Many biological processes are characterized by allometric relations of the type Y = Y0Mb between an observable Y and body mass M, which pervade at multiple levels of organization. In what regards the hematopoietic stem cell pool, there is experimental evidence that the size of the hematopoietic stem cell pool is conserved in mammals. However, demands for blood cell formation vary across mammals and thus the size of the active stem cell compartment could vary across species.
Here we investigate the allometric scaling of the hematopoietic system in a large group of mammalian species using reticulocyte counts as a marker of the active stem cell pool. Our model predicts that the total number of active stem cells, in an adult mammal, scales with body mass with the exponent ¾.
The scaling predicted here provides an intuitive justification of the Hayflick hypothesis and supports the current view of a small active stem cell pool supported by a large, quiescent reserve. The present scaling shows excellent agreement with the available (indirect) data for smaller mammals. The small size of the active stem cell pool enhances the role of stochastic effects in the overall dynamics of the hematopoietic system.
Citation: Dingli D, Pacheco JM (2006) Allometric Scaling of the Active Hematopoietic Stem Cell Pool across Mammals. PLoS ONE 1(1): e2. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0000002
Academic Editor: Christopher Arendt, Sanofi-Aventis, United States of America
Received: August 7, 2006; Accepted: August 31, 2006; Published: December 20, 2006
Copyright: © 2006 Dingli and Pacheco. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: JMP acknowledges financial support from FCT, Portugal.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Scaling, in physics, has provided fundamental insights from the tiny quark to the universe at large. In biology, allometric scaling  is typically associated with a simple power law: Y = Y0Mb, where Y is some observable and M is the mass of the organism. Allometric scaling has been identified on a wide range of observables –, from basal metabolic rate (BMR), heart rate, aortic and tree trunk radii, to unicellular genome lengths. Intriguingly, most of the scaling exponents b are multiples of the power 1/4, and the origin of this general dependence has been subjected to intense investigation. A beautiful explanation was proposed by West et al. , where the 3/4 exponent in BMR scaling was related to a surface to volume ratio in a four-dimensional biological world. Although other explanations have been proposed , the 3/4 scaling has been challenged ,  and plants have recently been found to scale differently , allometric scaling remains ubiquitous in biology, and has provided novel insights on various biological processes.
Blood is also ubiquitous, and has been the subject of investigation for centuries. Our present understanding of the hematopoietic system has improved tremendously since William Harvey described the circulatory system in the 17th century. Indeed, our current understanding relies on the concept of stem cells –. This view identifies the bone marrow as the site of active cell replication, responsible for the maintenance of the circulating blood cell pool that is continuously undergoing apoptotic senescence. Blood cell production is maintained by hematopoietic stem cells that have the capacity to both self-renew and differentiate into all types of blood cells  (see Figure 1). The number of hematopoietic stem cells has been estimated in various species using indirect methods. These include the SCID repopulating cell (SRC) assay , rescue of lethally irradiated mice and rats using serial dilutions of bone marrow derived cells ,  and ferrokinetic studies that estimate red blood cell production and correlate this with total marrow cellularity and the myeloid to erythroid ratio .
Hematopoietic stem cells exist in two distinct compartments: cells in N2 are actively replicating and contributing to blood cell formation.
They are supported by a larger quiescent pool (N1).
Cell replication leads to an exponential amplification (2K) of progeny that ultimately differentiate into the various types of cells present in the circulation.
Perhaps rather surprisingly, Abkowitz et al.  recently suggested that the total number of hematopoietic stem cells is conserved from mouse to humans, and proposed that this may apply to all mammals. They estimated that mammals have between 11000 and 22000 hematopoietic stem cells. Subsequent studies in Rattus norvegicus were consistent with this prediction . There is indirect evidence to suggest that this may also be true in elephants, whose African variant may reach a mass of approximately 6000 kg . However, the demands for blood cell production vary across species: the number of cells produced by a murine bone marrow over the life-time of a mouse is equal to what a human bone marrow produces in a day or a cat in a week .
