The epidemiology and possibly the etiology of bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) have recently been recognized to be heterogeneous. In particular, three types [classical (C) and two atypical (H, L)] have been identified, largely on the basis of characteristics of the proteinase K (PK)-resistant core of the misfolded prion protein associated with the disease (PrPres). The present study was conducted to characterize the 17 Canadian BSE cases which occurred prior to November 2009 based on the molecular and biochemical properties of their PrPres, including immunoreactivity, molecular weight, glycoform profile and relative PK sensitivity. Two cases exhibited molecular weight and glycoform profiles similar to those of previously reported atypical cases, one corresponding to H-type BSE (case 6) and the other to L-type BSE (case 11). All other cases were classified as C-type. PK digestion under mild and stringent conditions revealed a reduced protease resistance in both of these cases compared to the C-type cases. With Western immunoblotting, N-terminal-specific antibodies bound to PrPres from case 6 but not to that from case 11 or C-type cases. C-terminal-specific antibodies revealed a shift in the glycoform profile and detected a fourth protein fragment in case 6, indicative of two PrPres subpopulations in H-type BSE. No mutations suggesting a genetic etiology were found in any of the 17 animals by sequencing the full PrP-coding sequence in exon 3 of the PRNP gene. Thus, each of the three known BSE types have been confirmed in Canadian cattle and show molecular characteristics highly similar to those of classical and atypical BSE cases described from Europe, Japan and the USA. The occurrence of atypical cases of BSE in countries such as Canada with low BSE prevalence and transmission risk argues for the occurrence of sporadic forms of BSE worldwide.
Citation: Dudas S, Yang J, Graham C, Czub M, McAllister TA, Coulthart MB, et al. (2010) Molecular, Biochemical and Genetic Characteristics of BSE in Canada. PLoS ONE5(5): e10638. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0010638
Editor: Carles Lalueza-Fox, Institute of Evolutionary Biology (CSIC-UPF), Spain
Received: February 9, 2010; Accepted: April 21, 2010; Published: May 14, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Dudas et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Funding for this project was provided by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. The funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Prion diseases are invariably fatal neurological diseases that usually cause severe spongiform change in the brain associated with an accumulation of a misfolded isoform of the prion protein (PrPSc) . This misfolded isoform is conformationally distinct from the cellular prion protein (PrPC) and exhibits a feature important for diagnostic purposes – the partial resistance to proteinase K (PK) digestion. The PK-resistant core of PrPSc is denoted as PrPres . PrPres is often used for the detection of prion diseases, and its molecular features are useful to characterize the type of prion disease in individual cases. PrPres displays both variation in molecular size of the residual protein core, based on variation in the location of PK cleavage sites, and micro heterogeneity based on differential occupancy of two N-linked glycosylation sites in PrP. This leads to di-, mono- and unglycosylated protein subpopulations (glycoforms) that can vary in relative abundance as assessed by their reactivities on Western immunoblots. Variation in PK cleavage also results in changes in immunoreactivity profile of PrPres, as key epitopes may be present or absent in the PK-resistant core. Different prion disease types may also vary in PrPres conformational stability , .
Until recently, it was widely assumed that bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in cattle consisted of only a single, epidemiologically and biologically homogeneous type. This was based largely on the fact that experimental transmissions of the BSE agent to laboratory mice yielded a uniform lesion profile in the brain with invariable incubation time, irrespective of the source of BSE inoculum, but also on uniformity of PrPres characteristics –. The lesion profiles and incubation times in these mice were also undistinguishable from those seen in mice inoculated with human variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD). The PrPres from these patients and animals also showed similar molecular weights and glycoform profiles, using Western blot (WB) analyses , . These results strongly suggested that BSE was caused by a single strain of agent, and that exposure to the BSE agent was the most likely cause of human vCJD , .
However, in 2004, two new “atypical” types of BSE were identified in Italy and France. The Italian type was named bovine amyloidotic spongiform encephalopathy (BASE), because of the unusual and widespread occurrence of PrPSc-containing amyloid plaques in brain tissue . Molecular characterization of the PrPres from these cases revealed a more equal ratio of immunoreactivities for di- and monoglycosylated glycoforms and a lower molecular weight of the unglycosylated glycoform than seen in previous BSE cases. Thus indicating a different PK-cleavage site and supporting the notion of a novel prion disease type. The lower molecular weight also prompted designation of such cases as “L-type” BSE, as distinct from classical or “C-type” BSE. The French type had a distinctly higher molecular weight of PrPres bands compared to C-type BSE resulting in it being called high or “H-type” BSE . At least one of these two types of BSE, together known as atypical BSE, have since been detected in Germany , Japan , the Netherlands , Poland , Sweden , Switzerland , the United Kingdom  and the United States ; all in cattle 8 years of age and older. Two as-yet-unclassified cases of atypical BSE have also been reported in Japan and Belgium , .
Experiments with atypical H- and L-type isolates have demonstrated their transmissibility to cattle as well as to mice expressing the bovine prion protein and wild-type mice. These isolates clearly differ from C-type BSE because they display unique incubation periods, PrPres deposition patterns, and patterns of histological lesions , , . While the C-type BSE cases that occurred as part of the outbreak in the U.K., Europe, Japan and Canada were believed to be caused by the consumption of contaminated feedstuffs , the origins of H- and L-type BSE are unknown. It has been speculated that atypical BSE may be sporadic or genetically caused, and indeed, strong evidence for a causative role of high-penetrance genetic mutations has been found in at least one case . Either cause could be linked to the origin of C-type BSE but the question of origin may never be definitively answered . The full risks presented to human health by atypical BSE remain unknown, but data is available suggesting that L-type BSE may be zoonotic , .
