As the incidence of respiratory and allergic symptoms has been reported to be increased in children attending schools in close proximity to busy roads, it was hypothesised that PM from roadside schools would display enhanced oxidative potential (OP). Two consecutive one-week air quality monitoring campaigns were conducted at seven school sampling sites, reflecting roadside and urban background in London. Chemical characteristics of size fractionated particulate matter (PM) samples were related to the capacity to drive biological oxidation reactions in a synthetic respiratory tract lining fluid. Contrary to hypothesised contrasts in particulate OP between school site types, no robust size-fractionated differences in OP were identified due high temporal variability in concentrations of PM components over the one-week sampling campaigns. For OP assessed both by ascorbate (OPAA m−3) and glutathione (OPGSH m−3) depletion, the highest OP per cubic metre of air was in the largest size fraction, PM1.9–10.2. However, when expressed per unit mass of particles OPAA µg−1 showed no significant dependence upon particle size, while OPGSH µg−1 had a tendency to increase with increasing particle size, paralleling increased concentrations of Fe, Ba and Cu. The two OP metrics were not significantly correlated with one another, suggesting that the glutathione and ascorbate depletion assays respond to different components of the particles. Ascorbate depletion per unit mass did not show the same dependence as for GSH and it is possible that other trace metals (Zn, Ni, V) or organic components which are enriched in the finer particle fractions, or the greater surface area of smaller particles, counter-balance the redox activity of Fe, Ba and Cu in the coarse particles. Further work with longer-term sampling and a larger suite of analytes is advised in order to better elucidate the determinants of oxidative potential, and to fuller explore the contrasts between site types.
Citation: Godri KJ, Harrison RM, Evans T, Baker T, Dunster C, Mudway IS, et al. (2011) Increased Oxidative Burden Associated with Traffic Component of Ambient Particulate Matter at Roadside and Urban Background Schools Sites in London. PLoS ONE6(7): e21961. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0021961
Editor: Malcolm Gracie Semple, University of Liverpool, United Kingdom
Received: January 10, 2011; Accepted: June 13, 2011; Published: July 27, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Godri et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Funding for this study was received from NERC and MRC under the Environment and Human Health Program. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Children living or attending schools near busy roads have been reported to suffer from increased rates of respiratory problems, as well as impaired lung growth –. Consistent with a causal relationship between traffic emissions and impaired respiratory health Wjst et al.  demonstrated an inverse relationship between children's lung function with traffic density on the road servicing their school. In addition to traffic density, fleet composition also appears important, with evidence that children attending schools less than 100 m from roads carrying a high proportion of diesel vehicles suffer from not only reduced lung function, but also increased chronic respiratory symptoms, including cough, wheeze, and rhinitis .
Schools located near busy roads will experience increments in primary traffic emissions including nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide and particulate matter (PM). Studies referenced above investigating the respiratory responses to traffic exposure used traffic counts and proximity to roads as a proxy measure of primary vehicular emission exposure. It is however likely that a roadside source profile will provide even greater contrasts in PM composition relative to that observed at urban background or rural locations; appreciating these compositional contrasts will prove important in understanding the basis of the health effects observed in high traffic micro-environments. In this study two weekly sampling campaigns were performed at seven sites within the London Air Quality Network (LAQN) to examine composition and toxicity contrasts in gaseous and size-fractionated particulate pollutant concentrations at primary schools located near major roads and at urban/suburban background locations.
Whilst the association between adverse respiratory health and exposure to elevated concentrations of PM is robust, the strength of this relationship differs markedly between studies –. This heterogeneity likely reflects in part the use of bulk PM mass concentration as an exposure metric, which is insensitive to variation in physical and chemical characteristics, attributable to varying source contributions at a given location. Much attention has therefore been directed towards identifying components, or characteristics of PM that could be used to provide more precise metrics of their potential health impacts. As PM toxicity likely reflects the sum of multiple toxic components approaches focusing on single factors (e.g. particle size, chemical components) are unlikely to be fruitful. A measure of PM toxicity that integrates composition across size-fractions would seem a more logical strategy, with the long-term aim of establishing a ‘biologically-active’ PM metric for ambient air. PM oxidative potential (OP) has been proposed as such a metric, with numerous toxicological studies documenting PM-induced oxidative stress within the lung –. Oxidative potential, as measured in a cell free model, either by EPR, antioxidant depletion or DTT oxidation, reflects the integrated sum of its content of redox active components. ROS can also clearly be formed through the interaction of non-redox active components with tissues in vivo, though the relative balance between intrinsic and latent oxidative activities still needs to be accurately quantified, which is almost impossible in cell models which are already under a state of continuous oxidative stress –. This metric was examined in the present study to identify individual PM fractions and components that contribute significantly to the observed oxidative activity of ambient PM.
Materials and Methods
Sampling site description
Seven London primary school sites were selected to represent a wide geographical area (northwest to southeast London) (Figure 1). School sampling locations were classified as suburban (residential area on the outskirts of a town or city, Site A), urban background (Sites B–D), or roadside (sampling inlet between 1 and 5 m from the kerbside, Sites E–G). The sampling inlet height was positioned to 2 m above ground level at each site with the exception of Urban Background Site C which was located on the roof-top of a three-storey school building. Site selection was limited to primary schools which housed a LAQN monitoring station on its grounds or in proximity.
All LAQN sites selected were equipped with a Tapered Element Oscillating Microbalance (TEOM) with a 50°C heated inlet or R&P Filter Dynamics Measurement System (FDMS). Continuous mass concentrations of PM with an aerodynamic diameter of less than 10 (PM10) and 2.5 µm (PM2.5) were measured with 15 minute resolution by the TEOM or FDMS. To account for semi-volatile particulate matter losses by TEOM measurements, the volatile correction model (VCM) was applied, as recommended for comparison of TEOM PM10 measurements with the European Directive . Continuous 15 minute resolved gaseous nitrogen oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) measurements were taken at each LAQN site. This was further complemented with wind direction averaged at the same sampling interval at select Urban Background Sites B–D and Roadside Sites F and G.
