The introduction and maintenance of plasmids in cells is often associated with a reduction of growth rate. The reason for this growth reduction is unclear in many cases.
We observed a surprisingly large reduction in growth rate of about 50% of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 during methylotrophic growth in the presence of a plasmid, pCM80 expressing the tetA gene, relative to the wild-type. A less pronounced growth delay during growth under non-methylotrophic growth conditions was observed; this suggested an inhibition of one-carbon metabolism rather than a general growth inhibition or metabolic burden. Metabolome analyses revealed an increase in pool sizes of ethylmalonyl-CoA and methylmalonyl-CoA of more than 6- and 35-fold, respectively, relative to wild type, suggesting a strongly reduced conversion of these central intermediates, which are essential for glyoxylate regeneration in this model methylotroph. Similar results were found for M. extorquens AM1 pCM160 which confers kanamycin resistance. These intermediates of the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway have in common their conversion by coenzyme B12-dependent mutases, which have cobalt as a central ligand. The one-carbon metabolism-related growth delay was restored by providing higher cobalt concentrations, by heterologous expression of isocitrate lyase as an alternative path for glyoxylate regeneration, or by identification and overproduction of proteins involved in cobalt import.
This study demonstrates that the introduction of the plasmids leads to an apparent inhibition of the cobalt-dependent enzymes of the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway. Possible explanations are presented and point to a limited cobalt concentration in the cell as a consequence of the antibiotic stress.
Citation: Kiefer P, Buchhaupt M, Christen P, Kaup B, Schrader J, Vorholt JA (2009) Metabolite Profiling Uncovers Plasmid-Induced Cobalt Limitation under Methylotrophic Growth Conditions. PLoS ONE 4(11): e7831. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007831
Editor: Holger Bruggemann, Max Planck Institute for Infection Biology, Germany
Received: July 10, 2009; Accepted: October 10, 2009; Published: November 13, 2009
Copyright: © 2009 Kiefer et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by ETH Zürich. Evonik Degussa GmbH and North Rhine-Westphalia cofinanced by the European Union are acknowledged for supporting the development of LC-MS analytics. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: Evonik Degussa GmbH supported the development of the LC-MS analytics platform. There are no claims by Evonik Degussa GmbH on this study or parts of this study; no patents have been prepared or submitted.
The term “metabolic burden” has been coined to describe the consequences of the presence and maintenance of plasmids in cells usually associated with a reduction of growth rate , , . In addition to phenomena associated with overproduction of proteins that can strongly impact cell growth by consuming cellular resources or by interfering with host cell functions via its enzymatic activity or physical properties, different mechanisms are believed to account for plasmid-induced growth defects. Alterations in the physiological state of host cells transformed with plasmids, relative to the unmodified cells, are often ascribed to additional demands for ATP and precursors for DNA synthesis. This “metabolic burden” is supported by the observation that plasmid size correlates with a decrease in growth , ,  and by a correlation between plasmid copy number and decreased growth , . Although this is a generally accepted explanation provided by many authors, stoichiometric analyses showed that if no plasmid-encoded gene is expressed at high levels, even propagation of very high copy number vectors does not make much difference in global energy metabolism .
Diaz Ricci and Hernández  presented evidence for an alteration of the cellular regulatory status as a primary cause of plasmid-related growth defects. This might be the result of enzyme up-regulation leading to futile cycles or other energetically inefficient pathways . In a transcriptome comparison, candidates for such up-regulated factors responsible for the “metabolic burden” were found to be heat-shock proteins, many of which are proteases or chaperones . This study presents evidence for a carbon flux diversion from the glycolytic pathway to the pentose phosphate pathway as a consequence of plasmid maintenance.
The antibiotic resistance proteins encoded on many plasmids may also contribute to decreased growth rates by disturbing cellular functions. One example of toxic effects of an antibiotic resistance protein is Serratia marcescens lactamase blaSME-1, whose signal sequence seems to be involved in growth rate reduction of E. coli strains heterologously expressing this protein . Especially in case of the tetracycline resistance protein TetA, which when expressed in E. coli was found to result in decreased growth rates by several authors. Moyed and Bertrand  recognized that constitutive expression of TetA from multicopy plasmids strongly affects growth and speculated about the protein's interference with the function of the cytoplasmic membrane. Another report also described the negative effect of tetA expression on E. coli fitness even in the absence of antibiotic .
Gaining more insight into the molecular mechanisms underlying these phenomena is of great interest for different research areas such as the spread of antibiotic resistance among pathogenic microorganisms, plasmid stability in biotechnological applications, and genetic engineering strategies. Straightforward methods such as the “omics” technologies can be used to identify cellular changes leading to growth defects of plasmid-carrying cells. While transcriptomics and proteomics provide information on gene expression and proteins, metabolomics can give a more direct view into the physiology of the cell as a consequence of the end products of gene expression and - because of the high degree of connectivity in the metabolic network - yield integrative information .
Methylotrophic bacteria utilize reduced carbon substrates containing no carbon-carbon bonds as their sole source of carbon and energy . Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 is a model methylotrophic bacterium that is able to grow in the presence of methanol and methylamine. The genome of this Alphaproteobacterium was determined , and a number of “omics” technologies have been established and applied, helping to further expand our knowledge of methylotrophic metabolism , , , , . M. extorquens AM1 and other methylotrophs are of interest for biotechnological applications using methanol as an alternative non-food carbon source for conversion into value-added compounds . In this study, we used metabolome analysis as a means to elucidate the mechanism of the pronounced growth retardation of the model strain M. extorquens AM1 as a consequence of the presence of two plasmids, pCM80 and pCM160 , during growth in the presence of methanol as the sole carbon and energy source. Our results point to a strong reduction of ethylmalonyl-CoA mutase activity leading to inhibition of the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway, which is necessary for glyoxylate regeneration in M. extorquens AM1. We provide evidence for a reduced intracellular cobalt level in plasmid-containing cells; this is most probably responsible for the decreased activity of the cobalt-dependent enzymes of the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway.
