Background to the Debate
Current guidelines recommend that all fever episodes in African children be treated presumptively with antimalarial drugs. But declining malarial transmission in parts of sub-Saharan Africa, declining proportions of fevers due to malaria, and the availability of rapid diagnostic tests mean it may be time for this policy to change. This debate examines whether enough evidence exists to support abandoning presumptive treatment and whether African health systems have the capacity to support a shift toward laboratory-confirmed rather than presumptive diagnosis and treatment of malaria in children under five.
Citation: D'Acremont V, Lengeler C, Mshinda H, Mtasiwa D, Tanner M, Genton B (2009) Time To Move from Presumptive Malaria Treatment to Laboratory-Confirmed Diagnosis and Treatment in African Children with Fever. PLoS Med 6(1): e252. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.0050252
Published: January 6, 2009
Copyright: © 2009 D'Acremont et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: We were unable to contact Deo Mtasiwa or Hassan Mshinda before publication. Blaise Genton has therefore supplied the information regarding their contributions to the manuscript and competing interests, and this information is correct to the best of his knowledge. VD'A, CL, HM, DM, MT, and BG have permanent positions at their own institutions. VD'A is currently supported by a grant of the Swiss National Science Foundation (# 3270B0-109696) for introducing RDTs in pilot locations in Tanzania and evaluating their impact on routine diagnoses and drug prescription. No specific funding was received to write this article.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: ACT, artemisinin-based combination therapy; RDT, rapid diagnostic test; WHO, World Health Organization
Provenance: This Debate arose from an uncommissioned submission by Blaise Genton and colleagues that was reviewed by Mike English. We then commissioned contributions to a Debate from each author, which were not otherwise peer reviewed.
In this Viewpoint, Blaise Genton and colleagues argue in favor of abandoning presumptive treatment for under-fives. Mike English and colleagues present the opposing Viewpoint in a related article: English M, Reyburn H, Goodman C, Snow RW (2009) Abandoning presumptive antimalarial treatment for febrile children aged less than five years—A case of running before we can walk? PLoS Med 6(1): e1000015. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000015
Malaria has long been the number one cause of fever and the leading cause of child mortality in sub-Saharan Africa. As a result, the World Health Organization (WHO) recommends treating any fever episode in African children with antimalarial drugs to save lives. However, this approach may not be as safe as it was 20 years ago for two major reasons. Firstly, the proportion of fevers due to malaria has become significantly lower, even in highly endemic areas, and hence the relative likelihood of missing other potentially fatal diseases has become higher. Secondly, we now have new reliable rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) to allow proper diagnosis of malaria at all levels of the health system.
Evidence of Decreased Malaria Transmission in Sub-Saharan Africa, and Declining Proportion of Fevers Due To Malaria
There is growing evidence documenting a substantial decline in malaria transmission, morbidity, and mortality in more than 13 African countries where malaria control interventions have been implemented at scale. This reduction is also observed in areas with previously high levels of transmission (e.g., ). Although available data are not always spatially congruent, and therefore cannot necessarily be viewed as representing secular changes, the sharp decline in sub-Saharan Africa of the Plasmodium falciparum prevalence rate in children aged two to ten years—from 37% in the years 1985–1999 to 17% in 2000–2007—clearly documents this trend . This decrease implies that many of the areas previously defined as “high stable malaria transmission” have changed, or will soon change, into “moderate to low transmission” areas.
The lower the transmission, the lower the probability that a fever episode will be due to malaria. In Tanzania, a high-endemicity country, only one to four out of ten under-five patients with fever are parasitaemic in the rural settings (A. M. Kabanywany, 2007 and V. D'Acremont, 2008, personal communications) . With a decline in malaria's prevalence, the hazard of misdiagnosis of many children becomes significant. When giving an antimalarial, the health worker is less likely to look for another treatable cause of fever, and this leads to higher morbidity and mortality due to delay in giving appropriate treatment, as suggested by studies that showed higher case fatality rates among non-malaria fevers compared to malaria fevers .
