Carotenoids can confer somatic and reproductive benefits, but most evidence is from captive animal experimentation or single time-point sampling. Another perhaps more informative means by which to assess physiological contributions to animal performance is by tracking an individual's ability to increase or sustain carotenoids or other health-related molecules over time, as these are likely to be temporally variable.
In a field study of North American barn swallows (Hirundo rustica erythrogaster), we analyzed within-individual changes in carotenoid concentrations by repeatedly sampling the carotenoid profiles of individuals over the course of the breeding season. Our results demonstrate that carotenoid concentrations of individuals are temporally dynamic and that season-long balance of these molecules, rather than single time-point samples, predict reproductive performance. This was true even when controlling for two important variables associated with reproductive outcomes: (1) timing of breeding and (2) sexually selected plumage coloration, which is itself positively correlated with and concomitantly changes with circulating carotenoid concentrations.
While reproduction itself is purported to impose health stress on organisms, these data suggest that free-ranging, high-quality individuals can mitigate such costs, by one or several genetic, environmental (diet), or physiological mechanisms. Moreover, the temporal variations in both health-linked physiological measures and morphological traits we uncover here merit further examination in other species, especially when goals include the estimation of signal information content or the costs of trait expression.
Citation: Safran RJ, McGraw KJ, Wilkins MR, Hubbard JK, Marling J (2010) Positive Carotenoid Balance Correlates with Greater Reproductive Performance in a Wild Bird. PLoS ONE 5(2): e9420. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0009420
Editor: Cilla Kullberg, Stockholm University, Sweden
Received: November 20, 2009; Accepted: February 8, 2010; Published: February 25, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Safran et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Current research on carotenoids suggests that these molecules can improve health in a variety of animals, including humans , . For example, circulating concentrations of carotenoids minimize oxidative stress , [4,], but see , and influence immune system activity . Other studies suggest that circulating carotenoids are important underpinnings of condition-dependent signals related to mate-selection and competitive ability , . However, many of these results have been obtained from animals in captive situations, where researchers have limited ability to assess the evolutionary and ecological context in which these molecules are linked to survival and reproduction. Moreover, previous analyses of carotenoids have relied on point-sampling methods whereas it is likely–though unknown–that an individual's carotenoid profile in nature is temporally dynamic, as circulating concentrations respond to daily nutritional supplies and to physiological demands for combating oxidative crises , , . While these molecules certainly can be traded-off between somatic and reproductive functions , –, the degree to which individuals sustain circulating carotenoid supplies and how these affect reproductive performance are unknown.
In a field study of breeding male and female barn swallows (Hirundo rustica erythrogaster) from North America, we assessed within-individual changes in carotenoid profiles as a function of both morphology and reproductive performance. We focused on carotenoids in our research because of previously established correlations between circulating carotenoids and fitness in this species , . We also accounted for the degree of sexual ornamentation (ventral brown, melanin plumage coloration–not created by carotenoid pigmentation; ), which in European populations of barn swallows is associated with carotenoid status  and among North American birds is a strong predictor of social and genetic measures of breeding success , . We predicted that individuals best able to maintain a positive balance of these health-associated molecules (likely via foraging efficacy) may also be capable of greater seasonal reproductive performance.
Our results suggest that single assessments of carotenoid status do not capture temporal variation in this health-related variable. Instead, a seasonal measure of change in carotenoid concentration is a strong predictor of annual reproductive success. Further, sexually-selected plumage coloration appears to be temporally related to changes in carotenoids: ventral color appeared to change concomitantly with circulating carotenoid concentrations.
Materials and Methods
From May to August 2008, we monitored breeding in 71 uniquely marked adult barn swallows (33 males, 38 females) across 5 breeding sites in Boulder County, Colorado, USA (Latitude 40° 2′ 36″ N, Longitude 105° 16′ 39″ W). The number of breeding pairs at each site ranged from 8–18, (mean ± SD = 12±4.63). We captured birds at the start of the breeding season and obtained feather and blood samples as well as a number of morphological measurements, including the length of outer tail streamers and body mass. Swallows were recaptured for subsequent sampling throughout the breeding season. To compare changes in carotenoid concentrations across time, at three breeding sites we analyzed two successive plasma samples in 27 individuals for whom we had complete sets of morphological and reproductive performance data.