As of November 2009, 17 Canadian cases of BSE have been confirmed. In order to assess their potential origins and relatedness to classical and atypical BSE in other countries, an in-depth analysis of their PrPres molecular and biochemical features was performed, including immunoreactivity, glycoform profiles, molecular size and relative proteinase K sensitivity of their PrPres cores . In addition, DNA sequencing was carried out on the full PrP-coding sequence in exon 3 of the PRNP gene in each of the 17 animals to assess the possibility of causative genetic mutations. The information obtained provides a better understanding of the epidemiology of BSE types in Canada and of how similar these types are to cases identified worldwide.
Materials and Methods
Animals and tissues
Sixteen of the seventeen Canadian BSE cases were detected by the Canadian BSE surveillance network and were confirmed by the National BSE Reference Laboratory. All positive cases were identified by active surveillance using immunohstochemistry (IHC) or rapid tests approved by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA). Confirmation was based on IHC and immunoblotting of scrapie-associated fibrils (SAF). Further analyses were done using a modified Hybrid Western Blot. One Canadian-born case was detected and confirmed using IHC by the National Veterinary Services Laboratory in Ames, Iowa, USA. The key details of each of the 17 Canadian BSE cases are summarized in Table 1.
Tissue preparation and standard Prionics-Check Western blotting
Brain-stem tissue from each of the 17 cases was sampled at or close to the level of the obex. This tissue was used to prepare 10% (w/v) homogenates in 1 x Prionics homogenization buffer (Prionics-Check Western). Homogenization was performed for 45 s at 23,000 rpm in either a Prypcon container using the MediFASTH homogenizer (Consul AR) or in a Prioclip container using the Priogenizer homogenizer (Prionics AG). Initially, digestion of 100 µl of 10% homogenates was performed by adding 10 µl of digestion buffer (Prionics-Check Western) and 10 µl of PK (Prionics-Check Western), mixing thoroughly and incubating for 40 min at 48°C. The reactions were stopped by successive addition of 10 µl of digestion stop buffer (Prionics-Check Western), and 100 µl of 2× sample buffer (Prionics-Check Western). The samples were mixed well and then heated to 95°C for 5 min prior to gel electrophoresis and blotting.
Prior to analyses, the PrPres amounts from each case were equalized by loading various volumes of the digested samples. Different amounts of disease-associated protein in each case was due to variables beyond our control including incubation time and the amount and frequency of the challenge dose. This step allowed for standardization of each sample input resulting in a better assessment of antibody immunoreactivity and clear protein band profiles for determining molecular weights and glycoform profiles. The loading amount which produced the strongest signal with three distinct bands was selected for the remaining experiments except where otherwise noted.
Each Canadian BSE case was also tested with the Prionics-Check Western blot using a number of modified protocols, as described in the following sections. The methods used for biochemical characterisation are even possible with autolysed samples which can pose a challenge for histological and immunohistochemical examination. Field cases are sometimes of poor tissue quality which can make strain typing based on morphologic observations very difficult.
Proteinase K sensitivity
To determine the PK sensitivity of PrPSc in each of the Canadian BSE cases, phosphate- and Tris-based buffers (pH 6.5 and 8.0, respectively) designed for adjusting the tissue homogenate pH values were added . After mixing 60 µl of 10% homogenate with an equal volume of pH-adjustment buffer, the desired pH of the sample was verified using 20 µl of the sample. Proteinase K (5 mg/ml) was then added to the pH-adjusted homogenates to reach a final concentration of 50 µg/ml (Ph 6.5) or 500 µg/ml (pH 8.0). Digestions were performed for 60 min at 37°C. The reaction was stopped by the successive addition of 10 µl of digestion stop buffer (Prionics-Check Western) and 100 µl of 2× sample buffer (Prionics-Check Western). The samples were mixed well and heated to 95°C for 5 min prior to gel electrophoresis and blotting.
Deglycosylation with PNGase F
Deglycosylation of PrPres using peptide N-glycosidase F (PNGase F; New England Biolabs, USA) was performed following the manufacturer's instructions with minor modifications. Briefly, PrPres was denatured in a 3% (w/v) sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) solution instead of the denaturing buffer supplied. The treatment was carried out by incubating PK-digested, denatured PrPres (5–10 µl of 10% homogenate) with PNGase F (final concentration 150 U/µl) for 16 hours at 37°C. The samples were mixed well with an equal volume of 2× sample buffer and heated to 95°C for 5 min before proceeding to gel electrophoresis and Western blotting.
SDS-PAGE, Western blotting
The predetermined amount of each denatured sample (1.25–10 µl) was loaded on 12- or 17-well pre-cast 1 mm thickness, 12% Bis-Tris NuPAGE gels (Invitrogen, Canada). Electrophoresis was performed for 90 min at 100 V in 3-(N-morpholino)propanesulfonic acid (MOPS) running buffer (Invitrogen, Canada) with antioxidant (Invitrogen, Canada) using XCell SureLock Mini-Cells (Invitrogen, Canada). Magic Mark XP (Invitrogen, Canada) was used as a reference for molecular mass estimations. Electro-transfer, antibody binding, and chemiluminescence detection using CDP-Star and BioMax Light Chemiluminescence film (Kodak, United Kingdom) were performed following the Prionics-Check Western kit instructions (Prionics, Switzerland). Film images were then digitized to quantitate relative glycoform immunoreactivities using a BioRad ChemiDoc XRS (BioRad, Canada). The resulting image files were analyzed using the BioRad Quantity One software version 4.6.3 (BioRad, Canada), and the integrated optical densities and apparent molecular masses of the bands were exported for further calculations. Only bands with molecular masses ranging from 30 to 16 kDa were used to calculate the glycoform profile, in which the total integrated optical density of each glycoform band was expressed as a percentage of the summed integrated optical densities of the three bands in the triplet.
