Inclusion body myositis (IBM) is a poorly understood and refractory autoimmune muscle disease. Though widely believed to have no significant humoral autoimmunity, we sought to identify novel autoantibodies with high specificity for this disease.
Plasma autoantibodies from 65 people, including 25 with IBM, were analyzed by immunoblots against normal human muscle. Thirteen of 25 (52%) IBM patient samples recognized an approximately 43 kDa muscle protein. No other disease (N = 25) or healthy volunteer (N = 15) samples recognized this protein.
Citation: Salajegheh M, Lam T, Greenberg SA (2011) Autoantibodies against a 43 KDa Muscle Protein in Inclusion Body Myositis. PLoS ONE 6(5): e20266. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0020266
Editor: John A. Chiorini, National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research, United States of America
Received: January 3, 2011; Accepted: April 28, 2011; Published: May 23, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Salajegheh et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was sponsored by the Muscular Dystrophy Association (grants MDA92561 to Dr. Salajegheh and MDA4353 to Dr. Greenberg) URL: http://www.mdausa.org/. No additional external funding was received for this study. The named funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Dr. Salajegheh, Ms. Lam and Dr. Greenberg report no further financial disclosures in regards to this study.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The inflammatory myopathies are autoimmune diseases of skeletal muscle, and consist of three major subtypes: dermatomyositis, polymyositis, and inclusion body myositis (IBM). Circulating autoantibodies have been detected in dermatomyositis and polymyositis (reviewed in ) and sought in IBM ; however, none have been reported as prominently present in, or specific to, IBM .
Since 1984 , IBM has been believed to be a cytotoxic T-cell mediated disease with no humoral autoimmunity. Microarray studies reported in 2001, surprisingly showed that the most abundantly present transcripts in IBM muscle samples compared to normal muscle were immunoglobulin transcripts, unique to the B cell lineage , . This finding led to the demonstration in IBM muscle of abundant plasma cells  with immunoglobulin gene rearrangements, characteristic of clonal expansion in response to local antigen stimulation , as well as the presence of a permissive environment for ectopic lymphoid structures suggestive of local maturation of B cells in muscle . The presence of this recently elucidated B cell immunopathogenesis provided rationale for searching for circulating autoantibodies.
In this study we report identification of a circulating autoantibody against a 43-kDa muscle autoantigen that is specific to IBM among other patients with autoimmune myopathies that we examined.
We performed immunoblots with plasma samples from 25 people with IBM, 25 people with other autoimmune muscle disease (10 dermatomyositis, 10 polymyositis, and 5 myasthenia gravis), and 15 healthy volunteers against normal human muscle lysates. While previous studies have probed myositis blood against proteins derived from non-muscle sources, such as those prepared from HeLa cells , we sought autoantibodies against proteins derived from human muscle.
Immunoblots against normal human muscle lysates of blood samples from 65 people showed reactivity to an approximately 43 kDa muscle protein in 52% (13 of 25) of IBM samples and in no other autoimmune myopathy or healthy volunteer samples (0 of 40; p<0.0001 Fisher's exact test) (Figure 1). The detection of a 43 kDa muscle autoantigen thus had a sensitivity of 52% and specificity of 100% for IBM among 50 patients with autoimmune myopathies. The approximately 43-kDa band was sometimes (8 of 13 of positive samples) associated with a fainter nearby band, that may be seen with post-translational modification or partial protein degradation.
Images from all immunoblots are shown. Reactivity is present in 13 of 25 different inclusion body myositis (IBM) plasma samples, but in none of 10 dermatomyositis (DM), 10 polymyositis (PM), 5 myasthenia gravis (MG) or 15 normal volunteer (NL) plasma samples.
IBM is a disease of middle to late age; our patients with IBM were therefore older (mean age 68 years) than patients with other autoimmune myopathies (mean age 48 years), but the presence of the anti −43 kDa autoantibody did not appear age-associated. The mean age of the 13 IBM patients with anti-43-kDa autoantibodies (67 years) did not differ from the mean age of the 13 oldest control patients, none of whom had anti-43-kDa autoantibodies (64 years; p = 0.21 Mann-Whitney test). Even within the group of IBM, age played no role in the development of anti-43-kDA autoreactivity, as the mean age of IBM patients with autoreactivity (67 years) did not differ from those without autoreactivity (69 years; p = 0.76 Mann-Whitney test). Disease duration was not different between IBM patients demonstrating 43 kDa autoreactivity (6 years) and those without reactivity (8 years; p = 0.6 Mann-Whitney test). Gender (p = 0.21) and race (p = 1.0) were also not associated with the presence of the 43-kDa autoantibody when comparing all patients studied (Fisher's exact test for both analyses).
