Partial reduction of Hsp90 increases expression of morphological novelty in qualitative traits of Drosophila and Arabidopsis, but the extent to which the Hsp90 chaperone also controls smaller and more likely adaptive changes in natural quantitative traits has been unclear. To determine the effect of Hsp90 on quantitative trait variability we deconstructed genetic, stochastic and environmental components of variation in Drosophila wing and bristle traits of genetically matched flies, differing only by Hsp90 loss-of-function or wild-type alleles. Unexpectedly, Hsp90 buffering was remarkably specific to certain normally invariant and highly discrete quantitative traits. Like the qualitative trait phenotypes controlled by Hsp90, highly discrete quantitative traits such as scutellor and thoracic bristle number are threshold traits. When tested across genotypes sampled from a wild population or in laboratory strains, the sensitivity of these traits to many types of variation was coordinately controlled, while continuously variable bristle types and wing size, and critically invariant left-right wing asymmetry, remained relatively unaffected. Although increased environmental variation and developmental noise would impede many types of selection response, in replicate populations in which Hsp90 was specifically impaired, heritability and ‘extrinsic evolvability’, the expected response to selection, were also markedly increased. However, despite the overall buffering effect of Hsp90 on variation in populations, for any particular individual or genotype in which Hsp90 was impaired, the size and direction of its effects were unpredictable. The trait and genetic-background dependence of Hsp90 effects and its remarkable bias toward invariant or canalized traits support the idea that traits evolve independent and trait-specific mechanisms of canalization and evolvability through their evolution of non-linearity and thresholds. Highly non-linear responses would buffer variation in Hsp90-dependent signaling over a wide range, while over a narrow range of signaling near trait thresholds become more variable with increasing probability of triggering all-or-none developmental responses.
Citation: Milton CC, Ulane CM, Rutherford S (2006) Control of Canalization and Evolvability by Hsp90. PLoS ONE 1(1): e75. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0000075
Academic Editor: Carl-Philipp Heisenberg, Max Planck Institute of Molecular Cell Biology and Genetics, Germany
Received: August 7, 2006; Accepted: September 10, 2006; Published: December 20, 2006
Copyright: © 2006 Milton et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by a Scholar Award of the Damon Runyon-Walter Winchel Foundation and by NIH R01 GM068873 (S.R.) and by the Australian Research Council (C.C.M.).
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The Hsp90 stress response protein is an ancient, abundant and nearly ubiquitous protein chaperone that supports an essential group of conserved signal transduction proteins in nearly every organism and cell type examined –. A minimal level of Hsp90 is required for cell viability, however signaling by Hsp90 substrates is sensitive to much smaller reductions of the chaperone—in heterozygous mutants that are fully viable and apparently normal, signaling through numerous Hsp90 target pathways is already reduced. For example, in highly inbred flies, heterozygous Hsp90 mutants dominantly enhance heterozygous or partial function mutations of Hsp90 targets and other genes in Hsp90-dependent pathways, revealing previously unexpressed developmental phenotypes , . In outbred populations, partial reduction of Hsp90 reveals natural genetic variation for many and varied developmental phenotypes , . The expression of Hsp90-buffered phenotypes in wild populations or laboratory strains of Drosophila likely depends on the chance segregation of multiple, previously undetected polymorphisms in a few Hsp90 targets and multiple non-target genes with indirect effects on Hsp90-dependent pathways (SR; in preparation).
A balance between Hsp90 buffering and the expression of morphological traits is most likely moderated in nature by environmental stress. Stress-damaged proteins titrate Hsp90 from signal transduction proteins; despite transcriptional induction of Hsp90 and other chaperones by the heat shock response, it is believed that severe stresses in nature can temporarily overwhelm the Hsp90 chaperone system , . Indeed, across diverse species, Hsp90 buffers widespread morphological variation or controls characteristic developmental transitions, for example altered morphologies in laboratory and wild populations of Drosophila  and Arabidopsis , cortical patterning in Tetrahymena , , developmental progression in fungi , , and metamorphosis in Leishmania parasites  and Ascidian embryos . Although there is evidence supporting the occurrence of phenotypes controlled by Hsp90 during laboratory heat shock ,  and by associated chaperones during heat stress in nature , the relevance of the Hsp90 for evolution remains challenged by allegations that morphological changes controlled by Hsp90 are unequivocally “monstrous”, and that Hsp90-buffered variation is “unconditionally deleterious” , –. The extent to which the Hsp90 chaperone also controls smaller and more-likely adaptive changes in natural quantitative traits has been unclear , .
Heritable variation with small effects on quantitative traits is widely believed to be the usual substrate of most evolutionary change. In Drosophila, the number and position of mechanosensory bristles, and wing size and shape are most likely optimized by natural selection –. While many quantitative traits are normally variable, the stereotypical placement and number of scutellar (SC) and thoracic (TH) bristles is conserved across fly species and nearly invariant within and between populations . As a result of their intra- and inter-specific invariance, SC and TH bristle numbers have been extensively studied models of canalization , , a developmental robustness to variation believed to have evolved through strong stabilizing selection against genetic and/or environmental perturbations of an optimum phenotype , . Current models of canalization suggest that genetic buffering occurs as a by-product of environmental canalization, which should evolve under stronger and more consistent selective pressure , . These models predict that genetic and environmental canalization would therefore share common mechanism(s) , –, but this idea has not been tested for any canalized trait and population. Since Hsp90 mediates the impacts of genetic variation and environmental stress, it is a logical candidate for a “common mechanism of canalization” . We previously reported that Hsp90 had no effect on measures of environmental canalization of several normally variable quantitative traits while at the same time, across the same set of flies, Hsp90 did control morphological variation of qualitative features specific to particular strain backgrounds, measures of genetic canalization . This suggested that genetic and environmental buffering by Hsp90 are separable. The dissociation of its role buffering genetic variation from the more obvious role of Hsp90 as a stress-response protein buffering environmental variation calls into question the mechanism by which genetic canalization evolves.
Here we dissect the relationship between Hsp90 buffering, genetic and non-genetic components of morphological variation, canalization and evolvability in a large set of quantitative traits across a controlled population of flies with well-defined genetic backgrounds. We now report that Hsp90 also had little effect on the phenotypic variability or evolvability of the normally variable wing and bristle traits. Unexpectedly, Hsp90 effects were remarkably specific to the most invariant quantitative traits showing that whether Hsp90-buffered traits are quantitative or qualitative, they are threshold traits with a continuous underlying distribution of genetic and environmental effects (liability) determining the probability that they would be variably expressed. Consistent with theoretical predictions for the evolution of genetic canalization, Hsp90 simultaneously buffered components of genetic, stochastic and environmental variation. Under low Hsp90, predicted responses to selection of Hsp90-buffered traits increased with increased expression of variation. We conclude that during unpredictable changes and stressful environmental changes in nature, partial reductions of Hsp90 would destabilize previously invariable or canalized threshold traits and transiently provide a random expression of previously invariable quantitative trait phenotypes upon which selection could act.