Plasma was collected from the beginning (6 May) to the end (8 August) of the breeding season, with most samples being collected during the first half of the breeding season (average Julian sample collection date ± SD = 164, or 12 June, ±22; mean Julian clutch initiation date ± SD = 149.7, or 29 May, ±10.7). Blood samples were kept on ice for a maximum of 1–3 hrs before centrifugation, at which point plasma was separated and stored at −80°C for 3 months prior to carotenoid analyses.
Plumage Color Analyses
Following Safran & McGraw , plucked ventral feathers were taped to a standard white card background in the overlapping arrangement in which they appeared on the bird and stored in the dark. Feather samples were analyzed with an Ocean Optics USB4000 spectrometer (range 200–1100 nm) using a fiber-optic probe at an angle of 90° to the feather surface lit by a PX-2 pulsed xenon light source. Ambient light was excluded using a metal probe holder, which was placed against the feather sample; the probe was held at a constant distance from each sample, so that a 2.5 mm diameter of light hit the feather surface. Reflectance data were generated relative to a white standard (Ocean Optics WS-1) and a dark standard (all light excluded). Spectra were recorded with SpectraSuite software package (version 2.0.125), Ocean Optics Inc., Dunedin, FL). For each sample, 20 spectra were averaged to reduce noise from the spectrometer with an integration period of 200 ms. Our color measurement procedure was repeated three times for each sample, with the probe lifted between each scan. The three scans were performed at approximately the same location in the colored feather area. Repeatabilities were very high for our measures of color (R = 0.86–0.94), with brightness being the most repeatable (R = 0.94). The high repeatabilities of our color measurements indicate that the patch of color measured was indeed very homogenous, as we lift the sampling probe between measurements of the same sample. Further, measures among four ventral regions are also highly repeatable for this species  suggesting that our assessment of color in one region is fairly representative of color across the entire ventral surface of melanin-based feather coloration.
From the raw UV-VIS spectral data (300–700 nm), we computed tristimulus scores - hue, brightness, and chroma - which we defined as follows for the brown, melanic plumage of barn swallows : hue is the wavelength of maximum slope for a brown, melanic trait, brightness is the total amount of light reflected by the feather surface across the range of considered wavelengths, and red chroma is the reflectance in the red color range (600–700 nm) divided by the total spectral range (300–700 nm). Because hue, chroma and brightness are highly intercorrelated for individual color patches , we chose throat brightness (brightness is our most repeatable color measurement) as our measure of color for both males and females. We considered using an integrated measure of color, like those obtained using principal components analysis , but because we examined changes in plasma carotenoids as a function of changes in color we needed to use absolute, as opposed to relative (transformed), measures of color.
Carotenoid Assays and Analyses
We followed the methods of McGraw et al.  to extract carotenoids from 5–20 µl (mean ± SD = 18.54±3.66) plasma (following the ethanol: MTBE procedure) and to analyze carotenoid types and concentrations using high-performance liquid chromatography. Three carotenoid pigments were detected in plasma–lutein, zeaxanthin, and β-cryptoxanthin–all of which we previously reported in the egg yolks of barn swallows . Concentrations were determined in ug/ml from external standard curves. Repeatabilities are very high for our measures of carotenoid and vitamin concentrations (R = 0.89–0.94; [see also 19]; n = 71). In both males and females, concentrations of two of three carotenoids were all highly and positively intercorrelated: (lutein-zeaxanthin, β-cryptoxanthin- zeaxanthin; Spearman rank rho: 0.64 and 0.38 respectively, both P<0.05; n = 71) with the exception of β-cryptoxanthin and lutein (Spearman rank rho: −0.26, P<0.05; n = 71). Because we needed a raw measure of carotenoid concentrations to quantitatively measure changes over time variable reduction methods (e.g. principal components analysis) is not appropriate. Accordingly, we summed levels of all three carotenoids to obtain total plasma carotenoid concentration.