The pre-existing measurement infra-structure at each LAQN monitoring stations was augmented on a rolling basis for a period of 14 days during November 2007 and March 2008. Added instrumentation included a Micro-Orifice Uniform Deposit Impactor (MOUDI) and a Condensation Particle Counter (TSI CPC, Model 3022A). The CPC particle number concentration (PNC) measurements were recorded continuously with 15 minute resolution.
The total 14-day campaign at each site was subdivided into two 7-day MOUDI filter sampling periods. The MOUDI, operated at 30 L min−1, sampling size-fractions of PM with aerodynamic diameters less than 0.2 µm (PM0.2), between 0.2 and 1 µm (PM0.2–1), between 1 and 1.9 µm (PM1–1.9) and between 1.9 and 10.2 µm (PM1.9–10.2). All Teflon MOUDI filters were weighed before and after air sampling using a Sartorius model MC5 microbalance to determine the PM mass. Filters were equilibrated for 24 hours prior to weighing in a room with humidity (45 – 55%) and temperature (20±2°C) controls. To eliminate static electricity effects on filter weights, an ionising blower and α-particle source were employed. Following sampling, each MOUDI filter was halved for subsequent compositional and OP analysis.
The equivalence of PM10 mass concentrations derived from MOUDI filter samples and co-located semi-continuous TEOM measurements was evaluated. The latter was averaged to a seven-day basis comparable to the MOUDI filters' resolution. At least 75% of the fifteen minute TEOM measurements were required for weekly averages to be considered valid, excluding Sites F and G from this instrument inter-comparison. For Sites A–E, VCM corrected TEOM mass concentrations were greater than measurements given by the corresponding filter data (Table 1). The Bland-Altman method was considered to evaluate the equivalence between the two instrument measurements; the sampling methods consistently provided similar measurements (p = 0.0014). The mean measurement difference was −7.1 between the MOUDI and VCM corrected TEOM with 95% limits of agreement (−16.2, 2.0) containing all the difference scores. Temporal agreement was further investigated between the two instrument measurements (r2 = 0.86, p<0.0001, n = 10); despite the instrument agreement suggested by the Bland-Altman analysis, the linear regression slope (0.51 (µg m−3)MOUDI/(µg m−3)VCM TEOM) between MOUDI and VCM TEOM PM10 mass concentrations suggested a systematic bias. The non-unit MOUDI/VCM TEOM ratio which is consistent across all considered school sites is representative of semi-volatile constituent losses from the filter: the discrepancy between the two PM mass sampling methods was improved when raw TEOM concentrations were considered characterised by a linear regression slope of 0.83 (µg m−3)MOUDI/(µg m−3)Raw TEOM). Semi-volatile losses from the MOUDI Teflon filters are acknowledged as a weakness of the study's sampling setup, but cannot be avoided when size-fractionated sampling is required.
Chemicals and chelex water preparation
All chemicals used were obtained from Sigma Chemical Company Ltd (Poole, UK) and were of high pressure liquid chromatography grade. For chemical composition analysis, 18.2 MΩ-cm Millipore distilled deionised water was used. All water for OP analysis was deionised and ultra-filtered using an Elga-stat filtration system and further treated with Chelex-100 resin to eliminate any background metal contamination.
A quarter of the MOUDI filter from each impactor stage was used for water soluble inorganic ions and another quarter for total trace metal analysis. For the latter, filter segments were extracted using a dilute reverse aqua regia solution made up in distilled deionised water prior to sonication in an 80°C water bath for 1 hour . The solution was allowed to cool prior to filtration through an Acrodisc Syringe Filter (Pall Acrodisc 32 mm Syringe Filter, 0.45 µM Supor Membrane). Acid extracted solutions were stored at 4°C until analysis for concentrations of 27Al, 137Ba, 52Cr, 65Cu, 57Fe, 60Ni, 51V, and 66Zn using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (Aligent 7500ce with an Octopole Reaction System). All material (pipette tips, scissors, vials) that came into contact with the filters, or the filter extract solution were plastic and acid washed (2% HNO3) prior to use.
Filter material for water soluble cation (Na+, NH4+, K+, Mg2+, Ca2+) and anion (Cl−, NO3−, SO42−, PO43−) analysis was extracted in distilled deionised water (18.2 MΩ-cm) following mechanical shaking for 20 minutes. The resultant PM suspensions were then filtered with an Acrodisc Syringe Filter in a similar way to acid extracts. Anion species were measured on a Dionex ICS-2000 ion chromatography system eluted with electrodialytically generated (EG40) 20.5 mM KOH mobile phase. The ICS-2000 system was fitted with an anion guard (AG11-HC, 2×50 mm) and separator (AS11-HC, 2×250 mm) columns, both of which were maintained at 30°C. Sample solutions, following separation entered the ASRS-Ultra 52 mA suppressor and then a 2 mm carbonate removal device before passing through the thermally stabilised conductivity cell. A Dionex model DX100 ion chromatograph was used to measure cation species. PM extracts were then passed through a cation guard (CG12A) and analytical (CS12A) columns and finally routed into a conductivity detector (CD25A). The system was isocratically eluted with a 30 mN sulphuric acid mobile phase at a flow rate of 1.0 ml min−1. Each system was calibrated with multi-elemental standards prepared with working concentrations in the range 0.2 to 10 ppm.
Assessment of oxidative potential
PM collected on MOUDI filters was extracted in methanol by vortexing (10 minutes) and probe sonication (MSE Soniprep 150) using a titanium probe at an amplitude of 5 microns for 30 seconds. The extracted PM suspension was then evaporated to dryness under a gentle stream of nitrogen prior to resuspension to 150 µg mL−1 using Chelex-resin treated water containing 5% methanol.
An acellular model was employed to assess the OP of the size fractionated PM samples. Antioxidant depletion from a synthetic respiratory tract lining fluid (RTLF) was measured following a four hour incubation at 37°C to uniform mass concentrations of resuspended particulate matter (50 µg mL−1). The RTLF chemical model was comprised of physiologically relevant concentrations (200 µM) of urate (UA), ascorbate (AA) and glutathione (GSH) adjusted to pH 7.0. Following PM-RTLF exposures, samples were centrifuged at 13,000 rpm for 60 minutes at 4°C and then antioxidant concentrations were measured.
