The derivation of domestic cattle from the extinct wild aurochs (Bos primigenius) has been well-documented by archaeological and genetic studies. Genetic studies point towards the Neolithic Near East as the centre of origin for Bos taurus, with some lines of evidence suggesting possible, albeit rare, genetic contributions from locally domesticated wild aurochsen across Eurasia. Inferences from these investigations have been based largely on the analysis of partial mitochondrial DNA sequences generated from modern animals, with limited sequence data from ancient aurochsen samples. Recent developments in DNA sequencing technologies, however, are affording new opportunities for the examination of genetic material retrieved from extinct species, providing new insight into their evolutionary history. Here we present DNA sequence analysis of the first complete mitochondrial genome (16,338 base pairs) from an archaeologically-verified and exceptionally-well preserved aurochs bone sample.
DNA extracts were generated from an aurochs humerus bone sample recovered from a cave site located in Derbyshire, England and radiocarbon-dated to 6,738±68 calibrated years before present. These extracts were prepared for both Sanger and next generation DNA sequencing technologies (Illumina Genome Analyzer). In total, 289.9 megabases (22.48%) of the post-filtered DNA sequences generated using the Illumina Genome Analyzer from this sample mapped with confidence to the bovine genome. A consensus B. primigenius mitochondrial genome sequence was constructed and was analysed alongside all available complete bovine mitochondrial genome sequences.
For all nucleotide positions where both Sanger and Illumina Genome Analyzer sequencing methods gave high-confidence calls, no discrepancies were observed. Sequence analysis reveals evidence of heteroplasmy in this sample and places this mitochondrial genome sequence securely within a previously identified aurochsen haplogroup (haplogroup P), thus providing novel insights into pre-domestic patterns of variation. The high proportion of authentic, endogenous aurochs DNA preserved in this sample bodes well for future efforts to determine the complete genome sequence of a wild ancestor of domestic cattle.
Citation: Edwards CJ, Magee DA, Park SDE, McGettigan PA, Lohan AJ, Murphy A, et al. (2010) A Complete Mitochondrial Genome Sequence from a Mesolithic Wild Aurochs (Bos primigenius). PLoS ONE 5(2): e9255. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0009255
Editor: Michael Knapp, University of Otago, New Zealand
Received: October 1, 2009; Accepted: January 29, 2010; Published: February 17, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Edwards et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by Principal Investigator Grants from Science Foundation Ireland (project numbers: SFI/01/F.1/B028; 08/IN.l/B2038) and a Research Stimulus Grant from the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (project number: RSF 06 406). B.J.L. is supported by a Science Foundation Ireland Research Professorship (grant number: 05/RP1/908/EC07). C.J.E. was supported by a Science Foundation Ireland Research Frontiers Programme (project number: 05/RF/MAT031). Science Foundation Ireland (SFI) website: http://www.sfi.ie. Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (DAFF) website: http://www.agriculture.gov.ie/. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The now-extinct aurochs (Bos primigenius), which ranged throughout much of Eurasia and Northern Africa during the late Pleistocene and early Holocene, is widely accepted as the wild ancestor of modern cattle , . Archaeological evidence shows that domestication of this formidable animal occurred independently in the Near East and the Indian subcontinent between 10,000–8,000 years ago, giving rise to the two major domestic taxa observed today — humpless Bos taurus (taurine) and humped Bos indicus (zebu), respectively , . This is confirmed by genetic analyses of matrilineal mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequences, which reveal a marked differentiation between modern B. taurus and B. indicus haplotypes, demonstrating their derivation from two geographically- and genetically-divergent wild populations .
More recently, the fine-scale phylogeographic structure of extant bovine mtDNA sequence variation has been elucidated. The majority of taurine mtDNA sequences cluster within macro-haplogroup T, which consists of six sub-haplogroups (T, T1, T2, T3, T4 and T5) , , . Geographic distribution of these sub-haplogroups has provided evidence for the derived Near Eastern origin of European B. taurus and lent support for separate domestications of African and North East Asian B. taurus cattle , . B. indicus mtDNA sequences are highly divergent from B. taurus sequences, and fall within macro-haplogroup I. This macro-haplogroup is further subdivided into the I1 and I2 sub-haplogroups, which display some geographic partitioning across South Asia , , .
DNA sequences retrieved from ancient cattle have also shed light on the pre-domestication history of the Bos spp. lineage. Partial mtDNA control region and cytochrome b gene (CYTB) sequences from Central and Northern European aurochsen samples belong predominantly to a distinct haplogroup (designated ‘P’), which diverged from macro-haplogroup T prior to domestication, though substantially later than the branching leading to macro-haplogroup I , , , . A single exception, a sample from the Early Neolithic German site of Eilsleben, falls outside the clade containing haplogroup P and macro-haplogroup T, and has been assigned the novel haplotype E . A contrasting picture is seen in Italy, where all ancient aurochsen mtDNA control region sequences to date have been assigned to macro-haplogroup T . Molecular clock estimates based on ancient sequences indicate that haplogroup P underwent an expansion between 10,050 and 30,230 years prior to sample deposition, or approximately 16,000 to 36,000 years before present (yBP). This is consistent with a Late Glacial repopulation of Northern and Central Europe from Iberian and/or Balkan refugia . Expansion within haplogroup P seems to pre-date expansion within the sub-haplogroups of macro-haplogroup T, which appears to have occurred around the time of domestication in the Near East , , .
The observation that modern European B. taurus belong almost exclusively to macro-haplogroup T together with the absence of haplogroup P sequences in these animals suggests that there was no major maternal contribution to the European domestic cattle genetic pool from locally recruited wild cattle , , . However, the recent reporting of two novel, albeit rare, putative aurochs sequences (haplogroups Q and R) in modern animals sampled in Italy, together with the detection of a haplogroup P sequence in a modern taurine animal support at least some local adoption of wild aurochsen matrilines , . Moreover, the detection of pre-Neolithic macro-haplogroup T sequences in European aurochs samples has led some authors to argue that this haplogroup was not restricted to the Near East, and that wild haplogroup T females may have been incorporated locally into the European domestic pool . In contrast to mtDNA studies, analyses of paternally-inherited Y-chromosome haplotypes are equivocal on whether male aurochsen contributed to European B. taurus , .
The recent advent of high-throughput DNA sequencing technologies, also referred to as ‘next-generation sequencing’ (NGS) technologies, is heralding a new era for ancient DNA studies . Such investigations have already generated considerable DNA sequence information from extinct mammals, including complete mtDNA genomes from ancient woolly mammoth, thylacine, rhinoceroses and hominid samples, giving new insight into their evolutionary history , , , , , , , , . Future research is expected to reveal functional genetic polymorphisms, such as that previously reported for the Neanderthal mtDNA genome . NGS technologies also enable the quantification of post-mortem chemical modification and contamination with modern genetic material, the two major sources of error in ancient DNA sequencing , , , , , , .
In 2001, we reported DNA sequence variation in the most variable 240 base pair (bp) fragment of the mtDNA control region from four British aurochs samples . In this and subsequent laboratory studies performed by us, a single aurochs humerus bone sample (laboratory code CPC98) consistently yielded high-quality B. primigenius mtDNA sequences allowing phylogenetic placement of this sample within haplogroup P , . This sample was excavated in 1998 from Carsington Pasture Cave in Derbyshire, England, and has been radiocarbon dated to 6,738±68 calibrated (cal.) yBP. This pre-dates the start of the Neolithic period in Britain (5,900–5,580 cal. yBP)  and the earliest British macro-haplogroup T-carrying bone sample , giving a secure basis for its classification as B. primigenius.
Here, we present the complete mtDNA genome sequence of the CPC98 sample using a combination of conventional polymerase chain reaction (PCR)/Sanger DNA sequencing and a direct high-throughput sequencing approach (Illumina Genome Analyzer). To our knowledge, this study represents the first description of the complete mtDNA genome sequence of an archaeologically-verified aurochs. We have analysed the complete aurochs mtDNA genome sequence together with previously published complete mtDNA sequences generated from modern bovine samples. We discuss our findings in light of the current understanding of the evolutionary history of domestic cattle. In addition, we note that the high proportion of authentic aurochs DNA sequences preserved in this sample offers promise for future efforts to obtain a complete B. primigenius genome sequence.
