Physical activity modulates expression of metabolic genes and may therefore be a prerequisite for metabolic responses to environmental stimuli. However, the extent to which exercise interacts with environmental conditions to modulate metabolism is unresolved. Hence, we tested the hypothesis that even low levels of physical activity are beneficial by improving metabolic responsiveness to temperatures below the thermal neutral zone, thereby increasing the capacity for substrate oxidation and energy expenditure.
We used wild rats (Rattus fuscipes) to avoid potential effects of breeding on physiological phenotypes. Exercise acclimation (for 30 min/day on 5 days/week for 30 days at 60% of maximal performance) at 22°C increased mRNA concentrations of PGC1α, PPARδ, and NRF-1 in skeletal muscle and brown adipose tissue compared to sedentary animals. Lowering ambient temperature to 12°C caused further increases in relative expression of NRF-1 in skeletal muscle, and of PPARδ of brown adipose tissue. Surprisingly, relative expression of UCP1 increased only when both exercise and cold stimuli were present. Importantly, in sedentary animals cold acclimation (12°C) alone did not change any of the above variables. Similarly, cold alone did not increase maximum capacity for substrate oxidation in mitochondria (cytochrome c oxidase and citrate synthase activities) of either muscle or brown adipose tissue. Animals that exercised regularly had higher exercise induced metabolic rates in colder environments than sedentary rats, and temperature induced metabolic scope was greater in exercised rats.
Physical activity is a necessary prerequisite for the expression of transcriptional regulators that influence a broad range of physiological functions from energy metabolism to cardiovascular function and nutrient uptake. A sedentary lifestyle leads to decreased daily energy expenditure because of a lack of direct use of energy and a muted metabolic response to ambient temperature, which can be reversed even by low levels of physical activity.
Citation: Seebacher F, Glanville EJ (2010) Low Levels of Physical Activity Increase Metabolic Responsiveness to Cold in a Rat (Rattus fuscipes). PLoS ONE 5(9): e13022. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0013022
Editor: Lewis George Halsey, Roehampton University, United Kingdom
Received: June 16, 2010; Accepted: August 31, 2010; Published: September 27, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Seebacher, Glanville. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was partly funded by the Australian Research Council (grant DP0772438; www.arc.gov.au). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Animal health and reproductive success is largely determined by a balance between energy intake and expenditure. Too little chemical energy (adenosine triphosphate, ATP) available to cells will constrain animal function  and too much energy ingested will lead to obesity and disease –. Energy is expended to maintain cellular homeostasis, and on growth and locomotion. Physical activity is a default condition for most mammals  and the regulatory pathways that control ATP production have evolved with exercise as a principal selection pressure –. The mammalian genome may therefore be maladapted to inactivity to the extent that switching from an active to a sedentary lifestyle could disrupt metabolic signaling and cause medical conditions such as obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease –.
Aerobic, or oxidative, metabolism is the principal avenue for ATP production in all animals, and also for heat production in endotherms. In the cell, mitochondria are the site for oxidative metabolic pathways. The capacity of mitochondria to oxidise substrates derived from food is important for whole animal energy expenditure , but mitochondria are effective in facilitating whole body energy use only when cells are in a negative energy balance . Energy is stored in mitochondria as an electrochemical proton gradient across an inner membrane in which the principal metabolic protein complexes are situated. A negative energy balance is achieved by dissipating the proton gradient across the inner mitochondrial membrane; this can occur by ATP use in the cell resulting from physical activity, which will stimulate an enzyme in the inner mitochondrial membrane (complex V or FoF1 ATPase) to replenish ATP by phosphorylating ADP using energy provided by the proton gradient. Additionally, exposure to cold will stimulate heat production in mitochondria  by causing protons to pass through the inner membrane without ATP production, which is facilitated by activation of specific uncoupling proteins (uncoupling protein 1 or UCP1). Both cold exposure and exercise trigger transcriptional pathways that lead to increased mitochondrial abundance and oxidative capacity in skeletal muscle and brown adipose tissue –. Elevated oxidative capacity, which may be reflected in the increased activity of mitochondrial enzymes such as citrate synthase and cytochrome c oxidase , leads to increased substrate oxidation and energy use. Regulation of mitochondrial metabolism is to a large extent achieved by a relatively small number of transcription factors and their coactivators. The transcriptional co-activator peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma coactivator-1 alpha (PGC-1α) interacts with nuclear respiratory factors (NRF-1 and NRF-2) to stimulate mitochondrial biogenesis , –. Exercise also increases fatty acid oxidation in skeletal muscle by inducing peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor delta (PPARδ) expression, a transcriptional regulator of energy metabolism that plays an important role in the transcriptional regulation of muscle metabolism , –. One mechanism by which PPARδ modulates metabolism of skeletal muscle in mice is by causing a switch from glycolytic, fast muscle fibres to oxidative, slow muscle fibres, resulting in greater running performance and aerobic capacity . Interestingly, however, pharmacological stimulation of PPARδ, does not necessarily improve endurance performance although it does cause an increase in transcription of some genes important in oxidative metabolism . However, PPARδ stimulation in combination with physical activity induces the expression of a suite of metabolic genes, improves endurance performance, and reduces fat content, which indicates that exercise is a necessary trigger allowing PPARδ to interact with otherwise cryptic target genes . These data suggest that physical activity may be required to achieve patterns of gene expression that permit effective regulation of energy balance , , . Additionally, cold stimulates mitochondrial uncoupling and energy use in brown adipose tissue (BAT) by increasing the activity and transcription of mitochondrial uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1; , –).
In the absence of either cold or activity, metabolic responses will be muted, which may explain the limited metabolic response of experimental stimulation of metabolic regulators , . Although cold exposure and exercise may each stimulate mitochondrial flux and capacity, it is not clear whether the two act independently –, , . Hence, it was our aim to determine whether cold exposure and physical activity interact to modulate energy metabolism.
In the context of endothermic metabolism, “cold” may be defined as an ambient temperature below the thermal neutral zone when metabolic rates increase above basal rates . In practice, most endotherms experience environmental temperatures below their thermal neutral zone most of the time; for example, the thermal neutral zone of humans is 33–35°C, and that of Rattus fuscipes is 29–31°C. Metabolic responses triggered by ambient temperature therefore constitute a principal avenue of daily energy expenditure . If, however, metabolic responses to cold are dependent on a behavioural trigger such as physical activity, the reduction in daily energy use in sedentary animals would be twofold, firstly resulting from a lack of direct exercise-related energy use, and secondly resulting from a muted metabolic response to cold.
