Visceral leishmaniasis is a major neglected tropical disease, with an estimated 500,000 new cases and more than 50,000 deaths attributable to this disease every year. Drug therapy is available but costly and resistance against several drug classes has evolved. Despite all efforts, no commercial, let alone affordable, vaccine is available to date. Thus, the development of cost effective, needle-independent vaccines is a high priority. Here, we have continued efforts to develop live vaccine carriers based on recombinant Salmonella. We used an in silico approach to select novel Leishmania parasite antigens from proteomic data sets, with selection criteria based on protein abundance, conservation across Leishmania species and low homology to host species. Five chosen antigens were differentially expressed on the surface or in the cytosol of Salmonella typhimurium SL3261. A two-step procedure was developed to select optimal Salmonella vaccine strains for each antigen, based on bacterial fitness and antigen expression levels. We show that vaccine strains of Salmonella expressing the novel Leishmania antigens LinJ08.1190 and LinJ23.0410 significantly reduced visceralisation of L. major and enhanced systemic resistance against L. donovani in susceptible BALB/c mice. The results show that Salmonella are valid vaccine carriers for inducing resistance against visceral leishmaniasis but that their use may not be suitable for all antigens.
The leishmaniases are tropical diseases that affect the poorest of the poor. They are caused by Leishmania species, protozoan parasites transmitted by blood sucking insects and the visceral form of the disease is fatal. Vaccines that would tremendously boost disease control strategies need to be designed cost-efficiently and for the existing infrastructure. Salmonella-based live vaccines could fulfil these requirements as they can be cheaply produced on an industrial scale and the lyophilized product can be stored at room temperature and upon rehydration is ready for oral, needle-free application. Salmonella, like Leishmania, are intracellular pathogens that primarily target host macrophages. The bacteria induce a viscerotropic immune response. Herein lies a potentially significant advantage of using attenuated Salmonella as delivery vehicles for parasite antigens for vaccination against visceral leishmaniasis. We used in vivo inducible promoters and optimized expression systems to construct attenuated Salmonella carriers that deliver novel vaccine antigens and show a host protective effect in small rodent models of visceral leishmaniasis. These proof-of-concept studies should serve to further promote exploration of live Salmonella as a cost effective and widely applicable carrier for vaccination against leishmaniases.
Citation: Schroeder J, Brown N, Kaye P, Aebischer T (2011) Single Dose Novel Salmonella Vaccine Enhances Resistance against Visceralizing L. major and L. donovani Infection in Susceptible BALB/c Mice. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 5(12): e1406. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0001406
Editor: Diane McMahon-Pratt, Yale School of Public Health, United States of America
Received: April 4, 2011; Accepted: October 13, 2011; Published: December 27, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Schroeder et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by a Marie Curie Grant EU-EXT-25435 to TA, and by MRC Programme Grant G0400786 to PMK. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The leishmaniases are regarded as neglected tropical diseases. The causative protozoan parasites are transmitted through the bite of sandfly vectors. Currently an estimated 12 million people are infected, while 350 million people in 88 countries worldwide are at risk to develop one of the diseases associated with Leishmania parasites (http://www.who.int/leishmaniasis/burden/en/; ). The most severe form is visceral leishmaniasis (VL; also known as kala azar in India) a disease that is fatal if untreated. An estimated 500 000 new cases and 50 000 deaths are reported every year, with 90% occurring in Bangladesh, Nepal, India, Sudan, Ethiopia and Brazil (). VL caused by L. infantum/chagasi is zoonotic with dogs being the main reservoir; however, in areas endemic for L. donovani (e.g. India and Sudan) the disease is anthroponotic.
In many cases infection remains asymptomatic, most likely indicating immune control. However, patients with symptomatic VL experience fever, fatigue, weight loss and weakness often accompanied by hepato-splenomegaly and anaemia and, if untreated, may die from bacterial co-infections, internal bleeding and anaemia (reviewed by (2]). Chemotherapy is available, but due to high toxicity, adverse side effects and emerging parasite resistance, treatment options are limited –. Long treatment regimens and associated costs are additional critical factors preventing patient access and compliance. For example paromomycin, a newly registered drug, is given by intra-muscular injections over a period of 21 days. Though the cheapest drug available, treatment still costs between 5 and 10 US$ per course, making this drug too expensive in relation to household income . This economic burden of treatment is likely to remain for the foreseeable future. Thus, developing a vaccine for VL (and indeed for other forms of leishmaniasis) is high on the agenda of the World Health Assembly (resolution EB118.R3, Geneva 05/07).
Vaccination is considered possible because of the efficacy of the century-old practice of leishmanization against old world cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL), a treatment that affords life long protection as proven during its large scale use to protect military personnel in Israel, Iran and the former Soviet Union –. However, in some individuals, development of non-healing lesions, exacerbation of chronic disease and immunosuppression as a result of this procedure has been observed . The unsatisfactory safety profile, its questionable efficacy against infection with heterologous species and logistic hurdles render leishmanization problematic. Vaccines that relied on autoclaved or merthiolate-killed whole promastigotes formulated with or without Bacillus Calmette-Guerin as adjuvants were developed to remedy some of the shortcomings of leishmanization but a recent meta-analysis of clinical studies evaluating these vaccines did not support their efficacy .
Clinical testing of vaccines based on recombinant Leishmania antigens or fractionated parasite material is much less advanced, although numerous antigenic proteins have been shown to have vaccine potential in pre-clinical models (see reviews by –). These antigens were usually discovered by classical approaches, i.e. by screening with immune or hyperimmune sera from patients or infected animals. Antibody reactivity may not be an ideal criterion since protection is cell mediated and is thought to depend on both CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes –. More recently, however, parasite genome information has become available and vaccine-antigen discovery exploiting this information has been promoted . Recombinant DNA technology enables the formulation of subunit vaccines consisting of one or few specified antigens as DNA- and vectored vaccines, the latter exploiting viruses or bacteria as vaccine vehicles (summarised by , , ). Indeed, expressed sequence-tag based vaccine antigen discovery has been explored . However, of 100 ORFs tested only 14 showed detectable protective effects when tested in a high dose infection model of murine CL. This was probably not surprising given that gene expression is regulated mainly post transcriptionally in Leishmania and suggests a need to improve sequence selection criteria.
Here, we adapted a reverse vaccinology  approach to define novel candidate vaccines, starting from proteomic data sets that were generated recently  and ignoring whether or not proteins would be recognized by sera from infected hosts. Moreover, we optimized recombinant attenuated Salmonella as a vaccine carrier platform since they had been explored before as vectors for anti-Leishmania vaccines – and have already been developed for vaccination purposes in humans –.
Materials and Methods
Female BALB/c mice were purchased from Harlan UK, Charles River UK or bred and maintained under specific pathogen-free conditions in individually ventilated cages in the animal facilities of the School of Biological Sciences at the University of Edinburgh and the University of York. Animals were used at 6–9 weeks of age and were age matched within each experiment. All animal experiments adhered to the UK Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 and were conducted under Project Licenses granted by the UK Home Office and with local ethical approval (License # PPL 60/03581 to TA and PPL 60/03708 to PK).
Construction of expression plasmids
To inducibly express antigens on the surface of Salmonella, the E. coli adhesin involved in diffuse adherence (AIDA) autotransporter system was adapted and a variant of plasmid pKRI143  was constructed, pAIDA0, as previously described . Briefly, the sequence encoding cholera toxin B subunit signal peptide was followed by SpeI/BglII sites for in frame directional cloning of ORF of interest fused with downstream sequences coding for a hemagglutinin epitope (HA)-tag and the transporter domain of AIDA, all under the control of the in vivo inducible Mg2+ responsive PpagC promoter .
Vaccine antigen ORFs encoding L. donovani KMP-11 (LinJ35_V3.2260), ORF LinJ08.1190 (LinJ08_V3.1190), ORF LinJ09.1180 (LinJ09_V3.1180), ORF LinJ23.0410 (LinJ23_V3.0420), ORF LinJ25.1680 (LinJ25_V3.1670) and ORF LinJ35.0240 (LinJ35_V3.0140) were amplified from L. donovani (MHOM/INI/03BHU-55) genomic DNA using primers shown in table 1. ORF nomenclature and accession numbers are indicated in Table 2. Amplifications were carried out with the Platinum® Pfx DNA Polymerase kit (Invitrogen). PCR products were digested with SpeI and BglII and cloned into the equally digested pAIDA0 for transformation into SL3261 and E. coli JK321(UT5600 zih::Tn10 dsbA::kan) , respectively.