Summary of Sanger mtDNA Sequencing
A total of 31 primer pairs were designed, based on the GenBank B. taurus mtDNA reference sequence (GenBank accession no. V00654)  to generate partially-overlapping polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplicons, with an average length of 646 bp, spanning the complete sequence of the aurochs mtDNA genome. Successful PCR amplifications were produced from multiple independent CPC98 DNA extractions (ranging from two to seven independent DNA extractions) for all 31 amplicons using a multiplex PCR approach , and were sequenced bi-directionally using the conventional Sanger-based methodology. All independent PCR amplicons were sequenced between four and 17 times. Alignment of the DNA sequences (with PHRED scores ≥16) with the B. taurus reference mtDNA sequence allowed overlapping sequences to be identified, and assembled into a contiguous, complete CPC98 mtDNA sequence consisting of 16,338 bp. Sequencing depth across the contiguous 16,338 bp mtDNA genome ranged between 2× and 19× with an average of 7.9×. There is an apparent discrepancy in the sequencing depth for each mtDNA nucleotide (ranging from 2× to 19×) and the number of times independent amplicons were sequenced (ranging from 4× to 17×). This is due to the overlapping nature of several of the PCR amplicons and also the filtering of nucleotides displaying low PHRED scores (≤16). Detailed information for each of the PCR amplicons used for Sanger-based sequencing is provided in the supporting information (Table S1).
Summary of Illumina Genome Analyzer Sequencing and mtDNA Sequence Assembly
A total of 49,125,583 Illumina Genome Analyzer (GA) single sequence reads, each 36 nucleotides in length, were produced from three independently prepared CPC98 Illumina GA libraries and sequenced across 14 lanes of three flow cells. 13,292,821 reads (27.06%) were identified as consisting largely or entirely of Illumina GA sequencing adaptor sequence and were excluded.
Of the remaining non-Illumina GA adaptor reads, sequence alignment analysis showed that 8,053,754 reads (22.48% of the non-adaptor reads), comprising 289.93 Mb, mapped with high-confidence (PHRED score ≥30) to Btau4.0 build of the B. taurus reference nuclear genome sequence (http://genome.ucsc.edu/). Screening for potential duplicate read sequences (reads from the same Illumina GA library, mapping to the same base position on the same strand) found only 100,922 such reads (1.25% of the total non-adaptor reads aligning to the bovine genome). This yields a conservative total of 7,952,832 non-duplicate, bovine genome-aligned reads.
5,144 reads (0.06% of bovine genome-aligned reads with potential duplicates included), yielding 185.1 kb, mapped with high-confidence across their whole length to the B. taurus reference haplogroup P reference mtDNA sequence (GenBank accession no. DQ124389). Removal of all possible duplicate reads left 4,108 non-duplicate reads, giving 147.9 kb of sequence. These figures give a ratio of nuclear DNA reads to bovine mtDNA reads of 1,930:1. When genome size is considered, and assuming a bovine diploid nuclear genome size of 5.74 gigabases , we obtained an estimate of the ratio of mtDNA genome sequences to nuclear genome sequences of 182:1 in the CPC98 bone sample.
The 4,108 non-duplicate mtDNA reads were assembled into an alignment and the consensus was determined for each nucleotide position. The total length of the Illumina GA-generated mtDNA consensus sequence where ≥ two-fold coverage was obtained for each nucleotide position was 15,339 bp. The average read depth across these 15,339 bp was 9.6×. Interspersed within this sequence were 51 regions not covered by any reads or covered at a read depth of 1× only. For these sequence-poor regions, no sequence information was obtained for 420 nucleotide positions of the reference sequence and 581 nucleotide positions were covered at a read depth of 1×. The identity of the missing nucleotides and those nucleotides with 1× coverage was determined via comparison with the Sanger-generated CPC98 mtDNA sequence.
Comparison of the Illumina GA-generated 15,339 bp mtDNA consensus sequence with the Sanger sequence revealed a total of three nucleotide mismatches at positions 2,614, 10,045 and 16,121 (note: all nucleotide positions reported in this study are numbered according to the B. taurus mtDNA reference sequence, GenBank accession no. V00654). Two of these (nucleotide positions 2,614 and 10,045) were covered at a read depth of only 2× and exhibited ambiguous nucleotides. The corresponding positions in the Sanger sequence were unambiguous and were used for assembly of the final consensus mtDNA sequence. The final mismatch at position 16,121 displayed heteroplasmy and is discussed later. A summary of the DNA sequences generated using the Illumina GA for the CPC98 sample, including nuclear and mtDNA genomic data, is detailed in Table 1.
Overall, combined analysis of the Illumina GA and Sanger sequences yielded a final mtDNA consensus assembly of 16,338 bp. The lowest sequence coverage was 2×, for just one nucleotide position (nucleotide position 67). Eighty-nine positions were covered at 3× and all other positions were covered at 4× or greater. The combined average sequence depth across all 16,338 bp was estimated at 16.9×. This mtDNA consensus sequence was used for all subsequent analyses described here.
Estimates of CPC98 Contamination with Modern DNA
(a) Contamination with modern bovine DNA sequences.
To estimate the level of sequence contamination of the CPC98 Illumina GA libraries with modern bovine DNA, we first catalogued mtDNA single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) distinguishing haplogroup P sequences from modern macro-haplogroup T, Q, R and I sequences. We then scanned each of the 4,108 non-duplicate reads mapped to the bovine mtDNA for the presence or absence of these haplogroup P-specific alleles. For this, 130 modern macro-haplogroup T, six haplogroup Q, four haplogroup R and seven haplogroup I complete mtDNA sequences retrieved from GenBank (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) were aligned along with the published modern haplogroup P sequence (GenBank accession DQ124389) and the CPC98 mtDNA consensus sequence obtained from Sanger and Illumina GA sequencing. In total, 18 SNPs discriminating the two haplogroup P sequences from the haplogroup T, Q and I sequences were identified. When haplogroup R sequences are included in this analysis, this figure reduces to 16 SNPs. Nucleotide calls for these positions were obtained from the individual Illumina GA sequence reads.
A total of 117 CPC98 reads spanned the 18 SNPs differentiating the haplogroup P sequences from haplogroup T, Q and I sequences. When haplogroup R sequences are considered, 110 reads span the 16 haplogroup P-defining substitutions (the CPC98 consensus allele at position 6,160 and 16,264 are the same as the haplogroup R). In both cases, only one of these reads carried the non-haplogroup P allele: a ‘C’ allele at nucleotide position 7,952, for which the haplogroup P consensus allele is a ‘T’. Considering this T-to-C mismatch at position 7,952 as a possible modern haplogroup T, R, Q or I contaminant in the Illumina GA CPC98 mtDNA sequence data we obtain an upper limit for modern bovine contamination of 1/117 (0.85%) (Table 2).
(b) Contamination with modern human DNA sequences.
We next investigated possible human contamination in the Illumina GA CPC98 reads. As stated previously, 8,053,754 reads (of which only 1.25% are potential duplicates) mapped to the bovine genome (PHRED score ≥30). Further analysis of these bovine genome-aligned sequence reads showed that 7,868,524 reads (21.96% of all non-adaptor reads) mapped to the bovine genome but not the human genome; 185,097 reads (0.52%) mapped to both the bovine and human genomes; and 48,555 reads (0.14%) mapped to the human genome only. 27,779,008 reads (77.52%) contained sequences that could not be aligned to either the bovine or human genomes. These figures provide an upper limit of contamination of CPC98 reads with modern human DNA only of 0.14% (Table 1).
