Polistes paper wasps are models for understanding conditions that may have characterized the origin of worker and queen castes and, therefore, the origin of paper wasp sociality. Polistes is “primitively eusocial” by virtue of having context-dependent caste determination and no morphological differences between castes. Even so, Polistes colonies have a temporal pattern in which most female larvae reared by the foundress become workers, and most reared by workers become future-reproductive gynes. This pattern is hypothesized to reflect development onto two pathways, which may utilize mechanisms that regulate diapause in other insects. Using expressed sequence tags (ESTs) for Polistes metricus we selected candidate genes differentially expressed in other insects in three categories: 1) diapause vs. non-diapause phenotypes and/or worker vs. queen differentiation, 2) behavioral subcastes of worker honey bees, and 3) no a priori expectation of a role in worker/gyne development. We also used a non-targeted proteomics screen to test for peptide/protein abundance differences that could reflect larval developmental divergence. We found that foundress-reared larvae (putative worker-destined) and worker-reared larvae (putative gyne-destined) differed in quantitative expression of sixteen genes, twelve of which were associated with caste and/or diapause in other insects, and they also differed in abundance of nine peptides/proteins. Some differentially-expressed genes are involved in diapause regulation in other insects, and other differentially-expressed genes and proteins are involved in the insulin signaling pathway, nutrient metabolism, and caste determination in highly social bees. Differential expression of a gene and a peptide encoding hexameric storage proteins is especially noteworthy. Although not conclusive, our results support hypotheses of 1) larval developmental pathway divergence that can lead to caste bias in adults and 2) nutritional differences as the foundation of the pathway divergence. Finally, the differential expression in Polistes larvae of genes and proteins also differentially expressed during queen vs. worker caste development in honey bees may indicate that regulatory mechanisms of caste outcomes share similarities between primitively eusocial and advanced eusocial Hymenoptera.
Citation: Hunt JH, Wolschin F, Henshaw MT, Newman TC, Toth AL, Amdam GV (2010) Differential Gene Expression and Protein Abundance Evince Ontogenetic Bias toward Castes in a Primitively Eusocial Wasp. PLoS ONE 5(5): e10674. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0010674
Editor: James Arthur Robert Marshall, University of Bristol, United Kingdom
Received: December 31, 2009; Accepted: April 16, 2010; Published: May 17, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Hunt et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: JHH, MTH, and ALT received support from the US National Science Foundation (0819807, 0803317, 0641431); JHH received additional support from the University of Illinois Sociogenomics Initiative (Gene E. Robinson, PI) and from the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center (NSF #EF-0905608); FW was supported by a Feodor Lynen Fellowship from the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation; and GVA received support from the Research Council of Norway (175413, 180504, 185306 and 191699), the US National Science Foundation (0615502), the PEW Foundation (000068-001), and the National Institute of Aging (NIA P01 AG22500). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Determination of morphologically and behaviorally distinct worker and reproductive castes occurs during larval development in ants , honey bees and stingless bees , , vespine wasps , , and many (but not all) swarm-founding paper wasps , all of which represent “advanced eusocial”  insects. In contrast to advanced eusocial insects, worker and reproductive castes in “primitively eusocial”  insects are not morphologically distinct . For example, in most species of paper wasps (Polistes) both workers and reproductives encompass the full range of body sizes , . Therefore, a question that bears directly on conditions presumed to have characterized the threshold of insect social evolution  is to ask whether the differentiation of workers and gynes (presumptive foundresses and, therefore, presumptive future queens) in anatomically monomorphic “primitively eusocial” Hymenoptera also has an ontogenetic component, as in advanced eusocial forms.
Primitively eusocial paper wasps of the genus Polistes have long been used as models to investigate behavioral aspects of sociality in the wasp family Vespidae . Polistes' worker/queen caste determination occurs in the adult stage  and may be determined by constraints on breeding  such as physiological costs of work undertaken by workers  and/or behavioral dominance of workers by queens . Worker caste determination is not random, however, as Polistes colonies are characterized by a temporal pattern in which workers precede non-workers of the same generation , , , although both early non-workers  and late workers ,  may occur at low frequencies , . Hunt and Amdam  recognized that any adult female Polistes can become either a worker or queen and that worker/queen castes are determined among adults, but they proposed a specific hypothesis for a process whereby larval developmental divergence yields females reared early in the colony cycle that are biased to become workers and females reared later in the colony cycle that are biased to become gynes.
Multiple adult features have led previous investigators to suggest that the behavioral castes of primitively eusocial wasps are preceded by developmental divergence during larval growth . The evidence includes apparent morphological caste dimorphism in Polistes olivaceous ,  and Belonogaster petiolata , unequivocal morphological caste dimorphism in Ropalidia galimatia , and two phenotypes of reproductive development in newly-emerged Ropalidia marginata , , . Abdominal fat in adult female Polistes reared early in the colony cycle is scant and yellow, whereas abdominal fat in females reared late in the colony cycle is abundant and white , , , . Although ovarian development is slight in both workers and gynes, it is significantly greater in workers . If these adult morphological and physiological differences reflect a divergence during larval development that has the potential to bias larvae toward either worker or gyne caste, we reasoned that gene expression differences during larval development should exist. An expressed sequence tag (EST) project based on 454/Roche pyrosequencing, which yielded partial sequences for ca. 3,000 genes for Polistes metricus , can be a resource to test the hypothesis that Polistes females diverge during larval life onto two physiological tracks. In the first utilization of the EST resource, quantification of twenty-eight gene transcripts in the mature adult brain revealed that workers differed significantly from gynes that were the workers' same-generation siblings , a result corroborated in a large scale study that focused on brains of the same groups and included transcript profiling, via microarray, of approximately 3000 genes . These results are consistent with the hypothesis that Polistes workers and gynes are physiologically different despite being anatomically indistinguishable. The differences documented in ,  could reflect differential outcomes of early developmental events , . However, the data are based on adult sample material rather than larvae, thus they do not directly test the developmental divergence hypothesis.
Using the P. metricus EST resource, we designed research on larvae that would bear directly on developmental events during the larval stage. We predicted that if divergent developmental physiology underlies the difference between workers and gynes, then levels of gene and protein products should differ between worker-destined and gyne-destined larvae. We tested the predicted divergence by comparing field-collected foundress-reared (putative worker-destined) and worker-reared (putative gyne-destined) fifth (final) instar larvae of P. metricus in two ways. One study focused on the mRNA levels of 38 specifically-targeted candidate genes, and another study used a non-targeted proteomics approach .The mRNA candidate gene study was based on a priori expectations of difference. The proteomics analysis was non-targeted to enable an unbiased evaluation of foundress-raised vs. worker-raised larvae without a priori expectations. Thus, the proteomics analysis was an independent test that could identify new physiological markers as well as confirm or dismiss mRNA expression differences, thereby enabling added confidence in our data evaluation. Both methodological approaches have the potential to reveal the occurrence and characteristics of molecular separation between the two types of larvae.
Our study taxon, Polistes metricus is a common paper wasp in the Midwestern and Southeastern US. Specimens were collected in spring 2005 and 2007 from nests of P. metricus naturally-founded by solitary foundresses in “nest boxes” at two field sites near St. Louis, Missouri, USA, as previously described . Nests were not used in other studies, and they were undisturbed after marking the foundress with a dot of paint until the dates of specimen collections. Nests were selected for larval collections only if all nest cells contained apparently normal brood. At collection, forceps were used to remove larvae from their nest cells. Each larva was flash frozen within seconds in liquid N2, transferred to a labeled tube on dry ice, and stored at −80°C. One set of specimens was collected in mid-June, when the single foundress was the only adult wasp present. A second set was collected in the same manner from other nests in late July and early August, when the foundress was accompanied by a minimum of three workers. Specimens for this study were restricted to large fifth-instar larvae that were of a size that soon would begin spinning their pupal cocoon. Specimen collection data and causes for excluding 7 specimens are presented in Supplementary Table S1.
