytoene synthase and β-carotene hydroxylase, respectively  (Figures 1 and 2). Elimination or inactivation of one or several of these genes allows the use of these E. coli “carotenoid mutants” for testing the function of a particular gene of interest by co-transformation of the corresponding cDNA and analysis of complementation of the pathway. As previously done for the homologous gene carRP from M. circinelloides , heterologous expression in E. coli was performed with the Phycomyces carRA cDNA to test if its encoded protein had phytoene synthase and lycopene cyclase activities. The results of these analyses are shown in Table 2.
When the phytoene synthase (pAVB5 plasmid, crtB−) mutant was transformed with the carRA cDNA (pCS19), lycopene and β-carotene were produced, whereas no carotenoids were detected in the negative control (pUC19 co-transformation). Therefore, the carRA gene encodes an enzyme with phytoene synthase activity (Figure 7).
A: Phytoene synthase activity assay (crtB− strain; pAVB5). In the negative control (pUC19), bacteria do not accumulate any carotenoid and show a normal, whitish color. In the positive control (pAVB13), bacteria accumulate β-carotene and show a yellow phenotype. After transformation with pCS19, a light yellow color was detected (due to the β-carotene production as the result of the phytoene synthase activity from the carRA gene). B: Lycopene cyclase activity assay (crtY− strain; pAVB12). In the negative control (pUC19), bacteria accumulate lycopene and show a pink color. In the positive control (pAVB2), lycopene is converted into β-carotene resulting in a bright yellow color. Transformation with pCS19 led to a light-orange phenotype due to the β-carotene production as the result of the lycopene cyclase activity of the carRA gene. Data of HPLC analyses are shown in Table 2.
When the lycopene cyclase (pAVB12 plasmid, crtY−) mutant was transformed with the carRA cDNA, β-carotene was also produced though to a lower extent than with the positive control (pAVB2 plasmid carrying the crtY gene). However, in the negative control (pUC19 co-transformation) no β-carotene was detected. These results show that the CarRA protein also has lycopene cyclase activity (Figure 7).
Co-transformation assays using the phytoene synthase and lycopene cyclase double mutant (pAVB16 plasmid; crtB−, crtY−) were also performed. As expected, no carotenoids were detected with the negative control (pUC19) or the crtY (pAVB2) plasmids, while lycopene was accumulated after transformation with the crtB (pAVB13) plasmid. Co-transformation with the carRA plasmid pCS19, however, did not show any accumulation of carotenoids. It has been proposed that the enzymes encoded by the carotenogenic structural genes carB and carRA in Phycomyces form an enzymatic complex , . We decided to check if the co-expression in E. coli of both carB and carRA cDNAs from Phycomyces had an impact on the efficiency of carotenoid accumulation. For this purpose, the crtI gene from plasmid pAVB16 was replaced by the cDNA from the Phycomyces carB gene to obtain the new plasmid 6pCS16, and similar co-transformation experiments were performed. The analysis of the carotenoids produced by these co-transformants showed that, although in very small quantities, β-carotene was obtained with plasmid pCS19 carrying the carRA cDNA. These results indicate that an inefficient interaction between the enzymes encoded by the P. blakesleeanus and the E. uredovora genes could be the cause of the low efficiency of the Phycomyces enzymes in this heterologous system.
The bifunctional lycopene cyclase/phytoene synthase gene is found only in fungi, and it is thought to have been originated from the fusion of two ancestral genes involved in lycopene cyclization (crtYc and crtYd) and a phytoene synthase gene . The initial description of such a gene was carried out in X. dendrorhous (crtYB) . The same situation was later reported for M. circinelloides (carRP) , P. blakesleeanus (carRA)  and N. crassa (al-2) . As mentioned before, the N. crassa al-2 gene had been previously described as encoding the enzyme phytoene synthase . The insight gained with the fungal bifunctional gene description led to reveal al-2 also as the lycopene cyclase gene by isolation of new mutants and sequencing of their al-2 alleles  and by heterologous complementation in E. coli . For P. blakesleeanus, it was already suggested that a bifunctional gene controls the lycopene cyclase activity, but the new reports ,  led to a reconsideration of the second function associated with the carRA gene. The isolation of this gene and the sequencing of the allele in a number of mutants confirmed that it was altered in carA, carR and carRA strains . The lycopene cyclase function had always been associated with the carR mutants. However, carA mutants had never before been associated with mutation in the phytoene synthase gene. The description of the CarRA product as an enzyme with lycopene cyclase and phytoene synthase activities was based on sequence homology with the proteins encoded by the genes mentioned above, but no actual functional analyses were available. We have addressed here this issue by complementation of M. circinelloides phytoene synthase and/or lycopene cyclase mutants as well as by heterologous complementation in E. coli.
