Chronic wasting disease (CWD) of cervids is a prion disease distinguished by high levels of transmissibility, wherein bodily fluids and excretions are thought to play an important role. Using cervid bioassay and established CWD detection methods, we have previously identified infectious prions in saliva and blood but not urine or feces of CWD+ donors. More recently, we identified very low concentrations of CWD prions in urine of deer by cervid PrP transgenic (Tg[CerPrP]) mouse bioassay and serial protein misfolding cyclic amplification (sPMCA). This finding led us to examine further our initial cervid bioassay experiments using sPMCA.
We sought to investigate whether conventional test-negative deer, previously exposed orally to urine and feces from CWD+ sources, may be harboring low level CWD infection not evident in the 19 month observation period. We further attempted to determine the peripheral PrPCWD distribution in these animals.
Various neural and lymphoid tissues from conventional test-negative deer were reanalyzed for CWD prions by sPMCA and cervid transgenic mouse bioassay in parallel with appropriate tissue-matched positive and negative controls.
PrPCWD was detected in the tissues of orally exposed deer by both sPMCA and Tg[CerPrP] mouse bioassay; each assay revealed very low levels of CWD prions previously undetectable by western blot, ELISA, or IHC. Serial PMCA analysis of individual tissues identified that obex alone was positive in 4 of 5 urine/feces exposed deer. PrPCWD was amplified from both lymphoid and neural tissues of positive control deer but not from identical tissues of negative control deer.
Detection of subclinical infection in deer orally exposed to urine and feces (1) suggests that a prolonged subclinical state can exist, necessitating observation periods in excess of two years to detect CWD infection, and (2) illustrates the sensitive and specific application of sPMCA in the diagnosis of low-level prion infection. Based on these results, it is possible that low doses of prions, e.g. following oral exposure to urine and saliva of CWD-infected deer, bypass significant amplification in the LRS, perhaps utilizing a neural conduit between the alimentary tract and CNS, as has been demonstrated in some other prion diseases.
Citation: Haley NJ, Mathiason CK, Zabel MD, Telling GC, Hoover EA (2009) Detection of Sub-Clinical CWD Infection in Conventional Test-Negative Deer Long after Oral Exposure to Urine and Feces from CWD+ Deer. PLoS ONE 4(11): e7990. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007990
Editor: Jiyan Ma, Ohio State University, United States of America
Received: September 29, 2009; Accepted: October 29, 2009; Published: November 24, 2009
Copyright: © 2009 Haley et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by NIH/NCRR Ruth L. Kirschstein Institutional T32 R07072-03 and NIH/NIAID NO1-AI-25491-02 (EAH, GCT). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Chronic wasting disease (CWD) is an efficiently transmitted prion disease of cervids (e.g. deer, elk, and moose), and is the only known prion disease affecting free-ranging, non-domestic animals. The origins of CWD are uncertain, but the disease has been present in wild cervid populations of northern Colorado and southern Wyoming for at least 40 years , . Since its discovery, CWD has been identified in captive and free-ranging cervids in 15 states, 2 Canadian provinces, and Korea . As surveillance efforts have intensified, CWD has been detected in areas previously thought to be free of infection, including recent discoveries in West Virginia, New York, and Michigan , , . The prevalence of CWD varies across North America, but can be as high as 30% in some areas of Colorado or in captive populations , .
Although the mechanisms of CWD transmission are incompletely understood, there is evidence inferring that infection is transmitted horizontally via saliva and urine , , and may be acquired from the environment , , . With the expanded recognition of the disease across the continental United States, it is also likely that substantial human exposure has occurred. However, because of an apparently strong species barrier ,  and the as yet incompletely understood natural routes and kinetics of CWD transmission, the magnitude and consequence of this exposure remain speculative.
While infectious CWD prions have been detected in saliva, blood, urine, and feces (i.e. prionsialia, prionemia, prionuria, and prionochezia) conventional CWD diagnostic assays (e.g. western blotting, immunohistochemistry, and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) have been unable to identify PrPCWD in these materials , , , . In the same vein, the early and antemortem identification of subclinically infected individuals requires demonstration of PrPCWD in biopsied lymphoreticular system (LRS) tissues , , , . Improving the sensitivity of low level of CWD prion detection in excreta or at early sites of accumulation, may allow for earlier antemortem diagnosis and a stronger estimate of prevalence , , , , , an approach which could also aid in detection of human transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE's).
Apart from inoculation of susceptible hosts (bioassay), only in vitro amplification by serial protein misfolding amplification (sPMCA) , , ,  offers the potential for comparable sensitivity. Here we have employed both of the latter methods to demonstrate low levels of infectious prions in clinically normal, conventional assay-negative white-tailed deer orally exposed 19 months previously to urine and feces from CWD+ deer.
Materials and Methods
All animals were handled in strict accordance with good animal practice as defined by relevant national and/or local animal welfare bodies, and all animal work was approved by Colorado State University Animal and Care Use Committee (ACUC approval number 08-175A-01).
Five white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) were orally inoculated with urine (50ml total volume) and feces (50g total volume) from CWD+ donor deer. The deer were monitored for 19 months post inoculation (pi), during which time they remained asymptomatic. At 19 months pi, due to limitations in holding space imposed by other ongoing studies, the animals were euthanized, necropsied, and brain and lymphoid tissues examined for PrPCWD by western blotting (WB) and immunohistochemistry (IHC) . The sources of the urine and feces used for inoculation were three terminally-ill mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) of unknown PrP genotype. Three of the inoculated deer were homozygous for glycine (i.e. G/G) at cervid PrP position 96 (Deer #'s 134, 141, and 150), while two were heterozygous at that location (Deer #'s 111 and 124), with alleles encoding for both glycine and serine (G/S). Tissues from all five animals were negative for PrPCWD by WB and IHC and the animals were thus considered CWD-negative. The same tissue sets were collected from positive and negative control animals, including a deer inoculated intracranially (IC) with CWD+ brain (deer #106, G/S at position 96), two deer inoculated per os (PO) with saliva from CWD+ deer (deer #113 and 122, both G/G at position 96) and three deer inoculated by the IC and PO routes with brain homogenate from a CWD-naive deer (deer # 103 and 123, both G/G at position 96 and deer #4488 – G/S at this loci). Each deer was necropsied using fresh necropsy instruments, and all tissue samples were frozen at −70°C until use. All animals were maintained in accord with Colorado State University IACUC guidelines.