Antibodies and epitope-specific antibody reactivity
To compare epitope-specific PrPres antibody reactivities, the Prionics-Check Western kit specific monoclonal antibody (mAB) 6H4 was replaced in turn by each member of a panel of selected antibodies. Antibodies 12B2, P4 and SAF32 are PrP N-terminal-specific antibodies, antibodies 9A2, 6H4 and L42 are PrP core-specific antibodies and antibodies 94B4 and SAF84 are the PrP C-terminal-specific antibodies (Table 2).
DNA extraction and sequencing
Genomic DNA was extracted from 0.2–0.4 g unfixed brain tissue on different days to avoid cross-contamination, using a standard method (Proteinase K/phenol-chloroform/ethanol precipitation). PCR primers BTAPRNPDS9:19471U22 and BTAPRNPDS9:21426L20 were used with published PCR conditions and sequencing primers  to amplify and sequence the entire PrP-coding sequence located in exon 3 of the bovine PRNP gene from all 17 BSE-affected cattle, using BigDye® dideoxy cycle-sequencing chemistry (Applied Biosystems, USA). Sequence contigs were assembled, visually inspected and analyzed with LaserGene™ (DNAStar, USA) software.
In this study, we analyzed the molecular features of PrPres using both a standard and modified Prionics-Check Western Blot techniques. The characteristics used for typing the Canadian BSE cases are based on the molecular characterization of natural BSE case from other countries. Using these characteristics, the initial confirmatory classifications were supported resulting in 15 C-, 1 H- and 1 L-type Canadian BSE cases.
Molecular weights and glycoform profiles of PrPres
As part of the initial confirmation, all Canadian BSE cases were classified as C-, H-, or L-type on the basis of PrPres molecular weights and relative antibody immunoreactivities. In the 15 Canadian C-type BSE cases, the mean (± SD) relative immunoreactivities of di-, mono-, and unglycosylated moieties were 62.5±5.8, 25.6±2.5 and 12.0±4.5%, respectively. The molecular-mass estimates were 27.5±0.5, 21.8±0.7 and 17.6±0.6 kDa for the di-, mono- and unglycosylated bands, respectively. In the L-type case, the relative immunoreactivities were 39.3±0.6, 35.0±1.0 and 26.3±1.2%, and estimated molecular masses of the di-, mono- and unglycosylated moieties were all slightly lower (by ∼1 kDa) than those of the C-type, at 26.3±0.6, 20.7±0.6 and 17.3±0.6 kDa, respectively. The single H-type case had higher molecular masses (by ∼1.5 kDa) for all three bands, with di-, mono- and unglycosylated forms at 28.7±1.5, 23.3±1.2 and 19.3±1.2 kDa, respectively. When using core-specific or N-terminal-specific antibodies, the glycoform profile of the Canadian H-type case resembled the C-type cases with 58.3±2.5% digycosylated, 29.3±0.6% monoglycosylated, and 12.7±3.5% unglycosylated PrPres. When using a C-terminal antibody, however, the molecular weight (27.7±0.6, 22.7±0.6 and 17.7±0.6 kDa) was more similar to that of the C-type, and the glycoprofile (38.3±0.6, 36.7±0.6 and 25.0±1.0%) was more similar to the L-type BSE cases.
To directly compare the PrPres glycoform ratios from each case, the mean proportion of diglycosylated glycoform immunoreactivity was divided by the mean proportion of monoglycosylated glycoform immunoreactivity , . In the Canadian L-type case, this ratio was 1.1. When this ratio was determined for the C- type cases, the values ranged from 2.1 to 3.7. The H-type ratio was similar to that of the C-types when using a core-specific antibody with a value of 2.0, however when using a C-terminal antibody this ratio shifted down to a value of 1.2 (Table 3).
Variations in the molecular weights of the PrPres core associated with atypical BSE cases are often difficult to determine when all glycoforms are present, especially in L-type BSE which often displays a subtle band shift. Removal of the carbohydrate moieties from PrPres offers a way to enhance the estimates of the molecular-weight shifts in the L- and H-type PrPres cores.
For each of the BSE types, PNGase F treatment resulted in a subtle change in electrophoretic migration of the deglycosylated band when compared to the naturally occurring unglycosylated isoform (Fig. 1). None of the PNGase-treated samples showed complete removal of all carbohydrates, and the susceptibility to this treatment appeared type-dependent with the L-type Canadian BSE being the most completely deglycosylated. Deglycosylation of the H-type PrPres also resulted in the presence of two unglycosylated protein isoforms when using C-terminal antibodies for detection, one at 19 kDa and the other at 10 kDa (data not shown).
