A major pathological hallmark of AD is the deposition of insoluble extracellular β-amyloid (Aβ) plaques. There are compelling data suggesting that Aβ aggregation is catalysed by reaction with the metals zinc and copper.
We now report that the major human-expressed metallothionein (MT) subtype, MT-2A, is capable of preventing the in vitro copper-mediated aggregation of Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–42. This action of MT-2A appears to involve a metal-swap between Zn7MT-2A and Cu(II)-Aβ, since neither Cu10MT-2A or carboxymethylated MT-2A blocked Cu(II)-Aβ aggregation. Furthermore, Zn7MT-2A blocked Cu(II)-Aβ induced changes in ionic homeostasis and subsequent neurotoxicity of cultured cortical neurons.
These results indicate that MTs of the type represented by MT-2A are capable of protecting against Aβ aggregation and toxicity. Given the recent interest in metal-chelation therapies for AD that remove metal from Aβ leaving a metal-free Aβ that can readily bind metals again, we believe that MT-2A might represent a different therapeutic approach as the metal exchange between MT and Aβ leaves the Aβ in a Zn-bound, relatively inert form.
Citation: Chung RS, Howells C, Eaton ED, Shabala L, Zovo K, Palumaa P, et al. (2010) The Native Copper- and Zinc- Binding Protein Metallothionein Blocks Copper-Mediated Aβ Aggregation and Toxicity in Rat Cortical Neurons. PLoS ONE 5(8): e12030. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012030
Editor: Ashley I. Bush, Mental Health Research Institute of Victoria, Australia
Received: January 18, 2010; Accepted: July 15, 2010; Published: August 11, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Chung et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by research grants from the Australian Research Council (ARC, ID# DP0556630; DP0984673; LP0774820), National Health and Medical Research Council (ID# 490025, 544913) and Jack & Ethel Goldin Foundation. RSC holds an ARC Research Fellowship. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the most common form of dementia within the ageing population. AD accounts for between 50% and 60% of dementia cases . The pathological hallmarks of the disease include extracellular β-amyloid (Aβ) plaques, intracellular neurofibrillary tangles and dystrophic neurites . All of these hallmarks arise from the abnormal and unregulated overproduction of insoluble proteinaceous structures. These proteinaceous structures are responsible for the disruption to normal cellular functioning ultimately leading to cell death.
The main constituents of Aβ plaques are the 40- and 42-mer peptides, Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–42 , which associate to form abnormal extracellular deposits of fibrils and amorphous aggregates . Aβ is derived from the β-amyloid precursor peptide (APP), which is a normal protein ,  that is produced by neuronal and non-neuronal cells , . APP is processed by a combination of α-, β-, and/or γ- secretases to form numerous protein products. The plaque-forming Aβ1–42 and Aβ1–40 arise from the uncommon β-and γ-secretase cleavage of the APP.
The mechanisms underlying the aggregation of Aβ have been the subject of intense investigation. There is compelling data to suggest that the aggregation of Aβ is catalysed by reaction with the metals zinc and copper. Cu-mediated aggregation of Aβ leads to the formation of copper-bound, SDS-insoluble Aβ aggregates, that are neurotoxic due to the ability of Aβ-bound copper to undergo redox reactions at the cell membrane to generate reactive oxygen species , . Of note, Aβ plaques deposited in the AD brain are found to be enriched with metals, and in particular copper , .
Metallothioneins (MTs) are the major endogenous zinc- and copper- binding protein within the brain. The MT-1/2 isoforms (exemplified by the highly expressed member, MT-2A) are characterised as highly neuroprotective proteins essential for brain repair –. The metal-binding properties of MT-1/2 have been well investigated, and it is recognised that these proteins are capable of binding 7 divalent (Zn2+) and up to 12 monovalent (Cu+) metal ions in vivo through two distinct metal-thiolate clusters, termed the α- and β- domains . The importance of MT in maintaining metal homeostasis is clearly demonstrated in studies involving exposure to heavy metals (either by diet or environment) in MT-1/2 knockout mice, which leads to metal toxicity, while MT-1/2 overexpressing mice are relatively protected from heavy metal toxicity [see review, 17]. MTs also have important roles in copper homeostasis, evidenced by the crossing of a mouse model of Menkes disease (a copper efflux disease) with MT-1/2 knockout mice, which results in embryonic lethality .
Given the strong metal-binding properties of MT, we predict that these proteins may be involved in regulating the metal-binding and subsequent aggregation of Aβ. Indeed, there is substantial literature supporting a role for MTs in the pathophysiology of AD. These proteins are expressed by astrocytes, and their expression is significantly upregulated in regions of Aβ plaque pathology in the pre-clinical  and clinical AD brain , , as well as in the brains of transgenic AD mice . Notably, Meloni et al  recently reported that the Zn(II)-MT-3 isoform is capable of exchanging metals with Cu(II)-Aβ to prevent the formation of SDS-insoluble Cu(II)-Aβ aggregates. The goal of this study is to evaluate whether MT-2A, via its zinc- and copper- binding properties, also represents an endogenous protective mechanism against Aβ aggregation and toxicity.
MT-2A prevents copper-mediated formation of SDS-insoluble Aβ aggregates
To stimulate Aβ aggregation, 25µM of Aβ1–40 was mixed with an equimolar concentration of copper and 200µM ascorbate, and shaken at 300rpm for three days at 37°C. The resultant protein aggregates were collected by ultracentrifugation, resuspended in SDS-PAGE loading buffer and electrophoresed. Under these conditions, no Aβ1–40 was visualised on SDS-PAGE (Figure 1A), as a consequence of the formation of copper-bound SDS-insoluble aggregates (IA). In contrast, in the presence of Zn7MT-2A at the range of 2.5–25µM, Aβ1–40 formed aggregates (SA)(Figure 1B), which dissolved in SDS and resolved as a single band on SDS-PAGE of approximately 3–4kDa representing monomeric Aβ1–40 (Figure 1A). As shown recently by Meloni et al  the structurally related metallothionein isoform Zn7MT-3 was also capable of preventing formation of SDS-insoluble Aβ1–40 aggregates, but required a 10-fold higher concentration than Zn7MT-2A (Figure 1B). We also investigated whether Zn7MT-2A can prevent the Cu-mediated aggregation of Aβ1–42. Under the same experimental conditions, 25µM Zn7MT2A was able to completely prevent Cu-Aβ1–42 forming SDS-insoluble aggregates (results not shown).
