Telomerase is an enzyme that catalyzes the addition of nucleotides on the ends of chromosomes. Rare loss of function mutations in the gene that encodes the protein component of telomerase (TERT) have been described in patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF). Here we examine the telomere lengths and pulmonary fibrosis phenotype seen in multiple kindreds with heterozygous TERT mutations.
Methods and Findings
We have identified 134 individuals with heterozygous TERT mutations from 21 unrelated families. Available medical records, surgical lung biopsies and radiographs were evaluated retrospectively. Genomic DNA isolated from circulating leukocytes has been used to measure telomere lengths with a quantitative PCR assay. We find that telomere lengths of TERT mutation carriers decrease in an age-dependent manner and show progressive shortening with successive generations of mutation inheritance. Family members without TERT mutations have a shorter mean telomere length than normal, demonstrating epigenetic inheritance of shortened telomere lengths in the absence of an inherited TERT mutation. Pulmonary fibrosis is an age-dependent phenotype not seen in mutation carriers less than 40 years of age but found in 60% of men 60 years or older; its development is associated with environmental exposures including cigarette smoking. A radiographic CT pattern of usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP), which is consistent with a diagnosis of IPF, is seen in 74% of cases and a pathologic pattern of UIP is seen in 86% of surgical lung biopsies. Pulmonary fibrosis associated with TERT mutations is progressive and lethal with a mean survival of 3 years after diagnosis. Overall, TERT mutation carriers demonstrate reduced life expectancy, with a mean age of death of 58 and 67 years for males and females, respectively.
A subset of pulmonary fibrosis, like dyskeratosis congenita, bone marrow failure, and liver disease, represents a “telomeropathy” caused by germline mutations in telomerase and characterized by short telomere lengths. Family members within kindreds who do not inherit the TERT mutation have shorter telomere lengths than controls, demonstrating epigenetic inheritance of a shortened parental telomere length set-point.
Citation: Diaz de Leon A, Cronkhite JT, Katzenstein A-LA, Godwin JD, Raghu G, Glazer CS, et al. (2010) Telomere Lengths, Pulmonary Fibrosis and Telomerase (TERT) Mutations. PLoS ONE 5(5): e10680. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0010680
Editor: Rory Edward Morty, University of Giessen Lung Center, Germany
Received: December 28, 2009; Accepted: April 23, 2010; Published: May 19, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Diaz de Leon et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Supported by National Institutes of Health grants K23RR020632 and R01HL093096, the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation and the American Heart Association. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Telomerase is a multimeric ribonucleoprotein enzyme that catalyzes the addition of repetitive DNA sequence to telomeres, specialized structures at the ends of chromosomes. The human enzyme consists of both a functional RNA (hTR) and a reverse transcriptase protein component (hTERT), . Its action on telomeres solves the end-replication problem by counteracting the progressive shortening of the chromosome that occurs with each cell division. hTERT is highly expressed in germ cells, cells with proliferative potential and immortalized cancer cells, , .
Telomerase activity is restricted in humans. Evidence of this is seen by the progressive shortening of telomere lengths of human mononuclear leukocytes with age and several diseases of inherited telomerase dysfunction. Mutations in the genes encoding the telomerase complex were first found in patients with dyskeratosis congenita (DKC), and then in patients with bone marrow failure syndromes, pulmonary fibrosis and liver disease. While these are very different clinical diseases, a subset of each share a common pathogenesis related to short telomere lengths due to inherited germline telomerase mutations. DKC is a very rare multisystem disorder (prevalence of 1 in one million individuals) affecting children. Most DKC patients have mutations in the X-linked DKC1 gene, which encodes dyskerin; fewer patients have mutations in TERC, which encodes hTR. Case reports of rare kindreds have been described with mutations in TERT, NOP10, NHP2 and TINF2, which encode different components of the telomerase and the telomere complex. DKC is considered a syndrome of premature aging with death occurring at a median age of 16 years and a maximum of 50, usually from bone marrow failure, cancer or pulmonary disease.
Like DKC, idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) is a lethal disease; patients have a median survival of approximately 3–5 years after diagnosis. However, unlike DKC, IPF is much more common with its prevalence increasing with age to 65 cases per 100,000 for those 75 years or older . Heterozygous loss-of-function mutations in TERT have been found in up to 15% of kindreds with the familial pulmonary fibrosis,  and in 1–3% of sporadic cases, . IPF is one of the most common interstitial lung diseases (ILDs), a heterogeneous collection of lung disorders affecting mainly the supporting structures (interstitium) of the lung. A diagnosis of IPF portends a much worse prognosis than most other ILDs and predicts the lack of a therapeutic response with prednisone, which is commonly used to treat other ILDs. Within our initial reports of heterozygous TERT mutation carriers, most affected with pulmonary fibrosis were diagnosed with IPF but some had a granulomatous lung disease or pulmonary fibrosis which was not consistent with IPF. This raises the question of the actual spectrum of pulmonary phenotypes associated with TERT mutations.