We used mixed linear models to test for relationships between circulating plasma carotenoids with morphological and reproductive variables. These tests were run using JMP, version 7.0 software (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina). We incorporated ‘site’ as a random variable in our models to control for site differences and repeated measures of individuals at the same sites among our samples. We indicate this variable's significance in our tables by listing it in italics near the results of each model. All statistical tests reported are two-tailed and significance was assessed using an alpha level of 0.05. Degrees of freedom were calculated using the Kenward-Rogers method.
We directly analyzed gender differences in our data set in different ways. First (Table 1), we analyzed circulating concentrations as a function of morphological variation in each sex separately. Because we found similar effects of plumage color on carotenoid concentration in both males and females, we felt comfortable pooling individuals for each analysis to increase sample sizes for analyzing paired samples but included ‘gender’ (Tables 2 and 3) to conservatively control for possible sex differences in our data set. As no statistical effects of gender were detected, we did not include interaction terms with other covariates and ‘gender’ in multivariate models.
Because we employed a paired sampling design (repeated measurements on the same set of individuals), we calculated and then analyzed seasonal differences in several different variables, including mass, color, and circulating carotenoid concentrations. Within individuals, the differences between two successive samples were calculated by subtracting the first sample from the second. Accordingly, differences greater than zero indicate positive seasonal changes whereas differences less than zero indicate negative seasonal changes, unless specified, between sampling events. Moreover, in one analysis in which season-long measurements of all individuals in our study were pooled to examine differences in carotenoid concentrations across breeding sites, we use ‘individual’ as a random effect in the model to account for repeated measurements of individuals over time.
Potentially Confounding Effects on Circulating Carotenoid Concentrations
Controlling for repeated samples of both males and females over time within the same set of breeding sites, we found differences in total carotenoid concentrations of individuals across five breeding sites (carotenoids as a function of site differences: F 4,72.99 = 4.47, P<0.01, ‘individual identity’ controlled for as a random effect in the model individual) and as such controlled for these by using ‘site’ as a random variable in all analyses. Further, we found (1) no evidence of a seasonal decline in carotenoid concentrations (carotenoids as a function of sample date: F 1,53.95 = 0.943, P>0.33, site), (2) no relationship between the sample amount used in assays and total circulating carotenoids concentrations (carotenoid concentration as a function of sample amount: F 1, 57.56 = 0.04, P>0.80, site), and (3) finally, no influence of the number of days between sampling events (carotenoid concentration as a function of average number of days between samples ± = 33.40±19.27, range = 11–71; F 1,23.51 = 1.70, P>0.20, site, n = 27) and total circulating carotenoids concentrations, thus justifying the exclusion of these potentially confounding covariates in our models.
In our analyses related to reproductive performance, we include the covariate ‘clutch initiation date’ because this is a strong predictor of the number of fledged young produced by pairs (earlier breeders have a higher probability of producing larger clutches and two sets of broods; , ), and as such controls for seasonal effects of lay date variation, food availability, and different breeding schedules. Finally, because we did collect repeated samples on individuals that ended up being socially paired at the same nest, we randomly removed pair-mates (n = 5) from our analyses to avoid pseudo-replication of reproductive performance data. The results are consistent in both the larger sample containing pair-mates and the reduced sample.
Sex Differences in Melanin Plumage Color and Circulating Carotenoid Levels
As in our previous work , we found that males in our Colorado population had darker ventral coloration compared to females (throat brightness: F 1, 245.7 = 23.22, P<0.001, site). Further, males had significantly greater concentrations of circulating carotenoids than females (F 1, 59.19 = 28.88, P<0.001).