Only females become workers or gynes, therefore male larvae must be excluded from analysis. In Hymenoptera, females are diploid while males are haploid . Accordingly, we used a tissue chip from the posterior of some 2005 foundress-reared larvae and all worker-reared larvae to genotype 6 microsatellite loci. Female larvae were heterozygous at two or more loci and thus diploid. This approach reliably excludes haploid males. In certain circumstances, diploid eggs can develop into males , and this approach could fail to exclude such males. However, the production of such diploid males would be marked by the production of early males along with the first cohort of workers, and no such males were detected, indicating that diploid male production did not occur on any of the study nests. Methods and loci are described in .
Gene Selection and Primer Design
Thirty-eight genes were chosen for mRNA expression via real time quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (qRTPCR). Microarray analysis, now available for P. metricus  was not an option for this study; at the time of analysis (2006–2007) the resource was not developed, and cost constraints left us unable to print our own custom-made arrays.
Because diapause physiology may underlie developmental divergence in Polistes , literature was searched for genes differentially expressed in non-diapause vs. diapause phenotypes in other insect taxa (Table 1). Additional candidate genes were known to be differentially expressed in worker-destined vs. queen-destined honey bees (Apis mellifera), bumble bees (Bombus), and a stingless bee (Melipona quadrifasciata) (Table 1). We previously found a hexameric storage protein to be differentially expressed in putative worker-destined vs. gyne-destined larvae of P. metricus , , therefore it is particularly meaningful that one candidate gene encodes hexameric storage proteins. The absence/presence of hexameric storage protein could be a key physiological mediator of diapause-related larval pathway divergence, perhaps as a regulator of juvenile hormone (JH) in foundress-reared (low hexamerin, high JH) vs. worker-reared (high hexamerin, low JH) newly-emerged adults . We also quantified expression of an endogenous control gene, RSP8, as used in studies of A. mellifera , , .
Differences might occur between the two sets of collected larvae that would reflect differences in rearing conditions such as day length, temperature, or food resource availability rather than a developmental bias that would be revealed by the candidate genes. To begin to address this possibility, we selected a set of non-candidate genes related to foraging and differentially expressed between two adult behavioral castes of worker honey bees, nurses that perform tasks within the hive and foragers that perform tasks in the field . These genes are not among those found to be differentially expressed between developing larvae that become either worker or queen honey bees , , , . Several genes for which we had no a priori expectation of an association with caste development or foraging were included in the study as non-candidate genes based on ready availability of primers for them. One of these non-candidate genes, apolipoprotein, was a priori suspected of possible involvement in larval divergence because of the known difference of two types of abdominal fat in worker and gyne Polistes, but in the absence of documentation that it plays a role in either of our candidate gene categories, it was placed conservatively as a non-candidate gene.
Published sequences for candidate and non-candidate genes were used to search the Polistes metricus EST transcriptome (http://stan.cropsci.uiuc.edu/454/blast/waspblast.html) for BLAST sequence matches. If a match was found, primers were designed using Primer Express Version 2 (Applied Biosystems) using the DNA PCR module for qPCR using SYBR Green. Prior to design, sequences were screened for possible indels in A and T homopolymer runs. The sequences were translated, and BLASTP  was used to compare sequences to honey bee proteins to look for correctable frame shifts. Primer sequences are given in Table S2.
Gene Transcript Quantification
For the 2005 collections, total RNA was extracted from ca. 80% to 90% of each foundress-reared larva that remained after tissue chip removal (Sex Determination, above) or from whole foundress-reared and worker-reared larvae. Tissues were homogenized in Trizol reagent (Invitrogen) with a motorized pestle and centrifuged at 4°C. The aqueous phase was mixed with an equal volume of 70% EtOH and transferred to a Qiagen RNeasy mini spin column followed by the RNeasy extraction protocol. RNA quality was examined using an Agilent BioAnalyzer and its concentration quantified with a Nanodrop spectrophotometer. Two hundred ng of RNA were used for cDNA synthesis with ArrayScript, and quantification was performed as in . For each sample, quantitative PCR was performed in triplicate using 1.5 ng cDNA in 10 µl reactions composed of 2X-SybrGreen Master Mix (Applied Biosystems) and a final concentration of 0.25 µM gene-specific primers. 386-well plates were run on the Applied Biosystems 7900 HT System Detection System and analyzed with SDS version 2.2 software. Absolute quantification was determined using a genomic DNA standard curve.
The 2007 specimens were extracted using Trizol reagent as in 2005. Proteins were precipitated out of the phenol-chloroform phase (200 µg per sample) using a methanol/chloroform protocol  and redissolved in 40 µl Tris pH 8.5, 6 M urea, 2 M thiourea, 5 mM CaCl2, and 0.15 M NaCl. Samples then were vortexed and diluted in 160 µl Tris pH 8.5, 5 mM CaCl2, and 0.15 M NaCl. Protein concentration was determined by the Bradford assay. Samples were split, and 40 µg of each sample were subjected to SDS-PAGE followed by tryptic digestion or to direct in-liquid digestion as described previously .
SDS-PAGE was performed at 120 mV for 20 min. Each band was divided into five major pieces, and proteins were digested according to the following procedure: each gel piece was washed twice with 200 µl of NH4HCO3 followed by three washes with 50% acetonitrile/50% NH4HCO3. Gel pieces were then dried in a speed vac at 30°C for 15 min, followed by the addition of 10 µl of a 5 µg/ml protein standard (beta-lactoglobulin C7880-10MG in 0.15 M NaCl). Samples sat on ice for 10 min and were then dried in a speed vac at 30°C for 10 min. Subsequently, 20 µl trypsin solution (12.5 ng of trypsin/µl digestion buffer [25 mM NH4HCO3, 10% acetonitrile, 5 mM CaCl2]) were added, and the samples were incubated at 4°C for 30 min followed by the addition of 60 µl of digestion buffer. Proteins were digested overnight at 30°C, and peptides were extracted as described in the manual for Roche sequencing grade trypsin.
Peptides were analyzed by LC-MS/MS as described previously . Briefly, about 20 µg of in-liquid digested sample or the entire result from one in-gel digest were subjected to HPLC, and peptides were eluted directly into a linear ion trap (LTQ, Thermo Electron, San Diego, USA). Peptides were separated on a monolithic column (100 µm ID, Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) using a 105 min gradient ranging from 95% A (0.1% formic acid, 99.9% H2O) to 80% B (0.1% formic acid, 99.9% acetonitrile) for in-liquid digested samples and a 65 min gradient for in-gel digested samples, respectively. The top five most abundant MS peaks were automatically selected for MS/MS. OMSSA 2.0.0  was used to run the experimentally obtained spectra against a database containing the information of the P. metricus transcriptome contigs translated into all 6 possible reading frames as well as keratin, trypsin, and beta-lactoglobulin sequences. Only fully tryptic peptides were considered, and a maximum of two missed cleavages was accepted. Deamidation of N and Q, and methione oxidation were allowed as variable modifications. MS and MS/MS error tolerance was set at 0.8 Da.
mRNA expression data were analyzed using R statistical software. For three of the 38 genes (PmSh3β, PmInR2, and PmHSP90α), the same samples were run two times, so the data were average for the two replicates of these genes. In addition, two different contigs, PmHex70b (a) and PmHex70b (b) of Table 1, were found to correspond to the same P. metricus gene, thus their mRNA expression data, which were highly correlated (Pearson R = 0.98, p<0.0001), were averaged for analysis. All data were log transformed to normalize the residuals and divided by the expression values for each individual of PmRSP8 (NCBI accession #TI1888782351), which showed minimal variation across groups and individuals, as an endogenous control. Each gene was tested for differences between foundress-reared and worker-reared larvae using both ANOVA (lme function in R) and a non-parametric Mann-Whitney U test (wilcox.test function in R). Missing values (2 in total) were replaced with the median of the sample group for the respective gene before subjecting the data to the Mann-Whitney U test. In order to adjust for false discovery rate caused by repeated Mann-Whitney U testing, we used a type I error bootstrap correction with 1000 iterations per generation following an established procedure for large scale datasets coded by Matlab R2007b , , , . This approach established a corrected p-value cutoff at p≥0.1. Linear discriminant analysis (LDA, using the lda function in R) was performed on 16 genes that were significantly different based on both the ANOVA and Mann-Whitney U approaches (see Results). However, because the LDA failed due to high colinearity, we performed Pearson correlations (cor function with “Pearson” option in R) to identify which genes had highly correlated gene expression. The analysis identified several highly correlated genes that can be closely functionally related. PmPi3K was correlated with two other insulin pathway genes, PmILP2 (0.93) and PmIRS (0.954). PmILP2 was also correlated with PmIRS (0.948), PmRfaBp was correlated with two other lipoprotein genes, PmAPO (0.912) and PmHex70b (0.916), and PmeELF1a was correlated with PmSPARC (0.939). To eliminate the colinearity problem of LDA we removed PmPi3K, PmILP2, PmRfaBp and PmeELF1a before repeating the LDA analysis on the remaining 12 genes. The resulting linear discriminant function was used as a basis for leave-one-out cross validation (using the lda function in R with the “CV” option) to confirm the ability of the gene expression differences to correctly classify individuals as foundress-reared or worker-reared. Test scores and associated p values for both the Mann-Whitney U test and ANOVA are given in Table S3.