Results and Discussion
Growth Characterization of M. extorquens in the Absence and Presence of pCM80
M. extorquens AM1 and M. extorquens AM1 with pCM80 , which contains in its backbone a gene conferring tetracycline resistance for maintenance and selection of the plasmid, were cultivated in a bioreactor with either succinate or methanol as the sole carbon source. In the presence of succinate, M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 had a growth rate μ of 0.161±0.001 h−1, which is only slightly below the rate observed for M. extorquens AM1 in absence of the plasmid and antibiotic (0.168±0.008 h−1). In contrast, when both strains were grown in the presence of methanol as the sole carbon source, the growth rate of M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 was 0.070±0.005 h−1 and thus was roughly half the rate of M. extorquens AM1 (0.158±0.003 h−1). Thus under methylotrophic growth conditions rather than under non-methylotrophic growth conditions, the presence of the plasmid pCM80 significantly delayed growth in this experimental system.
In addition to catabolic oxidation of methanol to carbon dioxide , , M. extorquens AM1 uses specific pathways for one-carbon (C1) compound assimilation that are essential for growth in the presence of methanol: the serine cycle ,  in combination with the recently uncovered ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway (EMCP) , . The serine cycle allows incorporation of C1 units by forming serine from glycine and methylene-tetrahydrofolate, and regeneration of the glycine precursor glyoxylate is achieved via the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway. In order to investigate whether the decrease in growth observed as a consequence of pCM80 under methylotrophic growth conditions is linked to decreased metabolic activity of these C1-linked pathways, we performed targeted metabolite profiling of the respective central metabolites by 13C isotope dilution  using liquid chromatography high resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS). When comparing pool sizes determined for M. extorquens AM1 to those found for M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 in the presence of tetracycline, slight changes in pool sizes of serine cycle intermediates up to a factor of about 2 were observed (Table 1). Metabolite profiling of the EMCP intermediates by LC-HRMS  revealed much higher relative changes for certain intermediates when comparing M. extorquens AM1 and M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 (Table 2); an increase in concentration of ethylmalonyl-CoA greater than 6-fold for M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 was found, and there was also a 35-fold increase of the methylmalonyl-CoA pool. Both metabolites have in common their conversion by specific mutases ,  (i.e., ethylmalonyl-CoA mutase catalyzing the conversion of ethylmalonyl-CoA to methylsuccinyl-CoA, methylmalonyl-CoA mutase converting methylmalonyl-CoA to succinyl-CoA). These cofactor B12-dependent enzymes play a key role in glyoxylate regeneration in M. extorquens AM1  and are essential for growth on methanol whereas this pathway is dispensable for growth on succinate . Comparison of chromatographic peaks of ethylmalonyl-CoA and methylsuccinyl-CoA, as well as methylmalonyl and succinyl-CoA, obtained from LC-HRMS analysis (Fig. 1) revealed that the product and educt of the mutase catalyzed reactions are very similar in M. extorquens AM1. However, in M. extorquens AM1 pCM80, an important accumulation of the substrates of the reactions in the direction of the net flux of the EMCP was observed (Fig. 1). These results suggest a bottleneck within the EMCP specifically at the mutase reactions. However, since we cannot determine the specific S/R configuration of the substrates of the two mutase reactions using the metabolome analyses applied, it is also conceivable that the mutase-preceding step, ethylmalonyl-CoA/methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase, is affected. This protein has also been shown to be stimulated by Co2+ , , . As a consequence, down-regulation of gene expression or enzyme inhibition might occur and lead to the observed accumulation of pool sizes and ultimately reduced growth.
Ion chromatogram sections of CoA esters extracted from M. extorquens AM1 (A1, A2) and M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 in presence of tetracycline (B1, B2). 1: succinyl-CoA; 2: methylmalonyl-CoA; 3: methylsuccinyl-CoA; 4: ethylmalonyl-CoA.
Cobalt Dependency of Glyoxylate Regeneration In Vivo
The pCM80 plasmid harbors a gene providing resistance to tetracycline via active efflux of tetracycline out of the cell . Tetracycline efflux requires divalent cations for export, forming a chelate complex with the dication with the highest affinity to Co2+ for all investigated ions . It seems reasonable to assume that mutases and/or epimerase and tetracycline compete for free cobalt. The strong efflux of tetracycline may thus cause a drop in the intracellular cobalt concentrations below a threshold level required for sufficient activity of the cobalt-dependent enzymes of the EMCP, which would result in accumulation of ethylmalonyl-CoA and methylsuccinyl-CoA, reduced carbon flux through EMCP, and ultimately reduced growth in the presence of methanol.
In order to evaluate whether cobalt limited growth of M. extorquens AM1 pCM80, the strain as well as wild type were cultivated in shake flasks on minimal medium with methanol containing different cobalt concentrations, and growth rates were determined (Fig. 2). When the cobalt concentration was 10 times increased (12.6 µM), the measured growth rate of M. extorquens pCM80 doubled (0.144±0.005 h−1) corresponding to 84% of the growth rate of M. extorquens AM1. For the latter only a slight increase of less than 10% was observed with increasing cobalt concentration (0.171±0.010 h−1). Similar results were observed when cobalt concentration was increased 25 times and 100 times, though in the latter case a slight decrease of growth rates was observed for both strains (Fig. 2). The results show that the strong growth limitation of M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 in the presence of tetracycline during growth on minimal medium with methanol as the sole carbon source could be partially compensated by increasing the cobalt concentration in the medium. In a second step, we cultivated M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 in a bioreactor in the presence of tetracycline on minimal medium with methanol containing 10 times increased cobalt concentration. Similar to the results obtained from cultivations in shake flasks, two biological replicates revealed growth rates of 0.13 h−1 and 0.14 h−1. EMCP intermediates were extracted during exponential growth. Table 2, column B shows the fold changes of EMCP intermediates relative to the wild-type strain; all CoA ester pools were comparable to those observed for wild-type. Moreover, the accumulation of methylmalonyl-CoA and ethylmalonyl-CoA was no longer detectable, indicating that addition of cobalt overcomes the metabolic inhibition.