Experimental partition of genetic and non-genetic effects
We deconstructed the effect of Hsp90 on small variations in standard quantitative traits using genetically matched groups of F1 heterozygotes, differing only in whether they carried Hsp90 mutant (P582i) or control (Sami) alleles of Hsp90 on otherwise identical genetic backgrounds. Random differences in left-right symmetry, trait values among isogenic flies and genetic effects on trait means across wild backgrounds were used to parse developmental noise, micro-environmental and genetic variation. P582 is a marked P-element disruption of Hsp90 , which is not viable when homozygous and likely makes no Hsp90 protein . When heterozygous, P582 strongly reduces signaling through Hsp90-dependent pathways and uncovers previously cryptic morphogenic variation , , , . To ensure that Hsp90 mutant and control flies were isogenic, P582 was introduced into an extremely inbred and essentially homozygous wild background, Samarkand (Sam), by over 38 generations of backcrossing, introgression, and homogenization (creating P582i) . As shown in Figure 1, genetically identical mutant and control flies from the same maternal and vial environments were produced by crossing heterozygous P582i females to males from 9 highly inbred (>95% homozygous) Raleigh Inbred (RI) lines representing genotypes sampled at random from a wild population. To the extent that the Sam and RI lines were completely homozygous, the groups of F1 progeny were clones, hybrid for Sam and each RI line background, and differing only by Hsp90 allele.
Females heterozygous for P582i (Sam1;Sam2;P582i/Sami; left) were crossed to males from each of 9 highly inbred (95% homozygous) RI line backgrounds (different colors) to create matched “clones” of Hsp90 mutant and control male progeny from the same vial and maternal environments and hybrid for Sam and each RI line background.
To partition as cleanly as possible the effect of Hsp90 on genetic versus non-genetic variation, variation among the groups of 50 isogenic flies within each replicated genotype was used to measure the effect of Hsp90 on all sources of purely non-genetic variation (Ve ), and variation among the means of the RI line genotypes was used to measure its effect on genetic variation (VG ) from all sources of heritable variation segregating in the set of 9 RI line backgrounds. Total phenotypic variation (VP ) from the combined effects of genetic variation, environmental variation and developmental noise was derived from measurements on all 450 flies of every RI line genotype within each Hsp90 allele.
Phenotypic canalization and variability
There was a sharp distinction between the effects of Hsp90 on discrete quantitative traits, which usually do not vary between flies, and those that are naturally more variable. As shown previously, normally-variable wing and bristle traits were unaffected by Hsp90 . However, Hsp90 had highly significant and reproducible effects on total phenotypic variation (VP ) of scutellar (SC) and thoracic (TH) bristles (Fig. 2 and Tables 1 and 2), which are among the most invariant bristle traits in Drosophila, and have been previously studied models of canalization , . Twice as many Hsp90-mutant flies (P582i) had abnormal TH bristle numbers, and the severity of the TH bristle number defects increased from deviations of at most 2 TH bristles to as many as four. Even more striking, the number of flies with aberrant SC bristle numbers increased 4 to 5-fold in the Hsp90-mutants, from 8 control flies differing by a single SC bristle and clustered in a few RI line backgrounds, to 35 more severely abnormal P582i flies found multiply in every RI line background.
(A) Effects of P582i (yellow) and Sami (blue) alleles of Hsp90 in the isogenic Sam background on VP of mutant and control sets of 450 males across the 9 RI line backgrounds.
(B and C) Effects of 3rd chromosomes carrying null (P582), and dominant-negative (9J1) Hsp90 mutations or wild-type Sam alleles introgressed into the Sam background in mutant and control sets of 225 male or 225 female sibs.
TM6B contains the dominant Humeral (Hu) mutation , which increases humeral TH bristle numbers.
Therefore, for comparison of TH bristles between TM6B and the other genotypes we used TH-HU, indicating that TH was scored only for the remaining 18 non-humeral TH bristle types.
All experiments were conducted under temperature, density and humidity controlled conditions.
Environmental effects were further controlled by direct comparisons between flies from the same vial and maternal environments.
Coefficients of variation (CV = standard deviation/mean) are shown to enable between-trait comparisons. Statistical tests of the significance of Hsp90 effects on phenotypic variability and P-values are found in Table 1 (for A) and Table 2 (for B and C).
The specificity of Hsp90 toward the most invariant bristle traits did not depend on the particular Hsp90 allele or on the specific genetic background. When genetically outbred, wild-type flies were fed the Hsp90 inhibitor geldanamycin as 2nd or 3rd instar larvae, CV SC increased from 0, e.g. no abnormal flies among 100 flies tested, to 0.025 (P = 0.043 by Levine's test) and CV TH increased from 0.010 to 0.026 (P<0.0001). Phenotypic variation in the other, more variable traits was unaffected by geldanamycin . In a third experiment (Table 2), variation in SC, TH and OR was similarly increased by either loss-of-function (P582) or dominant negative (9J1) alleles of Hsp90 in the context of cloned 3rd chromosomes compared with wild-type alleles of Hsp90 on Sam or balancer (TM6B) 3rd chromosomes. Across the set of RI lines in the inbred Sam background flies had genotypes differing by the Hsp90 allele and third chromosomes (more than 1/3 of the genome). Interestingly, as reported for morphological traits , , the specific effect of Hsp90 on any inbred RI line depended on genetic background (highly significant Hsp90 X RI line interactions; Table 3). As has been generally proposed for canalized traits , these studies suggest that Hsp90 controls variability—the capacity to vary , through multiple genetic interactions (molecular epistasis) with its chaperone targets and through them, other polymorphic genes.
Developmental noise and micro-environmental variation
To ask whether Hsp90 also controlled components of environmental canalization, we measured its effect on two sources of non-genetic variation in the same set of wing and bristle traits in the same groups of P582i mutant and Sami control flies. Developmental noise (Ve within) results in stochastic perturbations of identical left and right features as they develop within single flies of the same genotype and environment. To estimate Ve within for each RI line, we averaged left-right measures of developmental noise [(L−R)/(L+R/2)] over the groups of 50 isogenic flies within each RI line background (mean fluctuating asymmetry , ). Purely environmental variation (Ve among ), unique to the micro-environments of individual flies, was measured directly as variation in each trait (L+R) among the same groups of flies.
When either measure of Ve was normalized by the mean trait value for each RI line background, the difference between the more variable and the invariant traits was striking (Fig. 3; compare left to right). While Ve within or Ve among was up to 10% of the mean of the normally variable OC, SP and VB bristle numbers, they were at least 10–100 fold lower for the most invariant traits (SC, TH, WC). Interestingly, either measure of Ve for WC was tightly controlled independent of Hsp90, while both forms of non-genetic variation in SC and TH were sharply increased in the Hsp90 mutants (P582i; Table 4). For SC and TH, Hsp90 simultaneously buffered quantitative variation specific to genetic backgrounds and variation from non-genetic (stochastic) developmental and environmental effects, suggesting that for particular traits, Hsp90 buffering provides a shared mechanism of genetic and environmental canalization. However, the curious trait-specificity and genetic-background dependence of Hsp90 effects is inconsistent with Hsp90 having evolved as a “canalization gene”, but suggests instead that traits evolve (or simply acquire, unselected), trait-specific and independent mechanisms buffering genetic and environmental variation. By promoting the activity of many developmental regulators, Hsp90 may simply be positioned as a passive regulator of interactions between multiple developmental pathways and competing genetic and environmental effects.
