The evolutionary history of Mesozoic terrestrial vertebrates from the Arabian Peninsula is virtually unknown. Despite vast exposures of rocky outcrops, only a handful of fossils have yet been described from the region. Here we report a multi-taxon dinosaur track assemblage near Madar village, 47 km north of Sana'a, Republic of Yemen. This represents the first dinosaur tracksite from the Arabian Peninsula, and the only multi-taxon dinosaur ichnosite in the Middle East.
Measurements were taken directly from trackway impressions, following standard ichnological conventions. The presence of bipedal trackmakers is evidenced by a long series of pes imprints preserving smoothly rounded posterior margins, no evidence of a hallux, bluntly rounded digit tips and digital divarication angles characteristic of ornithopod dinosaurs. Nearby, eleven parallel quadrupedal trackways document a sauropod herd that included large and small individuals traveling together. Based on the morphology of manus impressions along with a narrow-gauged stance, the quadrupedal trackways were made by non-titanosauriform neosauropods. Additional isolated tracks and trackways of sauropod and ornithopod dinosaurs are preserved nearby.
Taken together, these discoveries present the most evocative window to date into the evolutionary history of dinosaurs of the Arabian Peninsula. Given the limited Mesozoic terrestrial record from the region, this discovery is of both temporal and geographic significance, and massive exposures of similarly-aged outcrops nearby offer great promise for future discoveries.
Citation: Schulp AS, Al-Wosabi M, Stevens NJ (2008) First Dinosaur Tracks from the Arabian Peninsula. PLoS ONE 3(5): e2243. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0002243
Editor: Anna Stepanova, Paleontological Institute, Russian Federation
Received: February 19, 2008; Accepted: April 8, 2008; Published: May 21, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Schulp et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Partial funding for this work provided by the Yemen Geological Survey, Mr. T. Saleh, and Ohio University.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The dinosaur record of the Arabian Peninsula is limited to reports of isolated axial elements from the Sultanate of Oman , , and sauropod remains of possibly Jurassic age from Yemen . More broadly, published reports from the region are restricted to a distal tibia of an indeterminate theropod from Syria , a fragmentary ornithopod appendicular specimen from the Late Cretaceous of Jordan , and two brachiosaurid teeth from the early Cretaceous of southern Lebanon . Finally, theropod tracks have been reported near Jerusalem –. Here we describe a multi-taxon dinosaur ichnosite from the Republic of Yemen, representing the first record of dinosaur trackways on the Arabian Peninsula.
The dinosaur trackways described herein are located near the village of Madar, Arhab area, 47 km north of Sana'a, the capitol of the Republic of Yemen [Fig. 1A]. The main site, at 15°46′49″N, 44°14′25″E, is approximately 3 km west of the main road, and has been signposted and fenced by the Yemen Geological Survey. Additional tracks have been recognized nearby, within the villages of Arhab and Bait al Washr.
History of discovery
The first set of tracks at Arhab was discovered by Mohammed Al-Daheri, a local journalist. He notified M.A.W., who worked with the Yemen Geological Survey to protect the locality and contacted A.S. and N.J.S. to collaboratively assemble a detailed description of the tracksite. During the mapping effort, additional trackways were discovered west of the initial locality, including two poorly preserved trackways of bipeds along with 11 relatively well-preserved subparallel quadrupedal series [Fig 1]. Prospecting and mapping in December 2006 and February 2007 yielded two additional track sites at Bait al Washr village [15°48′41″N, 44°15′52″E], some 6 km east of the main track locality, as well as a few poorly preserved trackways preserved in the bedrock within the boundaries of the village.
The Arhab dinosaur tracksite is situated in a sub-horizontal outcrop of yellow limestones, locally covered with basalt flows. The track-bearing beds, representing a coastal mudflat environment, are of Middle Jurassic to lowermost Cretaceous age. The strata were initially introduced as Amran Series , and further described and defined as Amran Group . The Amran Group has subsequently been dated as Callovian-Berriasian in age based on ammonite fauna ; foraminiferal assemblages suggest a Bathonian-Berriasian age . The track-bearing layers are predominantly exposed as dipslopes, with little vegetation cover, and extending over a much wider area than actually prospected during the brief fieldwork, underscoring the potential for recognizing an even more diverse ichnofauna in the region.