Growth rates of M. extorquens AM1 strains observed during exponential growth on minimal medium with different cobalt concentrations. Values were determined for the wild-type strain (WT), strain AM1 with pCM80 plasmid coding for tetracycline resistance, and strain AM1 pCM160 plasmid coding for kanamycin resistance. Average values and standard deviations were calculated from three biological replicates carried out in shake flasks.
Introduction of Isocitrate Lyase
Heterologous expression of isocitrate lyase can partially restore glyoxylate regeneration in case the authentic system is blocked . For further evidence that glyoxylate regeneration limits growth of M. extorquens AM1 pCM80, growth of M. extorquens pCM80icl was determined. M. extorquens pCM80icl was cultivated on methanol with the same cultivation conditions as M. extorquens AM1 pCM80. Two biological replicates resulted in growth rates of 0.11 h−1 and 0.13 h−1, respectively. Compared to M. extorquens AM1, growth rates were partially restored when isocitrate lyase was introduced, a result that is in line with the assumption that cobalt limitation is the primary cause of growth delay via blocking the EMCP.
Characterization of M. extorquens in the Presence of pCM160
In the case that the mechanism of tetracycline resistance was the reason M. extorquens became low on intracellular cobalt in the presence of pCM80 and tetracycline, the presence of pCM160, which carries a gene for kanamycin resistance instead of the tetracycline resistance gene, should not affect growth in the same way pCM80 does. The kanamycin resistance gene encodes a nucleotidyltransferase that catalyzes the transfer of a nucleoside monophosphate group to the 4′-hydroxyl group of the aminoglycoside kanamycin to inactivate the antibiotic . To our knowledge there is no indication for an involvement of cobalt ions in the mechanism of action of this enzyme. To test the hypothesis of a less severe growth phenotype due to the presence of pCM160, M. extorquens AM1 pCM160 was cultivated on minimal medium with either methanol or succinate, in presence of the antibiotic. Three biological replicates yielded a growth rate of 0.142±0.01 h−1 on succinate, a rate that was about 15% below that of the wild-type strain (0.168±0.01 h−1). Surprisingly, on methanol the growth rate was 0.062±0.003 h−1, which was similar to that observed for M. extorquens pCM80. When performing cultivation on minimal medium with methanol as the sole carbon source at different cobalt concentrations, the growth rate increased significantly with increasing cobalt concentration in the medium, as observed for strain pCM80 (Fig. 2). When cobalt concentration was increased 10 times, the growth rate more than doubled (0.133±0.008 h−1), and similar growth rates were observed for higher cobalt concentrations, corresponding to 78% of the wild-type growth rate. Thus, poor methanol growth of the pCM160 strain could also be compensated by increasing the cobalt concentration in the medium (Fig. 2).
For further comparison, M. extorquens AM1 pCM160 was cultivated in shake flasks in the presence of kanamycin on minimal medium with natural labeled methanol containing the default cobalt concentration and on minimal medium with 99% 13C methanol containing a 10 times increased cobalt concentration. Cells were grown to a similar OD, and samples from both cultures were taken in parallel, mixed, and quenched at the same time. CoA esters were extracted from sample mixtures and subsequently analyzed by LC-HRMS. To evaluate reproducibility, the experiment was repeated applying 13C-labeled methanol to minimal medium with the default cobalt concentration. In addition, the same experiment was carried out with M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 in the presence of tetracycline as a control. Growth rates on minimal medium with default cobalt concentrations were 0.072 h−1 and 0.065 h−1 for M. extorquens AM1 pCM80, and 0.068 h−1 and 0.066 h−1 for M. extorquens AM1 pCM160. With a 10 times increased cobalt concentration, M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 yielded growth rates of 0.12 h−1 and 0.13 h−1, and M. extorquens AM1 pCM160 growth rates were 0.12 h−1 and 0.13 h−1. Thus, cobalt concentration had the same influence on growth on methanol for both strains. Table 3 shows the fold change of EMCP metabolites when increasing to ten times the cobalt concentration in the medium. Not only did both strains show very similar decreases of ethylmalonyl-CoA and methylmalonyl-CoA, but also, all measured EMCP intermediates underwent similar changes for both strains when cobalt concentration was increased. The results for M. extorquens pCM160 together with those obtained for M. extorquens pCM80 suggest that perturbation of intracellular cobalt concentration might be due to a more general response mechanism of antibiotic stress of M. extorquens AM1 rather than to the specific mechanism of tetracycline resistance, although a combination of the two effects is possible.
Overproduction of a Putative TonB-Dependent Cobalt Transporter
As propagation of either pCM80 or pCM160 caused very similar effects on growth rates and EMCP metabolite ratios, we tried to find another explanation for the plasmid-induced intracellular cobalt depletion. The exposure of cells to antibiotics can lead to the activation of a stress response, which includes changes in the expression of outer membrane proteins . To identify potential candidates for M. extorquens cobalt transporters, which could be down-regulated due to exposure to tetracycline or kanamycin in cells containing pCM80 or pCM160, we searched the genome for factors involved in cobalt uptake. In an in silico comparative genomic analysis to identify prokaryotic nickel and cobalt uptake transporters, a specific group of TonB-dependent receptors was presented based on conserved regulatory motifs and conserved colocalization in nickel or cobalt transport system operons . Experimental evidence for a nickel transport function across the outer membrane by a protein from this group has been provided ; this clearly extends the substrate spectrum of TonB-energized transport, previously thought to be restricted to iron complexes and cobalamin compounds . By performing a BLAST search on the M. extorquens genome with the hypothetical TonB-dependent cobalt transporter Daro_1684 from Dechloromonas aromatica ,  we identified two TonB-dependent receptors with high similarity to the D. aromatica protein: META2_0097, which has been designated a putative TonB-dependent receptor for iron transport by homology, and META1_1076, a TonB-dependent transporter homologous to numerous other uncharacterized bacterial outer membrane transporters. As META1_1076 most probably forms an operon with META1_1077, the latter encoding a putative periplasmic homolog of the cobalt chelatase CbiK, META1_1076 seemed to be a promising candidate for an outer membrane cobalt transporter.