This resulted in the formation of SDS-insoluble Aβ aggregates (IA), which were not visualised on SDS-PAGE (A). The presence of Zn7-MT2A (5–25µM) prevented formation of SDS-insoluble Aβ aggregates (A). Instead, SDS-soluble aggregates (SA) were formed, that were resolved as a single protein band of approximately 3–4kDa size, representing monomeric Aβ1–40 peptide (A). A range of different MT forms were tested for the ability to promote formation of SDS-soluble aggregates (SA)(B). Zn7MT-2A promoted formation of SDS-SA, and Zn7MT-3 had a similar effect but at 10-fold higher concentration (B). The ability of MT-2A to prevent formation of SDS-IA was linked to metal-binding properties, as different metallated forms of MT-2A had different effects upon Aβ aggregation (B). When Cu-Aβ1–40 or Cu-Aβ1–42 aggregates were generated by three days of incubation, and then incubated with shaking in the presence or absence of 25µM Zn7MT-2A for up to three days, this was unable de-aggregate either Cu-Aβ1–40 or Cu-Aβ1–42 pre-formed aggregates (C).
We also investigated whether MT-2A can de-aggregate pre-formed Cu-Aβ aggregates. Cu-Aβ1–40 and Cu-Aβ1–42 aggregates were produced as described above (three day incubation), after which time 25µM of Zn7MT-2A was added. However, incubation with Zn7MT-2A for up to three days was unable to de-aggregate either Cu-Aβ1–40 or Cu-Aβ1–42 pre-formed aggregates (Figure 1C).
To establish whether the metallation state of MT is responsible for the ability of MT-2A to prevent aggregation of Aβ1–40 into SDS-IA, several different metallated forms of MT-2A were used. We found that Cu10MT-2A was not able to prevent the formation of SDS-insoluble Aβ1–40 aggregates (Figure 1). Furthermore, chemical modification of MT-2A to block metal binding, by means of carboxymethylation of cysteine residues (CaMeMT-2A) abolished the ability of MT-2A to prevent formation of insoluble Aβ1–40 aggregates (Figure 1). Finally, metal free (apo) MT-2A was also unable to prevent copper-mediated formation of insoluble Aβ1–40. Based upon these observations, we predict that the zinc bound to MT is required for the ability of MT to block copper-mediated Aβ1–40 aggregation.
Evidence that Zn7MT-2A prevents copper-mediated Aβ aggregation via metal exchange
One possible explanation for our observations is that there is a metal exchange of copper and zinc between Zn7MT-2A and Cu(II)Aβ with the subsequent formation of Zn-bound Aβ aggregates and soluble Cu-bound MT. To test this hypothesis, the amount of copper and zinc present in the aggregated Aβ samples was determined using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). When Aβ1–40 was aggregated for three days in the presence of copper and ascorbate, the amount of copper/zinc detected within the pellet fraction following ultracentrifugation was 89.2/27.1ng (Table 1). However, when Aβ1–40 was aggregated in the presence of Zn7MT-2A, the amount of copper present in the pellet fraction was significantly reduced to 47.5ng (approximately 53% decrease), while there was a concomitant increase in zinc to 81.4ng (Table 1). There was no change in copper/zinc levels however when CaMeMT-2A was used (Table 1). This provides further evidence that a copper-zinc exchange has occurred between Cu(II)-Aβ and Zn7MT-2A. We therefore predict that the action of MT-2A to prevent the formation of insoluble Aβ aggregates is due to metal exchange of copper and zinc between Zn7MT-2A and Cu(II)Aβ with the subsequent formation of Zn-bound Aβ which only forms soluble protein aggregates.
Comparative measurement of the relative Cu(I)-binding affinity of MT-2A with MT-3
An explanation for the different abilities of MT-2A and MT-3 to alter Cu(II)-Aβ aggregation might lie in different copper-binding properties of MT-2A and MT-3. Formal thermodynamic analysis indicated that MT-3 has only slightly lower apparent Cu(I)-binding affinity (KCu = 0.47±0.01 fM) (Figure 2A) as compared with that which we have recently reported for MT-2A (KCu = 0.41±0.02 fM) . However, differences were observed in the composition and affinities of individual copper-thiolate clusters of MT-2 and MT-3. In ESI-MS studies in the presence of 10mM DTT, we observed that copper was bound to MT-3 in a mixture of major Cu12MT-3 and minor Cu10MT-3 forms (Figure 2B), while we have recently reported that MT-2A is predominantly found in Cu10MT-2A form . Addition of the high affinity Cu(I)-binding chelator DETC at 0.5 mM concentration was sufficient to convert Cu12MT-3 to a predominant Cu6MT-3 form, which could be further demetallated to apo-MT-3 at 3 mM DETC (Figure 2B). These observations indicate that MT-3 binds copper in two distinct hexacopper clusters exposing different Cu(I)-binding affinities. Conversely however, Cu10MT-2A was stable at up to 1.0 mM DETC, and that 1.5mM DETC was required to partially demetallate Cu10MT-2A to Cu6MT-2A . This suggests that tetracopper-thiolate cluster in Cu10MT-2A has higher Cu(I)-binding affinity than low-affinity hexacopper-thiolate cluster in Cu12MT-3, and may account for the greater ability of MT-2A to prevent Cu(II)-Aβ aggregation compared to MT-3. We predict from the amino acid composition of MT-2A and MT-3 that due to their high sequence homology that the N-terminal β-domains will share similar metal-binding properties (Figure 2C), most likely corresponding to the hexacopper-thiolate cluster that is demetallated by treatment with 3mM DETC. Subsequently, the C-terminal α-domain is likely to represent the metal thiolate cluster that differs between the two isoforms and which may contribute to the different copper-binding properties of MT-2A and MT-3. To test this hypothesis we switched the domains between isoforms to form chimeric recombinant MT-3β2α and MT-2β3α proteins (note the the beta-domains of each chimera are at the N-terminus, which is the same as native MTs). Indeed, Zn7MT-3β2α was capable of preventing copper mediated Aβ aggregation to a similar degree as Zn7MT-2A, while the Zn7MT-2β3α chimeric protein had a similar activity to Zn7MT-3 (Figure 2D).
