DNA barcoding, the analysis of sequence variation in the 5′ region of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase I (COI) gene, has been shown to provide an efficient method for the identification of species in a wide range of animal taxa. In order to assess the effectiveness of barcodes in the discrimination of Heteroptera, we examined 344 species belonging to 178 genera, drawn from specimens in the Canadian National Collection of Insects.
Analysis of the COI gene revealed less than 2% intra-specific divergence in 90% of the taxa examined, while minimum interspecific distances exceeded 3% in 77% of congeneric species pairs. Instances where barcodes fail to distinguish species represented clusters of morphologically similar species, except one case of barcode identity between species in different genera. Several instances of deep intraspecific divergence were detected suggesting possible cryptic species.
Although this analysis encompasses 0.8% of the described global fauna, our results indicate that DNA barcodes will aid the identification of Heteroptera. This advance will be useful in pest management, regulatory and environmental applications and will also reveal species that require further taxonomic research.
Citation: Park D-S, Foottit R, Maw E, Hebert PDN (2011) Barcoding Bugs: DNA-Based Identification of the True Bugs (Insecta: Hemiptera: Heteroptera). PLoS ONE 6(4): e18749. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0018749
Editor: M. Thomas P. Gilbert, Natural History Museum of Denmark, Denmark
Received: December 16, 2010; Accepted: March 9, 2011; Published: April 15, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Park et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This research was supported by funding to the Canadian Barcode of Life Network from NSERC, Genome Canada (through the Ontario Genomics Institute), and by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The true bugs (Insecta: Hemiptera: Heteroptera) represent the largest group of hemimetabolous insects, with more than 42,000 described species in over 5800 genera and 140 families . The order includes many economically important plant pests, animal disease vectors and predators employed in biological control , . Among the Heteroptera, there are a number of taxonomically difficult groups which include pest species (for example Lygus species ). As well, immature forms are generally difficult to identify using morphology-based keys.
The 5′ end of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I gene (COI) has been proposed as a standardized DNA “barcode” for the identification of species in the animal kingdom , . DNA barcodes could aid in the routine identification of Heteroptera in applied settings by enabling the recognition of morphologically cryptic species, by associating immature forms with adults (pest management), and by identifying eggs (phytosanitary applications) and fragmentary remains (food quality, ecological analyses).
Only a few prior studies have employed DNA sequences for species identification in the Heteroptera. Damgaard  found that COI sequences (in this case, from the 3′ end of the gene) were of limited utility in the identification of a Gerris species group. Memon et al.  confirmed the usefulness of variation in COI sequences in circumscribing a new hemipteran species, but found broad overlap in intraspecific and interspecific distances among sequences of 373 species of Hemiptera downloaded from GenBank. However, most of the latter data derive from studies specifically directed towards elucidating relationships within taxonomically problematic groups. Thus the available data are biased towards situations in which recent speciation reduces the observed level of inter-species sequence divergence, and may underestimate the utility of DNA barcoding as an identification tool among Heteroptera in general.
Recently, Jung et al.  presented COI barcode sequences for East Asian Heteroptera, and concluded that these barcodes can contribute to species identification. However, 79 of the 139 species treated were from three families (Anthocoridae (sensu lato), Miridae and Pentatomidae), and 11 of 25 families were represented by a single species, limiting the degree to which their conclusions may be generalized to Heteroptera as a whole. The present study expands the survey of sequence variation in the standard COI region in Heteroptera based on the analysis of identified specimens held in the Canadian National Collection of Insects.