Estimates of DNA Sequencing Errors for the CPC98 Aurochs Sample
The extent of DNA sequence error within the individual non-duplicate Illumina GA reads was assessed by comparing all non-duplicate Illumina GA nucleotide calls with the CPC98 consensus mtDNA sequence. 2,321 nucleotide mismatches were observed in a total of 147,549 individual Illumina GA nucleotide calls when compared to the CPC98 consensus sequence, yielding an estimated sequencing error rate of 1.57% (note: this figure excludes the observed heteroplasmy at position 16,121). C-to-T (n = 304; 0.81% consensus sequence C nucleotide calls called as T in individual Illumina GA reads) and G-to-A (n = 129; 0.70% consensus sequence G nucleotide calls called as A in individual Illumina GA reads) transitions accounted for 433 of the 2,321 identified nucleotide substitutions (18.66%) (Figure 1). C-to-A and G-to-T occur more frequently than expected mismatches caused by post-mortem cytosine deamination, namely C-to-T and G-to-A mismatches (1.11% C-to-A versus 0.81% for C-to-T and 1.51% G-to-T versus 0.70% for G-to-A), known to affect ancient DNA. Further analysis demonstrated that the majority of these detected nucleotide substitutions occur with the six 3′-most nucleotides of the individual Illumina GA 36 nucleotide-long reads—1,329/2,321 (57.30%) substitutions occur within these terminal six nucleotides (Figure 1).
(A) The number and proportion of each nucleotide called in the Illumina GA reads (vertical column) compared to the consensus mtDNA sequence (horizontal column) is presented. (B) Mean percentage of discordant nucleotides for each position across all individual Illumina GA sequence reads.
Sequence Analysis of the CPC98 Aurochs mtDNA Sequence
Alignment of the consensus CPC98 mtDNA sequence with the B. taurus mtDNA reference sequence (GenBank accession no. V00654) revealed a total of 71 variable nucleotide positions comprising 62 transitions, seven transversions and two indels (Figure 2). This result confirms the strong transitional bias in domestic animal mtDNA sequences as reported in previous studies , , , , , , , , , , . Twenty-two of these 71 (30.99%) nucleotide differences occur within the non-coding control region of the mtDNA genome. Of the remaining 49 substitutions, 37 occur in 12 of the 13 mitochondrial protein coding genes, five occur in five of the 22 mitochondrial tRNA genes, and seven occur in the two mitochondrial rRNA genes.
(A) Location of substitutions between the B. taurus reference and the B. primigenius (CPC98) mtDNA genome sequences. (B) Heteroplasmy detected from analysis of individual Illumina GA reads spanning nucleotide position 16,121. (C) Heteroplasmy at nucleotide position 16,121 detected from analysis of Sanger chromatograms. Nucleotide positions according to the bovine mtDNA reference sequence (GenBank accession no. V00654).
Notably, one nucleotide position in the control region sequence of CPC98 (16,121) is bi-allelic. Seven of the 11 non-duplicate Illumina GA reads spanning this position exhibited an A allele and the remaining four exhibited a G allele, while two potential duplicate reads also exhibited a G allele. The consensus nucleotide was an A/G polymorphism (MAQ program consensus sequence PHRED score = 44). The Sanger sequence data also showed that both A and G alleles were present at this position, as revealed by double chromatophore peaks (8× coverage from four independent DNA extracts). Given the high-confidence sequencing coverage and verification of this bi-allelic SNP from independently-prepared CPC98 DNA extracts using two sequencing technologies, we believe that this finding most probably represents mtDNA sequence heteroplasmy—namely the existence of two or more different mtDNA sequences within the same cell/tissue/individual (Figure 2).
Phylogenetic Analysis of the CPC98 Aurochs mtDNA Sequence
Phylogenetic analyses indicate that the CPC98 mtDNA sequence belongs to the previously defined aurochs-specific haplogroup P. Achilli and colleagues identified 37 substitutions that have occurred since this haplogroup diverged from the common ancestor with macro-haplogroup T and haplogroup Q . The CPC98 mtDNA sequence possesses 31 of these 37 nucleotide substitutions. Also, the phylogenetic tree presented in Figure 3 constructed from the CPC98 mtDNA consensus sequence, all available complete mtDNA sequences from domestic cattle (n = 148) and B. grunniens (yak; n = 5), shows that the CPC98 mtDNA sequence forms a distinct and well-supported (100% bootstrap support, 1,000 replicates) clade with the only other complete haplogroup P mtDNA sequence DQ124389.
Evolutionary distances were computed using the Maximum Composite Likelihood method and are in the units of the number of base substitutions per site. Only coding region sequences of the mtDNA genome were used for tree construction (mtDNA nucleotide position 364–15,791). Bootstrap values (1000 replicates) are shown next to the branches. The number of mtDNA sequences within each of the haplogroups is indicated. The haplogroup to which the CPC98 mtDNA genome sequence belongs is highlighted. Five complete mtDNA genome sequences from yak (B. grunniens) were used as outgroups.
Haplogroup P is a sister clade of the super-haplogroup QT with a previously estimated divergence time of 71,000 yBP . The DQ124389 sequence was encountered in a modern animal sampled in Korea and was deposited in GenBank in 2006 (Shin and Kim, unpublished data) and subsequently classified as belonging to haplogroup P , . Comparison of the consensus CPC98 mtDNA sequence with the DQ124389 mtDNA sequence revealed a total of 22 nucleotide differences, comprising 20 transitions (including two heteroplasmic sites: one at position 15,714 in DQ124389 and one at position 16,121 in CPC98) and two indels (Figure 4). Ten of the 22 nucleotide differences occur in the mtDNA control region, eight in three of the 13 protein-coding genes, two in the 16S rRNA gene, one in the tRNA-Tyr gene, and one in the tRNA-Thr gene.
Nucleotide positions according to the bovine mtDNA reference sequence (GenBank accession no. V00654).
To estimate the divergence time within haplogroup P, we first counted the number of substitutions [the parameter ‘rho’ (ρ)] between each of the CPC98 and DQ124389 samples and an inferred mutationally-equidistant ancestral sequence and multiplied by the previously used rate estimate of ~3,172 years per substitution in the coding region of the mtDNA genome (15,428 bp between nucleotide positions 364 and 15,791) . This generated a coalescence time of 19,032 years (95% confidence intervals 9,834-31,215 yBP). This figure however, must be adjusted as the CPC98 and DQ124389 samples are not contemporaneous, but lived 6,738±68 years apart according to radiocarbon dating. Adding half of this time difference gives a coalescence time of 22,401 yBP (95% confidence interval range 13,135-34,652 yBP).
Finally, we calculated genetic diversity statistics for each of the bovine mtDNA haplogroups including the data from the CPC98 sample and additional sequences from previously unanalysed haplogroup T sequences (Table 3). Taking these new data into account, nucleotide diversity (π) is highest in macro-haplogroup I compared to all other haplogroups. The diversity estimate for haplogroup P falls between that generated for macro-haplogroup T and haplogroup R.
DNA Sequence Diversity in Bovine Mitochondrial Protein and RNA Genes
The existence of potential functional nucleotide substitutions unique to haplogroup P was examined by aligning the CPC98 consensus mtDNA sequence with all complete modern cattle mtDNA sequences (n = 148) and screening for SNPs that occur in: (1) mitochondrial RNA genes and (2) mitochondrial protein-coding genes causing amino acid replacements. No non-synonymous substitutions were specific to and fixed in haplogroup P. Six of the 31 haplogroup P-defining substitutions present in the CPC98 mtDNA sequence occur in five different RNA genes. Four of these substitutions are unique to haplogroup P (nucleotide position 1,128 in 12S rRNA; 2,585 in 16S rRNA; 12,016 in tRNA-Ser and 15,673 in tRNA-Thr).
Metagenomic Analysis of Illumina Genome Analyzer CPC98 Reads
10.64% of the 840,000 sequence reads analysed were classified as belonging to the infraorder Pecora, with over half (5.44%) specifically classified as derived from B. taurus. The next most highly represented species were human (Homo sapiens) (1.11% of reads) and mouse (Mus musculus, 0.76% of reads). 4.52% of reads were classified as derived from green plants, 4.08% from fungi, 0.87% from bacteria and 0.14% from viruses. The majority of reads were either not assigned to any taxon (33.04% unknown) or classified very poorly (e.g. 24.19% were classified only as belonging to the Eukaryota) (Figure S1).
