Pneumonia remains the leading cause of death in young children globally and improved diagnostics are needed to better identify cases and reduce case fatality. Metabolomics, a rapidly evolving field aimed at characterizing metabolites in biofluids, has the potential to improve diagnostics in a range of diseases. The objective of this pilot study is to apply metabolomic analysis to childhood pneumonia to explore its potential to improve pneumonia diagnosis in a high-burden setting.
Eleven children with World Health Organization (WHO)-defined severe pneumonia of non-homogeneous aetiology were selected in The Gambia, West Africa, along with community controls. Metabolomic analysis of matched plasma and urine samples was undertaken using Ultra Performance Liquid Chromatography (UPLC) coupled to Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (TOFMS). Biomarker extraction was done using SIMCA-P+ and Random Forests (RF). ‘Unsupervised’ (blinded) data were analyzed by Principal Component Analysis (PCA), while ‘supervised’ (unblinded) analysis was by Partial Least Squares-Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA) and Orthogonal Projection to Latent Structures (OPLS). Potential markers were extracted from S-plots constructed following analysis with OPLS, and markers were chosen based on their contribution to the variation and correlation within the data set. The dataset was additionally analyzed with the machine-learning algorithm RF in order to address issues of model overfitting and markers were selected based on their variable importance ranking. Unsupervised PCA analysis revealed good separation of pneumonia and control groups, with even clearer separation of the groups with PLS-DA and OPLS analysis. Statistically significant differences (p<0.05) between groups were seen with the following metabolites: uric acid, hypoxanthine and glutamic acid were higher in plasma from cases, while L-tryptophan and adenosine-5′-diphosphate (ADP) were lower; uric acid and L-histidine were lower in urine from cases. The key limitation of this study is its small size.
Metabolomic analysis clearly distinguished severe pneumonia patients from community controls. The metabolites identified are important for the host response to infection through antioxidant, inflammatory and antimicrobial pathways, and energy metabolism. Larger studies are needed to determine whether these findings are pneumonia-specific and to distinguish organism-specific responses. Metabolomics has considerable potential to improve diagnostics for childhood pneumonia.
Citation: Laiakis EC, Morris GAJ, Fornace AJ Jr, Howie SRC (2010) Metabolomic Analysis in Severe Childhood Pneumonia in The Gambia, West Africa: Findings from a Pilot Study. PLoS ONE5(9): e12655. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0012655
Editor: Andy T. Y. Lau, University of Minnesota, United States of America
Received: March 4, 2010; Accepted: July 18, 2010; Published: September 9, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Laiakis et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was funded by Georgetown University and the Medical Research Council (UK). This work was supported in part by grant R31-10069 (WCU program) through the National Research Foundation of Korea funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Pneumonia is the biggest single cause of death in children, accounting for around 20% of 10 million deaths under the age of 5 years every year globally, 70% of these occurring in sub-Saharan Africa –. In The Gambia acute lower respiratory infection (ALRI), principally pneumonia, has been documented as the leading cause of death in young children , . The global burden of death from pneumonia will need to be markedly reduced if there is to be any prospect of achieving the United Nations' Millennium Development Goal 4 (MDG-4), that is, the reduction of under-5 mortality two-thirds by the year 2015 , . International momentum is building to meet this challenge .
Case management will remain a key strategy in reducing the mortality of pneumonia, and other infectious diseases, even if current vaccines fulfill their promise. Better diagnostics will be needed to improve case management, the more so as the introduction of conjugate vaccines worldwide changes the aetiology and epidemiology of pneumonia , . New laboratory approaches have the potential to deliver improvements in diagnostics and metabolomic analysis is one of these.
Metabolomics is a rapidly evolving field that aims to identify and quantify the concentration changes of all the metabolites (i.e., the metabolome) in a biofluid (e.g. blood, saliva, urine) or model system. This approach has been used successfully to identify biomarkers following exposure to ionizing radiation –, metastatic prostate cancer – and assess differences in gut microbiota –. Additionally, it has been utilized to identify biomarkers through Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) in primarily adult onset pneumonia with known causative agents – and in further elucidation of metabolic pathways of lung injury in mice , . Metabolomics has the potential to both improve the understanding of disease mechanisms and the diagnostics. It can be applied to easily accessible biofluids and may offer the eventual possibility of effective non-invasive bedside testing.
This paper describes the application of metabolomic methods in a pilot study to characterize children with and without severe pneumonia. The objective is to obtain preliminary data to assess whether metabolomic analysis might be able to distinguish these groups and hence have potential diagnostic application. It is also hoped that this data might provide pointers for the future exploration of disease mechanisms in childhood pneumonia.
Study Setting, Design, Patient Selection, Consent and Ethical Approval
The Gambia is a geographically long and narrow sub-Saharan African country, extending 400 km inland from the West African coast along the Gambia River. It has a population of 1.4 million, over 40% of which is less than 15 years of age (2003 census) . A study of the aetiology of childhood pneumonia is being undertaken in the coastal area of The Gambia (Fig. 1), in which cases of pneumonia are being enrolled along with community controls. The study area comprises Banjul, Kanifing, and Kombo (North, South, Central and East) municipalities. Written informed consent from the parent or guardian is required for inclusion in the study. Specific written informed consent is obtained for percutaneous lung aspiration where the procedure is indicated. The study was approved by the Gambia Government-Medical Research Council Joint Ethics Committee (L2008.28).
Entry Criteria and Case Definitions
Cases are children aged between 2 and 59 months, originating from within the study area, presenting to the Medical Research Council (MRC) hospital in Fajara, the Royal Victoria Teaching Hospital in Banjul (RVTH), Fajikunda Health Centre, Serekunda Health Centre, or Brikama Health Centre with severe or very severe pneumonia defined clinically by modified World Health Organization (WHO) criteria. Severe pneumonia is defined as cough or difficulty breathing, plus any of lower chest wall indrawing, nasal flaring, or an oxygen saturation of <90% on pulse oximetry (the latter defining very severe pneumonia). Children with a cough of two or more weeks, those with severe anemia (Hb <6 g/dL) and those with confirmed wheeze at recruitment are excluded. Community controls without WHO-defined pneumonia, matched by neighborhood age and sex, are recruited for cases in a 1∶1 ratio.
