A review of the current data on the cell density of normal adult human endothelial cells was carried out in order to establish some common parameters appearing in the different considered populations. From the analysis of cell growth patterns, it is inferred that the cell aging rate is similar for each of the different considered populations. Also, the morphology, the cell distribution and the tendency to hexagonallity are studied. The results are consistent with the hypothesis that this phenomenon is analogous with cell behavior in other structures such as dry foams and grains in polycrystalline materials. Therefore, its driving force may be controlled by the surface tension and the mobility of the boundaries.
Citation: Wörner CH, Olguín A, Ruíz-García JL, Garzón-Jiménez N (2011) Cell Pattern in Adult Human Corneal Endothelium. PLoS ONE 6(5): e19483. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0019483
Editor: Che John Connon, University of Reading, United Kingdom
Received: September 8, 2010; Accepted: April 7, 2011; Published: May 13, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Wörner et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: These authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Biological cell patterns are a contemporary theme of study, both for its intrinsic biological interest and also by their potential medical applications. Current research has been recently summarized  and lately, it is possible also to mention the works on the hexagonal packing of Drosophila wings  the results of on Drosophila retina , and a theoretical approach on geometric order in Drosophila imaginal discs .
Concerning the main theme of the present note, a concise treatment of the biology of the corneal endothelium appears in Bourne's review . It is a well established fact that corneal endothelial cells form a monolayer of mosaic-like cells, with two-dimensional tessellation on the posterior surface of the cornea. Also, it is well-known that its cellular morphological characteristics evolve with aging: some cells grow and others disappear. Polymegethism (cell size) and polymorphism (geometric cell parameters) are usually measured by optical microscopy. Several eye anomalies can be detected by a physical examination of this tissue, and therefore its “normal” characteristics need to be studied thoroughly.
The purpose of this note is to analyze the results of the increase in cell size in adult humans (or equivalently, the reduction in cell density) reported in the literature. It is important to note that results taken from different populations in diverse regions of the world are used, and also that the “normal adult eye” differs for these distinct populations depending on their geographical location. There is ample evidence for this last fact, as described, for example, by some recent papers , ; this would therefore imply that the endothelial cell characteristics also differ from place to place.
Being so diverse the sample population of the ten analyzed countries, our concern is to examine the rate of growth of the cell size. Therefore, it is the main proposal of this note to establish that the rate of increasing in the mean cell size shows similar behavior in all considered populations. In addition, it is suggested that this aging behavior is governed by capillary driving forces (surface tension) acting on the cell boundary.
With this goal in mind, we will examine evidence from other systems that present cell growth. Surface tension driven cellular patterns (by short, “foam-like” systems) have been studied in the current literature associated with grain growth in polycrystalline materials and cellular development in foams. Although there is not complete agreement in the way these complex systems evolve, recently, a theoretical treatment for two-dimensional grain growth in a stochastic framework has been proposed . Also, there are other proposed theoretical models . An appropriate vision of the “state of the art” on this matter appears in some seminal reviews -. On the other side, the Physics of foams have been comprehensively revised in a recent book  and reviewed in current works appearing in the literature , . As well, there have been approaches that simulate the grain growth behavior in polycrystalline materials by using soap froth patterns , .
Endothelial cell densities have been measured in adult humans by several research groups. There are results on the North American and Japanese populations ; Japanese data , Italian results , Iranian population , Pakistani data , Indian reports , and Phillipines . Also, it exists earlier results from American population , Danish records . Recently, Chinese data  and Portuguese measurements ,  had been published.
It is important to emphasize that the present note only refers to normal adult eyes. Although other cases are not considered, it is useful to state that there also exists substantial knowledge on the parameters of this cellular pattern for other types of population, i.e. children , animals  and also for abnormal endothelia . Obviously, the aforementioned references do not cover all the literature with reference to the important issue concerning non-adult human eyes.
In the following paragraphs, we analyze the evidence that support our proposal of a “foam-like” behavior for the endothelial cell pattern.