Morphological Correlates of Carotenoid Concentrations and Balance
In the early part of the breeding season (first sampling event), feather color brightness and not streamer length or body mass, significantly predicted variation in total carotenoid concentrations in both males and females (Table 1, Figure 1), such that both males and females with darker plumage color (lower brightness scores) had greater circulating concentrations of carotenoids at the start of the breeding season.
Variation in A) throat color, not B) streamer length, predicts variation in circulating carotenoid in male (shown) and female (similar trends not shown) barn swallows sampled at the beginning of the breeding season. N = 71 individuals.
Among morphological variables we analyzed, changes in carotenoid concentrations are predicted by body mass at the start of the breeding season, where heavier individuals (both males and females) were able to maintain greater carotenoid concentrations compared to birds lighter in mass (Table 2).
Finally, we uncovered intriguing concomitant relationships in both males and females between changes in plasma carotenoids and changes in plumage brightness [Figure 2: changes in carotenoid balance as a function of changes in throat brightness: F1, 6.29 = 6.70, P<0.05, controlling for gender: (F1,6.04 = 1.50, P>0.26), days between feather and plasma samples because melanin-based color is known to change over time: (F1, 6.09 = 2.97, P>0.14), and site differences, adjusted R-squared = 0.92]. Although body mass is another variable that changes within individuals over time, we did not uncover a correlation between changes in body mass and changes in carotenoid concentrations over time (F1,20.24 = 0.11, P>0.74, controlling for gender: (F1,19.85 = 2.57, P>0.13), days between sampling events (F1,20.31 = 1.11, P>0.30), and site differences).
Evidence of concomitant changes in carotenoids and ventral color suggesting a dynamic relationship between morphological and physiological traits: melanin-based color fading is strongly associated with a decline in carotenoid concentration in both males and females. N = 12 individuals for whom we had both two sets of carotenoid and feather samples.
Temporal Changes in Carotenoids, Not Data from Single Point Samples, Correlate with Reproductive Performance
Although two successive carotenoid measures were positively correlated within individuals [F1, 15.96 = 7.55, P<0.02, controlling for gender: (F 1,15.85 = 1.93, P>0.18), mass: (F1, 16.54 = 3.85, P>0.06), throat brightness: (F1, 16.16. = 2.15, P>0.16) and site differences, adjusted R-squared = 0.53], neither of these two temporally separate measures significantly predicted reproductive performance over the span of the four-month breeding season of this species (sample 1: F 1, 55.41 = 0.01, P>0.94, controlling for gender (F 1, 53.46 = 0.03, P>0.95) and site differences; sample 2: F 1, 19.93 = 3.81, P>0.10, controlling for gender (F 1, 19.82 = 0.05, P>0.82) and site differences). Instead, controlling for variation in clutch initiation date (and thus, breeding schedule), the change in carotenoid levels of individuals over our two sampling points was strongly and positively tied to seasonal reproductive success (total number of fledged young) even when accounting for variation in coloration (Table 3; Figure 3).
In our longitudinal field study of carotenoid circulation and breeding in barn swallows, we found that single-time-point estimates of carotenoid concentration were not significantly correlated with reproductive performance. Instead, we found that males and females who maintained high concentrations of these molecules over time were heavier in body mass and had greater seasonal reproductive success compared to individuals whose carotenoid concentrations declined during the breeding season. Moreover, we uncovered a strong relationship between changes in ventral coloration and carotenoid concentrations, suggesting that these variables are linked. These results are the first to elucidate patterns of temporal variation in carotenoid concentrations in a natural and functional reproductive context, but see  for an analysis of carotenoid change as a function of migration arrival date in barn swallows, and further suggest an important yet overlooked coupling between physiological and morphological variation .
Reproduction is thought to be one of the most somatically costly life-history traits and induces oxidative stress in many animals –. However, an experimental approach in captivity has been taken in nearly all of the work on this subject, and the role of individual variation is commonly overlooked . Indeed, it is becoming increasingly clear that individuals strongly vary in their ability to respond to internal and external sources of stress and that this fascinating source of variation has enormous implications for the interplay between physiology, morphology and life history evolution .
