Ventilator-associated pneumonia is the most prevalent acquired infection of patients on intensive care units and is associated with considerable morbidity and mortality. Evidence suggests that an improved understanding of the composition of the biofilm communities that form on endotracheal tubes may result in the development of improved preventative strategies for ventilator-associated pneumonia.
The aim of this study was to characterise microbial biofilms on the inner luminal surface of extubated endotracheal tubes from ICU patients using PCR and molecular profiling. Twenty-four endotracheal tubes were obtained from twenty mechanically ventilated patients. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) profiling of 16S rRNA gene amplicons was used to assess the diversity of the bacterial population, together with species specific PCR of key marker oral microorganisms and a quantitative assessment of culturable aerobic bacteria. Analysis of culturable aerobic bacteria revealed a range of colonisation from no growth to 2.1×108 colony forming units (cfu)/cm2 of endotracheal tube (mean 1.4×107 cfu/cm2). PCR targeting of specific bacterial species detected the oral bacteria Streptococcus mutans (n = 5) and Porphyromonas gingivalis (n = 5). DGGE profiling of the endotracheal biofilms revealed complex banding patterns containing between 3 and 22 (mean 6) bands per tube, thus demonstrating the marked complexity of the constituent biofilms. Significant inter-patient diversity was evident. The number of DGGE bands detected was not related to total viable microbial counts or the duration of intubation.
Molecular profiling using DGGE demonstrated considerable biofilm compositional complexity and inter-patient diversity and provides a rapid method for the further study of biofilm composition in longitudinal and interventional studies. The presence of oral microorganisms in endotracheal tube biofilms suggests that these may be important in biofilm development and may provide a therapeutic target for the prevention of ventilator-associated pneumonia.
Citation: Cairns S, Thomas JG, Hooper SJ, Wise MP, Frost PJ, Wilson MJ, et al. (2011) Molecular Analysis of Microbial Communities in Endotracheal Tube Biofilms. PLoS ONE 6(3): e14759. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0014759
Editor: Niyaz Ahmed, University of Hyderabad, India
Received: March 3, 2010; Accepted: October 30, 2010; Published: March 14, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Cairns et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: All authors are full time employees of the academic institutions stated. There are no current external funding sources for this study. The indirect funders (academic institutions) had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) is the most frequent nosocomial infection in the intensive care unit (ICU) occurring in 8–28% of mechanically ventilated patients , . Mortality rates are high (15–70%) and length of stay is increased, adding a cost of approximately $40,000 per patient , . The presence of an endotracheal tube is an independent risk factor for developing VAP and whilst tracheal intubation is necessary to facilitate mechanical ventilation, it also circumvents elements of patients' innate immunity. The endotracheal tube disrupts the cough reflex, promotes accumulation of tracheobronchial secretions and mucus, and provides a direct conduit for pathogenic microorganisms to reach the lower respiratory tract, increasing the risk of infection . Significantly, the endotracheal tube may also act as a reservoir for pathogens by providing a surface to which they can adhere and form biofilms , , . Polymicrobial biofilms develop rapidly following intubation along the inner lumen of the endotracheal tube, with well-organised antibiotic-resistant structures detectable within twenty-four hours , . Furthermore, 70% of patients with VAP have been reported as having identical pathogens present within the endotracheal tube biofilm as encountered in the lung , suggesting that the biofilm represents a significant and persistent source of pathogenic bacteria.
There is mounting evidence to support the concept that poor oral health is related to the aetiology of bacterial VAP and a number of studies have suggested improved oral hygiene may be effective at reducing its incidence -. Moreover, potential respiratory pathogens such as Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus, that are not generally regarded as normal inhabitants of the oral microflora, are isolated more frequently in the dental plaque of ICU patients than that of the general population , . Given that these potentially pathogenic bacteria are capable of adhering to and forming biofilms with the microflora of the oral cavity (i.e. dental plaque), it seems plausible that oral plaque bacteria may also be present in biofilms of endotracheal tubes. The presence of oral microorganisms in a biofilm within endotracheal tubes may have significance beyond facilitating the adherence of potential respiratory pathogens. Co-aggregation of different microbial species can enhance the virulence characteristics of certain bacteria, as well increasing their tolerance to antimicrobials .
The composition of biofilms in general , and those originating in the oral cavity, in particular, is often misrepresented by traditional cultural analysis . This distortion is apparent even for microorganisms amenable to culture, since recovery from a biofilm environment is subject to many biases including the ability of species to ‘out-compete’ neighbouring species in a given environment and variable replication times. The oral microflora is the most diverse bacterial community in the human body with over 700 species present, and cultural analysis is complex. In addition, given that over 50% of the oral microflora is considered to be unculturable or, more correctly, ‘not-yet-cultured’ the community composition is likely to be considerably distorted by cultural analysis .
Numerous culture independent approaches are available for the analysis of mixed microbial communities. One of the most useful has proven to be the community profiling technique known as denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE), a method used extensively by microbial ecologists for the study of environmental communities , . This approach has been successfully applied to the analysis of wounds, corneal ulcers, gastrointestinal tract and oral cavity -. DGGE is based on the PCR amplification of phylogenetically useful molecules (typically 16S ribosomal DNA) from mixed bacterial communities and the subsequent separation of the amplicons on a denaturing electrophoretic gel. The conditions allow the separation of bands of the same length that have different nucleotide composition. The resulting banding profiles can be analysed to reveal differences in the predominant bacterial composition of samples in cross-sectional and longitudinal studies.
The aim of this study was to characterise microbial biofilms on the inner luminal surface of extubated endotracheal tubes from ICU patients. More specifically the presence of oral marker bacteria and VAP associated pathogens was determined by PCR and the usefulness of DGGE community profiling for the analysis of the endotracheal tube biofilm was assessed.