Peptide quantities were analyzed using Statistica 6.0 (Mann Whitney U-tests) and Matlab R2007b (bootstrap correction for type 1 error, as for gene expression data above). Statistical analysis was based on spectral count , however the normalization procedure was specific to in-gel and in-liquid digested samples. For the in-gel digested samples, spectral counts were first normalized to the individual values for beta-lactoglobulin to account for possible differences in the digestion procedure. This was followed by normalization to the total spectral count for all bands of one lane to account for possible loading differences. Liquid samples were normalized to total spectral count only. Using a decoy database, the false discovery rate was determined to be ≤1%. Correction for type 1 error resulted in a corrected p-value cut-off equivalent of p≤0.05. Only hits with a spectral count of ≥3 in at least 3 of 5 replicates were considered.
Microsatellite analysis of 13 foundress-reared specimens from 2005 showed all to be females. A specimen for which no microsatellites amplified was eliminated from further analysis (Table S4a). All other foundress-reared specimens were assumed to be females, as has consistently been the case in studies at the same study sites , , . Eighteen of 29 worker-reared larvae were males, and one specimen was triploid (Table S4a). Sample sizes for gene expression analyses were 10 foundress-reared (putative worker-destined) and 7 worker-reared (putative gyne-destined). In 2007 only 6 of 23 worker-reared specimens were females (Table S4b). Sample sizes for peptide quantifications were 5 foundress-reared and 5 worker-reared (Table S1).
We quantified the expression of 38 genes (Table 1). Both the corrected Mann-Whitney U test and mixed model ANOVA identified the same 16 genes to be significantly differentially expressed between the two sets of larvae (Figure 1; Table 1). All 16 significantly differentially expressed genes were up-regulated in worker-reared (gyne-destined) larvae (Figure 1). Linear discriminant analysis of 12 significant genes succeeded in clearly separating the two groups from each other (Figure 2). For explanation of the 12 genes used for this analysis, see Methods: Statistical Analyses. Leave-one-out cross-validation classified 15 out of 17 (88%) as foundress- or worker-reared.
Sixteen genes (upper) and 9 peptides (lower) significantly differentially expressed in foundress-reared (FR; putative worker-destined) vs. worker-reared (WR; putative gyne-destined) P. metricus fifth-instar larvae. Bar at top gives color scale of relative expression from the mean expression: downregulation = blue; upregulation = yellow. Z-transformed transcript and peptide/protein abundances visualized using TMeV version 4.3.02.
Linear discriminant analysis of 12 genes significantly different at the mRNA level clearly separated foundress-reared (FR; putative worker-destined) and worker-reared (WR; putative gyne-destined) larvae. X axis = LD value; Y axis = LD value frequencies. 88% of individuals were correctly classified as FR or WR based on LD values.
Quantification of expression was performed on putative proteins, as identified by database entry hits. One or more peptides of a single mature protein can belong to one or several database entry hits, thus one protein might produce more than one hit entry. Of these database entry hits, 9 were significantly quantitatively different between the two sets of larvae (Figure 1; Table S5), and 7 were supported by at least two distinct peptides (Table S5). The hits included a peptide homologous to the hexameric storage protein arylphorin from the boll weevil, Anthonomus grandis, and that protein was identified in both in-gel and in-liquid digestion samples. Other hits indicated that several peptides homologous to an imaginal disc growth factor were up-regulated in gyne-destined larvae: a nuclear ribonucleoprotein; shrub; serpin; and apolipophorin-III (Figure 1; Table S5). Figure 3 illustrates the magnitude of differences for arylphorin, serpin, imaginal disc growth factor 4, and a shrub-like protein.
Quantities of four peptides/proteins significantly differentially expressed in foundress-reared (FR; putative worker-destined) vs. worker-reared (WR; putative gyne-destined) P. metricus fifth-instar larvae: median (dark squares), 25th-75 th percentiles (brackets), and outliers (open circles). Stars denote significant differences (Mann Whitney U-test, p≤0.05, n = 5 per group). Y-axis: spectral count for individual peptides/proteins corrected for overall spectral count. Sequences are homologous to: (a) arylphorin of the boll weevil (NCBI accession AAN63347); (b) serpin (contig 46732, rf 18257); (c) imaginal disc growth factor 4 (contig 46769); (d) shrub (contig 32130).
By targeted testing of 38 genes and non-restricted screening of protein levels, we found that mRNA expression of 16 of 38 quantified genes and quantities of 9 peptides/proteins were significantly up-regulated in worker-reared (putative gyne-destined) vs. foundress-reared (putative worker-destined) fifth instar larvae of Polistes metricus. The gene expression differences represent transcriptional differences at the time of specimen collection, while the differentially expressed peptides/proteins represent readily available stored protein of high abundance rather than active differences in transcription. Thus, our finding that none of the differently-expressed genes are represented among the differently-expressed peptides/proteins is consistent with processes commonly observed in molecular biology: transcript abundance does not always translate into protein abundance, and turnover rates can differ between mRNA and protein .
Because the larval developmental divergence that we hypothesize could incorporate genes related to diapause and to caste differences in highly eusocial insects, we had searched literature to find candidate genes in those two categories. Two candidate genes, oxidoreductase and Vg1, belonged in both categories. Non-candidate genes had been drawn from loci that are differentially expressed between behaviorally different nurse and forager honey bees. A few additional genes for which primers were readily available were included in the non-candidate gene category. In publications subsequent to our gene expression quantification, two non-candidate genes were documented to be in one of our candidate categories: Pi3K is diapause-related, and RfaBp plays a role in queen/worker differentiation . Correspondingly, three of our candidate genes, ILP2, InR1, and InR2, were found to be implicated in honey bee nurse/forager regulation . In addition, apolipoprotein, which had been classified as non-candidate due to the absence of documentation of its possible involvement in diapause or caste relatedness, was shown to play a role in queen/worker larval divergence. These overlaps in our classification of genes as candidate or non-candidate are not altogether surprising, given the pleiotropic nature of many genes as well as the suggestion that behavior differences among worker honey bees reflect in part an underlying ground plan of reproductive physiology , . These considerations make it biologically difficult to draw a clean contrast between our candidate genes and those non-candidate genes that came from studies of worker honeybees, In consequence, we cannot definitively exclude the possibility that our data reflect, at least in part, generalized expression differences that include genes both implicated and not implicated in pathways that could regulate larval developmental divergence. Nonetheless, one particular result provides support for specific rather than generalized gene expression differences: 12 of 20 (60%) candidate genes are differentially-expressed, whereas 4 of 18 (22%) non-candidate genes are differentially expressed.
The gene encoding heat shock protein 90α is up-regulated, and the protein itself is down-regulated, during pupal diapause of the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis , . We found a gene encoding this protein to be up-regulated in worker-reared larvae of P. metricus. Heat shock proteins are widely implicated as playing roles in insect diapause , , , , , as are hexamerins , ,  and several genes in the insulin pathway , , . Hexameric storage proteins are differentially regulated between queen-destined vs. worker-destined larvae of A. mellifera  and B. terrestris . We found up-regulation of PmHex70b, PmHSC70, and arylphorin protein in gyne-destined larvae. Hexamerin 2 was up-regulated in adult queens vs. workers of the tropical paper wasp P. canadensis , suggesting that the possible interplay of hexamerin expression and caste bias is not limited to Polistes species with exclusively temperate zone distributions. Note that the evolutionary relationships among the mRNA sequence for PmHex70b and the unsequenced gel bands previously called hexamerin 1 and 2 of  and hexamerin 2 of  remain to be ascertained.
