Prophylactic zinc supplementation has been shown to reduce diarrhea and respiratory illness in children in many developing countries, but its efficacy in children in Africa is uncertain.
To determine if zinc, or zinc plus multiple micronutrients, reduces diarrhea and respiratory disease prevalence.
Three cohorts: 32 HIV-infected children; 154 HIV-uninfected children born to HIV-infected mothers; and 187 HIV-uninfected children born to HIV-uninfected mothers.
Children received either 1250 IU of vitamin A; vitamin A and 10 mg of zinc; or vitamin A, zinc, vitamins B1, B2, B6, B12, C, D, E, and K and copper, iodine, iron, and niacin starting at 6 months and continuing to 24 months of age. Homes were visited weekly.
Primary outcome was percentage of days of diarrhea per child by study arm within each of the three cohorts. Secondary outcomes were prevalence of upper respiratory symptoms and percentage of children who ever had pneumonia by maternal report, or confirmed by the field worker.
Among HIV-uninfected children born to HIV-infected mothers, median percentage of days with diarrhea was 2.3% for 49 children allocated to vitamin A; 2.5% in 47 children allocated to receive vitamin A and zinc; and 2.2% for 46 children allocated to multiple micronutrients (P = 0.852). Among HIV-uninfected children born to HIV-uninfected mothers, median percentage of days of diarrhea was 2.4% in 56 children in the vitamin A group; 1.8% in 57 children in the vitamin A and zinc group; and 2.7% in 52 children in the multiple micronutrient group (P = 0.857). Only 32 HIV-infected children were enrolled, and there were no differences between treatment arms in the prevalence of diarrhea. The prevalence of upper respiratory symptoms or incidence of pneumonia did not differ by treatment arms in any of the cohorts.
When compared with vitamin A alone, supplementation with zinc, or with zinc and multiple micronutrients, did not reduce diarrhea and respiratory morbidity in rural South African children.
Citation: Luabeya K-KA, Mpontshane N, Mackay M, Ward H, Elson I, Chhagan M, et al. (2007) Zinc or Multiple Micronutrient Supplementation to Reduce Diarrhea and Respiratory Disease in South African Children: A Randomized Controlled Trial. PLoS ONE 2(6): e541. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0000541
Academic Editor: Jose M. Belizan, Institute of Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy, Argentina
Received: May 3, 2007; Accepted: May 9, 2007; Published: June 27, 2007
Copyright: © 2007 Luabeya et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was supported by grants from the United States National Institute of Health (1 UO1 AI45508-01, 1 K24 AI/HDO1671-01, D43TW05572-01 to Dr. Bennish) and the Wellcome Trust (Wellcome 62925 to Dr. Bennish and Wellcome 063009 to Dr. Van den Broeck. The National Institutes of Health provided training in good clinical practice to study staff, arranged for the study to be monitored by a contract research organization to ensure compliance with good clinical practice, and established a Data Monitoring and Safety Board to oversee the trial. The sponsor for the study was the host institution, the Africa Centre for Health and Population Studies, which gave discretion in the investigative team in study design, data analysis, manuscript preparation, and decisions on manuscript submission and publication.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Micronutrient deficiencies are common in children in developing countries, including children in South Africa.– Zinc deficiency is especially thought to be associated with an increased susceptibility to infection, and a greater severity of disease when infection occurs. Zinc is now recommended by the WHO for the treatment of children with diarrhea in developing countries, but its role for the prophylaxis of infection is less certain.
Studies in Asia and Latin American have generally found that prophylactic zinc reduces the incidence, duration and severity of diarrhea and pneumonia episodes when given to infants and young children. Few studies have been conducted of prophylactic administration of zinc in Africa,,  which differs, especially from Asia, in diet and patterns of growth in children, and in the burden of infectious diseases, especially HIV. Because micronutrient deficiencies are seldom isolated to a single micronutrient, there have also been efforts to provide supplements containing an array of micronutrients.
In KwaZulu-Natal, where this study was conducted, antenatal HIV prevalence is 39%. Children with HIV infection are known to be at high risk of infection and poor nutrition and growth, and those born to HIV-infected mothers but not themselves infected may be at increased risk of nutritional deficiencies because of parental illness.
The study was conducted in northern KwaZulu-Natal Province, South Africa. Median household income in the area is one-half the national average, 80% of the population lives below the national poverty line, and unemployment is 75%. There is little subsistence farming in this area despite 98% of households being defined as rural, and food insecurity within households is common. Most infants receive both breast and complementary feeding from early infancy, and the diet is known to be deficient in micronutrients.
Children were enrolled into the study by nurses at five government primary health care clinics. Study subjects were recruited from children coming to the clinics for routine visits, from households identified as having potentially eligible children based on surveillance conducted by the Africa Centre Demographic Information System, and from children enrolled at birth in an observational study of the determinants of mother-to-child transmission of HIV.
Children eligible for study were four to six months old. Children were excluded from study if they were: less than 60% of median weight-for-age using United States National Center for Health Statistics standards; had nutritional edema; had received vitamin or micronutrient supplements in the previous month; had diarrhea for more than seven days at the time of study enrollment; or were enrolled in another study of a clinical intervention.
To maintain community blinding to the HIV status of women enrolled in the study, we enrolled children in any cohort which reached targeted enrollment before enrollment was completed in other cohorts, provided them only their initial two weeks of supplement, and did not include them in the analysis.
Ethics and study monitoring
The study was approved by the Ethics Review Committee of the University of KwaZulu-Natal and the Institutional Review Board of Tufts-New England Medical Center. Before initiation the study was presented to the Community Advisory Board of the Africa Centre for their review and advice, and interim reports on study progress were provided to this Advisory Board. The study was also monitored by a Data Monitoring and Safety Board established by the NIH. Written informed consent to participate in the study, and to do HIV testing on both the mother and child, was obtained from all mothers whose children participated in the study.