Using probands initially identified with heterozygous TERT mutations and pulmonary fibrosis, we have expanded these families to identify 134 carriers of heterozygous TERT mutations, ranging in age from 5 to 88, with a mean age of 51 years. We have collected information regarding their medical history and environmental and occupational exposures. Here we show that 40% of TERT mutation carriers with a mean age of 51 years have self-reported pulmonary fibrosis, which is usually but not always clinically consistent with IPF. The relative frequencies of bone marrow dysplasias, cancer and other diseases are described for this cohort. Telomere lengths of mutation carriers in successive generations of the three largest kindreds show progressive telomere shortening. Related family members who do not inherit the TERT mutation have shorter telomeres than controls, demonstrating epigenetic inheritance of a shortened parental telomere set-point.
This study was approved by the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center Institutional Review Board. Cohorts of familial pulmonary fibrosis kindreds and sporadic cases of idiopathic interstitial pneumonias were collected as described. Each sporadic case and at least one member of each kindred with familial pulmonary fibrosis carried a diagnosis of IPF or unclassifiable interstitial pneumonia in concordance to established criteria. Written informed consent was obtained from all subjects. Each participant completed a questionnaire and self-reported their ethnicity, medical history, pulmonary symptoms, and exposures to fibrogenic medications, radiation and particulates. Medical records, open lung biopsy samples and radiographic studies were obtained when available. Genomic DNA was isolated from circulating leukocytes with an Autopure LS (Qiagen, Valencia, CA) or from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded archived tissue using the QIAmp DNA Mini Kit (Qiagen). Genomic DNA samples for the population of normal control subjects (n = 195, age 19–89 years) were obtained from a cohort of unrelated, multiethnic individuals from Dallas, Texas kindly provided by H. H. Hobbs.
CT Chest Scan Analysis
Available CT scans of the chest were obtained from different US medical centers and were independently reviewed by a chest radiologist (J.D.G.). Each scan was categorized as “typical or UIP” as defined in  with peripheral and basal reticulations, traction bronchiectasis and honeycombing. Those deemed “consistent with UIP” lacked honeycombing.
Surgical Lung Biopsy Analysis
Available lung biopsies were independently reviewed by a pulmonary pathologist (A.-L.K.).
Sequencing and Mutation Analysis
Sequencing of both TERT and TERC were performed as described.
Determination of Telomere Length
Genomic DNA was quantitated in triplicate using a ND-8000 spectrophotometer (NanoDrop Technologies; Wilmington, DE), stored at 50 ng/µl in TE (10 mM Tris, pH 8, 1 mM EDTA), diluted to 2 ng/µl in water and added as a 20 ng aliquot to the final reaction. Multiplexed quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) determination of telomere lengths were performed on a RotorGene real-time PCR system (Qiagen) as described with 0.15X SYBR Green I (Invitrogen) and the single copy Albumin gene primers at a final concentration of 500 nM. A standard curve was generated using serially diluted genomic DNA (ranging from 5 to 40 ng) pooled from 5 control individuals. Reference DNA isolated from cell line MCF7 (ATCC Cat#HTB-22), which has very short telomeres, and two control individuals were included on each run. RotorGene Q Software version 1.7.94 was used for the construction of standard curves and crossing point (Ct) values. T/S ratios were calculated as previously described. Each sample was assayed in triplicate. The final reported T/S value is the average T/S from two independent experiments. The relative T/S ratio was calculated by dividing the sample T/S value by the T/S value of the reference MCF7.
Telomerase Repeat Amplification Protocol (TRAP) Assay
Missense mutations in the TERT gene were introduced into the parental plasmid pGRN125 and TRAP assays were performed as described.
Analyses on quantitative traits were performed by fitting linear models and contingency tables were tested by using Fisher's exact test. All analyses were performed with the R software package, version 2.8.1 (www.r-project.org). The log transformed relative T/S ratio was normally distributed.
We have identified 21 different families with heterozygous coding mutations in the gene encoding the protein component of telomerase, TERT (Figure 1 and Table S1). Most of the families have been previously reported, . Eight have been identified more recently and all have been more fully expanded. From our collection of 106 unrelated kindreds with familial pulmonary fibrosis, 19 (18%) have been found with heterozygous TERT mutations. Previously, we reported that in a group of unrelated individuals with an idiopathic interstitial pneumonia and no family history of pulmonary fibrosis in a first or second-degree family member, 2 (3%) had a TERT mutation. We have also expanded these two families (S957R and R865C in Figure 1) and included them in the analysis. All of the missense mutations involve conserved residues in regions of the protein that have postulated roles in enzyme activity; none of the mutations were reported in a multiethnic panel of 528 controls or are present in the SNP database. Two of the mutations (V144M and R951W) have been found in different unrelated families. All the new mutations (R631Q, R671W, V867M, H925Q, R951W and G1063S) have not been identified previously and demonstrate reduced in vitro telomerase activity as measured by the telomere repeat amplication protocol (TRAP) assay (Figure S1). All probands have been sequenced for the entire coding exons and flanking introns of TERT and TERC. Only the families with TERT mutations have been included in this analysis.
