The evolution of eukaryotic cells is widely agreed to have proceeded through a series of endosymbiotic events between larger cells and proteobacteria or cyanobacteria, leading to the formation of mitochondria or chloroplasts, respectively. Engineered endosymbiotic relationships between different species of cells are a valuable tool for synthetic biology, where engineered pathways based on two species could take advantage of the unique abilities of each mutualistic partner.
We explored the possibility of using the photosynthetic bacterium Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942 as a platform for studying evolutionary dynamics and for designing two-species synthetic biological systems. We observed that the cyanobacteria were relatively harmless to eukaryotic host cells compared to Escherichia coli when injected into the embryos of zebrafish, Danio rerio, or taken up by mammalian macrophages. In addition, when engineered with invasin from Yersinia pestis and listeriolysin O from Listeria monocytogenes, S. elongatus was able to invade cultured mammalian cells and divide inside macrophages.
Our results show that it is possible to engineer photosynthetic bacteria to invade the cytoplasm of mammalian cells for further engineering and applications in synthetic biology. Engineered invasive but non-pathogenic or immunogenic photosynthetic bacteria have great potential as synthetic biological devices.
Citation: Agapakis CM, Niederholtmeyer H, Noche RR, Lieberman TD, Megason SG, Way JC, et al. (2011) Towards a Synthetic Chloroplast. PLoS ONE 6(4): e18877. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0018877
Editor: David M. Ojcius, University of California Merced, United States of America
Received: February 3, 2011; Accepted: March 10, 2011; Published: April 20, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Agapakis et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was funded by grants from the Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering, the National Science Foundation, and the Synthetic Biology Engineering Research Center. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
While the evolution of cooperation and altruism are often seen as paradoxical events in the course of natural selection, endosymbiosis has been recognized as a driver of evolutionary change. Not only has gene exchange been observed between hosts and symbionts , but the development of communities suitable to new ecological niches  and even the origin of the eukaryotic kingdom hinge on symbiotic collaborations , . Modern endosymbiotic relationships between bacteria and eukaryotic organisms reflect a remarkable diversity in how widely disparate species can interact in positive ways, from nutritional symbiosis between Buchnera and aphids , to nitrogen fixation by Rhizobia in plant root nodules  and photosynthetic symbiosis between algal chloroplasts and sea slugs .
Cooperative behavior and symbiotic relationships are widespread in nature and have recently begun to be exploited in synthetic biological networks of increasing complexity . Multi-component synthetic-ecological systems have been developed for hydrogen production through metabolic engineering  and for the production of other useful metabolites . Communication between cells has also been engineered for multiple applications, including pattern formation  and oscillators . Engineered communities have also been useful as a generalized model of cooperation and competition in microbial populations ,  and two-species metabolic modeling has been used in the identification of cooperating variants of E. coli . While invasive bacteria have been explored as tools for synthetic biology and targeted tumor killing bacteria , neutral or beneficial endosymbiosis has not been pursued.
There is a fine line between the pathological and beneficial in natural endosymbiotic events. Many endosymbiotic relationships that exist in nature are hypothesized to have begun through the acquisition of resistance to predation— bacterial resistance to lysosomal digestion by amoeba after phagocytosis or eukaryotic resistance to bacterial infection after intracellular invasion . Replicating these events in the laboratory may lead to a partial endosymbiosis. Symbiosis is generally thought to refer to a mutualistic relationship where both partners benefit, but the term can be construed rather broadly; Lynn Margulis paraphrases de Bary's 1879 definition of symbiosis as simply the “protracted physical associations among organisms of different species, without respect to outcome.”  We explored three paths for entry of photosynthetic bacteria into animal cells that would satisfy this broad definition of symbiosis (figure 1)—direct microinjection into zebrafish embryos to explore the in vivo dynamics in a whole animal model, engineering with invasin from Y. pestis (inv) and listeriolysin O from L. monocytogenes (llo) to allow invasion of mammalian endothelial cells, and endocytosis of inv and llo engineered strains by macrophages. Invasin is a bacterial surface protein that interacts with mammalian β1-integrins and causes uptake of the bacterial cells, while listeriolysin O is a hemolysin that disrupts the endosomal membrane and allows bacteria to enter the mammalian cytoplasm post-uptake.
A.) Direct microinjection of S. elongatus into zebrafish embryos allow exploration of in vivo dynamics of bacteria inside animal cells. B.) Invasion of mammalian cells through heterologous expression of invasin and listeriolysin O. C.) Phagocytosis of bacteria by macrophages. Bacteria subsequently escape from the endosomal compartment through expression of listeriolysin O.
Invasive bacteria cause several deadly infectious diseases in humans, caused by intracellular pathogens such as Y. pestis, L. monocytogenes, and enteroinvasive E. coli . Recent work in biological engineering and synthetic biology has focused on the development of non-infectious but invasive and deadly bacteria that target and destroy only specific cell types for disease treatment, particularly cancer , or for delivery of peptide  or nucleotide based vaccines  and RNA interference gene therapy .
