Reduced N-acetyl-aspartate (NAA) levels in magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) may visualize axonal damage even in the normal appearing white matter (NAWM). Demyelination and axonal degeneration are a hallmark in multiple sclerosis (MS).
To define the extent of axonal degeneration in the NAWM in the remote from focal lesions in patients with relapsing-remitting (RRMS) and secondary progressive MS (SPMS).
Material and Methods
37 patients with clinical definite MS (27 with RRMS, 10 with SPMS) and 8 controls were included. We used 2D 1H-MR-chemical shift imaging (TR = 1500ms, TE = 135ms, nominal resolution 1ccm) operating at 3Tesla to assess the metabolic pattern in the fronto–parietal NAWM. Ratios of NAA to creatine (Cr) and choline (Cho) and absolute concentrations of the metabolites in the NAWM were measured in each voxel matching exclusively white matter on the anatomical T2 weighted MR images.
No significant difference of absolute concentrations for NAA, Cr and Cho or metabolite ratios were found between RRMS and controls. In SPMS, the NAA/Cr ratio and absolute concentrations for NAA and Cr were significantly reduced compared to RRMS and to controls.
Citation: Aboul-Enein F, Krššák M, Höftberger R, Prayer D, Kristoferitsch W (2010) Reduced NAA-Levels in the NAWM of Patients with MS Is a Feature of Progression. A Study with Quantitative Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy at 3 Tesla. PLoS ONE5(7): e11625. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0011625
Editor: Juri G. Gelovani, University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, United States of America
Received: April 15, 2010; Accepted: June 1, 2010; Published: July 20, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Aboul-Enein et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was funded by the Multiple Sklerose Forschungsgesellschaft Wien (www.ms-ges.or.at) and by the Medical Research Society Vienna, DC (www.mfg22.at). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
MS is a chronic inflammatory disease of the central nervous system (CNS) of unknown origin causing demyelination and axonal degeneration . The immune reaction in MS patients is heterogeneous and compartmentalized within the CNS. It may be triggered temporarily or may take a continuous course –.
The diagnosis of clinical definite MS is established by typical clinical symptoms, a relapsing remitting course and paraclinical findings in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) –. Other disorders which may mimic MS must be ruled out.
In most cases MS follows a relapsing-remitting course (RRMS) with clearly defined relapses and no progression during clinical remissions . It is unclear why MS sometimes follows a benign RRMS course while in other cases converting into a progressive-relapsing course, with or without superposed relapses (SPMS). It is further unknown, why MRI lesion load does not consistently correlate to clinical disability –. Supposedly even in very early stages of RRMS a “clinical silent” focal or diffuse “background inflammation” not detectable in conventional MRI may progress and cause diffuse axonal damage. This subtle axonal degeneration may be visualized by magnetic resonance spectroscopy (1H-MRS) as reduction of N-acetyl-aspartate (NAA) levels –. These results are, however, controversially discussed, due to new insights from the recently improved 1H-MRS technique. Higher field strengths (3 Tesla) and chemical shift imaging have substantially increased the validity of 1H-MRS. To our knowledge, so far only one study using multivoxel 1H-MR 2D spectroscopic imaging (MRSI) operating at 3 Tesla was published . In this study, Kirov et al. found no reduction of NAA levels in 21 mildly disabled RRMS patients (mean expanded disability status scale (EDSS) of 1.4., mean disease duration of 2.3 years) compared to 15 matched controls.
The aim of our study was to define the axonal changes in the normal appearing white matter (NAWM) of SPMS and secondly, to reassess whether or not reduced NAA levels could be found in the NAWM of RRMS with improved MRSI operating at 3 Tesla.
Materials and Methods
The study was approved by the local Ethics Committee (Commission of Medical Ethics of Vienna; Ethic Approval/Registration Number: EK 06-169-VK). Informed written consent was obtained from all patients and volunteers.