Materials and Methods
Collection and processing of endotracheal tubes
A total of 24 extubated endotracheal tubes were obtained from 20 patients (12 male and 8 female; age range 20–79 years; mean 61 years) who were intubated and mechanically ventilated on the ICU of a university teaching hospital. Two endotracheal tubes were obtained from each of two of these patients and one patient provided three endotracheal tubes. The duration of intubation prior to endotracheal tube collection was 12–289 h (mean 92 h). Prior to the study the South East Wales IRB confirmed that the project raised no ethical issues and therefore informed consent was not required.
Collected endotracheal tubes were placed in a sealed sterile bag and transferred immediately to the microbiology laboratory for processing (undertaken within 1 h of endotracheal tube collection). From the central region of each endotracheal tube two 1 cm sections were cut and processed. One was used for quantitative microbial culture and the other for molecular analysis. The biofilm was aseptically removed from the endotracheal tube lumen using a sterile scalpel and this was resuspended in 2 ml of phosphate buffered saline (PBS). The preparation was vortex mixed for 30 s with sterilised glass beads to disrupt any biofilm aggregates.
Quantitation of microbial colonisation of the endotracheal tube
The PBS solution containing recovered biofilm was serial decimally diluted 106-fold. Using a spiral-plater system (Don Whitley Scientific, Shipley, UK), 50 µl volumes of each dilution was deposited on to agar media. Quantitation of aerobic microorganisms was achieved by culture on blood agar (BA; LabM, Bury, UK) whilst CHROMagar® Candida (CHROMagar, Paris, France) was used to detect Candida. Inoculated agars were incubated for 37 °C for 48 h. A total aerobic microbial count from the sections was obtained and expressed as total colony forming units (cfu) per cm2 of endotracheal tube section. In addition, Candida species were identified based on colony colour and appearance on CHROMagar® Candida  and by biochemical profiling using the Auxacolor 2 system (Bio-Rad, Hemel Hempstead, UK) .
16S ribosomal RNA gene-defined bacterial colonisation of endotracheal tubes
Sections from each region of the endotracheal tubes were analysed using molecular procedures. The method involved the extraction of total DNA from 500 µl of the PBS specimens using a Puregene® bacterial DNA isolation kit (Qiagen). A universal bacterial primer pair, 341F and 534R  was then used to amplify the 16S rRNA gene targets within the extracted samples using standard PCR and reaction conditions. Negative controls included a reagent control (sterile water served as PCR template) and a sample preparation control (sterile water used in place of the original sample and exposed to the entire extraction protocol). Positive controls of template DNA from three known species Porphyromonas gingivalis NCTC 11834T, Staphylococcus aureus NCTC 6571 and Streptococcus mutans NCTC 20523T) were also included. PCR products were then resolved by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) as outlined below with the products from the control microorganisms serving as markers to facilitate gel normalisation.
Denaturing Gradient Gel Electrophoresis
Polyacrylamide gels were cast using a model 385 gradient former (Bio-Rad). All gels comprised of 1×Tris-acetate-EDTA (TAE) buffer with 10% (w/v) acrylamide, 0.1% (v/v) TEMED, and 0.1% (w/v) ammonium persulphate (all materials from Sigma, Poole, UK). Gels also contained a parallel 30–60% gradient of denaturants (where 100% denaturant concentration was equal to 7 M urea and 40% [v/v] deionised formamide; Sigma).
Parallel DGGE was performed using the Bio-Rad D-Code system. Products from endotracheal tube extract PCRs were run alongside a marker comprising of an equal mixture of PCR products from the three known bacterial stains. DGGE was run in 1×TAE buffer at 56 °C and 160 V/cm2 for 30 min, followed by 40 V/cm2 for 16 h.
DGGE gels were stained with SYBR® Green I nucleic acid gel stain (Sigma) at approximately 4 °C for 30 min. Banding patterns were visualised under UV light using a GelDoc system (Bio-Rad). Gels were then aligned and standardised using the reference markers and GelCompar II software (Applied Maths, Sint-Martens-Latem, Belgium). The presence of individual bands in each profile was assessed using the same software, set to a 1% tolerance of band matching. Using Dice's coefficient and the UPGMA clustering method, a dendrogram of genetic similarity between samples was calculated.
Culture of microorganisms from biofilms recovered from endotracheal tubes
The results of microbial culture are summarised in Table 1. In the case of five endotracheal tube samples, no microbial growth was observed. The viable bacterial aerobic counts ranged between 2×104 and 2.1×108 cfu/cm2 of endotracheal tube section. In 5 endotracheal tubes no viable aerobic bacterial growth was detected, although in one of these tubes Candida was cultured. There was no apparent relationship between the determined bacterial load on the sample and the duration of intubation. In six endotracheal tubes from five patients, C. albicans was isolated following subculture on CHROMagar®Candida and biochemical identification.
DGGE estimation of species richness
The number of bands obtained by DGGE analysis is shown in Table 1 and typical profiles are presented in Figure 1. An average of 6 bands (range 3 to 22) per endotracheal tube sample was detected and the similarity in banding profiles ranged between 20 and 90% (Fig. 2). There was no apparent relationship between the duration of intubation and the number of DGGE bands detected, nor was there a high level of similarity for the DGGE profiles obtained for multiple endotracheal tubes from the same patients (i.e. patient 2, tubes 2 and 7; patient 17, tubes 21 and 24). However, similarity at 75% was evident for the profiles of two endotracheal tubes (14 and 15) which were obtained from patient 12 (Fig. 2). DGGE was shown to be reproducible with consistent profiles being generated upon both repeat and duplicate testing. The community profiles obtained demonstrated considerable inter-patient and intra-patient diversity.