Potential mechanisms that can explain these different production rates include (i) an active stem cell pool that varies with animal size, (ii) faster rates of replication as the size of the species increases, (iii) longer cell specific contribution to hematopoiesis and (iv) a number of committed cell lineages that produce terminally differentiated blood cells which increases with animal size (Figure 1), with none of these mechanisms being mutually exclusive.
Current models of hematopoiesis suggest that stem cells exist in two functionally distinct compartments : a quiescent, reserve pool where cells divide rarely, and another pool of actively replicating cells that contribute to hematopoiesis for some time to be replaced by cells from the reserve pool. Since the demands for blood cell production vary across species –, , it is possible that the active stem cell pool scales allometrically with adult mass despite the fact that the total number of stem cells may be conserved across mammalian species .
Potential explanations (i) and (ii) relate the hematopoietic system with animal size. Basal metabolism is clearly related to the hematopoietic system since hemoglobin, exclusively transported by red blood cells, is the main carrier of oxygen throughout the organism, thereby ensuring an adequate supply for metabolic needs. Consequently, it is natural to assume the existence of allometric scaling in the hematopoietic system, a feature which may prove insightful in determining the size and properties of the stem-cell pool.
In the following, we make use of allometric scaling to estimate the number of active stem cells contributing to hematopoiesis in adult mammals from voles to elephants.
Allometric scaling of the active stem-cell pool
As is well known, blood volume is a function of animal mass . Furthermore, rates of cell production in an animal should scale, under normal conditions, with the species specific BMR . The specific BMR -RM- has been shown to scale as RM∼M−1/4 across 27 orders of magnitude, from the sub-cellular respiratory complexes to unicellular organisms up to the largest mammals . If red blood cells of a given animal originate from NSC active stem cells, then we may expect that, per unit time, the number of red blood cells produced will scale as NSCRM. During hematopoiesis, stem cells divide and as the daughter cells become more differentiated, they progressively lose their ability to replicate. However, during replication the number of cells produced from one stem cell increases exponentially at an ideal rate of 2k, where k represents the number of distinct replication steps before the cell loses the ability to divide (Figure 1). Here we assume that the process exhibits the same efficiency across species and as such contributes with a constant factor to red blood cell production.
Red blood cell production is best evaluated by measuring the total number of circulating reticulocytes (RT) in a given species. Indeed, estimating blood production based on red blood cell survival may be misleading, since many extrinsic factors contribute to premature red blood cell destruction, and these can be difficult to quantify . On the other hand, circulating reticulocytes, precursors of red blood cells, should reflect more accurately blood production originating from the active stem cell pool. Consequently, we predict that reticulocyte production per day (RTD) scales as RTD∼NSCRM.
RTD can be obtained by dividing RT by the time required for reticulocyte maturation, τ. In other words, RTD∼RTτ−1∼RTRM since, under normal conditions, the specific BMR RM ultimately determines maturation time . Equating the two expressions for RTD allows us to predict that NSC∼RT. Therefore, we can deduce the allometric scaling of the active stem cell pool in the animal's bone marrow from the corresponding scaling of the total reticulocyte count across species. In Materials and Methods we describe how we collected data for RT from mammalian species, as well as the procedure used to determine its allometric exponent.