For AA and UA measurements, 50 µL of the incubated RTLF-PM supernatant was combined with 450 µL of ice cold 5% metaphosphoric acid . Reverse phase high pressure liquid chromatography with an EG&G amperometric electrochemical detector (Jones Chromatography, Hengoed, Wales) was used to simultaneously determine these antioxidant concentrations. The detector was operated with an electrode voltage of 400 mV, 5 second time constant and 500 nA cathodic output sensitivity. A 25 µL aliquot of sample solution was injected, using an auto-sampler (Model 231, Gilson), onto a analytical column (10×300 nm, 5 µm C18) and eluted with 0.2 mM K2HPO4-H3PO4 mobile phase containing 0.25 mM octanesulphonic acid (pH 2.1) at a flow rate of 1.0 mL min−1. AA and UA calibration curves (0–25 µM) were used to calculate sample concentrations.
The GSH concentration remaining in the RTLF after the 4 hour incubation was indirectly calculated by measuring total glutathione (GSx) and glutathione disulphide (GSSG) concentrations. These compounds were determined using the GSSG-reductase- 5,5′-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) assay . A 16.7 µL aliquot of the incubated RTLF-PM supernatant was added to 983.3 µL of 100 mM sodium phosphate buffer (pH 7.5) containing ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid. In parallel with all sample batches, a GSSG standard curve (0 – 165 pmol/50 µL GSSG, equivalent to 0 – 330 pmol/50 µLGSx) was also run. To measure GSx concentrations, 50 µL of the sample and standard solutions were dispensed onto a microtitre plate. Once 100 µL of reaction mixture (0.15 mM 5,5′-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid), 0.2 mM NADPH and 1 U glutathione reductase) was added to each well, the plate was immediately analysed on a plate reader (SpectraMAX 190; Molecular Devices) heated to 30°C. The total analysis period was two minutes during which time the formation rate of 5-thio-2-nitrobenzoic acid was measured at an absorbance of 405 nm. A similar protocol was employed to measure GSSG concentration. The only exception was that prior to sample combination with the reaction mixture, 5 µL of 2-vinyl pyridine was combined with 130 µL of sample and control solutions. These 2-vinyl pyridine solutions were vortexed for 5 seconds, followed by a one hour incubation period at room temperature. GSH was calculated by subtracting two times the GSSG concentration from the measured GSx concentration.
To guarantee inter-experimental standardisation, known particle and particle-free controls (positive: residual oil fly ash; negative: M120 carbon black) were also run in parallel with filter samples. Control material was resuspended similarly to ambient PM samples in Chelex water containing 5% methanol and probe sonicated to ensure the suspensions were homogeneous. Compositional details of the residual oil fly ash – and M120 ,  control particles have been published elsewhere.
The percentage of AA and GSH depletion over the 4 hour incubation period by each PM sample was calculated relative to particle-free control run in parallel. PM OP expressed on a unit mass basis was determined by standardising the percentage loss value by the final PM mass concentration used in the RTLF assay (50 µg mL−1) for ascorbate (OPAA µg−1) and reduced glutathione (OPGSH µg−1). PM OP was also calculated on a unit volume basis by accounting for ambient PM mass concentrations to yield individual measures describing ascorbate (OPAA m−3) and reduced glutathione (OPGSH m−3) depletion.
SPSS for windows (version 17) was used for statistical analyses. Comparison of PM chemical composition concentrations and OP measurements across sampling sites and PM size fractions were evaluated using one-way ANOVA with post-hoc testing using the Tukey HSD test. Variation of PM OP was evaluated using physico-chemical measurements (particle number, total trace metal and soluble inorganic ion concentrations) as explanatory variables in uni- and multi-variate linear regressions. The strength of uni-variate associations between these independent PM constituent variables and the OP metrics (AA and GSH expressed on a unit mass and volume basis) were assessed with Pearson correlations. Stepwise multi-variate linear regression analysis was also performed with a backward deletion procedure. Interactions between PM constituents were also considered and were used to form a priori assumptions regarding the covariates entered into multi-variate linear regression model. A p-value less than 0.05 was considered to be significant for all cases.
Results and Discussion
Vehicular emission related PM
Evaluation of continuous PNC, PM10 and gaseous (NOx = NO+NO2) pollutant concentrations collected over each site's two week campaign period (Table 1) did not indicate any significant increments at the roadside sites compared to urban background and suburban site types. This is not surprising as ambient measurements were collected sequentially across the school locations over short durations which enabled episodic periods to skew the PM and gaseous pollutant concentration distributions. When NOx and PM10 mass concentrations were considered for equivalent extended periods (the full academic year spanning September to June) at each of these schools using the LAQN online measurement archive (www.londonair.org.uk), a significant difference in concentration means was found between site types. Site type contrasts were also identified in diurnal fluctuations where the magnitude of NOx increase (indicative of primary vehicle emissions) was greater at roadside sites than at urban background locations.
A large carriageway was approximately 1.5 km west of Urban Background Site B with a busy residential road also running 300 m east of the site. These nearby roadways yielded the elevated PNC and NOx levels when data were analysed according to wind direction. Urban Background Site D was situated 400 m southeast of a major carriageway which likely caused the observed increase in PNC from this wind direction. Significantly lower primary particle and gaseous pollutant concentrations were measured at Urban Background Site C where the site was located on the roof of a three storey primary school. Although it is useful to note that two multi-lane carriageways, running east-west, are located 200 m north and south of the site.
The contribution of vehicle emissions to PM mass concentrations (TEOM PM10×1.3: Sites A-E; FDMS PM2.5: Sites F and G) was quantitatively evaluated at all sites using Pearson correlations between 15 minute resolved PM mass and NOx concentrations for the total two week sampling period –. Roadside Sites F and G, as expected, exhibited the strongest significant (p<0.0001) relationships (Site F: r2 = 0.81, n = 1274; Site G: r2 = 0.81, n = 1313) and the greatest contribution of vehicle derived PM. At Roadside Site E, the relationship between PM10 and NOx was decreased compared to Sites F and G (r2 = 0.27, n = 1220). Correlations were weaker but still significant for all urban background locations (Site B: r2 = 0.58, n = 1193; Site C: r2 = 0.07, n = 1475; Site D: r2 = 0.62, n = 1540) and the suburban site (Site A: r2 = 0.34, n = 1065); the lowest PM10-NOx association for Urban Background Site C was attributable to its roof-top location. Despite proximity of this site to a major carriageway, air quality was likely affected by a vertical gradient of PNC and NOx concentrations . Therefore, regardless of the site type, sampled PM was influenced by vehicular sources to some degree.
