There are no effective vaccines for visceral leishmaniasis (VL), a neglected parasitic disease second only to malaria in global mortality. We previously identified 14 protective candidates in a screen of 100 Leishmania antigens as DNA vaccines in mice. Here we employ whole blood assays to evaluate human cytokine responses to 11 of these antigens, in comparison to known defined and crude antigen preparations.
Whole blood assays were employed to measure IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-10 responses to peptide pools of the novel antigens R71, Q51, L37, N52, L302.06, J89, M18, J41, M22, M63, M57, as well as to recombinant proteins of tryparedoxin peroxidase (TRYP), Leishmania homolog of the receptor for activated C kinase (LACK) and to crude soluble Leishmania antigen (SLA), in Indian patients with active (n = 8) or cured (n = 16) VL, and in modified Quantiferon positive (EHC+ve, n = 20) or modified Quantiferon negative (EHC−ve, n = 9) endemic healthy controls (EHC).
Active VL, cured VL and EHC+ve groups showed elevated SLA-specific IFN-γ, but only active VL patients produced IL-10 and EHC+ve did not make TNF-α. IFN-γ to IL-10 and TNF-α to IL-10 ratios in response to TRYP and LACK antigens were higher in cured VL and EHC+ve exposed individuals compared to active VL. Five of the eleven novel candidates (R71, L37, N52, J41, and M22) elicited IFN-γ and TNF-α, but not IL-10, responses in cured VL (55–87.5% responders) and EHC+ve (40–65% responders) subjects.
Our results are consistent with an important balance between pro-inflammatory IFNγ and TNFγ cytokine responses and anti-inflammatory IL-10 in determining outcome of VL in India, as highlighted by response to both crude and defined protein antigens. Importantly, cured VL patients and endemic Quantiferon positive individuals recognise 5 novel vaccine candidate antigens, confirming our recent data for L. chagasi in Brazil, and their potential as cross-species vaccine candidates.
Visceral leishmaniasis is a parasitic infection that results in death in susceptible people unless they are treated. Current drugs are expensive and toxic, and there are no vaccines in use in humans. We know that it is possible to become immune to infection with this parasite because people who have been cured using drug treatment are resistant to further infection. In addition, a large percentage of people infected with the parasite remain asymptomatic and develop a specific immune response that can be measured using crude leishmanial antigens. We hypothesized that these resistant people might hold the key to understanding the kind of immune response required for protection. In this paper we compared the immune response to a series of novel vaccine candidates in people with active disease, in those drug-cured from the disease, and in the naturally resistant individuals. We show that immune individuals make strong cytokine responses to five of eleven novel vaccine candidates that were tested, making them ideal candidates to take forward in the development of a defined vaccine against leishmaniasis.
Citation: Singh OP, Stober CB, Singh AK, Blackwell JM, Sundar S (2012) Cytokine Responses to Novel Antigens in an Indian Population Living in an Area Endemic for Visceral Leishmaniasis. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 6(10): e1874. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0001874
Editor: Edgar M. Carvalho, Hospital Universitário, Brazil
Received: July 18, 2012; Accepted: September 10, 2012; Published: October 25, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Singh et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health (TMRC Grant No. IP50AI074321). No other funding agencies contributed to the work. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Visceral leishmaniasis (VL), also known as kala-azar, is a potentially fatal disease caused by obligate intracellular parasites of the Leishmania donovani species complex. VL is a serious public health problem in indigenous and rural populations in India, accounting for enormous morbidity and mortality, as well as major costs to both local and national health budgets. The estimated annual global incidence of VL is 200,000 to 400,000, and >90% of these cases occur in India, Bangladesh, Sudan, South Sudan, Ethiopia and Brazil . Interestingly, 80 to 90% of human infections are subclinical or asymptomatic, and this asymptomatic infection is associated with strong cell-mediated immunity , , , , . Only a small percentage of infected individuals develop severe disease , , and patients who recover from VL display resistance to reinfection . This suggests the development of protective immunity and provides a rational basis for the development of vaccines that impart potent cell-mediated immune responses. Furthermore, the factors that skew the immune response toward T helper 1 (Th1) or Th2/T regulatory (Treg) cell dominance are partially understood, and it is believed that direct interaction between parasite antigens and host immune cells participate to shape the subsequent pathogenic or protective immune responses , .
A key mechanism by which T cells mediate their effector functions is through the production of cytokines. However, heterogeneity of CD4+ T-cell cytokine responses has made it difficult to define immune correlates of protection after vaccination in leishmaniasis. In murine cutaneous leishmaniasis, the degree of protection in vaccinated mice was predicted by the frequency of CD4+ T cells simultaneously producing interferon-γ (IFN-γ), interleukin (IL)-2 and tumour necrosis factor (TNF, formerly TNF-α) . These multi-functional effector CD4+ T cells elicited by all vaccines tested were unique in producing high amounts of IFN-γ . In our own studies comparing vaccines with different efficacies in mice, we found that the balance between antigen-specific CD4 T cell-derived pro-inflammatory IFN-γ and regulatory IL-10 (and to a lesser extent IL-4 and IL-5), rather than magnitude of IFN-γ per se, provided the best correlate of a protective immune response . A strong tumour necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) response concurrent with IFN-γ has also been shown to be important in models of VL . A crucial step in vaccine development against human disease requires improved understanding of the functional heterogeneity of T-cell cytokine responses generated by candidate vaccine antigens. For example, one study in malaria reported that peptide-specific IFN-γ to a conserved epitope of the circumsporozoite surface protein was strongly associated with protection of humans again infection and disease , providing a precise target for vaccine design. Without a convincing single marker of protective immunity against leishmaniasis, vaccine development has to rely on screening a range of cytokines to gauge the balance between Th1 and Th2/T regulatory (Treg) responses.