To investigate the binding affinities of the individual copper-thiolate clusters of MT-3, we exposed Cu12MT-3 to the high affinity Cu(I)-binding chelator DETC (B). At 0.5 mM concentration DETC, Cu12MT-3 converted to a predominant Cu6MT-3 form, which could be further demetallated to apo-MT-3 at 3 mM DETC (B). Human MT-3 shares approximately 60% amino acid sequence homology with human MT-2A (C). Conserved cysteines are highlighted in yellow, and amino acid insertions indicated in purple. Zn7MT-3β2α was able to prevent formation of SDS-insoluble Aβ1–40 aggregates (IA), while Zn7MT-2β3α could only prevent insoluble aggregate formation at a concentration of 25µM (D).
MT-2A protects against Aβ toxicity in cultured cortical neurons
It has been reported previously that Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 but not Zn(II)-Aβ1–40 is toxic to cultured neurons , . The combination of equi-molar concentrations of Aβ1–40 and Cu(II) ions results in all free copper becoming rapidly bound to Aβ1–40 to form Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 . We maintained rat cortical neurons for three days in vitro (3DIV) followed by treatment with 40µM Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 and 300µM ascorbate. After 24 hours, this treatment resulted in about an 80% reduction in cell viability, as measured using an alamarBlue® cell viability assay (Figure 3A). In parallel experiments we performed direct cell counts to validate the alamarBlue® data, and observed a comparable degree of neurotoxicity in the presence of 40mM Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 (Figure S1). We found that Zn7MT-2A blocked Aβ-induced toxicity in a dose dependent manner (5–20µM range), with almost complete protection at a concentration of 20µM Zn7MT-2A (Figure 3A). Furthermore, 20µM of Zn7MT-2A was far more effective in protecting against Cu(II)-Aβ neurotoxicity than 20µM Zn7MT-3 (Figure 3A). Immunolabelling of neurons for the cytoskeletal protein tau demonstrated that Zn7MT-2A protected against Cu(II)-Aβ induced neuronal degeneration (Figure 3B–D). Treatment with ascorbate or Aβ1–40 alone had no effect upon viability (results not shown). Note that addition of MT-3 to neuronal cultures can have powerful neurotoxic effects in its own right, if applied in the presence of a brain derived extract or serum , , neither of which are present here. In contrast, in the absence of these agents, MT-3 alone has no discernible neurotoxic effect.
20µM of Zn7MT-2A was far more effective in protecting against Aβ1–40 neurotoxicity than 20µM Zn7MT-3 (A). Immunolabelling for tau demonstrated smooth cytoskeletal labelling in control (B) neurons, which became punctate and disassociated following Cu(II)Aβ1–40 treatment (C). Treatment with 20µM Zn7MT-2A prevented Aβ-induced structural changes in the neuronal cytoskeleton (D). Scale bar = 25mm.
To further investigate whether it is Cu(II)-Aβ and not free copper that is responsible for neurotoxicity, we fractionated a 40µM Cu(II)-Aβ solution on a PD MidiTrap™ G-25 column and determined the protein (A280) and metal (ICP-MS) content of each fraction. Only those fractions containing peptide also contained copper (Figure 4A), indicating that the Cu(II)-Aβ solution did not contain any free copper ions. The neurotoxicity of all fractions was subsequently tested, and only those containing Cu(II)-Aβ exhibited neurotoxic activity (Figure 4B), demonstrating that Cu(II)-Aβ is responsible for the neurotoxicity that we have observed in our experiments.
Only those fractions containing Aβ peptide also contained copper (A), indicating that the Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 solution did not contain any free copper ions. The neurotoxicity of all fractions was subsequently tested, and only those containing Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 exhibited neurotoxic activity (B). E – eluate, F – collected fraction.
To investigate whether MT-2A acts protectively via the zinc-copper metal exchange between Zn7MT-2A and Cu(II)-Aβ described above, Cu10MT-2A was used in the place of Zn7MT-2A, which resulted in no neuroprotection against Cu(II)-Aβ (Figure 5A). This suggests that the metal exchange between MT-2A and Cu(II)-Aβ is required for neuroprotection. Notably, Cu10MT-2A alone was not toxic to neurons (Figure 5A), confirming that when copper is bound to MT it is unable to produce ROS. In parallel experiments, we found that Zn7MT-2A was only able to mildly block the neurotoxicity of H2O2 when applied to cultured neurons (Figure 5B). The amount of H2O2 directly applied to the neurons was physiologically relevant as Huang and colleagues  found that 10µM Aβ1–40 or Aβ1–42 may generate up to 25µM H2O2 in 1 hour in the presence of substoichiometric amounts of Cu(II), depending on the oxygen tension. Since H2O2 is the direct ROS product of the interaction of Cu(II)-Aβ with cells , this suggests that the protective action of Zn7MT-2A is primarily upstream of ROS production. This is consistent with our results suggesting that Zn7MT-2A acts via a metal swap with Cu(II)-Aβ to prevent ROS formation.
Treatment of cortical neurons with 10µM or 100µM H2O2 for two hours resulted in substantial neuronal death, which was not prevented by co-treatment with 20µM Zn7MT-2A (B). Error bars represent standard error of the mean calculated from at least three experimental replicates. In panel A, * - p<0.05 compared to untreated cells (One-Way ANOVA). In panel B, Two-Way ANOVA analysis was performed, and * - p<0.05 compared to untreated cells, # - p<0.05 between treatments.