Study Samples and Preparation
Obex, vagal nerve, intermediolateral spinal cord segments, sections of ileum, and a number of lymphoid tissues, including tonsil and retropharyngeal, mesenteric, mediastinal, and ileocecocolic lymph nodes, were collected at necropsy and frozen at −70°C. In initial sPMCA and bioassay experiments, obex and retropharyngeal lymph node (RLN) tissues from individual animals were pooled, as both these tissues have proven sensitive in the identification of PrPCWD at various stages of infection , , , , , . In later serial PMCA (sPMCA) experiments, specific neural and LRS tissues were analyzed individually. In each case, a fifty milligram section of each tissue was washed twice in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), then homogenized and prepared as a 1% solution (w/v) in PBS using a FastPrep™ tissue homogenizer for 40s at power setting 6.5. All tissues were prepared in individual microcentrifuge tubes and homogenized in parallel in the same machine concurrent with controls.
Cervid PrP Transgenic Mice
Tg[CerPrP] line 5037 (tg5037) mice were generated in the Telling laboratory at the University of Kentucky . These mice express, both centrally and peripherally, an allelic variant of the prion gene possessed by Rocky Mountain Elk (Cervus elaphus), coding for glutamic acid at position 226 of the cervid prion protein. All mice were screened at weaning for the presence of the cervid PRNP transgene by conventional and real-time PCR. Mice testing negative for PrPCWD at the completion of bioassay studies were rescreened to confirm the presence of cervid transgene. Mice were inoculated and maintained in accord with Colorado State University IACUC guidelines.
Serial Protein Misfolding Cyclic Amplification (sPMCA)
Tissue homogenates from CWD-exposed deer, negative by WB, IHC, and ELISA, were assayed for PrPCWD by sPMCA. In initial experiments, CWD+ obex/RLN homogenate from a white-tailed deer IC-inoculated with CWD+ brain (deer #106) was used as a positive control, while tissue preparations from two sham-inoculated deer (#103 and 123) and untreated tg5037 mice were used as negative controls. In later experiments, a tissue set from a deer orally inoculated with CWD+ brain (deer #148) was selected for use as positive controls; negative control animals remained unchanged. All test samples were prepared in parallel with tissue-matched positive and negative controls as a 1% homogenate in PBS as described above and subsequently spiked into normal brain homogenate for amplification as described previously , , . Normal brain homogenate (NBH), the substrate for prion conversion in vitro, was prepared from tg5037 mice in a room that had not previously been used for prion research. Following euthanasia and perfusion with 5mM EDTA in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), whole brain was collected from naïve tg5037 mice and placed on ice. Brain homogenates were prepared as a 10% (w/v) solution in PMCA buffer (1% triton-X 100 [v/v], 5mM EDTA, and 150mM NaCl in PBS adjusted to a pH of 7.2) with the addition of Complete Protease Inhibitors (Roche Pharmaceuticals, Indianapolis, IN) using a dounce homogenizer. Homogenates were then centrifuged for 1 minute at 2000rpm and the supernatant frozen in single-experiment aliquots at −70°C in a “prion-free” room until use in PMCA. Fifteen µl of test or control tissue homogenate was added to 45µl of NBH and assayed, in parallel and in adjacent wells of a 96-well plate (USA Scientific, Ocala, FL); along with normal brain homogenate prepared from unexposed tg5037 mice as additional, unseeded negative controls. Plates were then sonicated using an ultrasonic processor (Misonix, Farmingdale, NY) and incubated at 37°C. Sonication parameters were set at 40s bursts at power level 7.0, followed by 30 minutes of incubation. Ninety six cycles of sonication were performed over 48 hours, with a 10µl aliquot transferred to 50µl of fresh NBH for serial amplification. Following three rounds of amplification, samples were evaluated by western blotting, as described below, for the presence of PrPCWD. Brain homogenates from all mice testing negative for PrPCWD in bioassay experiments were likewise analyzed to increase detection sensitivity. In analysis of individual cervid tissue samples, occasional differences were noted in the round in which amplification was initially observed. For this reason, we tallied the number of successive positive rounds for each sample in each repetition for semi-quantitative analysis. Over the course of sPMCA experiments, multiple NBH preparations were used, and each test or control sample was evaluated at least three times for repeated verification of results.
