Citation: Mulligan CJ, Norris SJ, Lukehart SA (2008) Molecular Studies in Treponema pallidum Evolution: Toward Clarity? PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2(1): e184. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0000184
Academic Editor: Albert Ko, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Brazil
Published: January 23, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Mulligan et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors wish to acknowledge support by the US Public Health Service, National Institutes grants AI 42143 and AI 63940 (SAL) and AI 69107 (SJN). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Syphilis is the best known treponemal infection and the disease has captured the attention of well-known physicians and the imaginations of writers and artists. In contrast, the nonvenereal treponemal infections (yaws, bejel, and pinta) have been endemic in remote regions of Africa, Southeast Asia, and South America, and are thus less well-known in western culture. However, these endemic treponematoses were so prevalent that, between 1952 and 1964, the World Health Organization (WHO) undertook a massive eradication campaign in which over 300 million people in Africa, South America, Southeast Asia, the South Pacific islands, and the Middle East were examined and ∼50 million were treated with penicillin . It is estimated that the burden of disease was reduced by 95%. In the mid 1980s, the Fogarty International Center and WHO sponsored a series of regional meetings to gather information about the status of the endemic treponematoses –. Numerous foci of infection were identified in Africa, Asia, and South America, and the recommendation was made to focus new efforts on control, with the goal of elimination. The HIV epidemic intervened and the attention of the global health community was appropriately diverted to AIDS, thus interrupting the momentum for elimination of the treponematoses. Since that time, because of little to no surveillance in many areas, the current magnitude of the diseases is unknown, although foci of yaws and endemic syphilis have periodically been reported. Several countries, including Indonesia and India, have current ongoing yaws control programs. In 2007, the WHO once again committed itself to eliminate yaws (http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/notes/2007/np04/en/index.html).
Traditionally, the human Treponematoses have been differentiated based upon their mode of transmission (sexual vs. non-venereal), clinical manifestations, serious sequelae (e.g. central nervous system [CNS] or cardiovascular involvement, congenital infection), and experimental host range (Table 1). In the mid-1900's, a disagreement raged over whether the etiologic agents of these infections were the same species, with mode of transmission and clinical course defined by culture and climate, or were different species with important biological differences ,. The agents are morphologically identical, and all induce reactivity in the standard serological tests used for syphilis diagnosis. Recent molecular studies have identified genetic signatures that can differentiate the existing strains of Treponema pallidum subspecies pallidum (syphilis), subspecies pertenue (yaws), and subspecies endemicum (bejel) , yet the molecular bases for the described differences in transmission and clinical course have not been defined.
How definitive are these clinical and epidemiological differences? Syphilis is usually transmitted sexually, but there are many examples in older textbooks of nonsexual transmission via direct contact; examples include digital infection of dentists via contact with oral lesions of syphilis patients, and infection of the nipple in wet nurses via oral lesions in infected infants. In contrast, yaws is generally transmitted by skin-to-skin contact in children, and infectious lesions are typically resolved before sexual debut, thus transmission during sexual activities is not recognized. Thus, mode of transmission appears to be defined by opportunity, rather than biology. There is similar overlap in clinical manifestations. The lesions of yaws are typically described as “frambesiform” (raised “berry-like” lesions compared to the ulcer or maculopapular rash of syphilis) yet there are numerous descriptions in the literature of less dramatic, even macular, yaws lesions in drier climates . Conversely, the condylomata lata of secondary syphilis can be raised and multilobed (“frambesiform”), and they appear in moist body folds, a common location for the frambesiform lesions of secondary yaws. Although gummatous destruction, particularly of bone and cartilage, is well-recognized in syphilis, yaws, and bejel, only syphilis is said to lead to CNS involvement and congenital infection. However, in a very thoroughly researched review article, Roman and Roman  argue eloquently that there is ample evidence for CNS, cardiovascular, and congenital infection in yaws. In that review, Blacklock  is quoted as stating that the “criteria used to differentiate syphilis and yaws were ‘nothing more than the statement of an epidemiological observation.’” As an example, the Haiti B strain was originally identified as T. pallidum subsp. pertenue because it was isolated from an 11-year old child with “typical generalized frambesiform yaws” , in a epidemiological setting of childhood infection. Yet molecular studies in several labs – have subsequently demonstrated that the Haiti B strain has molecular signatures consistent with T. pallidum subsp. pallidum. The Madras strain is another such example of a “yaws” isolate that appears in fact to be a pallidum strain based on molecular data. With regard to host range differences, the Haiti B strain was used extensively by Schell et al. – in their studies of yaws infection in the hamster model. It has been stated that hamsters do not regularly develop clinical manifestations of syphilitic disease ,, yet hamsters are readily infected by the Haiti B strain, now considered to be a pallidum strain. Thus the clinical, epidemiological, and host range criteria used to differentiate the agents of the treponematoses are soft.