Advances in our understanding of Leishmania pathogenesis and of the generation of host protective immunity, together with completed Leishmania genome sequences, have opened new avenues for vaccine research. Although significant progress has been made to understand mechanisms of VL immunity in humans , , there is no effective vaccine available for humans against any form of leishmaniasis. Drugs used in leishmaniasis therapy are significantly toxic, expensive and faced with increasing resistance. Limitations in pharmacotherapy argue for the development of a vaccine for VL. Vaccination with live virulent parasites, termed leishmanization, was practiced from ancient times until recently in many endemic areas . Vaccine trials involving whole, killed parasites were conducted in the 1970s and 1980s , . Although no overall statistically significant protection has been associated with any trial of these killed vaccines , , , , , a common theme has been protection in persons who showed conversion of Leishmania-specific delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) skin test responses during the trial, whether or not they received the vaccine. The latter points to the importance of understanding the immune response in exposed individuals who become infected but do not progress to clinical disease, which in the Indian endemic area has been equated to a positive modified Quantiferon response to leishmanial antigens in whole blood assays .
The genome sequence and proteome data (∼33.6 Mb genome and ∼8300 protein coding genes) of Leishmania major  provides a rich source of potential vaccine candidates. We recently described the identification of novel Leishmania antigens delivered as DNA vaccines to susceptible BALB/c mice, and identified 14 protective candidate antigens in a screen of 100 amastigote-expressed genes . To determine their potential as vaccine candidates for humans, we here evaluate the ability of 11 of these novel Leishmania vaccine candidates, along with soluble Leishmania antigen (SLA), recombinant Leishmania homolog of the receptor for activated C kinase (LACK), and tryparedoxin peroxidase (TRYP) proteins, to stimulate cytokine responses in whole blood from active and cured VL patients, and from modified Quantiferon positive and negative endemic health controls (EHC), in India.
Materials and Methods
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, India. Written informed consent was obtained from all adult subjects included in the study, or from the parents or guardians of individuals less than 18 years of age. Subjects belonged to 4 clinically well characterized groups: (i) active VL: cases of parasitologically confirmed, active VL (n = 8); (ii) cured VL: subjects who were definitively cured of VL and shown to have no parasites in splenic aspirates at least 6 months after treatment (n = 16); (iii) EHC with a positive antigen-specific IFN-γ response measured by modified Quantiferon (Cellestis, Chadstone, Australia) assay (cf. below) (EHC+ve, n = 20); and (iv) EHC testing negative by modified Quantiferon assay (EHC−ve, n = 9). Subjects having fever within the past month, and children less than five years of age, were excluded. Follow up visits were made to the homes of the EHC+ve and cured subjects 6 and 12 months after enrolment to monitor for the development of active VL. Demographic and clinical characteristics of participants enrolled in the vaccine study are summarized in Table 1. None of the cured VL or EHC subjects developed clinical VL during the 1 year follow-up.
Preparation of soluble leishmania antigen (SLA)
SLA from an Ethiopian strain of L. donovani (LV9) or L. major (LV39) were prepared at the Cambridge Institute for Medical Research, University of Cambridge School of Clinical Medicine, UK as described previously . SLA from an Indian strain of L. donovani was prepared at the Infectious Disease Research Laboratory, Banaras Hindu University, according to the published protocol of Scott and co-workers . The protein concentration was estimated using the BCA method . SLA was stored at −80°C until use.
Recombinant LACK and TRYP proteins were prepared as described , , with large-scale preparation, endotoxin removal and protein estimation out-sourced to Novexin Ltd. (Cambridge, UK). As previously described , overlapping 13–20-mer peptides (minimal overlap of 12 amino acids to ensure complete coverage of epitopes, 7–31 peptides/antigen depending on amino acid length of the protein) representing 11 (R71, Q51, L37, N52, L302.06, J89, M18, J41, M22, M63, M57) of 14 novel antigens identified  were synthesized commercially (Peptide2.0, Chantilly, VA), initially solubilized in dimethylsulfoxide (final concentration in the well <0.1% DMSO), and pooled (for peptides within each antigen) in endotoxin-free phosphate-buffered saline at a final concentration of 50 µg/mL per individual peptide. Peptides pools were stored at −80°C. Due to the size of peptides in the pools, some natural processing is required for epitope selection prior to epitope binding to class II and presentation to CD4+ T cells.
Diluted whole blood assay
The Quantiferon (Cellestis, Chadstone, Australia) whole blood assay was conducted on 147 endemic healthy individuals according to the manufacturer's instructions or to our published modifications , . From these data, 20 highly positive (above the cut-off value generated by the ROC curve) individuals were selected as the EHC+ve study group, and 9 individuals selected at random from below the cut-off value as the EHC−ve study group. Blood (5 mL) was collected into heparinised tubes, and samples diluted 1 in 8 in serum-free complete medium comprising RPMI supplemented with 2 mM L-glutamine, 100 µg/mL streptomycin, 100 IU/mL penicillin (Gibco, USA). Diluted blood (180 µL/well) was plated into 96-well U-bottomed plates (Nunc, Rochester, USA) and antigen added in triplicate wells at a final concentration of 10 µg/mL for TRYP, LACK and SLA, 5 µg/mL for PPD, PHA and the 11 novel antigen peptide pools, and made up to a volume of 200 µL. Plates were incubated at 37°C in 5% CO2 for 24 hours, 72 hours or 6 days. Supernatants from replicate wells were harvested, pooled and stored at −80°C until analysed by ELISA.