The three treatment arms were: vitamin A alone; vitamin A plus zinc; and vitamin A, zinc and multiple micronutrients. All supplements were given daily at home from entry into the study until 24 months of age. Vitamin A was given as the comparator regimen, rather than placebo, because the South African Department of Health guidelines recommend routine three-monthly vitamin A supplementation for children and clinics did not consistently provide vitamin A to children. Thus each of the three tablet formulations contained 1250 IU of vitamin A. Two of the three tablet formulations contained 10 mg of zinc as zinc gluconate. The multiple micronutrient tablets were similar to those used in recent international trials of multiple micronutrient supplementation, and in addition to vitamin A and zinc contained : 0.5 mg each of vitamins B1, B2 and B6; 0.9 µg vitamin B12; 35 mg vitamin C; 5 µg vitamin D; 6 mg vitamin E; 10 µg vitamin K; 0.6 mg copper as cupric gluconate; 150 µg folate; 50 µg iodine; 10 mg iron as ferrous fumerate; and 6 mg niacin. The supplements were manufactured as tablets by Hersil Ltd. (Lima, Peru) and packaged in blister packs of seven tablets. All three formulations were similar in color, taste, appearance and size. Because of a delay in shipment, 243 children enrolled in the study did not receive supplements for 11 weeks in 2005.
To study objective was to determine if zinc, or zinc plus multiple micronutrients, would reduce diarrhea and respiratory disease prevalence. We hypothesized that both zinc, and zinc plus multiple micronutrients, would reduce diarrhea and respiratory disease prevalence and examined their efficacy in a randomized controlled trial in children 6–24 months of age born to both HIV-infected and HIV-uninfected mothers.
The primary study outcome was the percentage of days of diarrhea per child compared between study arms within each of the three cohorts. Secondary diarrheal disease outcomes were measures of the severity of diarrhea (duration of episodes, maximum number of stools during an episode, episodes lasting 14 or more days, diarrhea episodes with blood in the stool, and clinic visits for diarrhea) and the distribution of diarrheal morbidity (proportion of children who ever had diarrhea and number of episodes per child). Respiratory disease outcome measures were the percentage of weeks of upper respiratory symptoms per child, the percentage of children who ever had pneumonia by maternal report, and the percentage of children with pneumonia confirmed by the field worker.
Diarrhea was considered to be present on any day the stool was more frequent or looser than normal or the stool contained water or blood. An episode of diarrhea terminated on the last day of diarrhea that was followed by two consecutive days without diarrhea. Blood was considered present in stool if reported by the mother. Upper respiratory tract infection was defined as the history (or presence during the field worker visit) of cough or runny nose. Because field workers asked about the occurrence of these signs since the last visit, rather than by day, the outcome was defined as prevalent weeks. Pneumonia by maternal report was considered to have occurred if there was a history of either fast breathing or chest in-drawing. Confirmed pneumonia was defined as an elevated respiratory rate at rest measured by the fieldworker using WHO/UNICEF Integrated Management of Childhood Illness guidelines.
This was done separately for each of the three cohorts and was based on percentage of days of diarrhea for each child by cohort and treatment arm. We assumed the percentage of days with diarrhea in HIV-infected children receiving vitamin A alone would be 4.4% (SD±0.9%); for those receiving vitamin A and zinc it would be 3.7%±0.9% (17% less than for those receiving vitamin A alone); and for those receiving multiple micronutrients it would be 3.0%±0.9% (33% less than for those receiving vitamin A alone and 20% less than for those receiving vitamin A and zinc). For HIV-uninfected children we postulated the same differences between treatment groups but with lower diarrhea prevalence rates: 3.3%±0.9% (vitamin A alone); 2.8%±0.9% (vitamin A and zinc); and 2.2%±0.9% (multiple micronutrient group). To determine with a power of 0.8 and a two-sided significance level of .05 if these postulated differences existed, 26 children were required in each of the three arms of the HIV-infected cohort, and 45 children in each of the three arms of the two cohorts of HIV-uninfected children. We expected mortality, migration, and withdrawals to diminish days of observation by 50% in the HIV-infected cohort and 25% in the HIV-uninfected groups. Thus the total sample size required was 156 in the HIV-infected cohort and 180 children in each of the two cohorts of HIV uninfected children.
An allocation list was prepared using computer-generated random numbers and a block size of six. Assignment to the three treatment arms was done separately for three cohorts of children stratified by HIV status of child and mother: HIV-infected children and mothers; HIV-uninfected children of HIV-infected mothers; and HIV-uninfected children of HIV-uninfected mothers.
Randomization–allocation concealment and implementation
The manufacturer prepared numbered packs of tablets corresponding to the allocation list. Children enrolled in the study were assigned by a study physician to one of the three study cohorts after results of the HIV tests became available. The physician then allocated the next pack of tablets from the blocks assigned to that cohort to the participant.
At enrollment study subjects had a physical examination and medical history taken by the study nurse. Weight was measured to a precision of 0.1 kg using an electronic digital scale and recumbent length to a precision of 0.1 cm using an infantometer. For determination of anthropometric centiles National Center for Health Statistics standards were used. Mothers and children had a blood sample taken for determination of HIV infection status if their status was not already known and documented, and for determining haemoglobin concentration. A two-week supply of tablets were provided at enrolment, and the mothers instructed on administering tablets to their child by crushing it and mixing it with food, and assuring that the child ate all the food the supplement was mixed in.