To differentially regulate protein expression levels, point mutations were introduced into the Shine-Dalgarno ribosomal binding sequence (RBS; underlined) using site directed mutagenesis. Forward primer for RBS3 (5′-GATCAATCTAGATTTAAGAAGCAGATATACATATGATTAAATTAAAATTTGGTG-3′), RBS4 (5′-GATCAATCTAGATTTAAGAAGGGAATATACATATGATTAAATTAAAATTTGGTG-3′) and RBS5 (5′-GATCAATCTAGATTTAAGAAAGAAATATACATATGATTAAATTAAAATTTGGTG-3′) were designed to amplify the cholera toxin signal peptide, HA-tag and antigen while simultaneously introducing the mutated Shine-Dalgarno sequence upstream of the signal peptide. The resulting PCR product was SpeI/BglII digested and re-ligated into pAIDA-Antigen. All resulting surface expression plasmids were subsequently named psVAC[# of RBS mutation]-antigen.
For expression of antigens in the salmonella cytosol L. donovani ORFs were amplified using primers described in Table 1. Resulting PCR products flanked by 5′ NdeI and 3′ BamHI sites were digested and first cloned downstream of a PpagC promoter into a pBR322-derived plasmid series already containing mutated Shine-Dalgarno sequences (RBS1 – AGGAA, RBS2 – GGGAA and RBS3 – AGCAG) described in  for transformation into SL3261. The resulting plasmids were subsequently named pcVAC[# of RBS mutation]-antigen. Preparation of live vaccine stocks, immunizations and determination of bacterial fitness by in vivo colonisation have been performed exactly as described before .
Purification of recombinant proteins
For generating recombinant proteins, Leishmania antigen ORFs were cloned into pET28a(+) (Novagen). All antigens were amplified using the NdeI and BamHI site containing primers described above. Recombinant proteins were purified as described previously . KMP-11, the only soluble protein was directly purified on a Nickel column (1 ml, HisTrap FF, GE Healthcare). All other antigens formed inclusion bodies which needed to be isolated and dissolved prior purification under denaturing conditions with an on-column refolding step .
Recombinant protein containing fractions eluted from columns (see Fig. S1) were pooled and protein concentrations determined using amidoblack ). Proteins LinJ08.1190, LinJ09.1180, LinJ23.0410 and LinJ25.1680 became insoluble when imidazole was removed; hence 50 µl/well of a 50 µg/ml protein eluate was used to coat 96-well plates (MaxiSorb, Nunc) for ELISA. Plates were sealed and stored at 4°C until needed. For T cell re-stimulation assays imidazole was removed by dialysis against TBS/150 mM NaCl and subsequently concentrated by ultrafiltration using Centricons® (Millipore) of appropriate pore size.
Enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay
ELISA for antigen-specific antibodies of different isotypes (IgG1 and IgG2a) from mouse serum has been performed as previously described . In brief, serial dilutions of individual sera were analysed. To estimate relative antibody concentrations, titers were determined corresponding to the value of the serum dilution giving a half maximal ELISA signal.
L. major infection and determination of parasite burden in limiting dilution assays
L. major promastigotes were grown in semi-defined medium until late stationary phase was reached. Two million parasites were injected into the left hind footpad and lesion size was measured as the difference in thickness between infected and uninfected footpad using a calliper. For determination of parasite numbers in organs mice were sacrificed by cerebral dislocation and organs (spleen, draining lymph node, footpad) were removed and homogenized. The single cell suspensions were adjusted to equal volumes and subjected to serial dilutions in 96-well tissue culture plates filled with SDM medium  supplemented with 20 µg/ml hygromycin and 50 µg/ml kanamycin, which was carried out in quadruplets. After 14 days at 27°C, parasite growth was scored microscopically and parasite load in the infected organs was calculated using the dilution where at least 2 of 4 wells (>37.5%) were positive . This dilution was multiplied by the total volume (in multiples of 0.1 ml) to derive the total number of parasites per organ.
Determination of hepato-splenomegaly and L. donovani burden in impression smears
Mice were killed by cervical dislocation and livers and spleens were removed and weighed. The body-mass index (BMI) was calculated as the organ weight in percentage of body weight. To determine parasitic burden in spleen and liver, impression smears were prepared on microscopic glass slides, fixed in methanol and stained with Giemsa. The number of parasites per 1000 host cell nuclei was counted using a light-field microscope and an immersion oil lens. Leishman-Donovan units (LDU) were calculated by multiplication of the number of parasites/1000 nuclei with the organ weight .
Histopathological analysis of hepatic response to L. donovani
Liver sections were processed for immunohistochemistry as described in detail elsewhere . Briefly, confocal microscopy was performed on acetone fixed 8 µm frozen sections stained with Alexa 488-conjugated F4/80 (eBioscience, United Kingdom and purified rabbit anti-mouse inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) (Abcam, United Kingdom) detected with donkey anti-rabbit Alexa 647. Sections were counterstained with 4′,6′-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI), and mounted in Pro-Long Gold antifade (Invitrogen) for examination on a LSM META 510 confocal microscope (Zeiss). Quantification of NOS2 staining was performed on randomly selected fields for each mouse, using Adobe Photoshop CS3 to determine the area of iNOS reactivity (as number of positively stained pixels) relative to total granuloma area (as pixels stained with F4/80). Granuloma maturation was assessed from hematoxylin-eosin (H&E)-stained tissue sections as described elsewhere .
Statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism Program (Version 4.0, GraphPad Software, San Diego, California). Depending on data passing normality tests, ANOVA was performed with appropriate post-tests for pairwise comparisons or Mann-Whitney tests were computed. P values less than 0.05 were considered significant.
In silico selection of novel antigen candidates from Leishmania
For the selection of novel antigen candidates, we conducted a bioinformatic analysis of a proteomic dataset that compared the proteomes of pro- and amastigote stages of L. mexicana . This data set was chosen because to date this is the only dataset containing information on truly intracellular parasites and because a comparison with data from a proteomic analysis of L. donovani axenic amastigotes suggested a very high degree of overlap with respect to abundant proteins . From a total of 509 proteins that reflect the set of highly abundant proteins, we selected five novel antigen candidates based on abundance, conservation throughout the genus and lack of homologies to host proteins (Figure 1). These criteria and, in addition, predicted subcellular localization were found before to be valuable to identify antigens for induction of protective T cell responses from complex organisms, operationally defined here as expressing ≫103 different protein antigens, e.g. to select antigens for vaccines against Helicobacter pylori . A further, Leishmania-relevant criterion was the expression of the potential antigen in appropriate life cycle stages. Preference was given to proteins expressed in the disease-causing intracellular amastigote stage, but, since early stages of infection after transmission of promastigotes were also considered relevant, antigen expression in both life cycle stages was not an exclusion criterion. Four selected antigens were present in the proteomic datasets of both stages while the LinJ23.0410 corresponding protein was present only in the amastigote dataset. Homologues of the encoding genes were found in all cases in L. major, L. infantum, L. donovani and L. braziliensis genomes with a very high degree of conservation (ranging from 78.9% to 95.8% identity of amino acid sequence, increasing to 87.6% to 99% when including conserved substitutions). Sequence homologies to proteins of mouse and human (human as final target and mouse as a model host) were excluded by BLAST searches. This approach was biased and preferentially excluded similar sequence-dependent epitopes. It was used here because it was assumed to enhance the likelihood of antigens to be recognized by T cells as “foreign” and to reduce the risk of potential autoimmune sequelae.
I: Abundance: A proteomic data set (c.f. Table S1 in ref.  consisting of 509 different proteins representing the most abundant proteins of L. mexicana was used as a starting set describing potential vaccine antigens. II: No sequence homology to target vaccination populations and conservation within Leishmania spp.: these criteria can be applied more or less stringently, we applied stringent thresholds for selecting against homologous proteins by focusing only on hypothetical conserved proteins (c.f. Table S1 in ref.  that at time of selection included LinJ09.1180) whereby the number of candidates was reduced to 185 at this step of selection. III: Life-cycle stage occurrence: proteomic evidence for expression of candidates in amastigotes or throughout the life cycle was required reducing the candidate list to 39 proteins. Preference was given in step VI to a set of six based on likelihood to be expressible as AIDA autotransporter fusion proteins in salmonella carriers and by re-iterating the selection based on conservation within the genus resulting in candidates with sequence identity >78%.
Novelty and expressability in our salmonella expression systems were additional final selection criterion but we also included the well characterized antigen KMP-11 as a reference vaccine antigen. This antigen has been shown to be protective against L. donovani, when administered as a DNA vaccine , .