Sample Collection, Selection, and Microbiology
Blood from cases was collected for culture and a full blood count, and urine was collected where practicable. Percutaneous lung aspiration for culture was performed where defined safety criteria were met and written informed consent was given. Blood and lung aspirate samples were also subjected to molecular analysis for pathogen detection using Streptococcus pneumoniae and Haemophilus influenzae specific primers (lytA and cpsA for S. pneumoniae, glpQ for H. influenzae) and 16SrRNA primers with sequencing of the gel electrophoresis bands for identification of other bacterial species. The culture and molecular methods used have been described elsewhere –. On 2 September 2008 one hundred fifteen severe cases had been enrolled in the study of which complete verified data were available for ninety three. Of these, eleven severe pneumonia cases and matched community controls were available that had both plasma and urine samples of sufficient volume for analysis and these were selected for this pilot study. The samples were stored at −40°C and aliquots were shipped on dry ice to Georgetown University for metabolomic analysis.
Urine and plasma samples were analyzed using Ultra Performance Liquid Chromatography (UPLC) coupled to Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (TOFMS) from Waters (Milford, MA). In particular, urine samples were deproteinized by 1∶5 dilution in 50% acetonitrile with 2 mM debrisoquine sulfate and 30 mM 4-nitrobenzoic acid as internal controls. Plasma samples were deproteinized by 1∶40 dilution in 66% acetonitrile containing 2 mM debrisoquine sulfate and 30 mM 4-nitrobenzoic acid as internal controls. Following centrifugation at 13,000× g, 5 mL of the supernatant were injected into the UPLC-TOFMS. A Waters Acquity UPLC BEH C18 2.1×50 mm column packed with 1.7 mm beads was used to separate the molecules in the biofluids set at 40°C for the urine and 60°C for plasma. The mobile phase flow rate was set at 0.5 mL/min. The gradient mobile phase consisted of water with 0.1% formic acid (A) and acetonitrile containing 0.1% formic acid (B). A 10 min urine sample run consisted of 0.5 min of 99% (A), 3.5 min of 20% (B), 4 min of 95% (B), 1 min of 99% (B), and finally 1 min of 99% (A). A 10 min plasma sample run consisted of 0.5 min of 100% of (A), 3.5 min of 60% of (B), 5 min of 100% of (B), and finally 1 min of 100% of (A). Mass spectrometry and accurate mass acquisition was performed with a Waters QTOF Premier® (Milford, MA) operating at either positive-ion (ESI+) or negative-ion (ESI-) electrospray ionization mode. The capillary voltage was set to 3200 V and the sampling cone voltage to 45 V. The desolvation gas flow was set to 800 L/h and the temperature was set to 350°C. The cone gas flow was set to 25 L/h for plasma and 15 L/h for urine and the temperature was set to 130°C. Intermittent injections of sulfadimethoxine as a lock mass ([M+H]+ = 311.0814 m/z and [M−H]− = 309.0658m/z) at a concentration of 300 pg/mL in 50% acetonitrile at a rate of 40 mL/min, were used for accurate mass measurements.
Data Processing and Multivariate Data Analysis
Mass chromatograms and spectra were acquired with the software MassLynx (Waters) in centroid format and markers were extracted with the software MarkerLynx (Waters). Urine samples were normalized to their respective creatinine relative peak area of [M+H]+ = 114.0667 m/z with retention time of 0.32 min before further analysis of the data. Two separate multivariate statistical methods were utilized for biomarker extraction, SIMCA-P+ vs 12.0 (Umetrics, Sweden) and the machine-learning algorithm Random Forests (RF). For SIMCA-P+ analysis, all centroid data were Pareto scaled, which increases the importance of low abundance ions without giving importance to noise. ‘Unsupervised’ (i.e. blinded, identity of the samples was not known by the Georgetown group) data were analyzed by Principal Component Analysis (PCA), while ‘supervised’ (i.e. unblinded, identity of the samples was later revealed) analysis was by Partial Least Squares-Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA) and Orthogonal Projection to Latent Structures (OPLS). Potential markers were extracted from S-plots constructed following analysis with OPLS, and markers were chosen based on their contribution to the variation and correlation within the data set.
In order to address issues concerning overfitting of the data, which is common with large datasets containing relatively small numbers of samples, Random Forests analysis was performed through R, a programming language that allows for statistical processing . Random Forests is a machine-learning algorithm that has been used successfully in identifying metabolic biomarkers in biofluids , , . The samples were assigned to control versus pneumonia groups and ten thousand trees were constructed with variable importances averaged over twenty five independent random forests. Multidimensional scaling plots were constructed with analysis of either the whole sample set or the top one hundred metabolites and percentages of classification accuracy were calculated. Bootstrapping of the results from the twenty five independent random trees was applied to determine the 95% confidence intervals of the variable importance ranks. Additionally, heatmaps were designed of the top fifty ions generated through RF. The samples were grouped by treatment and the metabolites were hierarchically clustered by complete linkage using the euclidian distance. To aid in visualization, each metabolite was scaled by the maximum intensity value of that metabolite in the data set (i.e. each row was divided by the maximum value in the row before color assignment).
Molecular Ion Identification
Selected ions that showed variable differences between the Control and Pneumonia groups were chosen for further analysis and identification. Fifteen ions from either urine or plasma samples were chosen based on the S-plot and RF significance ranking and exhibited statistically significant p-values (p<0.05) based on analysis of the means of the data through two-tailed t-test. Searches for the identity of the metabolites were conducted through the publicly available online database “Madison Metabolomics Consortium Database” (MMCD) with tol (ppm) equal to twenty and ions were validated through tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) against pure chemicals (Sigma Aldrich, St. Louis, MO). Chemicals of the highest available purity were either diluted in 50% acetonitrile for urine samples or 66% acetonitrile for plasma samples and fragmented with ramping collision energy of 5–30 eV. MS/MS spectra of the pure chemicals were compared to the biological sample MS/MS spectra for the masses in question.
Among the eleven children with clinically defined severe pneumonia (the cases), five were female and six were male, and six of the eleven were under two years old while five were two years or older. Ten had radiographic changes of pneumonia, while the other had a normal radiograph. The length of illness at presentation ranged from 1–7 days (median 3 days) and four children had reportedly received antibiotics before presentation. The total white blood count of cases ranged from 7.8 to 67.7×103/mm3 (median 13.4) compared to 3.9–11.0 (median 7.2) in community controls. Culture of blood (n = 11) or lung aspirate (n = 3) identified a pathogen in just one case (S. pneumoniae) and blood cultures were negative in all controls. Molecular analyses of plasma and lung aspirate identified an organism in seven out of eleven cases: S. pneumoniae in five, H. influenzae in one and S. pneumoniae and H. influenzae in the other. Five of the eleven asymptomatic community controls also had organisms identified (S. pneumoniae in one, H. influenzae in three, S. pneumoniae and H. influenzae in one).