In total, 37 patients with clinically definite MS and characteristic MRI and CSF findings were included . All patients showed oligoclonal bands. Twenty-seven patients followed a relapsing-remitting course with well defined relapses and lack of clinical progression between relapses. The RRMS patients were compared to 10 SPMS patients and 8 healthy controls (mean age, 46.3 years±6.3 [range, 17.0 to 65.0], female∶male = 7∶1). A complete survey of clinical data is given in table 1.
MRI and MRS
We used the same standardized protocol for 1H-MR 2D Spectroscopic Imaging (MRSI) as described in detail previously .
MRSI at magnetic field strength of 3 Tesla (TimTrio equipped with standard head 8 channel receive coil, Siemens Healthcare, Erlangen, Germany) was applied to assess the metabolic pattern in the NAWM. MRSI measurements were performed parallel to axial T1- and T2-weighted slices. Routine automatic adjustments were applied prior to data acquisition. PRESS sequence was used for rectangular VOI selection (8×8×1 cm) in the fronto-parietal white matter well above lateral ventricles. Special care was taken to avoid skull and subcutaneous tissue contamination. CHESS sequence was used for water suppression. Sequence parameters included TR/TE 1500/135 ms, 16×16 elliptical weighted phase encoding steps across a 16×16 cm FOV, slice thickness of 1cm, 50% Hanning filter and 3 averages. To obtain intern quantification reference additional scan with the same timing and geometrical parameters was taken without water suppression. The acquisition time of spectroscopic sequences was less than 15 minutes.
Quantification of the spectra was performed off-line in the time domain using jMRUI software package . Signals from voxels (8–12 voxels per RRMS patients and healthy controls, 3–8 voxels in SPMS patients) matching exclusively frontal and fronto-parietal white matter without any signs of lesion load on conventional T2 weighted images were selected. For the processing of metabolite spectra, remaining water signal was removed using HLSVD filter and amplitudes of Cho, Cr and NAA signals were calculated with AMARES –. Amplitude of water signal for each processed voxel was assessed from the scan without water suppression.
Concentrations of metabolites are given as ratios of signal intensities of NAA to Cr, NAA to Cho, and Cho to Cr respectively. Additionally, absolute concentrations of Cho, Cr and NAA were calculated using water signal from the identical voxel as internal reference. Mono exponential spin-lattice and spin-spin relaxation was assumed and published values of T1 (water: 832 ms; Cho: 1080 ms; Cr: 1240 ms; NAA: 1350 ms) and T2 (water: 110 ms; Cho: 187 ms; Cr: 156 ms; NAA: 295 ms) relaxation times of water and respective metabolites measured at 3T in NAWM of healthy volunteers were used for relaxation corrections –. The concentrations were calculated according to Kreis et al. as follows :where C stands for concentration, S for signal intensity, n for the number of chemically equivalent protons, fT1 for spin-lattice relaxation function (1-eTR/T1), fT2 for spin-spin relaxation function (e−TE/T2) and the indexes m for metabolite and w for water. Cw was for white matter was chosen 35880 mmol/l according to Ernst et al. .
Metabolic ratios and absolute concentrations obtained from individual voxels in NAWM were averaged for every patient. Intra-patient coefficient of variation averaged at 10% for Cho; 12% for Cr and 11% for NAA. Data are given as means for patient group. For statistical analysis nonparametric tests (Mann-Whitney, Kolmogorov-Smirnov) were applied (Statgraphics plus ©). All tests were classified as significant if the p-value was <0.05.
We studied 27 RRMS (mean disease duration, 5.6 years), 10 SPMS (mean disease duration, 12.7 years), and 8 healthy controls. Concentrations of metabolites were quantified in relation to each other as well as with respect to the concentration of internal tissue water of well defined regions of NAWM, and compared to recently published data .
Examples of MR spectra of RRMS, SPMS and healthy controls are given in figure 1. Relative standard deviation of spectral fitting for all included spectra was ≤5%. All MRS data of the NAWM are presented in detail in figure 2 (ratios of metabolites, relative concentrations) and in figure 3 (absolute metabolic concentrations). Our results may be summarized briefly as follows.