It can be further shown that as the variance in PM mass concentration explained by NOx increased, the concentration of Fe (p = 0.004), Cu (p = 0.022), and Ba (p = 0.007) also increased proportionally; this increase was not found to be statistically significant for any of the other metals measured. Fe, Cu and Ba were thus likely reflective of traffic derived emissions from brake wear  which were evident at all seven sampling sites.
Size-fractionated trace metal concentrations
Individual schools were grouped by urban background and roadside classifications and contrasts in mean size-fractionated trace metal concentrations were evaluated. Consistent with the NOx and PM10 mass concentration results, no significant differences were identified in trace metal concentrations for each of the measured size fractions between the two site types (Figure 2 and Figure 3); the only exception to this was PM1.9–10 Ba where concentrations were significantly greater at the roadside site schools. For the roadside site school grouping, Ba, Fe, Cu and Al concentrations were significantly elevated in the PM1.9–10 size fraction in comparison to other size fractions. Although, the increase of these trace metals was not significant for the urban background site group, a similar enrichment pattern was also observed. Moderate but not statistically significant enrichment of Ni, V and Zn in the PM0.2–1 size fraction was identified at roadside and urban background sites (Figure 3). As shown in Figure 4, these PM0.2–1 modal increases were accompanied by elevations in NH4+ and SO42− concentrations, most probably associated with long-range atmospheric transport processes. Data from individual sites appear in Figures S1, S2 and S3.
Each bar represents the mean and associated standard deviation. Diamond markers indicate the mean total PM10.2 trace metal concentration for each site. Comparison of roadside and urban background means between PM size fractions was performed using a one-way ANOVA with post-hoc testing using the Tukey HSD test. Significant contrast (p<0.05) are noted.
See the Figure 2 legend for a description of marker and statistical details.
See the Figure 2 legend for a description of marker and statistical details.
Although homogeneity of the size-fractionated trace metal profiles found at the two site types likely reflects the restricted, sequential sampling periods, which were subject to short-term meteorological effects, results confirm that both roadside and urban background schools were influenced by the same panel of sources. To identify these contributing sources common to both site types, bi-variate trace metal concentrations correlations were performed on each of the collected size-fractionated.
A strong relationship (p<0.01) was observed between Cu and Ba reflecting their common source in brake dust for all size-fractions other than PM0.2. All size-fractions of Ba and Cu were also well correlated with Fe (p<0.01); PM0.2 was again the exception for Cu-Fe correlations. Fe, Ba, and Cu are all derived from non-tailpipe traffic emissions and this common source was reflected in the strong positive correlations between species. Gietl et al.  and Birmili et al.  reported that these three trace metals all result from single uniform abrasive vehicular emissions, primarily brake pad debris; similarities were identified in temporal fluctuations, with the strongest linearity between these metal concentrations observed in the coarse mode.
Ni and V exhibited a strong association for all sample size-fractions (p<0.01). A relationship was found for Ni and V with Zn for all size-fractions (p<0.01) with the exception of V-Zn for PM0.2. Ni, V and Zn may be derived from both non-tailpipe vehicle – and oil combustion emissions –. A significant relationship between Zn with Fe and Cu (p<0.05) was observed for PM0.2–1 (p<0.01) and PM1.9–10.2. Ni and V were also both correlated with Fe for PM0.2 (p<0.01) and to a lesser extent with PM0.2–1 (p<0.05). However, for total PM10.2 mass, no correlation existed between Ni (r = 0.47, p = 0.09) and V (r = 0.36, p = 0.21) with Fe. V also lacked any correlation with Cu and Ba. Although a relationship was established between Ni, V, and Zn and known vehicular trace metal markers, episodic concentrations exclusive to these trace metals (90% percentile) were measured during only two of the site visits (Urban Background Site B week 2 and Site D week 1). Occurrence of elevated concentrations in the absence of elevation in the other metals suggests another potential source type. The United Kingdom National Atmospheric Emissions Inventory reports Ni and V are primary emitted from industrial fuel oil combustion and shipping sources, which do not have a local source in the Greater London Urban Area. Enrichment of Ni and V was noted in a similar PM size-fraction (0.1–1 µm) in Helsinki, Finland where these species were attributed to oil combustion . Similarly, Allen et al.  noted that size-fractionated Zn and Ni sampled in Birmingham, United Kingdom had the greatest concentrations in the accumulation mode and were thought to be the result of long range transported combustion sources. Moreover, Ni (r = 0.63; p = 0.02) and V (r = 0.66; p = 0.01) concentrations were significantly correlated with SO42− concentrations. Gaseous SO2 accompanies Ni and V in from shipping emissions , – and from other fuel oil combustion sources, and following long range transport, atmospheric processing would result in SO2 oxidation to particulate SO42−.
Particulate oxidative potential
Previous studies have indicated an increment in PM OP at high-traffic versus urban background locations  associated with elevated redox active Fe and Cu content . However, no robust site classification-dependent contrasts were found for either of the OP metrics in any of the size fractions measured (Figure 5). When variation across individual sites was considered, only Roadside Site F, which showed a strong traffic influence upon trace metal concentrations also exhibited the highest OP in both tests (Figure S4).
See the Figure 2 legend for a description of marker and statistical details.
As common sources were found to influence both the roadside and urban background school sites, all seven sites were aggregated and the mean size-fractionated OP response was evaluated. Distinct size fraction dependent contrasts were apparent in the data expressed per cubic metre, with highest PM OP associated with the coarse fraction. Some contrast in OPGSH µg−1 was found across the four PM size-fractions sampled but only a significant contrast between PM0.2 (0.38±0.16 µg−1) and PM1.9–10.2 (0.69±0.27 µg−1) (Figure 6). Levels of the OPGSH µg−1 metric increased with PM size and this occurred in parallel with measured metal species known to have a traffic origin, with concentrations of Fe, Cu, and Ba (ng µg−1) all enriched in the larger size fraction. Significant increases of these metals in larger size fractions, however, did not yield significant increases in OPAA µg−1 (α = 0.05); with no differences in this metric were identifiable between the four size fractions sampled. Homogeneity in OPAA µg−1 levels suggests a counteracting influence of components enriched in the smaller size fractions, possible Zn, Ni and V (Figure 6), but possibly also including trace organic compounds, or an effect of greater surface area per unit mass in smaller particles.
