The precise mechanisms involved in the initiation and progression of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) are not known. Early stages of RA often have non-specific symptoms, delaying diagnosis and therapy. Additionally, there are currently no established means to predict clinical responsiveness to therapy. Immune cell activation is a critical component therefore we examined the cellular activation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) in the early stages of RA, in order to develop a novel diagnostic modality.
Methods and Findings
PBMCs were isolated from individuals diagnosed with early RA (ERA) (n = 38), longstanding RA (n = 10), osteoarthritis (OA) (n = 19) and from healthy individuals (n = 10). PBMCs were examined for activation of 15 signaling effectors, using phosphorylation status as a measure of activation in immunophenotyped cells, by flow cytometry (phospho-flow). CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+ and CD20+ cells isolated from patients with ERA, RA and OA exhibited activation of multiple phospho-epitopes. ERA patient PBMCs showed a bias towards phosphorylation-activation in the CD4+ and CD20+ compartments compared to OA PBMCs, where phospho-activation was primarily observed in CD8+ cells. The ratio of phospho (p)-AKT/p-p38 was significantly elevated in patients with ERA and may have diagnostic potential. The mean fluorescent intensity (MFI) levels for p-AKT and p-H3 in CD4+, CD8+ and CD20+ T cells correlated directly with physician global assessment scores (MDGA) and DAS (disease activity score). Stratification by medications revealed that patients receiving leflunomide, systemic steroids or anti-TNF therapy had significant reductions in phospho-specific activation compared with patients not receiving these therapies. Correlative trends between medication-associated reductions in the levels of phosphorylation of specific signaling effectors and lower disease activity were observed.
Phospho-flow analysis identified phosphorylation-activation of specific signaling effectors in the PB from patients with ERA. Notably, phosphorylation of these signaling effectors did not distinguish ERA from late RA, suggesting that the activation status of discrete cell populations is already established early in disease. However, when the ratio of MFI values for p-AKT and p-p38 is >1.5, there is a high likelihood of having a diagnosis of RA. Our results suggest that longitudinal sampling of patients undergoing therapy may result in phospho-signatures that are predictive of drug responsiveness.
Citation: Galligan CL, Siebert JC, Siminovitch KA, Keystone EC, Bykerk V, Perez OD, et al. (2009) Multiparameter Phospho-Flow Analysis of Lymphocytes in Early Rheumatoid Arthritis: Implications for Diagnosis and Monitoring Drug Therapy. PLoS ONE 4(8): e6703. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0006703
Editor: Derya Unutmaz, New York University School of Medicine, United States of America
Received: February 24, 2009; Accepted: July 6, 2009; Published: August 20, 2009
Copyright: © 2009 Galligan et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The work was supported by grants from Genome Canada and The Arthritis Society (RG06/065). Additional funding was through Bristol-Meyer Squibb Irvington Institute Fellow and the Dana Foundation, the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute (N01-HV-28183I) (ODP). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a common, relapsing autoimmune disease primarily affecting the joints. RA affects approximately 1% of the population worldwide . The clinical manifestations include joint swelling, deformity, pain, stiffness, and weakness . Within the affected RA joint, there is proliferation of synovial lining cells, pannus accumulation over articular cartilage and erosion of the underlying bone. The rheumatoid synovium is an area of intense immunological activity ,  with a profound infiltration of inflammatory cells, including mononuclear cells and lymphocytes, which occasionally form secondary lymphoid structures . Additionally, RA is not exclusively restricted to the joints and other extra-articular manifestation occur and account for considerable mortality and morbidity . While the specific molecular events that lead to initiation and onset of RA are not known, a systemic activation of the immune system is considered to be a critical component of the disease.
The etiology of RA is unclear, however, many cells types including fibroblast like synovial cells (FLS), B and T lymphocytes, macrophages and neutrophils all contribute to joint inflammation. Both T and B lymphocytes have prominent roles in RA pathology. The genetic association of RA with specific HLA-DR1 underscores the importance of T lymphocytes in RA pathology . Additionally, adoptive transfer of CD4+ T cells from affected animals induces joint inflammation in healthy recipients , while blocking T cell activation clearly has beneficial consequences in human RA patients . Recently, a novel IL-17 secreting T cell subset (Th17) has been implicated in RA disease pathogenesis in both human RA and in mouse models of disease . B lymphocytes undoubtedly play a critical role in RA pathology, as autoantibodies are found in the majority of patients ,  and B cell depletion with rituximab results in significant improvement in disease symptoms . Additionally, B cells maintain T cell activation in the RA joint  and interactions between T and B cells may represent unique events in autoimmune disease . Taken together, the activation of T and B lymphocytes may be early precipitating events in disease pathology and, as such, may identify useful diagnostic markers of disease initiation and/or progression.
Effective management of RA requires early diagnosis and timely treatment to prevent significant joint destruction and improve patient outcomes. Diagnosis of RA is difficult and is based on specific clinical parameters, radiographic evidence of joint destruction and/or the presence of anti-CCP/RF antibodies , . The current criteria for diagnosis of RA have come under scrutiny due to an inability to establish the diagnosis of RA in the early stages of the disease . While considerable progress has been made in identifying predictive criteria for disease progression , , identification of definitive diagnostic markers with higher sensitivity and specificity are required. Early aggressive therapy with multiple DMARDs including biological agents is highly effective in preventing disease progression . Currently there are no specific and/or rapid tests for monitoring disease progression and/or responsiveness to therapy. Viewed altogether, these deficiencies promoted the examination of patient cells for the identification of early activation markers in RA.
Recent advances in flow cytometry have expanded the number of simultaneous analyses to greater than 13, allowing for the detection of both surface and intracellular factors, thereby enabling identification of specific cell subsets as well as their functional activation in a heterogeneous cell population. Phospho-specific flow cytometry (phospho-flow) permits the quantification of phosphorylation levels of intracellular signaling proteins in individual cells, including rare populations of cells , , . Phospho-flow is highly quantitative ,  and novel network-based screens of complex populations in disease samples can easily be obtained . Phospho-flow technology has identify mutated signaling pathways in leukemia , predicted responsiveness of leukemic patients to chemotherapy  and can assess the effectiveness of drug therapy in blocking cellular signaling . Accordingly, we have employed phospho-flow technology to analyze the peripheral blood (PB) of patients with early RA (ERA) and established RA and compared the phospho-flow signatures with those from the PB of patients with osteoarthritis (OA) and healthy individuals. In addition, patients were stratified according to medication status and phospho-specific activation was used to examine responsiveness to specific therapies. This exploratory study examined fifteen phospho-epitopes in 3 cell lineages: CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+, and CD20+. The data suggest that analysis of the phospho-activation status of the PB leukocyte population may useful for monitoring disease activity and/or responsiveness to therapy.
Signaling profiles in RA joint T cells
At the outset, to confirm the activation status of T cells in RA in the context of phosphorylation-activation, we employed a customized BD PowerBlot immunoarray as a high throughput Western blot screen for phosphorylated signaling effectors. 20 paired phospho-signaling effectors were evaluated. CD3+ T cells were isolated from the affected joints of 3 patients with established RA at the time of joint replacement and protein lysates prepared. We identified elevated levels of phosphorylated (p)-AKT, p-p38, p-JNK, p-STAT1, p-STAT3, p-STAT5, p-ATF2, p-cdc2, p-p120, p-PKARIIb and p-src in joint infiltrating CD3+ T cells (Figure 1). Notably, phosphorylation of src is consistent with T cell activation .
Cell lysates were prepared from ST lymphocytes isolated from the affected joints of 3 patients with late-stage RA, at the time of joint replacement, as described in Methods. Lysates were analyzed by a customized BD PowerBlot and data are shown as mean±SE. Values represent the average intensity of triplicate readings except for p-JNK, p-STAT5, p-cdc2 and p-src, which are averages of duplicate samples.