Comparison of mean-normalized components of purely-environmental variation (z-axis) across the RI line backgrounds (x-axis).
Developmental stability was calculated as the averaged (unsigned) deviations of left and right from the mean, i.e. (L+R)/2, within each individual (Ve within) or on the averaged (unsigned) deviations of each individual (L+R) from their clone means for each RI line genotype (Ve among).
There was generally no effect of Hsp90 allele (Sami, blue or P582i, yellow) on the variable traits, and a highly significant effect on either measure of Ve for canalized bristle traits but not wing area, which was highly canalized independent of Hsp90 (Table 4).
‘Extrinsic evolvability’, selection response
Since Hsp90 controlled sources of environmental variation (Ve ) and genetic variation manifest as strain-dependent effects (VGXG ), we wondered whether quantitative changes controlled by Hsp90, if favorable, could respond effectively to selection. For example, non-genetic sources of variation such as Ve within and Ve among cannot contribute to evolution, and should impede the response to many types of selection. To predict Hsp90 effects on ‘extrinsic evolvability’ , , we calculated the expected selection response for each of the 7 traits in the synthetic “population” of 9 RI line backgrounds, using each traits' total phenotypic (VP ) and genetic (VG ) components of variation and under any of three models of selection. For 6 of the 7 traits, all estimates of evolvability were higher in P582i mutant population than in the wild-type control population (Table 5). However, while this suggested WC and OR were 1.5 to 2 fold more likely to respond to selection, much more striking, previously invariant SC and TH bristle numbers were potentially as much as 14-fold more evolvable under some models of selection (Fig. 4). Despite the overall increase in random and purely non-genetic effects among the Hsp90 mutant flies, when previously invariable SC or TH bristle numbers were destabilized, they became simultaneously sensitized to the effects of multiple types of variation and their predicted responses to selection were also dramatically increased.
Fold-increase in the predicted response to truncation, directional or stabilizing selection of the ‘populations’ of 9 RI line genotypes in the P582i mutant relative to equivalent ‘populations’ of genotypes in the Sami control flies (Table 5).
Dominance variation, and variation resulting from the possible sensitivity of Hsp90-mutant flies to shared environmental effects would have confounded our estimates of extrinsic evolvability. To test the effect of Hsp90 on evolvability directly, we measured the response of SC bristle number to artificial selection. To get flies with abnormal SC bristles we raised a wild-type lab strain of flies (Canton-S) for one generation on media containing the Hsp90 inhibitor geldanamycin (GA). Parents with varying numbers of SC bristles were selected and crossed in groups of increasing mean SC bristle number. Their offspring were split during early larval stages into replicates raised on media with or without GA. Not surprisingly, without inhibitor the averaged SC phenotype of control flies followed the increasing SC bristle numbers of their parents, showing that although SC bristle numbers do not normally vary and could not be selected, populations still carry cryptic variation for this trait . Realized heritability (h2 ), a measure of additive genetic variation (VA ) contributing to the selection response, was reflected in the positive regression of offspring onto parental bristle number (Table 6). An abundance of VA affecting even normally-invariant or canalized traits is suggested by the ubiquity of “genetic background effects” and by the abundance of specific enhancers and suppressors of major developmental mutations . In early experiments used to demonstrate canalization, mutations or environmental perturbations initially reveal abnormalities and specifically document cryptic variation contributing to selection response , , . Indeed, extensive work by Rendel provides rigorous evidence for cryptic genetic variation and buffering of SC variation at even numbers of bristles by successive developmental thresholds .
Contrary to the simple expectation that reduction of Hsp90 by GA would increase the heritability and response to selection of SC bristle number, we found that in our inbred Canton-S stock, the selection response of offspring to increasing parental SC bristle numbers was completely abolished in the replicates raised on the Hsp90 inhibitor. The slope of the response and h2 were not different than 0 (Table 6). This surprising result was not simply an artifact of increased non-genetic variation among flies raised on GA. We found that in the Canton-S genetic background, GA decreased rather than increased phenotypic variation in SC (CV−GA = 0.053, CV+GA = 0.035; Bartlette's P = 0.0057, Levine's P = 0.4083). Even more surprising, the offspring of parents with 4 SC bristles had a higher number of SC bristes, regardless of GA treatment. Alleles causing extra SC bristles were therefore already segregating in our Canton-S stock. Indeed, when we examined untreated Canton-S flies, 9/197 (∼4.6%) had extra SC bristles due to variation that likely accumulated from the combined effects of loss of selective pressure, inbreeding and drift under standard conditions of laboratory propagation in vials.
Variation for abnormal SC was not restricted to potentially deleterious alleles accumulated in the unnatural environment of the lab. A strain dependence for the direction of Hsp90 effects on SC was also seen in one of the wild RI line backgrounds. In the RI-27 heterozygotes, the proportion of flies with abnormal SC numbers (in this case, 3 SC) was also higher in the Hsp90 wild-type background (Fig. 3; Sami; 10% abnormal; CV = 0.078). Similarly, when Hsp90 was mutant in RI-27 heterozygotes, the number of flies with abnormalities, and all forms of SC bristle variation, were simultaneously decreased (P582i; 2% abnormal; CV = 0.035; Levine's P = 0.0005). Interestingly, contradictory and strain-dependent effects on trait variability were described in classic studies of Drosophila wing vein canalization . Heat shock during a particular window of development normally produced flies with a crossveinless phenotype. However, rare strains have a high frequency of flies expressing crossveinless abnormalities, which were inexplicably reduced by heat treatment.
Threshold model of Hsp90-buffered variation
Well-characterized mechanisms of bristle development together with known Hsp90 biochemistry and standard quantitative genetic theory provide a coherent model encompassing the confusing, contradictory and strain dependent effects of Hsp90 within classical theory of threshold traits. An across-the-boards reduction of signal transduction resulting from Hsp90 mutation (or heat stress) would exacerbate the phenotypic effects of signaling weakened by the chance accumulation of reduced-function polymorphisms. But the same Hsp90-dependent reduction in signaling could also bring overactive signaling back down into the normal ranges, ameliorating the effects of a chance accumulation of activating polymorphisms. For example, in inbred lab strains, depending on genetic context the same Hsp90 alleles both enhance heterozygous loss-of-function mutations in other pathway components, exposing developmental phenotypes , and suppress over-expression phenotypes of dominant activating mutations in the same pathways, restoring normal phenotypes . Our data now suggest Hsp90 has similar effects on natural variation in the developmental pathways underlying quantitative traits.