The presence of β-carotene in the transformed strains of M. circinelloides and bacteria indicates that the P. blakesleeanus carRA gene does indeed encode a protein with both phytoene synthase and lycopene cyclase activities. Complementation of the carP4 (strain MS7), carRP5 (strain MS8), and carR9 (strain MS21) mutations indicates that the carRA gene is not only correctly transcribed, but also correctly translated in M. circinelloides. Nevertheless, the amounts of β-carotene accumulated in T7, T8 and T21 transformants are very small when compared to those detected in the wild type strain or after transformation of the same strains with the homologous gene carRP . An analogous heterologous complementation of the Mucor strain MS8 with the carRA gene of Blakeslea trispora has been described, also resulting in accumulation of small amounts of β-carotene in the transformants . Similar low levels of carotenoid accumulation were reported when the M. circinelloides phytoene dehydrogenase mutant strain MS23 (carB11) was transformed with the P. blakesleeanus carB gene . In that case the limited heterologous functional complementation achieved was attributed to the lack of specificity in the recognition of the initiation and termination transcription signals of the Phycomyces carB gene in Mucor, as mostly truncated carB transcripts were detected. A second explanation, which does not exclude the first one, is the fact that the formation of functional carotenogenic enzyme complexes in the transformants would be hampered by the simultaneous presence of both functional Phycomyces phytoene dehydrogenase subunits and mutant Mucor phytoene dehydrogenase subunits. In our case, the Phycomyces carRA gene seems to be correctly transcribed in Mucor. The particularly low β-carotene accumulation in T7, T8 and T21 transformants may be due to a low efficiency of the enzymatic activities of the protein/s expressed in this heterologous system. Therefore, alterations due to improper post-transcriptional or post-translational modifications, or failure to form a fully functional carotenogenic complex, are most likely responsible of the low level of complementation observed in these transformants. Integrative transformation is a rather uncommon event in Mucor . The fact that the transformants obtained in this work do maintain the plasmid by autonomous replication and the coenocytic nature of the mycelium in this fungus, could also be a factor in the low levels of carotenoids detected. In our analysis of the Mucor circinelloides carB gene , we were able to compare the results of three different transformants, one of which resulted from integration of the transforming plasmid. This unusual case proved that β-carotene biosynthesis in that particular transformant was almost ten times higher than in the highest β-carotene-accumulating transformant with autonomous replication. It is probable that integration of the plasmid carrying the Phycomyces carRA gene would result in a higher level of β-carotene biosynthesis. However, even in this case, the accumulated amounts could still be very low and, therefore, it would be difficult to discriminate this kind of transformants from the majority of autonomous replicating transformants.
The expression of the carRA cDNA in the so-called E. coli “carotenoid mutants” led to accumulation of β-carotene when either crtB (phytoene synthase) or crtY (lycopene cyclase) genes were disrupted. The detected amounts were low but significant, and prove unequivocally the function of the CarRA protein. However, the same result could not be obtained when both crtB and crtY genes were altered; these kind of unfitting results are not uncommon, and we encountered something similar in our previous characterization of the Mucor carRP gene when complementation of the “crtY mutant” could be detected with a particular plasmid but not with a different one . The low functional efficiency in complementation assays of E. coli “carotenoid mutants” is not surprising and has been reported in other cases. When bacteria deficient in the phytoene dehydrogenase activity were transformed with the Phycomyces carB and the Neurospora al-1 cDNAs , very small amounts of carotenoids were detected, and it was attributed to translational or post-translational failures. We have shown here that co-expression of the cDNAs of both structural genes from P. blakesleeanus, carB and carRA, increases the efficiency of carotenoid biosynthesis in an appropriately constructed E. coli strain. Since the enzymes encoded by the carotenogenic structural genes in Phycomyces are supposed to work by forming an enzyme complex , , , it is not surprising that when this complex is formed in transformed E. coli “carotenoid mutants” from a pool of subunits encoded by genes from different organisms the efficiency of the system decreases.