Phosphorylation-activation of PB cell subsets in ERA, RA and OA
Next, multiparameter phospho-FACS was employed to analyze the phosphorylation-activation status of specific signaling effectors in the PB of patients with ERA, established RA and OA, gating on CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+ and CD20+ cell populations. The 15 signaling effectors employed in this study were specifically chosen as they are critical signaling nodes activated by multiple pathways and are likely candidates as indicators of activation in multiple cell populations. Multiple phospho-epitopes were activated in the circulating CD4+ and CD8+ T cells and CD20+ B cells from ERA (Figure 2) and established RA patients (data not shown) compared with healthy individuals. Notably, p-AKT, p-CBL, p-JNK, p-PLC-γ, p-STAT1, p-STAT3, p-STAT6 and p-ZAP70 mean fluorescent intensity (MFI) levels were significantly elevated in ERA patient PB subsets in all three cellular compartments. The MFI values were not significantly different between the ERA and established RA patient PB subsets (Figure S1) for any of the 15 phospho-epitopes examined. Because this was an exploratory study investigating the general utility of phospho-flow in diagnosis and treatment, no correction for multiple comparisons was made in Figure 2, Figure S1, or other similar analyses (Please refer to the section on Statistical analysis). If we had corrected using the Bonferroni correction for 45 comparisons (as shown in Figures 2 and 3), a p-value of less than 0.0011 would be considered statistically significant. Rather than discourage the future study of potentially valuable phospho-epitopes by applying such a correction, we instead note that we have not adjusted for family-wise error.
PBMCs from patients with ERA (n = 10, closed circles) and healthy individuals (n = 10, open circles) were analyzed by multiparameter phospho-FACS, gating on CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+ and CD20+ cell populations, as indicated. Scatterplots of the MFI for15 phospho-specific epitopes are shown. Significant differences in MFI values were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
PBMCs from patients with ERA (n = 10, closed circles) and OA (n = 9, open circles) were analyzed by multiparameter phospho-FACS, gating on CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+ and CD20+ cell populations, as indicated. Scatterplots of the MFI for 15 phospho-specific epitopes are shown. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
Next we examined whether phosphorylation of specific signaling effectors was disease specific, by comparing the phosphorylation profiles of PBMC from ERA and OA patients. The MFI levels for p-AKT, p-CBL and p-JNK were statistically higher (p<0.05) in ERA patient PBMCs compared with OA patient PBMCs, in the CD4+, CD8+ and CD20+ compartments (Figure 3). Additionally, the extent of phosphorylation-activation, as measured by the number of phosphorylated signaling effectors for which the MFI values were significantly different between ERA and OA samples, was greatest in the CD4+ T cell population (Figure 3). For each of the phospho-epitopes we next set an arbitrary threshold MFI level that was 10% higher than the maximum MFI level recorded amongst the healthy individuals (Table 1). Our subsequent analysis, based on this threshold, distinguished ERA patients with activated phospho-epitopes in all three cell compartments (CD4+, CD8+ and CD20+) (Table 1). In contrast, OA patients had fewer phospho-epitopes activated, predominantly in the CD8+ T cell compartment (Table 1). Further analysis directly comparing the ERA and OA patient groups, again using a threshold of 10% greater than the highest OA patient MFI value, provided evidence for a distinguishing activation profile in the CD4+ T cells and CD20+ B cells in patients with ERA (Table 2). The data in Figure 4A reveal a significant difference (p<0.001) in the ratio of the CD8 range/CD4 range for p-AKT, p-CBL, p-H3, p-PLCγ and p-ZAP70 between RA and OA patients.
The data from Figure 3 are plotted to (A) compare the CD8 MFI range/CD4 MFI range for each of p-AKT, p-CBL, p-H3, p-PLCγ and p-ZAP70 and (B) to compare the p-AKT/p-p38 and p-JNK/p-p38 ratios, between ERA (n = 10) and OA (n = 9) patients, in the indicated cell populations. Significant differences were determined by ANOVA followed by Tukey's multiple comparison (p<0.05).
Scrutiny of ratios of MFI values between pairs of different phosphorylated signaling effectors identified that p-AKT and p-p38 ratios as well as p-JNK and p-p38 ratios distinguished between ERA and OA patients (Figure 4 B, C). Since p-p38 MFI values remained fairly constant across the control, OA and ERA patient specimens, we postulated that p-p38 serves as an internal control to normalize individual samples. Significant differences in the p-AKT/p-p38 ratios were observed in ERA compared with OA in the CD4+, CD8+ and CD20+ cell populations (Figure 4B, p<0.05), whereas the p-JNK/p-p38 ratios were significantly different in the CD4+ and CD8+ populations only (Figure 4C, p<0.05). There were no significant differences in these phospho-pair ratios between the OA and healthy individual cohorts, for any of the three cell types. As anticipated, examination of these phospho-pair ratios in RA patients with established disease, in their PB CD4, CD8 and CD20 cells likewise distinguished RA patients from healthy individuals and OA patients (data not shown). The diagnostic potential of this phospho-epitope ratio was assessed by calculating the percentage of patients with a p-AKT/p-p38 ratio or a p-JNK/p-p38 ratio greater than 1.5. A p-AKT/p-p38 ratio >1.5 was observed in 90% (9/10) of ERA patients and 80% (4/5) of RA patients with established disease, in the CD4, CD8 and CD20 PB cell populations. Notably, this threshold of >1.5 was only exceeded in one of the 10 (10%) healthy individuals in their CD20 cells. For the OA cohort, this ratio was exceeded in one (11%) of the CD4 samples and 2 (22%) of the CD8 and CD20 samples. A p-JNK/p-p38 ratio >1.5 was observed in PB CD4, CD8 and CD20 cells in 70% (7/10), 90% (9/10) and 50% (5/10) of ERA patients, respectively. p-JNK/p-p38 ratio >1.5 was observed in 80% (4/5), 60% (3/5) and 80% (4/5) of RA patients with established disease in their PB CD4, CD8 and CD20 cells, respectively. p-JNK/p-p38 ratio >1.5 was observed in 11% (1/9), 22% (2/9) and 22% (2/9) of OA patients in their PB CD4, CD8 and CD20 cells, respectively. None of the healthy individuals had p-JNK/p-p38 ratios >1.5.
p-H3 and p-AKT levels correlate with physician global assessment and DAS
In the next series of analyses, with specimens acquired from a distinct cohort of patients, we examined whether there existed a correlation between phosphorylation status in defined cell populations and disease activity. Clinical parameters measuring disease status (DAS28, physician global assessment (MDGA), CRP and ESR levels) were compared to phospho-activation levels. Correlations were observed between phospho-histone (H3) and p-AKT levels in the CD4+, CD8+ and CD20+ populations in the PB of ERA patients and their MDGA scores (Figure 5). Moreover, the extent of phosphorylation of H3 and AKT in the CD4+,CD8+ and CD20+ cells of the PB of ERA patients also directly correlated with DAS28 (Figure 5).
Effects of drug therapy on PBMC phospho-activation profile
We next examined the effects of specific disease modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (DMARDs) on the phosphorylation status of 12 phospho-epitopes in ERA patients. As a first screen, patients were grouped according to whether they were receiving a particular DMARD or not, regardless of whether a patient was on monotherapy or not. All patients in the drug study cohort were on some form of drug therapy (refer to Table S1). The effects of the non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID), methotrexate (MTX), sulphasalazine (SSZ), plaquenil (HCQ) and leflunomide (LEF), systemic steroids (predominantly prednisone), TNF inhibitors (Enbrel or Humira), and intra-articular (IA) steroids, were assessed. Notably, TNF inhibitors, LEF, systemic steroids and MTX therapy resulted in decreased activation of multiple phospho-eptiopes (Figure 6). Significant differences in MFI values were observed in the PBMC of patients on LEF (Figure 6, Figure S2) or systemic corticosteroids (Figure 6, Figure S3), compared to those patients not taking these specific DMARDs. Notably, 3 of the 5 patients on LEF were also receiving Enbrel. Interestingly, the phospho-activation signatures for each drug were not identical and patients on LEF exhibited reductions in p-STAT6 in their CD20+ B cells and reduced p-PLC-γ in their CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, while patients on systemic steroids showed decreases in p-BTK and p-JNK in their CD4+ cells, p-ERK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 in their CD20+ cells, and p-STAT4 in their CD4+ and CD8+ cells. Patients on TNF inhibitors (Enbrel or Humira) exhibited significant reductions in levels of p-AKT, p-BTK, p-ERK, p-JNK, p-p38, p-PLCγ, pSTAT1, p-STAT3, p-STAT5 and p-STAT6 in their CD4+ cells (Figure 6, Figure S4). Reductions in MFI values for p-AKT, p-p38, p-JNK, p-PLCγ, and p-STAT5 were also observed in their CD8+ cells and reductions in p-p38 were observed in their CD20+ cells.
Hierarchical clustering heatmap showing the level of statistical significance, as a p value, for the difference in MFI values for each indicated phospho-signaling effector comparing patients on therapy versus patients not on therapy. Statistical differences were calculated by Student's t test.