Identification of the bipedal trackmaker
The first tracksite discovery, a bipedal tridactyl series spanning 14 m, reveals 15 consecutive tracks heading in a SSW direction [Fig. 1A, B]. Pes length and width each average 56 cm. Average step and stride lengths are 107 cm and 207 cm, respectively. Corresponding average pace angulation is 151°. On the relatively well-preserved first three tracks, the axis of digit III exhibits an outward rotation of 4° from the trackway midline.
We refer these bipedal tracks to ornithopod trackmakers based on the following characteristics , : tracks are approximately equal in length and width; digits [particularly digit III] preserve a u-shaped outline with bluntly rounded tips; digit III width/length ratio is >0.5; digits exhibit no curvature nor is there evidence of a hallucal impression; the divarication of digit II-IV averages 65°; and the rear edge of footprint exhibits a smooth, convex margin.
Identification of the quadrupedal trackmaker
West of the tridactyl trackway, 11 subparallel quadrupedal trackways [Fig. 1A, C] preserve evidence of large and small quadrupedal animals traveling together in a herd. The longest [16 m] of these trackways currently preserves 16 consecutive footprints. As with the bipedal trackway, potential exists for discovering additional tracks by further exposing the layer along the northern edge of the site. Tracks do not preserve distinctive evidence of claws on either the manus or the pes [Fig. 1C]. Average stride lengths of the 11 individuals range from 187–252 cm; average pace angulation is 113°; pes length from 43–70 cm. Well-preserved tracks for the 11 individuals indicate average pes dimensions of 57 cm in length by 46 cm in width. Manus outlines are distinct for fewer trackmakers, but range between 21–31 cm in length and 34–42 cm in width.
We refer these quadrupedal tracks to neosauropods based on the following characteristics: the anteroposteriorly short, u-shaped manus impressions suggest an arc-shaped articulation of metacarpals, as observed in the Neosauropoda . The quadrupedal trackways at Arhab are relatively narrow-gauge, with the left and right pes tracks touching [but not overlapping] the trackway midline, unlike the wide-gauge trackways typically associated with titanosauriforms . Given this narrow-gauge stance, together with a more derived, arc-shaped manus impression, quadrupedal tracks at Arhab were likely made by nontitanosauriform neosauropods.
Co-occurrence of sauropod and ornithopod tracks in carbonates is relatively uncommon. The presence of neosauropod and ornithopod trackways in Yemen is consistent with the presence of body fossils of both groups on the African continent by the late Jurassic . At that time, the African and Arabian Peninsular landmasses had not yet been separated by the Red Sea.
Early potential ornithopods are known from the early Jurassic of South Africa, e.g., heterodontosaurs , , with undisputed ornithopods subsequently known throughout Africa, Asia, Europe, North America and Australia, reaching a zenith of known diversity  during the Cretaceous. Early Cretaceous bipedal dinosaur tracks have been reported from Cameroon ; with the 39 cm long tridactyl prints having a morphology “consistent with either iguanodont or theropod morphology” [20: p. 350]. As ornithopod body fossils are already well-represented in Africa by the late Jurassic –, their presence in Yemen is not unexpected. Because ornithopod tracks of this size are not well known from the late Jurassic, these tracks may suggest an early Cretaceous age for the deposits. If not, the ichnosite is of additional importance in preserving evidence of a rare early occurrence of a large ornithopod taxon.
