The brain is deemed “immunologically privileged” due to sparse professional antigen-presenting cells and lymphatic drainage, and to the blood-brain barrier. Although the actual extent of this privilege is controversial, there is general consensus about the limited need in intracerebral neural grafts for immunosuppressive regimens comparable to those used in other cases of allotransplantation. This has led over the past fifteen years to the use of either short-term or even no immunosuppression in most clinical trials with foetal neural transplant in patients with Parkinson's and Huntington's disease.
We report biological demonstration of alloimmunisation without signs of rejection in four grafted patients out of 13 studied during the course of a clinical trial involving fetal neural transplantation in patients with Huntington's Disease. Biological, radiological and clinical demonstration of an ongoing rejection process was observed in a fifth transplanted patient. The rejection process was, however, fully reversible under immunosuppressive treatment and graft activity recovered within six months.
There had been, up to date, no report of documented cases that could have cast a doubt on those procedures. Our results underline the need for a reconsideration of the extent of the so-called immune privilege of the brain and of the follow-up protocols of patients with intracerebral grafts. It also suggests that some of the results obtained in past studies with foetal neural transplants may have been biased by an unrecognized immune response to donor cells.
Citation: Krystkowiak P, Gaura V, Labalette M, Rialland A, Remy P, Peschanski M, et al. (2007) Alloimmunisation to Donor Antigens and Immune Rejection Following Foetal Neural Grafts to the Brain in Patients with Huntington's Disease. PLoS ONE 2(1): e166. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0000166
Academic Editor: Mark Cookson, Laboratory of Neurogenetics, National Institutes of Health, United States of America
Received: September 30, 2006; Accepted: October 6, 2006; Published: January 24, 2007
Copyright: © 2007 Krystkowiak et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: These results have been obtained as an ancillary study to the MIG-HD clinical trial (Multicentric Intracerebral Grafting in Huntington's Disease, NCT00190450) sponsored by Assistance-Publique/Hôpitaux de Paris, with additional support from Association Française contre les Myopathies and INSERM. The study sponsors have had no role either in study design, collection, analysis and interpretation of data, writing of the paper nor in decision to submit.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Transplantation of cells and tissues to the mammalian brain and CNS has been clinically assessed for more than 15 years, in several hundred patients with Parkinson or Huntington Disease. Because the brain was considered differently than almost all other organs, in terms of the possibility of an immune response, little consideration has been given up to now either to the potential existence of adverse consequences of a rejection process, or even to the existence any sign of allo-immunisation in patients. The mechanisms underlying this privilege are diverse, and probably cumulative, and results from the blood– brain barrier, the absence of professional antigen-presenting cells in the brain and the sparse lymphatic drainage from the central nervous system (reviewed in ). Experimental studies in animal models have, however, now revealed that the previously held view that the brain was an absolute immunologically privileged site allowing indefinite survival without rejection of grafts of cells was wrong. Activated lymphocytes can cross the BBB, certain cells such as microglia may have an antigen presenting cell capacity and there is lymphatic drainage from the brain into the cervical lymph nodes. Thus, the brain should be regarded as a site where immune responses can occur, albeit in a modified form. Up to now, however, there had been no report of an immune rejection process following foetal neural grafting to the brain of a patient. We report here a first human case of characterized rejection, and a number of transplanted patients with biological signs of all-immunisation against the antigens of the foetal donors.
Material and Methods
A phase II study looking for therapeutic efficacy of foetal neural grafts to the brain of patients with Huntington's disease (“MIG-HD”, ref. NCT00190450) is currently ongoing in Europe, following the promising results of a pilot study , , . The original protocol has been approved by the CCPPRB of the Hospital Henri-Mondor in Creteil on August 8, 2001. Additional protocols and modifications to the letter of information and informed consent related to the reported study were accepted by the same committee on May 17, 2005 and January 16, 2006. Specific information was given to patients, whose personal data are included in this paper and all signed and informed consent for publication.
This protocol involves a temporary immunosuppressive therapy with cyclosporin A stopped during the first year after bilateral grafting, azathioprin and prednisolone progressively decreased then stopped over the following months. The present study has been organized as an ancillary to the main trial. It concerned 13 patients (table 1), who had received foetal neural transplants in two successive stereotaxic neurosurgical sessions –first aiming at the right striatum, second at the left- three weeks to three months apart except in patient 2, in which a surgical complication (subdural hematoma) following the first graft precluded a second session.
Assessment protocols and imaging methods have been described in referenced studies , . As a potential source for subsequent controls, patient's blood and foetal donor tissue were systematically taken and kept frozen, as part of the original protocol. Up to now, it had never been necessary to study those samples, which were defrozen for the present analysis in all 13 patients. Search for anti-HLA I and II antibodies against foetal donor antigens were not part of the original protocol (but are now an approved addition). They were carried out on blood samples, and in one case cerebrospinal fluid (patient 3), using classical techniques.