L- (case 11, lanes 1 and 2), C- (case 12, lanes 3 and 4) and H- (case 6, lanes 5 and 6) type BSE after PK digestions with (+) and without (−) PNGase F deglycosylation. Core antibody 6H4 detection demonstrates the size differences between classical and atypical BSE and also a slight size shift between the unglycosylated and deglycosylated bands within each individual type of BSE. The lane labelled as M contains the molecular weight marker and weights are in kilodaltons.
Resistance to PK digestion
Proteinase K (PK) digestion under mild and stringent conditions revealed that the misfolded prion protein from C-type BSE is more PK-resistant than that from H- or L-type atypical BSE. Under mild conditions, the full-length PrPC was completely degraded, while PrPSc was converted to readily visualized amounts of PrPres for all of the BSE cases. Under stringent conditions in contrast, the remaining film signals of L- and H-type PrPres decreased significantly, while that of the C-type PrPres remained nearly at the same level. Densitometric quantification revealed that the C-type BSE PrPres only decreased by approximately 10% under the stringent conditions while the decrease in surviving PrPres was greater than 50% for both L- and H-type cases (Fig. 2).
L- (case 11, lanes 1 and 2), C- (case 12, lanes 3 and 4) and H- (case 6, lanes 5 and 6) type BSE after PK digestions at 37°C for one hour under mild (Mild: pH 6.5, PK 50 µg/ml) and stringent (Str.: pH 8.0, PK 500 µg/ml) conditions. Core antibody 6H4 detection demonstrates little change in the amount of PrPres surviving the stringent digestion in C-type BSE and a significant degradation of L-type PrPres and almost complete degradation of H-type PrPres under the stringent conditions. The lane labelled as M contains the molecular weight marker and weights are in kilodaltons.
Investigation of PrPres immunoreactivities using different antibodies
When N-terminal-specific, C-terminal-specific and core-specific antibodies were compared for their relative abilities to detect PrPres in the different types of BSE, further evidence supporting the initial classification of the different BSE types was established. The N-terminal-specific antibodies 12B2, P4 and SAF32 bound to all three bands of PrPres in H-type BSE, but very weakly or not at all to the PrPres bands of the C- or L-type BSE. The core-specific and C-terminal-specific antibodies 9A2, L42, 6H4, 94B4 and SAF84 bound to all three bands of the PrPres of the H-, L-, and C-type BSE (Table 4). Both C-terminal-specific antibodies also bound to a fourth band at around 10 kDa in the H-type BSE case.
A summary of diploid genotypes of the PrP-coding regions in PRNP exon 3 is provided in Table 5 for each of the 17 BSE cases in relation to a reference sequence (GenBank accession AJ298878). Although 4 previously known polymorphisms were observed, all of these were either translationally silent (CAG↔CAA in codon 78, CCC↔CCT in codon 113 and AAC↔AAT in codon 192) or have been shown previously to have no phenotypic association with BSE (OPR region carrying either 5 or 6 tandem repeat units).
The classification of BSE types based on molecular and biochemical properties involves molecular weight determination of PrPres. Atypical BSEs have a higher or lower apparent molecular mass of PrPres when compared to C-type BSE using WB analysis with core-specific antibodies. Such differences are in the range of 0.9 to 1.3 kDa for the H-type, but rather subtle for L-type (∼0.3 kDa) , , , . The Canadian H-type BSE case, detected in 2006, displays an obvious molecular weight shift of around 1.3 kDa, similar to that observed in some cases in other countries , . A lower molecular mass of PrPres for L-type BSE compared with C-type BSE has been recorded in cases from Italy, France, Japan, German, Poland and the Netherlands , , , , , , . The Canadian L-type BSE case has a subtle molecular weight shift downward compared to Canadian C-type cases, which made it initially challenging to confirm and additional supporting evidence was necessary.
PNGase F treatment to remove associated carbohydrates from glycosylated PrPres, which is intended to generate a single unglycosylated protein species for more precise molecular-weight estimation, provided further support for the size shifts in Canadian H- and L-type BSE cases detected in the initial analyses. Removal of carbohydrates also confirmed the presence of two sizes of unglycosylated PK-resistant fragments, at approximately 19 and 10 kDa, in the H-type case. Similar behaviour has been previously observed and was explained by the possibility of two subpopulations of PrPSc carrying two available PK-cleavage sites with different susceptibilities to digestion in H-type cases . PNGase F treatment results in some residual glycosylated PrPres, even under the most highly denaturing conditions. Susceptibility to deglycosylation was noted to be associated with BSE type, with PNGase F treatment being most effective on the L-type case and less effective on the H- and C-type Canadian cases. Presuming that glycosylation occurs on the same amino acid residues in all cases, this may be related to differences in the conformation and/or conformational stability of the different BSE types.
Another interesting observation in the deglycosylation experiments was the slightly lower migration rate of the deglycosylated band of each BSE type after treatment with PNGase F compared to the rate for the unglycosylated band in untreated samples (Fig. 1). This is believed to result from the N-linked carbohydrate removal process, which alters asparagine to aspartic acid and thus reduces electrophoretic mobility of protein-detergent complexes due to a decrease in the SDS:PrPres molar ratio .