Each bar represents the mean across the seven primary school sampling sites with the associated standard deviation. Dark and light grey column indicate measurements per unit mass and volume, respectively. Comparison of means between the PM size fractions was performed using a one-way ANOVA with post-hoc testing using the Tukey HSD test. Significant contrast (p<0.05) are noted for measurements per unit mass (#) and per unit volume (*).
To further examine the relationship of OP metrics variance and trace metal concentrations, bi-variate correlation analysis was performed. A statistically significant correlation was observed for not only OPGSH µg−1 and Fe (ng µg−1; r2 = 0.38, p = 0.02) but also OPGSH µg−1 and Cu (ng µg−1; r2 = 0.31, p = 0.04). It is also useful to recall that both these redox active trace metals expressed per unit mass were internally correlated (r = 0.91, p<0.0001), suggestive of a common source. The strength of the relationship between OPAA µg−1 and individual trace metals was in contrast only found to be significant for Ni (ng µg−1; r2 = 0.41, p = 0.01) and V (ng µg−1; r2 = 0.37, p = 0.02). This difference in the potential predictors of these antioxidant metrics was expected as no relationship existed between OPAA µg−1 and OPGSH µg−1 (r = 0.16, p = 0.59). This examination of antioxidant trends across PM size fractions thus suggested that AA and GSH depletion are sensitive to different panels of PM constituents, with a relationship across the measured size fractions between the GSH dependent OP metric and traffic related trace metals. Although total particulate oxidative burden as indicated by AA depletion was influenced by traffic derived metals, other sources responsible for elevated ambient Ni and V concentrations were predictive of this antioxidant's depletion.
The combined effects of what appeared to be two distinct sources (abrasive vehicular and a long range transported fuel oil combustion emissions) at these London sampling sites was investigated through linear regression modelling. Full details appear in Table S1. Trace metal factors represented the best determinants of the associated PM10.2 OP, consistent with previous studies , , . The multivariate models constructed to predict PM10.2 OP variance for both antioxidant metrics included iron as a factor (Table 2). PM-induced GSH oxidation in the RTLF model was sensitive to a source characteristic of Fe (and Cu), thus likely related to traffic derived emissions. Variance in the OP measured via AA depletion was best described by Fe and Zn concentrations. Both of these trace metals are primarily the result of non-tail pipe vehicle emissions; however, from the strong relationship of Zn with Ni (ng µg−1; r = 0.76, p<0.0001) and V (ng µg−1; r = 0.71, p<0.0001) coupled with the strength of the bi-variate correlation results of OPAA µg−1 – Ni (ng µg−1) and OPAA µg−1 – V (ng µg−1), it was likely that AA depletion measured in this London study was also sensitive to a long range fuel oil combustion source. When PM10.2 mass was forced into these model as an explanatory variable, the model's ability to predict OP variance over the trace metal variables alone did not increase. Moreover, no association was found between PM10.2 mass and AA or GSH related OP µg−1. It should be emphasised that elucidating the trace metals associated with OPAA µg−1 and OPGSH µg−1 metrics in the multi-variate regression method was ultimately limited by the statistical method used as the co-linearity of trace metals confounds results. Identification of the independent contribution of individual trace metals to OP was therefore limited if a common source origin existed.
Only PM constituents with intrinsic redox activity, including quinones and redox active metals, drive antioxidant depletion in the synthetic RTLF chemical model. Certain redox active trace metals were identified as significantly associated with the OP metrics and may be directly responsible for AA and GSH depletion. The current study did not measure the quinone composition of the sampled PM; however, non-redox active metals found to be predictive of OP via uni- and multi-variate regression analysis likely represent surrogate measures of constituents with intrinsic and non-latent redox active properties which were not quantified. Elucidating why individual RTLF antioxidants are sensitive to heterogeneous PM constituents is the subject of future studies being conducted currently and involving more extensive PM chemical characterisation.
This study demonstrates both the feasibility of performing a detailed air quality assessment, including compositional analysis of size fractionated PM and assessment of PM OP, at primary schools in London. The depth of analysis that can be applied to this data set is somewhat limited by the small number of visits performed at each location, but it is clear that coarser PM fractions contribute significantly to the OP in the ambient PM and should not therefore be excluded in consideration of PM health impacts. The regression analysis performed demonstrated that select redox active and non-active metals are better able to explain variance in PM OP than the bulk PM mass concentration. A consistent trend across all sites of elevated Fe mass concentrations in the coarse mode particles and strong correlations with other abrasive traffic markers (Cu and Ba) suggest the Fe associated with increased PM OP is related to vehicle emissions.
This study did not demonstrate an increment in PM OP at roadside school sites compared to those situated away from major roads. However, the locations of all schools examined were found to experience periods of high traffic influence (stop-go and idling) at the start and end of the school day and were subject to the advected traffic pollution. Therefore, regardless of the school site in London, there will be a traffic emission contribution to ambient PM. These emissions will increase the concentration of redox cycling trace metals which in turn cause a greater particulate oxidative burden.
Mean size-fractionated PM trace metal (Fe, Cu, Ba, Al) concentrations at primary school sampling sites. Each bar represents the mean of two filter samples per site visit with the associated standard deviation. Diamond markers indicate the mean total PM10.2 trace metal concentration for each site.
Mean size-fractionated PM trace metal (Ni, V, Zn) concentrations at primary school sampling sites. Each bar represents the mean of two filter samples per site visit with the associated standard deviation. Diamond markers indicate the mean total PM10.2 trace metal concentration for each site.
Mean size-fractionated PM soluble inorganic constituent concentrations at primary school sampling sites. Each bar represents the mean of two filter samples per site visit with the associated standard deviation. Diamond markers indicate the mean total PM10.2 soluble inorganic constituent concentration for each site.
Mean size-fractionated PM ascorbate and glutathione related oxidative potential at primary school sampling sites. Each bar represents the mean of two filter samples per site visit with the associated standard deviation. Diamond markers indicate the mean total PM10.2 oxidative potential for each site.