Fourteen months after grafting, one patient (patient 3) started to exhibit general alteration of clinical status with weight loss of 22 kg over three months, worsened choreic movements lateralised to the left side, gait disorders and falls. Brain MRI showed an ongoing encephalitic process with vasogenic oedema, extending from the striatum to the frontal cortex mostly on the right side (Figure 1). Positron emission tomography with 18F-deoxyglucose revealed decreased metabolic activity in the same area of the right hemisphere (Figure 1), whereas striatal metabolism increased by about 50% on the left side, as commonly observed in the presence of functional grafts , .
Magnetic resonance imaging and metabolic activity using 18F-deoxyglucose before surgery (T0), during the rejection process (T1) and after 6 months of reinstated immunosuppressive treatment (T2) are shown separately (upper and middle panel, respectively), then co-registered (lower panel). The white arrow indicates the right striatum. The false colour scale shows levels of metabolic activities from lowest (min) to highest (max).
After ruling out an infection on the basis of the lack of alteration of blood cells count, a graft rejection was hypothesized. A humoral response was indeed documented with anti-HLA I –but not II– antibodies in the blood (6 out of 30, i.e. cytotoxicity equivalent to 20% for a panel of 30 total lymphocyte suspensions) and in the cerebrospinal fluid (2 out of 30, i.e. cytotoxicity equivalent to 7% of the panel tested). The antibodies (IgG) were specifically directed against A3 and A11 class I HLAs. Control assay in a serum sample frozen immediately before surgery was negative for HLA antibodies, indicating post-operative occurrence of the specific B lymphocyte response. Biological demonstration of alloimmunisation against the graft tissues was provided by haplotyping preserved frozen samples from the three foetuses used for grafting, with HLA-A*3 allele in the foetus grafted on the right side, HLA-A*11 in one of the two foetuses grafted in the left striatum.
Aggressive acute anti-inflammatory treatment associated to reinstatement of the original immunosuppressive regimen rapidly led to regression of MRI signs of encephalitis. General clinical status remained altered for 4 more months then recovered, the patient regaining more than half of her lost weight. Anti-HLA I antibodies disappeared from blood and CSF samples. After 7 months of treatment, chorea lessened back to pre-rejection levels, while gait disorders and falls disappeared. The patient regained more than half of the lost weight. PET scan imaging then revealed the presence in the right striatum of two areas of increased metabolic activity (Figure 1) as compared not only to the hypometabolic state observed during the rejection episode, but also to preoperative values. After coregistration with the MRI, both areas suggest the presence of neural grafts.
Alloimmunisation to donors' antigens was sought in 12 other MIG-HD grafted patients followed up different times beyond the end of the period of immunosuppressive treatment. Four of them demonstrated alloimmunisation to one of the donors although none displayed either clinical or radiological signs of an ongoing rejection process (patients 2, 4, 5 and 11; Table 1). No specific pattern of alteration of blood cells counts could be identified in successive assessments over time that would differentiate the five alloimmunised patients (including the one with the ongoing rejection process) and the seven non-immunised patients (see Data S1). Because a search of alloimmunisation to foetal donor antigens was not part of the MIG-HD protocol before the identification of the rejection case reported here, it was not possible to determine the time of occurrence of HLA antibodies in the blood. It is interesting to mention, however, that one of the four positive patients (patient 11) had been transplanted less than six months before analysis as this shows that the humoral response to allo-antigens may occur under full immunosuppressive treatment, although it disappeared at a later time point, like in patient 3.
The main result of our study is the demonstration that a large proportion of patients who received intracerebral foetal neural grafts exhibited biological signs of allo-immunisation to donors' antigens, in general a few months after interruption of the immunosuppressive treatment. In one patient, this was accompanied by overt clinical, radiological and biological signs of an ongoing immune rejection process; this process was, however, fully reversible under treatment. These results call for a reconsideration of results of previous foetal neural grafts trials in which a deleterious effect of potentially similar immune responses was not examined. They underline the need for careful follow up of patients and appropriate immunosuppressive treatment in future clinical trials.