All these observations demonstrate that the P. blakesleeanus carRA gene determines the phytoene synthase and the lycopene cyclase activities and suggest that both, species-specific post-transcriptional or post-translational modifications and particular specific protein-protein interactions between the carB and carRA gene products, are essential factors for the correct enzymatic activity of the carotenogenic complex synthesizing β-carotene in P. blakesleeanus.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CS AV MIG APE EPB. Performed the experiments: CS AV MIG APE EPB. Analyzed the data: CS AV MIG APE EPB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: CS AV MIG APE EPB. Wrote the paper: CS AV MIG APE EPB.
- 1. von Lintig J (2010) Colors with functions: elucidating the biochemical and molecular basis of carotenoid metabolism. Annu Rev Nutr 30: 35–56.J. von Lintig2010Colors with functions: elucidating the biochemical and molecular basis of carotenoid metabolism.Annu Rev Nutr303556
- 2. Cazzonelli CI, Pogson BJ (2010) Source to sink: regulation of carotenoid biosynthesis in plants. Trends Plant Sci 15: 266–274.CI CazzonelliBJ Pogson2010Source to sink: regulation of carotenoid biosynthesis in plants.Trends Plant Sci15266274
- 3. Namitha KK, Negi PS (2010) Chemistry and biotechnology of carotenoids. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 50: 728–760.KK NamithaPS Negi2010Chemistry and biotechnology of carotenoids.Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr50728760
- 4. Cerdá-Olmedo E (1987) Carotene. In: Cerdá-Olmedo E, Lipson ED, editors. Phycomyces. Cold Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press. pp. 199–222.E. Cerdá-Olmedo1987Carotene.E. Cerdá-OlmedoED LipsonPhycomycesCold Spring Harbor, NYCold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press199222
- 5. Sandmann G (2002) Combinatorial biosynthesis of carotenoids in a heterologous host: a powerful approach for the biosynthesis of novel structures. Chembiochem 3: 629–635.G. Sandmann2002Combinatorial biosynthesis of carotenoids in a heterologous host: a powerful approach for the biosynthesis of novel structures.Chembiochem3629635
- 6. De la Guardia MD, Aragon CM, Murillo FJ, Cerda-Olmedo E (1971) A carotenogenic enzyme aggregate in Phycomyces: evidence from quantitive complementation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 68: 2012–2015.MD De la GuardiaCM AragonFJ MurilloE. Cerda-Olmedo1971A carotenogenic enzyme aggregate in Phycomyces: evidence from quantitive complementation.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A6820122015
- 7. Eslava AP, Cerdá-Olmedo E (1974) Genetic control of phytoene dehydrogenation in Phycomyces. Plant Science Letters 2: 9–14.AP EslavaE. Cerdá-Olmedo1974Genetic control of phytoene dehydrogenation in Phycomyces.Plant Science Letters2914
- 8. Aragon CM, Murillo FJ, de la Guardia MD, Cerda-Olmedo E (1976) An enzyme complex for the dehydrogenation of phytoene in Phycomyces. Eur J Biochem 63: 71–75.CM AragonFJ MurilloMD de la GuardiaE. Cerda-Olmedo1976An enzyme complex for the dehydrogenation of phytoene in Phycomyces.Eur J Biochem637175
- 9. Candau R, Bejarano ER, Cerda-Olmedo E (1991) In vivo channeling of substrates in an enzyme aggregate for beta-carotene biosynthesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 88: 4936–4940.R. CandauER BejaranoE. Cerda-Olmedo1991In vivo channeling of substrates in an enzyme aggregate for beta-carotene biosynthesis.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A8849364940