Left column, anatomical T2w MR Images with the depiction of MRSI PRESS box volume of interest (grey, 8×8 cm) and voxels (white) in the NAWM chosen for the spectroscopic data evaluation. Right column, representative MR spectra from a single voxel with original spectra (lower trace), AMARES estimate (second trace), individual components (third trace) and fit residue (upper trace). Data from RRMS (upper part) and SSPMS (middle part) patients as well as healthy controls (CON, lower part) are presented.
white, NAA/Cr ratio; grey, NAA/Cho ratios; black, Cho/Cr ratios; squares, RRMS patients (n = 27); circles, SPMS patients (n = 10); triangles, controls (n = 8); bars, means.
white, NAA [mM]; grey, Cr [mM]; black, Cho [mM]. squares, RRMS patients (n = 27); circles, SPMS patients (n = 10); triangles, controls (n = 8); bars, means.
1. Metabolite ratios, NAA/Cr, NAA/Cho and Cho/Cr
We found significant differences of metabolite ratios of RRMS (n = 27) compared to SPMS (n = 10) (NAA/Cr, p<0.0003; NAA/Cho, p<0.001), and between SPMS and controls (n = 8) (NAA/Cr, p<0.001; NAA/Cho, p<0.008).
No significant differences could be detected in all other comparisons (RRMS vs. controls, NAA/Cr, NAA/Cho and Cho/Cr and SPMS vs. controls, Cho/Cr) (figure 2).
2. Absolute metabolite concentrations [mM], NAA, Cr and Cho
NAA (figure 3, white symbols).
No significant difference of absolute NAA concentrations was found between RRMS (n = 27; NAA [mM] mean = 12.4±0.5; range 10.1 to 14.7) and controls (n = 8; NAA [mM] mean = 12.3±0.4; range 10.1 to 13.6). In SPMS NAA-levels (n = 10; NAA [mM] mean = 8.6±0.7; range 4.9 to 11.1) were significantly reduced compared to RRMS (n = 27; p<0.00001) and to controls (n = 8; p<0.001).
Cr (figure 3, grey symbols).
Absolute concentrations of Cr were found significantly reduced in SPMS (n = 10; Cr [mM] mean = 7.4±0.4; range 4.7 to 8.8) compared to RRMS (n = 27; Cr [mM] mean = 8.8±0.2; range 7.2 to 10.2) (p<0.0008). No significant differences were found between SPMS and controls (n = 8; Cr [mM] mean = 8.4±0.4; range 7.0 to 10.2), and between RRMS patients and controls.
Cho (figure 3, black symbols).
Absolute concentrations of Cho differed slightly between RRMS (n = 27; Cho [mM] mean = 2.6±0.1; range 2.1 to 3.3) and SPMS (n = 10; Cho [mM] mean = 2.2±0.1; range 1.5 to 2.8) (p<0.2). No differences of Cho concentrations were found between RRMS and controls (Cho [mM] mean = 2.5±0.1; range 2.1 to 3.2), and SPMS and controls.
Relation of absolute metabolite concentrations and EDSS.
We found only a weak, but significant correlation between reduced NAA levels and higher EDSS (linear regression: correlation coefficient −0.48, R2 = 23.4, standard error for the estimate = 1.9, ANOVA table p<0.002). No correlations were found between Cr or Cho concentrations and EDSS.
In summary, we found a significant reduction of NAA/Cr and NAA/Cho ratios and of absolute concentrations of NAA and Cr in SPMS patients only. Between RRMS and controls, ratios and absolute concentrations for the examined metabolites did not show significant differences.
In our study we analyzed NAA, Cr and Cho levels of the NAWM of 37 MS patients and controls with multivoxel 1H-MRSI operating at 3 Tesla. Our results for 27 RRMS patients and 8 controls are in accordance with recently published data of 21 RRMS and 15 controls . In addition we found significant changes in the NAWM of 10 SPMS.