We tested the null-hypothesis that chronic cold and regular low level exercise act independently to elicit similar metabolic responses. Hence, an animal that is sedentary and exposed to cold will have similar metabolic responses as an animal that is exercised in the warmth. The alternatively hypothesis is that there is a differential, and possibly an interactive effect of cold exposure and exercise on metabolic responses. To test these hypotheses, we exposed rats chronically to different thermal and exercise conditions in a two-factorial experimental design, and examined a functional cascade of responses from the expression of regulatory transcription factors to running performance. Our results show that metabolic responses to cold are dependent on low levels of physical activity, so that the principal avenues of daily energy expenditure are removed by a sedentary lifestyle.
In muscle, relative expression of all target genes was significantly greater in exercised animals (main effect, all F1,23>55.76, p<0.0001; Fig. 1a). There was significant interaction between exercise and thermal acclimation for NRF-1 expression (F1,23 = 4.98, p<0.05), which means exercised and warm acclimated animals had a lower expression than exercised, cold acclimated animals (Fig. 1a). PGC-1α relative expression was lower in warm acclimated animals (F1,23 = 6.42, p<0.02), but there was no significant interaction between exercise and thermal acclimation (F1,23 = 3.45, p = 0.078). Only exercise had a significant effect on PPARδ relative expression (F1,23 = 55.26, p<0.0001), and neither thermal acclimation nor the interaction were significant (F1,23 = 3.12, p = 0.092 and F1,23 = 0.02, p = 0.97, respectively).
Relative expression (mean ± s.e.m) of transcriptional regulators PGC-1α, NRF-1, and PPARδ in skeletal muscle (A) and BAT (B), and UCP1 in BAT (B) from cold exercised (blue bars), warm exercised (red bars), cold sedentary (blue striped bars) and warm sedentary (red striped bars) rats. The relative expression of all genes increased with exercise in both skeletal muscle and BAT. There were significant interactions between thermal acclimation and exercise for NRF-1 relative expression in muscle, and for PPARδ expression in BAT. UCP1 relative expression did not increase in response to either cold or exercise alone, but only when those two stimuli coincided. Significant differences are indicated by different letters above each column.
Similar to muscle, relative expression of all target genes increased with exercise treatment in BAT (main effect, all F1,23>15.90, p<0.0001; Fig. 1b). UCP1 mRNA levels in BAT did not increase either in response to cold or to exercise alone, but concentrations of UCP1 mRNA increased significantly when both cold and exercise stimuli were present (interaction: F1,23 = 9.74, p = 0.005; Fig. 1b). There was also an interaction between thermal acclimation and exercise in the relative expression of PPARδ (F1,23 = 4.56, p<0.05), and warm acclimated animals had lower expression when exercised but higher expression when sedentary (Fig. 1b). Contrary to expectation, cold exposure had no effect on the relative expression of PGC-1α or NRF-1 (all F1,23<0.5, p>0.49; Fig. 1b).
PGC-1α relative expression was a significant predictor of PPARδ and NRF-1 relative expression in both muscle and BAT, and also of UCP1 relative expression in BAT (Fig. 2).
There were significant associations between PGC-1α and PPARδ (a), NRF-1 (b) and UCP1 (c) relative expression in BAT, and between PGC-1α and PPARδ (d), NRF-1 (e) in skeletal muscle. Results form regression analyses are shown in each panel, and the axes are on a logarithmic scale.
Cytochrome c oxidase (COX) activity, an indicator of the maximal capacity of mitochondria for substrate oxidation, was significantly higher in skeletal muscle (F1,35 = 6.16, p<0.02; Fig. 3a) of exercised rats compared to sedentary rats. Cold acclimation did not cause an change in COX activity in muscle (F1,35 = 0.56, p = 0.46). Similarly, COX activity in BAT of exercised rats was significantly higher than in sedentary rats (F1,35 = 39.86, p<0.0001), but there was an interaction between exercise and thermal acclimation indicating that cold acclimated, exercised rats had the greatest COX activity (F1,32 = 11.16, p<0.002; Fig. 3b).
Activity (µmol substrate converted g−1 wet tissue; mean ± s.e.m) of cytochrome c oxidase (COX; A and B), citrate synthase (CS; C and D) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH; E and F) of cold exercised (blue bars), warm exercised (red bars), cold sedentary (blue hatched bars) and warm sedentary (red hatched bars) rat skeletal muscle and brown adipose tissue (BAT). Exercise had a significant effect on all enzyme activities, but the effect of cold exposure alone was limited. Letters above each column indicate significant differences.
Citrate synthase (CS) activity is a measure of mitochondrial abundance. In muscle, its activity was significantly higher in exercised (F1,27 = 115.84, p<0.0001) and warm acclimated rats (F1,27 = 6.08, p<0.03; Fig. 3c). In BAT, only exercise had a significant effect on CS activity (F1,27 = 142.68, p<0.0001), and thermal acclimation did not (F1,27 = 0.92, p = 0.35; Fig. 3d).
We determined lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) activity to assess whether there is a change in glycolytic, anaerobic ATP production. LDH activity was significantly higher in muscle of exercised rats compared to sedentary animals (F1,35 = 53.54, p<0.0001) but cold exposure had no effect (F1,35 = 0.061, p = 0.81; Fig. 3e). In BAT, neither exercise (F1,35 = 2.66, p = 0.11) nor thermal acclimation (F1,35 = 1.67, p = 0.21) affected LDH activity (Fig. 3f).
Whole animal oxygen consumption
Resting metabolic rate (RMR) increased with decreasing test temperature in exercised rats, and it was lower in exercised rats compared to sedentary rats at the higher ambient temperature of 22°C (exercise x test temperature interaction: F1,22 = 9,19, p<0.01; Fig. 4a). Temperature induced metabolic scope (RMR 12°C/22°C) was significantly greater in exercised rats compared to sedentary rats (F1,25 = 9.88, p<0.01) regardless of thermal acclimation (F1,25 = 0.001, p = 0.98; Fig. 4b). Exercise induced metabolic rate (EIMR) was significantly higher in cold acclimated rats compared to warm acclimated rats (F1,30 = 9.75, p<0.005). Importantly, exercise induced metabolic rate increased significantly in exercised rats at 12°C but not in sedentary rats (test temperature x exercise treatment interaction: F1,30 = 36.82, p<0.0001; Fig. 4c). Exercise induced metabolic scope (EIMR/RMR) was significantly greater in cold acclimated (F1,21 = 9.99, p<0.005) and exercised (F1,21 = 15.42, p<0.001) rats. Interestingly, at low temperature scope increased in cold acclimated and exercised rats but not in animals from other treatments (test temperature x exercise interaction: F1,21 = 4.99, p<0.05; Fig. 4d).
