Long- and short-term exposures to air pollution, especially fine particulate matter (PM2.5), have been linked to cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. One hypothesized mechanism for these associations involves microvascular effects. Retinal photography provides a novel, in vivo approach to examine the association of air pollution with changes in the human microvasculature.
Methods and Findings
Chronic and acute associations between residential air pollution concentrations and retinal vessel diameters, expressed as central retinal arteriolar equivalents (CRAE) and central retinal venular equivalents (CRVE), were examined using digital retinal images taken in Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) participants between 2002 and 2003. Study participants (46 to 87 years of age) were without clinical cardiovascular disease at the baseline examination (2000–2002). Long-term outdoor concentrations of PM2.5 were estimated at each participant's home for the 2 years preceding the clinical exam using a spatio-temporal model. Short-term concentrations were assigned using outdoor measurements on the day preceding the clinical exam. Residential proximity to roadways was also used as an indicator of long-term traffic exposures. All associations were examined using linear regression models adjusted for subject-specific age, sex, race/ethnicity, education, income, smoking status, alcohol use, physical activity, body mass index, family history of cardiovascular disease, diabetes status, serum cholesterol, glucose, blood pressure, emphysema, C-reactive protein, medication use, and fellow vessel diameter. Short-term associations were further controlled for weather and seasonality. Among the 4,607 participants with complete data, CRAE were found to be narrower among persons residing in regions with increased long- and short-term levels of PM2.5. These relationships were observed in a joint exposure model with −0.8 µm (95% confidence interval [CI] −1.1 to −0.5) and −0.4 µm (95% CI −0.8 to 0.1) decreases in CRAE per interquartile increases in long- (3 µg/m3) and short-term (9 µg/m3) PM2.5 levels, respectively. These reductions in CRAE are equivalent to 7- and 3-year increases in age in the same cohort. Similarly, living near a major road was also associated with a −0.7 µm decrease (95% CI −1.4 to 0.1) in CRAE. Although the chronic association with CRAE was largely influenced by differences in exposure between cities, this relationship was generally robust to control for city-level covariates and no significant differences were observed between cities. Wider CRVE were associated with living in areas of higher PM2.5 concentrations, but these findings were less robust and not supported by the presence of consistent acute associations with PM2.5.
Residing in regions with higher air pollution concentrations and experiencing daily increases in air pollution were each associated with narrower retinal arteriolar diameters in older individuals. These findings support the hypothesis that important vascular phenomena are associated with small increases in short-term or long-term air pollution exposures, even at current exposure levels, and further corroborate reported associations between air pollution and the development and exacerbation of clinical cardiovascular disease.
Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summary
Citation: Adar SD, Klein R, Klein BEK, Szpiro AA, Cotch MF, Wong TY, et al. (2010) Air Pollution and the Microvasculature: A Cross-Sectional Assessment of In Vivo Retinal Images in the Population-Based Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA). PLoS Med 7(11): e1000372. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000372
Academic Editor: Bruce P. Lanphear, Simon Fraser University, Canada
Received: January 27, 2010; Accepted: October 18, 2010; Published: November 30, 2010
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Public Domain declaration which stipulates that, once placed in the public domain, this work may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose.
Funding: This work was supported by awards RD831697 from the Environmental Protection Agency; EY000403 from the National Eye Institute; HL69979, N01-HC-95159 through N01-HC-95165, and N01-HC-95169 from the National Heart, Lung, Blood Institute; and K24ES013195, P50ES015915, P30ES07033 and R01ES016932 from the National Institutes of Environmental Health Sciences. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: Several authors (SDA, AAS, MSO, RGB, DSS, PDS, and JDK) have received unrestricted grant funding or support on unrestricted grant funds to study related topics from the Environmental Protection Agency, National Institutes of Heath, and/or the Health Effects Institute.
Abbreviations: AQS, Air Quality System; BMI, body mass index; CI, confidence interval; CRAE, central retinal arteriolar equivalents; CRVE, central retinal venular equivalents; df, degrees of freedom; EPA, Environmental Protection Agency; HDL, high-density lipoprotein; LDL, low-density lipoprotein; MESA, Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis; MESA Air, Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis and Air Pollution; PM2.5, fine particulate matter less than 2.5 µm in aerodynamic diameter; SD, standard deviation
Cardiovascular disease (CVD)—disease that affects the heart and/or the blood vessels—is a common cause of illness and death among adults in developed countries. In the United States, for example, the leading cause of death is coronary heart disease, a CVD in which narrowing of the heart's arteries by atherosclerotic plaques (fatty deposits that build up with age) slows the blood supply to the heart and may eventually cause a heart attack (myocardial infarction). Other types of CVD include stroke (in which atherosclerotic plaques interrupt the brain's blood supply) and peripheral arterial disease (in which the blood supply to the limbs is blocked). Smoking, high blood pressure, high blood levels of cholesterol (a type of fat), having diabetes, being overweight, and being physically inactive all increase a person's risk of developing CVD. Treatments for CVD include lifestyle changes and taking drugs that lower blood pressure or blood cholesterol levels.
Why Was This Study Done?
Another risk factor for CVD is exposure to long-term and/or short-term air pollution. Fine particle pollution or PM2.5 is particularly strongly associated with an increased risk of CVD. PM2.5—particulate matter 2.5 µm in diameter or 1/30th the diameter of a human hair—is mainly produced by motor vehicles, power plants, and other combustion sources. Why PM2.5 increases CVD risk is not clear but one possibility is that it alters the body's microvasculature (fine blood vessels known as capillaries, arterioles, and venules), thereby impairing the blood flow through the heart and brain. In this study, the researchers use noninvasive digital retinal photography to investigate whether there is an association between air pollution and changes in the human microvasculature. The retina—a light-sensitive layer at the back of the eye that converts images into electrical messages and sends them to the brain—has a dense microvasculature. Retinal photography is used to check the retinal microvasculature for signs of potentially blinding eye diseases such as diabetic retinopathy. Previous studies have found that narrower than normal retinal arterioles and wider than normal retinal venules are associated with CVD.
What Did the Researchers Do and Find?