Treatment status did not appear to affect autoantibody detection, even though most patients with IBM were untreated while most patients with DM and PM received immunomodulating therapy. Within the group of IBM, the proportion of antibody positive untreated patients (12 of 21) did not differ from that of antibody positive treated patients (1 of 4; p = 0.32 Fisher's exact test). Analysis of data of all untreated patients showed statistically significant development of autoantibodies in IBM (12 of 21) but not in other disease controls (0 of 7; p = 0.01 Fisher's exact test for both comparisons) despite lack of treatment. For the 16 IBM patients tested for anti-nuclear antibodies (ANA) there was no relationship between 43 kDa autoreactivity and a positive test for ANA (p = 1 Fisher's exact test).
Autoimmune muscle injury in IBM has been widely believed to be mediated by cytotoxic T cell mechanisms alone (reviewed in ). The demonstration of antigen-stimulated plasma cell antibody production  and now a circulating IBM autoantibody against a 43 kDa muscle protein provides compelling evidence for humoral autoimmunity in IBM. Because of the principal of linked recognition (B cell aided maturation of T cell requires that both B cell immunoglobulin and T cell receptor recognize the same molecular complex), antigens to which autoantibodies are directed may also be candidates for T cell directed autoimmunity. The modest sensitivity (52%) but very high specificity (100%) of this autoantibody, in our group of IBM and other inflammatory myopathy patients, is a feature shared by many other autoantibodies in myositis  .
While previous studies have reported an association between IBM and the presence of various autoantibodies, thus suggesting an autoimmune process in IBM, none have been identified as disease specific  and their prevalence is less than that seen with DM and PM     . In a review of 99 patients with sporadic IBM, 43 (44%) had elevated titers of one or more of nine different non disease-specific autoantibodies . While 8 of 16 (50%) of our IBM patients tested for autoantibodies where positive for ANA, there was no relationship between this positivity and the presence of 43 kDa autoreactivity.
The identity of the 43 kDa muscle autoantigen in IBM reported here, as well as its specificity to muscle tissue, remains to be determined. Technical aspects of myositis antigen identification have typically resulted in a several year lag between recognition of an autoantigen by its weight on immunoblots and its subsequent definitive identification. For example, recognition of a 140 kDa autoantigen in dermatomyositis  preceded its definitive identification as IFIH1 by 4 years . The eventual determination of this IBM autoantigen's identity may provide understanding of the pathogenesis of IBM and potentially aid in its diagnosis.
Materials and Methods
All samples originating from patients were derived after informed written consent was obtained and under protocols approved by the Partners Human Research Committee (PHRC), the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of Partners Research Management that is responsible for overseeing all human subject research conducted by Partners-affiliated investigators (such as Brigham and Women's Hospital).
Plasma samples from 25 patients with IBM (mean/range age 69/50–87 years), 25 patients with other autoimmune myopathies (mean/range age 48/24–91), and 15 healthy volunteers (mean/range age 52/34–62 years) were probed against normal human muscle lysates. Diagnostic criteria for IBM, dermatomyositis, and polymyositis were as previously described . In particular, all patients with IBM fulfilled European Neuromuscular Centre (ENMC) criteria for probable or definite IBM . All healthy volunteers were required to have been free of any infectious or inflammatory diseases, the use of immunomodulatory agents or vaccination at least for six months prior to collection of blood sample. Detailed description about patients and normal control characteristics, including age, gender, racial background, disease and diagnostic workup characteristics, treatment status, treatment response and 43 kDa muscle protein autoreactivity can be found in the supplemental tables (Table S1 and Table S2, respectively).
Preparation of gels and immunoblots
Muscle lysates were prepared and probed as previously described . Briefly, 5 mg of cryostat sectioned normal human muscle was dounce homogenized in 200 µl of lysis buffer (containing 10 mM HEPES, 10 mM KCl, 1 mM EDTA, 0.1 mM EGTA, 10 mM DTT, 5 mM MgCl2 and Roche Complete Protease Inhibitor) and centrifuged at 2,000 g for 10 minutes at 4°C. The supernatant was removed and 30 µg loaded in individual wells of 4–12% NuPAGE Novex Bis-Tris Gels (cat# NP0322BOX, Invitrogen). Proteins were separated using SDS-PAGE and transferred to a nitrocellulose membrane. We used human plasma (1∶1000 dilution) as primary antibody and goat anti human-IgG HRP (cat# 31410, Pierce Biotechnology, 1∶60,0000 dilution) as secondary antibody, both for 1 hour at room temperature. Blots were developed using the SuperSignal West Pico kit (cat# 34077, Pierce Biotechnology, 5 min, room temperature).
