Olfaction is an important sensory modality for mate recognition in many mammal species. Odorants provide information about the health status, genotype, dominance status and/or reproductive status. How and when odor profiles change during sexual maturation is, however often unclear, particularly in free-ranging mammals. Here, we investigated whether the wing sac odorant of male greater sac-winged bats (Saccopteryx bilineata, Emballonuridae) differs between young and adults, and thus offers information about sexual maturity to potential mating partners. Using gas chromatography – mass spectrometry, we found differences in the odorants of young and adult males prior and during, but not after the mating period. The wing sac odorant of adult males consists of several substances, such as Pyrocoll, 2,6,10-trimethyl-3-oxo-6,10-dodecadienolide, and a so far unidentified substance; all being absent in the odor profiles of juveniles prior to the mating season. During the mating season, these substances are present in most of the juvenile odorants, but still at lower quantities compared to the wing sac odorants of adults. These results suggest that the wing sac odorant of males encodes information about age and/or sexual maturity. Although female S. bilineata start to reproduce at the age of half a year, most males of the same age postpone the sexual maturation of their olfactory phenotype until after the first mating season.
Citation: Caspers BA, Schroeder FC, Franke S, Voigt CC (2011) Scents of Adolescence: The Maturation of the Olfactory Phenotype in a Free-Ranging Mammal. PLoS ONE 6(6): e21162. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0021162
Editor: Thomas Burne, University of Queensland, Australia
Received: January 31, 2011; Accepted: May 20, 2011; Published: June 27, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Caspers et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was supported in part by a grant from the German National Science Council (to CCV: DFG; Vo 890/9), the National Institutes of Health (GM 53830), and the Boyce-Thompson Institute (to FCS). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Publication fee was supported by the Open Access Publication Fund of Bielefeld University.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Maturing animals do not only develop full reproductive performance, but also converge towards an adult phenotype. This process of maturation extends well beyond morphological and physiological changes , and also includes the olfactory phenotype . For example, many sexually selected scent glands are regulated by plasma androgen levels, and when individuals maturate, external glands may become activated and thus secret volatiles in response to elevated plasma androgen levels –. Age differences in odor profiles have been documented for a variety of mammals such as laboratory rats: –, mandrills:  and Asian elephants: . But how and when odor profiles change during sexual maturation remains often unclear, particularly in free-ranging mammals. We asked whether odorants of a free-ranging mammal encodes for information about sexual maturity, and if so, which volatiles are changing during sexual maturation.
Although bats are mostly known for their acoustical capabilities, they also possess a variety of scent glands (e.g. –) whose secretions are predominantly used in social contexts –. Here, we investigated the ontogeny of a chemical signal that is used for courtship displays in adult male greater sac winged bats, Saccopteryx bilineata, and, thus, most likely shaped by sexual selection. Males of the Neotropical greater sac-winged bat, Saccopteryx bilineata, possess a pouch in the wing membrane which is filled with an odoriferous liquid –. The wing pouches are free of any glandular tissue  and male greater sac-winged bats spend up to one hour each day cleaning the pouches and mixing the odorants from saliva, urine and gland secretion . Past studies have confirmed that, apart from acoustic and visual signals, courtship behavior of males includes predominantly olfactory signals . In addition, wing sac odorants of male S. bilineata represent a composite signal which encodes information about species , individual identity and season .
Saccopteryx bilineata has an annual reproductive cycle with a short mating season in early December –. Usually, females give birth to a single young in May or June. Reproductive success of sexually mature juveniles differs largely between males and females of the same age cohort (cohort members = CM). Whereas almost all female CM get pregnant in their first mating season at an age of about 6 months, only approximately 5% of male CM sire offspring at this age , indicating that, in contrast to females, most male juveniles do not reach sexual maturity at this early age.
We used gas chromatography and mass spectrometry to find out whether the chemical signal used by male greater sac-winged bats might encode information about age and/or sexual maturation. In particular, we analyzed the wing sac odorant of juvenile and adult males and asked whether the composition of wing sac odorants differ between juveniles and adults.