Results and Discussion
By fitting the data collected for reticulocyte count across different mammalian species in the way described in the Materials and Methods section, we obtained a ¾ power law- scaling for the mass-dependence of the size of the active stem-cell pool, NSC ∼ M3/4 Using the well-studied cat data  as a reference, which estimates the size of the active stem cell pool as NSC = 13 after a stem cell transplant, the allometric relation above predicts that NSC = 111 in humans (mass = 70 kg). This result is very similar to the reported value NSC = 116 of active stem cells after bone marrow transplantation in humans . Under normal physiologic conditions, the active stem cell pool in the cat is composed of NSC≥40 cells . Using the minimum value, the allometric relation leads to an active pool size of NSC≈385 cells for humans. This result is very similar to estimates based on observation on adult women heterozygous for chronic granulomatous disease (CGD) . Furthermore, the present allometric scaling relation also predicts that one single stem cell is enough to maintain hematopoiesis for the entire lifespan of a mouse, consistent with published estimates . The overall consistency between the predictions based on the allometric relation and available (though scarce) data for mice, cats and humans suggests that allometric scaling provides a powerful tool to investigate the overall properties of the hematopoietic stem cell pool. On the other hand, such an overall consistency also provides additional support to the underlying assumptions made in the derivation of the allometric scaling relation. Extrapolating our data for the pilot whale (Globicephala macrorhynchus, mass ∼2250 kg) we estimate NSC = 4690 whereas for the Asian elephant (Elephas maximus, mass ∼6000 kg) NSC = 9640 cells, both of which are below the minimum number (11000) of total stem cells that are thought to be present in any mammal .
According to the Hayflick hypothesis, stem cells replicate a finite number of times before senescence . Associating the replication rate of stem cells with RM means the Hayflick hypothesis is equivalent to state that the lifespan of a stem cell scales with RM−1∼M1/4. In the laboratory experiments of Ref.  it was found that stem cells replicate, on average, once every 2.5 weeks in mice and once every 8.3 to 10 weeks in cats (after transplant). These estimates follow the M3/4scaling relation we derived. Extrapolating these observations to humans, we obtain a replication rate of once every ≈20 weeks, significantly lower than the measurements in Ref.  (1 year) or the extrapolation made in Ref.  (42 weeks). Note however that this latter number was estimated assuming from the outset that stem cells replicate 100 times during the lifetime of a human (80 years). In contrast, the existence of allometric scaling is the only requirement of our theory, from which the relevant number can be deduced without further assumptions. Furthermore, NSC = 111 results from allometric scaling for post-transplant conditions, which do not reflect normal adult hematopoiesis. If we take the allometric prediction for normal conditions - NSC = 385 - then we arrive at a replication value of approximately once every 60 weeks, close to the results based on an analysis of telomere shortening in human hematopoietic cells . The present estimates are consistent with the idea that mammals do not exhaust their hematopoietic stem cell reserve during their lifetime. Indeed, if we assume that a cell replicates 100 times before senescence, then the lifetime of a murine stem cell is longer than the lifetime of a mouse, consistent with the view  that a single stem cell may be enough to maintain hematopoiesis for the entire murine lifespan. In fact, our present allometric relation predicts that, although larger mammals require larger active stem cell pools, the expected lifetime of each species-specific stem cell is always longer than the expected lifetime of the mammal.
In retrospect, examining the possible explanations invoked in the beginning of this work, clearly argument (i) was given a precise allometric justification, whereas (ii) can be ruled out, since it would contradict the well-established allometric scaling of the specific BMR  which suggests that the rate of replication of cells decreases as the mass of the mammal increases. Argument (iii) derives from the Hayflick hypothesis and is supported by our estimates. The available data does not allow us to elaborate on argument (iv), but we can state that no special adaptations seem necessary to explain hematopoiesis in whales or elephants.
A ¾ scaling of NSC has been rationalized in terms of a surface-to-volume ratio in the four biological dimensions , . This calls for detailed studies of the structure-function relationships in the bone marrow. Indeed, the above scaling is consistent with the interpretation of the bone marrow as a heterogeneous microenvironment in which the active stem cell pool is distributed in surface niches , whereas the quiescent stem cell pool might presumably occupy the bulk of the bone marrow, in accord with the prevailing view of the stem cell pool as metaphorically compartmentalized . As such, detailed studies of bone marrow physiology may shed light on the mechanisms responsible for the ¾ scaling relations which pervade in living systems. Finally, the reduced size of the active stem cell pool in mice, cats and humans indicates that stochastic effects may play a sizeable role in the overall dynamics of the hematopoietic system in these mammals. Such effects will be explored elsewhere .