Trained fieldworkers visited the children at home weekly during the study. They supplied sufficient tablets to ensure a two week supply was on hand. Any tablets remaining from the previous supply were counted and recorded. At each home visit field workers observed the preparation and administration of a tablet, and waited for 30 minutes to observe any adverse effect.
At each visit field workers administered a standardized questionnaire that focused on diarrheal and respiratory morbidity using locally validated terms. If the mother reported diarrhea then the field worker asked for each day since the last visit if the stool was looser or more frequent than normal, contained water or blood, and the number of stools on the worst day of diarrhea. Mothers were asked if since the last visit the child had a runny nose or cough, difficult or fast breathing, or chest in-drawing. Field workers measured the respiratory rate at rest in any child with current or reported signs or symptoms of respiratory distress.
If the mother or another informant familiar with the child was not available during the scheduled home visit two further attempts were made to visit that week, following which the next planned weekly visit was made. Field workers collected information on events that occurred a maximum of 28 days before the visit.
Mothers and infants were requested to return for clinic visits at 7, 8, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21 and 24 months of age to assess growth and morbidity. Ill children were referred to the study nurses at the clinics, or for more serious illness to the district hospital. When antiretroviral therapy for children became available in clinics in January 2005 all children with HIV infection in the study were referred for evaluation.
Supervisors assessed reliability of field worker assessments by conducting unscheduled visits and comparing findings with interviews conducted the same day by field workers
HIV testing of children was done using a quantitative HIV RNA assay (Nuclisens HIV-1 QT, Organon Teknika or Nuclisens EasyQ HIV-1, Biomerieux, Boxtel, The Netherlands). Maternal HIV status was determined using two ELISA tests (first Vironostika HIV-1 Microelisa system and then Uni-Form II plus O if the first test was positive, both Biomèrieux) each of which had to be positive for HIV infection to be diagnosed. Hemoglobin determination was done at the clinic by study nurses using a portable HemoCue system (Angelholm, Sweden).
Data were entered into an electronic data base using an optical form scanning system (TeleForm version 7.1 Cardiff, Vista CA, USA) and were analyzed using SPSS version 13.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) and EpiInfo version 3.3.2 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, USA).
Analyses were done on a locked dataset using an analysis plan, and tests of significance, that were determined before the analyses were conducted. Analyses were initially conducted using coded treatment groups with the analysts blinded to the actual treatment.
Analysis of all outcomes was on an intention-to-treat basis–all participants for whom there were observations on study outcomes were included in the analysis. In addition to comparing baseline characteristics between children in the treatment groups, we also examined features during study that could have confounded study outcome. These were rates of drop-out and death, proportion of missing information, dietary pattern, adherence to treatment, and intake of other vitamin and micronutrient preparations. Any baseline or during treatment characteristics that differed significantly between treatment arms was tested for its association with the study outcome using Spearman's rank correlation test.
The primary outcome–percentage of days of diarrhea per child by cohort and treatment group-was not normally distributed as determined by the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, and a Kruskall-Wallis test was used to determine the overall significance of difference between treatment arms. For secondary outcomes and for baseline characteristics the significance of differences for continuous variables was tested using one-way ANOVA if the variable was normally distributed or the Kruskall-Wallis test if not normally distributed. Differences in proportions were tested with the χ2 test. Comparisons between individual groups were made only if the overall group comparison found a significant difference. To determine the effect size for the primary outcome, we determined the difference between medians, and the 95% confidence intervals for those differences, using the binomial method. All tests of differences or association were two-sided, and were considered significant if the P value was ≤ 0.05.
We also tested for any bias in assignment to treatment cohort (on the assumption that blinding may not have been completely effective) using the Berger-Exner test.
Recruitment, patient flow, and numbers analyzed
Study enrollment began in June 2003 and the last participant enrolled in October 2004. Patient observations were completed 31 January 2006. Three-hundred seventy-three children were enrolled in the study–32 HIV-infected children, 154 children without HIV infection born to HIV-infected mothers, and 187 children born to HIV-uninfected mothers (Figure 1). Thirty-seven children withdrew and one died before any home visits took place, leaving 335 children for whom information on outcomes was available and who were included in the analysis (Figure 1). One-hundred thirteen of these 335 children each received vitamin A alone or vitamin A plus zinc, and 109 of the children received multiple micronutrients. Ten of these 335 children never took the supplement but were included in this intention-to-treat analysis. Berger-Exner tests performed in each cohort separately showed no evidence of bias in assignment to treatment group. Controlling for treatment arm, the P-values for the partial correlation between percent days of diarrhea (the main outcome) and the remaining proportion of multivitamin tablets in the block at the time of random assignment to therapy was >0.23 in each of the three cohorts.
Twelve (3.6%) of the 335 children with at least one home visit died during the study, including 8 (29%) of the 28 children with HIV infection. An additional 88 (26.2%) of the 335 children who had at least one home visit did not complete the study (Table 1). Fifty-seven children moved out of the area during the study. Reasons given for withdrawal in the other 31 children included lack of time by parent to participate (2 children), the child not liking the taste of the tablets (3 children), objections from grandparent or father (2 children) and unspecified reasons in 24 children. The median duration of enrollment in the study was 447 days and did not differ significantly between groups.
Baseline demographic characteristics of the treatment groups in the three cohorts did not significantly differ with the exception of weight-for-length in the group of HIV-uninfected children born to HIV-uninfected mothers (Table 1).