The composition of wing sac odorants differed between adult and juvenile male S. bilineata (Figure 1) prior (Juvenile = Juv: N = 5; Adult = Ad: N = 5; ANOSIM (age as factor): Global R = 0.32; p = 0.022) and during (Juv: N = 8; Ad: N = 16 ANOSIM: Global R = 0.37; p = 0.007), but not after the mating season (Juv: N = 6; Ad: N = 9 ANOSIM: Global R = 0.033; p = 0.3, see Figure 2a).
For reasons of graphic power, we averaged the samples over individual, age and week. The graph shows the weekly odor sample compositions (a) of juvenile (open symbols) and adult (closed symbols) male S. bilineata prior (circles), during (triangles), and after the mating season (squares) and the relative amounts of two male specific substances (b,c). The two-dimensional non-metric Multidimensional Scaling (nMDS) plot of odorant composition is based on the Bray-Curtis Similarity indices, i.e. the closer the samples appear on the plot, the more similar the samples are. The bigger the bubble is, the higher the relative amount of the specific substance. The orientation in a nMDS is arbitrariness and axes are dimensionless.
Age differences prior the mating season were mainly due to the absence of male specific substances, especially substance A and 2,6,10-trimethyl-3-oxo-6,10-dodecadienolide (Table 1, Figure 2b). These substances were only present in one out of five juvenile odorants (20%) prior the mating season. During the matiTable 2; Figure b,c). For odor profiles collected from males after the mating season, we found neither differences in the presence of substances nor in the amount of substances between the odorant of juveniles and adults.
During ontogeny, animals mature until they have reached the adult phenotype. While the process itself is widely recognized due to the accompanying morphological and physiological changes, the maturation of the olfactory phenotype remains largely unknown for most animals. Here we show that juvenile and adult male Saccopteryx bilineata differed in the composition of the wing sac odorants prior and during the mating period but not afterwards. In addition, we demonstrate that prior to the mating season, the majority of juvenile wing sac extracts lacked the male specific substances 2,6,10-trimethyl–3-oxo-6,10-dodecadienolide, substance A and Pyrocoll (Figure 2b,c).
During the mating season, these substances were present in most of the samples, however at smaller quantities. Two of these substances, namely 2,6,10-trimethyl-3-oxo-6,10-dodecadienolide and substance A are species specific . Since the presence of these compounds coincides with the time of sexual maturity, we infer that some, if not all of these substances may serve as cues for sexual maturity because they may be associated with androgen regulated glands. Testosterone levels are indeed higher in adult male Saccopteryx than in juvenile males that remain with their mother until their first mating season . In male S. bilineata, three likely candidates for scent glands are found in the facial region . These facial glands, particularly those of the mandibular region, contribute to the male wing sac odorant , , and we speculate that these glands may be androgen regulated like many sexually dimorphic glands of other mammalian species .
In laboratory rats, it has already been demonstrated that sexual maturity is signaled by the presence of a few specific substances . Osada and co-workers  showed that the urine composition of adult and prepubescent males differ significantly, due to the presence of specific volatiles. Additional behavioral experiments showed that urine containing these specific substances is more attractive to adult females, indicating that the composition of urine in male rats is used by females to gain information about sexual maturity.