Macrophages can take up and phagocytose many different species of bacteria. However, most species of bacteria, including many pathogens, are unable to replicate in the cytoplasm of mammalian cells, and the precise mechanism of growth inhibition is unknown and a matter of controversy . In contrast, non-pathogenic Bacillus subtilis expressing heterologous hemolysin has been shown to escape phagosome digestion by macrophages and divide in the mammalian cytoplasm . However, microinjection studies have found that only those species that naturally divide in the cytoplasm were able to replicate upon injection into mammalian cells, with even intravacuolar pathogens unable to divide in the cytoplasm . To our knowledge, such experiments have not been attempted with photosynthetic bacteria or other autotrophs.
Nearly eighty years ago, photosynthetic algae were explored as symbionts for cells grown in tissue culture, as a method for renewing and replenishing growth media with oxygen and nutrients while removing waste products and carbon dioxide , . More recently, photosynthetic symbiosis in tissue culture was explored as a method for understanding the nutritional requirements of host and symbiont . We sought to explore the behavior of the photosynthetic bacteria Synechococcus elongatus inside eukaryotic cells as a platform for engineered photosynthetic endosymbiosis and found that cyanobacteria have little apparent effect on their host cells and can divide in the macrophage cytoplasm. Further engineering of metabolite production and secretion  in such endosymbiotic strains has the potential to lead to true mutualistic relationships between photosynthetic bacteria and mammalian cells, essentially creating artificial, engineerable, animal chloroplasts.
Materials and Methods
Cells and media
E. coli DH5α was used for all plasmid manipulation using standard procedures. S. elongatus PCC 7942 was cultured in BG-11 medium  at 30°C and illuminated by strong light. CHO and J774 cells were maintained using standard procedure in F-12 medium (Invitrogen) for CHO cells and RPMI 1640 medium (Invitrogen) for J774 cells. All media contained L-glutamine and were supplemented with 10% FBS (HyClone) and 1% Penicillin/Streptomycin Mix (Invitrogen). For culturing cells during infections outside of the controlled 5% CO2 atmosphere, Leibovitz's L-15 medium without phenol red (Invitrogen) was used for all cell lines, supplemented with 10% FBS for all cell types and 0.069 mg/ml proline for CHO cells.
Plasmids and DNA construction
The invasin gene from Yersinia pestis (inv) was subcloned from the pAC-TetInv plasmid  provided by Chris Voigt (University of California, San Franscisco) and listeriolysin O (llo) was amplified from Listeria monocytogenes genomic DNA provided by Heather Kamp (Harvard Medical School, Boston MA). Invasin DNA was amplified with primers adding a SpeI site upstream (5′-CGCAACTAGTATGGTTTTCCAGCCAATCAG-3′) and NotI and XbaI sites downstream (5′-CTGCAGCGGCCGCTAGCTCTAGATTATATTGACAGCGCACAGA-3′) Listeriolysin was amplified with primers adding a SpeI site, a ribosome binding site, and a short spacer for cloning downstream of invasin (5′-CGCAACTAGTAGGAGGAAAAACATATGAAAAAAATAATGCTAGTTTT-3′) and NotI and XbaI site downstream (5′-CTGCAGCGGCCGCTTCTAGATTATTCGATTGGATTATCTA-3′). Invasin and listeriolysin were then sequentially subcloned into the pNS3 vector for homologous recombination into Synechococcus neutral site 3 .
The pNS3-invllo vector was incubated overnight in the dark with a culture of S. elongatus PCC 7942 cells washed in 10 mM NaCl, and integration into the neutral site was selected using BG11 plates containing 1.5% Noble Agar and 12.5 µg/ml chloramphenicol. Expression of invasin and listeriolysin was induced with 100 µM IPTG for 24 hours.
Zebrafish embryos in the one-cell stage were injected with a solution containing mRNA for expression of membrane GFP (mGFP) and bacteria. Needles were pulled on a Sutter P2000 laser needle puller from Drummond glass capillary tubes. Eggs were injected with 2.3 nl of injection solution using a Nanoject. The injection solution consisted of injection buffer (50 mM NaCl, 1 mM Tris pH 8, 0.1 mM EDTA and 0.1% Phenol Red) and contained 40 ng of mGFP mRNA and 1 µl of a saturated bacterial suspension per 10 µl of injection solution. The bacterial suspension (S. elongatus or E. coli) was prepared by spinning down 1 ml of an overnight E. coli culture or a dense 24–48 h old, exponentially growing S. elongatus culture. The cells were resuspended in 1 ml of injection buffer without Phenol Red and again pelleted. The supernatant was removed; the cells were mixed and always used fresh for the injections.
Embryos were raised in egg water (0.3 g/L Instant Ocean, 75 mg/L CaSO4) slightly shaded from the light in the cyanobacterial incubator at 30°C. Egg water was changed as needed. To follow individual embryos over time, the embryos were separated from each other in 12-well plates.
Development of the embryos injected with bacteria was monitored with a fluorescence dissecting microscope. For confocal imaging the embryos were dechorionated and placed in imaging molds made from 1% (w/v) agarose in egg water. Mounted embryos were imaged in an upright Zeiss LSM 710 confocal microscope. The embryo was submerged in eggwater containing 1× Tricaine solution (10× Tricaine solution: 0.1% (w/v) Tricaine and 10 mM Tris in egg water adjusted to pH 7 with NaOH) for anesthetization.
All of our zebrafish protocols were approved by the Harvard Medical School (HMS) Office for Research Subject Protection and the HMS Standing Committee on Animals (IACUC Approval Number 04487).