Classical threshold trait models posit unseen distributions of cryptic genetic and environmental effects contributing to the probability of expressing discrete traits such as deformity or disease. To compare unseen distributions of continuous variation in the strength of SC bristle signaling in Hsp90 mutant and wild-type populations of RI line genotypes, we modeled SC as a classical threshold trait. Using the observed frequencies of flies with abnormal SC bristle numbers (SC = 2, 3, 5) in P582i mutant and Sami populations and a set of simple assumptions consistent with Hsp90 biochemistry and current understanding of bristle development, we determined inferred distributions of liability for abnormal SC numbers in each population. For example, we reasoned that a reduction in SC bristles could be caused by either abnormally low levels of proneural signaling or by abnormally high levels of inhibitory signaling , . As shown in Figure 5, under the simple assumptions of the threshold model, the distribution of hidden variation in the strength of SC signaling through combined proneural and lateral inhibition pathways (liability for abnormal bristle numbers) was shifted more than 2 1/2 SD units to the left in the P582i mutant flies. Indeed, threshold models featuring hidden distributions of genetic and/or environmental effects are the only way to describe the inheritance of highly discrete polygenic traits within the framework of standard quantitative genetics , , . As shown here, these threshold models resolve the apparently contradictory effects of Hsp90 buffering (or heat stress ) on discrete traits such as SC bristle number and provide a coherent theoretical basis for Hsp90 effects on phenotypic variation.
A threshold trait model was applied the effect of Hsp90 on signalling pathways underlying SC bristle development with assumptions based on current understanding of bristle development and Hsp90 function , .
The positions of upper and lower thresholds were estimated for P582i and Sami populations, which differed by the presence of wild-type (Sami) or heterozygous mutant (P582i) levels of Hsp90 in otherwise nearly identical genetic backgrounds (N = 450 flies each).
A consistent, but arbitrary, standard deviation (SD) scale was inferred from the frequency of abnormal flies in the P582i background, which had the highest frequencies of abnormal flies.
SC was canalized at 4 over a range of from 5 1/2 to 6 1/2 SD. On the same scale, we estimate that the P582i mutation decreased the strength of proneural and inhibitory bristle development pathways, shifting signalling across the population >2.5 SD to the left relative to fixed upper and lower thresholds.
Is Hsp90 a “canalization gene”?
The remarkable selectivity of Hsp90 for invariant (or canalized) features of both qualitative and quantitative traits is a surprising and previously unrecognized property of Hsp90 buffering, providing an organic distinction between the biological control of variation of normally invariant quantitative and qualitative traits on the one hand, and control of more naturally variable quantitative (or life history ) traits on the other. This distinction transcends an historical dichotomy between quantitative and qualitative traits, and is consistent with Waddington's original restriction of canalized traits to those with discrete developmental outputs  (e.g. qualitative morphologies and invariant (discrete) quantitative traits such as SC and TH ). Specific genetic mechanisms of canalization are implicit in the definition of canalization as an evolved feature of development. But is Hsp90 a “canalization gene” as has been suggested , . Did the Hsp90 chaperone system evolve to prevent the expression of abnormal phenotypes?
Stabilizing selection for an optimum intermediate phenotype would select against individuals with reduced genetic and environmental buffering. However, despite the fact that Hsp90 buffers developmental variation, the idea that Hsp90 chaperone and co-chaperone interactions with nearly 200 different signalling proteins evolved because of selection for canalization of development is hard to understand based on any known molecular mechanism, and difficult to reconcile with the trait-specificity and contradictory genetic background effects of Hsp90 we report here. The specificity of Hsp90 buffering for the most invariant (or canalized) features is suggestive of a general canalization gene, but for some traits in certain genetic backgrounds Hsp90 supported rather than masked abnormal phenotypes, which were more normal and less variable when Hsp90 was mutant or reduced by drug. And at least one highly invariant trait, left-right asymmetry in wing area, was tightly buffered independent of Hsp90.
It is also difficult to imagine how evolutionary recruitment of Hsp90 to particular components of a wide range of signalling pathways would increase developmental robustness or reduce variability. Hsp90 almost certainly originated as a chaperone for general protein folding and stability, and it seems much more likely it was later co-opted for the benefits of regulated signal transduction rather than because of selection for developmental stability. Hsp90 stabilization of immature and inactive signal transducers would allow previously constitutive signalling proteins to be held in late stage folding by the Hsp90 chaperone complex, poised until association with ligand or other proteins complete their maturation, folding and activation. Indeed, conformational changes associated with activation usually stabilize and “mature” Hsp90 targets, completing their folding . It seems much more likely that robustness against genetic and environmental variation emerge or evolve on a trait-by-trait basis. Many genes buffer genetic variation through extensive epistatic interactions ; it is long established that the phenotypes of developmental mutations are more variable than the wild-type . Hsp90 is repeatedly identified as a component of these same signalling pathways by genetic interaction screens. As a player in multiple pathways controlling many morphological features, one could predict that Hsp90 would control the variability of many different adult phenotypes, which become more variable as Hsp90 (and Hsp90 target function) is reduced.
Development can be thought of as a series of discrete decisions, integrating continuous input from numerous sources and translating them into all-or-none commitments. This digitization may be a key to the high fidelity and robustness of development in the face of noisy inputs from random environmental disturbances and genetic variation. As noted by Waddington, cells and tissues rarely get stuck in intermediate forms, but choose between alternate types suggestive of all-or-none switches . Robustness against genetic and environmental perturbation is not a property of any single gene, but is an emergent property resulting from the topology of connections between interacting genes. Genetic circuit properties that convert continuous responses into all-or-none events are increasingly well understood. For example, biological switches have been modelled mathematically , , discussed theoretically  and, more recently, synthesized in bacteria based on first principles , . Mitogen activated protein kinase (MAPK) pathways are Hsp90-dependent, and their non-linear kinetics are particularly well-studied , , . The MAPK phosphorelay system consists of three kinases in a linear pathway. Modelling MAPK pathway upstream inputs and downstream response using basic Michaelis-Menton kinetics describes increasing non-linearity (Hill coefficient) of the downstream response with successive addition of intervening kinases . Indeed, inflection points of sigmoidal responses of phenotype to continuous variation in the strength of underlying signals are a form of threshold.
We suggest that a defining feature of many Hsp90-dependent pathways may be they govern switch-like developmental decisions such as cell-fate or tissue-type specification. By definition, these non-linear developmental responses are insensitive (canalized) a wide range of input (Fig. 6). Selective pressure to buffer morphological variability in response to continuously varying developmental signals would favour the evolution of non-linearity and trait thresholds, which could occur relatively simply by chance addition of regulatory or positive feedback connections. But regardless of whether developmental stability and the digitization of development are selected adaptations, emerge as unselected by-products of genetic redundancy or are an unavoidable feature of the architecture of developmental networks, non-linearity of Hsp90-dependent pathways such as MAPK would both enable and explain Hsp90 control of phenotypic variability and canalization.
A simple consequence of steep non-linearity is that sensitivity to all kinds of perturbation and stochastic effects is expected to be highest at the inflection point (second panel from bottom).
This simple relationship between sensitivity to variation and the steepness of the signaling-phenotype relationship at the inflection point, the inverse of canalization (bottom panel), suggests why all variation increases in concert for individuals and/or populations near trait thresholds.