Four groups of tg5037 mice (n = 8/group) were anesthetized with ketamine and xylazine and inoculated intracerebrally into the left parietal lobe with 30µl of 1% obex/RLN homogenate. Positive control mice were inoculated with obex and RLN from a deer IC-inoculated with CWD+ brain (deer #106), while a single negative control group was inoculated with combined obex and RLN homogenates from two sham-inoculated deer (deer #103 and 123). Obex and RLN homogenates from two deer orally inoculated with urine and feces (deer #134 and 150) were selected for bioassay experiments based on their apparent amplification ability in sPMCA experiments (below). Incubation time was defined as the number of days from inoculation to the onset of clinical signs of transmissible spongiform encephalopathy (TSE), as previously described . Animals were euthanized when either signs of clinical TSE or distress were evident. Brain harvested at necropsy was divided longitudinally, with one hemi-section prepared for evaluation by western blotting and sPMCA and the remaining hemi-section fixed in 10% neutral-buffered formalin for immunohistochemical analysis
Western Blotting (WB)
Brain hemi-sections for WB and sPMCA were initially prepared as a 10% (w/v) solution in PMCA buffer. Eleven µl of sample homogenate were mixed with 7µl of sample buffer (0.1% [v/v] triton-X 100 and 4%(w/v) SDS in PBS) and digested with 2µl proteinase-K at 500µg/ml (final concentration: 50µg/ml) for 20′ at 37°C followed by 10′ at 45°C. Seven µl of 4× running buffer were then added to the sample, followed by denaturation for 5′ at 95°C. Twenty µl of this preparation were run on a pre-cast 12% SDS-PAGE gel (Invitrogen) in a Bio-Rad electrophoresis apparatus for 2 hours at 120mV. Samples were then transferred to a PVDF membrane (Millipore) for 1 hour at 110mV in a Bio-Rad transfer apparatus. PVDF membranes were subsequently blocked for 1 hour in 5%(w/v) powdered milk in 0.2% Tween-20 in tris-buffered saline (TBST), followed by application of the primary antibody, BAR224-HRP, diluted 1∶20,000 in TBST with 5% powdered milk, for 1 hour. Following washing, immunoreactivity was detected using an enhanced chemiluminescent detection system (ECL-plus, Amersham Biosciences) in a LAS 3000 imaging system. (Fuji Photo Film, Fuji Inc, Valhalla, NY)
Neuropathology and Immunohistochemistry (IHC)
Brain hemi-sections were fixed in formalin overnight, treated with 88% formic acid for one hour, washed in tap water and then stored in 60% ethanol prior to paraffinization. Paraffin-embedded tissue sections (6µm) were mounted onto positively charged glass slides, deparaffinized, and rehydrated through graded ethanol. To enhance detection, tissues were subjected to Heat Induced Epitope Retrieval (HIER) using an automated antigen-retrieval system (Retriever™) and a proprietary buffer solution (DakoCytomation Target Retrieval Solution, DAKO, Hamburg, Germany). Tissues were then stained with an automated immunostainer, using polyclonal PrP antibody R-505 as the primary antibody (a gift from Dr. Jan Langeveld, Central Veterinary Institute of Wageningen University), The Netherlands) at a 1∶500 final dilution, followed by secondary application of a universal anti-rabbit polyclonal antibody conjugated to horseradish peroxidase (HRP). Detection was completed using HRP-mediated hydrogen peroxide immunostaining (AEC+, DAKO), with hematoxylin as a counterstain.
To evaluate CWD-exposed, yet IHC-, and WB-negative, deer for subclinical CWD infection, we pooled obex and retropharyngeal lymph node (RLN) tissues in an effort to enhance detection sensitivity. Pooled tissues from individual animals were initially analyzed via serial PMCA (sPMCA) with results subsequently confirmed in two of these individuals using bioassay in cervidized tg5037 mice. Serial PMCA was then used to analyze individual nervous and LRS tissues to estimate the mechanism of CNS invasion in animals orally exposed to presumed low doses of CWD prions that may be present in urine and feces.
Serial PMCA Amplification of PrPCWD from Tissues of Deer Orally Exposed to Urine and Feces
Obex and RLN tissues collected at necropsy from experimentally exposed deer were prepared as a 1% solution in PBS and subjected to three rounds of sPMCA as described. In our experience, three rounds of amplification permits a 2000 to 4000-fold increase in sensitivity as compared to traditional western blotting detection, while maintaining 100% specificity , . In three independent experiments, obex and RLN homogenates from individual deer that had been orally inoculated with urine and feces from a CWD+ source (deer #'s 111, 124, 134, 141 and 150) consistently amplified PrPCWD by sPMCA. Positive control tissues from an IC-inoculated deer (deer #106) also successfully amplified PrPCWD through each round, while concurrently run control tissue homogenates from CWD-negative brain-inoculated deer (deer #'s 103 and 123) or naïve tg5037 mice were negative by sPMCA. (Figure 1)
Conventionally negative tissues from deer orally exposed to urine and feces from CWD+ sources (Deer #'s 111, 124, 134, 141, and 150, lanes 4–8) amplified PrPCWD after 2–3 rounds of PMCA, as did positive control tissues from deer #106 (lane 1). Tissue samples from two sham-inoculated deer (#103 and 123, lanes 2 and 3) and two untreated tg5037 mice (lanes 9 and 10) failed to amplify PrPCWD in three rounds of sPMCA.
Based on these findings, tissues from two white-tailed deer with the greatest apparent in vitro amplification ability (deer #134 and #150, Fig. 1), along with tissue-matched controls, were selected for further evaluation by tg5037 mouse bioassay. Groups of mice were inoculated with obex/RLN homogenates, monitored for clinical signs of prion infection, and euthanized when terminal disease was apparent. Brains from inoculated mice were evaluated for PrPCWD by WB, IHC and, when negative by these assays, also by sPMCA.
Authentic Prion Infectivity Identified in tg5037 Mouse Bioassay
In a group of 8 mice inoculated with obex/RLN homogenates from deer #134, 7 of the 8 mice developed clinical signs consistent with TSE, including progressive ataxia and weight loss, by 264 days post inoculation (dpi). WB and IHC confirmed the presence of PrPCWD in each of these seven mice. The remaining mouse in this group died of intercurrent disease at 161 dpi. This mouse showed no evidence of clinical TSE and was negative for PrPCWD by both IHC and WB. (Fig. 2, mouse #2-B) In a second group of mice, inoculated with tissues from deer #150, 8 of 8 mice developed similar clinical signs of TSE infection and were confirmed PrPCWD-positive by WB and IHC by 272 dpi. All mice inoculated with brain and RLN homogenates from positive control deer #106 developed clinical TSE and were PrPCWD-positive by 173 dpi, whereas negative control mice remained healthy until euthanasia at 340+ dpi, at which time they were also negative for PrPCWD by WB and IHC. (Fig. 3 and Table 1)
Kaplan-Meyer curve demonstrating prolonged incubation periods in mice inoculated with tissues from deer #134 and 150 as compared to mice inoculated with tissues from deer testing positive by conventional assays.
Except for a single mouse (mouse Tg 2-B, lane 4), all mice inoculated with tissues from deer #134 and 150 succumbed to prion disease (lanes 3–7), as did mice inoculated with CWD+ deer #106 (lanes 1 and 2). Mice inoculated with tissues from sham-inoculated deer showed no evidence of PrPCWD by western blot (lanes 8 and 9).