Aurochs mtDNA Sequence Authenticity and Preservation
Previous investigations have shown that the sequencing of ancient DNA is particularly sensitive to two major sources of error. Firstly, contamination with modern genetic material can result in the generation of inauthentic DNA sequences . Secondly, chemical modification of the bases in ancient sequences, primarily the deamination of cytosine residues to uracil, can cause nucleotide misincorporation in newly synthesised DNA during PCR amplification or DNA sequencing , . For the aurochs mtDNA genome presented here, four lines of evidence indicate that errors from both sources are low.
Firstly, we have achieved a high average sequence coverage of the CPC98 mtDNA genome using Illumina GA (9.1×) and Sanger (7.9× in total, with data generated from between two and seven independent primary multiplex PCRs) sequencing methodologies generated from multiple independent DNA extracts. For all nucleotide positions at which both Sanger and Illumina GA methods gave high-confidence calls, no discrepancies were observed. The consensus mtDNA sequence generated from both sequencing methods has a combined average sequencing depth of 16.9× across the complete genome (16,338 bp). This figure is comparable to the sequencing coverage generated for another ancient mammalian mtDNA genome recently retrieved from a bone sample .
Secondly, we see no evidence for contamination with modern bovine DNA. While our analysis does not exclude the possibility that the CPC98 mtDNA genome sequence has been contaminated with a modern haplogroup P sequence, this scenario seems unlikely given the extremely low frequency of this haplogroup in modern samples , , , , . When mtDNA sequences from all other modern bovine haplogroups (I, R, Q and T) are considered, we obtain a maximum possible estimate of modern contamination of 0.85%. Although comparable to the levels of modern contamination reported for ancient Neanderthal complete mtDNA genomes ,  this figure also corresponds to the observed rate of Illumina GA sequencing error detected for the CPC98 sample (discussed below).
We also observed that the number of Illumina GA reads mapping to the human genome, possibly indicating modern human contamination, is low. Of the total number of non-duplicated, non-Illumina GA adaptor sequence contaminant reads, 21.68% mapped exclusively to the bovine genome, compared with 0.52% mapping to both the bovine and human genomes. The latter group can most likely be explained by the presence of highly conserved sequences existing between the two genomes . Also, 0.14% of reads mapped solely to the human genome and did not match any sequence in the current bovine genome assembly. While this may be due to modern human contamination, and thus provide an upper estimate of any such contamination, it may equally reflect the incomplete status of the bovine genome sequence .
Thirdly, we observed no excess of the characteristic C-to-T and G-to-A misincorporations due to post-mortem cytosine deamination historically observed in ancient DNA studies. The absence of such nucleotide lesions in the CPC98 mtDNA sequence is attributable to the use, during Illumina GA library preparation, of Phusion® High-Fidelity DNA polymerase enzyme (New England Biosciences, see Materials and Methods section), which does not amplify efficiently through deaminated products of cytosine . The sequence errors observed are therefore not reflective of DNA diagenesis in the CPC98 but are most likely artefacts of the sequencing method used. We estimated the sequencing error rate for the individual Illumina GA reads to be 1.57%. Notably, the majority of errors occurred within the six 3′-most nucleotides of reads. This bias in the location of mismatched nucleotides, together with the observed excess of C-to-A and G-to-T sequencing errors, has previously been described as being inherent to the Illumina GA sequencing technology .
The proportion of non-duplicate, non-adaptor Illumina GA reads mapping to the aurochs (21.68%) is relatively high when compared with estimates of endogenous genetic material from other palaeogenomics surveys. While this figure is lower than that reported for ancient material retrieved from permafrost-preserved mammoth samples , , it is substantially higher when compared to other palaeogenetic studies where the proportion of endogenous sequences was estimated at between ~0.3%–6.0% , , , .
Finally, metagenomic analyses of the Illumina GA reads showed a high percentage of unambiguous B. taurus sequences. A substantially larger number of reads were classified as being derived from the infraorder Pecora with Bos spp. being the most probable source. Although this analysis identified a number of potential human sequences, we believe that this is due to over-representation of human genomic sequence in the GenBank non-redundant nucleotide database rather than contamination with modern human DNA. In support of this, a comparable number of Illumina GA reads were classified as M. musculus, another highly represented species in the database. It is difficult to make further conclusions regarding the other species contributing to the metagenome of CPC98 given the large number of unidentified sequences, reflecting the short Illumina GA read length used in this experiment .
Collectively, these findings support the contention that the B. primigenius mtDNA genome presented here is authentic.
Heteroplasmy in an Ancient mtDNA Genome
Our analysis revealed the presence of a single heteroplasmic nucleotide position (16,121) in the CPC98 mtDNA genome sequence. A recent assessment of complete human mtDNA genome sequences showed heteroplasmy to be relatively common, occurring in ~6.0% of all analysed samples . The heteroplasmic nucleotide position detected here occurs in the hypervariable region of the control region and has been previously identified as being a site where multiple substitutions have occurred . Consequently, our observation of heteroplasmy is highly plausible.
In this study, heteroplasmy in CPC98 was identified first via Illumina GA sequencing and then later confirmed by analysis of the Sanger chromatograms. The high sequence depth, combined with the digital nature of the NGS data, enables secure identification of heteroplasmic nucleotide loci in a way not previously possible given the analog nature of Sanger chromatogram data. Heteroplasmy has also been recently detected in an analysis of mtDNA sequences generated from archaeological human remains , and at a variable number tandem repeat (VNTR) locus in a complete mammoth mtDNA genome .
Genetic History of European B. primigenius Haplogroup P
Previous investigations have demonstrated that the predominant haplogroup within the Eurasian aurochs was haplogroup P , . Analysing the most variable portion of the mtDNA control region, Edwards et al.  showed that haplogroup P divergence predates divergence within macro-haplogroup T, the predominant haplogroup in modern B. taurus , , , , , . The analysis of complete mtDNA genome sequences presented here corroborates these findings. Mean mtDNA coding region pairwise nucleotide diversity (π) for the two haplogroup P sequences is ~1.2-fold higher than that for macro-haplogroup T (Table 3). The estimated divergence date for the two haplogroup P sequences (22,401 yBP) is 1.3-fold higher than that for macro-haplogroup T (16,000 yBP as estimated by Achilli et al. ). This divergence time agrees with the estimated time to the most recent common ancestor (TMRCA) for 51 predominantly Neolithic ancient haplogroup P samples of 17,230 years (95% confidence interval: 10,050 to 30,230 years) . Our estimate gives the date of divergence relative to present day, whereas that of Edwards et al.  is relative to the deposition date of the ancient samples, on average 6,262 years ago. This difference in time reference points accounts for the numerical difference between the time estimates.
The reduced level of diversity in macro-haplogroup T compared to that in haplogroup P reflects the differences in demographic history between the groups. Macro-haplogroup T underwent a Neolithic genetic bottleneck and subsequent rapid expansion as a consequence of domestication and ensuing millennia of animal husbandry , , , , . In contrast, the wild haplogroup P population existing in Europe until the arrival of macro-haplogroup T from the Near East was not subject to the same bottlenecking , .
Prospects for a Complete B. primigenius Nuclear Genome
The excellent preservation of the aurochs DNA within the CPC98 humerus sample, as demonstrated by the analysis of the mtDNA genome, paves the way for the sequencing of a complete aurochs nuclear genome. This potential is further supported by the generation of a large number (~7.9 million) of CPC98-derived DNA sequence reads (via Illumina GA sequencing) which map to regions of the B. taurus genome other than the mtDNA genome. Indeed, the mtDNA sequence presented here can be used during whole genome sequence assembly as an analytical standard of modern DNA contamination. This will provide confidence when obtaining multi-fold sequencing coverage of the complete aurochs genome.