Resting (RMR; A) and exercise induced (EIMR; C) metabolic rates (ml O2.g−1.hr−1) in cold exercised (blue bars), warm exercised (red bars), cold sedentary (blue hatched bars) and warm sedentary (red hatched bars) rats (mean ± s.e.m) measured at different ambient test temperatures (12°C and 22°C). Resting metabolic rates (A) were lowest in exercised animals at 22°C, and exercised induced metabolic rates (C) were highest in cold acclimated exercised rats. Temperature induced metabolic scope (RMR at 12°C/RMR at 22°C; B) was greatest in exercised rats, and exercise induced metabolic scope (EIMR/RMR; D) was greatest in cold acclimated exercised rats at 12°C. Letters above columns indicate significant differences; please note however that there were also significant interactions which are difficult to represent graphically.
Critical sustained running performance
Critical sustained running performance (Ucrit) varied with exercise, thermal acclimation and test temperature (three way interaction: F1,31 = 7.98, p<0.01), but none of the main effects was significant (all F1,31<2.3, p>0.14; Fig. 5). Ucrit was lower in warm acclimated rats at 12°C regardless of exercise training, and cold acclimated, exercise trained rats performed worst at 22°C. There is no indication that our exercise regime had a training effect that improved running performance (i.e. no main effect of exercise F1,31 = 0.007, p = 0.936).
Critical sustained running speed (Ucrit) of cold exercised (blue bars), warm exercised (red bars), cold sedentary (blue hatched bars) and warm sedentary (red hatched bars) rats at 12°C and 22°C (mean ± s.e.m). There was a three-way interaction between exercise, thermal acclimation, and test temperature. Cold acclimated animals performed best, and warm acclimated animal performed worst at 12°C. Cold acclimated and exercised rats performed worst at 22°C.
Physical activity at temperatures below the thermal neutral zone is the typical condition for non-dormant (torpid or asleep) animals. Here we show that physical activity and cold exposure interact in their effects on metabolism. Cold alone has no effect on transcriptional regulators and causes only a limited increase in mitochondrial enzyme activities. Coordination and quantitative adjustment of metabolic pathways depends on induction or repression of transcription of a small number of transcription factors and their coactivators , of which PGC-1α plays an overarching regulatory role . Modulation of PGC-1α leads to a large number of downstream effects that include cardiovascular function and angiogenesis , , substrate utilisation and switching, including insulin sensitivity, glucose transport, and gluconeogenesis , , and muscle fibre differentiation . Hence, our finding that routine physical activity is a necessary prerequisite for increases in PGC-1α expression in response to a second stimulus – cold in our case – has implications that extend beyond adjustments of metabolic rate. This role of exercise is emphasised by the fact that two principal targets of PGC-1α, NRF-1 and PPARδ, show similar expression patterns as PGC-1α in response to physical activity and cold, and that there is a significant correlation between PGC-1α relative expression and that of the other transcriptional regulators as well as UCP1. PGC-1α facilitates the interaction between NRF-1 and the mitochondrial transcription factor Tfam, which regulates mitochondrial DNA replication and transcription . PPARδ plays a critical role in the transcriptional regulation of muscle metabolism and mitochondrial fatty acid catabolism , , . Hence, at least in R. fuscipes, it appears that physical activity is a necessary prerequisite for increases in mitochondrial abundance and oxidative metabolism. Changes in the expression of transcriptional regulators are reflected in the increased activity of rate limiting enzymes of the tricarboxylic acid cycle and electron transport chain, as well as of glycolysis.
Cold can stimulate mitochondrial metabolism and abundance via the sympathetic nervous system, and adrenergic receptors on the cell surface can stimulate PGC-1α transcription via cAMP and CREB signalling . Similalry, excess caloric food intake is sensed by the brain, which will mediate an increase in energy expenditure via adrenergic receptors . The similar sympathetic pathways that induce energy expenditure in response to cold and caloric intake suggest that the latter response may also depend on a minimum of physical activity, although this suggestion must be verified experimentally. Exposure to temperatures below the thermal neutral zone effectively increases energy expenditure ,  that could counteract obesity. However, we show that such a response will be ineffective in the absence of regular physical activity, and that the temperature induced metabolic scope is significantly reduced in sedentary animals.
PGC-1α also regulates non-shivering thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue ,  by inducing the expression of uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1). UCP-1 facilitates non-shivering thermogenesis in BAT by uncoupling electron transport in the inner mitochondrial membrane from oxidative phosphorylation , . Interestingly, UCP-1 relative gene expression increased only in animals that exercised regularly. Hence, any BAT mediated increase in energy expenditure also relies on regular physical activity. As a corollary, adaptive thermogenesis in sedentary individuals living in more extreme environments may also be limited because of reduced UCP-1 expression, and because of the decreased mitochondrial capacity and abundance. The differences between treatment groups were pronounced even in our experimental environments that were relatively benign, and which did not compromise thermoregulation . We did not aim to push animals to their physiological limits as is often done when testing thermogenic capacity of mammals; rather, our data have important implication for day-to-day (routine) energy expenditure. Animals including humans live mostly below their thermal neutral zone, so that ambient temperature will act as a stimulator for metabolic activity and energy expenditure most of the time. For example, the thermal neutral zone of R. fuscipes in 29–31°C (Glanville, unpublished data), which the animals almost never experience in the wild . Similarly, the thermal neutral zone of humans is 33–35°C , which is rarely experienced except maybe at low latitudes. We show that although decreasing ambient temperature can potentially trigger energy expenditure, the responsiveness to ambient temperature changes is blunted in the absence of regular exercise. Hence, exercise is beneficial by directly causing expenditure of energy, and by enabling ambient temperature induced energy expenditure. One caveat to this conclusion is that sedentary animals had a higher metabolic rate at rest and at warm ambient temperatures (22°C) than exercised rats. However, with physical activity and a decrease in ambient temperatures metabolic rates increased above all other conditions, which confirms our hypothesis that physical activity and cold have an interactive effect on metabolic rate and energy expenditure. This conclusion is further confirmed by the fact that rats from the cold and exercise treatment had significantly greater food intake compared to all other treatments without, however, changing their body mass (36).