The earliest sauropods are described from Upper Triassic of South Africa , indicating that the initial diversification of the group likely occurred before the separation of much of Pangaea, and as with the ornithopods, certainly predated the breakup of Gondwana. By the mid-Jurassic, sauropod dinosaurs are known from either body fossils or footprints from every major continental landmass except Antarctica , indicating a more or less global distribution. Many sauropods from the southern landmasses belong to the Titanosauriformes . Titanosauriforms are characterized by derived postcranial morphological features including medially deflected femoral shafts and laterally expansive ilia that have been associated with a wide-gauge stance –. In contrast, the trackways at Arhab are relatively narrow-gauge, with the left and right pes tracks touching [but not overlapping] the trackway midline. Together, the narrow-gauge stance along with the more derived, arc-shaped manus impressions suggests the presence of nontitanosauriform neosauropods. Further, the presence of parallel sauropod trackways at Arhab has implications for inferring the behavior of the trackmakers, as the 11 trackways are roughly parallel, evenly spaced, and estimates of speed based on stride lengths appear fairly constant at approximately 3km/hour despite a likely fourfold difference in body mass between the smallest and largest individuals. Neosauropod taxa are well documented from the Gondwanan landmasses, and African neosauropods of consistent size with the trackmakers at Arhab include Nigersaurus, Rebbachisaurus and Algoasaurus . Finally, narrow-gauge sauropod trackways have been reported from Morocco ,  and Zimbabwe .
If ichnofossils are to be used as independent data points, their taxonomic attribution should not be based solely upon spatial and temporal coincidence . The footprints described herein preserve sufficient morphological detail to support the presence of both ornithopod and sauropod dinosaurs at Arhab. Taken together with the approximate age of the deposits, this assessment accords well with global patterns in dinosaurian evolution. Moreno and Benton  review what appears to be a marked transition from sauropod-dominated faunas, to ornithopod-dominated faunas at the Jurassic-Cretaceous boundary. It is only with intensified sampling effort that such patterns can be explored and tested in Afro-Arabia.
Materials and Methods
Trackways were exposed by clearing away sand, small rocks and debris. From the impressions, we obtained the following measurements: manus length and width (defined respectively as the maximum antero-posterior and mediolateral dimensions of an individual manus impression), pes length and width (defined respectively as the maximum antero-posterior and mediolateral dimensions of an individual pes impression), stride length (defined as the distance between the posteriormost margins of consecutive tracks of the same limb), step length (defined as the distance between the posteriormost margins of consecutive tracks within a forelimb pair or hind limb pair), pace angulation (defined as the angle formed between line segments connecting the posteriormost margins of consecutive hind limb tracks on ornithopod tracks, and the angle formed between line segments connecting the better-preserved anteriormost point of the pes on sauropod tracks), and digit divarication (defined as the angle formed between line segments approximating the long axes of digits II and IV). Estimates of speed for the 11 sauropod trackmakers were made using pes lengths and stride lengths measured directly from the tracksite, following calculations outlined in Alexander (1976): v≈0.25g0.5SL1.67h−1.17, where v indicates velocity, g equals the gravitational constant, SL equals stride length, and h equals hip height. Impressions with obvious overlap or breakage were excluded from the analysis. Individual tracks were traced onto transparent plastic film overlays. Overlays were scanned into Adobe Illustrator (version 10) and field measurements of pace angulation were checked for accuracy using Spot Advanced (version 3.5).
We thank the Yemen Geological Survey for permission to conduct this work. The research team was comprised of members of the Yemen Geological Survey, University of Sana'a, Natuurhistorisch Museum Maastricht and Ohio University. Students H. Dokan, B. Al-Botaily and F. Al-Nehmi assisted in the field. We gratefully acknowledge Dr. I. Al-Ganad for encouragement and advice, and Mr. T. Saleh for generous support of the project. We also thank colleagues Dr. M. As-Sururi of the Mineral Exploration Board of Yemen, and Dr. A. Al-Harthy, Dr. A.R. Al-Sayigh and Dr. S. Nasir of Sultan Qaboos University, Sultanate of Oman. M. Lockley made helpful comments that improved this paper.
Analyzed the data: NS AS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: NS AS MA. Wrote the paper: NS AS. Other: Participated in research and coordinated field logistics: MA.