Biochemical Confirmation of Bioassay
Western blot glycoform patterns were typical of CWD in Tg[CerPrP] tg5037 mice, spanning 21–27 kD following proteinase-K digestion and dominated by a di-glycosylated PrPCWD isoform. Representative WB's from each group are shown in Figure 2. Immunohistochemistry demonstrated a relatively narrow distribution of PrPCWD within the hippocampus of affected mice, colocalizing with vacuolization and spongiform degeneration of the neuropil. There was no apparent relationship between deposition pattern, lesion intensity, and source inoculum. (Fig. 4)
Vacuolated neurons and spongiform degeneration of the neuropil characteristic of TSE demonstrated by H&E staining and co-localization of PrPCWD florid plaques in the hippocampus of mice inoculated with tissues from urine and feces exposed and positive control deer. Brains of mice inoculated with tissues from sham-inoculated deer showed no evidence of spongiform degeneration or PrPCWD immunostaining. Anti-prion polyclonal antibody R-505 was used as the primary antibody. (Measure bar, 50 µm)
Serial PMCA Identification of PrPCWD in an Asymptomatic Mouse
Negative control mice and a single test mouse expiring with intercurrent disease at 161dpi, all of which were found negative for PrPCWD by WB and IHC, were further evaluated using sPMCA over three rounds of amplification. In three repeated sPMCA experiments, a subclinical prion infection was confirmed in the remaining mouse inoculated with tissue from deer #134 (mouse #Tg 2-B). None of the brains from mice inoculated with negative control tissues amplified PrPCWD, while positive control mice amplified PrPCWD successfully over three rounds. (Fig. 5)
Brain from a single tg5037 mouse (mouse Tg 2-B) was WB and IHC negative yet amplified PrPCWD after three rounds of sPMCA (lane 2), as did a positive control mouse (lane 1). Mice inoculated with tissues from sham-inoculated deer failed to amplify PrPCWD (lanes 3 and 4).
Analysis of Individual Neural and Lymphoid Tissues by sPMCA
To further examine the terminal distribution of CWD prions following oral exposure to presumed low concentrations of infectious prions in excreta, we analyzed individual tissue samples from control and test deer using sPMCA. Positive control tissues in these experiments were from two deer inoculated PO with saliva from CWD+ deer (deer #113 and 122), while identical tissue sets were collected from negative control deer #103, 123, and 4488. By analyzing obex and retropharyngeal tissues individually, PrPCWD amplification was found to occur exclusively in obex preparations from study animals. The levels of amplification observed were compared to serial dilutions of positive control tissue, and correlated to an approximately 20–40 fold dilution of 1% homogenate of deer #106 obex in NBH (data not shown). These results were surprising given that it has been reported that PrPCWD is commonly found to accumulate in the retropharyngeal lymph node, and other lymph nodes of the alimentary tract, prior to its appearance in the obex in experimental oral  and natural CWD infections , . We therefore sought to determine whether other lymphoid tissues were correspondingly bypassed in these deer.
In an attempt to understand if a strictly neural route of CNS invasion might have occurred, we performed sPMCA on the mesenteric, mediastinal, and ileocecocolic lymph nodes, tonsils, vagus nerve, intermediolateral spinal cord segments, and ileum from the above 5 urine/feces exposed deer and from positive and negative control deer. Surprisingly, while PrPCWD was amplified from a terminal tonsil biopsy of a single study deer, neither vagus nerve, nor the retropharyngeal, mesenteric, mediastinal or ileocecocolic lymph nodes were positive for PrPCWD by sPMCA in any of the deer orally exposed to urine and feces from CWD+ donors (Figure 6). As might be expected, protease-resistant prion protein was amplified from both neural and lymphoid tissues from the positive control deer, while no amplification was observed in corresponding tissues from negative control deer or multiple unseeded NBH controls examined concurrently and on the same plate as positive samples.
For each tissue, the number of sPMCA rounds producing a positive result was tabulated for three independent experiments of three rounds each. Samples appearing as positive in round 2 continued to be positive in round 3, and thus over the course of three experiments, were positive a total of 6 out of 9 rounds (e.g. obex samples from deer 134 and 150). Samples becoming positive in the first round were succeeded by positivity in rounds 2 and 3, and thus were positive in 9 out of 9 rounds (e.g. tonsil and RLN samples from deer 122 and 113). As would be expected, the greatest number of positive results was observed in the positive control tissues, with some variance among tissues and between animals. Deer orally exposed to urine and feces demonstrated PrPCWD amplification almost exclusively from the obex; the terminal tonsil collection from a single animal also was positive. By contrast, negative control tissues failed to amplify PrPCWD. RLN: retropharyngeal lymph node; MedLN: mediastinal lymph node; MesLN: mesenteric lymph node; ILN: ileocecocolic lymph node; IMLT: Intermediolateral spinal cord tract; SU: sample unavailable.
The salient feature of chronic wasting disease is its facile transmission among captive and free-ranging cervids. We have previously demonstrated infectious prions in the saliva and blood using cervid bioassay , . However, we were unable to identify PrPCWD in the tissues of deer orally exposed to combined urine and feces, even though our later studies employing Tg[CerPrP] mouse bioassay demonstrated very low levels of prion infectivity (surmised by long incubation/survival periods) in the urine of some CWD+ deer . In the current study, the enhanced sensitivities of sPMCA and intracerebral inoculation of cervid PrP-tg5037 mice have led us to conclude that at 19 months post inoculation, low levels of amplifiable and infectious CWD prions were in fact present in the brains of the exposed, yet asymptomatic and conventional assay negative, deer from our original oral bioassay studies , , thereby inferring that low levels of prion infectivity were present in the urine/feces inocula. Whether the apparent low concentrations of prions amplifiable from the obex of the urine/feces recipients could represent a persistent non-pathogenic prion carrier state, or rather (perhaps more likely) indicates that an observation period far exceeding 19 months would be required to reveal ultimately pathogenic prion infections in these animals, remains undetermined.
Our initial bioassay deer were inoculated with both urine and feces, thus our present findings cannot identify the specific excreta involved in CWD transmission. It seems likely, however, that both excreta may play an important role in the horizontal transmission of CWD, given the later demonstration of prion infectivity in urine  and feces  of CWD+ deer using transgenic mouse bioassay. Further experiments, employing cervid bioassay of separated excreta and sPMCA are underway to better answer this question.