Therefore we transformed an overexpression construct of this operon, pCM80-Mext META1_1076/META1_1077, into M. extorquens AM1 and determined the growth rate μ in methanol medium containing the default cobalt concentration and tetracycline. We found a growth rate of 0.122±0.003 h−1, corresponding to roughly 80% of the growth rate of M. extorquens AM1 in methanol medium. Overexpression of this TonB-dependent transport system thus suppressed the growth defect caused by limiting intracellular cobalt concentration in plasmid-bearing cells, suggesting that the observed growth defect phenomenon might be caused by antibiotic stress-mediated repression of this outer membrane cobalt transport system. Notably, a very recent study identified the same transporter system for cobalt uptake by an evolutionary experiment with M. extorquens AM1 on metal deficient growth media utilizing methanol as carbon source . It was shown that increased expression of this transporter in the mutant strain yielded increased growth rates under cobalt limitations compared to the ancestor strain. It is currently unclear whether the aforementioned putative TonB-dependent receptor META2_0097, which is annotated as an iron transporter, might also contribute to cobalt transport across the outer membrane in M. extorquens AM1. M. extorquens AM1 also contains a second putative periplasmic cobalt chelatase (META1_0967), as well as an operon encoding two factors known to constitute a cytoplasmic membrane cobalt transport system (CbtA (META1_1332) and CbtB (META1_1333)). Overexpression of the CbtA/B operon using a pCM80 construct did not result in an increase in growth rate compared to M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 (data not shown), suggesting that transport across the inner membrane might not be limiting under the antibiotic stress conditions.
It is well known that groups of microorganisms have a relatively high demand for certain trace elements that represent metal sites of key metabolic enzymes. Schönheit et al. discovered that at low concentrations of nickel (less than 100 nM), cobalt (less than 10 nM), and molybdenum (less than 10 nM), the quantity of Methanothermobacter marburgensis cells formed was roughly proportional to the amount of transition metal added to the medium when cells were grown on H2 and CO2 . Later the enzymes, such as methyl-CoM reductase (Ni), hydrogenases (Ni), acetyl CoA synthase/CO dehydrogenase (Ni), methyl transferases (Co), and formylmethanofuran dehydrogenase (Mo), were identified . When methanogens are grown in the presence of methanol, cobalt was found to become the primary limiting trace element . Another example is the alkyl tert-butyl ether-degrading Betaproteobacteria, which was shown to exhibit an elevated nutritional demand for cobalt due to the presence of a cobalamin-dependent mutase during growth on substrates possessing the tert-butyl moiety .
Here we demonstrated that metabolic profiling represents a useful method to observe bottlenecks in metabolism as a consequence of shortages of trace elements. This is of interest for the purposes of elucidation of novel pathways with yet uncharacterized enzymes and of engineering strategies for biotechnological applications. From the results it is obvious that cobalt is a critical trace element for methylotrophic growth of Methylobacterium extorquens, not only in the presence of antibiotics but also for the wild type in dependence upon the medium and concentrations employed. One may imagine that the high cobalamin requirement during growth in the presence of methanol makes Methylobacterium a good expression host for cobalamin-dependent enzymes. Our study also shows that the utilization of plasmids for strain improvement strategies might sometimes be critical; although the introduction of icl to the pCM80 plasmid results in a higher growth rate of M. extorquens compared to the empty plasmid, M. extorquens AM1 pCM80icl is still growing slower than the plasmid-free M. extorquens AM1 since the isocitrate lyase only partially compensates for inhibited activity of EMCP pathway introduced by pCM80 plasmid under the default experimental conditions.
Materials and Methods
Chemicals and Medium Composition
13C methanol (99%) was purchased from Cambridge Isotope Laboratories. All other chemicals were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. Acetonitrile, acetic acid, formic acid, and ammonium hydroxide used for HPLC solvents were of LC-MS degree. M. extorquens AM1 strains were grown on minimal medium as described previously , except that the default concentration of CoCl2⋅6H2O (0.3 mg L−1) was modified for a number of cultivation experiments (see Results). In the presence of the pCM80 plasmid and the pCM160 plasmid, 10 mg L−1 of tetracycline and 50 mg L−1 of kanamycin were added to the medium, respectively. Both plasmids are versatile broad-host-range vectors introduced for use in Gram-negative bacteria and in methylotrophs in particular. They are based on the pCM62 and pCM66 plasmids that were shown to be maintained in M. extorquens AM1 with equal efficiency .
DNA cloning was performed using standard methods . To construct plasmid pCM80-MetA1_1076/MetA1_1077, the operon containing ORFs MetA1_1076 and MetA1_1077 was amplified by PCR using primers TCGATCTAGAATGTCGCCGCTTCTGACGC and AGCTGAGCTCTCAGTTGGACTTCGGGTCGGTG with chromosomal DNA of M. extorquens AM1 as template. After digestion of the PCR product and plasmid pCM80  with XbaI and SacI, fragments were ligated. The E. coli isocitrate lyase gene was amplified from genomic E. coli DNA by PCR using primers ATATAAGCTTAACTATGGAGCATCTGCACA and TATATCTAGATTAGAACTGCGATTCTTCAG. After digestion of the PCR product and plasmid pCM80 with XbaI and HindIII, fragments were ligated to construct pCM80icl.
All pre-cultures were carried out in baffled shake flasks at 28°C and 110 rpm. Main cultures in shake flasks were carried out under the same conditions. Cultures were inoculated to an initial OD600 between 0.05 and 0.1. Main cultures in a bioreactor were carried out in a 500 mL bioreactor (Infors-HT, Bottmingen, Switzerland) with a 400 mL working volume at 28°C and at 1000 rpm. The pH was maintained at 7.0 by addition of 1 M ammonium hydroxide. Initial OD600 was about 0.3. Three independent cultivation experiments were carried out for shake flask experiments and two in case of bioreactor experiments.