- 1. Schulp AS, Hanna SS, Hartman AF, Jagt JWM (2000) A Late Cretaceous theropod caudal vertebra from the Sultanate of Oman. Cret Res 21: 851–856.AS SchulpSS HannaAF HartmanJWM Jagt2000A Late Cretaceous theropod caudal vertebra from the Sultanate of Oman.Cret Res21851856
- 2. Nolan SC, Skelton PW, Clissold BP, Smewing JD (1990) Maastrichtian to early Tertiary stratigraphy and palaeogeography of the central and northern Oman Mountains. In: Robertson AHF, Searle MP, Ries AC, editors. The geology and tectonics of the Oman region, Geol Soc Lond, Sp Pub 49. pp. 495–519.SC NolanPW SkeltonBP ClissoldJD Smewing1990Maastrichtian to early Tertiary stratigraphy and palaeogeography of the central and northern Oman Mountains.AHF RobertsonMP SearleAC RiesThe geology and tectonics of the Oman region, Geol Soc Lond, Sp Pub 49495519
- 3. Jacobs LL, Murry PA, Downs WR, El-Nakhal HA (1999) A dinosaur from the Republic of Yemen. In: Whybrow PJ, Hill A, editors. Fossil vertebrates of Arabia. New Haven: Yale University Press. pp. 454–459.LL JacobsPA MurryWR DownsHA El-Nakhal1999A dinosaur from the Republic of Yemen.PJ WhybrowA. HillFossil vertebrates of ArabiaNew HavenYale University Press454459
- 4. Hooijer DA (1968) A Cretaceous dinosaur from the Syrian Arab Republic. Proc Kon Nederl Akad Wetenschappen B 71: 150–152.DA Hooijer1968A Cretaceous dinosaur from the Syrian Arab Republic.Proc Kon Nederl Akad Wetenschappen B71150152
- 5. Martill DM, Frey E, Sadaqah RM (1996) The first dinosaur from the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. Neues Jahrb Geol Paläont, Mon 199: 147–154.DM MartillE. FreyRM Sadaqah1996The first dinosaur from the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.Neues Jahrb Geol Paläont, Mon199147154
- 6. Buffetaut E, Azar D, Nel A, Ziadé K, Acra A (2006) First nonavian dinosaur from Lebanon: a brachiosaurid sauropod from the Lower Cretaceous of the Jezzine District. Naturwiss 93: 440–443.E. BuffetautD. AzarA. NelK. ZiadéA. Acra2006First nonavian dinosaur from Lebanon: a brachiosaurid sauropod from the Lower Cretaceous of the Jezzine District.Naturwiss93440443
- 7. Avnimelech MA (1962) Dinosaur tracks in the Lower Cenomanian of Jerusalem. Nature 196: 264.MA Avnimelech1962Dinosaur tracks in the Lower Cenomanian of Jerusalem.Nature196264
- 8. Avnimelech MA (1962) Découverte d'empreintes de pas de Dinosaures dans le Cénomanien inférieur des environs de Jérusalem (Note préliminaire). CRAS Geol 8: 233–235.MA Avnimelech1962Découverte d'empreintes de pas de Dinosaures dans le Cénomanien inférieur des environs de Jérusalem (Note préliminaire).CRAS Geol8233235
- 9. Avnimelech MA (1966) Dinosaur tracks in the Judean Hills. Isr Acad Sci Hum Proc, Sci 1,. MA Avnimelech1966Dinosaur tracks in the Judean Hills. Isr Acad Sci Hum Proc, Sci 1,19
- 10. Lamare P (1930) Nature et extension des depôts secondaires dans l'Arabie, l'Ethiopie et les pays Somalis. Mém Soc Géol Fr, ns 6, fasc. 3–4, 14: 49–68.P. Lamare1930Nature et extension des depôts secondaires dans l'Arabie, l'Ethiopie et les pays Somalis. Mém Soc Géol Fr, ns 6, fasc. 3–4,144968
- 11. Beydoun ZR, et al. (1998) International lexicon of Stratigraphy Volume III Asia, Fascicule 10b2, Republic of Yemen, 2nd edition, IUGS Pub No. 34.ZR Beydoun1998International lexicon of Stratigraphy Volume III Asia, Fascicule 10b2, Republic of Yemen, 2nd edition, IUGS Pub No. 34.