Our behavioral observations and odor analyses suggest that the age at which male S. bilineata change their olfactory phenotype from adolescence to adulthood varies among individuals. With a few exceptions, the majority of male juveniles do not reach the olfactory phenotype during their first mating season. In most mammals, timing of maturation is influenced by intrinsic factors such as age, body size, or indirectly by body condition which is linked to environmental factors –. In some species, trade-offs occur between fitness-relevant components such as maturation and reproductive performance . Early maturation might ultimately result in early reproduction and thus in short term reproductive success, but in lower lifetime reproductive success, because of lower competitive ability . In the current study, two juvenile males took over a harem territory within their first year. Both males showed an adult like odor profile and one of the two even sired an offspring (Nagy pers. communication). These findings are consistent with an earlier study, which reported that approximately 5% of males sired offspring at the age of 6 month . Thus, only a small proportion of juvenile males reaches maturity and gains reproductive success during the first mating season. However, if reproduction is unlikely for juvenile males, it might be evolutionary stable to postpone reproduction until the likelihood of reproduction increases. Another explanation for the lack of adult odor profiles in juvenile males is that juveniles may also mask their gender to avoid excessive male-male competition during their first months in the natal colony.
Delayed maturation of morphological traits is a well documented phenomenon in birds –. In lazuli buntings (Passerina amoena) for example, male yearlings show a high variation of plumage coloration and males with a dull, female like plumage coloration or males with a bright, adult male like plumage coloration have a higher reproductive success than intermediate plumage colored yearlings .
Delayed maturation as a mechanism to avoid inbreeding  can probably be excluded, since greater sac-winged bats have female dispersal and the only close relative females in the colony are the mothers, which are still present the next mating season. It might be more likely, although at the moment very speculative that harem males suppress reproduction of yearlings to avoid competition, especially since most juveniles within the harem are sired by other males , .
Whether juveniles lacking the adult odorant are sexually immature or whether they merely avoid smelling like adults, i.e. follow a strategy of cryptic behavior, cannot be concluded with certainty from our data. But since the majority of juveniles do not sire offspring and have a distinct odor profile from adults, we assume that the presence of adult odorants coincides with sexual maturation and that females gain information about sexual maturity based on the wing sac odor profile. Olfactory cues are often by-products of every day metabolic processes and the process of sexual maturation in mammals is generally characterized by hormonal changes, leading to the assumption that chemical cues are probably difficult to manipulate and thus might be honest signals of sexual maturity.
Materials and Methods
Bat capturing and odor sample collection complied with the current laws of Costa Rica (Minesterio de Ambiente y Energia (Permission number: 135-2004-OFAU)). We captured the bats using nylon mist nets (Avinet, Dryden, USA, CH2, Mist Net) and collected odor samples directly at the site of capture. For odor collection, we wiped out the wing pouches with a piece of cotton wool. After odor collection the bats were released.
Study Site and Sample Collection
This study was conducted in the vicinity of “La Selva” Biological Station (10°25′ N. 84°00′ W) in Costa Rica (Province Heredia) administered by the Organization of Tropical Studies. We collected samples from September 2003 until January 2004, and November 2004 until March 2005 from four different colonies. We refer to the mating season as the period between the 50th and 52nd calendar week according to Voigt and co-workers –, . Samples collected prior to this period belonged to the pre-mating period and samples collected after this period belonged to the post-mating period. Since study colonies were part of a long-term project on the socio-biology of Saccopteryx bilineata, all colony members have been individually marked with colored plastic bands (AC Hughes LTD., Middlesex, UK, size XCL).
We captured bats between 0500 and 0600 hours when bats returned to the daytime roost or in the roost after their arrival (0600–0830 hours). For our study period, we categorized bats as subadults when they were born during the same year in which they were captured and all others as adults (older than 1 year). For a few individuals with unknown birth date, we assessed the age by the color and the structure of their wing sacs . In all cases, we collected as much liquid as possible by wiping out the wing sac with an odor free piece of cotton (Hartmann, Heidenheim, Germany, DIN 61640-CO, 100% cotton). For this, we twirled approximately 5 mg of cotton to a dapper (∼1 cm length, 0.3 cm width) and stored them in a Teflon-capped glass vial (2 ml, Rotilabo®, Karlsruhe, Germany). We washed and dried the cotton as well as the glass vial with dichloromethane (99.9%) before taking odor samples. All samples were stored in a freezer at –20°C until analysis. Each time we took a subsequent sample from the same individual, we altered between the left and right wing sac (i.e. right wing, left wing, right wing etc.) to guarantee that the odor profiles were not influenced by the previous sampling event. We added 100 µl of chemically pure dichloromethane (99.9%) to all samples for preservation. After odor collection, we released all bats at the site of capture.