- 10. Sanz C, Alvarez MI, Orejas M, Velayos A, Eslava AP, et al. (2002) Interallelic complementation provides genetic evidence for the multimeric organization of the Phycomyces blakesleeanus phytoene dehydrogenase. Eur J Biochem 269: 902–908.C. SanzMI AlvarezM. OrejasA. VelayosAP Eslava2002Interallelic complementation provides genetic evidence for the multimeric organization of the Phycomyces blakesleeanus phytoene dehydrogenase.Eur J Biochem269902908
- 11. Ootaki T, Lighty AC, Delbruck M, Hsu WJ (1973) Complementation between mutants of Phycomyces deficient with respect to carotenogenesis. Mol Gen Genet 121: 57–70.T. OotakiAC LightyM. DelbruckWJ Hsu1973Complementation between mutants of Phycomyces deficient with respect to carotenogenesis.Mol Gen Genet1215770
- 12. Gauger WL, Peláez MI, Álvarez MI, Eslava EP (1980) Mating type heterokarions in Phycomyces blakesleeanus. Exp. Mycol 4: 49–55.WL GaugerMI PeláezMI ÁlvarezEP Eslava1980Mating type heterokarions in Phycomyces blakesleeanus. Exp.Mycol44955
- 13. Cerda-Olmedo E (1975) The genetics of Phycomyces blakesleeanus. Genet Res 25: 285–296.E. Cerda-Olmedo1975The genetics of Phycomyces blakesleeanus.Genet Res25285296
- 14. Eslava AP, Alvarez MI, Burke PV, Delbruck M (1975) Genetic recombination in sexual crosses of Phycomyces. Genetics 80: 445–462.AP EslavaMI AlvarezPV BurkeM. Delbruck1975Genetic recombination in sexual crosses of Phycomyces.Genetics80445462
- 15. Eslava AP, Alvarez MI, Delbruck M (1975) Meiosis in Phycomyces. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 72: 4076–4080.AP EslavaMI AlvarezM. Delbruck1975Meiosis in Phycomyces.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A7240764080
- 16. Alvarez MI, Eslava AP (1983) Isogenic Strains of Phycomyces blakesleeanus Suitable for Genetic Analysis. Genetics 105: 873–879.MI AlvarezAP Eslava1983Isogenic Strains of Phycomyces blakesleeanus Suitable for Genetic Analysis.Genetics105873879
- 17. Orejas M, Pelaez MI, Alvarez MI, Eslava AP (1987) A genetic map of Phycomyces blakesleeanus. Mol Gen Genet 210: 69–76.M. OrejasMI PelaezMI AlvarezAP Eslava1987A genetic map of Phycomyces blakesleeanus.Mol Gen Genet2106976
- 18. Bejarano ER, Parra F, Murillo FJ, Cerdá-Olmedo E (1988) End-product regulation of carotenogenesis in Phycomyces. Arch Microbiol 150: 209–214.ER BejaranoF. ParraFJ MurilloE. Cerdá-Olmedo1988End-product regulation of carotenogenesis in Phycomyces.Arch Microbiol150209214
- 19. Almeida ER, Cerda-Olmedo E (2008) Gene expression in the regulation of carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces. Curr Genet 53: 129–137.ER AlmeidaE. Cerda-Olmedo2008Gene expression in the regulation of carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces.Curr Genet53129137
- 20. Obraztsova IN, Prados N, Holzmann K, Avalos J, Cerda-Olmedo E (2004) Genetic damage following introduction of DNA in Phycomyces. Fungal Genet Biol 41: 168–180.IN ObraztsovaN. PradosK. HolzmannJ. AvalosE. Cerda-Olmedo2004Genetic damage following introduction of DNA in Phycomyces.Fungal Genet Biol41168180
- 21. van Heeswijck R, Roncero MIG (1984) High-frequency transformation of Mucor with recombinant plasmid DNA. Carlsberg Res Commun 49: 578–583.R. van HeeswijckMIG Roncero1984High-frequency transformation of Mucor with recombinant plasmid DNA.Carlsberg Res Commun49578583
- 22. Iturriaga EA, Diaz-Minguez JM, Benito EP, Alvarez MI, Eslava AP (1992) Heterologous transformation of Mucor circinelloides with the Phycomyces blakesleeanus leu1 gene. Curr Genet 21: 215–223.EA IturriagaJM Diaz-MinguezEP BenitoMI AlvarezAP Eslava1992Heterologous transformation of Mucor circinelloides with the Phycomyces blakesleeanus leu1 gene.Curr Genet21215223