Transcripts of three genes that are part of insulin/insulin-like signaling pathways and play roles in growth, reproduction, and aging (PmPi3K, PmILP2, and PmIRS) are up-regulated in worker-reared (putative gyne-destined) P. metricus larvae, which emerge from pupation in apparent reproductive diapause , . In possible contrast to our finding, down-regulation of insulin signaling can set the stage for ovarian diapause in Drosophila  and Culex pipiens . Differences in life history stage at which diapause occurs could explain inter-taxon differences in diapause signatures that incorporate analogous regulatory pathways. Insulin/insulin-like (ILP) and target of rapamycin (TOR) nutrient signaling influence queen/worker caste development in honey bees , .
Two peptides with higher expression in worker-reared (putative gyne-destined) P. metricus larvae are homologous to an imaginal disc growth factor similar to proteins that have been previously described to cooperate with insulin to induce cellular proliferation, mobility, and polarization . The shrub-like peptide is similar to shrub, which in Drosophila is important in development of the neuronal system , perhaps pointing to an early initiation of determination of differences that subsequently have been observed between brains of adult worker vs. gyne P. metricus , .
Our data suggest a role for lipid metabolism in Polistes caste development via up-regulation of mRNA for an apolipoprotein and a retinoid- and fatty acid-binding protein plus higher levels of apolipophorin-III protein. Lipid transport utilizes specialized lipoprotein complexes, the apolipoproteins, that stabilize the lipid components and mediate metabolism , thus further supporting the idea that nutrient allocation affects caste-biased larval development in Polistes. Enhanced lipid metabolism might lead to enhanced lipid depositories in gynes, helping them survive the temperate winter or tropical dry season , , . Apolipoprotein was down-regulated in adult queens vs. workers of the tropical paper wasp P. canadensis .
Oxidoreductase is up-regulated in A. mellifera worker-destined larvae  and down-regulated in adult in-hive workers within nests vs. foragers that perform tasks in the field . We found an oxidoreductase to be up-regulated in putative gyne-destined larvae. A serpin homologue is significantly up-regulated in cDNA libraries of late instar worker larvae and adult workers relative to those of queens in the yellowjacket Vespula squamosa . We found higher serpin levels in putative gyne-destined larvae.
Our data suggest that several genes that are related to diapause in other insects are differentially expressed in foundress-reared and worker-reared larvae. This finding is consistent with the hypothesis that diapause physiology is foundational to the larval pathway divergence . However, the finding is confounded by seasonal differences. Because foundress-reared and worker-reared larvae do not overlap in time, our data cannot explicitly rule out that the differences we observed between the larval groups reflect environmental patterning of seasonally varying temperature or day length that could affect adult phenotypes. This concern is diminished by the findings that pupae of P. metricus can diverge onto two developmental pathways under a single temperature and day length regime  and that our significant findings include phylogenetically conserved genes and proteins with pleiotropic phenotypic outcomes that include the adult stage in many animals as described above. Moreover, if larval gene transcript/protein level differences are regarded causal to adult phenotype, our data cannot distinguish between effects on expression that emerge from seasonally varying influences such as food quality or its availability in the environment relative to the hypothesized role of quantitatively different larval nourishment caused by solitary foundress vs. collective worker feeding behavior. Differences in food quality might be reflected in the finding that worker-destined and gyne-destined larvae of P. metricus differ significantly in nutrient levels : gyne-destined larvae had higher levels of lipids and potassium, gained calories more quickly than worker-destined larvae, and stored more energy as they developed . A literature search revealed no data in support of seasonal environmental differences in food quantity for Polistes nor suggestions that such differences might occur. In contrast, support for a role played by differences in the quantity of food fed to larvae can be drawn from studies in many species of Polistes, reviewed in , that document a pattern of change in size from small adults produced early in the season when only the foundress is present, to larger adults produced in mid-season when a worker force is present, with some diminishment in size near the end of the colony cycle . Variation in larval feeding rates as a consequence of changes in the worker to larvae ratio ,  and presence of gynes and males  have been hypothesized to be the basis for the seasonal patterning of body size. Direct support for the hypothesized effects of low versus high larval nourishment can be drawn from experiments in which food supplementation of P. metricus led to higher fat content in both the field  and lab , higher survival of a laboratory cold test , and, in the field, larger colony size, higher survivorship, and production of more gynes , . Additionally, our data, in which most of the differentially-expressed genes and peptides/proteins are known to play roles in nutritionally-mediated physiological pathways, clearly mirror the regulatory importance of nutrition in caste-specific larval development of A. mellifera . Larval determination of worker and queen castes in honey bees depends on a difference in food quality as well as food quantity . In sum, there is considerable support for the hypothesis that difference in food quantity provisioned to larvae plays a major role in the larval divergence we have reported here.
Our findings from both gene and protein expression patterns favor rejection of the null hypothesis of no difference between foundress-reared and worker-reared larvae, and at the same time our findings fail to reject the hypothesis of larval pathway divergence presented by  and supported by . This conclusion incorporates three major findings. Our first major finding that gene transcript and protein level data support a role for diapause regulatory factors during larval divergence in Polistes metricus. Our second major finding is that differentially expressed genes and proteins are active in physiological pathways that respond to differences in larval nutrition. Our third major finding is the differential expression in a primitively eusocial paper wasp of some of the same genes and peptides/proteins that are implicated in worker/queen developmental divergence in highly eusocial bees. Our data therefore suggest that caste regulatory mechanisms in advanced eusocial Hymenoptera with dimorphic worker and queen castes are foreshadowed by mechanisms affecting divergence onto two developmental pathways in monomorphic primitively eusocial Hymenoptera. We propose that larval pathway divergence, as exemplified by Polistes, may also have been the foundation for caste divergence in more derived eusocial forms.
In conclusion, our data add a new dimension of support for the larval divergence hypothesis. Quantification of differential gene expression and protein abundance between larvae that could correspond to the two developmental classes has heretofore been a missing link between a possible environmental trigger and a consequent response of larval divergence. Although not conclusive, our results indicate that differential larval nourishment may be the environmental trigger and that differential activity of the physiological machinery that regulates diapause-derived circuits may be the consequent response. Taken collectively, our results point the way to multiple avenues of genomic and proteomic inquiry into the regulation of the worker/gyne phenotype divergence, not only in Polistes paper wasps but also in other eusocial Hymenoptera. We believe that such research can contribute significantly to a broad and clear understanding of the evolutionary origin of caste in eusocial insects and its regulation by nutrition, hormones, genes, and proteins.
Specimen identities, rearing conditions (FR = foundress-reared; WR = worker-reared); collection date, nest identities, and field site where collected. Field sites: Shaw = Shaw Nature Reserve near Gray Summit, Washington Co, Missouri; Tyson = Tyson Research Station near Eureka, St. Louis Co., Missouri. Specimen identities and nest numbers correspond to J. H. Hunt's field notes. The 2005 specimens were ancillary to a larger research project . Nests were not used in the other study, and they were undisturbed after marking the foundress with a dot of paint until the dates of specimen collections. Each nest was collected en toto, rendering impossible the collection of FR and WR specimens from the same nest. Specimens for this study were restricted to large fifth-instar larvae that were of a size that soon would begin spinning their pupal cocoon. The middle letter of each specimen ID (e.g., C, E, H) indicates the colony of origin. The 2007 specimens were not part of a larger project, hence the different notation. Each FR specimen in 2007 came from a different nest. Several specimens were not included in the analyses for the reasons given. “Data outlier” indicates that the expression values for all genes were approximately 2X higher than for the other samples, thus the samples were clear outliers. Because specimens were numbered beginning with 1 for the largest larva and then in descending sequence by size, numbers 12 and 16 for the data outliers indicate that they were earlier in development than other larvae in the study. Exclusion of these samples decreased, rather than increased, significance values of statistical tests (data not shown). 1. Hunt JH, Kensinger BA, Kossuth J, Henshaw MT, Norberg K, et al. (2007) From casteless to castes - a diapause pathway underlies the gyne phenotype in Polistes paper wasps. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 104: 14020-14025.