There was no significant difference between treatment groups in the primary outcome-percentage of days with diarrhea–in any of the three cohorts (Tables 2 and 3). The median percentage of days with diarrhea ranged from 3.4% to 7.1% in the three treatment arms in HIV-infected children, and from 1.8% to 2.7% in the treatment arms in the two cohorts of HIV-uninfected children. In all comparisons the 95% CI for the differences between groups crossed zero (Table 3). There was no difference between treatment arms in any of the secondary outcome measures of diarrhea severity or frequency (Table 2). Children enrolled in the study had a median of 2 episodes of diarrhea while in the study. During 352 person-years of observation for the children in the study there were a total of 1115 episodes of diarrhea, or 3.2 per year of observation. Only 28 children (8.4%) had episodes of persistent diarrhea lasting >14 days, and 79 (23.6%) ever had blood in their stool.
Respiratory disease morbidity.
There were no differences between study groups in the median percentage of weeks with upper respiratory symptoms, which ranged from 13.1% to 16.6% in the three treatment groups in the two cohorts of children without HIV infection; or in the percentage of children who had pneumonia confirmed by measured respiratory rate, which ranged from 4.3% to 19.1% (Table 2).
There was no effect of treatment when subjects 6–12 months or 12–24 months, or those less than 1.5 or 2.0 z scores of length-for age, were analyzed separately.
Study subjects received supplements 77% of days they were enrolled in the study (Table 1), but there was no significant difference between groups in percentage of days supplement was taken. Among the participant characteristics during study that might have confounded study outcome the only significant differences were the median number of study weeks that study subjects were fed cereal, which differed between treatment groups in both the cohorts of HIV-infected children, and HIV-uninfected children born to HIV-infected mothers; and the clinic used by HIV-infected children. Neither of these variables was associated with days of diarrhea, however, and thus we did not adjust for them in the analyses of outcomes.
In this study neither zinc combined with vitamin A, nor zinc and vitamin A combined with other micronutrients, reduced diarrhea and respiratory disease morbidity in three cohorts of children 6–24 months of age in rural South Africa–HIV-infected children, HIV-uninfected children born to HIV-infected mothers, or children born to HIV-infected mothers. Enrollment of children with HIV infection was much smaller than the proposed sample size in the study protocol, thus limiting any conclusions about efficacy in this cohort. But enrollment in the other two cohorts was approximately what was planned, and conclusions on findings in these cohorts are thus robust.
The findings of this study are in contrast to the preponderance of findings from previous studies. A meta-analysis of seven studies of continuous supplementation with zinc found a 25% reduction in diarrhea prevalence and 18% reduction in diarrhea incidence, and in the four studies included in the meta-analysis that reported the effect of zinc on pneumonia there was a 41% decrease in pneumonia incidence.
What differences in study population, study design or supplement formulation might have accounted for the lack of effect of zinc or micronutrient supplementation on diarrhea or respiratory morbidity in this study when compared to previous studies? Children enrolled in this trial had better anthropometric indices than those reported on in most previous studies. Despite the food insecurity and poverty in the community, only 6.4% of children in this study were <2 z scores for length-for-age, compared to 32–100% of children in studies included in the meta-analysis of prophylactic zinc supplementation. A number of studies have shown the impact of zinc prophylaxis is greatest on those who are stunted or underweight,, ,  or enrolled only those who were undernourished.,  ,  Studies that have not found an effect on diarrheal or respiratory morbidity have often included better nourished children. Other studies used zinc supplementation as secondary prophylaxis, enrolling children already ill with diarrhea,, ,  which may select for a population at greater risk of disease, and more likely to benefit from supplementation.
Diarrhea morbidity in this study was relatively low when compared to some studies showing an effect of zinc, where the reported incidence has been as high as an improbable 30 diarrhea episodes per child per year. Other studies, like ours, have found much lower rates,, ,  This suggests that either case definitions, or methods of ascertainment, in addition to biological and epidemiological factors, may play a role in the variation in diarrhea morbidity found in different studies. We used diarrhea case definitions that should be sensitive measures of diarrhea and that incorporated local terminology for diarrheal illness.,  The same is true for the definition of pneumonia–the commonly used WHO/UNICEF Integrated Management of Childhood Illness definition of pneumonia was used. The schedule of household visits–once per week–is one that is commonly used, and has been sensitive for detecting diarrhea during community-based studies. The incidence and percentage of days with diarrhea was consistent with what was predicted in estimating the sample size.
The dosage of zinc used in this study–10 mg per day for six months–is the regimen that has been most commonly used in prophylactic supplementation studies, and previous studies with this formulation of micronutrients have suggested good bio-availability. The proportion of study days that the supplement was taken–77% across all study participants–was lower than in some other studies, which have achieved adherence rates as high as 90%. This study was, however, conducted as an intention-to-treat study, and thus data from study participants who had stopped taking supplements, but who still agreed to home visits, are included in the analysis. Some studies have only provided supplementation six days per week. Other studies have provided 20 mg of zinc as a weekly supplement in order to improve convenience and adherence. The rate at which supplements were taken–effectively 5 days per week in this study–would in any case likely be the best that could be achieved under non-study conditions in a general population.
There was no placebo group in this study, and it is possible that vitamin A alone was sufficient to reduce diarrhea and respiratory morbidity. Although there is strong evidence for an effect of vitamin A on mortality in developing countries, there is less consistent evidence that vitamin A supplementation alone reduces diarrhea and respiratory morbidity, and some studies have even reported an increase in respiratory morbidity following vitamin A supplementation.
In October 2003, soon after study enrollment began, the South African government implemented regulations requiring the fortification of maize meal and wheat flour, including flour used by bakeries, with zinc and other micronutrients. The amount of fortification (up to 30 mg zinc per kg of maize meal for instance) in these staple foods, although unlikely to provide an amount of zinc equivalent to that in the supplements, may still have improved micronutrient status in children with access to commercially produced meal or bread. A previous study from South Africa, however, suggest that fortification of maize meal, the staple for these children, did not improve zinc nutriture.