To demonstrate the presence of selective immunoreactivity against a 43 kDa muscle protein in plasma of patients with IBM, compared with disease controls and healthy volunteers, as well as determining the effects of gender, treatment, race and ANA positivity on such reactivity we used the Fisher's exact test. We used the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test to determine the effect of age and disease duration on plasma immunoreactivity against the 43 kDa muscle protein.
Patient characteristics for 25 inclusion body myositis (IBM), 10 dermatomyositis (DM), 10 polymyositis (PM) and 5 myasthenia gravis (MG) patients.
Conceived and designed the experiments: MS SAG. Performed the experiments: MS TL. Analyzed the data: MS TL SAG. Wrote the paper: MS TL SAG.
- 1. Mammen AL (2010) Dermatomyositis and polymyositis: Clinical presentation, autoantibodies, and pathogenesis. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1184: 134–153.AL Mammen2010Dermatomyositis and polymyositis: Clinical presentation, autoantibodies, and pathogenesis.Ann N Y Acad Sci1184134153
- 2. Dalakas MC, Illa I, Gallardo E, Juarez C (1997) Inclusion body myositis and paraproteinemia: incidence and immunopathologic correlations. Ann Neurol 41: 100–104.MC DalakasI. IllaE. GallardoC. Juarez1997Inclusion body myositis and paraproteinemia: incidence and immunopathologic correlations.Ann Neurol41100104
- 3. Hengstman GJ, Brouwer R, Egberts WT, Seelig HP, Jongen PJ, et al. (2002) Clinical and serological characteristics of 125 Dutch myositis patients. Myositis specific autoantibodies aid in the differential diagnosis of the idiopathic inflammatory myopathies. J Neurol 249: 69–75.GJ HengstmanR. BrouwerWT EgbertsHP SeeligPJ Jongen2002Clinical and serological characteristics of 125 Dutch myositis patients. Myositis specific autoantibodies aid in the differential diagnosis of the idiopathic inflammatory myopathies.J Neurol2496975
- 4. Engel AG, Arahata K (1984) Monoclonal antibody analysis of mononuclear cells in myopathies. II: Phenotypes of autoinvasive cells in polymyositis and inclusion body myositis. Ann Neurol 16: 209–215.AG EngelK. Arahata1984Monoclonal antibody analysis of mononuclear cells in myopathies. II: Phenotypes of autoinvasive cells in polymyositis and inclusion body myositis.Ann Neurol16209215
- 5. Greenberg SA (2001) DNA microarray gene expression analysis technology and its application to neurological disorders. Neurology 57: 755–761.SA Greenberg2001DNA microarray gene expression analysis technology and its application to neurological disorders.Neurology57755761
- 6. Greenberg SA, Sanoudou D, Haslett JN, Kohane IS, Kunkel LM, et al. (2002) Molecular profiles of inflammatory myopathies. Neurology 59: 1170–1182.SA GreenbergD. SanoudouJN HaslettIS KohaneLM Kunkel2002Molecular profiles of inflammatory myopathies.Neurology5911701182
- 7. Greenberg SA, Bradshaw EM, Pinkus JL, Pinkus GS, Burleson T, et al. (2005) Plasma cells in muscle in inclusion body myositis and polymyositis. Neurology 65: 1782–1787.SA GreenbergEM BradshawJL PinkusGS PinkusT. Burleson2005Plasma cells in muscle in inclusion body myositis and polymyositis.Neurology6517821787
- 8. Bradshaw EM, Orihuela A, McArdel SL, Salajegheh M, Amato AA, et al. (2007) A Local Antigen-Driven Humoral Response Is Present in the Inflammatory Myopathies. J Immunol 178: 547–556.EM BradshawA. OrihuelaSL McArdelM. SalajeghehAA Amato2007A Local Antigen-Driven Humoral Response Is Present in the Inflammatory Myopathies.J Immunol178547556
- 9. Salajegheh M, Pinkus JL, Amato AA, Morehouse C, Jallal B, et al. (2010) Permissive environment for B-cell maturation in myositis muscle in the absence of B-cell follicles. Muscle Nerve 42: 576–583.M. SalajeghehJL PinkusAA AmatoC. MorehouseB. Jallal2010Permissive environment for B-cell maturation in myositis muscle in the absence of B-cell follicles.Muscle Nerve42576583
- 10. Sato S, Hirakata M, Kuwana M, Suwa A, Inada S, et al. (2005) Autoantibodies to a 140-kd polypeptide, CADM-140, in Japanese patients with clinically amyopathic dermatomyositis. Arthritis Rheum 52: 1571–1576.S. SatoM. HirakataM. KuwanaA. SuwaS. Inada2005Autoantibodies to a 140-kd polypeptide, CADM-140, in Japanese patients with clinically amyopathic dermatomyositis.Arthritis Rheum5215711576