1. Morphology. There is a striking similitude between the endothelium cell pattern and other cellular, non-biological patterns appearing in different contexts. All these configurations also show aging, i.e. its properties vary according the elapsed time. Fig. 1 shows a typical endothelium pattern and a soap froth pattern. Both are two-dimensional tessellations and although the scales are different, the distribution of the cells appears to be very similar. Analogous patterns also appear in other scenarios, i.e. lipids, metals, ceramics, Potts model, iron garnet, cucumber, geography and cosmological models as remarked in the literature . In all these phenomena, the driving force for the growth of the cells is the interface properties of the boundaries (also called capillary effects), and their movement is governed by the surface tension and the mobility of these boundaries.
On right, a two-dimensional foam is shown. Note the similitude of the outlines and the difference in scale.
2. Hexagonallity. Further evidence of this similitude is the tendency to hexagonallity. In these patterns, cells tend to stabilize in a hexagonal structure, as stipulated by the so called Mullins-von Neumann law for two-dimensional area growth of a single cell , . This law states that a cell with more than six sides grows and a cell with less than six sides shrinks, with equilibrium being obtained by hexagonal cells, in accordance with the equation:(1)
In this equation, dA/dt is the growth rate of a cell with n sides and C is a constant involving a geometrical factor and the surface tension and mobility of the boundary. This law is in agreement with the prevalence of hexagonal morphology in endothelial cell patterns, a well documented fact in the current literature . It is to be stressed that the Mullins-von Neumann law is valid for individual cells, whereas measured growth kinetics usually refers to mean values (see Eq. 2).
3. Kinetics of growth. One of the more known experimental facts about the kinetics of these phenomena is the increase in mean cell size (or the corresponding decrease in cell density). This behavior appears also neatly in the analysis of soap froth domain growth  and grain growth in polycrystalline materials , , .
In order to further explore this analogous behavior, we will analyze the numerical values measured of this parameter. The mean cell size kinetics in aging -taken from the corresponding values reported in the current literature- is depicted in Fig. 2. (In some examples from current literature aging kinetics are reported in terms of cell density. In these cases, the data has been homogenized and represented in terms of the corresponding cell mean size.).
The data for the considered reports show a strong tendency to have a constant slope. They appear in a band bounded by the measured Iranian values at the upper side and the Japanese values at the bottom. Data from India, Pakistan, Italy, Denmark, China, Philippines and Portugal and both records from the USA may be grouped as a set of similar results. As previously mentioned, different behavior depending on geographical origin is to be expected.
As already mentioned, the data show dispersion. To better expose our argument, we plot in Fig. 3 the results corresponding to USA and Japan measured values. In each of these cases the data are obtained from two different independent works; USA data ,  and Japan data , . It is observed that a linear fit for each of these groups shows similar slope (1.2 µm2/year and 1.4 µm2/year, respectively) so supporting our assertion that each set of data show a linear behavior. There is not sufficient evidence to assert that all considered data fits with the same slope and only an estimate of the order of 1 µm2/year, may be stated.
Slopes for both cases are indicated in the figure.
This incremental behavior confirms a well established qualitative fact on the aging kinetics of endothelial cells, but it is necessary to stress that this result, for adult populations, shows proportionality with time (that is, the displayed experimental points show a common slope) This outcome is true irrespective of the choice of population included in the different research samples.
In other terms, the considered patterns follow the “parabolic law” (it scales with size squared). This fact is a well established result –,  on the kinetics of this type of patterns, and states that the mean area grows linearly with time, according to the equation,(2)
In this equation, R is the cell size, <R2> is a measure of the mean cell area at time t and <R02> is the initial mean cell area. The k-value represents the slope of the corresponding plot and therefore can be inferred from the displayed data.
4. Statistical distribution. There is not agreement of the shape of the cell size distribution for foam-like structures. As already noted , “…determining the distribution of surfaces and volumes while the foam coarsens remain a subject of active research”. In fact, only to mention a recent intent on this matter it is possible to study a just published paper and references therein . However, as show in the above mentioned literature, there is an ample accord in the statement that this distribution is scale-invariant.
In absence of a definitive answer to the question of the distribution function and for the purposes of this note we will use the log-normal distribution. There are solid evidence on this assumption in the corresponding literature –. With this assumption in mind, by using the photographic record already published  and data extracted from an existing paper , the cell distribution at the central endothelial zone was examined. These statistics were calculated from the 1516 cells appearing in a plate of Schimmelpfennig's paper and 1500 cases considered in the Stoker and Schoessler's work. Consequently, we depict in Fig. 4 a log-normal plot of the data, which shows an excellent fit with the experimental result. (r2 = 0.97; χ2/dof = 0.0002; note the positive skewness).