Sampling, Quenching, and Extraction of Metabolites for Quantification
For the purpose of metabolic profiling experiments, cells were harvested during mid-exponential growth at 2<OD600<3. In case of small polar compounds (amino acids, organic acids, and small phosphorylated metabolites), a cell amount corresponding to 0.6 mg cell dry weight was sampled by fast filtration . The latter included a wash step to remove metabolites eventually present in the culture liquid phase. Metabolites were extracted over 8 min with boiling water . For metabolite quantification the isotope dilution method was applied . To this end, uniformly 13C-labeled cell extract from M. extorquens AM1 cells grown on methanol was added to the sample as internal standard when starting metabolite extraction. In the case of CoA esters, sampling and quenching of samples was performed as described . Similarly, for small polar metabolites, uniformly 13C-labeled cell extract from M. extorquens AM1 grown on methanol was added simultaneously with the sample to the quenching solution. For extraction, the sample was incubated for 15 min on ice. During incubation, samples were mixed for 10 s every 5 min. After addition of 20 mL of ice-cold deionized water, samples were chilled with liquid nitrogen. Frozen samples were stored at −20°C until freeze drying. When a LC-HRMS protocol with an improved sample desalting method was applied (see below), freeze dried samples were dissolved in 80 µl of ice-cold, 25 mM ammonium formate buffer (pH 3.5, 2% methanol), the suspension was centrifuged (14,000 g, 3 min, 0°C), and the supernatant was used for LC-HRMS analysis. Otherwise, samples were prepared as previously described .
All analyses were done using a Rheos 2200 HPLC instrument (Flux Instruments, Switzerland) with an LTQ Orbitrap mass spectrometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific), equipped with an electrospray ionization probe. Small polar compounds were analyzed as described previously . CoA esters were analyzed as described  or by applying a modified protocol with significantly improved desalting of the samples. For both protocols solvent A was 50 mM formic acid adjusted to pH 8.1 with ammonium hydroxide, and solvent B was methanol. The flow rate was 220 µL min-1, and the injection volume was 10 µL. In the case of the alternative protocol, a C18 analytical column (Gemini 50×2.0 mm, particle size 3 µm, Phenomenex) used for desalting was connected via a 6-port valve to a second C18 analytical column (Gemini 100×2.0 mm, particle size 3 µm). To desalt the sample, it was injected on the short column, which was connected to the waste. During desalting the flow of the second column was provided by a second HPLC pump. After 5 min the two columns were connected in line. The gradient of B was as follows: 0 min, 0%; 5 min 0%; 15 min, 23%; 25 min, 80%; 27 min, 80%; 27.5 min, 0%; 32 min, 0%. MS analysis was performed in the negative or in the positive FTMS mode at a resolution of 30,000. For the positive FTMS mode, sheath gas flow rate was 40, aux gas flow rate was 30, tube lens was 80 V, capillary voltage was 30 V, and ion spray was 4.7 kV. For the negative FTMS mode, gas flow rates were identical, tube lens was −90 V, capillary voltage was −4 V, and ion spray current was −4.7 kV.
Growth rates were determined from exponential fits of growth curves using the Matlab curve fitting tool. The goodness of fit criterion was an adjusted R2 value higher than 0.99. For metabolite quantification from cultivations in bioreactors the isotope dilution method developed by  was applied by adding U-13C labeled cell extract (internal standard) to the sample prior to metabolite extraction, and concentrations were calculated as follows:where AMUL is the area of the uniformly 13C-labeled mass peak, AM0 is the area of the monoisotopic mass peak, V0 is the sample volume, VMUL is the volume of the U-13C labeled cell extract, cMUL is the known concentration of the U-13C labeled metabolite of the internal standard, and X is the biomass concentration. When the absolute concentration of a metabolite in the internal standard was unknown, relative differences in pool sizes were calculated from normalized peak areas as follows:
For a set of cultivations in shake flasks CoA ester pool sizes of strains AM1 containing the plasmids pCM80 and pCM160 were compared to those of the wild type growing under default conditions applying the approach developed by Mashego et al. . To this end M. extorquens AM1 wild type was cultivated on default medium containing 99% U-13C whereas M. extorquens AM1 pCM80 and M. extorquens AM1 pCM160 were grown on natural labeled methanol. Defined amounts of 13C-labeled cells were quenched and extracted together with defined amounts of natural labeled extracts. Mass isotopomer distributions of CoA esters were determined by LC-MS. Since cultivations were carried out in shake flasks natural labeled CO2 from air was present. CoA esters formed on 13C methanol in shake flasks showed an increased fraction of partially 13C-labeled CoA esters though the mass isotopomer distributions of CoA esters formed on natural labeled and 13C-labeled methanol were completely separated. The observed increase of 12C carbon can be explained by operation of the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway during growth on methanol incorporating a significant fraction of CO2 into biomass . Therefore, to determine the relative difference between natural labeled and 13C-labeled CoA ester pool sizes [CoA ester]rel. all mass peaks M0, M1, …, Mn measured from natural labeled CoA esters (n.l.-CoA) and all mass isotopomers MMUL-m, …, MMUL-1, MMUL from CoA esters formed on 13C methanol (13C-CoA) were taken into account, and relative pool sizes of CoA esters were calculated as follows:
Conceived and designed the experiments: PK MB JS JAV. Performed the experiments: PK MB PC. Analyzed the data: PK MB PC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: PK BK. Wrote the paper: PK MB JS JAV.