Materials and Methods
Specimens for this study were drawn from the Canadian National Collection of Insects, Arachnids and Nematodes, Ottawa. Material collected more than 40 years ago was avoided in order to maximize the sequencing success rate. Whenever possible, more than one individual of a species was selected. An attempt was made to gain representation of all major heteropteran groups available, with more intensive coverage of certain groups. Thus, about 60% of the species are from the large family Miridae, and within this family, several speciose genera or species groups which present taxonomic difficulties were sampled more densely. A total of 1689 identified specimens were examined. Most specimens were from North America, but some were from Central America and Europe. A few specimens were preserved in 95% ethanol, but most were dried, pinned specimens collected over the past three decades (median age about 11 years). Collecting data were entered into BOLD, the Barcoding of Life Data System  and are available in the HCNC and HCNCS (“CNC Hemiptera”) projects (http://www.barcodinglife.org). A label was added to each specimen linking it with the corresponding record on BOLD.
CO1 Amplification and Sequencing
A single leg was removed from dried or ethanol-fixed specimens and DNA was extracted using standard glass fibre extraction protocol . PCR amplifications were done in a 12.5 µl volume including 6.25 µl of 10% trehalose, 2 µl of ultra pure water, 1.25 µl of 10 × PCR buffer (10 mM KCl, 10 mM (NH4)2SO4, 20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8.8), 2 mM MgSO4, 0.1% Triton X-100), 0.625 µl of MgCl2 (50 mM), 0.125 µl of each primer (10 uM), 0.0625 µl of 10 mM dNTP, 0.06 µl of Taq polymerase (Platinum® Taq, Invitrogen, CA) and 2 µl of extracted DNA. PCR primers used in this study are listed in Table 1. PCR thermocycling was performed under the following conditions: 2 min at 95°C; 5 cycles of 40 sec at 94°C, 40 sec at 45°C, 1 min at 72°C; 35 cycles of 40 sec at 94°C, 40 sec at 51°C, 1 min at 72°C; 5 min at 72°C; held at 4°C. Five additional cycles were added when using primer cocktail C_tRWF_t1 (mix of forward primers given in Table 1). PCR checks and DNA sequencing were carried out using standard methods. For about 68% of the samples, the primers LepF2_t1-3′ with a M13F tail on its 5′ end and LepR1 amplified the target 658-bp fragment of mitochondrial CO1 gene. When these primers were not successful, the primer cocktail C-tRWF_t1 (see Table 1) enabled amplification of the standard 658-bp barcode region together with a short upstream sequence in an additional 15% of the specimens. Specimens that were still recalcitrant were then amplified with the primer combination LepF2 (or C_tRWF_t1) with MHemR and MHemF with LepR1 to generate shorter overlapping sequences that allowed the creation of a composite sequence. Contigs and alignments were made using CodonCode Aligner Ver2.0.6 (CodonCode Co.). Sequence divergences were calculated using a K2P distance model  and a Neighbour-joining (NJ) tree  was generated to provide a graphic representation of the species divergences as implemented in the ‘Sequence analysis’ module on BOLD . All sequences corresponding to project HCNC have been deposited in GenBank (accession numbers HM394326 to HM394342, HM914596 to HM914598, and HQ105390 to HQ106459). Collection details, specimen photographs, sequences, trace files and GenBank accession numbers are available within the HCNC and HCNCS project files in BOLD.
Barcodes were obtained for about 80% of the specimens with successful amplification from specimens up to 35 years old. The 1276 sequences represent 380 species that belong to 191 genera in 30 families (Table 2). Of these, 1090 sequences (344 species, 178 genera, 29 families; see Table 3) were more than 500 bases in length. No stop codons or frame shifts were detected in the COI sequences, suggesting that none derive from pseudogenes (NUMTs). The following analysis only considers sequences with a length greater than 500 bp (see project HCNC). Shorter sequences are available in the HCNCS project, but not discussed further. The complete NJ tree derived from project HCNC is available as Appendix S1.
Table 3 and Figure 1 summarize divergences (K2P distance) among specimens at various taxonomic levels. Intraspecific divergences averaged 0.74% (range 0–7.72%, standard deviation 1.29%), with maximum intraspecific divergence exceeding 2% in 27 of the 344 species (Table 4). Congeneric species showed an average of 10.7% divergence (range 0–24.8%) with minimum interspecific distances exceeding 3% for more than three quarters of the species pairs. The remaining species fell into two categories: species pairs that shared closely similar or identical barcodes (Table 5A), and species pairs with low sequence divergence, but forming separate clusters (Table 5B).