The arrow indicates the index case. Circles represent females; squares represent males. Symbols with a slash indicate deceased subjects. Individuals with pulmonary fibrosis, blood dyscrasias and liver cirrhosis are indicated by red, green, and yellow symbols, respectively. Roman numerals indicate the generation. Numbers in parentheses indicate individuals for whom no DNA sample was available. The age at the time of consent or the age of death is indicated to the upper right of each symbol. The predicted amino acid changes that result from the TERT mutations are listed above each family. Some of the pedigrees have been modified to hide identifying features.
Direct genomic DNA sequencing for the proband's TERT mutation in the expanded families identified 134 heterozygous TERT mutation carriers with a mean age of 51 years. For some deceased individuals, archived formalin-fixed paraffin embedded tissue was obtained and directly sequenced for the mutation. Only individuals for whom the mutation was directly sequenced or could be inferred based upon the family structure have been included in our analysis. Most of the mutation carriers come from three large pedigrees (Figure 1). The self-described ethnicity of 90% of mutation carriers is white, the remainder is Hispanic.
Each subject completed a medical questionnaire including self-reporting of medical diagnoses; these were confirmed with medical records when available. Forty percent of the mutation carriers are affected with pulmonary fibrosis and almost half reported one of the following respiratory diseases: pulmonary fibrosis, obstructive sleep apnea, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, asthma or previous pneumothorax. Gastroesophageal reflux disease is reported by 26%, with gastritis and/or peptic ulcer disease found in ~8%. Eight percent of patients have elevated liver function tests and for one of these, cryptogenic liver cirrhosis was diagnosed. Osteopenia and/or osteoporosis are reported by over one-fourth of mutation carriers. Over 15% have at least one blood dyscrasia; mild anemia is more common than aplastic anemia or myelodysplastic syndrome combined. The relative frequencies of other diseases are listed in Table 1.
Telomere length of genomic DNA isolated from circulating leukocytes was determined using a modified multiplexed quantitative PCR assay. In short, this assay assesses the telomere length as a ratio of the telomere copy repeats to a single copy gene, relative to a reference sample. We have observed good correlation between this method and the standard Southern-blot method (terminal restriction fragment length analysis) for determining telomere length (Spearman's rank correlation = 0.83, P-value <2.2×10−16, Figure S2). We found that those with a TERT mutation (n = 86) have significantly shorter telomere lengths than an unrelated healthy cohort ranging in age from 19–89 years of age (P-value = 2.4×10−38, Figure 2B, 2C). Approximately 80% of TERT mutation carriers fell below the 10th percentile of the reference group; all were shorter than the 50th percentile (Figure 2B). Most of the TERT mutation carriers with pulmonary fibrosis, blood dyscrasias or liver cirrhosis were 40 years of age or older. The age-related decline in telomere lengths of the TERT mutation carriers was similar to that of the normal controls.
Mean telomere lengths as measured by a quantitative PCR assay for (A) normal subjects and (B) subjects with TERT mutations are plotted against age. (A) The telomere lengths of spouses (open symbols) and family members without TERT mutations (orange filled symbols) are shown relative to the 50th percentile (center line) and the 10th to 90th percentiles for 195 unrelated healthy individuals from 19–89 years of age (blue shaded region). (B) TERT mutation carriers without any clinical disease (open circles), with pulmonary fibrosis (red symbols), blood dyscrasias (green symbols) and liver cirrhosis (yellow symbols) are plotted against the same reference range. (C) Mean observed minus expected age-adjusted telomere length for the indicated groups. The minimum number of successive generations the TERT mutation has segregated in the kindred is indicated; G3 indicates subjects in the third successive generation with TERT mutations, i.e., the children with TERT mutations whose parents and grandparents also had a TERT mutation. G2+1 indicates subjects who do not have a telomerase mutation and are the offspring of individuals that represent the second successive generation with a TERT mutation. Bars show the mean value. (D) Mean observed minus expected age-adjusted telomere lengths for offspring of TERT mutation carriers with (+) and without (−) the mutation. Mean telomere lengths are shorter for offspring of fathers who carry a TERT mutation. P-values of 2.4×10−38 (*),1.01×10−5 (**), 0.01 (***) and linear trend test P-value of 0.04 (****).