There were no significant differences in the MFI values between patients prescribed NSAIDS (Figure 6, Figure S5), HCQ (Figure 6, Figure S6) or sulphasalazine (SSZ) (Figure 6, Figure S7) for any of the 12 phospho-epitopes in any of the cell types. Patients receiving IA steroids showed significant reductions in p-H3 in their CD4+, CD8+ and CD20+ cells (Figure 6, Figure S8). MTX therapy reduced p-STAT1 MFI values in CD20+ cells (p = 0.045) (data not shown). Given the effects of LEF and systemic steroid therapy on the activation profile of PBMCs, we re-examined the effects of MTX therapy on phosphorylation status, removing patients on LEF or systemic steroid therapy from these analyses. Our analysis revealed significant reductions in the phosphorylation of AKT and H3 in the PBMC CD4+ cells (Figure S9) but no change in the reduction in p-STAT1 observed in the CD20+ cells. However, reductions in CD20+ cell p-AKT and p-H3 and CD8 cell p-AKT were revealed.
In a final analysis of these data, we investigated the utility of phosphoflow measurements as correlates of patient responsiveness to therapy. The majority of patients in this study were responding to therapy, as shown by their decreases in DAS (−1.78±0.42, n = 23). Changes in DAS were assessed by subtracting the DAS at the time of sampling with the baseline DAS at their first clinic visit. Of note, some patients were only sampled at their baseline visit and, as such, a delta DAS could not be calculated. Given that anti-TNF therapy affected phospho-signaling effectors to the greatest extent and 3 of the 4 patients on anti-TNF therapy started therapy after their first clinic visit, we selected the data from this cohort for analysis. Patients receiving anti-TNF therapy had an overall decrease in the total tender joint count (TJC), swollen joint count (SJC) and DAS28 (Figure 7A). We observe a high degree of correlation between the DAS and MFI values for p-AKT (Figure 7C) and p-H3 (Figure 7B). These preliminary data suggest that phosphoflow analysis of a limited number of signaling effectors may be reflective of drug responsiveness, at least in the context of anti-TNF therapy, the subject of our ongoing investigations.
(A) Changes in tender joint count (TJC), swollen joint count (SJC) and DAS28 between the time of sampling and baseline scores are recorded for TNF inhibitors (TNFi) (n = 5, Enbrel or Humira), LEF (n = 6) and systemic steroids (n = 5). Values are the mean±SE. MFI values for (B) p-H3 (n = 4) and (C) p-AKT (n = 4) are plotted relative to changes in DAS in the PB CD4, CD8 and CD20 cell compartments, as indicated.
RA is a complex, polygenic autoimmune disease that progresses over decades and involves many different cell types, including both resident and recruited cells. Early diagnosis of RA is difficult since there is no single test, but a combination of predictive indices, incorporating clinical parameters, radiographic evidence of joint destruction and the presence of anti-CCP and RF antibodies. The identification of specific activating events that play a role in the pathogenesis and/or progression in RA would be invaluable for both diagnosis and monitoring responsiveness to therapy. Herein, we describe the use of phospho-flow analysis to quantitatively analyze multiple phospho-epitopes as indicators of PB lymphocyte activation.
Lymphocyte infiltration in the RA synovium is observed as either a diffuse inflammatory infiltrate or as clusters of lymphoid follicular aggregates. In some patients, these aggregates exhibit germinal centre-like activity. T cells in affected RA joints show signs of prior activation, are hyporesponsive to antigenic stimulation  yet resistant to apoptosis , . While we did not compare the level of activation of joint T cells to other inflammatory conditions, our data support previous studies that MAPKs are activated in OA and RA joint tissue . TNF and IL-1, cytokines implicated in disease development, induce activation of these signaling effectors . In addition to p38 and JNK MAPK activation, we observed AKT and STAT activation in CD3+ lymphocytes. AKT promotes cell survival, and MAPKs and STATs are associated with induction of cytokine gene expression, from which we infer that these RA PB lymphocytes may actively participate in the inflammatory response. Whether lymphocyte activation also occurs in the circulation, prior to arrival in the joint, is the subject of these investigations. PB sampling is less invasive than sampling affected joints, and here we show a similar activation profile in ERA PBMCs, from which we infer that lymphocyte activation may precede joint infiltration. While additional validation studies are still required, PB lymphocyte activation may be a reliable indicator/predictor of joint inflammation.
Notably, there were no significant differences in phosphorylation profiles between ERA and established RA PBMCs. The initial stages of autoimmunity involve a breakdown of B and T cell tolerance and in RA this is manifested by measurable levels of serum anti-CCP and/or anti RF antibodies, which are detected years before the onset of articular symptoms . For individuals to have an ERA diagnosis they must satisfy ACR criteria, by which time the mechanisms driving RA are already well established. Since the early RA joint cytokine profile is unique (Th2 skewed) , retrospective analysis of inflammatory arthropathies at earlier stages may provide insights into the dynamic changes in PBMCs at the onset of autoimmune disease.
Given the critical roles of CD4+ T cells and CD20+ B cells in autoimmune disease pathology, monitoring dynamic changes in these cell populations may provide insights into disease progression. The 15 signaling effectors employed in this study were specifically chosen as they are critical signaling nodes activated by multiple pathways and as such are likely candidates as indicators of activation in multiple cell populations. Specific signaling effectors (AKT, CBL, JNK, PLC-γ and STAT1) were significantly activated in the PBMC of ERA patients compared with healthy individuals. The MFI values of a subset of these effectors, p-AKT, p-CBL and p-JNK, were consistently higher in all three cell populations in ERA patient PBMCs compared to OA patient PBMCs. Notably, PB CD4+ cells exhibited the largest number of significantly elevated phospho-signaling effectors (Figure 3), underscoring the importance of these cells in autoimmunity. Additionally, a higher percentage of ERA patients showed phospho-activation in their PB CD20+ cells, consistent with B cell hyperreactivity distinguishing RA from OA , . However, given the variability across the OA and ERA samples, no single phospho-epitope emerged as a unique diagnostic. Further studies examining the activation status of specific cellular subsets such as CD4+Th17 cells, which are elevated in the circulation of RA patients , , may be indicative of disease stage and activity. While single phospho-epitopes were not diagnostic, p-AKT:p-p38 ratios and p-JNK:p-p38 ratios >1.5 distinguished between ERA and OA patients (Figure 4B, C). These ratios may be easily adapted into part of a clinical screening regime for the diagnosis of RA.
Our analysis included an examination of correlates between measures of disease activity and severity, or disease status, and levels of phosphorylation of signaling effectors in the different PB cell compartments. We identified correlations between the extent of phosphoryation of AKT and H3 in the CD4+, CD8+ and CD20+ PB cells of ERA patients and their MDGA score and DAS. AKT is a signaling effector associated with cell survival, cell proliferation and cytokine production. Both TNF and IL-17 induce signaling cascades that involve AKT activation. H3 phosphorylation is associated with gene transcription and cell division  and the correlation with MDGA score or DAS may point toward expansion of these cell populations.
Currently, factors that are predictive of ‘severity to be’ or responsiveness to particular therapeutic regimens remain, in the main, indicators of likelihood/probability, based on aggregate not individualized data. Many factors have been reported to predict disease progression, responsiveness to therapy or remission, including antibody levels to citrullinated peptides ,  and citrullinated fibrinogen , low baseline serum soluble IL-2 receptor levels , early response to DMARD treatment , , the active joint count  or urinary levels of C-terminal crosslinking telopeptide of type 1 (CTX-I) and type II (CTX-II) . Generally, RA patients with longer disease duration do not respond as well to treatment compared with patients with early disease, and female sex, prior DMARD use and disease activity . In this context, molecular markers that are accurately predictive in an individual of high risk of rapid progression as well as responsiveness to a particular drug therapy are still required.
Early aggressive treatment of RA is associated with beneficial patient outcomes and there is an accumulating consensus that there is a relatively narrow window of opportunity within which aggressive treatment of RA can produce permanent remission . Early MTX treatment slows disease progression and is the first drug of choice for RA , . However, not all patients are responsive to MTX and approximately 50% of patients are refractory to anti-TNF therapy . Current clinical practice involves monitoring therapeutic improvements over several months, whereas phospho-flow analysis represents a rapid alternative. Specifically, medication-induced changes in signature signaling phospho-epitope profiles are rapid. Although in our study cohort the majority of patients were on multiple medications (Table S1), data analysis distinguished the contributions of LEF, corticosteroids, MTX and anti-TNF therapy as signature reductions in phosphorylation profiles.