The researchers used digital retinal photography to measure the diameters of retinal blood vessels in the participants of the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA). This study is investigating CVD progression in people aged 45–84 years of various ethnic backgrounds who had no CVD symptoms when they enrolled in the study in 2000–2002. The researchers modeled the long-term outdoor concentration of PM2.5 at each participant's house for the 2-year period preceding the retinal examination (which was done between 2002 and 2003) using data on PM2.5 levels collected by regulatory monitoring stations as well as study-specific air samples collected outside of the homes and in the communities of study participants. Outdoor PM2.5 measurements taken the day before the examination provided short-term PM2.5 levels. Among the 4,607 MESA participants who had complete data, retinal arteriolar diameters were narrowed among those who lived in regions with increased long- and short-term PM2.5 levels. Specifically, an increase in long-term PM2.5 concentrations of 3 µg/m3 was associated with a 0.8 µm decrease in arteriolar diameter, a reduction equivalent to that seen for a 7-year increase in age in this group of people. Living near a major road, another indicator of long-term exposure to PM2.5 pollution, was also associated with narrowed arterioles. Finally, increased retinal venular diameters were weakly associated with long-term high PM2.5 concentrations.
What Do These Findings Mean?
These findings indicate that living in areas with long-term air pollution or being exposed to short-term air pollution is associated with narrowing of the retinal arterioles in older individuals. They also show that widening of retinal venules is associated with long-term (but not short-term) PM2.5 pollution. Together, these findings support the hypothesis that long- and short-term air pollution increases CVD risk through effects on the microvasculature. However, they do not prove that PM2.5 is the constituent of air pollution that drives microvascular changes—these findings could reflect the toxicity of another pollutant or the pollution mixture as a whole. Importantly, these findings show that microvascular changes can occur at the PM2.5 levels that commonly occur in developed countries, which are well below those seen in developing countries. Worryingly, they also suggest that the deleterious cardiovascular effects of air pollution could occur at levels below existing regulatory standards.
Please access these Web sites via the online version of this summary at http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000372.
- The American Heart Association provides information for patients and caregivers on all aspects of cardiovascular disease (in several languages), including information on air pollution, heart disease, and stroke
- The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has information on heart disease and on stroke
- Information is available from the British Heart Foundation on cardiovascular disease
- The UK National Health Service Choices website provides information for patients and caregivers about cardiovascular disease
- MedlinePlus provides links to other sources of information on heart disease and on vascular disease (in English and Spanish)
- The AIRNow site provides information about US air quality and about air pollution and health
- The Air Quality Archive has up-to-date information about air pollution in the UK and information about the health effects of air pollution
- The US Environmental Protection Agency has information on PM2.5
- The following Web sites contain information available on the MESA and MESA Air studies
Long- and short-term exposures to ambient and traffic-related air pollution, especially fine particulate matter (particulate matter less than 2.5 µm in aerodynamic diameter, or PM2.5), have been linked to higher rates of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality –. It has been hypothesized that impacts on microvascular function may play a role in these associations . Toxicological studies support this hypothesis as they have demonstrated that PM2.5 can impair microvascular endothelium-dependent dilation . One human study also demonstrated air pollution and exercise-induced ischemia in a pattern that was more consistent with impaired myocardial microvascular flow than altered larger epicardial vessel coronary circulation . Other human studies have shown links between air pollution and impaired vasodilatation or enhanced vasoconstriction in the forearm –, but none have directly explored associations with the microvasculature.
Retinal photography provides a noninvasive, in vivo, method for characterizing the human microvasculature since retinal vessels are 60–300 µm in diameter. Several studies have found that narrower arteriolar diameters and wider venular diameters, as measured by retinal photography, are each associated with increased risk of myocardial infarction, stroke, and cardiovascular mortality, independent of other traditional risk factors –. Furthermore, recent data from the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA) have linked narrower retinal arteriolar diameters with measures of subclinical cardiovascular disease including increased left ventricular mass, reduced aortic distensibility, and reduced large artery compliance –. These findings were independent of other cardiovascular risk factors, including blood pressure, diabetes, blood cholesterol level, family history of cardiovascular disease, body mass index (BMI), glucose level, and C-reactive protein, which have also been associated with retinal vessel diameter in the same cohort . It is unknown, however, if exposures to ambient and traffic-related air pollution are related to adverse retinal microvascular changes
Our primary aim was to investigate cross-sectional associations between long- and short-term air pollution concentrations and microvascular characteristics using arteriolar vessel diameter as measured by retinal photography in MESA, a well-characterized cohort with individual-level predictions of residential pollutant concentrations. We hypothesized that higher air pollution levels would be associated with narrowed retinal arteriole diameters. We also hypothesized that greater air pollution concentrations would be associated with widened retinal venular diameters.
MESA is a prospective cohort study designed to investigate the progression of subclinical and clinical cardiovascular disease . The cohort is comprised of 6,814 white, African American, Hispanic, and Asian (of Chinese decent) men and women recruited in six American communities (Baltimore, MD; Chicago, IL; Forsyth County, NC; Los Angeles County, CA; Northern Manhattan, NY; and St. Paul, MN). Participants were aged 45 to 84 y and free of clinical cardiovascular disease at their baseline exam (July 2000 to August 2002). This study met with the guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki. Institutional review board approval was granted at each study site, and written informed consent was obtained from all participants. Only participants with complete retinal, exposure, and covariate information were included in this analysis.
Retinal Photography and Grading
Retinal photography was performed at each field center using standardized methods during the second MESA examination, which took place between August 2002 and January 2004. Of the 6,233 participants that returned for this follow-up exam, 6,176 individuals had retinal photographs taken. For each participant, the optic disc and macula of both eyes were photographed in a darkened room using a 45° 6.3-megapixel digital nonmydriatic camera (Canon), and methods described in detail by Klein and colleagues . Trained graders who were masked to all participant characteristics reviewed all images at the University of Wisconsin Ocular Epidemiology Reading Center in Madison using previously reported protocols –. Briefly, retinal vessel diameters were measured using a computer-based program and summarized as central retinal arteriolar and venular equivalents (CRAE and CRVE, respectively). These equivalents represent a summary of vessel diameters within an area equal to 0.5–1 disc diameters from the optic disc margin. Vessel diameters for the right eye were selected for all analyses. Images from the left eye were used only if retinal vessel diameters could not be graded in the right eye. The reproducibility of the vessel diameter measurements in MESA were good, with intragrader and intergrader correlation coefficients of 0.78 to 0.99 .