When comparing telomere lengths between individuals, the values are age-adjusted and reported as an observed minus expected value (O-E value) (Figure 2C, 2D). There was no difference between telomere lengths of the reference population and the unrelated spouses, but we find that the mean telomere length of related family members without a TERT mutation was significantly shorter than the reference population (P-value = 1.01×10−5). For the three largest kindreds, we were able to estimate a minimal number of generations through which the TERT mutation segregated. For these three families, the mean telomere length of the TERT mutation carriers progressively shortened for each TERT-carrying generation, G3 through G5 (Figure 2C) (Linear trend test P-value = 0.04). The spread of telomere lengths of TERT mutation carriers was sufficiently broad to partially overlap the spectrum of lengths seen in the normal controls, spouses and related family members. We also studied the telomere lengths of children of TERT mutation carriers that did not inherit their grandparents' and parents' mutation (G2+1) and compared these to age-matched controls. Although not statistically significant, there was again a trend toward shorter telomere lengths of children without a TERT mutation who were born to TERT carriers corresponding to the number of successive generations the mutation segregated in the family. We investigated the telomere lengths as related by genotype and parental gender (Figure 2D). The telomere lengths of children who inherited a TERT mutation were shorter if the mutant allele was transmitted from the father rather than the mother, even after adjusting for the sex of the child (P-value = 0.01). A TERT mutation not transmitted from parent to child led to an increase in telomere length, regardless of parental gender, that did not reach the mean telomere length of controls.
Since pulmonary fibrosis is common in TERT mutation carriers, we sought to more carefully characterize the clinical interstitial lung disease phenotype (Table 2). We obtained and independently reviewed all available medical records and archived radiographic and pathologic specimens for those with a self-reported or family-reported diagnosis of pulmonary fibrosis. Only older adults were affected, with diagnoses made between 42 to 83 years of age. In general, men were more commonly affected (60%) than women (40%) and had an earlier clinical presentation, with a mean age of 54 vs. 63 years, respectively. Dyspnea and crackles were almost uniformly seen.
Pulmonary function tests and diffusion capacity measurements were available for a subset of those with pulmonary fibrosis (Table 3). All affected individuals had a decrease in the diffusion capacity, a cardinal parameter of IPF. In addition, the majority had evidence of restrictive physiology.
Over half were former or current smokers with a mean 21 pack-year cigarette smoking history. Each of the living TERT mutation carriers completed a pulmonary questionnaire that included self-reported drug, radiation, occupational or environmental exposures that have been linked to the development of pulmonary fibrosis. Over ninety-five percent of TERT mutation carriers with pulmonary fibrosis report an exposure to smoking and/or a fibrogenic environmental or occupational agent that may have contributed to the development of their interstitial lung disease. There appears to be a significant association between smoking and/or fibrogenic exposures with pulmonary fibrosis in TERT mutation carriers who are ≥40 years of age. (Table 4).
Radiographs, including CT scans of the chest, were evaluated for 39 different cases. For 29 (74%) subjects, the pattern of pulmonary fibrosis was typical for UIP, that is, there was patchy reticulation concentrated in the periphery and bases which was accompanied by honeycombing (Table 2). Honeycombing was generally mild or moderate, but occasionally severe. For 5 subjects, the pattern of fibrosis was consistent with UIP except for an absence of honeycombing. For the remaining 5 subjects, the CT scans were atypical of UIP because the fibrosis was predominantly located in the mid or upper lung fields or along the bronchi. Figure 3 shows representative CT scans typical of UIP, consistent with UIP but without honeycombing, and atypical for UIP. Enlarged mediastinal lymph nodes (exceeding 1 cm in the short axis) were found in 15 (38%) cases. Sixteen cases included expiratory scans, which detected air-trapping in 6 cases. All cases with a radiographic pattern typical or consistent with UIP had a pathologic diagnosis of UIP (n = 21; Table 5). Regardless of the specific radiographic pattern, all subjects with serial CT radiographs (n = 19) showed progression.
Computed tomography (CT) scans of three different subjects with pulmonary fibrosis. Representative cases are shown with a pattern typical of Usual Interstitial Pneumonia (UIP) with peripheral, basal-predominant fibrosis and moderate to severe honeycombing (A,B), a pattern consistent with UIP with peripheral, basal-predominant fibrosis in the absence of honeycombing (C,D), and a pattern atypical for UIP with fibrosis predominantly affecting the upper lobes and along the bronchi (E, F). Scans are shown at the level of the carina (A, C, E) and the lung base (B, D, F). The majority (25 cases or 86%) of TERT mutation carriers with lung specimens available for review had diagnostic histologic features of UIP. In this low magnification view of UIP (G), typical variegated honeycomb areas (top right) are seen alternating with normal areas (left) and scarred lung (bottom). The case shown in (H) shows increased inflammation and a small, loosely aggregated non-necrotizing granuloma (arrows) that is characterized by a cluster of epitheloid histiocytes and multinucleated giant cells surrounded by chronic inflammation in the interstitium. Panels G and H are shown at 40 and 100-fold magnification, respectively.