There has been hope that supplementation with multiple micronutrients might be more beneficial that supplementation with a single micronutrient, especially as deficiencies in one micronutrient may limit the functional activity of other micronutrients. To date, however, there has been little evidence that the addition of other micronutrients, including formulations similar to that used in this study, enhances the efficacy of zinc in reducing diarrhea and respiratory morbidity when the latter has been found effective. ,,,,, In at least two studies multiple micronutrient supplementation actually increased rates of morbidity when compared to placebo or zinc alone.,
None of the studies reported on in the meta-analysis finding efficacy of zinc prophylaxis for diarrhea or respiratory disease was conducted in Africa. Since the meta-analysis was conducted there have been at least five studies in addition to this one conducted in Africa that have examined the effect of zinc on diarrheal and respiratory morbidity, though in none except this one was it a primary study outcome (Table 5)., , – In a study in Ethiopia zinc significantly reduced the incidence of diarrhea and cough in children who were <2 z scores for length-for-age, but not in those who were better nourished. In a study in Burkina Faso there was a modest but significant 13% reduction in diarrhea prevalence, but no significant reduction in cough. A study in malnourished children in Lesotho of zinc supplementation for three months after hospital discharge found a reduction in diarrhea prevalence from 37% in the placebo to 3% in the zinc-supplemented group, and a reduction in acute respiratory infection from 39% to 3%. A study of multiple micronutrient supplementation in South Africa did not find an effect of a zinc-containing micronutrient mixture on diarrhea morbidity despite very high rates of diarrhea prevalence. A study in children in South Africa infected with HIV who were not on antiretroviral therapy found a reduction in diarrhea prevalence during scheduled or unscheduled clinic visits. A recent large study from Tanzania found no effect of zinc supplementation on overall mortality, or diarrhea-related mortality.
What are the policy implications of this study? Because of the heterogeneity of different populations of children in developing countries and the heterogeneity of the studies of zinc that have been conducted to date, generalizing from any single study is problematic. This study had as its outcomes the efficacy of zinc or multiple micronutrient supplementation as primary prophylaxis of diarrhea and respiratory morbidity. Neither supplement was efficacious for either indication.
The study was conducted in children that were less severely stunted than in most previous micronutrient supplementation studies, and who may have benefited from recent efforts to fortify staple food with micronutrients. But it is still a population which has a high burden of ill-health, with an infant mortality rate of 68 per thousand and an child mortality ratio of 98 per thousand. The findings of this study, along with a previously reported study of micronutrient supplementation conducted elsewhere in South Africa that did not show efficacy, do not provide support for the prophylactic use of zinc or multiple micronutrients to reduce diarrhea or respiratory morbidity in the general population of South African children.
We thank the community of Umkhanyakude for their support of the study; the mothers, children and families that participated; the nurses, supervisors and field staff for their devotion to and hard work; Nigel Rollins for assistance in conceptualization of the study, proposal and protocol development, and initial study implementation; Portia Mutevedzi and Nathalie Graham for assistance with laboratory studies; Cookie Govender and George Irving for assistance with data entry, and Mario Chen-Mok for advice on statistical methods.
Principal investigator for the study: MLB. Served as Project Directors: JVdB KAL. Supervised the field work for the study: NM. Conducted the laboratory studies: MM HW IE. Designed the study: MLB AT. Wrote the grant proposal: MLB. Wrote the initial study protocol: MLB JVdB. Revised the study protocol: KAL JVdB MLB. Designed the analysis plan and conducted the analysis: JVdB MLB. Drafted the manuscript: MLB KAL JVdB. Critically reviewed and approved the manuscript: all authors.
- 1. Vitamin&mineral deficiency. A global progress report The Micronutrient Initiative.. Vitamin&mineral deficiency. A global progress report The Micronutrient Initiative.(Accessed June 29,2004 at http://www.micronutrient.org/reports/reports/Full_e.pdf.). (Accessed June 29,2004 at http://www.micronutrient.org/reports/reports/Full_e.pdf.).
- 2. Labadarios D, Steyn NP, Maunder E, MacIntryre U, Gericke G, et al. (2005) The National Food Consumption Survey (NFCS): South Africa, 1999. Public Health Nutr 8: 533–43.D. LabadariosNP SteynE. MaunderU. MacIntryreG. Gericke2005The National Food Consumption Survey (NFCS): South Africa, 1999.Public Health Nutr853343
- 3. Mostert D, Steyn NP, Temple NJ, Olwagen R (2005) Dietary intake of pregnant women and their infants in a poor black South African community. Curationis 28: 12–9.D. MostertNP SteynNJ TempleR. Olwagen2005Dietary intake of pregnant women and their infants in a poor black South African community.Curationis28129
- 4. Fischer Walker C, Black RE (2004) Zinc and the risk for infectious disease. Annu Rev Nutr 24: 255–75.C. Fischer WalkerRE Black2004Zinc and the risk for infectious disease.Annu Rev Nutr2425575
- 5. Technical updates of the guidelines on Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI): evidence and recommendations for further adaptations World Health Organization.. Technical updates of the guidelines on Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI): evidence and recommendations for further adaptations World Health Organization.(Accessed June 29,2005 at http://www.who.int/child-adolescent-health/New_Publications/IMCI/ISBN_92_4_159348_2.pdf.). (Accessed June 29,2005 at http://www.who.int/child-adolescent-health/New_Publications/IMCI/ISBN_92_4_159348_2.pdf.).