Analysis of a complete B. primigenius genome sequence offers intriguing opportunities to study the recent evolutionary history of domesticated cattle and their wild ancestors, as well as providing insight into human prehistory. More crucially, a complete aurochs genome sequence will permit the identification of functional genetic differences between the B. taurus and B. primigenius lineages, especially those pertaining to agro-economic production traits that have been under intense selection, since the initial founding of domestic herds some 10,000 years ago.
Materials and Methods
Archaeological Sample Details
The aurochs sample analysed in this study (laboratory code CPC98) consists of the proximal half of a humerus retrieved from Carsington Pasture Cave, Derbyshire, England. (http://capra.group.shef.ac.uk/1/carsing.html). The control region of the mtDNA of this sample has been studied previously by Troy et al.  and Edwards et al.  using overlapping fragments of 201 bp and 411 bp, respectively. This sample was radiocarbon dated, as part of the analysis undertaken by Troy et al.  to 5,936±34 yBP (uncalibrated radiocarbon age). Using the online calibration programme CALIB (http://22.214.171.124/calib/), this equates to 6,738±68 cal. yBP. Therefore, this bone dates to the Mesolithic period in Britain and thus must be a B. primigenius animal, and not a morphological misidentification of a B. taurus animal. The Neolithic, and consequently domestic cattle, did not arrive in Britain until about 4,000 cal. BC —a timeframe equivalent to approx. 6,000 cal. yBP. The thermal age of this bone, defined as the time taken to produce a given degree of DNA degradation when temperature is held at a constant 10°C , , was calculated at 6,999 years, using the online DNA Recovery Rate Calculator (DRRC; personal communication, D. Harker 2009). The pre-Neolithic radiocarbon date, along with the excellent preservation of the specimen as demonstrated by us in previous studies , , , were the primary reasons why it was chosen for both Sanger and Illumina GA sequencing.
Ancient DNA Extraction
All ancient DNA extractions were performed in a specifically-dedicated ancient DNA laboratory. Powdered bone samples, weighing between 200 mg and 500 mg, were prepared using a small-scale version of the modified Yang et al. procedure  previously described by our group , ,  except that 200 µg/ml proteinase K (rather than 100 µg/ml) was added to the extraction buffer. Additionally, 5 µg/ml phage λ carrier DNA was added to the extraction buffer for those extracts analysed via Sanger sequencing only; no λ carrier DNA was added to the extracts analysed via Illumina GA technologies. In total, 13 DNA extractions were performed and all extracts gave sequence products. 10 extractions were sequenced via the Sanger sequencing method, while the other three were used to make three separate Illumina GA libraries. No extractions were analysed with both methods.
Sanger-Based DNA Sequencing of Ancient Aurochs DNA
Primer design for Sanger DNA sequencing.
The complete B. taurus mitochondrial genome  (GenBank accession no. V00654) was aligned with the complete mitochondrial sequences of sheep (Ovis aries ) and pig (Sus scrofa ) to identify regions of the genome that are strongly conserved between species. Primers were designed in these regions to give 31 overlapping primer pairs covering the entire genome (Table S1). The average PCR product length was 646 bp (ranging between 471 bp and 701 bp) and the average overlap between products, excluding primers, was 81 bases (ranging between 15 bp and 251 bp).
Multiplex amplification of the complete aurochs mtDNA genome.
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) set-up was conducted in a laboratory dedicated solely to pre-amplification ancient work. As extracted DNA can be a limiting factor to amplifying a whole mtDNA genome, a modified version of the multiplex PCR approach  was carried out. In their paper, Krause et al.  developed the multiplex approach to amplify the entire mitochondrial genome of a mammoth from just two initial PCR amplifications. In brief, this was accomplished by using primer pairs covering overlapping DNA sequence fragments across the complete mitochondrial genome. These primer pairs were then combined into three sets, each containing every third primer pair, with either 10 or 11 primer pairs in each set (Table S2). This was to avoid amplification of the short overlapping fragments during the multiplex step. Each of the three sets was used in a multiplex PCR amplification that required the same amount of ancient DNA template as would usually be used for amplifying a single target sequence. Subsequently, the three primary amplifications were diluted and used as templates in secondary PCR reactions, in which each product was amplified individually.
Multiplex primer mixes were made by adding equal amounts of all primers in that set at a concentration of 100 µM, and then adding either 4.0 µl (Amplification Sets 1 and 3) or 4.4 µl (Amplification Set 2) to each 20 µl 1st-round PCR tube, to give a final concentration of 1 µM. PCR amplifications were in 20 µl reaction volumes containing the following: 1× PCR buffer (10 mM Tris•HCl [pH 8.8]; 50 mM KCl; 0.1% Triton X-100), 4.0 mM MgCl2, 200 µM dNTPs, 1.0 µM of the primer mix, 0.5 units of Platinum Taq polymerase (Invitrogen), and 7.5 µl DNA, equating to ~15 mg of starting bone powder, as suggested by Krause et al. . First-round multiplex PCR was carried out in a dedicated PCR thermal cycler. Cycling parameters were as follows: 2 min denaturation step at 94°C, followed by 27 cycles of 20 s denaturation at 94°C, 30 s of annealing at 52°C, and 60 s of extension at 72°C, followed by a final 4 min extension step at 72°C. Between two and seven independent primary PCRs were performed for each of the three multiplex mixes.
A second-round PCR was then performed in the main analytical laboratory. The products from each first-round multiplex PCR were diluted 40-fold (780 µl of ddH2O was added to each 20 µl PCR amplification). Ten or 11 separate reactions (depending on the amplification set; Table S2) were performed in duplicate from each multiplex PCR, with one of the 31 primer pairs added. Amplification conditions were as for the first-round PCR, except the final primer concentration was increased to 1.5 µM. Reactions took place with 12.5 µl of diluted first-round PCR added to 50 µl reaction volumes. PCR cycling conditions were the same as in the first-round, except 33 cycles were used instead of 27. Products were then visualized on 1.5% agarose mini-gels. Multiple extraction and PCR blanks were included for each amplification and remained negative throughout.
PCR products were cleaned using the QIAquick PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen) according to the manufacturer's instructions, but with an additional wash step and elution in 40 µl of 1× TE buffer. Five separate batches of purified PCR products were Sanger-sequenced commercially by Macrogen Inc. (http://www.macrogen.com). Numbers of amplicons generated per primer pair are shown in Table S3. GC content of the amplified products ranged from 35% to 58%, with an average of 43%.
Authentication of Sanger-sequenced whole mtDNA genome.
The criteria for authenticating the mitochondrial genome sequence were as follows. Between two and five independent extractions were amplified for each primer region (Table S3). Reproducible data were designated as those that gave consistent sequences in at least four or more amplifications (numbers amplified per primer pair shown in Table S3). In order to be considered authentic, any mutations observed had to be replicated in sequences from two separate extracts. The Sanger mtDNA genome sequence derived from the CPC98 sample was, therefore, verified through independent extractions, amplifications and sequence determinations.
Both inter-lab and intra-lab replication was undertaken on separate samples of bone. Inter-lab replication was performed by B.S. at the Henry Wellcome Ancient Biomolecules Centre in Oxford. Using different extraction methods and primer pairs  a region of 654 bp was sequenced across the origin (from position 15,759 to 73), covering the tRNA-Pro gene and 68% of the 5′-end of the control region. Intra-lab replication was also carried at Trinity College Dublin as part of a CYTB study of aurochs samples . Again, different primer pairs were used to amplify two non-over-lapping fragments from the CYTB gene, totalling 365 bp (nucleotide positions 14,673-14,900 and 15,031–15,167).
In ancient mtDNA analysis, sequences can be recovered that are not authentic but derive from some external contaminant or the nuclear genome. We regard our Sanger B. primigenius sequence as genuine for the following reasons. By using separate samples of bone, a subset of sequences was independently replicated by B.S. at the Henry Wellcome Ancient Biomolecules Centre in Oxford using different extraction methods and primer pairs . The mtDNA sequence of the aurochs specimen is clearly of bovine origin but is unique. Each sequence generated using the Sanger method had a perfect match to overlapping fragments.