Molecular studies have identified signature polymorphisms that serve to differentiate the known strains of the three subspecies pallidum, pertenue, and endemicum . While these studies suggest that there are genetic differences among subspecies, the strains used to identify these distinctive signatures were classified by the clinical and epidemiological criteria described above and thus the molecular signatures may be biased. As mentioned above, two strains (Haiti B and Madras) were isolated from characteristic yaws lesions, yet they have the molecular signatures of the pallidum subspecies.
A New Study: On the Origin of the Treponematoses—A Phylogenetic Approach
Harper and colleagues  have examined a number of chromosomal regions in a total of 23 strains/samples representing the three T. pallidum subspecies and have identified regions of mutation (single nucleotide polymorphisms [SNP] or indels). Some of these polymorphisms have been previously described and others are novel. Importantly, this analysis included two new yaws samples from Guyana, representing the only South American yaws samples evaluated to date. Based upon 17 regions of mutation in the established strains, the authors constructed a phylogenetic tree of the concatenated sequences, and propose that this tree identifies the yaws subspecies as being the oldest, with the bejel and syphilis subspecies evolving subsequently. Unfortunately the DNA from the two new yaws samples from Guyana was too degraded to conduct extensive sequencing, so these samples were not included in the phylogenetic analysis. From these samples, the authors selected a subset of seven genetic regions for analysis. Based upon the homology of four SNPs in the Guyana samples with the group of pallidum strains, the authors conclude that the syphilis subspecies evolved from New World yaws strains.
Strengths and Limitations of the Study
The basis of the claim for a New World origin of venereal syphilis is sequence similarity between the Guyana yaws samples and the pallidum strains. However, the sequence similarity is based on only four SNPs. Furthermore, three of the SNPs cause non-synonymous changes and occur in a very short region (∼15 amino acids) of the tprI protein. This is an extraordinarily high rate of evolutionary change in a genus that has been characterized by very little change. Two of the SNPs (tprI 137 and 151) are shown to have evolved two independent times according to the authors' network analysis (Fig. 3 of Harper et al. ), a result that again makes little sense in a genus characterized by very little variation. One of those SNPs (tprI 151) also differs between two pertenue strains CDC-1 and CDC-2, which are strains that might be predicted to be identical given the very close geographical and chronological proximity of isolation. Finally, tprI is thought to be involved in pathogenesis  and thus is subject to the effects of natural selection, which violates the assumptions of phylogenetic analysis. Clearly the tprI locus is atypical of the treponemal genome and, thus, is not the best choice when trying to resolve the decades-old debate concerning the origin of venereal syphilis.