- 11. Greenberg SA (2007) Proposed immunologic models of the inflammatory myopathies and potential therapeutic implications. Neurology 69: 2008–2019.SA Greenberg2007Proposed immunologic models of the inflammatory myopathies and potential therapeutic implications.Neurology6920082019
- 12. Ghirardello A, Rampudda M, Ekholm L, Bassi N, Tarricone E, et al. (2010) Diagnostic performance and validation of autoantibody testing in myositis by a commercial line blot assay. Rheumatology (Oxford) 49: 2370–2374.A. GhirardelloM. RampuddaL. EkholmN. BassiE. Tarricone2010Diagnostic performance and validation of autoantibody testing in myositis by a commercial line blot assay.Rheumatology (Oxford)4923702374
- 13. Koffman BM, Rugiero M, Dalakas MC (1998) Immune-mediated conditions and antibodies associated with sporadic inclusion body myositis. Muscle Nerve 21: 115–117.BM KoffmanM. RugieroMC Dalakas1998Immune-mediated conditions and antibodies associated with sporadic inclusion body myositis.Muscle Nerve21115117
- 14. Brouwer R, Hengstman GJ, Vree Egberts W, Ehrfeld H, Bozic B, et al. (2001) Autoantibody profiles in the sera of European patients with myositis. Ann Rheum Dis 60: 116–123.R. BrouwerGJ HengstmanW. Vree EgbertsH. EhrfeldB. Bozic2001Autoantibody profiles in the sera of European patients with myositis.Ann Rheum Dis60116123
- 15. Gunawardena H, Betteridge ZE, McHugh NJ (2008) Newly identified autoantibodies: relationship to idiopathic inflammatory myopathy subsets and pathogenesis. Curr Opin Rheumatol 20: 675–680.H. GunawardenaZE BetteridgeNJ McHugh2008Newly identified autoantibodies: relationship to idiopathic inflammatory myopathy subsets and pathogenesis.Curr Opin Rheumatol20675680
- 16. Limaye VS, Lester S, Bardy P, Thompson P, Cox S, et al. (2010) A three-way interplay of DR4, autoantibodies and synovitis in biopsy-proven idiopathic inflammatory myositis. Rheumatol Int. VS LimayeS. LesterP. BardyP. ThompsonS. Cox2010A three-way interplay of DR4, autoantibodies and synovitis in biopsy-proven idiopathic inflammatory myositis.Rheumatol Int
- 17. Sordet C, Goetz J, Sibilia J (2006) Contribution of autoantibodies to the diagnosis and nosology of inflammatory muscle disease. Joint Bone Spine 73: 646–654.C. SordetJ. GoetzJ. Sibilia2006Contribution of autoantibodies to the diagnosis and nosology of inflammatory muscle disease.Joint Bone Spine73646654
- 18. Sato S, Hoshino K, Satoh T, Fujita T, Kawakami Y, et al. (2009) RNA helicase encoded by melanoma differentiation-associated gene 5 is a major autoantigen in patients with clinically amyopathic dermatomyositis: Association with rapidly progressive interstitial lung disease. Arthritis Rheum 60: 2193–2200.S. SatoK. HoshinoT. SatohT. FujitaY. Kawakami2009RNA helicase encoded by melanoma differentiation-associated gene 5 is a major autoantigen in patients with clinically amyopathic dermatomyositis: Association with rapidly progressive interstitial lung disease.Arthritis Rheum6021932200
- 19. Salajegheh M, Kong SW, Pinkus JL, Walsh RJ, Liao A, et al. (2010) Interferon-stimulated gene 15 (ISG15) conjugates proteins in dermatomyositis muscle with perifascicular atrophy. Ann Neurol 67: 53–63.M. SalajeghehSW KongJL PinkusRJ WalshA. Liao2010Interferon-stimulated gene 15 (ISG15) conjugates proteins in dermatomyositis muscle with perifascicular atrophy.Ann Neurol675363
- 20. Hoogendijk JE, Amato AA, Lecky BR, Choy EH, Lundberg IE, et al. (2004) 119th ENMC international workshop: trial design in adult idiopathic inflammatory myopathies, with the exception of inclusion body myositis, 10–12 October 2003, Naarden, The Netherlands. Neuromuscul Disord 14: 337–345.JE HoogendijkAA AmatoBR LeckyEH ChoyIE Lundberg2004119th ENMC international workshop: trial design in adult idiopathic inflammatory myopathies, with the exception of inclusion body myositis, 10–12 October 2003, Naarden, The Netherlands.Neuromuscul Disord14337345