Preparation of Ancient Aurochs DNA Extracts for Illumina Genome Analyzer Sequencing
Three independent extracts of aurochs DNA from sample CPC98 (labelled C1, C2 and C3), each organised into three separate ~30 µl aliquots (labelled C11–3, C21–3 and C31–3 —giving a total of nine aliquots), were prepared for high-throughput sequencing using an Illumina Genome Analyzer, in a dedicated ancient DNA facility based in the Smurfit Institute of Genetics, Trinity College Dublin. All 30 µl from each aurochs DNA extract aliquot (n = 9) was prepared for Illumina GA single-read DNA sequencing according to the Illumina Genome Analyzer Genomic DNA sample preparation kit protocol (Illumina, Catalogue no. 1003806). The step-wise details of the Illumina GA library preparations are detailed below.
Blunt end-repair of aurochs DNA extracts.
Each 30 µl aurochs DNA extract was included in a 100 µl final reaction mixture containing 1× T4 DNA ligase buffer with 1 mM dATP (New England BioLabs [NEB]), 400 µM of each dNTP (Invitrogen), 15 units T4 DNA polymerase (NEB), 5 units DNA Polymerase I Large (Klenow) Fragment (NEB) and 50 units T4 polynucleotide kinase (NEB). Reaction mixtures were incubated at 20°C for 30 mins, after which end-repaired DNA was purified using a QIAquick PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen) and eluted in 32 µl of elution buffer according to manufacturer's instructions.
Creation of a single 3′-dATP overhang on the end-repaired aurochs DNA extracts.
To facilitate Illumina GA adaptor ligation, a single ‘A’ base was added to the 3′-ends of the blunt-end repaired aurochs DNA extracts. 32 µl of purified phosphorylated blunt end-repaired aurochs extract DNA was included in a final 50 µl reaction mixture containing: 1× Klenow fragment buffer (NEB), 200 µM dATP (Invitrogen), and 15 units Klenow fragment with 3′-to-5′ exonuclease activity (NEB). Reactions were incubated at 37°C for 30 min, after which DNA was purified using a QIAquick MinElute Kit (Qiagen) and eluted in 19 µl of elution buffer according to manufacturer's instructions.
Illumina Genome Analyzer adaptor ligation.
Ligation reactions (in 50 µl volumes) involved incubation of 19 µl of phosphorylated blunt-ended aurochs DNA extracts, with a 3′-dATP overhang, with 1× DNA ligase buffer (NEB), 1 µl of the proprietary Illumina GA single-read genomic adaptors (Illumina, catalogue no. FC-102-1003) and 10 units T4 DNA ligase (Invitrogen). Extracts were incubated at room temperature for 15 minutes, purified using QIAquick MinElute Kit (Qiagen) and eluted in 19 µl of elution buffer according to manufacturer's instructions.
Illumina Genome Analyzer DNA library preparations via PCR enrichment of purified end-repaired, adaptor-ligated DNA templates.
Individual Illumina GA libraries (n = 9) were produced via PCR enrichment of the end-repaired adaptor-ligated DNA templates prior to sequencing. PCR amplifications (50 µl) comprised 19 µl of end-repaired-linker-ligated aurochs DNA, 1× Phusion® High-Fidelity DNA polymerase buffer (NEB), 1 µl of forward primer, 1 µl of reverse primer (Illumina, catalogue no. FC-102-1003), 250 nM of each dNTP (Invitrogen) and 1 unit Phusion® High-Fidelity DNA polymerase (NEB). PCR amplification reactions consisted of an initial denaturation step of 98°C for 30 s, 18 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 65°C for 30 s and 72°C for 30 s, followed by a final extension step of 72°C for 5 min. PCR products were visualised following electrophoresis on a 1.5% agarose gel stained with ethidium bromide (0.5 µg/ml). All aurochs DNA extract aliquots yielded successful genomic libraries for Illumina GA sequencing. Examination of the PCR products indicated the majority of the aurochs DNA inserts within the Illumina GA libraries were ~40–60 bp in length. Individual libraries (n = 9) were subsequently pooled according to their initial extract number (C11–3, C21–3 and C31–3) to form three final libraries labelled C1, C2 and C3, respectively. Pooled libraries were purified using a QIAquick PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen) and eluted in 30 µl elution buffer according to manufacturer's instructions. Purified libraries were quantified using a Qubit™ fluorometer (Invitrogen) and a Quant-iT™ double-stranded DNA High-Sensitivity Assay Kit (Invitrogen). The final molar concentration of each of the three pooled libraries ranged between 0.51–0.66 µM.
Illumina Genome Analyzer DNA sequencing.
Cluster generation and sequencing were carried out on an Illumina cluster station and Genome Analyzer II sequencer according to the manufacturer's instructions. Libraries were sequenced as single read 36-mers using the standard Illumina Genome Analyzer pipeline. Intensity files generated by the IPAR server software were base called using Bustard (the Illumina base caller). The first flow cell was processed using pipeline version 1.0. All subsequent flow cells were processed using pipeline version 1.3. The Illumina GA-generated FASTQ quality scores from pipeline 1.0 and pipeline 1.3 were converted to PHRED scores (Sanger encoded) for use with MAQ .
Assembly of a B. primigenius mtDNA Genome from Illumina Genome Analyzer Sequence Reads
The bovine genome (version 4.0, released October 2007) sequences for all chromosomes and unmapped scaffolds were downloaded from the UCSC genome browser website (http://genome.ucsc.edu). The GenBank haplogroup P complete mtDNA genome sequence (GenBank accession no. DQ124389) was downloaded in place of the Hereford bovine genome 4.0 mtDNA sequence. The human genome sequence (hg19/GRCh37, released February 2009) was also downloaded.
Alignment of Illumina Genome Analyzer reads to genome sequences.
Illumina GA reads were aligned to the bovine and human genome sequences using the software package MAQ (Mapping Alignment with Quality, available from http://maq.sourceforge.net). Prior to alignment, contaminant sequence reads exactly matching the 33bp Illumina GA adaptor sequence were removed using the MAQ program. Additional reads matching at least 12 out of any 13 consecutive adaptor nucleotides were excluded from the analyses. The MAQ program was used to align the remaining sequence reads with the genome template, permitting up to three mismatches per 36-nucleotide read. Aligned sequences mapping to the DQ124389 bovine mtDNA genome sequence were assembled into a consensus sequence with associated quality information for each nucleotide position using the ‘assemble’ option of MAQ. Data on the mapping of individual reads was obtained using the ‘pileup’ option of MAQ.
Metagenomic analyses of Illumina Genome Analyzer reads.
Metagenomic analyses was performed to produce a taxonomic profile of the of the Illumina GA CPC98 reads. For this, 60,000 non-adaptor reads were selected randomly from each of 14 flow-cell lanes and BLAST searched against the GenBank non-redundant nucleotide database (downloaded November 2nd 2009) using the BLASTN program  with a word size of 7 and an expectation value of 100. Metagenomic analysis was performed on the BLAST output using the software application MEGAN  to determine the lowest common taxonomic ancestor for each sequence read.
mtDNA Sequence Analysis and Phylogenetics
Full length Bos spp. mtDNA sequences were obtained from GenBank. Sequences were aligned manually using MEGA version 4 (Molecular Evolutionary Genetic Analysis , Table S4). Neighbour joining trees were constructed in MEGA 4 using the maximum composite likelihood method, with all positions containing gaps and missing data eliminated from the dataset. 1,000 bootstrap replicates were performed for each tree. The TMRCA for haplogroup P and 95% confidence interval for this time estimate was calculated using the program CRED . Diversity statistics were calculated using Arlequin Version 2.0 . The positions of the gene and control region sequences within the mtDNA genome are detailed in Table S5.
MEGAN metagenomic analysis of the aurochs CPC98 Illumina GA reads. 60,000 non-adapter reads were selected randomly from each of 14 flow-cell lanes and BLAST searched against the GenBank non-redundant nucleotide database. Results were analysed using MEGAN software. Figures shown are percentages of the total 840,000 reads assigned to different taxa.