Materials and Methods
Strain construction and inhibitor study
The strains used in this study and geldanamycin treatments have been described . To isolate the allelic effects of Hsp90 on quantitative trait variation independent of the effects of differing genetic backgrounds in mutant and control lines, we constructed highly isogenic Hsp90 mutant (P582i) and control (Sami) strains. A marked P-element allele of Hsp90 (P582) was introgressed into the extremely isogenic background Samarkand (Sam; kindly provided by T.F.C. Mackay). Sam was completely homozygous at nearly 100 350–500 bp sites sampled randomly across the 2nd and 3rd chromosomes (>30 Kb; S.R. unpublished). Based on more than 35 generations of backcrossing and homogenization, we estimated that less than 5 cM of the original P582 background would flank the P-element insertion site. To produce matched sets of mutant and control flies, heterozygous P582i females were crossed to males from 9 highly inbred (>95% homozygous) Raleigh Inbred (RI) lines representing genotypes sampled at random from a wild population . To control environmental variation, the F1 progeny were picked as 2nd instar larvae and raised in 5 replicated density, temperature (25°C.) and humidity controlled vials, after which 10 males per vial were selected at random and scored for bristle and wing features.
To study the effects of additional, unmarked alleles of Hsp90, entire Hsp90 mutant 3rd chromosomes were crossed into the standard Sam background with over 10 generations of backcrossing . Virgins heterozygous for either dominant negative (9J1) or null (P582) alleles balanced over TM6B in the Sam background (Sam1;Sam2;9J1/TM6B or Sam1;Sam2;P582/TM6B) were crossed to males from each RI line background. 5 flies of each sex were scored from each of 5 density, temperature, and humidity controlled replicate vials as described above. The TM6B controls and Hsp90 mutant sibs were from the same vials, reducing environmental and maternal effects. The experiment to test the effect of the Sam 3rd chromosome against each RI line background (Sam1;Sam2;Sam3 virgins X RI line males) was done separately. As TM6B contains the dominant Humeral (Hu) mutation , which increases humeral TH bristle numbers, TH-HU was used for comparison of TH bristles between TM6B and the other genotypes, indicating that TH was scored only for the remaining 18 non-humeral TH bristle types.
In experiments testing the effects of reduced Hsp90 on wild-type backgrounds Hsp90 was inhibited by geldanamycin. An outbred laboratory population of Canton-S flies, which had been maintained for several years in population cages to maintain a high effective population size (Ne ), was fed geldanamycin as 2nd or 3rd instar larvae. Adult flies were subsequently scored for quantitative wing and bristle traits. In the selection response experiment, a small and apparently inbred, laboratory stock of Canton-S. This strain had been maintained for many years under standard maintenance conditions in vials. Flies were raised on media containing 1 mg/ml geldanamycin. To measure the selection response, flies were collected as 0–72 hour embryos and split during early larval stages into replicates raised on media with or without geldanamycin, and adults were analyzed for SC bristle number.
Selection of dfe flies
The estsablishment of the deformed-eye (dfe) selection has been described previously . Briefly, among the F1 progeny of cross between a heterozygous Hsp90 mutants (19F2; ) and another lab strain we found a single heterozygous male (19F2/+) with eye deformity. That male was selected and crossed to 3–4 related, heterozygous females from the same F1 population, yielding several more flies with eye deformities in the F2 . By generation 4 numbers of dfe flies to found 3 related, but independent selection lines (high and low eye penetrance lines HE1–3 and LE1–3 ). Each generation, dfe flies were selected and crossed together and a similar number of related normal sibs were selected and crossed together to found high and low selection lines. With successive generations the dfe penetrance (fraction affect progeny) increased among the high lines, to the point that sufficient dfe polymorphisms were present that the trait no longer depended on Hsp90 reduction. The 19F2 allele, which was apparently deleterious even in heterozygous state, was coincidently lost. By generation 15, none of the flies from either high or low lines carried an Hsp90 mutation . Generation times were kept long in these lines by successive passaging of flies. Fitness tests were initiated on stocks isogenized from flies in generation F42 of selection.
Bristle traits SC, TH, SP, OR, OC and VB were scored on the left and right sides of each fly, after which wings were removed and photographed. Wing centroid (WC) is an overall measure of size. WC was determined from the exact positions of eight junctions of longitudinal veins with crossveins or wing margins. Trait means, standard deviations and coefficients of variation (CV = standard deviation/mean) were used to compare phenotypic variation among flies across all 9 RI lines between traits. Since equal numbers of flies from each cross and genotype were scored, we followed a balanced design for data analysis. For the P582i/RI experiment, Hsp90 mutant effects were compared in matched sets of sibs from the same vial/maternal environment but carrying a wild-type allele of Hsp90. For the P582 and 9J1 experiment, Hsp90 mutant effects were compared to wild-type alleles of Hsp90 on the TM6B balancer chromosome or the Sam 3rd chromosome. In this experiment the genetic backgrounds of the Hsp90 mutants and Sam controls differed by nearly 1/3rd of their genomes.
To measure the Hsp90-genetic background interaction effects, weighted ANOVAs were used to control for heteroscadacity, particularly in the distributions of the more discrete bristle types (SAS software, SAS Institute, Raleigh, NC). The effect of the P582i and Sami alleles of Hsp90, RI lines and their interaction on wing size and bristle traits were compared among the groups of 50 isogenic flies in each of the 9 RI line backgrounds. P-values were corrected for multiple comparisons using the Bonferroni correction.
Developmental noise and micro-environmental variation were analyzed in the P582i experiment. Developmental noise (Ve within), defined for each fly as the average unsigned deviation of left and right features from their mean within each individual or (|L-mi |/mi +|R-mi |/mi )/2 where mi = (L+R)/2, is equivalent to fluctuating asymmetry (FA = |L-R|/mi ) averaged over the mean values for each group of 50 isogenic flies from each RI line background. Microenvironmental variation (Ve among) was defined as the unsigned deviation of L+R traits of each fly from its clone mean (mc ). Because most flies were symmetric for left and right bristle number, measures of Ve within for all bristle traits were highly discrete. Allelic effects for Ve within were compared using the Mantel-Haensel (M-H) test of differences in the size of symmetrical and non-symmetrical classes between groups of P582i and control (Sami) flies. The trait distributions of the most invariant bristle types, SC, TH and OR were also highly discrete, and were analyzed using non-parametric M-H tests. However, for most comparisons, ANOVA gave qualitatively similar results. WC was fully continuous and testable only by ANOVA. P-values were corrected for multiple comparisons.
The effect of wild-type and mutant alleles of Hsp90 on the expected response to selection of the population of 9 RI line genotypes was approximated using observed components of genetic and environmental variation in the P582i experiment, and according to methods described by Houle . Broad sense heritability (H2 ) and total genetic variation (VG ) were substituted for realized heritability (h2 ) in these approximations, would have unpredictable effects on the exact approximations obtained. However, the size and consistency of the effects of Hsp90 allele, and an effect of Hsp90 on additive variation and realized heritability demonstrated by response to artificial selection confirm the overall conclusions. The effect of Hsp90 on h2 and VA for qualitative traits was confirmed previously , and an effect of Hsp90 on h2 and VA of SC was calculated from the slope of the regression of the mean offspring values from sets of parents of increasing mean scutellar bristle number using offspring estimates of mean SC from crosses which had >20 F1 progeny.