Bivariate correlation analysis for OPAA, OPGSH, mass concentration and metal variables expressed per unit volume in the top triangle (blue) and per unit mass in the bottom triangle (green) for PM10.2 and individual PM size fractions (N = 14). Correlations with p values less than 0.01 and 0.05 are highlighted in yellow and orange, respectively.
The authors would like to thank Royston Lawrence for his assistance with compilation of data.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RMH FJK. Performed the experiments: TE TB CD KJG. Analyzed the data: RMH KJG ISM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: RMH FJK. Wrote the paper: RMH KJG FJK ISM.
- 1. Janssen NAH, Brunekreef B, van Vliet P, Aarts F, Maliefste K, et al. (2003) The relationship between air pollution from heavy traffic and allergic sensitization, bronchial byperresponsiveness, and respiratory symptoms in Dutch schoolchildren. Environ Health Perspect 111: 1512–1518.NAH JanssenB. BrunekreefP. van VlietF. AartsK. Maliefste2003The relationship between air pollution from heavy traffic and allergic sensitization, bronchial byperresponsiveness, and respiratory symptoms in Dutch schoolchildren.Environ Health Perspect11115121518
- 2. Nicolai T, Carr D, Weiland SK, Duhme H, von Ehrenstein O, et al. (2003) Urban traffic and pollutant exposure related to respiratory outcomes and atopy in a large sample of children. Eur Respir J 21: 956–963.T. NicolaiD. CarrSK WeilandH. DuhmeO. von Ehrenstein2003Urban traffic and pollutant exposure related to respiratory outcomes and atopy in a large sample of children.Eur Respir J21956963
- 3. Sekine K, Shima M, Nitta Y, Adachi M (2004) Long term effects of exposure to automobile exhaust on the pulmonary function of female adults in Tokyo, Japan. Occup Environ Med 61: 350–357.K. SekineM. ShimaY. NittaM. Adachi2004Long term effects of exposure to automobile exhaust on the pulmonary function of female adults in Tokyo, Japan.Occup Environ Med61350357
- 4. Islam T, Gauderman WJ, Berhane K, McConnell R, Avol E, et al. (2007) Relationship between air pollution, lung function and asthma in adolescents. Thorax 62: 957–963.T. IslamWJ GaudermanK. BerhaneR. McConnellE. Avol2007Relationship between air pollution, lung function and asthma in adolescents.Thorax62957963
- 5. Gauderman WJ, Vora H, McConnell R, Berhane K, Gilliland F, et al. (2007) Effect of exposure to traffic on lung development from 10 to 18 years of age: a cohort study. Lancet 369: 571–577.WJ GaudermanH. VoraR. McConnellK. BerhaneF. Gilliland2007Effect of exposure to traffic on lung development from 10 to 18 years of age: a cohort study.Lancet369571577
- 6. Wjst M, Reitmeir P, Dold S, Wulff A, Nicolai T, et al. (1993) Road traffic and adverse effects on respiratory health in children. British Medical Journal 307: 596–600.M. WjstP. ReitmeirS. DoldA. WulffT. Nicolai1993Road traffic and adverse effects on respiratory health in children.British Medical Journal307596600
- 7. van Vliet P, Knape M, De Hartog J, Janssen N, Harssema H, et al. (1997) Motor vehicle exhaust and chronic respiratory symptoms in children living near freeways. Environ Res 74: 122–132.P. van VlietM. KnapeJ. De HartogN. JanssenH. Harssema1997Motor vehicle exhaust and chronic respiratory symptoms in children living near freeways.Environ Res74122132
- 8. Katsouyanni K, Touloumi G, Samoli E, Gryparis A, Le Tertre A, et al. (2001) Confounding and effect modification in the short-term effects of ambient particles on total mortality: Results from 29 European cities within the APHEA2 project. Epidemiology 12: 521–531.K. KatsouyanniG. TouloumiE. SamoliA. GryparisA. Le Tertre2001Confounding and effect modification in the short-term effects of ambient particles on total mortality: Results from 29 European cities within the APHEA2 project.Epidemiology12521531
- 9. Samet JM, Zeger SL, Dominici F, Curriero F, Coursac I, et al. (2000) The National Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution Study.Part II: JM SametSL ZegerF. DominiciF. CurrieroI. Coursac2000The National Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution Study.Part IIMorbidity and mortality from air pollution in the United States. The National Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution Study Part II: Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution in the United States. Morbidity and mortality from air pollution in the United States. The National Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution Study Part II: Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution in the United States.