Mammalian cell invasion assay
For infections of mammalian cells with bacteria, induced bacteria were washed and transferred from their culture medium into PBS (137 mM NaCl, 2.7 mM KCl, 10 mM Na2HPO4, 2 mM KH2PO4). Bacterial suspensions in PBS were set to the same OD and 100 µl of this suspension were added per 2 ml of cell culture medium per well of 12-well tissue culture dishes containing the mammalian cells. L-15 medium during the infection did not contain antibiotics. After the treatment of the cells with S. elongatus for 3 hours to overnight, the cells were washed with PBS three times and the medium was replaced by L-15 containing 100 µg/ml gentamicin, an antibiotic that does not cross the mammalian cell membrane. During and after infections of the mammalian cells with bacteria, the cultures were kept at 30°C in atmospheric CO2 levels. For S. elongatus, cells were illuminated with fluorescent lamps from both sides of the tissue culture plate.
For time-course of S. elongatus infection in macrophages, 10,000 J774 cells were plated per well of a 96-well plate in L-15 media and were allowed to attach to the bottom overnight at 37°C in the dark. Following attachment, 10 microliters of wild type or inv/llo engineered S. elongatus diluted to OD750 of 0.025–0.4 in PBS (corresponding to approximately <1 bacteria per macrophage to >4 bacteria per macrophage) were added to each well and incubated at 30°C in the light for six hours. Each well was then washed in PBS and the media was replaced with L-15 containing 100 µg/ml gentamicin and plates were incubated at 30°C in the light. One plate was removed every 24 hours and cells were fixed in 3% paraformaldehyde, cells were permeablized in 0.01% Triton-X in PBS and stained with DAPI. Plates were stored at 4°C in the dark and imaged at the same time using fluorescence microscopy.
FACS analysis of mammalian cells with intracellular bacteria
After 24 hour infection, CHO cells were washed in PBS, trypsinized, and resuspended in FACS buffer (PBS supplemented with 1%FBS). Cells were sorted with a BD FACSAria cell sorter based on red channel fluorescence. Cells positive for red fluorescence were gently reattached to glass-bottomed tissue culture dishes with concanavalin A and imaged with confocal microscopy.
Zebrafish embryos injected with S. elongatus hatch and thrive
Photosynthetic symbiosis exists in several underwater species, such as the sea slug Elysia chlorotica, which incorporates the chloroplasts from algae that it feeds on into the cells of its intricately branched digestive system, allowing it to survive for months photoautotrophically . While such a complex symbiotic relationship likely evolved over much longer time scales, we were interested in replicating the first step of an underwater photosynthetic symbiosis and exploring the in vivo dynamics of photosynthetic bacteria in a developing animal. We chose zebrafish embryos as they are easy to microinject, well studied, and are clear, allowing light to penetrate.
Up to ten million bacteria were injected into zebrafish embryos at the single cell stage to track the relationship between the vertebrate and bacterial cells through development. Red autofluorescent bacteria were found intracellularly throughout the embryo during development, including in the brain and even the lens of the eye (figure 2A–D) with no discernible morphological effects. Synechococcus survived inside the embryo's cells for up to twelve days based on continued red autofluorescence (figure 2F), at which time the experiment was terminated as the fish began to develop pigment that would block light to the intracellular bacteria.
Single optical slice confocal microscopy images of the anterior of the zebrafish embryo at A.) Day 1 post injection, B.) Day 2, C.) Day 3, D.) Day 4, and dissecting microscope images of embryos E.) Day 8, F.) Day 12 post injection. Zebrafish cell membranes are outlined in green, with red autofluorescent bacteria visible in cells throughout the embryo, including the eye (yellow arrows) and brain (white arrows). Red autofluorescence gradually decreased over the course of experimental observations, but remained visible in the brain of the young zebrafish even after 12 days.
In stark contrast, injecting E. coli cells killed the embryo within two hours (figure 3B). This rapid death occurred even when the E. coli were UV killed prior to injection (figure 3C) and when the Lipid A production was attenuated by deletion of msbB (figure 3D), a modification shown to decrease incidence of septic shock by tumor-targeting Salmonella . These data point to other surface markers that can cause the death seen in the E. coli injected embryos and a benign role for the non-pathogenic S. elongatus in vivo.
A.) Zebrafish embryo two hours after injection of S. elongatus. Cells appear red due to phenol red present in the injection buffer. B.) Injection of E. coli led to drastic morphological changes in the embryo after two hours, and this change was observed with E. coli cells that were C.) UV killed, or D.) ΔmsbB mutants.
Synechococcus expressing invasin and listeriolysin invade mammalian cells
We also sought to explore a more physiological model of intracellular invasion than direct microinjection. The bacterial virulence factors encoding mammalian cell invasion—invasin from Yersinia pestis —and escape from the lysosomal compartment—listeriolysin O from Listeria monocytogenes  have been identified, cloned, and shown to confer invasive behavior to non-pathogenic bacterial species. We inserted invasin and listeriolysin as a tandem operon in S. elongatus neutral site 3  and incubated induced S. elongatus cells with CHO cells at 50%–80% confluence overnight at 30°C in bright light.