Detailed data regarding participant health were collected during the first and second MESA clinical exams, including anthropometry as well as serum levels of high-density lipoprotein (HDL) and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol, glucose, homocysteine, and inflammatory markers . Information regarding participant demographics, medical history, and medication use was also obtained at these exams through technician-administered questionnaires. Residential addresses provided at the exams were assigned geographic coordinates using ArcGIS software, version 9.1 (ESRI), on the basis of the Dynamap/2000 street network (Tele Atlas).
City-wide covariates were also collected for each metropolitan statistical area from the US Census 2000 (http://www.census.gov/main/www/cen2000.html) and used in sensitivity analyses. Variables included information about the general population's age, race/ethnicity, educational attainment, nativity, unemployment, income, and poverty status. Consistent with the reanalysis of the Harvard Six Cities and the American Cancer Society Studies , we also explored confounding by city-average elevation, maximum temperature, and the variation in temperature as expressed by the standard deviation of daily readings.
Estimates of long-term ambient PM2.5 concentrations were computed for each participant using a hierarchical spatio-temporal model fit with a pragmatic estimation procedure described elsewhere ,. The data utilized to derive these predictions were 2-wk average concentrations of PM2.5 collected over the course of several years by regulatory monitoring stations from the US Environmental Protection Agency's Air Quality System (AQS) and supplemental monitoring stations specific to this project . Briefly, the hierarchical model decomposed the space-time field of concentrations into three pieces: (i) spatially varying long-term averages, (ii) spatially varying seasonal and long-term trends, and (iii) spatially correlated but temporally independent residuals. Model estimation and prediction were carried out using a multistep procedure that incorporated a large suite of spatial covariates such as proximity to major roadways and local land use to predict average PM2.5 concentrations at each subject's home location over the 2 y preceding the participant's exam date. Model selection and validation were carried out using cross-validation with city-specific cross-validated root mean square errors for predicting long-term average concentrations at Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis and and Air Pollution (MESA Air) monitoring locations between 0.34 and 0.94 µg/m3 .
Since our hierarchical model is currently only resolved to the 2-wk time scale, we did not apply this approach for our short-term analysis. Rather, city-wide average concentrations from AQS monitoring stations with complete time series during the period of interest were used to estimate daily concentrations of PM2.5. This approach is consistent with the majority of acute air pollution epidemiology research and is justified by the fact that daily PM2.5 concentrations are typically highly correlated across different locations within a region over time. On the basis of our hypothesis that acute impacts on the microvasculature would be rapid, we assigned concentrations for each participant for the day of their exam, the preceding day, and the average of the preceding 3 d. A priori, we selected concentrations on the day preceding the exam for our primary analyses, although we evaluated the other two time periods in sensitivity analyses.
In other sensitivity analyses, we explored the relationship between both outcomes and long-term average concentrations of PM2.5 measured at the nearest AQS monitor as a more traditional indicator of pollution. Additionally, we evaluated the impact of living near a major roadway as defined by living within 100 m of an interstate or US highway (Census Feature Class Code A1 or A2) or within 50 m of a state or county highway (CFCC A3). These distances were calculated in ArcGIS 9.1 on the basis of the TeleAtlas Dynamap 2000 road network.
Linear regression modeling was performed in R version 2.10.1 (The R Project) in order to examine cross-sectional associations between air pollution and retinal vessel diameters. Long-and short-term associations with air pollution concentrations were modeled independently and jointly. For both CRAE and CRVE, we performed our modeling in a phased approach and explored confounding by age, sex, race/ethnicity (white, African American, Chinese American, Mexican Hispanic, Dominican Hispanic, Puerto Rican Hispanic, and other Hispanic), and education (<high school, high school or equivalent, associate, bachelor, or technical degree, and graduate degree). We also considered lifestyle factors including smoking status (never, former, and current), alcohol consumption (user, nonuser), and physical activity in metabolic equivalent (MET)-minutes/week. In addition, confounding by BMI, waist to hip ratio, family history of cardiovascular disease (defined by a history of heart attack, stroke, or noninjury amputation among a parent, sibling, or child), history of diabetes mellitus (defined by the 2003 American Diabetes Association fasting criteria algorithm ), systolic and diastolic blood pressure, emphysema, as well as serum glucose, HDL and LDL cholesterol, homocysteine, and inflammatory markers (C-reactive protein and fibrinogen) levels was explored. On the basis of past research, which indicates that anatomical variation and measurement error in retinal caliber can lead to spurious associations –, we also explored confounding between CRAE and CRVE. By controlling for the fellow vessel type in our models, we are further able to address the scientific question of how air pollution is associated with vessel caliber relative to the fellow vessel. Although examined, income (<US$20,000, US$20,000 to <US$50,000, US$50,000 to <US$75,000, ≥US$75,000), secondhand smoke exposures, and medication use (antihypertensives, lipid-lowering medications, aspirin, cox-2 inhibitors, erectile dysfunction medications, beta agonists, sympathomimetics, verapamil, and vasodilators) were ultimately not included in our main models because there were more missing data for these parameters and sensitivity analyses demonstrated little impact on our results. While not of primary interest, we reported effect estimates for blood pressure and age on vessel diameters from the fully adjusted models for comparison purposes.
Linearity of all continuous variables was checked using LOESS smoothing fits. For CRAE, all variables were modeled as linear except for systolic blood pressure, which was modeled as a piecewise linear spline with a knot at 135 mmHg and BMI, which was modeled as a quadratic. For CRVE, only HDL cholesterol was modeled with a nonlinear function expressed as a piecewise linear spline with a knot at 100 mg/dl. For both outcomes, homocysteine levels were modeled using a log-transformation to reduce the impact of highly skewed values on the results. For our acute effect analyses, we included categorical variables for city and city-specific day of week effects as well as spline fits for city-specific trends in calendar day (12 degrees of freedom [df]/year), temperature (6 df), and dew point (6 df) using B-splines to control for confounding by seasonality and meteorology on the day of the clinical exam.