- 23. Ruiz-Hidalgo MJ, Eslava AP, Alvarez MI, Benito EP (1999) Heterologous expression of the Phycomyces blakesleeanus phytoene dehydrogenase gene (carB) in Mucor circinelloides. Curr Microbiol 39: 259–264.MJ Ruiz-HidalgoAP EslavaMI AlvarezEP Benito1999Heterologous expression of the Phycomyces blakesleeanus phytoene dehydrogenase gene (carB) in Mucor circinelloides.Curr Microbiol39259264
- 24. Iturriaga EA, Velayos A, Eslava AP (2000) The structure and function of the genes involved in the biosynthesis of carotenoids in the Mucorales. Biotechnol Bioprocess Eng 5: 263–274.EA IturriagaA. VelayosAP Eslava2000The structure and function of the genes involved in the biosynthesis of carotenoids in the Mucorales.Biotechnol Bioprocess Eng5263274
- 25. Cerda-Olmedo E (2001) Phycomyces and the biology of light and color. FEMS Microbiol Rev 25: 503–512.E. Cerda-Olmedo2001Phycomyces and the biology of light and color.FEMS Microbiol Rev25503512
- 26. Idnurm A, Rodriguez-Romero J, Corrochano LM, Sanz C, Iturriaga EA, et al. (2006) The Phycomyces madA gene encodes a blue-light photoreceptor for phototropism and other light responses. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 4546–4551.A. IdnurmJ. Rodriguez-RomeroLM CorrochanoC. SanzEA Iturriaga2006The Phycomyces madA gene encodes a blue-light photoreceptor for phototropism and other light responses.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A10345464551
- 27. Sanz C, Rodriguez-Romero J, Idnurm A, Christie JM, Heitman J, et al. (2009) Phycomyces MADB interacts with MADA to form the primary photoreceptor complex for fungal phototropism. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106: 7095–7100.C. SanzJ. Rodriguez-RomeroA. IdnurmJM ChristieJ. Heitman2009Phycomyces MADB interacts with MADA to form the primary photoreceptor complex for fungal phototropism.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A10670957100
- 28. Froehlich AC, Liu Y, Loros JJ, Dunlap JC (2002) White Collar-1, a circadian blue light photoreceptor, binding to the frequency promoter. Science 297: 815–819.AC FroehlichY. LiuJJ LorosJC Dunlap2002White Collar-1, a circadian blue light photoreceptor, binding to the frequency promoter.Science297815819
- 29. He Q, Cheng P, Yang Y, Wang L, Gardner KH, et al. (2002) White collar-1, a DNA binding transcription factor and a light sensor. Science 297: 840–843.Q. HeP. ChengY. YangL. WangKH Gardner2002White collar-1, a DNA binding transcription factor and a light sensor.Science297840843
- 30. Sanz C, Benito EP, Orejas M, Alvarez MI, Eslava AP (2010) Protein-DNA interactions in the promoter region of the Phycomyces carB and carRA genes correlate with the kinetics of their mRNA accumulation in response to light. Fungal Genet Biol 47: 773–781.C. SanzEP BenitoM. OrejasMI AlvarezAP Eslava2010Protein-DNA interactions in the promoter region of the Phycomyces carB and carRA genes correlate with the kinetics of their mRNA accumulation in response to light.Fungal Genet Biol47773781
- 31. Torres-Martinez S, Murillo FJ, Cerda-Olmedo E (1980) Genetics of lycopene cyclization and substrate transfer in beta-carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces. Genet Res 36: 299–309.S. Torres-MartinezFJ MurilloE. Cerda-Olmedo1980Genetics of lycopene cyclization and substrate transfer in beta-carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces.Genet Res36299309
- 32. Murillo FJ, Torres-Martinez S, Aragon CM, Cerda-Olmedo E (1981) Substrate transfer in carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces. Eur J Biochem 119: 511–516.FJ MurilloS. Torres-MartinezCM AragonE. Cerda-Olmedo1981Substrate transfer in carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces.Eur J Biochem119511516