Additionally, the phylogenetic and network analyses presented by Harper et al. are contradictory in that the phylogeny supposedly supports the evolution of pallidum from endemicum (Fig 2 of Harper et al. ) but the network (Fig 3 of Harper et al. ) is used to infer the origin of pallidum from New World pertenue strains. Part of the problem may be the fact that the phylogeny does not show significant structure, contrary to the authors' claims. When the tree is redrawn to show only branches with minimal 50% bootstrap support, the pertenue cluster disappears and all three subspecies, plus the simian isolate, branch off the most basal branch simultaneously (see Figure 1). This means that no evolutionary order can be inferred. Furthermore, since all strains were collected contemporaneously (at least on an evolutionary time scale), the branch lengths should all be approximately equivalent since a phylogeny reflects only mutational evolution (i.e. all treponemal strains should be equidistant from their common ancestor). The fact that the pallidum strains have longer branch lengths does not mean they evolved more recently, but instead is consistent with an argument for increased recombination or selection along the pallidum branch, i.e. essentially any phenomenon that violates the evolution-by-mutation-only assumption of a phylogenetic analysis. It is also perhaps noteworthy that the pallidum strains are all from the New World except for two strains (South Africa and Madras), whereas the endemicum and pertenue strains are all from the Old World (with the exception of the new Guyana strains). Thus, the reported sequence homology between the Guyana and pallidum strains may simply reflect geographic clustering of New World vs. Old World strains. It would be interesting, though perhaps not possible, to examine older European or Asian pallidum strains to see whether the phylogeny is altered.
This phylogeny is identical to the phylogeny of Harper et al. (Fig. 2) except that it has been re-estimated to show only branches with >50% bootstrap support for both maximum likelihood and maximum parsimony analyses. As with Harper et al.'s phylogeny, vertical distance is not meaningful, i.e. the placement of taxa along the vertical lines is inconsequential. Pertenue, endemicum and pallidum strains are depicted in green, blue, and red, respectively.
Caution, therefore, must be used in drawing conclusions about the evolution of “subspecies” that may represent a biological continuum, rather than discrete agents. Certainly, firm conclusions should not be based upon a few SNPs in two samples taken from a single location.
Despite the limitations of the Harper et al. analysis (as acknowledged by the authors in the discussion), the results reinforce another long-term question: How could the limited divergence between Treponema species and subspecies give rise to the observed differences in pathogenesis? Examination of ∼7 kb of sequence resulted in the identification of only 26 nucleotide substitutions among T. pallidum strains, or one difference for every 275 bp (99.6% identity). As indicated in the article, this figure most likely represents a gross overestimate of the overall degree of heterogeneity, because some of the DNA segments were selected because of their high variability. A recent report by Strouhal et al.  compared the sequences of T. pallidum subsp. pallidum (Nichols) and Treponema paraluiscuniculi (Strain Cuniculi A), the closely related spirochete that causes venereal spirochaetosis in rabbits but is not pathogenic to humans. A genome-wide analysis using microarray and whole genome restriction mapping indicated that the overall sequence similarity is in the range of 98.6 to 99.3%. Most of the differences identified are within tpr genes or neighboring genes. Based on these two studies and prior evidence, it is possible that genes within the tpr loci are primarily responsible for the differences in disease manifestations and host susceptibility.
T. pallidum is one of the few human bacterial pathogens that have not been cultivated in vitro, obviating experimental approaches such as mutational analysis and complementation to definitively identify virulence determinants. How then can our knowledge of genes related to treponemal evolution and pathogenesis be further refined? One possible approach is whole genome sequencing of multiple strains and comparison of the resulting sequences. The ongoing goal of inexpensive, ‘personalized’ human genome sequences has resulted in the development of multiple novel sequencing approaches; some of these methods can yield a high redundancy bacterial genome sequence for ∼US$400 in reagent costs . The new methodologies tend to yield shorter sequences per template (25 to 100 bp) and to have a higher error rate than Sanger sequencing. These shortcomings make the newer technologies more applicable to genome re-sequencing (e.g. the analysis of the closely related pathogenic Treponema strains) and can be ameliorated in part by combining the results of two or more sequencing technologies.
Because of the paucity of available endemicum strains and New World pertenue isolates, new approaches may be needed to analyze archival DNA specimens. Kolman et al.  were able to identify T. pallidum sequences by PCR amplification of DNA extracted from deformed bones (saber shins) in 200-year-old skeletal remains from Easter Island. Processes have been developed for isolation, whole genome amplification, and sequencing of DNA from individual bacterial cells ,. These methods, perhaps coupled with laser capture microscopy or techniques for dissecting out organisms, could be utilized to recover and obtain sequence information from ancient bones or preserved tissue specimens with treponemal infections.
