Tea consumption is associated with a lower risk of cardiovascular disease including stroke. Direct effects of tea components on the vasculature, particularly the endothelium, may partly explain this association.
We performed a meta-analysis of controlled human intervention studies on the effect of tea on flow-mediated dilation (FMD) of the brachial artery, a measurement of endothelial function, which is suggested to be associated with cardiovascular risk.
Human intervention studies were identified by systematic search of the databases Medline, Embase, Chemical Abstracts and Biosis through March 2009 and by hand-searching related articles. Studies were selected based on predefined criteria: intervention with tea as the sole experimental variable, placebo-controlled design, and no missing data on FMD outcome or its variability. A random effects model was used to calculate the pooled overall effect on FMD due to the intake of tea. The impact of various subject and treatment characteristics was investigated in the presence of heterogeneity.
In total, 9 studies from different research groups were included with 15 relevant study arms. The overall absolute increase in FMD of tea vs. placebo was 2.6% of the arterial diameter (95% CI: 1.8-3.3%; P-value <0.001) for a median daily dose of 500 mL of tea (2–3 cups). This is a relative increase of approximately 40% compared to the average FMD of 6.3% measured under placebo or baseline conditions. There was significant heterogeneity between studies (P-value <0.001) that might partly be explained by the cuff position either distal or proximal to the area of FMD measurement. No indication for publication bias was found.
Citation: Ras RT, Zock PL, Draijer R (2011) Tea Consumption Enhances Endothelial-Dependent Vasodilation; a Meta-Analysis. PLoS ONE 6(3): e16974. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0016974
Editor: Lise Lotte Gluud, Copenhagen University Hospital Gentofte, Denmark
Received: September 30, 2010; Accepted: January 11, 2011; Published: March 4, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Ras et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Unilever R&D Vlaardingen is the funder of this review as all authors are employed by this company. All authors were involved in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, and preparation of the manuscript. No external funding was involved.
Competing interests: All authors are employed by Unilever R&D Vlaardingen, The Netherlands. Unilever markets tea and tea-based products. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLoS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Tea consumption is associated with a reduced risk for cardiovascular disease (CVD) including stroke –. A suggested mechanism that may partly explain this association is the direct effect of tea on the vasculature, particularly the endothelium . The endothelium, the inner lining of all blood vessels, plays a central role in vascular homeostasis, including maintenance of vascular tone, balancing blood fluidity and blood clotting, and vascular inflammatory processes . Endothelial dysfunction refers to disruption of the homeostatic endothelial condition, and plays an important role in the development of atherosclerosis and CVD . Many CVD risk factors such as hypercholesterolemia, diabetes, hypertension, ageing, smoking and hyperglycaemia, have been shown to be accompanied by endothelial dysfunction , .
Endothelial (dys)function can be determined by assessing the degree of flow-mediated dilation (FMD) of the brachial artery , . FMD represents the endothelium-dependent relaxation of the artery, mediated via release of nitric oxide (NO), in response to a hyperaemic stimulus (increased flow established by the release of a supra-systolic inflated cuff around the arm), and is seen as a direct and reliable measure of vascular reactivity of the macro circulatory system. Although not conclusive –, evidence from prospective studies suggests that FMD is independently inversely associated with cardiovascular events –.
Several human intervention studies have investigated the effect of tea consumption on endothelial function –. The majority of these studies report a beneficial effect of tea on FMD. A meta-analysis by Hooper et al.  on flavonoids/flavonoid-rich foods and cardiovascular risk factors suggested a beneficial effect of black tea on FMD of 3.40% (95%CI: 1.85–4.95%) after long-term consumption, and 1.70% (95%CI: -0.17-3.57%) acutely after tea intake. These data were, however, based on only 2 studies, and several other studies on black and green tea and FMD have been published since.
We performed a meta-analysis of currently available data from human intervention studies on the effect of tea consumption on endothelial function as measured by FMD of the brachial artery. Objectives were to estimate the size of the overall effect and to identify the impact of various subject and treatment characteristics on the effect of tea on FMD in the presence of heterogeneity.
The supporting PRISMA checklist for this meta-analysis is available as supporting information; see Checklist S1.
Potential relevant published studies were identified from the databases Medline, Embase, Chemical Abstracts and Biosis (from starting date of the databases until March 2009). The following search terms were used to search in titles and abstracts: (tea or black tea or green tea or flavonoid? or tea extract? or tea component? or tea solid? or camellia sinensis) and (flow-mediated or flow mediated or FMD or endothelial function or endothelial dysfunction or endothelium-dependent or blood flow or arterial stiffness or vascular resistance or circulat* or micro-circulat* or microcirculat* or vasodilat* or dilat*). The search was limited to studies in human adults.
We selected human intervention studies that investigated the relationship between tea intake and FMD. The selection was performed in 2 steps. The first selection step was based on titles and abstracts. Studies were included if they met the following inclusion criteria: human intervention study with adults (with parallel or crossover design), intervention with tea as the only experimental variable, outcomes related to vascular function, endothelial function or FMD and no intentional co-intervention from which the effect of tea could not be isolated. During the second selection step, full texts of the papers were read to check whether the first selection step was done correctly, and to exclude studies based on the following criteria: missing data on FMD, no measures of variability of FMD reported, no suitable control treatment included in the design, and no full text available. We focussed on studies with freshly brewed tea or with tea powder that was produced by drying freshly brewed tea, excluding purified or isolated substances from tea. In case of unclarity, inclusion of a study was discussed among 2 of the authors (RTR and RD) to reach a decision. For completeness, potential relevant and eligible studies published after completion of the systematic search through March 2009 were also included.
Data extraction and quality assessment
For each of the studies selected, data were extracted using a custom-made database on identification of the study (author, year of publication, country), study design (parallel or crossover), subject characteristics (age, body mass index (BMI), gender, ethnicity and health status), diet, treatment characteristics (green or black tea, dosage of tea, duration, preparation of tea), FMD analysis characteristics (fasted or non-fasted, position of cuff, time of occlusion), FMD values with accompanying measures of variance, and study quality. When data were missing, the authors of the original study were approached to obtain these data (successful in 2 occasions , ).