Generation and optimization of S. typhimurium vaccine carrier strains
Subcellular localization and protein amount are not only useful criteria to select T cell vaccine antigens, they are also crucial parameters to consider in the construction of recombinant live vaccine carriers - such as bacteria - to induce antigen-specific cell mediated immunity , . Thus, two expression systems were adapted that directed antigens either to the cytosol or the surface of Salmonella and allow induced expression via the in vivo inducible promoter PpagC. We choose to control antigen production at the translational level and introduced a set of point mutations into a canonical ribosomal binding site (RBS) creating a set of four plasmid cassettes each for cytosolic and surface antigen expression. These mutations resulted in staggered protein expression levels when Salmonella strains carrying the respective plasmids were grown under conditions that activate the PpagC promoter (Figure S2). Heterologous protein expression can greatly reduce fitness of the carrier bacteria in vivo, thereby critically affecting the amount of total antigen delivered to the immune system and thus vaccine immunogenicity. This relationship is schematically shown in Figure 2A (left panel) and, as an example, is shown for vaccine strains engineered for cytosolic expression of LinJ23.0410 (Figure 2A, right panel). Colonisation of the Peyer's patches seven days after oral administration of 109 CFU was determined as a measure of bacterial fitness. Expression of LinJ23.0410 was clearly negatively correlated with the number of CFU found in Peyer's patches, i.e. vaccine strain fitness. Use of a canonical, non-mutated RBS (RBS0) resulted in high amounts of protein but greatly reduced bacterial fitness. Introduction of point mutations (RBS1, 2, 3) lowered expression levels from intermediate (RBS1) to very low (RBS2 and 3) which brought fitness back to the level of the empty carrier strain (Figure 2A right panel). A reduction of bacterial fitness far below 104 CFU in this assay, based on past experience (JS and TA unpublished), rendered vaccine strains non-immunogenic with respect to the recombinantly expressed antigen. Thus, out of 48 bacterial strains constructed and evaluated as shown for the example above, 10 strains were selected for further testing. Their respective fitness and antigen expression characteristics were as shown in Figure 2B.
Candidate antigen expression and ability to colonize Peyer's patches after intragastric inoculation was determined experimentally to select optimal strains. Expression of the HA-tagged antigens was assessed by SDS-PAGE in lysates of vaccine strains grown under low Mg2+ conditions to mimic the in vivo intraphagosomal environment that activates the PpagC promoter. Vaccine antigen expression was visualized by coomassie stain (cytosol expressing strains) or by Western blot analysis using an anti-HA tag antibody (surface expressing strains). (A, left panel) A schematic plot is shown to illustrate how the degree of foreign antigen expression reduces bacterial fitness and how both factors influence the immunogenicity of a carrier strain. (A, right panel) Real data example of fitness as a function of antigen expression using SL3261 expressing increasing amounts of LinJ23.0410 in the cytosol. (B) Characteristics of bacterial fitness and recombinant protein produced by final selected strains with surface (left panel) or cytosolic (right panel) expression.
Interestingly, antigens LinJ08.1190, LinJ09.1180, LinJ25.1680 and LinJ35.0240 could not be expressed in the cytosol (data not shown) but vaccine strains could be obtained, with the exception of LinJ35.0240, when the antigens were targeted to the bacterial surface. In consequence, only two vaccine strains expressing the antigens KMP-11 and LinJ23.0410 cytosolically could be included in the panel (Figure 2B, right panel). In addition, eight surface expression strains were selected (Figure. 2B, left panel). Surface expression of antigen LinJ35.0240 could not be detected via western blot despite a clear influence on bacterial fitness (Figure 2B left panel). Based on the latter, it was therefore decided to include psVAC5-35.0240 as an example for the respective antigen.
Protection of mice against L. major
All selected strains were next tested in vivo for their ability to protect BALB/c mice against visceralising L. major infection. These mice are highly susceptible to L. major infection, and have been suggested to provide a good mouse model for VL. Mice were vaccinated with a single dose of Salmonella vaccine strains, the carrier control SL3261 or treated with PBS. Mice were subsequently challenged with 2×106 late-stationary phase L. major promastigotes into the left hind footpad. Lesion size was monitored over a course of several weeks after which mice were randomized and selected for analysis of parasitic burden in footpad, lymph node and spleen.
A pilot study involving all 10 selected vaccine strains showed that vaccination with Salmonella carrying antigens LinJ08.1190 and LinJ23.0410 reduced lesion size and parasitic burden compared to the controls (see Figure S3). Interestingly, vaccination with antigen LinJ25.1680 expressing Salmonella exacerbated disease while the other vaccines including the KMP-11-expressing strains had no effect on disease progression compared to controls (Figure S3).
Thus, the presumably protective vaccine strains psVAC5-08.1190, pcVAC1-23.0410 and psVAC0-23.0410 as well as a mixture of these (from hereon named ‘vaccine allstars’), were further evaluated (Figure 3). Vaccination, especially with psVAC5-08.1190 and vaccine allstars, significantly delayed the onset and progression of footpad swelling in mice challenged nine weeks later (Figure 3A). Five weeks after infection, five animals per groups were selected randomly and parasitic burden in spleen, popliteal lymph node and footpad was determined. Parasite numbers in footpads and lymph nodes were not significantly different in the vaccine groups (Figure 3B, C) although a trend towards lower burdens was notable in mice vaccinated with psVAC0-23.0410, psVAC5-08.1190 and vaccine allstars (Figure 3B, C). The discrepancy between lesion size and parasite burden was surprising but is not without precedence. The inverse situation has been described in murine L. major infection when analysing TNR-p55 receptor deficient mice  or when mapping susceptibility loci , . However, mechanisms are currently not fully understood. The parasitic burden in the spleen was assessed as a surrogate marker of protection against visceral leishmaniasis. Immunisation with the psVAC5-08.1190 and allstars vaccines significantly reduced parasite numbers in the spleen compared to challenged only mice and a similar trend was noted for the surface expressing psVAC0-23.0140 vaccine (Figure 3D). Of note, five animals amongst those vaccinated with psVAC5-08.1190 and vaccine allstars had no detectable parasites in the spleen (Figure 3D). Hence, a single oral dose of Salmonella vectored vaccines that delivered both LinJ08.1190 with LinJ23.0410 significantly reduced visceral L. major parasite burdens in these highly susceptible BALB/c mice.
Ten mice per group were immunised intra-gastrically with 1010 CFU of salmonella vaccine strains and infected 9 weeks later with 3×106 stationary-phase L. major promastigotes into the left hind footpads. Footpad swelling (A) was monitored with a calliper using the uninfected right foot for reference. Values represent the mean ± standard error of the mean swelling per group and time point. Asterisks denote statistically significant differences (* P≤0.05, ** P≤0.01, *** P≤0.001; two tailed Mann-Whitney U test). Five weeks after infection 5 mice of each group were randomly selected and killed to determine parasite burden in footpads (B), draining lymph nodes (C) and spleens (D) by limiting dilution culture assay. The detection limit of the respective assays based on starting dilution was 65 parasites for spleen and 6500 for lymph node or footpad. The values of the burden per organ of all individual mice and median burden per group are shown. The asterisks denote statistically significant differences (* P≤0.05, ** P≤0.01; two-tailed Mann-Whitney U test). Error bars show standard error of the mean (SEM).
Protection of mice against L. donovani
Since conservation of the antigens among Leishmania species was a key selection criterion, we hypothesised that antigens which were protective against L. major would also protect against the causative agent of human VL, L. donovani. To test this hypothesis, we immunised BALB/c mice with strains psVAC5-08.1190 and vaccine allstars. Leishmania surface antigen KMP-11 had been shown to be protective against L. donovani in mice . Therefore and despite its poor performance in previous experiments, Salmonella strain pcVAC1-KMP, expressing KMP-11 in the cytosol, was included together with the carrier strain SL3261 and sham-immunisation in this study. Mice vaccinated with a single oral dose were challenged intravenously with 3×107 L. donovani amastigotes six weeks later. A characteristic for L. donovani infection in BALB/c mice is hepato-splenomegaly and the organ-specific control of the infection. Half of the mice were sacrificed on day 28 p.i., when liver parasite burden has usually reached its peak before the onset of self cure and when splenic parasite burden has begun to increase. The remaining animals were analysed at day 68 p.i. to assess long term control, particularly in the spleen.
An increased ratio of liver/spleen weight to body weight is an indirect measure of L. donovani infection induced inflammation and disease severity. Thus, body and organ weights were determined at necropsy (Table S1). The ratio for both liver (Figure 4A) and spleen (Figure 4B) increased between day 28 and day 68 in non-vaccinated animals and mice treated with either the carrier salmonella alone or the pcVAC1-KMP vaccine. In contrast, in animals vaccinated with psVAC5-08.1190 or the allstars vaccine, this ratio either increased less dramatically or not at all (Figure 4A, B). Mice immunized with psVAC5-08.1190 or the allstars vaccine had a mean liver parasite burden of 84.20±39.30 and 69.75±20.74 LDU, respectively at day 68 p.i. significantly reduced in comparison to the non-immunized group (361.0±66.79 LDU), the SL3261 carrier (189.0±63.79 LDU) or the pcVAC1-KMP treated animals (232.2±30.02 LDU; Figure 4C). Of note, the decrease noted after SL3261 treatment in comparison with the naïve controls was also significant (Figure 4C). The effects of the vaccines on splenic parasite burdens followed the same pattern (Figure 4D). Mice immunized with psVAC5-08.1190 or the allstars vaccine controlled parasite replication while numbers increased significantly between day 28 and 68 in all other study groups (Figure 4D). Immunisation with pcVAC1-KMP also did not protect mice from L. donovani infection and parasite burden increased over time (69.80±18.67 to 182.8±61.53), which was similar for SL3261 treated mice (Figure 4D).