Availability of RDTs for Malaria
The shift from symptom-based diagnosis to parasite-based management of malaria requires that clinicians have a reliable, easy-to-use, and inexpensive diagnostic test. It should have good sensitivity, require minimal training and equipment, and retain accuracy even after extensive storage under tropical conditions. All these characteristics are met by the new generation of RDTs. Two meta-analyses have clearly shown that the performance of RDTs is comparable to that of expert microscopy [5,6]. Appropriate action taken on the basis of the test result is now the key element for the successful introduction of RDTs. Unfortunately, this has not always been achieved in the implementation of RDTs so far, partly because the training was insufficient to change the clinician's perception of malaria risk . In addition, the ambiguous messages from WHO and national guidelines stating that malaria should be considered even in the presence of a negative test have added to the confusion .
At present risk levels, the risk of missing a malaria case due to a false-negative test is substantially smaller than the risk of the patient dying due to another severe disease because of the focus on malaria. The risk of a false-negative test and its potential consequences have recently been evaluated thoroughly in Uganda (using microscopy)  and in Tanzania (using RDTs) , and the safety of not treating malaria-negative children confirmed.
Box 1. Additional Arguments for a Shift from Presumptive Malaria Treatment to Laboratory-Confirmed Diagnosis and Treatment According To Test Results in Children Under Five with Fever
- Treating all fever patients with antimalarials leads to a huge drug wastage, and hence potential for drug shortage
- Inappropriate use of antimalarials leads to unnecessary adverse drug reactions
- Irrational use of antimalarial drugs leads to increased parasite resistance
- Potential mistrust on the part of the public on the real efficacy of artemisinin-based combination therapies (ACTs) due to use for inappropriate indications (viral or bacterial disease)
- Parasitological diagnosis and treatment with ACTs according to test results versus presumptive treatment with ACTs is costeffective in all current malaria-endemic situations (as long as test result is taken into account) [11,12]
A switch from presumptive treatment to laboratory-confirmed diagnosis and treatment is now urgent but needs to be carefully planned. Large-scale deployment of RDTs is a great challenge that requires theoretical and practical training, regular supervision, and sustained financial mechanisms to ensure constant availability. It is crucial that quality control is implemented at all steps.
Also, introduction of reliable diagnosis implies that clinicians need to be trained to manage the “negative syndrome” (patients with a negative malaria test). This is challenging after years of upholding the notion that fever equals malaria and requires substantial change in the behaviour of clinicians and caretakers. This is now a great opportunity to update and re-strengthen the Integrated Management of Childhood Illnesses to promote improved case management of African children.
The recent trend of malaria decline in Africa calls for a shift from presumptive treatment to laboratory-confirmed diagnosis and treatment in all areas, regardless of age and level of malaria transmission. Such a move is especially relevant with the new momentum towards elimination and is now realistic thanks to reliable RDTs. As part of renewed malaria control efforts, it is time to improve clinical management and abandon irrational use of drugs, i.e., antimalarial treatment for no malaria and no treatment for other potentially fatal causes of fevers.
Genton and Colleagues' Response to English and Colleagues' Viewpoint
In this section, Genton and colleagues respond to the points raised by English and colleagues in their opposing Viewpoint: English M, Reyburn H, Goodman C, Snow RW (2009) Abandoning presumptive antimalarial treatment for febrile children aged less than five years—A case of running before we can walk? PLoS Med 6(1): e1000015. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000015
We all agree that laboratory-confirmed diagnosis of malaria is the desirable goal. We disagree on the present status of evidence and the conditions needed to change the policy.
Evidence on RDT Performance
Evidence is accumulating showing that RDT performance is high, even when used in routine practice [13–15]. The authors of the study showing 65% sensitivity acknowledge themselves that “use of poor quality blood smear may impede reliable measurement of sensitivity and specificity and undermine confidence in the new diagnostic” . The issue nowadays is no longer about RDT performance but about how to best implement quality assurance.