While expression of invasin alone is sufficient for high efficiency invasion by E. coli for multiple mammalian cell types in culture (HeLa, U2OS, HepG2, CHO ), expression of both invasin and listeriolysin was required for invasion of CHO cells by S. elongatus, a result previously reported for engineered E. coli cells invading colon cancer cells . The invasion efficiency was such that 4.8% of mammalian cells were positive for the red channel autofluorescence from intracellular photosynthetic bacteria as measured by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) analysis (figure 4A). Sorted cells were imaged with confocal microscopy (figure 4B), confirming intracellular localization with approximately one bacterial cell per CHO cell analyzed.
A.) S. elongatus engineered with invasin and listeriolysin are able to invade CHO cells at a higher efficiency than S. elongatus harboring the empty vector or invasin alone. Cells positive for red fluorescence were sorted by FACS and B.) observed under confocal microscopy, showing intracellular localization of at least one bacterial cell per CHO cell in the majority of the cells observed.
Replication inside mammalian macrophages
Bacteria can also enter cells through phagocytosis, and escaping digestion by the lysosome is a prerequisite for pathogenic and symbiotic growth. Macrophages are a crucial part of the mammalian immune system, seeking out, engulfing and digesting foreign bodies and bacteria. The immortal mouse macrophage cell line J774 will quickly engulf large numbers of bacterial cells in culture. We therefore incubated plates of 50% confluent macrophages with varying concentrations of bacterial cells for one hour at 37°C for E. coli and six hours at 30°C for S. elongatus. As with zebrafish embryos, engulfed E. coli cells will quickly kill their host macrophages (figure 5A), while even high numbers of S. elongatus cells will remain inside J774 for several days with relatively little effect.
Large scale granulation is observed when macrophages take up E. coli that is A.) not expressing llo and to an even greater extent with B.) E. coli expressing llo off of the inducible lac promoter of the pNS3 vector. In contrast, macrophages displayed similar morphology two days after infection with C.) empty vector S. elongatus, D.) S. elongatus expressing inv and llo, and E.) macrophages untreated with bacteria but maintained at 30°C in bright light for two days.
E. coli highly expressing listeriolysin were observed to kill macrophages faster than wild type E. coli (figure 5B). However, after two days of incubation with Synechococcus, similar levels of cell death were observed in macrophages with Synechococcus with only the empty vector integrated (figure 5C), those expressing invasin and listeriolysin (figure 5D), and with macrophages without any bacteria (figure 5E).
Non-pathogenic bacteria that have been engineered with listeriolysin O to escape the macrophage endosome have been shown to replicate in the cytoplasm . However, there are many factors in the mammalian cytoplasm speculated to be involved in preventing bacterial growth, a fact suggested by the extremely small number of intracellular pathogens able to divide in the presumably nutrient-rich cytoplasm . S. elongatus requires little external metabolic input and grows at a relatively fast rate at intracellular carbon dioxide concentrations (one division every 8–12 hours). In addition, as we have shown (above) S. elongatus has a special relationship to eukaryotic antimicrobial systems as it is able to peacefully coexist with animal cells. As such, it is expected that S. elongatus engineered with listeriolysin O will be able to divide in the mammalian cytoplasm.
In the dark, S. elongatus phogocytosed by macrophages will rapidly lose red channel autofluorescence over the course of 12 hours, indicating death (figure 6A). In the light, wild type S. elongatus autofluorescence will more slowly decrease in intensity over several days (figure 6B, top row). S. elongatus engineered with invasin and listeriolysin, able to escape lysosome digestion, showed marked increase in autofluorescence in the first two days post-infection, with the number of autofluorescent bacteria decreasing only after 3 days (figure 6B, bottom row).
A.) Time lapse microscopy of macrophages infected with +inv+llo S. elongatus kept in the dark shows the gradual decrease in red autofluorescence over the course of 12 hours. In contrast, when kept in the light, B.) empty vector S. elongatus autofluorescence is observed to gradually decrease over the course of several days (top row), while a significant increase in red S. elongatus autofluorescence was observed in macrophages infected with inv llo S. elongatus for two days post-infection (bottom row). This fluorescence was observed to decrease after the third day of infection. C.) This change in fluorescence over time can be quantified as a change in background subtracted mean fluorescence in ImageJ and averaged over triplicate experiments. Empty vector (blue line) and +inv+llo S. elongatus (red line) show marked differences in growth when infected at similar densities of 1–2 bacterial cells per macrophage. D.) +inv+llo S. elongatus displayed infection density dependent growth rates in macrophages. Each line shows change in mean fluorescence in cells infected at a single starting density, ranging in multiples of two from fewer than one cell per macrophage to approximately 4 bacteria per macrophage. E.) Macrophage cell counts were variable across replicates and over the course of the experiment but displayed no significant difference between macrophages infected with empty vector S. elongatus at low (green line) or high density (blue line), or +inv+llo S. elongatus at low (red line) or high (yellow line) density. F.) When infected at low density of fewer than one bacteria per macrophage, S. elongatus division was observed during 18 hour time-lapse fluorescent microscopy in approximately 1% of macrophages observed, in particular those cells that contained more than one bacterial cell due to stochastic fluctuations.