Multivariate Data Analysis of Urine Samples
The urine samples were analyzed in both positive and negative ionization modes with the UPLS-TOFMS. Unsupervised PCA analysis revealed a good separation of the two groups when investigating the first two principal components for the results of positive ionization mode (Fig. 2A). However, a clearer separation of the groups for the negative mode data was seen when the samples were analyzed with PLS-DA (Fig. S1). Additionally, OPLS showed good clustering of the control and pneumonia groups, with larger variation in the pneumonia group (Fig. S1). The S-plots that were constructed from the OPLS analysis showed a significant number of ions up-regulated in the pneumonia group. Additionally, the supervised PLS-DA analysis with assignment of the groups based on disease status and sex revealed a sex dependent clustering of the pneumonia group, which was not present in the controls (Fig. S3). Similar analysis based on age or antibiotic usage within seven days of sample collection did not reveal any clear clustering (data not shown).
Panels A and B show PCA scores plots for urine (ESI+ mode) and for plasma (ESI - mode), respectively. PCA analysis is an unsupervised method of extracting information, where the classes (i.e. experimental groups) are unknown. Panels C and D show the S-plots constructed from the supervised OPLS analysis of urine (ESI+ mode) and plasma (ESI- mode) respectively. Ions with the highest abundance and correlation in the pneumonia group with respect to the controls are present on the upper far right hand quadrant, whereas ions with the lowest abundance and correlation in the pneumonia group with respect to the control group are residing in the lower far left hand quadrant. Ions are marked with either their identity or a number corresponding to Table 1. Panels E and F show heatmaps for urine (ESI+ mode) and plasma (ESI- mode) respectively. The heatmaps were constructed based on the top fifty metabolites of importance, which were extracted with Random Forests analysis. Variable differences are revealed between the control and pneumonia groups, with verified and unknown ions marked on the right corresponding to Table 1. The parallel analysis of the samples with SIMCA-P+ and Random Forests allows for the ability to verify that ions, which are identified through both ways (i.e. hypoxanthine), are highly significant, as depicted through two completely different algorithms. Additionally, it allows for the increase of the numbers of ions that are potential candidates for biomarkers.
RF analysis, utilizing the whole sample set of ions, showed distinct clustering of the two groups in positive mode; however, three of the pneumonia samples were misclassified as belonging in the control group. The overall classification accuracy of the sample set was 86.4%. The negative mode data had an overall classification accuracy of 95.5%, with only one sample of the pneumonia group misclassified as belonging in the controls. A heatmap was additionally constructed based on the top fifty ranked metabolites of the positive mode data, revealing patterns of differential levels of urinary metabolites between controls and pneumonia samples (Fig. 2E).
Ion selection for verification was based either on the abundance and correlation coordinates of the ions on the S-plot or the importance ranking from RF. Specifically, seven urinary ions were picked based on these criteria for further analysis. Of those, the identity of two ions was verified through MS/MS. Ion 1 from Table 1 with [M+H]+ = 169.0352 m/z and retention time of 0.3281 min was identified as uric acid, which is involved in the metabolism of purines (Fig. 3A, p = 0.026). Ion 2 with [M+Na]+ = 178.0586 m/z and retention time of 0.2729 min was verified as L-histidine (Fig. 3B, p = 0.004). Additional search for the protonated form of L-histidine revealed an ion at [M+H]+ = 156.078 m/z and retention time of 0.2864 min (Fig. 3C, p = 0.00196).
Data is represented at the mean ± SE of the peak areas extracted through the TOFMS data (with * representing p<0.05 and ** representing p<0.01). The real peak areas were normalized to each sample's respective creatinine ([M+H]+ = 114.0667 m/z) peak area.
Five additional urinary ions were further evaluated with MS/MS, though the identities were not verified against the pure chemicals that were tested. In particular ion number 8 ([M−H]− = 145.0606 m/z, retention time of 2.764 min), ion number 9 ([M+H]+ = 101.0356 m/z, retention time of 0.2948 min), ion number 10 ([M+H]+ = 335.0676 m/z, retention time of 2.3983 min), ion number 11 ([M+H]+ = 241.0326 m/z, retention time of 3.9999 min), and ion number 12 ([M+H]+ = 243.0986 m/z, retention time of 0.3166 min) were tested against L-glutamine, alanyl-glycine (Ala-Gly), adipic acid, and D-glutamine for ion 8, hydantoin for ion 9, b-nicotinamide mononucleotide for ion 10, L-cystine for ion 11, and b-thymidine for ion 12. Ions 3–7 and 15 (Table 1) have been clearly marked on Fig. 2D and 2F.
Multivariate Data Analysis of Plasma Samples
The plasma samples were also analyzed in both positive and negative ionization modes. No normalization was applied to the samples, unlike the urines, since the levels of the plasma that were obtained were tightly controlled. Analysis of the positive ionization mode data with the multivariate statistical software SIMCA-P+ demonstrated a good separation between the two groups at the PCA scores plot (Fig. S2). Only one sample of the control group was misclassified as belonging in the pneumonia group, meaning that its overall metabolite profile resembled closely that of the pneumonia group. The separation became clearer when supervised PLS-DA analysis was applied, demonstrating the variable differences between the two groups (Fig. S2). On the negative ionization mode, the PCA analysis also revealed a clear separation between the two experimental groups, with only one pneumonia sample being misclassified as belonging in the control group (Fig. 2B). Furthermore, the PLS-DA and OPLS scores plots revealed a distinct separation of controls from pneumonia samples (Fig. S2). For further analysis of ions, the negative mode S-plot was chosen for extraction of markers (Fig. 2D). RF analysis showed an overall classification accuracy of 86.4%, which increased to 90.9% when only the top one hundred ions were used to classify the samples into separate groups. The percentages of classification accuracy were identical for the analysis of both positive and negative mode data.