While removing carbohydrate groups is useful for molecular weight analysis, retaining these post-translational modifications is also valuable for BSE strain typing. In general, L-type BSE cases have a unique glycoform profile which includes a smaller proportion of diglycosylated PrPres and a larger proportion of mono- and unglycosylated PrPres when compared to C- and H-type , , , , , . This more balanced di- to monoglycosylated ratio is also seen in the Canadian L-type BSE case. In Canadian C-type and H-type cases, the average ratio of di- to monoglycosylated PrPres is consistently ≥2, while in the L-type case it is <1.5. When using C-terminal antibodies however, the Canadian H-type BSE di- to monoglycosylated ratio shifted closer to the L-type ratio. It was recently suggested that this may reflect the presence of a second population of PrPres in H-type BSE with a slightly lower molecular weight . This would result in the second population's diglycosylated band merging with the monoglycosylated band of the first population increasing its apparent abundance. Based on the fact that the altered glycoprofile and fourth band are only seen with C-terminal antibodies , it seems that this second PrPres population is cleaved between the epitopes detected by the core-specific and C-terminal-specific antibodies which could result in the observed ∼10 kDa size shift.
Conformational stability can also vary in different prion disease strains. This can be analyzed in different ways, but one of the simplest is to determine the proteinase K sensitivity of the misfolded protein using mild and stringent conditions . The H- and L-type BSE isolates displayed higher susceptibilities to PK digestion than the C-type isolates, suggesting that the conformation of the Canadian C-type BSE is more stable than the two atypical forms. This is similar to results from comparable analyses on C-type and atypical BSE done elsewhere , .
Proteinase K digestion under mild conditions induces N-terminal cleavage of PrPSc in all three BSE types to varying degrees. Selecting antibodies with epitopes localized on either side of the cleavage sites allows for another mechanism of BSE type differentiation. It has been demonstrated that C- and L-type BSE react only weakly with antibodies directed towards the N-terminal portion of PrPres (e.g., 12B2 antibody , ). This was also shown for Canadian cases. When testing Canadian H-type BSE, as is the case with other H-type BSE cases, there is strong binding with the N-terminal antibodies including 12B2, P4 and SAF32. Another similarity between Canadian H-type BSE and those found in other countries is the detection of a fourth band at approximately 10 kDa when using C-terminal-specific antibodies. This unique behaviour of H-type BSE needs further investigation to determine its source and what implications this may have on other H-type characteristics such as pathogenetic traits.
In May 2003, after the detection of the first indigenous case of BSE, Canadian surveillance was modified to increase test numbers to demonstrate the extremely low level of BSE in the country. This additional effort primarily targets “4D” cattle over 30 months of age. This includes animals that are dead, non-ambulatory (down), sick at ante mortem inspection (diseased), or presented for emergency slaughter (distressed). The program also includes animals of any age presenting clinical signs consistent with BSE. As of November 2009, this program had tested over 275,000 cattle as negative and 16 cattle as positive for BSE. An additional case was detected in the United States and traced back to Canada, for a total of 17 Canadian-born cases. The aim of our study was to provide an in-depth analysis of the molecular and biochemical properties of the PrPres associated with each of these cases and thus insight into the epidemiology of BSE in Canada. We confirmed the diagnoses of 15 C-, 1 L- and 1 H-type BSE cases by determining molecular mass, immunoreactivity, proteolytic sensitivity (stability) and glycoform profile.
In addition to shared molecular characteristics, a common feature of the majority of atypical BSE cases worldwide is their occurrence in older animals as compared to C-type BSE which is found in various age groups . Most atypical BSE cases have occurred in animals over 8 years old with an average age of 12 years , , , , , , . The Canadian atypical BSE cases occurred in a 16-year-old Charolais (H-type) and a 13.8-year-old Polled Hereford (L-type), both with clinical disease at the time of sampling. French, Italian, Dutch, Polish, and German atypical BSE cases have occurred in healthy slaughter animals but have also been reported among fallen stock, and these might have displayed unreported clinical abnormalities . This variation in clinical presentation adds to the list of questions that remain unanswered for these types of BSE.
The origin of atypical BSE is unknown, but sporadic, infectious and genetic mechanisms have all been suggested. Several groups have argued that these cases may represent the existence of a sporadic prion disease in bovines, perhaps similar in etiology to sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans , , , . Experimental infection of cattle with an isolate of naturally occurring British sheep scrapie resulted in differences in the PrPres electrophoretic profiles compared to classical C-type BSE which led to the suggestion that atypical BSE may be a result of transmission of a prion disease from a different natural host into cattle . In addition, an American H-type BSE case with a mutation (E211K) in the PRNP gene has been reported . This represents the first case of BSE with a potentially pathogenic mutation within the bovine PRNP gene, and experiments are underway to determine the potential importance of this mutation in the development of prion disease in cattle . We did not observe such mutations in the Canadian BSE cases analyzed as of November 2009, and negative results of a large population survey in US cattle strongly suggest that the E211K allele is not common in North American cattle . However, the intrinsically recurrent nature of genetic mutation, as shown particularly for the homologous E200K mutation known to cause genetic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans , means that the possibility that a small subpopulation of cattle that carry such mutations exist cannot be eliminated.
Our results indicate that the range of molecular characteristics of misfolded PrP in Canadian BSE cases is very similar to that observed in other countries and suggests a number of criteria to use when typing BSE cases (Table 6). It is also interesting that the Canadian atypical BSE cases match so well with cases from other countries in terms of their epidemiological profiles, including detection in older animals and no definitive cause of disease. Ongoing inoculation studies with Canadian BSE types in cattle and transgenic mice will provide clarification on how similar these isolates are after transmission using defined and controlled experimental inoculations. These studies should help to answer some of the many outstanding questions about atypical BSE and aid in policy development to reduce the risk of atypical BSE transmission to animals and humans.