Measurement of cytokines by ELISA
Cytokine release (IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-10) by antigen stimulated whole blood cells was measured at 24 hours, 72 hours, or 6 days. IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-10 were measured using matched antibody pairs (BD Pharmingen, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) by ELISA. The limit of detection for these ELISAs was 31 pg/mL. Background levels in non-stimulated control wells were deducted from antigen-stimulated values to determine antigen specific cytokine responses (with negative values recorded as zero). To control for inter-plate and intra-plate variation, a positive-control supernatant (1∶4 and 1∶8 dilution of PHA stimulated Non Endemic Healthy Controls (NEHC) whole blood pooled supernatant) was used in duplicate on each ELISA plate. The mean variability of these duplicate measurements was 2.53% (intra-plate variation). The coefficient of variation between plates (inter-plate variation) was 20.74% for IFN-γ, 10.78% for TNF-α and 18.04% for IL-10.
Because data were generally not normally distributed (as determined using the Kolgomorov-Smirnov test), data are plotted using box and whiskers (Tukey) plots, and statistical differences (P<0.05) between pairs of groups were determined using nonparametric 2-tailed Mann-Whitney tests. Nominal P-values are presented throughout (i.e. without correction for multiple testing). Plots were generated using GraphPad Prism 5 (San Diago, USA), and statistical analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism 5 or SPSS software v18.0.
SLA cytokine responses correlate with disease status
To investigate antigen specific production of IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-10 cytokines, diluted whole blood from different patient groups was initially stimulated with SLA from an Indian L. donovani strain. Comparison of responses over time post stimulation in active VL cases showed that all 3 cytokines were highest, and less variable, at the 24 hour time point (Fig. 1A–C). Active cases made variable responses to PPD reflecting prior exposure to Mycobacterium and indicating that ability to make a response to mycobacterial antigens is not compromised in active VL patients. Cured cases made similarly variable responses to PPD (Fig. S1). Between group comparisons at 24 hours post stimulation showed that active VL, cured VL, and EHC+ve study groups all made higher IFN-γ responses relative to EHC−ve subjects (Fig. 1D). The observation that active VL cases make a significant amount of IFN-γ is in line with our recent observations for whole blood assays using undiluted blood in a modified Quantiferon assay , . Of interest, while cured VL and active VL groups generated TNF-α concomitant with IFN-γ, the EHC+ve group did not (Fig. 1E), suggesting that production of this cytokine might relate to the pathogenic role of TNF-α in VL disease . Note, however, that this was not true for responses to putative vaccine candidates outlined below, which all elicited TNF-α concomitant with IFN-γ in the EHC+ve group. Importantly, only the active VL group made IL-10 in response to Indian L. donovani SLA (Fig. 1F), supporting previous data indicating that IL-10 is a key regulatory cytokine in VL patients , .
Box plots (Tukey) for cytokine production by peripheral whole blood cells in response to SLA (an Indian L. donovani strain, 10 µg/mL), or PPD (5 µg/mL) examined in active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 16), EHC+ve (n = 20) and EHC−ve (n = 9) groups by ELISA. (A–C) provide comparisons of cytokine levels over 24 hours, 72 hours and 6 days post stimulation with SLA or PPD in the active VL group (parallel data for IFN-γ responses in the cured VL group are provided in Fig. S1). (D–F) compare cytokine responses at 24 hours post stimulation across the 4 study groups. Antigen-stimulated cytokine responses are provided after subtraction of the non-stimulated control wells. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Cytokine responses to 3 different Leishmania strains, an Indian L. donovani strain (designated SLA), an Ethiopian L. donovani strain (LV9) and L. major strain (LV39) were compared (Fig. 2). For IFN-γ responses the two L. donovani preparations stimulated equivalent responses (Fig. 2A). Interestingly, SLA prepared from the local Indian L. donovani strain elicited significantly stronger 24 h TNF-α (Fig. 2B) and IL-10 responses (Fig. 2C) compared to Ethiopian L. donovani (p = 0.0003; p = 0.004) or the L. major strain (p = 0.028; p = 0.007). The L. major antigen was more variable in eliciting responses across all cytokines and time points.
Box plots (Tukey) for (A) IFN-γ, (B) TNF-α and (C) IL-10 responses in peripheral whole blood cells from active VL patients (n = 8) in response to SLA (an Indian L. donovani strain, 10 µg/mL), LV9 (Ethiopian L. donovani strain, 10 µg/mL), LV39 (L. major strain, 10 µg/mL). Antigen-stimulated cytokine responses are provided after subtraction of the non-stimulated control wells. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Cytokine responses to TRYP and LACK recombinant proteins
We previously demonstrated that high CD4-derived IFN-γ to low IL-10 ratios predicted vaccine success in mice when comparing TRYP and LACK as DNA with/without Modified Vaccinia Ankara vaccines , . Here, we examined immune responses to these potential vaccine antigens in clinically well characterized groups of human subjects. The full set of results for IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-10 responses to TRYP (Fig. S2) and LACK (Fig. S3) at 24 hours, 72 hours and 6 days post stimulation in active VL, cured VL, EHC+ve and EHC−ve study groups is provided in the figures S2 and S3. Of note, although the EHC−ve group comprised negative responders to Indian SLA by the modified Quantiferon assay, their cytokine responses to TRYP and LACK was rarely significantly different as a group from cured VL and EHC+ve groups. Hence, we conclude that there are exposed individuals amongst this EHC group, although we did not test non-endemic healthy control responses to these antigens. As this exposure status is variable and equivocal, we exclude them from further analysis of between group responses.