We included 77 samples from 32 males in our study. All samples were analyzed by gas-chromatography and mass spectrometry (GC-MS) using a Hewlett-Packard 5890 GC equipped with a 30 m J&W (J&W Scientific, Folsom, CA) DB5-coated capillary column linked to a Hewlett-Packard mass selective detector (MSD; 70eV EI). Odor samples were extracted by squeezing out the cotton dapper using a blunt point syringe (50 µl, Hamilton®, Bonaduz, Switzerland). We transferred the extracts each into glass vials (2 ml, Rotilabo®, Karlsruhe, Germany), that were equipped with a 100 µl inlet (Rotilabo® , Karlsruhe, Germany). The extracts were concentrated by evaporation to approximately 5 µl before analysis. Data were collected under the following GC conditions: 1.5 µl split-less injection, chemically pure helium as the carrier, 60°C inlet temperature, 3 min initial time, 10°C/min rate, 280°C final temperature, 20 min final time. Mass spectra were analyzed and compared to library spectra or in case of species specific substances by spectra of authentic samples to identify substances and to determine the composition of wing sac odor samples. One male specific substance, indicated as substance A, has not yet been defined.
We quantified the variation of wing sac odor composition by analyzing 12 focus substances, which met one of the following criteria: they were either found to be male-specific, represented a fatty acid, or were identified as a steroid. In order to determine the male-specific substances, we compared wing sac odorants of adult males with odorants collected from the rudimental wing sacs of females. In addition to male specific substances, we used fatty acids and steroids for the analysis of odor maturation, because previous studies have already shown their biological relevance in social and sexual contexts of other mammal species . In all GC runs, we quantified the relative contribution (%) of peak area of each focal substance to the total peak area of all focal substances. This procedure guaranteed that all samples were comparable, since the total amount of wing sac odorant differed among individuals and among samples of the same individual.
We compared the odor composition by computing a similarity matrix based on the Bray-Curtis-Similarity Index  and analyzed potential differences between a priori defined groups (factor: age) using a non parametric analysis of similarities (ANOSIM, ). We averaged samples per individual in case of more than one sample per individual within a season group. In case of group differences, we ran the SIMPER routine to determine the discriminating variables. Statistical analyses were performed using PRIMER 6.1.12 (Primer-236 E 2000 Ltd., Plymouth, UK). The significance level was set to α = 0.05 and we used two-tailed tests.
We thank the Costa Rican authorities for allowance to conduct research and OTS for supporting our research. We also thank Kamran Safi and an anonymous referee for helpful comments on an earlier version of the manuscript.
Conceived and designed the experiments: BAC CCV. Performed the experiments: BAC. Analyzed the data: BAC FCS SF. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: FCS SF. Wrote the paper: BAC SF FCS CCV.