Thank you to Dr. Jan Langeveld, Central Veterinay Institute of Wageningen University Research at Lelystad, The Netherlands, for providing the PrP specific antibodies 9A2, 12B2 and 94B4 and for his critical review of this manuscript. Dr. Connie Argue provided epidemiological data and a critical review of the manuscript. Laura Landry, Christine Mesa, Angela Sloan, Kristen Bedosky, Shannon Hiebert and Rhonda Mogk all provided expert technical support with DNA sequencing.
Conceived and designed the experiments: SD JY MBC SC. Performed the experiments: SD JY. Analyzed the data: SD JY CG MC TAM MBC SC. Wrote the paper: SD JY MBC SC.
- 1. Prusiner SB (2004) An introduction to prion biology and diseases. In: Prusiner SB, editor. Prion Biology and Diseases, Second Edition. Cold Spring Harbor: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press. pp. 1–87.SB Prusiner2004An introduction to prion biology and diseases.SB PrusinerPrion Biology and Diseases, Second EditionCold Spring HarborCold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press187
- 2. Jacobs JJ, Langeveld JP, Biacabe AG, Acutis PL, Polak MP, et al. (2007) Molecular discrimination of atypical bovine spongiform encephalopathy strains from a geographical region spanning a wide area in Europe. J Clin Microbiol 45: 1821–1829.JJ JacobsJP LangeveldAG BiacabePL AcutisMP Polak2007Molecular discrimination of atypical bovine spongiform encephalopathy strains from a geographical region spanning a wide area in Europe.J Clin Microbiol4518211829
- 3. Buschmann A, Gretzschel A, Biacabe AG, Schiebel K, Corona C, et al. (2006) Atypical BSE in Germany-proof of transmissibility and biochemical characterization. Vet Microbiol 117: 103–116.A. BuschmannA. GretzschelAG BiacabeK. SchiebelC. Corona2006Atypical BSE in Germany-proof of transmissibility and biochemical characterization.Vet Microbiol117103116
- 4. Telling GC, Parchi P, DeArmond SJ, Cortelli SJ, Montagna P, et al. (1996) Evidence for the conformation of the pathologic isoform of the prion protein enciphering and propagating prion diversity. Science 274: 2079–2082.GC TellingP. ParchiSJ DeArmondSJ CortelliP. Montagna1996Evidence for the conformation of the pathologic isoform of the prion protein enciphering and propagating prion diversity.Science27420792082
- 5. Bruce M, Chree A, McConnell I, Foster J, Pearson G, et al. (1994) Transmission of bovine spongiform encephalopathy and scrapie to mice: strain variation and the species barrier. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 343: 405–411.M. BruceA. ChreeI. McConnellJ. FosterG. Pearson1994Transmission of bovine spongiform encephalopathy and scrapie to mice: strain variation and the species barrier.Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci343405411
- 6. Hill AF, Desbruslais M, Joiner S (1997) The same prion strain causes vCJD and BSE. Nature 389: 448–450.AF HillM. DesbruslaisS. Joiner1997The same prion strain causes vCJD and BSE.Nature389448450
- 7. Orge L, Simas P, Fernandes AC, Ramos M, Galo A (2000) Similarity of the lesion profile of BSE in Portugese cattle to that described in British cattle. Vet Rec 147: 486–488.L. OrgeP. SimasAC FernandesM. RamosA. Galo2000Similarity of the lesion profile of BSE in Portugese cattle to that described in British cattle.Vet Rec147486488
- 8. Stack MJ, Chaplin MJ, Clark J (2002) Differentiation of prion protein glycoforms from naturally occurring sheep scrapie, sheep-passaged scrapie strains (CH1641 and SSBP1), bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) cases andRomney and Cheviot breed sheep experimentally inoculated with BSE using two monoclonal antibodies. Acta Neuropathol 104: 279–86.MJ StackMJ ChaplinJ. Clark2002Differentiation of prion protein glycoforms from naturally occurring sheep scrapie, sheep-passaged scrapie strains (CH1641 and SSBP1), bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) cases andRomney and Cheviot breed sheep experimentally inoculated with BSE using two monoclonal antibodies.Acta Neuropathol10427986
- 9. Collinge J, Sidle K, Meads J, Ironside J, Hill A (1996) Molecular analysis of prion strain variation and the aetiology of ‘new variant’ CJD. Nature 383: 685–690.J. CollingeK. SidleJ. MeadsJ. IronsideA. Hill1996Molecular analysis of prion strain variation and the aetiology of ‘new variant’ CJD.Nature383685690
- 10. Gavier-Widén D, Stack MJ, Baron T, Balachandran A, Simmons M (2005) Diagnosis of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in animals: a review. J Vet Diagn Invest 17: 509–527.D. Gavier-WidénMJ StackT. BaronA. BalachandranM. Simmons2005Diagnosis of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in animals: a review.J Vet Diagn Invest17509527
- 11. Bruce ME, Will RG, Ironside JW, McConnell I, Drummond D, et al. (1997) Transmissions to mice indicate that ‘new variant’ CJD is caused by the BSE agent. Nature 389: 498–501.ME BruceRG WillJW IronsideI. McConnellD. Drummond1997Transmissions to mice indicate that ‘new variant’ CJD is caused by the BSE agent.Nature389498501