Materials and Methods
The total number of circulating reticulocytes was calculated as the product of the concentration of circulating reticulocytes in the blood and the blood volume of mature animals for each species. In Figure 2 we plot the logarithm of RT as a function of the logarithm of the mass, for mammals that cover over six orders of magnitude. The range varied from voles with a mass of 20 g up to a pilot whale with an average mass of 2250 kg. The data corresponds to the mean value of the reticulocyte count for each species (detailed minimum and maximum counts are provided in Table S1). The dashed blue line was obtained from a linear regression, which leads to an exponent of 0.745≈¾ (R2 = 0.94, p<0.0001). The confidence intervals limit the allometric exponent between 0.70 and 0.76. The intercept of the fitting curve at a mass of 1 gram is 7.641. Hence, we estimate a value of ∼108 for the reticulocyte count of the smallest mammal (a shrew with a mass of 3 g).
We plot the logarithm of reticulocyte count of a given mammal as a function of the logarithm of its mass (in gram).
Plotted data correspond to a total of 40 mammal species with masses ranging over 6 orders of magnitude, from voles to whales.
The data corresponds to the mean value of the reticulocyte count for each species.
A straight linear fit leads to a coefficient of 0.745, remarkably close to the ¾ exponent (R2 = 0.94, p<0.0001, CI 0.70–0.76), with an intercept of 7.641.
Hence for the smallest mammal (a shrew with ∼3 gram), we predict a reticulocyte count of ∼1×108.
We wish to thank Professor Susan Cotter (Tufts University), Dr Michael Blanco, (Mayo Clinic, Rochester) and Professor Peter Vogel (University of Lausanne) for many helpful suggestions.
Conceived and designed the experiments: JP DD. Analyzed the data: JP DD. Wrote the paper: JP DD
- 1. Huxley JS (1932) Problems of relative growth. Dial Press. New York, USA.JS Huxley1932Problems of relative growth.Dial PressNew York, USA
- 2. Schmidt-Nielsen K (1984) Why is animal size so important? Cambridge University Press. New York, USA.K. Schmidt-Nielsen1984Why is animal size so important?Cambridge University PressNew York, USA
- 3. West GB, Woodruff WH, Brown JH (2002) Allometric scaling of metabolic rate from molecules and mitochondria to cells and mammals. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99 Suppl 1: 2473–2478.GB WestWH WoodruffJH Brown2002Allometric scaling of metabolic rate from molecules and mitochondria to cells and mammals.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99 Suppl124732478
- 4. West GB, Brown JH, Enquist BJ (1999) The fourth dimension of life: fractal geometry and allometric scaling of organisms. Science 284: 1677–1679.GB WestJH BrownBJ Enquist1999The fourth dimension of life: fractal geometry and allometric scaling of organisms.Science28416771679
- 5. West GB, Brown JH (2005) The origin of allometric scaling laws in biology from genomes to ecosystems: towards a quantitative unifying theory of biological structure and organization. J Exp Biol 208: 1575–1592.GB WestJH Brown2005The origin of allometric scaling laws in biology from genomes to ecosystems: towards a quantitative unifying theory of biological structure and organization.J Exp Biol20815751592
- 6. Banavar JR, Maritan A, Rinaldo A (1999) Size and form in efficient transportation networks. Nature 399: 130–132.JR BanavarA. MaritanA. Rinaldo1999Size and form in efficient transportation networks.Nature399130132
- 7. White CR, Seymour RS (2003) Mammalian basal metabolic rate is proportional to body mass2/3. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 4046–4049.CR WhiteRS Seymour2003Mammalian basal metabolic rate is proportional to body mass2/3.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A10040464049