- 1. Sisk CL, Foster DL (2004) The neural basis for puberty and adolescence. Nature Neuroscience 10: 1040–1047.CL SiskDL Foster2004The neural basis for puberty and adolescence.Nature Neuroscience1010401047
- 2. Johannson BG, Jones TM (2007) The role of chemical communication in mate choice. Biol Rev 82: 265–289.BG JohannsonTM Jones2007The role of chemical communication in mate choice.Biol Rev82265289
- 3. Ebling FJ (1972) The Response of the cutaneous glands to steroids. Gen Comp Endocr: Suppl 3223–237.FJ Ebling1972The Response of the cutaneous glands to steroids.Gen CompEndocrSuppl 3223237
- 4. Ebling FJ (1977) Hormonal control of mammalian skin glands. In Dietland Müller-Schwarze. Maxwell M. Mozell (eds). Chemical Signals of Vertebrates 1. Plenum Pub Corp. pp. 17–33.FJ Ebling1977Hormonal control of mammalian skin glands.In Dietland Müller-Schwarze. Maxwell M. Mozell (eds). Chemical Signals of Vertebrates 1. Plenum Pub Corp1733
- 5. Mykytowycz R (1972) The behavioural role of the mammalian skin glands. Naturwissenschaften 4: 133–139.R. Mykytowycz1972The behavioural role of the mammalian skin glands.Naturwissenschaften4133139
- 6. Zhang J-X, Zhang Z-B, Wang Z-W (2001) Scent, social status, and reproductive condition in rat-like hamsters (Cricetulus triton). Physiol Behav 74: 415–420.J-X ZhangZ-B ZhangZ-W Wang2001Scent, social status, and reproductive condition in rat-like hamsters (Cricetulus triton).Physiol Behav74415420
- 7. Myers JS (1964) Stimulus control of mouse killing rats. J Comp Physiol Psychol 58: 112–117.JS Myers1964Stimulus control of mouse killing rats.J Comp Physiol Psychol58112117
- 8. Osada K, Kasiwayanagi M, Izumi H (2009) Profiles of volatiles in male rat urine: the effect of puberty on the female attraction. Chem Sens 34: 713–721.K. OsadaM. KasiwayanagiH. Izumi2009Profiles of volatiles in male rat urine: the effect of puberty on the female attraction.Chem Sens34713721
- 9. Setchell JM, Vaglio S, Moggi-Cecchi J, Boscaro F, Calamai L, et al. (2010) Chemical composition of scent-gland secretions in an old world monkey (Mandrillus sphinx): Influence of sex, male status, and individual identity. Chem Sens 35: 205–220.JM SetchellS. VaglioJ. Moggi-CecchiF. BoscaroL. Calamai2010Chemical composition of scent-gland secretions in an old world monkey (Mandrillus sphinx): Influence of sex, male status, and individual identity.Chem Sens35205220
- 10. Rasmussen LEL, Riddle HS, Krishnamurthy V (2002) Chemical communication: Mellifluous matures to malodorous in musth. Nature 415: 975–976.LEL RasmussenHS RiddleV. Krishnamurthy2002Chemical communication: Mellifluous matures to malodorous in musth.Nature415975976
- 11. Schaffer J (1940) Die Hautdrüsenorgane der Säugetiere. Urban & Schwarzenberg, Berlin & Wien. J. Schaffer1940Die Hautdrüsenorgane der Säugetiere.Urban & Schwarzenberg, Berlin & Wien
- 12. Quay WB (1970) Integument and derivates. In WA Wimsatt (ed.) Biology of bats. Vol. 2 Academic Press, New York. pp. 1–56.WB Quay1970Integument and derivates.In WA Wimsatt (ed.) Biology of bats. Vol. 2 Academic Press, New York156
- 13. Bloss J, Acree TE, Bloss JM, Hood WR, Kunz TH (2002) Potential use of chemical cues for colony –mate recognition in the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus. J Chem Ecol 28: 819–834.J. BlossTE AcreeJM BlossWR HoodTH Kunz2002Potential use of chemical cues for colony –mate recognition in the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus.J Chem Ecol28819834
- 14. Dechmann DKN, Safi K (2005) Studying communication in bats. Cognition, Brain, Behaviour IX: 479–496.DKN DechmannK. Safi2005Studying communication in bats.Cognition, Brain, BehaviourIX479496