LEF, MTX and corticosteroids are broad immunosuppressive agents that reduce pain and swelling of affected joints, reduce cytokine production and limit radiological damage , , , , , . In addition, LEF blocks T and B cell proliferation and activation , , , inhibits TNF dependent NF-κB signaling, reduces matrix metalloproteinase expression and inflammatory cytokine production , , , , . Consistent with published data , we provide evidence that LEF reduces p-STAT6 levels in CD20+ B cells, which may direct reductions in antibody production. Interestingly, prednisone reduced p-STAT3 levels, and recent data suggest that steroid treatment causes reductions in IL-17 production . Cognizant that STAT3 activation is critical for the development of IL-17 producing T cells , , it is intriguing to speculate that LEF and prednisone therapy may suppress inflammation via inhibiting the phosphorylation-activation of STAT3. Additionally, LEF inhibits Th17 generation through inhibition of p-STAT6  and we also observed reductions in p-STAT6 levels in patients on these medications. Notably, p-STAT4 levels were dramatically reduced in both the CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in patients on steroid therapy. Certainly, STAT4 has been associated with an increased risk of RA and mice lacking STAT4 are resistant to experimental arthritis . STAT4 expression in joints of patients with ERA has been reported  and here we show that prednisone may function in part by blocking STAT4 activation.
Despite its widespread use as a therapy for RA, the mechanisms of action of MTX are complex and not entirely characterized . MTX inhibits dihydrofolate reductase and limits cell proliferation . Therefore, we had anticipated that patients on MTX therapy would exhibit reductions in multiple phospho-signaling effectors, as was the case. Significant reductions in p-AKT and p-H3 MFI values correlated with disease scores. MTX reduces JAK/STAT activation within the joints . Notably, MTX treatment did reduce the levels of phosphorylation of AKT and STAT1.
Results from more than a decade of clinical trials has provided compelling evidence that TNF inhibitors reduce disease activity and delay joint damage . TNF activates multiple kinases (p38, ERK, JNK) and will induce the expression of other pro-inflammatory cytokines that, in turn, invoke pro-inflammatory signaling events associated with kinase activation. Therefore, the substantive therapeutic effects of anti-TNF therapy are a consequence of both direct inhibition of TNF and a blockade of TNF-inducible other pro-inflammatory cytokines. TNF blockade leads to more profound anti-inflammatory outcomes than conventional DMARDs  and herein we show that anti-TNF therapy reduced phosphorylation levels of signaling effectors to a greater extent than other DMARDs. Notably the anti-TNF therapy was predominantly initiated during the course of this study, therefore, it is possible that the potency of this drug and sampling close to initiation of therapy gave the most significant effects.
Viewed altogether, these data demonstrate the utility of multi-parameter phospho-flow analysis for monitoring the activation status of discrete PB cell populations in ERA. Quantitative examination of the extent of phosphorylation of critical signaling effectors has the potential to be diagnostic for RA. Moreover, we provide preliminary evidence that reductions in the extent of phosphorylation of these biomarkers may predict responsiveness to drug therapy. Our results suggest that longitudinal sampling of patients undergoing therapy may result in phospho-signatures that not only correlate with drug responsiveness but also may predict patient responsiveness to a specific class of drug. Our ongoing studies are directed to extending these observations in a larger prospective cohort of ERA patients.
Materials and Methods
Sample collection involved confirmation of the diagnosis of RA and OA using clinical, serologic and radiological data. Informed written consent was obtained from all study participants and institutional approval was granted by the Mount Sinai Hospital, St. Michael's Hospital and Sunnybrook and Women's College Health Sciences Centre ethics committees (Toronto, ON). Early RA was defined as patients within the first year following the onset of symptoms with a minimum of 3 swollen joints. Both ERA and established RA patients were diagnosed according to the American College of Rheumatology 1987 revised criteria . The study included a total of 38 ERA patients, 10 late RA patients, 19 OA patients and 10 control, healthy individuals (non-RA, non-OA). The average age of patients in this study was 44.1 years for ERA (range 17–73) and 57.0 years for late RA (range 36–72) with a median disease duration of <1 year for early RA and 10 years for late RA. Clinical parameters were recorded at the time of sample collection and are summarized in Table 3. Multiple samples were collected from some ERA patients and almost all patients in this study were receiving medication (Table S1).
RA synovial tissue (ST) samples (n = 3) were collected from patients with erosive, end-stage RA at the time of joint replacement surgery. All ST specimens were immediately transferred to research personnel for processing.
Human PB was collected into heparinized vacutainer tubes and PBMCs were isolated by Ficoll gradient centrifugation at 800 g for 20 minutes. The PBMC layer was washed, counted, resuspended in 90% human serum (Irvine Scientific, Irvine, CA) and 10% DMSO (Sigma, St Louis, MO) and frozen in liquid nitrogen to maintain cellular activation levels. Blood samples from control, healthy adults (University Health Network, Toronto) were handled and processed in parallel.
Cell surface and intracellular phospho-specific flow cytometry
For flow cytometric analysis, human PBMCs were thawed at 37°C, washed twice and incubated for 1 hour. PBMC were then fixed in 2% paraformaldehyde at 37°C for 10 minutes. Cells were counted, pelleted and resuspended at 1×107/ml in FACS buffer. Cells were washed and permeabilized with 90% ice-cold methanol for 15 min: PBMCs were stained with directly conjugated antibodies against CD4 (RPA-T4), CD8 (RPA-T8), CD20 (L27) and phospho-epitopes (Becton-Dickinson; San Jose, CA, unless otherwise specified) as previously described (Table S2). Intracellular stains consisted of phospho-specific proteins for p-AKT (Biosource, pS473), p-BTK (pY551), p-PLC-γ (pY783), p-cbl (pY700), p-H3 (Cell Signaling Technology, pSer10), p-JNK (Biosource, pTpY183/185), p-p38 (pT180/Y202), p-p44/42 (pT201/Y202), p-lck (pY505), p-ZAP70 (pY319), p-STAT1 (pY701), p-STAT3 (pY705), p-STAT4 (pY693), p-STAT5 (pS727) and p-STAT6 (pY641). Cells were washed twice and 100,000-500,000 cells were acquired on an LSRII FACS machine operated at Stanford University (12 color, BD Biosciences) acquired with DiVa software (Beckton Dickinson) and analyzed with Flojo (Treestar). Data were acquired on an initial set of samples (controls n = 10, ERA n = 10, RA n = 5, OA n = 9) and a second and larger cohort of samples (ERA n = 40, RA n = 10, OA n = 10) was used to assess correlations and drug related effects.
Synovial lymphocyte isolation and BD PowerBlot analysis
CD3+ T cells from ST from affected RA joints were isolated by enzymatic digestion with collagenase I, II, IV (3 mg/g tissue) and DNase (2 mg/g tissue) for 0.5–2 hours at 37°C, depending on the sample size. Single cell suspensions were collected after straining the digest through a 70 µm filter. T cells were purified by negative selection, using 0.1″ StemSep magnetic columns and antibodies against CD32, CD19, CD56, CD66b, glycophorin A, 5E11 and dextran. Contaminating macrophages were removed by 2 hour incubation on tissue culture plastic. CD3+ T cell lysates were collected in lysis buffer (10 mM Tris,pH 7.4, 1 mM sodium orthovanadate, 1% SDS), sonicated and frozen at −80°C. Protein samples (200 µg) were resolved by electrophoresis on a 4–15% gradient SDS-polyacrylamide gel and transferred onto an Immobilon-P membrane (Millipore) and analyzed as previously described . Samples were analyzed by a customized phosphoprotein BD array using the average of duplicate (n = 2) or triplicate (n = 1) readings. 57 proteins were assessed in these arrays.
Results are expressed as the mean±SE, unless otherwise indicated. Populations were compared with Student's t-test with no assumption of equal variance, unless otherwise noted. P-values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant. Correlation coefficients and associated p-values were computed using linear regression. ANOVA was performed on samples with multiple groups followed by Tukey's Multiple Comparison test. Statistical tests were performed using either the R environment for statistical computing (www.r-project.org) or Prism (GraphPad Software, San Diego CA).