Figure 1a: 1, P. gingivalis; 2, S. aureus; 3, S. mutans; 4, mixed marker of P. gingivalis, S. aureus and S. mutans; 5, ETT1; 6, ETT2; 7, ETT3; 8, ETT4; 9, ETT5; 10, ETT7; 11, ETT8; 12, ETT9; 13, ETT10; 14, ETT11; 15, mixed marker of P. gingivalis, S. aureus and S. mutans. Figure 1b: 1, mixed marker of P. gingivalis, S. aureus and S. mutans; 2, ETT12; 3, ETT14; 4, ETT15; 5, ETT19; 6 ETT21; 7, ETT25; 8, ETT26; 9, mixed marker of P. gingivalis, S. aureus and S. mutans. Figure 1c: 1, Plaque sample control; 2, mixed marker of P. gingivalis, S. aureus and S. mutans; 3, ETT13; 4, ETT16;5, ETT17; 6, ETT18; 7, ETT20; 8, ETT22; 9, ETT23; 10, ETT24; 11, mixed marker of P. gingivalis, S. aureus and S. mutans.
Detection of marker bacteria by species specific PCR
At least one of the oral marker bacterial species (S. mutans or P. gingivalis) was detected by PCR for 9 different patients. Of these 9 patients, PCR was positive only for S. mutans in 4 patients, as was the case for P. gingivalis, the endotracheal tube from one patient (Patient 19, endotracheal tube 23) was positive for both oral bacterial species (Table 1). Figure 3 shows a typical result of the P. gingivalis specific PCR using template DNA obtained from the biofilms recovered from the endotracheal tubes. The detection of the VAP associated species P. aeruginosa and S. aureus occurred in 4 and 6 patients, respectively. The patient distribution of these microorganisms is presented in Table 1.
Lane 26 contains the result from a dental plaque sample known to contain P. gingivalis, used here as a positive control. Lane 27 is a positive control using template DNA from P. gingivalis NCTC 11834T. Lane 28 is the template-free negative control.
Sottile and colleagues first suggested a link between the endotracheal biofilm and pulmonary infection , and this was supported by identical pathogenic bacteria being present in the lung of patients with VAP and the endotracheal biofilm . This concept has been substantiated by a number of experimental and clinical studies, which have used antimicrobial (silver coated) endotracheal tubes to inhibit biofilm formation -, reduce colonisation of the airway - and decrease the incidence of VAP . The reduction in the number and delay of onset of VAP in a large clinical trial is encouraging, however, bacteria can develop silver resistance  and other strategies, which target biofilm formation, may prove to be valuable. In order to prevent endotracheal tube biofilm formation, knowledge of the source of the microorganisms involved is essential.
Improved oral hygiene has proved to be an effective strategy for reducing VAP - and since potential respiratory pathogens are isolated from dental plaque (a biofilm) of mechanically ventilated patients , , we hypothesised that microbes which constitute the normal oral flora might be present in the endotracheal biofilm. In an in vitro Ventilator-Endotracheal-Lung model incorporation of representative species of the oral microflora prior to the addition of pathogens traditionally associated with respiratory infection, augments the subsequent biofilm (JG Thomas, unpublished data), raising the possibility that normal oral microflora may represent pioneering colonising species and promote subsequent endotracheal tube biofilm development. The inner surface of the endotracheal tube provides a unique environment of high shear forces, bi-directional flow, and a restricted immunological environment, which favours a sessile rather than planktonic bacterial life form and thus biofilm formation. The endotracheal biofilm is a complex three-dimensional structure with cyclical bacterial communities many of which are difficult to isolate by conventional planktonic culture techniques . Bacterial species regarded as appropriate markers of the oral microflora (P. gingivalis and S. mutans) were detected in 9 of the 20 patients using species specific PCR. Streptococcus mutans was selected as a target species due to its recognised ability to promote biofilm formation, whilst P. gingivalis was included as a representative species of strictly anaerobic bacteria.
Interestingly, Candida albicans, which is also a common coloniser of the oral cavity, was detected by culture in the endotracheal tubes from 5 patients. This yeast produces filamentous growth forms, which could readily enhance formation and structural stability of the biofilm . Interactions between individual elements of the oral microflora and their capacity to form biofilms are complex. Streptococcus mutans enables C. albicans to bind to synthetic surfaces, coaggregation being dependent on the production of water insoluble glucans and direct cell-cell contact , , . Candida albicans also demonstrates synergistic and antagonistic interactions with S. aureus and P. aeruginosa, which account for 20% and 24% of VAP respectively . Pseudomonas aeruginosa can neither bind nor kill yeast-forms of C. albicans, however this bacterium can form a dense biofilm on C. albicans filaments . Significantly, P. aeruginosa virulence factors associated with human disease (e.g. secreted phospholipase C) have also been linked with biofilm formation and killing of the filamentous forms of C. albicans which might then provide nutrients for bacterial biofilm development . Colonisation of the respiratory tract with C. albicans is associated with an increased risk of Pseudomonas VAP , and conversely antifungal treatment of patients demonstrating airway colonisation with Candida spp. have less P. aeruginosa VAP . An anti-candidal approach has also been successful in reducing the biofilm on laryngeal prosthetic devices . The variation in aerobic bacterial counts between patients ranged between 0 and 2.1×108 cfu/cm2. The reason for such variation (including the absence of bacterial growth in 5 endotracheal tubes) could in part relate to the effectiveness of the seal between endotracheal tube cuff and mucosal wall of the trachea. A totally effective seal would prevent leakage of pooled secretions from above the cuff leading to subsequent contamination of the endotracheal tube lumen and lungs. The effectiveness of the seal will vary with pressure variation between the balloon of the cuff and by the extent of ‘folding’ in the cuff material. Micro-channels generated by such folds can serve as conduits for microbial passage. Oral hygiene parameters of the patients were not assessed in this study and it may be the case that patients with poorer oral hygiene exhibited higher endotracheal tube contamination and vice versa. Some loss of microbial viability between the time of removal of the endotracheal tube from the patient and its subsequent processing for culture is likely, despite the time between these procedures being kept as short as possible. The fact that microbial DNA was obtained from these endotracheal tubes would suggest microbial cells (viable or non-viable) had been present and highlights the benefit of supplementing the culture analysis with molecular investigation.