(0.06 MB DOC)
Forward (FW) and reverse (RV) primer sequences for each putative gene used for quantitative real-time rtPCR of 5th instar larvae of Polistes metricus.
(0.06 MB DOC)
Results of statistical comparisons of mRNA abundance for the 38 tested genes, comparing FR (foundress reared) and WR (worker reared) larvae. Genes significantly different between larval categories are in bold. “lm” indicates linear model ANOVA; “MWU” indicates Mann-Whitney U test.
(0.06 MB DOC)
Microsatellite genotypes for worker reared (WR) P. metricus larvae. Larvae found to be heterozygous at one or more loci must be diploid, and thus female, while larvae that have only one allele at each locus are potentially male and were excluded from analyses.
(0.11 MB DOC)
Peptides/proteins used in the MWU-test. Criteria for using a peptide/protein: spectrum count of at least 3 present for at least 3 out of 5 replicates. N = 5 samples per group. Note that the table contains redundant data. Peptides can match to different databases (Apis, Nasonia, Polistes contigs) and isoform sequences. Also, two different kinds of experiments were run. Several contigs can belong to the same protein. For some contigs peptides matched to more than one reading frame (can be distinguished by the Accession number). Red font = results from in-solution digestion. Black font = results from in-gel digestion. p-value = bootstrap analysis (1000 iterations) verified validity, i.e. probability of Type I error is not inflated by multiple comparisons.
(0.11 MB DOC)
Navdeep S. Mutti was actively involved in this research, but his contribution has been transferred to a separate publication. We are grateful for his participation, and we especially thank him for his patience through the long gestation of this project and manuscript. We also thank Bart J. Kensinger, Jessie A. Kossuth, and Jesse A. J. Hunt for assistance with field work; Patricia Hester for assistance with proteomics sample preparation; Larry Mandarino and Zhengping Yi for providing access to the MS facilities; Fernando E. Miguez for advice on statistical analyses; Gene E. Robinson for use of laboratory facilities and equipment and for helpful discussions; the North Carolina State University social insects lunch bunch for review of the manuscript, two anonymous reviewers for particularly helpful comments, and the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center (NESCent) for JHH's support during manuscript revision.
Conceived and designed the experiments: JHH FW. Performed the experiments: JHH FW MTH. Analyzed the data: FW MTH AT GVA. Wrote the paper: JHH FW MTH AT GVA. Searched Apis mellifera genome for sequence matches to candidate genes: TCN. Designed primers for Polistes metricus: TCN.
- 1. Hölldobler B, Wilson EO (1990) The ants. Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. B. HölldoblerEO Wilson1990The ants.CambridgeBelknap Press of Harvard University Pressxii +732
- 2. Michener CD (1974) The social behavior of the bees: A comparative study. Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. CD Michener1974The social behavior of the bees: A comparative study.CambridgeBelknap Press of Harvard University Pressxii +404
- 3. Wilson EO (1971) The insect societies. Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. EO Wilson1971The insect societies.CambridgeBelknap Press of Harvard University Pressx +548
- 4. Greene A (1991) Dolichovespula and Vespula. In: Ross KG, Matthews RW, editors. The social biology of wasps. Ithaca: Comstock Publishing Associates, Cornell University Press. pp. 263–305.A. Greene1991Dolichovespula and Vespula.KG RossRW MatthewsThe social biology of waspsIthacaComstock Publishing Associates, Cornell University Press263305
- 5. Matsuura M (1991) Vespa and Provespa. In: Ross KG, Matthews RW, editors. The social biology of wasps. Ithaca: Comstock Publishing Associates, Cornell University Press. pp. 232–262.M. Matsuura1991Vespa and Provespa.KG RossRW MatthewsThe social biology of waspsIthacaComstock Publishing Associates, Cornell University Press232262
- 6. Noll FB, Wenzel JW, Zucchi R (2004) Evolution of caste in Neotropical swarm-founding wasps (Hymenoptera: Vespidae; Epiponini). American Museum Novitates 3467: 1–24.FB NollJW WenzelR. Zucchi2004Evolution of caste in Neotropical swarm-founding wasps (Hymenoptera: Vespidae; Epiponini).American Museum Novitates3467124
- 7. Batra SWT (1966) Nests and social behavior of halictine bees of India. Indian Journal of Entomology 28: 375–393.SWT Batra1966Nests and social behavior of halictine bees of India.Indian Journal of Entomology28375393
- 8. Sullivan JD, Strassmann JE (1984) Physical variability among nest foundresses in the polygynous social wasp, Polistes annularis. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 15: 249–256.JD SullivanJE Strassmann1984Physical variability among nest foundresses in the polygynous social wasp, Polistes annularis.Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology15249256
- 9. Hunt JH (2007) The evolution of social wasps. New York: Oxford University Press. JH Hunt2007The evolution of social wasps.New YorkOxford University Pressxxi +259
- 10. O'Donnell S (1998) Reproductive caste determination in eusocial wasps (Hymenoptera: Vespidae). Annual Review of Entomology 43: 323–346.S. O'Donnell1998Reproductive caste determination in eusocial wasps (Hymenoptera: Vespidae).Annual Review of Entomology43323346
- 11. Reeve HK (2001) In search of unified theories in sociobiology: Help from social wasps. In: Dugatkin LA, editor. Model Systems in Behavioral Ecology. Princeton: Princeton University Press. pp. 57–71.HK Reeve2001In search of unified theories in sociobiology: Help from social wasps.LA DugatkinModel Systems in Behavioral EcologyPrincetonPrinceton University Press5771
- 12. Wheeler DE (1986) Developmental and physiological determinants of caste in social Hymenoptera: evolutionary implications. The American Naturalist 128: 13–34.DE Wheeler1986Developmental and physiological determinants of caste in social Hymenoptera: evolutionary implications.The American Naturalist1281334
- 13. Sumner S, Kelstrup H, Fanelli D (2010) Reproductive constraints, direct fitness and indirect fitness benefits explain helping behaviour in the primitively eusocial wasp, Polistes canadensis. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 277: 1721–1728.S. SumnerH. KelstrupD. Fanelli2010Reproductive constraints, direct fitness and indirect fitness benefits explain helping behaviour in the primitively eusocial wasp, Polistes canadensis.Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B27717211728
- 14. Marchal P (1897) La castration nutriciale chez les Hyménoptères sociaux. Comptes rendus des séances de la Société de Biologie (Paris) 1897: 556–557.P. Marchal1897La castration nutriciale chez les Hyménoptères sociaux.Comptes rendus des séances de la Société de Biologie (Paris)1897556557
- 15. Pardi L (1948) Dominance order in Polistes wasps. Physiological Zoology 21: 1–13.L. Pardi1948Dominance order in Polistes wasps.Physiological Zoology21113
- 16. West Eberhard MJ (1969) The social biology of polistine wasps. Miscellaneous Publications, Museum of Zoology, University of Michigan 140: 1–101.MJ West Eberhard1969The social biology of polistine wasps.Miscellaneous Publications, Museum of Zoology, University of Michigan1401101
- 17. Reeve HK (1991) Polistes. In: Ross KG, Matthews RW, editors. The social biology of wasps. Ithaca: Comstock Publishing Associates, Cornell University Press. pp. 99–148.HK Reeve1991Polistes.KG RossRW MatthewsThe social biology of waspsIthacaComstock Publishing Associates, Cornell University Press99148
- 18. Reeve HK, Peters JM, Nonacs P, Starks PT (1998) Dispersal of first “workers” in social wasps: casuses and implications of an alternative reproductive strategy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 95: 13737–13742.HK ReeveJM PetersP. NonacsPT Starks1998Dispersal of first “workers” in social wasps: casuses and implications of an alternative reproductive strategy.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA951373713742