To explore the importance of site on our models, we first tested for statistically significant interactions by city. We then decomposed our PM2.5 concentrations into between- and within-city exposure contrasts to examine the contribution of each to any observed associations and investigated results stratified by city. Finally, we explored the possibility of confounding of our overall associations by individual city-level factors. We further investigated differential susceptibility by including interaction terms for age, race/ethnicity, gender, obesity, diabetes, hypertension, use of specific classes of hypertensive medications, and use of anti-inflammatory medications.
With retinal data missing for 283 participants, address or exposure data missing for 1,104 persons, and covariate data missing for 243 persons, 4,607 individuals were examined in this analysis. Descriptive statistics are presented in Table 1 for individuals with complete information as well as those individuals excluded from analysis. Included participants were 53% women among four race/ethnicities (40% white, 26% African American, 12% Chinese American, and 22% Hispanic). Of the Hispanics in the population, 52%, 14%, 14%, and 35% were of Mexican, Dominican, Puerto Rican, and other descent, respectively. With a mean age of 63 y, 44% of the population had hypertension, 13% had diabetes (an additional 15% had impaired glucose), and 58% had a family history of cardiovascular disease. Excluded individuals were qualitatively similar to the main cohort although they were slightly older, of lower socioeconomic position, and had higher prevalence of hypertension and diabetes.
The mean CRAE in the population was 144 µm and the mean CRVE was 214 µm (Table 2). Long-term concentrations of outdoor PM2.5 were similar between our spatio-temporal model predictions and the closest EPA-monitoring station with means of 16 µg/m3 across all participants and standard deviations of 3 µg/m3. As anticipated, short-term concentrations were more variable than long-term averages (standard deviations [SDs] of 9 µg/m3 for the shortest time frames) and low correlations were found between our short- and long-term average concentrations (0.25 in crude analyses and 0 after adjustment for site). Approximately 30% of the population was living near a major roadway.
Retinal Arteriolar Diameters
In multivariate regression models, CRAE was negatively associated with long-term average modeled PM2.5 levels with a greater magnitude of association seen with increasing control for potentially confounding variables (Table 3). The strongest effect estimate was found in the model fully adjusted for all personal, health, lifestyle characteristics, and CRVE. Similar results were found in a model that included concentrations of PM2.5 on the day preceding the health exam. In this final joint model, an interquartile increase of 3 µg/m3 in our modeled long-term PM2.5 concentrations was associated with a −0.8 µm (95% confidence interval [CI] −1.1 to −0.5) decrease in CRAE. This association was quantitatively similar to a 7-y increase in age or a 3-mm Hg increase in diastolic blood pressure in our predictive models for CRAE.
Figure 1 illustrates the chronic relationship between CRAE and the underlying trimodal distribution of long-term PM2.5 concentrations in the cohort with clusters of individuals living in St. Paul and Winston Salem (the lowest polluted cities), New York, Chicago, and Baltimore (the three modestly polluted cities), and Los Angeles (the most polluted city). Given the larger variation in long-term average concentrations between cities (SD = 3.3 µg/m3) as compared to within-cities (SD = 1.1 µg/m3), our overall results were driven by differences in air pollution levels between cities. This finding is illustrated by Figure 2, which shows the largest city-wide average retinal diameters among participants in the two least polluted cities and the smallest city-wide average diameters among persons in the most polluted city, after control for all confounders in a model including short-term concentrations. Partitioning the PM2.5 variation into city-wide means and deviations from that mean, we found that between-city differences in concentration were associated with a −0.9 µm (95% CI −1.2 to −0.5) decrease in CRAE per 3 µg/m3. Controlling for site using a random intercepts and random slopes model, we found that a 3 µg/m3 increase in PM2.5 was associated with a −0.7 µm (95% CI −1.2 to −0.1) decrease in CRAE. Controlling for site as a fixed effect resulted in a decrease of −0.4 µm (95% CI −1.3 to 0.5) per 3 µg/m3.
Note: CRAE values represent residuals from full joint model (i.e., model controlled for age, sex, race/ethnicity, BMI, waist-to-hip ratio, income, education, smoking history, alcohol use, family history of cardiovascular disease, LDL, HDL, blood pressure, diabetes, glucose, physical activity, emphysema, CRP, fibrinogen, homocysteine, CRVE, and previous day PM2.5 concentration). Data are plotted as a cubic polynomial with 3 df.
Notes: CRAE values presented as the residuals from a model controlled for age, sex, race/ethnicity, BMI, waist-to-hip ratio, income, education, smoking history, alcohol use, family history of cardiovascular disease, LDL, HDL, blood pressure, diabetes, glucose, physical activity, emphysema, CRP, fibrinogen, homocysteine, CRVE, and previous day PM2.5 concentration.
In spite of weaker and less precise estimates within city, we found no evidence of statistically significant differences in association by city (p-value for interaction = 0.6). In addition, our overall results (which include between and within-city variability in PM2.5) were robust to exclusion of any of the six cities, with the weakest association found when excluding Baltimore, New York, or Winston-Salem (−0.8 µm [95% CI −1.1 to −0.4] decrease per 3 µg/m3) and the strongest association found when excluding St. Paul (−1.1 µm [95% CI −1.6 to −0.7] decrease per 3 µg/m3). Furthermore, control for a variety of city-wide covariates including age, race/ethnicity, socioeconomic status, weather, and elevation did not qualitatively change our findings (unpublished data).We also found consistency between our modeled estimates of long-term average PM2.5 concentrations and the long-term average PM2.5 concentrations directly measured at the EPA monitoring station nearest the participants' residences, which also had negative, although generally smaller, associations with CRAE. Negative associations with larger CIs were also found for residential proximity to major roadways. In the fully adjusted, joint models, a 3-µg/m3 increase in PM2.5 measured at the nearest monitor was associated with a −0.5 µm decrease (95% CI −0.8 to −0.1) in CRAE and living close to a major roadway was associated with a −0.7 µm decrease (95% CI −1.4 to 0.1) in CRAE.