The present study has shown that DGGE can be used to generate community profiles of the microflora associated with endotracheal tubes. This non-cultural approach has revealed significant microbial diversity with between 3 and 22 (mean 6) bands present per sample. These results are similar to those of other studies of microbial communities assessed by non-cultural methods. In the majority of systems studied, molecular methods detect the presence of a greater number of species than culture alone. For example, in the analysis of failed root canal lesions, between one and 26 bands (mean six) were detected by molecular methods compared to 3-4 isolates detected by culture .
There is no direct correlation between the number of bands detected by DGGE and the number of species present in a sample since numerous factors affect band number including sampling, PCR and differential DNA extraction biases, heteroduplex formation and divergence within multicopy number rDNA families. However, following excision and sequence analysis of individual bands present on DGGE gels, it has been reported that on average each band represents not just one, but an average of 2.7 phylotypes or bacterial species . Therefore, the species richness within the endotracheal tube may be even greater than that implied in the current study.
Previous studies of complex human microbial communities using DGGE have revealed similar levels of diversity to that encountered in the present study. In a study of the microflora associated with dental abscesses from two different geographical locations a total of 99 distinct bands were detected . In both this and an earlier study of root canal lesions many of the observed bands were shared between patient profiles . Although a small number of shared bands were observed in our current study, the inter-patient profile diversity was generally greater when compared to previous studies. Moreover, there was significant intra-patient diversity for the three patients from whom more than one endotracheal tube community profile was obtained. The marked diversity revealed is perhaps not surprising given that the oropharyngeal microflora is considered to be the most complex in the human body with more than 700 different species present of which over 50 % have not yet been cultivated .
Of the numerous culture-independent approaches that are available, DGGE has proven useful in the analysis of many different microbial communities, both environmental and those associated with human infection. The principle advantage is the ability to analyse those bacteria which are either difficult to culture or which have not yet been cultured. The presence in bronchoalveolar lavages (BALs) of both novel microorganisms and those that are already ‘known’ on the basis of sequence characterisation but have not yet been cultivated, has been demonstrated . This research employed a ribosomal RNA cloning and sequencing approach which provided valuable information on the microbial composition of BALs obtained from traumatic ICU patients. The approach demonstrated considerable diversity of bacterial types present in BAL samples with over 54 different bacterial types present, of which 38 had not previously been detected at this site.
Both DGGE and the cloning/sequencing approach have a role to play in the analysis of complex microflora including VAP associated bacteria. DGGE is less technically demanding, less labour intensive and more affordable. Consequently, it may be used for the simultaneous analysis of multiple samples, facilitating the direct comparison of bacterial communities from numerous sources and the effects of interventions in longitudinal studies. DGGE has been used successfully to demonstrate differences in profiles between two distinct patients groups, both in geographic and clinical contexts. The method has been used to demonstrate that both the diversity and complexity of the plaque microflora was less in children with caries compared to caries free children . Differences in DGGE profiles of dental abscesses of Brazilian and USA origin have also been shown . In contrast to many other profiling techniques, DGGE has the advantage that if marker signatures or bands appear to be significant, the bands can be excised and sequenced for further characterisation. In this way, a better characterisation of the microflora associated with dental caries has been demonstrated . Furthermore, as in the current study, the technique can incorporate marker profiles of species of interest .
Care must however be taken if DGGE is used as a technique for species identification as it does have severe limitations in this regard. Since sequences from different species can co-migrate to the same position in the gel  identification based on excised band sequencing requires every fragment to be singularised before sequencing. This can involve either another gradient gel electrophoresis step or a time-consuming cloning process . Furthermore if comparison is made with specific PCR analysis then consideration has to be made to the lower sensitivity of DGGE when compared to PCR directed against a specific microorganism . It has been reported that the sensitivity of DGGE in a mixed community is about 103 cells . However, in terms of community profiling this may not necessarily be a disadvantage since DGGE will reflect the predominant microorganisms present and in the field of medical microbiology, numerical predominance is a fundamental principle.
In summary, a combination of PCR, molecular profiling and culture was used to ascertain the bacterial diversity and presence of specific marker microorganisms in endotracheal tube biofilms. In this context, molecular profiling using DGGE demonstrated considerable biofilm compositional complexity and inter-patient diversity and, as a method that facilitates the study of shifts in the ecological balance of biofilms, will prove invaluable in future longitudinal or interventional studies. We hypothesised that oral microorganisms form part of the endotracheal tube biofilm and, indeed, demonstrated that these bacteria were present. This observation offers the possibility of alternative therapeutic strategies, not necessarily based on anti-infective agents, for preventing VAP which may include mechanically reducing oral plaque, the targeting of quorum sensing signal molecules ,  or modulation of the oral microflora .
Conceived and designed the experiments: SC JGT SH MW PJF DWW. Performed the experiments: SC JGT SH MW PJF DWW. Analyzed the data: SC JGT SH MW PJF MW MAOLL DWW. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SC. Wrote the paper: SH MW PJF MW MAOLL DWW.