- 8. Dodds PS, Rothman DH, Weitz JS (2001) Re-examination of the “3/4-law” of metabolism. J Theor Biol 209: 9–27.PS DoddsDH RothmanJS Weitz2001Re-examination of the “3/4-law” of metabolism.J Theor Biol209927
- 9. Reich PB, Tjoelker MG, Machado JL, Oleksyn J (2006) Universal scaling of respiratory metabolism, size and nitrogen in plants. Nature 439: 457–461.PB ReichMG TjoelkerJL MachadoJ. Oleksyn2006Universal scaling of respiratory metabolism, size and nitrogen in plants.Nature439457461
- 10. Till JE, McCulloch EA, Siminovitch L (1964) A Stochastic Model of Stem Cell Proliferation, Based on the Growth of Spleen Colony-Forming Cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 51: 29–36.JE TillEA McCullochL. Siminovitch1964A Stochastic Model of Stem Cell Proliferation, Based on the Growth of Spleen Colony-Forming Cells.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A512936
- 11. Worton RG, McCulloch EA, Till JE (1969) Physical separation of hemopoietic stem cells differing in their capacity for self-renewal. J Exp Med 130: 91–103.RG WortonEA McCullochJE Till1969Physical separation of hemopoietic stem cells differing in their capacity for self-renewal.J Exp Med13091103
- 12. Dick JE (2003) Stem cells: Self-renewal writ in blood. Nature 423: 231–233.JE Dick2003Stem cells: Self-renewal writ in blood.Nature423231233
- 13. Dick JE, Magli MC, Huszar D, Phillips RA, Bernstein A (1985) Introduction of a selectable gene into primitive stem cells capable of long-term reconstitution of the hemopoietic system of W/Wv mice. Cell 42: 71–79.JE DickMC MagliD. HuszarRA PhillipsA. Bernstein1985Introduction of a selectable gene into primitive stem cells capable of long-term reconstitution of the hemopoietic system of W/Wv mice.Cell427179
- 14. Passegue E, Jamieson CH, Ailles LE, Weissman IL (2003) Normal and leukemic hematopoiesis: are leukemias a stem cell disorder or a reacquisition of stem cell characteristics? Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: Suppl 111842–11849.E. PassegueCH JamiesonLE AillesIL Weissman2003Normal and leukemic hematopoiesis: are leukemias a stem cell disorder or a reacquisition of stem cell characteristics?Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A100Suppl 11184211849
- 15. Spangrude GJ, Smith L, Uchida N, Ikuta K, Heimfeld S, et al. (1991) Mouse hematopoietic stem cells. Blood 78: 1395–1402.GJ SpangrudeL. SmithN. UchidaK. IkutaS. Heimfeld1991Mouse hematopoietic stem cells.Blood7813951402
- 16. Larochelle A, Vormoor J, Hanenberg H, Wang JC, Bhatia M, et al. (1996) Identification of primitive human hematopoietic cells capable of repopulating NOD/SCID mouse bone marrow: implications for gene therapy. Nat Med 2: 1329–1337.A. LarochelleJ. VormoorH. HanenbergJC WangM. Bhatia1996Identification of primitive human hematopoietic cells capable of repopulating NOD/SCID mouse bone marrow: implications for gene therapy.Nat Med213291337
- 17. McCarthy KF (1997) Population size and radiosensitivity of murine hematopoietic endogenous long-term repopulating cells. Blood 89: 834–841.KF McCarthy1997Population size and radiosensitivity of murine hematopoietic endogenous long-term repopulating cells.Blood89834841
- 18. McCarthy KF (2003) Marrow frequency of rat long-term repopulating cells: evidence that marrow hematopoietic stem cell concentration may be inversely proportional to species body weight. Blood 101: 3431–3435.KF McCarthy2003Marrow frequency of rat long-term repopulating cells: evidence that marrow hematopoietic stem cell concentration may be inversely proportional to species body weight.Blood10134313435