- 33. Velayos A, Lopez-Matas MA, Ruiz-Hidalgo MJ, Eslava AP (1997) Complementation analysis of carotenogenic mutants of Mucor circinelloides. Fungal Genet Biol 22: 19–27.A. VelayosMA Lopez-MatasMJ Ruiz-HidalgoAP Eslava1997Complementation analysis of carotenogenic mutants of Mucor circinelloides.Fungal Genet Biol221927
- 34. Fraser PD, Ruiz-Hidalgo MJ, Lopez-Matas MA, Alvarez MI, Eslava AP, et al. (1996) Carotenoid biosynthesis in wild type and mutant strains of Mucor circinelloides. Biochim Biophys Acta 1289: 203–208.PD FraserMJ Ruiz-HidalgoMA Lopez-MatasMI AlvarezAP Eslava1996Carotenoid biosynthesis in wild type and mutant strains of Mucor circinelloides.Biochim Biophys Acta1289203208
- 35. Velayos A, Eslava AP, Iturriaga EA (2000) A bifunctional enzyme with lycopene cyclase and phytoene synthase activities is encoded by the carRP gene of Mucor circinelloides. Eur J Biochem 267: 5509–5519.A. VelayosAP EslavaEA Iturriaga2000A bifunctional enzyme with lycopene cyclase and phytoene synthase activities is encoded by the carRP gene of Mucor circinelloides.Eur J Biochem26755095519
- 36. Verdoes JC, Krubasik KP, Sandmann G, van Ooyen AJ (1999) Isolation and functional characterisation of a novel type of carotenoid biosynthetic gene from Xanthophyllomyces dendrorhous. Mol Gen Genet 262: 453–461.JC VerdoesKP KrubasikG. SandmannAJ van Ooyen1999Isolation and functional characterisation of a novel type of carotenoid biosynthetic gene from Xanthophyllomyces dendrorhous.Mol Gen Genet262453461
- 37. Schmidhauser TJ, Lauter FR, Schumacher M, Zhou W, Russo VE, et al. (1994) Characterization of al-2, the phytoene synthase gene of Neurospora crassa. Cloning, sequence analysis, and photoregulation. J Biol Chem 269: 12060–12066.TJ SchmidhauserFR LauterM. SchumacherW. ZhouVE Russo1994Characterization of al-2, the phytoene synthase gene of Neurospora crassa. Cloning, sequence analysis, and photoregulation.J Biol Chem2691206012066
- 38. Arrach N, Schmidhauser TJ, Avalos J (2002) Mutants of the carotene cyclase domain of al-2 from Neurospora crassa. Mol Genet Genomics 266: 914–921.N. ArrachTJ SchmidhauserJ. Avalos2002Mutants of the carotene cyclase domain of al-2 from Neurospora crassa.Mol Genet Genomics266914921
- 39. Sandmann G, Zhu C, Krubasik P, Fraser PD (2006) The biotechnological potential of the al-2 gene from Neurospora crassa for the production of monocyclic keto hydroxy carotenoids. Biochim Biophys Acta 1761: 1085–1092.G. SandmannC. ZhuP. KrubasikPD Fraser2006The biotechnological potential of the al-2 gene from Neurospora crassa for the production of monocyclic keto hydroxy carotenoids.Biochim Biophys Acta176110851092
- 40. Misawa N, Nakagawa M, Kobayashi K, Yamano S, Izawa Y, et al. (1990) Elucidation of the Erwinia uredovora carotenoid biosynthetic pathway by functional analysis of gene products expressed in Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 172: 6704–6712.N. MisawaM. NakagawaK. KobayashiS. YamanoY. Izawa1990Elucidation of the Erwinia uredovora carotenoid biosynthetic pathway by functional analysis of gene products expressed in Escherichia coli.J Bacteriol17267046712
- 41. Arrach N, Fernandez-Martin R, Cerda-Olmedo E, Avalos J (2001) A single gene for lycopene cyclase, phytoene synthase, and regulation of carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98: 1687–1692.N. ArrachR. Fernandez-MartinE. Cerda-OlmedoJ. Avalos2001A single gene for lycopene cyclase, phytoene synthase, and regulation of carotene biosynthesis in Phycomyces.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A9816871692
- 42. Ruiz-Hidalgo MJ, Benito EP, Sandmann G, Eslava AP (1997) The phytoene dehydrogenase gene of Phycomyces: regulation of its expression by blue light and vitamin A. Mol Gen Genet 253: 734–744.MJ Ruiz-HidalgoEP BenitoG. SandmannAP Eslava1997The phytoene dehydrogenase gene of Phycomyces: regulation of its expression by blue light and vitamin A.Mol Gen Genet253734744