Evidence on the Safety of the Management Strategy Based on Laboratory Confirmation of Parasites
Although the debate about laboratory-confirmed diagnosis versus presumptive treatment has been ongoing for years, nobody has embarked on the definitive study to show that mortality is not higher with the former than the latter. We have recent evidence confirming that the strategy based on documented diagnosis is safe , even in uncontrolled settings . We consider that accumulated experience in all age groups and studies including more than 3,000 children under five are enough to decide on a policy change.
Evidence on Health Workers' Beliefs and Behaviour
New evidence shows that clinicians trust and act upon RDT results. Indeed, in recent studies conducted under programmatic conditions, 2%–10% of all patients with negative results were given antimalarials  (D'Acremont et al., unpublished data). This contrasts with disappointing results published earlier  and illustrates the behaviour change that can be achieved through proper training and trust gained by accumulating field experience with RDTs.
To align practices in formal care settings with those at community level, we propose to also use RDTs outside health facilities. It is safe and feasible . Moreover, it fits with the new WHO Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases and UNICEF initiative that promotes community-integrated management of malaria/pneumonia/diarrhoea rather than home-based management of malaria.
More Data on Malaria Epidemiology
Improved data on local malaria epidemiology will not help much. We already know that heterogeneity is huge and rapidly evolving. Only a uniform policy across all age groups and epidemiological settings is likely to be implemented appropriately. This is best illustrated by the conclusion made by one of the authors of the opposing Viewpoint in a recent paper: “Despite different recommendations for patients below and above 5 years of age, malaria diagnosis and treatment practices were similar in the two age groups… Malaria diagnosis recommendations differing between age groups appear complex to implement; further strengthening of diagnosis and treatment practices under AL policy is required.” .
We strongly believe that the policy should be changed even if all conditions for perfect implementation are not fulfilled. In areas where RDTs have been deployed at scale, clinicians have understood that the performance and usefulness of RDTs is not different in a child under five years than in an adult. The time needed to achieve all conditions English et al. consider necessary to have a policy change will only lead to more deaths due to diseases other than malaria left untreated and to the emergence of parasite resistance consequent to irrational use of drugs. A policy change is desirable to deliver clear and simple messages. Staggered implementation will follow according to country capacity, as is done for laboratory-confirmed diagnosis and treatment in other age groups.
- 1. World Health Organization (2008) Impact of long-lasting insecticidal-treated nets (LLINs) and artemisinin-based combination therapies (ACTs) measured using surveillance data, in four African countries. World Health Organization2008Impact of long-lasting insecticidal-treated nets (LLINs) and artemisinin-based combination therapies (ACTs) measured using surveillance data, in four African countries.Available: http://www.who.int/malaria/docs/ReportGFImpactMalaria.pdf. Accessed 17 November 2008. Available: http://www.who.int/malaria/docs/ReportGFImpactMalaria.pdf. Accessed 17 November 2008.