Results for active VL, cured VL and EHC+ve groups are summarised in figures 3 (TRYP) and 4 (LACK). For both antigens, the pattern of IFN-γ and TNF-α responses across the 3 groups is generally established at 24 hours, and clear cut by 72 hours and 6 days, post stimulation. For these two cytokines, responses were significantly lower in active VL compared to cured VL and EHC+ve groups at 72 hours and 6 days post stimulation. The pattern of responses for IL-10 was similar (i.e. higher in cured VL and EHC+ve compared to active VL), but more clearly apparent at 24 hours post-stimulation. This led to interesting between group differences in the ratios of IFN-γ to IL-10 and TNF-α to IL-10 at 24 hours, when ratios were significantly higher in the active VL group compared to cured VL and EHC+ve groups (particularly for TRYP), compared to 6 days of stimulation where the reverse was true for both antigens. For both antigens, the ratios of IFN-γ to IL-10 and TNF-α to IL-10 were highest in the EHC+ve group, suggesting that a potent pro-inflammatory response relative to modest levels of IL-10 may correlate with protection from disease in this confirmed Quantiferon positive exposed EHC group.
Box plots (Tukey) for TRYP recombinant protein (10 µg/mL) stimulated cytokine release at (A–E) 24 hours, (F–G) 72 hours, and (K–O) 6 days post stimulation in active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 20) and EHC+ve (n = 20) study groups (full data for all study groups are provided in Fig. S2). Data are presented for each cytokine response at the different time points (A,F,K IFN-γ; B,G,L TNF-α; C,H,M IL-10) as well as for the ratios of IFN-γ to IL-10 (D,I,N) and TNF-α to IL-10 (E,J,O). Antigen-stimulated cytokine responses are provided after subtraction of the non-stimulated control wells. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Box plots (Tukey) for LACK recombinant protein (10 µg/mL) stimulated cytokine release at (A–E) 24 hours, (F–G) 72 hours, and (K–O) 6 days post stimulation in active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 20) and EHC+ve (n = 20) study groups (full data for all study groups are provided in Fig. S3). Data are presented for each cytokine response at the different time points (A,F,K IFN-γ; B,G,L TNF-α; C,H,M IL-10) as well as for the ratios of IFN-γ to IL-10 (D,I,N) and TNF-α to IL-10 (E,J,O). Antigen-stimulated cytokine responses are provided after subtraction of the non-stimulated control wells. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Antigen specific cytokine release in response to novel vaccine antigens
We previously identified 14 protective Leishmania antigens in a screen of 100 candidates delivered as DNA vaccines to susceptible BALB/c mice . We measured IFN-γ and TNF-α as effector pro-inflammatory cytokine responses to peptide pools for each of 11 of these antigens in diluted whole blood assays, and IL-10 as a measure of their ability to elicit a regulatory cytokine response. A full summary of responder status on a categorical scale (− = <20 pg/ml; + = 20–99 pg/ml; ++ = 100–249; +++ = 250–499 pg/ml; ++++ = 500–10000 pg/ml; ++++ = >10000 pg/ml) to each of the 11 antigens, and to control SLA, PPD and PHA stimulations, is provided for all individuals in Tables S1 and S2. As these antigens were based on L. major sequence data, the antigens are presented throughout in order of their percent identity to L. infantum, as reported by us previously . As would be predicted on the basis of genetic heterogeneity in HLA-restricted T cell responses and other background genetic and environmental factors, not all individuals make a response to individual candidate vaccine antigens. Using cured VL patients as an initial evaluation of percent responders (≥20 ng/mL above background) with time post stimulation, we observed maximal IFN-γ responders at 24 hours and 72 hours post stimulation (Fig. 5A), with 55–87.5% responders to 5 of the novel antigens (R71, L37, N52, J41 and M22; of these L37 exceptional in eliciting the highest sustained IFN-γ responses at day 6 post stimulation, see also Table S2). Comparing across groups for the 72 hour time point (Fig. 5B), we observed 40–65% responders to these 5 novel antigens in the EHC+ve group, with ≥25% of active VL cases also making IFN-γ responses to these antigens. Looking across cytokine responses for these 5 antigens (Fig. 6), we observe a similar profile of TNF-α responses in cured VL and EHC+ve groups as we observed for IFN-γ, but no IL-10. Even amongst active VL cases, N52 was the only antigen to elicit IL-10 responses (Fig. 6L). As for TRYP and LACK, a small number (22–33%) of responders was observed in the EHC−ve group, consistent with evidence of exposure in these individuals despite their negative response in the modified Quantiferon assay. Alternatively, these might represent non-specific responses to these antigens as we did not include non-endemic controls in our study. In summary, we have identified five Leishmania antigens from 11 putative vaccine candidates tested that stimulate potent pro-inflammatory recall responses in exposed but protected individuals (cured VL patients and EHC+ve) in the absence of regulatory IL-10, providing potential immunotherapeutic or vaccine targets for future investigation.
Bar graphs indicating the percentage of responders to peptide pools (5 µg/mL) for each of 11 novel antigens (A) at 24 hours, 72 hours and 6 days post stimulation for the cured VL group, and (B) across active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 16), EHC+ve (n = 20) and EHC−ve (n = 9) groups at the 72 hour time point. Numbers immediately under the bars indicate the percent identity between the originally sequenced L. major proteins and their L. infantum orthologues. See also tables S1 and S2.
Dot plots showing individual cytokine responses in subjects from active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 16), EHC+ve (n = 20) and EHC−ve (n = 9) groups 24 hours post stimulation of whole blood assays with peptide pools (5 µg/mL) for the 5 antigens R71, L37, N52, J41, and M22. Data are presented for each cytokine response (A–E IFN-γ; F–J TNF-α; K–O IL-10). Bars indicate the mean group response. Antigen-stimulated cytokine responses are provided after subtraction of the non-stimulated control wells. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001. Data for 72 hours and 6 days post stimulation are presented in Fig. S4 and Fig. S5, respectively.