In summary, we have reviewed the data concerning entothelian cell growth. What's more, it is here proposed that the aging of cells in endothelial tissue follows the laws of the cellular two-dimensional patterns already studied in other structures, as suggested by its morphological structure, the linearity of the mean cell growth rate and the prevalence of cells with a hexagonal shape. Strong added evidence is given by the correlation shown in the analysis of the scaled statistical cell distribution. In other words, corneal epithelial cells form a foam-like system, restricted to the experimental evidence found in human adults.
The fitting of the data to linear forms is a consequence of the original already published data. The use of an exponential fitting -as suggested in some references- is a valid hypothesis only if we include infant patients. Data in humans , , ,  and mice  show experimental results. The rapid fall in cell density for children is clearly related with the growth of the cornea itself, that is, the pattern of cells has a more spacious growing environment. In the adult case, the size of the cornea is fixed and the cells have a limited space to grow. When we discard the data corresponding to infants, the linear relationship is recovered.
Perhaps, a comment on the evidence of different patterns in central and peripheral corneal zones seems in order. As already noted , , the shapes and distribution of the cells from these different zones give dissimilar (although not strongly different) morphological results. In the framework of the analogy with other patterns, it is possible to speculate that this effect is due to the boundary constraints caused by the finite size of the cornea. In other words, as cells grow, stagnation effects occur which are more significant in the border area. This braking effect has been well documented for thermal grooves in thin films  and in domain growth of soap froths and polycrystalline materials with quenched impurities , . Therefore, it is possible to assume that cell growth in the central endothelium corneal zone is analogous to “free” cell growth without constrains.
It is worth noting that these conclusions put a sound basis for a clever insight of Schoessler and Ornsborn . Referring to the aging of growth pattern, they wrote: “we believe…that a more likely explanation is that many cells are “shrinking” and others are expanding to fill in the space.”
As a final remark, it is a well know fact that endothelian cells do not replicate in-vivo (at least in the necessary amount to replace disappearing cells). Instead, they do reproduce in-vitro . The crucial point seems to be, why the reproductive behavior of these cells is different in an aggregate than in a single cell? We guess that this paper may offer a new perspective on this question.
As noted in the introduction section, data for cell densities in adult human endothelial cells were obtained from the literature –. Data for cell size fraction distribution (Fig. 4) were obtained from the works of Schimmelpfenning  and Stoker and Schoessler . These numerical results were processed by standard graphical and statistical software.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CHW AO JLR-G NG-J. Performed the experiments: CHW AO JLR-G NG-J. Analyzed the data: CHW AO JLR-G NG-J. Wrote the paper: CHW.
- 1. Lecuit T, Lenne P-F (2007) Cell surface mechanism and the control of cell shape, tissue patterns and morphogenesis. Nature Rev M Cell Biol 8: 633–644.T. LecuitP-F Lenne2007Cell surface mechanism and the control of cell shape, tissue patterns and morphogenesis.Nature Rev M Cell Biol8633644
- 2. Classen A-K, Anderson KI, Marois E, Eaton S (2005) Hexagonal packing of drosophila wing epithelial cells by the planar cell polarity pathway. Develp Cell 9: 805–817.A-K ClassenKI AndersonE. MaroisS. Eaton2005Hexagonal packing of drosophila wing epithelial cells by the planar cell polarity pathway.Develp Cell9805817