Frequency of pairwise divergence among specimens within species, among species within genera, and among genera within families.
Sequence Divergence Patterns
There was one instance of barcode sharing by members of different genera: Rhinocapsus vanduzeei (2 of 3 specimens) shared sequences with 2 of 5 specimens of Plagiognathus morrisoni, and maximum distance between specimens of R. vanduzeei and members of the P. fuscipes species group (P. emarginatae, fuscipes and morrisoni) was 0.806%. If R. vanduzeei is excluded, the minimum distance between members of different genera within a family is 5.05% (mean 19.8%, maximum 35.8%). Among the 228 species with congeneric species in the current analysis, the nearest neighbour of 193 (85%) was a congener.
As indicated by the NJ tree (Fig. 2 and Appendix S1), members of a particular family normally formed a coherent cluster. The principal exceptions involved members of the superfamily Lygaeoidea, the constituent families of which were, until recently, usually included in a more broadly defined family Lygaeidae. Similarly, members of the Coreoid families Coreidae and Rhopalidae were not separated into cohesive clusters by the barcode results. On the other hand, the largest (and best sampled) family, Miridae, formed a relatively cohesive group, with only two genera, Tupiocoris and Usingerella, somewhat remote from the rest of the family. The sequence distance between specimens in different families was always great than 12% (mean 23.67%, range 12.2–36.7%).
This study complements the strong representation of the Anthocoridae (sensu lato) and Pentaomidae in the taxonomic coverage of the work of Jung et al.  by providing greater representation of the aquatic Heteroptera and Lygaeoid families, and a more extensive treatment of the important family Miridae. The broad patterns of intraspecific versus interspecific divergence obtained here confirm the values reported by Jung et al.  (their reported mean values are included in Table 3). In general, COI barcodes for each species formed a distinct cluster separated from its nearest neighbour, but there were exceptions. Some of these cases involved unusually large intraspecific distances (Table 4) while others involved cases of little or no separation between species (Table 5). Where barcodes failed to distinguish species, the taxa involved were ordinarily morphologically similar and closely related. However, there was one exception; Rhinocapsus vanduzeei shared the same COI sequence as some members of the Plagiognathus fuscipes species group. All species involved in the Rhinocapsus/Plagionathus cluster were represented by more than one individual, making it unlikely that cross-contamination or misplacement of specimens during processing had occurred.
Cases of deep intraspecific divergence (Table 4) can reflect misidentifications, cryptic taxa, ancestral polymorphisms, or introgression. However, past studies have shown that many of these cases involve cryptic species and there was evidence for their presence in several of the present cases. For example, specimens of Homaemus aeneifrons fell into two groups, one consisting of specimens from eastern Canada, the other from western Canada. The western subspecies, H. aeneifrons extensus, possesses distinct male genitalic characters , and this case of deep sequence difference supports the treatment of the subspecies as distinct sibling species. Lygocoris pabulinus is a widespread Holarctic species with no accepted subspecies. However, we detected marked sequence divergence (maximum = 5.98%) among the 20 specimens, and this variation fell into three groups separated by more than 2.98% versus a maximum within-group divergence of 0.96% (Fig. 3). One of these groups included specimens from Germany, the second was collected from across North America (British Columbia to Ontario), and the third from western North America (British Columbia to Arizona), suggesting unrecognized species may be present. Tupiocoris rubi illustrates an example of deep barcode differences associated with a biological difference. Members of this species fell into two groups: two specimens with identical barcodes were collected on blackberry, but they were 5% divergent from three specimens found on currant, suggesting that two host-specific taxa are involved (differing morphologically from another species on currant, T. ribesi, not included in the current study). Specimens of Psallus falleni (all from Vancouver Island, British Columbia, Canada) also fell into two very distinct haplotype groups with 7.6% divergence, suggesting that this species should also be examined further. Among the Korean species treated by Jung et al. , there was one example of unusually large divergence within a putative species (the Anthocorid, Scolopocelis albodecussata, with one individual differing by at least 12% from the remaining specimens), attributed to the possible existence of a cryptic species.