In the initial sPMCA and bioassay experiments, to maximize use of available tg5037 mice, we analyzed homogenates of combined neural (obex) and lymphoreticular (LRS) tissues for the CWD prion protein. Information on the pathogenesis of CWD indicated that, following oral exposure, PrPCWD is first detectable in lymphatic tissues draining the alimentary tract, especially retropharyngeal lymph node and Peyer's patches , , , , . Thereafter, it is assumed that neural transport may be occur through anterograde ascension via myenteric or LRS sympathetic and parasympathetic neural networks to the central nervous system , paralleling the pathogenesis of sheep scrapie , . Thus the earliest and most prominent CNS PrPCWD accumulation is in the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus in the obex , , , followed by centrifugal neural spread to peripheral sites. We were therefore surprised to find that PrPCWD amplification was restricted to the obex of 4 out of 5 urine/feces inoculated deer. As with any assay, there is the potential for sample quality or the presence of inhibitors to affect test results, thereby explaining the absence of detectable PrPCWD in the lymphoid tissues of urine and feces inoculated deer. However, the abundant successful amplification of PrPCWD in lymphoid tissues of saliva-inoculated deer infers that a significant technical barrier to PrPCWD amplification from lymph node is unlikely to explain the results. Thereby, we surmised that either CWD prions may have bypassed amplification in the LRS of these deer or were no longer present at detectable levels in the periphery. While these results are in contrast to the current concept of CWD pathogenesis , , , , absence of LRS involvement has been observed in natural cases of scrapie , , ,  and bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) of cattle and sheep , , , . In scrapie-infected sheep, for example, the absence of scrapie amplification in the LRS as a result of host PrP genotype, limited dose exposure, tissue route/conduit, or prion strain selection are all supported by available evidence , , , , and may also be plausible in cases of CWD. The deer included in our study were of two PrP genotypes at position 96, expressing either G/G or G/S, both of which have been shown to be LRS competent in the pathogenesis of CWD, although slower pathogenesis has been linked to 96S , . In naturally occurring cases of bovine spongiform encephalopathy, the BSE prion seems to exclusively utilize autonomic neural pathways for neuro-invasion, a defining characteristic of BSE , , , . It is possible that CWD strains may eventually be uncovered with BSE-like phenotypes which could be selected for by low dose exposure. Nevertheless, there have been no reports of PrPCWD detection solely in the CNS of infected deer. Thus the exact route by which CWD prions accessed the CNS of deer in the present study remains unidentified.
Detection of CWD prions in the present study samples relied heavily on sPMCA, with cervid transgenic mouse bioassay as a confirmatory assay. Given the risk of spurious positive results possible with multiple rounds of sPMCA, whether due to “spontaneous generation” or contamination , , , we took great care to minimize this risk using approaches that parallel those to reduce cross-contamination in nested PCR. These precautions took two forms: avoiding cross-contamination during sample collection and initial processing, and prevention of intra-experimental cross-contamination. Animals were necropsied in order of approximate level of infection (based on inoculation material and known tonsil biopsy results), beginning with negative controls, followed by animals exposed yet biopsy negative throughout the study, and finally exposed, biopsy positive animals. Fresh necropsy instruments were used for each necropsy, with the central nervous system tissues removed at the completion of the necropsy. All study and control samples were then prepared in parallel using identical equipment and reagents. Normal brain homogenate substrates were prepared and loaded in sPMCA plates in a laboratory not used for prion study using disposable or sterilized equipment. Negative controls included multiple samples from both sham-inoculated cervids and uninfected Tg[CerPrP]-tg5037 mice. In addition, the number of amplification rounds was limited to three to help ensure specificity. Perhaps most importantly, the positive sPMCA results identified in brain and lymph node homogenates were confirmed by bioassay to provide support the conclusion that the sPMCA+ tissues did in fact harbor infectious prions.
In summary, we provide evidence for the presence of infectious prions in the brains of conventional prion-assay-negative deer orally exposed 19 months earlier to urine and feces from CWD-infected donor deer. This apparent low level of prion infection was amplified by sPMCA, confirmed by Tg[CerPrP] mouse bioassay, and detected only in the obex region of the brain. These results demonstrate the potential for CWD prion transmission via urine and/or feces, and highlight the application of more sensitive assays such as sPMCA in identification of CWD infection, pathogenesis, and prevalence.
The authors would like to sincerely thank David Osborne and Sally Dahmes, Carl Miller and Robert Warren and the Warnell School of Forestry, University of Georgia, without whom the primary experiments in cervids could not have been performed. We thank Dr. Michael Miller of the Colorado Division of Wildlife, who provided initial samples of CWD+ brain and bodily fluids. Timothy Kurt provided much valued assistance with assay development and interpretation. For excellent long term care and sample collection from source deer and transgenic mice, we thank Sheila Hays and Jeanette Hayes-Klug. For her vital contribution to developing the Tg[CerPrP] mice used in these studies we thank Tanya Seward at the University of Kentucky. Finally, we thank the reviewers for providing important criticisms to improve this manuscript.
Conceived and designed the experiments: NJH EAH. Performed the experiments: NJH. Analyzed the data: NJH CKM MDZ GCT EAH. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: NJH CKM MDZ GCT EAH. Wrote the paper: NJH EAH.
- 1. Williams ES, Young S (1980) Chronic wasting disease of captive mule deer: a spongiform encephalopathy. J Wildl Dis 16: 89–98.ES WilliamsS. Young1980Chronic wasting disease of captive mule deer: a spongiform encephalopathy.J Wildl Dis168998
- 2. Williams ES, Young S (1982) Spongiform encephalopathy of Rocky Mountain elk. J Wildl Dis 18: 465–471.ES WilliamsS. Young1982Spongiform encephalopathy of Rocky Mountain elk.J Wildl Dis18465471
- 3. Sigurdson CJ (2008) A prion disease of cervids: chronic wasting disease. Vet Res 39: 41.CJ Sigurdson2008A prion disease of cervids: chronic wasting disease.Vet Res3941
- 4. http://www.wvdnr.gov/2005news/05news167.shtm: Chronic Wasting Disease Found in Hampshire County Deer. Date Accessed: November 4th, 2009. http://www.wvdnr.gov/2005news/05news167.shtm: Chronic Wasting Disease Found in Hampshire County Deer. Date Accessed: November 4th, 2009.