- 6. Bhutta ZA, Black RE, Brown KH, Gardner JM, Gore S, et al. (1999) Prevention of diarrhea and pneumonia by zinc supplementation in children in developing countries: pooled analysis of randomized controlled trials. Zinc Investigators' Collaborative Group. J Pediatr 135: 689–97.ZA BhuttaRE BlackKH BrownJM GardnerS. Gore1999Prevention of diarrhea and pneumonia by zinc supplementation in children in developing countries: pooled analysis of randomized controlled trials. Zinc Investigators' Collaborative Group.J Pediatr13568997
- 7. Umeta M, West CE, Haidar J, Deurenberg P, Hautvast JG (2000) Zinc supplementation and stunted infants in Ethiopia: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet 355: 2021–6.M. UmetaCE WestJ. HaidarP. DeurenbergJG Hautvast2000Zinc supplementation and stunted infants in Ethiopia: a randomised controlled trial.Lancet35520216
- 8. Muller O, Becher H, van Zweeden AB, Ye Y, Diallo DA, et al. (2001) Effect of zinc supplementation on malaria and other causes of morbidity in west African children: randomised double blind placebo controlled trial. Bmj 322: 1567.O. MullerH. BecherAB van ZweedenY. YeDA Diallo2001Effect of zinc supplementation on malaria and other causes of morbidity in west African children: randomised double blind placebo controlled trial.Bmj3221567
- 9. The state of the world's children UNICEF.. The state of the world's children UNICEF.(Accessed June 30,2006 at http://www.unicef.org/sowc06/pdfs/sowc06_fullreport.pdf.). (Accessed June 30,2006 at http://www.unicef.org/sowc06/pdfs/sowc06_fullreport.pdf.).
- 10. National HIV and syphilis prevalence survey South Africa 2005 South Africa Department of Health.. National HIV and syphilis prevalence survey South Africa 2005 South Africa Department of Health.(Accessed August 6,2006 at http://www.doh.gov.za/docs/reports/2005/hiv.pdf.). (Accessed August 6,2006 at http://www.doh.gov.za/docs/reports/2005/hiv.pdf.).
- 11. Bailey RC, Kamenga MC, Nsuami MJ, Nieburg P, St Louis ME (1999) Growth of children according to maternal and child HIV, immunological and disease characteristics: a prospective cohort study in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo. Int J Epidemiol 28: 532–40.RC BaileyMC KamengaMJ NsuamiP. NieburgME St Louis1999Growth of children according to maternal and child HIV, immunological and disease characteristics: a prospective cohort study in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo.Int J Epidemiol2853240
- 12. A profile of KwaZulu-Natal: demographics, poverty, inequality and unemployment Provide Project.. A profile of KwaZulu-Natal: demographics, poverty, inequality and unemployment Provide Project.(Accessed June 30,2005 at http://www.elsenburg.com/provide/documents/BP2005_1_5%20Demographics%20KZ.pdf.). (Accessed June 30,2005 at http://www.elsenburg.com/provide/documents/BP2005_1_5%20Demographics%20KZ.pdf.).
- 13. Bland RM, Rollins NC, Coutsoudis A, Coovadia HM (2002) Breastfeeding practices in an area of high HIV prevalence in rural South Africa. Acta Paediatr 91: 704–11.RM BlandNC RollinsA. CoutsoudisHM Coovadia2002Breastfeeding practices in an area of high HIV prevalence in rural South Africa.Acta Paediatr9170411
- 14. Faber M (2005) Complementary foods consumed by 6-12-month-old rural infants in South Africa are inadequate in micronutrients. Public Health Nutr 8: 373–81.M. Faber2005Complementary foods consumed by 6-12-month-old rural infants in South Africa are inadequate in micronutrients.Public Health Nutr837381
- 15. Hamill PV, Drizd TA, Johnson CL, Reed RB, Roche AF, et al. (1979) Physical growth: National Center for Health Statistics percentiles. Am J Clin Nutr 32: 607–29.PV HamillTA DrizdCL JohnsonRB ReedAF Roche1979Physical growth: National Center for Health Statistics percentiles.Am J Clin Nutr3260729
- 16. Lock G (2003) The foodLET vehicle designed for and used in the IRIS I intervention. Food Nutr Bull 24: S16–9.G. Lock2003The foodLET vehicle designed for and used in the IRIS I intervention.Food Nutr Bull24S169
- 17. Kauchali S, Rollins N, Van den Broeck J (2004) Local beliefs about childhood diarrhoea: importance for healthcare and research. J Trop Pediatr 50: 82–9.S. KauchaliN. RollinsJ. Van den Broeck2004Local beliefs about childhood diarrhoea: importance for healthcare and research.J Trop Pediatr50829
- 18. Gardner MJ, Altman DG (1989) Statistics with confidence. Confidence intervals and statistical guidelines. London: British Medical Journal. MJ GardnerDG Altman1989Statistics with confidence. Confidence intervals and statistical guidelines.LondonBritish Medical Journal
- 19. Berger VW, Exner DV (1999) Detecting selection bias in randomized clinical trials. Control Clin Trials 20: 319–27.VW BergerDV Exner1999Detecting selection bias in randomized clinical trials.Control Clin Trials2031927
- 20. Ruel MT, Rivera JA, Santizo MC, Lonnerdal B, Brown KH (1997) Impact of zinc supplementation on morbidity from diarrhea and respiratory infections among rural Guatemalan children. Pediatrics 99: 808–13.MT RuelJA RiveraMC SantizoB. LonnerdalKH Brown1997Impact of zinc supplementation on morbidity from diarrhea and respiratory infections among rural Guatemalan children.Pediatrics9980813
- 21. Baqui AH, Zaman K, Persson LA, El Arifeen S, Yunus M, et al. (2003) Simultaneous weekly supplementation of iron and zinc is associated with lower morbidity due to diarrhea and acute lower respiratory infection in Bangladeshi infants. J Nutr 133: 4150–7.AH BaquiK. ZamanLA PerssonS. El ArifeenM. Yunus2003Simultaneous weekly supplementation of iron and zinc is associated with lower morbidity due to diarrhea and acute lower respiratory infection in Bangladeshi infants.J Nutr13341507