A variety of defined antigens have been investigated as vaccine antigen candidates for VL in animal models , , , but few have advanced to human clinical trials , . One limitation in the search for an effective vaccine for leishmaniasis is the lack of information on immunological correlates of natural and vaccine-mediated protection in humans. In recent studies we have highlighted the use of a modified Quantiferon assay to screen for naturally exposed resistant individuals in the Indian study area . That assay relies on 3 mL of undiluted whole blood. Here we show that individuals positive by the modified Quantiferon assay are also positive in our 96-well plate assays using diluted whole blood, providing the means to more efficient screening in large-scale epidemiological studies as has been used previously in studies of mycobacterial diseases , , . Importantly too, our 96-well plate assay also showed that active VL patients were positive for IFN-γ in these diluted whole blood 96-well plate assays. Our initial demonstration  that active VL patients are positive for IFN-γ in the modified Quantiferon assay was remarkable given the numerous previous studies that had failed to observe cellular proliferation or IFN-γ release after stimulation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells from active VL patients with crude Leishmania antigen , , , . Ability to measure this IFN-γ response in the diluted whole blood assay described here will also facilitate more efficient screening of active VL cases using smaller blood volumes in a 96-well plate format.
In human and murine cells infected in vitro, and in mice in vivo, clearance of Leishmania parasites requires IFN-γ. However, IFN-γ alone does not predict vaccine-mediated protection in mice , , , . Rather, the simultaneous production of IFN-γ, IL-2 and TNF-α by a particular subset of CD4 T cells , and/or the balance between pro-inflammatory IFN-γ/TNF-α and regulatory IL-10 , , , , have been variously shown to be predictive of vaccine outcome. Epidemiological studies indicate that patients drug-cured from L. donovani infection are protected against subsequent clinical disease , and it is thought that exposed individuals who test as positive to crude leishmanial antigens in the modified Quantiferon assay employed in our study area in India are infected asymptomatic individuals who are resistant to developing active VL disease . Therefore, in the analysis of human immune responses to known and novel antigens presented here, we hypothesized that ability to stimulate IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-10 in cured VL and EHC+ve individuals, compared to active VL cases, would provide some insight into their potential as vaccine candidates.
Our investigations focused initially on the known vaccine candidates TRYP and LACK. Although others have found LACK protective in murine models of cutaneous leishmaniasis , in the virulent model of visceralising L. major LV39 infection in mice we found that TRYP was protective but LACK was not . Although the vaccine-induced IFN-γ responses were similar between the two antigens in mice, lower IL-10 was elicited by TRYP than LACK, resulting in higher IFN-γ to IL-10 ratios as correlates of protective immunity. In the human studies described here, we found that TRYP and LACK were equivalent to each other in the magnitudes of IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-10 responses elicited, and in generating higher IFN-γ to IL-10 and TNF-α to IL-10 ratios in putatively protected cured VL and EHC+ve individuals than in active VL cases. It was of interest that in India, the asymptomatic EHC+ve group had equivalent responses to the cured VL group, whereas in our recent study  of the same antigens (and antigen preparations) in Brazil, we found that asymptomatic DTH+ve individuals had lower ratios of IFN-γ to IL-10 and TNF-α to IL-10 compared to cured VL patients. This was due to higher IL-10 responses in the DTH+ve group compared to the cured VL group, leading us to suggest that a measure of modulation of the pro-inflammatory response by IL-10 in the DTH+ve group might contribute to the protective response. In active VL disease, high levels of TNF-α contribute to fever and cachexia, and are detrimental , and it is not yet known what role in pathogenesis is played by the strong 24 hour IFN-γ responses observed in whole blood assays in active VL , .
In our analysis of novel vaccine candidates, we found that 5 antigens (R71, L37, N52, J41 and M22) elicited IFN-γ and TNF-α responses in a high percentage of cured VL (55–87.5%) and EHC+ve (40–65%) subjects. This represents remarkable replication of recent findings from an area endemic for L. infantum chagasi in northern Brazil, where 4 of these antigens (R71, L37, N52 and M22; same preparations of peptide pools) also elicited strong IFN-γ and TNF-α responses in both cured VL and exposed asympotmatic DTH+ individuals . In Brazil, responses to J41 were only observed in the cured VL group, but the sample size for DTH+ individuals was small (n = 4). Strong responses were also observed in Brazil to two additional antigens, L302.06 and M18, for which a lower percentage (<30%) of responders were observed in India. This may reflect small samples sizes, differences in amino acid sequences of the parasites, and/or differences in HLA alleles between the two populations. On balance, all of these antigens remain strong candidates in the context of a multivalent cross-species vaccine against leishmaniasis. R71 and L37 are ribosomal proteins with high (100 and 99%, respectively) percentage identity at the amino acid level between L. major and L. infantum . N52 is a V-ATPase subunit F which also has high (94%) identity across the two species. J41 and M22 are hypothetical proteins of unknown function which, despite lower percent identities (73% and 61%, respectively) between L. major and L. infantum, appear to provide cross-reactive epitopes that are recognised in both Brazil  and India. An important contrast between the two endemic regions was the almost complete lack of IL-10 responses to these novel antigens (same preparations of peptide pools) in the Indian study in both cured VL and EHC+ve groups, whereas in the Brazilian study cured VL subjects who were positive for IFN-γ and TNF-α responses also produced IL-10. N52 was also unique in being the only antigen to stimulate IL-10 responses in active VL patients, suggesting that responses to this antigen might provide an important early diagnostic biomarker for disease-associated IL-10 in VL. Further studies are needed to evaluate more carefully the differences in cytokine responses to individual antigens in active compared to cured VL groups, as well as between cured VL and exposed asymptomatic DTH+ or modified Quantiferon positive groups. Unlike Brazil , , DTH responses have not provided a sensitive means of evaluating cell mediated immune response in cured VL or exposed individuals in India , pointing to potential differences in cell-mediated responses between DTH+ compared to Quantiferon positive exposed asymptomatic individuals that might hold the key to uncovering the true correlates of vaccine-induced immunity in leishmaniasis.