- 2. Guerra CA, Gikandi PW, Tatem AJ, Noor AM, Smith DL, et al. (2008) The limits and intensity of Plasmodium falciparum transmission: Implications for malaria control and elimination worldwide. PLoS Med 5: e38.CA GuerraPW GikandiAJ TatemAM NoorDL Smith2008The limits and intensity of Plasmodium falciparum transmission: Implications for malaria control and elimination worldwide.PLoS Med5e38
- 3. Wang SJ, Lengeler C, Mtasiwa D, Mshana T, Manane L, et al. (2006) Rapid Urban Malaria Appraisal (RUMA) II: Epidemiology of urban malaria in Dar es Salaam (Tanzania). Malar J 4: 28.SJ WangC. LengelerD. MtasiwaT. MshanaL. Manane2006Rapid Urban Malaria Appraisal (RUMA) II: Epidemiology of urban malaria in Dar es Salaam (Tanzania).Malar J428
- 4. Reyburn H, Mbatia R, Drakeley C, Carneiro I, Mwakasungula E, et al. (2004) Overdiagnosis of malaria in patients with severe febrile illness in Tanzania: A prospective study. BMJ 329: 1212.H. ReyburnR. MbatiaC. DrakeleyI. CarneiroE. Mwakasungula2004Overdiagnosis of malaria in patients with severe febrile illness in Tanzania: A prospective study.BMJ3291212
- 5. Marx A, Pewsner D, Egger M, Nuesch R, Bucher HC, et al. (2005) Meta-analysis: Accuracy of rapid tests for malaria in travelers returning from endemic areas. Ann Intern Med 142: 836–846.A. MarxD. PewsnerM. EggerR. NueschHC Bucher2005Meta-analysis: Accuracy of rapid tests for malaria in travelers returning from endemic areas.Ann Intern Med142836846
- 6. Ochola LB, Vounatsou P, Smith T, Mabaso ML, Newton CR (2006) The reliability of diagnostic techniques in the diagnosis and management of malaria in the absence of a gold standard. Lancet Infect Dis 6: 582–588.LB OcholaP. VounatsouT. SmithML MabasoCR Newton2006The reliability of diagnostic techniques in the diagnosis and management of malaria in the absence of a gold standard.Lancet Infect Dis6582588
- 7. Hamer DH, Ndhlovu M, Zurovac D, Fox M, Yeboah-Antwi K, et al. (2007) Improved diagnostic testing and malaria treatment practices in Zambia. JAMA 297: 2227–2231.DH HamerM. NdhlovuD. ZurovacM. FoxK. Yeboah-Antwi2007Improved diagnostic testing and malaria treatment practices in Zambia.JAMA29722272231
- 8. D'Acremont V, Lengeler C, Genton B (2007) Stop ambiguous messages on malaria diagnosis. BMJ 334: 489.V. D'AcremontC. LengelerB. Genton2007Stop ambiguous messages on malaria diagnosis.BMJ334489
- 9. Njama-Meya D, Clark TD, Nzarubara B, Staedke S, Kamya MR, et al. (2007) Treatment of malaria restricted to laboratory-confirmed cases: A prospective cohort study in Ugandan children. Malar J 6: 7.D. Njama-MeyaTD ClarkB. NzarubaraS. StaedkeMR Kamya2007Treatment of malaria restricted to laboratory-confirmed cases: A prospective cohort study in Ugandan children.Malar J67
- 10. D'Acremont V, Kahama-Maro J, Mtasiwa D, Lengeler C, Genton B (2008) Withdrawing antimalarials in febrile children with a negative rapid diagnostic test is safe in a moderately endemic area of Tanzania [abstract 397]. V. D'AcremontJ. Kahama-MaroD. MtasiwaC. LengelerB. Genton2008Withdrawing antimalarials in febrile children with a negative rapid diagnostic test is safe in a moderately endemic area of Tanzania [abstract 397].ASTMH 57th Annual Meeting; 7–11 December 2008; New Orleans, Louisiana, United States. ASTMH 57th Annual Meeting; 7–11 December 2008; New Orleans, Louisiana, United States.