- 5. http://www.agmkt.state.ny.us/AD/release.asp?ReleaseID=1420: POSITIVE CASE OF CWD FOUND IN ONEIDA COUNTY DEER. Date Accessed: November 4th, 2009. http://www.agmkt.state.ny.us/AD/release.asp?ReleaseID=1420: POSITIVE CASE OF CWD FOUND IN ONEIDA COUNTY DEER. Date Accessed: November 4th, 2009.
- 6. http://www.michigan.gov/dnr/0,1607,7-153-198865-,00.html Michigan's First Case of Chronic Wasting Disease Detected at Kent County Deer Breeding Facility. Date Accessed: November 4th, 2009. http://www.michigan.gov/dnr/0,1607,7-153-198865-,00.html Michigan's First Case of Chronic Wasting Disease Detected at Kent County Deer Breeding Facility. Date Accessed: November 4th, 2009.
- 7. Williams ES (2005) Chronic wasting disease. Vet Pathol 42: 530–549.ES Williams2005Chronic wasting disease.Vet Pathol42530549
- 8. Keane DP, Barr DJ, Bochsler PN, Hall SM, Gidlewski T, et al. (2008) Chronic wasting disease in a Wisconsin white-tailed deer farm. J Vet Diagn Invest 20: 698–703.DP KeaneDJ BarrPN BochslerSM HallT. Gidlewski2008Chronic wasting disease in a Wisconsin white-tailed deer farm.J Vet Diagn Invest20698703
- 9. Mathiason CK, Powers JG, Dahmes SJ, Osborn DA, Miller KV, et al. (2006) Infectious prions in the saliva and blood of deer with chronic wasting disease. Science 314: 133–136.CK MathiasonJG PowersSJ DahmesDA OsbornKV Miller2006Infectious prions in the saliva and blood of deer with chronic wasting disease.Science314133136
- 10. Mathiason CK, Hays SA, Powers J, Hayes-Klug J, Langenberg J, et al. (2009) Infectious Prions in Pre-Clinical Deer and Transmission of Chronic Wasting Disease Solely by Environmental Exposure. PLoS ONE 4: e5916.CK MathiasonSA HaysJ. PowersJ. Hayes-KlugJ. Langenberg2009Infectious Prions in Pre-Clinical Deer and Transmission of Chronic Wasting Disease Solely by Environmental Exposure.PLoS ONE4e5916
- 11. Miller MW, Williams ES, Hobbs NT, Wolfe LL (2004) Environmental sources of prion transmission in mule deer. Emerg Infect Dis 10: 1003–1006.MW MillerES WilliamsNT HobbsLL Wolfe2004Environmental sources of prion transmission in mule deer.Emerg Infect Dis1010031006
- 12. Johnson CJ, Phillips KE, Schramm PT, McKenzie D, Aiken JM, et al. (2006) Prions adhere to soil minerals and remain infectious. PLoS Pathog 2: e32.CJ JohnsonKE PhillipsPT SchrammD. McKenzieJM Aiken2006Prions adhere to soil minerals and remain infectious.PLoS Pathog2e32
- 13. Johnson CJ, Pedersen JA, Chappell RJ, McKenzie D, Aiken JM (2007) Oral Transmissibility of Prion Disease Is Enhanced by Binding to Soil Particles. PLoS Pathog 3: e93.CJ JohnsonJA PedersenRJ ChappellD. McKenzieJM Aiken2007Oral Transmissibility of Prion Disease Is Enhanced by Binding to Soil Particles.PLoS Pathog3e93
- 14. Kong Q, Huang S, Zou W, Vanegas D, Wang M, et al. (2005) Chronic wasting disease of elk: transmissibility to humans examined by transgenic mouse models. J Neurosci 25: 7944–7949.Q. KongS. HuangW. ZouD. VanegasM. Wang2005Chronic wasting disease of elk: transmissibility to humans examined by transgenic mouse models.J Neurosci2579447949
- 15. Raymond GJ, Bossers A, Raymond LD, O'Rourke KI, McHolland LE, et al. (2000) Evidence of a molecular barrier limiting susceptibility of humans, cattle and sheep to chronic wasting disease. EMBO J 19: 4425–4430.GJ RaymondA. BossersLD RaymondKI O'RourkeLE McHolland2000Evidence of a molecular barrier limiting susceptibility of humans, cattle and sheep to chronic wasting disease.EMBO J1944254430
- 16. Tamguney G, Miller MW, Wolfe LL, Sirochman TM, Glidden DV, et al. (2009) Asymptomatic deer excrete infectious prions in faeces. Nature 461: 529–532.G. TamguneyMW MillerLL WolfeTM SirochmanDV Glidden2009Asymptomatic deer excrete infectious prions in faeces.Nature461529532
- 17. Haley NJ, Seelig DM, Zabel MD, Telling GC, Hoover EA (2009) Detection of CWD prions in urine and saliva of deer by transgenic mouse bioassay. PLoS ONE 4: e4848.NJ HaleyDM SeeligMD ZabelGC TellingEA Hoover2009Detection of CWD prions in urine and saliva of deer by transgenic mouse bioassay.PLoS ONE4e4848
- 18. Spraker TR, Gidlewski TL, Balachandran A, VerCauteren KC, Creekmore L, et al. (2006) Detection of PrP(CWD) in postmortem rectal lymphoid tissues in Rocky Mountain elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni) infected with chronic wasting disease. J Vet Diagn Invest 18: 553–557.TR SprakerTL GidlewskiA. BalachandranKC VerCauterenL. Creekmore2006Detection of PrP(CWD) in postmortem rectal lymphoid tissues in Rocky Mountain elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni) infected with chronic wasting disease.J Vet Diagn Invest18553557
- 19. Wolfe LL, Spraker TR, Gonzalez L, Dagleish MP, Sirochman TM, et al. (2007) PrPCWD in rectal lymphoid tissue of deer (Odocoileus spp.). J Gen Virol 88: 2078–2082.LL WolfeTR SprakerL. GonzalezMP DagleishTM Sirochman2007PrPCWD in rectal lymphoid tissue of deer (Odocoileus spp.).J Gen Virol8820782082
- 20. Wild MA, Spraker TR, Sigurdson CJ, O'Rourke KI, Miller MW (2002) Preclinical diagnosis of chronic wasting disease in captive mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) using tonsillar biopsy. J Gen Virol 83: 2629–2634.MA WildTR SprakerCJ SigurdsonKI O'RourkeMW Miller2002Preclinical diagnosis of chronic wasting disease in captive mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) using tonsillar biopsy.J Gen Virol8326292634