Results of our study demonstrate that only a percentage of individuals respond to vaccine antigens that have individually been shown to be protective in mice. This suggests that defined vaccine for use in humans will need to be complex multi-epitope/antigens vaccines. To date, only one multicomponent vaccine, Leish-111f, has been assessed in a large clinical trial . Our recent small-scale clinical trial in a L. donovani endemic area showed Leish-F1-MPL-SE was safe and well tolerated in people with and without prior VL exposure and induced strong antigen-specific T cell responses . The data presented here, and in our earlier study from Brazil , provide evidence to support a number of novel candidates that could be taken forward as vaccines against human leishmaniasis.
Box plots (Tukey) for IFN-γ production by peripheral whole blood cells in response to SLA (an Indian L. donovani strain, 10 µg/mL), or PPD (5 µg/mL) as measured by ELISA. The IFNγ responses in (A) the active VL group (n = 8) are compared with (B) the cured VL group (n = 16), over 24 hours, 72 hours and 6 days post stimulation with SLA or PPD. The data presented in main figure 1 are a subset of the data presented here. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Box plots (Tukey) for TRYP recombinant protein (10 µg/mL) stimulated cytokine release at (A–E) 24 hours, (F–G) 72 hours, and (K–O) 6 days post stimulation in active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 20), EHC+ve (n = 20) and EHC-ve (n = 9) study groups. Data are presented for each cytokine response at the different time points (A,F,K IFN-γ; B,G,L TNF-α; C,H,M IL-10) as well as for the ratios of IFN-γ to IL-10 (D,I,N) and TNF-α to IL-10 (E,J,O). Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Box plots (Tukey) for LACK recombinant protein (10 µg/mL) stimulated cytokine release at (A–E) 24 hours, (F–G) 72 hours, and (K–O) 6 days post stimulation in active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 20), EHC+ve (n = 20) and EHC-ve (n = 9) study groups. Data are presented for each cytokine response at the different time points (A,F,K IFN-γ; B,G,L TNF-α; C,H,M IL-10) as well as for the ratios of IFN-γ to IL-10 (D,I,N) and TNF-α to IL-10 (E,J,O). Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Dot plots showing individual cytokine responses in subjects from active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 16), EHC+ve (n = 20) and EHC−ve (n = 9) groups 72 hours post stimulation of whole blood assays with peptide pools (5 µg/mL) for the 5 antigens R71, L37, N52, J41, and M22. Data are presented for each cytokine response (A–E IFN-γ; F–J TNF-α; K–O IL-10). Bars indicate the mean group response. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
Dot plots showing individual cytokine responses in subjects from active VL (n = 8), cured VL (n = 16), EHC+ve (n = 20) and EHC−ve (n = 9) groups 6 days post stimulation of whole blood assays with peptide pools (5 µg/mL) for the 5 antigens R71, L37, N52, J41, and M22. Data are presented for each cytokine response (A–E IFN-γ; F–J TNF-α; K–O IL-10). Bars indicate the mean group response. Statistical differences between groups determined using the non-parametric Man-Whitney test are indicated by bars above columns, * indicates p<0.05, ** p<0.01, and *** p<0.001.
IFN-γ responses in individuals cured from VL at 24 hours, 72 hours, and 6 days after stimulation of whole blood ex vivo with candidate vaccine antigens (peptide pools; 5 µg/mL), SLA (10 µg/mL), PPD (5 µg/mL), or mitogen PHA (5 µg/mL). IFN-γ levels were measured by ELISA. Percent identity with L. infantum sequence at the amino acid level is indicated below candidate vaccine antigens (R71, Q51, etc.), which were originally derived from L. major.
IFN-γ responses in EHC +ve (EC-01 to EC-20), active VL (Vl-1 to VL-8) and EHC-ve (EC-42 to EC-50) individuals at 72 hours after stimulation of whole blood ex vivo with candidate vaccine antigens (peptide pools; 5 µg/mL), SLA (10 µg/mL), PPD (5 µg/mL), or mitogen PHA (5 µg/mL). IFN-γ levels were measured by ELISA.
We would like to thank the hospital staffs at Kala–azar Medical Research Centre, Muzaffarpur for their assistance in the collection of blood samples and all research scholars of Infectious Disease Research Laboratory, Banaras Hindu University for their kind help during the study. Om Prakash Singh thanks CSIR, New Delhi, India for providing a Senior Research Fellowship.
Conceived and designed the experiments: CBS JMB. Performed the experiments: OPS AKS. Analyzed the data: OPS JMB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: CBS JMB. Wrote the paper: OPS CBS JMB. Supervised the research: SS.
- 1. Alvar J, Velez ID, Bern C, Herrero M, Desjeux P, et al. (2012) Leishmaniasis worldwide and global estimates of its incidence. PLoS ONE 7: e35671.
- 2. Badaro R, Jones TC, Carvalho EM, Sampaio D, Reed SG, et al. (1986) New perspectives on a subclinical form of visceral leishmaniasis. J Infect Dis 154: 1003–1009.
- 3. Badaro R, Jones TC, Lorenco R, Cerf BJ, Sampaio D, et al. (1986) A prospective study of visceral leishmaniasis in an endemic area of Brazil. J Infect Dis 154: 639–649.
- 4. Jeronimo SM, Oliveira RM, Mackay S, Costa RM, Sweet J, et al. (1994) An urban outbreak of visceral leishmaniasis in Natal, Brazil. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 88: 386–388.