- 1. Ruffell A, Adamcova L (2008) Ventilator-associated pneumonia: prevention is better than cure. Nurs Crit Care 13: 44–52.A. RuffellL. Adamcova2008Ventilator-associated pneumonia: prevention is better than cure.Nurs Crit Care134452
- 2. Amin A (2009) Clinical and economic consequences of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Clin Infect Dis 49: S36–43.A. Amin2009Clinical and economic consequences of ventilator-associated pneumonia.Clin Infect Dis49S3643
- 3. Palmer LB (2009) Ventilator-associated infection. Curr Opin Pulm Med 15: 230–235.LB Palmer2009Ventilator-associated infection.Curr Opin Pulm Med15230235
- 4. Jackson WL, Shorr AF (2006) Update in ventilator-associated pneumonia. Curr Opin Anaesthesiol 19: 117–121.WL JacksonAF Shorr2006Update in ventilator-associated pneumonia.Curr Opin Anaesthesiol19117121
- 5. Pneumatikos IA, Dragoumanis CK, Bouros DE (2009) Ventilator-associated pneumonia or endotracheal tube-associated pneumonia? Anesthesiol 110: 673–680.IA PneumatikosCK DragoumanisDE Bouros2009Ventilator-associated pneumonia or endotracheal tube-associated pneumonia?Anesthesiol110673680
- 6. Bauer TT, Torres A, Ferrer R, Heyer CM, Schultze-Werninghaus G, et al. (2002) Biofilm formation in endotracheal tubes. Association between pneumonia and the persistence of pathogens. Monaldi Arch Chest Dis 57: 84–87.TT BauerA. TorresR. FerrerCM HeyerG. Schultze-Werninghaus2002Biofilm formation in endotracheal tubes. Association between pneumonia and the persistence of pathogens.Monaldi Arch Chest Dis578487
- 7. Ramirez P, Ferrer M, Torres A (2007) Prevention measures for ventilator-associated pneumonia: a new focus on the endotracheal tube. Curr Opin Infect Dis 20: 190–197.P. RamirezM. FerrerA. Torres2007Prevention measures for ventilator-associated pneumonia: a new focus on the endotracheal tube.Curr Opin Infect Dis20190197
- 8. Adair CG, Gorman SP, Feron BM, Byers LM, Jones DS, et al. (1999) Implications of endotracheal tube biofilm for ventilator-associated pneumonia. Intensive Care Med 25: 1072–1076.CG AdairSP GormanBM FeronLM ByersDS Jones1999Implications of endotracheal tube biofilm for ventilator-associated pneumonia.Intensive Care Med2510721076
- 9. Koeman M, van der Ven AJ, Hak E, Joore HC, Kaasjager K, et al. (2006) Oral decontamination with chlorhexidine reduces the incidence of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 173: 1348–1355.M. KoemanAJ van der VenE. HakHC JooreK. Kaasjager2006Oral decontamination with chlorhexidine reduces the incidence of ventilator-associated pneumonia.Am J Respir Crit Care Med17313481355
- 10. O'Keefe-McCarthy S (2006) Evidence-based nursing strategies to prevent ventilator-acquired pneumonia. Dynamics 17: 8–11.S. O'Keefe-McCarthy2006Evidence-based nursing strategies to prevent ventilator-acquired pneumonia.Dynamics17811
- 11. Tantipong H, Morkchareonpong C, Jaiyindee S, Thamlikitkul V (2008) Randomized controlled trial and meta-analysis of oral decontamination with 2% chlorhexidine solution for the prevention of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 29: 131–136.H. TantipongC. MorkchareonpongS. JaiyindeeV. Thamlikitkul2008Randomized controlled trial and meta-analysis of oral decontamination with 2% chlorhexidine solution for the prevention of ventilator-associated pneumonia.Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol29131136
- 12. Chan EY (2009) Oral decontamination for ventilator-associated pneumonia prevention. Aus Crit Care 22: 3–4.EY Chan2009Oral decontamination for ventilator-associated pneumonia prevention.Aus Crit Care2234
- 13. Brennan MT, Bahrani-Mougeot F, Fox PC, Kennedy TP, Hopkins S, et al. (2004) The role of oral microbial colonization in ventilator-associated pneumonia. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 98: 665–672.MT BrennanF. Bahrani-MougeotPC FoxTP KennedyS. Hopkins2004The role of oral microbial colonization in ventilator-associated pneumonia.Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod98665672
- 14. Scannapieco FA (2006) Pneumonia in nonambulatory patients: The role of oral bacteria and oral hygiene. JADA 137: 21S–25S.FA Scannapieco2006Pneumonia in nonambulatory patients: The role of oral bacteria and oral hygiene.JADA13721S25S
- 15. Burmølle M, Webb JS, Rao D, Hansen LH, Sørensen SJ, et al. (2006) Enhanced biofilm formation and increased resistance to antimicrobial agents and bacterial invasion are caused by synergistic interactions in multispecies biofilms. Appl Environ Microbiol 72: 3916–3923.M. BurmølleJS WebbD. RaoLH HansenSJ Sørensen2006Enhanced biofilm formation and increased resistance to antimicrobial agents and bacterial invasion are caused by synergistic interactions in multispecies biofilms.Appl Environ Microbiol7239163923
- 16. Donlan RM, Costerton W (2002) Biofilms survival mechanisms of clinically relevant microorganisms. Clin Microbiol Rev 15: 167–193.RM DonlanW. Costerton2002Biofilms survival mechanisms of clinically relevant microorganisms.Clin Microbiol Rev15167193
- 17. Aas JA, Paster BJ, Stokes LN, Olsen I, Dewhirst FE (2005) Defining the normal bacterial flora of the oral cavity. J Clin Microbiol 43: 5721–5732.JA AasBJ PasterLN StokesI. OlsenFE Dewhirst2005Defining the normal bacterial flora of the oral cavity.J Clin Microbiol4357215732