For short-term concentrations of PM2.5, we found that with CRAE, a 9-µg/m3 increase in exposure the day prior to the exam (the interquartile difference) was associated with a −0.4-µm decrease (95% CI −0.8 to 0.1, p = 0.09) in CRAE in the fully adjusted model, which included chronic air pollution exposures (Table 3). These associations were insensitive to adjustment for long-term concentrations and city, although they were slightly weakened by control for meteorology and other vessel diameter. Some sensitivity to exposure window was also found with the strongest point estimates of decreased diameter generally observed for our a priori hypothesized exposure period of the previous day. Decreases of −0.2 µm (95% CI −0.6 to 0.3) and −0.1 µm (95% CI −0.5 to 0.3) were seen for a 9 µg/m3 increase in the current day and 7 µg/m3 increase in the previous 3 d concentrations, respectively.
Only gender appeared to significantly modify the association between long-term exposures to air pollution and CRAE, with men demonstrating a larger reduction in retinal diameter (−1.3 µm [95% CI −1.7 to −0.8]) than women (−0.4 µm [95% CI −0.8 to 0.1]) for the same difference (3 µg/m3) in PM2.5 concentrations. These findings were not found in the short-term analysis, and no other factors were found to significantly modify the associations between air pollution and CRAE, including the presence of diabetes and race/ethnicity.
Retinal Venular Diameters
As hypothesized, long-term PM2.5 concentrations were associated with wider venular diameters (larger CRVE) in our multivariate models (Table 3). The strongest association was found in the fully adjusted model, including control for CRAE, with similar results for the model that included concentrations of PM2.5 on the day preceding the health exam. An interquartile increase of approximately 3 µg/m3 in long-term average PM2.5 was associated with a 0.9 µm (95% CI 0.4–1.4 µm) increase in CRVE. Partitioning the PM2.5 variability into a city mean and deviations from that mean, we found that between-city differences were more strongly and significantly associated with CRVE (1.0 µm [95% CI 0.4–1.5] per 3 µg/m3) than were pooled within-city differences (0.5 µm [95% CI −0.8 to 1.9] per 3 µg/m3). In fact, sensitivity analyses demonstrated that these results were driven by between city differences on the basis of the cities with the highest (Los Angeles) and lowest (St. Paul) concentrations (Figure 3). Exclusion of either of these cities resulted in a 20%–30% reduction in the effect estimate and a loss of statistical significance. Like for CRAE, analyses of individual cities demonstrated highly variable results although St. Paul was found to have a statistically significant association with CRVE with a 7.0 µm (95% CI 1.5–12.6) increase predicted per 3 µg/m3 in PM2.5 (results not shown).
Notes: CRVE values presented as the residuals from a model controlled for age, sex, race/ethnicity, BMI, waist-to-hip ratio, income, education, smoking history, alcohol use, family history of cardiovascular disease, LDL, HDL, blood pressure, diabetes, glucose, physical activity, emphysema, CRP, fibrinogen, homocysteine, CRAE, and previous day PM2.5 concentration.
Associations derived using modeled concentrations and concentrations measured directly at the nearest EPA monitor were similar to our spatio-temporal estimates with a 1.1 µm (95% CI 0.6–1.6 µm) increase per 3 µg/m3. Living near a major roadway was associated with decreased rather than increased venular diameter, but this association was not statistically significant in the fully adjusted model (results not shown). Short-term exposures were not associated with venular diameters (Table 3).
In a large population-based cohort study of adults without preexisting cardiovascular disease, we found independent associations between long- and short-term concentrations of fine particulate air pollution and vessel diameters of the retinal microvasculature, as measured using standardized photographic methods. Increased air pollution concentrations were associated with retinal arteriolar narrowing, an outcome that has previously been associated with increased risk of myocardial infarction, stroke, hypertension, and cardiovascular mortality, independent of other traditional risk factors. –.
An increase of 3 µg/m3 in long-term PM2.5 concentrations predicted at participant homes was associated with a −0.8 µm or −0.6% decrease in arteriolar diameter. This decrease is of the same order of magnitude as that of more traditional risk factors, with reductions equivalent to those seen for a 7-y increase in age or a 3-mm Hg increase in diastolic blood pressure in this cohort. Daily increases in PM2.5 concentrations were similarly associated with narrower arteriolar diameters, though these associations were not statistically significant (p = 0.09). All associations persisted after control for hypertension and other factors previously reported to be associated with narrower retinal arterioles and venular diameters. Although positive associations were demonstrated between chronic exposures to ambient PM2.5 and venular diameters, increases that have been associated with risk of stroke ,, these relationships were less robust and less consistent across exposure metrics than those found for CRAE.
This investigation is, to our knowledge, the first study to directly examine the relationship of ambient air pollution and in vivo measures of the human microvasculature. This study adds to previous in vivo work on the impacts of air pollution focused on larger vessels and extends past investigations on the ocular manifestations of environmental exposures – by evaluating them in a population-based cohort with high quality information on exposure, outcome, and confounders. Our findings support the hypothesis that subclinical microvascular changes are associated with PM exposures, even within the range of concentrations common in many developed countries with adopted pollution control measures and at levels much lower than are often found in newly industrialized urban centers. Finally, jointly modeling the short- and long-term impacts of a pollutant on vascular health provides new evidence that both time frames may be relevant for this outcome and enlarges the limited knowledge base in an area of substantial scientific uncertainty.
Our results are generally consistent with the existing literature on air pollution and the human vasculature, which has thus far examined associations with vessel diameter and function in the forearm. Several studies have used ultrasound to study the brachial artery, a conduit vessel with distinct anatomical and functional properties. In experimental settings, short-term exposures to high levels of air pollutants have been shown to elicit vasoconstriction of the brachial artery but not impair endothelium-dependent dilation ,–. In observational studies, short-term exposures have been associated with impaired endothelium-dependent vasodilation ,. Though the brachial artery assesses endothelial function in a vessel comparable to the epicardial coronary arteries, it has not been shown, to date, to be generalizable to the microvasculature of the heart and lungs, which are critically important in the progression of clinical vascular disease .