To further confirm that Zn7MT-2A is blocking the detrimental effects of oxidative stress induced by Cu(II)-Aβ, we have measured changes in ionic homeostasis of neurons in response to Cu(II)-Aβ using a microelectrode ion flux measuring (MIFE) technique. The MIFE technique allows direct measurement in changes in K+ and Ca2+ fluxes in response to Cu(II)-Aβ. Treatment with Cu(II)Aβ1–40 (in the presence of ascorbate) induced a rapid efflux of K+ out of neurons, peaking at 4.2±0.65 min after Cu(II)-Aβ application with K+ outflow continuing over a period of 20 minutes (Figure 6A). The treatment also led to a moderate influx of Ca2+, peaking at 6.45±1.35 min after the Cu(II)-Aβ application (indicated by crossing zero line) with Ca2+ uptake continuing over the experimental period (Figure 6C). Treatment with Zn7MT-2A completely blocked Cu(II)-Aβ induced changes in K+ and Ca2+ fluxes, at a concentration of >5µM (Figure 6B, D). Individual treatments with either Aβ1–40 or Zn7MT-2A alone (in the presence of ascorbate) had no effect upon any of the ions measured (results not shown).
Treatment with 40µM Cu(II)Aβ1–40 resulted in a massive efflux of K+ out of neurons (A), and Ca2+ influx into neurons (B). Quantification of net ion flux revealed that co-treatment with Zn7MT-2A completely blocked Cu(II)Aβ-induced changes in K+ (A and C) and Ca2+ fluxes (B and D), at a concentration of >5mM. For all MIFE data, the sign convention is “influx positive”. Error bars represent standard error of the mean calculated from at least three different experiments. * - p<0.05 compared to Cu(II)-Aβ treated cells (One-Way ANOVA).
The major findings of this study are that the major human-expressed subtype of metallothionein, MT-2A, is capable of preventing the formation of the toxic Cu-mediated aggregates of Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–42. This action of MT-2A appears to involve a metal-swap between Zn7MT-2A and Cu(II)-Aβ since neither Cu10MT-2A or carboxymethylated MT-2A blocked Cu(II)-Aβ aggregation. Furthermore, Zn7MT-2A blocked Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 induced neurotoxicity of cultured cortical neurons. We propose that there is therapeutic potential in a MT-2A based approach to reducing Aβ deposition in AD.
It is well established that MT-1/2 expression is elevated in response to almost all forms of stress to the brain, including traumatic-, ischaemic or chemical- brain injury , , , or in neurodegenerative conditions such as ALS or EAE (an experimental animal model of multiple sclerosis). The common consensus is that MT-1/2 act neuroprotectively, via intracellular functions such as metal detoxification and quenching of oxidative free radicals. More recently, it has been demonstrated that MT-1/2 can be actively secreted by astrocytes under certain pathophysiological conditions , and subsequently act from an extracellular location directly upon neurons to activate intracellular neuroprotective pathways , , . However, an unexpected and specific protective function of MT in the AD brain has recently been proposed by Meloni and colleagues , who have found that Zn7MT-3 is able to prevent copper-mediated aggregation of Aβ in vitro, and protect a neuronal cell line from soluble Aβ1–40 toxicity. There is some controversy over the level of expression of MT-3 in the AD brain, although it appears that expression is downregulated in AD. Furthermore, the expression of MT-3 is not induced by metals or oxidative stress, and this protein displays neurotoxic actions under some conditions , , suggesting that it is unlikely that this protein contributes greatly to a protective mechanism against Aβ aggregation and toxicity. The MT-1/2 isoforms however (as exemplified by MT-2A) are broadly expressed within the adult brain, and greatly elevated levels of expression of these proteins have been noted in the AD brain –.
We now report that MT-2A is also capable of preventing copper-mediated Aβ aggregation (both Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–42), and that this involves a specific metal exchange interaction. Hence, Zn7MT-2A (but not Cu10MT-2A or CaMeMT-2A) prevents soluble Cu(II)-Aβ1–40 from forming SDS-insoluble Aβ1–40 aggregates. This observation might be explained by the well-characterised ability of higher binding affinity metals (ie: copper) to displace lower affinity metals (ie: zinc) within MT [for review see 33]. Similarly, published reports indicate that Aβ has a Cu(II) binding affinity of between 10−6 to 10−11 , , while MT-2A has been reported to have a binding affinity for Cu(II) of 10−19 . This supports the proposition that MT-2A is capable of removing Cu(II) ions from Cu(II)-Aβ. Interestingly, we found that apo-MT-2A (metal free MT-2A) was unable to prevent soluble Cu(II)-Aβ from forming SDS-insoluble Aβ aggregates. Apo-MT-2A has a high affinity for free copper initially suggesting that it might be able to extract Cu from Aβ aggregates. It is possible that the apo-MT rapidly becomes oxidised (via disulphide-bond formation between cysteine residues), which would prevent apo-MT from binding to metals. Or it might be that the ability of MT to participate in an inter-molecular interaction with Aβ under biological conditions is dependent on not just the relative copper binding affinity between the two proteins, but also on the tertiary structure of the zinc-metallated form of metallothionein, which is fundamentally different to the uncoordinated structure found in the apo-thionein. Finally, ICP-MS demonstrated that there was almost 40% less copper in the pellet fraction when Cu(II)-Aβ was aggregated in the presence of Zn7MT-2A. In summary, we provide strong evidence that a metal exchange between Cu(II)-Aβ and Zn7MT-2A is responsible for blocking the aggregation of Aβ into an insoluble form.
In our studies, we noted that Zn7MT-2A was effective at 10-fold lower concentrations than Zn7MT-3 in preventing copper-mediated Aβ1–40 aggregation. We predict that this difference might be related to the relative copper binding affinities of MT-2A and MT-3, and based upon our experiments with chimeric MT proteins we believe that the α-domain of MT-2A is particularly important in this activity. We note that the relative affinity of the α- and β- domains of MT for copper means that the activity of MT-2A and MT-3 towards copper-induced Aβ aggregation will probably depend on the molar ratio of MT to Aβ. In this regard, it is generally considered that the β-domain of MT fills with copper first, followed by the α-domain. We show that MT-2A will prevent aggregation of Cu(II)-Aβ even at low relative levels of this isoform (eg 0.5–5 µM MT to 25 µM Aβ), whereas MT-3 requires a higher MT∶Aβ ratio (25 µM MT to 25 µM Aβ) for activity. This most likely also explains the difference between MT-2A and MT-3 in the neurotoxicity data, in which we used 40µM Cu(II)-Aβ to 20µM MT. We predict that when the ratio of Aβ to MT is equimolar that it will be primarily the β-domains of MT that will be filled with copper, and that in this scenario MT-2A and MT-3 will protect equally against Cu(II)-Aβ neurotoxicity.