- 18. Muyzer G, de Waal EC, Uitterlinden AG (1993) Profiling of complex microbial populations by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis of polymerase chain reaction-amplified genes coding for 16S rRNA. Appl Environ Microbiol 59: 695–700.G. MuyzerEC de WaalAG Uitterlinden1993Profiling of complex microbial populations by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis of polymerase chain reaction-amplified genes coding for 16S rRNA.Appl Environ Microbiol59695700
- 19. Muyzer G, Smalla K (1998) Application of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) and temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) in microbial ecology. Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek 73: 127–141.G. MuyzerK. Smalla1998Application of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) and temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) in microbial ecology.Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek73127141
- 20. Fujimoto C, Maeda H, Kokeguchi S, Takashiba S, Nishimura F, et al. (2003) Application of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) to the analysis of microbial communities of subgingival plaque. J Periodontal Res 38: 440–445.C. FujimotoH. MaedaS. KokeguchiS. TakashibaF. Nishimura2003Application of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) to the analysis of microbial communities of subgingival plaque.J Periodontal Res38440445
- 21. Millar MR, Linton CJ, Cade A, Glancy D, Hall M, et al. (1996) Application of 16S rRNA gene PCR to study bowel flora of preterm infants with and without necrotizing enterocolitis. J Clin Microbiol 34: 2506–2510.MR MillarCJ LintonA. CadeD. GlancyM. Hall1996Application of 16S rRNA gene PCR to study bowel flora of preterm infants with and without necrotizing enterocolitis.J Clin Microbiol3425062510
- 22. Schabereiter-Gurtner C, Maca S, Rölleke S, Nigl K, Lukas J, et al. (2001) 16S rDNA-based identification of bacteria from conjunctival swabs by PCR and DGGE fingerprinting. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 42: 1164–1171.C. Schabereiter-GurtnerS. MacaS. RöllekeK. NiglJ. Lukas200116S rDNA-based identification of bacteria from conjunctival swabs by PCR and DGGE fingerprinting.Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci4211641171
- 23. Zijnge V, Harmsen HJ, Kleinfelder JW, van der Rest ME, Degener JE, et al. (2003) Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis to study bacterial community structure in pockets of periodontitis patients. Oral Microbiol Immunol 18: 59–65.V. ZijngeHJ HarmsenJW KleinfelderME van der RestJE Degener2003Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis to study bacterial community structure in pockets of periodontitis patients.Oral Microbiol Immunol185965
- 24. Zoetendal EG, von Wright A, Vilpponen-Salmela T, Ben-Amor K, Akkermans ADL, et al. (2002) Mucosa-associated bacteria in the human gastrointestinal tract are uniformly distributed along the colon and differ from the community recovered from feces. Appl Environ Microbiol 68: 3401–3407.EG ZoetendalA. von WrightT. Vilpponen-SalmelaK. Ben-AmorADL Akkermans2002Mucosa-associated bacteria in the human gastrointestinal tract are uniformly distributed along the colon and differ from the community recovered from feces.Appl Environ Microbiol6834013407
- 25. Pfaller MA, Houston A, Coffmann S (1996) Application of CHROMagar Candida for rapid screening of clinical specimens for Candida albicans, Candida tropicalis, Candida krusei, and Candida (Torulopsis) glabrata. J Clin Microbiol 34: 58–61.MA PfallerA. HoustonS. Coffmann1996Application of CHROMagar Candida for rapid screening of clinical specimens for Candida albicans, Candida tropicalis, Candida krusei, and Candida (Torulopsis) glabrata.J Clin Microbiol345861
- 26. Sheppard DC, deSouza E, Hashmi Z, Robson HG, René P (1998) Evaluation of the Auxacolor system for biochemical identification of medically important yeasts. J Clin Microbiol 36: 3726–3727.DC SheppardE. deSouzaZ. HashmiHG RobsonP. René1998Evaluation of the Auxacolor system for biochemical identification of medically important yeasts.J Clin Microbiol3637263727
- 27. Rölleke S, Muyzer G, Wawer C, Wanner G, Lubitz W (1996) Identification of bacteria in a biodegraded wall painting by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis of PCR-amplified gene fragments coding for 16S rRNA. App Environ Microbiol 62: 2059–2065.S. RöllekeG. MuyzerC. WawerG. WannerW. Lubitz1996Identification of bacteria in a biodegraded wall painting by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis of PCR-amplified gene fragments coding for 16S rRNA.App Environ Microbiol6220592065
- 28. Chen Z, Saxena D, Caufield PW, Ge Y, Wang M, et al. (2007) Development of species-specific primers for detection of Streptococcus mutans in mixed bacterial samples. FEMS Microbiol Lett 272: 154–162.Z. ChenD. SaxenaPW CaufieldY. GeM. Wang2007Development of species-specific primers for detection of Streptococcus mutans in mixed bacterial samples.FEMS Microbiol Lett272154162
- 29. Kulekci G, Leblebicioglu B, Keskin F, Ciftci S, Badur S (2008) Salivary detection of periodontopathic bacteria in periodontally healthy children. Anaerobe 14: 49–54.G. KulekciB. LeblebiciogluF. KeskinS. CiftciS. Badur2008Salivary detection of periodontopathic bacteria in periodontally healthy children.Anaerobe144954