In our correlational study, we obviously cannot ascribe causal effects of such circulating carotenoid changes on offspring output per se. However, longitudinal studies such as ours that clearly demonstrate the important dynamics of physiological underpinnings of reproductive performance are essential for motivating future experimental studies and addressing the limitations of current data sets. Of course, it is important to consider the potential sources of variation in carotenoid accumulation as they may pertain to reproductive performance. Prior studies of birds have shown that elevated carotenoid accumulation can improve maternal egg production  as well as egg-yolk conditions for embryonic development , but here we show a longer- and later-term association between body carotenoid supplies and reproduction. Previous analyses of barn swallows from two geographically separate populations in North America demonstrate that females paired to darker males (shown here to have greater circulating concentrations of carotenoids) fed shared offspring at a greater rate . It is therefore plausible that relationships between ventral color and reproductive success  are to some extent mediated by parental carotenoid status. Interestingly, additional variables related to fecundity are not significantly correlated with carotenoid status, including clutch initiation date, clutch size, or the probability of multiple broods (RJS unpubl. data), suggesting that differential allocation of parental care may be important for explaining our results.
Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that physiological underpinnings of traits like ventral color, body mass, carotenoids, and reproduction are highly dynamic and that the positive management of physiological regulators (e.g. hormones, carotenoids) is adaptive , . Moreover, dynamical relationships between morphological and physiological traits are critical to account for when calculating the costs of both developing and expressing morphological signals used in competitive and reproductive contexts. Although previous research has demonstrated seasonal changes in melanin-based plumage in barn swallows , the interesting linkage between seasonal changes in coloration and carotenoid concentrations suggest that some individuals are both better at maintaining feather coloration and acquiring carotenoids via diet–possibly due to abilities to dedicate time both for preening and efficient foraging. Whereas previous studies have relied on single samples from individuals, our results suggest that repeated sampling schemes are perhaps best for gaining more comprehensive information about individual-variation in carotenoids in an ecological and evolutionary context.
For assistance, we thank Andrew Flynn, Connor Fitzhugh, Monica Brandhuber, and Lori Fraser. We are grateful to various landowners throughout Boulder County for access to their barn swallows. We thank Drs. Barbara Demmig-Adams, Sam Flaxman, Patrik Nosil and Brett Melbourne (all at University of Colorado) and Dr. Richard Prum (Yale University) for interesting discussions related to this work.
Conceived and designed the experiments: RJS. Performed the experiments: RJS MRW. Analyzed the data: RJS JKH JM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: RJS KJM JKH. Wrote the paper: RJS KJM. Detailed editing of the manuscript: KJM. Field data collection: MRW. Manuscript revisions: MRW. Extensive color data analysis: JKH. Extensive data collection on plumage coloration: JM.
- 1. Hughes DA (2001) Dietary carotenoids and human immune function. Nutrition 17: 823–827.DA Hughes2001Dietary carotenoids and human immune function.Nutrition17823827
- 2. Krinsky NI (2001) Carotenoids as antioxidants. Nutrition 17: 815–817.NI Krinsky2001Carotenoids as antioxidants.Nutrition17815817
- 3. Alonso-Alvarez C, Bertrand S, Devevey G, Gaillard M, Prost J, et al. (2004a) An experimental test of the dose-dependent effects of carotenoids and immune activation on sexual signals and antioxidant activity. Am Nat 164: 651–659.C. Alonso-AlvarezS. BertrandG. DeveveyM. GaillardJ. Prost2004aAn experimental test of the dose-dependent effects of carotenoids and immune activation on sexual signals and antioxidant activity.Am Nat164651659DOI:10.1086/424971. DOI:10.1086/424971.