Ten mice per group were immunised intra-gastrically with 1010 CFU salmonella vaccine strains and 6 weeks later infected with 3×106 lesion-derived L. donovani amastigotes. Five mice per group were sacrificed at day 28 and five at 68 post infection. Animals were weighed and spleen and liver organ weights were determined to compute organ to body weight ratios for liver (A) and spleen (B). Giemsa stained impression smears of liver (C) and spleen (D) were assessed under the microscope and parasites per 1000 nuclei expressed as Leishman-Donovan Unit (LDU). * P≤0.05, ** P≤0.01, *** P<0.001; one-way ANOVA and Tukey post-test. Error bars show standard error of the mean (SEM).
In summary, a single oral dose of salmonella vectored vaccines delivering LinJ08.1190 and/or LinJ23.0410 significantly reduced hepato-splenomegaly and visceral infection in mice infected with L. donovani, the causative agent of human VL.
To assess immune responses during vaccination and infection, we measured antigen-specific antibody isotype titres as a surrogate of the underlying CD4+ T cell response, given the known correlation between IL-4 and IgG1 responses and between IFNγ and IgG2a . Serum was assessed in vaccinated mice four weeks after immunisation and on day 28 and 68 post infection with L. donovani to test for antigen-specific antibodies. Four weeks after vaccination but before infection, vaccine antigen-specific antibody titers were below the limit of detection (Figure 5A–F). In agreement with the fact that KMP-11-specific antibodies are produced during human VL , infected non-vaccinated mice or SL3261 carrier immunized mice generated anti-KMP-11 antibodies (Figure 5A, B). This anti-KMP-11 response was very similar in the pcVAC1-KMP vaccinated group (Figure 5C). In contrast, vaccines expressing LinJ08.1190 and/or LinJ23.0410 primed animals for the production of specific antibodies that became detectable after the boosting infection on day 28 and 68 post infection (Figure 5D–F) but no antibodies against the respective recombinant proteins were detectable by ELISA (detection limit of assay was at titers ≤20) during infection in naïve, SL3261 or pcVAC1-KMP treated animals (not shown). This indicated that LinJ08.1190 and/or LinJ23.0410 were not naturally immunogenic during infection of BALB/c mice.
IgG1 and IgG2a antibody isotypes specific for the respective vaccination antigen were determined in sera from each mouse individually by ELISA using plates coated with purified antigens KMP-11, LinJ08.1190 and LinJ23.0410. Titers of antibodies recognizing specific antigens of sera prepared at the indicted time points are shown from naïve (A), SL3261 carrier control (B) and pcVAC1-KMP vaccine strain (C) immunized animals or psVAC5-08.1190 vaccine (D) or vaccine allstars (E, F) treated mice. Values represent mean titers calculated from individually tested sera. The test had a sensitivity to detect antibodies with titers of <20. Error bars show standard error of the mean (SEM). n.d. not detected. Statistical significance: * P<0.05, ** P<0.01 by two-tailed Mann-Whitney U test.
Next, the ratios of vaccine antigen-specific IgG1 and IgG2a were calculated for each mouse and time point (Figure 6) to seek evidence for a bias in type 1 vs. type 2 immune response. Over the course of infection significant and different skewing was noted between the treatment groups. Anti-KMP-11 IgG1 to IgG2a ratios were above 1 in pcVAC1-KMP vaccinated mice which was therefore not different from the response to KMP in infected only or SL3261 vaccinated mice. In comparison, anti-vaccine antigen specific IgG1 to IgG2a ratios, however, were significantly different in sera from psVAC5-08.1190 or allstars vaccinated mice with values around 1 or below (Figure 6; p<0.05).
The ratios of antigen-specific IgG1 and IgG2a serum titres (as shown in Fig. 5) were calculated for sera of each individual mouse within their respective vaccination group for both time points (day 28 and day 68). Error bars show standard error of the mean (SEM).
Finally, to assess the underlying cellular response in a more direct manner, we examined the level of granulomatous inflammation in infected mice that were either unvaccinated or had been vaccinated with control SL3261 Salmonella or with allstars (Figure 7). At day 28 p.i, there was a small but significant increase in the number of granulomas observed in the liver of allstars vaccinated mice (Figure 7A). We next measured the maturation stage of each granuloma, using established scoring criteria . Granuloma maturation was similar between all groups of mice at day 28 p.i. (with a small but not significant trend towards enhanced maturation in allstars vaccinated mice). By day 68 p.i., however, mice vaccinated with either SL3261 or allstars showed enhanced granuloma maturation compared to non vaccinated mice. Although the results of this analysis are in keeping with the enhanced ability of these vaccinated mice to reduce parasite burden, it was not a sufficiently sensitive technique to discriminate between the resistance induced by SL3261 and allstars (c.f. Figure 4D). Finally, we measured the area within each granuloma that stained positive for iNOS, as one measure of functional capacity at these inflammatory foci. There were no significant differences in the iNOS response between vaccinated and non-vaccinated mice at either time point by this criterion (Figure 7D). Hence, the main tissue correlate of protection induced by allstars vaccination was an increase in the rapidity of granuloma formation, suggesting that vaccination may have heightened the frequency of CD4+ and/or CD8+ T cells able to facilitate this focal inflammatory response.
Liver sections were taken from mice used to assess parasite burden (Fig. 4) and stained for iNOS and F4/80. Nuclei were counterstained with DAPI. (A). Number of granulomas per 50 random fields of view (n = 5 mice per time point). (B and C) Granuloma maturation status was graded as described in Materials and Methods into no response (hatched bar), immature (open bar), mature (grey bar) and empty (black bar). Data were obtained from ∼50 granulomas per mouse and 4–5 mice at both day 28 (B) and day 68 (C) post infection. D. iNOS staining was assessed by determining the proportion of granuloma macrophage area that was stained for iNOS. Data are derived from between 35–90 granulomas from 5 mice per time point.
We had previously reported on the proteome of the intracellular amastigote stage of L. mexicana  which showed extensive overlap with proteins identified in L. donovani axenic amastigotes . Because of this overlap, the former proteomic dataset was exploited here to adapt a reverse vaccinology approach to develop a vaccine against VL. We applied the criteria of protein abundance, within parasite genus conservation, and absence of homologous proteins in host organisms to select novel candidate vaccine antigens aimed to induce cellular immunity. These criteria may not be optimal though to select targets for inducing antibody-dependent immunity. Four of five selected candidates could be expressed in recombinant form and when delivered by recombinant Salmonella two reduced and one exacerbated disease progression in a murine L. major infection model. These results suggest that the frequency of identifying immunologically relevant proteins by this method is high and may well be superior to previous strategies that relied on mRNA expression and genome data for antigen selection ,  with a hit frequency of ∼15%.
Leishmania like other kinetoplastids regulate gene expression mostly post-transcriptionally and mRNA abundance data alone may not be informative to predict protein abundance. However, as in shown in other systems  and Leishmania  actual protein abundance in amastigotes is highly relevant if the protein is to become a target of the immune response . Analysis of the proteome data sets suggested that bias in codon usage indicates translational bias and therefore is highly correlated with protein abundance . Hence, codon usage may be used to rank ORFs and serve as a substitute parameter for protein abundance in the absence of real protein expression data to refine pure in silico selection of candidate antigens. This becomes particularly relevant for selecting membrane proteins that are severely underrepresented in current proteomic data sets.
The two protective antigens, LinJ08.1190 and LinJ23.0410, expressed by Salmonella carriers were immunogenic in these vaccines yet, based on antibody responses, were not a target of the immune response to L. donovani infection, at least not in mice. This is noteworthy since many Leishmania vaccine antigens including KMP-11 currently favoured by other groups have been identified using sera from patients –. Our findings with the salmonella vectored KMP-11 vaccine suggest that these immunoselection approaches may introduce an extra hurdle for vaccine development since the natural antigen-specific response may be skewed and, possibly, even be disease exacerbating , . The requirement for an additional type 1 immune response inducing adjuvants, IL-12, to achieve protective effects with a KMP-11 DNA vaccine in the murine L. major model  is in good agreement with this idea. Furthermore, a fusion protein called LEISH-F1 - also known as Leish-110F, Leish-111f or MML – was derived from the sequence of three immunoselected parasite antigens. LEISH-F1 is the most advanced protein-based subunit Leishmania vaccine in trial to date and has shown promising effects when tested in a therapeutic setting against human American CL . However, this is not the case when used to prevent visceral canine disease after high dose experimental infection  or to treat naturally acquired VL in dogs . In contrast, Leishmune®, a vaccine based on a glycoproteic fraction of L. donovani that was not immunoselected, is licensed for the prevention of canine VL in Brazil and has shown efficacy in the field . Interestingly, the Leishmune® vaccine antigens are poorly recognized by sera from dogs suffering from VL and vaccination therefore is not interfering with sero-surveillance programs . Thus, reverse vaccinology based approaches as presented here are likely to significantly broaden the choice of protective antigens.