- 30. Lavenir R, Jocktane D, Laurent F, Nazaret S, Cournover B (2007) Improved reliability of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PCR detection by the use of the species-specific ecfX gene target. J Microbiol Meth 70: 20–29.R. LavenirD. JocktaneF. LaurentS. NazaretB. Cournover2007Improved reliability of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PCR detection by the use of the species-specific ecfX gene target.J Microbiol Meth702029
- 31. Liu ZM, Shi XM, Pan F (2007) Species-specific diagnostic marker for rapid identification of Staphylococcus aureus. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis 59: 379–382.ZM LiuXM ShiF. Pan2007Species-specific diagnostic marker for rapid identification of Staphylococcus aureus.Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis59379382
- 32. Sottile FD, Marrie TJ, Prough DS, Hobgood CD, Gower DJ, et al. (1986) Nosocomial pulmonary infection: possible etiologic significance of bacterial adhesion to endotracheal tubes. Crit Care Med 14: 265–270.FD SottileTJ MarrieDS ProughCD HobgoodDJ Gower1986Nosocomial pulmonary infection: possible etiologic significance of bacterial adhesion to endotracheal tubes.Crit Care Med14265270
- 33. Olsen ME, Harmon BG, Kollef MH (2002) Silver-coated endotracheal tubes associated with reduced bacterial burden in the lungs of mechanically ventilated dogs. Chest 121: 863–870.ME OlsenBG HarmonMH Kollef2002Silver-coated endotracheal tubes associated with reduced bacterial burden in the lungs of mechanically ventilated dogs.Chest121863870
- 34. Berra L, De Marchi L, Yu ZX, Laquerriere P, Baccarelli A, et al. (2004) Endotracheal tubes coated with antiseptics decrease bacterial colonization of the ventilator circuits, lungs, and endotracheal tube. Anesthesiology 100: 1446–1456.L. BerraL. De MarchiZX YuP. LaquerriereA. Baccarelli2004Endotracheal tubes coated with antiseptics decrease bacterial colonization of the ventilator circuits, lungs, and endotracheal tube.Anesthesiology10014461456
- 35. Berra L, Kolobow T, Laquerriere P, Pitts B, Bramati S, et al. (2008) Internally coated endotracheal tubes with silver sulfadiazine in polyurethane to prevent bacterial colonization: a clinical trial. Intensive Care Med 34: 1030–1037.L. BerraT. KolobowP. LaquerriereB. PittsS. Bramati2008Internally coated endotracheal tubes with silver sulfadiazine in polyurethane to prevent bacterial colonization: a clinical trial.Intensive Care Med3410301037
- 36. Berra L, Curto F, Li Bassi G, Laquerriere P, Pitts B, et al. (2008) Antimicrobial-coated endotracheal tubes: an experimental study. Intensive Care Med 34: 1020–1029.L. BerraF. CurtoG. Li BassiP. LaquerriereB. Pitts2008Antimicrobial-coated endotracheal tubes: an experimental study.Intensive Care Med3410201029
- 37. Kollef MH, Afessa B, Anzueto A, Veremakis C, Kerr KM, et al. (2008) Silver-coated endotracheal tubes and incidence of ventilator-associated pneumonia: the NASCENT randomized trial. JAMA 300: 805–813.MH KollefB. AfessaA. AnzuetoC. VeremakisKM Kerr2008Silver-coated endotracheal tubes and incidence of ventilator-associated pneumonia: the NASCENT randomized trial.JAMA300805813
- 38. Percival SL, Bowler PG, Russell D (2005) Bacterial resistance to silver in wound care. J Hosp Infect 60: 1–7.SL PercivalPG BowlerD. Russell2005Bacterial resistance to silver in wound care.J Hosp Infect6017
- 39. Wolcott RD, Ehrlich GD (2008) Biofilms and chronic infections. JAMA 299: 2682–2684.RD WolcottGD Ehrlich2008Biofilms and chronic infections.JAMA29926822684
- 40. Lopez-Ribot JL (2005) Candida albicans biofilms: more than filamentation. Curr Biol 15: R453–R455.JL Lopez-Ribot2005Candida albicans biofilms: more than filamentation.Curr Biol15R453R455
- 41. Branting C, Sund ML, Linder LE (1989) The influence of Streptococcus mutans on adhesion of Candida albicans to acrylic surfaces in vitro. Arch Oral Biol 34: 347–353.C. BrantingML SundLE Linder1989The influence of Streptococcus mutans on adhesion of Candida albicans to acrylic surfaces in vitro.Arch Oral Biol34347353
- 42. Shinada K, Ozaki F, Cordiero JG, Okada S, Shimoyama K, et al. (1995) A morphological study of interactions of Candida albicans and Streptococcus mutans. Kokubyo Gakkai Zasshi 62: 281–286.K. ShinadaF. OzakiJG CordieroS. OkadaK. Shimoyama1995A morphological study of interactions of Candida albicans and Streptococcus mutans.Kokubyo Gakkai Zasshi62281286
- 43. Shirtliff ME, Peters BM, Jabra-Rizk MA (2009) Cross-kingdom interactions: Candida albicans and bacteria. FEMS Microbiol Lett 299: 1–8.ME ShirtliffBM PetersMA Jabra-Rizk2009Cross-kingdom interactions: Candida albicans and bacteria.FEMS Microbiol Lett29918
- 44. Park DR (2005) The microbiology of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Respir Care 50: 742–763.DR Park2005The microbiology of ventilator-associated pneumonia.Respir Care50742763
- 45. Hogan DA, Kolter R (2002) Pseudomonas-Candida interactions: an ecological role for virulence factors. Science 296: 2229–2232.DA HoganR. Kolter2002Pseudomonas-Candida interactions: an ecological role for virulence factors.Science29622292232
- 46. Azoulay E, Timsit JF, Tafflet M, de Lassence A, Darmon M, et al. (2006) Candida colonization of the respiratory tract and subsequent pseudomonas ventilator-associated pneumonia. Chest 129: 110–117.E. AzoulayJF TimsitM. TaffletA. de LassenceM. Darmon2006Candida colonization of the respiratory tract and subsequent pseudomonas ventilator-associated pneumonia.Chest129110117