- 12. Howarth MK, Morris NJ (1998) The Jurassic and Lower Cretaceous of Wadi Hajar, Southern Yemen. Bull Nat Hist Mus (Geol) 54: 1–32.MK HowarthNJ Morris1998The Jurassic and Lower Cretaceous of Wadi Hajar, Southern Yemen.Bull Nat Hist Mus (Geol)54132
- 13. Al-Wosabi MA (2001) Stratigraphical and sedimentological studies on the Jurassic Amran Sequence, East Sana'a District, Yemen Republic. Sana'a University. MA Al-Wosabi2001Stratigraphical and sedimentological studies on the Jurassic Amran Sequence, East Sana'a District, Yemen Republic.Sana'a University278PhD. Thesis. PhD. Thesis.
- 14. Farlow JO, Chapman RE (1997) The Scientific Study of Dinosaur Footprints. In: Farlow JO, Brett-Surman MK, editors. The Complete Dinosaur. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. pp. 519–553.JO FarlowRE Chapman1997The Scientific Study of Dinosaur Footprints.JO FarlowMK Brett-SurmanThe Complete DinosaurBloomingtonIndiana University Press519553
- 15. Thulborn T (1990) Dinosaur Tracks. London: Chapman & Hall. T. Thulborn1990Dinosaur Tracks.LondonChapman & Hall410
- 16. Carrano MT, Wilson JA (2001) Taxon distributions and the tetrapod track record. Paleobiol 27: 564–582.MT CarranoJA Wilson2001Taxon distributions and the tetrapod track record.Paleobiol27564582
- 17. Weishampel DB, et al. (2004) Dinosaur distribution. In: Weishampel DB, Dodson P, Osmólska H, editors. The Dinosauria. Berkeley/Los Angeles: University of California Press. pp. 517–606.DB Weishampel2004Dinosaur distribution.DB WeishampelP. DodsonH. OsmólskaThe DinosauriaBerkeley/Los AngelesUniversity of California Press517606
- 18. Crompton AW, Charig AJ (1962) A new ornithischian from the Upper Triassic of South Africa. Nature 196: 1074–1077.AW CromptonAJ Charig1962A new ornithischian from the Upper Triassic of South Africa.Nature19610741077
- 19. Gow CE (1975) A new heterodontosaurid from the Red Beds of South Africa showing clear evidence of tooth replacement. Zool J Linn Soc 57: 335–339.CE Gow1975A new heterodontosaurid from the Red Beds of South Africa showing clear evidence of tooth replacement.Zool J Linn Soc57335339
- 20. Jacobs LL, et al. (1989) Dinosaur Footprints from the Lower Cretaceous of Cameroon, West Africa. In: Gillette DD, Lockley MG, editors. Dinosaur Tracks and Traces. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 349–351.LL Jacobs1989Dinosaur Footprints from the Lower Cretaceous of Cameroon, West Africa.DD GilletteMG LockleyDinosaur Tracks and TracesCambridgeCambridge University Press349351
- 21. Ginsburg L, de Lapparent AF, Lornet B, Taquet P (1966) Empreintes de pas de vertébrés tétrapodes dans les séries continentales à l'ouest d'Agadès (République du Niger). CRAS 263D: 28–31.L. GinsburgAF de LapparentB. LornetP. Taquet1966Empreintes de pas de vertébrés tétrapodes dans les séries continentales à l'ouest d'Agadès (République du Niger).CRAS263D2831
- 22. Goodwin MB, Clemens WA, Schaff CR, Wood CB (1996) New occurrences of Mesozoic vertebrates from the Upper Blue Nile Gorge and nearby tributaries, Ethiopia. J Vert Paleont 16: (suppl.)38A.MB GoodwinWA ClemensCR SchaffCB Wood1996New occurrences of Mesozoic vertebrates from the Upper Blue Nile Gorge and nearby tributaries, Ethiopia.J Vert Paleont16(suppl.)38A
- 23. Goodwin MB, et al. (1999) Mesozoic continental vertebrates with associated palynostratigraphic dates from the northwestern Ethiopian plateau. J Vert Paleont 19: 728–741.MB Goodwin1999Mesozoic continental vertebrates with associated palynostratigraphic dates from the northwestern Ethiopian plateau.J Vert Paleont19728741