Selected ions for further verification and validation were chosen through the S-plots and RF top ranked lists. In particular, ion number 3 with [M−H]− = 167.0202 m/z, retention time of 0.3179 min was verified as uric acid, which as mentioned earlier is involved in the purine metabolism. Plasma levels of uric acid appear to be upregulated in the pneumonia group relative to the controls, although not statistically significant (Fig. 4A, p = 0.119). This is in contrast to the urine levels where the uric acid levels are downregulated in the pneumonia group (Fig. 3A, p = 0.026). Ion number 4 with [M−H]− = 135.0303 m/z, retention time of 0.3158 min was verified to be hypoxanthine, also involved in the metabolism of purines (Fig. 4B, p = 0.008). Ion number 5 with [M−H]− = 146.0447 m/z, retention time of 0.2821 min was verified to be glutamic acid, involved in multiple metabolic processes (Fig. 4C, p = 0.0165). Ion number 6 with [M−H]− = 203.0811 m/z, retention time of 1.6051 min was verified to be L-tryptophan, which is an essential amino acid and the only stereoisomer used in structural or enzymatic proteins (Fig. 4D, p = 0.006). Ion number 7 with [M−H]− = 426.0235 m/z and retention time of 0.3533 min was verified to be adenosine-5′-diphosphate (ADP) (Fig. 4E, p = 0.0004).
Data is represented as mean ± SE of the peak areas extracted through the TOFMS data (with * representing p<0.05 and ** representing p<0.01). Unlike the urine samples, plasma samples do not require normalization to a particular metabolite since the volumes obtained are tightly controlled. Uric acid (Panel A) is upregulated in pneumonia plasma levels, although not statistically significant (p = 0.119). This is in contrast to the urine findings. Hypoxanthine and glutamic acid levels in Panels B and C are significantly upregulated in pneumonia samples. On the other hand, L-tryptophan and adenosine-5′-diphosphate (ADP) in Panels D and E are significantly downregulated in pneumonia samples.
Four additional ions were further investigated with MS/MS against pure chemicals; however, their identity was not verified as the MS/MS spectra differed significantly. In particular ion number 13 ([M+H]+ = 274.0924 m/z, retention time of 0.317 min), ion number 14 ([M+H]+ = 112.0496 m/z, retention time of 0.3231 min), and ion number 15 ([M−H]− = 145.0604 m/z, retention time of 0.273 min) were tested against 2′-deoxyadenosine and muramic acid for ion 13, cytosine and pyrrole-2-carboxylic acid for ion 14, and L-glutamine, Ala-Gly, adipic acid, and D-glutamine for ion 15. Ions 3–6, 14 and 15 (Table 1) have clearly been marked on both the S-plot and the heatmap (Fig. 4D and F).
Metabolomics is a powerful new technology that allows for the assessment of global metabolic profiles in easily accessible biofluids and biomarker discovery in order to distinguish between diseased and non-diseased status. We utilized this approach in a pilot study in urine and plasma samples from pneumonia patients from The Gambia. The global metabolic profiling and subsequent multivariate analysis clearly distinguished severe pneumonia patients from matched community controls. Although no common pathogenic factor was identified in all the cases, it is noteworthy that a similar disease manifestation allows for similar metabolic profiles and identification of biomarkers. Six metabolites emerged as markers of key differences between the two groups: uric acid, L-histidine, hypoxanthine, glutamic acid, L-tryptophan, and ADP. These metabolites together are important for the host response to infection through antioxidant, inflammatory and antimicrobial pathways, and energy metabolism.
Our observation of lower levels of urinary uric acid in severe pneumonia patients relative to controls suggests increased tubular reabsorption and renal retention of the analyte perhaps to protect against oxidative stress , . In contrast, plasma levels of uric acid were elevated in pneumonia cases. In in vitro studies, uric acid reacted rapidly with ozone and conferred protection of plasma lipids from peroxidation and erythrocyte lysis . Additional studies have shown that uric acid released from injured cells constitutes a major endogenous danger signal that activates the NALP3 inflammasome (also called cryopyrin or NLRP3), leading to IL-1b production  as part of the host response to lung inflammation and fibrosis. Taken together, these studies suggest that uric acid plays a major anti-inflammatory role in pneumonia cases and allows for protection of the host organism from oxidative damage. Additionally, plasma hypoxanthine levels were elevated in patients relative to controls. Hypoxanthine and xanthine are the precursors of uric acid and uric acid was also elevated in the plasma of pneumonia patients, although not statistically significant. Xanthine on the other hand was not identified as a marker through the statistical analysis. High concentrations of hypoxanthine, xanthine, and uric acid have also been shown in patients with bacterial meningitis . This may be because sepsis provokes significant alterations in energy metabolism homeostasis with hypoxanthine and uric acid, offering possibly useful surrogate markers of infection , . Elevation of hypoxanthine has also been reported during septic shock and may reflect early high energy nucleotide failure .
An additional marker with potentially important implications for disease outcome is ADP. The main role of ADP in the blood is the activation of platelets for effective hemostasis and blood aggregation , . Our results indicated that ADP levels in plasma from pneumonia patients are downregulated. This in turn may lead to decreased platelet activation and decreased formation of aggregates and thromboemboli. Lack of purinergic receptors for ADP is a possible way to protect against aggregate formation, however the reduced plasma levels of ADP in pneumonia patients in our studies could confer a protective mechanism against organ failure , . Nonetheless, other mechanisms, such as chemokine activation , appear to mediate the platelet activation under certain conditions, such as low ADP availability. Further work is required in this direction of low plasma ADP in pneumonia cases and its role in disease outcome and patient survival.
The last three markers identified in this study are amino acids. Hendriksen et al stressed that glutamic acid uptake and synthesis is important for full Streptococcus pneumoniae fitness and virulence . The higher levels of glutamic acid in the plasma in patients relative to controls in our study may indicate cellular injury and protection. Additionally, excess circulation of glutamic acid during the disease state requires special attention in this particular human population as it can be associated with central nervous system damage, which is sometimes associated with severe pneumonia . L-tryptophan, on the other hand, was lower in plasma of patients relative to controls. Tryptophan starvation is a recognized antimicrobial defense mechanism through Indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) and mediates immunoregulatory effects . It is possible therefore, that tryptophan starvation initially exhibits an antimicrobial effect to aid in fighting the disease status and later contributes in regulating the T-cell response from a possible overstimulation . Urinary L-histidine was also lower in patients relative to controls. L-histidine is a precursor for the synthesis of histamine, a major contributor to inflammation, asthma, and potentially pneumonia in both human  and animal studies . The lack on detection of histamine in urines of pneumonia patients and retention of L-histidine is possible indication that histidine is being converted to histamine in the tissues of pneumonia patients and contributing to their inflammatory state and propagation of disease status.