The rate of division in the macrophage cytoplasm was quantified for varying densities of S. elongatus in 96 well plates. Mean, background subtracted fluorescence was averaged for triplicate infections. At similar starting density of approximately 2 bacteria per macrophage, there is marked contrast between empty vector (blue) and +inv+llo (red) S. elongatus (figure 6C). Rates of division in the engineered strain were correlated to S. elongatus infection densities. At the lowest concentrations, with fewer than one bacterial cell per macrophage, the engineered strain is digested more slowly than wild type S. elongatus, but does not show large-scale evidence of division, but as infection density is doubled, the rate of growth increases and begins to level off at the highest density (1–4 bacteria per macrophage, figure 6D). Differences in S. elongatus growth did not correlate with decrease in macrophage cell counts over time, which remained variable but consistent between wells at different infection densities over time (figure 6E). Even at the lowest infection density, +inv+llo S. elongatus division was observed in approximately 1% of cells tracked with time-lapse microscopy (figure 6F).
Complex relationships between many different species of organisms characterize the biological world, but the details of these symbiotic relationships have proven difficult to untangle through reductionist experimentation. Simplified, engineered multi-species relationships can provide a framework for studying natural symbiotic relationships . We show that photosynthetic bacteria can be engineered to invade and divide inside mammalian cells for use as a platform for further engineering or study of evolutionary dynamics of endosymbiosis.
A synthetic approach to photosynthetic mutualism in animal tissue culture has been attempted previously many years ago, with mixed populations of algae and animal cells showing gas and nutrient exchange in culture , , . More recently, amoeba infected with a naturally occurring parasitic bacteria and carefully cultivated over several years eventually became dependent on the bacterial symbiont, showing that endosymbiosis can be established quite rapidly under the right conditions .
Natural endosymbiosis between photosynthetic organisms and animal species occurs in many marine species such as corals and sponges, whose simple body plans and high surface-to-volume ratios make such associations valuable . While these marine photosymbioses have been studied for many years, the first evidence of a facultative photosynthetic endosymbiosis in vertebrates was only recently discovered between the embryo of the spotted salamander and green algae . Algal-salamander associations had previously been observed extracellularly , with gas exchange between the algae and salamander shown to be beneficial but not required for the developing embryo . These newly discovered intracellular interactions occur only in the embryo, with algae dying by the time the larvae begins to feed and no evidence of vertical transmission from the underground-dwelling adult salamander.
Such natural events show how rare bacterial-vertebrate endosymbiosis is, as well as how benign photosynthetic associations can be when they are established. We used a synthetic approach to developing photosynthetic associations with animal cells, finding that injecting S. elongatus into the zebrafish embryo does not affect fish development. As in the natural endosymbiosis, the photosynthetic cells slowly died, but remained in the animal for several weeks.
There are no known mammalian endosymbioses, and the mammalian cytoplasmic environment also remains poorly studied, with little understood about virulence factors that promote pathogenic intracellular growth in the handful of bacterial species able to replicate in the mammalian cytoplasm or mammalian factors that prevent growth and target bacterial pathogens for destruction . Furthermore, while our understanding of microbial metabolism in isolated pure cultures is deep for commonly studied organisms, the metabolism of bacterial communities is currently probed primarily through metagenomics techniques that remain limited . The metabolism of symbiotic bacteria or pathogens living in vivo is likewise poorly characterized, with evidence that in vivo metabolism differs significantly from that in pure laboratory culture .
Intracellular pathogens and symbionts alike must be able to take nutrients from their cellular hosts. Genes such as Hpt, the glucose-6-phosphate translocase from L. monocytogenes, allow for assimilation of host sugars . Studies with auxotrophic strains of L. monocytogenes show the extent of the external metabolic requirement for intracellular division , , . In contrast, S. elongatus requires very little input from its external environment besides light, carbon dioxide, and a small number of salts and minerals . This minimal requirement may be central to our observation that photosynthetic bacteria can replicate inside the macrophage. Indeed, non-pathogenic photosynthetic autotrophs seem to have a privileged relationship with eukaryotic cells, able to coexist and even grow inside with relatively little damage to the host cell compared to even non-virulent E. coli.
Engineering a mutualistic metabolic endosymbiosis remains extremely difficult due to the sheer metabolic requirement of immortalized cells in culture. Based on concentrations of glucose and fructose secreted by engineered strains of S. elongatus  we estimate that each CHO cell would require on the order of 25 cyanobacterial cells to sustain growth, and J774 macrophages would require approximately 14,000 bacteria per cell to provide adequate glucose supply, numbers significantly higher than those observed in our experimental analysis. Relationships based on other secreted metabolites, small molecules, or enzymes may prove to be adequate for establishing an engineered mutualism. Additionally, improvements in the secretion of essential nutrients by Synechococcus will further aid this approach.
Just as synthetic biology can be used to query the principles underlying complex signaling or transcriptional networks, a synthetic approach can be used to uncover the complex dynamics underlying symbiotic relationships. Engineering of microbial communities and (endo)symbioses between different species has tremendous potential as a tool for synthetic biology , where growth is limited by the complexity of combining modular genetic devices in a cellular context . Communities of cells working together can achieve results that pure cultures cannot. An engineerable photosynthetic symbiont can provide a light-controlled, orthogonal platform for engineering animal cells.
The authors would like to thank Jodene Moore and the HMS Systems Biology FACS facility for help with flow cytometry and cell sorting, Jennifer Waters, Lara Petrak, and the Nikon Imaging Center at Harvard Medical School for help with confocal microscopy, Dante D'India for zebrafish care, Kyle Perry, Bruno Afonso, Mara Inniss, Patrick Boyle, Jake Wintermute, Devin Burrill, and Mike Super for technical assistance and valuable discussion.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CMA HN RRN TDL SGM JCW PAS. Performed the experiments: CMA HN RRN TDL. Analyzed the data: CMA HN RRN TDL. Wrote the paper: CMA.