- 4. Hõrak P, Saks L, Zilmer Z, Karu U, Zilmer K (2007) Do dietary antioxidants alleviate the cost of immune activation? An experiment with greenfinches. Am Nat 170: 625–635.P. HõrakL. SaksZ. ZilmerU. KaruK. Zilmer2007Do dietary antioxidants alleviate the cost of immune activation? An experiment with greenfinches.Am Nat170625635DOI:10.1086/521232. DOI:10.1086/521232.
- 5. Costantini D, Møller AP (2008) Carotenoids as minor antioxidants for birds. Funct Ecol 22: 367–370.D. CostantiniAP Møller2008Carotenoids as minor antioxidants for birds.Funct Ecol22367370
- 6. McGraw KJ, Ardia DR (2003) Carotenoids, immunocompetence, and the information content of sexual colors: an experimental test. Am Nat 162: 704–712.KJ McGrawDR Ardia2003Carotenoids, immunocompetence, and the information content of sexual colors: an experimental test.Am Nat162704712DOI:10.1086/378094. DOI:10.1086/378094.
- 7. Blount JD, Metcalfe NB, Birkhead TR, Surai PF (2003) Carotenoid modulation of immune function and sexual attractiveness in zebra finches. Science 300: 125–127.JD BlountNB MetcalfeTR BirkheadPF Surai2003Carotenoid modulation of immune function and sexual attractiveness in zebra finches.Science300125127DOI:10.1126/science.1082141. DOI:10.1126/science.1082141.
- 8. Pike TW, Blount JD, Bjerkeng B, Lindstrom J, Metcalfe NB (2007) Carotenoids, oxidative stress and female mating preference for longer lived males. Proc Roy Soc B 274: 1591–1596.TW PikeJD BlountB. BjerkengJ. LindstromNB Metcalfe2007Carotenoids, oxidative stress and female mating preference for longer lived males.Proc Roy Soc B27415911596DOI:10.1098/rspb.2007.0317. DOI:10.1098/rspb.2007.0317.
- 9. Ninni P, de Lope F, Saino N, Haussy C, Møller AP (2004) Antioxidants and condition-dependence of arrival in a migratory passerine. Oikos 105: 55–64.P. NinniF. de LopeN. SainoC. HaussyAP Møller2004Antioxidants and condition-dependence of arrival in a migratory passerine.Oikos1055564DOI:10.1111/j.0030-1299.2004.12516.x. DOI:10.1111/j.0030-1299.2004.12516.x.
- 10. Catoni C, Peters A, Schaefer M (2008) Life history trade-offs are influenced by the diversity, availability, and interactions of dietary antioxidants. Anim Behav 76: 1107–1119.C. CatoniA. PetersM. Schaefer2008Life history trade-offs are influenced by the diversity, availability, and interactions of dietary antioxidants.Anim Behav7611071119
- 11. Costantini D, Verhulst S (2009) Does high antioxidant capacity indicate low oxidative stress? Funct Ecol 23: 506–509.D. CostantiniS. Verhulst2009Does high antioxidant capacity indicate low oxidative stress?Funct Ecol23506509DOI:10.1111/j.1365-2435.2009.01546.x. DOI:10.1111/j.1365-2435.2009.01546.x.
- 12. Wiersma P, Selman C, Speakman JR, Verhulst S (2004) Birds sacrifice oxidative protection for reproduction. Proc Roy Soc B 271: S360–363.P. WiersmaC. SelmanJR SpeakmanS. Verhulst2004Birds sacrifice oxidative protection for reproduction.Proc Roy Soc B271S360363DOI:10.1098/rsbl.2004.0171. DOI:10.1098/rsbl.2004.0171.
- 13. Bertrand S, Alonso-Alvarez C, Devevey G, Faivre B, Prost J (2006) Carotenoids modulate the trade-off between egg production and resistance to oxidative stress. Oecologia 147: 576–584.S. BertrandC. Alonso-AlvarezG. DeveveyB. FaivreJ. Prost2006Carotenoids modulate the trade-off between egg production and resistance to oxidative stress.Oecologia147576584DOI:10.1007/s00442-005-0317-8. DOI:10.1007/s00442-005-0317-8.