- 5. Jeronimo SM, Teixeira MJ, Sousa A, Thielking P, Pearson RD, et al. (2000) Natural history of Leishmania (Leishmania) chagasi infection in Northeastern Brazil: long-term follow-up. Clin Infect Dis 30: 608–609.
- 6. Gidwani K, Jones S, Kumar R, Boelaert M, Sundar S (2011) Interferon-gamma release assay (modified Quantiferon) as a potential marker of infection for Leishmania donovani, a proof of concept study. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 5: e1042.
- 7. Ostyn B, Gidwani K, Khanal B, Picado A, Chappuis F, et al. (2011) Incidence of symptomatic and asymptomatic Leishmania donovani infections in high-endemic foci in India and Nepal: a prospective study. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 5: e1284.
- 8. Bern C, Haque R, Chowdhury R, Ali M, Kurkjian KM, et al. (2007) The epidemiology of visceral leishmaniasis and asymptomatic leishmanial infection in a highly endemic Bangladeshi village. Am J Trop Med Hyg 76: 909–914.
- 9. Yazdanbakhsh M, Sacks DL (2010) Why does immunity to parasites take so long to develop? Nat Rev Immunol 10: 80–81.
- 10. Nylen S, Sacks D (2007) Interleukin-10 and the pathogenesis of human visceral leishmaniasis. Trends Immunol 28: 378–384.
- 11. Darrah PA, Patel DT, De Luca PM, Lindsay RW, Davey DF, et al. (2007) Multifunctional TH1 cells define a correlate of vaccine-mediated protection against Leishmania major. Nat Med 13: 843–850.
- 12. Stober C, Lange U, Roberts MTM, Alcami A, Blackwell JM (2005) IL-10 from regulatory T cells determines vaccine efficacy in murine Leishmania major infection. J Immunol 175: 2517–2514.
- 13. Dondji B, Deak E, Goldsmith-Pestana K, Perez-Jimenez E, Esteban M, et al. (2008) Intradermal NKT cell activation during DNA priming in heterologous prime-boost vaccination enhances T cell responses and protection against Leishmania. Eur J Immunol 38: 706–719.
- 14. Reece WH, Pinder M, Gothard PK, Milligan P, Bojang K, et al. (2004) A CD4(+) T-cell immune response to a conserved epitope in the circumsporozoite protein correlates with protection from natural Plasmodium falciparum infection and disease. Nat Med 10: 406–410.
- 15. Badaro R, Lobo I, Nakatani M, Muinos A, Netto EM, et al. (2001) Successful use of a defined antigen/GM-CSF adjuvant vaccine to treat mucosal Leishmaniasis refractory to antimony: A case report. Braz J Infect Dis 5: 223–232.
- 16. Khalil EA, El Hassan AM, Zijlstra EE, Mukhtar MM, Ghalib HW, et al. (2000) Autoclaved Leishmania major vaccine for prevention of visceral leishmaniasis: a randomised, double-blind, BCG-controlled trial in Sudan. Lancet 356: 1565–1569.
- 17. Noazin S, Khamesipour A, Moulton LH, Tanner M, Nasseri K, et al. (2009) Efficacy of killed whole-parasite vaccines in the prevention of leishmaniasis: a meta-analysis. Vaccine 27: 4747–4753.
- 18. Antunes CM, Mayrink W, Magalhaes PA, Costa CA, Melo MN, et al. (1986) Controlled field trials of a vaccine against New World cutaneous leishmaniasis. Int J Epidemiol 15: 572–580.
- 19. Khalil EA, El Hassan AM, Zijlstra EE, Mukhtar MM, Ghalib HW, et al. (2000) Autoclaved Leishmania major vaccine for prevention of visceral leishmaniasis: a randomised, double-blind, BCG-controlled trial in Sudan. Lancet 356: 1565–1569.
- 20. Mayrink W, da Costa CA, Magalhaes PA, Melo MN, Dias M, et al. (1979) A field trial of a vaccine against American dermal leishmaniasis. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 73: 385–387.
- 21. Momeni AZ, Jalayer T, Emamjomeh M, Khamesipour A, Zicker F, et al. (1999) A randomised, double-blind, controlled trial of a killed L. major vaccine plus BCG against zoonotic cutaneous leishmaniasis in Iran. Vaccine 17: 466–472.
- 22. Sharifi I, FeKri AR, Aflatonian MR, Khamesipour A, Nadim A, et al. (1998) Randomised vaccine trial of single dose of killed Leishmania major plus BCG against anthroponotic cutaneous leishmaniasis in Bam, Iran. Lancet 351: 1540–1543.
- 23. Singh OP, Gidwani K, Kumar R, Nylen S, Jones SL, et al. (2012) Reassessment of immune correlates in human visceral leishmaniasis as defined by cytokine release in whole blood. Clin Vaccine Immunol 19: 961–966.
- 24. Ivens AC, Peacock CS, Worthey EA, Murphy L, Aggarwal G, et al. (2005) The genome of the kinetoplastid parasite, Leishmania major. Science 309: 436–442.
- 25. Stober CB, Lange UG, Roberts MT, Gilmartin B, Francis R, et al. (2006) From genome to vaccines for leishmaniasis: screening 100 novel vaccine candidates against murine Leishmania major infection. Vaccine 24: 2602–2616.
- 26. Scott P, Pearce E, Natovitz P, Sher A (1987) Vaccination against cutaneous leishmaniasis in a murine model. II. Immunologic properties of protective and nonprotective subfractions of soluble promastigote extract. J Immunol 139: 3118–3125.
- 27. Smith PK, Krohn RI, Hermenson GT, Mallia AK, Gartner FH, et al. (1985) Measurement of protein using bicinchoninic acid. anal Bio Chem 150: 76.