Both of our acclimation treatments were below the thermal neutral zone of the species, which mean that rats even in our warm (22°C) treatment may have had increased metabolic capacities compared to minimum levels at temperatures within the thermal neutral zone. Nonetheless, the muted response of sedentary rats to a further decrease in acclimation temperatures from 22°C to 12°C is extraordinary, both with respect to the implications discussed above and with respect to the consensus in the literature that cold stimulates metabolic responses, particularly in BAT (19, 27). Our acclimation and test temperatures were purposely moderate, and cold-induced metabolic responses in the laboratory are commonly observed at much lower ambient temperatures (<5°C; e.g. 19). More extreme cold exposure will stimulate uncoupling proteins and BAT oxidative capacity in the absence of physical activity (26, 27). Responses of BAT to very low temperatures alone are adaptive for animals that have to cope with extreme cold, and it suggests that there may be a threshold of activation below which exercise becomes relatively unimportant for BAT activation. This latter suggestion is speculative, but provides the basis for an interesting and feasible hypothesis to test.
There was no training effect on locomotor performance as a result of the exercise regime we imposed on the animals. Hence, metabolic responses to exercise do not require intensive exercise or training regimes that lead to increased locomotor performance. Thermal acclimation had a greater effect on locomotor performance than exercise, which is in contrast to the metabolic responses we report and indicates that running at this level is not constrained by metabolic capacity.
Regular physical activity not only increases energy expenditure directly, but also modulates gene expression patterns of metabolic regulators. Gene expression patterns induced by a sedentary lifestyle result in metabolic patterns that are the precursors of metabolic diseases prevalent among humans , , –. For example, decreased PGC1α expression results in increased insulin resistance, predisposing an animal to obesity and type 2 diabetes . Impaired glucose and fatty acid metabolism due to decreased PPARδ expression also increases the risk of obesity and type 2 diabetes , –. The deletion of PPARδ results in increased fat accumulation in the heart and decreased survival in mouse models . Additionally, decreased concentrations of glucose transporter 4 (GLUT4) as a result of reduced NRF-1 expression in sedentary animals leads to a fall in glucose transport which predisposes individuals to type 2 diabetes , .
When combined with cold exposure, exercise promotes uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation by increasing the expression of UCP1 in BAT. Increased expression of UCP1 increases the proportion of energy derived from fatty acid oxidation that is released as heat, rather than being deposited as white adipose tissue; this provides an important avenue by which exercise facilitates increased energy expenditure and counteracts obesity . Obesity, although complicated by social and cultural influences, is due to an excess of energy intake over energy expenditure . In mouse models, over-expression of UCP1 results in obesity resistance – while ablation of UCP1 induces obesity . Brown adipose tissue therefore plays an important role in the energy balance of the whole organism including adult humans , , but we show that exercise is a necessary condition for this role to be realised. A practical implication of our results is that research on metabolism using sedentary animals is likely to produce results that are limited in their generality, and which cannot be transferred to more ecologically relevant contexts.
Materials and Methods
All experimental procedures were approved by the University of Sydney Animal Ethics Committee (permit L04/12-2006/3/4512) and the NSW National Parks and Wildlife Services (Scientific License S12186).
Experimental animals and acclimation treatments
We used a wild rodent, the bush rat Rattus fuscipes, as a model to avoid potential problems from inbreeding and thereby altered exercise responses in laboratory strains. Bush rats were trapped near Sydney, Australia (33°42′41″S, 151°13′58″E) and kept individually in plastic cages (350×220×220 mm). We used only adult animals, and excluded any pregnant females; all experimental groups had a even sex ratio. Rats were fed ad libitum on a mixture of commercial rodent mix and diced apples. Median body mass of experimental animals was 115.0 g and body mass did not change significantly during the acclimation treatments in any experimental group. For more information on food intake and body mass of the animals please see .
After a 14 day habituation period, rats were randomly allocated to either a cold (12°C) or a warm (22°C) acclimation treatment with a constant photoperiod of 12L:12D in all treatments; acclimation treatments lasted for 30 days. The rationale for our treatments was to expose animals to conditions naturally and routinely experienced rather than testing physiological limits under extreme conditions. Hence, acclimation temperatures were based on mean winter and summer temperatures naturally experienced by the population from which the rats were sampled . Please note, however, that even the “warm” experimental conditions are below the thermal neutral zone of the animals. Within each thermal acclimation group, rats were allocated to either a sedentary (n = 10 cold and n = 10 warm) or an exercise (n = 8 cold and n = 8 warm) treatment. We took especial care to minimise handling of the animals, and to treat all experimental animals the same during the acclimation period to minimise any potential confounding effects of handling.
Rats in the exercise treatments were run in a wheel on five days per week throughout the acclimation period. In each exercise session, bush rats were placed individually into an enclosed, motorised running wheel for 30 minutes at 60% of the running speed that resulted in exercise induced metabolic rate as determined in preliminary studies (according to methods described in Locomotor performance below). Bush rats were euthanased by an overdose of sodium pentabarbitone (120 mg kg−1 i. p.) on a day following an exercise day, but the animals were not exercised on the day of euthanasia.
Skeletal muscle and BAT samples were collected at the time of euthanasia and immediately stored in RNAlater (Ambion, USA) at −20°C. RNA extraction and reverse transcription were conducted according to published protocols . Quantitative RT-PCR was performed on an Applied Biosystems 7500 qRT-PCR machine (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, USA). Commercial gene expression assays for Rattus norvegicus (TaqMan, Applied Biosystems) were used for analyses of PPARδ, PGC-1α and NRF-1 mRNA concentrations according to the manufacturer's instructions.