- 11. Lubell Y, Reyburn H, Mbakilwa H, Mwangi R, Chonya K, et al. (2007) The cost-effectiveness of parasitologic diagnosis for malaria-suspected patients in an era of combination therapy. Am J Trop Med Hyg 77: 128–132.Y. LubellH. ReyburnH. MbakilwaR. MwangiK. Chonya2007The cost-effectiveness of parasitologic diagnosis for malaria-suspected patients in an era of combination therapy.Am J Trop Med Hyg77128132
- 12. Shillcutt S, Morel C, Goodman C, Coleman P, Bell D, et al. (2008) Cost-effectiveness of malaria diagnostic methods in sub-Saharan Africa in an era of combination therapy. Bull World Health Organ 86: 101–110.S. ShillcuttC. MorelC. GoodmanP. ColemanD. Bell2008Cost-effectiveness of malaria diagnostic methods in sub-Saharan Africa in an era of combination therapy.Bull World Health Organ86101110
- 13. Hopkins H, Bebell L, Kambale W, Dokomajilar C, Rosenthal PJ, et al. (2008) Rapid diagnostic tests for malaria at sites of varying transmission intensity in Uganda. J Infect Dis 197: 510–518.H. HopkinsL. BebellW. KambaleC. DokomajilarPJ Rosenthal2008Rapid diagnostic tests for malaria at sites of varying transmission intensity in Uganda.J Infect Dis197510518
- 14. Abeku TA, Kristan M, Jones C, Beard J, Mueller DH, et al. (2008) Determinants of the accuracy of rapid diagnostic tests in malaria case management: Evidence from low and moderate transmission settings in the East African highlands. Malar J 7: 202.TA AbekuM. KristanC. JonesJ. BeardDH Mueller2008Determinants of the accuracy of rapid diagnostic tests in malaria case management: Evidence from low and moderate transmission settings in the East African highlands.Malar J7202
- 15. Bharti PK, Silawat N, Singh PP, Singh MP, Shukla M, et al. (2008) The usefulness of a new rapid diagnostic test, the First Response Malaria Combo (pLDH/HRP2) card test, for malaria diagnosis in the forested belt of central India. Malar J 7: 126.PK BhartiN. SilawatPP SinghMP SinghM. Shukla2008The usefulness of a new rapid diagnostic test, the First Response Malaria Combo (pLDH/HRP2) card test, for malaria diagnosis in the forested belt of central India.Malar J7126
- 16. McMorrow ML, Masanja MI, Abdulla SM, Kahigwa E, Kachur SP (2008) Challenges in routine implementation and quality control of rapid diagnostic tests for malaria—Rufiji District, Tanzania. Am J Trop Med Hyg 79: 385–390.ML McMorrowMI MasanjaSM AbdullaE. KahigwaSP Kachur2008Challenges in routine implementation and quality control of rapid diagnostic tests for malaria—Rufiji District, Tanzania.Am J Trop Med Hyg79385390
- 17. Reyburn H, Mbakilwa H, Mwangi R, Mwerinde O, Olomi R, et al. (2007) Rapid diagnostic tests compared with malaria microscopy for guiding outpatient treatment of febrile illness in Tanzania: Randomised trial. BMJ 334: 403.H. ReyburnH. MbakilwaR. MwangiO. MwerindeR. Olomi2007Rapid diagnostic tests compared with malaria microscopy for guiding outpatient treatment of febrile illness in Tanzania: Randomised trial.BMJ334403
- 18. Lemma HR, Desta A, Fottrel E, Barnabas B, Bianchi A, et al. (2008) Impact of deployment of artemether lumefantrine (AL) in combination with rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) at community level in Tigray region, Northern Ethiopia [abstract FC018]. Strengthening Health Systems and the Global Health Workforce. Geneva Forum: Towards Global Access to Health. pp. 25–28.HR LemmaA. DestaE. FottrelB. BarnabasA. Bianchi2008Impact of deployment of artemether lumefantrine (AL) in combination with rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) at community level in Tigray region, Northern Ethiopia [abstract FC018].Strengthening Health Systems and the Global Health WorkforceGeneva ForumTowards Global Access to Health2528May 2008; Geneva, Switzerland. May 2008; Geneva, Switzerland.
- 19. Zurovac D, Njogu J, Akhwale W, Hamer DH, Larson BA, et al. (2008) Effects of revised diagnostic recommendations on malaria treatment practices across age groups in Kenya. Trop Med Int Health 13: 784–787.D. ZurovacJ. NjoguW. AkhwaleDH HamerBA Larson2008Effects of revised diagnostic recommendations on malaria treatment practices across age groups in Kenya.Trop Med Int Health13784787