Quality of the studies was assessed by to a tool that was specifically developed for this meta-analysis based on the Delphi Consensus . The following criteria were used for scoring the quality of each study: proper randomization procedure (quality score = 1 point), similarity of treatment groups in relevant variables at baseline (1 point), specification of eligibility criteria (1 point), blinding of subjects and investigators (each 1 point), valid point estimates and measures of variability presented for FMD (1 point), and data on degree of compliance (1 point). A combined quality score was obtained by adding the scores for each criterion. Thus, quality score could range from 0 to 7 points. The quality scores were used only for performing subgroup analyses to examine whether the net response in FMD was different in studies with high vs. low quality. Because scoring of quality is intrinsically subjective, the quality scores were not used to exclude lower quality studies from the meta-analysis or to weigh the studies.
FMD is expressed as follows: FMD (%) = [(hyperaemic diameter – resting diameter)/resting diameter] ×100 , where resting diameter is the diameter of the brachial artery before any flow stimulus in the artery is created, and hyperaemic diameter is the diameter of the artery observed after release of the inflated cuff. For cross-over studies, the net response in FMD was calculated by subtracting the mean FMD value at the end of control period from the mean FMD value at the end of the treatment period. For parallel studies, the net response in FMD was calculated by subtracting the mean change in FMD in the control group from the mean change in the treatment group, where mean change is FMD value at the end of the intervention minus the FMD value at the start of the intervention.
For calculating the pooled overall effect of tea on FMD, we weighed the studies by the inverse of their variance (1/SE2) (SE = standard error), giving more weight to more precise studies. When not provided, the SE of the net change was derived from P-values or calculated according to the equations by Follmann et al. . For the latter, we assumed a within-subject correlation coefficient of 0.5 . Since it is unlikely that all the heterogeneity in results is due to the treatment itself, a random effect model according to the methods described by DerSimonian and Laird and van Houwelingen et al. was used to take both within- and between-trial variance into account , . Calculations were done using the PROC MIXED model of the SAS analytical system (version 9.2).
The extent of heterogeneity between studies was assessed by estimating the proportion of total variation across studies due to variability between studies rather than due to chance, using the Cochran's Q statistic and the I2 statistic , , . The I2-statistic ranges between 0 and 100%; an I2-value above 50% indicates relevant heterogeneity .
To relate the size of the observed FMD responses to one or more potential covariates, we performed weighted meta-regression , . The pre-defined covariates were health status (healthy or diseased), mean age, mean baseline FMD, dose of tea, type of tea (green or black tea), type of placebo (hot water or caffeine controlled), duration of tea (short-term/acute or long-term/chronic (>2 weeks)) and quality. In addition, we calculated a pooled FMD effect for different subgroups of the covariates under investigation. For the continuous variables, subgroups were defined based on above or below the median values. In case a subgroup consisted of less than 5 study arms, no subgroup analysis was performed; instead, we performed sensitivity analysis excluding those studies placed in the smallest subgroup.
To assess presence of publication bias, we visually inspected the symmetry of a funnel plot of the net effects on FMD observed in all studies expressed against their respective precisions (1/SE). The degree of funnel plot asymmetry was assessed by regression analysis of the standard normal deviate as a function of the precision . Absence of publication bias is reflected in an intercept close to 0 with the slope of the regression line close to the overall effect size. The intercept provides a measure of asymmetry if P-value <0.1.
Characteristics of included studies
A total of 478 potentially relevant papers were retrieved with the systematic search. Based on the predefined selection criteria, 470 papers were excluded for different reasons (Figure 1). One eligible study was retrieved after the search , yielding a total of 9 studies with 15 study arms for this meta-analysis (Table 1). Seven studies had a crossover design , –, , ,  and two a parallel design , .
*One study was identified after the systematic search through March 2009.
A total of 213 subjects participated in the 9 studies. The number of subjects per study ranged from 14 to 50 subjects. Mean age ranged from 30.0 to 62.1 years and BMI from 22.1 to 29.7 kg/m2. One study included only men  whereas 2 studies included only women , ; in the remaining studies, except for 1 study that did not report gender , the percentage male ranged from 60% to 93%. In 5 out of 9 studies, subjects were healthy or mildly hypercholesterolemic; the other studies included renal transplant recipients , chronic kidney disease patients , or coronary artery disease patients , . Mean baseline FMD ranged from 4.3% to 7.8%.
Seven studies investigated the effect of black tea; only 3 studies investigated (also) green tea , , . In the majority of the studies, tea was brewed by infusing a certain amount of tea (5–10 g/d) in a defined amount of hot water (450–1250 mL) for a defined time period (2–5 min); in 2 studies ,  tea was prepared by dissolving a tea powder in hot water. The study by Grassi et al.  used a control drink that contained an equal amount of caffeine as the tea interventions; the remaining studies used hot water without caffeine as control. Six studies investigated the acute effects on FMD, 30–120 minutes after drinking the prescribed amount of tea , –, , , or the acute effects upon 1 week of daily tea consumption , whereas 3 studies (also) investigated the long-term effects (4 weeks) on FMD after an overnight fast and abstinence of tea , , . Except for 2 studies that determined FMD with the occlusion cuff placed proximally to the area of measurement , , the majority of the studies determined FMD with the occlusion cuff placed distally. Only 2 studies ,  used a semi-automated edge-detection system to determine the brachial artery diameter.
Heterogeneity and publication bias
Between-study heterogeneity as assessed by the Q-statistic was significant (62.1, P-value <0.001, with accompanying I2 statistic 75.8%) justifying the use of a random effects model for calculating the pooled overall effect.
Visual inspection of the funnel plot (Figure 2) did not clearly indicate presence of publication bias. Indeed, regression analysis of the standard normal deviate as a function of the precision did not reveal clear funnel plot asymmetry (intercept: P-value = 0.176), indicating absence of publication bias.