Primers were designed from sequences obtained from GenBank for Rattus norvegicus uncoupling-protein 1 [GenBank: NM012682; forward: gactcggatcctggaacgtc; reverse: gcataggagcccagcatagg] and nuclear 28S RNA [GenBank: V01270; forward: gcctcacgatccttctgacc; reverse: aacccagctcacgttcccta]. For these genes we used real-time PCR reactions with SYBR green that contained 1× SensiMixPlus SYBR (Quantace, United Kingdom), 4.5 mM MgCL2, 600 nM primer and 50 ng cDNA. The cycle consisted of 95°C for 7 min, 40 cycles of 95°C for 15 s and 66°C for 1 min; 95°C for 15 s; 60°C for 1 min, and 95°C for 15 s. We performed melt curve analysis to ensure that only a single PCR product was amplified, and all assays were run in duplicate. Relative gene expression of the target gene was calculated according to  with the nuclear ribosomal 28S RNA gene as reference gene and the grand mean of all treatments as control; in the text we refer to ‘relative expression’ in the sense of .
Skeletal muscle (vastis lateralis) and BAT were collected at the time of euthanasia and were transferred into liquid nitrogen immediately after collection and stored at −80°C for later analysis of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), cytochrome c oxidase (COX) and citrate synthase (CS) activities. Enzyme activities were determined according to published protocols  at 37°C .
Whole animal oxygen consumption
Standard flow through respirometry was used to measure whole animal rates of oxygen consumption at 12°C and 22°C . Rats rested at the test temperature in the metabolic chambers (100×80×120 mm) for 2 h before measurements of resting oxygen consumption; animals were observed with a remote camera during measurements. Oxygen consumption was measured with a gas analyzer (ML206, ADInstruments) connected to a computerised recording system (PowerLab; ADInstruments). Resting metabolic rate of all rats was measured at each temperature in a random order. Design, calibration and use of the system followed published protocol with room air (20.95% O2) and pure N2 (0% O2) used for calibration of the gas analyser . Carbon dioxide was scrubbed from the air using granules of Baralyme before entering the chamber and from subsampled gas prior to analysis. Water was absorbed from the air before entering the chamber with Drierite and after the chamber using a drying tube (MLA0343, ADInstruments). Air was pumped through the chamber at a rate of 600–700 mL.min−1. Gas sampling rates were set at 100 mL.min−1, and flow rates were measured with a flowhead (MLT10L, ADInstruments) connected to a spirometer (ML141, ADInstruments) and the PowerLab system (ADInstruments). When oxygen consumption had plateaued, generally after 2 hours, resting metabolic rate was determined as the mean of the five lowest consecutive oxygen consumption measurements. Mass specific oxygen consumption (mL. O2. hr−1. g−1) was calculated using the standard equation VO2 = V1 (F1O2-FeO2)/(1-FeO2) where V1 is the inlet air flow rate (ml.h−1), F1O2 is the inlet fractional O2 content (0.2095) and FeO2 is the excurrent fractional O2 content . Measurements were made in a temperature controlled room (±0.5°C), and the temperature within the chamber was measured with a calibrated thermocouple connected to a PowerLab (ADInstruments). The animals were post-absorptive and in their resting phase during the measurements. For all oxygen consumption measurements, reference samples were taken before and following the trials. Exercise induced metabolic scope was calculated by dividing exercise induced metabolic rate (see Locomotor performance below) by resting metabolic rate. Temperature induced metabolic scope was calculated by dividing resting metabolic rate at 12°C by resting metabolic rate at 22°C.
Critical sustained running speed (Ucrit) was measured at 12°C and 22°C in ramped speed trials in a motorised running wheel fixed within a Perspex metabolic chamber (220×120×240 mm), which also allowed measurements of oxygen consumption (see oxygen consumption above). Wheel speed was controlled by a motor regulated with a DC power supply (MP3090; Powertech, Osborne Park, WA, Australia) and rotations were counted with a cyclometer calibrated to the circumference of the running wheel. The settings on the power supply were calibrated for wheel rotations (km.h−1) so that running speed could be controlled by adjusting the DC power input. The running wheel was placed in a temperature-controlled room and the temperature within the wheel was monitored with a calibrated thermocouple connected to a computerised recording system (Powerlab, AD Instruments, Sydney, Australia).
Critical sustained running speed was determined as Ucrit = Uf+[(tf/ti)Ui], where Uf is the greatest running speed maintained for a whole time interval, tf is time spent at the final speed, ti is the time interval between speed increments and Ui is the speed increment . Pilot studies were performed to determine ti (150 s), Ui (0.25 km.h−1) and initial running speed (0.75 km.h−1). Animals were placed individually in the wheel and allowed to habituate at the test temperature for 2 h. All but one rat in the warm-exercised treatment ran in the wheel. Animals were run until fatigued, which was defined as the time when animals could no longer maintain position in the wheel. Each rat was run at 12°C and at 22°C in random order, with a minimum of 24 h between runs.
Oxygen consumption was measured during the running trials to give exercise induced metabolic rate at 12°C and 22°C. Oxygen consumption was measured using the same set-up as described above for resting metabolic rate. However, for measurements of exercise induced metabolic rate the flow rate was increased to 1400 mL.min−1. Exercise induced metabolic rate was calculated as the highest instantaneous VO2 averaged over 1 min intervals .
We analysed relative expression of target genes , enzyme activities, and temperature induced metabolic scope by 2-way analyses of variance (ANOVA), with thermal acclimation and exercise as independent, fixed factors. Resting and exercise induced metabolic rate and scope, and sustained running speed were analysed by 3-way ANOVA with thermal acclimation and exercise as independent, fixed factors, and ambient test temperature at which trials were performed as repeated measure. We used Levene's test to test for homogeneity of variances, and data were log transformed in case of heteroscedacity.
To explore relationships between PGC-1α and its target genes, we performed regression analyses between PGC-1α relative expression and that of PPARδ, NRF1, and UCP1 across all treatments. All data are expressed as means + s.e.m. and the level of significance was α = 0.05.
We used the truncated-product method  to assess the effect of multiple hypotheses testing on the validity of p values. Briefly, the truncated-product method considers the distribution of p values from multiple hypothesis tests to provide a table-wide p value for the overall hypothesis that significant results in the set were truly significant rather than due to chance. Multiple comparisons did not bias the statistical results presented here (p<0.001).
We thank the Keay laboratory and the Northern Beaches Animal Clinic, Sydney for assistance with surgery and I. Tyson for assistance in equipment construction and field work.
Conceived and designed the experiments: FS EJG. Performed the experiments: EJG. Analyzed the data: FS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: FS. Wrote the paper: FS.