- 10. Zanobetti A, Schwartz J, Samoli E, Gryparis A, Touloumi G, et al. (2002) The temporal pattern of mortality responses to air pollution: A multicity assessment of mortality displacement. Epidemiology 13: 87–93.A. ZanobettiJ. SchwartzE. SamoliA. GryparisG. Touloumi2002The temporal pattern of mortality responses to air pollution: A multicity assessment of mortality displacement.Epidemiology138793
- 11. Li N, Kim S, Wang M, Froines J, Sioutas C, et al. (2002) Use of a stratified oxidative stress model to study the biological effects of ambient concentrated and diesel exhaust particulate matter. Inhal Toxicol 14: 459–486.N. LiS. KimM. WangJ. FroinesC. Sioutas2002Use of a stratified oxidative stress model to study the biological effects of ambient concentrated and diesel exhaust particulate matter.Inhal Toxicol14459486
- 12. Nel AE, Diaz-Sanchez D, Li N (2001) The role of particulate pollutants in pulmonary inflammation and asthma: Evidence for the involvement of organic chemicals and oxidative stress. Curr Opin Pulm Med 7: 20–26.AE NelD. Diaz-SanchezN. Li2001The role of particulate pollutants in pulmonary inflammation and asthma: Evidence for the involvement of organic chemicals and oxidative stress.Curr Opin Pulm Med72026
- 13. Pourazar J, Mudway IS, Samet JM, Helleday R, Blomberg A, et al. (2005) Diesel exhaust activates redox-sensitive transcription factors and kinases in human airways. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 289: L724–L730.J. PourazarIS MudwayJM SametR. HelledayA. Blomberg2005Diesel exhaust activates redox-sensitive transcription factors and kinases in human airways.Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol289L724L730
- 14. Halliwell B (2003) FEBS Lett 540: 3–6.B. Halliwell2003FEBS Lett54036
- 15. Halliwell B, Whiteman M (2004) Br J Pharmacol 142: 231–55.B. HalliwellM. Whiteman2004Br J Pharmacol14223155
- 16. DETR (1999) "Assistance with the Review and Assessment of PM10 Concentration in Relation to the Proposed EU Stage 1 Limit Values". London.DETR1999"Assistance with the Review and Assessment of PM10 Concentration in Relation to the Proposed EU Stage 1 Limit Values"London
- 17. Allen AG, Nemitz E, Shi JP, Harrison RM, Greenwood JC (2001) Size distributions of trace metals in atmospheric aerosols in the United Kingdom. Atmos Environ 35: 4581–4591.AG AllenE. NemitzJP ShiRM HarrisonJC Greenwood2001Size distributions of trace metals in atmospheric aerosols in the United Kingdom.Atmos Environ3545814591
- 18. Iriyama K, Yoshiura M, Iwamoto T, Ozaki Y (1984) Simultaneous determination of uric and ascorbic acids in human serum by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography with electrochemical detection. Anal Biochem 141: 238–243.K. IriyamaM. YoshiuraT. IwamotoY. Ozaki1984Simultaneous determination of uric and ascorbic acids in human serum by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography with electrochemical detection.Anal Biochem141238243
- 19. Baker MA, Cerniglia GJ, Zaman A (1990) Microtiter plate assay for the measurement of glutathione and glutathione disulfide in large numbers of biological samples. Anal Biochem 190: 360–365.MA BakerGJ CernigliaA. Zaman1990Microtiter plate assay for the measurement of glutathione and glutathione disulfide in large numbers of biological samples.Anal Biochem190360365
- 20. Costa DL, Dreher KL (1997) Bioavailable transition metals in particulate matter mediate cardiopulmonary injury in healthy and compromised animal models. Environ Health Perspect 105: 1053–1060.DL CostaKL Dreher1997Bioavailable transition metals in particulate matter mediate cardiopulmonary injury in healthy and compromised animal models.Environ Health Perspect10510531060
- 21. Dreher KL, Jaskot RH, Lehmann JR, Richards JH, McGee JK, et al. (1997) Soluble transition metals mediate residual oil fly ash induced acute lung injury. J Toxicol Environ Health Part A 50: 285–305.KL DreherRH JaskotJR LehmannJH RichardsJK McGee1997Soluble transition metals mediate residual oil fly ash induced acute lung injury.J Toxicol Environ Health Part A50285305
- 22. Pritchard RJ, Ghio AJ, Lehmann JR, Winsett DW, Tepper JS, et al. (1996) Oxidant generation and lung injury after particulate air pollutant exposure increase with the concentrations of associated metals. Inhal Toxicol 8: 457–477.RJ PritchardAJ GhioJR LehmannDW WinsettJS Tepper1996Oxidant generation and lung injury after particulate air pollutant exposure increase with the concentrations of associated metals.Inhal Toxicol8457477
- 23. Hatch GE, Boykin E, Graham JA (1985) Inhalable particles and pulmonary host defense: In vivo and in vitro effects of ambient air and combustion particles. Environ Res 36: 67–80.GE HatchE. BoykinJA Graham1985Inhalable particles and pulmonary host defense: In vivo and in vitro effects of ambient air and combustion particles.Environ Res366780
- 24. Zielinski H, Mudway IS, Bérubé KA, Murphy S, Richards R, et al. (1999) Modeling the interactions of particulates with epithelial lining fluid antioxidants. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 277: L719–L726.H. ZielinskiIS MudwayKA BérubéS. MurphyR. Richards1999Modeling the interactions of particulates with epithelial lining fluid antioxidants.Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol277L719L726
- 25. Miller CA, Linak WP, King C, Wendt JOL (1998) Fine particle emissions from heavy fuel oil combustion in a firetube package boiler. Combustion Science and Technology 134: 477–502.CA MillerWP LinakC. KingJOL Wendt1998Fine particle emissions from heavy fuel oil combustion in a firetube package boiler.Combustion Science and Technology134477502
- 26. Fuller GW, Green D (2006) Evidence for increasing concentrations of primary PM10 in London. Atmos Environ 40: 6134–6145.GW FullerD. Green2006Evidence for increasing concentrations of primary PM10 in London.Atmos Environ4061346145
- 27. Harrison R, Deacon A, Jones M, Appleby RM (1997) Sources and processes affection concentrations of PM10 and PM2.5 particulate matter in Birmingham (U.K.). Atmos Environ 31: 4103–4117.R. HarrisonA. DeaconM. JonesRM Appleby1997Sources and processes affection concentrations of PM10 and PM2.5 particulate matter in Birmingham (U.K.).Atmos Environ3141034117
- 28. Deacon A, Derwent R, Harrison RM, Middleton D, Moorcroft S (1997) Analysis and interpretation of measurements of suspended particulate matter at urban background sites in the United Kingdom. Atmos Environ 203: 17–36.A. DeaconR. DerwentRM HarrisonD. MiddletonS. Moorcroft1997Analysis and interpretation of measurements of suspended particulate matter at urban background sites in the United Kingdom.Atmos Environ2031736