Specimen data are available on BOLD through the specimen identifiers.
In contrast to cases of deep intra-specific divergence, members of certain species complexes showed sequence sharing. Significantly, some of the species in these complexes showed high variation, a result which might reflect introgression or misidentification. As a consequence, these groups (e.g. Plagiognathus obscurus group, Labopidea nigrosetosa group, Orthotylus alni group) appear both as cases of high intraspecific variation (Table 4) and as cases of failed taxon discrimination (Table 5a). Plagiognathus obscurus and species closely related to it showed patterns of sequence variation that conflicted with current taxonomic assignments (Fig. 4) although its taxonomy was recently revised  and the specimens in our study were identified to reflect this treatment. However, specimens of P. obscurus fell into two groups separated by a minimum distance of 4.37%, contrasting with a maximum of 2.45% within-group divergence, a result suggesting cryptic species. The more diverse of these two groups of P. obscurus samples is intermixed with samples of Plagiognathus brunneus and Plagiognathus shoshonea. Because these species have an aggregate maximum divergence of almost 2.5%, they may represent a case of shared ancestral polymorphisms, or of species with past histories of divergence that are now introgressing. Two of these species, P. obscurus and P. brunneus, are morphologically very similar, so that misidentification is certainly a possible explanation. However, P. shoshonea is fairly easily recognized by its larger size, shape of male genitalia, host association, and color pattern. Misidentification of this species is therefore unlikely to have contributed to the observed patterns. Other species in this genus, such as Plagiognathus emarginatae, Plagiognathus fuscipes and Plagiognathus morrisoni, are morphologically similar to each other and indistinguishable by barcodes, probably reflecting recent speciation. Among the Korean species treated by Jung et al. , three of six nominal Apolygus species (Miridae) formed a single complex neighbour-joining cluster.
Specimen data are available on BOLD through the specimen identifiers.
Close similarity of DNA barcodes among members of different genera (Plagiognathus and Rhinocapsus) is unusual but not unreported in other insect groups. Hausmann et al.  found COI sequence sharing among several species of the Geometrid (Lepidoptera) genera Elophus and Sciadia. Specimens of the aphids Aulacorthum dorsatum and Ericaphis wakibae (Foottit et al. ) have identical barcode sequences. In both cases, the authors suggest that the generic definitions require re-evaluation. This is a possible explanation for the situation encountered here, despite the obvious morphological differences currently used to distinguish the genera. However, other mechanisms are also possible, including character convergence, introgression, and lateral transfer mediated by microbial symbionts or pathogens.
Patterns of barcode similarity (Fig. 2 and Appendix S1) show a surprising congruence with current hypotheses of higher-level taxonomic relationships. In genera with more than one species in our data set, the nearest neighbour for 86% of these species was a congener. For families represented by more than one species, the nearest neighbour for all but eight species was in the same family. Because of these patterns, COI barcodes can be an indicator of generic or family-level affinity of unknown taxa, especially useful when fragmentary remains or immature forms are involved. In our experience, COI divergences of less than 5% generally provide a good indication of generic identity. When compared against the remainder of the data set using this 5% threshold, 91 species (26%) were correctly identified to genus, 1 was misidentified, and the other 252 species remained unplaced (116 of these due to the lack of congeners in the data set). Similarly, use of a 10% divergence threshold placed 48% of species in the correct family, and none were misplaced.