A number of subunit vaccine delivery platforms, including purified proteins or mixtures of glycans and glycoproteins, recombinant DNA, viral and bacterial vectors have been evaluated experimentally in murine models of leishmaniases (review by . However, very few have entered or passed clinical testing and amongst them no vectored vaccine. We have chosen Salmonella as a carrier since these bacteria had already been positively evaluated by several groups in experimental models of leishmaniases –. Moreover, they are being developed as recombinant carriers against a number of pathogens including Helicobacter pylori, Hepatitis B virus and Plasmodium falciparum , . In the context of a major neglected disease such as VL, their main advantages are their excellent safety profile, simple and low-cost production at industrial scale, possibility to store as lyophilized product at room temperature, and oral application route, thus reducing the requirements for extensive infrastructure. In addition, Salmonella are potent inducers of long-lived cell-mediated immunity including CD8+ T cells , . Induction of CD8+ T cells is particularly efficient by vaccines delivered by viral or bacterial carriers and may be a crucial characteristic of anti-Leishmania vaccines, since both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are required for optimal anti-leishmanial immunity and granuloma formation –. While we do not yet have formal proof that our vaccines induced antigen-specific CD8+ T cells, bioinformatics analysis using CD8 T cell epitope/HLA-binding peptide prediction algorithms suggested epitopes presentable by major HLA alleles e.g. of human populations in VL endemic areas in India . In the context of VL, Salmonella have the additional property to generate viscerotropic immune responses which may explain that the main protective effect was observed at the level of visceralizing infection in the L. major model. Moreover, depending on serovar, S. enterica exhibits broad or narrow host ranges. Serovar Typhimurium that was used here has the potential to deliver vaccine antigens in humans  as well as in dogs – while attenuated S. enterica Typhi can be engineered to deliver human vaccines , .
In summary, we report the identification of two novel candidate vaccine antigens against VL by reverse vaccinology and the optimized construction of live Salmonella carriers. These VL vaccines could potentially be used to combat VL in the zoonotic, as well as the anthroponotic cycle of the disease.
Post-column fractions of purified his-tagged antigens. His-tagged Leishmania antigens were expressed and purified from E. coli cell from inclusion bodies (LinJ23.0410 (A); LinJ08.1190 (B)) or lysates (KMP11 (C)) using nickel column liquid chromatography as described in Materials and Methods. Collected fractions were separated on SDS-Gels to determine yield and purity and selected fractions (box) were pooled and subsequently subjected to downstream processing such as dialysis and ultrafiltration.
Two-step strategy for the selection of vaccine strains expressing cytosolic KMP-11 for in vivo testing. Bacterial fitness (top panel) was determined as ability of the vaccine strain to colonize the Peyer's patches of mice seven days after single dose oral administration of 1010 CFU with KMP-11 expressing SL3261 (open symbols) or carrier SL3261 control (closed symbol; Schroeder and Aebischer (32)). For antigen expression (bottom panel), bacterial strains were grown under conditions mimicking the intraphagosomal environment (low Mg2+, Ca2+) and thus activating PpagC promoter activated vaccine antigen expression. Translational efficiency depended on ribosomal binding site sequences that were the only difference between expression plasmids pcVAC0-3. 20 µg whole bacterial lysate per strain was loaded onto SDS gels and bands were visualized by coomassie stain. Black arrowhead indicates induced protein of interest (KMP-11).
Pilot-study to identify vaccine strains protective against L. major infection. Mice (10 per group) were immunised orally with a single dose of 1010 CFU of Salmonella vaccine strains carrying the indicated vaccine antigen expression plasmids or the carrier control SL3261. Twelve weeks later animals were challenged with 2×106 L. major promastigotes into the left hind foot pad. Lesion size (A) was monitored with a calliper using the uninfected right foot as reference. Values represent mean swelling in mm and bars show standard errors of the mean (SEM). Asterisks denote statistical thresholds * P≤0.05, ** P≤0.01, *** P≤0.001 determined by two-tailed Mann-Whitney U test. Seven weeks after infection, three mice per group were randomly selected for determination of parasite burden in the foot pad (B), draining lymph node (D and spleen (C) were by limiting dilution assay as described in Materials and Methods. n.d. denotes not determined.
Organ and body weights were determined for each mouse in the respective groups immunized with SL3261 or SL3261 carrying the indicated vaccine antigen expression plasmid in comparison to a group of untreated mice. Five mice per group per time point were killed by cervical dislocation and livers and spleens were removed and weighed. The body-mass indices (BMIs; see Fig. 4 in main manuscript) were calculated based on the mean weight values. n.d. = not done.
Conceived and designed the experiments: JS TA PK. Performed the experiments: JS NB TA. Analyzed the data: JS NB TA PK. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: JS TA NB PK. Wrote the paper: JS PK TA.
- 1. Herwaldt BL (1999) Leishmaniasis. Lancet 354: 1191–1199.BL Herwaldt1999Leishmaniasis.Lancet35411911199
- 2. Chappuis F, Sundar S, Hailu A, Ghalib H, Rijal S, et al. (2007) Visceral leishmaniasis: what are the needs for diagnosis, treatment and control? Nat Rev Microbiol 5: 873–882.F. ChappuisS. SundarA. HailuH. GhalibS. Rijal2007Visceral leishmaniasis: what are the needs for diagnosis, treatment and control?Nat Rev Microbiol5873882
- 3. Polonio T, Efferth T (2008) Leishmaniasis: drug resistance and natural products. Int J Mol Med 22: 277–286.T. PolonioT. Efferth2008Leishmaniasis: drug resistance and natural products.Int J Mol Med22277286
- 4. Lira R, Sundar S, Makharia A, Kenney R, Gam A, et al. (1999) Evidence that the high incidence of treatment failures in Indian kala-azar is due to the emergence of antimony-resistant strains of Leishmania donovani. J Infect Dis 180: 564–567.R. LiraS. SundarA. MakhariaR. KenneyA. Gam1999Evidence that the high incidence of treatment failures in Indian kala-azar is due to the emergence of antimony-resistant strains of Leishmania donovani.J Infect Dis180564567
- 5. Meheus F, Balasegaram M, Olliaro P, Sundar S, Rijal S, et al. (2010) Cost-Effectiveness analysis of combination therapies for visceral leishmaniasis in the Indian subcontinent. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 4(9): e818.F. MeheusM. BalasegaramP. OlliaroS. SundarS. Rijal2010Cost-Effectiveness analysis of combination therapies for visceral leishmaniasis in the Indian subcontinent.PLoS Negl Trop Dis49e818
- 6. Olliaro PL, Guerin PJ, Gerstl S, Haaskjold AA, Rottingen JA, et al. (2005) Treatment options for visceral leishmaniasis: a systematic review of clinical studies done in India, 1980–2004. Lancet Infect Dis 5: 763–774.PL OlliaroPJ GuerinS. GerstlAA HaaskjoldJA Rottingen2005Treatment options for visceral leishmaniasis: a systematic review of clinical studies done in India, 1980–2004.Lancet Infect Dis5763774
- 7. Nadim A, Javadian E, Tahvildar-Bidruni G, Ghorbani M (1983) Effectiveness of leishmanization in the control of cutaneous leishmaniasis. Bull Soc Pathol Exot Filiales 76: 377–383.A. NadimE. JavadianG. Tahvildar-BidruniM. Ghorbani1983Effectiveness of leishmanization in the control of cutaneous leishmaniasis.Bull Soc Pathol Exot Filiales76377383
- 8. Khamesipour A, Rafati S, Davoudi N, Maboudi F, Modabber F (2006) Leishmaniasis vaccine candidates for development: a global overview. Indian J Med Res 123: 423–438.A. KhamesipourS. RafatiN. DavoudiF. MaboudiF. Modabber2006Leishmaniasis vaccine candidates for development: a global overview.Indian J Med Res123423438