- 15. Caspers BA, Voigt CC (2009) Temporal and spatial distribution of male scent marks in the polygynous greater sac-winged bat. Ethology. 115: 713–720.BA CaspersCC Voigt2009Temporal and spatial distribution of male scent marks in the polygynous greater sac-winged bat. Ethology.115713720
- 16. Caspers BA, Schroeder FC, Franke S, Streich JW, Voigt CC (2009) Odour based species recognition in two sympatric species of sac-winged bats (S. bilineata, S. leptura): Combining chemical analysis and odour preference tests. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 63: 741–749.BA CaspersFC SchroederS. FrankeJW StreichCC Voigt2009Odour based species recognition in two sympatric species of sac-winged bats (S. bilineata, S. leptura): Combining chemical analysis and odour preference tests.Behav Ecol Sociobiol63741749
- 17. Caspers BA, Wibbelt G, Voigt CC (2009) Histological examinations of facial glands in saccopteryx bilineata (Chiroptera, Emballonuridae), and their potential use in territorial marking. Zoomorphology 128: 37–43.BA CaspersG. WibbeltCC Voigt2009Histological examinations of facial glands in saccopteryx bilineata (Chiroptera, Emballonuridae), and their potential use in territorial marking.Zoomorphology1283743
- 18. Starck D (1958) Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Armtaschen und anderer Hautdrüsenorgane von Saccopteryx bilineata Temminck 1838 (Chiroptera, Emballonuridae). Gegenbaur morphologisches Jahrbuch 99: 3–25.D. Starck1958Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Armtaschen und anderer Hautdrüsenorgane von Saccopteryx bilineata Temminck 1838 (Chiroptera, Emballonuridae).Gegenbaur morphologisches Jahrbuch99325
- 19. Voigt CC, von Helversen O (1999) Storage and display of odor in male Saccopteryx bilineata Emballonuridea. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 47: 29–40.CC VoigtO. von Helversen1999Storage and display of odor in male Saccopteryx bilineata Emballonuridea.Behav Ecol Sociobiol472940
- 20. Voigt CC, Behr O, Caspers B, von Helversen O, Knoernschild M, et al. (2008) Songs, scents, and senses: sexual selection in the greater sac-winged bat, Saccopteryx bilineata. J Mammal 89: 1401–1410.CC VoigtO. BehrB. CaspersO. von HelversenM. Knoernschild2008Songs, scents, and senses: sexual selection in the greater sac-winged bat, Saccopteryx bilineata.J Mammal8914011410
- 21. Caspers B, Franke S, Voigt CC (2008) The wing-sac odour of male greater sac-winged bats Saccopteryx bilineata (Emballonuridae) as a composite signal. Chemical Signals of Vertebrates XI. (J. Hurst, R.J. Beynon, S.C. Roberts, and T.D. Wyatt eds.). Springer Verlag, Berlin, Germany. pp. 151–160.B. CaspersS. FrankeCC Voigt2008The wing-sac odour of male greater sac-winged bats Saccopteryx bilineata (Emballonuridae) as a composite signal.Chemical Signals of Vertebrates XI(J. Hurst, R.J. Beynon, S.C. Roberts, and T.D. Wyatt eds.). Springer Verlag, Berlin, Germany151160
- 22. Voigt CC, Schwarzenberger F (2008) Female reproductive endocrinology of a small tropical bat (Saccopteryx bilineata; Emballonuridae) monitored by fecal hormone metabolites. J Mammal 89: 50–57.CC VoigtF. Schwarzenberger2008Female reproductive endocrinology of a small tropical bat (Saccopteryx bilineata; Emballonuridae) monitored by fecal hormone metabolites.J Mammal895057
- 23. Greiner S, Schwarzenberger F, Voigt CC (2011) Predictable estrus timing of a small tropical mammal in an almost a-seasonal environment. Journal of Tropical Ecology 27: 121–131.S. GreinerF. SchwarzenbergerCC Voigt2011Predictable estrus timing of a small tropical mammal in an almost a-seasonal environment.Journal of Tropical Ecology27121131