Thresholds for expression of abnormal SC bristle numbers were modeled based on known Hsp90 genetics and biochemistry, bristle development pathways and a set of simple assumptions of threshold trait models:
1) Loss-of-function mutations are generally recessive to wild-type alleles. We followed Rendel  in assuming that wild-type populations are closer to upper thresholds. In our case, the upper threshold was explicitly defined by line RI-27. (By contrast with any other RI line, RI-27 had significantly more abnormal flies in the Sami background than in P582i mutants.) For nearly every known Hsp90 target, reduction of Hsp90 decreases the activity of its substrate proteins , . For these reasons, we placed the P582i distribution to the left of the Sami distribution, indicating that the P582i population had reduced overall levels of signaling.
2) Bristle patterning in Drosophila is accomplished by a complex network of proneural signalling and lateral inhibition, with opposing effects on bristle number . Decreased proneural function beyond a lower threshold reduces bristle number, decreased lateral inhibition increases bristle number, and over-activation of either process would have the opposite effect. Liability for abnormal bristles is a function combining opposing signals through these pathways.
4) To put the distributions on the same scale required that we assume that the SD of both Sami and P582i distributions were equal . As shown by our data this is not a correct assumption. However, if we included the increased variance of the P582i population in the model, the calculated shift in distributions would be greater than the shift seen here. Therefore we have estimated a minimum bound for Hsp90 effects.
5) The order of thresholds was determined by the relative frequencies of each SC bristle class (2,3,4,5) initially on a standard normal distribution (m = 0, SD = 1) with the most likely classes being closest to normal (4SC).
6) We assumed that the means of each RI line distribution in Sami would be shifted left by similar amounts by the P582i mutant. Inverse probability densities were calculated using http://davidmlane.com/hyperstat/z_table.html. In the Sami background most RI lines had no abnormal flies; 5/450 flies had 3 SC (0.0111; all in line RI-27), and 3/450 flies had 5 SC (0.0067). In the P582i population across 9 RI lines 19/450 flies (0.0422) had 3 SC bristles, 12/450 had 5 SC (0.0267) and 3/450 had 2 SC (0.0067).
The order of thresholds, determined by the relative frequencies of each SC bristle class (2,3,4,5) was initially based on standard normal distributions (m = 0, SD = 1) with the most likely classes being closest to normal (4SC). The lowest (rightmost) threshold was defined with 2 at the rightmost position next to 5 (2|5; −2.473), the second lowest (5|3; −1.833), and the third threshold for the most frequent aberrant bristle class (3) was adjacent to normal (3|4; −1.435). Using methods described by Wright , we arbitrarily converted the distance between the 2|5 and 3|4 thresholds to 1 SD unit by converting the SD of the P582i distribution to (1/distance between old thresholds) and calculating the positions of the new, SD-normalized thresholds (the products of the previous thresholds and the new SD = 0.9634) . We next placed the wild-type (Sami) distribution on the same scale, with the mean of the lower distribution (P582i) still arbitrarily set to 0. The mean of the Sami distribution (N = 450) was determined using three different methods based on different assumptions. First, the 3 RI line/Sami distributions (N = 50) that had abnormal flies presumably beyond an upper threshold (in Sami) and below the lower threshold (in P582i). We determined the expected means of each RI line distribution in Sami and P582i based on frequencies of normal (4SC) flies in Sami on the lower 3|4 threshold and in P582i on the upper 4|3 threshold. We then calculated on the SD scale, the average shift left of each distribution resulting from the P582i allele. Averaging the means of the 9 RI line/Sami distributions set the mean shown for the global Sami distribution (N = 450) at 2.47, allowing upper (rightmost) thresholds for the Sami distribution to be calculated by probit analysis (4|3, 4.495; 3|5, 4.554). Three different methods for determining the upper threshold geldanamycin gave similar results: from 2 (assuming that the frequency of abnormal flies beyond the lower threshold in the Sami distribution was<0.001) to 2.2 assuming that only the abnormal flies in RI-27 were beyond the upper threshold in the Sami background), to 2.47 as determined above.
Thanks to Elizabeth Housworth for statistical advice and to Andy Clark, Joe Felsenstein and several anonymous referees for their careful readings of several versions of this manuscript.
Conceived and designed the experiments: SR CM CC. Performed the experiments: SR KG CM CC CU. Analyzed the data: SR CM CC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SR. Wrote the paper: SR.
- 1. Richter K, Buchner J (2001) Hsp90: chaperoning signal transduction. J Cell Physiol 188: 281–290.K. RichterJ. Buchner2001Hsp90: chaperoning signal transduction.J Cell Physiol188281290
- 2. Nollen EA, Morimoto RI (2002) Chaperoning signaling pathways: molecular chaperones as stress-sensing ‘heat shock’ proteins. J Cell Sci 115: 2809–2816.EA NollenRI Morimoto2002Chaperoning signaling pathways: molecular chaperones as stress-sensing ‘heat shock’ proteins.J Cell Sci11528092816
- 3. Rutherford SL, Zuker CS (1994) Protein folding and the regulation of signaling pathways. Cell 79: 1129–1132.SL RutherfordCS Zuker1994Protein folding and the regulation of signaling pathways.Cell7911291132
- 4. Picard D, Khursheed B, Garabedian M, Fortin M, Lindquist S, et al. (1990) Reduced levels of hsp90 compromise steroid receptor action in vivo. Nature 348: 166–168.D. PicardB. KhursheedM. GarabedianM. FortinS. Lindquist1990Reduced levels of hsp90 compromise steroid receptor action in vivo.Nature348166168
- 5. Cutforth T, Rubin GM (1994) Mutations in Hsp83 and cdc37 impair signaling by the sevenless receptor tyrosine kinase in Drosophila. Cell 77: 1027–1036.T. CutforthGM Rubin1994Mutations in Hsp83 and cdc37 impair signaling by the sevenless receptor tyrosine kinase in Drosophila.Cell7710271036
- 6. Rutherford SL, Lindquist S (1998) Hsp90 as a capacitor for morphological evolution. Nature 396: 336–342.SL RutherfordS. Lindquist1998Hsp90 as a capacitor for morphological evolution.Nature396336342
- 7. Queitsch C, Sangster TA, Lindquist S (2002) Hsp90 as a capacitor of phenotypic variation. Nature 417: 618–624.C. QueitschTA SangsterS. Lindquist2002Hsp90 as a capacitor of phenotypic variation.Nature417618624