This study contributes to the assembly of a DNA barcode library for the Heteroptera. Although less than 1% of the world fauna has been analyzed, the present data indicate that COI barcoding provides a useful identification tool for this group. Subsequent expansion of the database to cover all important groups of Heteroptera will make it possible to reliably and routinely identify species of environmental and economic importance.
Neighbour-joining tree (K2P distances) for 1090 COI sequences greater than 500 bases in length from 340 species of Heteroptera. Collection data, sequences, and trace files are available on BOLD in the HCNC project at http://www.boldsystems.
We gratefully acknowledge the many taxonomic specialists who identified the specimens used in this study, especially M.D. Schwartz, Canadian National Collection, Ottawa (Miridae) and G.G.E. Scudder, University of British Columbia, Vancouver (other families). We thank M.D. Schwartz for supplying useful information on the taxonomy and suggestions for sampling of the Miridae. We also thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments and suggestions.
Conceived and designed the experiments: D-SP RF EM PDNH. Performed the experiments: D-SP. Analyzed the data: D-SP RF EM PDNH. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: D-SP RF EM PDNH. Wrote the paper: D-SP RF EM PDNH.
- 1. Henry TJ (2009) Biodiversity of the Heteroptera. In: Foottit RG, Adler PH, editors. Insect Biodiversity: Science and Society. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell. pp. 223–263.TJ Henry2009Biodiversity of the Heteroptera.RG FoottitPH AdlerInsect Biodiversity: Science and SocietyOxfordWiley-Blackwell223263
- 2. Schaeffer CW, Pinazzi AR, editors. (2000) Heteroptera of Economic Importance. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press. 828 p.CW SchaefferAR Pinazzi2000Heteroptera of Economic Importance.Boca Raton, FloridaCRC Press828
- 3. Schwartz MD, Foottit RG (1998) Revision of the Nearctic species of the genus Lygus Hahn, with a review of the Palaearctic species (Heteroptera: Miridae). Memoirs on Entomology, International 10: 1–428.MD SchwartzRG Foottit1998Revision of the Nearctic species of the genus Lygus Hahn, with a review of the Palaearctic species (Heteroptera: Miridae).Memoirs on Entomology, International101428
- 4. Hajibabaei M, deWaard JR, Ivanova NV, Ranasingham S, Dooh RT, et al. (2005) Critical factors for assembling a high volume of DNA barcodes. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 360: 1959–1967.M. HajibabaeiJR deWaardNV IvanovaS. RanasinghamRT Dooh2005Critical factors for assembling a high volume of DNA barcodes.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences36019591967
- 5. Floyd RM, Wilson JJ, Hebert PDN (2009) DNA barcodes and insect biodiversity. In: Foottit RG, Adler PH, editors. Insect Biodiversity: Science and Society. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell. pp. 417–432.RM FloydJJ WilsonPDN Hebert2009DNA barcodes and insect biodiversity.RG FoottitPH AdlerInsect Biodiversity: Science and SocietyOxfordWiley-Blackwell417432
- 6. Damgaard J (2008) MtDNA diversity and species phylogeny of western Palaearctic members of the Gerris lacustris group (Hemiptera-Heteroptera: Gerridae) with implications for “DNA barcoding” of water striders. Insect Systematics & Evolution 39: 107–120.J. Damgaard2008MtDNA diversity and species phylogeny of western Palaearctic members of the Gerris lacustris group (Hemiptera-Heteroptera: Gerridae) with implications for “DNA barcoding” of water striders.Insect Systematics & Evolution39107120
- 7. Memon N, Meier R, Manan A, Su KF-Y (2006) On the use of DNA sequences for determining the species limits of a polymorphic new species in the stink bug genus Halys (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae) from Pakistan. Systematic Entomology 31: 703–710.N. MemonR. MeierA. MananKF-Y Su2006On the use of DNA sequences for determining the species limits of a polymorphic new species in the stink bug genus Halys (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae) from Pakistan.Systematic Entomology31703710
- 8. Jung S, Duwal RK, Lee S (2011) COI barcoding of true bugs (Insecta, Heteroptera). Molecular Ecology Resources 11: 266–270.S. JungRK DuwalS. Lee2011COI barcoding of true bugs (Insecta, Heteroptera).Molecular Ecology Resources11266270
- 9. Ratnasingham S, Hebert PDN (2007) The Barcode of Life Data System. Molecular Ecology Notes 7: 355–364.S. RatnasinghamPDN Hebert2007The Barcode of Life Data System.Molecular Ecology Notes7355364(www.barcodinglife.org). (www.barcodinglife.org).