- 1. Kleine T, Maier UG, Leister D (2009) DNA Transfer from Organelles to the Nucleus: The Idiosyncratic Genetics of Endosymbiosis. Annu Rev Plant Biol 60: 115–138.T. KleineUG MaierD. Leister2009DNA Transfer from Organelles to the Nucleus: The Idiosyncratic Genetics of Endosymbiosis.Annu Rev Plant Biol60115138
- 2. Pelz O, Tesar M, Wittich RM, Moore ER, Timmis KN, et al. (1999) Towards elucidation of microbial community metabolic pathways: unravelling the network of carbon sharing in a pollutant-degrading bacterial consortium by immunocapture and isotopic ratio mass spectrometry. Environ Microbiol 1: 167–174.O. PelzM. TesarRM WittichER MooreKN Timmis1999Towards elucidation of microbial community metabolic pathways: unravelling the network of carbon sharing in a pollutant-degrading bacterial consortium by immunocapture and isotopic ratio mass spectrometry.Environ Microbiol1167174
- 3. Gray M, Burger G, Lang B (1999) Mitochondrial evolution. Science 283: 1476.M. GrayG. BurgerB. Lang1999Mitochondrial evolution.Science2831476
- 4. Howe CJ, Barbrook AC, Nisbet RER, Lockhart PJ, Larkum AWD (2008) The origin of plastids. Philos Trans R Soc Lond, B, Biol Sci 363: 2675–2685.CJ HoweAC BarbrookRER NisbetPJ LockhartAWD Larkum2008The origin of plastids.Philos Trans R Soc Lond, B, Biol Sci36326752685
- 5. Douglas A (1998) Nutritional interactions in insect-microbial symbioses: aphids and their symbiotic bacteria Buchnera. Annual Review of Entomology 43: 17–37.A. Douglas1998Nutritional interactions in insect-microbial symbioses: aphids and their symbiotic bacteria Buchnera.Annual Review of Entomology431737
- 6. Markmann K, Parniske M (2009) Evolution of root endosymbiosis with bacteria: How novel are nodules? Trends Plant Sci 14: 77–86.K. MarkmannM. Parniske2009Evolution of root endosymbiosis with bacteria: How novel are nodules?Trends Plant Sci147786
- 7. Rumpho ME, Summer EJ, Manhart JR (2000) Solar-powered sea slugs. Mollusc/algal chloroplast symbiosis. Plant Physiol 123: 29–38.ME RumphoEJ SummerJR Manhart2000Solar-powered sea slugs. Mollusc/algal chloroplast symbiosis.Plant Physiol1232938
- 8. Chin JW (2006) Modular approaches to expanding the functions of living matter. Nat Chem Biol 2: 304–311.JW Chin2006Modular approaches to expanding the functions of living matter.Nat Chem Biol2304311
- 9. Waks Z, Silver PA (2009) Engineering a Synthetic Dual-Organism System for Hydrogen Production. Appl Environ Microbiol 75: 1867–1875.Z. WaksPA Silver2009Engineering a Synthetic Dual-Organism System for Hydrogen Production.Appl Environ Microbiol7518671875
- 10. Bayer T, Widmaier D, Temme K, Mirsky E, Santi D, et al. (2009) Synthesis of methyl halides from biomass using engineered microbes. J Am Chem Soc 131: 6508–6515.T. BayerD. WidmaierK. TemmeE. MirskyD. Santi2009Synthesis of methyl halides from biomass using engineered microbes.J Am Chem Soc13165086515
- 11. Basu S, Gerchman Y, Collins CH, Arnold FH, Weiss R (2005) A synthetic multicellular system for programmed pattern formation. Nature 434: 1130–1134.S. BasuY. GerchmanCH CollinsFH ArnoldR. Weiss2005A synthetic multicellular system for programmed pattern formation.Nature43411301134
- 12. McMillen D, Kopell N, Hasty J, Collins JJ (2002) Synchronizing genetic relaxation oscillators by intercell signaling. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 679–684.D. McMillenN. KopellJ. HastyJJ Collins2002Synchronizing genetic relaxation oscillators by intercell signaling.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA99679684
- 13. Gore J, Youk H, Van Oudenaarden A (2009) Snowdrift game dynamics and facultative cheating in yeast. Nature 459: 253–256.J. GoreH. YoukA. Van Oudenaarden2009Snowdrift game dynamics and facultative cheating in yeast.Nature459253256
- 14. Shou W, Ram S, Vilar JMG (2007) Synthetic cooperation in engineered yeast populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 1877–1882.W. ShouS. RamJMG Vilar2007Synthetic cooperation in engineered yeast populations.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA10418771882
- 15. Wintermute EH, Silver PA (2010) Emergent cooperation in microbial metabolism. Molecular Systems Biology 6: 1–7.EH WintermutePA Silver2010Emergent cooperation in microbial metabolism.Molecular Systems Biology617
- 16. Anderson JC, Clarke EJ, Arkin AP, Voigt CA (2006) Environmentally controlled invasion of cancer cells by engineered bacteria. J Mol Biol 355: 619–627.JC AndersonEJ ClarkeAP ArkinCA Voigt2006Environmentally controlled invasion of cancer cells by engineered bacteria.J Mol Biol355619627