Our results show that foetal neural cells grafted to the brain may provoke a humoral response as other organ transplants , with specific alloimmunisation to donors' antigens in a significant proportion of patients. The role of the humoral response has been extensively studied in the pathogenesis of acute or hyperacute vascular rejection, but is now also demonstrated in chronic rejection. The appearance of HLA antibodies after transplantation is associated, in kidney, pancreas, heart and lung transplantation with poor transplant outcome and the occurrence of both acute and chronic rejection (review in ). After kidney transplantation, the humoral response was generally detected before transplant failure , suggesting that HLA antibodies could be responsible for transplant dysfunction. Previous studies have found wide variations in the percentage of patients with HLA antibodies after kidney transplantation, ranging between 12 and 60%. Our results are, thus, well in keeping with those obtained in other organ transplants, indicating that the immunological privilege of the brain may not extend as much to the activation of a humoral response. There are, however, major differences between the consequences of that allo-immunisation in the brain as compared to other organs. It is worth noting, first, that the presence of anti-HLA antibodies was not accompanied in all except one of our cases by overt signs of graft rejection. Second, even in the one case in whom an ongoing rejection process was identified, full reversion of the deleterious process could be obtained under treatment, including a functional recovery of the graft. This, together with previous evidence in animals , , showing in particular that triggering of an immune response may not lead to complete tissue rejection even in the presence of physiological signs, points to the existence of specific features of an immune response in the brain.
Our results call for reconsideration of the results of past clinical trials with foetal neural grafts performed, for most of them, in patients with Parkinson's disease. To our knowledge, there has been no systematic follow up of possible immune responses to grafts up to now in those trials, and immunosuppressive regimens have been extremely diverse, ranging from a classical long term tri-therapy ,  down to no treatment altogether , with various intermediate situations comparable to the one used in this study [13,14]. What could have been the consequences of an inappropriate, or insufficiently maintained immunosuppressive regimen is but, at this point, a matter of speculation. Nevertheless, it is worth underlining the fact that at least in one large scale study a negative evolution of the results over time, following a first period of clinical improvement, was hypothetically related to the event of an otherwise undetermined immune response . Also possibly relevant to our data is the appearance of major dyskinetic adverse effects in the long term following grafting in patients with Parkinson's disease . Alloimmunisation to donors may indeed have contributed to those partially negative results and to the occurrence of delayed side-effects as, even in the absence of overt signs of a rejection process, effected neural grafts produce and elicit cytokine responses that may contribute to adverse functional effects observed in patients.
Our results clearly point to the fact that immune responses in the brain are complex, but cannot be ignored when it comes to repair strategies involving cellular transplants. New experimental studies are definitely needed in order to better comprehend and delineate the immunological privilege of the brain. The results of those experimental studies will allow us, in the future, to define more precisely the extent to which immunosuppressive regimens can be adapted to the specific case of intracerebral transplants. Until this redefinition is available, long term immunosuppressive treatment and thorough follow up of the immunological status of patients are likely indispensable.
Blood cell counts. First grafting session is set at Time 0. Other times are indicated in months in relation to it. Counts corresponding to periods of presence of anti-foetal HLA antibodies identified in the blood of the patients are in bold.
(0.27 MB DOC)
Pr Serge Blond in Lille, and Dr Stéphane Palfi in Créteil are gratefully acknowledged for performing all neurosurgical steps with patients included in this paper. The authors wish to thank Pr Jean-Paul Soulillou, Pr Jean-Paul Dessaint and Pr Michel Goldman for contributing to the analysis of the results. Principal investigator of the MIG-HD trial is Dr AC Bachoud-Lévi. Centres involved are : CHU Henri-Mondor Créteil, CHRU Lille, CHRU Angers, CHU Toulouse, CHU Nantes/Rennes, Hôpital Erasme Bruxelles.
Conceived and designed the experiments: MP PK PR AB. Performed the experiments: PK VG ML AB. Analyzed the data: MP VG ML AR PR AB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: AR. Wrote the paper: MP PK PR AB.