Other studies, which have examined an amalgamation of vessels smaller than the brachial artery using forearm plethysmography have similarly shown diminution in forearm blood flow following short-term exposure to diesel exhaust ,. Furthermore, recent toxicological investigations have demonstrated that acute exposures to PM blunt arteriolar dilatation of skeletal and subepicardial muscle in rats. These studies also demonstrated increased leukocyte adhesion and rolling in paired venules, elevated leukocyte deposition, increased oxidative stress, and decreased bioavailability of nitric oxide ,,,. Research also has suggested that air pollution can contribute to elevated blood pressure in humans ,.
Our findings of widened venular diameters with chronic exposures to air pollution are similarly consistent with the literature based on investigations of cigarette smoke ,. Although the biological mechanisms for these associations remain to be fully elucidated, it is thought that CRVE widening might be, at least partially, due to systemic inflammation . Nevertheless, our observed associations for CRVE should be interpreted with caution as they were not robust to exposure parameterization or timing of exposure, were driven entirely by differences between the two cities with the highest and lowest ambient air pollution concentrations, and were sensitive to control for CRAE.
Taken together, our findings support an increasingly consistent view of the downstream mechanisms through which particulate matter exposures might cause the clinical cardiovascular disease observed to be associated with air pollution in epidemiological studies. As such, these results further enhance the biological plausibility of observed air pollution–disease relationships. Although we cannot directly identify the upstream pathways of short and long-term exposures to PM2.5 that might have caused the observed narrowing of retinal arterioles, the fact that our findings persisted following adjustment for blood pressure and hypertension status may imply that these microvasculature changes are not a response to other changes in vascular resistance.
Our findings of significantly narrower retinal arteriolar diameters (and significant widening of retinal venular diameters) among persons residing in areas with higher long-term concentrations of air pollution are unique and support many published findings of elevated cardiovascular mortality risk in areas of elevated pollution. –. The observation of independent associations with microvascular phenomenon for short-term and long-term concentrations of PM2.5 is consistent with an impact of chronic pollution exposure that exceeds what can be ascribed to short-term increases in pollutant concentrations. Although we cannot fully exclude the possibility of confounding between short- and long-term associations without temporally resolved spatial predictions on a shorter time scale, this joint modeling method may help to further disentangle acute and long-term relationships with the cardiovascular system.
It should be noted that our long-term exposure findings were driven by between-city differences in pollution concentrations, most likely as the result of enhanced variability in PM2.5 concentrations between cities as compared to within any city. Our findings, however, are supported by a nonsignificant negative association with our pooled estimate of within-city variability, a lack of sensitivity of the arteriolar results to exclusion of any one particular city, and consistent negative associations for short-term fluctuations in pollution that are independent of city. The observed associations are also unlikely to be due to differences in data collection as standardized methods were used to maintain consistency across sites in retinal image collection. Similarly, all measures were read in a masked manner by a single centralized reading center using a validated protocol to standardize the grading of image parameters. Finally, our results also were found to be qualitatively similar across models with differing levels of control for many potential confounders (individual-level and city-wide).
Another point to note is that there was a relatively high proportion of missing data (16%) as a result of incomplete participant geocoding. Although individuals in rural or newer areas might be less likely to be geocoded, we do not anticipate any bias to our analysis since the likelihood of data being missing should be unrelated to the outcome.
Overall, these findings may have practical relevance since relationships with subclinical microvascular changes were found at PM2.5 levels that commonly occur in developed nations and well below those in developing countries. With a mean long-term concentration of 16 µg/m3, these levels were similar to the annual National Ambient Air Quality Standard of 15 µg/m3 established by the US EPA for PM2.5. The observation of a linear trend in the relationship between PM2.5 and CRAE further supports past findings , which have failed to find evidence of a threshold and suggest that the cardiovascular effects of air pollution can occur at levels below existing regulatory standards. Since different airborne pollutants can be correlated in the environment, we cannot exclude the possibility that these results might also reflect the toxicity of another correlated pollutant or the pollution mixture as a whole. As the MESA Air project proceeds with additional refinements to the air pollution estimates, including indoor predictions and investigation of other copollutants, and the MESA study collects an additional round of retinal photography in this cohort, we will be able to confirm our findings and examine this phenomenon in greater detail.
Long- and short-term concentrations of fine particulate matter were associated with observable differences in microvascular structure in a cross-sectional analysis of a large cohort, characterized by high quality information on exposure, outcome, and potential confounders. Individuals with higher long- and short-term air pollution concentrations had narrower arteriolar diameters, even after control for typical risk factors. We also found associations between chronic but not acute air pollution levels and widened retinal venules, another marker of microvascular disease, although these associations were less robust. Overall, our findings enhance the biological plausibility of the hypothesis that important vascular phenomena are associated with small increases in short-term or long-term air pollution exposures, even at current exposure levels. These results further support reported associations between air pollution and the development and exacerbation of clinical cardiovascular disease.
The authors are grateful for the other investigators, staff, and participants of the MESA, MESA Eye, and MESA Air studies for their valuable contributions to this work. A full list of MESA investigators and institutions can be found at http://www.mesa-nhlbi.org.
ICMJE criteria for authorship read and met: SDA RK BEKK AAS MFC TYW MSO SS RGB DSS MLD PDS JDK. Agree with the manuscript's results and conclusions: SDA RK BEKK AAS MFC TYW MSO SS RGB DSS MLD PDS JDK. Designed the experiments/the study: SDA MFC DSS JDK. Analyzed the data: SDA AAS SS. Collected data/did experiments for the study: RK BEKK SS RGB MLD. Enrolled patients: RGB MLD. Wrote the first draft of the paper: SDA. Contributed to the writing of the paper: SDA RK BEKK AAS MFC TYW MSO SS RGB DSS MLD PDS JDK. Critically revised manuscript for important intellectual content: BEKK. Developed statistical models: AAS. Helped to develop the collaboration with MESA that led to MESA AIR, and helped obtain funding for MESA AIR from the EPA: DSS. Reviewed the results of various analyses and suggested additional analyses: DSS. Responsible for the spatio-temporal model and estimates of exposure: PDS.