PBMC activation patterns are similar in RA and ERA. PBMCs from patients with RA (n = 5, open circles) and ERA (n = 10, closed circles) were analyzed by multiparameter phospho-FACS, gating on CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+ and CD20+ cell populations, as indicated. Scatterplots of the MFI for 15 phospho-specific epitopes are shown. No significant differences in MFI values were identified, calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(2.37 MB TIF)
LEF affects the phosphorylation status of ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on LEF (n = 6 except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 4; open circles) versus those not receiving this DMARD (n = 31 except for p-JNK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 where n = 30 and p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 19; closed circles). Data are shown for each of the indicated cell populations. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(1.02 MB TIF)
Systemic steroids affect the phosphorylation status of ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on systemic steroids (n = 9 except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 6; open circles) versus those not (n = 28 except for p-JNK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 where n = 27 and p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 17; closed circles). Data are shown for each of the indicated cell populations. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(1.12 MB TIF)
TNF inhibitors lower the activation status of ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on TNF inhibitors (n = 5 except for p-AKT, p-BTK, p-JNK, p-p38, p-H3 and p-STAT3 where n = 4; Enbrel or Humira, open circles) versus those not receiving anti-TNF therapy (n = 32, except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 19; closed circles). Data are shown for each of the indicated CD4+ cell populations. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(1.18 MB TIF)
NSAID therapy does not affect phosphorylation- activation in ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on NSAIDs (n = 20 except for p-JNK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 where n = 18 and p-AKT, p-BTK and pH3 where n = 12; open circles) versus those not (n = 17 except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 11; closed circles). Data are shown for each of the indicated cell populations. NSAIDS included ibuprophen, naprosyn, Arthrotec, Diclonefac, Bextra, Celebrex, Mobicox, Meloxicam and Vioxx. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(2.43 MB TIF)
The effects of Plaquenil therapy on phospho-signaling in ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on plaquenil (n = 22 except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 14; open circles) versus those not (n = 15 except for p-JNK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 where n = 14 and p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 9; closed circles). Data are shown for each of the indicated cell populations. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(2.41 MB TIF)
The effects of Sulphasalazine therapy on phospho-signaling in ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on sulfasalazine (n = 9 except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 4; open circles) versus those not (n = 28 except for p-JNK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 where n = 27 and p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 19; closed circles). Data are shown for each of the indicated cell populations. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(2.32 MB TIF)
The effects of IA steroid therapy on phospho-signaling in ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on intra-articular (IA) steroids (n = 17 except for p-JNK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 where n = 16 and p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 11; open circles) versus those not (n = 20 except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 12; closed circles). IA steroids included DepoMD, Kenalg1 and dexamethasone. Data are shown for each of the indicated cell populations. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(2.33 MB TIF)
Methotrexate therapy decreases phospho-signaling in ERA PBMCs. PB MFI values for each of the indicated phospho-epitopes are plotted to compare ERA patients on MTX (no LEF or systemic steroids) (n = 15 except for p-JNK, p-p38 and p-STAT3 where n = 13 and p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 8; open circles) versus those not (n = 12 except for p-AKT, p-BTK and p-H3 where n = 9; closed circles). Data are shown for each of the indicated cell populations. Significant differences were calculated by Student's t test (p<0.05).
(2.42 MB TIF)
The authors gratefully acknowledge Susan Dubbin for co-ordinating patient sample collection and Dennis Mitchell, Mileidys Alvarez, Thomas Burian and Ramtin Rahbar for technical assistance.
Conceived and designed the experiments: ODP ENF. Performed the experiments: ODP. Analyzed the data: CLG JCS ODP ENF. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: JCS KAS ECK VB ODP. Wrote the paper: CLG ENF. Manuscript revision: JCS KAS ECK VB ODP. Acquired data: KAS ECK VB. Interpreted data: KAS ECK VB.
- 1. Gabriel SE (2001) The epidemiology of rheumatoid arthritis. Rheum Dis Clin North Am 27: 269–281.SE Gabriel2001The epidemiology of rheumatoid arthritis.Rheum Dis Clin North Am27269281
- 2. Lee DM, Weinblatt ME (2001) Rheumatoid arthritis. Lancet 358: 903–911.DM LeeME Weinblatt2001Rheumatoid arthritis.Lancet358903911
- 3. Firestein GS (2005) Immunologic mechanisms in the pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis. J Clin Rheumatol 11: S39–44.GS Firestein2005Immunologic mechanisms in the pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis.J Clin Rheumatol11S3944
- 4. (1998) Randomised double-blind placebo-controlled study of interferon beta-1a in relapsing/remitting multiple sclerosis. PRISMS (Prevention of Relapses and Disability by Interferon beta-1a Subcutaneously in Multiple Sclerosis) Study Group. Lancet 352: 1498–1504.1998Randomised double-blind placebo-controlled study of interferon beta-1a in relapsing/remitting multiple sclerosis. PRISMS (Prevention of Relapses and Disability by Interferon beta-1a Subcutaneously in Multiple Sclerosis) Study Group.Lancet35214981504
- 5. Palmer DG (1995) The anatomy of the rheumatoid lesion. Br Med Bull 51: 286–295.DG Palmer1995The anatomy of the rheumatoid lesion.Br Med Bull51286295
- 6. Wolfe F, Mitchell DM, Sibley JT, Fries JF, Bloch DA, et al. (1994) The mortality of rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheum 37: 481–494.F. WolfeDM MitchellJT SibleyJF FriesDA Bloch1994The mortality of rheumatoid arthritis.Arthritis Rheum37481494
- 7. Bowes J, Barton A (2008) Recent advances in the genetics of RA susceptibility. Rheumatology (Oxford) 47: 399–402.J. BowesA. Barton2008Recent advances in the genetics of RA susceptibility.Rheumatology (Oxford)47399402
- 8. Banerjee S, Webber C, Poole AR (1992) The induction of arthritis in mice by the cartilage proteoglycan aggrecan: roles of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. Cell Immunol 144: 347–357.S. BanerjeeC. WebberAR Poole1992The induction of arthritis in mice by the cartilage proteoglycan aggrecan: roles of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells.Cell Immunol144347357
- 9. Buch MH, Vital EM, Emery P (2008) Abatacept in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Res Ther 10: Suppl 1S5.MH BuchEM VitalP. Emery2008Abatacept in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis.Arthritis Res Ther10Suppl 1S5
- 10. Lubberts E (2003) The role of IL-17 and family members in the pathogenesis of arthritis. Curr Opin Investig Drugs 4: 572–577.E. Lubberts2003The role of IL-17 and family members in the pathogenesis of arthritis.Curr Opin Investig Drugs4572577
- 11. Mewar D, Wilson AG (2006) Autoantibodies in rheumatoid arthritis: a review. Biomed Pharmacother 60: 648–655.D. MewarAG Wilson2006Autoantibodies in rheumatoid arthritis: a review.Biomed Pharmacother60648655