- 12. Collinge J, Rossor M (1996) A new variant of prion disease. Lancet 347: 916–917.J. CollingeM. Rossor1996A new variant of prion disease.Lancet347916917
- 13. Casalone C, Zanusso G, Acutis P, Acutis P, Ferrari S, et al. (2004) Identification of a second bovine amyloidotic spongiform encephalopathy: molecular similarities with sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101: 3065–3070.C. CasaloneG. ZanussoP. AcutisP. AcutisS. Ferrari2004Identification of a second bovine amyloidotic spongiform encephalopathy: molecular similarities with sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA10130653070
- 14. Biacabe AG, Laplanche JL, Ryder S, Baron T (2004) Distinct molecular phenotypes in bovine prion diseases. EMBO Rep 5: 110–115.AG BiacabeJL LaplancheS. RyderT. Baron2004Distinct molecular phenotypes in bovine prion diseases.EMBO Rep5110115
- 15. Hagiwara K, Yamakawa Y, Sato Y, Nakamura Y, Tobiume M, et al. (2007) Accumulation of monoglycosylated form-rich, plaque-forming PrPSc in the second atypical bovine spongiform encephalopathy case in Japan. Jpn J Infect Dis 60: 305–308.K. HagiwaraY. YamakawaY. SatoY. NakamuraM. Tobiume2007Accumulation of monoglycosylated form-rich, plaque-forming PrPSc in the second atypical bovine spongiform encephalopathy case in Japan.Jpn J Infect Dis60305308
- 16. Polak MP, Zmudzinski JF, Jacobs JG, Langeveld JP (2008) Atypical status of bovine spongiform encephalopathy in Poland: a molecular typing study. Arch Virol 153: 69–79.MP PolakJF ZmudzinskiJG JacobsJP Langeveld2008Atypical status of bovine spongiform encephalopathy in Poland: a molecular typing study.Arch Virol1536979
- 17. Tester S, Juillerat V, Doherr MG, Haase B, Polak M, et al. (2009) Biochemical typing of pathological prion protein in aging cattle with BSE. Virol J. S. TesterV. JuilleratMG DoherrB. HaaseM. Polak2009Biochemical typing of pathological prion protein in aging cattle with BSE.Virol J10.1186/1743-422X-6-64. 10.1186/1743-422X-6-64.
- 18. Terry LA, Jenkins R, Thorne L, Everest SJ, Chaplin MJ, et al. (2007) First case of H-type bovine spongiform encephalopathy identified in Great Britain. Vet Rec 160: 873–874.LA TerryR. JenkinsL. ThorneSJ EverestMJ Chaplin2007First case of H-type bovine spongiform encephalopathy identified in Great Britain.Vet Rec160873874
- 19. Richt JA, Kunkle RA, Alt D, Nicholson EM, Hamir AN, et al. (2007) Identification and characterization of two bovine spongiform encephalopathy cases diagnosed in the United States. J Vet Diagn Invest 19: 142–154.JA RichtRA KunkleD. AltEM NicholsonAN Hamir2007Identification and characterization of two bovine spongiform encephalopathy cases diagnosed in the United States.J Vet Diagn Invest19142154
- 20. Yamakawa Y, Hagiwara K, Nohtomi K, Nakamura Y, Nishijima M, et al. (2003) Atypical proteinase K-resistant prion protein (PrPres) observed in an apparently healthy 23-month-old Holstein steer. Jpn J Infect Dis 56: 221–222.Y. YamakawaK. HagiwaraK. NohtomiY. NakamuraM. Nishijima2003Atypical proteinase K-resistant prion protein (PrPres) observed in an apparently healthy 23-month-old Holstein steer.Jpn J Infect Dis56221222
- 21. Bosschere De, Roels S, Vanopdenbosch E (2004) Atypical case of bovine spongiform encephalopathy in an East-Flemish cow in Belgium. J Appl Res Vet Med 2: 52–54.De BosschereS. RoelsE. Vanopdenbosch2004Atypical case of bovine spongiform encephalopathy in an East-Flemish cow in Belgium.J Appl Res Vet Med25254
- 22. Béringue V, Bencsik A, Le Dur A, Reine F, Laï TL, et al. (2006) Isolation from Cattle of a Prion Strain Distinct from That Causing Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy. PLoS Pathog 2: e112.V. BéringueA. BencsikA. Le DurF. ReineTL Laï2006Isolation from Cattle of a Prion Strain Distinct from That Causing Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy.PLoS Pathog2e112
- 23. Capobianco R, Casalone C, Suardi S, Mangieri M, Miccolo C, et al. (2007) Conversion of the BASE prion strain into the BSE strain: the origin of BSE? PLoS Pathog 3: e31.R. CapobiancoC. CasaloneS. SuardiM. MangieriC. Miccolo2007Conversion of the BASE prion strain into the BSE strain: the origin of BSE?PLoS Pathog3e31
- 24. Nicholson EM, Brunelle BW, Richt JA, Kehrli ME, Greenlee JJ (2008) Identification of a Heritable Polymorphism in Bovine PRNP Associated with Genetic Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathy: Evidence of Heritable BSE. PLoS One 3: e2912.EM NicholsonBW BrunelleJA RichtME KehrliJJ Greenlee2008Identification of a Heritable Polymorphism in Bovine PRNP Associated with Genetic Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathy: Evidence of Heritable BSE.PLoS One3e2912
- 25. Richt JA, Hall SM (2008) BSE case associated with prion protein gene mutation. PLoS Pathogens. JA RichtSM Hall2008BSE case associated with prion protein gene mutation.PLoS Pathogens10.1371/journal.ppat.1000156. 10.1371/journal.ppat.1000156.