- 10. Ivanova NV, Dewaard JR, Hebert PDN (2006) An inexpensive, automation-friendly protocol for recovering high-quality DNA. Molecular Ecology Notes 6: 998–1002.NV IvanovaJR DewaardPDN Hebert2006An inexpensive, automation-friendly protocol for recovering high-quality DNA.Molecular Ecology Notes69981002
- 11. Kimura M (1980) A simple method for estimating evolutionary rate of base substitutions through comparative studies of nucleotide sequences. Journal of Molecular Evolution 16: 11–120.M. Kimura1980A simple method for estimating evolutionary rate of base substitutions through comparative studies of nucleotide sequences.Journal of Molecular Evolution1611120
- 12. Saitou N, Nei N (1987) The neighbour-joining method: a new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Molecular Biology and Evolution 4: 406–425.N. SaitouN. Nei1987The neighbour-joining method: a new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees.Molecular Biology and Evolution4406425
- 13. Walley GS (1929) Notes on Homaemus with a key to the species (Hemip, Scutelleridae). The Canadian Entomologist 61: 253–256.GS Walley1929Notes on Homaemus with a key to the species (Hemip, Scutelleridae).The Canadian Entomologist61253256
- 14. Schuh RT (2001) Revision of New World Plagiognathus Fieber, with comments on the Palearctic fauna and the description of a new genus (Heteroptera: Miridae: Phylinae). Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 266: 1–267.RT Schuh2001Revision of New World Plagiognathus Fieber, with comments on the Palearctic fauna and the description of a new genus (Heteroptera: Miridae: Phylinae).Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History2661267
- 15. Hausmann A, Haszprunar G, Hebert PDN (2011) DNA barcoding the Geometrid fauna of Bavaria (Lepidoptera): successes, surprises, and questions. PLoS ONE 6(2): e17134.A. HausmannG. HaszprunarPDN Hebert2011DNA barcoding the Geometrid fauna of Bavaria (Lepidoptera): successes, surprises, and questions.PLoS ONE62e17134
- 16. Foottit RG, Maw HEL, von Dohlen CD, Hebert PDN (2008) Species identification of aphids (Insecta: Hemiptera: Aphididae) through DNA barcodes. Molecular Ecology Resources 8: 1189–1201.RG FoottitHEL MawCD von DohlenPDN Hebert2008Species identification of aphids (Insecta: Hemiptera: Aphididae) through DNA barcodes.Molecular Ecology Resources811891201
- 17. Hebert PDN, Penton EH, Burns JM, Janzen DH, Hallwachs W (2004) Ten species in one: DNA barcoding reveals cryptic species in the neotropical skipper butterfly Astraptes fulgerator. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 101: 14812–14817.PDN HebertEH PentonJM BurnsDH JanzenW. Hallwachs2004Ten species in one: DNA barcoding reveals cryptic species in the neotropical skipper butterfly Astraptes fulgerator.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America1011481214817
- 18. Park D-S, Suh S-J, Oh H-W, Hebert PDN (2010) Recovery of the mitochondrial COI barcode region in diverse Hexapoda through tRNA-based primers. BMC Genomics 11: 243.D-S ParkS-J SuhH-W OhPDN Hebert2010Recovery of the mitochondrial COI barcode region in diverse Hexapoda through tRNA-based primers.BMC Genomics11243