1H-MRS allows an assessment of subtle metabolic changes within the NAWM , . NAA is almost exclusively found in active mitochondria of neurons and axons and is thus a marker of axonal function and integrity . Reduced levels of NAA are suggestive for axonal degeneration or axonal loss, or both . They may correlate to histopathological changes and proposed histotoxic mechanisms in MS , . Whether reduced NAA levels in MS patients reflect microscopic axonal changes due to primary tissue damage, or due to axonal transection in remote demyelinating lesions remains unclear . While some studies found decreased NAA levels in the NAWM of MS patients –, others did not , , . These divergent results may be explained by the very small and heterogeneous patient cohorts (e.g. 2 RRMS and 12 SPMS aged from 28 to 61 years, and 4 controls aged 33 to 48 years in van Walderveen et al., 1999 ), by the use of a 1.5 Tesla 1H-MRS and by the measurement of metabolite ratios instead of absolute metabolite concentrations –.
The signal-to-noise ratio and spectral resolution are markedly reduced in magnetic field strengths lower than 3 Tesla. This suggests the use of 1H-MRS operating at 3 Tesla instead of 1.5 Tesla , –. Furthermore only the improved MRSI allows for a robust quantification of the respective signals simultaneously in large brain regions , –.
Metabolite ratios are less sensitive than absolute concentrations of individual metabolites , . The quantification of the metabolite concentration is usually based on the metabolite signal ratio to Cr which is regarded as “internal reference” for metabolite ratios –. But the concentration of Cr may vary in different pathological conditions and at different age , –. The Cr peak is composed of creatine and phosphocreatine. Cr occurs mainly in glial cells, and is considered as a marker of cell energy metabolism and mitochondrial function . Increased Cr levels may indicate glial cell proliferation or higher glial cell metabolism and tissue repair mechanisms . NAA levels might be normal, because neuronal cell bodies remote from the focal or diffuse white matter lesions may be unaffected and may maintain the axonal transport of mitochondria to their distal ends. Markedly reduced Cr levels might reflect the complete collapse of glial cell metabolism preceding axonal changes, significant reduction of glial cells, or tissue scar formation.
Lower NAA/Cr ratios must therefore not per se be interpreted as axonal dysfunction or loss, if absolute NAA levels remain unchanged but Cr levels are increased , –. Vrenken et al., for example, found significantly reduced NAA/Cr ratios in the NAWM of 76 MS patients (RRMS, SPMS and PPMS), while absolute concentrations for NAA were not reduced but Cr was increased . They concluded that increased glial cell numbers, and not axonal loss or dysfunction might be a common feature in the NAWM of MS patients .
In conclusion, we want to emphasize that the normal NAA levels found in our RRMS patients do not necessarily indicate normal NAWM. Tissue changes in MS patients are heterogeneous and too complex to be detected by measuring only few metabolites . Spectral appearance and spin-spin relaxation properties of further metabolites that might be changing in the NAWM (e.g. glutamate, glutamine, myo-Inositol and lipids) favour the measurements with shorter echo time, whereas flatter spectral baseline at longer echo times increases the precision of the NAA, Cr and Cho measurements.
MRSI was useful for demonstrating changes in the NAWM of SPMS in our and in other studies clearly , . But there is still an ongoing discussion, whether MRSI is sensitive to detect also subtle axonal changes in the NAWM of benign or stable RRMS patients. However, reduced NAA levels in RRMS without signs of progression might be a strong indicator for clinically still undetectable progressive axonal degeneration. This could identify patients with progressive RRMS at a very early stage prior to clinical deterioration –. MRS therefore may provide crucial information for treatment decision, as lesion load does not necessarily correlate with disease activity and progression , , , .
For MR Spectroscopy analysis MRUI software was used (http://www.mrui.uab.es./mrui). MRUI development and improvement was secured thanks to the European Union project HCM-CHRX-CT94-0432 (1994–1997) and TMR/Networks ERB -FMRX -CT970160 (1998–2001).17
Conceived and designed the experiments: FAE MK DP WK. Performed the experiments: FAE MK DP. Analyzed the data: FAE MK DP WK. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: FAE MK RH. Wrote the paper: FAE MK WK.