- 29. Imhof D, Weingartner E, Vogt U, Dreiseidler A, Rosenbohm E, et al. (2005) Vertical distribution of aerosol particles and NOx close to a motorway. Atmos Environ 39: 5710–5721.D. ImhofE. WeingartnerU. VogtA. DreiseidlerE. Rosenbohm2005Vertical distribution of aerosol particles and NOx close to a motorway.Atmos Environ3957105721
- 30. Gietl JK, Lawrence RG, Thorpe AJ, Harrison RM (2010) Identification of brake wear particles and derivation of a quantitative tracer for brake dust at a major road. Atmos Environ 44: 141–146.JK GietlRG LawrenceAJ ThorpeRM Harrison2010Identification of brake wear particles and derivation of a quantitative tracer for brake dust at a major road.Atmos Environ44141146
- 31. Birmili W, Allen AG, Bary F, Harrison RM (2006) Trace metal concentrations and water solubility in size-fractionated atmospheric particles and influence of road traffic. Environ Sci Technol 40: 1144–1153.W. BirmiliAG AllenF. BaryRM Harrison2006Trace metal concentrations and water solubility in size-fractionated atmospheric particles and influence of road traffic.Environ Sci Technol4011441153
- 32. Westerlund KG (2001) Metal emissions from Stockholm traffic—wear of brake linings. SL Infrateknik AB 3: KG Westerlund2001Metal emissions from Stockholm traffic—wear of brake linings.SL Infrateknik AB3
- 33. Doyle IR, Barr HA, Nicholas TE (1994) Distribution of surfactant protein A in rat lung. Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol 11: 405–415.IR DoyleHA BarrTE Nicholas1994Distribution of surfactant protein A in rat lung.Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol11405415
- 34. Sorme L, Bergback B, Lohm U (2001) Goods in the anthroposphere as a metal emissions source-a case study of Stockholm, Sweden. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution Focus 1: 213–227.L. SormeB. BergbackU. Lohm2001Goods in the anthroposphere as a metal emissions source-a case study of Stockholm, Sweden.Water, Air, and Soil Pollution Focus1213227
- 35. Harrison RM, Smith DJT, Pio CA, Castro LM (1997) Comparative receptor modelling study of airborne particulate pollutants in Birmingham (United Kingdom), Coimbra (Portugal) and Lahore (Pakistan). Atmos Environ 31: 3309–3321.RM HarrisonDJT SmithCA PioLM Castro1997Comparative receptor modelling study of airborne particulate pollutants in Birmingham (United Kingdom), Coimbra (Portugal) and Lahore (Pakistan).Atmos Environ3133093321
- 36. Isaksen I, Persson TA, Selin Lindgren E (2001) Identification and assessment of ship emissions and their effects in the harbour of Goteborg, Sweden. Atmos Environ 35: 3659–3666.I. IsaksenTA PerssonE. Selin Lindgren2001Identification and assessment of ship emissions and their effects in the harbour of Goteborg, Sweden.Atmos Environ3536593666
- 37. Huang X, Olmez I, Aras K, Gordon GE (1994) Emissions of trace elements from motor vehicles: potential marker elements and source composition profile. Atmos Environ 28: 1385–1391.X. HuangI. OlmezK. ArasGE Gordon1994Emissions of trace elements from motor vehicles: potential marker elements and source composition profile.Atmos Environ2813851391
- 38. Church TM, Arimoto R, Barrie LA, Dehairs F, Jickells TD, et al. (1988) The long-range atmospheric transport of trace elements:a critical evaluation. In: Knap AH, editor. The Long-range Atmospheric Transport of Natural and Contaminant Substances. the Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers. pp. 37–58.TM ChurchR. ArimotoLA BarrieF. DehairsTD Jickells1988The long-range atmospheric transport of trace elements:a critical evaluation.AH KnapThe Long-range Atmospheric Transport of Natural and Contaminant Substancesthe NetherlandsKluwer Academic Publishers3758
- 39. Pakkanen TA, Kerminen V-M, Loukkola K, Hillamo RE, Aarnio P, et al. (2003) Size distributions of mass and chemical components in street-level and rooftop PM1 particles in Helsinki. Atmos Environ 37: 1673–1690.TA PakkanenV-M KerminenK. LoukkolaRE HillamoP. Aarnio2003Size distributions of mass and chemical components in street-level and rooftop PM1 particles in Helsinki.Atmos Environ3716731690
- 40. Dalsoren SB, Eide MS, Endresen O, Mjelde A, Gravir G, et al. (2009) Update on emissions and environmental impacts from the international fleet of ships: the contribution from major ship types and ports. Atmos Chem Phys 9: 2171–2194.SB DalsorenMS EideO. EndresenA. MjeldeG. Gravir2009Update on emissions and environmental impacts from the international fleet of ships: the contribution from major ship types and ports.Atmos Chem Phys921712194
- 41. Capaldo K, Corbett J, Kasibhatla P, Fischbeck P, Pandis S (1999) Effects of ship emissions on sulphur cycling and radiative climate forcing over the ocean. Nature 400: 743–746.K. CapaldoJ. CorbettP. KasibhatlaP. FischbeckS. Pandis1999Effects of ship emissions on sulphur cycling and radiative climate forcing over the ocean.Nature400743746
- 42. Corbett JJ, Fishbeck P (1997) Emissions from ships. Science 278: 823–824.JJ CorbettP. Fishbeck1997Emissions from ships.Science278823824
- 43. Wessel A, Birmili W, Albrecht C, Hellack B, Jermann E, et al. (2010) Oxidant generation and toxicity of size-fractionated ambient particles in human lung epithelial cells. Environ Sci Technol 44: 3539–3545.A. WesselW. BirmiliC. AlbrechtB. HellackE. Jermann2010Oxidant generation and toxicity of size-fractionated ambient particles in human lung epithelial cells.Environ Sci Technol4435393545
- 44. Kelly F, Anderson R, Armstrong B, Atkinson R, Barratt B, et al. (2009) "Congestion Charging Scheme in London: Assessing its Impact on Air Quality"F. KellyR. AndersonB. ArmstrongR. AtkinsonB. Barratt2009"Congestion Charging Scheme in London: Assessing its Impact on Air Quality"
- 45. Nawrot TS, Kunzli N, Sunyer J, Shi T, Moreno T, et al. (2009) Oxidative properties of ambient PM2.5 and elemental composition: Heterogeneous associations in 19 European cities. Atmos Environ 43: 4595–4602.TS NawrotN. KunzliJ. SunyerT. ShiT. Moreno2009Oxidative properties of ambient PM2.5 and elemental composition: Heterogeneous associations in 19 European cities.Atmos Environ4345954602
- 46. Kunzli N, Mudway IS, Gotschi T, Shi T, Kelly FJ, et al. (2006) Comparison of oxidative properties, light absorbance, and total and elemental mass concentration of ambient PM2.5 collected at 20 European sites. Environ Health Perspect 114: 684–690.N. KunzliIS MudwayT. GotschiT. ShiFJ Kelly2006Comparison of oxidative properties, light absorbance, and total and elemental mass concentration of ambient PM2.5 collected at 20 European sites.Environ Health Perspect114684690