- 22. Ninh NX, Thissen JP, Collette L, Gerard G, Khoi HH, et al. (1996) Zinc supplementation increases growth and circulating insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) in growth-retarded Vietnamese children. Am J Clin Nutr 63: 514–9.NX NinhJP ThissenL. ColletteG. GerardHH Khoi1996Zinc supplementation increases growth and circulating insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) in growth-retarded Vietnamese children.Am J Clin Nutr635149
- 23. Meeks Gardner J, Witter MM, Ramdath DD (1998) Zinc supplementation: effects on the growth and morbidity of undernourished Jamaican children. Eur J Clin Nutr 52: 34–9.J. Meeks GardnerMM WitterDD Ramdath1998Zinc supplementation: effects on the growth and morbidity of undernourished Jamaican children.Eur J Clin Nutr52349
- 24. Roy SK, Tomkins AM, Haider R, Behren RH, Akramuzzaman SM, et al. (1999) Impact of zinc supplementation on subsequent growth and morbidity in Bangladeshi children with acute diarrhoea. Eur J Clin Nutr 53: 529–34.SK RoyAM TomkinsR. HaiderRH BehrenSM Akramuzzaman1999Impact of zinc supplementation on subsequent growth and morbidity in Bangladeshi children with acute diarrhoea.Eur J Clin Nutr5352934
- 25. Sur D, Gupta DN, Mondal SK, Ghosh S, Manna B, et al. (2003) Impact of zinc supplementation on diarrheal morbidity and growth pattern of low birth weight infants in kolkata, India: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, community-based study. Pediatrics 112: 1327–32.D. SurDN GuptaSK MondalS. GhoshB. Manna2003Impact of zinc supplementation on diarrheal morbidity and growth pattern of low birth weight infants in kolkata, India: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, community-based study.Pediatrics112132732
- 26. Long KZ, Montoya Y, Hertzmark E, Santos JI, Rosado JL (2006) A double-blind, randomized, clinical trial of the effect of vitamin A and zinc supplementation on diarrheal disease and respiratory tract infections in children in Mexico City, Mexico. Am J Clin Nutr 83: 693–700.KZ LongY. MontoyaE. HertzmarkJI SantosJL Rosado2006A double-blind, randomized, clinical trial of the effect of vitamin A and zinc supplementation on diarrheal disease and respiratory tract infections in children in Mexico City, Mexico.Am J Clin Nutr83693700
- 27. Sazawal S, Black RE, Bhan MK, Jalla S, Sinha A, et al. (1997) Efficacy of zinc supplementation in reducing the incidence and prevalence of acute diarrhea–a community-based, double-blind, controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr 66: 413–8.S. SazawalRE BlackMK BhanS. JallaA. Sinha1997Efficacy of zinc supplementation in reducing the incidence and prevalence of acute diarrhea–a community-based, double-blind, controlled trial.Am J Clin Nutr664138
- 28. Penny ME, Marin RM, Duran A, Peerson JM, Lanata CF, et al. (2004) Randomized controlled trial of the effect of daily supplementation with zinc or multiple micronutrients on the morbidity, growth, and micronutrient status of young Peruvian children. Am J Clin Nutr 79: 457–65.ME PennyRM MarinA. DuranJM PeersonCF Lanata2004Randomized controlled trial of the effect of daily supplementation with zinc or multiple micronutrients on the morbidity, growth, and micronutrient status of young Peruvian children.Am J Clin Nutr7945765
- 29. Rosado JL, Lopez P, Munoz E, Martinez H, Allen LH (1997) Zinc supplementation reduced morbidity, but neither zinc nor iron supplementation affected growth or body composition of Mexican preschoolers. Am J Clin Nutr 65: 13–9.JL RosadoP. LopezE. MunozH. MartinezLH Allen1997Zinc supplementation reduced morbidity, but neither zinc nor iron supplementation affected growth or body composition of Mexican preschoolers.Am J Clin Nutr65139
- 30. Coldham C, Ross D, Quigley M, Segura Z, Chandramohan D (2000) Prospective validation of a standardized questionnaire for estimating childhood mortality and morbidity due to pneumonia and diarrhoea. Trop Med Int Health 5: 134–44.C. ColdhamD. RossM. QuigleyZ. SeguraD. Chandramohan2000Prospective validation of a standardized questionnaire for estimating childhood mortality and morbidity due to pneumonia and diarrhoea.Trop Med Int Health513444
- 31. Smuts CM, Lombard CJ, Benade AJ, Dhansay MA, Berger J, et al. (2005) Efficacy of a foodlet-based multiple micronutrient supplement for preventing growth faltering, anemia, and micronutrient deficiency of infants: the four country IRIS trial pooled data analysis. J Nutr 135: 631S–8S.CM SmutsCJ LombardAJ BenadeMA DhansayJ. Berger2005Efficacy of a foodlet-based multiple micronutrient supplement for preventing growth faltering, anemia, and micronutrient deficiency of infants: the four country IRIS trial pooled data analysis.J Nutr135631S8S
- 32. Fawzi WW, Chalmers TC, Herrera MG, Mosteller F (1993) Vitamin A supplementation and child mortality. A meta-analysis. Jama 269: 898–903.WW FawziTC ChalmersMG HerreraF. Mosteller1993Vitamin A supplementation and child mortality. A meta-analysis.Jama269898903
- 33. Vitamin A supplementation and child morbidity and mortality in developing countries United Nations University Press.. Vitamin A supplementation and child morbidity and mortality in developing countries United Nations University Press.(Accessed July 7,1994 at http://www.unu.edu/unupress/food/8F154e/8F154E04.htm#Vitamin%20A%20supplementation%20and%20child%20morbidity%20and%20mortality%20in%20developing%20countries.). (Accessed July 7,1994 at http://www.unu.edu/unupress/food/8F154e/8F154E04.htm#Vitamin%20A%20supplementation%20and%20child%20morbidity%20and%20mortality%20in%20developing%20countries.).