- 1. Compston A, Coles A (2002) Multiple sclerosis. Lancet 359: 1221–1231.A. CompstonA. Coles2002Multiple sclerosis.Lancet35912211231
- 2. Aboul-Enein F, Rauschka H, Kornek B, Stadelmann C, Stefferl A, et al. (2003) Preferential loss of myelin-associated glycoprotein reflects hypoxia-like white matter damage in stroke and inflammatory brain diseases. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 62: 25–33.F. Aboul-EneinH. RauschkaB. KornekC. StadelmannA. Stefferl2003Preferential loss of myelin-associated glycoprotein reflects hypoxia-like white matter damage in stroke and inflammatory brain diseases.J Neuropathol Exp Neurol622533
- 3. Confavreux C, Alastair Compston (1996) The natural history of multiple sclerosis. In: Alastair Compston, editor. Mc Alpine's Multiple Sclerosis, 4th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Churchill Livingstone Elsevier. pp. 183–269.C. ConfavreuxCompston Alastair1996The natural history of multiple sclerosis.Compston AlastairMc Alpine's Multiple Sclerosis, 4th edPhiladelphia, PAChurchill Livingstone Elsevier183269
- 4. Lassmann H, Brück W, Lucchinetti CF (2007) The immunopathology of multiple sclerosis: an overview. Brain Pathol 17: 210–218.H. LassmannW. BrückCF Lucchinetti2007The immunopathology of multiple sclerosis: an overview.Brain Pathol17210218
- 5. Tintoré M, Rovira A, Martínez MJ, Rio J, Díaz-Villoslada P, et al. (2000) Isolated demyelinating syndromes: comparison of different MR imaging criteria to predict conversion to clinically definite multiple sclerosis. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 21: 702–706.M. TintoréA. RoviraMJ MartínezJ. RioP. Díaz-Villoslada2000Isolated demyelinating syndromes: comparison of different MR imaging criteria to predict conversion to clinically definite multiple sclerosis.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol21702706
- 6. Polman CH, Reingold SC, Edan G, Filippi M, Hartung HP, et al. (2005) Diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis: 2005 revisions to the “McDonald Criteria”. Ann Neurol 58: 840–846.CH PolmanSC ReingoldG. EdanM. FilippiHP Hartung2005Diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis: 2005 revisions to the “McDonald Criteria”.Ann Neurol58840846
- 7. Miller DH, Weinshenker BG, Filippi M, Banwell BL, Cohen JA, et al. (2008) Differential diagnosis of suspected multiple sclerosis: a consensus approach. Mult Scler 14: 1157–1174.DH MillerBG WeinshenkerM. FilippiBL BanwellJA Cohen2008Differential diagnosis of suspected multiple sclerosis: a consensus approach.Mult Scler1411571174
- 8. Li DK, Held U, Petkau J, Daumer M, Barkhof F, et al. (2006) MRI T2 lesion burden in multiple sclerosis: a plateauing relationship with clinical disability. Neurology 66: 1384–1389.DK LiU. HeldJ. PetkauM. DaumerF. Barkhof2006MRI T2 lesion burden in multiple sclerosis: a plateauing relationship with clinical disability.Neurology6613841389
- 9. Chard DT, Griffin CM, McLean MA, Kapeller P, Kapoor R, et al. (2002) Brain metabolite changes in cortical grey and normal-appearing white matter in clinically early relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. Brain 125: 2342–2352.DT ChardCM GriffinMA McLeanP. KapellerR. Kapoor2002Brain metabolite changes in cortical grey and normal-appearing white matter in clinically early relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis.Brain12523422352
- 10. De Stefano N, Narayanan S, Matthews PM, Francis GS, Antel JP, et al. (1999) In vivo evidence for axonal dysfunction remote from focal cerebral demyelination of the type seen in multiple sclerosis. Brain 122: 1933–39.N. De StefanoS. NarayananPM MatthewsGS FrancisJP Antel1999In vivo evidence for axonal dysfunction remote from focal cerebral demyelination of the type seen in multiple sclerosis.Brain122193339