- 1. Das J (2006) The role of mitochondrial respiration in physiological and evolutionary adaptation. Bioessays 28: 890–901.J. Das2006The role of mitochondrial respiration in physiological and evolutionary adaptation.Bioessays28890901
- 2. Lowell BB, Spiegelman BM (2000) Towards a molecular understanding of adaptive thermogenesis. Nature 404: 652–660.BB LowellBM Spiegelman2000Towards a molecular understanding of adaptive thermogenesis.Nature404652660
- 3. Gillis LJ, Kennedy LC, Gillis AM, Bar-Or O (2002) Relationship between juvenile obesity, dietary energy and fat intake and physical activity. International J Obesity 26: 458–463.LJ GillisLC KennedyAM GillisO. Bar-Or2002Relationship between juvenile obesity, dietary energy and fat intake and physical activity.International J Obesity26458463
- 4. Redinger RN (2009) Fat storage and the biology of energy expenditure. Transl Res 154: 52–60.RN Redinger2009Fat storage and the biology of energy expenditure.Transl Res1545260
- 5. Bennett AF, Ruben JA (1979) Endothermy and activity in vertebrates. Science 206: 649–654.AF BennettJA Ruben1979Endothermy and activity in vertebrates.Science206649654
- 6. Booth FW, Laye MJ (2009) Lack of adequate appreciation of physical exercise's complexities can pre-emp appropriate design and interpretation in scientific discovery. J Physiol 587: 5527–5540.FW BoothMJ Laye2009Lack of adequate appreciation of physical exercise's complexities can pre-emp appropriate design and interpretation in scientific discovery.J Physiol58755275540
- 7. Booth FW, Roberts CK (2008) Linking performance and chronic disease risk: indices of physical performance are surrogates for health. Brit J Sport Med 42: 950–952.FW BoothCK Roberts2008Linking performance and chronic disease risk: indices of physical performance are surrogates for health.Brit J Sport Med42950952
- 8. Handschin C, Spiegelman BM (2008) The role of exercise and PGC1 alpha in inflammation and chronic disease. Nature 454: 463–469.C. HandschinBM Spiegelman2008The role of exercise and PGC1 alpha in inflammation and chronic disease.Nature454463469
- 9. Grundy SM (2008) A changing paradigm for prevention of cardiovascular disease: emergence of the metabolic syndrome as a multiplex risk factor. Eur Heart J Suppl 10: B16–B23.SM Grundy2008A changing paradigm for prevention of cardiovascular disease: emergence of the metabolic syndrome as a multiplex risk factor.Eur Heart J Suppl10B16B23
- 10. Booth FW, Laye MJ, Lees SJ, Rector RS, Thyfault JP (2008) Reduced physical activity and risk of chronic disease: the biology behind the consequences. Eur J Appl Physiol 102: 381–390.FW BoothMJ LayeSJ LeesRS RectorJP Thyfault2008Reduced physical activity and risk of chronic disease: the biology behind the consequences.Eur J Appl Physiol102381390
- 11. Huang PL (2009) eNOS, metabolic syndrome and cardiovascular disease. Trends Endocrin Metabol 20: 295–302.PL Huang2009eNOS, metabolic syndrome and cardiovascular disease.Trends Endocrin Metabol20295302
- 12. Booth FW, Chakravarthy MV, Spangenburg EE (2002) Exercise and gene expression: physiological regulation of the human genome through physical activity. J Physiol 543: 399–411.FW BoothMV ChakravarthyEE Spangenburg2002Exercise and gene expression: physiological regulation of the human genome through physical activity.J Physiol543399411
- 13. Narkar VA, Downes M, Yu RT, Embler E, Wang YX, et al. (2008) AMPK and PPAR delta agonists are exercise mimetics. Cell 134: 405–415.VA NarkarM. DownesRT YuE. EmblerYX Wang2008AMPK and PPAR delta agonists are exercise mimetics.Cell134405415
- 14. Moyes CD (2003) Controlling muscle mitochondrial content. J Exp Biol 206: 4385–4391.CD Moyes2003Controlling muscle mitochondrial content.J Exp Biol20643854391
- 15. Hoehn KL, Turner N, Swarbrick MM, Wilks D, Preston E, et al. (2010) Acute or chronic upregulation of mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation has no net effect on whole-body energy expenditure or adiposity. Cell Metabol 11: 70–76.KL HoehnN. TurnerMM SwarbrickD. WilksE. Preston2010Acute or chronic upregulation of mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation has no net effect on whole-body energy expenditure or adiposity.Cell Metabol117076
- 16. Dauncey MJ (1981) Influence of mild cold on 24 h energy expenditure, resting metabolism and diet-induced thermogenesis. Brit J Nutr 45: 257–267.MJ Dauncey1981Influence of mild cold on 24 h energy expenditure, resting metabolism and diet-induced thermogenesis.Brit J Nutr45257267
- 17. Scarpulla RC (2008) Transcriptional paradigms in mammalian mitochondrial biogenesis and function. Physiol Rev 88: 611–638.RC Scarpulla2008Transcriptional paradigms in mammalian mitochondrial biogenesis and function.Physiol Rev88611638
- 18. Wu ZD, Puigserver P, Andersson U, Zhang CY, Adelmant G, et al. (1999) Mechanisms controlling mitochondrial biogenesis and respiration through the thermogenic coactivator PGC-1. Cell 98: 115–124.ZD WuP. PuigserverU. AnderssonCY ZhangG. Adelmant1999Mechanisms controlling mitochondrial biogenesis and respiration through the thermogenic coactivator PGC-1.Cell98115124
- 19. Puigserver P, Wu Z, Park CW, Graves R, Wright M, et al. (1998) A cold-inducible coactivator of nuclear receptors linked to adaptive thermogenesis. Cell 92: 829–839.P. PuigserverZ. WuCW ParkR. GravesM. Wright1998A cold-inducible coactivator of nuclear receptors linked to adaptive thermogenesis.Cell92829839
- 20. Puigserver P, Spiegelman BM (2003) Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma coactivator 1 alpha (PGC-1 alpha): Transcriptional coactivator and metabolic regulator. Endocr Rev 24: 78–90.P. PuigserverBM Spiegelman2003Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma coactivator 1 alpha (PGC-1 alpha): Transcriptional coactivator and metabolic regulator.Endocr Rev247890