- 26. Kong Q, Zheng M, Casalone C, Qing L, Huang S, et al. (2008) Evaluation of the human transmission risk of an atypical bovine spongiform encephalopathy prion strain. J Virol 82: 3697–3701.Q. KongM. ZhengC. CasaloneL. QingS. Huang2008Evaluation of the human transmission risk of an atypical bovine spongiform encephalopathy prion strain.J Virol8236973701
- 27. Comoy EE, Casalone C, Lescoutra-Etchegaray N, Zanusso G, Freire S, et al. (2008) Atypical BSE (BASE) transmitted from asymptomatic aging cattle to a primate. PLoS One 3: e3017.EE ComoyC. CasaloneN. Lescoutra-EtchegarayG. ZanussoS. Freire2008Atypical BSE (BASE) transmitted from asymptomatic aging cattle to a primate.PLoS One3e3017
- 28. Clawson ML, Heaton MP, Keele JW, Smith TP, Harhay GP, et al. (2006) Prion gene haplotypes of U.S. cattle. BMC Genet. ML ClawsonMP HeatonJW KeeleTP SmithGP Harhay2006Prion gene haplotypes of U.S. cattle.BMC Genet10.1186/1471-2156-7-51. 10.1186/1471-2156-7-51.
- 29. Baron T, Biacabe AG, Arsac JN, Benestad S, Groschup MH (2007) Atypical transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) in ruminants. Vaccine 25: 5625–5630.T. BaronAG BiacabeJN ArsacS. BenestadMH Groschup2007Atypical transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) in ruminants.Vaccine2556255630
- 30. Biacabe AG, Jacobs JG, Bencsik A, Langeveld JP, Baron TG (2007) H-Type Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy Complex Molecular Features and Similarities with Human Prion Diseases. Prion 1: 61–68.AG BiacabeJG JacobsA. BencsikJP LangeveldTG Baron2007H-Type Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy Complex Molecular Features and Similarities with Human Prion Diseases.Prion16168
- 31. Heaton MP, Keele JW, Harhay GP, Richt JA, Koohmaraie M, et al. (2008) Prevalence of the prion protein gene E211K variant in U.S. cattle. BMC Vet Res. MP HeatonJW KeeleGP HarhayJA RichtM. Koohmaraie2008Prevalence of the prion protein gene E211K variant in U.S. cattle.BMC Vet Res10.1186/1746-6148-4-25. 10.1186/1746-6148-4-25.
- 32. Lee HS, Sambuughin N, Cervenakova L, Chapman J, Pocchiari M, et al. (1999) Ancestral origins and worldwide distribution of the PRNP 200K mutation causing familial Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease. Am J Hum Genet 64: 1063–1070.HS LeeN. SambuughinL. CervenakovaJ. ChapmanM. Pocchiari1999Ancestral origins and worldwide distribution of the PRNP 200K mutation causing familial Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease.Am J Hum Genet6410631070
- 33. Langeveld JP, Jacobs JG, Erkens JH, Bossers A, van Zijderveld FG, et al. (2006) Rapid and discriminatory diagnosis of scrapie and BSE in retro-pharyngeal lymph nodes of sheep. BMC Vet. Res. JP LangeveldJG JacobsJH ErkensA. BossersFG van Zijderveld2006Rapid and discriminatory diagnosis of scrapie and BSE in retro-pharyngeal lymph nodes of sheep.BMC Vet. Res10.1186/1746-6148-2-19. 10.1186/1746-6148-2-19.
- 34. Thuring CM, Erkens JH, Jacobs JG, Bossers A, Van Keulen LJ, et al. (2004) Discrimination between scrapie and bovine spongiform encephalopathy in sheep by molecular size, immunoreactivity, and glycoprofile of prion protein. J Clin Microbiol 42: 972–980.CM ThuringJH ErkensJG JacobsA. BossersLJ Van Keulen2004Discrimination between scrapie and bovine spongiform encephalopathy in sheep by molecular size, immunoreactivity, and glycoprofile of prion protein.J Clin Microbiol42972980
- 35. Féraudet C, Morel N, Simon S, Volland H, Frobert Y, et al. (2005) Screening of 145 anti-PrP monoclonal antibodies for their capacity to inhibit PrPSc replication in infected cells. J Biol Chem 280: 11247–11258.C. FéraudetN. MorelS. SimonH. VollandY. Frobert2005Screening of 145 anti-PrP monoclonal antibodies for their capacity to inhibit PrPSc replication in infected cells.J Biol Chem2801124711258
- 36. Korth C, Stierli B, Streit P, Moser M, Schaller O, et al. (1997) Prion (PrPSc)-specific epitope defined by a monoclonal antibody. Nature 390: 74–77.C. KorthB. StierliP. StreitM. MoserO. Schaller1997Prion (PrPSc)-specific epitope defined by a monoclonal antibody.Nature3907477
- 37. Gretzschel A, Buschmann A, Langeveld J, Groschup MH (2006) Immunological characterization of abnormal prion protein from atypical scrapie cases in sheep using a panel of monoclonal antibodies. J Gen Virol 87: 3715–3722.A. GretzschelA. BuschmannJ. LangeveldMH Groschup2006Immunological characterization of abnormal prion protein from atypical scrapie cases in sheep using a panel of monoclonal antibodies.J Gen Virol8737153722