- 17. Cirillo JD (1999) Exploring a novel perspective on pathogenic relationships. Trends Microbiol 7: 96–98.JD Cirillo1999Exploring a novel perspective on pathogenic relationships.Trends Microbiol79698
- 18. Margulis L (1990) Words as battle cries–symbiogenesis and the new field of endocytobiology. Bioscience 40: 673–677.L. Margulis1990Words as battle cries–symbiogenesis and the new field of endocytobiology.Bioscience40673677
- 19. Kenny B, Valdivia R (2009) Host–microbe interactions: bacteria. Curr Opin Microbiol 12: 1–3.B. KennyR. Valdivia2009Host–microbe interactions: bacteria.Curr Opin Microbiol1213
- 20. Forbes NS (2010) Engineering the perfect (bacterial) cancer therapy. Nat Rev Cancer 1–10.NS Forbes2010Engineering the perfect (bacterial) cancer therapy.Nat Rev Cancer110
- 21. Bermudes D, Zheng L-m, King IC (2002) Live bacteria as anticancer agents and tumor-selective protein delivery vectors. Current opinion in drug discovery & development 5: 194–199.D. BermudesL-m ZhengIC King2002Live bacteria as anticancer agents and tumor-selective protein delivery vectors.Current opinion in drug discovery & development5194199
- 22. Sizemore DR, Branstrom AA, Sadoff JC (1995) Attenuated Shigella as a DNA delivery vehicle for DNA-mediated immunization. Science 270: 299–302.DR SizemoreAA BranstromJC Sadoff1995Attenuated Shigella as a DNA delivery vehicle for DNA-mediated immunization.Science270299302
- 23. Xiang S, Fruehauf J, Li CJ (2006) Short hairpin RNA-expressing bacteria elicit RNA interference in mammals. Nat Biotechnol 24: 697–702.S. XiangJ. FruehaufCJ Li2006Short hairpin RNA-expressing bacteria elicit RNA interference in mammals.Nat Biotechnol24697702
- 24. Ray K, Marteyn B, Sansonetti P, Tang C (2009) Life on the inside: the intracellular lifestyle of cytosolic bacteria. Nature Reviews Microbiology 7: 333–340.K. RayB. MarteynP. SansonettiC. Tang2009Life on the inside: the intracellular lifestyle of cytosolic bacteria.Nature Reviews Microbiology7333340
- 25. Bielecki J, Youngman P, Connelly P, Portnoy DA (1990) Bacillus subtilis expressing a haemolysin gene from Listeria monocytogenes can grow in mammalian cells. Nature 345: 175–176.J. BieleckiP. YoungmanP. ConnellyDA Portnoy1990Bacillus subtilis expressing a haemolysin gene from Listeria monocytogenes can grow in mammalian cells.Nature345175176
- 26. Goetz M, Bubert A, Wang G, Chico-Calero I, Vazquez-Boland JA, et al. (2001) Microinjection and growth of bacteria in the cytosol of mammalian host cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 12221–12226.M. GoetzA. BubertG. WangI. Chico-CaleroJA Vazquez-Boland2001Microinjection and growth of bacteria in the cytosol of mammalian host cells.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA981222112226
- 27. Buchsbaum R, Buchsbaum M (1934) AN ARTIFICIAL SYMBIOSIS. Science 80: 408–409.R. BuchsbaumM. Buchsbaum1934AN ARTIFICIAL SYMBIOSIS.Science80408409
- 28. Buchsbaum R (1937) Chick tissue cells and Chlorella in mixed cultures. Physiological Zoology 10: 373–380.R. Buchsbaum1937Chick tissue cells and Chlorella in mixed cultures.Physiological Zoology10373380
- 29. Taylor DL (1978) Artificially Induced Symbiosis Between Marine Flagellates and Vertebrate Tissues in Culture. J Protozool 25: 77–81.DL Taylor1978Artificially Induced Symbiosis Between Marine Flagellates and Vertebrate Tissues in Culture.J Protozool257781
- 30. Niederholtmeyer H, Wolfstadter BT, Savage DF, Silver PA, Way JC (2010) Engineering cyanobacteria to synthesize and export hydrophilic products. Appl Environ Microbiol 1–23.H. NiederholtmeyerBT WolfstadterDF SavagePA SilverJC Way2010Engineering cyanobacteria to synthesize and export hydrophilic products.Appl Environ Microbiol123
- 31. Stanier RY, Kunisawa R, Mandel M, Cohen-Bazire G (1971) Purification and properties of unicellular blue-green algae (order Chroococcales). Bacteriol Rev 35: 171–205.RY StanierR. KunisawaM. MandelG. Cohen-Bazire1971Purification and properties of unicellular blue-green algae (order Chroococcales).Bacteriol Rev35171205
- 32. Low K, Ittensohn M, Le T, Platt J, Sodi S, et al. (1999) Lipid A mutant Salmonella with suppressed virulence and TNFα induction retain tumor-targeting in vivo. Nat Biotechnol 17: 37–41.K. LowM. IttensohnT. LeJ. PlattS. Sodi1999Lipid A mutant Salmonella with suppressed virulence and TNFα induction retain tumor-targeting in vivo.Nat Biotechnol173741
- 33. Isberg RR, Voorhis DL, Falkow S (1987) Identification of invasin: a protein that allows enteric bacteria to penetrate cultured mammalian cells. Cell 50: 769–778.RR IsbergDL VoorhisS. Falkow1987Identification of invasin: a protein that allows enteric bacteria to penetrate cultured mammalian cells.Cell50769778