We also found that Zn7MT-2A protects neurons against Cu(II)-Aβ toxicity. We believe that this involves a zinc/copper metal-exchange between Zn7MT-2A and Cu(II)-Aβ that subsequently prevents Aβ-bound copper from participating in redox-reactions and producing reactive oxygen species [as suggested in 23]. Hence, only Zn7MT-2A but not Cu10MT-2A or CaMeMT-2A was capable of protecting cortical neurons from soluble Cu(II)-Aβ neurotoxicity. Notably, Cu10MT-2A itself was not toxic to neurons, indicating that when copper is bound to MT (for instance following metal-swap with Cu(II)-Aβ) that it is unable to produce ROS. As evidence that MT-2A is not acting downstream by scavenging the H2O2 generated by Cu(II)-Aβ, we found that Zn7MT-2A provided only a small degree of protection against direct H2O2 neurotoxicity. This suggests that Zn7MT-2A neuroprotection against Cu(II)-Aβ is primarily afforded through a zinc/copper metal swap and subsequent inhibition of H2O2 generation. We do note that it is possible that when Cu(II)-Aβ is applied to neurons that some copper is released from the complex, and that this free copper is also partly responsible for neurotoxicity. Although, as noted by Meloni et al , we think that only a small amount of copper is released from Cu(II)-Aβ upon addition into the culture medium and the primary cause of neurotoxicity is the Cu(II)-Aβ complex.
Finally, using a direct and sensitive technique, MIFE, to measure the kinetics of ion fluxes, we were able to determine that oxidative stress (H2O2) generated by soluble Cu(II)-Aβ induces a rapid net efflux of K+ and mild net influx of Ca2+ into cortical neurons most likely via increased oxidative stress. Notably, K+ efflux from cells is a well established trigger of apoptosis. These observations are also in accordance with the results of other groups who have demonstrated that H2O2 induces substantial dysregulation in neuronal K+ channel conductance  and calcium homeostasis . Importantly, we found that treatment with Zn7MT-2A completely abolished the Cu(II)-Aβ-induced changes in K+ and Ca2+ net ion fluxes. Taken together, our data suggests that the neuroprotective actions of MT-2A lie in its ability to exchange metals with Cu(II)-Aβ to stop production of ROS, and preventing subsequent detrimental changes in ionic balance within neurons.
We believe that our results may reflect a physiological action of MT-2A in the Alzheimer's brain. For instance, MT-1/2 levels in the adult human brain have been reported to be approximately 40µg/g . Expression is primarily by astrocytes, with very low levels of MT-2A expressed in neurons. We have recently reported that secretion of MT-2A by cultured astrocytes can be induced under certain physiological conditions and that extracellular MT-2A can be detected in the site of a physical injury to the brain . Hence, it is conceivable that under stressful situations MT-2A may be secreted from astrocytes into the synaptic vicinity and reach the levels that we have demonstrated are capable of modulating Cu-mediated Aβ aggregation.
Because of the considerable published data linking metal-binding to the aggregation of Aβ, metal-chelation drugs have been proposed as a potential therapy for AD , . An excellent example of this approach is the administration of the copper- and zinc- chelating drug clioquinol, which has been reported to prevent plaque formation in transgenic AD mice . The use of such metal-chelating drugs might not only reduce metal-mediated aggregation of Aβ, but also limit the formation of Cu(II)-Aβ and thus prevent the generation of oxidative stress and subsequent neurotoxicity. One criticism of metal-chelation therapies for AD is that these chelating agents remove metal from Aβ leaving a metal-free Aβ that could feasibly readily bind metals again. Hence, more recently, metal redistribution has been proposed as a more appropriate goal of metal-targeted strategies for AD . In this regard, we believe that MT-2A might represent a possible candidate as a metal-redistribution therapeutic agent, as the metal exchange between MT and Aβ leaves the Aβ in a Zn-bound non-toxic form, and redistributes copper into an inert Cu-MT form.
In summary we provide compelling evidence that MT-2A can protect against copper-induced Aβ aggregation and neurotoxicity. This action of MT-2A appears to involve a metal-swap between Zn7MT-2A and Cu(II)-A Furthermorė MT-2A can block Cu(II)-Aβ induced changes in ion homeostasis and neurotoxicity of cultured cortical neurons. We propose that there is therapeutic potential in a MT-2A based approach to reducing Aβ deposition in AD.
MT proteins were provided by Bestenbalt LLC (Estonia) as >98% pure HPLC-purified proteins. For this study we have used Zn7MT-2A, Zn7MT-3, and different metallated forms of MT-2A including Cu10MT-2A and carboxymethylated MT-2A (CaMeMT-2A). All MT proteins were provided directly from Bestenbalt in lyophilised form in either a metal free (apo), or in Zn7MT or C10MT state, Metallation of MT-2A was prepared as we have described previously for Zn7MT-3 . Briefly, the protein was dissolved in 20 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8 and the pH was lowered to 2.5. Ten equivalents of Zn2+ or 12 equivalents of Cu+ was added and the pH raised to 8. The buffer was exchanged to 10 mM ammonium bicarbonate, and the solution frozen at −80°C and freeze dried. The lyophilised proteins were reconstituted in Milli-Q water (pH 7.4) immediately prior to use.
In vitro copper-mediated Aβ aggregation assay
Synthetic monomeric Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–42 were purchased from EZBiolab (US). The dried Aβ peptide contains trifluoroacetate (TFA) as a counterion, and in analysis it was found that the synthetic Aβ used in this study contained approximately 5–10% TFA. For in vitro Aβ aggregation studies, purified Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–42 (EZBiolab) was dissolved in Tris buffer (20mM Tris-HCl, 100mM NaCl, pH 7.4) to give a 25µM solution, followed by addition of an equimolar concentration of CuCl2 and 200µM ascorbate. The solution was incubated at 37°C for 72hrs with shaking (300 rpm). Aβ aggregation was assessed by gel electrophoresis. Briefly, aggregates were collected by ultracentrifugation at 20,000G for 1 hour then resuspended in LDS (lithium dodecyl sulfate) sample buffer (Invitrogen) and electrophoresed under reducing conditions (β-mercaptoethanol in sample and Invitrogen anti-oxidant supplement in the running buffer) on a 10% Nu-Page Bis-Tris gel (Invitrogen) at 200V for 30 minutes. Protein bands were visualized using Coomassie brilliant blue stain. Aggregates were assessed as SDS-soluble when the Aβ protein was observed in monomeric form on the gel and as SDS-insoluble when not observed on the gel.
Electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) metal binding analysis
Copper binding affinity of MT-3 was determined in strictly similar conditions and by identical approach, which we have recently elaborated for MT-2A . Briefly, 3.3 µM samples of apo-MT-3 were reconstituted with Cu(I) by addition of 12 equivalents of Cu(I)DTT complex in 20 mM ammonium acetate pH 7.5 in the presence of 10 mM DTT. After addition of various concentrations of Cu(I)-chelating reagent diethyl dithio carbamate (DETC), samples were incubated for 2 minutes and injected into the electrospray ion source of QSTAR Elite ESI-Q-TOF MS instrument (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, USA) by a syringe pump at 6 µl/min and ESI-MS spectra were recorded over a 5 minute period in m/Z region from 500–3000 Da at following instrument parameters: ion spray voltage 5500 V; source gas 45 l/min; curtain gas 20 l/min; declustering potential 60V; focusing potential 320 V; detector voltage 2300V.
The Cu-binding affinity of MT-3 was determined from ESI-MS titration results of Cu12MT-3 with DETC by correlating the fractional occupancy of Cu(I)-binding sites in MT-3 with the concentration of free Cu(I) ions. The fractional occupancy of Cu(I)-binding sites in MT-3 (Y) was calculated from ESI-MS spectra (considering that there are 12 Cu(I) binding sites in MT-3) by using the following equation:(1)where ICunMT-3 denotes the intensity of the CunMT-3 peak in the ESI-MS spectra. The fractional occupancy of Cu(I) binding sites in MT-3 was correlated with the concentration of free Cu(I) ions in the sample calculated using the apparent dissociation constant for DETC that we have recently determined using the same techniques (KCu = 13.8 fM) . The obtained binding curve for MT-3, presented in Fig. 2C, was fitted nonlinearly with the Hill equation (equation 2) and also linearly to the linear version of the Hill equation with the program “Origin 6.1” (OriginLab Corporation, USA).(2)
The nonlinear fitting presented in Fig. 2C yielded KCu values of 0.47±0.01 fM and n values of 1.25±0.06 and n = 1.34 was obtained in linear fitting mode. KCu is equal to the concentration of free Cu(I) ions at half saturation of MT-3 with Cu(I) ions, reflecting the apparent average affinity of MT-3 towards Cu(I) ions, which is similar to that for MT-2 KCu values of 0.41±0.02 fM . A Hill coefficient close to 1 indicates that there exists only weak apparent positive cooperativity in the binding of Cu(I) ions to MT-3, whereas strong positive cooperativity (n = 3.3) exists in case of MT-2, which is demetallated in very narrow range of free Cu(I) ions . As seen from Fig. 2B there are two metal-thiolate clusters in Cu12MT-3, both composed from 6 Cu(I) ions. The first hexacopper-thiolate cluster dissociates readily in the presence of 0.5 mM DETC, whereas DETC can not dissociate copper from Cu10MT-2 even at 1 mM concentration . The second hexacopper-thiolate cluster of MT-3 is half desaturated at 3 mM DETC, which is similar to the behaviour of hexacopper-thiolate cluster in MT-2 .
Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) metal content analysis
In some cases, the Aβ aggregation pellet and supernatant fractions were collected post-ultracentrifugation and their metal content determined by Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS). Prior to analysis samples were further diluted 10× with ultra-pure water (>18 MOhm) with nitric acid and Indium (as an internal standard) addition to final concentrations 1% and 100 ppb, respectively. Analysis was undertaken using an ELEMENT High Resolution ICP-MS operating in medium resolution mode, enabling 63Cu and 66Zn isotopes to be monitored free from overlapping spectral interferences. Both elements were quantified using external calibration methodology, with blank subtraction. Typical analytical protocols have been presented previously .
Rodent cortical neural cell cultures
All animal procedures were performed in accordance with the animal ethics guidelines of the University of Tasmania Animal Ethics Committee. Neural cultures were prepared as reported previously , and briefly involved the removal of cortices from embryonic day 17 Hooded Wistar embryos, which were incubated with 0.1% trypsin in HEPES buffer at 37°C for 20 minutes. After three washes with warmed HEPES, the tissue was triturated and plated at 5×104 cells per coverslip onto 13mm2 glass coverslips in Neurobasal medium (Gibco) and maintained at 37°C in humidified air containing 5% CO2.
Rat cortical neuron toxicity assay
To induce cortical neuron toxicity, 40µM soluble Aβ1–40 was applied to neurons in the presence of 40µM CuCl2 and 300µM ascorbate. Under these specific conditions, it has been demonstrated that all free copper is rapidly bound by Aβ1–40 . The presence of physiological levels of ascorbate permits cycling between copper (II) and (I) oxidation states, as occurs within cellular environments allowing copper to bind to proteins in either Cu(I) or Cu(II) oxidation states. After 24 hours, neuronal viability was measured by the degree of cellular metabolic reduction of alamarBlue®, determined by fluorescence (excitation 535nm, emission 595nm), and was expressed as the percentage of the signal obtained from the vehicle-treated culture. Aβ1–40 was used in this study because there is a wider differential in the relative toxicity of copper vs zinc forms of Aβ1–40 compared to Aβ1–42 (ie: only Cu-Aβ1–40 and not Zn-Aβ1–40 is neurotoxic, while both Cu- and Zn-Aβ1–42 are neurotoxic). Using Aβ1–40 thus maximises the effect of the hypothesised metal swap between ZnMT-2A and Cu-Aβ1–40, and removes the additional but complicating possibility that metallothionein can independently protect against Zn-Aβ1–42 toxicity.
Statistical analyses of tissue culture experiments
For each experiment unless otherwise stated, a minimum of four wells from at least three separate cultures (derived from different animals), were used for quantification, blinded to conditions. Statistical analysis was completed using SPSS 16.0 (SPSS). When data was unequally distributed, data was transformed so that the residuals were approximately normally distributed. Statistical significance was calculated using One-Way and Two-Way ANOVA with Tukey's Post Hoc Test. All graphical data is presented as mean ± SEM, significance p<0.05.