- 14. Monaghan P, Metcalfe N, Torres R (2009) Oxidative stress as a mediator of life history trade-offs: mechanisms, measurements, and interpretation. Ecol Lett 12: 75–92.P. MonaghanN. MetcalfeR. Torres2009Oxidative stress as a mediator of life history trade-offs: mechanisms, measurements, and interpretation.Ecol Lett127592
- 15. Saino N, Stradi R, Ninni P, Møller AP (1999) Carotenoid plasma concentration, immune profile, and plumage ornamentation of male barn swallows (Hirundo rustica). Am Nat 15: 441–448.N. SainoR. StradiP. NinniAP Møller1999Carotenoid plasma concentration, immune profile, and plumage ornamentation of male barn swallows (Hirundo rustica).Am Nat15441448DOI:10.1086/303246. DOI:10.1086/303246.
- 16. McGraw KJ, Safran RJ, Evans MR, Wakamatsu K (2004) European barn swallows use melanin pigments to color their feathers brown. Behav Ecol 15: 889–891.KJ McGrawRJ SafranMR EvansK. Wakamatsu2004European barn swallows use melanin pigments to color their feathers brown.Behav Ecol15889891DOI:10.1093/beheco/arh109. DOI:10.1093/beheco/arh109.
- 17. Safran RJ, McGraw KJ (2004) Plumage coloration, not length or symmetry of tail-streamers, is a sexually selected trait in North American barn swallows. Behav Ecol 15: 455–461.RJ SafranKJ McGraw2004Plumage coloration, not length or symmetry of tail-streamers, is a sexually selected trait in North American barn swallows.Behav Ecol15455461DOI:10.1093/beheco/arh035. DOI:10.1093/beheco/arh035.
- 18. Safran RJ, Neuman CR, McGraw KJ, Lovette IJ (2005) Dynamic paternity allocated as a function of male plumage color in barn swallows. Science 309: 2210–2212.RJ SafranCR NeumanKJ McGrawIJ Lovette2005Dynamic paternity allocated as a function of male plumage color in barn swallows.Science30922102212DOI:10.1126/science.1115090. DOI:10.1126/science.1115090.
- 19. McGraw KJ, Tourville EA, Butler MW (2008) A quantitative comparison of the commonly used methods for extracting carotenoids from avian plasma. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 62: 1991–2002.KJ McGrawEA TourvilleMW Butler2008A quantitative comparison of the commonly used methods for extracting carotenoids from avian plasma.Behav Ecol Sociobiol6219912002DOI:10.1007.s00265-008-0622-4. DOI:10.1007.s00265-008-0622-4.
- 20. Safran RJ, Pilz KM, McGraw KJ, Correa S, Schwabl H (2008) Maternal deposition of egg-yolk androgens and carotenoids in barn swallows: is allocation related to indicators of parental quality? Behav Ecol Sociobiol 62: 427–438.RJ SafranKM PilzKJ McGrawS. CorreaH. Schwabl2008Maternal deposition of egg-yolk androgens and carotenoids in barn swallows: is allocation related to indicators of parental quality?Behav Ecol Sociobiol62427438DOI:10.1007/s00265-007-0470-7. DOI:10.1007/s00265-007-0470-7.
- 21. Safran RJ (2004) Adaptive site selection rules and variation in group size of barn swallows: individual decisions predict population patterns. Am Nat 164: 121–131.RJ Safran2004Adaptive site selection rules and variation in group size of barn swallows: individual decisions predict population patterns.Am Nat164121131
- 22. Safran RJ (2006) Nest-Site Selection Decisions in Barn Swallows: What Predicts Reproductive Performance? Can J Zool 84: 1533–1539.RJ Safran2006Nest-Site Selection Decisions in Barn Swallows: What Predicts Reproductive Performance?Can J Zool8415331539
- 23. Safran RJ, Adelman J, McGraw KJ, Hau M (2008) Sexual signal exaggeration affects physiological state in a social vertebrate. Curr Biol 18: R461–462.RJ SafranJ. AdelmanKJ McGrawM. Hau2008Sexual signal exaggeration affects physiological state in a social vertebrate.Curr Biol18R461462DOI:10.1016/j.cub.2008.03.031. DOI:10.1016/j.cub.2008.03.031.