- 1. Antal GM, Causse G (1985) The control of endemic treponematoses. Rev Infect Dis 7: Suppl 2S220–226.GM AntalG. Causse1985The control of endemic treponematoses.Rev Infect Dis7Suppl 2S220226
- 2. WHOYaws and Other Endemic Treponematoses AFR/CD/58; 1986 Feb 3–6, 1986; Brazzaville, Africa. World Health Organization. WHOYaws and Other Endemic Treponematoses AFR/CD/58; 1986 Feb 3–6, 1986; Brazzaville, Africa.World Health Organization
- 3. Antal GM, Burke JP, Geizer I, Lukehart SA (1985) Inter-regional meeting on yaws and other endemic treponematoses. Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health 17: 1–96.GM AntalJP BurkeI. GeizerSA Lukehart1985Inter-regional meeting on yaws and other endemic treponematoses.Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health17196
- 4. Burke JP, Hopkins DR, Hume JC, Perine PL, St. John R (1985) Reviews of infectious diseases. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. JP BurkeDR HopkinsJC HumePL PerineR. St. John1985Reviews of infectious diseases.Chicago, ILUniversity of Chicago Press
- 5. Hudson EH (1965) Treponematosis in perspective. Bull World Health Org 32: 735–748.EH Hudson1965Treponematosis in perspective.Bull World Health Org32735748
- 6. Hackett CJ (1963) On the origin of the human treponematoses. Bull World Health Org 29: 7–41.CJ Hackett1963On the origin of the human treponematoses.Bull World Health Org29741
- 7. Centurion-Lara A, Molini BJ, Godornes C, Sun E, Hevner K, et al. (2006) Molecular differentiation of Treponema pallidum subspecies. J Clin Microbiol 44: 3377–3380.A. Centurion-LaraBJ MoliniC. GodornesE. SunK. Hevner2006Molecular differentiation of Treponema pallidum subspecies.J Clin Microbiol4433773380
- 8. Vorst FA (1985) Clinical diagnosis and changing manifestations of treponemal infection. Rev Infect Dis 7: Suppl 2S327–331.FA Vorst1985Clinical diagnosis and changing manifestations of treponemal infection.Rev Infect Dis7Suppl 2S327331
- 9. Roman GC, Roman LN (1986) Occurrence of congenital, cardiovascular, visceral, neurologic, and neuro-ophthalmologic complications in late yaws: a theme for future research. Rev Infect Dis 8: 760–770.GC RomanLN Roman1986Occurrence of congenital, cardiovascular, visceral, neurologic, and neuro-ophthalmologic complications in late yaws: a theme for future research.Rev Infect Dis8760770
- 10. Blacklock D (1932) Yaws and syphilis. Ann Trop Med Parasitol 26: 423–455.D. Blacklock1932Yaws and syphilis.Ann Trop Med Parasitol26423455
- 11. Turner TB, Hollander DH (1957) Biology of the Treponematoses. Geneva: World Health Organization. TB TurnerDH Hollander1957Biology of the Treponematoses.GenevaWorld Health Organization
- 12. Centurion-Lara A, Castro C, Castillo R, Shaffer JM, Van Voorhis WC, et al. (1998) The flanking region sequences of the 15-kDa lipoprotein gene differentiate pathogenic treponemes. J Infect Dis 177: 1036–1040.A. Centurion-LaraC. CastroR. CastilloJM ShafferWC Van Voorhis1998The flanking region sequences of the 15-kDa lipoprotein gene differentiate pathogenic treponemes.J Infect Dis17710361040
- 13. Cameron CE, Lukehart SA, Castro C, Molini B, Godornes C, et al. (2000) Opsonic potential, protective capacity, and sequence conservation of the Treponema pallidum subspecies pallidum Tp92. J Infect Dis 181: 1401–1413.CE CameronSA LukehartC. CastroB. MoliniC. Godornes2000Opsonic potential, protective capacity, and sequence conservation of the Treponema pallidum subspecies pallidum Tp92.J Infect Dis18114011413