The sex dependent clustering of the pneumonia group, which was not present in the controls, points to differences in the metabolic response to pneumonia between male and female patients. Sex differences have been documented in survival following community-acquired pneumonia and nosocomial infections, which could be explained by differences in immune responses, genetics, or sex hormone levels , . Additionally, a study by Casimir et al on childhood pneumonia revealed significant differences in inflammatory markers between male and female patients , making identification of metabolic differences between male and female patients an attractive candidate for future studies on diagnosis and drug development.
This small-scale preliminary study has clear limitations. It is not possible to say whether the metabolomic profile seen in these children with severe pneumonia is pneumonia-specific or associated with a wider spectrum of illness. Either of these possibilities is potentially diagnostically significant, and further work investigating the specificity of the findings must be done to resolve this question. The literature reporting metabolomic analysis in infectious diseases is limited. The majority of the work has been conducted in meningitis patients and considerable work has been conducted on the assessment of global metabolic profiling of bacteria –. Pneumonia specific urinary metabolomic studies have concentrated on primarily adult populations with specific aetiology; however, this study is the first to provide pneumonia metabolomic analysis in urine and plasma from a specific pediatric population in parallel. Additionally, the differences in markers identified could be attributed to age and population related differences, overall aetiology of the pneumonia phenotype, and technologies and analytical methods utilized. This study was too small to define organism-specific metabolic responses, which will be useful for diagnosis, and it was not possible using available sensitive molecular techniques to distinguish causative pathogens from asymptomatic ‘DNAemia’. This is a general challenge for the growing field of molecular diagnostics rather than a limitation of this study in particular. The size of this study also means it has likely failed to identify other metabolites that will be important for diagnostics in the future.
The ability of the methods used in this study to clearly distinguish the children with severe pneumonia from their controls points to the considerable potential of metabolomics to improve diagnosis in sick children and to advance the knowledge of disease mechanisms. This preliminary work's importance is further emphasized by the fact that specific markers were identified in an outbred human population with genetic variability, no clear common causative agent, and simply a shared clinical syndrome. Metabolomics may provide an effective means to overcome the inability of current molecular pathogen detection techniques to distinguish causative pathogens from organisms that are ‘innocent bystanders’. Larger scale studies are now needed to determine the extent of its potential and to identify markers for different causative agents and for other potentially important aspects of disease such as illness severity, key comorbidities, and response to treatment. Once a panel of key biomarkers has been established there is the potential to take metabolomics closer to the bedside through its incorporation into point-of-care devices, which it is hoped will deliver breakthroughs in care in high mortality settings, and the evolution of which will likely be rapid in the next few years.
Scores plots generated through the chemometric software SIMCA-P+ vs 12.0. A and B depict the separation between the controls and pneumonia groups when assessing the metabolic profile of urines under positive ionization mode. A is a plot generated from PLS-DA analysis whereas B is an OPLS plot, from which we are able to determine that a greater variability exists within the pneumonia group, possibly due to different aetiological agents. C, D, and E panels in order represent the PCA, PLS-DA and OPLS plots of the negative ionization mode urines.
(0.36 MB TIF)
Scores plots generated through SIMCA-P+ based on the metabolic profiles of plasma samples from controls and pneumonia patients. A, B, and C panels show the PCA, PLS-DA and OPLS scores plots from positive ionization mode plasma samples, respectively. D and E show the PLS-DA and OPLS scores plots from the negative ionization mode.
(0.37 MB TIF)
PLS-DA scores plots examining the existence of sex differences based on metabolic profiles between control and pneumonia groups. Panels A (ESI+) and B (ESI-) based on urinary metabolic profiles clearly depict that possible differences based on sex could exist in the pneumonia group. In panels C (ESI+) of plasma samples separation of profiles based on sex is still evident, whereas in panel D (ESI-) of plasma samples the separation is not existent.
(0.38 MB TIF)
The authors would like to acknowledge the Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center Proteomics and Metabolomics Shared Resource (PMSR) for their help in data acquisition, and members of the Medical Research Council (UK) The Gambia's clinic, field, laboratory, data and support services teams for contributing to the study. We would also like to thank the participants and their families.
Conceived and designed the experiments: ECL GAM AFJ SH. Performed the experiments: ECL GAM. Analyzed the data: ECL GAM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: ECL GAM AFJ. Wrote the paper: ECL GAM AFJ SH.
- 1. Black RE, Morris SS, Bryce J (2003) Where and why are 10 million children dying every year? Lancet 361: 2226–2234.RE BlackSS MorrisJ. Bryce2003Where and why are 10 million children dying every year?Lancet36122262234
- 2. Garenne M, Ronsmans C, Campbell H (1992) The magnitude of mortality from acute respiratory infections in children under 5 years in developing countries. World Health Stat Q 45: 180–191.M. GarenneC. RonsmansH. Campbell1992The magnitude of mortality from acute respiratory infections in children under 5 years in developing countries.World Health Stat Q45180191
- 3. Mathers CSC, Fat DGlobal Burden of Disease 2000: version 2, methods and results. CSC MathersD. FatGlobal Burden of Disease 2000: version 2, methods and results
- 4. Mulholland K (2003) Global burden of acute respiratory infections in children: implications for interventions. Pediatr Pulmonol 36: 469–474.K. Mulholland2003Global burden of acute respiratory infections in children: implications for interventions.Pediatr Pulmonol36469474
- 5. Mulholland K (2007) Childhood pneumonia mortality—a permanent global emergency. Lancet 370: 285–289.K. Mulholland2007Childhood pneumonia mortality—a permanent global emergency.Lancet370285289
- 6. Rudan I, Boschi-Pinto C, Biloglav Z, Mulholland K, Campbell H (2008) Epidemiology and etiology of childhood pneumonia. Bull World Health Organ 86: 408–416.I. RudanC. Boschi-PintoZ. BiloglavK. MulhollandH. Campbell2008Epidemiology and etiology of childhood pneumonia.Bull World Health Organ86408416
- 7. WHO (2003) Draft Report of Consultative Meeting to Review Evidence and Research Priorities in Management of Acute Respiratory Infections (ARI). Geneva: World Health Organization Report No.: WHO/FCH/CAH/03.9. WHO2003Draft Report of Consultative Meeting to Review Evidence and Research Priorities in Management of Acute Respiratory Infections (ARI).Geneva: World Health Organization Report No.: WHO/FCH/CAH/03.9
- 8. Wold Health Organization (2002) Revised Global Burden of Disease (GBD) 2002. Wold Health Organization2002Revised Global Burden of Disease (GBD) 2002.Estimates in Geneva: WHO; p.2005. Estimates in Geneva: WHO; p.2005.