- 24. Yates AM, Kitching JW (2003) The earliest known sauropod dinosaur and the first steps towards sauropod locomotion. Proc Roy Soc Lond B 270: 1753–1758.AM YatesJW Kitching2003The earliest known sauropod dinosaur and the first steps towards sauropod locomotion.Proc Roy Soc Lond B27017531758
- 25. Wilson JA (2005) Integrating ichnofossil and body fossil records to estimate locomotor posture and spatiotemporal distribution of early sauropod dinosaurs: a stratocladistic approach. Paleobiol 31: 400–423.JA Wilson2005Integrating ichnofossil and body fossil records to estimate locomotor posture and spatiotemporal distribution of early sauropod dinosaurs: a stratocladistic approach.Paleobiol31400423
- 26. Jacobs LL, Winkler DA, Kaufulu ZM, Downs WR (1990) The Dinosaur Beds of northern Malawi, Africa. Nat Geogr Res 6: 196–204.LL JacobsDA WinklerZM KaufuluWR Downs1990The Dinosaur Beds of northern Malawi, Africa.Nat Geogr Res6196204
- 27. Schulp AS, Brokx WA (1999) Maastrichtian Sauropod Footprints from the Fumanya site, Bergueda, Spain. Ichnos 6: 239–250.AS SchulpWA Brokx1999Maastrichtian Sauropod Footprints from the Fumanya site, Bergueda, Spain.Ichnos6239250
- 28. Wilson JA, Carrano MT (1999) Titanosaurs and the origin of “wide-gauge” trackways: A biomechanical and systematic perspective on sauropod locomotion. Paleobiol 25: 252–267.JA WilsonMT Carrano1999Titanosaurs and the origin of “wide-gauge” trackways: A biomechanical and systematic perspective on sauropod locomotion.Paleobiol25252267
- 29. Henderson DM (2006) Burly gaits: centers of mass, stability, and the trackways of sauropod dinosaurs. J Vert Paleont 26: 907–921.DM Henderson2006Burly gaits: centers of mass, stability, and the trackways of sauropod dinosaurs.J Vert Paleont26907921
- 30. Dutuit JM, Ouazzou A (1980) Découverte d'une piste de Dinosaure sauropode sur le site d'empreintes de Demnat (Haut Atlas Marocain). Mém Soc Géol Fr, ns 139: 95–102.JM DutuitA. Ouazzou1980Découverte d'une piste de Dinosaure sauropode sur le site d'empreintes de Demnat (Haut Atlas Marocain).Mém Soc Géol Fr, ns13995102
- 31. Ishigaki S (1989) Footprints of swimming sauropods from Morocco,. In: Gillette DD, Lockley MG, editors. Dinosaur Tracks and Traces. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 83–86.S. Ishigaki1989Footprints of swimming sauropods from Morocco,DD GilletteMG LockleyDinosaur Tracks and TracesCambridgeCambridge University Press8386
- 32. Ahmed AA, Lingham-Soliar T, Broderick T (2004) Giant sauropod tracks from the Middle-Late Jurassic of Zimbabwe in close association with theropod tracks. Lethaia 37: 467–470.AA AhmedT. Lingham-SoliarT. Broderick2004Giant sauropod tracks from the Middle-Late Jurassic of Zimbabwe in close association with theropod tracks.Lethaia37467470
- 33. Moreno K, Benton MJ (2005) Occurrence of sauropod dinosaur tracks in the Upper Jurassic of Chile (redescription of Iguanodonichnus frenki). J S Am Earth Sci 20: 253–257.K. MorenoMJ Benton2005Occurrence of sauropod dinosaur tracks in the Upper Jurassic of Chile (redescription of Iguanodonichnus frenki).J S Am Earth Sci20253257
- 34. Alexander, RMcN (1976) Estimates of speeds of dinosaurs. Nature 261: 129–130.Alexander, RMcN1976Estimates of speeds of dinosaurs.Nature261129130