- 19. Abkowitz JL, Catlin SN, McCallie MT, Guttorp P (2002) Evidence that the number of hematopoietic stem cells per animal is conserved in mammals. Blood 100: 2665–2667.JL AbkowitzSN CatlinMT McCallieP. Guttorp2002Evidence that the number of hematopoietic stem cells per animal is conserved in mammals.Blood10026652667
- 20. Gordon MY, Lewis JL, Marley SB (2002) Of mice and men…and elephants. Blood 100: 4679–4680.MY GordonJL LewisSB Marley2002Of mice and men…and elephants.Blood10046794680
- 21. Abkowitz JL, Persik MT, Shelton GH, Ott RL, Kiklevich JV, et al. (1995) Behavior of hematopoietic stem cells in a large animal. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 92: 2031–2035.JL AbkowitzMT PersikGH SheltonRL OttJV Kiklevich1995Behavior of hematopoietic stem cells in a large animal.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A9220312035
- 22. Reya T, Morrison SJ, Clarke MF, Weissman IL (2001) Stem cells, cancer, and cancer stem cells. Nature 414: 105–111.T. ReyaSJ MorrisonMF ClarkeIL Weissman2001Stem cells, cancer, and cancer stem cells.Nature414105111
- 23. Burke JD (1954) Blood volume in mammals. Physiological Zoology 26: 1–21.JD Burke1954Blood volume in mammals.Physiological Zoology26121
- 24. Eadie GS, Brown IW Jr. (1953) Red blood cell survival studies. Blood 8: 1110–1136.GS EadieIW Brown Jr.1953Red blood cell survival studies.Blood811101136
- 25. West GB, Brown JH, Enquist BJ (2001) A general model for ontogenetic growth. Nature 413: 628–631.GB WestJH BrownBJ Enquist2001A general model for ontogenetic growth.Nature413628631
- 26. Abkowitz JL, Linenberger ML, Newton MA, Shelton GH, Ott RL, et al. (1990) Evidence for the maintenance of hematopoiesis in a large animal by the sequential activation of stem-cell clones. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 87: 9062–9066.JL AbkowitzML LinenbergerMA NewtonGH SheltonRL Ott1990Evidence for the maintenance of hematopoiesis in a large animal by the sequential activation of stem-cell clones.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A8790629066
- 27. Nash R, Storb R, Neiman P (1988) Polyclonal reconstitution of human marrow after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation. Blood 72: 2031–2037.R. NashR. StorbP. Neiman1988Polyclonal reconstitution of human marrow after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation.Blood7220312037
- 28. Buescher ES, Alling DW, Gallin JI (1985) Use of an X-linked human neutrophil marker to estimate timing of lyonization and size of the dividing stem cell pool. J Clin Invest 76: 1581–1584.ES BuescherDW AllingJI Gallin1985Use of an X-linked human neutrophil marker to estimate timing of lyonization and size of the dividing stem cell pool.J Clin Invest7615811584
- 29. Hayflick L, Moorhead PS (1961) The serial cultivation of human diploid cell strains. Exp Cell Res 25: 585–621.L. HayflickPS Moorhead1961The serial cultivation of human diploid cell strains.Exp Cell Res25585621
- 30. Rufer N, Brummendorf TH, Kolvraa S, Bischoff C, Christensen K, et al. (1999) Telomere fluorescence measurements in granulocytes and T lymphocyte subsets point to a high turnover of hematopoietic stem cells and memory T cells in early childhood. J Exp Med 190: 157–167.N. RuferTH BrummendorfS. KolvraaC. BischoffK. Christensen1999Telomere fluorescence measurements in granulocytes and T lymphocyte subsets point to a high turnover of hematopoietic stem cells and memory T cells in early childhood.J Exp Med190157167
- 31. Moore KA, Lemischka RI (2006) Stem cells and their niches. Science 311: 1880–1885.KA MooreRI Lemischka2006Stem cells and their niches.Science31118801885
- 32. Dingli D, Traulsen A, Pacheco MJ (2006) Stochastic dynamics of hematopoietic tumor stem cells. (Submitted)D. DingliA. TraulsenMJ Pacheco2006Stochastic dynamics of hematopoietic tumor stem cells. (Submitted)