(0.60 MB TIF)
PCR primer sequence information for each of the 31 overlapping amplicons used for Sanger sequencing. Nucleotide positions are given based on the reference bovine mtDNA genome sequence (GenBank accession no. V00654).
(0.07 MB DOC)
A list of the multiplex PCR amplicon sets.
(0.03 MB DOC)
The number of PCR amplicons generated per primer pair.
(0.06 MB DOC)
A list of all complete bovine mtDNA sequences used for sequence and phylogenetic analysis in this study. The GenBank accession number and the macro-haplogroup/haplogroup to which individual mtDNA genome sequence belongs are provided.
(0.15 MB DOC)
The nucleotide positions of each mtDNA gene and the mtDNA control region. Base positions are according to the Bos taurus reference mtDNA genome sequence (GenBank accession no. V00654).
(0.07 MB DOC)
We would like to thank J.F. Baird for helpful discussions and scientific advice, and D. Harker and M.J. Collins (both University of York) for thermal age calculations. We are also greatly indebted to M.T. Gilbert (University of Copenhagen, Denmark) and A.W. Briggs (Max Planck Institute, Germany) for helpful comments and insights.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CJE DAM DGB BL DM. Performed the experiments: CJE DAM AJL AM BS. Analyzed the data: CJE DAM SDEP PAM EKF MR DGB DM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: AJL AM BS AC BL. Wrote the paper: CJE DAM SDEP DGB DM.
- 1. Clutton-Brock J (1989) The walking larder: patterns of domestication, pastoralism, and predation. xxii. London: Unwin Hyman. 368 p.
- 2. Mason IL (1984) Evolution of domesticated animals. xii. London: Longman. 452 p.
- 3. Bradley DG, Magee DA (2006) Genetics and the origins of domestic cattle. In: Zeder MA, Bradley DG, Emshwiller E, Smith BD, editors. Documenting domestication: new genetic and archaeological paradigms. London: University of California Press. pp. 317–328.
- 4. Helmer D, Gourichon L, Monchot H, Peters J, Sana Segui M (2005) Identifying early domestic cattle from Pre-Pottery Neolithic sites on the Midddle Euphrates using sexual dimorphism. In: Vigne J-D, Peters J, Helmer D, editors. The first steps of animal domestication: new archaeozoological approaches. Oxford: Oxbow. pp. 86–95.
- 5. Bruford MW, Bradley DG, Luikart G (2003) DNA markers reveal the complexity of livestock domestication. Nat Rev Genet 4: 900–910.
- 6. Achilli A, Olivieri A, Pellecchia M, Uboldi C, Colli L, et al. (2008) Mitochondrial genomes of extinct aurochs survive in domestic cattle. Curr Biol 18: R157–158.
- 7. Mannen H, Kohno M, Nagata Y, Tsuji S, Bradley DG, et al. (2004) Independent mitochondrial origin and historical genetic differentiation in North Eastern Asian cattle. Mol Phylogenet Evol 32: 539–544.
- 8. Troy CS, MacHugh DE, Bailey JF, Magee DA, Loftus RT, et al. (2001) Genetic evidence for Near-Eastern origins of European cattle. Nature 410: 1088–1091.
- 9. Baig M, Beja-Pereira A, Mohammad R, Kulkarni K, Farah S, et al. (2005) Phylogeography and origin of Indian domestic cattle. Current Science 89: 38–40.
- 10. Chen SY, Lin BZ, Baig M, Mitra B, Lopes RJ, et al. (2010) Zebu cattle are an exclusive legacy of the South Asia Neolithic. Mol Biol Evol 27: 1–6.
- 11. Magee DA, Mannen H, Bradley DG (2007) Duality in Bos indicus mtDNA diversity: Support for geographical complexity in zebu domestication. In: Petraglia MD, Allchin B, editors. The evolution and history of human populations in South Asia: inter-disciplinary studies in archaeology, biological anthropology, linguistics, and genetics. Dordrecht: Springer. pp. 385–392.
- 12. Bailey JF, Richards MB, Macaulay VA, Colson IB, James IT, et al. (1996) Ancient DNA suggests a recent expansion of European cattle from a diverse wild progenitor species. Proc Biol Sci 263: 1467–1473.
- 13. Edwards CJ, Bollongino R, Scheu A, Chamberlain A, Tresset A, et al. (2007) Mitochondrial DNA analysis shows a Near Eastern Neolithic origin for domestic cattle and no indication of domestication of European aurochs. Proc Biol Sci 274: 1377–1385.
- 14. Stock F, Edwards CJ, Bollongino R, Finlay EK, Burger J, et al. (2009) Cytochrome b sequences of ancient cattle and wild ox support phylogenetic complexity in the ancient and modern bovine populations. Anim Genet 40: 694–700.
- 15. Beja-Pereira A, Caramelli D, Lalueza-Fox C, Vernesi C, Ferrand N, et al. (2006) The origin of European cattle: evidence from modern and ancient DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 8113–8118.
- 16. Achilli A, Bonfiglio S, Olivieri A, Malusa A, Pala M, et al. (2009) The multifaceted origin of taurine cattle reflected by the mitochondrial genome. PLoS One 4: e5753.
- 17. Magee DA, Meghen C, Harrison S, Troy CS, Cymbron T, et al. (2002) A partial african ancestry for the creole cattle populations of the Caribbean. J Hered 93: 429–432.
- 18. Bollongino R, Elsner J, Vigne JD, Burger J (2008) Y-SNPs do not indicate hybridisation between European aurochs and domestic cattle. PLoS One 3: e3418.
- 19. Gotherstrom A, Anderung C, Hellborg L, Elburg R, Smith C, et al. (2005) Cattle domestication in the Near East was followed by hybridization with aurochs bulls in Europe. Proc Biol Sci 272: 2345–2350.
- 20. Clark AG (2008) Genome sequences from extinct relatives. Cell 134: 388–389.
- 21. Briggs AW, Good JM, Green RE, Krause J, Maricic T, et al. (2009) Targeted retrieval and analysis of five Neandertal mtDNA genomes. Science 325: 318–321.
- 22. Ermini L, Olivieri C, Rizzi E, Corti G, Bonnal R, et al. (2008) Complete mitochondrial genome sequence of the Tyrolean Iceman. Curr Biol 18: 1687–1693.
- 23. Gilbert MT, Drautz DI, Lesk AM, Ho SY, Qi J, et al. (2008) Intraspecific phylogenetic analysis of Siberian woolly mammoths using complete mitochondrial genomes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105: 8327–8332.
- 24. Gilbert MT, Kivisild T, Gronnow B, Andersen PK, Metspalu E, et al. (2008) Paleo-Eskimo mtDNA genome reveals matrilineal discontinuity in Greenland. Science 320: 1787–1789.
- 25. Gilbert MT, Tomsho LP, Rendulic S, Packard M, Drautz DI, et al. (2007) Whole-genome shotgun sequencing of mitochondria from ancient hair shafts. Science 317: 1927–1930.
- 26. Green RE, Malaspinas AS, Krause J, Briggs AW, Johnson PL, et al. (2008) A complete Neandertal mitochondrial genome sequence determined by high-throughput sequencing. Cell 134: 416–426.
- 27. Miller W, Drautz DI, Janecka JE, Lesk AM, Ratan A, et al. (2009) The mitochondrial genome sequence of the Tasmanian tiger (Thylacinus cynocephalus). Genome Res 19: 213–220.
- 28. Willerslev E, Gilbert MT, Binladen J, Ho SY, Campos PF, et al. (2009) Analysis of complete mitochondrial genomes from extinct and extant rhinoceroses reveals lack of phylogenetic resolution. BMC Evol Biol 9: 95.
- 29. Krause J, Briggs AW, Kircher M, Maricic T, Zwyns N, et al. (2009) A complete mtDNA genome of an early modern human from Kostenki, Russia. Curr Biol [Epub ahead of print].