- 19. Cini A, Dapporto L (2009) Atumnal helpers of Polistes dominulus represent a distinct behavioural phenotype. Annales Zoologici Fennici 46: 423–430.A. CiniL. Dapporto2009Atumnal helpers of Polistes dominulus represent a distinct behavioural phenotype.Annales Zoologici Fennici46423430
- 20. Dapporto L, Palagi E, Turillazzi S (2005) Sociality outside the nest: helpers in pre-hibernating clusters of Polistes dominulus. Annales Zoologici Fennici 42: 135–139.L. DapportoE. PalagiS. Turillazzi2005Sociality outside the nest: helpers in pre-hibernating clusters of Polistes dominulus.Annales Zoologici Fennici42135139
- 21. Hunt JH, Amdam GV (2005) Bivoltinism as an antecedent to eusociality in the paper wasp genus Polistes. Science 308: 264–267.JH HuntGV Amdam2005Bivoltinism as an antecedent to eusociality in the paper wasp genus Polistes.Science308264267
- 22. Alam SM (1958) Some interesting revelations about the nest of Polistes hebroeus Fabr. (Vespidae, Hymenoptera) - the common yellow wasp of India. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of Calcutta 11: 113–122.SM Alam1958Some interesting revelations about the nest of Polistes hebroeus Fabr. (Vespidae, Hymenoptera) - the common yellow wasp of India.Proceedings of the Zoological Society of Calcutta11113122
- 23. Kundu HL (1967) Observations on Polistes hebraeus (Hymenoptera). Birla Institute of Technological Science, Journal (Pilani) 1: 152–161.HL Kundu1967Observations on Polistes hebraeus (Hymenoptera).Birla Institute of Technological Science, Journal (Pilani)1152161
- 24. Keeping MG (2002) Reproductive and worker castes in the primitively eusocial wasp Belonogaster petiolata (DeGeer) (Hymenoptera: Vespidae): evidence for pre-imaginal differentiation. Journal of Insect Physiology 48: 867–879.MG Keeping2002Reproductive and worker castes in the primitively eusocial wasp Belonogaster petiolata (DeGeer) (Hymenoptera: Vespidae): evidence for pre-imaginal differentiation.Journal of Insect Physiology48867879
- 25. Wenzel JW (1992) Extreme queen-worker dimorphism in Ropalidia ignobilis, a small-colony wasp (Hymenoptera: Vespidae). Insectes Sociaux 39: 31–43.JW Wenzel1992Extreme queen-worker dimorphism in Ropalidia ignobilis, a small-colony wasp (Hymenoptera: Vespidae).Insectes Sociaux393143
- 26. Gadagkar R, Bhagavan S, Chandrashekara K, Vinutha C (1991) The role of larval nutrition in pre-imaginal biasing of caste in the primitively eusocial wasp Ropalidia marginata (Hymenoptera: Vespidae). Ecological Entomology 16: 435–440.R. GadagkarS. BhagavanK. ChandrashekaraC. Vinutha1991The role of larval nutrition in pre-imaginal biasing of caste in the primitively eusocial wasp Ropalidia marginata (Hymenoptera: Vespidae).Ecological Entomology16435440
- 27. Gadagkar R, Bhagavan S, Malpe R, Vinutha C (1990) On reconfirming the evidence for pre-imaginal caste bias in a primitively eusocial wasp. Proceedings of the Indian Academy of Sciences (Animal Science) 99: 141–150.R. GadagkarS. BhagavanR. MalpeC. Vinutha1990On reconfirming the evidence for pre-imaginal caste bias in a primitively eusocial wasp.Proceedings of the Indian Academy of Sciences (Animal Science)99141150
- 28. Gadagkar R, Vinutha C A S, Gore AP (1988) Pre-imaginal biasing of caste in a primitively eusocial insect. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 233: 175–189.R. GadagkarS. Vinutha C AAP Gore1988Pre-imaginal biasing of caste in a primitively eusocial insect.Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B233175189
- 29. Eickwort K (1969) Separation of the castes of Polistes exclamans and notes on its biology (Hym.: Vespidae). Insectes Sociaux 16: 67–72.K. Eickwort1969Separation of the castes of Polistes exclamans and notes on its biology (Hym.: Vespidae).Insectes Sociaux166772
- 30. Strassmann JE, Lee RE, Rojas RR, Baust JG (1984) Caste and sex differences in cold-hardiness in the social wasps, Polistes annularis and Polistes exclamans (Hymenoptera, Vespidae). Insectes Sociaux 31: 291–301.JE StrassmannRE LeeRR RojasJG Baust1984Caste and sex differences in cold-hardiness in the social wasps, Polistes annularis and Polistes exclamans (Hymenoptera, Vespidae).Insectes Sociaux31291301
- 31. Karsai I, Hunt JH (2002) Food quantity affects traits of offspring in the paper wasp Polistes metricus (Hymenoptera: Vespidae). Environmental Entomology 31: 99–106.I. KarsaiJH Hunt2002Food quantity affects traits of offspring in the paper wasp Polistes metricus (Hymenoptera: Vespidae).Environmental Entomology3199106
- 32. Toth AL, Bilof KBJ, Henshaw MT, Hunt JH, Robinson GE (2009) Lipid stores, ovary development, and brain gene expression in Polistes females. Insectes Sociaux 56: 77–84.AL TothKBJ BilofMT HenshawJH HuntGE Robinson2009Lipid stores, ovary development, and brain gene expression in Polistes females.Insectes Sociaux567784
- 33. Toth AL, Varala K, Newman TC, Miguez FE, Hutchison S, et al. (2007) Wasp gene expression supports an evolutionary link between maternal behavior and eusociality. Science 318: 441–444.AL TothK. VaralaTC NewmanFE MiguezS. Hutchison2007Wasp gene expression supports an evolutionary link between maternal behavior and eusociality.Science318441444
- 34. Toth AL, Varala K, Henshaw MT, Rodriguez-Zas S, Hudson ME, et al. (2010) Brain transcriptomic analysis in paper wasps identifies genes associated with behavior across social insect lineages. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B. AL TothK. VaralaMT HenshawS. Rodriguez-ZasME Hudson2010Brain transcriptomic analysis in paper wasps identifies genes associated with behavior across social insect lineages.Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B
- 35. Bohm MK (1972) Effects of environment and juvenile hormone on ovaries of the wasp, Polistes metricus. Journal of Insect Physiology 18: 1875–1883.MK Bohm1972Effects of environment and juvenile hormone on ovaries of the wasp, Polistes metricus.Journal of Insect Physiology1818751883
- 36. Wolschin F, Amdam GV (2007) Comparative proteomics reveal characteristics of life-history transitions in a social insect. Proteome Science 5: Article #10.F. WolschinGV Amdam2007Comparative proteomics reveal characteristics of life-history transitions in a social insect.Proteome Science5Article #10
- 37. Hunt JH, Kensinger BA, Kossuth J, Henshaw MT, Norberg K, et al. (2007) From casteless to castes – a diapause pathway underlies the gyne phenotype in Polistes paper wasps. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 104: 14020–14025.JH HuntBA KensingerJ. KossuthMT HenshawK. Norberg2007From casteless to castes – a diapause pathway underlies the gyne phenotype in Polistes paper wasps.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA1041402014025
- 38. Heimpel GE, de Boer JG (2008) Sex determination in the Hymenoptera. Annual Review of Entomology 53: 209–230.GE HeimpelJG de Boer2008Sex determination in the Hymenoptera.Annual Review of Entomology53209230
- 39. Liebert AE, Johnson RN, Switz GT, Starks PT (2004) Triploid females and diploid males: underreported phenomena in Polistes wasps? Insectes Sociaux 51: 205–211.AE LiebertRN JohnsonGT SwitzPT Starks2004Triploid females and diploid males: underreported phenomena in Polistes wasps?Insectes Sociaux51205211
- 40. Toth AL, Varala K, Henshaw MT, Rodriguez-Zas SL, Hudson ME, et al. (2010) Brain transcriptomic analysis in paper wasps identifies genes associated with behaviour across social insect lineages. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B. AL TothK. VaralaMT HenshawSL Rodriguez-ZasME Hudson2010Brain transcriptomic analysis in paper wasps identifies genes associated with behaviour across social insect lineages.Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B
- 41. Hunt JH, Buck NA, Wheeler DE (2003) Storage proteins in vespid wasps: characterization, developmental pattern, and occurrence in adults. Journal of Insect Physiology 49: 785–794.JH HuntNA BuckDE Wheeler2003Storage proteins in vespid wasps: characterization, developmental pattern, and occurrence in adults.Journal of Insect Physiology49785794