- 24. Wang Y (2001) A cost of reproduction: oxidative stress susceptibility is associated with increased egg production in Drosophila melanogaster. Exp Gerontol 36: 1349–1359.Y. Wang2001A cost of reproduction: oxidative stress susceptibility is associated with increased egg production in Drosophila melanogaster.Exp Gerontol3613491359DOI:10.1016/S0531-5565(01)00095-X. DOI:10.1016/S0531-5565(01)00095-X.
- 25. Alonso-Alvarez C, Bertrand S, Devevey G, Prost J, Faivre B, et al. (2004b) Oxidative stress as a proximate cost of reproduction. Ecol Lett 7: 363–368.C. Alonso-AlvarezS. BertrandG. DeveveyJ. ProstB. Faivre2004bOxidative stress as a proximate cost of reproduction.Ecol Lett7363368DOI:10.111/j.1461-0248.2004.00594.x. DOI:10.111/j.1461-0248.2004.00594.x.
- 26. Dowling DK, Simmons LW (2009) Reactive oxygen species as universal constraints in life-history evolution. Proc Roy Soc B 276: 1737–1745.DK DowlingLW Simmons2009Reactive oxygen species as universal constraints in life-history evolution.Proc Roy Soc B27617371745DOI:10.1098.rspb.2008.1791. DOI:10.1098.rspb.2008.1791.
- 27. Ardia DR (2005) Individual quality mediates tradeoffs between reproductive effort and immune function in tree swallows. J Anim Ecol 74: 517–524.DR Ardia2005Individual quality mediates tradeoffs between reproductive effort and immune function in tree swallows.J Anim Ecol74517524DOI:10.1111/j.1365-2656.2005.00950.x. DOI:10.1111/j.1365-2656.2005.00950.x.
- 28. Saino N, Ferrari R, Romano M, Martinelli R, Møller AP (2003) Experimental manipulation of egg carotenoids affects immunity of barn swallow nestlings. Proc R Soc Lond B 270: 2485–2489.N. SainoR. FerrariM. RomanoR. MartinelliAP Møller2003Experimental manipulation of egg carotenoids affects immunity of barn swallow nestlings.Proc R Soc Lond B27024852489DOI:10.1098/rspb.2003.2534. DOI:10.1098/rspb.2003.2534.
- 29. Maguire SE, Safran RJ (2010) Morphological and genetic predictors of parental care in the North American barn swallow. J Avian Biol 41: 1–9.SE MaguireRJ Safran2010Morphological and genetic predictors of parental care in the North American barn swallow.J Avian Biol4119DOI 10.1111/j.1600-048X.2009.04806.x. DOI 10.1111/j.1600-048X.2009.04806.x.
- 30. Rubenstein DR, Hauber ME (2008) Dynamic feedback between phenotype and physiology in sexually selected traits. Trends in Ecol and Evol 23: 655–658.DR RubensteinME Hauber2008Dynamic feedback between phenotype and physiology in sexually selected traits.Trends in Ecol and Evol23655658DOI:10.1016/j.tree.2008.07.010. DOI:10.1016/j.tree.2008.07.010.
- 31. Hasegawa M, Arai E, Watanabe M, Nakamura M (2008) Methods for correcting plumage color fading in the Barn Swallow. Ornithol Sci 7: 117–122.M. HasegawaE. AraiM. WatanabeM. Nakamura2008Methods for correcting plumage color fading in the Barn Swallow.Ornithol Sci7117122