- 21. Baar K, Wende AR, Jones TE, Marison M, Nolte LA, et al. (2002) Adaptations of skeletal muscle to exercise: rapid increase in the transcriptional coactivator PGC-1. Faseb J 16: 1879–1886.K. BaarAR WendeTE JonesM. MarisonLA Nolte2002Adaptations of skeletal muscle to exercise: rapid increase in the transcriptional coactivator PGC-1.Faseb J1618791886
- 22. Luquet S, Lopez-Soriano J, Holst D, Fredenrich A, Melki J, et al. (2003) Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor delta controls muscle development and oxydative capability. Faseb J 17: 2299–2301.S. LuquetJ. Lopez-SorianoD. HolstA. FredenrichJ. Melki2003Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor delta controls muscle development and oxydative capability.Faseb J1722992301
- 23. Wang YX, Lee CH, Tiep S, Yu RT, Ham JY, et al. (2003) Peroxisome-proliferator-activated receptor delta activates fat metabolism to prevent obesity. Cell 113: 159–170.YX WangCH LeeS. TiepRT YuJY Ham2003Peroxisome-proliferator-activated receptor delta activates fat metabolism to prevent obesity.Cell113159170
- 24. Wang YX, Zhang CL, Yu RT, Cho HK, Nelson MC, et al. (2004) Regulation of muscle fiber type and running endurance by PPAR delta. PLoS Biol 2: 1532–1539.YX WangCL ZhangRT YuHK ChoMC Nelson2004Regulation of muscle fiber type and running endurance by PPAR delta.PLoS Biol215321539
- 25. Nedergaard J, Golozoubova V, Matthias A, Asadi A, Jacobsson A, et al. (2001) UCP1: the only protein able to mediate adaptive non-shivering thermogenesis and metabolic inefficiency. Biochim Et Biophys Acta-Bioenergetics 1504: 82–106.J. NedergaardV. GolozoubovaA. MatthiasA. AsadiA. Jacobsson2001UCP1: the only protein able to mediate adaptive non-shivering thermogenesis and metabolic inefficiency.Biochim Et Biophys Acta-Bioenergetics150482106
- 26. Klingenspor M (2003) Cold-induced recruitment of brown adipose tissue thermogenesis. Exp Physiol 88: 141–148.M. Klingenspor2003Cold-induced recruitment of brown adipose tissue thermogenesis.Exp Physiol88141148
- 27. Cannon B, Nedergaard J (2004) Brown adipose tissue: Function and physiological significance. Physiol Rev 84: 277–359.B. CannonJ. Nedergaard2004Brown adipose tissue: Function and physiological significance.Physiol Rev84277359
- 28. Arany Z, Novlkov M, Chin S, Rosenzweig A, Spiegelman BM (2006) Transverse aortic constriction leads to accelarated heart failure in mice lacking PPAR-γ coactivator 1α. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103: 10086–10091.Z. AranyM. NovlkovS. ChinA. RosenzweigBM Spiegelman2006Transverse aortic constriction leads to accelarated heart failure in mice lacking PPAR-γ coactivator 1α.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA1031008610091
- 29. Chinsomboon J, Ruas J, Gupta RK, Thom R, Shoag J, et al. (2009) The transcriptional coactivator PGC-1α mediates exercise-induced angiogenesis in skeletal muscle. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106: 21401–21406.J. ChinsomboonJ. RuasRK GuptaR. ThomJ. Shoag2009The transcriptional coactivator PGC-1α mediates exercise-induced angiogenesis in skeletal muscle.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA1062140121406
- 30. Jäger S, Handschirm C, St.-Pierre J, Spiegelman BM (2007) AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) action in skeletal muscle via direct phosphorylation of PGC-1α. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 12017–12022.S. JägerC. HandschirmJ. St.-PierreBM Spiegelman2007AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) action in skeletal muscle via direct phosphorylation of PGC-1α.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA1041201712022
- 31. Li X, Monks B, Ge Q, Birnbaum MJ (2007) Akt/PKB regulates hepatic metabolism by directly inhibiting PGC-1α transcription coactivator. Nature 447: 1012–1017.X. LiB. MonksQ. GeMJ Birnbaum2007Akt/PKB regulates hepatic metabolism by directly inhibiting PGC-1α transcription coactivator.Nature44710121017
- 32. Lin J, Wu H, Tarr PT, Zhang C-Y, Wu Z, et al. (2001) Transcription co-activator PGC-1α drives the formation of slow-twitch muscle fibres. Nature 418: 797–801.J. LinH. WuPT TarrC-Y ZhangZ. Wu2001Transcription co-activator PGC-1α drives the formation of slow-twitch muscle fibres.Nature418797801
- 33. Holloway GP, Bonen A, Spriet LL (2009) Regulation of skeletal muscle mitochondrial fatty acid metabolism in lean and obese individuals. American J Clin Nutr 89: 455S–462S.GP HollowayA. BonenLL Spriet2009Regulation of skeletal muscle mitochondrial fatty acid metabolism in lean and obese individuals.American J Clin Nutr89455S462S
- 34. Bachman ES, Dhillon H, Zhang C-Y, Cinti S, Bianco AC (2002) βAR signaling required for diet-induced thermogenesis and obesity resistance. Nature 297: 843–845.ES BachmanH. DhillonC-Y ZhangS. CintiAC Bianco2002βAR signaling required for diet-induced thermogenesis and obesity resistance.Nature297843845
- 35. Cannon B, Nedergaard J (2009) Thermogenesis challenges the adipostat hypothesis for body-weight control. Proc Nutr Soc 68: 401–407.B. CannonJ. Nedergaard2009Thermogenesis challenges the adipostat hypothesis for body-weight control.Proc Nutr Soc68401407
- 36. Glanville EJ, Seebacher F (2010) Lower body temperatures are advantageous for a small mammal (bush rat, Rattus fuscipes) experiencing chronic cold. J Mammal. EJ GlanvilleF. Seebacher2010Lower body temperatures are advantageous for a small mammal (bush rat, Rattus fuscipes) experiencing chronic cold.J Mammalin press. in press.