- 9. Khamesipour A, Dowlati Y, Asilian A, Hashemi-Fesharki R, Javadi A, et al. (2005) Leishmanization: use of an old method for evaluation of candidate vaccines against leishmaniasis. Vaccine 23: 3642–3648.A. KhamesipourY. DowlatiA. AsilianR. Hashemi-FesharkiA. Javadi2005Leishmanization: use of an old method for evaluation of candidate vaccines against leishmaniasis.Vaccine2336423648
- 10. Hosseini SM, Hatam GR, Ardehali S (2005) Characterization of Leishmania isolated from unhealed lesions caused by leishmanization. East Mediterr Health J 11: 240–243.SM HosseiniGR HatamS. Ardehali2005Characterization of Leishmania isolated from unhealed lesions caused by leishmanization.East Mediterr Health J11240243
- 11. Noazin S, Khamesipour A, Moulton LH, Tanner M, Nasseri K, et al. (2009) Efficacy of killed whole-parasite vaccines in the prevention of leishmaniasis: a meta-analysis. Vaccine 27: 4747–4753.S. NoazinA. KhamesipourLH MoultonM. TannerK. Nasseri2009Efficacy of killed whole-parasite vaccines in the prevention of leishmaniasis: a meta-analysis.Vaccine2747474753
- 12. Kedzierski L (2010) Leishmaniasis Vaccine: Where are We Today? J Glob Infect Dis 2: 177–185.L. Kedzierski2010Leishmaniasis Vaccine: Where are We Today?J Glob Infect Dis2177185
- 13. Okwor I, Uzonna J (2009) Vaccines and vaccination strategies against human cutaneous leishmaniasis. Hum Vaccin 5: 291–301.I. OkworJ. Uzonna2009Vaccines and vaccination strategies against human cutaneous leishmaniasis.Hum Vaccin5291301
- 14. Costa CHN, Peters NC, Maruyama SR, de Brito EC Jr, de Miranda Santos IKF, et al. (2011) Vaccines for the Leishmaniases: Proposals for a Research Agenda. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 5: e943.CHN CostaNC PetersSR MaruyamaEC de Brito JrIKF de Miranda Santos2011Vaccines for the Leishmaniases: Proposals for a Research Agenda.PLoS Negl Trop Dis5e943
- 15. Stager S, Alexander J, Kirby AC, Botto M, Rooijen NV, et al. (2003) Natural antibodies and complement are endogenous adjuvants for vaccine-induced CD8+ T-cell responses. Nat Med 9: 1287–1292.S. StagerJ. AlexanderAC KirbyM. BottoNV Rooijen2003Natural antibodies and complement are endogenous adjuvants for vaccine-induced CD8+ T-cell responses.Nat Med912871292
- 16. Basu R, Bhaumik S, Haldar AK, Naskar K, De T, et al. (2007) Hybrid cell vaccination resolves Leishmania donovani infection by eliciting a strong CD8+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response with concomitant suppression of interleukin-10 (IL-10) but not IL-4 or IL-13. Infect Immun 75: 5956–5966.R. BasuS. BhaumikAK HaldarK. NaskarT. De2007Hybrid cell vaccination resolves Leishmania donovani infection by eliciting a strong CD8+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response with concomitant suppression of interleukin-10 (IL-10) but not IL-4 or IL-13.Infect Immun7559565966
- 17. Muller I, Kropf P, Etges RJ, Louis JA (1993) Gamma interferon response in secondary Leishmania major infection: role of CD8+ T cells. Infect Immun 61: 3730–3738.I. MullerP. KropfRJ EtgesJA Louis1993Gamma interferon response in secondary Leishmania major infection: role of CD8+ T cells.Infect Immun6137303738
- 18. Gurunathan S, Sacks DL, Brown DR, Reiner SL, Charest H, et al. (1997) Vaccination with DNA encoding the immunodominant LACK parasite antigen confers protective immunity to mice infected with Leishmania major. J Exp Med 186: 1137–1147.S. GurunathanDL SacksDR BrownSL ReinerH. Charest1997Vaccination with DNA encoding the immunodominant LACK parasite antigen confers protective immunity to mice infected with Leishmania major.J Exp Med18611371147
- 19. Dumonteil E (2009) Vaccine development against Trypanosoma cruzi and Leishmania species in the post-genomic era. Infect Genet Evol 9: 1075–1082.E. Dumonteil2009Vaccine development against Trypanosoma cruzi and Leishmania species in the post-genomic era.Infect Genet Evol910751082
- 20. Palatnik-de-Sousa CB (2008) Vaccines for leishmaniasis in the fore coming 25 years. Vaccine 26: 1709–1724.CB Palatnik-de-Sousa2008Vaccines for leishmaniasis in the fore coming 25 years.Vaccine2617091724
- 21. Coler RN, Reed SG (2005) Second-generation vaccines against leishmaniasis. Trends Parasitol 21: 244–249.RN ColerSG Reed2005Second-generation vaccines against leishmaniasis.Trends Parasitol21244249
- 22. Stober CB, Lange UG, Roberts MT, Gilmartin B, Francis R, et al. (2006) From genome to vaccines for leishmaniasis: screening 100 novel vaccine candidates against murine Leishmania major infection. Vaccine 24: 2602–2616.CB StoberUG LangeMT RobertsB. GilmartinR. Francis2006From genome to vaccines for leishmaniasis: screening 100 novel vaccine candidates against murine Leishmania major infection.Vaccine2426022616
- 23. Rappuoli R (2000) Reverse vaccinology. Curr Opin Microbiol 3: 445–450.R. Rappuoli2000Reverse vaccinology.Curr Opin Microbiol3445450
- 24. Paape D, Lippuner C, Schmid M, Ackermann R, Barrios-Llerena ME, et al. (2008) Transgenic, fluorescent Leishmania mexicana allow direct analysis of the proteome of intracellular amastigotes. Mol Cell Proteomics 7: 1688–1701.D. PaapeC. LippunerM. SchmidR. AckermannME Barrios-Llerena2008Transgenic, fluorescent Leishmania mexicana allow direct analysis of the proteome of intracellular amastigotes.Mol Cell Proteomics716881701
- 25. Yang DM, Fairweather N, Button LL, McMaster WR, Kahl LP, et al. (1990) Oral Salmonella typhimurium (AroA-) vaccine expressing a major leishmanial surface protein (gp63) preferentially induces T helper 1 cells and protective immunity against leishmaniasis. J Immunol 145: 2281–2285.DM YangN. FairweatherLL ButtonWR McMasterLP Kahl1990Oral Salmonella typhimurium (AroA-) vaccine expressing a major leishmanial surface protein (gp63) preferentially induces T helper 1 cells and protective immunity against leishmaniasis.J Immunol14522812285
- 26. McSorley SJ, Xu D, Liew FY (1997) Vaccine efficacy of Salmonella strains expressing glycoprotein 63 with different promoters. Infect Immun 65: 171–178.SJ McSorleyD. XuFY Liew1997Vaccine efficacy of Salmonella strains expressing glycoprotein 63 with different promoters.Infect Immun65171178
- 27. Lange UG, Mastroeni P, Blackwell JM, Stober CB (2004) DNA-Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium primer-booster vaccination biases towards T helper 1 responses and enhances protection against Leishmania major infection in mice. Infect Immun 72: 4924–4928.UG LangeP. MastroeniJM BlackwellCB Stober2004DNA-Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium primer-booster vaccination biases towards T helper 1 responses and enhances protection against Leishmania major infection in mice.Infect Immun7249244928
- 28. Salerno-Goncalves R, Wyant TL, Pasetti MF, Fernandez-Vina M, Tacket CO, et al. (2003) Concomitant induction of CD4+ and CD8+ T cell responses in volunteers immunized with Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi strain CVD 908-htrA. J Immunol 170: 2734–2741.R. Salerno-GoncalvesTL WyantMF PasettiM. Fernandez-VinaCO Tacket2003Concomitant induction of CD4+ and CD8+ T cell responses in volunteers immunized with Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi strain CVD 908-htrA.J Immunol17027342741
- 29. Aebischer T, Bumann D, Epple HJ, Metzger W, Schneider T, et al. (2008) Correlation of T cell response and bacterial clearance in human volunteers challenged with Helicobacter pylori revealed by randomised controlled vaccination with Ty21a-based Salmonella vaccines. Gut 57: 1065–1072.T. AebischerD. BumannHJ EppleW. MetzgerT. Schneider2008Correlation of T cell response and bacterial clearance in human volunteers challenged with Helicobacter pylori revealed by randomised controlled vaccination with Ty21a-based Salmonella vaccines.Gut5710651072
- 30. Bumann D, Hueck C, Aebischer T, Meyer TF (2000) Recombinant live Salmonella spp. for human vaccination against heterologous pathogens. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol 27: 357–364.D. BumannC. HueckT. AebischerTF Meyer2000Recombinant live Salmonella spp. for human vaccination against heterologous pathogens.FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol27357364
- 31. Rizos K, Lattemann CT, Bumann D, Meyer TF, Aebischer T (2003) Autodisplay: efficacious surface exposure of antigenic UreA fragments from Helicobacter pylori in Salmonella vaccine strains. Infect Immun 71: 6320–6328.K. RizosCT LattemannD. BumannTF MeyerT. Aebischer2003Autodisplay: efficacious surface exposure of antigenic UreA fragments from Helicobacter pylori in Salmonella vaccine strains.Infect Immun7163206328