- 1. Bailey JE (1993) Host-vector interactions in Escherichia coli. Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol 48: 29–52.JE Bailey1993Host-vector interactions in Escherichia coli.Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol482952
- 2. Bailey JE, Da Silva NA, Peretti SW, Seo JH, Srienc F (1986) Studies of host-plasmid interactions in recombinant microorganisms. Ann N Y Acad Sci 469: 194–211.JE BaileyNA Da SilvaSW PerettiJH SeoF. Srienc1986Studies of host-plasmid interactions in recombinant microorganisms.Ann N Y Acad Sci469194211
- 3. Glick BR (1995) Metabolic load and heterologous gene expression. Biotechnol Adv 13: 247–261.BR Glick1995Metabolic load and heterologous gene expression.Biotechnol Adv13247261
- 4. Cheah UE, Weigand WA, Stark BC (1987) Effects of recombinant plasmid size on cellular processes in Escherichia coli. Plasmid 18: 127–134.UE CheahWA WeigandBC Stark1987Effects of recombinant plasmid size on cellular processes in Escherichia coli.Plasmid18127134
- 5. Khosravi M, Ryan W, Webster DA, Stark BC (1990) Variation of oxygen requirement with plasmid size in recombinant Escherichia coli. Plasmid 23: 138–143.M. KhosraviW. RyanDA WebsterBC Stark1990Variation of oxygen requirement with plasmid size in recombinant Escherichia coli.Plasmid23138143
- 6. Ryan W, Parulekar SJ, Stark BC (1989) Expression of beta-lactamase by recombinant Escherichia coli strains containing plasmids of different sizes-effects of pH, phosphate, and dissolved oxygen. Biotechnol Bioeng 34: 309–319.W. RyanSJ ParulekarBC Stark1989Expression of beta-lactamase by recombinant Escherichia coli strains containing plasmids of different sizes-effects of pH, phosphate, and dissolved oxygen.Biotechnol Bioeng34309319
- 7. Birnbaum S, Bailey JE (1991) Plasmid presence changes the relative levels of many host cell proteins and ribosome components in recombinant Escherichia coli. Biotechnol Bioeng 37: 736–745.S. BirnbaumJE Bailey1991Plasmid presence changes the relative levels of many host cell proteins and ribosome components in recombinant Escherichia coli.Biotechnol Bioeng37736745
- 8. Seo JH, Bailey JE (1985) Effects of recombinant plasmid content on growth properties and cloned gene product formation in Escherichia coli. Biotechnol Bioeng 27: 1668–1674.JH SeoJE Bailey1985Effects of recombinant plasmid content on growth properties and cloned gene product formation in Escherichia coli.Biotechnol Bioeng2716681674
- 9. da Silva NA, Bailey JE (1986) Theoretical growth yield estimates for recombinant cells. Biotechnol Bioeng 28: 741–746.NA da SilvaJE Bailey1986Theoretical growth yield estimates for recombinant cells.Biotechnol Bioeng28741746
- 10. Diaz Ricci JC, Hernandez ME (2000) Plasmid effects on Escherichia coli metabolism. Crit Rev Biotechnol 20: 79–108.JC Diaz RicciME Hernandez2000Plasmid effects on Escherichia coli metabolism.Crit Rev Biotechnol2079108
- 11. Ow DS, Lee DY, Yap MG, Oh SK (2008) Identification of cellular objective for elucidating the physiological state of plasmid-bearing Escherichia coli using genome-scale in silico analysis. Biotechnol Prog 25: 61–67.DS OwDY LeeMG YapSK Oh2008Identification of cellular objective for elucidating the physiological state of plasmid-bearing Escherichia coli using genome-scale in silico analysis.Biotechnol Prog256167
- 12. Ow DS-W, Nissom PM, Philp R, Oh SK-W, Yap MG-S (2006) Global transcriptional analysis of metabolic burden due to plasmid maintenance in Escherichia coli DH5[alpha] during batch fermentation. Enzyme and Microbial Technology 39: 391–398.DS-W OwPM NissomR. PhilpSK-W OhMG-S Yap2006Global transcriptional analysis of metabolic burden due to plasmid maintenance in Escherichia coli DH5[alpha] during batch fermentation.Enzyme and Microbial Technology39391398
- 13. Marciano DC, Karkouti OY, Palzkill T (2007) A fitness cost associated with the antibiotic resistance enzyme SME-1 beta-lactamase. Genetics 176: 2381–2392.DC MarcianoOY KarkoutiT. Palzkill2007A fitness cost associated with the antibiotic resistance enzyme SME-1 beta-lactamase.Genetics17623812392
- 14. Moyed HS, Bertrand KP (1983) Mutations in multicopy Tn10 tet plasmids that confer resistance to inhibitory effects of inducers of tet gene expression. J Bacteriol 155: 557–564.HS MoyedKP Bertrand1983Mutations in multicopy Tn10 tet plasmids that confer resistance to inhibitory effects of inducers of tet gene expression.J Bacteriol155557564
- 15. Lee SW, Edlin G (1985) Expression of tetracycline resistance in pBR322 derivatives reduces the reproductive fitness of plasmid-containing Escherichia coli. Gene 39: 173–180.SW LeeG. Edlin1985Expression of tetracycline resistance in pBR322 derivatives reduces the reproductive fitness of plasmid-containing Escherichia coli.Gene39173180
- 16. Nielsen J, Oliver S (2005) The next wave in metabolome analysis. Trends Biotechnol 23: 544–546.J. NielsenS. Oliver2005The next wave in metabolome analysis.Trends Biotechnol23544546
- 17. Chistoserdova L, Kalyuzhnaya MG, Lidstrom ME (2009) The expanding world of methylotrophic metabolism. Annu Rev Microbiol 63: 477–499.L. ChistoserdovaMG KalyuzhnayaME Lidstrom2009The expanding world of methylotrophic metabolism.Annu Rev Microbiol63477499
- 18. Vuilleumier S, Chistoserdova L, Lee MC, Bringel F, Lajus A, et al. (2009) Methylobacterium genome sequences: a reference blueprint to investigate microbial metabolism of C1 compounds from natural and industrial sources. PLoS One 4: e5584.S. VuilleumierL. ChistoserdovaMC LeeF. BringelA. Lajus2009Methylobacterium genome sequences: a reference blueprint to investigate microbial metabolism of C1 compounds from natural and industrial sources.PLoS One4e5584
- 19. Bosch G, Skovran E, Xia Q, Wang T, Taub F, et al. (2008) Comprehensive proteomics of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 metabolism under single carbon and nonmethylotrophic conditions. Proteomics 8: 3494–3505.G. BoschE. SkovranQ. XiaT. WangF. Taub2008Comprehensive proteomics of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 metabolism under single carbon and nonmethylotrophic conditions.Proteomics834943505