- 34. Regulations relating to the fortification of certain foodstuffs Ministry of Health South Africa.. Regulations relating to the fortification of certain foodstuffs Ministry of Health South Africa.(Accessed July 7,2003 at http://www.doh.gov.za/docs/regulations/2003/ffortification.html.). (Accessed July 7,2003 at http://www.doh.gov.za/docs/regulations/2003/ffortification.html.).
- 35. de Romana DL, Salazar M, Hambidge KM, Penny ME, Peerson JM, et al. (2005) Longitudinal measurements of zinc absorption in Peruvian children consuming wheat products fortified with iron only or iron and 1 of 2 amounts of zinc. Am J Clin Nutr 81: 637–47.DL de RomanaM. SalazarKM HambidgeME PennyJM Peerson2005Longitudinal measurements of zinc absorption in Peruvian children consuming wheat products fortified with iron only or iron and 1 of 2 amounts of zinc.Am J Clin Nutr8163747
- 36. Faber M, Kvalsvig JD, Lombard CJ, Benade AJS (2005) Effect of a fortified maize-meal porridge on anemia, micronutrient status, and motor development of infants. Am J Clin Nutr 82: 1032–9.M. FaberJD KvalsvigCJ LombardAJS Benade2005Effect of a fortified maize-meal porridge on anemia, micronutrient status, and motor development of infants.Am J Clin Nutr8210329
- 37. Tielsch JM, Khatry SK, Stoltzfus RJ, Katz J, LeClerq SC, et al. (2006) Effect of routine prophylactic supplementation with iron and folic acid on preschool child mortality in southern Nepal: community-based, cluster-randomised, placebo-controlled trial. Lancet 367: 144–52.JM TielschSK KhatryRJ StoltzfusJ. KatzSC LeClerq2006Effect of routine prophylactic supplementation with iron and folic acid on preschool child mortality in southern Nepal: community-based, cluster-randomised, placebo-controlled trial.Lancet36714452
- 38. Lopez de Romana G, Cusirramos S, Lopez de Romana D, Gross R (2005) Efficacy of multiple micronutrient supplementation for improving anemia, micronutrient status, growth, and morbidity of Peruvian infants. J Nutr 135: 646S–52.G. Lopez de RomanaS. CusirramosD. Lopez de RomanaR. Gross2005Efficacy of multiple micronutrient supplementation for improving anemia, micronutrient status, growth, and morbidity of Peruvian infants.J Nutr135646S52
- 39. Untoro J, Karyadi E, Wibowo L, Erhardt MW, Gross R (2005) Multiple micronutrient supplements improve micronutrient status and anemia but not growth and morbidity of Indonesian infants: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. J Nutr 135: 639S–45.J. UntoroE. KaryadiL. WibowoMW ErhardtR. Gross2005Multiple micronutrient supplements improve micronutrient status and anemia but not growth and morbidity of Indonesian infants: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial.J Nutr135639S45
- 40. Smuts CM, Dhansay MA, Faber M, van Stuijvenberg ME, Swanevelder S, et al. (2005) Efficacy of multiple micronutrient supplementation for improving anemia, micronutrient status, and growth in South African infants. J Nutr 135: 653S–9S.CM SmutsMA DhansayM. FaberME van StuijvenbergS. Swanevelder2005Efficacy of multiple micronutrient supplementation for improving anemia, micronutrient status, and growth in South African infants.J Nutr135653S9S
- 41. Bobat R, Coovadia H, Stephen C, Naidoo KL, McKerrow N, et al. (2005) Safety and efficacy of zinc supplementation for children with HIV-1 infection in South Africa: a randomised double-blind placebo-controlled trial. Lancet 366: 1862–7.R. BobatH. CoovadiaC. StephenKL NaidooN. McKerrow2005Safety and efficacy of zinc supplementation for children with HIV-1 infection in South Africa: a randomised double-blind placebo-controlled trial.Lancet36618627
- 42. Makonnen B, Venter A, Joubert G (2003) A randomized controlled study of the impact of dietary zinc supplementation in the management of children with protein-energy malnutrition in Lesotho. I: mortality and morbidity. J Trop Pediatr 49: 340–52.B. MakonnenA. VenterG. Joubert2003A randomized controlled study of the impact of dietary zinc supplementation in the management of children with protein-energy malnutrition in Lesotho. I: mortality and morbidity.J Trop Pediatr4934052
- 43. Sazawal S, Black RE, Ramsan M, Chwaya HM, Dutta A, et al. (2007) Effect of zinc supplementation on mortality in children aged 1–48 months: a community-based randomised placebo-controlled trial. Lancet 369: 927–34.S. SazawalRE BlackM. RamsanHM ChwayaA. Dutta2007Effect of zinc supplementation on mortality in children aged 1–48 months: a community-based randomised placebo-controlled trial.Lancet36992734
- 44. Garrib A, Jaffar S, Knight S, Bradshaw D, Bennish ML (2006) Rates and causes of child mortality in an area of high HIV prevalence in rural South Africa. Trop Med Int Health 11: 1841–8.A. GarribS. JaffarS. KnightD. BradshawML Bennish2006Rates and causes of child mortality in an area of high HIV prevalence in rural South Africa.Trop Med Int Health1118418