- 42. Ben-Shahar Y, Leung HT, Pak WL, Sokolowski MB, Robinson GE (2003) cGMP-dependent changes in phototaxis: a possible role for the foraging gene in honey bee division of labor. Journal of Experimental Biology 206: 2507–2515.Y. Ben-ShaharHT LeungWL PakMB SokolowskiGE Robinson2003cGMP-dependent changes in phototaxis: a possible role for the foraging gene in honey bee division of labor.Journal of Experimental Biology20625072515
- 43. Corona M, Velarde RA, Remolina S, Moran-Lauter A, Wang Y, et al. (2007) Vitellogenin, juvenile hormone, insulin signaling, and queen honey bee longevity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 104: 7128–7133.M. CoronaRA VelardeS. RemolinaA. Moran-LauterY. Wang2007Vitellogenin, juvenile hormone, insulin signaling, and queen honey bee longevity.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA10471287133
- 44. Ament SA, Corona M, Pollock HS, Robinson GE (2008) Insulin signaling is involved in the regulation of worker division of labor in honey bee colonies. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 105: 4226–4231.SA AmentM. CoronaHS PollockGE Robinson2008Insulin signaling is involved in the regulation of worker division of labor in honey bee colonies.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA10542264231
- 45. Whitfield CW, Cziko AM, Robinson GE (2003) Gene expression profiles in the brain predict behavior in individual honey bees. Science 302: 296–299.CW WhitfieldAM CzikoGE Robinson2003Gene expression profiles in the brain predict behavior in individual honey bees.Science302296299
- 46. Evans JD, Wheeler DE (1999) Differential gene expression between developing queens and workers in the honey bee, Apis mellifera. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 96: 5575–5580.JD EvansDE Wheeler1999Differential gene expression between developing queens and workers in the honey bee, Apis mellifera.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA9655755580
- 47. Corona M, Estrada E, Zurita M (1999) Differential expression of mitochondrial genes between queens and workers during caste determination in the honeybee Apis mellifera. The Journal of Experimental Biology 202: M. CoronaE. EstradaM. Zurita1999Differential expression of mitochondrial genes between queens and workers during caste determination in the honeybee Apis mellifera.The Journal of Experimental Biology202
- 48. Wheeler DE, Buck N, Evans JD (2006) Expression of insulin pathway genes during the period of caste determination in the honey bee, Apis mellifera. Insect Molecular Biology 15: 597–602.DE WheelerN. BuckJD Evans2006Expression of insulin pathway genes during the period of caste determination in the honey bee, Apis mellifera.Insect Molecular Biology15597602
- 49. Patel A, Fondrk MK, Kaftanoglu O, Emore C, Hunt G, et al. (2007) The making of a queen: TOR pathway is a key player in diphenic caste development. PLoS ONE 2(6): e509.A. PatelMK FondrkO. KaftanogluC. EmoreG. Hunt2007The making of a queen: TOR pathway is a key player in diphenic caste development.PLoS ONE2(6)e509
- 50. Altschul SF, Gish W, Miller W, Myers EW, Lipman DJ (1990) Basic logical alignment search tool. Journal of Molecular Biology 215: 403–410.SF AltschulW. GishW. MillerEW MyersDJ Lipman1990Basic logical alignment search tool.Journal of Molecular Biology215403410
- 51. Wessel D, Flugge UI (1984) A method for the quantitative recovery of protein in dilute solution in the presence of detergents and lipids. Analytical Biochemistry 138: 141–143.D. WesselUI Flugge1984A method for the quantitative recovery of protein in dilute solution in the presence of detergents and lipids.Analytical Biochemistry138141143
- 52. Wolschin F, Amdam GV (2007) Plasticity and robustness of protein patterns during reversible development in the honey bee (Apis mellifera). Analytical and Bioanalitical Chemistry 389: 1095–1100.F. WolschinGV Amdam2007Plasticity and robustness of protein patterns during reversible development in the honey bee (Apis mellifera).Analytical and Bioanalitical Chemistry38910951100
- 53. Geer LY, Markey SP, Kowalak JA, Wagner L, Xu M, et al. (2004) Open mass spectrometry search algorithm. Journal of Proteome Research 3: 958–964.LY GeerSP MarkeyJA KowalakL. WagnerM. Xu2004Open mass spectrometry search algorithm.Journal of Proteome Research3958964
- 54. Wolschin F, Gadau J (2009) Deciphering proteomic signatures of early diapause in Nasonia. PLoS ONE 4: e6394.F. WolschinJ. Gadau2009Deciphering proteomic signatures of early diapause in Nasonia.PLoS ONE4e6394
- 55. Wolschin F, Munch D, Amdam GV (2009) Structural and proteomic analyses reveal regional brain differences during honeybee aging. Journal of Experimental Biology 212: 4027–4032.F. WolschinD. MunchGV Amdam2009Structural and proteomic analyses reveal regional brain differences during honeybee aging.Journal of Experimental Biology21240274032
- 56. Hunt JH, Dove MA (2002) Nourishment affects colony demographics in the paper wasp Polistes metricus. Ecological Entomology 27: 467–474.JH HuntMA Dove2002Nourishment affects colony demographics in the paper wasp Polistes metricus.Ecological Entomology27467474
- 57. Rossi AM, Hunt JH (1988) Honey supplementation and its developmental consequences: evidence for food limitation in a paper wasp, Polistes metricus. Ecological Entomology 13: 437–442.AM RossiJH Hunt1988Honey supplementation and its developmental consequences: evidence for food limitation in a paper wasp, Polistes metricus.Ecological Entomology13437442
- 58. Gygi SP, Rochon Y, Franza BR, Aebersold R (1999) Correlation between protein and mRNA abundance in yeast. Molecular Cell Biology 19: 1720–1730.SP GygiY. RochonBR FranzaR. Aebersold1999Correlation between protein and mRNA abundance in yeast.Molecular Cell Biology1917201730
- 59. Amdam GV, Norberg K, Hagen A, Omholt SW (2003) Social exploitation of vitellogenin. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 100: 1799–1802.GV AmdamK. NorbergA. HagenSW Omholt2003Social exploitation of vitellogenin.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA10017991802
- 60. Amdam GV, Norberg K, Fondrk MK, Page RE Jr (2004) Reproductive ground plan may mediate colony-level selection effects on individual foraging behavior in honey bees. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 101: 11350–11355.GV AmdamK. NorbergMK FondrkRE Page Jr2004Reproductive ground plan may mediate colony-level selection effects on individual foraging behavior in honey bees.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA1011135011355
- 61. Page RE, Amdam GV (2007) The making of a social insect: developmental architectures of social design. BioEssays 29: 334–343.RE PageGV Amdam2007The making of a social insect: developmental architectures of social design.BioEssays29334343
- 62. Flannagan RD, Tammariello SP, Joplin KH, Cikra-Ireland RA, Yocum GD, et al. (1998) Diapause-specific gene expression in pupae of the flesh fly Sarcophaga crassipalpis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 95: 5616–5620.RD FlannaganSP TammarielloKH JoplinRA Cikra-IrelandGD Yocum1998Diapause-specific gene expression in pupae of the flesh fly Sarcophaga crassipalpis.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA9556165620
- 63. Rinehart JP, Denlinger DL (2000) Heat-shock protein 90 is down-regulated during pupal diapause in the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis, but remains responsive to thermal stress. Insect Molecular Biology 9: 641–645.JP RinehartDL Denlinger2000Heat-shock protein 90 is down-regulated during pupal diapause in the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis, but remains responsive to thermal stress.Insect Molecular Biology9641645
- 64. Yocum GD, Joplin KH, Denlinger DL (1998) Upregulation of a 23 kDa small heat shock protein transcript during pupal diapause in the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis. Insect Biochemistry and Molecular Biology 28: 677–682.GD YocumKH JoplinDL Denlinger1998Upregulation of a 23 kDa small heat shock protein transcript during pupal diapause in the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis.Insect Biochemistry and Molecular Biology28677682