- 3. Hayashi T, Carthew RW (2004) Surface mechanism mediate pattern formation in the developing retina. Nature 431: 647–652.T. HayashiRW Carthew2004Surface mechanism mediate pattern formation in the developing retina.Nature431647652
- 4. Gibson MG, Patel AB, Perrimon N (2006) The emergence of geometrical order in proliferating metazoan epithelia. Nature 442: 1038–1041.MG GibsonAB PatelN. Perrimon2006The emergence of geometrical order in proliferating metazoan epithelia.Nature44210381041
- 5. Bourne WM (2003) Biology of the corneal endothelium in health and disease. Eye 17: 912–918.WM Bourne2003Biology of the corneal endothelium in health and disease.Eye17912918
- 6. Semes L, Shaikh A, Mcgwin G, Barlett JD (2006) The relationship between race, iris color, central cornea thickness and intraocular pressure. Optom Vis Sci 86: 512–515.L. SemesA. ShaikhG. McgwinJD Barlett2006The relationship between race, iris color, central cornea thickness and intraocular pressure.Optom Vis Sci86512515
- 7. Oliveira C, Harizman N, Girkin CA, Xio A, Tello C (2007) Axial length and optic disc size in normal eyes. B J Ophthalmol 91: 36–39.C. OliveiraN. HarizmanCA GirkinA. XioC. Tello2007Axial length and optic disc size in normal eyes.B J Ophthalmol913639
- 8. Pande CS, Cooper KP (2008) Self-similar grain size distributions in two dimensions: Analytical solution. Acta. Mater 56: 4200–4205.CS PandeKP Cooper2008Self-similar grain size distributions in two dimensions: Analytical solution. Acta.Mater5642004205
- 9. Rios PR, Glicksman ME (2008) Polyhedral model for self similar grain growth. Acta Mater 56: 1165–1171.PR RiosME Glicksman2008Polyhedral model for self similar grain growth.Acta Mater5611651171
- 10. Fradkov VE, Udler D (1994) Two-dimensional normal grain growth: topological aspects. Adv Phys 6: 739–789.VE FradkovD. Udler1994Two-dimensional normal grain growth: topological aspects.Adv Phys6739789
- 11. Thompson CV (1990) Grain growth in thin films. Annu Rev Mat Sc 20: 245–268.CV Thompson1990Grain growth in thin films.Annu Rev Mat Sc20245268
- 12. Weaire D, Hutzler S (1999) The physics of foams, Oxford University Press, Oxford. 245 p.D. WeaireS. Hutzler1999The physics of foams, Oxford University Press, Oxford.245
- 13. Glazier JA, Weaire D (1992) The kinetics of cellular patterns. J Phys Condens Matter 4: 1867–1894.JA GlazierD. Weaire1992The kinetics of cellular patterns.J Phys Condens Matter418671894
- 14. Villermaux E (2006) Two-hundred years of capillarity research. Phys Today 56: 39–44.E. Villermaux2006Two-hundred years of capillarity research.Phys Today563944
- 15. Wörner CH, Olguín A, Ortiz M, Herrera O (2002) Cell growth in a pinned soap froth. Phys Rev E65: 021404(1–4).CH WörnerA. OlguínM. OrtizO. Herrera2002Cell growth in a pinned soap froth.Phys RevE65021404(14)
- 16. Wörner CH, Olguín A, Ortiz M, Herrera O, Flores JC, et al. (2003) Final cell size distribution in a Zener pinned structure. Acta Mater 51: 6263–6267.CH WörnerA. OlguínM. OrtizO. HerreraJC Flores2003Final cell size distribution in a Zener pinned structure.Acta Mater5162636267
- 17. Matsuda M, Yee RW, Edelhauser HF (1985) Comparison of the corneal endothelium cell density and morphology in an American and Japanese population. Arch Ophthalmology 103: 68–70.M. MatsudaRW YeeHF Edelhauser1985Comparison of the corneal endothelium cell density and morphology in an American and Japanese population.Arch Ophthalmology1036870
- 18. Suda T (1984) Mosaic change pattern in human corneal endothelium with age. Jpn J Ophthal 28: 331–338.T. Suda1984Mosaic change pattern in human corneal endothelium with age.Jpn J Ophthal28331338