- 21. O'Rourke KI, Zhuang D, Lyda A, Gomez G, Williams ES, et al. (2003) Abundant PrP(CWD) in tonsil from mule deer with preclinical chronic wasting disease. J Vet Diagn Invest 15: 320–323.KI O'RourkeD. ZhuangA. LydaG. GomezES Williams2003Abundant PrP(CWD) in tonsil from mule deer with preclinical chronic wasting disease.J Vet Diagn Invest15320323
- 22. Spraker TR, Balachandran A, Zhuang D, O'Rourke KI (2004) Variable patterns of distribution of PrP(CWD) in the obex and cranial lymphoid tissues of Rocky Mountain elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni) with subclinical chronic wasting disease. Vet Rec 155: 295–302.TR SprakerA. BalachandranD. ZhuangKI O'Rourke2004Variable patterns of distribution of PrP(CWD) in the obex and cranial lymphoid tissues of Rocky Mountain elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni) with subclinical chronic wasting disease.Vet Rec155295302
- 23. Castilla J, Gutierrez-Adan A, Brun A, Doyle D, Pintado B, et al. (2004) Subclinical bovine spongiform encephalopathy infection in transgenic mice expressing porcine prion protein. J Neurosci 24: 5063–5069.J. CastillaA. Gutierrez-AdanA. BrunD. DoyleB. Pintado2004Subclinical bovine spongiform encephalopathy infection in transgenic mice expressing porcine prion protein.J Neurosci2450635069
- 24. Hill AF, Collinge J (2003) Subclinical prion infection in humans and animals. Br Med Bull 66: 161–170.AF HillJ. Collinge2003Subclinical prion infection in humans and animals.Br Med Bull66161170
- 25. Hill AF, Collinge J (2003) Subclinical prion infection. Trends Microbiol 11: 578–584.AF HillJ. Collinge2003Subclinical prion infection.Trends Microbiol11578584
- 26. Soto C, Saborio GP, Anderes L (2002) Cyclic amplification of protein misfolding: application to prion-related disorders and beyond. Trends Neurosci 25: 390–394.C. SotoGP SaborioL. Anderes2002Cyclic amplification of protein misfolding: application to prion-related disorders and beyond.Trends Neurosci25390394
- 27. Saborio GP, Permanne B, Soto C (2001) Sensitive detection of pathological prion protein by cyclic amplification of protein misfolding. Nature 411: 810–813.GP SaborioB. PermanneC. Soto2001Sensitive detection of pathological prion protein by cyclic amplification of protein misfolding.Nature411810813
- 28. Kurt TD, Perrott MR, Wilusz CJ, Wilusz J, Supattapone S, et al. (2007) Efficient in vitro amplification of chronic wasting disease PrPRES. J Virol 81: 9605–9608.TD KurtMR PerrottCJ WiluszJ. WiluszS. Supattapone2007Efficient in vitro amplification of chronic wasting disease PrPRES.J Virol8196059608
- 29. Fox KA, Jewell JE, Williams ES, Miller MW (2006) Patterns of PrPCWD accumulation during the course of chronic wasting disease infection in orally inoculated mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus). J Gen Virol 87: 3451–3461.KA FoxJE JewellES WilliamsMW Miller2006Patterns of PrPCWD accumulation during the course of chronic wasting disease infection in orally inoculated mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus).J Gen Virol8734513461
- 30. Keane DP, Barr DJ, Keller JE, Hall SM, Langenberg JA, et al. (2008) Comparison of retropharyngeal lymph node and obex region of the brainstem in detection of chronic wasting disease in white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus). J Vet Diagn Invest 20: 58–60.DP KeaneDJ BarrJE KellerSM HallJA Langenberg2008Comparison of retropharyngeal lymph node and obex region of the brainstem in detection of chronic wasting disease in white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus).J Vet Diagn Invest205860
- 31. Sigurdson CJ, Williams ES, Miller MW, Spraker TR, O'Rourke KI, et al. (1999) Oral transmission and early lymphoid tropism of chronic wasting disease PrPres in mule deer fawns (Odocoileus hemionus). J Gen Virol 80(Pt 10): 2757–2764.CJ SigurdsonES WilliamsMW MillerTR SprakerKI O'Rourke1999Oral transmission and early lymphoid tropism of chronic wasting disease PrPres in mule deer fawns (Odocoileus hemionus).J Gen Virol80(Pt 10)27572764
- 32. Race BL, Meade-White KD, Ward A, Jewell J, Miller MW, et al. (2007) Levels of abnormal prion protein in deer and elk with chronic wasting disease. Emerg Infect Dis 13: 824–830.BL RaceKD Meade-WhiteA. WardJ. JewellMW Miller2007Levels of abnormal prion protein in deer and elk with chronic wasting disease.Emerg Infect Dis13824830
- 33. Hibler CP, Wilson KL, Spraker TR, Miller MW, Zink RR, et al. (2003) Field validation and assessment of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for detecting chronic wasting disease in mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus), white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), and Rocky Mountain elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni). J Vet Diagn Invest 15: 311–319.CP HiblerKL WilsonTR SprakerMW MillerRR Zink2003Field validation and assessment of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for detecting chronic wasting disease in mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus), white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), and Rocky Mountain elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni).J Vet Diagn Invest15311319
- 34. Angers RC, Seward TS, Napier D, Green M, Hoover E, et al. (2009) Chronic wasting disease prions in elk antler velvet. Emerg Infect Dis 15: 696–703.RC AngersTS SewardD. NapierM. GreenE. Hoover2009Chronic wasting disease prions in elk antler velvet.Emerg Infect Dis15696703