- 1. Brook RD, Rajagopalan S, Pope CA, Brook JR, Bhatnagar A, et al. (2010) Particulate matter air pollution and cardiovascular disease: an update to the scientific statement from the American Heart Association. Circulation 121: 2331–2378.
- 2. Hoek G, Brunekreef B, Goldbohm S, Fischer P, van den Brandt PA (2002) Association between mortality and indicators of traffic-related air pollution in the Netherlands: a cohort study. Lancet 360: 1203–1209.
- 3. Maheswaran R, Elliott P (2003) Stroke mortality associated with living near main roads in England and Wales - A geographical study. Stroke 34: 2776–2780.
- 4. Tonne C, Melly S, Mittleman M, Coull B, Goldberg R, et al. (2007) A case-control analysis of exposure to traffic and acute myocardial infarction. Environ Health Perspect 115: 53–57.
- 5. Adar SD, Kaufman JD (2007) Cardiovascular disease and air pollutants: evaluating and improving epidemiological data implicating traffic exposure. Inhal Toxicol 19: 135–149.
- 6. Pope CA, Dockery DW (2006) Health effects of fine particulate air pollution: lines that connect. Air Waste 56: 709–742.
- 7. Nurkiewicz TR, Porter DW, Barger M, Castranova V, Boegehold MA (2004) Particulate matter exposure impairs systemic microvascular endothelium-dependent dilation. Environ Health Perspect 112: 1299–1306.
- 8. Mills NL, Tornqvist H, Gonzalez MC, Vink E, Robinson SD, et al. (2007) Ischemic and thrombotic effects of dilute diesel-exhaust inhalation in men with coronary heart disease. N Engl J Med 357: 1075–1082.
- 9. Rundell KW, Hoffman JR, Caviston R, Bulbulian R, Hollenbach AM (2007) Inhalation of ultrafine and fine particulate matter disrupts systemic vascular function. Inhal Toxicol 19: 133–140.
- 10. Mills NL, Tornqvist H, Robinson SD, Gonzalez M, Darnley K, et al. (2005) Diesel exhaust inhalation causes vascular dysfunction and impaired endogenous fibrinolysis. Circulation 112: 3930–3936.
- 11. O'Neill MS, Veves A, Zanobetti A, Sarnat JA, Gold DR, et al. (2005) Diabetes enhances vulnerability to particulate air pollution - Associated impairment in vascular reactivity and endothelial function. Circulation 111: 2913–2920.
- 12. Brook RD, Brook JR, Urch B, Vincent R, Rajagopalan S, et al. (2002) Inhalation of fine particulate air pollution and ozone causes acute arterial vasoconstriction in healthy adults. Circulation 105: 1534–1536.
- 13. Wong TY, Kamineni A, Klein R, Sharrett AR, Klein BE, et al. (2006) Quantitative retinal venular caliber and risk of cardiovascular disease in older persons - The Cardiovascular Health Study. Arch Intern Med 166: 2388–2394.
- 14. Witt N, Wong TY, Hughes AD, Chaturvedi N, Klein BE, et al. (2006) Abnormalities of retinal microvascular structure and risk of mortality from ischemic heart disease and stroke. Hypertension 47: 975–981.
- 15. Wong TY, Klein R, Nieto FJ, Klein BEK, Sharrett AR, et al. (2003) Retinal microvascular abnormalities and 10-year cardiovascular mortality - A population-based case-control study. Ophthalmology 110: 933–940.
- 16. Duan YK, Mo JP, Klein R, Scott IU, Lin HM, et al. (2007) Age-related macular degeneration is associated with incident myocardial infarction among elderly Americans. Ophthalmology 114: 732–737.
- 17. Wong TY, Klein R, Couper DJ, Cooper LS, Shahar E, et al. (2001) Retinal microvascular abnormalities and incident stroke: the atherosclerosis risk in communities study. Lancet 358: 1134–1140.
- 18. Wong TY, Klein R, Sharrett AR, Duncan BB, Couper DJ, et al. (2002) Retinal arteriolar narrowing and risk of coronary heart disease in men and women - The atherosclerosis risk in communities study. JAMA 287: 1153–1159.
- 19. McGeechan K, Liew G, Macaskill P, Irwig L, Klein R, et al. (2009) Prediction of incident stroke events based on retinal vessel caliber: a systematic review and individual-participant meta-analysis. Am J Epidemiol 170: 1323–1332.
- 20. Cheung N, Bluemke DA, Klein R, Sharrett AR, Islam FMA, et al. (2007) Retinal arteriolar narrowing and left ventricular remodeling - The multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis. J Am Coll Cardiol 50: 48–55.
- 21. Cheung N, Islam FMA, Jacobs DR, Sharrett AR, Klein R, et al. (2007) Arterial compliance and retinal vascular caliber in cerebrovascular disease. Ann Neurol 62: 618–624.
- 22. Cheung N, Sharrett AR, Klein R, Criqui MH, Islam A, et al. (2007) Aortic distensibility and retinal arteriolar narrowing - The multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis. Hypertension 50: 617–622.
- 23. Wong TY, Islam FMA, Klein R, Klein BEK, Cotch MF, et al. (2006) Retinal vascular caliber, cardiovascular risk factors, and inflammation: The Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA). Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 47: 2341–2350.
- 24. Bild DE, Bluemke DA, Burke GL, Detrano R, Roux AVD, et al. (2002) Multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis: objectives and design. Am J Epidemiol 156: 871–881.
- 25. Klein R, Klein BEK, Knudtson MD, Wong TY, Cotch MF, et al. (2006) Prevalence of age-related macular degeneration in 4 racial/ethnic groups in the multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis. Ophthalmology 113: 373–380.
- 26. Wong TY, Knudtson MD, Klein R, Klein BEK, Meuer SM, et al. (2004) Computer-assisted measurement of retinal vessel diameters in the beaver dam eye study - Methodology, correlation between eyes, and effect of refractive errors. Ophthalmology 111: 1183–1190.