- 9. Greenwood BM, Greenwood AM, Bradley AK, Tulloch S, Hayes R, et al. (1987) Deaths in infancy and early childhood in a well-vaccinated, rural, West African population. Ann Trop Paediatr 7: 91–99.BM GreenwoodAM GreenwoodAK BradleyS. TullochR. Hayes1987Deaths in infancy and early childhood in a well-vaccinated, rural, West African population.Ann Trop Paediatr79199
- 10. Jaffar S, Leach A, Greenwood AM, Jepson A, Muller O, et al. (1997) Changes in the pattern of infant and childhood mortality in upper river division, The Gambia, from 1989 to 1993. Trop Med Int Health 2: 28–37.S. JaffarA. LeachAM GreenwoodA. JepsonO. Muller1997Changes in the pattern of infant and childhood mortality in upper river division, The Gambia, from 1989 to 1993.Trop Med Int Health22837
- 11. Greenwood B (2008) A global action plan for the prevention and control of pneumonia. Bull World Health Organ 86: 322–32A.B. Greenwood2008A global action plan for the prevention and control of pneumonia.Bull World Health Organ8632232A
- 12. Secretary General of the United Nations (2001) Road Map Towards the Implementation of the United Nations Millenium Declaration: Report of Secretary General to Fifty-Sixth Session of the United Nations General Assembly. Secretary General of the United Nations2001Road Map Towards the Implementation of the United Nations Millenium Declaration: Report of Secretary General to Fifty-Sixth Session of the United Nations General Assembly
- 13. Qazi S WM, Boschi-Pinto C, Cherian T (2008) Global Action Plan for the Prevention and Control of Pneumonia (GAPP): Report of an Informal Consultation: La Mainaz, Gex, France, 5–7 March 2007. World Health Organization. WM Qazi SC. Boschi-PintoT. Cherian2008Global Action Plan for the Prevention and Control of Pneumonia (GAPP): Report of an Informal Consultation: La Mainaz, Gex, France, 5–7 March 2007.World Health Organization
- 14. Howie SR, Adegbola RA (2006) Pneumonia and child mortality. Lancet 368: 1646.SR HowieRA Adegbola2006Pneumonia and child mortality.Lancet3681646
- 15. Scott JA, English M (2008) What are the implications for childhood pneumonia of successfully introducing Hib and pneumococcal vaccines in developing countries? PLoS Med 5: e86.JA ScottM. English2008What are the implications for childhood pneumonia of successfully introducing Hib and pneumococcal vaccines in developing countries?PLoS Med5e86
- 16. Lanz C, Patterson AD, Slavik J, Krausz KW, Ledermann M, et al. (2009) Radiation metabolomics. 3. Biomarker discovery in the urine of gamma-irradiated rats using a simplified metabolomics protocol of gas chromatography-mass spectrometry combined with random forests machine learning algorithm. Radiat Res 172: 198–212.C. LanzAD PattersonJ. SlavikKW KrauszM. Ledermann2009Radiation metabolomics. 3. Biomarker discovery in the urine of gamma-irradiated rats using a simplified metabolomics protocol of gas chromatography-mass spectrometry combined with random forests machine learning algorithm.Radiat Res172198212
- 17. Patterson AD, Li H, Eichler GS, Krausz KW, Weinstein JN, et al. (2008) UPLC-ESI-TOFMS-based metabolomics and gene expression dynamics inspector self-organizing metabolomic maps as tools for understanding the cellular response to ionizing radiation. Anal Chem 80: 665–674.AD PattersonH. LiGS EichlerKW KrauszJN Weinstein2008UPLC-ESI-TOFMS-based metabolomics and gene expression dynamics inspector self-organizing metabolomic maps as tools for understanding the cellular response to ionizing radiation.Anal Chem80665674
- 18. Tyburski JB, Patterson AD, Krausz KW, Slavik J, Fornace AJJ, et al. (2008) Radiation metabolomics. 1. Identification of minimally invasive urine biomarkers for gamma-radiation exposure in mice. Radiat Res 170: 1–14.JB TyburskiAD PattersonKW KrauszJ. SlavikAJJ Fornace2008Radiation metabolomics. 1. Identification of minimally invasive urine biomarkers for gamma-radiation exposure in mice.Radiat Res170114
- 19. Tyburski JB, Patterson AD, Krausz KW, Slavik J, Fornace AJJ, et al. (2009) Radiation metabolomics. 2. Dose- and time-dependent urinary excretion of deaminated purines and pyrimidines after sublethal gamma-radiation exposure in mice. Radiat Res 172: 42–57.JB TyburskiAD PattersonKW KrauszJ. SlavikAJJ Fornace2009Radiation metabolomics. 2. Dose- and time-dependent urinary excretion of deaminated purines and pyrimidines after sublethal gamma-radiation exposure in mice.Radiat Res1724257
- 20. Griffin JL, Kauppinen RA (2007) Tumour metabolomics in animal models of human cancer. J Proteome Res 6: 498–505.JL GriffinRA Kauppinen2007Tumour metabolomics in animal models of human cancer.J Proteome Res6498505
- 21. Jordan KW, Cheng LL (2007) NMR-based metabolomics approach to target biomarkers for human prostate cancer. Expert Rev Proteomics 4: 389–400.KW JordanLL Cheng2007NMR-based metabolomics approach to target biomarkers for human prostate cancer.Expert Rev Proteomics4389400
- 22. Serkova NJ, Glunde K (2009) Metabolomics of cancer. Methods Mol Biol 520: 273–295.NJ SerkovaK. Glunde2009Metabolomics of cancer.Methods Mol Biol520273295
- 23. Sreekumar A, Poisson LM, Rajendiran TM, Khan AP, Cao Q, et al. (2009) Metabolomic profiles delineate potential role for sarcosine in prostate cancer progression. Nature 457: 910–914.A. SreekumarLM PoissonTM RajendiranAP KhanQ. Cao2009Metabolomic profiles delineate potential role for sarcosine in prostate cancer progression.Nature457910914
- 24. Jansson J, Willing B, Lucio M, Fekete A, Dicksved J, et al. (2009) Metabolomics reveals metabolic biomarkers of Crohn's disease. PLoS One 4: e6386.J. JanssonB. WillingM. LucioA. FeketeJ. Dicksved2009Metabolomics reveals metabolic biomarkers of Crohn's disease.PLoS One4e6386