- 65. Yocum GD (2001) Differential expression of two HSP70 transcripts in response to cold shock, thermoperiod, and adult diapause in the Colorado potato beetle. Journal of Insect Physiology 47: 1139–1145.GD Yocum2001Differential expression of two HSP70 transcripts in response to cold shock, thermoperiod, and adult diapause in the Colorado potato beetle.Journal of Insect Physiology4711391145
- 66. Rinehart JP, Yocum GD, Denlinger DL (2000) Developmental upregulation of inducible hsp70 transcripts, but not the cognate form, during pupal diapause in the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis. Insect Biochemistry and Molecular Biology 30: 515–521.JP RinehartGD YocumDL Denlinger2000Developmental upregulation of inducible hsp70 transcripts, but not the cognate form, during pupal diapause in the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis.Insect Biochemistry and Molecular Biology30515521
- 67. Lewis DK, Spurgeon D, Sappington TW, Keeley LL (2002) A hexamerin protein, AgSP-1, is associated with diapause in the boll weevil. Journal of Insect Physiology 48: 887–901.DK LewisD. SpurgeonTW SappingtonLL Keeley2002A hexamerin protein, AgSP-1, is associated with diapause in the boll weevil.Journal of Insect Physiology48887901
- 68. Denlinger DL (2002) Regulation of diapause. Annual Review of Entomology 47: 93–122.DL Denlinger2002Regulation of diapause.Annual Review of Entomology4793122
- 69. Williams KD, Busto M, Suster ML, So AK-C, Ben-Shahar Y, et al. (2006) Natural variation in Drosophila melanogaster diapause due to the insulin-regulated PI3-kinase. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 103: 15911–15915.KD WilliamsM. BustoML SusterAK-C SoY. Ben-Shahar2006Natural variation in Drosophila melanogaster diapause due to the insulin-regulated PI3-kinase.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA1031591115915
- 70. Sim C, Denlinger DL (2009) A shut-down in expression of an insulin-like peptide, ILP-1, halts ovarian maturation during the overwintering diapause of the mosquito Culex pipiens. Insect Molecular Biology 18: 325–332.C. SimDL Denlinger2009A shut-down in expression of an insulin-like peptide, ILP-1, halts ovarian maturation during the overwintering diapause of the mosquito Culex pipiens.Insect Molecular Biology18325332
- 71. Sim C, Denlinger DL (2008) Insulin signaling and FOXO regulate the overwintering diapause of the mosquito Culex pipiens. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 105: 6777–6781.C. SimDL Denlinger2008Insulin signaling and FOXO regulate the overwintering diapause of the mosquito Culex pipiens.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA10567776781
- 72. Pereboom JJM, Jordan WC, Sumner S, Hammond RL, Bourke AFG (2005) Differential gene expression in queen-worker caste determination in bumble-bees. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 272: 1145–11562.JJM PereboomWC JordanS. SumnerRL HammondAFG Bourke2005Differential gene expression in queen-worker caste determination in bumble-bees.Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B272114511562
- 73. Sumner S, Pereboom JJM, Jordan WC (2006) Differential gene expression and phenotypic plasticity in behavioural castes of the primitively eusocial wasp, Polistes canadensis. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 273: 19–26.S. SumnerJJM PereboomWC Jordan2006Differential gene expression and phenotypic plasticity in behavioural castes of the primitively eusocial wasp, Polistes canadensis.Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B2731926
- 74. Kawamura K, Shibata T, Saget O, Peel D, Bryant PJ (1999) A new family of growth factors produced by the fat body and active on Drosophila imaginal disc cells. Development 126: 211–219.K. KawamuraT. ShibataO. SagetD. PeelPJ Bryant1999A new family of growth factors produced by the fat body and active on Drosophila imaginal disc cells.Development126211219
- 75. Sweeney NT, Brenman JE, Jan YN, Gao FB (2006) The coiled-coil protein shrub controls neuronal morphogenesis in Drosophila. Current Biology 16: 1006–1011.NT SweeneyJE BrenmanYN JanFB Gao2006The coiled-coil protein shrub controls neuronal morphogenesis in Drosophila.Current Biology1610061011
- 76. Van der Horst DJ, Roosendaal SD, Rodenburg KW (2009) Circulatory lipid transport: lipoprotein assembly and function from an evolutionary perspective. Molecular and Cellular Biochemistry 326: 105–119.DJ Van der HorstSD RoosendaalKW Rodenburg2009Circulatory lipid transport: lipoprotein assembly and function from an evolutionary perspective.Molecular and Cellular Biochemistry326105119
- 77. Hunt JH, Brodie RJ, Carithers TP, Goldstein PZ, Janzen DH (1999) Dry season migration by Costa Rican lowland paper wasps to high elevation cold dormancy sites. Biotropica 31: 192–196.JH HuntRJ BrodieTP CarithersPZ GoldsteinDH Janzen1999Dry season migration by Costa Rican lowland paper wasps to high elevation cold dormancy sites.Biotropica31192196
- 78. Gobbi N, Noll FB, Penna MAH (2006) “Winter” aggregations, colony cycle, and seasonal phenotypic change in the paper wasp Polistes versicolor in Brazil. Naturwissenschaften 93: 487–494.N. GobbiFB NollMAH Penna2006“Winter” aggregations, colony cycle, and seasonal phenotypic change in the paper wasp Polistes versicolor in Brazil.Naturwissenschaften93487494
- 79. Hoffman EA, Goodisman MAD (2007) Gene expression and the evolution of phenotypic diversity in social wasps. BMC Biology 5: 23.EA HoffmanMAD Goodisman2007Gene expression and the evolution of phenotypic diversity in social wasps.BMC Biology523
- 80. Judd TM, Magnus RM, Fasnacht MP (2010) A nutritional profile of the social wasp Polistes metricus: Differences in nutrient levels between castes and changes within castes during the annual life cycle. Journal of Insect Physiology 56: 42–56.TM JuddRM MagnusMP Fasnacht2010A nutritional profile of the social wasp Polistes metricus: Differences in nutrient levels between castes and changes within castes during the annual life cycle.Journal of Insect Physiology564256
- 81. Mead F, Pratte M (2002) Prey supplementation increases productivity in the social wasp Polistes dominulus Christ (Hymenoptera Vespidae). Ethology Ecology & Evolution 14: 111–128.F. MeadM. Pratte2002Prey supplementation increases productivity in the social wasp Polistes dominulus Christ (Hymenoptera Vespidae).Ethology Ecology & Evolution14111128
- 82. Winston ML (1987) The biology of the honey bee. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. ML Winston1987The biology of the honey bee.CambridgeHarvard University Pressxiii +281
- 83. Judice CC, Carazzole MF, Festa F, Sogayar MC, Hartfelder K, et al. (2006) Gene expression profiles underlying alternative caste phenotypes in a highly eusocial bee, Melipona quadrifasciata. Insect Molecular Biology 15: 33–44.CC JudiceMF CarazzoleF. FestaMC SogayarK. Hartfelder2006Gene expression profiles underlying alternative caste phenotypes in a highly eusocial bee, Melipona quadrifasciata.Insect Molecular Biology153344
- 84. Barchuk AR, Cristino AS, Kucharski R, Costa LF, Simões ZLP, et al. (2007) Molecular determinants of caste differentiation in the highly eusocial honeybee Apis mellifera. BMC Developmental Biology 2007 7: 70.AR BarchukAS CristinoR. KucharskiLF CostaZLP Simões2007Molecular determinants of caste differentiation in the highly eusocial honeybee Apis mellifera.BMC Developmental Biology2007 770
- 85. Hayward SAL, Pavlides SC, Tammariello SP, Rinehart JP, Denlinger DL (2005) Temporal expression patterns of diapause-associated genes in flesh fly pupae from the onset of diapause through post-diapause quiescence. Journal of Insect Physiology 51: 631–640.SAL HaywardSC PavlidesSP TammarielloJP RinehartDL Denlinger2005Temporal expression patterns of diapause-associated genes in flesh fly pupae from the onset of diapause through post-diapause quiescence.Journal of Insect Physiology51631640