- 11. De Stefano N, Filippi M, Miller D, Pouwels PJ, Rovira A, et al. (2007) Guidelines for using proton MR spectroscopy in multicenter clinical MS studies. Neurology 69: 1942–1952.N. De StefanoM. FilippiD. MillerPJ PouwelsA. Rovira2007Guidelines for using proton MR spectroscopy in multicenter clinical MS studies.Neurology6919421952
- 12. Sarchielli P, Presciutti O, Pelliccioli GP, Tarducci R, Gobbi G, et al. (1999) Absolute quantification of brain metabolites by proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy in normal-appearing white matter of multiple sclerosis patients. Brain 122: 513–521.P. SarchielliO. PresciuttiGP PelliccioliR. TarducciG. Gobbi1999Absolute quantification of brain metabolites by proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy in normal-appearing white matter of multiple sclerosis patients.Brain122513521
- 13. Sijens PE, Mostert JP, Oudkerk M, De Keyser J (2006) (1)H MR spectroscopy of the brain in multiple sclerosis subtypes with analysis of the metabolite concentrations in gray and white matter: initial findings. Eur Radiol 16: 489–495.PE SijensJP MostertM. OudkerkJ. De Keyser2006(1)H MR spectroscopy of the brain in multiple sclerosis subtypes with analysis of the metabolite concentrations in gray and white matter: initial findings.Eur Radiol16489495
- 14. Wattjes MP, Harzheim M, Lutterbey GG, Klotz L, Schild HH, et al. (2007) Axonal damage but no increased glial cell activity in the normal-appearing white matter of patients with clinically isolated syndromes suggestive of multiple sclerosis using high-field magnetic resonance spectroscopy. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 28: 1517–1522.MP WattjesM. HarzheimGG LutterbeyL. KlotzHH Schild2007Axonal damage but no increased glial cell activity in the normal-appearing white matter of patients with clinically isolated syndromes suggestive of multiple sclerosis using high-field magnetic resonance spectroscopy.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol2815171522
- 15. Kirov II, Patil V, Babb JS, Rusinek H, Herbert J, et al. (2009) MR Spectroscopy Indicates Diffuse Multiple Sclerosis Activity During Remission. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 80: 1330–1336.II KirovV. PatilJS BabbH. RusinekJ. Herbert2009MR Spectroscopy Indicates Diffuse Multiple Sclerosis Activity During Remission.J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry8013301336
- 16. Aboul-Enein F, Krssák M, Höftberger R, Prayer D, Kristoferitsch W (2010) Diffuse White Matter Damage Is Absent in Neuromyelitis Optica. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 31: 76–79.F. Aboul-EneinM. KrssákR. HöftbergerD. PrayerW. Kristoferitsch2010Diffuse White Matter Damage Is Absent in Neuromyelitis Optica.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol AJNR Am J Neuroradiol317679Epub Sept. 2009. Epub Sept. 2009.
- 17. Naressi A, Couturier C, Devos JM, Janssen M, Mangeat C, et al. (2001) Java-based graphical user interface for the MRUI quantitation package. MAGMA 12: 141–152.A. NaressiC. CouturierJM DevosM. JanssenC. Mangeat2001Java-based graphical user interface for the MRUI quantitation package.MAGMA12141152
- 18. de Beer R, van den Boogaart A, van Ormondt D, Pijnappel WW, den Hollander JA, et al. (1992) Application of time-domain fitting in the quantification of in vivo 1H spectroscopic imaging data sets. NMR Biomed 5: 171–178.R. de BeerA. van den BoogaartD. van OrmondtWW PijnappelJA den Hollander1992Application of time-domain fitting in the quantification of in vivo 1H spectroscopic imaging data sets.NMR Biomed5171178
- 19. Vanhamme L, van den Boogaart A, Van Huffel S (1997) Improved method for accurate and efficient quantification of MRS data with use of prior knowledge. J Magn Reson 129: 35–43.L. VanhammeA. van den BoogaartS. Van Huffel1997Improved method for accurate and efficient quantification of MRS data with use of prior knowledge.J Magn Reson1293543