- 14. Noordhoek GT, Wieles B, van der Sluis JJ, van Embden JD (1990) Polymerase chain reaction and synthetic DNA probes: a means of distinguishing the causative agents of syphilis and yaws? Infect Immun 58: 2011–2013.GT NoordhoekB. WielesJJ van der SluisJD van Embden1990Polymerase chain reaction and synthetic DNA probes: a means of distinguishing the causative agents of syphilis and yaws?Infect Immun5820112013
- 15. Schell RF, Musher DM, editors. (1983) Pathogenesis and Immunology of Treponemal Infection. New York, NY: Marcel Dekker, Inc. RF SchellDM Musher1983Pathogenesis and Immunology of Treponemal Infection.New York, NYMarcel Dekker, Inc
- 16. Schell RF, Le Frock JL, Babu JP, Chan JK (1979) Use of CB hamsters in the study of Treponema pertenue. Br J Vener Dis 55: 316–319.RF SchellJL Le FrockJP BabuJK Chan1979Use of CB hamsters in the study of Treponema pertenue.Br J Vener Dis55316319
- 17. Schell RF, Le Frock JL, Babu JP (1978) Passive transfer of resistance to frambesial infection in hamsters. Infect Immun 21: 430–435.RF SchellJL Le FrockJP Babu1978Passive transfer of resistance to frambesial infection in hamsters.Infect Immun21430435
- 18. Harper KN, Ocampo PS, Steiner BM, George RW, Silverman MS, et al. (2007) On the Origin of the Treponematoses: A Phylogenetic Approach. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2(1): e148. doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000148.KN HarperPS OcampoBM SteinerRW GeorgeMS Silverman2007On the Origin of the Treponematoses: A Phylogenetic Approach.PLoS Negl Trop Dis2(1)e148. doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000148
- 19. Giacani L, Sambri V, Marangoni A, Cavrini F, Storni E, et al. (2005) Immunological evaluation and cellular location analysis of the TprI antigen of Treponema pallidum subsp. pallidum. Infect Immun 73: 3817–3822.L. GiacaniV. SambriA. MarangoniF. CavriniE. Storni2005Immunological evaluation and cellular location analysis of the TprI antigen of Treponema pallidum subsp. pallidum.Infect Immun7338173822
- 20. Strouhal M, Smajs D, Matejkova P, Sodergren E, Amin AG, et al. (2007) Genome differences between Treponema pallidum subsp. pallidum strain Nichols and T. paraluiscuniculi strain Cuniculi A. Infect Immun 75: 5859–5866.M. StrouhalD. SmajsP. MatejkovaE. SodergrenAG Amin2007Genome differences between Treponema pallidum subsp. pallidum strain Nichols and T. paraluiscuniculi strain Cuniculi A.Infect Immun7558595866
- 21. Bentley DR (2006) Whole-genome re-sequencing. Curr Opin Genet Dev 16: 545–552.DR Bentley2006Whole-genome re-sequencing.Curr Opin Genet Dev16545552
- 22. Kolman CJ, Centurion-Lara A, Lukehart SA, Owsley DW, Tuross N (1999) Identification of Treponema pallidum subspecies pallidum in a 200-year-old skeletal specimen. J Infect Dis 180: 2060–2063.CJ KolmanA. Centurion-LaraSA LukehartDW OwsleyN. Tuross1999Identification of Treponema pallidum subspecies pallidum in a 200-year-old skeletal specimen.J Infect Dis18020602063
- 23. Marcy Y, Ouverney C, Bik EM, Losekann T, Ivanova N, et al. (2007) Dissecting biological “dark matter” with single-cell genetic analysis of rare and uncultivated TM7 microbes from the human mouth. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 11889–11894.Y. MarcyC. OuverneyEM BikT. LosekannN. Ivanova2007Dissecting biological “dark matter” with single-cell genetic analysis of rare and uncultivated TM7 microbes from the human mouth.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A1041188911894
- 24. Zhang K, Martiny AC, Reppas NB, Barry KW, Malek J, et al. (2006) Sequencing genomes from single cells by polymerase cloning. Nat Biotechnol 24: 680–686.K. ZhangAC MartinyNB ReppasKW BarryJ. Malek2006Sequencing genomes from single cells by polymerase cloning.Nat Biotechnol24680686