Lung biopsy specimens from 29 cases, including 22 surgical biopsies and 8 explants (both biopsy and explant were available for one case) were reviewed independently. The majority (25 cases or 86%) had diagnostic histologic features of UIP with a characteristic heterogeneous mixture of interstitial fibrosis containing both collagen deposition and fibroblast foci, islands of normal lung, and areas of architectural distortion with parenchymal scarring and/or honeycomb change. In 10 cases (35%) chronic inflammation, consisting of a mixture of lymphocytes and plasma cells, was increased in the scarred areas of the lung and in adjacent interstitium compared to that usually seen in typical UIP. Another unusual feature seen in 5 cases (17%) was the presence of scattered histiocytes and/or small, loose non-necrotizing granulomas within the interstitium (Table 5); these are also not usually seen in typical UIP. Areas of acute lung injury, including bronchiolitis obliterans-organizing pneumonia (BOOP) or diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) were superimposed on UIP in 4 cases, and were indicative of the accelerated form of UIP/IPF. Four cases could not be classified as UIP. The diagnosis in one could not be established because of the extent of DAD superimposed on the honeycomb change. Clinically, this subject was diagnosed with interstial pneumonitis and died less than 8 weeks from the start of her symptoms (Table 5). One case showed only BOOP along with unclassifiable subpleural fibrosis; this subject died from respiratory failure secondary to “COPD and pulmonary fibrosis” four years from diagnosis. Another case had chronic interstitial pneumonia with fibrosis that could not be further classified; this subject died 14 months after the surgical lung biopsy was obtained. A final case contained only a minute fragment of subpleural scar that was considered insufficient for diagnosis. For all four non-classifiable cases, the biopsies were taken from a single lobe.
Pulmonary fibrosis for TERT mutation carriers is an age-related phenotype. None of the mutation carriers were diagnosed with pulmonary fibrosis prior to 40 years of age. The penetrance of pulmonary fibrosis increased to 60% and 50% for men and women, respectively, ≥60 years of age (Figure 4A). Individuals heterozygous for TERT mutations died at an early age. For 29 male mutation carriers, the average age of death was 57.7. For 24 female mutation carriers, the average age of death was 66.6. In comparison, the life expectancy of individuals in the US in 2006 was 75.1 and 80.2 for men and women, respectively. For most of the TERT mutation carriers, the cause of death was related to respiratory insufficiency. On average, the mean life expectancy of TERT mutation carriers with pulmonary fibrosis was 3 years from the time of diagnosis (Figure 4B). We find that a heterozygous TERT mutation status predicted a clinical outcome of progressive pulmonary fibrosis that mirrors the clinical course of IPF.
(A) Penetrance of pulmonary fibrosis is shown for men (yellow) and women (blue bars) of different ages. No one less than 40 years of age exhibited pulmonary fibrosis. Penetrance of pulmonary fibrosis for men vs. women 40–49, 50–59 and ≥60 years of age is 14% vs. 2%, 38% vs. 14%, and 60% vs. 50%, respectively. (B) Kaplan-Meier survival curve of 47 different TERT mutation carriers with pulmonary fibrosis demonstrate a mean survival of 3 years after diagnosis.
Genetic mutations in the TERT gene are the most frequent molecular defect found in patients with autosomal dominant pulmonary fibrosis. This disease can be considered a “telomeropathy,” like DKC, bone marrow failure and liver disease, when caused by germline mutations in telomerase and characterized by short telomere lengths. In this study, we describe the spectrum of diseases associated with heterozygous TERT mutations. This study was biased toward collecting subjects with pulmonary disease as the probands of each family were all collected based upon their known diagnosis of pulmonary fibrosis. However, as we expanded the kindreds, we discovered many other TERT mutation carriers with a similar phenotype. Overall, 40% of 134 TERT mutation carriers with a mean age of 51 carry a diagnosis of pulmonary fibrosis. All TERT mutations were discovered in individuals of white or Hispanic ancestry, similar to previous reports, .
This study demonstrates several similarities and differences between the different “telomeropathies.” First, the cardinal features of DKC, reticulated hyperpigmented skin, oral mucosal leukoplakia and dystrophic nails, are not seen in this cohort of TERT mutation carriers. Second, the age at the onset of disease can be very different. DKC is a usually a disease of childhood; bone marrow failure due to TERT mutations can affect individuals of a wide range of ages. In contrast, the pulmonary fibrosis phenotype is age-dependent. None of the TERT mutation carriers less than 40 years of age have pulmonary fibrosis, but 60% and 50% of men and women, respectively, have pulmonary fibrosis at ≥60 years of age. Third, the clinical spectrum of disease seen in these TERT mutation carriers is milder than seen with DKC. Over 85% of DKC patients have a manifestation of bone marrow failure, 20% have pulmonary disease, and fewer have premature graying, extensive dental loss, esophageal strictures, peptic ulceration and an increased cancer predisposition. Here we find aplastic anemia in 2 TERT mutation carriers, but isolated anemia in 18 individuals. Similarly, crytogenic liver cirrhosis is found in one TERT mutation carrier, but elevated liver function tests are seen in 11 individuals. Three other individuals for whom genomic DNA was not available for sequence analysis died from hepatitis-related liver cirrhosis. This is consistent with a recent report of a wide spectrum of familial liver disease in kindreds with telomerase mutations, including two TERT mutation families . While bone marrow dysfunction or liver cirrhosis can be found concurrently with pulmonary fibrosis, these diseases are frequently found in different individuals. The compilation of diseases related to telomerase dysfunction seen in different members of the same family rather than in the same individual is a common feature of the TERT kindreds. The observations in these families suggest that the penetrance of the TERT mutation is incomplete, though substantial (~40%) in causing pulmonary fibrosis and that expression is highly variable.