- 12. van Venrooij WJ, van Beers JJ, Pruijn GJ (2008) Anti-CCP Antibody, a Marker for the Early Detection of Rheumatoid Arthritis. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1143: 268–285.WJ van VenrooijJJ van BeersGJ Pruijn2008Anti-CCP Antibody, a Marker for the Early Detection of Rheumatoid Arthritis.Ann N Y Acad Sci1143268285
- 13. Edwards JC, Szczepanski L, Szechinski J, Filipowicz-Sosnowska A, Emery P, et al. (2004) Efficacy of B-cell-targeted therapy with rituximab in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. N Engl J Med 350: 2572–2581.JC EdwardsL. SzczepanskiJ. SzechinskiA. Filipowicz-SosnowskaP. Emery2004Efficacy of B-cell-targeted therapy with rituximab in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.N Engl J Med35025722581
- 14. Takemura S, Klimiuk PA, Braun A, Goronzy JJ, Weyand CM (2001) T cell activation in rheumatoid synovium is B cell dependent. J Immunol 167: 4710–4718.S. TakemuraPA KlimiukA. BraunJJ GoronzyCM Weyand2001T cell activation in rheumatoid synovium is B cell dependent.J Immunol16747104718
- 15. Arnett FC, Edworthy SM, Bloch DA, McShane DJ, Fries JF, et al. (1988) The American Rheumatism Association 1987 revised criteria for the classification of rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheum 31: 315–324.FC ArnettSM EdworthyDA BlochDJ McShaneJF Fries1988The American Rheumatism Association 1987 revised criteria for the classification of rheumatoid arthritis.Arthritis Rheum31315324
- 16. Banal F, Dougados M, Combescure C, Gossec L (2008) Sensitivity and specificity of the American College of Rheumatology 1987 criteria for the diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis according to disease duration: a systematic literature review and meta-analysis. Ann Rheum Dis. F. BanalM. DougadosC. CombescureL. Gossec2008Sensitivity and specificity of the American College of Rheumatology 1987 criteria for the diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis according to disease duration: a systematic literature review and meta-analysis.Ann Rheum Dis
- 17. Kuriya B, Cheng CK, Chen HM, Bykerk VP (2008) Validation of a prediction rule for development of rheumatoid arthritis in patients with early undifferentiated arthritis. Ann Rheum Dis. B. KuriyaCK ChengHM ChenVP Bykerk2008Validation of a prediction rule for development of rheumatoid arthritis in patients with early undifferentiated arthritis.Ann Rheum Dis
- 18. van der Helm-van Mil AH, Detert J, le Cessie S, Filer A, Bastian H, et al. (2008) Validation of a prediction rule for disease outcome in patients with recent-onset undifferentiated arthritis: moving toward individualized treatment decision-making. Arthritis Rheum 58: 2241–2247.AH van der Helm-van MilJ. DetertS. le CessieA. FilerH. Bastian2008Validation of a prediction rule for disease outcome in patients with recent-onset undifferentiated arthritis: moving toward individualized treatment decision-making.Arthritis Rheum5822412247
- 19. Goekoop-Ruiterman YP, de Vries-Bouwstra JK, Allaart CF, van Zeben D, Kerstens PJ, et al. (2005) Clinical and radiographic outcomes of four different treatment strategies in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis (the BeSt study): a randomized, controlled trial. Arthritis Rheum 52: 3381–3390.YP Goekoop-RuitermanJK de Vries-BouwstraCF AllaartD. van ZebenPJ Kerstens2005Clinical and radiographic outcomes of four different treatment strategies in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis (the BeSt study): a randomized, controlled trial.Arthritis Rheum5233813390
- 20. Krutzik PO, Irish JM, Nolan GP, Perez OD (2004) Analysis of protein phosphorylation and cellular signaling events by flow cytometry: techniques and clinical applications. Clin Immunol 110: 206–221.PO KrutzikJM IrishGP NolanOD Perez2004Analysis of protein phosphorylation and cellular signaling events by flow cytometry: techniques and clinical applications.Clin Immunol110206221
- 21. Krutzik PO, Nolan GP (2003) Intracellular phospho-protein staining techniques for flow cytometry: monitoring single cell signaling events. Cytometry A 55: 61–70.PO KrutzikGP Nolan2003Intracellular phospho-protein staining techniques for flow cytometry: monitoring single cell signaling events.Cytometry A556170
- 22. Perez OD, Krutzik PO, Nolan GP (2004) Flow cytometric analysis of kinase signaling cascades. Methods Mol Biol 263: 67–94.OD PerezPO KrutzikGP Nolan2004Flow cytometric analysis of kinase signaling cascades.Methods Mol Biol2636794
- 23. Krutzik PO, Nolan GP (2006) Fluorescent cell barcoding in flow cytometry allows high-throughput drug screening and signaling profiling. Nat Methods 3: 361–368.PO KrutzikGP Nolan2006Fluorescent cell barcoding in flow cytometry allows high-throughput drug screening and signaling profiling.Nat Methods3361368
- 24. Irish JM, Anensen N, Hovland R, Skavland J, Borresen-Dale AL, et al. (2007) Flt3 Y591 duplication and Bcl-2 overexpression are detected in acute myeloid leukemia cells with high levels of phosphorylated wild-type p53. Blood 109: 2589–2596.JM IrishN. AnensenR. HovlandJ. SkavlandAL Borresen-Dale2007Flt3 Y591 duplication and Bcl-2 overexpression are detected in acute myeloid leukemia cells with high levels of phosphorylated wild-type p53.Blood10925892596
- 25. Irish JM, Hovland R, Krutzik PO, Perez OD, Bruserud O, et al. (2004) Single cell profiling of potentiated phospho-protein networks in cancer cells. Cell 118: 217–228.JM IrishR. HovlandPO KrutzikOD PerezO. Bruserud2004Single cell profiling of potentiated phospho-protein networks in cancer cells.Cell118217228
- 26. Krutzik PO, Crane JM, Clutter MR, Nolan GP (2008) High-content single-cell drug screening with phosphospecific flow cytometry. Nat Chem Biol 4: 132–142.PO KrutzikJM CraneMR ClutterGP Nolan2008High-content single-cell drug screening with phosphospecific flow cytometry.Nat Chem Biol4132142
- 27. Mustelin T, Alonso A, Bottini N, Huynh H, Rahmouni S, et al. (2004) Protein tyrosine phosphatases in T cell physiology. Mol Immunol 41: 687–700.T. MustelinA. AlonsoN. BottiniH. HuynhS. Rahmouni2004Protein tyrosine phosphatases in T cell physiology.Mol Immunol41687700
- 28. Cope AP, Londei M, Chu NR, Cohen SB, Elliott MJ, et al. (1994) Chronic exposure to tumor necrosis factor (TNF) in vitro impairs the activation of T cells through the T cell receptor/CD3 complex; reversal in vivo by anti-TNF antibodies in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. J Clin Invest 94: 749–760.AP CopeM. LondeiNR ChuSB CohenMJ Elliott1994Chronic exposure to tumor necrosis factor (TNF) in vitro impairs the activation of T cells through the T cell receptor/CD3 complex; reversal in vivo by anti-TNF antibodies in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.J Clin Invest94749760
- 29. Firestein GS, Yeo M, Zvaifler NJ (1995) Apoptosis in rheumatoid arthritis synovium. J Clin Invest 96: 1631–1638.GS FiresteinM. YeoNJ Zvaifler1995Apoptosis in rheumatoid arthritis synovium.J Clin Invest9616311638
- 30. Makrygiannakis D, Revu S, Neregard P, Af Klint E, Snir O, et al. (2008) Monocytes are essential for inhibition of synovial T cell glucocorticoid mediated apoptosis in rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Res Ther 10: R147.D. MakrygiannakisS. RevuP. NeregardE. Af KlintO. Snir2008Monocytes are essential for inhibition of synovial T cell glucocorticoid mediated apoptosis in rheumatoid arthritis.Arthritis Res Ther10R147
- 31. Schett G, Tohidast-Akrad M, Smolen JS, Schmid BJ, Steiner CW, et al. (2000) Activation, differential localization, and regulation of the stress-activated protein kinases, extracellular signal-regulated kinase, c-JUN N-terminal kinase, and p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase, in synovial tissue and cells in rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheum 43: 2501–2512.G. SchettM. Tohidast-AkradJS SmolenBJ SchmidCW Steiner2000Activation, differential localization, and regulation of the stress-activated protein kinases, extracellular signal-regulated kinase, c-JUN N-terminal kinase, and p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase, in synovial tissue and cells in rheumatoid arthritis.Arthritis Rheum4325012512