- 19. Roszkowska AM, Colosi P, D'Angelo P, Ferreti G (2004) Age-related modifications of the corneal endothelium in adults. Int Ophtal 25: 163–166.AM RoszkowskaP. ColosiP. D'AngeloG. Ferreti2004Age-related modifications of the corneal endothelium in adults.Int Ophtal25163166
- 20. Hashemian MN, Moghimi S, Fard MA, Fallah MR, Mansouri MR (2006) Corneal endothelial cell density and morphology in normal Iranian eyes. (1-5).BMC Ophthalmology 6: 9. MN HashemianS. MoghimiMA FardMR FallahMR Mansouri2006Corneal endothelial cell density and morphology in normal Iranian eyes.1-5BMC Ophthalmology 69
- 21. Ashraf KM, Saeed MU, Zia R (2006) Corneal endothelial cell density in a normal Pakistani population. Eye 20: 116–118.KM AshrafMU SaeedR. Zia2006Corneal endothelial cell density in a normal Pakistani population.Eye20116118
- 22. Rao SK, Ranjan SP, Fogla R, Gangdharan S, Padmanabhan P, et al. (2000) Corneal endothelial cell density and morphology in normal Indian eyes. Cornea 19: 820–823.SK RaoSP RanjanR. FoglaS. GangdharanP. Padmanabhan2000Corneal endothelial cell density and morphology in normal Indian eyes.Cornea19820823
- 23. Padilla MDB, Sibayan SAB, Gonzalez CSA (2004) Corneal endothelial cell density and morphology in normal Filipino eyes. Cornea 23: 129–135.MDB PadillaSAB SibayanCSA Gonzalez2004Corneal endothelial cell density and morphology in normal Filipino eyes.Cornea23129135
- 24. Yee RW, Matsuda M, Schultz RO, Edelhauser HF (1985) Changes in the normal corneal endothelial cellular pattern as a function of age. Curr Eye Res 4: 671–678.RW YeeM. MatsudaRO SchultzHF Edelhauser1985Changes in the normal corneal endothelial cellular pattern as a function of age.Curr Eye Res4671678
- 25. Möller-Pedersen T (1977) A comparative study of human keratocyte and endothelial cell density during aging. Cornea 16: 333–338.T. Möller-Pedersen1977A comparative study of human keratocyte and endothelial cell density during aging.Cornea16333338
- 26. Yunliang S, Yuqiang H, Ying-Peng L, Ming-Zhi Z, Lam DCS (2007) Corneal cell density and morphology in healthy Chinese eyes. Cornea 26: 130–132.S. YunliangH. YuqiangL. Ying-PengZ. Ming-ZhiDCS Lam2007Corneal cell density and morphology in healthy Chinese eyes.Cornea26130132
- 27. Gonzalez-Meijome JM, Jorge J, Queiros A, Peixoto-de-Matos SC, Parafita MA (2010) Two single descriptors of endothelian polymegethism and pleomorphism. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 248: 1159–1166.JM Gonzalez-MeijomeJ. JorgeA. QueirosSC Peixoto-de-MatosMA Parafita2010Two single descriptors of endothelian polymegethism and pleomorphism.Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol24811591166
- 28. Jorge J, Queiros A, Peixoto-de-Matos SC, Ferrer-Blasco T, Gonzalez-Meijome JM (2010) Age-related changes of corneal endothelium in normal eyes with a non-contact microscope. J Emmetropia 1: 132–139.J. JorgeA. QueirosSC Peixoto-de-MatosT. Ferrer-BlascoJM Gonzalez-Meijome2010Age-related changes of corneal endothelium in normal eyes with a non-contact microscope.J Emmetropia1132139
- 29. Müller A, Doughty MJ (2002) Assessments of corneal endothelial cell density in growing children and its relationship to horizontal corneal diameter. Optom Vis Sc 79: 762–770.A. MüllerMJ Doughty2002Assessments of corneal endothelial cell density in growing children and its relationship to horizontal corneal diameter.Optom Vis Sc79762770
- 30. Jun AS, Chakravarti S, Edelhauser HF, Kimos M (2007) Aging Changes of Mouse Corneal Endothelium and Descemet's Membrane. Exp Eye Res 83: 890–896.AS JunS. ChakravartiHF EdelhauserM. Kimos2007Aging Changes of Mouse Corneal Endothelium and Descemet's Membrane.Exp Eye Res83890896
- 31. Snellingen T, Rao GN, Shrestha JK, Huq F, Cheng H (2001) Quantitative and morphological characteristics of the human corneal endothelium in relation to age, gender, and ethnicity in cataract populations of South Asia. Cornea 20: 55–58.T. SnellingenGN RaoJK ShresthaF. HuqH. Cheng2001Quantitative and morphological characteristics of the human corneal endothelium in relation to age, gender, and ethnicity in cataract populations of South Asia.Cornea205558