- 43. Sambrook J, Fritsch EF, Maniatis T (1989) Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual. New York: Cold Spring Harbor laboratory. J. SambrookEF FritschT. Maniatis1989Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory ManualNew YorkCold Spring Harbor laboratory
- 44. Sutter RP (1975) Mutations affecting sexual development in Phycomyces blakesleeanus. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 72: 127–130.RP Sutter1975Mutations affecting sexual development in Phycomyces blakesleeanus.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A72127130
- 45. Velayos A, Blasco JL, Alvarez MI, Iturriaga EA, Eslava AP (2000) Blue-light regulation of phytoene dehydrogenase (carB) gene expression in Mucor circinelloides. Planta 210: 938–946.A. VelayosJL BlascoMI AlvarezEA IturriagaAP Eslava2000Blue-light regulation of phytoene dehydrogenase (carB) gene expression in Mucor circinelloides.Planta210938946
- 46. Moller EM, Bahnweg G, Sandermann H, Geiger HH (1992) A simple and efficient protocol for isolation of high molecular weight DNA from filamentous fungi, fruit bodies, and infected plant tissues. Nucleic Acids Res 20: 6115–6116.EM MollerG. BahnwegH. SandermannHH Geiger1992A simple and efficient protocol for isolation of high molecular weight DNA from filamentous fungi, fruit bodies, and infected plant tissues.Nucleic Acids Res2061156116
- 47. Choi HT, Revuelta JL, Sadhu C, Jayaram M (1988) Structural organization of the TRP1 gene of Phycomyces blakesleeanus: implications for evolutionary gene fusion in fungi. Gene 71: 85–95.HT ChoiJL RevueltaC. SadhuM. Jayaram1988Structural organization of the TRP1 gene of Phycomyces blakesleeanus: implications for evolutionary gene fusion in fungi.Gene718595
- 48. Blasco JL, RoeBink D, Iturriaga EA, Eslava AP, Galland P (2001) Photocarotenogenesis in Phycomyces. Expression of the carB gene encoding phytoene dehydrogenase. J Plant Res 114: 25–31.JL BlascoD. RoeBinkEA IturriagaAP EslavaP. Galland2001Photocarotenogenesis in Phycomyces. Expression of the carB gene encoding phytoene dehydrogenase.J Plant Res1142531
- 49. Ruiz-Hidalgo MJ, Lopez-Matas MA, Velayos A, Fraser PD, Bramley PM, et al. (1995) Carotenoid mutants of Mucor circinelloides. Bot Acta 108: 396–400.MJ Ruiz-HidalgoMA Lopez-MatasA. VelayosPD FraserPM Bramley1995Carotenoid mutants of Mucor circinelloides.Bot Acta108396400
- 50. Sandmann G (2002) Molecular evolution of carotenoid biosynthesis from bacteria to plants. Physiologia Plantarum 116: 431–440.G. Sandmann2002Molecular evolution of carotenoid biosynthesis from bacteria to plants.Physiologia Plantarum116431440
- 51. Rodriguez-Saiz M, Paz B, De La Fuente JL, Lopez-Nieto MJ, Cabri W, et al. (2004) Blakeslea trispora genes for carotene biosynthesis. Appl Environ Microbiol 70: 5589–5594.M. Rodriguez-SaizB. PazJL De La FuenteMJ Lopez-NietoW. Cabri2004Blakeslea trispora genes for carotene biosynthesis.Appl Environ Microbiol7055895594
- 52. Arnau J, Ströman P (1993) Gene replacement and ectopic integration in the zygomycete Mucor circinelloides. Curr Genet 23: 542–546.J. ArnauP. Ströman1993Gene replacement and ectopic integration in the zygomycete Mucor circinelloides.Curr Genet23542546
- 53. Yanisch-Perron C, Vieira J, Messing J (1985) Improved M13 phage cloning vectors and host strains: nucleotide sequences of the M13mp18 and pUC19 vectors. Gene 33: 103–119.C. Yanisch-PerronJ. VieiraJ. Messing1985Improved M13 phage cloning vectors and host strains: nucleotide sequences of the M13mp18 and pUC19 vectors.Gene33103119