The net FMD responses are expressed against their respective precisions (1/SE) in 15 study arms. The net responses are scattered around the pooled overall effect of 2.6% (dotted line). In case the most extreme outlier (red circle) is excluded from the analyses, the net responses are more symmetrically scattered around the adjusted pooled overall effect of 2.4% (red dotted line).
Effect of tea on FMD
In each of the individual studies, except for one , tea showed a statistically significant effect on FMD. In all studies combined, consumption of tea increased FMD vs. control by 2.6% of arterial dilation (95% CI: 1.8–3.3%; P-value <0.001), which is a relative improvement of approximately 40% compared to the average FMD of 6.3% under placebo (for cross-over trials) or baseline (for parallel trials) conditions (Figure 3). The median dose was 500 mL tea per day, which is equivalent to 2–3 cups per day.
The net FMD responses and 95% confidence intervals of 15 study arms from 9 studies investigating the effect of tea on FMD are shown. The dotted line indicates the pooled overall FMD effect (2.6%), in which each study arm was weighed by the inverse of its variance (1/SE2). In case of multiple study arms, the intervention is specified between brackets.
Of the variation in FMD responses between the studies, study quality score explained 52%, type of placebo 20%, type of tea 17%, health status 9%, study duration 6%, age 1%, baseline FMD 1%, and dose of tea <1%. Only the quality score of trials significantly correlated with the net FMD responses (P-value = 0.002). However, this correlation lost significance (P-value = 0.725) when all covariates were simultaneously included in the model. Furthermore, the study with the highest reported response in FMD was ranked with the lowest quality score . Excluding this study from the analysis did not materially affect the overall effect (average FMD response 2.4%, see post-hoc analyses), but reduced the association between the quality score and the FMD effect considerably (P-value = 0.030; R2 = 0.34). This indicates that the size of the response is less explained by the quality score when considering the disproportional impact of this study on the covariate analysis.
Analysis of the overall FMD effect of tea within predefined subgroups (with data from at least 5 study arms) indicated significant overall FMD effects for subgroups with diseased and healthy subjects, young and old subjects, high and low baseline FMD values, different amounts of tea prescribed, different study quality scores, black tea as intervention, when using hot water as control, and with acute intake of tea (Table 2). Between predefined subgroups, no significant differences in FMD responses were found, except for study quality score with higher quality studies showing smaller improvements in FMD (P-value = 0.005).
In post hoc analyses, we checked the impact of 2 individual studies with specific characteristics on the overall estimated effect on FMD; we excluded the study by Grassi et al.  because it had with 4 study arms a disproportionally large weight, and the study by Ardalan et al.  because it included renal transplant recipients representing a very specific population. Exclusion of these studies did not substantially affect the outcome; the pooled overall FMD effect estimate without the study by Grassi et al. was 3.0% (95% CI: 2.1–4.0; P-value <0.001) and without the study by Ardalan et al. 2.4% (95% CI: 1.7–3.0; P-value <0.001) vs. the 2.6% (95% CI: 1.8–3.3%) in all 9 studies. Furthermore, excluding the most extreme outlier  from the publication bias analysis improved the symmetry of the funnel (intercept: P-value = 0.401) supporting the indication of absence of publication bias (Figure 2).
Also in post hoc analyses, we investigated the impact of cuff position (either proximal or distal to the area of ultrasound measurement) on the FMD response to tea consumption. Based on meta-regression, cuff position was significantly correlated with the FMD responses; smaller responses to tea were observed with distal occlusion (P-value 0.017; R2 = 0.36). Due to the limited number of studies that used proximal occlusion, we performed sensitivity analysis only including those studies that used distal occlusion (n = 12) and calculated a significant overall FMD effect of 2.1% (95% CI: 1.5–2.7; P-value <0.001).
Tea effects on endothelium-independent vasodilation
The majority of studies, except for two , , assessed endothelium-independent vasodilation by sublingual administration of nitroglycerine spray. No effect of tea was found in 6 out of 7 studies (data not shown). Only Hodgson et al.  reported a small but significant enhancement of the endothelium-independent vasodilation after black tea consumption.
In this meta-analysis, we summarized published evidence from 9 human intervention studies that investigated the effect of tea consumption on endothelial function as measured by FMD. It was found that moderate consumption of tea substantially enhances FMD. This is in line with findings from a previous meta-analysis on flavonoids/flavonoid-rich foods and cardiovascular risk factors , that included 2 studies on tea and FMD published at that time , . The effect of tea on FMD seems robust because the estimated overall effect is large and the effect was observed in 8 out of 9 studies including different study populations and different tea types. Also, we could not detect indications of systematic publication bias.
During the last decade, FMD has been increasingly used as tool to assess effects of therapeutic interventions on endothelial function in humans. The relevance of FMD for predicting CVD risk independent of other well-established risk factors is crucial in this respect. Several prospective studies, but not all –, indicate an independent inverse association between FMD and risk for cardiovascular events, not only in patients with varying stages of arterial disease –, but also in subjects without diagnosis of CVD , . FMD has been shown to add to the predictive value of ankle-brachial pressure index  and hyperaemic flow velocity  in patients with peripheral arterial disease. In addition, Chan et al.  showed an interaction between carotid plaque burden and endothelial function for predicting future adverse vascular events in coronary artery disease patients. On the contrary, FMD does not seem to be independently associated with CVD outcomes when intima-media thickness is considered at the same time , . Whether improvement in FMD in response to treatment can predict CVD risk was assessed in at least 2 studies. The study by Kitta et al.  suggested that optimized therapy to reduce risk factors for coronary artery disease is effective in improving FMD in CVD patients, with persistent impairment in FMD being an independent predictor of events. Modena et al.  showed that in postmenopausal women, antihypertensive therapy positively affects FMD, and that improvement in FMD identified patients with a subsequent more favourable prognosis for events when adjusted for changes in other risk factors such as SBP and DBP. Thus, taken together, an independent association is suggested between FMD and CVD risk, although causality remains to be proven.