The “telomeropathies” are related to each other due to a shared pathogenic mechanism of telomere shortening. While telomere lengths are short in this TERT cohort, they are not as short as is usually seen with DKC patients. For the TERT mutation carriers in this study, 79% have telomere lengths shorter than the 10th percentile and 56% have lengths shorter than the 1st percentile of healthy controls. In contrast, 100% of DKC patients have lengths below the 1st percentile of normals. We see an age-dependent decline in telomere length for the TERT mutation carriers. In contrast, an age-dependent decline is not seen in DKC patients perhaps because the affected individuals may have already reached their minimal telomere lengths, .
Autosomal dominant DKC due to mutations in TERC, which encodes hTR, or TERT can demonstrate disease anticipation with increasing severity and an earlier onset in successive generations , . The anticipation is due to inheritance of both shorter telomeres and the parental telomerase mutation. Here we show that although disease or death can occur earlier in successive generations, anticipation is not the rule for all the TERT kindreds. Given the lethality of pulmonary fibrosis and the late onset of this disease, DNA samples from individuals belonging to preceding generations were not available. However, evaluation of telomere lengths of DNA samples of following generations of TERT mutations has shown a statistical trend toward further telomere shortening for three large kindreds. Transmission of the TERT mutation from the father, rather than the mother, led to shorter mean telomere lengths of the children. Whether these short telomere lengths are due to the number of cell divisions of the spermatogonia, relative to the egg, prior to fertilization or to sex-related genomic imprinting is not clear. However, this finding is similar to other reports of a strong paternal influence on telomere length, .
We see shortening of telomere lengths for family members who are wild-type for both TERT alleles in comparison with two reference groups: healthy unrelated controls and spouses marrying into the family. These family members have evidence of telomere shortening in the absence of a TERT mutation; their telomere shortening represents an epigenetic modification that has been stably inherited from the parent with a TERT mutation. Inherited short telomere lengths in the absence of telomerase mutations have been reported previously in one large TERC kindred and have been elegantly studied in mice. Genetic breeding strategies have produced mice with short telomere lengths; these exhibit degenerative defects even though telomerase is wildtype, . We have previously reported that ~25% of human subjects with the sporadic idiopathic interstitial pneumonias have short telomere lengths (<10th percentile) in the absence of telomerase mutations, suggesting a role of this epigenetic modification in the development of non-familial pulmonary fibrosis. It is currently unknown whether human family members in these TERT kindreds have any clinical phenotypes that may be associated with short telomere lengths in the absence of an inherited telomerase mutation.
A major limitation of this study is that it is a family-based observational study. Due to ascertainment bias, the prevalence of pulmonary fibrosis is likely much higher for this group than a randomly collected population-based cohort with telomerase mutations. Although the questionnaires were completed prospectively by subject participants, medical records and studies were reviewed retrospectively. Not all subjects underwent the same work up for each medical diagnosis. Pulmonary fibrosis is an age-related phenotype and relevant clinical data was missing for many of the historical cases. CT scans of the chest were not widely performed prior to 1980. In addition, pathology review was not possible for all since many of the affected individuals had not undergone surgical lung biopsies. The exposure data is also fraught with recollection bias; those with lung disease may be more likely to remember the occupational or environmental exposures that they later have been told are associated with pulmonary fibrosis. It is also difficult to retrospectively quantitate past life-long respiratory exposures or obtain accurate exposure histories from deceased individuals. Despite these limitations, the pulmonary phenotype was characterized with available data.
Most of the originally reported TERT mutation cases had IPF, but some did not fit the narrow diagnostic criteria for this disease, . One goal was to determine what percent of TERT mutation carriers represent IPF using modern diagnostic criteria. The interstitial lung disease associated with the TERT mutations is characterized uniformly by dyspnea and a decreased diffusion capacity. Almost three-fourths have a radiographic pattern of pulmonary fibrosis that is typical of IPF. However, 13% have a pattern that is atypical for IPF, either with reticulation that is upper or mid-lung zone predominant or fibrosis that occurs along bronchi. An upper lung predominant pattern of fibrosis can be consistent with clinical diagnoses of sarcoidosis, pneumoconioses or chronic hypersensitivity pneumonitis, diagnoses which some of these individuals carried. However, despite a wide range of treatment courses, pulmonary fibrosis was progressive with a mean survival of 3 years from diagnosis. There seemed to be no difference in the radiologic and pathologic patterns related to specific TERT mutations.
The coexistence of inflammation and fibrosis may be a characteristic of organ disease associated with telomerase mutations. Over 35% of the chest CT scans showed enlarged mediastinal lymph nodes, a radiographic finding that is usually not seen with IPF. While UIP was the predominant pathologic feature in surgical lung specimens, 17% also had scattered histiocytes and/or non-necrotizing granulomas and 35% had increased amounts of interstitial inflammation. These features seen in the absence of UIP generally portend a better response to immunosuppressant medication. Liver disease associated with telomerase mutations is heterogeneous in severity and pathology with findings of co-existent fibrosis and inflammation.