- 32. Santos LL, Dacumos A, Yamana J, Sharma L, Morand EF (2008) Reduced arthritis in MIF deficient mice is associated with reduced T cell activation: down-regulation of ERK MAP kinase phosphorylation. Clin Exp Immunol 152: 372–380.LL SantosA. DacumosJ. YamanaL. SharmaEF Morand2008Reduced arthritis in MIF deficient mice is associated with reduced T cell activation: down-regulation of ERK MAP kinase phosphorylation.Clin Exp Immunol152372380
- 33. Raza K, Falciani F, Curnow SJ, Ross EJ, Lee CY, et al. (2005) Early rheumatoid arthritis is characterized by a distinct and transient synovial fluid cytokine profile of T cell and stromal cell origin. Arthritis Res Ther 7: R784–795.K. RazaF. FalcianiSJ CurnowEJ RossCY Lee2005Early rheumatoid arthritis is characterized by a distinct and transient synovial fluid cytokine profile of T cell and stromal cell origin.Arthritis Res Ther7R784795
- 34. Singh R, Aggarwal A, Misra R (2007) Th1/Th17 cytokine profiles in patients with reactive arthritis/undifferentiated spondyloarthropathy. J Rheumatol 34: 2285–2290.R. SinghA. AggarwalR. Misra2007Th1/Th17 cytokine profiles in patients with reactive arthritis/undifferentiated spondyloarthropathy.J Rheumatol3422852290
- 35. Shen H, Goodall JC, Hill Gaston JS (2009) Frequency and phenotype of peripheral blood Th17 cells in ankylosing spondylitis and rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheum 60: 1647–1656.H. ShenJC GoodallJS Hill Gaston2009Frequency and phenotype of peripheral blood Th17 cells in ankylosing spondylitis and rheumatoid arthritis.Arthritis Rheum6016471656
- 36. Prigent C, Dimitrov S (2003) Phosphorylation of serine 10 in histone H3, what for? J Cell Sci 116: 3677–3685.C. PrigentS. Dimitrov2003Phosphorylation of serine 10 in histone H3, what for?J Cell Sci11636773685
- 37. Meyer O, Labarre C, Dougados M, Goupille P, Cantagrel A, et al. (2003) Anticitrullinated protein/peptide antibody assays in early rheumatoid arthritis for predicting five year radiographic damage. Ann Rheum Dis 62: 120–126.O. MeyerC. LabarreM. DougadosP. GoupilleA. Cantagrel2003Anticitrullinated protein/peptide antibody assays in early rheumatoid arthritis for predicting five year radiographic damage.Ann Rheum Dis62120126
- 38. Forslind K, Ahlmen M, Eberhardt K, Hafstrom I, Svensson B (2004) Prediction of radiological outcome in early rheumatoid arthritis in clinical practice: role of antibodies to citrullinated peptides (anti-CCP). Ann Rheum Dis 63: 1090–1095.K. ForslindM. AhlmenK. EberhardtI. HafstromB. Svensson2004Prediction of radiological outcome in early rheumatoid arthritis in clinical practice: role of antibodies to citrullinated peptides (anti-CCP).Ann Rheum Dis6310901095
- 39. Nielen MM, van der Horst AR, van Schaardenburg D, van der Horst-Bruinsma IE, van de Stadt RJ, et al. (2005) Antibodies to citrullinated human fibrinogen (ACF) have diagnostic and prognostic value in early arthritis. Ann Rheum Dis 64: 1199–1204.MM NielenAR van der HorstD. van SchaardenburgIE van der Horst-BruinsmaRJ van de Stadt2005Antibodies to citrullinated human fibrinogen (ACF) have diagnostic and prognostic value in early arthritis.Ann Rheum Dis6411991204
- 40. Kuuliala A, Leirisalo-Repo M, Mottonen T, Hannonen P, Nissila M, et al. (2005) Serum soluble interleukin-2 receptor predicts early remission in patients with recent-onset rheumatoid arthritis treated with a single disease-modifying antirheumatic drug. Clin Exp Rheumatol 23: 243–246.A. KuulialaM. Leirisalo-RepoT. MottonenP. HannonenM. Nissila2005Serum soluble interleukin-2 receptor predicts early remission in patients with recent-onset rheumatoid arthritis treated with a single disease-modifying antirheumatic drug.Clin Exp Rheumatol23243246
- 41. Verstappen SM, van Albada-Kuipers GA, Bijlsma JW, Blaauw AA, Schenk Y, et al. (2005) A good response to early DMARD treatment of patients with rheumatoid arthritis in the first year predicts remission during follow up. Ann Rheum Dis 64: 38–43.SM VerstappenGA van Albada-KuipersJW BijlsmaAA BlaauwY. Schenk2005A good response to early DMARD treatment of patients with rheumatoid arthritis in the first year predicts remission during follow up.Ann Rheum Dis643843
- 42. Berglin E, Lorentzon R, Nordmark L, Nilsson-Sojka B, Rantapaa Dahlqvist S (2003) Predictors of radiological progression and changes in hand bone density in early rheumatoid arthritis. Rheumatology (Oxford) 42: 268–275.E. BerglinR. LorentzonL. NordmarkB. Nilsson-SojkaS. Rantapaa Dahlqvist2003Predictors of radiological progression and changes in hand bone density in early rheumatoid arthritis.Rheumatology (Oxford)42268275
- 43. Gerber LH, Furst G, Yarboro C, el-Gabalawy H (2003) Number of active joints, not diagnosis, is the primary determinant of function and performance in early synovitis. Clin Exp Rheumatol 21: S65–70.LH GerberG. FurstC. YarboroH. el-Gabalawy2003Number of active joints, not diagnosis, is the primary determinant of function and performance in early synovitis.Clin Exp Rheumatol21S6570
- 44. Garnero P, Landewe R, Boers M, Verhoeven A, Van Der Linden S, et al. (2002) Association of baseline levels of markers of bone and cartilage degradation with long-term progression of joint damage in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis: the COBRA study. Arthritis Rheum 46: 2847–2856.P. GarneroR. LandeweM. BoersA. VerhoevenS. Van Der Linden2002Association of baseline levels of markers of bone and cartilage degradation with long-term progression of joint damage in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis: the COBRA study.Arthritis Rheum4628472856
- 45. Anderson JJ, Wells G, Verhoeven AC, Felson DT (2000) Factors predicting response to treatment in rheumatoid arthritis: the importance of disease duration. Arthritis Rheum 43: 22–29.JJ AndersonG. WellsAC VerhoevenDT Felson2000Factors predicting response to treatment in rheumatoid arthritis: the importance of disease duration.Arthritis Rheum432229
- 46. Cush JJ (2007) Early rheumatoid arthritis – is there a window of opportunity? J Rheumatol Suppl 80: 1–7.JJ Cush2007Early rheumatoid arthritis – is there a window of opportunity?J Rheumatol Suppl8017
- 47. van Dongen H, van Aken J, Lard LR, Visser K, Ronday HK, et al. (2007) Efficacy of methotrexate treatment in patients with probable rheumatoid arthritis: a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial. Arthritis Rheum 56: 1424–1432.H. van DongenJ. van AkenLR LardK. VisserHK Ronday2007Efficacy of methotrexate treatment in patients with probable rheumatoid arthritis: a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial.Arthritis Rheum5614241432
- 48. Mikuls TR, O'Dell J (2000) The changing face of rheumatoid arthritis therapy: results of serial surveys. Arthritis Rheum 43: 464–465.TR MikulsJ. O'Dell2000The changing face of rheumatoid arthritis therapy: results of serial surveys.Arthritis Rheum43464465
- 49. Genovese MC, Becker JC, Schiff M, Luggen M, Sherrer Y, et al. (2005) Abatacept for rheumatoid arthritis refractory to tumor necrosis factor alpha inhibition. N Engl J Med 353: 1114–1123.MC GenoveseJC BeckerM. SchiffM. LuggenY. Sherrer2005Abatacept for rheumatoid arthritis refractory to tumor necrosis factor alpha inhibition.N Engl J Med35311141123
- 50. Chong AS, Finnegan A, Jiang X, Gebel H, Sankary HN, et al. (1993) Leflunomide, a novel immunosuppressive agent. The mechanism of inhibition of T cell proliferation. Transplantation 55: 1361–1366.AS ChongA. FinneganX. JiangH. GebelHN Sankary1993Leflunomide, a novel immunosuppressive agent. The mechanism of inhibition of T cell proliferation.Transplantation5513611366
- 51. Manna SK, Aggarwal BB (1999) Immunosuppressive leflunomide metabolite (A77 1726) blocks TNF-dependent nuclear factor-kappa B activation and gene expression. J Immunol 162: 2095–2102.SK MannaBB Aggarwal1999Immunosuppressive leflunomide metabolite (A77 1726) blocks TNF-dependent nuclear factor-kappa B activation and gene expression.J Immunol16220952102
- 52. Arvidson NG, Gudbjornsson B, Larsson A, Hallgren R (1997) The timing of glucocorticoid administration in rheumatoid arthritis. Ann Rheum Dis 56: 27–31.NG ArvidsonB. GudbjornssonA. LarssonR. Hallgren1997The timing of glucocorticoid administration in rheumatoid arthritis.Ann Rheum Dis562731