- 34. Cossart P, Vicente MF, Mengaud J, Baquero F, Perez-Diaz JC, et al. (1989) Listeriolysin O is essential for virulence of Listeria monocytogenes: direct evidence obtained by gene complementation. Infect Immun 57: 3629–3636.P. CossartMF VicenteJ. MengaudF. BaqueroJC Perez-Diaz1989Listeriolysin O is essential for virulence of Listeria monocytogenes: direct evidence obtained by gene complementation.Infect Immun5736293636
- 35. Wintermute E, Silver PA (2010) Dynamics in the mixed microbial concourse. Genes & Development 24: 2603–2614.E. WintermutePA Silver2010Dynamics in the mixed microbial concourse.Genes & Development2426032614
- 36. Taylor DL (1978) Artificially Induced Symbiosis Between Marine Flagellates and Vertebrate Tissues in Culture. J Protozool 25: 77–81.DL Taylor1978Artificially Induced Symbiosis Between Marine Flagellates and Vertebrate Tissues in Culture.J Protozool257781
- 37. Jeon K (1987) Change of Cellular “Pathogens” into Required Cell Componentsa. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 503: 359–371.K. Jeon1987Change of Cellular “Pathogens” into Required Cell Componentsa.Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences503359371
- 38. Venn AA, Loram JE, Douglas AE (2008) Photosynthetic symbioses in animals. J Exp Bot 59: 1069–1080.AA VennJE LoramAE Douglas2008Photosynthetic symbioses in animals.J Exp Bot5910691080
- 39. Kerney R, Kim E, Hangarter RP, Heiss AA, Bishop CD, et al. (2011) Intracellular invasion of green algae in a salamander host. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108(14): R. KerneyE. KimRP HangarterAA HeissCD Bishop2011Intracellular invasion of green algae in a salamander host.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA108(14)
- 40. Gilbert P (1944) The alga-egg relationship in Ambystoma maculatum, a case of symbiosis. Ecology 25: 366–369.P. Gilbert1944The alga-egg relationship in Ambystoma maculatum, a case of symbiosis.Ecology25366369
- 41. Tattersall G, Spiegelaar N (2008) Embryonic motility and hatching success of Ambystoma maculatum are influenced by a symbiotic alga. Can J Zool 86: 1289–1298.G. TattersallN. Spiegelaar2008Embryonic motility and hatching success of Ambystoma maculatum are influenced by a symbiotic alga.Can J Zool8612891298
- 42. Tyson G, Chapman J, Hugenholtz P, Allen E, Ram R, et al. (2004) Community structure and metabolism through reconstruction of microbial genomes from the environment. Nature 428: 37–43.G. TysonJ. ChapmanP. HugenholtzE. AllenR. Ram2004Community structure and metabolism through reconstruction of microbial genomes from the environment.Nature4283743
- 43. Muñoz-Elías E, McKinney J (2006) Carbon metabolism of intracellular bacteria. Cellular microbiology 8: 10–22.E. Muñoz-ElíasJ. McKinney2006Carbon metabolism of intracellular bacteria.Cellular microbiology81022
- 44. Chico-Calero I, Suárez M, González-Zorn B, Scortti M, Slaghuis J, et al. (2002) Hpt, a bacterial homolog of the microsomal glucose-6-phosphate translocase, mediates rapid intracellular proliferation in Listeria. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 431.I. Chico-CaleroM. SuárezB. González-ZornM. ScorttiJ. Slaghuis2002Hpt, a bacterial homolog of the microsomal glucose-6-phosphate translocase, mediates rapid intracellular proliferation in Listeria.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA99431
- 45. Stritzker J, Janda J, Schoen C, Taupp M, Pilgrim S, et al. (2004) Growth, virulence, and immunogenicity of Listeria monocytogenes aro mutants. Infection and immunity 72: 5622.J. StritzkerJ. JandaC. SchoenM. TauppS. Pilgrim2004Growth, virulence, and immunogenicity of Listeria monocytogenes aro mutants.Infection and immunity725622
- 46. Marquis H, Bouwer H, Hinrichs D, Portnoy D (1993) Intracytoplasmic growth and virulence of Listeria monocytogenes auxotrophic mutants. Infection and immunity 61: 3756.H. MarquisH. BouwerD. HinrichsD. Portnoy1993Intracytoplasmic growth and virulence of Listeria monocytogenes auxotrophic mutants.Infection and immunity613756
- 47. Brenner K, You L, Arnold F (2008) Engineering microbial consortia: a new frontier in synthetic biology. Trends Biotechnol 26: 483–489.K. BrennerL. YouF. Arnold2008Engineering microbial consortia: a new frontier in synthetic biology.Trends Biotechnol26483489
- 48. Purnick PEM, Weiss R (2009) The second wave of synthetic biology: from modules to systems. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 10: 410–422.PEM PurnickR. Weiss2009The second wave of synthetic biology: from modules to systems.Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol10410422