- 32. Schroeder J, Aebischer T (2009) Recombinant outer membrane vesicles to augment antigen-specific live vaccine responses. Vaccine 27: 6748–6754.J. SchroederT. Aebischer2009Recombinant outer membrane vesicles to augment antigen-specific live vaccine responses.Vaccine2767486754
- 33. Dunstan SJ, Simmons CP, Strugnell RA (1999) Use of in vivo-regulated promoters to deliver antigens from attenuated Salmonella enterica var. Typhimurium. Infect Immun 67: 5133–5141.SJ DunstanCP SimmonsRA Strugnell1999Use of in vivo-regulated promoters to deliver antigens from attenuated Salmonella enterica var. Typhimurium.Infect Immun6751335141
- 34. Jose J, Kramer J, Klauser T, Pohlner J, Meyer TF (1996) Absence of periplasmic DsbA oxidoreductase facilitates export of cysteine-containing passenger proteins to the Escherichia coli cell surface via the Iga beta autotransporter pathway. Gene 178: 107–110.J. JoseJ. KramerT. KlauserJ. PohlnerTF Meyer1996Absence of periplasmic DsbA oxidoreductase facilitates export of cysteine-containing passenger proteins to the Escherichia coli cell surface via the Iga beta autotransporter pathway.Gene178107110
- 35. Bumann D (2002) Examination of salmonella gene expression in an infected mammalian host using the green fluorescent protein and two-colour flow cytometry. Mol Microbiol 43: 1269–1283.D. Bumann2002Examination of salmonella gene expression in an infected mammalian host using the green fluorescent protein and two-colour flow cytometry.Mol Microbiol4312691283
- 36. Dieckmann-Schuppert A, Schnittler HJ (1997) A simple assay for quantification of protein in tissue sections, cell cultures, and cell homogenates, and of protein immobilized on solid surfaces. Cell Tissue Res 288: 119–126.A. Dieckmann-SchuppertHJ Schnittler1997A simple assay for quantification of protein in tissue sections, cell cultures, and cell homogenates, and of protein immobilized on solid surfaces.Cell Tissue Res288119126
- 37. Taswell C (1981) Limiting dilution assays for the determination of immunocompetent cell frequencies. I. Data analysis. J Immunol 126: 1614–1619.C. Taswell1981Limiting dilution assays for the determination of immunocompetent cell frequencies. I. Data analysis.J Immunol12616141619
- 38. Smelt SC, Cotterell SE, Engwerda CR, Kaye PM (2000) B cell-deficient mice are highly resistant to Leishmania donovani infection, but develop neutrophil-mediated tissue pathology. J Immunol 164: 3681–3688.SC SmeltSE CotterellCR EngwerdaPM Kaye2000B cell-deficient mice are highly resistant to Leishmania donovani infection, but develop neutrophil-mediated tissue pathology.J Immunol16436813688
- 39. Beattie L, Phillips R, Brown N, Owens BM, Chauhan N, et al. (2010) IRF-7 contributes to the control of Leishmania donovani in the mouse liver. Infect Immun. L. BeattieR. PhillipsN. BrownBM OwensN. Chauhan2010IRF-7 contributes to the control of Leishmania donovani in the mouse liver.Infect Immun
- 40. Sabarth N, Hurwitz R, Meyer TF, Bumann D (2002) Multiparameter selection of Helicobacter pylori antigens identifies two novel antigens with high protective efficacy. Infect Immun 70: 6499–6503.N. SabarthR. HurwitzTF MeyerD. Bumann2002Multiparameter selection of Helicobacter pylori antigens identifies two novel antigens with high protective efficacy.Infect Immun7064996503
- 41. Basu R, Roy S, Walden P (2007) HLA class I-restricted T cell epitopes of the kinetoplastid membrane protein-11 presented by Leishmania donovani-infected human macrophages. J Infect Dis 195: 1373–1380.R. BasuS. RoyP. Walden2007HLA class I-restricted T cell epitopes of the kinetoplastid membrane protein-11 presented by Leishmania donovani-infected human macrophages.J Infect Dis19513731380
- 42. Basu R, Bhaumik S, Basu JM, Naskar K, De T, et al. (2005) Kinetoplastid membrane protein-11 DNA vaccination induces complete protection against both pentavalent antimonial-sensitive and -resistant strains of Leishmania donovani that correlates with inducible nitric oxide synthase activity and IL-4 generation: evidence for mixed Th1- and Th2-like responses in visceral leishmaniasis. J Immunol 174: 7160–7171.R. BasuS. BhaumikJM BasuK. NaskarT. De2005Kinetoplastid membrane protein-11 DNA vaccination induces complete protection against both pentavalent antimonial-sensitive and -resistant strains of Leishmania donovani that correlates with inducible nitric oxide synthase activity and IL-4 generation: evidence for mixed Th1- and Th2-like responses in visceral leishmaniasis.J Immunol17471607171
- 43. Rollenhagen C, Sorensen M, Rizos K, Hurvitz R, Bumann D (2004) Antigen selection based on expression levels during infection facilitates vaccine development for an intracellular pathogen. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 8739–8744.C. RollenhagenM. SorensenK. RizosR. HurvitzD. Bumann2004Antigen selection based on expression levels during infection facilitates vaccine development for an intracellular pathogen.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A10187398744
- 44. Hess J, Gentschev I, Miko D, Welzel M, Ladel C, et al. (1996) Superior efficacy of secreted over somatic antigen display in recombinant Salmonella vaccine induced protection against listeriosis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 1458–1463.J. HessI. GentschevD. MikoM. WelzelC. Ladel1996Superior efficacy of secreted over somatic antigen display in recombinant Salmonella vaccine induced protection against listeriosis.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A9314581463
- 45. Kanaly ST, Nashleanas M, Hondowicz B, Scott P (1999) TNF receptor p55 is required for elimination of inflammatory cells following control of intracellular pathogens. J Immunol 163: 3883–3889.ST KanalyM. NashleanasB. HondowiczP. Scott1999TNF receptor p55 is required for elimination of inflammatory cells following control of intracellular pathogens.J Immunol16338833889
- 46. Sakthianandeswaren A, Elso CM, Simpson K, Curtis JM, Kumar B, et al. (2005) The wound repair response controls outcome to cutaneous leishmaniasis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 15551–15556.A. SakthianandeswarenCM ElsoK. SimpsonJM CurtisB. Kumar2005The wound repair response controls outcome to cutaneous leishmaniasis.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A1021555115556
- 47. Handman E, Elso C, Foote S (2005) Genes and susceptibility to leishmaniasis. Adv Parasitol 59: 1–75.:1–75.E. HandmanC. ElsoS. Foote2005Genes and susceptibility to leishmaniasis.Adv Parasitol59175.:1–75
- 48. Snapper CM, Paul WE (1987) Interferon-gamma and B cell stimulatory factor-1 reciprocally regulate Ig isotype production. Science 236: 944–947.CM SnapperWE Paul1987Interferon-gamma and B cell stimulatory factor-1 reciprocally regulate Ig isotype production.Science236944947
- 49. Trujillo C, Ramirez R, Velez ID, Berberich C (1999) The humoral immune response to the kinetoplastid membrane protein-11 in patients with American leishmaniasis and Chagas disease: prevalence of IgG subclasses and mapping of epitopes. Immunol Lett 70: 203–209.C. TrujilloR. RamirezID VelezC. Berberich1999The humoral immune response to the kinetoplastid membrane protein-11 in patients with American leishmaniasis and Chagas disease: prevalence of IgG subclasses and mapping of epitopes.Immunol Lett70203209
- 50. Rosenzweig D, Smith D, Opperdoes F, Stern S, Olafson RW, et al. (2008) Retooling Leishmania metabolism: from sand fly gut to human macrophage. FASEB J 22: 590–602.D. RosenzweigD. SmithF. OpperdoesS. SternRW Olafson2008Retooling Leishmania metabolism: from sand fly gut to human macrophage.FASEB J22590602
- 51. Stober CB (2004) From genomes to vaccines for leishmaniasis. Methods Mol Biol 270: 423–38.:423–438.CB Stober2004From genomes to vaccines for leishmaniasis.Methods Mol Biol27042338.:423–438
- 52. Almeida R, Norrish A, Levick M, Vetrie D, Freeman T, et al. (2002) From genomes to vaccines: Leishmania as a model. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 357: 5–11.R. AlmeidaA. NorrishM. LevickD. VetrieT. Freeman2002From genomes to vaccines: Leishmania as a model.Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci357511