- 53. Schuerwegh AJ, van Offel JF, Bridts CH, Stevens WJ, De Clerck LS (2001) Influence of longterm therapy with methotrexate and low dose corticosteroids on type 1 and type 2 cytokine production in CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. J Rheumatol 28: 1793–1799.AJ SchuerweghJF van OffelCH BridtsWJ StevensLS De Clerck2001Influence of longterm therapy with methotrexate and low dose corticosteroids on type 1 and type 2 cytokine production in CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes of patients with rheumatoid arthritis.J Rheumatol2817931799
- 54. Auphan N, DiDonato JA, Rosette C, Helmberg A, Karin M (1995) Immunosuppression by glucocorticoids: inhibition of NF-kappa B activity through induction of I kappa B synthesis. Science 270: 286–290.N. AuphanJA DiDonatoC. RosetteA. HelmbergM. Karin1995Immunosuppression by glucocorticoids: inhibition of NF-kappa B activity through induction of I kappa B synthesis.Science270286290
- 55. Tian H, Cronstein BN (2007) Understanding the mechanisms of action of methotrexate: implications for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis 65: 168–173.H. TianBN Cronstein2007Understanding the mechanisms of action of methotrexate: implications for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis.Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis65168173
- 56. Siemasko KF, Chong AS, Williams JW, Bremer EG, Finnegan A (1996) Regulation of B cell function by the immunosuppressive agent leflunomide. Transplantation 61: 635–642.KF SiemaskoAS ChongJW WilliamsEG BremerA. Finnegan1996Regulation of B cell function by the immunosuppressive agent leflunomide.Transplantation61635642
- 57. Chong AS, Rezai K, Gebel HM, Finnegan A, Foster P, et al. (1996) Effects of leflunomide and other immunosuppressive agents on T cell proliferation in vitro. Transplantation 61: 140–145.AS ChongK. RezaiHM GebelA. FinneganP. Foster1996Effects of leflunomide and other immunosuppressive agents on T cell proliferation in vitro.Transplantation61140145
- 58. Cherwinski HM, Cohn RG, Cheung P, Webster DJ, Xu YZ, et al. (1995) The immunosuppressant leflunomide inhibits lymphocyte proliferation by inhibiting pyrimidine biosynthesis. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 275: 1043–1049.HM CherwinskiRG CohnP. CheungDJ WebsterYZ Xu1995The immunosuppressant leflunomide inhibits lymphocyte proliferation by inhibiting pyrimidine biosynthesis.J Pharmacol Exp Ther27510431049
- 59. Urushibara M, Takayanagi H, Koga T, Kim S, Isobe M, et al. (2004) The antirheumatic drug leflunomide inhibits osteoclastogenesis by interfering with receptor activator of NF-kappa B ligand-stimulated induction of nuclear factor of activated T cells c1. Arthritis Rheum 50: 794–804.M. UrushibaraH. TakayanagiT. KogaS. KimM. Isobe2004The antirheumatic drug leflunomide inhibits osteoclastogenesis by interfering with receptor activator of NF-kappa B ligand-stimulated induction of nuclear factor of activated T cells c1.Arthritis Rheum50794804
- 60. Elkayam O, Yaron I, Shirazi I, Judovitch R, Caspi D, et al. (2003) Active leflunomide metabolite inhibits interleukin 1beta, tumour necrosis factor alpha, nitric oxide, and metalloproteinase-3 production in activated human synovial tissue cultures. Ann Rheum Dis 62: 440–443.O. ElkayamI. YaronI. ShiraziR. JudovitchD. Caspi2003Active leflunomide metabolite inhibits interleukin 1beta, tumour necrosis factor alpha, nitric oxide, and metalloproteinase-3 production in activated human synovial tissue cultures.Ann Rheum Dis62440443
- 61. Burger D, Begue-Pastor N, Benavent S, Gruaz L, Kaufmann MT, et al. (2003) The active metabolite of leflunomide, A77 1726, inhibits the production of prostaglandin E(2), matrix metalloproteinase 1 and interleukin 6 in human fibroblast-like synoviocytes. Rheumatology (Oxford) 42: 89–96.D. BurgerN. Begue-PastorS. BenaventL. GruazMT Kaufmann2003The active metabolite of leflunomide, A77 1726, inhibits the production of prostaglandin E(2), matrix metalloproteinase 1 and interleukin 6 in human fibroblast-like synoviocytes.Rheumatology (Oxford)428996
- 62. Klimiuk PA, Kita J, Chwiecko J, Sierakowski S (2009) The changes in serum chemokines following leflunomide therapy in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Clin Rheumatol 28: 17–21.PA KlimiukJ. KitaJ. ChwieckoS. Sierakowski2009The changes in serum chemokines following leflunomide therapy in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.Clin Rheumatol281721
- 63. Siemasko K, Chong AS, Jack HM, Gong H, Williams JW, et al. (1998) Inhibition of JAK3 and STAT6 tyrosine phosphorylation by the immunosuppressive drug leflunomide leads to a block in IgG1 production. J Immunol 160: 1581–1588.K. SiemaskoAS ChongHM JackH. GongJW Williams1998Inhibition of JAK3 and STAT6 tyrosine phosphorylation by the immunosuppressive drug leflunomide leads to a block in IgG1 production.J Immunol16015811588
- 64. Yu CR, Mahdi RM, Liu X, Zhang A, Naka T, et al. (2008) SOCS1 regulates CCR7 expression and migration of CD4+ T cells into peripheral tissues. J Immunol 181: 1190–1198.CR YuRM MahdiX. LiuA. ZhangT. Naka2008SOCS1 regulates CCR7 expression and migration of CD4+ T cells into peripheral tissues.J Immunol18111901198
- 65. de Beaucoudrey L, Puel A, Filipe-Santos O, Cobat A, Ghandil P, et al. (2008) Mutations in STAT3 and IL12RB1 impair the development of human IL-17-producing T cells. J Exp Med 205: 1543–1550.L. de BeaucoudreyA. PuelO. Filipe-SantosA. CobatP. Ghandil2008Mutations in STAT3 and IL12RB1 impair the development of human IL-17-producing T cells.J Exp Med20515431550
- 66. Liu X, Lee YS, Yu CR, Egwuagu CE (2008) Loss of STAT3 in CD4+ T cells prevents development of experimental autoimmune diseases. J Immunol 180: 6070–6076.X. LiuYS LeeCR YuCE Egwuagu2008Loss of STAT3 in CD4+ T cells prevents development of experimental autoimmune diseases.J Immunol18060706076
- 67. Gonzalez-Alvaro I, Ortiz Garcia AM, Dominguez-Jimenez C, Aragon-Bodi A, Diaz-Sanchez B, et al. (2008) Inhibition of TNF and IL-17 production by leflunomide involves the JAK/STAT pathway. Ann Rheum Dis. I. Gonzalez-AlvaroAM Ortiz GarciaC. Dominguez-JimenezA. Aragon-BodiB. Diaz-Sanchez2008Inhibition of TNF and IL-17 production by leflunomide involves the JAK/STAT pathway.Ann Rheum Dis
- 68. Hildner KM, Schirmacher P, Atreya I, Dittmayer M, Bartsch B, et al. (2007) Targeting of the transcription factor STAT4 by antisense phosphorothioate oligonucleotides suppresses collagen-induced arthritis. J Immunol 178: 3427–3436.KM HildnerP. SchirmacherI. AtreyaM. DittmayerB. Bartsch2007Targeting of the transcription factor STAT4 by antisense phosphorothioate oligonucleotides suppresses collagen-induced arthritis.J Immunol17834273436
- 69. Muller-Ladner U, Judex M, Ballhorn W, Kullmann F, Distler O, et al. (2000) Activation of the IL-4 STAT pathway in rheumatoid synovium. J Immunol 164: 3894–3901.U. Muller-LadnerM. JudexW. BallhornF. KullmannO. Distler2000Activation of the IL-4 STAT pathway in rheumatoid synovium.J Immunol16438943901
- 70. Walker JG, Ahern MJ, Coleman M, Weedon H, Papangelis V, et al. (2006) Changes in synovial tissue Jak-STAT expression in rheumatoid arthritis in response to successful DMARD treatment. Ann Rheum Dis 65: 1558–1564.JG WalkerMJ AhernM. ColemanH. WeedonV. Papangelis2006Changes in synovial tissue Jak-STAT expression in rheumatoid arthritis in response to successful DMARD treatment.Ann Rheum Dis6515581564
- 71. Bingham CO 3rd (2008) Emerging therapeutics for rheumatoid arthritis. Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis 66: 210–215.CO Bingham 3rd2008Emerging therapeutics for rheumatoid arthritis.Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis66210215
- 72. Bathon JM, Martin RW, Fleischmann RM, Tesser JR, Schiff MH, et al. (2000) A comparison of etanercept and methotrexate in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis. N Engl J Med 343: 1586–1593.JM BathonRW MartinRM FleischmannJR TesserMH Schiff2000A comparison of etanercept and methotrexate in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis.N Engl J Med34315861593
- 73. Stanton RJ, McSharry BP, Rickards CR, Wang EC, Tomasec P, et al. (2007) Cytomegalovirus destruction of focal adhesions revealed in a high-throughput Western blot analysis of cellular protein expression. J Virol 81: 7860–7872.RJ StantonBP McSharryCR RickardsEC WangP. Tomasec2007Cytomegalovirus destruction of focal adhesions revealed in a high-throughput Western blot analysis of cellular protein expression.J Virol8178607872