- 30. Briggs AW, Stenzel U, Johnson PL, Green RE, Kelso J, et al. (2007) Patterns of damage in genomic DNA sequences from a Neandertal. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 14616–14621.
- 31. Brotherton P, Endicott P, Sanchez JJ, Beaumont M, Barnett R, et al. (2007) Novel high-resolution characterization of ancient DNA reveals C>U-type base modification events as the sole cause of post mortem miscoding lesions. Nucleic Acids Res 35: 5717–5728.
- 32. Poinar HN, Schwarz C, Qi J, Shapiro B, Macphee RD, et al. (2006) Metagenomics to paleogenomics: large-scale sequencing of mammoth DNA. Science 311: 392–394.
- 33. Schwarz C, Debruyne R, Kuch M, McNally E, Schwarcz H, et al. (2009) New insights from old bones: DNA preservation and degradation in permafrost preserved mammoth remains. Nucleic Acids Res 37: 3215–3229.
- 34. Stiller M, Green RE, Ronan M, Simons JF, Du L, et al. (2006) Patterns of nucleotide misincorporations during enzymatic amplification and direct large-scale sequencing of ancient DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 13578–13584.
- 35. Brown A (2007) Dating the onset of cereal cultivation in Britain and Ireland: the evidence from charred cereal grains. Antiquity 81: 1042–1052.
- 36. Anderson S, de Bruijn MH, Coulson AR, Eperon IC, Sanger F, et al. (1982) Complete sequence of bovine mitochondrial DNA. Conserved features of the mammalian mitochondrial genome. J Mol Biol 156: 683–717.
- 37. Krause J, Dear PH, Pollack JL, Slatkin M, Spriggs H, et al. (2006) Multiplex amplification of the mammoth mitochondrial genome and the evolution of Elephantidae. Nature 439: 724–727.
- 38. Elsik CG, Tellam RL, Worley KC, Gibbs RA, Muzny DM, et al. (2009) The genome sequence of taurine cattle: a window to ruminant biology and evolution. Science 324: 522–528.
- 39. Bradley DG, MacHugh DE, Cunningham P, Loftus RT (1996) Mitochondrial diversity and the origins of African and European cattle. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 5131–5135.
- 40. Loftus RT, MacHugh DE, Bradley DG, Sharp PM, Cunningham P (1994) Evidence for two independent domestications of cattle. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 91: 2757–2761.
- 41. Meadows JR, Cemal I, Karaca O, Gootwine E, Kijas JW (2007) Five ovine mitochondrial lineages identified from sheep breeds of the near East. Genetics 175: 1371–1379.
- 42. Naderi S, Rezaei HR, Taberlet P, Zundel S, Rafat SA, et al. (2007) Large-scale mitochondrial DNA analysis of the domestic goat reveals six haplogroups with high diversity. PLoS One 2: e1012.
- 43. Vila C, Leonard JA, Gotherstrom A, Marklund S, Sandberg K, et al. (2001) Widespread origins of domestic horse lineages. Science 291: 474–477.
- 44. Green RE, Briggs AW, Krause J, Prufer K, Burbano HA, et al. (2009) The Neandertal genome and ancient DNA authenticity. EMBO J 28: 2494–2502.
- 45. Greagg MA, Fogg MJ, Panayotou G, Evans SJ, Connolly BA, et al. (1999) A read-ahead function in archaeal DNA polymerases detects promutagenic template-strand uracil. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 96: 9045–9050.
- 46. Dohm JC, Lottaz C, Borodina T, Himmelbauer H (2008) Substantial biases in ultra-short read data sets from high-throughput DNA sequencing. Nucleic Acids Res 36: e105.
- 47. Miller W, Drautz DI, Ratan A, Pusey B, Qi J, et al. (2008) Sequencing the nuclear genome of the extinct woolly mammoth. Nature 456: 387–390.
- 48. Blow MJ, Zhang T, Woyke T, Speller CF, Krivoshapkin A, et al. (2008) Identification of ancient remains through genomic sequencing. Genome Res 18: 1347–1353.
- 49. Green RE, Krause J, Ptak SE, Briggs AW, Ronan MT, et al. (2006) Analysis of one million base pairs of Neanderthal DNA. Nature 444: 330–336.
- 50. Noonan JP, Coop G, Kudaravalli S, Smith D, Krause J, et al. (2006) Sequencing and analysis of Neanderthal genomic DNA. Science 314: 1113–1118.
- 51. Ramirez O, Gigli E, Bover P, Alcover JA, Bertranpetit J, et al. (2009) Paleogenomics in a temperate environment: shotgun sequencing from an extinct Mediterranean caprine. PLoS One 4: e5670.
- 52. Huson DH, Auch AF, Qi J, Schuster SC (2007) MEGAN analysis of metagenomic data. Genome Res 17: 377–386.
- 53. Irwin JA, Saunier JL, Niederstatter H, Strouss KM, Sturk KA, et al. (2009) Investigation of heteroplasmy in the human mitochondrial DNA control region: a synthesis of observations from more than 5000 global population samples. J Mol Evol 68: 516–527.
- 54. Rogaev EI, Moliaka YK, Malyarchuk BA, Kondrashov FA, Derenko MV, et al. (2006) Complete mitochondrial genome and phylogeny of Pleistocene mammoth Mammuthus primigenius. PLoS Biol 4: e73.
- 55. Smith CI, Chamberlain AT, Riley MS, Cooper A, Stringer CB, et al. (2001) Neanderthal DNA. Not just old but old and cold? Nature 410: 771–772.
- 56. Smith CI, Chamberlain AT, Riley MS, Stringer C, Collins MJ (2003) The thermal history of human fossils and the likelihood of successful DNA amplification. J Hum Evol 45: 203–217.
- 57. Yang DY, Eng B, Waye JS, Dudar JC, Saunders SR (1998) Technical note: Improved DNA extraction from ancient bones using silica-based spin columns. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 105: 539–543.
- 58. MacHugh DE, Edwards CJ, Bailey JF, Bancroft DR, Bradley DG (2000) The extraction and analysis of ancient DNA from bone and teeth: a survey of current methodologies. Ancient Biomolecules 3: 81–102.
- 59. MacHugh DE, Troy CS, McCormick F, Olsaker I, Eythorsdottir E, et al. (1999) Early medieval cattle remains from a Scandinavian settlement in Dublin: genetic analysis and comparison with extant breeds. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 354. : 99–108; discussion 108–109.
- 60. Hiendleder S, Mainz K, Plante Y, Lewalski H (1998) Analysis of mitochondrial DNA indicates that domestic sheep are derived from two different ancestral maternal sources: no evidence for contributions from urial and argali sheep. J Hered 89: 113–120.
- 61. Lin CS, Sun YL, Liu CY, Yang PC, Chang LC, et al. (1999) Complete nucleotide sequence of pig (Sus scrofa) mitochondrial genome and dating evolutionary divergence within Artiodactyla. Gene 236: 107–114.
- 62. Shapiro B, Drummond AJ, Rambaut A, Wilson MC, Matheus PE, et al. (2004) Rise and fall of the Beringian steppe bison. Science 306: 1561–1565.
- 63. Li H, Ruan J, Durbin R (2008) Mapping short DNA sequencing reads and calling variants using mapping quality scores. Genome Res 18: 1851–1858.
- 64. Altschul SF, Madden TL, Schaffer AA, Zhang J, Zhang Z, et al. (1997) Gapped BLAST and PSI-BLAST: a new generation of protein database search programs. Nucleic Acids Res 25: 3389–3402.
- 65. Tamura K, Dudley J, Nei M, Kumar S (2007) MEGA4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 4.0. Mol Biol Evol 24: 1596–1599.
- 66. Macaulay VA (1998) CRED: Credible Regions for Coalescence Times. Univ. Oxford.
- 67. Schneider S, Roessli D, Excoffier L (2000) ARLEQUIN Ver. 2.0: A Software for Population Genetics Data Analysis Department of Anthropology, University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.