- 25. Kinross J, von Roon AC, Penney N, Holmes E, Silk D, et al. (2009) The gut microbiota as a target for improved surgical outcome and improved patient care. Curr Pharm Des 15: 1537–1545.J. KinrossAC von RoonN. PenneyE. HolmesD. Silk2009The gut microbiota as a target for improved surgical outcome and improved patient care.Curr Pharm Des1515371545
- 26. Tuohy KM, Gougoulias C, Shen Q, Walton G, Fava F, et al. (2009) Studying the human gut microbiota in the trans-omics era—focus on metagenomics and metabonomics. Curr Pharm Des 15: 1415–1427.KM TuohyC. GougouliasQ. ShenG. WaltonF. Fava2009Studying the human gut microbiota in the trans-omics era—focus on metagenomics and metabonomics.Curr Pharm Des1514151427
- 27. Waldram A, Holmes E, Wang Y, Rantalainen M, Wilson ID, et al. (2009) Top-down systems biology modeling of host metabotype-microbiome associations in obese rodents. J Proteome Res 8: 2361–2375.A. WaldramE. HolmesY. WangM. RantalainenID Wilson2009Top-down systems biology modeling of host metabotype-microbiome associations in obese rodents.J Proteome Res823612375
- 28. Cassiday L (2009) Diagnosing pneumonia with urinary metabolomics. J Proteome Res 8: 5409–5410.L. Cassiday2009Diagnosing pneumonia with urinary metabolomics.J Proteome Res854095410
- 29. Mahadevan S, Shah SL, Marrie TJ, Slupsky CM (2008) Analysis of metabolomic data using support vector machines. Anal Chem 80: 7562–7570.S. MahadevanSL ShahTJ MarrieCM Slupsky2008Analysis of metabolomic data using support vector machines.Anal Chem8075627570
- 30. Slupsky CM, Rankin KN, Fu H, Chang D, Rowe BH, et al. (2009) Pneumococcal pneumonia: potential for diagnosis through a urinary metabolic profile. J Proteome Res 8: 5550–5558.CM SlupskyKN RankinH. FuD. ChangBH Rowe2009Pneumococcal pneumonia: potential for diagnosis through a urinary metabolic profile.J Proteome Res855505558
- 31. Serkova NJ, Van Rheen Z, Tobias M, Pitzer JE, Wilkinson JE, et al. (2008) Utility of magnetic resonance imaging and nuclear magnetic resonance-based metabolomics for quantification of inflammatory lung injury. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 295: L152–61.NJ SerkovaZ. Van RheenM. TobiasJE PitzerJE Wilkinson2008Utility of magnetic resonance imaging and nuclear magnetic resonance-based metabolomics for quantification of inflammatory lung injury.Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol295L15261
- 32. Slupsky CM, Cheypesh A, Chao DV, Fu H, Rankin KN, et al. (2009) Streptococcus pneumoniae and Staphylococcus aureus pneumonia induce distinct metabolic responses. J Proteome Res 8: 3029–3036.CM SlupskyA. CheypeshDV ChaoH. FuKN Rankin2009Streptococcus pneumoniae and Staphylococcus aureus pneumonia induce distinct metabolic responses.J Proteome Res830293036
- 33. Gambian Central Statistics Department (2003) 2003 Census. Gambian Central Statistics Department20032003 Census
- 34. Adegbola RA, Falade AG, Sam BE, Aidoo M, Baldeh I, et al. (1994) The etiology of pneumonia in malnourished and well-nourished Gambian children. Pediatr Infect Dis J 13: 975–982.RA AdegbolaAG FaladeBE SamM. AidooI. Baldeh1994The etiology of pneumonia in malnourished and well-nourished Gambian children.Pediatr Infect Dis J13975982
- 35. Morris GA, Ikumapayi UN, Antonio M, Howie SR, Adegbola RA (2008) A novel Campylobacter jejuni sequence type from a culture-negative patient in the Gambia. PLoS One 3: e1773.GA MorrisUN IkumapayiM. AntonioSR HowieRA Adegbola2008A novel Campylobacter jejuni sequence type from a culture-negative patient in the Gambia.PLoS One3e1773
- 36. Smith-Vaughan H, Byun R, Nadkarni M, Jacques NA, Hunter N, et al. (2006) Measuring nasal bacterial load and its association with otitis media. BMC Ear Nose Throat Disord 6: 10.H. Smith-VaughanR. ByunM. NadkarniNA JacquesN. Hunter2006Measuring nasal bacterial load and its association with otitis media.BMC Ear Nose Throat Disord610
- 37. Breiman L (2001) Random Forests. Machine Learning 45: 5–32.L. Breiman2001Random Forests.Machine Learning45532
- 38. Patterson AD, Lanz C, Gonzalez FJ, Idle JR (2009) The role of mass spectrometry-based metabolomics in medical countermeasures against radiation. Mass Spectrom Rev. AD PattersonC. LanzFJ GonzalezJR Idle2009The role of mass spectrometry-based metabolomics in medical countermeasures against radiation.Mass Spectrom Rev
- 39. Becker BF (1993) Towards the physiological function of uric acid. Free Radic Biol Med 14: 615–631.BF Becker1993Towards the physiological function of uric acid.Free Radic Biol Med14615631
- 40. Mene P, Punzo G (2008) Uric acid: bystander or culprit in hypertension and progressive renal disease? J Hypertens 26: 2085–2092.P. MeneG. Punzo2008Uric acid: bystander or culprit in hypertension and progressive renal disease?J Hypertens2620852092
- 41. Gasse P, Riteau N, Charron S, Girre S, Fick L, et al. (2009) Uric acid is a danger signal activating NALP3 inflammasome in lung injury inflammation and fibrosis. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 179: 903–913.P. GasseN. RiteauS. CharronS. GirreL. Fick2009Uric acid is a danger signal activating NALP3 inflammasome in lung injury inflammation and fibrosis.Am J Respir Crit Care Med179903913
- 42. Rodriguez-Nunez A, Camina F, Lojo S, Rodriguez-Segade S, Castro-Gago M (1993) Concentrations of nucleotides, nucleosides, purine bases and urate in cerebrospinal fluid of children with meningitis. Acta Paediatr 82: 849–852.A. Rodriguez-NunezF. CaminaS. LojoS. Rodriguez-SegadeM. Castro-Gago1993Concentrations of nucleotides, nucleosides, purine bases and urate in cerebrospinal fluid of children with meningitis.Acta Paediatr82849852