- 47. Nseir S, Jozefowicz E, Cavestri B, Sendid B, Di Pompeo C, et al. (2007) Impact of antifungal treatment on Candida-Pseudomonas interaction: a preliminary retrospective case-control study. Intensive Care Med 33: 137–142.S. NseirE. JozefowiczB. CavestriB. SendidC. Di Pompeo2007Impact of antifungal treatment on Candida-Pseudomonas interaction: a preliminary retrospective case-control study.Intensive Care Med33137142
- 48. Dijk F, Westerhof M, Busscher HJ, van Luyn MJ, van Der Mei HC (2000) In vitro formation of oropharyngeal biofilms on silicone rubber treated with a palladium/tin salt mixture. J Biomed Mater Res 51: 408–412.F. DijkM. WesterhofHJ BusscherMJ van LuynHC van Der Mei2000In vitro formation of oropharyngeal biofilms on silicone rubber treated with a palladium/tin salt mixture.J Biomed Mater Res51408412
- 49. Rôças IN, Siqueira JF Jr, Aboim MC, Rosado AS (2004) Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis of bacterial communities associated with failed endodontic treatment. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 98: 741–749.IN RôçasJF Siqueira JrMC AboimAS Rosado2004Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis of bacterial communities associated with failed endodontic treatment.Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod98741749
- 50. Li Y, Ge Y, Saxena D, Caufield PW (2007) Genetic profiling of the oral microbiota associated with severe early-childhood caries. J Clin Microbiol 45: 81–87.Y. LiY. GeD. SaxenaPW Caufield2007Genetic profiling of the oral microbiota associated with severe early-childhood caries.J Clin Microbiol458187
- 51. Machado de Oliveira JC, Siqueira JF Jr, Rôças IN, Baumgartner JC, Xia T, et al. (2007) Bacterial community profiles of endodontic abscesses from Brazilian and USA subjects as compared by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis. Oral Microbiol Immunol 22: 14–18.JC Machado de OliveiraJF Siqueira JrIN RôçasJC BaumgartnerT. Xia2007Bacterial community profiles of endodontic abscesses from Brazilian and USA subjects as compared by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis analysis.Oral Microbiol Immunol221418
- 52. Bahrani-Mougeot FK, Paster BJ, Coleman S, Barbuto S, Brennan MT, et al. (2007) Molecular analysis of oral and respiratory bacterial species associated with ventilator-associated pneumonia. J Clin Microbiol. 45: 1588–1593.FK Bahrani-MougeotBJ PasterS. ColemanS. BarbutoMT Brennan2007Molecular analysis of oral and respiratory bacterial species associated with ventilator-associated pneumonia.J Clin Microbiol.4515881593
- 53. Fujimoto C, Maeda H, Kokeguchi S, Takashiba S, Nishimura F, et al. (2003) Application of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) to the analysis of microbial communities of subgingival plaque. J Periodontal Res 38: 440–445.C. FujimotoH. MaedaS. KokeguchiS. TakashibaF. Nishimura2003Application of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) to the analysis of microbial communities of subgingival plaque.J Periodontal Res38440445
- 54. Jackson CR, Roden EE, Churchill PF (2000) Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis can fail to separate 16S rDNA fragments with multiple base differences. Mol Biol Today 1: 49–51.CR JacksonEE RodenPF Churchill2000Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis can fail to separate 16S rDNA fragments with multiple base differences.Mol Biol Today14951
- 55. Gafan GP, Spratt DA (2005) Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis gel expansion (DGGEGE)-an attempt to resolve the limitations of co-migration in the DGGE of complex polymicrobial communities. FEMS Microbiol Lett 253: 303–307.GP GafanDA Spratt2005Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis gel expansion (DGGEGE)-an attempt to resolve the limitations of co-migration in the DGGE of complex polymicrobial communities.FEMS Microbiol Lett253303307
- 56. Cocolin L, Bisson LF, Mills DA (2000) Direct profiling of the yeasts dynamics in wine fermentations. FEMS Microbiol Lett 189: 81–87.L. CocolinLF BissonDA Mills2000Direct profiling of the yeasts dynamics in wine fermentations.FEMS Microbiol Lett1898187
- 57. De Sordi L, Mühlschlegel FA (2009) Quorum sensing and fungal-bacterial interactions in Candida albicans: a communicative network regulating microbial coexistence and virulence. FEMS Yeast Res 9: 990–999.L. De SordiFA Mühlschlegel2009Quorum sensing and fungal-bacterial interactions in Candida albicans: a communicative network regulating microbial coexistence and virulence.FEMS Yeast Res9990999
- 58. Le Berre R, Faure K, Nguyen S, Pierre M, Ader F, et al. (2006) Quorum sensing: a new clinical target for Pseudomonas aeruginosa? Med Mal Infect 36: 349–357.R. Le BerreK. FaureS. NguyenM. PierreF. Ader2006Quorum sensing: a new clinical target for Pseudomonas aeruginosa?Med Mal Infect36349357
- 59. Forrestier C, Guelon D, Cluytens V, Gillart T, Sirot J, et al. (2008) Oral probiotic and prevention of Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot study in intensive care unit patients. Crit Care 12: R69.C. ForrestierD. GuelonV. CluytensT. GillartJ. Sirot2008Oral probiotic and prevention of Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot study in intensive care unit patients.Crit Care12R69