- 32. Kim H-S (2010) von Neumann-Mullins equation in the Potts model of two-dimensional grain growth. Comp Mater Sci 50: 600–606.H-S Kim2010von Neumann-Mullins equation in the Potts model of two-dimensional grain growth.Comp Mater Sci50600606
- 33. Mullins WW (1956) Two-dimensional motion of idealized grain boundaries. J App Phys 27: 900–904.WW Mullins1956Two-dimensional motion of idealized grain boundaries.J App Phys27900904
- 34. Schimmelpfennig BH (1984) Direct and indirect determination of nonuniform cell densities distribution in human corneal endothelium. Inv Ophthalmo Vis Sci 25: 223–229.BH Schimmelpfennig1984Direct and indirect determination of nonuniform cell densities distribution in human corneal endothelium.Inv Ophthalmo Vis Sci25223229
- 35. Atkinson HV (1988) Theories of normal grain growth in pure single phase systems. Acta Met 36: 469–491.HV Atkinson1988Theories of normal grain growth in pure single phase systems.Acta Met36469491
- 36. Fisher FD, Svoboda J, Gamsjäger E, Oberaigner ER (2008) From distribution functions to evolution equations for grain growth and coarsening. Acta Mater 56: 5395–5400.FD FisherJ. SvobodaE. GamsjägerER Oberaigner2008From distribution functions to evolution equations for grain growth and coarsening.Acta Mater5653955400
- 37. Feltham P (1957) Grain growth in metals. Acta Met 5: 97–105.P. Feltham1957Grain growth in metals.Acta Met597105
- 38. Fátima-Vaz M, Fortes MA (1988) Grain size distributions: The lognormal and gamma distribution functions. Scripta Metall 22: 35–40.M. Fátima-VazMA Fortes1988Grain size distributions: The lognormal and gamma distribution functions.Scripta Metall223540
- 39. Humphreys FJ, Hathery M (1995) Recrystallization and related annealing phenomena, Pergamon, Oxford. 628 p.FJ HumphreysM. Hathery1995Recrystallization and related annealing phenomena, Pergamon, Oxford628
- 40. Stoker EG, Schoessler JP (1985) Corneal endothelial polymegathism induced by PMMA contact lens wear. Inv Ophthalmol Vis Sc 26: 857–863.EG StokerJP Schoessler1985Corneal endothelial polymegathism induced by PMMA contact lens wear.Inv Ophthalmol Vis Sc26857863
- 41. Armitage WJ, Dick AD, Bourne WM (2003) Predicting endothelial cell loss and long-term corneal graft survival. Ophthalmol Vis Sci 44: 3326–3331.WJ ArmitageAD DickWM Bourne2003Predicting endothelial cell loss and long-term corneal graft survival.Ophthalmol Vis Sci4433263331
- 42. Bourne WM, Nelson LR, Hodge DO (1997) Central corneal endothelian cell changes over a ten-year period. Ophthalmol Vis Sci 38: 779–782.WM BourneLR NelsonDO Hodge1997Central corneal endothelian cell changes over a ten-year period.Ophthalmol Vis Sci38779782
- 43. Amann J, Holley GP, Lee S-B, Edelhauser HF (2003) Increased endothelial cell density in the paracentral and peripheral regions of the human cornea. American J Ophthalmol 135: 584–590.J. AmannGP HolleyS-B LeeHF Edelhauser2003Increased endothelial cell density in the paracentral and peripheral regions of the human cornea.American J Ophthalmol135584590
- 44. Mullins WW (1958) The effect of thermal grooving on grain boundary motion. Acta Met 6: 414–427.WW Mullins1958The effect of thermal grooving on grain boundary motion.Acta Met6414427
- 45. Schoessler JP, Ornsborn GN (1987) A theory of corneal endothelial polymegethism and aging. Curr Eye Res 6: 301–306.JP SchoesslerGN Ornsborn1987A theory of corneal endothelial polymegethism and aging.Curr Eye Res6301306
- 46. Joyce NC (2005) Cell cycle status in human corneal endothelium. Exp Eye Res 81: 629–638.NC Joyce2005Cell cycle status in human corneal endothelium.Exp Eye Res81629638