Potential health properties of tea are likely due to certain chemical substances extracted from the tea leaves. The active tea substances responsible for the increase in FMD are still unknown, but a specific role for certain flavonoids, such as the catechins epicatechin, epigallocatechin, epigallocatechin gallate, and epicatechin gallate has been suggested . The caffeine in tea probably does not contribute to the effect; an oral dose of pure caffeine was found to not significantly affect FMD  or even reduced FMD . Also, tea solids dose-dependently affect FMD when caffeine intake is kept constant . In one study , tea did not significantly improve FMD. An explanation may be found in the fact that FMD was measured only shortly (60–90 min) after tea consumption. Since catechin plasma concentrations peak 1–2 h after intake in fasted state and 2–3 h in postprandial state , , it may be that the catechins were not yet fully absorbed at the time of the FMD assessment. However, whether the catechins are the true actives remains to be elucidated.
With the studies included in our analysis, we were not able to confirm a dose-response relation between amount of tea consumed and FMD response as was suggested by the study by Grassi et al. . The absence of a clear dose-response relation may be due to the inaccuracy of expressing tea intake as volume of beverage consumed per day rather than as amount of potentially active substances ingested in the different tea interventions. The included studies used different tea products and preparation methods with varying amounts of tea leaves, brewing time, and water temperatures. These differences presumably result in different concentrations of active substances per tea serving . It has been estimated that approximately 84% of total polyphenol content in tea is flavonoids . Black tea contains on average 992 mg/L of total polyphenols, whereas green tea contains 591 mg/L . A dose of 500 mL of tea (∼2–3 cups) can thus be estimated to contain on average 415 mg of flavonoids for black tea and 248 mg for green tea. However, these are rough estimates and, in practice, the variation between tea brews will be large.
A proposed mechanism by which dietary flavonoids could affect FMD is that they improve the bioactivity of the endothelium-derived vasodilator NO  by enhancing NO synthesis or by decreasing superoxide-mediated NO breakdown . Flavonoids may increase endothelial NO production ,  by stimulating Akt-mediated endothelial-derived NO synthase activity , , and additionally decrease levels of the vasoconstrictor endothelin-1 . Another mechanistic explanation is that methylated flavonoids inhibit nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase activity, and thereby reduce the generation of reactive superoxide and hydroxyperoxide . However, the precise mechanism is not yet fully revealed, and different potentially active flavonoids and their metabolites may have different effects. No indication of endothelial-independent vasodilatory effects of tea was found in the included studies. Although not conclusive, this makes it unlikely that consumption of tea sensitizes arterial smooth muscle cells for NO.
Because heterogeneity between studies was significant, we analyzed the impact of potential covariates on the relationship between tea and FMD in order to identify factors that could explain differences in findings between studies. Only the study quality score was significantly associated with the size of the FMD response observed after tea consumption, with higher quality studies showing smaller improvements in FMD than the lower quality studies. However, this association was no longer significant when corrected for other covariates in the same model. It should be noted that scoring the quality of a study is intrinsically subjective. Thus, the apparent relation between study quality and observed effect on FMD should be interpreted with caution. Overall, the number of studies included in this meta-analysis was too limited to allow a thorough, reliable analysis of sources of heterogeneity.
Our study has other limitations. Firstly, reproducibility of a functional marker such as FMD is low as compared to most biochemical markers. Standardized protocols for imaging techniques, as for example recently described by Thijsen et al. , are required to reduce within-subject variability. These should include multiple measurements and duplicate readings, preferably using automated vessel wall boundary detection devices , . Such an automated device was used in only 2 out of 9 studies included in the present meta-analysis. Also, the position of the occlusion cuff, either proximal or distal to the area of FMD measurement, is important to consider. A post-hoc analysis suggested that cuff position has an impact on the size of the FMD response after tea consumption, with larger effects on FMD when using the proximal occlusion method, which may explain part of the heterogeneity found between the studies. Doshi et al.  have shown that FMD assessed by the distal occlusion method can be abolished by infusion of the NO synthase inhibitor NG-monomethyl-L-arginine, but is only partly inhibited (by ∼35%) when using the proximal occlusion method. This indicates that dilation after proximal occlusion is not entirely NO-mediated. Because an enhanced tea effect on FMD was found with the proximal cuff placement, it may be speculated that tea affects the vasodilatory response beyond affecting NO bioavailability via mechanisms still to be revealed , . A second limitation of our analysis is that the majority of included studies measured FMD acutely, i.e. about 2 hours after ingestion of a defined dose of tea. Although an improvement in FMD by tea was also seen after longer-term (4 weeks) regular tea consumption, the clinical relevance of acute improvements in FMD is unclear. Thirdly, this meta-analysis included 2 studies that compared more than 1 active treatment to the same control treatment , . Although bias due to multiple inclusion of the same control group can not be excluded, we considered this as the best possible approach to not exclude valuable data from treatment arms (i.e. different doses). Excluding the study that contributed most to the overall estimate with 4 treatment arms vs. the same control group  did not materially affect the results.
In conclusion, our findings indicate that tea consumption results in substantial effects on the vascular endothelium as indicated by an improved endothelial-dependent vasodilation in the first hours after intake, and also after longer-term regular consumption of tea. This effect may partly explain the relationship between tea consumption and reduced CVD risk in population studies when assuming that FMD offers independent predictive value for CVD endpoints. However, to what extent tea-mediated improvement in endothelial function is indeed causally related to a reduction in cardiovascular events can only be determined by large, long-term randomized trials on clinical endpoints.
The authors would like to thank Dr. Petra Verhoef and Dr. Kim van der Zander for their contributions to the design and reporting of this meta-analysis.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RR PZ RD. Performed the experiments: RR RD. Analyzed the data: RR RD PZ. Wrote the paper: RR PZ RD.