- 8. Roberts SP, Feder ME (1999) Natural hyperthermia and expression of the heat shock protein Hsp70 affect developmental abnormalities in Drosophila melanogaster. Oecologia 121: 323–329.SP RobertsME Feder1999Natural hyperthermia and expression of the heat shock protein Hsp70 affect developmental abnormalities in Drosophila melanogaster.Oecologia121323329
- 9. Frankel J, Nelsen EM (2001) The effects of supraoptimal temperatures on population growth and cortical patterning in Tetrahymena pyriformis and Tetrahymena thermophila: a comparison. J Eukaryot Microbiol 48: 135–146.J. FrankelEM Nelsen2001The effects of supraoptimal temperatures on population growth and cortical patterning in Tetrahymena pyriformis and Tetrahymena thermophila: a comparison.J Eukaryot Microbiol48135146
- 10. Frankel J, Williams NE, Nelsen EM, Keeling PJ (2001) An evaluation of Hsp90 as a mediator of cortical patterning in Tetrahymena. J Eukaryot Microbiol 48: 147–160.J. FrankelNE WilliamsEM NelsenPJ Keeling2001An evaluation of Hsp90 as a mediator of cortical patterning in Tetrahymena.J Eukaryot Microbiol48147160
- 11. Loubradou G, Begueret J, Turcq B (1997) A mutation in an HSP90 gene affects the sexual cycle and suppresses vegetative incompatibility in the fungus Podospora anserina. Genetics 147: 581–588.G. LoubradouJ. BegueretB. Turcq1997A mutation in an HSP90 gene affects the sexual cycle and suppresses vegetative incompatibility in the fungus Podospora anserina.Genetics147581588
- 12. Loubradou G, Begueret J, Turcq B (1999) MOD-D, a Galpha subunit of the fungus Podospora anserina, is involved in both regulation of development and vegetative incompatibility. Genetics 152: 519–528.G. LoubradouJ. BegueretB. Turcq1999MOD-D, a Galpha subunit of the fungus Podospora anserina, is involved in both regulation of development and vegetative incompatibility.Genetics152519528
- 13. Wiesgigl M, Clos J (2001) Heat shock protein 90 homeostasis controls stage differentiation in Leishmania donovani. Mol Biol Cell 12: 3307–3316.M. WiesgiglJ. Clos2001Heat shock protein 90 homeostasis controls stage differentiation in Leishmania donovani.Mol Biol Cell1233073316
- 14. Bishop CD, Bates WR, Brandhorst BP (2002) HSP90 function is required for morphogenesis in ascidian and echinoid embryos. Dev Genes Evol 212: 70–80.CD BishopWR BatesBP Brandhorst2002HSP90 function is required for morphogenesis in ascidian and echinoid embryos.Dev Genes Evol2127080
- 15. Wagner GP, Chiu CH, Hansen TF (1999) Is Hsp90 a regulator of evolvability? J Exp Zool 285: 116–118.GP WagnerCH ChiuTF Hansen1999Is Hsp90 a regulator of evolvability?J Exp Zool285116118
- 16. Dickinson WJ, Seger J (1999) Cause and effect in evolution. Nature 399: 30.WJ DickinsonJ. Seger1999Cause and effect in evolution.Nature39930
- 17. Gibson G, Wagner G (2000) Canalization in evolutionary genetics: a stabilizing theory? Bioessays 22: 372–380.G. GibsonG. Wagner2000Canalization in evolutionary genetics: a stabilizing theory?Bioessays22372380
- 18. Meiklejohn CD, Hartl DL (2002) A single mode of canalization. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 17: 468–473.CD MeiklejohnDL Hartl2002A single mode of canalization.Trends in Ecology and Evolution17468473
- 19. Milton CC, Huynh B, Batterham P, Rutherford SL, Hoffmann AA (2003) Quantitative trait symmetry independent of Hsp90 buffering: distinct modes of genetic canalization and developmental stability. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 13396–13401.CC MiltonB. HuynhP. BatterhamSL RutherfordAA Hoffmann2003Quantitative trait symmetry independent of Hsp90 buffering: distinct modes of genetic canalization and developmental stability.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A1001339613401
- 20. Debat V, Milton C, Rutherford S, Hoffmann AA, Klingenberg CP (2006) Hsp90 and the quantitative variation of wing shape in Drosophila melanogaster. Evolution. V. DebatC. MiltonS. RutherfordAA HoffmannCP Klingenberg2006Hsp90 and the quantitative variation of wing shape in Drosophila melanogaster.Evolutionin press. in press.
- 21. Gilchrist GW, Huey RB, Serra L (2001) Rapid evolution of wing size clines in Drosophila subobscura. Genetica 112–113: 273–286.GW GilchristRB HueyL. Serra2001Rapid evolution of wing size clines in Drosophila subobscura.Genetica112–113273286
- 22. Huey RB, Gilchrist GW, Carlson ML, Berrigan D, Serra L (2000) Rapid evolution of a geographic cline in size in an introduced fly. Science 287: 308–309.RB HueyGW GilchristML CarlsonD. BerriganL. Serra2000Rapid evolution of a geographic cline in size in an introduced fly.Science287308309
- 23. Powell JR (1997) Progress and prospects in evolutionary biology : the Drosophila model. New York: Oxford University Press. JR Powell1997Progress and prospects in evolutionary biology : the Drosophila model.New YorkOxford University Pressxiv, 562
- 24. Simpson P, Woehl R, Usui K (1999) The development and evolution of bristle patterns in Diptera. Development 126: 1349–1364.P. SimpsonR. WoehlK. Usui1999The development and evolution of bristle patterns in Diptera.Development12613491364
- 25. Pineiro R (1992) Selection for canalization at extra dorsocentral and scutellar bristles in Drosophila melanogaster. J Hered 83: 445–448.R. Pineiro1992Selection for canalization at extra dorsocentral and scutellar bristles in Drosophila melanogaster.J Hered83445448
- 26. Rendel JM (1967) Canalisation and gene control. London: Logos Press. JM Rendel1967Canalisation and gene control.LondonLogos Press
- 27. Waddington CH (1957) The strategy of the genes; a discussion of some aspects of theroetical biology. New York: Macmillan. CH Waddington1957The strategy of the genes; a discussion of some aspects of theroetical biology.New YorkMacmillanix, 262
- 28. Schmalhausen II (1986) Factors of evolution: the theory of stabilizing selection. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. II Schmalhausen1986Factors of evolution: the theory of stabilizing selection.ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
- 29. Wagner GP, Booth G, Bagheri-Chaichian H (1997) A population genetic theory of canalization. Evolution 51: 329–347.GP WagnerG. BoothH. Bagheri-Chaichian1997A population genetic theory of canalization.Evolution51329347
- 30. Eshel I, Matessi C (1998) Canalization, genetic assimilation and preadaptation. A quantitative genetic model. Genetics 149: 2119–2133.I. EshelC. Matessi1998Canalization, genetic assimilation and preadaptation. A quantitative genetic model.Genetics14921192133
- 31. Ancel LW, Fontana W (2000) Plasticity, evolvability, and modularity in RNA. J Exp Zool 288: 242–283.LW AncelW. Fontana2000Plasticity, evolvability, and modularity in RNA.J Exp Zool288242283
- 32. FlyBase http://flybase.bio.indiana.edu . FlyBase http://flybase.bio.indiana.edu .