Ion-selective flux measurements
The theory of non-invasive microelectrode ion flux (MIFE) measurements was reviewed recently  and the complete experimental procedure including ion-selective microelectrode fabrication and cell preparation and immobilisation are given elsewhere , . Cortical neurons for the MIFE measurements were grown for three days at a 1×105 cells/well on poly-L-lysine cover slips as described above. By day three a dense monolayer of neurons had developed. Cells were washed in and adapted to the MIFE artificial CSF (aCSF) for one hour prior to experiments. The composition of the aCSF was: 150mM NaCl, 0.5mM KCl, 0.5mM CaCl2, 1.5mM MgCl2, 1.25mM NaH2PO4, 5mM NaHCO3, 25mM glucose, pH 7.2. Data was acquired at a rate of 15 samples/sec and later averaged over 10 second intervals. Each experiment was repeated upon at least four different coverslips from three different neuronal cultures.
Direct cell counting revealed that treatment of 3DIV rat cortical neuron cultures with 40µM Cu(II)Aβ1–40 resulted in significant neuronal death, which could be blocked by the co-addition of 20µM of Zn7MT-2A. Error bars represent standard error of the mean calculated from at least three different experiments. * - p<0.05 (One-Way ANOVA).
(3.21 MB TIF)
We thank Bestenbalt, LLC, for providing metallothionein protein for this project. We thank Dr. Russell Thompson for his help with statistical analyses, and Dr. Ashley Townsend for his assistance with the ICP-MS.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RC CH EDE LS PP WRB JCV AW. Performed the experiments: RC CH EDE LS KZ PP AW SR. Analyzed the data: RC CH EDE LS KZ PP RS AW SR. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: RC RS. Wrote the paper: RC CH PP JCV AW.
- 1. Blennow K, de Leon MJ, Zetterberg H (2006) Alzheimer's disease. Lancet 368: 387–403.
- 2. Selkoe DJ, Podlisny MB (2002) Deciphering the genetic basis of Alzheimer's disease. Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics 3: 67–99.
- 3. Glenner GG, Wong CW (1984) Alzheimers-Disease - Initial Report of the Purification and Characterization of a Novel Cerebrovascular Amyloid Protein. Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 120: 885–890.
- 4. Mattson MP (2004) Pathways towards and away from Alzheimer's disease. Nature 430: 631–639.
- 5. Haass C, Schlossmacher MG, Hung AY, Vigo-Pelfrey C, Mellon A, et al. (1992) Amyloid Beta-Peptide Is Produced by Cultured-Cells During Normal Metabolism. Nature 359: 322–325.
- 6. Seubert P, Vigo-Pelfrey C, Esch F, Lee M, Dovey H, et al. (1992) Isolation and Quantification of Soluble Alzheimers Beta-Peptide from Biological-Fluids. Nature 359: 325–327.
- 7. Busciglio J, Gabuzda DH, Matsudaira P, Yankner BA (1993) Generation of Beta-Amyloid in the Secretory Pathway in Neuronal and Nonneuronal Cells. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 90: 2092–2096.
- 8. Mesulam NM (1999) Neuroplasticity failure in Alzheimer's disease: Bridging the gap between plaques and tangles. Neuron 24: 521–529.
- 9. Bush AI, Pettingell WH, Multhaup G, d Paradis M, Vonsattel JP, et al. (1994) Rapid induction of Alzheimer A beta amyloid formation by zinc. Science 265(5177): 1464–1467.
- 10. Huang XD, Cuajungco MP, Atwood CS, Hartshorn MA, Tyndall JD, et al. (1999b) Cu(II) potentiation of Alzheimer A beta neurotoxicity. Correlation with cell-free hydrogen peroxide production and metal reduction. Journal of Biological Chemistry 274: 37111–37116.
- 11. Adlard PA, Bush AI (2006) Metals and Alzheimer's disease. J Alzheimers Dis 10(2–3): 145–163.
- 12. Cuajungco MP, Goldstein LE, Nunomura A, Smith MA, Lim JT, et al. (2000) Evidence that the beta-amyloid plaques of Alzheimer's disease represent the redox-silencing and entombment of A beta by zinc. Journal of Biological Chemistry 275: 19439–19442.
- 13. Penkowa M, Carrasco J, Giralt M, Moos T, Hidalgo J (1999) CNS wound healing is severely depressed in metallothionein I- and II-deficient mice. J Neurosci 19(7): 2535–2545.
- 14. Chung RS, Vickers JC, Chuah MI, West AK (2003) Metallothionein-IIA promotes initial neurite elongation and postinjury reactive neurite growth and facilitates healing after focal cortical brain injury. Journal of Neuroscience 23: 3336–3342.
- 15. Chung RS, Penkowa M, Dittmann J, King CE, Bartlett C, et al. (2008) Redefining the Role of Metallothionein within the Injured Brain. Journal of Biological Chemistry 283: 15349–15358.
- 16. Kägi JH, Kojima Y (1987) Chemistry and biochemistry of metallothionein. Experientia Suppl 52: 25–61.
- 17. Coyle P, Philcox JC, Carey LC, Rofe AM (2002) Metallothionein: the multipurpose protein. Cell Mol Life Sci 59: 627–647.
- 18. Kelly EJ, Palmiter RD (1996) A murine model of Menkes disease reveals a physiological function of metallothionein. Nat Genet 13: 219–222.
- 19. Adlard PA, West AK, Vickers JC (1998) Increased density of metallothionein I/II-immunopositive cortical glial cells in the early stages of Alzheimer's disease. Neurobiology of Disease 5: 349–356.
- 20. Richarz AN, Brätter P (2002) Speciation analysis of trace elements in the brains of individuals with Alzheimer's disease with special emphasis on metallothioneins. Anal Bioanal Chem 372(3): 412–417.
- 21. Zambenedetti P, Giordano R, Zatta P (1998) Metallothioneins are highly expressed in astrocytes and microcapillaries in Alzheimer's disease. J Chem Neuroanat 15(1): 21–26.