- 1. Peters U, Poole C, Arab L (2001) Does tea affect cardiovascular disease? A meta-analysis. Am J Epidemiol 154: 495–503.U. PetersC. PooleL. Arab2001Does tea affect cardiovascular disease? A meta-analysis.Am J Epidemiol154495503
- 2. Arab L, Liu W, Elashoff D (2009) Green and Black Tea Consumption and Risk of Stroke. A Meta-Analysis. Stroke 2009. L. ArabW. LiuD. Elashoff2009Green and Black Tea Consumption and Risk of Stroke.A Meta-Analysis. Stroke 2009
- 3. Vita JA (2003) Tea consumption and cardiovascular disease: effects on endothelial function. J Nutr 133: 3293S–7S.JA Vita2003Tea consumption and cardiovascular disease: effects on endothelial function.J Nutr1333293S7S
- 4. Widlansky ME, Gokce N, Keaney JF Jr, Vita JA (2003) The clinical implications of endothelial dysfunction. J Am Coll Cardiol 42: 1149–60.ME WidlanskyN. GokceJF Keaney JrJA Vita2003The clinical implications of endothelial dysfunction.J Am Coll Cardiol42114960
- 5. Ross R (1999) Atherosclerosis: an inflammatory disease. N Engl J Med 340: 115–26.R. Ross1999Atherosclerosis: an inflammatory disease.N Engl J Med34011526
- 6. Celermajer DS, Sorensen KE, Bull C, Robinson J, Deanfield JE (1994) Endothelium-dependent dilation in the systemic arteries of asymptomatic subjects relates to coronary risk factors and their interaction. J Am Coll Cardiol 24: 1468–74.DS CelermajerKE SorensenC. BullJ. RobinsonJE Deanfield1994Endothelium-dependent dilation in the systemic arteries of asymptomatic subjects relates to coronary risk factors and their interaction.J Am Coll Cardiol24146874
- 7. Bonetti PO, Lerman LO, Lerman A (2003) Endothelial dysfunction: a marker of atherosclerotic risk. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 23: 168–75.PO BonettiLO LermanA. Lerman2003Endothelial dysfunction: a marker of atherosclerotic risk.Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol2316875
- 8. Celermajer DS, Sorensen KE, Gooch VM, Spiegelhalter DJ, Miller OI, et al. (1992) Non-invasive detection of endothelial dysfunction in children and adults at risk of atherosclerosis. Lancet 340: 1111–5.DS CelermajerKE SorensenVM GoochDJ SpiegelhalterOI Miller1992Non-invasive detection of endothelial dysfunction in children and adults at risk of atherosclerosis.Lancet34011115
- 9. Corretti MC, Anderson TJ, Benjamin EJ, Celermajer D, Charbonneau F, et al. (2002) Guidelines for the ultrasound assessment of endothelial-dependent flow-mediated vasodilation of the brachial artery: a report of the International Brachial Artery Reactivity Task Force. J Am Coll Cardiol 39: 257–65.MC CorrettiTJ AndersonEJ BenjaminD. CelermajerF. Charbonneau2002Guidelines for the ultrasound assessment of endothelial-dependent flow-mediated vasodilation of the brachial artery: a report of the International Brachial Artery Reactivity Task Force.J Am Coll Cardiol3925765
- 10. Shimbo D, Grahame-Clarke C, Miyake Y, Rodriguez C, Sciacca R, et al. (2007) The association between endothelial dysfunction and cardiovascular outcomes in a population-based multi-ethnic cohort. Atherosclerosis 192: 197–203.D. ShimboC. Grahame-ClarkeY. MiyakeC. RodriguezR. Sciacca2007The association between endothelial dysfunction and cardiovascular outcomes in a population-based multi-ethnic cohort.Atherosclerosis192197203
- 11. Fathi R, Haluska B, Isbel N, Short L, Marwick TH (2004) The relative importance of vascular structure and function in predicting cardiovascular events. J Am Coll Cardiol 43: 616–23.R. FathiB. HaluskaN. IsbelL. ShortTH Marwick2004The relative importance of vascular structure and function in predicting cardiovascular events.J Am Coll Cardiol4361623
- 12. Frick M, Suessenbacher A, Alber HF, Dichtl W, Ulmer H, et al. (2005) Prognostic value of brachial artery endothelial function and wall thickness. J Am Coll Cardiol 46: 1006–10.M. FrickA. SuessenbacherHF AlberW. DichtlH. Ulmer2005Prognostic value of brachial artery endothelial function and wall thickness.J Am Coll Cardiol46100610
- 13. Gokce N, Keaney JF, Hunter LM, Watkins MT, Nedeljkovic ZS, et al. (2003) Predictive value of noninvasively determined endothelial dysfunction for long-term cardiovascular events in patients with peripheral vascular disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 41: 1769–75.N. GokceJF KeaneyLM HunterMT WatkinsZS Nedeljkovic2003Predictive value of noninvasively determined endothelial dysfunction for long-term cardiovascular events in patients with peripheral vascular disease.J Am Coll Cardiol41176975
- 14. Brevetti G, Silvestro A, Schiano V, Chiariello M (2003) Endothelial dysfunction and cardiovascular risk prediction in peripheral arterial disease: additive value of flow-mediated dilation to ankle-brachial pressure index. Circulation 108: 2093–8.G. BrevettiA. SilvestroV. SchianoM. Chiariello2003Endothelial dysfunction and cardiovascular risk prediction in peripheral arterial disease: additive value of flow-mediated dilation to ankle-brachial pressure index.Circulation10820938
- 15. Karatzis EN, Ikonomidis I, Vamvakou GD, Papaioannou TG, Protogerou AD, et al. (2006) Long-term prognostic role of flow-mediated dilatation of the brachial artery after acute coronary syndromes without ST elevation. Am J Cardiol 98: 1424–8.EN KaratzisI. IkonomidisGD VamvakouTG PapaioannouAD Protogerou2006Long-term prognostic role of flow-mediated dilatation of the brachial artery after acute coronary syndromes without ST elevation.Am J Cardiol9814248