- 37. Glanville EJ, Seebacher F (2010) Plasticity in body temperature and metabolic capacity sustains winter activity in a small endotherm (Rattus fuscipes). Comp Biochem Physiol A 155: 383–391.EJ GlanvilleF. Seebacher2010Plasticity in body temperature and metabolic capacity sustains winter activity in a small endotherm (Rattus fuscipes).Comp Biochem Physiol A155383391
- 38. Mekjavic IB, Eiken O (2006) Contribution of thermal and nonthermal factors to the regulation of body temperature in humans. J Appl Physiol 100: 2065–2072.IB MekjavicO. Eiken2006Contribution of thermal and nonthermal factors to the regulation of body temperature in humans.J Appl Physiol10020652072
- 39. Nunn AVW, Bell JD, Guy GW (2009) Lifestyle-induced metabolic inflexibility and accelerated ageing syndrome: insulin resistance, friend or foe? Nutr Metabol 6: AVW NunnJD BellGW Guy2009Lifestyle-induced metabolic inflexibility and accelerated ageing syndrome: insulin resistance, friend or foe?Nutr Metabol6
- 40. O'Gorman DJ, Krook A (2008) Exercise and the Treatment of Diabetes and Obesity. Endocrinol Metabol Clin North Am 2008, 37: 887–.DJ O'GormanA. Krook2008Exercise and the Treatment of Diabetes and Obesity.Endocrinol Metabol Clin North Am2008, 37887–
- 41. Cheng L, Ding G, Qin Q, Huang Y, Lewis W, et al. (2004) Cardiomyocyte-restricted peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-delta deletion perturbs myocardial fatty acid oxidation and leads to cardiomyopathy. Nature Med 10: 1245–1250.L. ChengG. DingQ. QinY. HuangW. Lewis2004Cardiomyocyte-restricted peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-delta deletion perturbs myocardial fatty acid oxidation and leads to cardiomyopathy.Nature Med1012451250
- 42. Holloszy JO (2008) Regulation by exercise of skeletal muscle content of mitochondria and GLUT4. J Physiol Pharmacol 59: 5–18.JO Holloszy2008Regulation by exercise of skeletal muscle content of mitochondria and GLUT4.J Physiol Pharmacol59518
- 43. Fruhbeck G, Becerril S, Sainz N, Garrastachu P, Garcia-Velloso MJ (2009) BAT: a new target for human obesity? Trends Pharmacol Sci 30: 387–396.G. FruhbeckS. BecerrilN. SainzP. GarrastachuMJ Garcia-Velloso2009BAT: a new target for human obesity?Trends Pharmacol Sci30387396
- 44. Kopecky J, Clarke G, Enerback S, Spiegelman B, Kozak LP (1995) Expression of the mitochondrial uncoupling protein gene from the aP2 gene promoter prevents genetic obesity. J Clin Invest 96: 2914–2923.J. KopeckyG. ClarkeS. EnerbackB. SpiegelmanLP Kozak1995Expression of the mitochondrial uncoupling protein gene from the aP2 gene promoter prevents genetic obesity.J Clin Invest9629142923
- 45. Kozak LP, Anunciado-Koza R (2008) UCP1: its involvement and utility in obesity. Int J Obesity 32: S32–S38.LP KozakR. Anunciado-Koza2008UCP1: its involvement and utility in obesity.Int J Obesity32S32S38
- 46. Feldman HM, Golozoubova V, Cannon B, Nedergaard J (2009) UCP1 ablation induces obesity and abolishes diet-induced thermogenesis in mice exempt from thermal stress by living at thermoneutrality. Cell Metab 9: 203–209.HM FeldmanV. GolozoubovaB. CannonJ. Nedergaard2009UCP1 ablation induces obesity and abolishes diet-induced thermogenesis in mice exempt from thermal stress by living at thermoneutrality.Cell Metab9203209
- 47. Lichtenbelt WDV, Vanhommerig JW, Smulders NM, Drossaerts J, Kemerink GJ (2009) Cold-activated brown adipose tissue in healthy men. New Engl J Med 360: 1500–1508.WDV LichtenbeltJW VanhommerigNM SmuldersJ. DrossaertsGJ Kemerink2009Cold-activated brown adipose tissue in healthy men.New Engl J Med36015001508
- 48. Enerbäck S (2010) Human brown adipose tissue. Cell Metab 11: 248–252.S. Enerbäck2010Human brown adipose tissue.Cell Metab11248252
- 49. Seebacher F, Murray , SA (2007) Transient receptor potential ion channels control thermoregulatory behaviour in reptiles. PLoS One 2: e281.F. SeebacherMurraySA2007Transient receptor potential ion channels control thermoregulatory behaviour in reptiles.PLoS One2e281
- 50. Pfaffl MW (2001) A new mathematical model for the relative quantification in real-time RT-PCR. Nucl Acid Res 29: 2002–2007.MW Pfaffl2001A new mathematical model for the relative quantification in real-time RT-PCR.Nucl Acid Res2920022007
- 51. Seebacher F, Guderley H, Elsey RM, Trosclair PL (2003) Seasonal acclimatisation of muscle metabolic enzymes in a reptile (Alligator mississippiensis). J Exp Biol 206: 1193–1200.F. SeebacherH. GuderleyRM ElseyPL Trosclair2003Seasonal acclimatisation of muscle metabolic enzymes in a reptile (Alligator mississippiensis).J Exp Biol20611931200
- 52. Withers PC (2001) Design, calibration and calculation for flow-through respirometry systems. Aust J Zool 49: 445–461.PC Withers2001Design, calibration and calculation for flow-through respirometry systems.Aust J Zool49445461
- 53. Brett JR (1964) The respiratory metabolism and swimming performance of young sockeye salmon. J Fish Res 21: 1183–1226.JR Brett1964The respiratory metabolism and swimming performance of young sockeye salmon.J Fish Res2111831226
- 54. Chappell MA, Garland T, Rezende EL, Gomes FR (2004) Voluntary running in deer mice: speed, distance, energy costs and temperature effects. J Exp Biology 207: 3839–3854.MA ChappellT. GarlandEL RezendeFR Gomes2004Voluntary running in deer mice: speed, distance, energy costs and temperature effects.J Exp Biology20738393854
- 55. Zaykin DV, Zhivotovky LA, Westfall PH, Weir BS (2002) Truncated product method for combining p-values. Gen Epidemiol 22: 170–185.DV ZaykinLA ZhivotovkyPH WestfallBS Weir2002Truncated product method for combining p-values.Gen Epidemiol22170185