- 1. Barker RA, Widner H (2004) Immune problems in central nervous system cell therapy. NeuroRx. 1: 472–481.RA BarkerH. Widner2004Immune problems in central nervous system cell therapy.NeuroRx.1472481
- 2. Bachoud-Levi AC, Remy P, Nguyen JP, Brugieres P, Lefaucheur JP, et al. (2000) Motor and cognitive improvements in patients with Huntington's disease after neural transplantation. The Lancet 356: 1975–1979.AC Bachoud-LeviP. RemyJP NguyenP. BrugieresJP Lefaucheur2000Motor and cognitive improvements in patients with Huntington's disease after neural transplantation.The Lancet35619751979
- 3. Gaura V, Bachoud-Levi AC, Ribeiro MJ, Nguyen JP, Frouin V, et al. (2004) Striatal neural grafting improves cortical metabolism in Huntington's disease patients. Brain 127: 65–72.V. GauraAC Bachoud-LeviMJ RibeiroJP NguyenV. Frouin2004Striatal neural grafting improves cortical metabolism in Huntington's disease patients.Brain1276572
- 4. Bachoud-Levi AC, Gaura V, Brugieres P, Lefaucheur JP, Boisse MF, et al. (2006) Effect of fetal neural transplants in patients with Huntington's disease 6 years after surgery: a long-term follow-up study. Lancet Neurol. 5: 303–9.AC Bachoud-LeviV. GauraP. BrugieresJP LefaucheurMF Boisse2006Effect of fetal neural transplants in patients with Huntington's disease 6 years after surgery: a long-term follow-up study.Lancet Neurol.53039
- 5. Hourmant M, Cesbron-Gautier A, Terasaki PI, Mizutani K, Moreau A, et al. (2005) Frequency and clinical implications of development of donor-specific and non-donor-specific HLA antibodies after kidney transplantation. J Am Soc Nephrol 16: 2804–2812.M. HourmantA. Cesbron-GautierPI TerasakiK. MizutaniA. Moreau2005Frequency and clinical implications of development of donor-specific and non-donor-specific HLA antibodies after kidney transplantation.J Am Soc Nephrol1628042812
- 6. Mc Kenna RM, Takemoto S, Terasaki PI (2000) Anti-HLA antibodies after solid organ transplantation. Transplantation 69: 319–326.RM Mc KennaS. TakemotoPI Terasaki2000Anti-HLA antibodies after solid organ transplantation.Transplantation69319326
- 7. Lee PC, Terasaki PI, Takemoto SK, Lee PH, Hung CJ, et al. (2002) All chronic rejection failures of kidney transplants were preceded by the development of HLA antibodies. Transplantation 74: 1192–1194.PC LeePI TerasakiSK TakemotoPH LeeCJ Hung2002All chronic rejection failures of kidney transplants were preceded by the development of HLA antibodies.Transplantation7411921194
- 8. Hantraye P, Riche D, Maziere M, Isacson O (1992) Intrastriatal transplantation of cross-species fetal striatal cells reduces abnormal movements in a primate model of Huntington disease Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89: 4187–4191.P. HantrayeD. RicheM. MaziereO. Isacson1992Intrastriatal transplantation of cross-species fetal striatal cells reduces abnormal movements in a primate model of Huntington diseaseProc Natl Acad Sci USA8941874191
- 9. W Wood MJ, Charlton HM, Wood KJ, Kajiwara K, Byrnes AP (1996) Immune responses to adenovirus vectors in the nervous system. Trends Neurosci 19: 497–501.MJ W WoodHM CharltonKJ WoodK. KajiwaraAP Byrnes1996Immune responses to adenovirus vectors in the nervous system.Trends Neurosci19497501
- 10. Lindvall O, Sawle G, Widner H, Rothwell JC, Bjorklund A, et al. (1994) Evidence for long-term survival and function of dopaminergic grafts in progressive Parkinson's disease. Ann Neurol. 35: 172–80.O. LindvallG. SawleH. WidnerJC RothwellA. Bjorklund1994Evidence for long-term survival and function of dopaminergic grafts in progressive Parkinson's disease.Ann Neurol.3517280
- 11. Widner H, Tetrud J, Rehncrona S, Snow B, Brundin P, et al. (1992) Bilateral fetal mesencephalic grafting in two patients with parkinsonism induced by 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP) N Engl J Med. 327: 1556–63.H. WidnerJ. TetrudS. RehncronaB. SnowP. Brundin1992Bilateral fetal mesencephalic grafting in two patients with parkinsonism induced by 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP)N Engl J Med.327155663
- 12. Freed CR, Greene PE, Breeze RE, Tsai WY, DuMouchel W, et al. (2001) Transplantation of embryonic dopamine neurons for severe Parkinson's disease. New Eng J Med 344: 710–719.CR FreedPE GreeneRE BreezeWY TsaiW. DuMouchel2001Transplantation of embryonic dopamine neurons for severe Parkinson's disease.New Eng J Med344710719
- 13. Defer GL, Geny C, Ricolfi F, Fenelon G, Monfort JC, et al. (1994) Long-term outcome of unilaterally transplanted parkinsonian patients. I. Clinical approach. Brain. 119: 41–50.GL DeferC. GenyF. RicolfiG. FenelonJC Monfort1994Long-term outcome of unilaterally transplanted parkinsonian patients. I. Clinical approach. Brain.1194150
- 14. Olanow CW, Goetz CG, Kordower JH, Stoessl AJ, Sossi V, et al. (2003) A double-blind controlled trial of bilateral fetal nigral transplantation in Parkinson's disease. Ann Neurol. 54: 403–414.CW OlanowCG GoetzJH KordowerAJ StoesslV. Sossi2003A double-blind controlled trial of bilateral fetal nigral transplantation in Parkinson's disease.Ann Neurol.54403414