- 16. Chan SY, Mancini GB, Kuramoto L, Schulzer M, Frohlich J, et al. (2003) The prognostic importance of endothelial dysfunction and carotid atheroma burden in patients with coronary artery disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 42: 1037–43.SY ChanGB ManciniL. KuramotoM. SchulzerJ. Frohlich2003The prognostic importance of endothelial dysfunction and carotid atheroma burden in patients with coronary artery disease.J Am Coll Cardiol42103743
- 17. Yeboah J, Folsom AR, Burke GL, Johnson C, Polak JF, et al. (2009) Predictive value of brachial flow-mediated dilation for incident cardiovascular events in a population-based study: the multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis. Circulation 120: 502–9.J. YeboahAR FolsomGL BurkeC. JohnsonJF Polak2009Predictive value of brachial flow-mediated dilation for incident cardiovascular events in a population-based study: the multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis.Circulation1205029
- 18. Shechter M, Issachar A, Marai I, Koren-Morag N, Freinark D, et al. (2009) Long-term association of brachial artery flow-mediated vasodilation and cardiovascular events in middle-aged subjects with no apparent heart disease. Int J Cardiol 134: 52–8.M. ShechterA. IssacharI. MaraiN. Koren-MoragD. Freinark2009Long-term association of brachial artery flow-mediated vasodilation and cardiovascular events in middle-aged subjects with no apparent heart disease.Int J Cardiol134528
- 19. Duffy SJ, Keaney JF Jr, Holbrook M, Gokce N, Swerdloff PL, et al. (2001) Short- and long-term black tea consumption reverses endothelial dysfunction in patients with coronary artery disease. Circulation 104: 151–6.SJ DuffyJF Keaney JrM. HolbrookN. GokcePL Swerdloff2001Short- and long-term black tea consumption reverses endothelial dysfunction in patients with coronary artery disease.Circulation1041516
- 20. Hodgson JM, Puddey IB, Burke V, Watts GF, Beilin LJ (2002) Regular ingestion of black tea improves brachial artery vasodilator function. Clin Sci (Lond) 102: 195–201.JM HodgsonIB PuddeyV. BurkeGF WattsLJ Beilin2002Regular ingestion of black tea improves brachial artery vasodilator function.Clin Sci (Lond)102195201
- 21. Hirata K, Shimada K, Watanabe H, Otsuka R, Tokai K, et al. (2004) Black tea increases coronary flow velocity reserve in healthy male subjects. Am J Cardiol 93: 1384–1388.K. HirataK. ShimadaH. WatanabeR. OtsukaK. Tokai2004Black tea increases coronary flow velocity reserve in healthy male subjects.Am J Cardiol9313841388
- 22. Hodgson JM, Burke V, Puddey IB (2005) Acute effects of tea on fasting and postprandial vascular function and blood pressure in humans. J Hypertens 23: 47–54.JM HodgsonV. BurkeIB Puddey2005Acute effects of tea on fasting and postprandial vascular function and blood pressure in humans.J Hypertens234754
- 23. Jochmann N, Lorenz M, Krosigk A, Martus P, Bohm V, et al. (2008) The efficacy of black tea in ameliorating endothelial function is equivalent to that of green tea. Br J Nutr 99: 863–8.N. JochmannM. LorenzA. KrosigkP. MartusV. Bohm2008The efficacy of black tea in ameliorating endothelial function is equivalent to that of green tea.Br J Nutr998638
- 24. Lorenz M, Jochmann N, Krosigk A, Martus P, Baumann G, et al. (2007) Addition of milk prevents vascular protective effects of tea. Eur Heart J 28: 219–23.M. LorenzN. JochmannA. KrosigkP. MartusG. Baumann2007Addition of milk prevents vascular protective effects of tea.Eur Heart J2821923
- 25. Kim W, Jeong MH, Cho SH, Yun JH, Chae HJ, et al. (2006) Effect of green tea consumption on endothelial function and circulating endothelial progenitor cells in chronic smokers. Circ J 70: 1052–7.W. KimMH JeongSH ChoJH YunHJ Chae2006Effect of green tea consumption on endothelial function and circulating endothelial progenitor cells in chronic smokers.Circ J7010527
- 26. Alexopoulos N, Vlachopoulos C, Aznaouridis K, Baou K, Vasiliadou C, et al. (2008) The acute effect of green tea consumption on endothelial function in healthy individuals. Eur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil; 15: 300–5.N. AlexopoulosC. VlachopoulosK. AznaouridisK. BaouC. Vasiliadou2008The acute effect of green tea consumption on endothelial function in healthy individuals.Eur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil;153005
- 27. Hooper L, Kroon PA, Rimm EB, Cohn JS, Harvey I, et al. (2008) Flavonoids, flavonoid-rich foods, and cardiovascular risk: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am J Clin Nutr 88: 38–50.L. HooperPA KroonEB RimmJS CohnI. Harvey2008Flavonoids, flavonoid-rich foods, and cardiovascular risk: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.Am J Clin Nutr883850
- 28. Park CS, Kim W, Woo JS, Ha SJ, Kang WY, et al. (2009) Green tea consumption improves endothelial function but not circulating endothelial progenitor cells in patients with chronic renal failure. Int J Cardiol. CS ParkW. KimJS WooSJ HaWY Kang2009Green tea consumption improves endothelial function but not circulating endothelial progenitor cells in patients with chronic renal failure.Int J Cardiol
- 29. Verhagen AP, de Vet HC, de Bie RA, Kessels AG, Boers M, et al. (1998) The Delphi list: a criteria list for quality assessment of randomized clinical trials for conducting systematic reviews developed by Delphi consensus. J Clin Epidemiol 51: 1235–41.AP VerhagenHC de VetRA de BieAG KesselsM. Boers1998The Delphi list: a criteria list for quality assessment of randomized clinical trials for conducting systematic reviews developed by Delphi consensus.J Clin Epidemiol51123541
- 30. Follmann D, Elliott P, Suh I, Cutler J (1992) Variance imputation for overviews of clinical trials with continuous response. J Clin Epidemiol 45: 769–73.D. FollmannP. ElliottI. SuhJ. Cutler1992Variance imputation for overviews of clinical trials with continuous response.J Clin Epidemiol4576973