- 20. Guo X, Lidstrom ME (2008) Metabolite profiling analysis of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 by comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography coupled with time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Biotechnol Bioeng 99: 929–940.X. GuoME Lidstrom2008Metabolite profiling analysis of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 by comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography coupled with time-of-flight mass spectrometry.Biotechnol Bioeng99929940
- 21. Kiefer P, Portais JC, Vorholt JA (2008) Quantitative metabolome analysis using liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry. Anal Biochem 382: 94–100.P. KieferJC PortaisJA Vorholt2008Quantitative metabolome analysis using liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry.Anal Biochem38294100
- 22. Laukel M, Rossignol M, Borderies G, Volker U, Vorholt JA (2004) Comparison of the proteome of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 grown under methylotrophic and nonmethylotrophic conditions. Proteomics 4: 1247–1264.M. LaukelM. RossignolG. BorderiesU. VolkerJA Vorholt2004Comparison of the proteome of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 grown under methylotrophic and nonmethylotrophic conditions.Proteomics412471264
- 23. Okubo Y, Skovran E, Guo X, Sivam D, Lidstrom ME (2007) Implementation of microarrays for Methylobacterium extorquens AM1. OMICS 11: 325–340.Y. OkuboE. SkovranX. GuoD. SivamME Lidstrom2007Implementation of microarrays for Methylobacterium extorquens AM1.OMICS11325340
- 24. Schrader J, Schilling M, Holtmann D, Sell D, Filho MV, et al. (2009) Methanol-based industrial biotechnology: current status and future perspectives of methylotrophic bacteria. Trends Biotechnol 27: 107–115.J. SchraderM. SchillingD. HoltmannD. SellMV Filho2009Methanol-based industrial biotechnology: current status and future perspectives of methylotrophic bacteria.Trends Biotechnol27107115
- 25. Marx CJ, Lidstrom ME (2001) Development of improved versatile broad-host-range vectors for use in methylotrophs and other Gram-negative bacteria. Microbiol 147: 2065–2075.CJ MarxME Lidstrom2001Development of improved versatile broad-host-range vectors for use in methylotrophs and other Gram-negative bacteria.Microbiol14720652075
- 26. Chistoserdova L, Chen S-W, Lapidus A, Lidstrom ME (2003) Methylotrophy in Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 from a genomic point of view. J Bacteriol 185: 2980–2987.L. ChistoserdovaS-W ChenA. LapidusME Lidstrom2003Methylotrophy in Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 from a genomic point of view.J Bacteriol18529802987
- 27. Vorholt JA (2002) Cofactor-dependent pathways of formaldehyde oxidation in methylotrophic bacteria. Arch Microbiol 178: 239–249.JA Vorholt2002Cofactor-dependent pathways of formaldehyde oxidation in methylotrophic bacteria.Arch Microbiol178239249
- 28. Anthony C (1982) The biochemistry of methylotrophs. C. Anthony1982The biochemistry of methylotrophs.Academic Press, London, UK. Academic Press, London, UK.
- 29. Large PJ, Quayle JR (1963) Microbial growth on C(1) compounds. 5. Enzyme activities in extracts of Pseudomonas AM1. Biochem J 87: 386–396.PJ LargeJR Quayle1963Microbial growth on C(1) compounds. 5. Enzyme activities in extracts of Pseudomonas AM1.Biochem J87386396
- 30. Erb TJ, Berg IA, Brecht V, Muller M, Fuchs G, et al. (2007) Synthesis of C5-dicarboxylic acids from C2-units involving crotonyl-CoA carboxylase/reductase: the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 10631–10636.TJ ErbIA BergV. BrechtM. MullerG. Fuchs2007Synthesis of C5-dicarboxylic acids from C2-units involving crotonyl-CoA carboxylase/reductase: the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA1041063110636
- 31. Peyraud R, Kiefer P, Christen P, Massou S, Portais JC, et al. (2009) Demonstration of the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway by using 13C metabolomics. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106: 4846–4851.R. PeyraudP. KieferP. ChristenS. MassouJC Portais2009Demonstration of the ethylmalonyl-CoA pathway by using 13C metabolomics.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA10648464851
- 32. Wu L, Mashego MR, van Dam JC, Proell AM, Vinke JL, et al. (2005) Quantitative analysis of the microbial metabolome by isotope dilution mass spectrometry using uniformly 13C-labeled cell extracts as internal standards. Anal Biochem 336: 164–171.L. WuMR MashegoJC van DamAM ProellJL Vinke2005Quantitative analysis of the microbial metabolome by isotope dilution mass spectrometry using uniformly 13C-labeled cell extracts as internal standards.Anal Biochem336164171
- 33. Erb TJ, Retey J, Fuchs G, Alber BE (2008) Ethylmalonyl-CoA mutase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides defines a new subclade of coenzyme B12-dependent acyl-CoA mutases. J Biol Chem 283: 32283–32293.TJ ErbJ. ReteyG. FuchsBE Alber2008Ethylmalonyl-CoA mutase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides defines a new subclade of coenzyme B12-dependent acyl-CoA mutases.J Biol Chem2833228332293
- 34. Korotkova N, Lidstrom ME (2004) MeaB is a component of the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase complex required for protection of the enzyme from inactivation. J Biol Chem 279: 13652–13658.N. KorotkovaME Lidstrom2004MeaB is a component of the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase complex required for protection of the enzyme from inactivation.J Biol Chem2791365213658
- 35. Leadlay PF (1981) Purification and characterization of methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase from Propionibacterium shermanii. Biochem J 197: 413–419.PF Leadlay1981Purification and characterization of methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase from Propionibacterium shermanii.Biochem J197413419