- 28. Stober CB, Jeronimo SMB, Pontes NN, Miller EN, Blackwell JM (2012) Cytokine responses to novel antigens in a peri-urban population in Brazil exposed to Leishmania infantum chagasi. Am J Trop Med Hyg in press.
- 29. Barral-Netto M, Badaro R, Barral A, Almeida RP, Santos SB, et al. (1991) Tumor necrosis factor (cachectin) in human visceral leishmaniasis. J Infect Dis 163: 853–857.
- 30. Nylen S, Maurya R, Eidsmo L, Manandhar KD, Sundar S, et al. (2007) Splenic accumulation of IL-10 mRNA in T cells distinct from CD4+CD25+ (Foxp3) regulatory T cells in human visceral leishmaniasis. J Exp Med 204: 805–817.
- 31. Stober CB, Lange UG, Roberts MT, Alcami A, Blackwell JM (2007) Heterologous priming-boosting with DNA and modified vaccinia virus Ankara expressing tryparedoxin peroxidase promotes long-term memory against Leishmania major in susceptible BALB/c Mice. Infect Immun 75: 852–860.
- 32. Rafati S, Nakhaee A, Taheri T, Taslimi Y, Darabi H, et al. (2005) Protective vaccination against experimental canine visceral leishmaniasis using a combination of DNA and protein immunization with cysteine proteinases type I and II of L. infantum. Vaccine 23: 3716–3725.
- 33. Samant M, Gupta R, Kumari S, Misra P, Khare P, et al. (2009) Immunization with the DNA-encoding N-terminal domain of proteophosphoglycan of Leishmania donovani generates Th1-type immunoprotective response against experimental visceral leishmaniasis. J Immunol 183: 470–479.
- 34. Tewary P, Jain M, Sahani MH, Saxena S, Madhubala R (2005) A heterologous prime-boost vaccination regimen using ORFF DNA and recombinant ORFF protein confers protective immunity against experimental visceral leishmaniasis. J Infect Dis 191: 2130–2137.
- 35. Duthie MS, Raman VS, Piazza FM, Reed SG (2012) The development and clinical evaluation of second-generation leishmaniasis vaccines. Vaccine 30: 134–141.
- 36. Chakravarty J, Kumar S, Trivedi S, Rai VK, Singh A, et al. (2011) A clinical trial to evaluate the safety and immunogenicity of the LEISH-F1+MPL-SE vaccine for use in the prevention of visceral leishmaniasis. Vaccine 29: 3531–3537.
- 37. Black GF, Dockrell HM, Crampin AC, Floyd S, Weir RE, et al. (2001) Patterns and implications of naturally acquired immune responses to environmental and tuberculous mycobacterial antigens in northern Malawi. J Infect Dis 184: 322–329.
- 38. Black GF, Fine PEM, Warndorff DK, Floyd S, Weir RE, et al. (2001) Relationship between IFN-gamma and skin test responsiveness to Mycobacterium tuberculosis PPD in healthy, non-BCG-vaccinated young adults in Northern Malawi. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 5: 664–672.
- 39. Black GF, Weir RE, Floyd S, Bliss L, Warndorff DK, et al. (2002) BCG-induced increase in interferon-gamma response to mycobacterial antigens and efficacy of BCG vaccination in Malawi and the UK: two randomised controlled studies. Lancet 359: 1393–1401.
- 40. Ghalib HW, Piuvezam MR, Skeiky YA, Siddig M, Hashim FA, et al. (1993) Interleukin 10 production correlates with pathology in human Leishmania donovani infections. J Clin Invest 92: 324–329.
- 41. Saha S, Mondal S, Ravindran R, Bhowmick S, Modak D, et al. (2007) IL-10- and TGF-beta-mediated susceptibility in kala-azar and post-kala-azar dermal leishmaniasis: the significance of amphotericin B in the control of Leishmania donovani infection in India. J Immunol 179: 5592–5603.
- 42. Carvalho EM, Badaro R, Reed SG, Jones TC, Johnson WD Jr (1985) Absence of gamma interferon and interleukin 2 production during active visceral leishmaniasis. J Clin Invest 76: 2066–2069.
- 43. Roberts MTM, Stober C, McKenzie AN, Blackwell JM (2005) IL-4 and IL-10 collude in vaccine failure for novel exacerbatory antigens in murine Leishmania major infection. Infect Immun 73: 7620–7628.
- 44. Jayakumar A, Castilho TM, Park E, Goldsmith-Pestana K, Blackwell JM, et al. (2011) TLR1/2 activation during heterologous prime-boost vaccination (DNA-MVA) enhances CD8+ T Cell responses providing protection against Leishmania (Viannia). PLoS Negl Trop Dis 5: e1204.
- 45. Dondji B, Perez-Jimenez E, Goldsmith-Pestana K, Esteban M, McMahon-Pratt D (2005) Prime-boost vaccination using the LACK antigen protects against murine visceral leishmaniasis. Infect Immun 73: 5286–5289.
- 46. Greenblatt CL (1988) Cutaneous leishmaniasis: The prospects for a killed vaccine. Parasitol Today 4: 53–54.
- 47. Gurunathan S, Sacks DL, Brown DR, Reiner SL, Charest H, et al. (1997) Vaccination with DNA encoding the immunodominant LACK parasite antigen confers protective immunity to mice infected with Leishmania major. J Exp Med 186: 1137–1147.
- 48. Gidwani K, Rai M, Chakravarty J, Boelaert M, Sundar S (2009) Evaluation of leishmanin skin test in Indian visceral leishmaniasis. Am J Trop Med Hyg 80: 566–567.
- 49. Coler RN, Reed SG (2005) Second-generation vaccines against leishmaniasis. Trends Parasitol 21: 244–249.