- 20. Wansapura JP, Holland SK, Dunn RS, Ball WS Jr (1999) NMR relaxation times in the human brain at 3.0 tesla. J Magn Reson Imaging 9: 531–538.JP WansapuraSK HollandRS DunnWS Ball Jr1999NMR relaxation times in the human brain at 3.0 tesla.J Magn Reson Imaging9531538
- 21. Mlynárik V, Gruber S, Moser E (2001) Proton T (1) and T (2) relaxation times of human brain metabolites at 3 Tesla. NMR Biomed 14: 325–331.V. MlynárikS. GruberE. Moser2001Proton T (1) and T (2) relaxation times of human brain metabolites at 3 Tesla.NMR Biomed14325331
- 22. Träber F, Block W, Lamerichs R, Gieseke J, Schild HH (2004) 1H metabolite relaxation times at 3.0 tesla: Measurements of T1 and T2 values in normal brain and determination of regional differences in transverse relaxation. J Magn Reson Imaging 19: 537–545.F. TräberW. BlockR. LamerichsJ. GiesekeHH Schild20041H metabolite relaxation times at 3.0 tesla: Measurements of T1 and T2 values in normal brain and determination of regional differences in transverse relaxation.J Magn Reson Imaging19537545
- 23. Bagory M, Durand-Dubief F, Ibarrola D, Confavreux C, Sappey-Marinier D (2007) “Absolute” quantification in Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy: validation of a clinical protocol in multiple sclerosis. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 1: 3458–3461.M. BagoryF. Durand-DubiefD. IbarrolaC. ConfavreuxD. Sappey-Marinier2007“Absolute” quantification in Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy: validation of a clinical protocol in multiple sclerosis.Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc134583461
- 24. Kreis R (1997) Quantitative localized 1H MR spectroscopy for clinical use. Prog Nucl Mag Res Sp 31: 155–195.R. Kreis1997Quantitative localized 1H MR spectroscopy for clinical use.Prog Nucl Mag Res Sp31155195
- 25. Ernst T, Kreis R, Ross BD (1993) Absolute quantification of water and metabolites in the human brain. I. Compartments and water. J Magn Reson B 102: 1–8.T. ErnstR. KreisBD Ross1993Absolute quantification of water and metabolites in the human brain. I. Compartments and water.J Magn Reson B10218
- 26. Bitsch A, Bruhn H, Vougioukas V, Stringaris A, Lassmann H, et al. (1999) Inflammatory CNS demyelination: histopathologic correlation with in vivo quantitative proton MR spectroscopy. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 20: 1619–1627.A. BitschH. BruhnV. VougioukasA. StringarisH. Lassmann1999Inflammatory CNS demyelination: histopathologic correlation with in vivo quantitative proton MR spectroscopy.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol2016191627
- 27. Aboul-Enein F, Lassmann H (2005) Mitochondrial damage and histotoxic hypoxia: a pathway of tissue injury in inflammatory brain disease? Acta Neuropathol 109: 49–55.F. Aboul-EneinH. Lassmann2005Mitochondrial damage and histotoxic hypoxia: a pathway of tissue injury in inflammatory brain disease?Acta Neuropathol1094955
- 28. Fu L, Matthews PM, De Stefano N, Worsley KJ, Narayanan S, et al. (1998) Imaging axonal damage of normal-appearing white matter in multiple sclerosis. Brain 121: 103–113.L. FuPM MatthewsN. De StefanoKJ WorsleyS. Narayanan1998Imaging axonal damage of normal-appearing white matter in multiple sclerosis.Brain121103113
- 29. van Walderveen MA, Barkhof F, Pouwels PJ, van Schijndel RA, Polman CH, et al. (1999) Neuronal damage in T1-hypointense multiple sclerosis lesions demonstrated in vivo using proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Ann Neurol 46: 79–87.MA van WalderveenF. BarkhofPJ PouwelsRA van SchijndelCH Polman1999Neuronal damage in T1-hypointense multiple sclerosis lesions demonstrated in vivo using proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy.Ann Neurol467987