- 33. Ding D, Parkhurst SM, Halsell SR, Lipshitz HD (1993) Dynamic Hsp83 RNA localization during Drosophila oogenesis and embryogenesis. Mol Cell Biol 13: 3773–3781.D. DingSM ParkhurstSR HalsellHD Lipshitz1993Dynamic Hsp83 RNA localization during Drosophila oogenesis and embryogenesis.Mol Cell Biol1337733781
- 34. van der Straten A, Rommel C, Dickson B, Hafen E (1997) The heat shock protein 83 (Hsp83) is required for Raf-mediated signalling in Drosophila. Embo J 16: 1961–1969.A. van der StratenC. RommelB. DicksonE. Hafen1997The heat shock protein 83 (Hsp83) is required for Raf-mediated signalling in Drosophila.Embo J1619611969
- 35. Hermisson J, Wagner GP (2004) The population genetic theory of hidden variation and genetic robustness. Genetics 168: 2271–2284.J. HermissonGP Wagner2004The population genetic theory of hidden variation and genetic robustness.Genetics16822712284
- 36. Wagner GP, Altenberg L (1996) Perspective: complex adaptations and the evolution of evolvability. Evolution 50: 967–976.GP WagnerL. Altenberg1996Perspective: complex adaptations and the evolution of evolvability.Evolution50967976
- 37. Markow TA (1994) Developmental instability : its origins and evolutionary implications : proceedings of the International Conference on Developmental Instability: Its Origins and Evolutionary Implications, Tempe, Arizona, 14–15 June 1993. Dordrecht [Netherlands] ; Boston: Kluwer Academic. TA Markow1994Developmental instability : its origins and evolutionary implications : proceedings of the International Conference on Developmental Instability: Its Origins and Evolutionary Implications, Tempe, Arizona, 14–15 June 1993.Dordrecht [Netherlands] ; BostonKluwer Academic440
- 38. Palmer RA Markow TA, editor. (1994) Fluctuating asymmetry analyses: a primer.;RA Palmer1994Fluctuating asymmetry analyses: a primer.;TA Markow
- 39. Lynch M, Walsh B (1998) Genetics and analysis of quantitative traits. Sunderland, Mass: Sinauer. M. LynchB. Walsh1998Genetics and analysis of quantitative traits.Sunderland, MassSinauerxvi, 980
- 40. Rutherford SL (2003) Between genotype and phenotype: protein chaperones and evolvability. Nat Rev Genet 4: 263–274.SL Rutherford2003Between genotype and phenotype: protein chaperones and evolvability.Nat Rev Genet4263274
- 41. Houle D (1992) Comparing evolvability and variability of quantitative traits. Genetics 130: 195–204.D. Houle1992Comparing evolvability and variability of quantitative traits.Genetics130195204
- 42. Rutherford SL (2000) From genotype to phenotype: buffering mechanisms and the storage of genetic information. Bioessays 22: 1095–1105.SL Rutherford2000From genotype to phenotype: buffering mechanisms and the storage of genetic information.Bioessays2210951105
- 43. Scharloo W (1991) Canalization: genetic and developmental aspects. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 22: 65–93.W. Scharloo1991Canalization: genetic and developmental aspects.Annu Rev Ecol Syst226593
- 44. Mohler JD (1965) The influence of some crossveinless-like genes on the crossveinless phenocopy sensitivity in Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics 51: 329–340.JD Mohler1965The influence of some crossveinless-like genes on the crossveinless phenocopy sensitivity in Drosophila melanogaster.Genetics51329340
- 45. Calleja M, Renaud O, Usui K, Pistillo D, Morata G, et al. (2002) How to pattern an epithelium: lessons from achaete-scute regulation on the notum of Drosophila. Gene 292: 1–12.M. CallejaO. RenaudK. UsuiD. PistilloG. Morata2002How to pattern an epithelium: lessons from achaete-scute regulation on the notum of Drosophila.Gene292112
- 46. Wright S (1934) An analysis of variability in number of digits in an inbred strain of guinea pigs. Genetics 19: 506–536.S. Wright1934An analysis of variability in number of digits in an inbred strain of guinea pigs.Genetics19506536
- 47. Falconer DS, Mackay TFC (1996) Introduction to quantitative genetics. Essex, England: Longman. DS FalconerTFC Mackay1996Introduction to quantitative genetics.Essex, EnglandLongmanxiii, 464
- 48. Stearns SC, Kaiser M, Kawecki TJ (1995) The differential genetic and environmnetal canalization of fitness components in Drosophila melanogaster. J Evol Biol 8: 539–557.SC StearnsM. KaiserTJ Kawecki1995The differential genetic and environmnetal canalization of fitness components in Drosophila melanogaster.J Evol Biol8539557
- 49. Bergman A, Siegal ML (2003) Evolutionary capacitance as a general feature of complex gene networks. Nature 424: 549–552.A. BergmanML Siegal2003Evolutionary capacitance as a general feature of complex gene networks.Nature424549552
- 50. Goldbeter A, Koshland DE Jr (1984) Ultrasensitivity in biochemical systems controlled by covalent modification. Interplay between zero-order and multistep effects. J Biol Chem 259: 14441–14447.A. GoldbeterDE Koshland Jr1984Ultrasensitivity in biochemical systems controlled by covalent modification. Interplay between zero-order and multistep effects.J Biol Chem2591444114447
- 51. Nijhout HF, Berg AM, Gibson WT (2003) A mechanistic study of evolvability using the mitogen-activated protein kinase cascade. Evol Dev 5: 281–294.HF NijhoutAM BergWT Gibson2003A mechanistic study of evolvability using the mitogen-activated protein kinase cascade.Evol Dev5281294
- 52. Ferrell JE Jr (1996) Tripping the switch fantastic: how a protein kinase cascade can convert graded inputs into switch-like outputs [see comments]. Trends Biochem Sci 21: 460–466.JE Ferrell Jr1996Tripping the switch fantastic: how a protein kinase cascade can convert graded inputs into switch-like outputs [see comments].Trends Biochem Sci21460466
- 53. Gardner TS, Cantor CR, Collins JJ (2000) Construction of a genetic toggle switch in Escherichia coli. Nature 403: 339–342.TS GardnerCR CantorJJ Collins2000Construction of a genetic toggle switch in Escherichia coli.Nature403339342
- 54. Judd EM, Laub MT, McAdams HH (2000) Toggles and oscillators: new genetic circuit designs [In Process Citation]. Bioessays 22: 507–509.EM JuddMT LaubHH McAdams2000Toggles and oscillators: new genetic circuit designs [In Process Citation].Bioessays22507509
- 55. Koshland DE Jr, Goldbeter A, Stock JB (1982) Amplification and adaptation in regulatory and sensory systems. Science 217: 220–225.DE Koshland JrA. GoldbeterJB Stock1982Amplification and adaptation in regulatory and sensory systems.Science217220225
- 56. Fry JD, Heinsohn SL, Mackay TF (1998) Heterosis for viability, fecundity, and male fertility in Drosophila melanogaster: comparison of mutational and standing variation. Genetics 148: 1171–1188.JD FrySL HeinsohnTF Mackay1998Heterosis for viability, fecundity, and male fertility in Drosophila melanogaster: comparison of mutational and standing variation.Genetics14811711188