- 27. Knudtson MD, Lee KE, Hubbard LD, Wong TY, Klein R, et al. (2003) Revised formulas for summarizing retinal vessel diameters. Curr Eye Res 27: 143–149.
- 28. Hubbard LD, Brothers RJ, King WN, Clegg LX, Klein R, et al. (1999) Methods for evaluation of retinal microvascular abnormalities associated with hypertension/sclerosis in the atherosclerosis risk in communities study. Ophthalmology 106: 2269–2280.
- 29. Health Effects Institute (2000) Reanalysis of the Harvard Six Cities Study and the American Cancer Society Study of Particulate Air Pollution and Mortality. Boston: Health Effects Institute.
- 30. Sampson PD, Szpiro AA, L. S, JL, Kaufman JD (2009) Pragmatic estimation of a spatio-temporal air quality model with irregular monitoring data. UW Biostatistics Working Paper Series Working Paper 353.
- 31. Szpiro A, Sampson P, Sheppard L, Lumley T, Adar S, et al. (2009) Predicting intra-urban variations in air pollution with complex spatio-temporal dependencies. Environmetrics 21: 606–631.
- 32. Cohen MA, Adar SD, Allen RW, Avol E, Curl CL, et al. (2009) Approach to estimating participant pollutant exposures in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis and Air Pollution (MESA Air). Environ Sci Technol 43: 4687–4693.
- 33. Genuth S, Alberti K, Bennett P, Buse J, DeFronzo R, et al. (2003) Follow-up report on the diagnosis of diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Care 26: 3160–3167.
- 34. Liew G, Sharrett AR, Kronmal R, Klein R, Wong TY, et al. (2007) Measurement of retinal vascular caliber: Issues and alternatives to using the arteriole to venule ratio. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 48: 52–57.
- 35. Liew G, Sharrett AR, Wang JJ, Klein R, Klein BEK, et al. (2008) Relative importance of systemic determinants of retinal arteriolar and venular caliber. Arch Ophthal 126: 1404–1410.
- 36. Liew G, Wong TY, Mitchell P, Wang JJ (2006) Are narrower or wider retinal venules associated with incident hypertension? Hypertension 48: E10–E10.
- 37. Lois N, Abdelkader E, Reglitz K, Garden C, Ayres JG (2008) Environmental tobacco smoke exposure and eye disease. Br J Ophthalmol 92: 1304–1310.
- 38. Memisogullari R, Yuksel H, Coskun A, Yazgan O, Bilgin C (2007) High serum homocysteine levels correlate with a decrease in the blood flow velocity of the ophthalmic artery in highway toll collectors. Tohoku J Exp Med 212: 247–252.
- 39. Remky A, Dressen D, Plange N, Korinth G, Drexler H, et al. (2004) Retinal vessel diameters determined in an ergo-medical field study: diameter changes associated with the occupational exposure to carbon disulfide. Association Research Vision Ophthalmology Inc. 45: E-Abstract 5253.
- 40. Sliwka U, Krasney JA, Simon SG, Schmidt P, Noth J (1998) Part one: Effects of sustained low-level elevations of carbon dioxide on cerebral blood flow and autoregulation of the intracerebral arteries in humans. Aviat Space Environ Med 69: 299–306.
- 41. Urch B, Brook JR, Wasserstein D, Brook RD, Rajagopalan S, et al. (2004) Relative contributions of PM2.5 chemical constituents to acute arterial vasoconstriction in humans. Inhal Toxicol 16: 345–352.
- 42. Peretz A, Kaufman JD, Trenga CA, Allen J, Carlsten C, et al. (2008) Effects of diesel exhaust inhalation on heart rate variability in human volunteers. Environ Res 107: 178–184.
- 43. Brook RD, Urch B, Dvonch JT, Bard RL, Speck M, et al. (2009) Insights into the mechanisms and mediators of the effects of air pollution exposure on blood pressure and vascular function in healthy humans. Hypertension 54: 659–U420.
- 44. LeBlanc AJ, Cumpston JL, Chen BT, Frazer D, Castranova V, et al. (2009) Nanoparticle inhalation impairs endothelium-dependent vasodilation in subepicardial arterioles. J Toxicol Environ Health A 72: 1576–1584.
- 45. Törnqvist H, Mills NL, Gonzales M, Miller MR, Robinson SD, et al. (2007) Persistent endothelial dysfunction following diesel exhaust inhalation in man. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 176: 395–400.
- 46. Nurkiewicz TR, Porter DW, Barger M, Millecchia L, Rao KMK, et al. (2006) Systemic microvascular dysfunction and inflammation after pulmonary particulate matter exposure. Environ Health Perspect 114: 412–419.
- 47. Nurkiewicz TR, Porter DW, Hubbs AF, Stone S, Chen BT, et al. (2009) Pulmonary nanoparticle exposure disrupts systemic microvascular nitric oxide signaling. J Toxicol Sci 110: 191–203.
- 48. Auchincloss AH, Roux AVD, Dvonch JT, Brown PL, Barr RG, et al. (2008) Associations between recent exposure to ambient fine particulate matter and blood pressure in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA). Environ Health Perspect 116: 486–491.
- 49. Kifley A, Liew G, Wang JJ, Kaushik S, Smith W, et al. (2007) Long-term effects of smoking on retinal microvascular caliber. Am J Epidemiol 166: 1288–1297.
- 50. Dockery DW, Pope CA 3rd, Xu X, Spengler JD, Ware JH, et al. (1993) An association between air pollution and mortality in six U.S. cities. N Engl J Med 329: 1753–1759.
- 51. Pope CA, Burnett RT, Thurston GD, Thun MJ, Calle EE, et al. (2004) Cardiovascular mortality and long-term exposure to particulate air pollution - Epidemiological evidence of general pathophysiological pathways of disease. Circulation 109: 71–77.
- 52. Miller KA, Siscovick DS, Sheppard L, Shepherd K, Sullivan JH, et al. (2007) Long-term exposure to air pollution and incidence of cardiovascular events in women. N Engl J Med 356: 447–458.