- 24. Nagy M, Heckel G, Voigt CC, Mayer F (2007) Female biased dispersal and patrilocal kin groups in a mammal with resource-defence polygyny. Proc R Soc Lond B 274: 3019–3025.M. NagyG. HeckelCC VoigtF. Mayer2007Female biased dispersal and patrilocal kin groups in a mammal with resource-defence polygyny.Proc R Soc Lond B27430193025
- 25. Voigt CC, Streich JW, Dehnhard M (2007) Assessment of fecal testosterone metabolite analysis in free ranging Saccopteryx bilineata (Chiroptera; Emballonuridae). Acta Chiropterologica 9: 463–475.CC VoigtJW StreichM. Dehnhard2007Assessment of fecal testosterone metabolite analysis in free ranging Saccopteryx bilineata (Chiroptera; Emballonuridae).Acta Chiropterologica9463475
- 26. Stevenson IR, Bancroft DR (1995) Fluctuating trade-offs favour precocial maturity in male Soay sheep. Proc R Soc Lond B 262: 267–275.IR StevensonDR Bancroft1995Fluctuating trade-offs favour precocial maturity in male Soay sheep.Proc R Soc Lond B262267275
- 27. Trillmich F, Mueller B, Kaiser S, Krause J (2009) Puberty in female cavies (Cavia aperea) is affected by photoperiod and social conditions. Physiol Behav 96: 476–480.F. TrillmichB. MuellerS. KaiserJ. Krause2009Puberty in female cavies (Cavia aperea) is affected by photoperiod and social conditions.Physiol Behav96476480
- 28. Stearns SC (1976) Life history tactics: a review of ideas. Q Rev Biol 51: 3–47.SC Stearns1976Life history tactics: a review of ideas.Q Rev Biol51347
- 29. Stearns SC, Koella JC (1986) The evolution of phenotypic plasticity in life-history traits: predictions of reaction norms for age and size at maturity. Evolution 40: 893–913.SC StearnsJC Koella1986The evolution of phenotypic plasticity in life-history traits: predictions of reaction norms for age and size at maturity.Evolution40893913
- 30. Greene E, Lyon BE, Muehter VR, Ratcliffe L, Oliver SJ, et al. (2000) Desruptive sexual selection for plumage coloration in a passerine bird. Nature 407: 1000–1003.E. GreeneBE LyonVR MuehterL. RatcliffeSJ Oliver2000Desruptive sexual selection for plumage coloration in a passerine bird.Nature40710001003
- 31. Muehter VR, Greene E, Ratcliffe L (1997) Delayed plumage maturation in Lazuli buntings: test of the female mimicry and status signaling hypothesis. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 41: 281–290.VR MuehterE. GreeneL. Ratcliffe1997Delayed plumage maturation in Lazuli buntings: test of the female mimicry and status signaling hypothesis.Behav Ecol Sociobiol41281290
- 32. Pusey A, Wolf M (1996) Inbreeding avoidance in animals. Trends Ecol Evolut 11: 201–206.A. PuseyM. Wolf1996Inbreeding avoidance in animals.Trends Ecol Evolut11201206
- 33. Tannenbaum R (1975) Reproductive Strategies in the White-lined bat. PhD Dissertation. Cornell University. R. Tannenbaum1975Reproductive Strategies in the White-lined bat.PhD Dissertation. Cornell University
- 34. Burger BV (2005) Mammalian Semiochemicals. Topics in Current Chemistry 240: 231–278.BV Burger2005Mammalian Semiochemicals.Topics in Current Chemistry240231278
- 35. Clarke KR, Somerfield PJ, Chapman MG (2006) On resemblance measures for ecological studies, including taxonomic dissimilarities and a zero-adjusted Bray-Curtis coefficient for denuded assemblages. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 330: 55–80.KR ClarkePJ SomerfieldMG Chapman2006On resemblance measures for ecological studies, including taxonomic dissimilarities and a zero-adjusted Bray-Curtis coefficient for denuded assemblages.J Exp Mar Biol Ecol3305580
- 36. Clarke KR (1993) Non-parametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structure. Aust J Ecol 18: 117–143.KR Clarke1993Non-parametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structure.Aust J Ecol18117143