Over ninety-five percent of the TERT mutation carriers have smoked or had an exposure to a fibrogenic agent that has been linked to the development of pulmonary fibrosis. This suggests a role of environmental factors in triggering lung injury in a tissue that is more susceptible. Some of the variable expressivity of the clinical phenotype of TERT mutation carriers may be related to environmental injury of susceptible cells and organs, with possible influences from other genetic and epigenetic factors. Since there is reduced penetrance of lung fibrosis even for the oldest age bracket, modification of environmental exposures may prevent or delay the onset of disease for those who have inherited this genetic risk. In the upcoming era of genomic medicine, it will become imperative to counsel the next generations of individuals with germline telomerase mutations to avoid exposure to any agents that can harm those cells and organs that are especially sensitive to telomerase dysfunction.
Evaluation of novel rare TERT mutations. (A) Sequence electropherograms of PCR products amplified from genomic DNA of individuals heterozygous for mutations in TERT. Wild-type (wt) and mutant cDNA sequences are listed directly below the tracings. Heterozygous missense mutations are indicated at the positions marked by the short arrows. (B) Amino acid alignment of the TERT sequences of Homo sapiens (human), Macaca mulatta (monkey), Canis familiaris (dog), Bos taurus (cow), Mus musculus (mouse), Rattus norvegicus (rat), Gallus gallus (chicken), Xenopus laevis (frog), Schizosaccharomyces pombe (yeast), and Arabidopsis thaliana (plant). (C) Relative telomerase activity of TERT mutations as measured by the telomere repeat amplification protocol (TRAP) assay are calculated as a ratio of the intensity of the sample's telomerase products to that of an internal control band and normalized to wild-type activity. Error bars represent the SD of duplicate experiments. Parallel reactions using [35S]methionine were run on a sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel to confirm equal expression of the TERT wild-type and mutant proteins.
(1.16 MB TIF)
Correlation between telomere lengths measured by Southern blot (TRFL, kb) and by multiplexed real-time PCR (Relative LN(T/S ratio)) for 387 different genomic samples. The Southern blot method for determining telomere length (Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Analysis) was performed as described . A relative LN (T/S ratio) = 1 corresponds to a terminal restriction fragment length of 4.5 kb. By linear regression analysis, the correlation between the two are highly significant (Spearman's rank correlation = 0.83, P-value <2.2×10−16).
(2.77 MB TIF)
Distribution of TERT mutations for 134 heterozygous mutation carriers.
(0.01 MB PDF)
The authors are indebted to the patients and their family members for their cooperation in participating in this research study; Ji (Erica) Han and Jennifer Fehmel for their assistance in obtaining blood samples and medical records and Zheng Hu and Lauren Miller for excellent technical assistance.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CKG. Performed the experiments: ADdL JTC ALAK JDG. Analyzed the data: ADdL JTC ALAK JDG GR CX CKG. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: GR CSG RLR CEG ERG CX. Wrote the paper: CKG.
- 1. Greider CW, Blackburn EH (1985) Identification of a specific telomere terminal transferase activity in Tetrahymena extracts. Cell 43: 405–413.
- 2. Feng J, Funk WD, Wang SS, Weinrich SL, Avilion AA, et al. (1995) The RNA component of human telomerase. Science 269: 1236–1241.
- 3. Broccoli D, Young JW, de Lange T (1995) Telomerase activity in normal and malignant hematopoietic cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 92: 9082–9086.
- 4. Wright WE, Piatyszek MA, Rainey WE, Byrd W, Shay JW (1996) Telomerase activity in human germline and embryonic tissues and cells. Dev Genet 18: 173–179.
- 5. Kim NW, Piatyszek MA, Prowse KR, Harley CB, West MD, et al. (1994) Specific association of human telomerase activity with immortal cells and cancer. Science 266: 2011–2015.
- 6. Hastie ND, Dempster M, Dunlop MG, Thompson AM, Green DK, et al. (1990) Telomere reduction in human colorectal carcinoma and with ageing. Nature 346: 866–868.
- 7. Calado RT, Young NS (2009) Telomere Disease. New England Journal of Medicine 361: 2353–2365.
- 8. Heiss NS, Knight SW, Vulliamy TJ, Klauck SM, Wiemann S, et al. (1998) X-linked dyskeratosis congenita is caused by mutations in a highly conserved gene with putative nucleolar functions. Nat Genet 19: 32–38.
- 9. Vulliamy T, Marrone A, Goldman F, Dearlove A, Bessler M, et al. (2001) The RNA component of telomerase is mutated in autosomal dominant dyskeratosis congenita. Nature 413: 432–435.
- 10. Armanios M, Chen JL, Chang YP, Brodsky RA, Hawkins A, et al. (2005) Haploinsufficiency of telomerase reverse transcriptase leads to anticipation in autosomal dominant dyskeratosis congenita. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 15960–15964.