- 31. de Bree A, van Mierlo LA, Draijer R (2007) Folic acid improves vascular reactivity in humans: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am J Clin Nutr 86: 610–7.A. de BreeLA van MierloR. Draijer2007Folic acid improves vascular reactivity in humans: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.Am J Clin Nutr866107
- 32. DerSimonian R, Laird N (1986) Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials; 7: 177–88.R. DerSimonianN. Laird1986Meta-analysis in clinical trials.Control Clin Trials;717788
- 33. Van Houwelingen HC, Arends LR, Stijnen T (2002) Advanced methods in meta-analysis: multivariate approach and meta-regression. Stat Med 21: 589–624.HC Van HouwelingenLR ArendsT. Stijnen2002Advanced methods in meta-analysis: multivariate approach and meta-regression.Stat Med21589624
- 34. Cochran WG (1954) The combination of estimates from different experiments. Biometrics 10: 101–29.WG Cochran1954The combination of estimates from different experiments.Biometrics1010129
- 35. Higgins JP, Thompson SG (2002) Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med 21: 1539–58.JP HigginsSG Thompson2002Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis.Stat Med21153958
- 36. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG (2003) Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ 327: 557–60.JP HigginsSG ThompsonJJ DeeksDG Altman2003Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses.BMJ32755760
- 37. Thompson SG, Sharp SJ (1999) Explaining heterogeneity in meta-analysis: a comparison of methods. Stat Med 18: 2693–708.SG ThompsonSJ Sharp1999Explaining heterogeneity in meta-analysis: a comparison of methods.Stat Med182693708
- 38. Thompson SG, Higgins JP (2002) How should meta-regression analyses be undertaken and interpreted? Stat Med 21: 1559–73.SG ThompsonJP Higgins2002How should meta-regression analyses be undertaken and interpreted?Stat Med21155973
- 39. Egger M, Davey SG, Schneider M, Minder C (1997) Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 315: 629–34.M. EggerSG DaveyM. SchneiderC. Minder1997Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test.BMJ31562934
- 40. Ardalan MR (2007) Black tea improves endothelial function in renal transplant recipients. Transplantation-proceedings 39: 1139–42.MR Ardalan2007Black tea improves endothelial function in renal transplant recipients.Transplantation-proceedings39113942
- 41. Grassi D, Mulder T, Draijer D, Desideri G, Molhuizen H, et al. (2009) Black tea consumption dose-dependently improves flow-mediated dilation in healthy males. Journal of Hypertension 27: 774–81.D. GrassiT. MulderD. DraijerG. DesideriH. Molhuizen2009Black tea consumption dose-dependently improves flow-mediated dilation in healthy males.Journal of Hypertension2777481
- 42. Huang AL, Silver AE, Shvenke E, Schopfer DW, Jahangir E, et al. (2007) Predictive value of reactive hyperemia for cardiovascular events in patients with peripheral arterial disease undergoing vascular surgery. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 27: 2113–9.AL HuangAE SilverE. ShvenkeDW SchopferE. Jahangir2007Predictive value of reactive hyperemia for cardiovascular events in patients with peripheral arterial disease undergoing vascular surgery.Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol2721139
- 43. Kitta Y, Obata JE, Nakamura T, Hirano M, Kodama Y, et al. (2009) Persistent impairment of endothelial vasomotor function has a negative impact on outcome in patients with coronary artery disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 53: 323–30.Y. KittaJE ObataT. NakamuraM. HiranoY. Kodama2009Persistent impairment of endothelial vasomotor function has a negative impact on outcome in patients with coronary artery disease.J Am Coll Cardiol5332330
- 44. Modena MG, Bonetti L, Coppi F, Bursi F, Rossi R (2002) Prognostic role of reversible endothelial dysfunction in hypertensive postmenopausal women. J Am Coll Cardiol 40: 505–10.MG ModenaL. BonettiF. CoppiF. BursiR. Rossi2002Prognostic role of reversible endothelial dysfunction in hypertensive postmenopausal women.J Am Coll Cardiol4050510
- 45. Widlansky ME (2007) Acute EGCG supplementation reverses endothelial dysfunction in patients with coronary artery disease. Journal-of-the-American-College-of-Nutrition 26: 95–102.ME Widlansky2007Acute EGCG supplementation reverses endothelial dysfunction in patients with coronary artery disease.Journal-of-the-American-College-of-Nutrition2695102
- 46. Papamichael CM, Aznaouridis KA, Karatzis EN, Karatzi KN, Stamatelopoulos KS, et al. (2005) Effect of coffee on endothelial function in healthy subjects: the role of caffeine. Clin Sci (Lond) 109: 55–60.CM PapamichaelKA AznaouridisEN KaratzisKN KaratziKS Stamatelopoulos2005Effect of coffee on endothelial function in healthy subjects: the role of caffeine.Clin Sci (Lond)1095560
- 47. Manach C, Williamson G, Morand C, Scalbert A, Remesy C (2005) Bioavailability and bioefficacy of polyphenols in humans. I. Review of 97 bioavailability studies. Am J Clin Nutr 81: 230S–42S.C. ManachG. WilliamsonC. MorandA. ScalbertC. Remesy2005Bioavailability and bioefficacy of polyphenols in humans. I. Review of 97 bioavailability studies.Am J Clin Nutr81230S42S
- 48. Chow HH, Hakim IA, Vining DR, Crowell JA, Ranger-Moore J, et al. (2005) Effects of dosing condition on the oral bioavailability of green tea catechins after single-dose administration of Polyphenon E in healthy individuals. Clin Cancer Res 11: 4627–33.HH ChowIA HakimDR ViningJA CrowellJ. Ranger-Moore2005Effects of dosing condition on the oral bioavailability of green tea catechins after single-dose administration of Polyphenon E in healthy individuals.Clin Cancer Res11462733