- 22. Carrasco J, Adlard P, Cotman C, Quintana A, Penkowa M, et al. (2006) Metallothionein-I and -III expression in animal models of Alzheimer disease. Neuroscience 143(4): 911–922.
- 23. Meloni G, Sonois V, Delaine T, Guilloreau L, Gillet A, et al. (2008) Metal swap between Zn-7-metallothionein-3 and amyloid-beta-Cu protects against amyloid-beta toxicity. Nature Chemical Biology 4: 366–372.
- 24. Banci L, Bertini I, Ciofi-Baffoni S, Kozyreva T, Zovo K, et al. (2010) Affinity gradients drive copper to cellular destinations. Nature 465(7298): 645–648.
- 25. Cardoso SM, Rego AC, Pereira C, Oliveira CR (2005) Protective effect of zinc on amyloid-beta 25–35 and 1–40 mediated toxicity. Neurotox Res 7(4): 273–281.
- 26. Uchida Y, Takio K, Titani K, Ihara Y, Tomonaga M (1991) The growth inhibitory factor that is deficient in the Alzheimer's disease brain is a 68 amino acid metallothionein-like protein. Neuron 7(2): 337–347.
- 27. Chung RS, Vickers JC, Chuah MI, Eckhardt BL, West AK (2002) Metallothionein-III inhibits initial neurite formation in developing neurons as well as postinjury, regenerative neurite sprouting. Experimental Neurology 178: 1–12.
- 28. Huang X, Atwood CS, Hartshorn MA, Multhaup G, Goldstein LE, et al. (1999) The A beta peptide of Alzheimer's disease directly produces hydrogen peroxide through metal ion reduction. Biochemistry 38(24): 7609–7616.
- 29. Chung RS, Adlard PA, Dittmann J, Vickers JC, Chuah MI, West AK (2004) Neuron-glia communication: metallothionein expression is specifically up-regulated by astrocytes in response to neuronal injury. Journal of Neurochemistry 88: 454–461.
- 30. Trendelenburg G, Prass K, Priller J, Kapinya K, et al. Serial analysis of gene expression identifies metallothionein-II as major neuroprotective gene in mouse focal cerebral ischemia. J Neurosci 22(14): 5879–5888.
- 31. Ambjørn M, Asmussen JW, Lindstam M, Gotfryd K, Jacobsen C, et al. (2008) Metallothionein and a peptide modeled after metallothionein, EmtinB, induce neuronal differentiation and survival through binding to receptors of the low-density lipoprotein receptor family. J Neurochem 104(1): 21–37.
- 32. Fitzgerald M, Nairn P, Bartlett CA, Chung RS, West AK, et al. (2007) Metallothionein-IIA promotes neurite growth via the megalin receptor. Exp Brain Res 183: 171–180.
- 33. Hidalgo J, Aschner M, Zatta P, Vasák M (2001) Roles of the metallothionein family of proteins in the central nervous system. Brain Res Bull 55(2): 133–45.
- 34. Syme CD, Nadal RC, Rigby SE, Viles JH (2004) Copper binding to the amyloid-beta (Abeta) peptide associated with Alzheimer's disease: folding, coordination geometry, pH dependence, stoichiometry, and affinity of Abeta-(1–28): insights from a range of complementary spectroscopic techniques. J Biol Chem 279(18): 18169–18177.
- 35. Guilloreau L, Damian L, Coppel Y, Mazarguil H, Winterhalter M, et al. (2006) Structural and thermodynamical properties of CuII amyloid-beta16/28 complexes associated with Alzheimer's disease. J Biol Inorg Chem 11(8): 1024–1038.
- 36. Hamer DH (1986) Metallothionein. Annu Rev Biochem 55: 913–5135.
- 37. Wake H, Watanabe M, Moorhouse AJ, Kanematsu T, Horibe S, et al. (2007) Early changes in KCC2 phosphorylation in response to neuronal stress result in functional downregulation. J Neurosci 27(7): 1642–1650.
- 38. Pouokam E, Rehn M, Diener M (2009) Effects of H2O2 at rat myenteric neurones in culture. Eur J Pharmacol 615(1–3): 40–49.
- 39. Erickson JC, Sewell AK, Jensen LT, Winge DR, Palmiter RD (1994) Enhanced neurotrophic activity in Alzheimer's disease cortex is not associated with down-regulation of metallothionein-III (GIF). Brain Res 649: 297–304.
- 40. Gaeta A, Hider RC (2005) The crucial role of metal ions in neurodegeneration: the basis for a promising therapeutic strategy. Br J Pharmacol 146(8): 1041–59.
- 41. Hegde ML, Bharathi P, Suram A, Venugopal C, Jagannathan R, et al. (2009) Challenges associated with metal chelation therapy in Alzheimer's disease. J Alzheimers Dis 17(3): 457–468.
- 42. Cherny RA, Atwood CS, Xilinas ME, Gray DN, Jones WD, et al. (2001) Treatment with a copper-zinc chelator markedly and rapidly inhibits beta-amyloid accumulation in Alzheimer's disease transgenic mice. Neuron 30(3): 665–676.
- 43. Eriste E, Kruusel K, Palumaa P, Jörnvall H, Sillard R (2003) Purification of recombinant human apometallothionein-3 and reconstitution with zinc. Protein Expr Purif 31: 161–165.
- 44. Townsend AT (2000) Enhanced sensitivity for Os isotope ratios by magnetic sector ICP-MS with a capacitive decoupling Pt guard electrode. Fresenius J Anal Chem 367: 614–620.
- 45. Chung RS, McCormack GH, King AE, West AK, Vickers JC (2005) Glutamate induces rapid loss of axonal neurofilament proteins from cortical neurons in vitro. Exp Neurol 193: 481–488.
- 46. Shabala L, Ross T, McMeekin T, Shabala S (2006a) Non-invasive microelectrode ion flux measurements to study adaptive responses of microorganisms to the environment. FEMS Microbiol Rev 30: 472–486.
- 47. Shabala L, Ross T, Newman I, McMeekin T, Shabala S (2001) Measurements of net fluxes and extracellular changes of H+, Ca2+, K+, and NH4+ in Escherichia coli using ion -selective microelectrodes. J Microbiol Methods 46: 119–129.