- 11. Walne AJ, Vulliamy T, Marrone A, Beswick R, Kirwan M, et al. (2007) Genetic heterogeneity in autosomal recessive dyskeratosis congenita with one subtype due to mutations in the telomerase-associated protein NOP10. Hum Mol Genet.
- 12. Vulliamy T, Beswick R, Kirwan M, Marrone A, Digweed M, et al. (2008) Mutations in the telomerase component NHP2 cause the premature ageing syndrome dyskeratosis congenita. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105: 8073–8078.
- 13. Savage SA, Giri N, Baerlocher GM, Orr N, Lansdorp PM, et al. (2008) TINF2, a component of the shelterin telomere protection complex, is mutated in dyskeratosis congenita. Am J Hum Genet 82: 501–509.
- 14. Marciniak RA, Johnson FB, Guarente L (2000) Dyskeratosis congenita, telomeres and human ageing. Trends Genet 16: 193–195.
- 15. (2002) American Thoracic Society/European Respiratory Society International Multidisciplinary Consensus Classification of the Idiopathic Interstitial Pneumonias. This joint statement of the American Thoracic Society (ATS), and the European Respiratory Society (ERS) was adopted by the ATS board of directors, June 2001 and by the ERS Executive Committee, June 2001. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 165: 277–304.
- 16. Raghu G, Weycker D, Edelsberg J, Bradford WZ, Oster G (2006) Incidence and prevalence of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 174: 810–816.
- 17. Armanios MY, Chen JJ, Cogan JD, Alder JK, Ingersoll RG, et al. (2007) Telomerase mutations in families with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis. N Engl J Med 356: 1317–1326.
- 18. Tsakiri KD, Cronkhite JT, Kuan PJ, Xing C, Raghu G, et al. (2007) Adult-onset pulmonary fibrosis caused by mutations in telomerase. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 7552–7557.
- 19. Cronkhite JT, Xing C, Raghu G, Chin KM, Torres F, et al. (2008) Telomere shortening in familial and sporadic pulmonary fibrosis. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 178: 729–737.
- 20. Alder JK, Chen JJ, Lancaster L, Danoff S, Su SC, et al. (2008) Short telomeres are a risk factor for idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105: 13051–13056.
- 21. Cawthon RM (2009) Telomere length measurement by a novel monochrome multiplex quantitative PCR method. Nucleic Acids Res 37: e21.
- 22. Yamaguchi H, Calado RT, Ly H, Kajigaya S, Baerlocher GM, et al. (2005) Mutations in TERT, the gene for telomerase reverse transcriptase, in aplastic anemia. N Engl J Med 352: 1413–1424.
- 23. Heron M, Hoyert DL, Murphy SL, Xu J, Kochanek KD, et al. (2009) Deaths: final data for 2006. Natl Vital Stat Rep 57: 1–134.
- 24. Garcia CK, Wright WE, Shay JW (2007) Human diseases of telomerase dysfunction: insights into tissue aging. Nucleic Acids Res.
- 25. Dokal I (2000) Dyskeratosis congenita in all its forms. Br J Haematol 110: 768–779.
- 26. Calado RT, Regal JA, Kleiner DE, Schrump DS, Peterson NR, et al. (2009) A spectrum of severe familial liver disorders associate with telomerase mutations. PLoS ONE 4: e7926.
- 27. Du HY, Pumbo E, Ivanovich J, An P, Maziarz RT, et al. (2009) TERC and TERT gene mutations in patients with bone marrow failure and the significance of telomere length measurements. Blood 113: 309–316.
- 28. Goldman F, Bouarich R, Kulkarni S, Freeman S, Du HY, et al. (2005) The effect of TERC haploinsufficiency on the inheritance of telomere length. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 17119–17124.
- 29. Alter BP, Baerlocher GM, Savage SA, Chanock SJ, Weksler BB, et al. (2007) Very short telomere length by flow FISH identifies patients with Dyskeratosis Congenita. Blood.
- 30. Vulliamy T, Marrone A, Szydlo R, Walne A, Mason PJ, et al. (2004) Disease anticipation is associated with progressive telomere shortening in families with dyskeratosis congenita due to mutations in TERC. Nat Genet 36: 447–449.
- 31. Njajou OT, Cawthon RM, Damcott CM, Wu SH, Ott S, et al. (2007) Telomere length is paternally inherited and is associated with parental lifespan. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 12135–12139.
- 32. Nordfjall K, Svenson U, Norrback KF, Adolfsson R, Roos G (2009) Large-scale parent-child comparison confirms a strong paternal influence on telomere length. Eur J Hum Genet.
- 33. Hao LY, Armanios M, Strong MA, Karim B, Feldser DM, et al. (2005) Short telomeres, even in the presence of telomerase, limit tissue renewal capacity. Cell 123: 1121–1131.
- 34. Armanios M, Alder JK, Parry EM, Karim B, Strong MA, et al. (2009) Short Telomeres are Sufficient to Cause the Degenerative Defects Associated with Aging. Am J Hum Genet.