- 49. Astill C, Birch MR, Dacombe C, Humphrey PG, Martin PT (2001) Factors affecting the caffeine and polyphenol contents of black and green tea infusions. J Agric Food Chem 49: 5340–7.C. AstillMR BirchC. DacombePG HumphreyPT Martin2001Factors affecting the caffeine and polyphenol contents of black and green tea infusions.J Agric Food Chem4953407
- 50. Lakenbrink C, Lapczynski S, Maiwald B, Engelhardt UH (2000) Flavonoids and other polyphenols in consumer brews of tea and other caffeinated beverages. J Agric Food Chem 48: 2848–52.C. LakenbrinkS. LapczynskiB. MaiwaldUH Engelhardt2000Flavonoids and other polyphenols in consumer brews of tea and other caffeinated beverages.J Agric Food Chem48284852
- 51. Grassi D, Aggio A, Onori L, Croce G, Tiberti S, et al. (2008) Tea, flavonoids, and nitric oxide-mediated vascular reactivity. J Nutr 138: 1554S–60S.D. GrassiA. AggioL. OnoriG. CroceS. Tiberti2008Tea, flavonoids, and nitric oxide-mediated vascular reactivity.J Nutr1381554S60S
- 52. Fitzpatrick DF, Hirschfield SL, Ricci T, Jantzen P, Coffey RG (1995) Endothelium-dependent vasorelaxation caused by various plant extracts. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 26: 90–5.DF FitzpatrickSL HirschfieldT. RicciP. JantzenRG Coffey1995Endothelium-dependent vasorelaxation caused by various plant extracts.J Cardiovasc Pharmacol26905
- 53. Loke WM, Hodgson JM, Proudfoot JM, McKinley AJ, Puddey IB, et al. (2008) Pure dietary flavonoids quercetin and (-)-epicatechin augment nitric oxide products and reduce endothelin-1 acutely in healthy men. Am J Clin Nutr 88: 1018–25.WM LokeJM HodgsonJM ProudfootAJ McKinleyIB Puddey2008Pure dietary flavonoids quercetin and (-)-epicatechin augment nitric oxide products and reduce endothelin-1 acutely in healthy men.Am J Clin Nutr88101825
- 54. Persson IA, Josefsson M, Persson K, Andersson RG (2006) Tea flavanols inhibit angiotensin-converting enzyme activity and increase nitric oxide production in human endothelial cells. J Pharm Pharmacol 58: 1139–44.IA PerssonM. JosefssonK. PerssonRG Andersson2006Tea flavanols inhibit angiotensin-converting enzyme activity and increase nitric oxide production in human endothelial cells.J Pharm Pharmacol58113944
- 55. Anter E, Thomas SR, Schulz E, Shapira OM, Vita JA, et al. (2004) Activation of endothelial nitric-oxide synthase by the p38 MAPK in response to black tea polyphenols. J Biol Chem 279: 46637–43.E. AnterSR ThomasE. SchulzOM ShapiraJA Vita2004Activation of endothelial nitric-oxide synthase by the p38 MAPK in response to black tea polyphenols.J Biol Chem2794663743
- 56. Lorenz M, Wessler S, Follmann E, Michaelis W, Dusterhoft T, et al. (2004) A constituent of green tea, epigallocatechin-3-gallate, activates endothelial nitric oxide synthase by a phosphatidylinositol-3-OH-kinase-, cAMP-dependent protein kinase-, and Akt-dependent pathway and leads to endothelial-dependent vasorelaxation. J Biol Chem 279: 6190–5.M. LorenzS. WesslerE. FollmannW. MichaelisT. Dusterhoft2004A constituent of green tea, epigallocatechin-3-gallate, activates endothelial nitric oxide synthase by a phosphatidylinositol-3-OH-kinase-, cAMP-dependent protein kinase-, and Akt-dependent pathway and leads to endothelial-dependent vasorelaxation.J Biol Chem27961905
- 57. Schewe T, Steffen Y, Sies H (2008) How do dietary flavanols improve vascular function? A position paper. Arch Biochem Biophys 476: 102–6.T. ScheweY. SteffenH. Sies2008How do dietary flavanols improve vascular function? A position paper.Arch Biochem Biophys4761026
- 58. Thijssen DHJ, Black MA, Pyke KE, Padilla J, Atkinson G, et al. (2010) Assessment of flow mediated dilation (FMD) in humans: a methodological and physiological guideline. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. DHJ ThijssenMA BlackKE PykeJ. PadillaG. Atkinson2010Assessment of flow mediated dilation (FMD) in humans: a methodological and physiological guideline.Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol
- 59. De Roos NM, Bots ML, Schouten EG, Katan MB (2003) Within-subject variability of flow-mediated vasodilation of the brachial artery in healthy men and women: implications for experimental studies. Ultrasound Med Biol 29: 401–6.NM De RoosML BotsEG SchoutenMB Katan2003Within-subject variability of flow-mediated vasodilation of the brachial artery in healthy men and women: implications for experimental studies.Ultrasound Med Biol294016
- 60. Herrington DM, Fan L, Drum M, Riley WA, Pusser BE, et al. (2001) Brachial flow-mediated vasodilator responses in population-based research: methods, reproducibility and effects of age, gender and baseline diameter. J Cardiovasc Risk 8: 319–28.DM HerringtonL. FanM. DrumWA RileyBE Pusser2001Brachial flow-mediated vasodilator responses in population-based research: methods, reproducibility and effects of age, gender and baseline diameter.J Cardiovasc Risk831928
- 61. Doshi SN, Naka KK, Payne N, Jones CJ, Ashton M, et al. (2001) Flow-mediated dilatation following wrist and upper arm occlusion in humans: the contribution of nitric oxide. Clin Sci (Lond) ; 101: 629–35.SN DoshiKK NakaN. PayneCJ JonesM. Ashton2001Flow-mediated dilatation following wrist and upper arm occlusion in humans: the contribution of nitric oxide.Clin Sci (Lond);10162935
- 62. Pyke and Tschakovsky (2005) The relationship between shear stress and flow-mediated dilatation: implications for the assessment of endothelial function. J Physiol 568: 357–369.Pyke and Tschakovsky2005The relationship between shear stress and flow-mediated dilatation: implications for the assessment of endothelial function.J Physiol568357369