- 43. Schmidt H, Weigand MA, Li C, Schmidt W, Martin E, et al. (1997) Intestinal formation of hypoxanthine and uric acid during endotoxemia. J Surg Res 71: 61–66.H. SchmidtMA WeigandC. LiW. SchmidtE. Martin1997Intestinal formation of hypoxanthine and uric acid during endotoxemia.J Surg Res716166
- 44. Jabs CM, Neglen P, Eklof B (1995) Breakdown of adenine nucleotides, formation of oxygen free radicals, and early markers of cellular injury in endotoxic shock. Eur J Surg 161: 147–155.CM JabsP. NeglenB. Eklof1995Breakdown of adenine nucleotides, formation of oxygen free radicals, and early markers of cellular injury in endotoxic shock.Eur J Surg161147155
- 45. Fabre JE, Nguyen M, Latour A, Keifer JA, Audoly LP, et al. (1999) Decreased platelet aggregation, increased bleeding time and resistance to thromboembolism in P2Y1-deficient mice. Nat Med 5: 1199–1202.JE FabreM. NguyenA. LatourJA KeiferLP Audoly1999Decreased platelet aggregation, increased bleeding time and resistance to thromboembolism in P2Y1-deficient mice.Nat Med511991202
- 46. Gear AR, Suttitanamongkol S, Viisoreanu D, Polanowska-Grabowska RK, Raha S, et al. (2001) Adenosine diphosphate strongly potentiates the ability of the chemokines MDC, TARC, and SDF-1 to stimulate platelet function. Blood 97: 937–945.AR GearS. SuttitanamongkolD. ViisoreanuRK Polanowska-GrabowskaS. Raha2001Adenosine diphosphate strongly potentiates the ability of the chemokines MDC, TARC, and SDF-1 to stimulate platelet function.Blood97937945
- 47. Murugappan S, Kunapuli SP (2006) The role of ADP in platelet function. Frontiers in Bioscience 11: 1977–1986.S. MurugappanSP Kunapuli2006The role of ADP in platelet function.Frontiers in Bioscience1119771986
- 48. Hendriksen WT, Kloosterman TG, Bootsma HJ, Estevao S, de Groot R, et al. (2008) Site-specific contributions of glutamine-dependent regulator GlnR and GlnR-regulated genes to virulence of Streptococcus pneumoniae. Infect Immun 76: 1230–1238.WT HendriksenTG KloostermanHJ BootsmaS. EstevaoR. de Groot2008Site-specific contributions of glutamine-dependent regulator GlnR and GlnR-regulated genes to virulence of Streptococcus pneumoniae.Infect Immun7612301238
- 49. Yue S, Lou Z, Yu P, Zeng PChanges in glutamate and GABA in cerebrospinal fluid of patients with pneumonia complicated with central nervous system damag. Hunan Yi Ke Da Xue Xue Bao 24: 287–289.S. YueZ. LouP. YuP. ZengChanges in glutamate and GABA in cerebrospinal fluid of patients with pneumonia complicated with central nervous system damag.Hunan Yi Ke Da Xue Xue Bao24287289
- 50. Muller A, Heseler K, Schmidt SK, Spekker K, Mackenzie CR, et al. (2008) The missing link between indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase mediated antibacterial and immunoregulatory effects. J Cell Mol Med. A. MullerK. HeselerSK SchmidtK. SpekkerCR Mackenzie2008The missing link between indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase mediated antibacterial and immunoregulatory effects.J Cell Mol Med
- 51. Xu X, Zhang D, Zhang H, Wolters PJ, Killeen NP, et al. (2006) Neutrophil histamine contributes to inflammation in mycoplasma pneumonia. J Exp Med 203: 2907–2917.X. XuD. ZhangH. ZhangPJ WoltersNP Killeen2006Neutrophil histamine contributes to inflammation in mycoplasma pneumonia.J Exp Med20329072917
- 52. Burian K, Hegyesi H, Buzas E, Endresz V, Kis Z, et al. (2003) Chlamydophila (Chlamydia) pneumoniae induces histidine decarboxylase production in the mouse lung. Immunol Lett 89: 229–236.K. BurianH. HegyesiE. BuzasV. EndreszZ. Kis2003Chlamydophila (Chlamydia) pneumoniae induces histidine decarboxylase production in the mouse lung.Immunol Lett89229236
- 53. Combes A, Luyt CE, Trouillet JL, Nieszkowska A, Chastre J (2009) Gender impact on the outcomes of critically ill patients with nosocomial infections. Crit Care Med 37: 2506–2511.A. CombesCE LuytJL TrouilletA. NieszkowskaJ. Chastre2009Gender impact on the outcomes of critically ill patients with nosocomial infections.Crit Care Med3725062511
- 54. Reade MC, Yende S, D'Angelo G, Kong L, Kellum JA, et al. (2009) Differences in immune response may explain lower survival among older men with pneumonia. Crit Care Med 37: 1655–1662.MC ReadeS. YendeG. D'AngeloL. KongJA Kellum2009Differences in immune response may explain lower survival among older men with pneumonia.Crit Care Med3716551662
- 55. Casimir GJ, Mulier S, Hanssens L, Zylberberg K, Duchateau J (2009) GENDER DIFFERENCES IN INFLAMMATORY MARKERS IN CHILDREN. Shock. GJ CasimirS. MulierL. HanssensK. ZylberbergJ. Duchateau2009GENDER DIFFERENCES IN INFLAMMATORY MARKERS IN CHILDREN.Shock
- 56. Henderson JP, Crowley JR, Pinkner JS, Walker JN, Tsukayama P, et al. (2009) Quantitative metabolomics reveals an epigenetic blueprint for iron acquisition in uropathogenic Escherichia coli. PLoS Pathog 5: e1000305.JP HendersonJR CrowleyJS PinknerJN WalkerP. Tsukayama2009Quantitative metabolomics reveals an epigenetic blueprint for iron acquisition in uropathogenic Escherichia coli.PLoS Pathog5e1000305
- 57. Himmelreich U, Malik R, Kuhn T, Daniel HM, Somorjai RL, et al. (2009) Rapid etiological classification of meningitis by NMR spectroscopy based on metabolite profiles and host response. PLoS One 4: e5328.U. HimmelreichR. MalikT. KuhnHM DanielRL Somorjai2009Rapid etiological classification of meningitis by NMR spectroscopy based on metabolite profiles and host response.PLoS One4e5328
- 58. Sintchenko V, Iredell JR, Gilbert GL (2007) Pathogen profiling for disease management and surveillance. Nat Rev Microbiol 5: 464–470.V. SintchenkoJR IredellGL Gilbert2007Pathogen profiling for disease management and surveillance.Nat Rev Microbiol5464470