- 35. Kurt TD, Telling GC, Zabel MD, Hoover EA (2009) Trans-species amplification of PrP(CWD) and correlation with rigid loop 170N. Virology 387: 235–243.TD KurtGC TellingMD ZabelEA Hoover2009Trans-species amplification of PrP(CWD) and correlation with rigid loop 170N.Virology387235243
- 36. Carlson GA, Kingsbury DT, Goodman PA, Coleman S, Marshall ST, et al. (1986) Linkage of prion protein and scrapie incubation time genes. Cell 46: 503–511.GA CarlsonDT KingsburyPA GoodmanS. ColemanST Marshall1986Linkage of prion protein and scrapie incubation time genes.Cell46503511
- 37. Sigurdson CJ, Spraker TR, Miller MW, Oesch B, Hoover EA (2001) PrP(CWD) in the myenteric plexus, vagosympathetic trunk and endocrine glands of deer with chronic wasting disease. J Gen Virol 82: 2327–2334.CJ SigurdsonTR SprakerMW MillerB. OeschEA Hoover2001PrP(CWD) in the myenteric plexus, vagosympathetic trunk and endocrine glands of deer with chronic wasting disease.J Gen Virol8223272334
- 38. van Keulen LJ, Bossers A, van Zijderveld F (2008) TSE pathogenesis in cattle and sheep. Vet Res 39: 24.LJ van KeulenA. BossersF. van Zijderveld2008TSE pathogenesis in cattle and sheep.Vet Res3924
- 39. Beekes M, McBride PA (2007) The spread of prions through the body in naturally acquired transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. FEBS J 274: 588–605.M. BeekesPA McBride2007The spread of prions through the body in naturally acquired transmissible spongiform encephalopathies.FEBS J274588605
- 40. Peters J, Miller JM, Jenny AL, Peterson TL, Carmichael KP (2000) Immunohistochemical diagnosis of chronic wasting disease in preclinically affected elk from a captive herd. J Vet Diagn Invest 12: 579–582.J. PetersJM MillerAL JennyTL PetersonKP Carmichael2000Immunohistochemical diagnosis of chronic wasting disease in preclinically affected elk from a captive herd.J Vet Diagn Invest12579582
- 41. Jeffrey M, Begara-McGorum I, Clark S, Martin S, Clark J, et al. (2002) Occurrence and distribution of infection-specific PrP in tissues of clinical scrapie cases and cull sheep from scrapie-affected farms in Shetland. J Comp Pathol 127: 264–273.M. JeffreyI. Begara-McGorumS. ClarkS. MartinJ. Clark2002Occurrence and distribution of infection-specific PrP in tissues of clinical scrapie cases and cull sheep from scrapie-affected farms in Shetland.J Comp Pathol127264273
- 42. Jeffrey M, Martin S, Thomson JR, Dingwall WS, Begara-McGorum I, et al. (2001) Onset and distribution of tissue prp accumulation in scrapie-affected suffolk sheep as demonstrated by sequential necropsies and tonsillar biopsies. J Comp Pathol 125: 48–57.M. JeffreyS. MartinJR ThomsonWS DingwallI. Begara-McGorum2001Onset and distribution of tissue prp accumulation in scrapie-affected suffolk sheep as demonstrated by sequential necropsies and tonsillar biopsies.J Comp Pathol1254857
- 43. Jeffrey M, Ryder S, Martin S, Hawkins SA, Terry L, et al. (2001) Oral inoculation of sheep with the agent of bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE). 1. Onset and distribution of disease-specific PrP accumulation in brain and viscera. J Comp Pathol 124: 280–289.M. JeffreyS. RyderS. MartinSA HawkinsL. Terry2001Oral inoculation of sheep with the agent of bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE). 1. Onset and distribution of disease-specific PrP accumulation in brain and viscera.J Comp Pathol124280289
- 44. Siso S, Jeffrey M, Gonzalez L (2009) Neuroinvasion in sheep transmissible spongiform encephalopathies: the role of the haematogenous route. Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol 35: 232–246.S. SisoM. JeffreyL. Gonzalez2009Neuroinvasion in sheep transmissible spongiform encephalopathies: the role of the haematogenous route.Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol35232246
- 45. Wells GA (2003) Pathogenesis of BSE. Vet Res Commun 27: Suppl 125–28.GA Wells2003Pathogenesis of BSE.Vet Res Commun27Suppl 12528
- 46. Terry LA, Marsh S, Ryder SJ, Hawkins SA, Wells GA, et al. (2003) Detection of disease-specific PrP in the distal ileum of cattle exposed orally to the agent of bovine spongiform encephalopathy. Vet Rec 152: 387–392.LA TerryS. MarshSJ RyderSA HawkinsGA Wells2003Detection of disease-specific PrP in the distal ileum of cattle exposed orally to the agent of bovine spongiform encephalopathy.Vet Rec152387392
- 47. Agrimi U, Cosseddu G, Castilla J, Fernandez-Borges N, Di Bari MA, et al. U. AgrimiG. CossedduJ. CastillaN. Fernandez-BorgesMA Di BariPMCA and Bank Voles: an Update; 2008 10/10/2008; Madrid, Spain. PMCA and Bank Voles: an Update; 2008 10/10/2008; Madrid, Spain.
- 48. Deleault NR, Harris BT, Rees JR, Supattapone S (2007) From the Cover: Formation of native prions from minimal components in vitro. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 9741–9746.NR DeleaultBT HarrisJR ReesS. Supattapone2007From the Cover: Formation of native prions from minimal components in vitro.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A10497419746
- 49. Barria MA, Mukherjee A, Gonzalez-Romero D, Morales R, Soto C (2009) De novo generation of infectious prions in vitro produces a new disease phenotype. PLoS Pathog 5: e1000421.MA BarriaA. MukherjeeD. Gonzalez-RomeroR. MoralesC. Soto2009De novo generation of infectious prions in vitro produces a new disease phenotype.PLoS Pathog5e1000421