- 36. Stabler SP, Marcell PD, Allen RH (1985) Isolation and characterization of DL-methylmalonyl-coenzyme A racemase from rat liver. Arch Biochem Biophys 241: 252–264.SP StablerPD MarcellRH Allen1985Isolation and characterization of DL-methylmalonyl-coenzyme A racemase from rat liver.Arch Biochem Biophys241252264
- 37. Levy SB, McMurry L (1978) Plasmid-determined tetracycline resistance involves new transport systems for tetracycline. Nature 276: 90–92.SB LevyL. McMurry1978Plasmid-determined tetracycline resistance involves new transport systems for tetracycline.Nature2769092
- 38. Yamaguchi A, Udagawa T, Sawai T (1990) Transport of divalent cations with tetracycline as mediated by the transposon Tn10-encoded tetracycline resistance protein. J Biol Chem 265: 4809–4813.A. YamaguchiT. UdagawaT. Sawai1990Transport of divalent cations with tetracycline as mediated by the transposon Tn10-encoded tetracycline resistance protein.J Biol Chem26548094813
- 39. Korotkova N, Lidstrom ME (2001) Connection between poly-beta-hydroxybutyrate biosynthesis and growth on C(1) and C(2) compounds in the methylotroph Methylobacterium extorquens AM1. J Bacteriol 183: 1038–1046.N. KorotkovaME Lidstrom2001Connection between poly-beta-hydroxybutyrate biosynthesis and growth on C(1) and C(2) compounds in the methylotroph Methylobacterium extorquens AM1.J Bacteriol18310381046
- 40. Legoffic F, Martel A, Capmau ML, Baca B, Goebel P, et al. (1976) New plasmid-mediated nucleotidylation of aminoglycoside antibiotics in Staphylococcus aureus. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 10: 258–264.F. LegofficA. MartelML CapmauB. BacaP. Goebel1976New plasmid-mediated nucleotidylation of aminoglycoside antibiotics in Staphylococcus aureus.Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy10258264
- 41. Viveiros M, Dupont M, Rodrigues L, Couto I, Davin-Regli A, et al. (2007) Antibiotic stress, genetic response and altered permeability of E. coli. PLoS One 2: e365.M. ViveirosM. DupontL. RodriguesI. CoutoA. Davin-Regli2007Antibiotic stress, genetic response and altered permeability of E. coli.PLoS One2e365
- 42. Rodionov DA, Hebbeln P, Gelfand MS, Eitinger T (2006) Comparative and functional genomic analysis of prokaryotic nickel and cobalt uptake transporters: evidence for a novel group of ATP-binding cassette transporters. J Bacteriol 188: 317–327.DA RodionovP. HebbelnMS GelfandT. Eitinger2006Comparative and functional genomic analysis of prokaryotic nickel and cobalt uptake transporters: evidence for a novel group of ATP-binding cassette transporters.J Bacteriol188317327
- 43. Schauer K, Gouget B, Carriere M, Labigne A, de Reuse H (2007) Novel nickel transport mechanism across the bacterial outer membrane energized by the TonB/ExbB/ExbD machinery. Mol Microbiol 63: 1054–1068.K. SchauerB. GougetM. CarriereA. LabigneH. de Reuse2007Novel nickel transport mechanism across the bacterial outer membrane energized by the TonB/ExbB/ExbD machinery.Mol Microbiol6310541068
- 44. Schauer K, Rodionov DA, de Reuse H (2008) New substrates for TonB-dependent transport: do we only see the ‘tip of the iceberg’? Trends Biochem Sci 33: 330–338.K. SchauerDA RodionovH. de Reuse2008New substrates for TonB-dependent transport: do we only see the ‘tip of the iceberg’?Trends Biochem Sci33330338
- 45. Chou HH, Berthet J, Marx CJ (2009) Fast growth increases the selective advantage of a mutation arising recurrently during evolution under metal limitation. PLoS Genet 5: e1000652.HH ChouJ. BerthetCJ Marx2009Fast growth increases the selective advantage of a mutation arising recurrently during evolution under metal limitation.PLoS Genet5e1000652
- 46. Schönheit P, Moll J, Thauer RK (1979) Nickel, cobalt, and molybdenum requirement for growth of Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum. Arch Microbiol 123: 105–107.P. SchönheitJ. MollRK Thauer1979Nickel, cobalt, and molybdenum requirement for growth of Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum.Arch Microbiol123105107
- 47. Thauer RK (1998) Biochemistry of methanogenesis: a tribute to Marjory Stephenson. 1998 Marjory Stephenson Prize Lecture. Microbiol 144: 2377–2406.RK Thauer1998Biochemistry of methanogenesis: a tribute to Marjory Stephenson. 1998 Marjory Stephenson Prize Lecture.Microbiol14423772406
- 48. Gonzalez-Gil G, Kleerebezem R, Lettinga G (1999) Effects of nickel and cobalt on kinetics of methanol conversion by methanogenic sludge as assessed by on-line CH4 monitoring. Appl Environ Microbiol 65: 1789–1793.G. Gonzalez-GilR. KleerebezemG. Lettinga1999Effects of nickel and cobalt on kinetics of methanol conversion by methanogenic sludge as assessed by on-line CH4 monitoring.Appl Environ Microbiol6517891793
- 49. Rohwerder T, Breuer U, Benndorf D, Lechner U, Müller RH (2006) The alkyl tert-butyl ether intermediate 2-hydroxyisobutyrate is degraded via a novel cobalamin-dependent mutase pathway. Appl Environ Microbiol 72: 4128–4135.T. RohwerderU. BreuerD. BenndorfU. LechnerRH Müller2006The alkyl tert-butyl ether intermediate 2-hydroxyisobutyrate is degraded via a novel cobalamin-dependent mutase pathway.Appl Environ Microbiol7241284135
- 50. Sambrook J, Russell DW, editors. (2001) Molecular cloning - a laboratory manual. New York: Cold Spring Harbor Press. J. SambrookDW Russell2001Molecular cloning - a laboratory manual.New YorkCold Spring Harbor Press
- 51. Bolten CJ, Kiefer P, Letisse F, Portais JC, Wittmann C (2007) Sampling for metabolome analysis of microorganisms. Anal Chem 79: 3843–3849.CJ BoltenP. KieferF. LetisseJC PortaisC. Wittmann2007Sampling for metabolome analysis of microorganisms.Anal Chem7938433849
- 52. Mashego MR, Wu L, Van Dam JC, Ras C, Vinke JL, et al. (2004) MIRACLE: mass isotopomer ratio analysis of U-13C-labeled extracts. A new method for accurate quantification of changes in concentrations of intracellular metabolites. Biotechnol Bioeng 85: 620–628.MR MashegoL. WuJC Van DamC. RasJL Vinke2004MIRACLE: mass isotopomer ratio analysis of U-13C-labeled extracts. A new method for accurate quantification of changes in concentrations of intracellular metabolites.Biotechnol Bioeng85620628