- 30. Bellmann-Strobl J, Stiepani H, Wuerfel J, Bohner G, Paul F, et al. (2009) MR spectroscopy (MRS) and magnetisation transfer imaging (MTI), lesion load and clinical scores in early relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis: a combined cross-sectional and longitudinal study. Eur Radiol 19: 2066–2074.J. Bellmann-StroblH. StiepaniJ. WuerfelG. BohnerF. Paul2009MR spectroscopy (MRS) and magnetisation transfer imaging (MTI), lesion load and clinical scores in early relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis: a combined cross-sectional and longitudinal study.Eur Radiol1920662074
- 31. Vrenken H, Barkhof F, Uitdehaag BM, Castelijns JA, Polman CH, et al. (2005) MR spectroscopic evidence for glial increase but not for neuro-axonal damage in MS normal-appearing white matter. Magn Reson Med 53: 256–266.H. VrenkenF. BarkhofBM UitdehaagJA CastelijnsCH Polman2005MR spectroscopic evidence for glial increase but not for neuro-axonal damage in MS normal-appearing white matter.Magn Reson Med53256266
- 32. Kolind SH, Mädler B, Fischer S, Li DK, MacKay AL (2009) Myelin water imaging: Implementation and development at 3.0T and comparison to 1.5T measurements. Magn Reson Med 62: 106–115.SH KolindB. MädlerS. FischerDK LiAL MacKay2009Myelin water imaging: Implementation and development at 3.0T and comparison to 1.5T measurements.Magn Reson Med62106115
- 33. Wattjes MP, Lutterbey GG, Harzheim M, Gieseke J, Träber F, et al. (2006) Higher sensitivity in the detection of inflammatory brain lesions in patients with clinically isolated syndromes suggestive of multiple sclerosis using high field MRI: an intraindividual comparison of 1.5 T with 3.0 T. Eur Radiol 16: 2067–2073.MP WattjesGG LutterbeyM. HarzheimJ. GiesekeF. Träber2006Higher sensitivity in the detection of inflammatory brain lesions in patients with clinically isolated syndromes suggestive of multiple sclerosis using high field MRI: an intraindividual comparison of 1.5 T with 3.0 T.Eur Radiol1620672073
- 34. Leary SM, Brex PA, MacManus DG, Parker GJ, Barker GJ, et al. (2000) A (1)H magnetic resonance spectroscopy study of aging in parietal white matter: implications for trials in multiple sclerosis. Magn Reson Imaging 18: 455–459.SM LearyPA BrexDG MacManusGJ ParkerGJ Barker2000A (1)H magnetic resonance spectroscopy study of aging in parietal white matter: implications for trials in multiple sclerosis.Magn Reson Imaging18455459
- 35. Jansen JF, Backes WH, Nicolay K, Kooi ME (2006) 1H MR spectroscopy of the brain: absolute quantification of metabolites. Radiology 240: 318–332.JF JansenWH BackesK. NicolayME Kooi20061H MR spectroscopy of the brain: absolute quantification of metabolites.Radiology240318332
- 36. Brief EE, Moll R, Li DK, Mackay AL (2009) Absolute metabolite concentrations calibrated using the total water signal in brain (1)H MRS. NMR Biomed 22: 349–354.EE BriefR. MollDK LiAL Mackay2009Absolute metabolite concentrations calibrated using the total water signal in brain (1)H MRS.NMR Biomed22349354
- 37. Helms G, Stawiarz L, Kivisäkk P, Link H (2000) Regression analysis of metabolite concentrations estimated from localized proton MR spectra of active and chronic multiple sclerosis lesions. Magn Reson Med 43: 102–110.G. HelmsL. StawiarzP. KivisäkkH. Link2000Regression analysis of metabolite concentrations estimated from localized proton MR spectra of active and chronic multiple sclerosis lesions.Magn Reson Med43102110
- 38. Bonneville F, Moriarty DM, Li BS, Babb JS, Grossman RI, et al. (2002) Whole-brain N-acetylaspartate concentration: correlation with T2-weighted lesion volume and expanded disability status scale score in cases of relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 23: 371–375.F. BonnevilleDM MoriartyBS LiJS BabbRI Grossman2002Whole-brain N-acetylaspartate concentration: correlation with T2-weighted lesion volume and expanded disability status scale score in cases of relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol23371375