- 53. Aebischer T, Wolfram M, Patzer SI, Ilg T, Wiese M, et al. (2000) Subunit vaccination of mice against new world cutaneous leishmaniasis: comparison of three proteins expressed in amastigotes and six adjuvants. Infect Immun 68: 1328–1336.T. AebischerM. WolframSI PatzerT. IlgM. Wiese2000Subunit vaccination of mice against new world cutaneous leishmaniasis: comparison of three proteins expressed in amastigotes and six adjuvants.Infect Immun6813281336
- 54. Overath P, Aebischer T (1999) Antigen presentation by macrophages harboring intravesicular pathogens. Parasitol Today 15: 325–332.P. OverathT. Aebischer1999Antigen presentation by macrophages harboring intravesicular pathogens.Parasitol Today15325332
- 55. Forgber M, Basu R, Roychoudhury K, Theinert S, Roy S, et al. (2006) Mapping the antigenicity of the parasites in Leishmania donovani infection by proteome serology. PLoS One 1: e40.M. ForgberR. BasuK. RoychoudhuryS. TheinertS. Roy2006Mapping the antigenicity of the parasites in Leishmania donovani infection by proteome serology.PLoS One1e40
- 56. Forgber M, Gellrich S, Sharav T, Sterry W, Walden P (2009) Proteome-based analysis of serologically defined tumor-associated antigens in cutaneous lymphoma. PLoS One 4: e8376.M. ForgberS. GellrichT. SharavW. SterryP. Walden2009Proteome-based analysis of serologically defined tumor-associated antigens in cutaneous lymphoma.PLoS One4e8376
- 57. Skeiky YA, Guderian JA, Benson DR, Bacelar O, Carvalho EM, et al. (1995) A recombinant Leishmania antigen that stimulates human peripheral blood mononuclear cells to express a Th1-type cytokine profile and to produce interleukin 12. J Exp Med 181: 1527–1537.YA SkeikyJA GuderianDR BensonO. BacelarEM Carvalho1995A recombinant Leishmania antigen that stimulates human peripheral blood mononuclear cells to express a Th1-type cytokine profile and to produce interleukin 12.J Exp Med18115271537
- 58. Goto Y, Coler RN, Guderian J, Mohamath R, Reed SG (2006) Cloning, characterization, and serodiagnostic evaluation of Leishmania infantum tandem repeat proteins. Infect Immun 74: 3939–3945.Y. GotoRN ColerJ. GuderianR. MohamathSG Reed2006Cloning, characterization, and serodiagnostic evaluation of Leishmania infantum tandem repeat proteins.Infect Immun7439393945
- 59. Peters C, Aebischer T, Stierhof YD, Fuchs M, Overath P (1995) The role of macrophage receptors in adhesion and uptake of Leishmania mexicana amastigotes. J Cell Sci 108: 3715–3724.C. PetersT. AebischerYD StierhofM. FuchsP. Overath1995The role of macrophage receptors in adhesion and uptake of Leishmania mexicana amastigotes.J Cell Sci10837153724
- 60. Deak E, Jayakumar A, Cho KW, Goldsmith-Pestana K, Dondji B, et al. (2010) Murine visceral leishmaniasis: IgM and polyclonal B-cell activation lead to disease exacerbation. Eur J Immunol 40: 1355–1368.E. DeakA. JayakumarKW ChoK. Goldsmith-PestanaB. Dondji2010Murine visceral leishmaniasis: IgM and polyclonal B-cell activation lead to disease exacerbation.Eur J Immunol4013551368
- 61. Bhaumik S, Basu R, Sen S, Naskar K, Roy S (2009) KMP-11 DNA immunization significantly protects against L. donovani infection but requires exogenous IL-12 as an adjuvant for comparable protection against L. major. Vaccine 27: 1306–1316.S. BhaumikR. BasuS. SenK. NaskarS. Roy2009KMP-11 DNA immunization significantly protects against L. donovani infection but requires exogenous IL-12 as an adjuvant for comparable protection against L. major.Vaccine2713061316
- 62. Nascimento E, Fernandes DF, Vieira EP, Campos-Neto A, Ashman JA, et al. (2010) A clinical trial to evaluate the safety and immunogenicity of the LEISH-F1+MPL-SE vaccine when used in combination with meglumine antimoniate for the treatment of cutaneous leishmaniasis. Vaccine 28: 6581–6587.E. NascimentoDF FernandesEP VieiraA. Campos-NetoJA Ashman2010A clinical trial to evaluate the safety and immunogenicity of the LEISH-F1+MPL-SE vaccine when used in combination with meglumine antimoniate for the treatment of cutaneous leishmaniasis.Vaccine2865816587
- 63. Moreno J, Nieto J, Masina S, Canavate C, Cruz I, et al. (2007) Immunization with H1, HASPB1 and MML Leishmania proteins in a vaccine trial against experimental canine leishmaniasis. Vaccine 25: 5290–5300.J. MorenoJ. NietoS. MasinaC. CanavateI. Cruz2007Immunization with H1, HASPB1 and MML Leishmania proteins in a vaccine trial against experimental canine leishmaniasis.Vaccine2552905300
- 64. Miret J, Nascimento E, Sampaio W, Franca JC, Fujiwara RT, et al. (2008) Evaluation of an immunochemotherapeutic protocol constituted of N-methyl meglumine antimoniate (Glucantime) and the recombinant Leish-110f+MPL-SE vaccine to treat canine visceral leishmaniasis. Vaccine 26: 1585–1594.J. MiretE. NascimentoW. SampaioJC FrancaRT Fujiwara2008Evaluation of an immunochemotherapeutic protocol constituted of N-methyl meglumine antimoniate (Glucantime) and the recombinant Leish-110f+MPL-SE vaccine to treat canine visceral leishmaniasis.Vaccine2615851594
- 65. Palatnik-de-Sousa CB, Silva-Antunes I, Morgado AA, Menz I, Palatnik M, et al. (2009) Decrease of the incidence of human and canine visceral leishmaniasis after dog vaccination with Leishmune in Brazilian endemic areas. Vaccine 27: 3505–3512.CB Palatnik-de-SousaI. Silva-AntunesAA MorgadoI. MenzM. Palatnik2009Decrease of the incidence of human and canine visceral leishmaniasis after dog vaccination with Leishmune in Brazilian endemic areas.Vaccine2735053512
- 66. Galen JE, Pasetti MF, Tennant S, Ruiz-Olvera P, Sztein MB, et al. (2009) Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi live vector vaccines finally come of age. Immunol Cell Biol 87: 400–412.JE GalenMF PasettiS. TennantP. Ruiz-OlveraMB Sztein2009Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi live vector vaccines finally come of age.Immunol Cell Biol87400412
- 67. Aebischer T, Walduck A, Schroeder J, Wehrens A, Chijioke O, et al. (2008) A vaccine against Helicobacter pylori: towards understanding the mechanism of protection. Int J Med Microbiol 298: 161–168.T. AebischerA. WalduckJ. SchroederA. WehrensO. Chijioke2008A vaccine against Helicobacter pylori: towards understanding the mechanism of protection.Int J Med Microbiol298161168
- 68. Salerno-Goncalves R, Sztein MB (2009) Priming of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi-specific CD8+ T cells by suicide dendritic cell cross-presentation in humans. PLoS One 4: e5879.R. Salerno-GoncalvesMB Sztein2009Priming of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi-specific CD8+ T cells by suicide dendritic cell cross-presentation in humans.PLoS One4e5879
- 69. Schroeder J, Aebischer T (2011) Vaccines for Leishmaniasis: From proteome to vaccine candidates. Hum Vaccin 7: 10–15.J. SchroederT. Aebischer2011Vaccines for Leishmaniasis: From proteome to vaccine candidates.Hum Vaccin71015
- 70. Angelakopoulos H, Hohmann EL (2000) Pilot study of phoP/phoQ-deleted Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium expressing Helicobacter pylori urease in adult volunteers. Infect Immun 68: 2135–2141.H. AngelakopoulosEL Hohmann2000Pilot study of phoP/phoQ-deleted Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium expressing Helicobacter pylori urease in adult volunteers.Infect Immun6821352141
- 71. Petavy AF, Hormaeche C, Lahmar S, Ouhelli H, Chabalgoity A, et al. (2008) An oral recombinant vaccine in dogs against Echinococcus granulosus, the causative agent of human hydatid disease: a pilot study. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2: e125.AF PetavyC. HormaecheS. LahmarH. OuhelliA. Chabalgoity2008An oral recombinant vaccine in dogs against Echinococcus granulosus, the causative agent of human hydatid disease: a pilot study.PLoS Negl Trop Dis2e125
- 72. McVey DS, Chengappa MM, Mosier DE, Stone GG, Oberst RD, et al. (2002) Immunogenicity of chi4127 phoP- Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium in dogs. Vaccine 20: 1618–1623.DS McVeyMM ChengappaDE MosierGG StoneRD Oberst2002Immunogenicity of chi4127 phoP- Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium in dogs.Vaccine2016181623
- 73. Chabalgoity JA, Moreno M, Carol H, Dougan G, Hormaeche CE (2000) Salmonella typhimurium as a basis for a live oral Echinococcus granulosus vaccine. Vaccine 19: 460–469.JA ChabalgoityM. MorenoH. CarolG. DouganCE Hormaeche2000Salmonella typhimurium as a basis for a live oral Echinococcus granulosus vaccine.Vaccine19460469